Latest / Word Balloon Comics Podcast / Cracking Open The DC Vault With Marty Pasko
Transcript
- 0:02Hey, everybody, welcome back. It's word Balloon the come up a conversation
- 0:06show. John Suntress here. I hope you had a great fourth weekend.
- 0:09What a weird thing when holidays fall on Tuesdays. I think you know most
- 0:15companies are like, yeah, let's give an extra day off, five day
- 0:18weekend. Well, anyway, great show tonight on Word Balloon Live. I'm
- 0:25gonna be talking to Joe Casey. He's got a brand new book out Junior
- 0:28Baker tied to his Butcher Baker book from back in the day, and we'll
- 0:34be talking about that and the writer's strike and a whole lot more. But
- 0:38in the meantime, I want to represent this wonderful conversation I had with Marty
- 0:43Pascal when he had the assignment of writing the text for the DC Vault.
- 0:48Do you remember the DC Vault, all those Vault book projects. There were
- 0:53a series of Vault books that came out from Running Press. They referred to
- 0:57it as a museum in a book because it would include reproductions of very interesting
- 1:03memorabilia, chokes, you name it, and we discuss these with Marty.
- 1:08But Marty got the assignment to write the text for the book and perfect choice.
- 1:14I mean, Marty also updated the Superman encyclopedia back in the day,
- 1:19and we get into how we got the assignment and the kind of cool stuff
- 1:23that you could find. There's a Marvel vault, there's a Spider Man vault,
- 1:26lots of these things. If you search eBay or third party booksellers,
- 1:32you can still find it. You can even still find it brand new on
- 1:34Amazon. So if you're at all curious after hearing this a while purchasing the
- 1:40dcvat vault. Those are some of the ways to find it. The DC
- 1:44Vault. We're cracking it open with Marty Pascal on today's word below. Get
- 1:51ready for the ultimate comic book Extravagance Terriffic on his Backamo he can Sun It
- 1:55uncas Pill, Connecticut from July twenty eighth to the thirty over one comic book
- 1:57creators, tons of celebrities, and hundreds of vendors all under one route.
- 2:01Meet your favorite comic book writers and artists, the good celebrities from movies and
- 2:05TV, and explore treasure troph of comics and collectibles Terrificon where dreams come true
- 2:08for comic book fans. Don't miss out to lat twenty eight to thirtieth at
- 2:13Mohegan Sun and Uncansfield, Connecticut, and get your tickets now at terrific coon
- 2:15dot com. Terrificon the Ultimate comic book Experience. Word Balloon is brought to
- 2:21you by my followers, The League of word Balloon Listeners. That's the name
- 2:25I gave my followers through Patreon. Patreon dot com slash word balloon Listen.
- 2:31Things are tough this year. I won't deny it for me financially. If
- 2:37you've ever considered supporting word balloon, I could really use your help. So
- 2:40if you think word Balloon is worth the price of a comic book, even
- 2:46a dollar a month would be greatly appreciated. Patreon dot com slash word Balloon.
- 2:51Thank you very much for your patronage and your attention the League of word
- 2:57Balloon Listeners. If you subscribe to word Balloon, I will send you an
- 3:00email that we'll have a Domino mask in Cape Ben a nice League of Word
- 3:04Balloon Listeners emblem that you've seen here on word balloon as well. But thank
- 3:09you for your support. Patreon dot com slash word Balloon. Word Balloon is
- 3:15brought to you by Alex ross Art dot com. Alex will be at San
- 3:21Diego Comicon in just a few weeks. His booth number is twenty four to
- 3:25fifteen. You can't miss the Alex Ross booth always this incredible gallery presentation of
- 3:35some of his most iconic covers and interiors, but also new stuff as well
- 3:40that you will likely see on your favorite comic covers in the months ahead.
- 3:46Make sure you check out Alex Ross Art dot com at San Diego Comicon Booth
- 3:52twenty four fifteen. It's always very distinctly and gigantically located in the center of
- 3:59the act in San Diego on the main convention floor. Check it out or
- 4:03go online for Alex rossart dot com. How did you get the assignment of
- 4:09writing the text for the DC Vault? Well, there are I think the
- 4:13best way to answer that is to say that there are about three people,
- 4:16maybe three or four who have an ongoing relationship with DC now who have the
- 4:25kind of perspective on the history of the company that I do. Because of
- 4:30the length of my association and the others weren't available. Okay, it came
- 4:36to me. But what I think made them think of me for it was
- 4:43the fact that I've had I'm remember the last generation of people who have participated
- 4:49directly in the oral history by virtue of the people that I knew and worked
- 4:55with. So all of the research and all of the arranging of the material
- 5:02was informed by having had conversations with Bill Finger, having known Bob Cannon,
- 5:10or having met Mort Weiss, and having talked to Julie Schwartz at a great
- 5:15length over the course of a close working relationship and personal relationship, and having
- 5:20a wealth of anecdotes, and I kept notes all those years. So what
- 5:28a lot of what I was able to do with the text was place it
- 5:32in a context I think that many other writers who have covered this material really
- 5:39didn't didn't have because it wasn't part of their personal experience. And fortunately,
- 5:46you know, I proposed that we try to leverage that also, and fortunately
- 5:50I also unfortunately they went along with it. I also proposed that we not
- 5:57try to do a puff piece, but get as close as something that is
- 6:03produced in effect by the company that is the subject of the the can be
- 6:09to awards an all presentation is material, and the reason for that is that
- 6:15a very candid view of the company's history is already out there in other other
- 6:21referenced tests. Okay, Jerry Jones's wonderful Bookmen of Tomorrow is a perfect example
- 6:27of that. I agree, And it would be I felt disingenuous to try
- 6:34to back away from that. The reality is what it is, and it's
- 6:40ancient history in so many cases that really we didn't have to worry too much
- 6:46about coloring the fascinating truth, except in cases where you know there might be
- 6:57might have been legal issues or obviously we don't. I mean, it's not.
- 7:01It was never my intent or anyone else does intend to malign anybody,
- 7:05Okay, And we wanted to be protective of the ongoing relationships that the company
- 7:10has. But it was, it was, it was. What I'm saying
- 7:13is it was a real opportunity here not only to present fascinating UH collectibles in
- 7:19recreation and in image images of things that haven't been generally seen, and also
- 7:28be able to enhance it with some text that um isn't coy. I guess
- 7:34it's the best way to play it. And that's that's what we tried to
- 7:38do. And of course we'll lead it to the to the readers to decide
- 7:40whether we've succeeded well. I've enjoyed reading it and also looking at all the
- 7:46different reproductions of the collectibles and other items. I mean, that's that was
- 7:51the beauty of the book that proceeded it last year. I'm assuming the same
- 7:56company that made the Marvel Fault. Yes, it's exactly the same team to
- 8:00book pack at your Becker and Mayor who did a wonderful job of assembling all
- 8:03the collect collectibles, the imagery and supervising the manufacturer of the recreations in the
- 8:11plastic sleeves, and they package that for the publisher running press. The text
- 8:20and obviously the artifacts themselves were sourced by DC, but it isn't per se
- 8:26a DC publication. But yes, yet, the same team that did the
- 8:28marble Ball. Okay, and yeah, I almost wondered, Barty, if
- 8:31they like told you, hey, there's a closet, you know, start
- 8:33rifling through it. I mean, really, when when you have a big
- 8:37company like this that has gone through the changes that it has over the decades,
- 8:41how much did you literally have to unearth some of these things or were
- 8:46you involved with that end of the of the production? I mean, I
- 8:50know you wrote the text, but how involved were you in terms of picking
- 8:52some of these things that were reproduced not very much, okay, is this
- 8:56book is actually the work of a wonderful team of very dedicated and tireless people.
- 9:05And I I you know, if I start to mention names, I'll
- 9:07inevitably leave somebody out. The acknowledgement pages as dense as it is, because
- 9:15I think pretty close to a hundred different collectors helped to supply images from their
- 9:20personal collection in addition to the material that was in the DC Library. We
- 9:28had three guys, John Wells, Mark Wade, and Mike Tiefenbacher who went
- 9:35over the manuscript that their fine tooth come for it any errors and discrepancies,
- 9:41And in some cases we had to make judgment calls because the parties couldn't agree
- 9:46simply because a lot of this stuff hasn't been carefully documented or whatever documentation there
- 9:52has been lost to history. Okay, so a lot of a lot of
- 9:54stuff is guests work after the fact, but I think in nine percent of
- 10:03vacations the material is accurate. But it was a huge, a huge cast
- 10:09of people who got involved with pulling this stuff together. Because you should you
- 10:13should know that what was submitted to Becker and Meyrick to cherry pick Frown was
- 10:22something like twice as much, or it's not three times much materials would actually
- 10:24made it into the book. Wow, my original manuscript was twice as long,
- 10:28no kidding, Um, yeah, because we discovered pretty quickly into it
- 10:35that what we were trying to do was synopsize a company with a seventy five
- 10:39year history, or seventy four to this year. It will be seventy five
- 10:41next year, Okay, in twenty thousand words, and we knew that the
- 10:50challenge was going to be to hit all of the highlights and try to bring
- 10:54something new to the next a context, which we tried to do in the
- 10:58text with with a historical context, and I don't just mean the history of
- 11:03the United United States histories such as you know, how the war effected publishing
- 11:07It's on, but rather also a history of popular culture. One of the
- 11:16things that always fascinated me is the trends in experimenting with different genres, for
- 11:22example, that went on in the period between the first Golden Age of superheroes
- 11:28their revival in the late fifty and I never had a sense, until being
- 11:37called upon to put it all together of what drove the kind of experimentation that
- 11:43they did. For example, Lassie unexpectedly became the huge radio hit in nineteen
- 11:48forty eight, and this led to a plethora of dog adventure comics from all
- 11:56kinds of publishers, and DC had two notable entries in that one in which
- 12:01was a character Streaked, the Wonder Dog that knocked Green Lantern out of his
- 12:07own magazine. Wow. The whole Western trend was essentially started by the fact
- 12:13that in nineteen forty eight, hop Along Cassidy became a huge hit on television
- 12:18to kids because all of the feature films were released and were so successful that
- 12:22they did a whole new series of half hour episodes. And then Gene Autry
- 12:28came to television, and Roy Rogers came to television, and in nineteen forty
- 12:31eight Dell Comments was publishing the most successful comic book distributed Roy Rogers, exceeding
- 12:39Captain Marvels failed at a tight Wow. Yeah. Well, and the way
- 12:43before you get off the dogs, because you mentioned Streak, now, I'm
- 12:46assuming was Rex, the other big dog, Rex, the one yes,
- 12:50okay, yes, Rex in fact was just Streaked painted white. Well,
- 12:58there was no there was no Master who was a superhero but what I mean
- 13:01by that is it was the same essential, essentially the same creative, Bob
- 13:07Cannaga writing it for Julie Schwartz as the editor. Okay, okay, And
- 13:11in fact, that's a perfect example of something that we had to cut for
- 13:16length. We went on um at some length of the original manuscripts talking about
- 13:20how hilarious these sentient animal comics were, you know, to a to an
- 13:28adult sensibility in the modern egge where you know, we know that we answer
- 13:31for MorphOS pets, but there's nothing probably going on in there, you know
- 13:35except blah blah blah Rover blah blah blah Rover. You know, so here
- 13:39you have all of these you have all of these characters who can solve mystery.
- 13:45You know, there's there's deductive reasoning going on, and they're dialing telephones
- 13:50with with you know, there's a pencils held between their jobs, and it's
- 13:54just it's it's it's a hoots, it's you know, it's a kind of
- 14:00to fancy that you just can't appreciate nowadays. Well, now, and you
- 14:03mentioned how, as you say, pop culture trends would affect what kind of
- 14:07books were being made, and I think it's amazing that DC held the license
- 14:11to an incredible pop culture phenomenon and it was barely acknowledged in their comic books.
- 14:18And it's good timing as well, because a new film is coming out
- 14:22in just a couple of weeks and that's James Bond. And can you explain
- 14:26how DC managed to reek millions off the licensing of the James Bond character.
