Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Deposition Survival Guide for New Attorneys
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to Deposition Survival Guide for New
- 0:05Attorneys. I'm Neha Wall, Vice Chair of the HBA's
- 0:08Bursar Section, and I am delighted to introduce
- 0:11our speaker, Tyler Pabujian. Tyler Pabujian is
- 0:15an attorney at Panache and Ravabuti in Los Angeles
- 0:19and focuses his practice on catastrophic personal
- 0:21injury and wrongful death cases throughout California
- 0:25and Nevada. Tyler has assisted in securing eight
- 0:28figure settlements for his clients and has recently
- 0:31part of the trial team that obtained a nearly
- 0:3349 million verdict from Van Nye's jury in the
- 0:37personal injury case of Hakimi versus City of
- 0:39Los Angeles. And now let's get started, Tyler.
- 0:44Okay. All right. Good afternoon, everyone. This
- 0:48is a pleasure. So basically this webinar is geared
- 0:53at some deposition tricks, planning, preparation
- 0:56from your attorneys. We'll go over everything
- 0:59from preparing an outline towards strategic questionings,
- 1:06ways to use exhibits, and a little bit of a review
- 1:08process after you take your depositions. So I'm
- 1:11just going to share my screen. So let's get into
- 1:14it. OK, so we're going to kind of tackle this
- 1:17one by one, starting with preparation. Okay,
- 1:24so in preparing, there's usually five things
- 1:26I like to keep in mind, starting with the witness
- 1:28you're going to be deposing, then about the issues
- 1:31that are going to go into that deposition, the
- 1:33types of exhibits you're going to want to use,
- 1:35and then from there, building your outline, and
- 1:38of course, knowing the law, so you're not driving
- 1:41during the deposition. Okay, so knowing the witness,
- 1:45be taking a defendant driver deposition, maybe
- 1:47a PMQ, it's a third party witness. All of that's,
- 1:51of course, relevant into how you're going to
- 1:53prepare, what type of exhibits you're going to
- 1:55pull, et cetera. And you also kind of want to
- 1:58think about how they're going to fit in your
- 2:00case, in the sense, are they going to be good
- 2:03for you? Are they going to be bad for you? Is
- 2:05it going to be a more cross -examination type
- 2:07of deposition or purely fact -finding? Whether
- 2:11you're a strictly liability witness, a damages
- 2:13witness, or both, and you're going to want to
- 2:15prepare accordingly, determining based on that.
- 2:19OK. And again, knowing the issues, which goes
- 2:24right on top of the type of witness you're going
- 2:27to be deposing. So for instance, if this is a
- 2:31disputed liability case and there's some argument
- 2:33about whether the light was red versus green,
- 2:36you're obviously going to want to spend a lot
- 2:37of time on that if you're taking the adverse
- 2:39driver's depot. You always want to think about
- 2:44comparative fault when doing liability depots.
- 2:46Try to hammer out the other side story of if
- 2:49they think anyone else bears any fault, science
- 2:52bears any fault, or something of that nature.
- 2:56And as we'll get into when talking about your
- 2:58outline and preparing, these are all going to
- 3:00be headings that you either have questions ready
- 3:03to go or certain subtopics about these specific
- 3:06issues. And then same thing if it's a damages
- 3:09witness, whether it's a treater, maybe a paramedic,
- 3:13first responder, you're going to just kind of
- 3:17tackle your outline the same way. and trying
- 3:19to figure out, you know, is one of the issues
- 3:22in the case, whether the injury was related to
- 3:24the accident, maybe there was some pre -existing
- 3:27injury, and you're going to really want to kind
- 3:30of narrow these issues down and kind of keep
- 3:33them in the back of your mind when preparing.
- 3:35So you can kind of boil it down into, this is
- 3:38what I want to get out of this depot. I want
- 3:40to make sure this issue is covered. I want to
- 3:42make sure that I know everything this witness
- 3:44is going to say at trial about whether this accident,
- 3:47or excuse me, whether this injury was related
- 3:49to the accident, whether they think this light
- 3:52was red versus green. So you're not surprised
- 3:54at trial and you kind of know what you're getting
- 3:56into when you put them on the stand. All right.
- 4:05Once you have those things in the back of your
- 4:07mind, who your witness is, what the issues are,
- 4:10start compiling your exhibits. There's a plethora
- 4:14of different types of exhibits from reports,
- 4:17personnel files, medical records, vehicle codes,
- 4:22photos of the scene, surveillance, dash cam footage,
- 4:26even pulling up discovery responses, the notice
- 4:29of deposition where you requested documents.
- 4:32All that sort of stuff, I like to think like
- 4:34start big, put everything in a folder maybe that
- 4:37might be somewhat relevant into a deposition
- 4:42folder for that witness. And then as you're kind
- 4:44of crafting your outline, you can kind of narrow
- 4:46down which ones you're going to use. Or it's
- 4:49always great just to have everything kind of
- 4:51at your disposal just in case something comes
- 4:53up and you want to pull it real quickly. And
- 4:56so I have here an image that says it's for a
- 5:01defendant driver depot folder with the different
- 5:05exhibits that I would plan on using during that
- 5:08deposition. I have my outline, the word document
- 5:11at the top, and then just all the various types
- 5:14of exhibits that I plan on using. Now comes time
- 5:24for the outline. So with building your outline,
- 5:28it's really up to you how you want to craft it.
- 5:32Some people like just doing big headings with
- 5:35subheadings and then a couple bullet points under
- 5:37each one. And for instance, as opposed to you
- 5:43writing questions or having very specific things
- 5:47after each question, it's really preference.
- 5:53However, you're going to want to set it up by
- 5:55topic. That really helps keep you on track. And
- 5:59you're going to start with the admonitions, which
- 6:00are just the ground rules of the deposition.
