Latest / Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick, powered by CBT News / How Dealers Win Q4 with Fixed Ops, Omnichannel, and Fewer Vendors
Transcript
- 0:09Announcer: You're watching Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.
- 0:14Jim Fitzpatrick: Hey everyone, Jim Fitzpatrick.
- 0:15Jim Fitzpatrick: Thanks so much for joining me on another edition of Inside Automotive right here at the CBT Automotive Network.
- 0:20Jim Fitzpatrick: We are joined by Mr.
- 0:21Jim Fitzpatrick: John Fitzpatrick, who is the CEO of Force Marketing.
- 0:24Jim Fitzpatrick: You've seen him here before on CBT News.
- 0:26Jim Fitzpatrick: John, thank you so much for taking the time out of your busy schedule to uh join us.
- 0:29Jim Fitzpatrick: It's always great catching up.
- 0:31John Fitzpatrick: Absolutely.
- 0:32Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 0:32Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh but but really you are uh your your company and you you're just like always going, going, going.
- 0:38Jim Fitzpatrick: You guys are on fire, you've just landed some huge deals, which we may talk about today.
- 0:44Jim Fitzpatrick: But uh you you guys handle some 1,500 rooftops now?
- 0:47John Fitzpatrick: Yeah, about that.
- 0:47John Fitzpatrick: Wow.
- 0:48John Fitzpatrick: And 14 uh OEM partnerships through the certified program.
- 0:53Jim Fitzpatrick: So yeah.
- 0:53Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, that's fantastic.
- 0:54Jim Fitzpatrick: Great.
- 0:55Jim Fitzpatrick: That's a big part of the business.
- 0:56John Fitzpatrick: It is.
- 0:56Jim Fitzpatrick: So let's talk about um here we are, you know, going into the or really we're into the last quarter of 2025.
- 1:03Jim Fitzpatrick: Every dealer out there trying to figure out how do we finish the year strong.
- 1:07Jim Fitzpatrick: Uh I know the EVs 12% last month, you know, which which really kind of gave everybody a jolt, no pun intended.
- 1:13Jim Fitzpatrick: Um but uh but but that was a good thing, you know.
- 1:16Jim Fitzpatrick: And I I think it opened a lot of people's eyes as to the fact that, oh, people may might may want EVs, you know, even though the we know the $7,500 has gone away since September 30th.
- 1:25Jim Fitzpatrick: But so there's a lot to talk about, a lot to catch up on.
- 1:28Jim Fitzpatrick: But what are you asking your clients and telling your clients to focus on as we go into these the last three months of 2025?
- 1:35John Fitzpatrick: Yeah, it's a great question.
- 1:36John Fitzpatrick: You know, it it's rooted in the the- you know the brilliance is in the basics.
- 1:40John Fitzpatrick: It's we're kind of there uh in many ways in auto.
- 1:42John Fitzpatrick: Uh again, with all the uncertainties, the tariffs, the different inventory levels, the you know, customer buying habits, you know, whether or not they can afford affordability is still a major, major, major topic.
- 1:52John Fitzpatrick: You know, in all of our ads, we're really trying to promote price and and incentives as helping them drive down the affordability topic because that's definitely in the hearts and minds of customers, right?
- 2:03John Fitzpatrick: Uh, which goes hand in hand with customer retention.
- 2:06John Fitzpatrick: So you know, having a strong fixed ops department, making sure that every customer that comes in that maybe doesn't buy because maybe they don't think that they can afford, well, let's fix up the car that they're in and keep that business it at the dealership.
- 2:18John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 2:19John Fitzpatrick: Um, it's so important for dealers to make sure that they've got a fine-tuned, you know, customer lifetime, lifecycle management process.
- 2:27John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 2:27John Fitzpatrick: Um, oftentimes what we have found uh is that the OEM programs are great, uh, but there's a lot of holes in them.
- 2:33John Fitzpatrick: They're not really going after everybody that that the dealer should be going after to bring them back in in service.
- 2:39Jim Fitzpatrick: So what do you mean by that?
- 2:39John Fitzpatrick: So there's a big opportunity there.
- 2:41John Fitzpatrick: So I'll give you an example.
- 2:42John Fitzpatrick: So there's a lot of the uh programs don't go after the off-brand vehicles that you sold.
- 2:47John Fitzpatrick: Right, right.
- 2:47John Fitzpatrick: So let's say you're a Toyota dealer, right?
- 2:49John Fitzpatrick: But you sold a Kia out of your used car lot, right?
- 2:51John Fitzpatrick: Well, do you want to service that Kia?
- 2:53Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, of course.
- 2:53Jim Fitzpatrick: Of course, of course.
- 2:54John Fitzpatrick: Yeah, and we know that if we do service that Kia, we have we have set we're seven times more likely to buy a Toyota the next time that Kia driver wants the next car.
- 3:03John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 3:04John Fitzpatrick: Right?
- 3:04John Fitzpatrick: And so of course we want that business.