- 14:33Well. One of Jack Leeberwitz's nephews was a gentleman by the name of Jay
- 14:41Emmett who started working for the company very very early in his career in the
- 14:48mid fifties, and Jay saw the potential of licensing consumer product licensing above and
- 14:58beyond the company had already been successful with there had always been a licensing program,
- 15:05but DC was DC was always a visionary company in that it recognized before
- 15:09any of the other comics publishers that the thing that would carry them through the
- 15:13lean times. You know, published publishing sales are cyclical like anything else.
- 15:18They realized that what would carry them through those lean times would be a continuing
- 15:24revenue stream from licensing, and they got into that with cross promotions with Kellogs
- 15:30when Kellogs was sponsoring the radio show but radio was primarily they were. They
- 15:33were the first company into radio, followed quickly by Archie actually Fox with the
- 15:39Blue Beetle Radio Show shortly before that. But DC was the first company into
- 15:43radio. Wow, and this had been and then they controlled the production themselves.
- 15:48It wasn't subcontracted, so the TV the way it is. But I'm
- 15:52if you'll just bear with me about I want to get back to answering your
- 15:56questions that what Jay saw was there was a great potential to expand on that
- 16:04in the consumer product category. And he was the first person to run a
- 16:10licensing department at that time for a comic book company that worked on models that
- 16:15are pretty much still operative today in terms of quality control. There had been
- 16:19a number, for example, of Superman costumes Halloween costumes to kids, but
- 16:25they weren't terribly accurate in terms of the way they recreated the costume. Emmett
- 16:29made a deal with Ben Cooper for an authentic looking Superman Halloween costume and it
- 16:37went through the roof and that was the test case until Licensing Corporation of America,
- 16:42the division that the licensing department eventually became, was often running but as
- 16:48part of his business model. He said, well, we basically our big
- 16:52guns are a Superman, Superman and Superman. Sure, and Batman was a
- 16:59very close second. There were, you know, at various points Batman licenses.
- 17:04But and of course this is ironic because of what we now know today,
- 17:07but until nineteen sixty six and the craziness caused by that, or generated
- 17:11rather by that that television show, um Batman was was it was a distant
- 17:15second, and as was Wonder Woman. Okay, so they needed other things,
- 17:21and so he structured the company so that it wasn't just the licensing arm
- 17:26of DC Comment or National Periodical, because it was caused at the time called
- 17:29at the time, but rather what it was was a licensing company and an
- 17:34agency, if you will, within the company, independent from the core operations
- 17:40of the publisher. And that allowed and when it was set up that way,
- 17:44they were also representing other properties, among them things that were in some
- 17:53way participated in or controlled by the other division of DC, which was Independent
- 18:00News. We have not been able to find out any from any documentation research
- 18:07that we did, whether there's a direct connection, but what we do know
- 18:10is Playboy magazine, distributed by Independent News, was the first publication in this
- 18:18country to expose the writings of Ian Fleming to the American public. It was
- 18:26serialized in the Playboy magazine. The story ye exactly, and the theory is,
- 18:32the supposition is that Emmet's team had their eye on Bond for a while
- 18:38and couldn't make anything happen with it. There was, of course, there
- 18:45is a sexual component of sexual RNDO that was completely inappropriate under the comics of
- 18:49the Comics Code. Certainly, so that may explain why it wasn't a viable
- 18:53comic book, as you know, and I believe there is a reproduction of
- 18:57the cover in the vall in the DC ball. They did a Doctor No
- 19:03comic book in Showcase. Yes, and it was not an adaptation of the
- 19:10film in the sense that Bob Brown's artwork did not render likenesses of Sean Connery
- 19:17or any of the other past members. Okay, and it tanked possible and
- 19:21conceivably because it was so deluded, it was so had to be so watered
- 19:25down, um that it didn't really recognize the source material. But as part
- 19:30of the exploitation of James Bond, um Emmett obtained the rights to the distinctive
- 19:44trench coat to James Bond War and the license on that the official James Bond
- 19:52trench coat, and then all of the then all of the toys that came
- 19:55out of it, you know, toys for adults, the Ashton Martin with
- 19:59the all the various props and things built into it. All the were the
- 20:03like the Corgy toys or the cars and stuff like that that I think came
- 20:07later, Okay, but what I'm what I'm saying is when you make the
- 20:11initial deal for the license, you enumerate all the product categories and you you
- 20:15lay out at the very very beginning what you have the right to represent.
- 20:22And in that sense, m It's a team were visionary and as we say
- 20:27in the book, by the time Steve Ross and his Kinney Na Kinney Services
- 20:37acquired National Periodicals or MPP in actually it was called it was three separate divisions,
- 20:42it really wasn't the publishing operations that they were interested in so much,
- 20:47because you know, publishing is a low margin business. What they wanted was
- 20:52the licensing Corporation of America and independent news distributor at Playboy, Popper Mechanics and
- 20:56some of the several other the best selling the top acress magazines of the day,
- 21:03Yeah, the top magazines, and yeah, and that's what that was
- 21:06my point though, Marty, And I'm glad you said it, because yeah,
- 21:07it's the licensing division that really has been the engine since its development.
- 21:12And and you know, sometimes I think comic book fans forget that about you
- 21:17know, their favorite comicbook companies and the characters, and that they are trademarks
- 21:21and license licensing properties at the end of the day, and the count books
- 21:26are really just one component of it, and that really it is the lunchboxes
- 21:29and the bedsheets and the coloring books, and you know, to to the
- 21:33degree of other other you know, exploiting for example, as you say,
- 21:37and I want to go back to this, Let's the thing is, it
- 21:41is arguable whether that's that's true anymore though really, because well it depends.
- 21:45See, this is what I've always said to people who have some of have
- 21:52frustrations with DC, for example, as freelancers. I'm often finding myself pointing
- 21:57out, no, your beef is not necessarily with BC Comic and you're looking
- 22:02at DC differently people. Because the company has such a well known history,
- 22:08it is very very easy to overlook the fact that it's not a small,
- 22:11privately held company anymore. I mean, I work for that company in the
- 22:17seventies for a time before my more recent tour of duty, and it was
- 22:19essentially six guys in the closets. But it has It is now a profitable
- 22:27division of a very profitable movie studiosion division of the largest entertainment conglomerate on the
- 22:33planet. What am I saying. I'm saying that at every level within the
- 22:40managerial flow chart, people are looking at the company from a completely different perspective
- 22:44with a different set of expectation. Comic book fans have a perspective on the
- 22:51company that's not dissimilar from that of the people who are working in the comics
- 22:56end of the business, and that's their bread and butter, and that's their
- 22:59daily life. So there's no real opportunity to correct that misperception. But it
- 23:04is difficult if you're talking about DC as a company, as a publishing company,
- 23:12it's difficult to say it's a dependent on the licensing. Okay, it
- 23:18justifies its existence to its corporate parent by creating new products to license. But
- 23:25the goal, if not necessarily the mandate of the company itself, is for
- 23:30the publishing opts if possible to support the company. And as we say in
- 23:36the book, that was the great goal that was in genet cons and Paul
- 23:41Evits's mind when they became the head of the management team in the early eighties.
- 23:51Their big dream was to make the core business of the company a profit
- 23:57center rather than a loss rated and they succeeded in that. And there have
- 24:02been a, you know, a couple of speed bumps along the way since
- 24:04then, but that's pretty much I think where the company, you know,
- 24:07has been. If you but if you back up and you look at the
- 24:11big picture, and you say, from a Time Warner or from a Warner
- 24:15Brothers perspective, what is DC DC is an intellectual property library and that and
- 24:26it exists to support the expectation of that library in other media. But again,
- 24:33it's all about perspective and from the world I come from. And I
- 24:36understand this because having worked in that end of the business. I'll talk about
- 24:41things like Brandon Entertainment, and I'll talk about the Superman brand and hardcore comic
- 24:48book people, especially on the editorial side, look at me as if I'm
- 24:52speaking a heresy, because I sound I sound like one of the you know,
- 24:56the licensing ye, and there's no there's no no harm, no foul
- 25:02either way. But my point is just simply that that the beast itself is
- 25:07so large now that you really can look at it from a number of different
- 25:11perspectives. And depending upon what you know division or you know department rather of
- 25:18DC, you're in you're like one of those you know the blind men in
- 25:22the old the Indian blindman in the old story. But they each have a
- 25:26part of the elephant. Okay, you know the story. Well, they're
- 25:30holding the trunk and they say, I have a beast that is snake as
- 25:33a snake okay, And the other one is holding the tale and says,
- 25:37oh I have I am holding an ox. The idea is the thing is
- 25:42so vast and they can't see. They just know their end of it.
- 25:47Sure, I don't know if any of this is making any sense. No,
- 25:48I no, it does, And I think it will open eyes to
- 25:52to some hardcore fans that can't get beyond the monthly stories. And this is
- 25:56the answer to questions like, you know, at the end of No Man's
- 26:00Land, why didn't they kill the joker? I mean, my god,
- 26:03he's reached this point, and there's probably because there are people above that say,
- 26:07no, the Joker is a character that needs to still exist in the
- 26:10comic books so that we can continue to exploit him in our other pursuits.
- 26:15And thankfully that is the case, or else maybe Heath Ledger wouldn't have played
- 26:18the Joker in Batman begin or the latest Dark Night movie, but by using
- 26:22a specific example of the Joker, a very exploitable character. Obviously, Yep,
- 26:29what you bring to mind is another illustration of this idea of the differing
- 26:33perspective and the managerial philosophies that govern DC change obviously as management changes, and
- 26:47they change also as the potential exploit exploitability of the material becomes apparent. What
- 26:52a what am I saying in a nice in a high folute way is that
- 27:00DC in recent years has moved away from being left alone to do its own
- 27:07thing, with the assumption that the comic book continuity is separate from the mass
- 27:11medium continuity. And because comic books are in a smaller play on a smaller
- 27:18playing field, it doesn't really matter all that much in the grand scheme of
- 27:23things whether there's a separate continuity. I mean, the classic Disney philosophy is,
- 27:27of course that it's either on model or it isn't, and everything is
- 27:33executed in exactly the same way top down. And in the early nineties,
- 27:37I remember when I was working for Warner Brothers Animation, there was a lot
- 27:38of consternation and when they were developing Batman, the animated series about whether you
- 27:45know, the Batman of the cartoons should wear black like the movie, or
- 27:49where the gray and blue color scheme of the comic and the Originally there was
- 27:56a faction that thought, no at all, everything has to be uniform.
- 28:00You have to present one image. And then someone came along and said,
- 28:03we'll wait a minute, we can actually get multiple different product line and so
- 28:07you have the kind of system that exists today, where there's a set of
- 28:11product that is tied into the movie, there's a set of products that's tied
- 28:14into the comics, there's a set of product is tied into the cartoon version
- 28:18of the characters, and so on and so on. They finally go,
- 28:19oh, wait a minute, we're cutting our nose to spite our face here,
- 28:22Yeah, we can. We can go for it all. And so
- 28:27what that spawned was a period and that's when I worked for the company between
- 28:33ninety five and two thousand and five, where essentially the attitude was, let
- 28:37them do their thing with the comics, and we'll do our thing with the
- 28:41consumer products out here in California, and then everybody's happy, okay. In
- 28:47recent years, however, comic books qua comic books as opposed to oh,
- 28:53this is just a pop cultural figure that we don't really know where the television.
- 28:59You know, like when bat In the movie came out, people were
- 29:00going on, we oh, yeah, it's based on the old TV shits,
- 29:02no know, it's based on the comico. It was a comic book.
- 29:03Yeah you heard that kind of stuff. Sure you're not going to hear
- 29:07that today, obviously. And now there I'm getting the sense that there is
- 29:15more of an interest in having the comics reflect the larger incarnation of the material,
- 29:23meaning the more highly visible one of them, of the mass media,
- 29:29and because that is a rich subject unto itself, one of the things we
- 29:37did in the book was de emphasized the media. It's been it's been covered.
