Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Decline a Job Offer Without Burning Bridges
Transcript
- Lucas: You go through three rounds of interviews. You negotiate. You sign the offer letter. You give notice at your current job. And then — your current boss comes back with a counteroffer that actually changes things. Luna: And suddenly you're the person who said yes and then said no. It feels like you've already burned the bridge with the new company. Lucas: Exactly. And that feeling — that guilt, that anxiety — is what keeps people in situations they should leave. But the data tells a different story. A 2023 survey from iCIMS found that roughly 12 percent of candidates who accept an offer end up not starting. That's one in eight. Recruiters see this regularly. Luna: So it's not this rare, shameful thing that ruins your reputation forever. Lucas: It's common enough that good recruiters have a process for it. The question is how you handle it. And there's a right way and a very wrong way. Luna: Let's talk about the wrong way first. I think we've all heard the horror stories: someone sends a one-sentence email, or just ghosts, or tries to negotiate again after accepting. Lucas: Ghosting is the worst. You go radio silent, the recruiter is left assuming you'll show up on day one, they've already told the hiring manager you're confirmed, maybe they've even turned down other candidates. Then the start date comes and nothing. That recruiter will remember your name — and not in a good way. Luna: And industries are smaller than people think. Especially in specialized fields like biotech or enterprise software, recruiters move between companies. That reputation follows you. Lucas: There's a specific case I want to dig into. A marketing manager we'll call Sarah. She accepted a senior manager role at a competitor, gave notice at her current agency, and then her current CEO offered her a new title, a 20 percent raise, and a direct report — something she'd been asking for for two years. Luna: And she took it. She called the new company's recruiter and said she was staying. Lucas: She did. And she handled it well. She called, not emailed. She acknowledged the inconvenience. She was specific about why — not 'a better opportunity,' but 'my current company addressed the growth ceiling I was worried about.' She didn't apologize excessively, but she expressed genuine gratitude. And the recruiter? She told me later that she'd re-hire Sarah in a heartbeat, because she was professional and direct. Luna: That's the key — the recruiter's reaction. They're not personally offended. Their job is to fill roles. If you make it easy for them to move on, they respect you. Lucas: Right. The recruiter's biggest fear isn't losing a candidate — it's losing time. So the best thing you can do is call early, explain clearly, and give them enough information to restart the search without having to guess what happened. Luna: What about the level of honesty? Should you tell them it's a counteroffer? Lucas: I think you should. Not every detail, but the general shape. 'My current employer came back with an offer I couldn't ignore' is honest without being boastful. The one thing you should never say is anything negative about the company you just accepted from. Don't say 'I realized the commute was too long' or 'I wasn't sure about the culture.' That just makes the recruiter feel like they misrepresented the role. Luna: Also, don't say 'I'll keep you in mind for future opportunities' unless you genuinely mean it. Lucas: That's a good point. Empty platitudes are worse than silence. If you say that, the recruiter expects you to follow up. If you don't, it's another small mark against you. Better to say 'I hope we cross paths again' and leave it there. Luna: And before we get into the script — you know, we talk a lot on this show about career moves that feel awkward but are actually normal. And one reason we can have these honest conversations is that this show doesn't run ads. We don't have to sell you anything, and we don't have to sell your attention to a sponsor. If you've gotten value from episodes like this one, the only way we keep the lights on — and keep it ad-free — is through listener support at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a simple page, no recurring subscription, just a way to say 'this helped.' Lucas: Yeah, and that support is what lets us spend time on specific cases like Sarah's instead of rushing through generic tips. So thank you to anyone who's already contributed. Luna: Alright. Let's get into the script. You've accepted, you've gotten a counteroffer, you've decided to stay. What do you actually say on that call? Lucas: First, you call the recruiter or hiring manager — whoever was your main point of contact. Do this as soon as you've made your decision. The worst thing is waiting 48 hours because you're nervous. That wasted time is what annoys people. Luna: And you call, not text or email. Lucas: Yes. A call shows courage and respect. If you get voicemail, leave a brief message asking them to call you back. Then send a follow-up email saying the same thing. Don't deliver the news in voicemail or email. The actual conversation should be live. Luna: What does the script sound like? Lucas: Something like: 'Hi, thank you again for the offer and for the time you've invested in me. I've made a difficult decision. My current employer has presented me with a counteroffer that addresses the growth opportunities I was looking for, and I've decided to stay with them. I know this creates a gap for you, and I'm sorry for the inconvenience. I truly appreciated getting to know your team, and I hope we can stay connected on LinkedIn.' Luna: That's good. No over-explaining, no defensiveness, no 'I'm sorry but' — just 'I'm sorry, and here's why.' Lucas: Exactly. And then you pause. Let them react. Most recruiters will say something like 'I understand, it happens.' A few might ask if there's anything they could have done differently. If they do, answer honestly but briefly. 'The counteroffer was a combination of title and compensation that I couldn't match elsewhere' — that's fine. Don't get into a negotiation. Luna: What if you haven't signed the offer yet? Is that different? Lucas: It is different. If you haven't signed, you're not rescinding acceptance — you're declining an offer. That's less fraught. You can still use the same script, but you don't need to apologize as much. You can say 'I've decided to stay with my current employer after receiving a counteroffer.' The recruiter might be disappointed, but they haven't stopped their search yet. Luna: There's another scenario: what if you want to accept the counteroffer but you're worried your current employer will see you as a flight risk? Lucas: That's a real concern. There's a statistic from a study by the Society for Human Resource Management — about 40 percent of people who accept a counteroffer leave within a year anyway, either because the underlying issues weren't just about money, or because the employer's trust is damaged. So if you stay, you have to be sure the counteroffer isn't just a band-aid. Ask yourself: is this really fixing the reason I wanted to leave? Luna: And if it is, you stay. But you should also have a conversation with your current boss about how you'll work together going forward. 'I appreciate this, and I'm committed to the team. Let's revisit in six months to make sure this is working for both of us.' Lucas: That's smart. It makes it a partnership rather than a concession. And it signals that you're not going to be a passive employee who just took the money. Luna: What about the new company? Even if you handle it perfectly, is there any long-term damage? Lucas: There can be, but it's usually mild. If you apply to that same company in two years, the recruiter or hiring manager might remember that you backed out. But if you were professional, they'll also remember that you were upfront and respectful. I've seen people get hired years later at companies they'd previously turned down. It's not a permanent black mark. Luna: So the key takeaway: call early, be honest about the counteroffer, apologize for the inconvenience, and don't over-explain. Lucas: And one more thing: don't burn the bridge on your way out by badmouthing the new company to your current employer. Keep it clean. 'I had a great experience with them, but I'm excited to stay here' — that's all you need to say. Luna: I think the biggest fear people have is that they're being disloyal or ungrateful. But a job acceptance is a business decision. Recruiters know that. The only thing they can't forgive is being treated like an afterthought. Lucas: Exactly. Treat them like a professional partner, and they'll treat you the same way. Even when the answer is no. Luna: Good advice. That's all we have time for today. We'll be back next episode with another career question that's harder to ask than it is to answer.