Latest / CitiesSpeak With Clarence Anthony / Improving Public Discourse with Tim Shriver & Tami Pyfer
Transcript
- 0:08Melanie Fonder Kaye, Senior Executive, National League of Cities: Welcome back to Cityspeak.
- 0:10Melanie Fonder Kaye, Senior Executive, National League of Cities: I am your host, Melanie Fonder Kaye, senior executive with the National League of Cities.
- 0:14Melanie Fonder Kaye, Senior Executive, National League of Cities: Cityspeak gives listeners an insider's view of what local leadership in America means today and features conversations with government leaders and policy experts on the biggest issues and challenges facing America's cities, towns, and villages.
- 0:28Melanie Fonder Kaye, Senior Executive, National League of Cities: We're bringing you a special episode of CitiesSpeak today, courtesy of our friends at the Massachusetts Municipal Association.
- 0:34Melanie Fonder Kaye, Senior Executive, National League of Cities: It's a conversation with Dignity Index co-creators Tim Schreiber and Tami Pyfer talking about their hopeful and practical path to improving public discourse and strengthening our relationships.
- 0:46Melanie Fonder Kaye, Senior Executive, National League of Cities: Tim and Tami discuss the importance of dignity, the role of local leaders in fighting against what they call the contempt industrial complex and where they see change happening every day at school board meetings, in city council chambers, and other community gatherings.
- 1:03Melanie Fonder Kaye, Senior Executive, National League of Cities: This conversation is hosted by MMA Executive Director, Adam Chapdelane, and MMA Communications Director, John Willette, for their podcast called the 351.
- 1:14Melanie Fonder Kaye, Senior Executive, National League of Cities: They're doing great work up in Massachusetts, and I hope you'll check out their podcast, which really digs in on municipal government issues and what makes great leaders tech.
- 1:23Melanie Fonder Kaye, Senior Executive, National League of Cities: The 351 is available wherever you get your podcasts.
- 1:43Tim Shriver: And if you look at all of the great positive changes in our country's history where dignity was expanded, where more people were included, it always started with people saying, I'm going to do it differently.
- 2:23Speaker 5: Respect and trust is often absent from the public discourse.
- 2:28Speaker 4: Yeah, and unfortunately, we've been seeing it enter the local government arena.
- 2:32Speaker 4: But where we see a discouraging trend, today we're joined by guests who see opportunity.
- 2:38Speaker 5: We're in the midst of our Connect 351 event at the Menino Center in Boston, where we convene to share ideas, draw inspiration, and prepare for the year ahead.
- 2:49Speaker 5: And we have the pleasure of talking with the leadership of an innovative national nonprofit in the studio here.
- 2:56Speaker 5: Leaders we turn to for ideas and inspiration around how to reduce divisiveness and restore dignity to public discourse.
- 3:07Speaker 4: At a time when many feel like the glue that holds communities together is becoming weaker, our guests today have a mission to change that through their organization, Unite, where Timothy Shriver is CEO and founder, and Tami Pyfer is the Chief External Affairs Officer.
- 3:22Speaker 4: Unite focuses on healing social and civic divisions in our country right now.
- 3:26Speaker 4: Tim, Tami, welcome.
- 3:29Tim Shriver: Thanks for having us.
- 3:30Speaker 4: Thank you for having us.
- 3:31Speaker 5: Tammy, let's start with you.
- 3:33Speaker 5: Why does an organization focused on healing divisions want to look to local communities and appeal to local leaders?
- 3:41Tami Pyfer: Well, you touched on it just a little bit.
- 3:43Tami Pyfer: We've seen how some of the national toxic political rhetoric is seeping into cities.
- 3:49Tami Pyfer: And I served on a city council for eight years.
- 3:52Tami Pyfer: I know what that's like.
- 3:53Tami Pyfer: And I've watched as those meetings have become more and more difficult to manage because of what's happening at the national level.
- 4:01Tami Pyfer: We have a strategy that we like to call our grass tops and grassroots strategy.
- 4:06Tami Pyfer: We know that when we look to national leaders or the grass tops, whether it be our federal leaders in the Congress, the Senate, the White House, or our governors, they have a big stage and they have a lot of people that watch and listen to them.
- 4:20Tami Pyfer: We also have the grassroots strategy.
- 4:23Tami Pyfer: That's in cities and towns and school boards and with community groups and faith groups.
- 4:29Tami Pyfer: And what we're hoping to do is to create a movement of people who understand what they're seeing, that can recognize dignity and contempt and use that language that we're teaching with our index so that they start to shift the conversations in their community.
- 4:47Tami Pyfer: They start to expect dignity from the people who represent them, who expect dignity from the people who inform them and who entertain them.
- 4:56Tami Pyfer: I think the local city council and town leadership is in a unique position to be kind of a bridge between that grassroots and the grass tops, right?
- 5:07Tami Pyfer: They're visible in their communities, but they still are in a position to make kind of some groundswell movement type building things happen.
- 5:15Tami Pyfer: And so that's why we're here at your conference today and speaking to locally elected officials.
- 5:21Speaker 4: I mean, I love thinking about local government as that glue, as that connective tissue.
- 5:26Speaker 4: I also can't resist a tariff management joke for local government, but I I like it.
- 5:31Speaker 4: I like it a lot.
- 5:32Speaker 4: Tim, local government, at least in most of the country, has historically been nonpartisan.
- 5:37Speaker 4: More recently, it's been harder to sort of like stay nonpartisan in the face of so many divisive issues, even in small cities and towns.
- 5:46Speaker 4: How have you observed that change and how are you thinking about trying to tackle that challenge?
- 5:51Tim Shriver: I think the important thing to remember here is that there is a huge constituency in our country starving for change.
- 5:57Tim Shriver: Hundreds of millions of Americans feel homeless, feel scared, feel unlistened to, feel cynical and pessimistic because they don't see people treating each other with dignity.
- 6:11Tim Shriver: They don't see public officials treating each other with dignity, they don't see that this happening at school board meetings, they don't see it happening on the news at night.
- 6:20Tim Shriver: They scroll through the news, they this none of this is good for me.
- 6:24Tim Shriver: And we're starving for someone, something, some place to be reminded that that's not the only option.
- 6:30Tim Shriver: Contempt is not the only option.
- 6:33Tim Shriver: And as Tammy just said so well, for many of us, when we look to our neighborhoods and our communities and our places of worship and our civic organizations, when we look to the Lions and the church groups and so on, we see people who actually want to work together.