- 29:42They felt pretty much to death, okay, in the form that it
- 29:48would have had to have been covered in this book, which is a you
- 29:52know, it would have to be just a few passages about the media versions
- 29:56of thing. Okay, a really interesting coverage of these characters in mass media
- 30:03is a book onto itself, and it's one I'd love to be involved in
- 30:07if it ever gets written some day. But we chose to focus on that
- 30:14level of just looking at the comic books and the publishing. But it's inscapable,
- 30:18as you see. As you see in the book, so many of
- 30:23the evolutionary changes in the content of the publishing were driven by things in the
- 30:29media, so at least we have to cover some of that to give it
- 30:32a context. There's a chapter that talks about how dcs survived the slower sales
- 30:45period of the fifties, the post war years, yes, beginning with the
- 30:49you know, the collapse of the superhero and before the superhero, the superhero
- 30:55renaisance, and of course the disaster of the comics code and the collapse of
- 30:59the prime very comic book distributor in nineteen fifty seven. And when you talk
- 31:06about all of those things, you have to reference the media, so that
- 31:10that is that is a part of it. Once again, I'm not sure
- 31:14what well, no, I no, I think this is all really interesting
- 31:18and it does, as you say, it dovetails into um how you cover
- 31:22these things in in the DC vault. But as you say, obviously there's
- 31:25tons of comic book content, and there's tons of amazing uh reproductions of cover
- 31:32sketches by Joe Hubert and so many other wonderful artists. And I mean really
- 31:37the great thing too, is, um the ashcans of various titles that that
- 31:42didn't happen. And I want to ask you about one specifically, and I
- 31:45think it's double Action. Yes. Now, I saw a sports illustration in
- 31:51that ash can, and I didn't see an artist identified, and I want
- 31:53to make a guess and say that that's Bill Gallo, because um it sure
- 31:59look it's like his stuff. And he's a very popular New York sports cartoonist
- 32:04who's done wonderful work in sports collectibles and has worked for and I don't know
- 32:07specifically which papers he's worked for, but I know he used to work for
- 32:12one of the boxing magazines that I used to work for, and that's Boxing
- 32:15Illustrated, and I would go back to nineteen forty. Yeah, he's he's
- 32:19an I mean, he was a really young guy getting started. He's in
- 32:22his seventies now, and yeah, I think he I well, maybe you
- 32:25know, I guess if it was the year nineteen forty it was WG was
- 32:30the initials next to the illustration, and it sure as hell looks like his
- 32:32stuff. Again, I could be wrong, but I know, I hate
- 32:37to cop out on you, but that really is the kind of question that
- 32:44knows what the wonderful collectors and consultants that I mentioned, okay, if anyone
- 32:50would know the answer to them to day what? But it reminded something that
- 32:52I meant to mention before that the project began. The kickoff meeting began with
- 32:59Alan Asherman, the DC archivist and the manager of the library, Paul Evitts,
- 33:06myself, George Brewer of the Design Department, and Steve Cortet, the
- 33:09in house editor of this book. We had, by the way, some
- 33:15truly terrific editors on this book, Amy Whiteman at Becker and Mayor and Steve
- 33:21Quortet a wonderful guy to work with, totally unflappable. You know, he
- 33:28routinely fields these daunting assignments with the greatest grace in equanimity, and I can't
- 33:35say enough quod things about it. But Steve managed what would have what could
- 33:40have easily become a very very chaotic process without him in a beautiful way.
- 33:46What we did was we brainstormed. When we came out of that meeting with
- 33:53a seven page list of things that could be included in the book. And
- 34:00the reason we had to start at that was because so much of this stuff,
- 34:05so much of the kinds of stuff that you might be tempted to put
- 34:07into a book like this, are already visible on the internet, have already
- 34:13been reprinted. The goal was not just to produce the DC valls, but
- 34:19to reach to the back of the vall, to a corner of the d
- 34:22vault, below the dust off stuff that people haven't seen. Because unless you
- 34:29do that, we're not bringing too much new to the party. And that's
- 34:34not a negative at all. That's what that speaks to is the passionate interest
- 34:38in DC that so many people have, so they've gone to the trouble to
- 34:43find this stuff out. So it was all it was a game of we're
- 34:45going to get them with this one they've never they've never seen, And what
- 34:51we did was we exploited the personal collections of people who were there. Julie
- 34:55Schwartz in effective bequeathed uh years and years and years of records to the company
- 35:07and the ashcans. At least at least two of the ash cans were from
- 35:12this little private stash that Paul had of things. I mean, the stuff
- 35:15has kept under lock and key and kept very you know, taken very very
- 35:19seriously. Obviously. Sure there's only the company itself understands the value of this
- 35:23sitting on this stuff on the collectives market. And I'm sure, although I
- 35:29wasn't there observing it first time, I'm sure there was a lot of um,
- 35:31almost mission impossible kind of like intrigues transporting things. But the year the
- 35:40most interesting thing about all the research was discovering that something that I'd always known,
- 35:50having you know, grown up in this business in a sense, but
- 35:53never fully appreciated, which was how little regard the cree eighters of the earliest
- 36:00material had for the idea that anyone would be interested in this stuff. And
- 36:05you've you've heard this over and over again. Absolutely. I remember when I
- 36:07was a kid, the first tour that I took at the of the DC
- 36:10offices, everybody was given a page of original arts. Wow memento. Why
- 36:16because they were just shredding it and thrown at that anyway, I wanted to
- 36:20get rid of its somehow. Do you still have yours from that tour?
- 36:22Yeah? I have some dailies from the Batman syndicated stread. Most of the
- 36:28see like I said, you know, twice as many things were proposed as
- 36:31could actually fit in the book and when. And most of my stuff was
- 36:35on the media side. Okay. A button from a promotion done by WABC
- 36:40Radio in New York, um on the occasion of the opening of the Broadway
- 36:45musical It's a Bird, It's playing in Superman. Okay. Um. A
- 36:51lot of stuff from the various custom comics and promotional things that I did and
- 37:00my last tour, and everybody who was invited to contributes have this kind of
- 37:05specialty. They had these little things that you know, and it really had
- 37:09to be ultimately up to Beccah and theyre and running press as to what was
- 37:15included. So there was a lot of a lot of stuff that I'm sure
- 37:20it could fill up a DC Vault two if they ever wanted to do one.
- 37:24And and you know, it was it was, it was. It
- 37:28was frustrating, only slightly because you realized, well, there's no way we
- 37:31can include all of this staff. So if you start, if you start
- 37:34saying, oh, gee, I wish we could have you know, but
- 37:36everybody, everybody has their mental list of things that they would would all like
- 37:38to see in the book. Well, definitely, but some of the things
- 37:42that were included. I'm glad because I remember that Treasury Addition Superman Dollar Book,
- 37:47oversized book that came out in the seventies, and in it there was
- 37:52conceptual art from Neil Adams of a of a proposed Disneyland like Superman amusement park
- 37:58to be built in my state, Illinois, at the tip of at the
- 38:01bottom of the state, and and certainly Metropolis, Illinois has its Superman celebration
- 38:07every year, and it's a wonderful thing. But man, Neil just drew
- 38:10this incredible thing. And I really as and I mean I was six or
- 38:14seven years old when I bought this comic, and I'm like, oh,
- 38:16man, I can't wait till they build this. And and there's there's a
- 38:20wonderful inclusion of the Hall of Villains, and you see people just looking at
- 38:25these statues of Mixies Pitolick and Lex Luthor and there's the parasite and Brainiac.
- 38:31It's you know, it's just that's just one of the things that I remember
- 38:35seeing. But then in addition to that, you've got conceptual art from the
- 38:38Batman TV series. As we said, you know, wonderful ruffs of cover
- 38:44art, and you know, not only the the obvious characters of the Trinity
- 38:47like Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman, but Captain Marvel, of course
- 38:52Ragman, a great little piece of Joe Huberd art of a couple of pages
- 38:55of Ragman. And and then the best of too is the memo and especially
- 39:00the Inner Office memos were evolving around things like the crisis, and I'll let
- 39:04you talk a little bit about that because that is like, you know,
- 39:08that's like finding the you know, the arc, and that's like Indiana Jones
- 39:12finding the ark and everything and seeing the Rosetta stone of the building blocks of
- 39:15what became one of the biggest events of DC comics. Well, they said,
- 39:21we're indebted to a very large past of contributors, of people who had
- 39:28hung on to things and made them available for the book. And it really
- 39:36is an astonishing example of collaboration among a very large group of people. But
- 39:43because in that seven page worsht that we came out of the initial meeting with
- 39:49it spawned so many other things, because the minute you start to inquire about,
- 39:52well does anything survive from second sexual project, you start getting oh,
- 39:57I have kept all my notes on this, or do you want you want
- 39:59to? You know, people were suddenly offering us stuff, and I would
- 40:04say about half of stuff that ended up in the book with stuff that was
- 40:06anticipated and the other half of stuff that was discovered in the course of putting
- 40:10the material together. And the original conversations were things like to go back to
- 40:15to your point about the crisis, or actually, the one I'm thinking about
- 40:19it is Mike Carlin's charts on the death of Superman count to do it.
- 40:22That's cool, Absolutely, go right ahead. And that would be a case,
- 40:24well, that would be a case if we sat in the room going,
- 40:27you know, Paul, I remember seeing that, and I remember,
- 40:30you know, his attitude was, remember being very impressed at the sureness of
- 40:32how they worked that out. And then the question, I wonder if Mike
- 40:37still has that in his file, you know, And and every time a
- 40:40question like that was posed, the person would come back and say yes and
- 40:45I've got this, and I've got that, and I've got this, and
- 40:45then suddenly there was this embarrassment of riches, if you will, ten more
- 40:51things when you were looking for one. Yeah, and obviously the further back
- 40:55you go, the further back you go, the more the more amazing and
- 41:00impressive. A lot of it is. Oh absolutely, I mean that's the
- 41:01thing. I'm mentioning things that I think, you know, current readers might
- 41:05appreciate. But man, you're right. Like, for example, the guy
- 41:08before DC really became DC, Malcolm wheel Nicholson, the first publisher. I
- 41:15wanted to mention him because, um, he in his original publications was kind
- 41:22of his own character. I mean, he had his own little adventures that
- 41:27he apparently would go on and was writing about, you know, his own
- 41:30experiences in the pulpse that he printed, and also these early comic books.
- 41:35Am I correct? Yes, yes, Colorful does not begin to describe the
- 41:42picture Roman emerges from the charchs that he is a beloved figure at DC.
- 41:51So one of my jobs was to reconcile the conflicting impressions that we have of
- 41:57him from various writings and also from me the artifacts of the anecdotes themselves,
- 42:01but he certainly seems to have emerged as a person who was more of a
- 42:09storyteller and an adventurer and a larger than life figure than a purse string clutching
- 42:19businessman. And I think the picture that the book paints pretty much makes that
- 42:23clear. And I think you can argue that each of the three principles who
- 42:30founded the company with the Nicholson, Jack Levioitz, and Harry don Hmfeld were
- 42:37each indispensable, page had something to contribute that would not have created the company
- 42:45that emerged had they not all contributed in the measure that they did. I
- 42:52think each one of those people was indispensable to the success of the company.
- 42:58The different may have been that Wheeler Nicholson was gambling, was throwing things against
- 43:05the wall to see what would stick. And Leibowitz and Donenfeld, by virtue
- 43:14of having been publishers and printers of a number of magazines, the Early Pulpse,
- 43:21the Racy Men's Pulpse in particular, spective they had a greater sense of
- 43:29when to be risk adverse and when not debated. Okay, wait until you
- 43:34have sales figures for thou three issues before you launch another title. You can
- 43:39actually to think. But on the other hand, had Wheeler Nicholson not had
- 43:47impulses that another perspective might have seen as reckless, you wouldn't have had detectives
- 43:54and action all occurring at the same time. Because by that point in nineteen
- 44:01thirty seven, when the other two partners were, you know, taking over
- 44:06the control of the company, the need for a certain number of titles to
- 44:12launch new material, and the idea that you had to you had to take
- 44:16those kinds of risks was already firmly established. I guess what I'm saying is
- 44:22I think Leavero's on his own might have been too conservative. Donnan Fell on
- 44:27his own would have focused more on just the physical manufacturing and the distribution channel,
- 44:35and Wheeler Nicholson on his own would have focused almost entirely on the creative,
- 44:38with a somewhat naive belief that only that and no marketing would drive product.
