Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / JK Rowling, Clingy Boyfriends, Woke Professors and Other Things
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners, It's just me again today. I thought I would
- 0:02answer some patron emails and reminder that I'm still sick so I might sound a
- 0:09little hoarse with my voice, and also a reminder that I'm recording this in
- 0:15late July, so if around this episode the time that it's published, you
- 0:19see me on Instagram hanging out with other people. I am all likely out
- 0:24of the contagious zone. My doctor even said that he thinks I'm out of
- 0:28the contagious zone now, but I am just trying to play it safe.
- 0:32I don't have COVID at least I've tested negative for COVID, so it's unlikely
- 0:37I have COVID. I think I just have like a regular cold that I
- 0:40remember getting before. You know, I said in an earlier episode that I
- 0:44haven't been sick and I think four plus years. And it's a very weird
- 0:49experience, you know, after the pandemic. I'm sure all y'all have been
- 0:53sick at least once, maybe with COVID, so you already broke that seal.
- 0:57But for me, you know, it was all the worry of viruses
- 1:00and whatnot, and then to finally be sick. It's like, oh yeah,
- 1:04I remember this feeling all right. This next emails from a partier patron,
- 1:07Maria. She says, I thought you might find this short podcast series
- 1:11interesting. Selfishly, I would love to know your thoughts on it. It's
- 1:15called The Witch Trials of JK Rolling. Thank you for everything that you do,
- 1:19doctor Kirk. I feel like your content helps me to be a better
- 1:23daughter, sister, partner, friend, and physician and of email. Well
- 1:26that's high praise, Brian, Thank you for that. Yeah. I did
- 1:30listen to the podcast The Witch Trials of JK Rolling, and what do I
- 1:34say? Well, what I'll say is that when I was listening to the
- 1:38podcast, it seemed biased towards JK Rolling. It didn't seem to present the
- 1:46full breadth of everything that she has said that was transphobic on the internet.
- 1:51So if you just listen to the podcast and you don't look into it yourself,
- 1:56you might find yourself swaye JK Rolling and against those who are criticizing her.
- 2:04That's my opinion. The other thing that the podcast I think does,
- 2:08and I think it does it well, is that it points out that in
- 2:12our current society, and maybe we've always been like this, that we tend
- 2:16to have mob mentality when it comes to attacking people, and in today's bill
- 2:22you it's attacking people online, right, And I appreciated that. After myself
- 2:28being a very minor, minor victim of that during the Johny Depp amber Heard
- 2:32trial last year, I can attest to just how horrible it is. And
- 2:37I can't imagine what it'd be like to be someone like Rolling. You know,
- 2:39it's one thing to criticize her and maybe even ban her books or something.
- 2:45It's another thing for JK. Rolling to feel in fear for her life
- 2:49on a constant basis. So there's something going on in our culture that needs
- 2:53to change, and it points out that, I think pretty effectively. What
- 2:59also the post does is it lays out the inherent sexism and misogyny in our
- 3:04society that has been around for you know, centuries, but even in history,
- 3:10there were times when our society would be going through something difficult and for
- 3:16whatever reason, women would be the lightning rod for everyone's hatred and men somehow
- 3:23are completely off the hook. Because you know, we understand that there's a
- 3:25lot of transphobia and our society committed by people of all genders, right,
- 3:30but for whatever reason, women are often the most attacked people, right so,
- 3:36and not only women, but feminist whom you know, because she is
- 3:39a feminist who is has been fighting for women. And that's another interesting part
- 3:46of the podcast, as it goes into her history, which I didn't know
- 3:47anything about. Another interesting part of the podcast is that JK. Rowling is
- 3:52a very well spoken person, very well read person. She you know,
- 3:55the way that I thought of her before listening to the pod cast was that
- 4:00she was just this old person who was out of touch and tweeting all this
- 4:03nonsense. But when you actually hear her, the nonsense that she posts online
- 4:10is actually coming from a very educated place. And that was another thing I
- 4:13thought, well, given how smart she is, and given that in a
- 4:16lot of ways she's on the right side of history, why is she doing
- 4:19this? And I thought, well, maybe she doesn't understand how the internet
- 4:23works or something. Then I also thought there could be a part of her
- 4:27that's traumatized and when people push back on her, particularly maybe in an aggressive
- 4:30way, given her traumas of being aggressed upon, that she just kind of
- 4:35shuts down and says, no, you're not going to win. I will
- 4:40win. So I was wondering if something like that was going on, because
- 4:43the podcast really reveals a very smart but traumatized individual JK Rowling, like really
- 4:49really smart. I was just off the cuff. Jk Rowling could speak of
- 4:55history and sexism and trauma and emotion and society, and I don't know,
- 5:02I was just you know, at this At the same time, I'm impressed
- 5:05with her, I'm just like, well, then, why are you saying
- 5:08these horrible things online? Like yea, all you gotta do is just say
- 5:13it differently. There's so many other ways you could be saying these things,
- 5:15you know. So yeah, that was my reaction to that. Oh and
- 5:19the other thing that the podcast really illuminated me to was the fans of Harry
- 5:25Potter. You know, for me, Harry Potter came out when I was
- 5:28an adult. I remember seeing the first Harry Potter book in you know,
- 5:31at the in the nineties and early aughts, I was doing therapy in people's
- 5:36homes. And one of the things that not all the work I was doing
- 5:41was in homes, but a good portion and there are years of my early
- 5:45career where I was doing that ninety nine percent of the time, and I
- 5:49would enter the home and the you know, i'd be the family therapist,
- 5:54and if I wanted to talk individually with anyone, it would be easier if
- 5:57we went into a room instead of just being in the living room, because
- 6:00if we're in the living room, whether people can hear and they're sort of
- 6:02walking in and out. So if I was talking to a kid, I
- 6:05would go into their room and talk with them. It was also a great
- 6:09opportunity to get to know the kid by seeing their room. You know,
- 6:13you get to learn a lot about people when you see the things that they
- 6:16have in their room. Anyway, and I started seeing this Harry Potter book
- 6:21everywhere, and I remember thinking, huh, what is this? He has
- 6:25this way before the movies and everything, right, and you know, some
- 6:29of the kids would be talking about the books and stuff anyway, So for
- 6:32me when oh, and then as the books started to come out, they
- 6:39became more and more popular, and my mom actually had the books on tape
- 6:43audio cassette. I have a mild form of dyslexia, which makes it hard
- 6:46for me to read, so I usually only read if I'm doing it for
- 6:51academia, because that's about as much as my brain can handle. So I
- 6:56don't typically read fiction because it just it's frustrating, and it actually kind of
- 7:01is hurtful. It hurts my brain sometimes. So when audiobooks came out,
- 7:05I was elated because I could finally quote unquote read these books that I always
- 7:10wanted to read. I listened to the first Game of Thrones books, you
- 7:14know, way back to twenty two years ago or something. I listened to
- 7:17the First Game of Thrones book and with Harry Potter. So my mom also
- 7:23listens to books, and it was on audio cassette back then. She had
- 7:26the first four books on audio cassette, and I borrowed them from her and
- 7:30listened to them and really loved the first book. The second book not so
- 7:35much. The third book I liked, fourth was okay, But the first
- 7:39I just find I just wish to me, you can't nothing comes close to
- 7:45that first book. Really. It's just a magical excuse. The pun book
- 7:48and story and everything is perfect, the setting. I remember when I was
- 7:54listening to the book, I thought this would be an excellent movie. It
- 7:58was almost like rolling was writing a screen play as a novel, right or
- 8:01writing a novel as a screenplay, Because I could see the movie in my
- 8:07head the way she was writing, you know, I could hear the soundtrack
- 8:11and everything, and when the movie came out, everything was perfect, except
- 8:15for Harry Potter himself. I had a very different vision of what Harry Potter
- 8:18looked like, but everyone else was just spot on anyway. So when the
- 8:24controversy around JK. Rowling was going on in Earnest a few years ago ish,
- 8:31it didn't really shatter me because I'm not a huge Harry Potter fan.