- 6:04And then maybe go into some background, and then
- 6:07here I have liability, and then the different
- 6:10sequences of maybe the accident or the collision,
- 6:13starting with pre -incident, the incident, post
- 6:16-incident. And under those subheadings, you can
- 6:18have tailored questions for each one, or again,
- 6:22just some sort of ideas that you wanna make sure
- 6:24you ask. And again, it's preference. You can
- 6:36write your questions out one by one by one, scoop
- 6:40them by ideas. Like I said, no one way to do
- 6:44it. However, it's caution not to get glued to
- 6:47your outline because a lot of times your witness
- 6:49is going to take you off of your outline and
- 6:51maybe go on a tangent, which could be relevant.
- 6:54And it's, you know, fruitful to explore and beneficial
- 6:58to kind of dig a little deeper. I have Tom Hanks
- 7:01here. Life is like a box of chocolates. Never
- 7:03know what you're going to get. You know, you
- 7:05ask some questions, it steers you one way, and
- 7:07then maybe you get some sort of a mission that
- 7:10ends up being great for your case. So it's good
- 7:14to have the outline as structure and to follow
- 7:16it and to keep you on track But don't be afraid
- 7:19to if you hear something that the witness says
- 7:22to kind of follow up Circle back with him and
- 7:26then come back to your outline afterwards And
- 7:33then the last thing I have here is knowing the
- 7:35law okay, there's you know a couple couple things
- 7:39you want to keep in mind regarding the law of
- 7:42depositions. Okay. And this will kind of help
- 7:45you have some more confidence with opposing counsel
- 7:48or with what you can and can't do with the witness
- 7:51and stuff of that nature. And there might be
- 7:54a little more than this, but I feel like these
- 7:56are kind of the core themes to keep in mind.
- 7:58The first one being that the really only proper
- 8:02objections in a deposition that need to be stated
- 8:05to preserve the record form of the question objections.
- 8:10And when you're deposing another party, the council
- 8:14can only instruct their witness not to answer
- 8:17based on privacy or privilege. Instructing them
- 8:19not to answer based on relevance or hearsay or
- 8:23something of that nature isn't a proper basis.
- 8:28And in some cases that might happen where council
- 8:31kind of fights with you on the record and instructs
- 8:35not to answer you ask him what his basis is or
- 8:37her and they state relevance or something other
- 8:40than privacy or privilege and in that circumstance
- 8:44i think personally best practice don't argue
- 8:47on the record um you know keep it brief say that's
- 8:51not a proper basis to instruct not to answer
- 8:54however i'll move forward and i'd like to mark
- 8:56the record here and then you're gonna want to
- 8:59follow up with the witness After you ask your
- 9:03question that council instructs not to answer
- 9:05on, you're gonna wanna follow and say, are you
- 9:07choosing to follow your council's instruction
- 9:10not to answer or are you not answering for some
- 9:13other reason, like not understanding the question.
- 9:16This will help clarify the record if you do have
- 9:19to bring some motion to compel, if it's a really
- 9:22material matter that you need an answer to that
- 9:25the witness did understand the question. And
- 9:28the pure basis is counsel obstructing the deposition.
- 9:32That's the reason for him not answering. OK,
- 9:35let's go. Bullet point two, in the Emerson electric
- 9:38case, that gave us the holding where you can
- 9:42compel the witness to mark exhibits, to act stuff
- 9:45out, to draw things. So let's say you have an
- 9:50image of the scene of the collision. And you
- 9:53ask one of the drivers, where were you at the
- 9:55time? What lane were you in? You have them mark
- 9:59maybe with an X. That's the lane I was traveling
- 10:02in. OK, where was the area of impact? Draw a
- 10:05circle there. OK, where was the other driver?
- 10:08What direction was he heading in? Draw an arrow
- 10:10in a different color. And that's great, because
- 10:13you can now use that exhibit in other ways, maybe
- 10:16show it to another witness down the road to see
- 10:18if they agree. Obviously, when you're doing that,
- 10:22you're going to want to make sure the record
- 10:23is clear, what they're marking, what color. But
- 10:28this case, you know, makes it a proper thing
- 10:32that you can have a witness do. And then we have
- 10:36the third bullet point, which is pretty important
- 10:39and should be discussed pretty early on in the
- 10:42deposition after maybe the admonitions is that
- 10:45you're entitled to know everything the deponent
- 10:48used to prepare for their deposition, whether
- 10:52they reviewed the traffic collision report. whether
- 10:55they looked at any medical records, whether they
- 10:57looked at any discovery responses, anything like
- 11:01that. Even if their counsel showed it to them
- 11:03under this evidence code, section 771, the deponent
- 11:08is authorized to tell you what they used to prepare
- 11:11for their deposition. And that's great because
- 11:13it helps inform when you go forward and ask your
- 11:16questions. What they've already looked at versus
- 11:19what they haven't so maybe some of those exhibits
- 11:21overlap with what you plan on showing Now the
- 11:27last one is entitled to best estimate and we'll
- 11:30get a little bit more into this But there's a
- 11:33whole host of other admissions. You're gonna
- 11:35want to go through, you know that They're where
- 11:38they're under the penalty of perjury sworn into
- 11:41the truth, of course But I feel like this best
- 11:45estimate one is a great tool for newer attorneys
- 11:48to use when they maybe get stuck or jumbled up
- 11:51with the witness who gives a lot of I don't knows.
