Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / From the Base to Capitol Hill: Advocating for Credit Unions with Jason Stverak of DCUC
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:02episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm excited today to be here with Jason Sterk, the Defense Credit Union
- 0:08counsel, chief Advocacy Officer.
- 0:11Jason, how are you doing this morning?
- 0:12I'm doing great.
- 0:13Mark, yourself.
- 0:14I'm doing great.
- 0:15I'm down in Hollywood, Florida.
- 0:17The sun is shining, and I reached out to you last week.
- 0:20I've, you've been pretty active, the world's been active, but you've
- 0:23been having some really cool posts on LinkedIn and some really nice
- 0:26things that you're doing for credit unions in general and for DCUC.
- 0:30So I wa I thought it'd be good.
- 0:31We haven't chatted in a while.
- 0:32I thought it'd be good to catch up and talk about some hot topics.
- 0:36Absolutely,
- 0:36Jason Stverak: Look forward to talking to you and your listeners.
- 0:38Treichel: Yeah, very good.
- 0:39And for a listener who may not be aware of DC uc, and what it is you're doing, if you
- 0:44could give a summary of the organization and your role and in the organization.
- 0:49Jason Stverak: Yeah, happily DC uc or the Defense Credit Union Council
- 0:52is the pro Predo is the preeminent voice for defense and veterans credit
- 0:57unions all across the industry.
- 0:59We're going pa into our 61st year of being in existence.
- 1:03But we have been advocating primarily on behalf of defense related credit unions.
- 1:09And if you go back in time, those were the ones that were just on base.
- 1:13Or on the military installation, but as the credit union industry has
- 1:16changed, credit unions have grown, defense credit unions have grown,
- 1:19off base to serve more people.
- 1:21We've expanded our reach as in terms of our advocacy priorities because we like
- 1:26to say we represent every credit union because every credit union has a veteran.
- 1:30And we're very proud of that.
- 1:32And we look forward to continually growing our.
- 1:36Advocacy efforts 'cause the issues that impact your credit union impact
- 1:40defense credit unions as well.
- 1:42Treichel: I think that's a great point to make, especially, I'm sure
- 1:45you were over at America's Credit Union's, G-A-C-A-A, as was I.
- 1:50And, NAFCU and Q emerged which is generally viewed as a good thing, but one
- 1:55of the aspects of that is there's one less voice, one less letter writer to Congress.
- 2:00And I think it's important to hear from d different perspectives and I think that's
- 2:04something that DC uc has always done, but you can fill a little bit of a void there.
- 2:09I.
- 2:10With there being one less trade association out there, I think the
- 2:13importance of those that are left is even that much more important.
- 2:16Jason Stverak: Obviously I agree with you a hundred percent, mark.
- 2:19And, the phrase iron sharpens irons is incredibly important.
- 2:22But the ability for the different voices.
- 2:25In the credit union movement we may sing the same song but we need multiple
- 2:30voices working on behalf of the movement.
- 2:32And we're proud to speak on behalf of our defense related credit unions
- 2:36and veterans related credit unions.
- 2:38But we're not afraid to talk about issues that impact every credit union
- 2:43from my home area of the Dakotas.
- 2:46We worked with just an example with Dax eu to work on letters to the Senate Ag
- 2:51Committee and in the House Ag Committee in relation to what we can do to help open up
- 2:56access to capital in rural America and the issues that every credit union has with
- 3:00farm credit services in rural America.
- 3:03Treichel: Very good.
- 3:03It's funny that you with that connection, you just reminded me of something.
- 3:06So when I started at NCA back in 1986, I had parts of South Dakota
- 3:11and North Dakota in my district.
- 3:13Jason Stverak: Oh, fantastic.
- 3:14Treichel: And I remember a credit union that shall rename
- 3:16nameless a really good one.
- 3:18And they shared they had a building and they shared it with Farm Credit Services.
- 3:22They had a lease, a long-term lease with Farm Credit services,
- 3:25and it, they really played a good positive role in that community.
- 3:28So I hadn't thought about that place in a while.
- 3:30Jason Stverak: No, absolutely.
- 3:31And you, some people say when they talk about the Dakotas,
- 3:33they call it fly over country.
- 3:34I just call it home amen.
- 3:36Treichel: Amen.
- 3:37Very good.
- 3:37Very good.
- 3:38So interesting times we're living in, with the new administration and what
- 3:41that means and what it doesn't mean.
- 3:43But there's also some things that are out there that kind of
- 3:46intertwine with the administration.
- 3:48Some things that were going on before Trump took office and one of
- 3:52those that I wanted to mention, and you had a really nice post on this
- 3:55the other day the Durban Marshall Bill, also known as the credit card.
- 4:01Competition act.
- 4:02Yep.
- 4:02And that relates to interchange income.
- 4:04If you could tee that up, what that.