- 6:47Tim Shriver: We don't see Republicans and Democrats, we don't see richer, we see collaborators, we see people who share a common purpose.
- 6:53Tim Shriver: We're having this conversation on the verge of a big snowstorm.
- 6:57Tim Shriver: So within a few hours, we're gonna see thousands and thousands of public works people working all through the night.
- 7:03Tim Shriver: Right.
- 7:03Tim Shriver: We're not gonna look out at them and say, who did you vote for?
- 7:06Tim Shriver: We're gonna look out at them and say, Thank you for helping us, thank you for coming when we were in need.
- 7:11Tim Shriver: And still the ambulance came when we were struggling.
- 7:13Tim Shriver: In the middle of the storm, someone came.
- 7:15Tim Shriver: This is what local government does for us.
- 7:17Tim Shriver: This is where the teacher shows up for the kid who couldn't get to school.
- 7:20Tim Shriver: And we're saying, My God, look, that teacher is amazing.
- 7:24Tim Shriver: So this is what our country is starving for.
- 7:28Tim Shriver: Our gamble here is that if we give people the language to express what they already want, they'll say, yes, oh, that's it.
- 7:37Tim Shriver: You know, sometimes in life you're you're looking around, you're going, I can't quite name what the heck is wrong here.
- 7:42Tim Shriver: I can't quite name what I'm feeling.
- 7:44Tim Shriver: And then someone gives you the word.
- 7:45Tim Shriver: Americans are looking for the language to talk to each other and to challenge each other to treat each other better.
- 7:52Tim Shriver: We're not waiting, but we are starving.
- 7:55Tim Shriver: So we think local government, local leaders, local educators, all these, you know, cops, emergency responders, firefighters, teachers, public works officials.
- 8:07Tim Shriver: These are the interface between most of us and our leaders.
- 8:11Tim Shriver: Let's remind ourselves to treat them with dignity.
- 8:14Tim Shriver: We don't have to agree with everything the school board does, but we don't have to insult.
- 8:18Tim Shriver: We don't have to agree with everything the town manager or the mayor or the city council does, but we don't have to demonize.
- 8:24Tim Shriver: And by the way, it doesn't work anyway.
- 8:26Tim Shriver: It just makes things worse.
- 8:28Speaker 4: Right.
- 8:28Speaker 4: I mean, and it it feels like you touched on this this morning in your remarks.
- 8:33Speaker 4: It's a little bit of a battle between the contempt industrial complex and everybody else in America who goes about life probably being fairly kind and treating other people with dignity.
- 8:43Tim Shriver: That's right.
- 8:44Tim Shriver: I mean, we have this huge messaging machine that's telling us to hate other Americans.
- 8:50Tim Shriver: And it invariably says, love your country and hate the people in it.
- 8:53Tim Shriver: All of us know there's something wrong with that story.
- 8:55Tim Shriver: But we're about to celebrate the 250th anniversary of the country, a country dedicated to the idea that all people are created equal, that we have inalienable rights given to us by our creator, that no one can take away from us, that we want to fulfill by making our country more perfect generation after generation, seeking greater and greater dignity for more and more people.
- 9:14Tim Shriver: We all believe that.
- 9:15Tim Shriver: And yet we turn on the news at night and you think to yourself, well, I should hate those sons of guns who live in that state, or I got to stop those people from having any power in our country because they're gonna they'll destroy the country.
- 9:26Tim Shriver: Who are those people?
- 9:27Tim Shriver: Well, those are Americans.
- 9:28Tim Shriver: Wait a minute.
- 9:29Tim Shriver: So we're all locked in this like that, wait a minute, this isn't making sense.
- 9:33Tim Shriver: We're gonna have parades, we're gonna have documentaries, we're gonna read speeches from the founding era of our country, we're gonna challenge the founders for what they did wrong and celebrate them for what they did right.
- 9:45Tim Shriver: And then, by the way, we're gonna hate the rest of the people in the country.
- 9:48Tim Shriver: No, no, no, no, no.
- 9:50Tim Shriver: That doesn't work.
- 9:51Tim Shriver: That dog won't hunt.
- 9:52Tim Shriver: So, you know, we've got to snap out of what the contempt industrial complex is telling us.
- 9:58Tim Shriver: They're monetizing our anger.
- 10:00Tim Shriver: The algorithm is monetizing our fear, partisan news is monetizing our contempt for other people and the other party, whichever one you're in, you're being hated on by the other one.
- 10:10Tim Shriver: Right.
- 10:11Tim Shriver: In almost the same language, by the way.
- 10:13Tim Shriver: I mean, when you start to see it, it's like, oh my God, this is this is amazing.
- 10:16Tim Shriver: I like to say we don't suggest that there is moral equivalence in all issues.
- 10:21Tim Shriver: People on both sides of the political aisle have passionate convictions that they differ with the other party in.
- 10:28Tim Shriver: Our view is good, that's democracy.
- 10:31Tim Shriver: Be passionate, but don't use the tactics for your passion that attempt to dehumanize and destroy other human beings.
- 10:40Tim Shriver: That's not that's not a good way to achieve your passion.
- 10:42Tim Shriver: So there may not be moral equivalence, but right now most of us see that there's tactical equivalence.
- 10:50Tim Shriver: Meaning most of what we hear about is people using the same tactics of dehumanizing contempt, which ironically make it impossible to solve problems, increase the chances of violence, and tear our families apart.
- 11:04Tami Pyfer: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: Something, Tim, that you had said this morning, the data that you put up about these top five or six issues that are dividing the country.
- 11:12Tami Pyfer: But when you look at the data, like 80% of Americans, over 80%, agree on what the solutions to those issues are.
- 11:20Tami Pyfer: We are being lied to through this contempt industrial complex, the media, the system, the algorithm.
- 11:27Tami Pyfer: And when people understand that they're being lied to, or understand that people actually think more similar to you than you think, that changes the way you look at people.
- 11:39Tami Pyfer: Even in city council meetings, when when you realize that, you know, 80% of the issues that you're facing, uh, or 80% of the people, even in the room, it's like, you know, that most of those people actually agree that A, this is a problem, and we probably agree somewhat on the solution.
- 11:54Tami Pyfer: You start to see them differently and you start to consider the solutions that are being brought to you by the public works department differently, knowing that it's like, oh, this is gonna be a battle.