- 11:55And we'll kind of go over in more detail the
- 11:57best practice of using this admonition, this
- 12:02best estimate tool to kind of dig deeper and
- 12:06get through some testimony. All right, here we
- 12:11kind of just went over this, but it outlines
- 12:13what I was saying regarding the objections. One
- 12:17other thing to highlight, speaking objections
- 12:19are improper. It falls also under the Stewart
- 12:23v. Colonial Western case. So you might have a
- 12:26veteran opposing counsel who is speaking through
- 12:30their objections saying, I detest your definition
- 12:38of employee relationship, and that's not relevant
- 12:42and prejudicial to my client, blah, blah, blah,
- 12:45blah, blah. That's all great. But really, the
- 12:48purpose of objections are to preserve the record
- 12:50as to form the question objections. And anytime
- 12:53you have counsel speaking at you, their objections,
- 12:57again, we're not going to want to argue with
- 12:59them. It might, it's just going to muddy up the
- 13:01record even more. Best practice, I think, is
- 13:05to just remind them counsel appreciate your objections
- 13:08however speaking objections are improper i'd
- 13:11like to continue my deposition again relevance
- 13:15not a basis to instruct not to answer it has
- 13:17to be privacy or privilege so you know whether
- 13:20it's attorney client privilege work product privilege
- 13:23or some other codified privilege or statutory
- 13:27privilege those are really the only grounds not
- 13:29to instruct a witness not to answer And again,
- 13:33in the cases where counsel does instruct their
- 13:38witness not to answer, you're always gonna wanna
- 13:40follow up with the witness and say, are you choosing
- 13:42your counsel's advice not to answer or is it
- 13:44for some other reason? Again, we just wanna move
- 13:48forward, keep it going. Let's not try to get
- 13:50hung up on things and argue on the record. But
- 13:55you're always creating and preserving this issue
- 13:57if you ever do need to bring a motion to compel.
- 14:04Okay. And again, as I was kind of referring to
- 14:08earlier, using the best estimate tool, it's great
- 14:12to explain at the outset where you explain to
- 14:16the witness, do you understand the difference
- 14:18between an estimate and a guess? You might give
- 14:21an example where, you know, the classic lawyer
- 14:24one is where You can provide me with an estimate
- 14:28of how wide your table is, right? Yeah, three
- 14:30to four feet, probably. Okay, but you've never
- 14:32seen my table. You couldn't give a best estimate
- 14:35as to the width of my table. That would be purely
- 14:37a guess. That's an example people use, okay?
- 14:41But it's good to remind them that all the testimony
- 14:43they're here to give today to you is you're entitled
- 14:49to all of it, absent a guess. You don't want
- 14:53them guessing. but you're entitled to their best
- 14:56estimate. They're sworn testimony under oath.
- 14:59They're entitled to give you their best estimate.
- 15:01And if they purely don't know, that's one thing.
- 15:04But if they have any basis to estimate, approximate,
- 15:11or give some sort of range to you, you're entitled
- 15:13to it. And so it might come up midway through
- 15:16the deposition where you're getting a lot of,
- 15:18I don't know. It's like, I don't know what time
- 15:20it was. I don't know how far ahead the car was
- 15:22in front of me. And in those circumstances, it's
- 15:26beneficial to bring back up this tool and say,
- 15:29look, I understand that you're having trouble
- 15:31recollecting an exact thing about something that
- 15:35may have happened two years ago. But at the end
- 15:37of the day, I'm entitled to your best estimate
- 15:40and not asking you to guess. But you do have
- 15:42some personal knowledge as to what happened.
- 15:45And if you have any sort of thing that can provide
- 15:48some approximation, I'm entitled to it. And so
- 15:52even if you don't know the exact time, I'm entitled
- 15:54to whether it's between 1230 and 1 PM, or whether
- 15:58that car ahead of you was five to 10 feet, because
- 16:01at the end of the day, you do have personal knowledge,
- 16:03you did perceive it. And there is there is a
- 16:08tolerable reason for you to give me that testimony.
- 16:11So I call that using it as a sword when you bring
- 16:14it up midway through the deposition. kind of
- 16:18using it to your advantage to get out some testimony
- 16:20when you might get stuck, or might be dealing
- 16:24with an evasive witness. And so that kind of
- 16:29covers it for preparation. Again, there might
- 16:37be a little more to it we could have gone over
- 16:39in terms of the law. However, I think those are
- 16:41the core themes to keep in mind. to not get rattled
- 16:44early on if you're getting a bunch of objections
- 16:47or instructions not to answer. But we'll get
- 16:52into actually deposing the witness strategy and
- 16:57kind of going into it, some of the sort of goals
- 16:59and things you're going to want to accomplish.
- 17:07Okay, so I think there's two goals when taking
- 17:10a deposition. fact finding and then getting sound
- 17:13bites or golden nuggets. And, you know, at the
- 17:18end of the day, the ultimate goal is fact finding.
- 17:22So what we're doing is we're asking a witness
- 17:25of something happened or what they think someone
- 17:29else did or why their opinion is X or why they
- 17:33believe why. Because at the end of the day, again,
- 17:40depositions are the big, and then at trial, it's
- 17:43the small, it's the narrow stuff we're going
- 17:45to be asking about. So that's why this is a moment
- 17:48to get everything you need to know that could
- 17:51come up at trial. And so we want to hear, we
- 17:54don't want to just ask leading questions or ask
- 17:56really targeting things. We kind of want to cover
- 18:00it all just to cover cover our bases. And so,
- 18:05you know, Like, for example, if we're taking
- 18:08the defendant driver's deposition in a motor
- 18:10vehicle accident, you know, it might be best
- 18:14to kind of follow this outline of when asking
- 18:16questions. I like starting big with an open -ended
- 18:19question. Have them explain to you how the collision
- 18:22occurred in a lot of detail. And you're probably
- 18:25going to get a rambling response. There's going
- 18:28to be some stuff in there that's confusing, some
- 18:30stuff in there that is maybe a little inconsistent.
- 18:34However, it's good to get that on the record.
- 18:38And then from there, you're going to want to
- 18:39break up that testimony, confirm some of the
- 18:42stuff they said in that long winded answer. Whether,
- 18:45yeah, he was going this speed right before the
- 18:49collision. And it was sunny outside. And I was
- 18:55just merging on the freeway when he turned left.
- 18:57Break that all down and get them into individual
- 19:00questions. OK, it was sunny at the time of the
- 19:03collision. OK. you were merging onto the freeway
- 19:06right before the incident. That's correct, right?
- 19:09And then once you kind of build all that foundational
- 19:11stuff from what they told you, you summarize
- 19:13it. Say, okay, to summarize, sir, based on your
- 19:16testimony, it's fair to say you were merging
- 19:19right before the incident. It was sunny outside.