- 3:06John Fitzpatrick: These programs, again, while great, we're not telling them to turn them off.
- 3:09John Fitzpatrick: There's just a lot of holes of opportunity.
- 3:11John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 3:11John Fitzpatrick: Um, there's the customer pay versus warranty pay conversation.
- 3:14John Fitzpatrick: We know the customer pay is a lot more profitable for the dealer, right?
- 3:17John Fitzpatrick: We want to focus on that.
- 3:18John Fitzpatrick: If we're gonna put a unit up uh and take time in the service bay, don't we want that to be the most profitable unit?
- 3:24John Fitzpatrick: Don't we want it to be the one that helps us hit our president's goals and you know all of our achieve all of our metrics so that we're in great standing with the OEM?
- 3:32John Fitzpatrick: Of course we do.
- 3:33John Fitzpatrick: And so our product sort of wraps around that OEM product so that there's nothing falling through the cracks when it comes to retention.
- 3:40John Fitzpatrick: It's a very, very important piece of their marketing.
- 3:43John Fitzpatrick: Um we know the trade-in quality can be you know significant if done right.
- 3:47John Fitzpatrick: Uh you you've preached that for years uh on the service side of the business.
- 3:51John Fitzpatrick: And so now you've got you've got an inventory component.
- 3:54John Fitzpatrick: Um that absolutely leads a lot of our discussions because even the dealers that believe that, hey, look, I'm writing, we have dealers writing 300 ROs a day.
- 4:03John Fitzpatrick: 56 bays, right?
- 4:05Jim Fitzpatrick: Nice.
- 4:06John Fitzpatrick: They have opportunities.
- 4:07John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 4:07John Fitzpatrick: When you're putting you know high volume units in operation, right, you have to be even better on the retention side.
- 4:13John Fitzpatrick: And so whether you're a small dealer and you're not pumping out the volume, uh, you know very much so that you need you know the the the your absorption rate to be high and your service department to be running running strong, but the the big dealers do too.
- 4:26John Fitzpatrick: And when we look at brand loyalty, what we're seeing is that not only has brand loyalty been on a decline, it's kind of steadied out at like 50%, right?
- 4:33John Fitzpatrick: But you're seeing dealer loyalty is below that.
- 4:36John Fitzpatrick: And so there's an opportunity for the dealer to make sure that they're keeping their customers loyal.
- 4:43John Fitzpatrick: Yep and then as these dealer groups have gotten bigger and bigger, I want them loyal to my family of brands.
- 4:48John Fitzpatrick: I no longer offer five different OEM you know nameplates.
- 4:52John Fitzpatrick: I've got 35.
- 4:53John Fitzpatrick: Right to know that how many stores have gone from five to 20 stores in the last five years.
- 4:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 4:57Jim Fitzpatrick: You got something for everyone in the family.
- 4:58John Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 4:58John Fitzpatrick: And so we we want to keep all of them, so that's really utilizing the first party data, understanding where the customer is, meeting them where they are, having a personal communication with them that recognizes we know you're driving a Toyota because we sold it to you, but we also know that you're looking for a BMW right now.
- 5:11John Fitzpatrick: By the way, we have a BMW store.
- 5:13John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 5:13John Fitzpatrick: And that was that wasn't the case seven years ago when you bought that Toyota.
- 5:16John Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 5:17John Fitzpatrick: That sort of conversation, using data across different uh dealership platforms, very, very important.
- 5:22John Fitzpatrick: So these are the kind of conversations we're having right now.
- 5:24John Fitzpatrick: It's really fine too.
- 5:25John Fitzpatrick: But if I if I had to put it into one category for Q4, uh it would absolutely be customer retention.
- 5:32Jim Fitzpatrick: Okay, okay.
- 5:33Jim Fitzpatrick: Um from the looks of my mailbox when I go to it every day, uh dealers are still, local dealers are still challenged in the data that they've got and how to manage it and keep it clean, right?
- 5:44Jim Fitzpatrick: Because I'm getting, you know, uh offers from my BMW dealership that I purchased the vehicle from eight years ago, sold the car four years ago, and they're asking if I would like to come in and have my you know my my my BMW service.
- 5:59Jim Fitzpatrick: Yep.
- 5:59Jim Fitzpatrick: Haven't owned a BMW in four years, okay?
- 6:02Jim Fitzpatrick: So things like that that still exist.
- 6:05John Fitzpatrick: Big time.
- 6:06John Fitzpatrick: It's a major problem.
- 6:06Jim Fitzpatrick: It really is.
- 6:07John Fitzpatrick: We've got we've got a dirty data problem in auto, and then on top of that, we have way too many vendors with their hands inside of the first party data.
- 6:16Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, yeah, for sure.
- 6:17John Fitzpatrick: That is a major problem.
- 6:17John Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 6:18John Fitzpatrick: In fact, so much so if I look at our two of our bigger wins, and a lot of these groups don't really like to you know share you know these RFP processes, so I'll leave the nameplates out.