- 4:07Bill is supposed to do what it really does and how it in my opinion,
- 4:11and I think in your opinion, it's gonna be harmful to credit unions.
- 4:15But if you could walk through that, I think that'd be great.
- 4:17Jason Stverak: Yeah.
- 4:17Obviously the Creditor Competition Act impacts interchange and I'll give the,
- 4:22the higher level discussion of that and it's negative impact specifically
- 4:26to defense credit unions, but the entire credit union industry that.
- 4:31When we go and use our credit cards, I'm not talking debit,
- 4:33I'm talking credit cards.
- 4:35The majority of Americans want safe and secure transactions and what we have
- 4:39in the Durban Marshall Amendment is a.
- 4:42Move by government to force a additional, payment networks to
- 4:48come in and dramatically impact the interchange revenue that your
- 4:53local credit union's gonna have.
- 4:55And where that specifically impacts defense credit unions is that many of
- 5:00the individuals as they're coming into the military, 18, 19, 20-year-old kids,
- 5:04let's be honest with that's what they are.
- 5:06Don't have a credit history or may have a, made some poor
- 5:09choices in their teenage years.
- 5:11And they walk into the local credit union, just say, you know what?
- 5:14I need a credit card, a $500 limit, a thousand dollars limit just
- 5:17to be able to handle expenses.
- 5:19And interchange allows defense credit unions.
- 5:23To take a risk on that individual and there can be no higher
- 5:26calling for a credit union, specifically a defense credit union.
- 5:30For those that are willing to, on their own, make the choice to serve our
- 5:34nation, they are worth us as financial institutions to say, you know what?
- 5:39We're gonna make sure that if your car breaks down, you're gonna have enough.
- 5:43Access to capital, that's what it is.
- 5:46Access to capital on your credit card to be able to make those payments
- 5:50or to be able to make sure that you can get groceries for the week.
- 5:52Because, the sad fact is that many of those at the E four, that type
- 5:56of level of enlisted personnel they're at the poverty level.
- 6:00A lot of 'em are on food stamps.
- 6:01So that minimal access to capital that defense credit unions can provide for them
- 6:06is sometimes the the difference between making it or not making it that month.
- 6:11And if you, we don't have those resources, we're not gonna be able to take that
- 6:17risk on the person who has a slightly.
- 6:20Le less than ideal credit score or no credit score.
- 6:24And we're gonna say, you know what?
- 6:25We don't think you're worthy to serve.
- 6:28Go out the front gate to the payday loan lenders and pay four, 500, 6% interest.
- 6:33And we're just putting them in a cycle of debt.
- 6:35And that's wrong.
- 6:37And that's why we're fighting so hard to ensure that.
- 6:40Every credit union has the resources it needs to be able to serve those
- 6:44that others have left behind or are just starting to enter, the
- 6:48American financial lifecycle,
- 6:51Treichel: And that, that's very well said.
- 6:53And as you're thinking that, I'm thinking about, the.
- 6:57The theoretical discussion about just the concept fees are bad.
- 7:00It's easy to think fees are bad, we, fees should be lower without
- 7:04thinking about the ramifications of those fees on the real world.
- 7:08And there's no more real world than the person you just described who's trying to
- 7:12get started trying to defend this country.
- 7:15And those fees.
- 7:17Serve a purpose.
- 7:18They create the infrastructure so that the credit unions are able to provide
- 7:22that service and that if there is a loss or there are costs associated with
- 7:26it, and oh, by the way, the staff that they have, the credit unions have to
- 7:29hire to operate that program, whether it's the accounting side or whether it's
- 7:34dealing with, visa or whoever directly the inflation on those folks, right?
- 7:39So you got the inflation driving up the salaries of the folks administering
- 7:42it, and you've got this law.
- 7:44Proposing taking away the fees that in reality subsidize it.
- 7:49And it the whole junk fee concept is linked to this.
- 7:53And they may not directly be linked, but they are linked in my mind.
- 7:57Jason Stverak: They, no, mark, they are linked.
- 7:58They're a part of the threat or, the, the pressure on non-interest
- 8:02bearing income for credit unions, and.
- 8:05I was on a call when I was at a CU with then CFEP, director Chopra, and
- 8:10we were talking overdraft and we were talking, the, the driving down overdraft
- 8:14fees and limiting them and the and the comment was made you can just
- 8:18make it up on credit card interest.
- 8:19And it's at some point.
- 8:22E the more you take away from revenue streams that you're gonna have to cut
- 8:27somewhere, you're gonna cut in terms of branches being open, hours being served,
- 8:32programs being offered, et cetera.
- 8:34When dur, we call it Durbin 1.0,
- 8:36this is, going back, 2010 and they did this for debit card.
- 8:40And they promised it's not gonna be a reduction in service.
- 8:44Free checking's not gonna go away.
- 8:45Rewards are not gonna go away for debit cards.