- 12:02Tami Pyfer: I'm gonna, you know, I mean, I used to do this in city council meetings.
- 12:05Tami Pyfer: It's like, I'm gonna gear up for this big battle because I would assume, you know, that the other people coming to the meeting were automatically against me because I had been, you know, just conditioned really to gear up for a battle.
- 12:16Tami Pyfer: When when now it's like actually, people probably agree pretty much with the problem.
- 12:21Tami Pyfer: And maybe the solution, something Tim likes to say is that disagreement isn't the problem.
- 12:27Tami Pyfer: It's the solution.
- 12:28Tami Pyfer: So having those different voices in the room that you can hear the different perspectives is actually part, that's good.
- 12:35Tami Pyfer: That's healthy and it's part of the solution.
- 12:37Speaker 5: So you mentioned this contempt industrial complex.
- 12:40Speaker 5: And you see an opportunity to make progress at the local level, but is there hope for this sort of bubbling up?
- 12:49Speaker 5: Like that's a huge, powerful sounding force.
- 12:52Speaker 5: Yeah.
- 12:53Tim Shriver: Well, you know, I was talking to a rabbi, asked me that question.
- 12:56Tim Shriver: I said, Well, we're kind of fans of that kid with the ruddy complexion who was handsome to behold.
- 13:01Tim Shriver: His name was David in the Bible, right?
- 13:04Tim Shriver: And he uh he famously can encountered Goliath.
- 13:07Tim Shriver: Look, the theory of change here is that culture changes when subcultures arise that show a different way.
- 13:14Tim Shriver: And if you look at all of the great positive changes in our country's history where dignity was expanded, where more people were included in the story of the country, when more people got their rights to vote, to participate, to contribute, to work, people with disabilities, getting the chance to work.
- 13:31Tim Shriver: It happened when more dignity, when the circle of dignity expanded.
- 13:35Tim Shriver: And all of a sudden people said, okay, yes, we can hire you, Mr.
- 13:39Tim Shriver: Smith, Mr.
- 13:39Tim Shriver: Ms.
- 13:40Tim Shriver: Jones.
- 13:40Tim Shriver: You have Down syndrome, but we'll find a place for you.
- 13:42Tim Shriver: We know you have gifts to give.
- 13:44Tim Shriver: That's the expansion narrative.
- 13:46Tim Shriver: It always started with people saying, I'm gonna do it differently.
- 13:51Tim Shriver: So each of us, this is where you don't have to wait for a presidential election.
- 13:55Tim Shriver: You don't have to wait for the midterms.
- 13:57Tim Shriver: Do what you need to do for the midterms.
- 13:58Tim Shriver: I'm all for whatever it is you want to do.
- 14:00Tim Shriver: But we don't have to wait to be countercultural in this respect.
- 14:03Tim Shriver: We can, as city managers, as city council members, as municipal officials, we can say, we're gonna do it differently.
- 14:10Tim Shriver: I don't care what they're gonna do.
- 14:12Tim Shriver: Let the president, let the Senate, let the Congress, let the administration, let the Democrats, whoever in Washington do what they're gonna do.
- 14:19Tim Shriver: We're doing it differently here in one of these 351 towns.
- 14:23Tim Shriver: I'm not Ben Afflack, Matt Damon, and Jimmy Fouts.
- 14:26Tim Shriver: I can't name them all.
- 14:28Tim Shriver: They had prompters.
- 14:29Tim Shriver: I don't buy it.
- 14:30Tim Shriver: But we're gonna do it differently here, because we don't want to live like that.
- 14:35Tim Shriver: We don't want to live yelling at each other.
- 14:37Tim Shriver: We don't want to live feeling unsafe in our own neighborhoods.
- 14:40Tim Shriver: We don't want to feel distrustful of every person.
- 14:42Tim Shriver: We'll challenge public works to do a better job or public education or police department.
- 14:47Tim Shriver: Yes, we will.
- 14:48Tim Shriver: We'll bring our grievances to the mayor, to the city council, and so on.
- 14:52Tim Shriver: We'll make it and that's how we make it better.
- 14:54Tim Shriver: Right.
- 14:55Tim Shriver: That's how democracy works.
- 14:57Tim Shriver: You're a CEO, you're a communications guy, you tell him things sometimes he doesn't want to hear in order to make him better, right?
- 15:04Tim Shriver: So he has to I'm I didn't mean to get personal there.
- 15:06Tim Shriver: You did earlier today.
- 15:08Tim Shriver: But that's how it works.
- 15:10Tim Shriver: That's how we grow.
- 15:11Tim Shriver: Uh it's not always pleasant to hear the other point of view, but it always leads us, challenges us, causes us to think differently.
- 15:18Tim Shriver: Okay, wait a second.
- 15:20Tim Shriver: What is she thinking?
- 15:21Tim Shriver: What is he trying to say to me?
- 15:23Tim Shriver: Oh, oh, I see.
- 15:25Tim Shriver: Okay, maybe that's a good.
- 15:26Tim Shriver: Oh, oh, yeah, there's a solution.
- 15:28Tim Shriver: And then before you know it, the public works department, the school system, the police department, the fire department, all these things, they got a little better because they listened to something that they didn't start thinking, but they were made smarter by listening to someone from a different point of view.
- 15:43Tim Shriver: That's democracy.
- 15:44Tim Shriver: I agree.
- 15:45Tim Shriver: I agree.
- 15:46Speaker 4: So let's talk specifically about dignity.
- 15:49Speaker 4: I'm curious, you know, in your early days, how you honed in on the term dignity.
- 15:55Speaker 4: And then I'm curious for our listeners to learn more about the dignity index.
- 15:58Speaker 4: You know, it's a really applicable tool.
- 16:01Speaker 4: It's a it's something you can bring back to your community.
- 16:03Speaker 4: But yeah, if you could start by talking a little bit about like what was it about that word that started to build this concept?
- 16:08Tami Pyfer: Well, when I first came to the team, they had already been working on this project for some time.
- 16:14Tami Pyfer: But in late 2020, early 2021, I'm this Republican from Utah reading Arthur Brooks, you know, a conservative Republican.
- 16:24Tami Pyfer: And I was reading his book called Love Your Enemies, talking about uh contempt and how that we have a contempt problem.
- 16:32Tami Pyfer: And if we want to solve the polarization problem, we have to solve the contempt problem.