- 19:22He was going this amount of speed. And then right
- 19:24when you turned over into his lane is when the
- 19:27collision occurred. Isn't that true? Once you
- 19:30kind of have that all painted in your record
- 19:32and you kind of have all that foundational stuff
- 19:35that he testified to is kind of when you get
- 19:38into more of the juicy questions that you want
- 19:40to lock in that are going to maximize your case,
- 19:44build reliability theory, build your damages
- 19:47that you can use as soundbites when you're drafting
- 19:50a demand letter, drafting a mediation brief,
- 19:54putting something before the judge to include
- 19:56with depot citations, anything like that. And
- 20:00so that's kind of why Jean Paul mentalized it
- 20:03in the fact finding first, and then kind of once
- 20:06you have the foundational stuff, kind of go in,
- 20:09try to get the kill, try to get, okay, he did
- 20:12have the right of way, isn't that right? Okay,
- 20:14you did fail to yield to his right of way, isn't
- 20:18that true? And if you could get those, great,
- 20:20because at the end of the day, that's gonna add
- 20:22a lot of value. Okay. So, again, we talked about
- 20:31compiling exhibits. Now, using them in deposition
- 20:36is great. It's great for new attorneys too. I
- 20:40love using them because it helps keep my questions
- 20:42on track, kind of helps me keep the issues in
- 20:45mind, break things down. It also has a practical
- 20:48purpose in terms of laying foundation, in terms
- 20:52of getting things admitted at a later date. One
- 20:58thing that might be a little overlooked for newer
- 21:00attorneys is when and how to use them during
- 21:04the deposition. For instance, we'll kind of go
- 21:07through an example here in a second, but it's
- 21:09also good when compiling them and maybe preparing
- 21:12your outline that you think about the structure
- 21:14of, oh, I'm going to make sure I show this exhibit
- 21:16with this statement before I show this one, just
- 21:20to see what he says about this before I show
- 21:22him this. Here's a whole gamut of exhibits. But
- 21:30again, as I was kind of saying, great for authentication
- 21:33purposes like foundation. For instance, if you
- 21:38have some sort of business record, it's always
- 21:42great to look up the evidence code section to
- 21:45get that record in. For instance, a business
- 21:49record exception, because what you're going to
- 21:50want to do is you're going to look at those elements
- 21:52and you're going to ask, hey, Is this record
- 21:56normally prepared in the regular course of your
- 21:58business? This isn't some sort of one -off record,
- 22:03right? The custodian who prepares this is who?
- 22:07They're going to get all that information out.
- 22:09So when it comes time, at the time of trial,
- 22:13you have laid the foundation through this depot
- 22:16testimony. And again, think about when compiling
- 22:20the exhibit, what's the purpose of it? How are
- 22:22you going to use it? Is this something strictly
- 22:24for impeachment? Is this to get clarification
- 22:27of the way this thinks about how something happened?
- 22:30Or something else? It's all great to keep in
- 22:33the back of your mind. Okay. Now, we're going
- 22:43to watch a video to kind of help flesh out this
- 22:48notion of using exhibits. Now, this is a case
- 22:53where there is a truck, a tractor trailer making
- 22:57a turn at an intersection but from the middle
- 23:01lane. And essentially what happens when he's
- 23:04making the turn from the middle lane, a car on
- 23:06the right comes and tries to speed past. And
- 23:10it leads to two pedestrians getting struck by
- 23:13the gear trying to pass the right turning truck.
- 23:17Now, we're going to see through some of the testimony
- 23:21of the defendant driver, how to use this video
- 23:24along with his statements in the traffic collision
- 23:26report and other sorts of exhibits and how it
- 23:29kind of plays out and how to deal with an adverse
- 23:31witness. So I'll play the video one moment. It's
- 23:53a horrible video. And, you know, going into the
- 23:57deposition, you're gonna taking a deposition
- 24:01of a driver in a video like, like there's clear
- 24:04fault. You never really know how that witness
- 24:07is going to handle seeing that or being asked
- 24:09questions about it. For instance, as we'll see
- 24:15in this deposition, the driver of the truck thought
- 24:18he was completely in the right and that that's
- 24:20how that turn had been made. So before, you know,
- 24:26taking that deposition, you can just show that
- 24:29video right out the gate. However, I think the
- 24:32best practices get their understanding of what
- 24:36happened, what went down, what they thought they
- 24:38did right, what they thought others did wrong.
- 24:41And then you kind of get into the exhibits, their
- 24:44statements, the video, etc. So first, I have
- 24:50a traffic collision report with that driver statement.
- 24:54Okay. Now, when showing someone a report where
- 24:59they gave a statement, for instance, or told
- 25:02someone X and it was written down, whether it's
- 25:05a police officer they told it to, or some other
- 25:07agency, you're always going to want to ask, you
- 25:10know, is what you said is that statement you
- 25:13gave truthful, honest, and accurate? You're going
- 25:17to want to lock them in to what they said. Okay.
- 25:24So what you told the officer was honest, accurate,
- 25:26and truthful, correct? Of course. All right.
- 25:31And then, you know, after laying some other foundation,
- 25:34you bring up this statement and you're going
- 25:37to want to ask if he agrees with that statement
- 25:39that was prepared in the report. Not sure why
- 25:48the highlight is blocking out the vertical part
- 25:51of the statement However, his statement was he
- 25:54was traveling between the number one and number
- 25:56two lanes You know, you're gonna read that prior
- 26:00to your deposition prior to taking his deposition
- 26:02and think well I watched the video none of his
- 26:05vehicle was in that far right lane solely in
- 26:08that middle That middle lane Okay, so ask a follow
- 26:13-up after you're gonna read in the statement
- 26:15Ask if he agrees. Okay. And then follow up with
- 26:19him. Do you agree with that statement that you
- 26:21operated your vehicle between the number one
- 26:23and number two lane prior to making your turn?
- 26:27Yes. Clean admission. Now you're going to want
- 26:35to show them the video. You've got to lock them
- 26:37in, show them the video, and you're going to
- 26:39walk through it with them. Okay. For instance,
- 26:44No part of your vehicle at zero seconds in its
- 26:48frame is in the far right lane. Correct? Correct.