- 44:45So each of those men contributed equally to laying the foundation for the company
- 44:51that followed. But Wheeler Nicholson is a different called figures to nail down because
- 45:01he was a self mythologizer, even much more so than than Jack Liebowitz.
- 45:07Okay, I'm sorry, Rather Harry Donon's own okay, and his descendants do
- 45:14have a relationship with the company. Okay. Their perception of this is,
- 45:22you know, because it select three or four generations on sure, my sentiment
- 45:24at their perception of Wheeler Nicholson is itself kind of day. So in a
- 45:30sense as far as who this guy was, he gets the last laugh because
- 45:36he's gotten he has been able to write his own magacy and it is precisely
- 45:38the material that you're reacting to in your question. Yeah, the only evidence
- 45:43left are the stories that he left behind. Exactly interesting. And yeah,
- 45:45I mean the other thing that I like too is because we know the editors
- 45:52that were keepers of certain characters. And if you go back, you know
- 45:54that Julie Schwartz was editing Superman. Before Julie, it was mort Weisinger before
- 46:00mord it was Whitney Ellsworth. Am I correct? Well, Whitney Whitney Ellsworth
- 46:05was a line editor only for a relatively brief period of time. Okay,
- 46:09what Whitney Ellsworth was effectively by as early as I think nineteen forty one,
- 46:15when Mort Weisinger joined the company, was the editorial director. But they didn't
- 46:22have that title, per say, Okay, the first person to have that
- 46:25title was Harry Donenfeldt's son Irwin, who came to the company in from nineteen
- 46:30forty eight. What wit Ellsworth did was coordinate the editorial assignments, set up
- 46:37the structure by which the material was produced, and the workloads were distributed across
- 46:45several different editors in terms of character franchise. So there weren't there weren't those
- 46:50kinds of editorial fiefdoms that you were thinking of as you frame your questions.
- 46:57Yes, mort Weisinger was the editor of super Man, but he did not
- 47:01consolidate his control over that character until around nineteen fifty. Okay, up until
- 47:07that point, Jack Shift edited the Superboy titles, right, I'm sorry.
- 47:14Throughout the fifties, Jack Schiff edited the Superboy titles, but the Superman titles
- 47:19were consolid under Moore, and throughout the fifties there was this gradual shift,
- 47:22but it really wasn't until the height of the success of the television series,
- 47:28like mid fifty fifty four fifty five, and of course by that point more
- 47:31it is already the story editors television series that all the Superman material was brought
- 47:38together under more and all the batmanmentary was put together and brought together under Jack
- 47:45Shift. Okay, but there was a real strong sense, I think on
- 47:49Widow's Worth part that you don't want to concentrate too much power in terms of
- 47:54control over a franchise in one editorial office. And as with Elsworth, you
- 48:01know, essentially was divorced from any involvement in the in the publications from about
- 48:07nineteen fifty two armor because he was producing the television series. Well, yeah,
- 48:09that's what I was wondering that that that through line in terms of when
- 48:14he went to Hollywood, and and really you know, that's as you say,
- 48:19it's interesting that the company had control of how the properties were exploited in
- 48:24the media. And I know I am curious about that. And you started
- 48:29with the radio show. I want to talk about that for a second because
- 48:32before we get back to TV, because as you say, Kelloggs came in
- 48:36with Pep and the Superman serial began. And I don't mean the Clunchy Cereal
- 48:40and the Adventures. The children's episode. Actual Superman had been on the radio
- 48:46for a little over two years before Kellogg's actually got involved. Okay, okay,
- 48:52it began as a local program in New York sponsored by an obscure oatmeal
- 48:57company. So we put it. I can't remember the name of the company
- 49:00anyway, um, and it ran locally and then it was syndicated on transcription
- 49:05desk um, so it wasn't I would go ahead out of out of work,
- 49:09out of WR. Okay. And then it took them two years and
- 49:14everything moved much more slowly in those days. Uh, for a major sponsor
- 49:19to pick them up. And then they went Matt national on the Mutual network.
- 49:23Yes, which which w R was a part of. It was WR
- 49:27in New York, w g N in Chicago, and w x y Z
- 49:30now w x YT in Detroit. I know. They were three of the
- 49:35hubs that provided a lot of the programming. Yes, are you talking?
- 49:37You are you talking about the station out of Detroit that produced the Green Striker,
- 49:42created the Green Hornets for it. Oh, actually, I should take
- 49:45that back. They were part of the Blue Network, weren't they. Well,
- 49:46actually, you know this is where my whole time radio fandom cut kicks
- 49:51in. Oh, don't get me started. We'll digress, and you'll have
- 49:53so much editing to do. No, it's well, it's all superhero talk.
- 49:58So it's okay, it works. That's a sub I get feared in
- 50:00my heart too. I noticed that more and more with a lot of writers
- 50:05and artists that I speak to. Of your agent and my agent older,
- 50:08I should say it. Forgive me, Marty, because I know you're saying,
- 50:12because I know you're older, but it's okay. But no, it's
- 50:14you know, I agree. I think old radio is great. But I
- 50:17want to ask because you mentioned it in the book. Um, there was
- 50:21a writer for the Superman Radio Show and his last name was Kennedy. I
- 50:27want to say, was a sterling Kennedy or something like that, but he
- 50:30oh, I actually no, I know what you're a friend, Um,
- 50:32a member the name of Stetson Kennedy, thank you, who was actually a
- 50:37political activist. Yes, he was not a writer. He was. He
- 50:40was a spy, if you will, in a sense for the Superman Radio
- 50:45Show, and in the sense that what he had done is he had gone
- 50:47undercovered and infiltrated a plan cell and wrote lived to write about the inner workings,
- 50:57the rituals and so on. And he was because credited with being one
- 51:00of the first journalists among a group of them, to shed a certain harsh
- 51:10light in a certain degree of close scrutiny and get away with it to the
- 51:15KKK. And what he did was he said a lot of details of how
- 51:19they worked and the mentality and so on. Two writers for the radio show,
- 51:24and they produced a I guess a week of continuity because the shows were
- 51:30fifteen minutes called Knight of the Fiery Cross, I believe, or Clan of
- 51:36the Fiery Cross. I don't have my notes in front in front of me.
- 51:38Obviously there's something something to that effect. And that that became the first,
- 51:45um arguably the first maybe not maybe not the first, but certainly one
- 51:51of the first indictments of organized racial discrimination in a children medium. And I
- 52:01don't know what the awards that it won, where I knew it did word
- 52:06I did, but I'm not sure if, like you know, the Peabodies
- 52:08were around at that time. But that we cite that in the book as
- 52:14a one of a number of early examples of the pro social or social consciousness
- 52:24orientation of DC. That although comics fans today look upon the institution of the
- 52:31Comics Code as a really dark and sad chapter in comics, much much the
- 52:37way I suppose liberals look at McCarthyism. The fact remains that DC was uniquely
- 52:49positioned to accommodate the kinds of concerns that made the comic book the Companies more
- 52:59viable or either I should say, less objectionable in the late in the late
- 53:05fifties, and it came by it. Honestly. One of the great ironies
- 53:09that we talk about in the book, and Chris Jerry Jones and his goes
- 53:14on at great length about this, is that Jack Leebowitz actually began life as
- 53:19a socialist, a dedicated socialist. He also happened to be a CPA who
- 53:24put himself through Business School of New York University by working as an accountant,
- 53:30a paradox to be sure. That kind of social conscience that he represented and
- 53:40a concern about what was respectable and being peculiar where the children were impressionable that
- 53:46that drove a lot of DC's decision making. And then of course when Jack
- 53:51Shift came aboard, he was perhaps the most I don't want to say bleeding
- 53:57hard, because that's usually construted as a pejorative. I don't mean it that
- 54:00way, but he was considered to be among the staff the most sensitive to
- 54:06these kinds of things, and he was always the first to volunteer for any
- 54:13of the more progressive things that they were trying to do. There was I
- 54:15don't think that the plate from Johnny Everyman made it into the book, but
- 54:21there was a series in World Finest called Johnny every Man, which was essentially
- 54:27a plea for tolerance. Um, I mean it was. It was an
- 54:32argument. The entire series was an argument for respect for cultural diversity, some
- 54:37forty years ahead of its time. Wow. Yeah. And one of the
- 54:43advisors to DC was pearl s Buck, a Nobel laureate. God you know.
- 54:47Oh yeah, they they took that kind of stuff very seriously. But
- 54:54what you can't really know, this many years after the fact, is how
- 54:58much of that was driven by a social consciousness exclusively, or how much of
- 55:05it was driven by, you know, fear of reprisal and the need to
- 55:08cover your you know what. And I suspect it's a little bit of both.
- 55:12But as I said, I think, you know, most of it
- 55:15really was born of a belief that you were doing a good work and presenting
- 55:22certain ideas to kids. And as we know, especially as we got into
- 55:27the fifties, the idea of teaching kids good citizenship was very much part of
- 55:34the point of the realm, you know, Yeah, that's well, that's
- 55:36and that's the interesting thing. How things started off a more editorial with a
- 55:42more of an adult editorial, kind of bent superman, kind of fighting for
- 55:45the common man, as he did in especially the very early years of Action,
- 55:50and how it, as you say, morphed into a way to teach
- 55:52children how to how to behave and act properly in a social manner. And
- 55:58it is interesting that those things were going on. And then yet, as
- 56:00as we all know, in the fifties, doctor Wortham comes along and suddenly
- 56:06says, hey, Bruce a dick man, I don't know, I think
- 56:07that's kind of a queer relationship, and you know, and suddenly finds all
- 56:10these little hidden meanings although there's that, But then and I don't know about
- 56:15this. Did did Wortham really get into the wonder woman craziness that is kind
- 56:23of self evident in some of the art that still exists from the forties and
- 56:28kind of the s and quality that that the that the book add back then.
- 56:31Seduction of the Innocent itself covers a great deal of territory um in a
- 56:39comparatively swim volume. Okay, And I say comparatively. What I mean by
- 56:45that is exhaustive treatises in hardcovers on the subject of comic books are much more
- 56:52commonplace today than they were in nineteen forty eight. I remember, for the
- 56:59longest time in most public libraries there were exactly two books, and two books
- 57:02only on comic books that you could find. Jules Feiffer and who else.
- 57:06No, No, I'm talking. I'm about material published a good twenty years
- 57:10before Jules Feiffer. Okay, I'm thinking the grant was the Comics published in
- 57:15nineteen forty eight. Again, the comics, okay, but the author is
- 57:22Colton waw waug h. It's out of print. It's a very obscure book,
- 57:28but it was published in the same year a Seeduction of the Innocent,
- 57:30and like Seeduction of the Years and Law's book is a very skin volume.
- 57:36But it not only covers comic books, it covers comic strips. And the
- 57:40same kind of striking a glancing blow to every subject approach is evident in Seduction
- 57:46of the Innocent. The oft quoted lines about Superman being a nutchee in Power
- 57:53Fantasy with Area disturbing area and overtones, and the line about the Batman and
- 57:59Rob than being the wish dream of two homosexual kiding together. These have been
- 58:04quoted over and over again, um, you know, over the fifty fifty
- 58:08plus year since the books, so I'm sure. But they are also pretty
- 58:13much the only things he says in the book about either Superman or a Batman.