- 16:35Tami Pyfer: My Democratic colleagues in DC were reading a book by Donna Hicks called Dignity.
- 16:41Tami Pyfer: And that term uh just really resonated with all of us as being kind of two ends of the spectrum.
- 16:50Tami Pyfer: Donna worked in international conflict resolution for two and a half decades and found that dignity and recognizing and honoring the dignity in every individual was just the most powerful tool she had in her toolkit when she was mediating this conflict.
- 17:07Tami Pyfer: And dignity, we talk about the language a lot.
- 17:10Tami Pyfer: We talk about words like respect and civility, and a lot of organizations and states have civility initiatives, which is great.
- 17:17Tami Pyfer: I'm glad they do.
- 17:19Tami Pyfer: Uh, we talk about respect and needing to respect people.
- 17:22Tami Pyfer: But dignity is a notch higher than civility and respect.
- 17:26Tami Pyfer: Civility, I think, is a baseline.
- 17:28Tami Pyfer: Respect, we believe, has to be earned.
- 17:31Tami Pyfer: You can earn my respect.
- 17:32Tami Pyfer: But even if you don't earn my respect, I still need to treat you with dignity.
- 17:37Tami Pyfer: You have dignity.
- 17:38Tami Pyfer: Uh, I can't give it to you, I can't take it away from you, I cannot treat you with dignity, but that's inherent.
- 17:44Tami Pyfer: And that word seemed to resonate.
- 17:46Tami Pyfer: I know it did with our team, and it has seemed to resonate with so many people.
- 17:50Tami Pyfer: It's just it's a different, it's it's a different way of looking at ourselves.
- 17:55Tami Pyfer: Tim mentioned teaching people this language, and I'll never forget one of the early presentations I made during the break.
- 18:03Tami Pyfer: A woman said, I need to talk to you, you know, out in the hallway.
- 18:06Tami Pyfer: And I was, I was worried that I had maybe offended her.
- 18:09Tami Pyfer: You know, she wanted to talk in private, and and and she was crying.
- 18:13Tami Pyfer: And I said, Is everything okay?
- 18:14Tami Pyfer: She said, I I feel like there's been a target on my back.
- 18:19Tami Pyfer: And uh she worked in education and she said, even family members, I feel like are out to get me.
- 18:24Tami Pyfer: She said, You just gave me the language I need to understand what's happening.
- 18:30Tami Pyfer: She said, I feel like my dignity is being violated.
- 18:33Tami Pyfer: That's what's happening.
- 18:34Tami Pyfer: She said, I've never known how to express that.
- 18:37Tami Pyfer: But now that I understand that it's dignity, she said, I see things differently.
- 18:41Tami Pyfer: Thank you for giving me that language.
- 18:43Tami Pyfer: And she says, now I know how to respond differently.
- 18:46Tami Pyfer: Now I know how to explain to people when we're having these discussions, how they're hurting me, because you gave me the language.
- 18:52Tami Pyfer: And dignity is that language.
- 18:54Tim Shriver: Yeah, I mean, I think it's interesting from a political perspective.
- 18:57Tim Shriver: When we polled this word, it did not poll well.
- 19:00Tim Shriver: Huh.
- 19:00Tim Shriver: Respect polled higher.
- 19:01Tim Shriver: So did civility.
- 19:03Tim Shriver: When you asked people to use the language that they would naturally use to describe some of these qualities, dignity is not at the top of the list.
- 19:10Tim Shriver: And so we looked at this, and a friend of mine, who's a pollster, Frank Lundz, he said, you got to change your work to uh respect.us.
- 19:16Tim Shriver: And so I said, so we we talked, I talked to him about it.
- 19:19Tim Shriver: And it actually made us double down on keeping the word that was less intuitive, less natural, less conversational.
- 19:27Tim Shriver: So people listening to this may be thinking, yeah, I respect people that are different, or I want to treat them well.
- 19:32Tim Shriver: We're not asking you just to respect people.
- 19:35Tim Shriver: We're asking you to respect their dignity.
- 19:37Tim Shriver: It's a different thing, right?
- 19:38Tim Shriver: So we're we're inviting, as Tammy just so elegantly shared, we're inviting people to tap into a different frequency here.
- 19:45Tim Shriver: This is not, did you do the right thing?
- 19:47Tim Shriver: This is not if you're being arrested for a crime, did you do the right thing?
- 19:52Tim Shriver: If you're being convicted of a crime, you did not do the right thing.
- 19:54Tim Shriver: Right.
- 19:54Tim Shriver: We are saying that even though you committed a crime or I committed, you will be treated with dignity.
- 19:59Tim Shriver: So we're asking people to tap into a slightly different frequency here.
- 20:04Tim Shriver: I can be fiercely opposed to what you believe in, but fiercely protective of your dignity.
- 20:10Tim Shriver: How do I do that?
- 20:11Tim Shriver: Tricky, right?
- 20:12Tim Shriver: This is this is why the index has been so helpful to people because it allows you to express disagreement fiercely and forcefully without violating dignity and maintaining to some extent that as a sacred space.
- 20:28Tim Shriver: So it's almost like a new skill, right?
- 20:30Tim Shriver: And I like to think it's the new superpower because the world is getting smaller, it's more diverse, we're coming from lots of different places, we're trying to navigate differences of religion and ethnicity and culture and hit history and storytelling, a lot of things that maybe past generations could have just sort of pushed under the rug.
- 20:47Tim Shriver: We don't do that anymore.
- 20:48Tim Shriver: We bring it out from under the rug.
- 20:50Tim Shriver: Our kids are gonna have to learn how to capture this superpower.
- 20:55Tim Shriver: Like I need to try to understand and treat you with dignity, but I also need to be able to express to you my truth.
- 21:02Tim Shriver: And I need to be able to speak my truth with force.
- 21:05Tim Shriver: Don't tell me to neutralize my passions.
- 21:08Tim Shriver: That's not helpful.
- 21:09Tim Shriver: Don't tell me to become a centrist.
- 21:12Tim Shriver: Oh, just split the difference.
- 21:13Tim Shriver: You believe strongly, A, but just why don't you compromise?
- 21:16Tim Shriver: No, that's not our message.
- 21:18Tim Shriver: Our message is a little different.
- 21:20Tim Shriver: Our message is hold on to the dignity of the other human being, see them, and use that as part of the way in which you express your position.
- 21:30Tim Shriver: It will make you more effective.