- 8:35In fact, I have kind of a love hate relationship with it, well,
- 8:39like slightly hate, you know, because the books are formulaic in that
- 8:46it's like a Scooby Doo episode in which they you know, the common thing
- 8:50that Scooby Doo episodes would do was there'd be all these mysteries, you know
- 8:54that Scooby Doo and Shaggy and everyone be like, oh, what's going on,
- 8:58what's going on? And then in the last minute of the show suddenly
- 9:03everything would be revealed. So it's not really a mystery, it's more like,
- 9:07oh my god, what's happening that it was sort of like a lost
- 9:11episode with a very unsatisfying, real quick ending. Also, I wasn't young,
- 9:18so when I listened to them, I was in my thirties and it
- 9:22just didn't resonate with me. However, I learned from you know, life,
- 9:26but also from this podcast that for younger people who would have been about
- 9:30Harry Potter's agent really people of all ages, but particularly if you grew up
- 9:33in an abusive household and you always had a fantasy of being able to rise
- 9:39above it or something, and you felt like a misfit, and this you
- 9:43could just imagine that this book, of this series, this culture would be
- 9:48a godsend, you know. And so for a lot of people, people
- 9:52who felt like they were on the outside of society, often a lot of
- 9:54LGBTQ people, write, a lot of trans kids, a lot of gay
- 9:58kids, really took to the Harry Potter world because you could say, the
- 10:03story kind of codes as the triumph of the non mainstream kids, you know,
- 10:09and so you know, attacking kids for being muggles, and attacking kids
- 10:15for being poor and attacking kids, you know, and and then those kids
- 10:18end up, you know, with Ron and Hermione and Harry. They they
- 10:22rise above it all and it's it's a glorious, you know story, and
- 10:26along those in that way, especially when you string out the books over time
- 10:31and the fandom and the movies and amy. So when Rolling comes out and
- 10:37is apparently transphobic, then it's devastating, right it because not only were the
- 10:43books important, but Rolling herself was important. It wasn't just the books,
- 10:48it was also her herself, and for her to you know, dig her
- 10:52heels in with some of her transphobic messages, it was very hurtful and very
- 11:00traumatic for these people and very upsetting. You know. It's one thing when
- 11:05you just hear a Republican politician saying these things. You expect that, But
- 11:09it's another thing when someone that you opened yourself up to, that you allowed
- 11:15into your soul, such as JK. Rolling, and then that person turns
- 11:20on you in the ways that you expect people to turn on you from far
- 11:26away. Your anger can be much greater towards that person than it would be
- 11:31towards a more distant person. So I think that was another part of the
- 11:35story, was that the vitriol and the anger against JK. Rowling had to
- 11:43do with that, you know, so, And I'm sure it's way more
- 11:46complicated the way I'm saying, because you know, I don't really follow these
- 11:48things. But yeah, so the Witch Trials of JK. Rowling, I
- 11:52think a well done podcast and pretty easy, pretty quick. But if you
- 11:58listen to that and only that, then I'm guessing you're going to walk away
- 12:01with a biased point of view towards JK. Rolling All right. This next
- 12:07emails from middle tier patron Jess from Denver. She says, I have an
- 12:11ongoing issue ending things with someone who moved to my state hoping to be with
- 12:16me. We dated in his state and lived together off and on during the
- 12:22start of the pandemic, but then I moved out to Colorado, and at
- 12:26first I was down with him moving here, but I quickly realized that we
- 12:31were that we weren't compatible, and he's not the one, Okay, So
- 12:37just trying to get everything straight here, Jess. You were dating someone off
- 12:41and on, or you were dating someone and you were off and on living
- 12:45together, and then you were moving to Colorado and either you wanted him to
- 12:50come or he offered to come with you to Colorado he did, so now
- 12:54you're both living in Colorado in Denver, I'm guessing, and because that's what
- 12:58you said, you're just from Denver, and then you quickly realized that you
- 13:03weren't compatible and that you didn't want to Not only you didn't want to live
- 13:07with him, but you didn't want to be in a relationship with him.
- 13:07Okay, before he moved out here, I wrote him an email letting him
- 13:11know I can only offer friendship and that he should only move here for himself,
- 13:16not me. Oh so, before he moved out to Colorado, I
- 13:20wrote him an email letting him know I can only offer friendship. So it
- 13:26sounds like you broke up as a couple. You moved to Colorado. He
- 13:31wanted to be with you, He says, Hey, I want to come
- 13:33out, and you're like, hey, yeah, if you want to move
- 13:35out, that's fine, but we're only going to be friends. We're not
- 13:39going to be romantic going on. He still moved out here and since then
- 13:43has been persistent about being together. I have gone along with it because I
- 13:50feel bad he sold his house in another state and moved here. I hate
- 13:54to feel I'm letting him down and hurting him, even though I know a
- 13:58clean rake is kinder to him as well. I barely tell him I love
- 14:03him back, but he keeps telling me he loves me, and he doesn't
- 14:07know what he would do without me, and I feel so pressured. I've
- 14:13given him many overt signals that I'm not interested in more than a friendship,
- 14:16but he is very pushy. I can't end it. I feel responsible that
- 14:22he moved here for me, and what if he doesn't listen and keeps persisting?
- 14:28Is an email okay? To end things. He is very adamant and
- 14:31persistent, and it's hard for me. It's hard for me too in it
- 14:35in person, hard for me to do it in person. I just want
- 14:37to be free of this relationship, and it's eating away at me that I
- 14:41haven't completely ended it in a vima. Yeah, I've run into this a
- 14:46lot in my office and also in my personal life. Yeah. You're very
- 14:50self aware, so that's good. You understand the situation. You know.
- 14:54Your language is kind of interesting. I just want to take a second to
- 15:00reeled down on some of the things that you said. You say that he
- 15:03moved out here and he's persistent about being together, and then you say I
- 15:07have gone along with meaning that you have agreed to be with him romantically because
- 15:13I feel bad he sold his house. And then you say I barely tell
- 15:16him I love him back. So it's good that you can admit that that
- 15:22you have gone along with the relationship, that you have told him that you
- 15:28love him back, and so you know, it's good that you can admit
- 15:33that because it's not like he's just forcing a relationship on you. Now,
- 15:37if we were there observing this relationship, it's possible that you are being coerced.