- 8:48Money's gonna be passed on to the consumer and all those things.
- 8:51Never ha it never came to fruition.
- 8:54You've got the, the Richmond Fed coming out with a study that there were no
- 8:57cost savings passed along, et cetera.
- 8:59It's, we have empirical evidence that the promises made now by the Durban 2.0
- 9:04supporters, senators Marshall and Senators Durban are not gonna come to fruition.
- 9:09And for many people, the kind of the, not the dirty little secret, but the
- 9:12kind of unheard of is that for defense credit unions, they lose money having.
- 9:18A branch on base because, because of security, there's no foot traffic,
- 9:24there's just the members that you know.
- 9:26And so there, there a fully staffed, fully operational branch of the
- 9:32credit union that might have four or five people walk through or, 10
- 9:36cars drive through, the drive through with the tellers, but they're there.
- 9:40It is a lost leader because they believe it is.
- 9:44Their boards of directors and their members and their leadership believes that
- 9:47it is their obligation their commitment to service to so that, that airman or
- 9:52that marine who gets off at four and they need to get, they, they need to get cash
- 9:57to pay the babysitter on their way home.
- 9:59They're gonna be there till five or six if you take away interchange, if you take
- 10:03away other, additional revenue streams.
- 10:07You're gonna force that credit union say, you know what?
- 10:09We're only open two days a week.
- 10:10We're only gonna be open from nine to three.
- 10:13And what that does, ultimately, let's keep walking those dominoes as they're
- 10:17falling, is that you're creating additional stress on an individual that
- 10:21serves in the military who may within 24 hours notice, be deployed and then.
- 10:28Honey, you need, you gotta tell your spouse, your husband, your
- 10:31wife or partner hey, you gotta go down and make the mortgage payment.
- 10:35It's not open.
- 10:35Who I need to call somebody, I've gotta get everything ordered.
- 10:38There's nobody there.
- 10:38The call center got closed down 'cause they don't have the resources.
- 10:41There's the unintended consequences of this are mind boggling.
- 10:45My, my are numbing as well in that, financial readiness for defense
- 10:51credit unions is military readiness.
- 10:54If you're deployed let's go an example, it's in the news.
- 10:56I'm not breaking any news here.
- 10:57News, you deployed seven B twos from Whiteman Air Force Base out of Missouri.
- 11:03So you've got seven crews who have may or may not families on base.
- 11:07There's the defense credit union.
- 11:09You're told to go, may don't know the amount of lead up time that you had.
- 11:13They've been deployed over to Diego Garcia in the middle of the Indian Ocean.
- 11:17Not, I'm fairly confident there's not a branch there of their credit
- 11:20union, but they can feel confident that their local defense credit union
- 11:24on base, they, somebody from their family walks in, they'll take care of
- 11:28'em and they'll be there as long as they need them to be there because.
- 11:32Interchange, and I know I'm circling it back.
- 11:35Interchange allows them the resources they need to ensure that, it is a
- 11:40political, the political term kicked around for the Bush administration.
- 11:43No one is left behind, right?
- 11:44And no one of the military, starting with the active duty to their families
- 11:50is forgotten or missed as that.
- 11:56Service member deploy so that they can focus on doing their job and
- 12:00in some instances staying alive.
- 12:02And they don't have to worry about, hey is it can my is the
- 12:06mortgage payment gonna be made?
- 12:07Is the credit card gonna be being made?
- 12:09Is someone gonna work?
- 12:10We've got coming up and, we got people worrying about.
- 12:12I gotta make sure my taxes are filed in time, those, and the credit union becomes
- 12:16that, that flag, that main tent flag pole tent post where all of those financial
- 12:22readiness issues come together and and it starts with having the resources to
- 12:26do it, and it gets back to interchange.
- 12:28Treichel: No, that's very well said.
- 12:30That was a great summary of how it impacts the military credit unions in particular.
- 12:35And you touched upon the overdraft protection as well and, the lack
- 12:39of the interchange can cause things that trigger services to dry up
- 12:43and push towards payday lending.
- 12:44Same can happen with overact draft protection.
- 12:48A lot going on with the capping of the fees to the Trump administration,
- 12:51trying to blow that up to the NCA board under Biden saying the
- 12:56large credit unions need to pro.
- 12:58Report more ul, excuse me, report more granular information to chairman Halman,
- 13:04then saying we a reverse on that to, to Harper and ska taking not offense to
- 13:08that to saying that pivot doesn't make sense and there should be transparency.
- 13:13Any more thoughts on any of those?
- 13:15Tentacles related to overdraft protection as it relates to defense, credit unions.
- 13:20And, no,
- 13:21Jason Stverak: We're very happy that the, the Congress is moving
- 13:26forward with the Congressional Review Act, repeal of the CFBs overdraft
- 13:30protection, overdraft lowering it to $5.