- 58:19I don't recall him mentioning Wonder Woman, but that just may be because
- 58:24I didn't need to consult those sections of the book for the research. Pretty
- 58:29much all of the Wonder Woman stuff has been documented by Less Daniel, and
- 58:37so in that case, it was just a matter of you know, fact
- 58:40checking, seeing was there anything less out stuff that you put you know that
- 58:45that that hadn't been gotten right, okay. And the only thing that I
- 58:49was able to contribute beyond that really was to be able to talk about it
- 58:51in somewhat frank or language. Less would describe these things and would quote liberally
- 58:57from the correspondence I'm talking about. He did two books. They're wonderful books,
- 59:00by the way, they are about Wonder Woman exclusively, and he goes
- 59:07he's able because of the space he has to go into a great deal more
- 59:12detail. But one of the things that isn't really touched on quite as much
- 59:17is the nervousness that was engendered by some of that early material. Certainly more
- 59:31people know more about alternative sexuality, bondage, and discipline. I don't want
- 59:42to say as and them that really wasn't an element of the material, But
- 59:45people know more about that today in the general public than did then. So
- 59:47it was a lot easier for some of the stranger overtones of that material to
- 59:52go unnoticed. But you got the sense that they were always worrying. It
- 59:59drove Shelley may to distraction. To the point, and this is something that
- 1:00:01we couldn't get into the book. It drove Shelley Mayor to such distraction that
- 1:00:05he hired an editor whose exclusive job. This is before Bob Canada came aboard
- 1:00:12okay, because Bob Bob got involved with Wonder Woman. After Marston died Create
- 1:00:17the Creator Um, he hired a woman named Dorothy Rubicek, who was known
- 1:00:25as the primarily as the romance editor Dorothy Wolfolk when she came back to DC
- 1:00:30about twenty years later. Okay, and Dorothy's entire job was sending letters to
- 1:00:37William Moulton Marston. That consisted essentially of no, no, you can't do
- 1:00:43that. We'll get in trouble. It is you know, I this was
- 1:00:50material for children, so you'll forgive my laughing, but you know you can't
- 1:00:53help that. And you see when when when when he dies and Canada takes
- 1:00:58over and it's all it's all documents in the visuals in the DC vault.
- 1:01:02You go from these covers of you know, the bullets and bracelets and the
- 1:01:07last binding people and change, you know the Amazon women are enslaves and tied
- 1:01:13up and change. Sure, you go from all of these covers too,
- 1:01:16suddenly these static shots drawn by Bob Oxner in his best teen comedy style of
- 1:01:24Steve Trevor showing up in front of Wonder Woman with a bouquet of flowers and
- 1:01:29she's standing there employees Coyley, you have expect to see cartoon hearts round her
- 1:01:35hand. They stopped just short of that. Well, they were very much
- 1:01:37like the Lowest Lane books and really, unfortunately, to the detriment of Wonder
- 1:01:42Woman's characterization, she did kind of you know, there was that component of
- 1:01:46you know, what do I do about my boyfriend Steve as opposed to being
- 1:01:50the the hero that she has you know, become again today and thankfully it's
- 1:01:54a it's a bit you know there. The effort is there to make the
- 1:01:59you know, women hero as important as men heroes and everything. And we've
- 1:02:01got cool people like Greg Rucca and Gail Simone and Philimenez and George Perez and
- 1:02:06all the let you know, people that have really helped redefine the character in
- 1:02:08the last twenty five years. So well, I think I think you have
- 1:02:13to give the lions share of the credit to making that character viable ultimately to
- 1:02:17Cairenburger and George Perez very cool. I'm sorry, no, I'm a great
- 1:02:22I'm saying, please go on. And that may be one of the more
- 1:02:25impressive accomplishments to DC, you know, has been able to pull off,
- 1:02:30which to shake this character that was so well known yet in terms of strict
- 1:02:40bottom line dollars and cents, never a tremendous performer, but had to continue
- 1:02:49to be published at various points in its history for overwriting concerns. For example,
- 1:02:54it was at one point in its history it was losing money domestically,
- 1:03:00it was doing very well at received so they couldn't cancel it. And there
- 1:03:05was a rights reversion clause in the deal where if DC stopped publishing Wonder Woman
- 1:03:09for any particular length of time, all rights would revert to the Marstonist day.
- 1:03:13Wow. Okay, well there you go, and you know they're Therein
- 1:03:16is another interesting wrinkle about the company, as you say, if you don't
- 1:03:22use the character, you know it could revert back to And obviously that was
- 1:03:24the specific contract I'm assuming with the Marston family. Yeah, that was that
- 1:03:30was a specific uh A right, I should say, a unique case.
- 1:03:35So that was that was part of it, part of the deal that that
- 1:03:37Charlie Gaines made. Okay, Um, you go into detail as well.
- 1:03:43I should mention, as you mentioned, Charlie Gaines h the All American line
- 1:03:46versus the National line and the merging of the two lines eventually. And and
- 1:03:52as you say, Wonder Woman was an all American character. Gains character,
- 1:03:54Um Green Lantern was for the Flash was those are the three big ones that
- 1:04:00I could think of Athense And because to the best of our knowledge, I
- 1:04:04remember again we had a whole team of people doing the research on this.
- 1:04:10There we don't have copies of contracts to shed any light on some of this
- 1:04:13stuff. But the interrelationship between All Americans and DC was extremely complex, and
- 1:04:30to this day we were not able to completely unravel it because we don't have
- 1:04:33the contracts that excel out what exactly the relationship was. I I just do
- 1:04:39remember Julie Schwartz telling me so many times that we never understood ourselves what the
- 1:04:47connection between the two companies. Where we just knew that the characters showed up
- 1:04:51in each other's books from time to time, we didn't know how that worked.
- 1:04:57And the way I remember, the way Julie described it to the NTC
- 1:04:59said, one day I was working in the All American offices, and then
- 1:05:06another day we moved and instead of the everybody on my floor being an All
- 1:05:14American editor, suddenly I was working, you know, down the hall from
- 1:05:19Mort and Mort Weisinger had been his childhood friends, but they didn't actually work
- 1:05:26together, or rather work in the same in the same physical space for a
- 1:05:30few years. And the way he described it was, it was this way
- 1:05:32one day, it was another way the next day. We never really knew
- 1:05:36why. But the thing that keeps coming back to me, and it just
- 1:05:42goes back to what I was saying earlier about how little people took any of
- 1:05:45this stuff seriously. You know, it was a job, it was It
- 1:05:48might have been a fun job for some people, which you always got the
- 1:05:51impression that it wasn't really what they wanted to do, you know. I
- 1:05:56mean the earliest comic book artists were failed strip cartoonists or magazine illustrators for that
- 1:06:02matter. Some of the was such a thing as magazine illustration. Comics were
- 1:06:08the thing to fill in between those advertising jobs that really paid the rent.
- 1:06:12You know. So all the history is informed by the overwriting sense, and
- 1:06:18I'm talking about just like the first thirty years of the business. All they
- 1:06:23started to change by them at sixty, But prior to that, all of
- 1:06:28the history, how much or how little of it there is, and how
- 1:06:30reliable it is, is due to the fact that they all the thinking about
- 1:06:35this kind of thing when it comes to keeping records and so forth, was
- 1:06:40driven by a sense of well, nobody's going to care about there. Who
- 1:06:42gives a shit? Sure? Yeah? Well, and you mentioned Withney Ellsworth.
- 1:06:46The main confusion about well Ellsworth's role, the main reason why most people
- 1:06:51who paid attention to Innieches and old comic books, think that you know,
- 1:06:57he had more of a role to play in the publishing operations in the fifties
- 1:07:00than he actually did. Was that his name, he's lit his editor in
- 1:07:03the book. He's not the actual editor in the sense of a line editor.
- 1:07:06He's more of a super supervising editor. And his is the only credit
- 1:07:10in the book. And if this continues for approximately eight years when he's not
- 1:07:15even doing that job, and I think magnified by the fact that if you
- 1:07:19watch the Superman's show, he is the only name of his only producer.
- 1:07:24Yes, he sat out on the coast full time. But but point is,
- 1:07:27I always assumed that there must have been horrible resentment on the part of
- 1:07:30the editors that they didn't get any credit for their work. Yeah, no,
- 1:07:33kidding, Well, that turns out not to have been the case,
- 1:07:39at least as far as Julie Schwartz was concerned. Murray Murray Boltenot never claimed
- 1:07:44to care. I asked him about that once. But Murray was the kind
- 1:07:46of guy where you got the feeling that if it bothered him, he wouldn't
- 1:07:48say anything about it because he thought, well, maybe I'm being petty and
- 1:07:51I shouldn't you know, okay, but Julie's editors, we didn't care.
- 1:07:57A raise would have been better than having our names in the A. DJA
- 1:08:01and everybody everybody will you know, says that in a business where there isn't
- 1:08:10the opportunity to feel like a demi celebrity. But once the fans came along
- 1:08:14in the mid sixties and they started paying close attention, and DC perhaps belatedly
- 1:08:18recognized that there was a potential commercial value in publishing the credits on the books,
- 1:08:24as Stanley had been doing for about seven or eights prior to that,
- 1:08:30until all of that happened. They're what you get the sense that the pioneers
- 1:08:34of the business were toiling and anonymity and we're just happy to have it that
- 1:08:41way, with a few rare exceptions, and those are the ones who are
- 1:08:48known as personalities, and they're usually on the talent side rather than on the
- 1:08:51editor editorial or managerial side. Certainly, Bob Kane had a very finely developed
- 1:08:58sense of self promotion absolutely early on. Yeah, and that is the interesting
- 1:09:01thing. And you see then in the book that he was one of those
- 1:09:05few artists that would truly sign the front page of every feature and then there
- 1:09:11was his name, Bob Kane. I think that's that's amazing. And we
- 1:09:15all hear the stories about Bob came and of course, and uh, you
- 1:09:17know, did you I heard quite a few from Bill Finger after Well that's
- 1:09:21you know, I want to ask, because you said you mentioned that you
- 1:09:24that you knew Bill Finger and everything, and what what about that whole Batman
- 1:09:29dynamic of Bill Kane, Bob Finger, Shelley Shelley moldenof all those guys working
- 1:09:34I have about I had a two hour conversation with Bill Finger in like nineteen
- 1:09:42seventy three. He could come up to the office to pick up or like
- 1:09:46some kind of some kind of check, okay, But he wasn't actually writing
- 1:09:50for the company, So I mean, I don't know what what was going
- 1:09:53on there. Um, I mean I think he might have done some work,
- 1:09:59um for reprint thing, you know, like an introduction or a text
- 1:10:02page or something, Okay. And that was another thing we discovered. But
- 1:10:04by the way, just briefly which that there's this huge stack of unpublished material
- 1:10:10that we didn't have. You know, they couldn't be reproduced. But we
- 1:10:12drew, We drew on heavily in the research and what they are there the
- 1:10:15first person accounts of the creation of things by there as individuals. But this
- 1:10:19wasn't I don't think this was what he was there for. But I got
- 1:10:23his take on the creation of Batman because I mean I was I was so
- 1:10:28astonished to be, you know, sitting in this bullpen. Now he's waiting
- 1:10:32to see an editor. I'm just sitting working there out in the open,
- 1:10:35in a cubicle. And that was the other thing that was so amazing about
- 1:10:39the working at DC in the early seventies was how accessible so many of these
- 1:10:45people who would would be lionized at conventions only a few years later were And
- 1:10:53you always had this sense that they were kind of mystified that suddenly or there
- 1:10:57were all these people who were interested. And you've seen that in more recent
- 1:11:00years. I mean, I think Martin O'Dell came to that kind of late.
- 1:11:03Yeah, you know, realizing that there was a whole bunch of there
- 1:11:06were a whole bunch of people out there who were, you know, really
- 1:11:11jazzed by the would have been jazzed to meet the guy who created a green
- 1:11:14land. Absolutely, and you remember, you see these guys at the conventions
- 1:11:16today even. I mean, this one of the things that's amazing. You
- 1:11:21know, the Craig Fleshil. Do you know that name, Yes, they
- 1:11:24do. That's one of the names of the DC vault. Absolutely one of
- 1:11:27the Golden Age artists. Wonderful, no kidding, Oh my god. He
- 1:11:30was one of the consultants on this book. Steve Cortaire, editor, dealt
- 1:11:33directly with Craig Wow. Yes, So, I mean, we had the
- 1:11:36access of the memories of people who were working for the company in nineteen thirty
- 1:11:41five. It's it's it's amazing way the way state with anyway. The the
- 1:11:46story of the creation of Batman is essentially the one I heard from Bill Finger.