- 6:27John Fitzpatrick: But we've got a 60 plus store group that we that we we just brought on, and a 35 plus group.
- 6:32John Fitzpatrick: So about a hundred stores and two groups, and and the commonality of those two groups coming aboard to us was we need to limit our vendors, we need to limit the amount of people that have their hands in the data cookie jar, if you will.
- 6:43John Fitzpatrick: Um and we've strategically partnered up with folks that do a really good job in data management, that are connected in terms of the data pipes to our audience IQ customer data platform, that we can use their data in a in a in a in first and foremost, clean it and then make sure we're driving personalization and all these communication touch points that we're having with them.
- 7:04John Fitzpatrick: And that no one else, or at least we're policing very strongly who else is putting you know those proverbial hands in the cookie jar.
- 7:12John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 7:12John Fitzpatrick: Right?
- 7:13John Fitzpatrick: But it's because that's a big problem.
- 7:14John Fitzpatrick: There's too many vendors firing off messages in all of these different categories.
- 7:19Jim Fitzpatrick: Right, right.
- 7:19Jim Fitzpatrick: But isn't it isn't it needed?
- 7:21Jim Fitzpatrick: Like if if in in the event I'm a dealer, I've got vendors in there, aren't they in there for a purpose or a reason?
- 7:26Jim Fitzpatrick: Or are you saying that there's vendors in there that have no business even really being in there?
- 7:30John Fitzpatrick: I I I believe that there are vendors in there that have no business being in there.
- 7:33John Fitzpatrick: I believe also that there are vendors that can do a lot of those things, right?
- 7:40John Fitzpatrick: So it's almost like pick a winner and see how much they can do.
- 7:44Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 7:44John Fitzpatrick: Rather than five different marketing companies, one just handles my email, one handles my Conquest email.
- 7:50John Fitzpatrick: Okay, so just an email right there.
- 7:51John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 7:51John Fitzpatrick: You got two different vendors.
- 7:53John Fitzpatrick: I mean, right?
- 7:54John Fitzpatrick: Then you've got the OEM that's gonna say, well, we'll take care of your, you know, a segment of the There's just so much opportunity to create a better customer experience, like you just said, we're gonna go to the code.
- 8:03Jim Fitzpatrick: Or to screw it up.
- 8:04John Fitzpatrick: Yeah, and then think about the ad waste.
- 8:05Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 8:06Jim Fitzpatrick: Think about the ad waste.
- 8:07Jim Fitzpatrick: I was thinking the same thing every every time I open up an envelope.
- 8:09Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 8:09Jim Fitzpatrick: Not only am I, you know, upset that I'm still getting this, and it's like these guys don't know me, although they're probably patting themselves on the back to say we know all of our customers and we're reaching out to them, well, you're not, but also the money involved.
- 8:20Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 8:21Jim Fitzpatrick: In the in the printing and the postage.
- 8:22John Fitzpatrick: We we still have it for us the same two things we started with almost two decades ago, which was can we help dealers decrease their advertising expense as one of their three big biggest expenses, right?
- 8:33John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 8:33John Fitzpatrick: You've always preached this.
- 8:34John Fitzpatrick: They've got people, inventory, and marketing.
- 8:36John Fitzpatrick: Well, can we help them drive down their marketing by being more efficient?
- 8:39John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 8:39John Fitzpatrick: We could 20 years ago, we definitely can now.
- 8:42Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 8:42John Fitzpatrick: Right?
- 8:42John Fitzpatrick: And then the second one that if we do that, we drive a more personalized conversation with all of the folks inside of their database, will that create a better customer experience?
- 8:50John Fitzpatrick: Of course it will.
- 8:51John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 8:52John Fitzpatrick: And so those two things are still driving all of our innovation, everything that we're doing, all of our dealership conversations.
- 8:58John Fitzpatrick: And we sit down with our dealer groups and and look at them and say, look, we've got this vendor over here, they're doing a very unique thing.
- 9:03John Fitzpatrick: There are times you say, you know what?
- 9:05John Fitzpatrick: Keep them focused on that particular area of the business, they're doing a really good job.
- 9:10John Fitzpatrick: Their return on ad spend is fantastic.
- 9:12Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 9:12John Fitzpatrick: Oftentimes, though, you see that there are just far too many vendors.
- 9:16John Fitzpatrick: And what dealer groups particularly have found themselves doing, they're not managing their marketing or ad expense.
- 9:22John Fitzpatrick: They're managing their vendors.
- 9:23John Fitzpatrick: Because that's become a task in and of itself.
- 9:26John Fitzpatrick: Yeah, for sure.
- 9:27John Fitzpatrick: And so as I look forward and as I look for our business, how do how do we continue to drive value into the auto space?
- 9:34John Fitzpatrick: It's helping dealers shrink the world.
- 9:37John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 9:37John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 9:37John Fitzpatrick: And also have a better customer experience, you know, as a benefactor of being more strategic, more aligned with your data, less vendors that are operating.
- 9:47Jim Fitzpatrick: Is this the byproduct of different management teams coming into dealerships?