- 15:43It's possible that he is giving signals that something dangerous could happen if you
- 15:48don't agree with it. And if that's the case, then you're in an
- 15:52abusive relationship and you need to get support to get out of it. But
- 15:56I'm not hearing anything overt about that to me. What if you were my
- 16:02friend? Obviously, the easiest advice I could give is to break up and
- 16:08end it. But if you haven't done it by now, since you already
- 16:11have all this self awareness, then I would recommend therapy because the issue is
- 16:18deeper than even this guy, the fact that you would stay in a relationship
- 16:22that you don't want to be in. And I get it, you know
- 16:23you feel bad. You might have given him mixed signals. He moved out.
- 16:27It doesn't sound like you gave him mixed signals. But you know,
- 16:30at least you care about him and you don't want to hurt his feelings.
- 16:34But you still know that it's worse for him if you don't break up with
- 16:37him, because it's bad for him to be in a relationship with somebody doesn't
- 16:41want to be with you. But you know, so, Yeah, I
- 16:45would go to therapy to work on your people pleasing impulses and your perhaps lack
- 16:51of connection with your own needs, with perhaps your lack of a certainness,
- 16:56your lack of acknowledging what's really happening. You know, you might have had
- 17:00a lot of denial growing up in your family of origin. Because I'm guessing
- 17:04that this email represents a moment of clarity for you, and that when you're
- 17:10in the moment with him, you just kind of push it aside. Because
- 17:14I'll tell you, since I'm not a people pleaser myself, not really.
- 17:18I may certainly have tendencies, but I'm not really in that direction. If
- 17:22I was in your shoes, I wouldn't be able to handle it. Second
- 17:26by second, I would be so upset and bothered and annoyed that I wouldn't
- 17:33be able to help myself. But to say I'm breaking up with you and
- 17:38I can't ever see you again, and stop pestering me. You know what
- 17:41I mean? For you, it sounds like internally you might occasionally have these
- 17:47feelings, so getting in touch with those feelings because you deserve to be in
- 17:51touch with those feelings, but also a great portion of one's ability to build
- 17:56a life that is good for you is to be in touch with those feelings
- 18:00and to have them be spontaneously accessed so that in the moment it will motivate
- 18:04behavior. Because if I were you, Jess, I would be fucking pissed,
- 18:08not necessarily at him, but at the scenario, like this guy's wasting
- 18:14your time and invading your space. Maybe it's partly your fault, but still
- 18:18it's it's annoying to be forced into relationship, to have to hang out with
- 18:23someone romantically and act like you want to be with them or at least appease
- 18:29them when you don't want to be with them. I mean, I'm guessing
- 18:32deep down there's a lot of anger in you and the fact that you don't
- 18:36have access to that and it doesn't motivate you to do something about it.
- 18:41And I'm not saying you're supposed to smack them across the face. I'm saying,
- 18:44you know that anger of just like, no, I'm not going to
- 18:45live another day with this stupid situation. I don't want this. You know.
- 18:52The fact that you don't have access to that or it doesn't up,
- 18:55it doesn't well up within you the way it would for me, means that
- 18:59there's a problem, a whole number of circumstances in your life, past,
- 19:03present, future in which will harm you because you're not in touch with those
- 19:08feelings. So I think therapy would help. All right, let's take a
- 19:11break, all right. The next email is from anonymous middle tier patron.
- 19:19She wrote in and asked me to comment on a news story that's going around
- 19:25regarding a student at Antioch University where I teach, who is complaining about how
- 19:30woke the university is. And I mean, that's my summary of it.
- 19:36I don't know if that's how this individual would describe it. So for various
- 19:41legal and ethical reasons, I can't speak about this case in particular, of
- 19:44course, but what I will say in general is that there have been a
- 19:49handful of situations like this over the past three decades of my involvement with Antioch,
- 19:56and what I'll say is that, you know, and I've never been
- 20:02the target. Well I have been kind of the target of one of them,
- 20:07but not really. My point is is that I'm usually an outsider looking
- 20:11in and I'm curious about it. You know, I'll hear about a new
- 20:15story that will be circulating about one or more students who was saying they were
- 20:21mistreated by the university, maybe even by my program, and they might be
- 20:26suing the program or complaining about this and that. And what I'll say is
- 20:32that the dynamics are difficult because the student technically can say whatever they want unless
- 20:40they're lying, right, But if they are complaining about their experiences in class,
- 20:45they can speak publicly about those complaints, of course, because they have
- 20:49rights and freedom of speech. But as a university, we don't necessarily have
- 20:56and as professors, we don't necessarily have that freedom to publicly defend ourselves for
- 21:02a variety of ethical and legal reasons. So often what ends up happening is
- 21:06when you have a conflict between a student and a program or a student and
- 21:11a professor, and the student decides to go public. There's no counter story,
- 21:17there's no other side to the story that's being offered because of various different
- 21:22ethical, legal, and really marketing reasons because universities typically in my experience,
- 21:26don't want to get into that sort of public fighting back and forth with a
- 21:32student. So often what will happen is that if you are someone from the
- 21:37outside of the university and you're hearing this complaint and you don't hear any counter
- 21:42to the complaint, then it can be very convincing. Right. It's like,
- 21:45well, you have one story and you don't have any counter story,
- 21:49so it's more likely that you're going to believe that story. At least you're
- 21:55not given an opportunity to hear from the other side. Because universities are building
- 22:02up for is either you know, legal action which doesn't necessarily involve public uh
- 22:08you know statements, and also trying to protect themselves from a potential lawsuit in
- 22:15the future. You know, there's just a lot of reasons as why a
- 22:18student can complain about a university and be very convincing because the university is sort
- 22:25of hamstrung. You know, their hands are tied behind their back. So
- 22:29is this a situation like that. Maybe I don't know, it's not.
- 22:33I'm not involved in any of this drama, so I can't really tell on
- 22:38a completely unrelated note. What I will talk about now is the politics or
- 22:45the viewpoints of various different universities over time, and one of the things that
- 22:51well, i'll just speak from my own personal experience. So when I entered
- 22:55my master's program in the mid nineties, I was one of the only men,
- 23:00one of the only sis straight men, particularly in my program and in
- 23:06a number of courses. Of course, in a counseling program you're going to
- 23:10talk about sexism and bias, and there were discussions about those topics, and
- 23:15most of it was very enriching and very safe for me to participate in.
- 23:19But there would be times when I would feel hurt by some of the things
- 23:25that were being set And when I was twenty five twenty four years old,
- 23:29I didn't know what I know now, So I imagine some of that hurt
- 23:33as a student was actually not necessarily justified. You know, when you come
- 23:37from a privileged group and you hear the underprivileged, the victims of your privilege,
- 23:44speaking out against it, it can feel threatening because sometimes the language is
- 23:48absolute, like, well, you know, men, all they do is
- 23:52want to put women down right, and as a man, being myself,
- 23:56I would say, well, I don't want to put women down, and
- 24:00it's you know, the discourse around this can be confusing. Can one say,
- 24:06well, you know, men, they're trying to keep women down while
- 24:10also believing that a lot of men don't consciously want to keep women down,
- 24:14and maybe a lot of men are actually fighting to level the playing field so
- 24:18to be. Yeah, but sometimes the discourse requires, you know, kind
- 24:22of stark absolute statements, or it's appropriate to say some things, you know,
- 24:27depending, It really just depends. But anyway, so as a man,
- 24:32I would be hurt sometimes by some of the things that were said about
- 24:36my kind and it would upset me. But what do I do with that
- 24:41upset? Now, some of my upset was probably justified. I would agree
- 24:45with it today. Might someone back then had said something really unfair about men,
- 24:51like, well, you know, all men, all they want to
- 24:52do is sexually assault women all the time. That is completely empirically not true,
- 24:57And I'm offended and people believe I've heard people say such things and that's
- 25:03absurd and dehumanizing to me and awful and pigeonholing and just terrible and wrong.