- 21:32Tim Shriver: So, you know, this is kind of uh a little bit intuitive, but also a little counterintuitive and a little bit challenging for all of us, you know.
- 21:41Tim Shriver: Uh, and I would just say for myself, doing this work has challenged me to live my life differently.
- 21:47Tim Shriver: I'm constantly thinking, oh, wait a second, now how do I do this?
- 21:50Tim Shriver: How do I hold this one, this family member?
- 21:54Tim Shriver: You know, this moment, this news story.
- 21:56Tim Shriver: Right.
- 21:56Tim Shriver: It's challenging.
- 21:57Tim Shriver: We think it's sort of Hidden issue of our time that we have to elevate.
- 22:02Tim Shriver: We don't necessarily have all the answers, but we have invitations to the conversations around how we do this.
- 22:07Tami Pyfer: And Adam, I was just going to add to what Tim's saying.
- 22:09Tami Pyfer: It's like, this is hard work and it's an ongoing process.
- 22:12Tami Pyfer: This is a long game.
- 22:14Tami Pyfer: This isn't, I'm going to come to your city council, I'm going to train you for 45 minutes, and everything's going to be great.
- 22:18Tami Pyfer: This is an ongoing self-reflection, self-improvement.
- 22:23Tami Pyfer: I struggle with certain people or certain issues that I bring it up, Tammy.
- 22:28Tami Pyfer: Present company included.
- 22:30Tami Pyfer: No, it's but it's like it's not the time to come.
- 22:34Tami Pyfer: It's a challenge.
- 22:35Tami Pyfer: And when people get involved, when when you say when you kind of sign up for this movement, just know that it's the long haul.
- 22:42Tami Pyfer: It's going to take time to turn around the country in some regards when we talk about that and relationships that we have.
- 22:50Tami Pyfer: But it's well worth the struggle.
- 22:53Tami Pyfer: And I've learned a lot about myself and gotten better in a lot of ways and still have a lot of people.
- 22:59Tim Shriver: Tammy, as you say, it's very true.
- 23:01Tim Shriver: Changing culture's always got a medium to long arc, right?
- 23:04Tim Shriver: That's just the way it is.
- 23:05Tim Shriver: You think of any big change.
- 23:07Tim Shriver: It didn't happen like that.
- 23:09Tim Shriver: Maybe the end result moved quickly, but a lot of people struggled.
- 23:13Tim Shriver: So culture change does take time.
- 23:15Tim Shriver: What's exciting, I think, for us is how many people get it right away.
- 23:20Tim Shriver: And people, I mean, I've talked to dozens of people just here as we're gathered here in Boston for this occasion.
- 23:27Tim Shriver: I've talked to dozens of people just in the last two hours.
- 23:29Tim Shriver: We get it.
- 23:30Tim Shriver: We're going to change.
- 23:31Tim Shriver: We're going to do this.
- 23:32Tim Shriver: You know, that was a three.
- 23:33Tim Shriver: I told my, I called my wife and told her she used and this is after just 10 minutes of exposure.
- 23:38Tim Shriver: Yeah.
- 23:38Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 23:39Tim Shriver: So there is both the long arc of change, but there's also the intuitive hunger of the moment.
- 23:45Tim Shriver: You know, I think in business they say, you know, sometimes there's a market demand, but there's no product.
- 23:50Tim Shriver: And then when you get the product, all of a sudden you're like, whoa, baby, we got it.
- 23:54Tim Shriver: You know, we hit the market right at the right time.
- 23:56Tim Shriver: There was market.
- 23:57Tim Shriver: The demand was there, and we put it on the shelf, and man, it's flying off the shelf.
- 24:01Tim Shriver: We feel a little bit like there's a huge demand.
- 24:04Tim Shriver: And we're we're not the only product, but we're part of a product that people are starving for.
- 24:10Tim Shriver: So they're like, oh yes, finally.
- 24:12Tim Shriver: So there's a quick movement here, too, in addition to the harder work that follows the initial insights.
- 24:19Speaker 5: I want to sort of tap into a vein of some questions that you had, Tammy, in your Wiimo session about sort of practical applications.
- 24:27Speaker 5: And our members work really hard to make their local communities hum.
- 24:33Speaker 5: They're deeply invested in the work.
- 24:35Speaker 5: And when the heat is coming at you, what is the best initial response?
- 24:42Speaker 5: And I also want to ask, as a local leader, if you observe it, you're not the target of it, but you observe it.
- 24:51Speaker 5: Do you have a role to play there?
- 24:55Tami Pyfer: I would say the first response, uh, Tim talked about this a little bit is to take a breath when it's coming at you in particular.
- 25:03Tami Pyfer: I think anyone that's been involved in politics has taken some arrows and sometimes from people that you thought were your friends and they're not anymore, and they're coming at you publicly.
- 25:14Tami Pyfer: So taking a breath, taking breathe.
- 25:17Tami Pyfer: Uh, there's other, you know, skills uh associated with that.
- 25:20Tami Pyfer: Tim talked about turtling, where you go into your shell, breathe, have some positive self-down.
- 25:25Tami Pyfer: I can do this, it's okay, and then regulate before you respond.
- 25:29Tami Pyfer: What has helped with the dignity index is I see people differently.
- 25:33Tami Pyfer: And I try to look at the understory of why they are so upset.
- 25:38Tami Pyfer: What is driving their emotion and their sometimes hatred toward me, that sounds like hatred toward me.
- 25:43Tami Pyfer: And being able to see people differently is part of that regulation, that self-regulation.
- 25:50Tami Pyfer: And then respond in a way that you're listening.
- 25:54Tami Pyfer: A lot of times people just need to feel heard.
- 25:57Tami Pyfer: And I talked about this in the Wiimo session is a lot of times people come up to public comment, and because of the technology that we have and our minutes and our board agendas on a laptop and everything's on there, that sometimes it's something as simple as making eye contact with that person at the meeting, putting your computer aside, listening, taking notes, writing down what they're saying.
- 26:18Tami Pyfer: I've suggested even, you know, briefly interrupting, saying, I'm sorry, I'm I'm taking notes.
- 26:23Tami Pyfer: Can you repeat that so that people know that they've been listened to?
- 26:26Tami Pyfer: And it's not performative.
- 26:27Tami Pyfer: You should take notes, but when people see you taking notes, it's like, okay, they're listening.
- 26:32Tami Pyfer: Someone's listening to me.