- 9:52Jim Fitzpatrick: Obviously, we still suffer from a big turnover in the industry.
- 9:55Jim Fitzpatrick: And I, as a GM, come in, take over.
- 9:57Jim Fitzpatrick: I got my guy for this, I got my guy for that, I got this company I've worked with in the past, let them come in.
- 10:03Jim Fitzpatrick: Meanwhile, the last generation of companies that the last general manager brought to the table, or maybe even the dealer principal, maybe the store was sold.
- 10:11Jim Fitzpatrick: So now you've got kind of this quilt effect of all of these different vendors.
- 10:15Jim Fitzpatrick: Sometimes the dealer doesn't even know about all of the vendors that that store has.
- 10:20Jim Fitzpatrick: That's correct.
- 10:20Jim Fitzpatrick: If I'm a dealer and I have uh 25 stores, it's almost impossible for me to know intimately what's going on in on that level with 25 rooftops.
- 10:28Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 10:29Jim Fitzpatrick: So they're counting on 25 different GMs.
- 10:31John Fitzpatrick: And they want them to be held accountable to their PL, right?
- 10:34Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 10:35John Fitzpatrick: Drive your property manager.
- 10:36John Fitzpatrick: Here's the other thing: the consolidation, the M&A activity.
- 10:39John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 10:39John Fitzpatrick: Right?
- 10:39John Fitzpatrick: You buy a store, it's not going to be top on the list to say, let's have them migrate to our DMS system and our CRM system and all of our different ad packages and everything like that.
- 10:50John Fitzpatrick: And so that gets put off and put off while they're running the store and that that's an issue.
- 10:54John Fitzpatrick: There's certifications, right?
- 10:55John Fitzpatrick: Every OEM has got a list, a short list, right?
- 10:57John Fitzpatrick: Maybe 10 vendors, 15 vendors on there, right?
- 11:00John Fitzpatrick: Well, those are not all the same across the actors, right?
- 11:02John Fitzpatrick: Look, there's you know, I think there's 25 programs out there, maybe 22 programs.
- 11:07John Fitzpatrick: We're on 14 of them.
- 11:08John Fitzpatrick: Okay.
- 11:08John Fitzpatrick: We're not on all of them.
- 11:09John Fitzpatrick: There's very few vendors, if any, at this point, that are on every single one.
- 11:13Jim Fitzpatrick: Okay.
- 11:13John Fitzpatrick: So then that's a creates a little bit of a problem, right?
- 11:15John Fitzpatrick: Because if you're very focused on being on program and having your co-op seamless, you might think about things a certain way.
- 11:21John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 11:22John Fitzpatrick: So there's reasons why.
- 11:23Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 11:24John Fitzpatrick: But what we're finding is the most uh sophisticated dealers that are like, all right, no more noise.
- 11:29John Fitzpatrick: We got to shrink the world.
- 11:30John Fitzpatrick: Who can handle the data first and foremost the most effectively?
- 11:33John Fitzpatrick: Because that is the most important thing.
- 11:35John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 11:36John Fitzpatrick: What you just described of stop sending messages to my physical mailbox or my virtual mailbox on a unit that I sold back to you three years ago.
- 11:43John Fitzpatrick: Stop doing that.
- 11:44John Fitzpatrick: It's very, very frustrating.
- 11:45John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 11:45John Fitzpatrick: And every time you do it, you're just lower than you're ever going to earn my business.
- 11:49John Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 11:49Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 11:50Jim Fitzpatrick: And it's always it always starts out by saying, you know, as a as a uh valued customer of ours.
- 11:55Jim Fitzpatrick: You know what I mean?
- 11:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Well, actually, I'm not that valued because-
- 11:59John Fitzpatrick: And that's what everybody thinks, right?
- 12:00John Fitzpatrick: And so that that the data component, understanding how to use it, understanding how to operate in a in an omnichannel world where the customer is so fluid.
- 12:08John Fitzpatrick: Oh, yeah.
- 12:08John Fitzpatrick: I just had a great conversation with the folks over at TikTok.
- 12:11John Fitzpatrick: They're finally figuring some things out in their platform for scalability.
- 12:14John Fitzpatrick: We're excited about where that could go.
- 12:15John Fitzpatrick: Folks at Amazon are doing some incredible things.
- 12:18John Fitzpatrick: Watch out, Amazon.
- 12:19John Fitzpatrick: Here's another, you know, huge category for them to figure out a way to dominate.
- 12:23John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 12:24John Fitzpatrick: Uh, right.
- 12:24John Fitzpatrick: And and and then just there's so many other vendors, right?
- 12:27John Fitzpatrick: Connected TV continues to be a great place to put your ad dollars.
- 12:31John Fitzpatrick: Dealers for years have grown their businesses on site, sound and motion, right?
- 12:35John Fitzpatrick: With jingles and on every single, you know, programming in a hyper-local marketplace.
- 12:38John Fitzpatrick: CTV brings an incredible opportunity to connect with customers that are shopping on their uh, you know, on all the devices in their household.