- 25:12So might someone have said something like that back then. Yeah, I'm guessing
- 25:17someone did. So some of my hurt back then might have been as a
- 25:21student, might have been justified. Some of it might have been just a
- 25:23reaction of like realizing and facing my privilege, you know. So that is
- 25:30something that a lot of privileged individuals will experience when they enter into this,
- 25:37into a university, or into a situation where you're going to hear people talking
- 25:41about topics like this. And the way that I dealt with it was I
- 25:45just buried it. When I was hurt. I didn't speak up in class.
- 25:49I was too shy. I also knew I didn't know anything, and
- 25:53so I just thought, well, that doesn't sound right to me. But
- 25:56I don't know. I know, I don't know a lot of things.
- 26:00There was some benefit to me being twenty four and really not of that world
- 26:04of the psychology, social justice world that kept me very humble, I at
- 26:10least I hope so anyway, and so I just didn't say anything. I
- 26:14didn't do anything. And other people, though, might react differently, right,
- 26:18they might say, no, you can't say those things about my people.
- 26:22You know. Another venue or this would get talked about is around white
- 26:25people and people in discussions about racism will say, well, you know,
- 26:30white people, or things along those lines. You know, people are upset,
- 26:33they're hurt, they're angry about past racist acts that they've been victimized by
- 26:37by white people, and they will talk about it in a hurt angry way,
- 26:41which is natural. And so if you are a privileged white person,
- 26:47you are faced with that hurt of like, oh, they're talking about me,
- 26:51they're talking about my family, and they're talking about my people. How
- 26:55do I feel about that? Are they correct? Are they going too far?
- 27:00What's happening right now? What do I do? Some people will be
- 27:03quiet, like being Some people will process it in a healthy way, like
- 27:08just raising their hand and saying, I'm having some feelings of hurt and I
- 27:11don't know how to process that. You know, I don't know if it's
- 27:15just because I'm not used to hearing these things and I need to be kind
- 27:19of hurt in this way, or maybe I'm hurt because for legitimate reasons.
- 27:25I don't know. Can we talk about that? You know, that'd be
- 27:26a legitimate, healthy way to raise your hand. I was too shy and
- 27:30probably still am to say such a thing. But other people might get angry.
- 27:33They might say, no, you can't do that. You are giving
- 27:37in to the woke culture. You are too liberal, and this is a
- 27:44problem because the program is too political. You know, this kind of thing
- 27:48that will some people react that way. Yeah, I would say it's very
- 27:51rare that people will react that last way, but they can. And when
- 27:56you do that, you might kind of dig in right, and then you
- 28:00might come to find yourself in conflict with the whole entire program. Now,
- 28:04the other thing I'll say, as a professor at Antioch for many, many
- 28:08years, what I will say is that sometimes conflicts between students and professors,
- 28:15everyone's playing a role, and if you just hear the complaints, you might
- 28:21really it's well, I'll just say it's similar to couple therapy. A couple
- 28:25will come into my office and each will tell their side of the story,
- 28:30and as I'm listening to each side of the story, I am sympathizing with
- 28:33each side. Let's say it's a heterosexual couple. The wife is telling me,
- 28:37oh, he's so irresponsible on DDD, and I'm like, oh boy,
- 28:41that sounds rap like you sound wife, You sound like you're the reasonable
- 28:45one in Your husband is the jerk face. And then I listened to the
- 28:49husband and he's like, well, she's always criticizing me and yelling at me,
- 28:55and her expectations are always too high. And I'm like, oh,
- 28:59husband, you sound really reasonable, and she sounds really stern and unfair.
- 29:03So what's the real story, then, who's right who's wrong? Well,
- 29:07often it's because little conflicts were not dealt what we're not dealt with well in
- 29:12the beginning, and then that blossomed into a bigger problem. And so with
- 29:18students and professors or students and programs, often that's the case as well.
- 29:22I can't know individual situations, but often that is the case. For instance,
- 29:26as an example that will illustrate this, I'll give an example for my
- 29:30own life as a professor that I was dealing with directly. I'll change details
- 29:36or I won't give very many details to mass the the identities. But a
- 29:40student that I was working with a lot, many many years ago, she
- 29:45was found to have been committing some fairly egregious ethical violations as an intern.
- 29:51And when I tried to help her with it, I said, hey,
- 29:56you can't do this again, so I'm going to give you a second chance.
- 30:00So don't ever do this again. And then she did it again,
- 30:03and then I said, Okay, this is really the last chance. You
- 30:07can't ever do this again, so don't ever do this again. And then
- 30:11she did it again. And then I went back to her again. I
- 30:14said, if you do it one more time, I will have to take
- 30:18major action against you, maybe even kicking you out of the program. So
- 30:22don't ever do this again. And then she did it again, and then
- 30:25I kicked her out of the program. And then she sued the university and
- 30:29me, and she did not win because I had documented everything and it was
- 30:32all very cut and dry, and it was a sad moment for me.
- 30:36I never want to do that sort of thing. But they were egregious ethical
- 30:40violations. I had given her multiple chances. I had been very direct with
- 30:44her. I thought I was very fair with her. And the fact that
- 30:47she kept committing the same exact ethical violation every time, it wasn't even like
- 30:52a different ethical violation. There were other ethical violations. That was the other
- 30:56thing is, you know, as with the ethics cases that I will review,
- 31:00the problem is just the tip of the iceberg, the identified problem,
- 31:03you know, sort of like with al capone he was imprisoned because of tax
- 31:07evasion, but that's just the tip of the iceberg in terms of all the
- 31:11criminal acts that al Capone had committed. So it's similar with clinicians. When
- 31:15they commit an ethical violation that requires major action, it usually is not an
- 31:21anomaly that they have this one problem anyway. So the problem, though,
- 31:26if I could rewind the clock, was it began as a as a a
- 31:33seed was planted years prior to this with her that I think, if I
- 31:38were to summarize it, she was anxious and she didn't feel secure, and
- 31:45I think the way that she dealt with it was to try to cut corners
- 31:52or she might have It's hard to talk about this without going into specifics,
- 31:56but I just be as short as possible. I think if I could go
- 32:02on a time machine and go back to her at the beginning of the program
- 32:06and coach her along the way, I think she would have been better set
- 32:13up such that she wouldn't feel the need to commit the ethical violation. You
- 32:17know, it's like, why did she keep doing these kinds of things?