- 26:34Tami Pyfer: And it helps you because you're taking notes.
- 26:37Tami Pyfer: You can understand maybe the problem better.
- 26:40Tami Pyfer: Those are some suggestions I have in a council meeting.
- 26:43Tami Pyfer: I believe that we also have an obligation to stand up for people that are being treated poorly.
- 26:49Tami Pyfer: Uh, we call it challenging contempt.
- 26:51Tami Pyfer: And I gave an example of a school board meeting that I watched where a speaker in public comment was, you know, coming after a teacher in the district and saying some really awful things.
- 27:02Tami Pyfer: And because of the legalities that we see in our meetings, you know, the lawyer says I can't say this, and the city attorney says you can't respond.
- 27:09Tami Pyfer: It's not on the agenda.
- 27:10Tami Pyfer: Yeah, that's true to some extent.
- 27:12Tami Pyfer: But you can also say things like, I want the minutes to reflect that I disagree with what the speaker just said.
- 27:19Tami Pyfer: I appreciate you coming to speak, but I disagree.
- 27:21Tami Pyfer: And I want the record to reflect my appreciation for the teachers that we have in the district.
- 27:25Tami Pyfer: I mean, being able to challenge it in that way, I don't think breaks any of the laws, but it shows that someone is speaking for that person being demonized.
- 27:35Tim Shriver: Yeah, I disagree, is good is good language.
- 27:37Tim Shriver: And it's healthy language because of maybe where I come from or family and traditions I was born into.
- 27:43Tim Shriver: I was born in Boston and raised in a democratic family, progressive family, and so on.
- 27:47Tim Shriver: And people just assume, you know, I'm a woke psycho, liberal, whatever, that you know, the people, how are they characterize?
- 27:55Tim Shriver: What I found is when those questions come, almost every time the person ends up saying to me, No one's listening to me.
- 28:03Tim Shriver: They posted, but they didn't feel heard.
- 28:07Tim Shriver: They spoke, but they didn't feel seen.
- 28:10Tim Shriver: They challenged, but they didn't feel welcomed.
- 28:12Tim Shriver: Now that doesn't make their opinion necessarily my opinion, but it means that some of the anger is often coming from a place of deep frustration and even shame.
- 28:24Tim Shriver: I believe X and no one listens to me.
- 28:27Tim Shriver: No one fears.
- 28:28Tim Shriver: And fear and people, I'm shamed for it.
- 28:31Tim Shriver: I'm mocked by the other side for my beliefs.
- 28:35Tim Shriver: You know, think about it.
- 28:36Tim Shriver: If you were shamed and mocked and not listened to and not seen and not understood, you might get angry.
- 28:41Tim Shriver: And you might think that anger is your only now, that doesn't excuse hostile behavior or contemptuous behavior, but it helps us to understand that a lot of times the anger is coming from a place of simply deep frustration that they haven't been hurt.
- 28:58Tim Shriver: You know, saying to someone who's ready to cancel you, you know, I had this experience two weeks ago.
- 29:02Tim Shriver: A group did a 15 whereas proclamation condemning our work.
- 29:07Tim Shriver: And my I re I read Wait, condemning the dignity?
- 29:11Speaker 4: Yes, yeah, I know.
- 29:13Tim Shriver: Specifically.
- 29:13Tim Shriver: Specifically.
- 29:14Tim Shriver: So I read, I said, well, can we get in touch with the guys that that are the the chair of the committee?
- 29:19Tim Shriver: And it was like, yeah, well, maybe, but I mean they hate you.
- 29:22Tim Shriver: I was like, yeah, but I mean, we should at least talk to them.
- 29:24Tim Shriver: Yeah.
- 29:25Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 29:25Tim Shriver: And the next thing you know, the next afternoon, we're having a conversation, and the guy's like, yeah, you know, we shouldn't have done it, you know, maybe we could have done it differently, and we don't like this, but maybe we could talk about that.
- 29:35Tim Shriver: Let's have more conversations.
- 29:36Tim Shriver: And what you could have seen as a screed of really unpleasant language directed at us turned into a conversation.
- 29:45Tim Shriver: Now, are we going to agree?
- 29:48Tim Shriver: Unlikely.
- 29:49Tim Shriver: But really, I said, you know, think what you want to think, but condemning?
- 29:54Tim Shriver: I mean, we're trying to help the country here.
- 29:57Tim Shriver: I mean, we're we may not have the best solution, maybe you have a better one.
- 30:00Tim Shriver: But really?
- 30:01Tim Shriver: The guy was like, yeah, you're right.
- 30:03Tim Shriver: So this is the point Tammy was making earlier that we've been lied to a lot about each other.
- 30:07Tim Shriver: And when we don't know each other and we don't talk, the lie festers and the frustration deepens, and the screeds and the anger and the hostility and the contempt pour out.
- 30:19Tim Shriver: And a lot of times it's based on a lack of information and a lack of connection.
- 30:24Tim Shriver: You know, I don't know who said it, but we connect a lot nowadays, more than ever.
- 30:30Tim Shriver: How many friends do you have on Facebook?
- 30:32Tim Shriver: You have a 500, or you have 5,000, or you have 50,000.
- 30:35Tim Shriver: Oh my God, you have so many friends, followers, people who like what you say.
- 30:38Tim Shriver: How many people do you really communicate with?
- 30:41Tim Shriver: How many people really understand you?
- 30:43Tim Shriver: Quite low.
- 30:44Tim Shriver: A huge number of Americans report no.
- 30:47Speaker 5: Yes, yeah.
- 30:47Speaker 5: Connect has a different meaning than it did.
- 30:49Speaker 5: Yeah.
- 30:50Tim Shriver: So we're we're we're we're deceived a little bit into thinking we're feeling more connected and tethered to each other.
- 30:57Tim Shriver: We're not.
- 30:57Tim Shriver: Actually, the explosion of communication is actually, in many ways, resulted in an explosion of isolation.
- 31:04Tim Shriver: Right.
- 31:05unknown: Yeah.
- 31:05Speaker 4: You know, so much of what you're saying rings true.
- 31:07Speaker 4: I I used to work as a town manager before I was in this role.
- 31:11Speaker 4: And um I'm having memories as you're talking of, you know, getting that really challenging, potentially even sort of, you know, below five on the index email from somebody about, you know, it could be a very tactical or basic issue.
- 31:22Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 31:23Speaker 4: And the impulse is, I'm not going to respond to this.