- 13:33And granted, I the argument on the counter size this only
- 13:36impacts 10 billion above, but.
- 13:38It impacts the entire industry.
- 13:40If you're if it's pen fed and you at the local credit union, across the
- 13:44street or across town, if they've got a $5 overdraft fee, you gotta match it.
- 13:47That, that's competition.
- 13:49Absolutely.
- 13:49Everyone can understand that.
- 13:50Absolutely.
- 13:50So $5 for them is $5 for you.
- 13:53The Senate Banking, housing and Urban Affairs chairman Tim Scott.
- 13:56Introduce sj Senate Joint Resolution 18, which would and by an act
- 14:02of Congress roll this back.
- 14:03It passed the Senate last week.
- 14:05It is expect it is scheduled to be on the house floor this week.
- 14:09We expect that it will pass, then be signed into the law by the president.
- 14:12We think this is a good thing.
- 14:14The decision on what an accredit union's overdraft program should
- 14:19be decided by the members.
- 14:20We're democratically controlled.
- 14:22We have credit unions that have eliminated the fees.
- 14:24We have credit unions that have dramatically lowered them because
- 14:28that is what that credit union and its members believed is the best policy
- 14:33because they've had to make that choice.
- 14:34If we don't have overdraft fees, how are we gonna make sure we have
- 14:37the revenue as we discussed earlier?
- 14:39Keep the doors open, handle these programs.
- 14:41They said that was best for their communities.
- 14:43And y you know what?
- 14:45The great thing I is about the Overdrive programs with credit unions
- 14:49is that you have to opt into 'em.
- 14:52They're fully disco disclosed.
- 14:54It's when you set up your account, you can ask for it.
- 14:56They explain it to you.
- 14:58But the one thing that nobody really talks about, and I'm guess I'm dating myself
- 15:02here, that with my gray hair is that I can remember a time going to my local
- 15:06grocery store back home in South Dakota where there would be a list of people
- 15:10that says, do not accept a check from.
- 15:13And your name.
- 15:14So here's here's the question you wanna ask yourself.
- 15:17Do you wanna go back to that situation?
- 15:20Or do you want an individual who is, four 30 on a Friday, is
- 15:25trying to, use their debit card to buy groceries for the weekend.
- 15:29Might have just miscalculated or doesn't have enough funds
- 15:33that you want it to go through.
- 15:36Then there's no issue, no embarrassment, nobody's called out, and then there's a
- 15:40fee associated with that you've agreed to.
- 15:43I would rather have that than the, what, you need to return all the items and and
- 15:47have that if you're a credit union, you wanna be known as the credit union that
- 15:51prevents people from buying groceries.
- 15:53Nobody does, no community bank does, in, in all honesty, I'm sure
- 15:56even Chase doesn't, we, we can have that discussion at a later point.
- 16:01If you support doing away with all overdraft fees, are you
- 16:05prepared for the replacement?
- 16:07Because what will have to happen is that you're not gonna allow
- 16:10your account to be overdrawn.
- 16:11That just makes sense.
- 16:13And are you prepared to return to that part?
- 16:17Or return to that system and for I think mo majority of Americans, but most
- 16:21importantly for the majority of credit union members, boards of directors and
- 16:24credit union champions and leaders.
- 16:26No, that's not what we want to do.
- 16:28We have a, we have something that I think the latest polling or data
- 16:32released, even last week was over two thirds of the people in this country.
- 16:36Are happy with overdraft.
- 16:38I know credit unions, from PenFed and others, they have if they see
- 16:42you having, multiple sit down with you, give them a call give you
- 16:46financial training, is there an issue?
- 16:48I've seen I know there are defense credit unions Hey, the payroll changed.
- 16:51The spouse.
- 16:52So they had their bills on autopay, but they didn't change it when
- 16:56the new pay, change in when the money was being deposited in the
- 16:59account, they were getting hit.
- 17:00So it's hey, let's help make that change for you.
- 17:02And there are some people who just need some budgeting help.
- 17:04We used, I, when I was in high school, I had two economics courses and we
- 17:08did, how do you balance your checkbook?
- 17:10Some of that stuff is not taught anymore.
- 17:12So the credit unions have stepped in particularly defense credit
- 17:16unions to provide that training.
- 17:18And one of the, one of the obligations we have to serve on base is to provide
- 17:23free financial literacy training for anybody who walks in the door.
- 17:26And we're happy to do that.
- 17:28It overdraft is a necessary program for individuals to ensure that.
- 17:34They can purchase what they need to purchase.
- 17:36And, the economy can keep rolling
- 17:39Treichel: and, and mergers happen because fees evaporate and the ability to, to
- 17:46fund staffing, to fund these programs with smaller credit unions, at some
- 17:50point in time they end up throwing the towel in because they, because all these
- 17:54regulations and the regulatory burden has nibbled around the edges of what they.