- 26:53And then, okay, at two seconds when you're beginning
- 26:56making your turn, still, you've entered the intersection,
- 26:59but none of your vehicle is in the far right
- 27:01lane, right? Keep walking it through because
- 27:05this goes to how he's gonna present at trial,
- 27:08his credibility, and all these other issues and
- 27:11kind of narrows down. what actually happened.
- 27:18So when using video exhibits, kind of as I was
- 27:20saying, you're always going to want to pull up
- 27:22the video, you know, state state how long it
- 27:25is 22 second, 22 second video marking it as exhibit
- 27:30seven. Okay, you're going to play it through
- 27:34once, let the witness watch it, explain to him
- 27:37and play this through once then ask you some
- 27:39questions afterwards. After that, you'll probably
- 27:42ask some foundational questions, like, sure,
- 27:46that's your truck, right? This appears to be
- 27:49the intersection where the collision occurred,
- 27:51right? You have no doubt this is a video of the
- 27:53collision, correct? And then again, you're going
- 27:57to want to play and pause, then finish it. Play,
- 28:00pause, collision. As I was saying, at this point
- 28:04in the intersection, you're making the turn.
- 28:06The light was yellow, right? By the time the
- 28:10collision happened, you still hadn't cleared
- 28:11the intersection, correct? Correct. Now, I was
- 28:25just giving you, you know, example questions
- 28:27and testimony, but I'll tell you, it's not a
- 28:31clean record. And that's something we haven't
- 28:33really talked about is the ultimate goal of taking
- 28:36the deposition. is not winning the deposition
- 28:39or making the witness mad and angry and giving
- 28:43you great statements. The real goal is getting
- 28:46a clean record that you can cleanly use in the
- 28:49future, whether it's playing it at trial or like
- 28:52I said, using it as a man letter or mediation
- 28:55brief or something like that. You don't want
- 28:57a bunch of questions with long rambling answers
- 29:00that aren't responsive. You want a clean yes
- 29:03or no answer or something of the sort. and it
- 29:07might be tricky when you have a witness who's
- 29:11adverse to you and is not giving you those sound
- 29:14bites or that clean record. So if you're here,
- 29:19this is some testimony regarding that video.
- 29:24And at this moment, you have not began your turn,
- 29:27right? And then you say something, of course
- 29:28I started, but one has to be careful, blah, blah,
- 29:31blah, blah, blah. That wasn't responsive to the
- 29:33question. It was actually, Not even answering
- 29:37the question how I thought he would I'm showing
- 29:40him a picture of a still frame of him Not in
- 29:42the intersection. You said you already started
- 29:44to start Then you kind of just gotta sign them
- 29:51and remind them and say, you know, that wasn't
- 29:53my question sir I'm just asking you about what
- 29:56we're looking at this point. You don't see your
- 29:58tractor trailer beginning its turn yet, correct?
- 30:02Then he says if you want me to answer that's
- 30:04correct Okay, not a clean yes or no, but you
- 30:09know, there's only so much digging you can really
- 30:10do to get a clean record However closing counsel
- 30:17hated that response hated When he said if you
- 30:22want me to answer as you can see it gives a long
- 30:25-winded instruction to the witness Telling him
- 30:29that he can't just answer something just because
- 30:32he thinks that's what I want the answer to be
- 30:36um and you know it's kind of uncomfortable to
- 30:41deal with when you have counsel interjecting
- 30:43like that and uh the witness is obviously listening
- 30:46to them and that's that's really important to
- 30:49take note of because you're gonna have to take
- 30:51back control in those situations because from
- 30:53there on out the witness isn't going to be listening
- 30:56to you and thinking it's your deposition they're
- 30:58going to be listening to their attorney and not
- 31:01answering questions as they would if they weren't
- 31:04giving them such coaching. So in these scenarios,
- 31:09it may be proper to tell counsel, counsel, I
- 31:13appreciate your interjection, but no witness
- 31:14coaching, please. This is my deposition and I'll
- 31:16conduct it as I see fit. And then you're going
- 31:19to instruct to the witness. Well, so. I'll circle
- 31:29back to that. The witness then after that, after
- 31:31hearing his counsel's instruction, he says, no,
- 31:33I cannot answer that question. And I can't answer
- 31:36any of the questions I've been asked. Well, that
- 31:39could destroy your whole prior testimony you
- 31:42got from him and muddy it up and do the opposite
- 31:48of making a clean record, for instance. So in
- 31:52this circumstance, you kind of have to rein it
- 31:55back in and say, Look, sir, are you saying you
- 32:00can't answer my questions because your counsel
- 32:03is applying? You shouldn't answer them or because
- 32:05you don't understand them because at the end
- 32:07of the day if he understands the questions And
- 32:10he gives you answers. Those are proper responses
- 32:13Now if he's saying didn't understand any of my
- 32:16prior questions, that's a different story I Didn't
- 32:24really even answer that last question of whether
- 32:28He was following his counsel's advice. He just
- 32:30says no, because of the way one drives for safety
- 32:32and security, one can answer those questions.
- 32:36And then again, you want it clean. Sure, you
- 32:39understand the questions I've been asking you.
- 32:42I understand. Okay, then you kind of move on.