- 31:26Speaker 4: It's a jerk.
- 31:27Speaker 4: Right.
- 31:27Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 31:28Speaker 4: But we did build a practice of giving detailed responses when we would take that time.
- 31:32Speaker 4: Often that person who was quite angry would be appreciative.
- 31:36Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 31:36Speaker 4: You still might not resolve their issue, right?
- 31:38Speaker 4: They still might be really angry that that sidewalk just can't get plowed or whatever it might be.
- 31:42Speaker 4: Right.
- 31:42Speaker 4: When we wouldn't respond.
- 31:44Speaker 4: Maybe we were too busy, maybe someone was distracted.
- 31:47Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 31:48Speaker 4: Of course, we get a second or third, even more angry email.
- 31:52Speaker 4: Exactly.
- 31:53Speaker 4: Right.
- 31:53Speaker 4: And then unwinding that.
- 31:55Speaker 4: Exactly.
- 31:56Tami Pyfer: It gets harder and harder to rebuild that relationship.
- 31:58Tami Pyfer: Yeah.
- 31:58Tami Pyfer: That's right.
- 31:59Speaker 5: We want to ask if you can tell us what each of you have learned in this work about people who are there just to win arguments or have power versus those who are trying to find the best answer for as many as possible.
- 32:13Tim Shriver: Well, the first thing I'd say is I don't think there are people on both sides.
- 32:16Tim Shriver: I think we move each of us in and out of those two modes.
- 32:20Tim Shriver: I think there are times in life where you just can't resist making a point and showing how foolish the other person's point is.
- 32:28Tim Shriver: And there are times in life where you don't need to make a point, you want to make a difference.
- 32:32Tim Shriver: So take any example, attacking the current president if you're a progressive, or the previous president if you're a conservative.
- 32:38Tim Shriver: A lot of people just sometimes said that felt good.
- 32:41Tim Shriver: I just called him every name in the book.
- 32:42Tim Shriver: You didn't make a doggone bit of difference to anybody in the world, but you felt better.
- 32:46Tim Shriver: Okay.
- 32:47Tim Shriver: Unfortunately, that is where it ends for many people.
- 32:51Tim Shriver: What we're all seeing, though, is that the country is awakening to that's not good enough.
- 32:55Tim Shriver: Making a point, demeaning the other guy, destroying the other party is not good enough.
- 33:01Tim Shriver: It's not good enough.
- 33:02Tim Shriver: And it results in a back and forth game of that paralyzes the country and makes us look foolish on the world stage and makes us feel rotten and makes our kids feel discouraged about the future.
- 33:12Tim Shriver: It's not good enough to make a point.
- 33:15Tim Shriver: We've got to recognize that this country depends on people trying to make a difference.
- 33:19Tim Shriver: So we say that dignity is a tool for problem solving.
- 33:24Tim Shriver: Because if you treat people with dignity, you have a chance to solve the problem.
- 33:28Tim Shriver: If you treat them with contempt, you are guaranteed to make the problem worse.
- 33:32Tim Shriver: When you treat someone with contempt, you make an enemy for your cause.
- 33:35Tim Shriver: So if you want to make a friend for your cause, the more dignity you give them, the better chance you've got.
- 33:40Tim Shriver: It's not a guarantee, but I can almost guarantee you that when you treat them with contempt, you make an enemy for your cause.
- 33:46Speaker 5: And you're not gonna penetrate, you're not gonna get through to them.
- 33:50Tim Shriver: I mean, we've seen that in the last several elections.
- 33:52Tim Shriver: I mean, the country uh, you know, people campaigning, spending hunt billions of dollars to destroy this politician or that billions.
- 34:00Tim Shriver: Yep.
- 34:01Tim Shriver: How many votes they move?
- 34:03Tim Shriver: Not even a three percent.
- 34:05Tim Shriver: Not even, not even, not two percent.
- 34:08Tim Shriver: They don't move anybody.
- 34:09Tim Shriver: What if all those billions of dollars were spent trying to elevate the story of people actually learning how to solve the problems and trying to challenge politicians to follow our civic leaders who are solving the problem of that sidewalk or solving the problem of the water supply, the energy supply, the infrastructure, the grid, the schools, the emergency responders, the healthcare system, all those things?
- 34:30Tim Shriver: People actually solving those.
- 34:31Tim Shriver: What if we spend billions of dollars finding the people doing the work and put them on billboards and said, Mr.
- 34:38Tim Shriver: Vice President or Senator or Congressman or president, uh, speak to this issue.
- 34:43Tim Shriver: We want to know why you can't do what Joe Jones is doing in Framingham or Waltham or Hyandis or Barnstable or, you know, that's not bad, right?
- 34:51Tim Shriver: That's all I got, though.
- 34:56Tami Pyfer: He's just showing off now.
- 34:58Speaker 4: Aaron Powell So let me ask you earlier, you talked about the grassroots and the grass tops and the local government being the connective tissue.
- 35:05Speaker 4: If you had one takeaway, like one thing you'd ask local leaders to do, like what would be that first step?
- 35:10Speaker 4: The members who are listening, people who attended today and listened to both of you speak, what would you what would you tell them?
- 35:16Tami Pyfer: Aaron Powell I would ask them to give it a try, cautioning that it's not easy.
- 35:23Tami Pyfer: And the first several attempts wouldn't because people do come at you.
- 35:28Tami Pyfer: I was thinking when Tim was explaining that, how many public hearings I've been at where someone will get up angry about a project and call us every name in the book and you rotten, no good, you know, son of a gun, and you're doing this.
- 35:40Tami Pyfer: I know you're gonna make a terrible decision, but I want you to vote no.
- 35:43Tami Pyfer: It's like, wow, you just persuaded me.
- 35:46Tami Pyfer: Like, no, I really want to do what you asked, right?
- 35:49Tami Pyfer: But I would ask councilmen, first I would thank them for their for their work.
- 35:53Tami Pyfer: This is really, really hard work.
- 35:55Tami Pyfer: Honestly, God bless, you know, our elected officials, especially at the local level.
- 35:59Tami Pyfer: But I would ask them to take a chance and then to have a little patience and and lead, you know, step into that leadership role that they're already in and and lead with dignity and see where it can land.
- 36:12Tim Shriver: The first step that we found to be very practical is to spend three to five minutes with Dignity Index, pull it down off the web, look at it, read each level, score yourself once or twice, and then commit to training people who are your colleagues.