- 12:45John Fitzpatrick: Um there's just so many very strategic data-driven ways to reach the customer as you're sort of setting up your dealer group for not only a strong closing Q4, but what does 26 look like?
- 12:58John Fitzpatrick: 27, maybe you're aggressive, you're buying stores, you want to think about this thing.
- 13:02John Fitzpatrick: You know, we'd love an opportunity, or folks like us, and there are a few out there uh that are that are that that have a customer data platform that have stayed vertical specific, that are really dedicated in driving a better customer experience.
- 13:14John Fitzpatrick: But I will say one of the things that continues to be a differentiator for us, particularly, is our our knowledge and our expertise on the on the service side of the business, on the fixed op side, and having one conversation with the customer, right?
- 13:25John Fitzpatrick: Not two, not one on the variable side and one on the fixed side.
- 13:28John Fitzpatrick: That's gotta be one conversation.
- 13:29John Fitzpatrick: The dealer knows it as I mean the customer knows it as one, it should always be one.
- 13:33John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 13:33John Fitzpatrick: Uh and so that's a big that's a big opportunity.
- 13:37Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, you it's funny, I'm I'm going back, I guess almost five years now that you uh that you were you sat here at CBT News announcing the acquisition of GSM Gulf State's marketing, which was a big deal.
- 13:49Jim Fitzpatrick: Um and uh and I think you guys just hit the gas pedal ever since that point with marketing for fixed ops departments, right?
- 13:56John Fitzpatrick: That's exactly right.
- 13:57John Fitzpatrick: Yeah, they we knew we had to build or buy a fixed ops product.
- 14:00John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 14:01John Fitzpatrick: So when that opportunity came about from the Friedkin Family, we the reason we jumped all over it is again, it was already on our roadmap.
- 14:07John Fitzpatrick: We've got to build this thing, and we felt like it was a perfect fit.
- 14:09John Fitzpatrick: I think we just felt like we were too far behind.
- 14:11John Fitzpatrick: You know, and here's an opportunity to buy a tech stack that created Toyota Care, right?
- 14:17John Fitzpatrick: So huge opportunity for us to your point.
- 14:20John Fitzpatrick: We not even look back for a second.
- 14:22John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 14:23John Fitzpatrick: Most of our clients are on some level of that product.
- 14:26John Fitzpatrick: Uh we're winning deals because of that product.
- 14:28John Fitzpatrick: We're winning RFP opportunities on the variable ops side that didn't even have fixed ops in the conversation in the RFP.
- 14:34John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 14:34John Fitzpatrick: But we're winning the RFP because we have that as an hey, there's more value we can bring to the table.
- 14:39John Fitzpatrick: Sure, kind of.
- 14:39John Fitzpatrick: Our number one focus is how much value can we bring to these dealer groups.
- 14:43John Fitzpatrick: We're not just an agency or a tech partner.
- 14:46John Fitzpatrick: We want to really help drive value, drive meaningful business decisions.
- 14:50John Fitzpatrick: Um and and and that's that's what we've stayed true to.
- 14:54Jim Fitzpatrick: That's great.
- 14:54Jim Fitzpatrick: That's great.
- 14:55Jim Fitzpatrick: Um this is kind of a a side question here, and I don't know that you know or would really have too much data on it.
- 15:02Jim Fitzpatrick: But well, I interviewed so many fixed ops directors that are now into mobile service, as you know.
- 15:07Jim Fitzpatrick: Some some have got 40 and 50 trucks on the road.
- 15:10Jim Fitzpatrick: It's been in just an incredible thing.
- 15:12Jim Fitzpatrick: Ford, as you know, has gotten behind mobile service.
- 15:15Jim Fitzpatrick: Is that- has that changed anything with regard to the marketing of a dealer that has made a commitment in the area of mobile service?
- 15:21Jim Fitzpatrick: And what is your take on that?
- 15:23John Fitzpatrick: Yeah, not yet, and it should.
- 15:24Jim Fitzpatrick: Okay.
- 15:25John Fitzpatrick: Right?
- 15:25John Fitzpatrick: I I mean, to me it makes total sense.
- 15:27Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 15:28John Fitzpatrick: Why would I go to the dealership?
- 15:30John Fitzpatrick: Uh by the way, I think it's a differentiator, too, right?
- 15:32Jim Fitzpatrick: I do too.
- 15:32Jim Fitzpatrick: I do too.
- 15:33John Fitzpatrick: Jiffy Lube's still in the business, but you know, ABC Toyota and where you bought the car from is is gonna say, I'm gonna come to your car and your house and service it or your work and service it.
- 15:43John Fitzpatrick: Isn't that a key differentiator for customer loyalty at the dealer level?
- 15:47Jim Fitzpatrick: Which by the way, we've got to be careful because I think there is an ABC Toyota.
- 15:50John Fitzpatrick: Is there an ABC Toyota?
- 15:52Jim Fitzpatrick: I was told that one time because I often use it.