- 18:00So I'm excited that I'm excited that you're excited that it looks like this
- 18:03will pass and that this will be some more permanence to local control of
- 18:08what's appropriate for the credit union.
- 18:10What's appropriate for that membership.
- 18:12That, that.
- 18:14People can avoid the payday lenders and can avoid having their checks put up in
- 18:18the bar or the restaurant saying, that you're not a good person, if you will.
- 18:23'cause they are good people.
- 18:24Bad things happen,
- 18:24Jason Stverak: absolutely
- 18:25Treichel: bad things happen
- 18:26Jason Stverak: to good people.
- 18:27And it happens every day and thankfully.
- 18:30Many of those situations there, there's a credit union they can walk into.
- 18:33Let me give you an example of, what a credit union can do
- 18:36for someone who's fallen down.
- 18:38We have a defense credit union in Texas, and they told me this story during a
- 18:42meeting at our Defense Matters, which was held at the time of GAC recently, and
- 18:47they talked about that they had a kid.
- 18:49Who had made some bad financial choices when they were 16, 17 parents got him
- 18:53a credit card, all that type of stuff.
- 18:55And had fallen behind credit card, credit score took a big hit.
- 18:59And I.
- 19:00The kid is up for an appointment to West Point.
- 19:03So the father and the son walk into the credit union
- 19:06and say, here's our situation.
- 19:08What can you do to help credit union without batting an eye?
- 19:12Walks in and says, let's get you a loan.
- 19:13Let's get these all consolidated.
- 19:15Let's get this all taken care of.
- 19:16Let's get your credit score back up.
- 19:18Because in the military, having huge deaths and a low
- 19:21score is considered a risk.
- 19:22And he was on track everything, but this was the one thing that
- 19:26was the red light for getting it.
- 19:28They worked with him, helped him put him back on track from my understanding
- 19:32of kids going to West Point,
- 19:34Treichel: fantastic.
- 19:34That's what credit unions are all about.
- 19:37Absolutely.
- 19:38So you touched on we've touched on CFPB, the edges of the CFPB.
- 19:42I know you recently the DCUC had a, some comments on potential restructuring
- 19:49or, looking forward to what.
- 19:51How to improve CFPB and a couple things.
- 19:54There was a reference to all the costs of their regulations.
- 19:57And there was a reference to UAP that caught my in interpretations
- 20:01and how that's broad.
- 20:03And then there was also a reference to I think, creating an independent
- 20:07inspector general for the CFPB, which caught my eye because at NCUA we.
- 20:12Have an in, independent inspector General who reviews things of NCA.
- 20:16So any of those three things are all three of 'em.
- 20:19You wanna highlight the udap.
- 20:21The Inspector General and just the general costs of CFPB regs,
- 20:26Jason Stverak: In, in terms of general costs it's death by a thousand cuts.
- 20:29It's you hear oh, it's only gonna cost you a couple bucks here, or five bucks here.
- 20:33But at the end, when all of those regulations start adding up, and
- 20:37when you add CFPB on top of NCUA on top of, the state and other.
- 20:42Other obligations, that they have, whether it's unemployment, insurance,
- 20:45and o other stuff is running a business.
- 20:48It can quickly cause you to.
- 20:51For lack of a better term, go out of business.
- 20:53Merge.
- 20:53I'm not talking about the pen Feds, the navy feds, the vice
- 20:57stars, the Randolph Brooks.
- 20:59I'm talking about the credit union.
- 21:00That's a hundred thousand dollars.
- 21:02And there is one, and Todd er talked about it in our defense matters that,
- 21:06the, the 10, the five, the 15, the 20, the 50 millions, a hundred millions.
- 21:11It becomes a choice of okay, we can't be open on Fridays, or we're gonna,
- 21:14we're now 10 to four and then, you're gonna it's about not hiring that next
- 21:18teller to help ensure processing people through in the morning, et cetera.
- 21:22I.
- 21:23Rolling back, the cost not only at CFPB, but across government's important
- 21:28because it frees up the credit union to be able to serve its members.
- 21:33Now, the, by a motto is to trust the credit union to serve its members.
- 21:38And, 99.9%
- 21:40of the time, the credit union makes the right choice on behalf
- 21:44on behalf of it of its membership.
- 21:46And then in terms of the, the independent, IG just makes sense.
- 21:50And the fact that you need someplace that if there is an issue that you
- 21:55can go to an independent arbitrator it's it would be, it's hey you go to
- 21:59you go to the car dealership, you get sold to lemon, and you're person you
- 22:02complain to is the car dealership.
- 22:04And so what are they, who is their natural alliance gonna, gonna be with, it's
- 22:08gonna be with, with a car dealership.
- 22:10But having that ability you know what, I think I've been wrong, or
- 22:13I think I have an issue to have someone who's, who is independent.