- 32:21Well, I think it was a problem that was building up over time that
- 32:27no one was aware of, and she wasn't making anyone aware of it,
- 32:30and I think it was anxiety related for her. So when we have these
- 32:34kinds of situations between students and professors, oftentimes what I find is that when
- 32:42I come on the CNAs program director for a while, and so I would
- 32:45get notified about these conflicts between students and professors, and so I'd be called
- 32:49in to fix the problem by both parties, and the kinds of complaints I
- 32:54would hear from both sides would be pretty severe. But from my experience as
- 32:59a professor, I surmised that if the two parties, the student and or
- 33:04the professor, had addressed the tension earlier on, then it wouldn't have blossomed
- 33:09into what it became. You know, when it comes to couple therapy,
- 33:13a marriage therapy, divorce, you know is a pretty rough situation. Sometimes
- 33:17there could be very angry divorces where it's like I hate you, I never
- 33:21want to see you, I can't believe I ever married you before. You
- 33:23know, there's a lot of resentment and hatred towards the other person. Well
- 33:28how did you get there? You know, there's these little steps along the
- 33:30way, and if you can trace yourself all the way back to the beginning
- 33:35of that. You know, in a marriage, maybe divorce was inevitable,
- 33:37but it didn't have to blossom into this this mega hatred of each other.
- 33:43You know. Well, sometimes when you have students and programs, that can
- 33:47happen as well. All right. The sext email is from good old patron
- 33:52Natasha from California. She says, Hey, Kirk, hope you're enjoying the
- 33:54Seattle summer. I'm I'm really listening to the Narcissistic Personnel short of Deep Dive
- 34:00and was wondering what specifically you disliked about it, So just chiming in.
- 34:04I said in a recent podcast that I listened to the rerun of the Narcissistic
- 34:08Personally Short podcast chapters, and I mean, I don't know what I said
- 34:14exactly, but I was kind of cringing at the beginning of the series,
- 34:19so I was wanting to maybe redo it. Going on with email, I
- 34:22realize it's a very long Deep Dive, so there's probably a lot you could
- 34:27say. But are there core themes you feel you missed? Thanks for reading
- 34:30end of email. Yeah, No, I don't think I missed core themes.
- 34:34Well, my understanding has Furthered since I made that series. So yeah,
- 34:40there's little nuances that I would like to add to. But from my
- 34:46memory when I was listening to the rerun, I remember just thinking I could
- 34:52tell so little peak beyond the curtain. When I am making a deep dive,
- 34:58in particular, I am sta wearing out my computer screen pretty much the
- 35:00entire time. I'm looking at an outline, and then I will go on
- 35:05tangents, but I always come back to the outline. Well, the outline
- 35:10is written in, often in a very long way, you know. It's
- 35:15not just like keywords like a power point. It's like long sentences that I've
- 35:21written out in my outline. And so one of the things that can happen
- 35:25to me if I'm not on the ball is that as I'm reading the outline
- 35:31subconsciously or in my mind, I'm also talking. I'm reading the outline with
- 35:37half of my brain and speaking with the other half of my brain, and
- 35:40I think when I do that, I end up rambling and also repeating myself
- 35:46a lot. Because another aspect of this outline process for me is I'll make
- 35:52the outline and the topic will be kind of in my head, and then
- 35:57I look at the outline as I'm talking, and then I'll get like to
- 36:00the first three bullet points out of ten, and then I'll think, oh,
- 36:05I should talk about that, Oh I should talk about that, and
- 36:07I'm sort of going off outline, you know, I'm going away from the
- 36:08outline, and then when I come back to the outline, I didn't realize
- 36:14that I addressed those tangents in the outline itself, so then I end up
- 36:16repeating certain points. So anyway, point is is that the beginning of narcissisic
- 36:22Personality Deep Deep Dive. I just didn't like the beginning, the first hour
- 36:28or something. I just felt like I was just off and I just want
- 36:31to redo that pretty much. All right, let's take a break. Okay,
- 36:38we're back from the break. Middle tier patron Mark from Brooklyn. He
- 36:42wrote in and said about three years ago, in the midst of the COVID
- 36:45lockdowns and social distancing, I discovered your podcast. Your Attachment Deep Dive was
- 36:51one of the few things I have ever read or listened to that I can
- 36:53honestly say was life changing. So I just want to begin this email by
- 36:58saying truly thank you for hosting this podcast and making psychology accessible for regular people.
- 37:02As it would turn out, your podcast has had such an impact on
- 37:06me that it inspired me to make a career change and become a therapist.
- 37:10I was thirty two and I applied to go back to school to study psychology
- 37:14as an undergraduate, and now I'm thirty five. I am staying for one
- 37:17more year to complete my bachelor's before moving on to grad school. Well,
- 37:22just chemming in here, Mark, that is fantastic news. I think we
- 37:25might have communicated at some point, but either way, Yeah, that is
- 37:30so honored that you would do that, and that you know I could have
- 37:34been a part of that journey. That's a huge honor. So thank you
- 37:37for that email. Going on with your email here, Okay, Now I
- 37:40have an actual question for you. I'll be applying for graduate programs in the
- 37:44fall. My GPA is three point nine. I have been volunteering as a
- 37:49research assistant, I was a teaching assistant this past semester, and I will
- 37:53be attending a clinical internship in the fall at a well known hospital here in
- 37:57New York City. So I feel confident about my ability to get the right
- 38:01to get into the right graduate program. Just chiming in here, Well,
- 38:06it depends mark what sort of graduate program you want to go into. I
- 38:08mean, certainly your experience will help with any program you apply to, but
- 38:14like my program at Antioch, we don't necessarily emphasize those kinds of experience things
- 38:21like as a research assistant. We are a clinical program. So although research
- 38:25assistants do, you learn certain skills, but they're not really necessarily translatable to
- 38:30being a therapist. You probably know how to read research better and how to
- 38:37understand it and integrate it better, which will help you clinically, but it
- 38:39won't necessarily help you with listening skills and social justice and that kind of stuff.
- 38:45Anyway, going on at the beginning of this past so what I say
- 38:49that, But I don't know what sort of programs you're going to apply to.
- 38:52If you're going to apply to like a regular master's program, that's one
- 38:54thing. If you're going to apply to be a psychologist, and a doctorate
- 38:58program is another thing. If you're going to apply to become a research psychologist,
- 39:02that's the whole other thing. At the beginning of the past spring semester,
- 39:07I felt dead set on trying to get into a PhD program for clinical
- 39:09psych because of my academic performance, but after talking to several professors, they
- 39:16mostly talked me out of it. As you mentioned on the podcast yourself,
- 39:21if your goal is to be a therapist, then there are not many reasons
- 39:24to pursue a doctorate. Yeah, that's true. They have also helped me
- 39:29to realize that even with my credentials, I am unlikely to be admitted into
- 39:32a PhD program without additional schooling and published research. Well, again, it
- 39:37depends on the sort of PhD program like at the University of Washington here in
- 39:42Seattle, if you try to apply to the PhD program in psychology and that's
- 39:46a non clinical research based program, then yeah, at the sort of higher
- 39:52end psychology doctorate programs, and again these are non clinical. Basically, you're
- 39:57learning how to do research on rap and humans and you're in that cycle of
- 40:02publish or parish and funding and all that kind of stuff, and you know,
- 40:07it's a it's a cool, exciting world in some ways, but not
- 40:10for me. Uh so, uh, there's that. But if you're applying
- 40:15to get into clinical PhD programs like a site E program is usually you know,
- 40:22a psychology doctorate program, then your background it won't hurt you by any
- 40:28means, but also won't necessarily help you because again, the site programs don't
- 40:32necessarily care if you have research experience. I mean maybe some do, and
- 40:37certainly we don't look at GPA very much. I can only speak from experience.