- 15:54Jim Fitzpatrick: Any town, too.
- 15:55John Fitzpatrick: There's probably any town too-
- 15:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Anytown Toyota, right?
- 15:57John Fitzpatrick: No, but a good friend of mine, Amit, is is running Kirby.
- 16:00John Fitzpatrick: They're doing a great job in this area.
- 16:02John Fitzpatrick: They've got most of the GM business, if not all of the GM business.
- 16:05John Fitzpatrick: They're pushing it in a really big way.
- 16:06Jim Fitzpatrick: That's great.
- 16:07John Fitzpatrick: Um and and I had had a conversation with him recently.
- 16:09John Fitzpatrick: It's like there's dealers jumping aboard on this left and right.
- 16:13John Fitzpatrick: There's still some hesitancy.
- 16:14Jim Fitzpatrick: I know Amit, he's a good guy.
- 16:15John Fitzpatrick: Yeah, he's a great guy, he's running a good company, but um, but I think it's just been a little slow, but that doesn't mean that that's not where the train's headed.
- 16:21Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 16:21Jim Fitzpatrick: Right?
- 16:21Jim Fitzpatrick: So it's just it would be a differentiator for me in buying the car.
- 16:24Jim Fitzpatrick: For sure.
- 16:24Jim Fitzpatrick: In other words, if a Ford, if I'm going to a Ford store, they have got uh mobile service and and uh and either A, if I go to another Ford store and they say, Yeah, we're we haven't done that yet, I'm going back to the first store, or even if I go to another brand, I go to a Chevy and they say, Yeah, we don't we don't we don't do mobile service, that's a huge advan- you know advantage that that dealership's got, not to mention how it's not that how how bad is it to have that mobile service truck pull up to a neighborhood.
- 16:51John Fitzpatrick: With the branding element on it
- 16:53Jim Fitzpatrick: Exactly, where people are going, they're coming out to service your vehicle?
- 16:55Jim Fitzpatrick: You gotta be kidding me.
- 16:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 16:56Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, you've got now uh the attention of all of those neighbors thinking, how come we don't have this for sure.
- 17:02Jim Fitzpatrick: You know?
- 17:02John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 17:02Jim Fitzpatrick: So it's interesting.
- 17:04Jim Fitzpatrick: I I would think that those you're we'll probably see that more um in incorporated into the marketing of the dealership, right?
- 17:11John Fitzpatrick: It should be- if they have it, you should be talking about it, right?
- 17:13John Fitzpatrick: There should be some version of, you know, you know, we always talked about the customer bill of rights kind of thing where it's like if you buy from this group, these are things you can expect.
- 17:22Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 17:22John Fitzpatrick: Right?
- 17:22John Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 17:23John Fitzpatrick: And they're differentiated from anywhere else that you might buy, that would be a big one.
- 17:26Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 17:27John Fitzpatrick: Right?
- 17:27John Fitzpatrick: And and so leaning into it into the messaging when you're trying to get that, you know, that 2% of the market to sway your way, you know, that's a that's a great one.
- 17:35Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 17:35Jim Fitzpatrick: Um, I've spoken to a number of GMs that have said, you know, over the years, because marketing has gotten so sophisticated, I come from the days that we had a full page ad and we had a great TV spot and a radio spot.
- 17:47Jim Fitzpatrick: Maybe we even had a-
- 17:49John Fitzpatrick: Life was so simple back then.
- 17:50Jim Fitzpatrick: Maybe we even had a radio remote, and you old timers know what I'm talking about at the dealership on Saturday.
- 17:55Jim Fitzpatrick: But things have changed substantially, and uh you can hold your emails, I get it.
- 18:00Jim Fitzpatrick: But um, but nevertheless, it seems as though you almost need somebody now, as GMs have told me, on the payroll in the dealership, working with the vendors, because we're we're car guys, we're car gals.
- 18:14Jim Fitzpatrick: We don't know all of these different different uh uh different levels of marketing and all of these things that obviously you know and the other marketing companies know and the experts know.
- 18:26Jim Fitzpatrick: We're not experts in marketing, right?
- 18:27Jim Fitzpatrick: However, we are commissioned as general managers and managers of stores to almost be experts and know what to ask of our vendors and what not to ask and what to expect of them and who's doing what.
- 18:40Jim Fitzpatrick: And then to your point, you've got so many people, you know, with their hands uh making in the soup, so to speak, that, or so many chefs in the kitchen that you're like, Well, I don't know how to manage that.
- 18:51Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, you have any recommendations for dealers that go, ah, when it comes to my marketing, I've got so many different people.
- 18:57John Fitzpatrick: Look, I think there's a reason why there's there's economies of scale, there's a reason why all of the publics and all of the major groups have full in-house marketing teams.
- 19:05Jim Fitzpatrick: Right to work, to work with.
- 19:06John Fitzpatrick: They might not actually be pulling the levers, but to your point, yeah, they are managing the vendors and they're doing it, they're doing a good job, right?