- 22:17But, and independent, truly independent.
- 22:19Not for you, not for them, but it's gonna find, adjudicate correctly,
- 22:23I think is incredibly important.
- 22:24And as they are reimagining.
- 22:28What the CFPB can be in the future, because let's have that
- 22:33honest political discussion.
- 22:35It's in statute, it's creation.
- 22:37It sits on Fs o and, it's a part of the it's a part it's a part of
- 22:41the law that there is not 60 votes in the Senate to get rid of it.
- 22:46There is at best 53, maybe 54, depending upon somebody's mood that day.
- 22:52So what you need to do is take this opportunity to do reforms.
- 22:56We've advocated for a multi-member commission, so it isn't one
- 23:00individual, we've advocated for changing its appropriation process
- 23:05while the Supreme Court has ruled.
- 23:07The current way is constitutional.
- 23:09It doesn't mean that's the way it has to be done, let's put it under the
- 23:13appropriation process where Congress can be that check to currently one person
- 23:19deciding what they wanna do with, with the US economy essentially moving forward.
- 23:23Treichel: Yeah it, the way it was structured, made it I think, I'm sure.
- 23:28People who wanted it to come into play realized how powerful it could become.
- 23:33But now that you see that, they basically say, I need this much money
- 23:37because I say I need this much money.
- 23:39And then they have the broad interpretations of what Udap
- 23:42means, and it's just one person.
- 23:44It makes that, too powerful of a position, in my opinion.
- 23:47I love the idea of going to a commission or, whether that's three or five, pick
- 23:51a number of folks that that provides that wisdom of crowd and less control
- 23:57in one hand, I think would be a fabulous change that, you're right, it's gonna
- 24:01be here, but let's take an opportunity to see if there's a ways to improve it.
- 24:05So one o one other thing that I saw on, on, on your LinkedIn was there was a story
- 24:13that you reported on about vice presidents JD Vance, praising Navy Federal Credit
- 24:19Union for some things that had gone on.
- 24:21If you could describe what happened there for my listeners,
- 24:25I think that'd be pretty cool.
- 24:26Jason Stverak: Yes.
- 24:26And vice president Advanced used Navy Federal as a member of what
- 24:30happened when he was in the Marines, but I want your audience and everyone
- 24:33to know that what Navy did is what defense credit unions do every day.
- 24:38Sure.
- 24:38In terms of protecting them from, predatory lenders.
- 24:41And if you didn't see the story from last week vice President Vance before
- 24:44he went to Greenland spent some time at Quantico here in, in the Virginia area
- 24:48visiting with at the Marine Corps base.
- 24:50You may have seen him shoot the m you know, the M 2 4 3, the saw,
- 24:54and that's what got the attention.
- 24:56But part of his speech where he talked about, he was a young Marine
- 25:00and he talked about just being outta high school, directionless,
- 25:04not knowing where he, how to make decisions, where he is going in life.
- 25:07And he decided he needed to go get a new car.
- 25:10And wow, there was somebody right outside that front gate that
- 25:13was gonna be very happy to sell 'em a new car at 21% interest.
- 25:16And so he walks back and tells his gunny his gunny sergeant, I think it was,
- 25:20and says, wow, look at this great deal.
- 25:22I'm getting with 21% interest.
- 25:23And he goes, looks at him like, okay, we're gonna take you down.
- 25:27Took him down to Navy Federal and they worked out and got him what
- 25:30the actual interest rate should be.
- 25:32And this is the dirty little secret that, that unfortunately we've seen
- 25:36in the defense credit union industry, but also the members of the military
- 25:39have experienced is that they are targets for predatory lenders.
- 25:44That, for many of these, this, that first check is the largest
- 25:47check they've ever gotten, right?
- 25:48This might be their first time they've had a, a checking account and they're
- 25:51like, you know what, I'm gonna blow it all on a new a new car or the a hundred,
- 25:56the 85 inch TV and the PS five, and, and I'll just do it buying, I'll just do it
- 26:01on the Renta Center, or I'll do it in, five year payments to buy a PS five.
- 26:06And they're not it's.
- 26:09In financial decisions that are gonna hinder you for a long time in the future.
- 26:13And what that gun did, what that sergeant did was help the vice president get to.
- 26:20The institution that wants to help the me, these service
- 26:24members, and it was Navy Federal.
- 26:26In this example, it's Hickum out in, in, in Hawaii.
- 26:29It's Randolph Brooks.
- 26:31It's key, it's keys down in Key West.
- 26:34Defense credit unions see this happen every single day where they'll
- 26:38have someone walk in and say, Hey, I just was out at the car lot and
- 26:42they're gonna finance me for 32%.
- 26:44And they're like, okay, why don't we just get you approved here?
- 26:47It's 6% and they're like, 6%.
- 26:49How'd you do this?
- 26:49It's 'cause you're being taken advantage of because they're
- 26:52expecting you not to know any better.