- 1:11:53It is supported by other accounts, but of course it's all anecdotal,
- 1:11:58and Bob Kane is no longer with us to speak to it. So what
- 1:12:02we had to do, of course, be very It was to be very
- 1:12:05careful that this was their recollection. But the story that we tell, and
- 1:12:12I don't want to I don't want to give it away for someone who's going
- 1:12:14to read the book, but it is that essentially, you get the impression
- 1:12:17that Kaine had a very vague concept for Batman, and with Bill's help.
- 1:12:24Detail upon detail, you know, was sort of fed to him or strongly
- 1:12:28suggested by Bill, and and over a laborious give and take process, or
- 1:12:33trial and error process over a weekend, they came up with the concept.
- 1:12:41And because of the deals that were struck and the fact that the material always
- 1:12:46brought Kaine signature, there's always been a feeling among fans that perhaps we don't
- 1:12:53know what the exact nature of the origin of the character. And of course,
- 1:12:59as we all know, memory idealizes there's a very strong self aggrandizing or
- 1:13:04promotional streak in all of us. And I think it's just human nature to
- 1:13:09run the risk of overstating your contribution to something when you talk about something.
- 1:13:15So it's it's one of the interesting challenges of the book, and I believe
- 1:13:20it to the readers to decide whether it's been met or not. Was to
- 1:13:27present these new takes, with these different takes, with these little herd takes
- 1:13:30on the origin of some of this material because of its own interest value,
- 1:13:35without necessarily presenting it as gospel truth of history. And that was important to
- 1:13:44us because the pockets of memory of these various people to the extent that it's
- 1:13:48been recorded and still survives. Is as much a corner of a vault as
- 1:13:54any of the artifacts in the book itself. Very cool. I wanted to
- 1:13:59ask about it. And as we're talking about the Batman world, um one
- 1:14:02creator in the seventies that had a lot in late sixties that had a lot
- 1:14:05to do with Batman who was a comic strip artist on his own and did
- 1:14:10some work from Marvel as well. But I think wrote a lot of interesting
- 1:14:13stories not just for Batman, but also on some of the war titles as
- 1:14:15well. Frank Robins, because I really think he's one of the forgotten guys
- 1:14:20when it comes to a lot of the Batman stuff, And I think he
- 1:14:24really As I'm starting to reread a lot of the reprinted material that's been in
- 1:14:28the showcase books and and I just become more and more aware of what he
- 1:14:31was doing for both companies in the seventies. It's like, Man, you
- 1:14:34really never hear about what Frank Robbins was doing. All you ever hear here
- 1:14:39is the comic strip fans who know Johnny Hazzard and compare his work to Milton
- 1:14:45Kenneff and and that stuff. But yeah, tell me, tell me about
- 1:14:47Frank Robbins. Oh, okay, Frank. I only met Frank one okay,
- 1:14:53in Julie's office. And Frank was one of those people who had an
- 1:15:00amazing memory for people's names and what he heard they'd said about it. I
- 1:15:06remember the story. I remember about Frank personally. I can tell you a
- 1:15:10little bit more about him. But when he first started working as a writer
- 1:15:15for Julie Schwartz and not as an artist. That was in the late sixties
- 1:15:20when Andrew and x Positore had started drawing The Flash and Frank Robins started at
- 1:15:27about nineteen sixty eight. In the Flash, and as it was a bio,
- 1:15:30mentioned that he had worked for RKO Studios, and that's all he said.
- 1:15:36And in my you know, I was a kid, and as you
- 1:15:39know, in my fan the fanboy, presumptuous presumptuousness was there. I automatically
- 1:15:44assumed that he was a screenwriter, and I wrote some letter of comment I
- 1:15:46said something about, you know, I was a former Ark screenwriter, Frank
- 1:15:49Rabbins rember. So he comes into the office. The very first thing,
- 1:15:55you know, he's introduced, because look he's Martin past going on it.
- 1:16:00I never worked for our Kao as a screenwriter, and I'm like, WHOA,
- 1:16:03why don't you talking? I have this vague recollection of having written this
- 1:16:08letter some some you know, six or seven years later. And we laughed
- 1:16:12and it was a very very pleasant conversation. And what struck me about Frank
- 1:16:15was that he was, again, like so many of these people, totally
- 1:16:23self effacing, and not in an ingratiating way, but in a very sincere
- 1:16:30and honest way, just very matter of fact about the things that he had
- 1:16:33done. But by the time I had met him, I had also had
- 1:16:38done enough reading and in self education on the whole syndicated strip area to understand
- 1:16:45who he was. A former assistant of NOELH. Sickles, who is a
- 1:16:48giant in that field, is the primary influence of Milton Caniff and from their
- 1:16:59spawn or was a seminal influence therefore on a number of people who are considered
- 1:17:06gods among classic comic book art fans. Alex Tos, Carmine Infantino. All
- 1:17:13of these people have branched out on their own in their own very distinct styles.
- 1:17:16But if you look at the material of the late forties, you see
- 1:17:21that Carmine, Alex to blanking on a lot of their names. There's there's
- 1:17:29a whole group of them, and they're almost all inked by Frank Gequoia.
- 1:17:31And the art all looks very much alike. It is all heavily influenced by
- 1:17:36Noel Sickles. You look at Johnny Hazard and you see exactly the same kind
- 1:17:44of thing, except in the syndicated strip area. And Frank Frank as an
- 1:17:49artist, was one of those lucky people who didn't have to do the comics
- 1:17:53because he was He was on a successful syndicated strip, and that was that
- 1:17:58was the that was the your vibe, as we point out in the book,
- 1:18:00that all the cartoonists of that era aspired to, but Frank would never
- 1:18:06Frank was part of the influx of talent that Carmine and Santino engineered when he
- 1:18:14took over. The editors were primarily people with writing backgrounds when they worked under
- 1:18:19Irwin Donensvilles. Carmine represented the first time someone with an art background, somebody
- 1:18:26who had actually created the product, was in charge of the staffing and made
- 1:18:33suggestions about who to get to do various things, and he brought a lot
- 1:18:38of people. He and Joe Orlando brought a lot of really talented people back
- 1:18:43into the fold or into the fold in the late sixties and early seventies,
- 1:18:48and Frank was one of the first people, I think, to discover what
- 1:18:51a lot of guys in recent years like how we chaken. I'm sorry,
- 1:18:56Howard, I just automatically think of him as you know, Howie. But
- 1:19:00I understand now he prefers to be thought out anyway. Howard is discovered in
- 1:19:04recent years that it can be just as gratifying to write rather than to draw,
- 1:19:10and you can do it faster and do more of it. And so
- 1:19:13I think Frank was perfectly happy to just to be a writer. But what
- 1:19:15people don't but I know as to the contributions to Batman, it endures today.
- 1:19:20He created Man that there you go. He created a whole number of
- 1:19:25other characters that are still part of the DC continuity, but in lesser,
- 1:19:30in lesser roles. But I know what you mean about his art, But
- 1:19:38it was so idiosyncratic by comparison to what comic book fans were used to.
- 1:19:43Did I recall that it was viewed very much as an acquired taste at the
- 1:19:45time. I completely understand. I was one of those kids in the seventies
- 1:19:48that was like, what is this? And yet it kept and yet I
- 1:19:53kept buying the books. I mean, I loved his run on the Invaders,
- 1:19:57and it was a crazy looking Captain America and name and all of them.
- 1:20:00But you really do as as you get older, you appreciate it more
- 1:20:03and more. Well if if if you become as I've had to out of
- 1:20:08necessity just to keep myself viable in the industry, more art literate. You
- 1:20:13look at this stuff through a whole different set of eyes when you revisit it
- 1:20:15thirty years later. Yep, and you look at Oh my god, it's
- 1:20:18so noir and jump cuts. Yep, it's a look at the way that's
- 1:20:23slighted, look at the look at the way the blacks are spotted. Oh
- 1:20:26my goodness. But when you're a kid, you're just focusing on the things
- 1:20:30that disorient, disorient you. Like that odd habit he would have of not
- 1:20:33creating points on the balloon tail with the bloontails would just sort of disappear behind
- 1:20:39people's heads. And if you look at the stuff where he was he was
- 1:20:45allowed to do the balloon shapes as opposed to the Letterer, you'll you'll see
- 1:20:47that, and it's you know, when you I don't want to get into
- 1:20:55an argument for elitism, but there's there's something to be said for an informed
- 1:20:58opinion, you know, as a post. Yeah. Absolutely, no,
- 1:21:03that's great, man, um I you know the no, Marty, don't
- 1:21:11kid yourself. Man, where this is all going in? This is great
- 1:21:13and no, because this is what people need to understand. I mean,
- 1:21:15I I really one of the reasons why I appreciate talking to uh people of
- 1:21:20and I'm sorry, I don't mean to keep aging you, but people that
- 1:21:24worked when you did your generation is they have to know what happened before nineteen
- 1:21:29ninety and I think that a lot of younger readers don't know the the interesting
- 1:21:32stories and how we got to where we are now. The only reason,
- 1:21:36the only way you understand it is if you understand what happened before. And
- 1:21:40that's why a book like the DC Vault is a wonderful, uh, you
- 1:21:45know example to to look at and really appreciate all the different evolutions of the
- 1:21:48company and where where people started and how things turned out and where they are
- 1:21:54today. It's great. I mean, they're you know, you've got a
- 1:21:57page of spy in there, the this Siegel Schuster feature that was in I'm
- 1:22:02assuming Detective that was pre Superman. Um, I'm sorry, it's called Spy.
- 1:22:11Uh Spy Siegel and Schusters. Oh yeah, I mean, and there's
- 1:22:15you know, there's examples there and there's a wonderful little section where I forget
- 1:22:17the protagonist's name, but you see him and you see the heroine, and
- 1:22:21there are there are flashes of of Clark and Lois and those depictions of of
- 1:22:27these these characters in Spy. Or you mentioned how Noel Sickles was such an
- 1:22:31influence on all these wonderful artists that we do know, like Alex Toth and
- 1:22:35Infantino and Frank Robins. But um, I wanted to ask two about oh
- 1:22:41god, wash Roy Crane. And it sounds like Roy Crane was a very
- 1:22:46early influence on a lot of uh, the first generation of the Golden Age
- 1:22:51comic book artists and stuff. And I'm sorry that Captain Jack No that was
- 1:22:57that is a Washtubs or why Crane. I'm trying. Is it a Roy
- 1:23:01Crane? I know, I know, I know the name, and I'm
- 1:23:04seeing the art, but I can't I'm blanking on what I think it's washed.
- 1:23:08I want to say wash tubs or I'm not even sure they see another
- 1:23:12part we can cut out. It's nowhere. I had when the image that
- 1:23:16pomps into my head about Roy Crane is someone who was not a very detailed
- 1:23:24renderer. It the the images were not exactly cartoony. They were naturalistic,
- 1:23:30but they were very open. And I keep seeing a face in my head
- 1:23:34that looks like an American tin Tin and I could be okay, out of
- 1:23:39my brain, absolutely no idea. No. I mean, well, let
- 1:23:45me let me ask you about an era specific era that you were one of
- 1:23:48the flies on the wall, and that is during the DC implosion of the
- 1:23:51late seventies, and you kind of, I think touched on that when you
- 1:23:55mentioned Jeanette and Paul's importance in showing the company what it could be. I
- 1:24:00mean, we're things like that that period. And I've seen Stephen Grant mentioned
- 1:24:04this in a lot of his columns that he writes online, that people don't
- 1:24:09understand that DC came very close to stop publishing comics and just you know,
- 1:24:14we don't really need the count books we've you know, let's just stick to
- 1:24:16the licensing and stuff. Can you talk about that period and what Paul and
- 1:24:20Janette were able to convince the others about. If I'm getting this correct as
- 1:24:25far as the people is, I think a number of different things that for
- 1:24:30people of mine, and I hate the phrase generation in this business, think
- 1:24:33of a separate I think you're conflating them. Okay, please see Implosion is
- 1:24:38a term that I associate very very specifically with one moment in time when an
- 1:24:45expansion effort was made, A very aggressive expansion effort was made based on projections
- 1:24:54from current sales, and then there was a lot of surprise information at the
- 1:24:59eleven dollars that suggested that a more prudent business model should be applied and maybe
- 1:25:06this is not the right time to grow the lines that it thinks that is.