- 19:13John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 19:14John Fitzpatrick: And they're really analytical, they they they they're great to work with.
- 19:17John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 19:18John Fitzpatrick: Um, and that's where we can really help a dealer- I mean, I think there's a reason why most of our 1,500 dealers come, there's a parent company organization, and uh, you know, and they're part of a 30-store group or a even a hundred-store group, is because they've got those team of folks, of marketing folks, that take it off the GM's plate, even the service manager's plate, yeah, to some degree, and say, hey, we're gonna manage this partner and uh and then report back to you on the things you need to know, and you report back to us, and that is absolutely very, very helpful in the process.
- 19:51John Fitzpatrick: It creates speed.
- 19:52Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 19:53Jim Fitzpatrick: The average dealer, I think today they say owns two dealerships.
- 19:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Um, they're not the big conglomerates, although they get all the fanfare and you know what have you.
- 20:00Jim Fitzpatrick: But the average dealer out there owns two dealerships.
- 20:02Jim Fitzpatrick: They don't necessarily-
- 20:03John Fitzpatrick: If you have two dealerships, you should have at least one person that's managing the marketing.
- 20:06Jim Fitzpatrick: That's handling them one.
- 20:06Jim Fitzpatrick: For sure.
- 20:07Jim Fitzpatrick: That's important to the two.
- 20:08Jim Fitzpatrick: And then the one person has got to be very well versed on all of these different vendors that are out there.
- 20:13Jim Fitzpatrick: It's not just a question of sending the logo over anymore.
- 20:16Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, it's it's it's really they've got to be, they've got to be dialed in with everything that's going on.
- 20:21Jim Fitzpatrick: They do.
- 20:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 20:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 20:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Absolutely.
- 20:23Jim Fitzpatrick: It's incredible.
- 20:24Jim Fitzpatrick: So if I'm a dealer and I say, John, we want to close 2025 strong, and you've mentioned a few of them already today, but what what are the one or two things that I really need to be laser focused on to get the dollars, to get the units too, over the curb.
- 20:38Jim Fitzpatrick: You touched on on fixed ops, that's obviously gonna help my bottom line.
- 20:41John Fitzpatrick: Make sure that's dialed in.
- 20:42John Fitzpatrick: So that's number one.
- 20:43John Fitzpatrick: Number two is gonna be make sure you're you have an you have an affordability message in all of your markets.
- 20:47John Fitzpatrick: Okay.
- 20:48John Fitzpatrick: Okay?
- 20:48John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 20:48John Fitzpatrick: Because that resonates with that.
- 20:50John Fitzpatrick: That resonates, right?
- 20:51John Fitzpatrick: So you know how much lease penetration do you have is gonna be an important metric to look at, right?
- 20:55John Fitzpatrick: We know that the the the lease buyer in an affordability driven marketplace, they're gonna lean into that.
- 21:03John Fitzpatrick: Okay, because right, it's oftentimes less expensive on a lease than on a purchase.
- 21:08John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 21:08John Fitzpatrick: And so, you know, maybe you got to drum some of that lease conversation back up, both on your site but in your messaging.
- 21:14John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 21:14John Fitzpatrick: Um, you know, and then third, I would just make sure that you know you really take a hard look, Q4 is a great time to do it, in in not just- I love bringing this up.
- 21:25John Fitzpatrick: Bring up your your even if it's an Excel spreadsheet of all the money going out in advertising and marketing.
- 21:31John Fitzpatrick: First notice how long that is and how many different line items there are.
- 21:34John Fitzpatrick: Then the second thing is how, if you look month over month over month, just like the same three months, was your Google ad spend the exact same meta, the exact same, you know, dealer.com, whatever, maybe that's gonna be the same because it's your website or something.
- 21:49John Fitzpatrick: Sure, sure.
- 21:50John Fitzpatrick: Uh, you know, your third party leads, right?
- 21:52John Fitzpatrick: Are they all the exact same?
- 21:53John Fitzpatrick: And then ask yourself, was the marketplace the exact same, or will it be, you think, in October as it was in June?
- 22:01John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 22:01John Fitzpatrick: If the answer is no, it's a different marketplace and there's different dynamics, yeah.
- 22:05John Fitzpatrick: Well then why is the spend the exact same?
- 22:06John Fitzpatrick: Okay, I gotcha.
- 22:07John Fitzpatrick: Right?
- 22:07John Fitzpatrick: You should follow?
- 22:08John Fitzpatrick: Yeah, of course.
- 22:09John Fitzpatrick: Where I'm going there?
- 22:10Jim Fitzpatrick: You can't just set and forget it.
- 22:11John Fitzpatrick: That doesn't make sense to me.
- 22:12John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 22:12John Fitzpatrick: How could it just be 10 grand a month in Google?
- 22:14John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 22:14John Fitzpatrick: That's just it.
- 22:14John Fitzpatrick: That's just what we spend.
- 22:15John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 22:15John Fitzpatrick: Well, Google is is based on intent.