- 26:54And that's why defense credit unions be, that they're the first line in defending
- 27:00members of the military and their families away from these predatory lenders.
- 27:03And it gets back, go all the way back to interchange that we are
- 27:07able to do this because we have the resources to take a risk and to,
- 27:12be able to serve these members or.
- 27:14There's no other choice than for them to walk out the front door and get a
- 27:18$500 payday loan at 200% in some percent interest because, they just needed a short
- 27:25term for three or four days, until their check in, until their payroll came in.
- 27:28Treichel: But a great story.
- 27:29Yeah.
- 27:29And a circle is complete.
- 27:30'cause it all comes back to, nibbling ways at the fees on the
- 27:33interchange, et cetera, et cetera.
- 27:35Jason, this was great.
- 27:35Is there any questions, any other things I should have asked you that
- 27:39you'd like to discuss here today?
- 27:41Jason Stverak: No, obviously the other big issue we're all talking about
- 27:44here in DC and up on Capitol Hill is credit union tax status fight.
- 27:47Oh yeah.
- 27:47Last Thursday it's our understanding house ways and means Republican
- 27:51members did get together.
- 27:52They did meet in terms of it was a very general discussion
- 27:56with the administration, what the budget's gonna look like.
- 27:59We're expecting probably the next two to three weeks the, the pencils are gonna get
- 28:04sharpened and we're gonna start having the discussions about how to pay for things.
- 28:08And that's where we need to make sure that particularly defense credit unions and
- 28:12all credit unions voices are being heard.
- 28:14This week we are very particularly targeting the
- 28:18chair and ranking members of.
- 28:20Ways and means in the House and Senate financials do the writing of
- 28:23the tax of the tax law with defense credit union CEOs from their home
- 28:27states in their home districts, so that they understand the importance
- 28:32of the tax status to defense, credit union's ability to serve the military.
- 28:38And again, it'll circle all the way back if we lose our tax status.
- 28:42There is.
- 28:43Mil, depending on the size of the credit union, hundreds of
- 28:46thousands of dollars, millions of dollars that then has to be found.
- 28:52Sure.
- 28:53And so you're gonna have to make choices.
- 28:55Do you cut back on services?
- 28:56Do you cut back on hours?
- 28:57Do you cut back on?
- 28:59Having, as we talked about, taking a risk on those, on, on those, young
- 29:04service members you're not gonna have the resources to be able to do that.
- 29:07So we are pushing you out the front door through the front gate to the
- 29:11payday loan lenders, because I.
- 29:14We don't have the resources anymore to be able to protect it
- 29:16because now we gotta pay taxes.
- 29:17Now in, the, ICBA has come along and said it's only gonna be at a billion and above.
- 29:23Whether you are navy federal or you're, that a hundred thousand dollars
- 29:27credit union, the DNA of a defense credit union and every credit union
- 29:32is to use that tax status to serve.
- 29:35And I don't care what your size is, the moment you start saying, okay.
- 29:39A billion and above, you're essentially you're you don't represent what a credit
- 29:44union is anymore, and a billion and a billion and below, you actually do.
- 29:48So that doesn't make any sense to me because I.
- 29:52We get our tax status based upon, not our asset size, but our structure and
- 29:59what we do for the community, how we give back, what we support because
- 30:04the banks are organized around to provide profit for their shareholders.
- 30:08I have no problem with that.
- 30:09That's the choice you make that's fantastic.
- 30:11Credit unions are organized around, I've always said, even
- 30:15when I was up on Capitol Hill.
- 30:18The question of what can I do to serve my community or for our
- 30:22defense credit unions, what can we do to serve those who serve?
- 30:26And if you take our tax status away, you are going to greatly
- 30:33inhibit our ability to protect.
- 30:36Our members who are serving and protecting us.
- 30:39And then it gets back into that argument again.
- 30:41If the, if we don't have the resources to ensure that the financial readiness of
- 30:46our members is met and insured, then we're not gonna be, have the military readiness
- 30:52to respond to threats around the globe.
- 30:56Treichel: Well said.
- 30:56Stated.
- 30:57And it's so good that you're out there communicating the message now.
- 31:02Be before they're behind closed doors, trying to make it all add up, right?
- 31:05Because they need to know going into those discussions on what the budget's
- 31:08gonna be that credit union's tax exemption needs to just be not up for
- 31:14discussion and the fine work that you do letting them know what credit unions do.
- 31:19It's important times.
- 31:21Very important times.
- 31:22Jason Stverak: And it is like that credit union difference
- 31:24about that credit union in Texas.
- 31:25There's another DCUC member that's not a traditional defense credit union because,
- 31:30any credit union can join DCUC 'cause you have a veteran in party population.
- 31:34ENBR Credit Union on Nashville, I don't know if you follow their
- 31:37program that they, a pilot program that they have for cancer patients.