- 36:28Tim Shriver: Commit to learning how to raise your score.
- 36:31Tim Shriver: It sounds really small, larger scheme of things.
- 36:34Tim Shriver: We had so many things to worry about.
- 36:35Tim Shriver: How important is this?
- 36:36Tim Shriver: We think it's really important.
- 36:38Tim Shriver: Show people if you're on a school board, invite the other train, you know, invite Tammy to come and train your school board.
- 36:44Tim Shriver: Or we have trained the trainers where we're training people to train school boards or police and municipal and education departments and so on.
- 36:52Tim Shriver: Make a commitment now.
- 36:54Tim Shriver: You know, I closed today with a line uh Dr.
- 36:57Tim Shriver: King wrote in his extraordinary letter from a Birmingham City jail, where he said, you know, the question isn't whether we're going to be extremists.
- 37:04Tim Shriver: The question is are we gonna be extremists for hate or for love?
- 37:06Tim Shriver: There's nothing wrong with being an extremist.
- 37:08Tim Shriver: I would suggest we're a lot better off if we had extremists for love.
- 37:12Tim Shriver: So I would say to people, look, you're you're really busy.
- 37:14Tim Shriver: You don't have time for much.
- 37:16Tim Shriver: This is an important issue.
- 37:17Tim Shriver: Take it seriously.
- 37:19Tim Shriver: Spend 10 minutes thinking about and learning a little bit about dignity.
- 37:22Tim Shriver: And then if you're interested and you see the possibility, try to raise the quality of your rhetoric and invite others around you to do the same.
- 37:29Tim Shriver: And if you're if you're really interested, call us up and we'll come out and we'll offer some training and some workshops.
- 37:35Tim Shriver: We have uh lots of role-playing and fun activities you can do to challenge yourself and the unintended consequences, your home life might get better.
- 37:44Tim Shriver: Uh and I think our country has a better shot if more people understand that.
- 37:49Speaker 5: And what's the web address?
- 37:51Tami Pyfer: Yeah, I'm compelled to uh to invite you to join us on our website, dignity.us.
- 37:55Tami Pyfer: And you can sign up, click, and you can get our newsletters every week.
- 37:59Tami Pyfer: We write essays.
- 38:00Tami Pyfer: We're probably gonna write about you guys next week.
- 38:02Tami Pyfer: There's gonna be photos.
- 38:03Tami Pyfer: Okay.
- 38:04Tami Pyfer: It's it's a community.
- 38:05Tami Pyfer: It's a movement.
- 38:05Tami Pyfer: We're building a movement and we have a community, and they respond you know, every week.
- 38:09Tami Pyfer: You know, this really touched me, or I used this last week, and thank you for mentioning this.
- 38:13Tami Pyfer: But it you're part of something.
- 38:15Tami Pyfer: And so we would invite people to join us.
- 38:18Tami Pyfer: Uh, join the website, sign up for our newsletter, and track the movement, be part of the movement.
- 38:23Speaker 5: Yeah.
- 38:23Speaker 5: This has been such a terrific conversation, but we're at our last question now.
- 38:27Speaker 5: And so we like to end every episode of this podcast with this question, which is what gives you hope right now?
- 38:35Tami Pyfer: I'm gonna start on this one because what gives me hope right now is seeing the people I saw today.
- 38:40Tami Pyfer: Again, I I've been there, and so I feel like a special connection.
- 38:44Tami Pyfer: And I know how hard that work is.
- 38:47Tami Pyfer: I know how rewarding it is and can be as well.
- 38:50Tami Pyfer: But what gives me hope today is seeing our locally elected officials that like it is a thankless job, I'm telling you.
- 38:58Tami Pyfer: But wow, you know, they're serving us and they make my life better personally and my home, and they're making the lives of people here in Massachusetts better.
- 39:08Tami Pyfer: And I just thank God for them.
- 39:10Tami Pyfer: That gives me a lot of hope.
- 39:12Tim Shriver: I think this country is bursting with hope.
- 39:15Tim Shriver: Teachers in our country give me hope.
- 39:17Tim Shriver: Every time I visit a school, I was a teacher for a period of time.
- 39:20Tim Shriver: I have enormous admiration for what our educators do, so few resources, so much selfless giving.
- 39:26Tim Shriver: But right now, I'm also watching our political leaders.
- 39:29Tim Shriver: I'm watching how many of them are changing.
- 39:31Tim Shriver: People saying, wait a minute, we got to change.
- 39:34Tim Shriver: And we're seeing this on both sides.
- 39:36Tim Shriver: We're seeing it in governors and municipal officials, we're seeing in the National Governors Association, we have uh almost a uh uh ten governors who want to change, themselves are committing to change.
- 39:47Tim Shriver: You know, when you see your political leaders moving, you know they're starting to hear.
- 39:52Tim Shriver: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 39:52Tim Shriver: You know how politicians are.
- 39:54Tim Shriver: I grew up around politicians.
- 39:54Tim Shriver: Culture moves politics, pay attention.
- 39:57Tim Shriver: And when they see an issue starting to emerge, they want to get on it.
- 40:00Tim Shriver: We're starting to see that.
- 40:02Tim Shriver: It's baby steps.
- 40:03Tim Shriver: Some of it's inauthentic.
- 40:05Tim Shriver: Don't think I'm naive here.
- 40:06Tim Shriver: But we're starting to see baby steps that people are listening to Americans who are starving for a change.
- 40:12Tim Shriver: That gives me hope.
- 40:13Tim Shriver: I'm very confident because of it.
- 40:15Tim Shriver: Well, thank you both so much.
- 40:17Tim Shriver: Thank you.
- 40:17Tim Shriver: This has been an exception.
- 40:18Tim Shriver: Thanks for having me.
- 40:18Tim Shriver: Thanks for having us.
- 40:27NLC: Thanks for listening to City Speak with Clarence Anthony.
- 40:30NLC: If you like the show, let us know.
- 40:32NLC: Share this episode with your friends, and make sure to subscribe.
- 40:35NLC: We're curious to hear what you think, what you want more of, and how we can improve.
- 40:40NLC: If you have feedback or an idea for a guest you'd like Clarence to sit down with, send us your thoughts at Cityspeak Podcast at nlc.org.
- 40:48NLC: Join us next month for a new episode.
- 40:50NLC: Like and subscribe here or wherever you get your podcast.
- 40:53NLC: See you next time.