- 22:18John Fitzpatrick: People going in, typing in, I'm interested in something.
- 22:22John Fitzpatrick: That fluctuates.
- 22:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, it's dynamic.
- 22:23Jim Fitzpatrick: It's-
- 22:23John Fitzpatrick: Right, it's not it's a dynamic, it's a moving number, it should be a variable.
- 22:25John Fitzpatrick: By the way, they should all be variable.
- 22:26Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 22:27John Fitzpatrick: Based on the data points brought back to say, what does our marketplace look like?
- 22:30John Fitzpatrick: You show me someone that's got a changing number, just take the spreadsheet.
- 22:33John Fitzpatrick: If I the first thing I look at is, oh, those are changing numbers.
- 22:35John Fitzpatrick: They're doing something.
- 22:36John Fitzpatrick: Right?
- 22:36John Fitzpatrick: That tells me right off the bat they're doing something that the next guy is not.
- 22:40John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 22:40John Fitzpatrick: And that's where you could start that process.
- 22:43John Fitzpatrick: Once you go down this rabbit hole, you will start to realize where your ROAS return on ad spend really is.
- 22:49John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 22:50Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 22:50John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 22:50John Fitzpatrick: And you know, Brian Pash does a good job at highlighting this in the market in our space.
- 22:56John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 22:56John Fitzpatrick: He's got an event coming up.
- 22:57John Fitzpatrick: Eric Mercado, one of our VPs, is speaking at it down in Palm Beach area.
- 23:02John Fitzpatrick: Uh he does a great job.
- 23:03John Fitzpatrick: Unbelievable.
- 23:04John Fitzpatrick: And he's really focused on all of these metrics and and bringing attention to them.
- 23:08John Fitzpatrick: Um I think we're actually down there talking about on the fixed op side, actually.
- 23:12John Fitzpatrick: Um if that's something that resonates with you, and and if not, you can't make it down there, I would tap us.
- 23:17John Fitzpatrick: Because we can we can stay focused in one key area and then grow with a group.
- 23:21John Fitzpatrick: That's one of the things that we've built in our family of brands.
- 23:24John Fitzpatrick: We've got we drive automotive, we've got force marketing, and we've got Gulf States Marketing known as GSM.
- 23:29John Fitzpatrick: Any of those doors you can walk into for a very specific reason on how we can help your dealer group.
- 23:34John Fitzpatrick: And then once you're inside the house, if you need the other tools in the toolbox, great, they're there for you.
- 23:40John Fitzpatrick: And if you don't, that's okay too.
- 23:42John Fitzpatrick: We're gonna do what you're- what you need us to do.
- 23:44John Fitzpatrick: We'll constantly show you areas of opportunity and we will test you, right?
- 23:49John Fitzpatrick: To say, hey, you gotta understand this is an opportunity here, right?
- 23:52John Fitzpatrick: Right?
- 23:52John Fitzpatrick: But if you tell us, hey, you know what, there's not spend for that, or we don't believe in that, that's fine too.
- 23:55John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 23:55John Fitzpatrick: It's still our job to showcase you in a proactive way.
- 23:58John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 23:58John Fitzpatrick: It's another topic.
- 23:59John Fitzpatrick: There's all too often just too many partners that are just, you know, what do you want to do this month?
- 24:04John Fitzpatrick: Sitting back.
- 24:05John Fitzpatrick: And they just get very, very frustrated with that.
- 24:07John Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 24:07John Fitzpatrick: That should not be the case.
- 24:08John Fitzpatrick: It should be here's what the data says you should do this month.
- 24:10John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 24:10John Fitzpatrick: You want to do it or not?
- 24:11John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 24:11John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 24:12John Fitzpatrick: And if not, what part of the strategy do you like and what part of the strategy do you not like?
- 24:15John Fitzpatrick: Because this is what we see.
- 24:16John Fitzpatrick: Yeah, of course.
- 24:17John Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 24:17John Fitzpatrick: And that should be in advance of the month, by the way, around the fifth of the month.
- 24:19John Fitzpatrick: So, anyways, there's a lot of opportunities there.
- 24:22John Fitzpatrick: That's what I would be looking at.
- 24:23John Fitzpatrick: Long answer to your question on the one, two, three, but this is the time to be looking at your partners.
- 24:28John Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 24:28John Fitzpatrick: And are they the right partners for 2026?
- 24:30Jim Fitzpatrick: I was just gonna say, lining those guys up, lining them up for great, great.
- 24:33Jim Fitzpatrick: John Fitzpatrick, president CEO of Force Marketing.
- 24:36Jim Fitzpatrick: Thank you so much for stopping by.
- 24:37Jim Fitzpatrick: It's always great.
- 24:38Jim Fitzpatrick: It's always great seeing you.
- 24:39Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 24:39Jim Fitzpatrick: So uh yeah, special treat from me.
- 24:42John Fitzpatrick: It's fun.
- 24:43Jim Fitzpatrick: All right, take care.
- 24:47Announcer: Thanks for watching Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.