- 32:46You give them a speech. Look, I'm entitled to
- 32:48your best testimony, your most honest testimony,
- 32:51and everything you can recollect and testify
- 32:54to based on your personal knowledge. I ask that
- 32:57you give me responsive questions so we don't
- 32:58have to suspend this deposition and come back
- 33:00another day and remind them of those ground rules
- 33:06that you set forth at the beginning. And this
- 33:08is one of those instances where you follow up
- 33:11with them with using that as munitions as a sword
- 33:15versus a shield. And then this kind of just illustrates
- 33:25what I was just talking about, you kind of give
- 33:27them a little speech that you're entitled to
- 33:29their best testimony, and if they know, they're
- 33:32supposed to give you answers. We don't want guesses,
- 33:35but what I'm showing you, a video of the collision
- 33:38and asking very simple, basic questions, I'm
- 33:42entitled to your testimony that are responsive
- 33:44to my questions. And when they keep giving you
- 33:47answers that aren't responsive, that aren't maybe
- 33:50clean yes or nos, is when you kind of have to
- 33:52do some witness control. and use techniques like,
- 33:56OK, my question is thanks, or I appreciate your
- 33:59response, but yes or no. You didn't begin your
- 34:03turn at this moment. Now, another type of exhibit,
- 34:13always great to use, are rules, whether they're
- 34:16training manuals, policy handbooks, vehicle code
- 34:19sections. commercial driver handbooks, anything
- 34:24like that. These are great exhibits to use once
- 34:28you've already kind of talked about the collision,
- 34:31maybe got their story out, story out about what
- 34:34happened after showing the video of what happened.
- 34:39It's great to maybe pull up any relevant code
- 34:42sections, handbooks, or policies that you can
- 34:44then ask the witness on. So for instance, turning
- 34:48back to this case, he was a truck driver. be
- 34:51a commercial truck driver. All commercial truck
- 34:53drivers have to get a specialized license and
- 34:56review this commercial handbook. And so before
- 35:01the deposition, I reviewed this handbook, control
- 35:04F, making right turns, kind of the safety practices
- 35:08and rules that instruct commercial drivers on
- 35:11how to perform those turns, where their wheels
- 35:13should be during making the turn, et cetera.
- 35:19So again, these are great tools to use because
- 35:22you're going to pull up any relevant section
- 35:23in this handbook, read it to them, ask if they
- 35:26understand it, and then ask follow up questions
- 35:29if they acted in accordance with the rules that
- 35:31they were aware of. And whether they're aware
- 35:35of the handbook or not is also great testimony
- 35:38because if they don't know about the commercial
- 35:39handbook and their commercial driver, that looks
- 35:42bad too. And just to lay some foundation with
- 35:46them, you know, you're going to say, sir. You
- 35:49had to get a specialized license to drive the
- 35:51truck you were driving on the day of the accident,
- 35:53right? Right. You had to take a test, correct?
- 35:56You had to review the commercial driver handbook,
- 35:59right? And you remember reviewing that handbook,
- 36:01and you did review that handbook. And you agreed
- 36:04those are the rules of the road when operating
- 36:06your commercial truck, correct? Then you're going
- 36:11to pull up the exhibit, mark it, and then go
- 36:14to your relevant section that you've already
- 36:16pulled. and then kind of highlight what you're
- 36:19going to read to them and ask them follow -up
- 36:20questions. Now, in this case example, the driver
- 36:26was very hostile thinking that the Camry that
- 36:32was on the right lane was trying to pass him
- 36:34and that he was completely at fault. Now, this
- 36:41code section was right on the money, or excuse
- 36:43me, this rule in the handbook was right on the
- 36:45money. because it even warns that drivers should
- 36:49keep the back end of their vehicle as close to
- 36:51the curb as possible because this will avoid,
- 36:53you know, other cars on the right giving them
- 36:57an opportunity to try to pass up. And this is
- 37:01great foundation for them to kind of get more
- 37:04testimony to clarify whether they think what
- 37:07they did was correct in accordance with this
- 37:10rule section or something different. Okay. Now,
- 37:23we kind of went through some of the goals of
- 37:25the deposition, shared strategy with using exhibits,
- 37:30and kind of how to handle maybe an evasive witness,
- 37:32some techniques, have a rating control with counsel,
- 37:35stuff like that. That's all pretty good general
- 37:38stuff to keep in mind. Something that might be
- 37:43a little more Also beneficial to keep in mind
- 37:48is the words you use when phrasing your questions,
- 37:51the art of word choice. Now I think it's really
- 37:55important, especially when you're trying to get
- 37:57those sound bites and that clean record of asking
- 37:59questions with the right language, because obviously
- 38:04there's some words that may detract from your
- 38:09theory of the case, while other words can be
- 38:11supplemented to enhance your theory of the case.
- 38:18So I call it phrasing your questions with intent.
- 38:21For instance, plaintiff's attorney. I don't call
- 38:25a motor vehicle accident an accident. I always
- 38:28call it a collision. In the depot, at the time
- 38:31of the collision, where are we looking? At the
- 38:34time of the collision, how fast are you going?
- 38:38OK. And the reason we want to do this is because
- 38:41we want to think about our audience. Who is going
- 38:45to read this depot? Is a mediator going to read
- 38:48this in my brief? Do I want to say incident versus
- 38:51collision? I'd rather have the mediator here
- 38:53or see collision. Or if it's being shown to a
- 38:56jury for maybe impeachment purposes or just being
- 38:58played on trial, I want to ingrain and have them
- 39:03appreciate the seriousness of this event. So
- 39:06it's really important, pre -depo, to kind of
- 39:09get these, use this wordsmithing technique with
- 39:13some of those key crucial questions you know
- 39:15you're going to ask. because those are going
- 39:16to be your golden nugget sound bites. And I just
- 39:23have a slide with just some basic words, plaintiff
- 39:27-oriented words that I try to keep in mind when
- 39:32thinking of my questions. For instance, if I'm
- 39:37referring to An injury someone suffered, I would
- 39:41call it a catastrophic injury, assuming it is
- 39:44a catastrophic injury such as a very severe fracture
- 39:48or amputation. I try to sprinkle in these words
- 39:53when asking questions that have yes or no answers.
- 39:56You agree this was a life altering event, correct?