- 31:41I've had multiple discussions with their president and CEO Ron Smith,
- 31:44and you should probably get him on.
- 31:45Yeah.
- 31:46Honestly, mark what this program is that they've had, one of the
- 31:50great and I speak of this coming from some personal experience.
- 31:54My wife is a cancer survivor, so what they wanted to ensure is one of the
- 31:59single greatest impediments to beating cancer is stress and financial stress.
- 32:05Sure.
- 32:06And that they did not want, have someone to be able to walk in to their
- 32:10credit union and they're in their car loan or their home loan and they just
- 32:14throw the keys and says, I can't do anymore 'cause I can't go to work.
- 32:16And they're like, wait, what's going on here?
- 32:18Why?
- 32:18Why are you doing this?
- 32:18It's I got cancer.
- 32:20I'm going through treatments, I and I can't work.
- 32:22And they're like, okay, here's what's gonna happen.
- 32:24All of your loans.
- 32:26We're pushing them out six months, 0%.
- 32:28Just show, just, there's the proof that you could do it and you note from
- 32:31your doctor, all that type of stuff.
- 32:34Then, because we're gonna help you beat this because you can't go to treatment
- 32:40if you've had to turn in your car.
- 32:41'cause you can't pay your car loan.
- 32:42So it's like you're not gonna worry about this.
- 32:46Then they worry then six months, five months into the months, talk
- 32:50to you, Hey, how are things going?
- 32:52Doing better.
- 32:53Doctor says they still can't work great.
- 32:54Pushing it out six more months, and then they sit down, they
- 32:57got you budgeted everything else that you're taking care of.
- 33:00What can we do?
- 33:00And this is how Ron explained it to me.
- 33:02And then let's say six more months after that, they're like, you know
- 33:04what, I've won, I'm in remission.
- 33:07I'm going back to work next month.
- 33:09And they're like, that's great.
- 33:10We're gonna push out another six months again.
- 33:13But we're also gonna give you probably a 0% interest loan to
- 33:15make sure you're back on your feet.
- 33:17And then we're gonna work with you to reset up your payments so
- 33:20that you're not hit right away.
- 33:23With the car loan or the mortgage loan or something, your mortgage payments
- 33:26and so that, that credit union is walking step in step so that you can
- 33:31focus on winning the war on cancer.
- 33:35And we will focus on having your back.
- 33:38We.
- 33:39Take care of you.
- 33:40That's why we have our tax status.
- 33:43That's why we, fight so hard for interchange.
- 33:46That's why, we talk about that, that overdraft needs to be a,
- 33:51a member to the union, to the credit union discussion because.
- 33:56That allows that credit union to have resources to be able to do these things.
- 33:59And that's, that, that's the choice that a democratically organized,
- 34:04financial cooperative can make.
- 34:06And it's exciting to tell those stories.
- 34:09I, I up with two members of Congress, with, a couple weeks ago and they're
- 34:12like, tell me why you should keep your tax status and tell 'em that story.
- 34:15Okay, done.
- 34:16Yeah, you've.
- 34:17And I don't fault banks or anything, they're organized to make
- 34:21sure this month or this quarter, you've hit your share price.
- 34:24We're organized to say.
- 34:27At the end of this quarter, how many kids got clothed, how many backpacks
- 34:31we filled, going back to school, how many, how many people we've
- 34:35helped through, like what Enbr does.
- 34:37Those are the things that are exciting.
- 34:39Office there a little bit, but just amazing that story.
- 34:42Treichel: I love.
- 34:42I love it.
- 34:42What a powerful story that, that.
- 34:44Best credit union story I've heard in quite some time.
- 34:47Jason this has been fantastic.
- 34:49I appreciate all these great updates.
- 34:51Interesting times.
- 34:52If someone is listening and they'd like to, every credit union has
- 34:56somebody who's a veteran, right?
- 34:58So if someone listens to this and they'd say, Hey, I'd to talk about
- 35:01the possibility of joining A-D-C-U-C, or do they just wanna talk to you
- 35:05about something in general, what's the best way for someone to reach you?
- 35:08Jason Stverak: Go to dc uc.org.
- 35:10And you can click on and be able to contact me or just my email address is all
- 35:15lowercase letter J-S-T-V-E-R ak@dcuc.org.
- 35:21We're on LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook, however you wanna
- 35:24get ahold of us, let us know.
- 35:26Or, if your local credit union likely is possibly a member.
- 35:30Go in, ask them.
- 35:31We're there to help them 'cause we work for them, and I know they work for you
- 35:35as an individual credit union member.
- 35:37Perfect.
- 35:38Jason, thanks so much for your time
- 35:39Treichel: today.
- 35:40Thank you so much.
- 35:41And listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 35:43As always.
- 35:44I hope you will listen again soon.
- 35:46This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.