- 1:25:12That moment in time is remembered primarily for having spawned the rare collectible canceled
- 1:25:17comics cavalcade, because there was a huge volume of material that has been created.
- 1:25:24Remember this is also when the dollar comics were also, you know,
- 1:25:26absolutely started, if I'm not mistaken, late seventies, seventy eight, seventy
- 1:25:30nine. Yeah, But what it's impact has on the goal of making the
- 1:25:41comic book business the publishing the core business operate profitable in and of itself without
- 1:25:48being reliant on ancillary revenue stream. The delay in information under the old signment
- 1:26:00method of distribution, where you didn't have final sales figures until six months at
- 1:26:06a minimum after the off sale date of any particular comic book, was thought
- 1:26:13at the time accurately or not, I can't say, but was thought at
- 1:26:15the time to have been one of the causes of the DC implosion. Late
- 1:26:23breaking information that was an unpleasant surprise. That trauma, plus the fact that
- 1:26:32the business always knew that it was essentially publishing three copies of everything for everyone
- 1:26:39it's sold, led to the belief that a greater emphasis on product for this
- 1:26:49burgeoning new thing called the comic book shop, which in the late seventies was
- 1:26:55just getting started in a couple of isolated places around the country. And of
- 1:27:00course DC was experimenting with its own direct sales with a thing called the comic
- 1:27:04book, comic bookmobile, or the comic mobile, which was essentially the equivalent
- 1:27:10of a traveling library, you know, a bookmobile, except it was comic
- 1:27:14books and they weren't being loaned, that they were being sold, and that
- 1:27:19was just done locally in New York. It was kind of a test,
- 1:27:23okay, and I think ultimately they backed away from it because they felt it
- 1:27:28really wasn't quid business to essentially be competing in essence with their own distributors,
- 1:27:32no matter on how small a scale. Okay, I could see that,
- 1:27:35sure, But all of these things made people start to think, well,
- 1:27:41maybe there's a different way of doing things, and Marvel was having some of
- 1:27:45the same thoughts a little bit later. My read of history, my recollection
- 1:27:50was that the DC took most of the gambles, and then Marble just followed
- 1:27:54suit and in some cases be DC at its own game. But that's a
- 1:28:00separate book. So in that sense, the DC implosion did have a factor
- 1:28:11in the drive to comp with new business models, and it really wasn't until
- 1:28:19what is now called ID distribution or distribution at news stands under the consignment method,
- 1:28:26returnable was the emphasized and the lion's share of the sales were being done
- 1:28:35through the direct market, which evolved throughout the early eighties and became started to
- 1:28:42become the industry standard the primary way in which the material was distributed by the
- 1:28:46late eighties eighty seven, or so the DC imposion of the late seventies had
- 1:28:54some role in that. But what you speak of about thinking of the life
- 1:29:00sing as the primary revenue and thinking of the management management of the merchandising and
- 1:29:08the licensing as the core business rather than the publishing, I'm not just sure
- 1:29:13that was ever actually the case. It was sort of like, well,
- 1:29:16we know our core business is publishing, but we also know we can't make
- 1:29:20as much money out of it, so there's always this search for what we
- 1:29:24used the next Superman, which we need use the next Batman, We need
- 1:29:26the next breakout hit that will drive all of this product, so that if
- 1:29:31you know, anthrow costs up blood when it shows up on the stands,
- 1:29:34it's not, you know, the end of the world. And by I
- 1:29:40think the late seventies, at the time of the transition from Carmine to Genet
- 1:29:45cons that way of thinking about the business model was traditional. It was about
- 1:29:55twenty years old by that point, so many blishers who didn't have licensing programs
- 1:30:02had fallen by the wayside, and two of the the two publishers who had
- 1:30:11the most robust program in that area, MLJ or Archie and DC. Of
- 1:30:16course were the ones that were in a lot of cases last man standing.
- 1:30:20And you know, as we say in this as we chronicle in the DC
- 1:30:24Vault, after American distribution when under in nineteen fifty seven, Martin Goodman was
- 1:30:31of Marvel were at that time, I guess timely Atlas was left without a
- 1:30:39distributor and he had to turn to leave with it and his independent news to
- 1:30:45distribute his comics. So in that sense, Archie and DC were the you
- 1:30:50know, kind of like the last men standing. And not coincidentally, they
- 1:30:55were also the driving forces behind the creation of the comics code. And one
- 1:30:59of the things that is always had me scratching my head is why Marvel did
- 1:31:04not come to the party in terms of trying to aggressively exploit their library and
- 1:31:10mass media until so late in the game, like nineteen sixty six or sixty
- 1:31:15seven, right with the Bashki Spider Man cartoon and the Marvel Superheroes Wheel,
- 1:31:18things like that, and and of course all the coloring books and everything else,
- 1:31:24I guess. But the answer that you usually hear is to to that
- 1:31:30question is, well, don't forget the franchises and properties that are considered to
- 1:31:34be the Marvel Stars such as Spider Man and Fantastic Four, and so I
- 1:31:39weren't really created until you know, fifty nine or sixty right in the resurgence
- 1:31:44of the superheroes, that the Justice League and all of the you know,
- 1:31:50the the Earth to Red Conning, you know, you know what I'm talking
- 1:31:55about superheroes. Oh yeah, yeah, drove all of that. But the
- 1:31:58fact is, not all the Marvel superheroes were created by by stand in nineteen
- 1:32:04sixty or fifth nineteen fifties. No, it took a couple of years.
- 1:32:08There was there was the Mariner. There was Captain Marnivel. I mean,
- 1:32:12I'm sorry, Captain America. Maybe not too many more, but there were
- 1:32:17other properties and there was more of a history there. So I guess what
- 1:32:25I'm wondering is is it really as simple as what it seems to be on
- 1:32:29the face of it, which is that it's just a matter of some people
- 1:32:31having a vision and other people not. The only other publisher, as I
- 1:32:35said earlier, in the early forties who understood the value of getting a radio
- 1:32:40presence for the material and that would and that that would hopefully drive comic book
- 1:32:44sales was Fox, the company that was the publisher of the Blue Beal in
- 1:32:48nineteen forty. Now there was a syndicated Blue Beal radio show for about two
- 1:32:54years and then it disappeared. And that's a case of someone who had the
- 1:33:00right idea, but you know, couldn't make it work because Fox itself was
- 1:33:04a pretty had a pretty troubled history as yeahublisher, and didn't last very long.
- 1:33:09But why Wine's Marvel did not earlier embrace the goal of creating a media
- 1:33:20presence, I've never fully understood, because it looked like there wasn't a lot
- 1:33:25of energy devoted to that even after they were arguably the number two, you
- 1:33:30know, publisher of comics, which was in which was in the early six
- 1:33:33years. But then again, you you get a different perspective if you're superhero
- 1:33:40centric than if you're not. And as if you're looking at all comics,
- 1:33:45you might argue that the second and perhaps Written and Publishing might have said the
- 1:33:50first a primary publisher of comics even in the early sixties was Dell and later
- 1:33:57gold Key. You know, if they're all the same company, I believe,
- 1:34:00right, But if you're looking but if you're just talking to superhero terms,
- 1:34:04then it's really just DC and Marvel pretty much from fifty nine through I
- 1:34:12guess in mid eighties, well, and I guess now. I mean,
- 1:34:15it sounds like, especially what we heard this summer from the top at Warner
- 1:34:21Films, the Film Division, it sounds like maybe they are realizing the mistakes
- 1:34:29they made with Superman Returns and that it is important to have even more input
- 1:34:35from the comic book division, seeing the success across the street that Marvel has
- 1:34:41had now that they you know, in the case of Marvel Films, obviously
- 1:34:44it starts with the publisher and they, you know, they've created their own
- 1:34:47film company, whereas DC is a component of Warner Films, and in a
- 1:34:53lot of ways, it's no different than some of those other subheadings of film
- 1:34:57divisions underneath Warner and I'm I'm blanking right now on some of the names of
- 1:35:00them. But you're talking about the other imprint, Yeah, well, like
- 1:35:04how Touchstone is a division of Disney and High Yeah, things like that,
- 1:35:09But that they're suddenly realizing maybe they need a more direct injection from the count
- 1:35:14book division to create the right type of movie because you know, again that
- 1:35:18well that's been that's been an ongoing effort for a number of years sure when
- 1:35:26I was working in the Creative Services department that that was a large part of
- 1:35:30my job for a couple of years, setting the scripts for problems with multiple
- 1:35:40iterations of a franchise. For example, when you have a Superman cartoon show
- 1:35:45and you have small Bill going on at the same time as a Superman movie
- 1:35:48has been developed, so as to preserve the integrity of the brand, it
- 1:35:57becomes necessary to carve territory that is sacrosancd to the other development. In other
- 1:36:06words, a large part of my job would be to say to the small
- 1:36:11Ville people, DC would prefer that you not go there, because that's a
- 1:36:14key element in the upcoming film where its DC was charged with the responsibility of
- 1:36:20helping to coordinate information about what aspect of the material was being exploited and communicated
- 1:36:30among the various divisions. That became such an important part of DC's role that
- 1:36:36Gregory Novik, who is the senior Vice president I believe Creative Affairs is his
- 1:36:44title. Okay. He was brought in I believe in two thousand and four
- 1:36:50and he is based primarily on the Coast, and he is charged with overseeing
- 1:36:56the liaise between DC and Warner brother, But that's actually a very small part
- 1:37:00of this job. Now he is, in a sense a de facto producer.
- 1:37:08I only say that just to be careful because I don't want to misstate.
- 1:37:11I don't know whether he will actually be carrying a producing credit or has
- 1:37:15carried a producing credit on the projects that he is spearheaded, but DC playing
- 1:37:20more of an active role on the production side. You are correct in perceiving
- 1:37:26that it is not it is not something that needs to be widely publicizing the
- 1:37:34sense of it's not it's not necessarily something that is you'll see in the average
- 1:37:38press release. Right. But DC, as we say in the book,
- 1:37:44DC has gone from being I think the way it's put to a NAT buzzing
- 1:37:49in Horner Brothers year to respected and valuable contributor. There you go, exactly,
- 1:37:55because they certainly don't have the time to dig through the library. Right.
- 1:38:00So what you know? So there's there's a guy at DC now named
- 1:38:04Ivan Cone, I believe, who does what I used to do in the
- 1:38:09sense of, um, okay, Chris Nolan wants to know about such and
- 1:38:13such a character. Can you put together a care package as they used to
- 1:38:16call it, supervised the shipping of these huge boxes of commons. Sure,
- 1:38:21you know, but it's much more. It's much broader and much more sophisticated
- 1:38:26than that. And I guess, I guess the short form of it is
- 1:38:30talking to somebody at DC probably gets you a better take on what your repeat
- 1:38:35business audience is going to think of your movie than talking to Harry Nole.
- 1:38:40Okay, no disrespect to Harry, No, I'm sure I understand that,
- 1:38:44you know when you were there. I just finished an interview with Jeff Lobe
- 1:38:47a couple of weeks ago, and he had mentioned again when they wonderful man
- 1:38:53and a wonderful writer. He's a funny guy. He was telling me about
- 1:38:56when he was on Smallville when they were thinking about bringing Chloe's all of it
- 1:39:00into the comic books, and were you Were you there when that was all
- 1:39:03being discussed. Well, no, well I may well have been, but
- 1:39:08it wouldn't necessarily been something that was on my radar. Okay. Jeff had
- 1:39:12a very unusual position in the sense that he was not only a major contributor
- 1:39:15to the television series, but he was also very much aware of what was
- 1:39:19going on in the comics and very much plugged into that end of the world
- 1:39:24because he was a writer. So what I was more concerned about was rather,
- 1:39:32actually, what I mean to say is what I was charged with monitoring
- 1:39:36was how did the Superman universe as being as it was interpreted by the Smallville
- 1:39:43staff stack up against what was being developed in the feature area and what was
- 1:39:50being done in animation. Okay, And it was all it was a matter
- 1:39:54of just making sure that you don't you don't play outside your sandbox, and
- 1:39:58you don't you don't step on somebody else development, sure, so, but
- 1:40:01how it worked in the other way exactly. That's the new material created in
- 1:40:08mass media and brought into the comics. That was strictly between editorial and the
- 1:40:13productions themselves. And usually I think the way that work was editorial would be
- 1:40:16guided by what Paul knew, Okay, but I was I was never brought
- 1:40:20into that, and that department I don't think really touches the comics that much.