- 40:00Correct. You agree if you're asking your doctor,
- 40:03you agree he will suffer from a permanent impairment
- 40:07in his leg? right? These all kind of enhance
- 40:12the type of, the type of nature of the words,
- 40:17or excuse me, these really enhance the way these
- 40:21sound bites come off, because it gives them more
- 40:24teeth. And I have down here, KC 3905, which is
- 40:29our pain and suffering instruction, and it lists
- 40:31all the different types of items of harm that
- 40:34one is compensable for, such as inconvenience,
- 40:38loss of enjoyment of life, mental suffering,
- 40:43disfigurement, humiliation, grief, anxiety, all
- 40:48those are listed in that instruction. And because
- 40:51those are technically items of damages to your
- 40:55pain and suffering component, to your non economic
- 40:58damages, it's great when you can get testimony
- 41:01that have clear sound bites of You agree he's
- 41:05experiencing loss of enjoyment of life because
- 41:07he can no longer walk, right? You agree that
- 41:10his finger is disfigured after it got fractured,
- 41:13correct? You agree that it's very inconvenient
- 41:16for him that he can no longer mobilize himself
- 41:19to the bathroom. Now, what we're basically doing
- 41:22is we're matching evidence to elements. That's
- 41:25kind of what it's all about at the end of the
- 41:26day and what you're going to want to prove at
- 41:27trial. And kind of following up on that on damages
- 41:35because we really think I feel like a lot about
- 41:38liability and getting a lot of liability emissions
- 41:40and stuff like that. Don't underestimate the
- 41:44type of testimony you can get with respect to
- 41:47damages. Even if it's a liability witness, even
- 41:50if you're taking the defendant driver's deposition,
- 41:52there's a chance you can get some great damages
- 41:55testimony. You just have to try. And I have a
- 41:58bunch of examples here of how you can do it and
- 42:02how it can even be used in a very strategic way.
- 42:10For instance, in this last case we've already
- 42:11been talking about, always ask, you'd characterize
- 42:15this as a catastrophic collision, right? Which
- 42:19gives kind of a weird response that doesn't really
- 42:22respond to the severity of this collision. Okay,
- 42:27kind of gonna walk them through it, follow them
- 42:29back through. and just say, you know, I probably
- 42:32said, look, someone got struck, a pedestrian
- 42:35got struck by a vehicle, right? Right. And kind
- 42:37of walk them through, follow back up with a clean
- 42:40question, say, my question is this, this was
- 42:42a severely catastrophic event. If anybody's hit,
- 42:46even if it's light, I'd consider it catastrophic
- 42:48and horrific. Wasn't a clean yes, but you know,
- 42:52we'll take it in this instance, because at the
- 42:54end of the day, in your mediation brief or in
- 42:56your demand letter, you're just going to say,
- 42:58look, the defendant driver, the other party even
- 43:01agrees that what happened here today or what
- 43:04happened on the date of that collision was a
- 43:07catastrophe. State the depot. Okay, I have a
- 43:15clip here of kind of evoking damage testimonies.
- 43:19And this is a case where a bus collided with
- 43:24a center divider. Right here, we have the bus
- 43:28driver being deposed. And this is my boss conducting
- 43:32the deposition. However, it not only illustrates
- 43:37getting damages testimony from a liability witness,
- 43:40but also kind of handling a witness that isn't
- 43:42going to give you, yes, this was a severely catastrophic
- 43:46event, or yes, this bus is severely damaged.
- 43:53Hopefully this sound plays. Might take a second
- 44:04to load. But you're going to want to show them
- 44:09exhibit. You're going to want to show them this
- 44:12bus picture. Hold on. I'm not hearing it. Stop
- 44:30sharing. One second. Okay, I'm having an audio
- 45:44issue, but I'll give you the rundown. Basically,
- 45:48I'm asking him, look, you characterize this as
- 45:52an impact with major damage, right? He goes,
- 45:57it's damaged. He goes, no, my question is, looking
- 46:01at this bus with a smashed window in, this constitutes
- 46:05major damage, right, sir? I mean, it looks damaged.
- 46:11Then you ask him some follow -up questions. Sir,
- 46:14you're an experienced bus driver, right? Yes.
- 46:16Okay. And you know, this isn't a minor collision.
- 46:20You would agree, right? And you might say, well,
- 46:23I don't know. It depends on who you ask. Well,
- 46:24I'm asking you. And there are people injured
- 46:27to your knowledge in this bus, right? Yes. There
- 46:30was a window smashed in. The A -frame spat, correct?
- 46:33Looking at this image, we see the entrance all
- 46:36disfigured, correct? Okay. Are you saying you
- 46:40don't consider what we see in this picture, this
- 46:43damaged bus, to be major severe damage? He may
- 46:47give it to you, he may not. If he doesn't give
- 46:49it to you, that's fine, move on. He kind of looks,
- 46:52you know, not like the most credible person,
- 46:55not agreeing this is some significant damage.
- 47:02Okay, hopefully this sound works. If it doesn't...
- 47:07I'll just I'll just explain it away. So this
- 47:12kind of goes along the lines of taking treater
- 47:16depositions, first responder depositions like
- 47:19paramedics, because in these depositions, you
- 47:23know, they're kind of methodical and a lot of
- 47:25times boring, especially taking a paramedics
- 47:28deposition. A lot of times when you take a paramedic
- 47:32deposition, they don't even remember what they
- 47:34responded to, why they're even there. They're
- 47:37really just going to kind of look at their report
- 47:40and answer some questions based on that. Other
- 47:43than that, it's kind of hard to get a lot out
- 47:47of them. That's really beneficial. It's great
- 47:49for foundational stuff, sure. But when it comes
- 47:52to kind of maximizing your case and using some
- 47:55sound bites, it could be difficult at times.
- 47:59I feel like a good way to kind of prime your
- 48:02witness, whether it's a paramedic, a firefighter.
- 48:06or someone who was at the scene, looking at your
- 48:09client, treating them. A good thing to do is
- 48:12to show them exhibits first before asking those
- 48:16kind of tight questions about, this person looked
- 48:20like he was in severe pain, right? The person
- 48:22you were treating was clearly suffering, correct?
- 48:26It's hard to ask those questions to them if they
- 48:28don't remember. It's best if you have body worn
- 48:31footage to show them responding to the person,
- 48:35hearing them scream, hearing them hearing or
- 48:39seeing the type of bruising or abrasions on them,
- 48:43showing them that jogs their memory and makes
- 48:46them more flexible into giving you those clean
- 48:49emissions. So like in here in this case, walking
- 48:54through the paramedic, this was a case where
- 48:56a pedestrian got struck by a car making a right
- 48:58turn or left turn onto a one way. And it was
- 49:02a really horrific event. However, the paramedic,
- 49:06the no independent recollection of this scene
- 49:09in treating treating this patient. So walk through
- 49:15within the body worn footage pointing them out.