- 40:43In my program, we look at GPA, but you know, I
- 40:46would have people that would have like a two point five and their bachelor degree,
- 40:51but they got their bachelor's like twenty five years ago and it was in
- 40:53a different topic, you know, so it it kind of varies. But
- 40:58yeah, my guess is is that I don't know. If you're looking for
- 41:01a non clinical research based PhD program, I'm guessing there are clinical PhD programs
- 41:06that are highly sought after. I'm also guessing that in the Northeast, in
- 41:09New England, in New York City, there are elitist PhD programs. On
- 41:15the West Coast, we're more relaxed about those kinds of things. We don't
- 41:20have those kinds of institutions and those kind of traditions and that kind of elitism.
- 41:24I think that might be present out there, So I you know,
- 41:28it kind of depends on what you're looking for. But anyway, they help
- 41:31me to realize that even with my credentials, I am unlikely to be admitted
- 41:35into a PhD program. This realization has been somewhat demoralizing because I have been
- 41:38absolutely busting my ass for these past two years. But I understand why they
- 41:44are right. Well again, Mark, it depends on what you're busting your
- 41:46ass for. Maybe the rest of your email will explain. In light of
- 41:50that, I have been looking at some top mental health counseling programs in my
- 41:53area. So yeah, if you're looking at a mental health counseling master's program,
- 41:58you don't have to bust your ass to get get into those programs.
- 42:00That's a very different world. Typically, you know, Masters of Mental Health,
- 42:04or Masters of Social Work, or Masters of Marriage and Family Therapy,
- 42:06Masters accouncling. These programs are pretty easy to get into, and it largely
- 42:10depends on your interview and your essay and has much less to do with your
- 42:15GPA and the kinds of resume that you have, because most people can't have
- 42:22a resume that really applies to the program. You know, when I was
- 42:27looking at applicants in my program, the applicants, you know, maybe one
- 42:31out of twenty would have some sort of experience. Like if I had an
- 42:36applicant who was a nanny, for example, and had worked a lot with
- 42:39children, I actually considered that to be a pretty good indicator that they do
- 42:44what they were getting into and that they had some skills in working with kids
- 42:46and families. But you know, it's a far cry from being a therapist,
- 42:50but at least it was something in that direction, you know. So
- 42:53you know, someone can get a four oh in their bachelor's degree in psychology,
- 42:59and for me as a professor, when I would see that on the
- 43:00application, I'd be like, well, that doesn't necessarily mean there going to
- 43:04be a good student and a master's program. As a clinician, it's a
- 43:07very different world. And honestly, sometimes I would see people that had really
- 43:12good grades and I would admit them, and they weren't a good fit because
- 43:15they were more academically minded instead of human minded, you know, being a
- 43:20counselor being a therapist, it's much more loose and about humans and unmeasurable things
- 43:27like your bond and how good you make someone feel, that sort of thing.
- 43:30But anyway, so you say, in line of that, I've been
- 43:32looking at some top mental health. The other thing is is I wouldn't worry
- 43:36about top mental health counseling programs. I mean, I would avoid going to
- 43:40a shitty program. But anyone who says, oh, that's the top mental
- 43:45health counseling program, yeah, I would just be skeptical of those kinds of
- 43:49claims. And I've also said this before that ninety nine percent of what you
- 43:53will learn as a clinician will not happen in graduate school. Graduate school,
- 43:57you'll learn a lot, and it'll give you some you know, foundations,
- 44:00but it's just one step among thousands of steps regarding your development as a human
- 44:07being and as a clinician. So it doesn't you know, you could go
- 44:10to the shittiest mental health counseling program in your area and it's not going to
- 44:15affect things. The other thing is like, if you're going to be a
- 44:16clinician, clients don't give a shit. They don't care where you went to
- 44:20school. You know, I've been practicing for almost thirty years. I would
- 44:25bet that I've never been asked by a client where I went to school,
- 44:30or I would bet I've never even been asked by a client what my degree
- 44:34is. They just know that I'm you know, somehow calling myself a professional
- 44:38therapist. They might not even know. Does that mean I have a doctorate
- 44:43or a master's or a bachelor. They just don't know and they don't care.
- 44:47So, you know, thinking, and I think you're in a mindset
- 44:51of academia and elitism that might actually derail you in your ability to choose the
- 44:59best program what you need as a program that fits well with you. Like
- 45:01let's say that one of the mid tier counseling programs in your area is actually
- 45:07the one that you feel the most comfortable at. Well, I would tell
- 45:09you to go to the one that you feel the most comfortable at. Going
- 45:13on, but one professor who I have grown close to this semester, has
- 45:16been adamantly trying to get me out of going to that top mental health counseling
- 45:21program as well and encouraging me to go into social work instead. He has
- 45:25been very insistent on this. He keeps mentioning how social workers have a much
- 45:29better lobbying organization, how bad the lobbying organization is for counselors, how social
- 45:35workers have much better career opportunities, and how they get reimbursed significantly more and
- 45:39more often than counselors do for insurance even in private practice. I keep telling
- 45:45him my end goal is to open a private practice and I have little to
- 45:49no interest in casework and policy related course work. But he keeps doubling down
- 45:52and saying it won't matter after I graduate, and that I will learn to
- 45:55be a therapist on the job, and that the grad school curriculum doesn't matter.
- 46:00He did recommend Smith College to me because he knows I'm interested in a
- 46:04program with a psychodynamic orientation, but they are the only psychodynamic social work program
- 46:08I have been able to find, so just chiming in there. Yeah,
- 46:12it's hard to find programs that are actually oriented even towards any particular theory,
- 46:19let alone psychodynamic usually counts. Master's programs are there to teach you a variety
- 46:24of the theories, if not all of the main umbrella theories. So there's
- 46:30that. But you'll find that programs will tend to focus on certain things,
- 46:35basically because you have professors that like a certain thing, you know, like
- 46:38people that went to my university and took a lot of classes with me were
- 46:43exposed to a lot of psychodynamic and attachment oriented theory and would have left the
- 46:47university with a lot of knowledge with that, But that was just because they
- 46:51took up a lot of classes with me. If they didn't take any classes
- 46:53with me, that they might not have had any psychodynamic or any attachment oriented
- 46:58talk. So it just kind of depends on the program. Some programs are
- 47:00more buttoned up about that. We need to make sure we really hammer this
- 47:05idea into people. Going out to email. After some googling and Internet research,
- 47:08I have found a lot of people who seem to agree with him.
- 47:10There are tons of threads where people are being talked out of attending counseling programs.