- 1:40:26I can see a situation whereby the creative affairs department would have to facilitate
- 1:40:32a movie adaptation, and that has happened when I when I'm at the Superman
- 1:40:36Returns comic book adaptations. Gregory himself had to intervene to get a lot of
- 1:40:43the supporting material and explain to the studio, now, you don't understand we
- 1:40:46have a lead time. There's a point past which we can't be working on
- 1:40:50this. It's presses only run so fast and so for it. So what
- 1:40:56we had to do was negotiate things like, well, we can't give you
- 1:40:59visual reference for this because it's all in post it's all in post production,
- 1:41:03it's all CGI. We ourselves don't know what it's going to look like.
- 1:41:09Because the question would become, well, do you have some artists renderings so
- 1:41:12we can figure out how to fake it? And then they go, well,
- 1:41:15we don't know, and then that would be the point at which that
- 1:41:16department would have to step in and say, let's work it out in such
- 1:41:19a way that everybody is protected because there's a need, there's a need to
- 1:41:23create the product. But as you know, there is so much fan interest
- 1:41:29in the content of this thing, and that if you have a surprise built
- 1:41:32into it, you have to guard this stuff like it's oh yeah, I
- 1:41:38mean yeah, yeah, I mean I I could tell you stories about of
- 1:41:43getting movie scripts, you know, and you have to sign out and practically
- 1:41:46have a retinal scan before they let you, you know, look at it,
- 1:41:49and they're sent they're sent to you printed on, they're sent to you
- 1:41:54printed on, or rather they are originally generated by what's called the memeo departmental
- 1:41:59there's no memo right anymore. They're printed on red paper, and you know
- 1:42:02why, because you can't photocopy reading exactly, and inevitably you find yourself on
- 1:42:09the phone with a secretary saying thank you for the script, but I can't
- 1:42:12read it. I was gonna say, man, you need you need good
- 1:42:15glasses to be able to read that stuff. So alf the time before,
- 1:42:16it's very yes, it's very dark gray with a little black oil, black
- 1:42:19marks on it. You know. So what basically what I'm what I'm saying
- 1:42:24is is that that whole operation has to coordinate these things for everybody, everybody's
- 1:42:30needs and that and they do a remarkable job of it, considering considering how
- 1:42:34much pressure there is involved, because you know, movies and them themselves are
- 1:42:39expensive and special effects movies are much more expensive. And it's a very very
- 1:42:43large operation. But it's a it's an extremely well oiled machine, and it's
- 1:42:45it's fascinating to be a part of it. If you have the long perspective
- 1:42:50of a fan, in the sense of, no matter how young you are,
- 1:42:56used to have some interest I think in the history or some sense of
- 1:42:59it absolutely comes to you. Whether you want it or not. There is
- 1:43:03still that sense of wow, who would have thought that this? Well,
- 1:43:09I have to correct myself. It is a generational thing. People who have
- 1:43:15a memory of the only iteration of their beloved superhero comics in the world outside
- 1:43:25of comics being the occasional board game, the occasional toys, and a very
- 1:43:30cheesy and obscure cartoon you know where they where They limited the animation stuff limited
- 1:43:34that it consists of, like you know, an arm going up and down.
- 1:43:39People who have that frame of reference dream free years of a day when
- 1:43:45their favorite superheroes be given the big budget treatment on the movie screen and action
- 1:43:49figures and toys of all kinds, you know, and it's all come to
- 1:43:55path, whether it's with the expanded licensing programs or things like DC Direct,
- 1:44:00which fills which fills the gap of you know, well, our projections say
- 1:44:08we can't manufacture a green lantern um a green lantern replica in the right color
- 1:44:16that Walmart wants and they won't take it anyway. But there's a ready made
- 1:44:24market for this. It will be willing to pay at retail far more than
- 1:44:28what Walmart thinks the upper end price point for the thing, you know.
- 1:44:31And so that was that was that was a master stroke that uh you know,
- 1:44:38we chronicle in the last last chapter of the book of the way DC
- 1:44:41has expanded the amazing growth. One of the things that we've been asked is
- 1:44:46why is the book waited so heavily toward the early years and the major events
- 1:44:56of the last twenty years seem to be covered in broad strokes. And the
- 1:45:03answer goes directly to what the point of the book is. The DC Vault
- 1:45:10is about exposing little known curios and using them to illustrate a history of the
- 1:45:17company with a focus, we hope on the never before heard or see now
- 1:45:25it can be told. Was the field that we were going for succeeded or
- 1:45:28not? Again, as I say, I'll lay that up to the reader.
- 1:45:31But with the Internet and the passionate interest of DC's many fans, anything
- 1:45:41you want to know in any kind of detail about what has gone on in
- 1:45:45the last twenty years is available to you. Bet and since, as I
- 1:45:50said before covering in seventy covered in seventy five history, and seventy five year
- 1:45:56history only twenty thousand words, you have obviously something has to be you know,
- 1:46:01it has to be left out or has to be summarized in broader terms.
- 1:46:05We tried to leave nothing important out. But I think that we succeeded
- 1:46:15in addressing the goal of exposing the readership to things that they won't be able
- 1:46:23to find anywhere else. And as I say, we did that by prevailing
- 1:46:28upon a fast army of collectors to share with us. The materials long and
- 1:46:35have to be very very carefully photographed, some of it by a wonderful photographer.
- 1:46:42The mark with I don't want to you know, I have this desire
- 1:46:46to give credit where credit is due. But you know, I understand now
- 1:46:49what Oscar vins in the acceptance speeches, what they mean when they say I
- 1:46:56want to thank you, but I know I'll leave somebody out, so I
- 1:46:59won't say anybody and the person nobody's happen, you know. Well, that's
- 1:47:02what the acknowledgements are for inside the book and everything. But no, and
- 1:47:05they're in a very small type because there's so many people that we are so
- 1:47:10grateful too. Well, that's cool, it's not it really. I congratulate
- 1:47:13you guys, because it really is. It's an amazing book. And as
- 1:47:16you say, uh, it does cover the past in a way that isn't
- 1:47:19covered elsewhere. And you don't know where you're going if you don't know where
- 1:47:23you've been, And that's the point I think of this book, and I
- 1:47:26think it succeeds so well, well, my hat's after you for spreading that
- 1:47:30message. My pleasure. Man, it's Christmas time. I mean, this
- 1:47:33is really a good This is a good idea for a gift if you've got
- 1:47:35somebody that really is a DC fan. And I mean it's the again.
- 1:47:41The the replicated collectibles that are inside are as amazing as the text itself,
- 1:47:45and the beautiful pictures that start with they're much more amazing. Theist for the
- 1:47:50books. I'm just throwing the space around the picture. No, but you're
- 1:47:55now you're telling the story, man, and I think it's it's a cool
- 1:47:58story. And that's the thing again, you don't you really don't know DC
- 1:48:01until you really check this book out. And as you say, there have
- 1:48:04been other histories of comics and stuff. But I think this point of view
- 1:48:09is a very important one that again, the supplementary material only illustrates what you've
- 1:48:15written about, and it's just a it's a great story and really interesting facts,
- 1:48:18and I mean, any person that really does love comics would really appreciate
- 1:48:24again seeing some of this stuff for the first time and really understand we're standing
- 1:48:28where a lot of these ideas first came from, and how they were exploited
- 1:48:31and in the different ways that they were exploited. And also just the incredible
- 1:48:34art from the early pages to the jam poster that has people as varied as
- 1:48:41Bob Kane and Dave Gibbons. I mean, you've got a Bob Kane Batman
- 1:48:44standing in the same group with Dave Gibbons, roor Shock, and I mean
- 1:48:47it's it's that kind of span of history that we're seeing in this book.
- 1:48:51So hats off to him already, nice job, And honestly, next year,
- 1:48:56when it is the seventy fifth anniversary, we should really come back and
- 1:49:00talk more about the company's full history and get into some more of the stories,
- 1:49:04because you know you, I really I envy you for being where you've
- 1:49:09been in the company and seeing a lot of the different changes and all the
- 1:49:12different people that have come through the door, and that you know, you're
- 1:49:15you're one of the You're one of the guys men. You were writing,
- 1:49:16you were writing the books and also observed a lot of the great art and
- 1:49:19writing that was going on around you as well. So well, I think
- 1:49:23there's a group of us who believe very much in the idea of pay it
- 1:49:27for it. I know, I know Paul Levitts endorses that tremendously. He
- 1:49:30has a much more acute sense than any of it of how much of the
- 1:49:34history of the company is dependent upon oral history. And so there's a group
- 1:49:41of us who, as I said, are a member of the last generation
- 1:49:45of people who had any contact with the founding fathers yep of the industry,
- 1:49:53and what we remember, even though it's secondhand, oral history is an oral
- 1:50:00history, and we have one of one of our own. Because you know,
- 1:50:03people who worked in the seventies, the younger, the youngest, the
- 1:50:06youngest of us who worked in the seventies are now speaking for that era because
- 1:50:13more and more of the people who were seminal figures in the changes between the
- 1:50:16seventies and the eighties that built the reconfigure the comic book industry that we know
- 1:50:20today are passing on. Yeah, and what I what I and people who
- 1:50:28many many of my friends and colleagues who feel the same way, are proud
- 1:50:32to do, feel a sense of an obligation to do is to be able
- 1:50:36to do if we can for the generations that come after us. Um what
- 1:50:42people like Bill Finger we're doing. In to our conversation the Bullpender with this
- 1:50:46this kid who is ganda at the idea of talking about that's awesome. Well,
- 1:50:53thanks you your tying party. I thank you. I've been keeping you
- 1:50:55up and I don't want to my pleasure and I thank your pr interest.
- 1:51:05There you go with my buddy, the late great Marty Pasco from a few
- 1:51:09years back, discussing the DC Vault once again. Tonight on We're Balloon Live.
- 1:51:14Really happy to welcome Joe Casey back to Ward Balloon. He has a
- 1:51:16brand new book, Junior Baker. We're going to talk about that. We'll
- 1:51:19talk about his thoughts on the Writer's Strike. I hope to see spider verse
- 1:51:25between now and when I speak to Joe, so that I can ask him
- 1:51:29his thoughts as a guy that has spent a long time now in the animation
- 1:51:32business. His thoughts on the Spider Verse movie. Does it inspire him to
- 1:51:38try things differently from a visual standpoint? A whole bunch more. I'm really
- 1:51:42looking forward to it. I had his Man of Action co conspirator, Steve
- 1:51:46siegelan a few weeks ago, and I'm always happy to have Joe back on
- 1:51:50Ward Balloon got Joe was one of those first year guests that I can't believe
- 1:51:55I'm talking to Joe Casey. This is incredible. You know when you consider
- 1:51:59his history at both DC and Marvel, and you know what he's been doing
- 1:52:01for the last twenty plus years in animation, creating Ben ten in Generation Rex
- 1:52:08and so much more so. I hope you enjoined us tonight for this great
- 1:52:12conversation live Joe Casey. It's going to be at ten o'clock Eastern, nine
- 1:52:16pm Central at seven o'clock Pacific time, and that'll be on you Word Balloon's
- 1:52:21YouTube channel and you can watch via Facebook and Twitter. So I hope you
- 1:52:26join us tonight for the Joe Casey Conversation. More great stuff coming this week
- 1:52:30on word Balloon. I hope you'll join us July just getting started, and
- 1:52:33so is word Balloon, with a new slate of great conversations. Until next
- 1:52:38time, thanks for listening. Word Balloon is a copyright feature of Shaky Productions.
- 1:52:42Copyright twenty twenty three.