- 47:15I also read that some of the psychoanalytic institutes in New York City don't
- 47:20accept counselors into their programs. Is my professor right, Well, a counseling
- 47:23degree really limit my work opportunities, ability to accept insurance, and ability to
- 47:28attend psychoanalytic institute in the future. End of email. Well, the problem
- 47:32here, Mark is that, like I was saying earlier, there's a huge
- 47:36divide between the West Coast and the northeast. So I don't really know I
- 47:40know enough about the difference between the West Coast and Northeast to know that the
- 47:45Northeast does have a long tradition of this bifurcation or something between psychologists, psychiatrists,
- 47:54social workers, and then everyone else, whereas on the West Coast,
- 47:59social workers are the way that you are talking about them initially, you know
- 48:02where they're more. Not only are they somewhat trained in being a therapist,
- 48:07but they're also trained on casework and policy related coursework and other kinds you know,
- 48:10other kinds of teamwork, like working in a hospital. And so if
- 48:15someone was in Seattle and they wanted to be in private practice, I would
- 48:17not recommend that they get a degree in social work. Now, could you,
- 48:22as your professor says, get a degree in social work and have it
- 48:24work out find Yeah. Absolutely. I know many of licensed clinical social workers
- 48:29who are fantastic therapists. I've had one of my primary therapists that I've had
- 48:34over the years is a social worker. So, like I was saying earlier,
- 48:37your graduate program doesn't have a lot to do with where you end up
- 48:42five, ten, twenty years later into your career. So I would I
- 48:46guess I would listen to the people around you know, there's a chance if
- 48:50you if you plan on staying in the Northeast. There's a chance that the
- 48:52advice that I give about that topic is not applicable to you, you know.
- 48:58Having said that, they're people all over the world that will email in.
- 49:01If you're in Britain, if you're in Australia, if you're in Ireland,
- 49:05or if you're in Germany. There's a whole different Japan. There's a
- 49:07whole different system in these other countries. And I guess one could say that
- 49:12there's a significantly different system between the West Coast and the northeast. There's also
- 49:16a significantly different system between California and Washington and Oregon. You know, California
- 49:22has this whole other system that is kind of odd and oriented towards marriage and
- 49:25family therapy. So anyway, but I would be skeptical about someone, you
- 49:31know, I don't know. I don't live in your area. I don't
- 49:34know a lot of clinicians in your area. But I'm skeptical of the statement
- 49:37that if you get a counseling masters that it would be significantly worse in the
- 49:45end, you know, But I don't know. So maybe I would ask
- 49:49around for more opinions, maybe even ask for the reimbursement rates that the insurance
- 49:55will give a for an you know, usually it's like a fifty minute session,
- 50:00five minute session. Asking the local and you know a couple insurance companies
- 50:04local like the Blue Cross, Blue Shield, and ask them what is your
- 50:07reimbursement rate for fifty five minute counseling session versus a fifty five minute social work
- 50:13counseling session, and maybe get some data around that. I don't know.
- 50:16I don't know, but so I don't know how helpful I am. It
- 50:22also depends on where you stand on where you plan on practicing. Right,
- 50:24if you plan on practicing in the Northeast, and I would listen to professionals
- 50:28out there, But if you plan on practicing anywhere else the United States,
- 50:30you know, in my anecdotal and I looked into this a lot as well
- 50:35in terms of research, my understanding the last I looked at the data was
- 50:38that counselors around the country are highly respected as our marriage family therapists, as
- 50:44our social workers. So this idea that you would be worse off by being
- 50:46counselor just doesn't make a lot of sense to me. But who knows,
- 50:49I don't know. I guess my answer is, I don't know. Right.
- 50:52The sext email is from anonymous middle tier patrons. She says, have
- 50:55you ever been friends with someone who could be labeled as an abuser? I've
- 51:00been watching your videos on Ed and Liz about not getting triangulated, staying differentiated,
- 51:06and listening more instead of advising. So just chiming in here if you
- 51:09don't watch these shows with me. There's a couple on ninety Day fiance Ed
- 51:14and Liz, and from the way it looks, it looks like Ed is
- 51:19a emotional and verbal abuser of Liz, maybe even a gaslighter of Liz.
- 51:25It's not severe severe, but it's notable. And it appears that Ed gets
- 51:31threatened and insecure pretty easily with jealousy and then he resorts to this calm attack
- 51:39that he will exhibit to Liz. And Liz has a lot of issues in
- 51:45her childhood that makes it harder for her to push back, but she does
- 51:47push back sometimes anyway, And so sometimes I don't know exactly what the patrons
- 51:53talking about, but I was probably talking about how it's easy to be convinced
- 52:00by one side or the other, to get triangulated, to get pulled in,
- 52:04and that if you want to be helpful to the couple and yourself.
- 52:07Then remaining differentiated is important. So going on which I understand to be good
- 52:14advice to not get triangulated. But my friend is in a mutually toxic relationship
- 52:20and I don't know what to do. When my one friend asked directly for
- 52:24my advice, I don't know what to say. End of email. Okay,
- 52:29So you're saying that you have a friend who's in a mutually toxic relationship
- 52:34and your friend is like, hey, what do I do? And you
- 52:37feel the compulsion to give advice, probably advice like hey, you should probably
- 52:43break up or you should draw boundaries or something, and your friend is saying,
- 52:49hey, you know, I don't know what to do. Tell me
- 52:51what to do? You know. One thing to think about is that when
- 52:54you actually look at the situation, sometimes your friend might actually not be directly
- 53:00asking for advice. They might just be venting and it might feel like they're
- 53:04asking for advice, but they're not actually consciously asking for advice. But let's
- 53:12just assume that your friend is actually asking for advice, and now providing advice
- 53:16doesn't mean that you're being dysfunctionally triangulated. The fact that you're listening to your
- 53:22friend, means you're already being triangulated to some extent. Right, it's just
- 53:25a matter of what you do with that triangulation. So, for example,
- 53:30if I had a friend that came to me and said, oh, and
- 53:34it was just like years and years of this, they're just saying, oh,
- 53:37you know, I had another fight with my partner, and you know,
- 53:38we're fighting all the time, and he just never listens to me,
- 53:43and he stays out all night and drinks I don't know even know what he
- 53:45might be cheating on me or something, you know, and I would feel
- 53:49bad for my friend. I'd feel hurt and angry for my friend, and
- 53:52I'd say, like, you know, you don't have to deal with this
- 53:53ship. You should be able to leave. And I would feel that urge
- 53:58to say that sort of thing. But I hope I would know that notion
- 54:01has occurred. I mean, that's That's the thing you always want to check
- 54:04in with yourself is ask yourself this question before you give device. Is it
- 54:07probable that the person has already thought of this? Because if they've already thought
- 54:12of it, then why do you think they need to be told that sort
- 54:15of stuff? You know, of course, in my situation the example that
- 54:19I'm giving, my friend knows that she can break up with her partner.
- 54:22She knows that, So why do I think it's important that I say that
- 54:27out loud? It doesn't make any sense, right, So, and there's
- 54:29a lot of different situations. But I would check in with myself and say,
- 54:32I have an urge to tell her to break up. I wish for
- 54:36her to break up, and that's my issue, not her issue. Okay,
- 54:38what do I do with that? Well, I have to put that
- 54:42aside for now, and then I would try to refocus on how can I
- 54:46be a good friend? Okay, not how can I fix the problem,
- 54:50but how can I be a good friend? And that's a very different point
- 54:53of view, hopefully, So if I'm going to be a good friend,
- 54:58well, a good friend doesn't offer for stupid pieces of advice that are obvious.
- 55:01A good friend is there listening. A good friend provides empathy. So
- 55:07I might say something like, especially if my friend is literally asking me please
- 55:10tell me what to do, what would you do? I would say something
- 55:13like, yeah, I mean it sounds like a really difficult situation. I
- 55:17mean, obviously you can break up if you want to, but you know,
- 55:20I think it's more complicated than that. But all I can say is
- 55:23I appreciate just how difficult the situation is. I'm guessing that you do have
- 55:29affection for your partner and that's what keeps you in it. I'm guessing there
- 55:31are pros and cons and it's a conundrum. You know, how do you
- 55:36know when to leave? How do you know when to stay? And also
- 55:39it sounds like he's really hurting you, and there's a lot of hurt maybe
- 55:44going both ways. You know, it just makes me sad to hear that
- 55:47about your life. I'm sad for you, and you know I'm with you
- 55:52and I'm here for you in whatever way you want me to be here.
- 55:53You know, things like that that I mean, it's kind of cheesy what
- 55:55I'm saying, but you know, along those lines, right, I'm being
- 55:59more tentative. I'm not giving advice. I'm speaking from the heart. I'm
- 56:02empathizing. I am reflecting back to them that I hear them, that I
- 56:07appreciate there. You know, that's why people tend to go to therapists,
- 56:12because therapists are more likely to do this kind of thing, because friends are
- 56:15not very good at doing this kind of thing. Therapists are much better at
- 56:19being able to empathize and speak in a more tentative, humble, caring way
- 56:24rather than just jumping to a piece of advice. You know, you talk
- 56:29to someone else, you know, say this woman is talking to her other
- 56:31friend. The other friend might just be like, you need to leave.
- 56:35What's wrong with you? You're you're in a toxic relationship. You know.
- 56:37There can be some shaming involved, like I can't believe you're constantly burdening me
- 56:43with this, like just shit or get off the pot kind of a thing.
- 56:45And that's why people go to therapist because they hopefully are trained and know
- 56:52that that's not really what's going to help. But it's not what the person
- 56:54wants. It's not really what's going to help them to move on to the
- 56:58next step. Sometimes we will prompt people to take action is if they are
- 57:02finally heard and understood by at least somebody, you know. Sometimes you have
- 57:07to start from the ground level of just like you are understood, I understand
- 57:12you, I see you, I recognize what's happening for you. I validate
- 57:15your feelings. And then once they have that under their belt, then the
- 57:20person can actually take action, maybe breaking up or maybe not or asserting themselves
- 57:23or something. So that's how I do it. You know your question,
- 57:30patron, You're like, you know, have you ever been friends with someone
- 57:32who could be labeled as an abuser? Because well, actually that's a bit
- 57:37different of a question now that I'm looking at it. So if my friend
- 57:40was the abuser, because you said mutually toxic, but if my friend was
- 57:45the toxic person, Okay, well that's a little different. Similar, But
- 57:51so if if I had a friend that was giving me indications or well,
- 57:57I've been in these shoes. I've had friends who I have, at least
- 58:01in my head, labeled as being abusive to their partners, not physically but
- 58:07verbally abusive and I, you know, sort of dominant, and I see
- 58:14if they came to me, well, it depends on their relationship. But
- 58:16I can think of one relationship where I have. I had a friend who
- 58:22I observed, you know, a couple of decades ago, to be abusive
- 58:25to his wife verbally, and the first couple of times I saw it,
- 58:30I was like, what was that? Because it was different than his normal
- 58:35behavior. The way he treated his wife was very different than his other kinds
- 58:38of behavior, and I didn't really know what to do with it. But
- 58:42over time it happened repeatedly, and so I don't know exactly how it came
- 58:46up, but it just sort of randomly came up in conversation and I said,
- 58:50well, you know, i'll tell you I think you're I don't think
- 58:52I used the word abuse, but I think I used the word sexist or
- 58:57overpowering or uncaring or something, you know. I think I said something like,
- 59:02you know, sometimes you can be pretty harsh with your wife, and
- 59:06I don't know what's going on there. It sounds like you're getting triggered at
- 59:08times, but you talk to her in a way that you don't talk to
- 59:12other people. And you know, I'm not his therapists, so we don't
- 59:16have that kind of venue to necessarily dive deep into that sort of thing.
- 59:22But but that's what I would say, and I, you know, at
- 59:24the time, and I think I correctly surmise that it wouldn't ruin our relationship.
- 59:30You know, I could say that and not have him say, well,
- 59:35I hate you now that kind of thing. So I was trying to
- 59:37help. I was trying to help him and her by telling him that he
- 59:43needs to look at the way that he treats her. You know, So,
- 59:45whether you're a friend or a therapist and someone is coming to you for
- 59:50help, the key is always to keep your eye on what do you think
- 59:53will help? Because I ran it, you know, and any student of
- 59:58mine knows that the matter I kept saying was do what is helpful, Do
- 1:00:02what is helpful, because so much of learning how to be a therapist feels
- 1:00:07like you're learning rules like, oh, you never do this, and you
- 1:00:10always do this. And I would try to break that from my trainees by
- 1:00:15saying, there's no endeavors and always in therapy, there's there's only that you
- 1:00:21need to try to be helpful. And you know, like there'll be these
- 1:00:24things like you never cross your legs in therapy, or never accept a gift
- 1:00:29in therapy, And what I'll say is is that, well, in general,
- 1:00:34it probably isn't helpful to accept gifts from clients, but sometimes it might
- 1:00:37actually be helpful to accept a gift from a client. And so you need
- 1:00:43to do what is helpful. And in the moment, you probably are the
- 1:00:45only one who knows whether or not it's going to be helpful. And you
- 1:00:47can make justifications for it when in doubt, take the easier, more safe
- 1:00:52route by not accepting the gift. But you know, people will say like,
- 1:00:57well, is it okay if I do this? Or what if this
- 1:01:00happens? Or what am I supposed to do when this happens? And I
- 1:01:01would say, well, what do you think will help? What do you
- 1:01:04think will help? What do you think will help? Be helpful? So,
- 1:01:07when your friend comes to you and they are determined by you to be
- 1:01:13abusive and they're asking for advice, do what is helpful. Don't do what
- 1:01:16you think is the right way to do it, because that can actually be
- 1:01:21unhelpful. You know, these sort of rules like don't get triangulated are only
- 1:01:25there. They're not rules. They're just guidelines on how to be helpful to
- 1:01:30everyone, how to create the best outcome. Okay, So, if your
- 1:01:35friend comes to you and it would be helpful to confront them, then confront
- 1:01:38them. If it won't be helpful to confront them, then don't confront them.
- 1:01:43If it's helpful to give them advice, like, hey, I think
- 1:01:46you're being abusive and I advise you not to do that, And you think
- 1:01:53that your friend will hear that somewhat, or it'll plan a seed or something.
- 1:02:00Maybe you do that, but if you think he's not going to listen,
- 1:02:04or he's going to misinterpret you, or it's going to cause a whole
- 1:02:07other problem, like now there's a conflict between you and your friend, then
- 1:02:10that's not necessarily the best course of action. So yeah, that's what I'll
- 1:02:14say about that. All Right, Well, that does it for that episode
- 1:02:17of psychology in Seattle. I feel like we were talking about a lot of
- 1:02:21random things in this episode, and hopefully by the next time I'm podcasting,
- 1:02:25I will be over this cold. And everyone please take care of yourself because
- 1:02:29you deserve it, You really really do.