- 49:17Sir, that's you, right? That looks like you.
- 49:19Yes. Okay. And we see here a person being put
- 49:24on a stretcher, right? Yeah, you hear them screaming,
- 49:26correct? Yeah, I hear them screaming in the video.
- 49:29Then you walk through the patient care report
- 49:31where it says this person was reporting level
- 49:3310 pain at this point. This person reported this
- 49:36level pain at this point. This person required
- 49:40critical care and treatment. Once you walk through
- 49:43all that with them, they kind of have a clear
- 49:45understanding of what actually happened. Maybe
- 49:48they remember little bits and pieces, but at
- 49:50the end of the day, you're going to finish off
- 49:52that depot with a set of damages questions saying,
- 49:56Sir, the person you were treating was in a severely
- 49:58catastrophic condition, right? He was traumatically
- 50:01injured, correct? He needed critical emergency
- 50:05care, yes? And those you might not always get,
- 50:10but you'll have a better shot if you're showing
- 50:12the witness more to help them kind of grasp what
- 50:16they remember, what actually happened, and the
- 50:19severity of what happened. We'll see if this
- 50:22plays with sound. Hopefully it does. So showing
- 50:33this body worn footage and then asking questions.
- 50:36This is the paramedic. I don't think you can
- 50:42hear it, but again, asking those questions. Traumatically
- 50:46injured, severely catastrophic. Yes, yes, yes.
- 50:49Got all of those. It's great. This is another
- 50:57way to kind of get good damages testimony out
- 51:00of it. or a paramedic or someone who doesn't
- 51:03really remember what happened is going through
- 51:06the report prior to the deposition and then highlighting
- 51:09things that are very favorable to your case.
- 51:14And even though they may not remember that that's
- 51:16what happened to that patient or that client,
- 51:18have them explain that because you're gonna get
- 51:21really good testimony and you can use that in
- 51:23various ways. Again, I don't know if the video
- 51:27is gonna play here, but essentially, I saw in
- 51:31the report prior to this deposition that the
- 51:34ER doctor, not even this witness, the ER doctor
- 51:38said in the narrative of the patient care report
- 51:40that the appliance limber was mashed. That's
- 51:46kind of an atypical way to phrase some medical
- 51:49trauma. So I asked him in your own words, based
- 51:52on your understanding of, based on your experience
- 51:55in training, How would you explain to someone
- 51:59when you hear that a liver is mashed it goes
- 52:01on and on about what that entails and You know
- 52:05how severe it must have been for an ER doctor
- 52:07to say and use that word mashed Let me go back
- 52:21one second Okay, you didn't see it in that video,
- 52:36but what was so great about having that paramedic,
- 52:42that life -like paramedic, he was actually the
- 52:45one who transported the patient from one critical
- 52:47care facility in Eureka all the way to UC Davis
- 52:51and was with them the whole time, is that we
- 52:55actually used that testimony in a mediation video.
- 52:58We made an entire about 22 minute long video
- 53:00for mediation purposes. where we had animations
- 53:05of the accident, we had surgical animations of
- 53:09the urethral repair and the pelvic fracture being
- 53:13repaired with these screws and plates, the ankle
- 53:16fracture, the liver being lacerated. And yeah,
- 53:20it's great to have an animation, but it's great
- 53:22when you have the treaters talking about it with
- 53:25sworn testimony to overlay on those animations.
- 53:29And so if you do have something coming up like
- 53:32a mediation date, maybe a demand you want to
- 53:35get out or a video you want to make, it's kind
- 53:38of great to keep that in mind. You have these
- 53:42depots noticed and you have them upcoming to
- 53:44think about. I want to get some testimony about
- 53:47him talking about this type of injury and ask
- 53:50it in this way so I can play it over this animation
- 53:53or so I can include it in the demand letter to
- 53:56really hammer this issue. Because at the end
- 54:01of the day, you can use this testimony in a variety
- 54:04of ways, whether it's for a video, mediation
- 54:06video, whether it's an emotion, a day in the
- 54:11life video, anything like that. So while we're
- 54:15fact finding at the end of the day, and that
- 54:17should be like the overarching goal of getting
- 54:19the story of what happened or what they think
- 54:21about this, getting these clean record soundbites.
- 54:25can serve a lot of purpose on the back end too
- 54:29in other ways than just that trial. So I just
- 54:35have here some important takeaways regarding,
- 54:37you know, the importance of damages testimony
- 54:40other than just liability is like I was saying,
- 54:43think and plan ahead. Like if you have something
- 54:46coming up or you want to make a mediation video,
- 54:49or you know you want to make a demand letter.
- 54:52really spelling out the damages or really spelling
- 54:55out that, hey, the other side doesn't think what
- 54:58happened here was a big deal. I need to get some
- 55:01testimony. This was a big deal. And this was
- 55:03a severe event. This was a catastrophic collision.
- 55:07Keep that in mind when you're taking these depositions
- 55:12because this could help you in the future. Words
- 55:15meant to maximize the soundbites as we talked
- 55:17about, you know, accident versus collision. catastrophe,
- 55:24trauma, life altering, upending, using those
- 55:28KC elements, loss of enjoyment of life, pain
- 55:31and suffering, disfigurement. And then, you know,
- 55:38there'll be times where you're kind of going
- 55:40and it feels a little awkward to ask these sort
- 55:42of questions. And you might get awkward responses.
- 55:48That's okay. It's better to ask than to, you
- 55:52know, down the road being like, I wish I could
- 55:54just try that out. Even if you don't get anything
- 55:56or the witness looks at you weird, it's okay.
- 55:59You just move on. It's a long deposition anyway.
- 56:02You should really try to push yourself to try
- 56:04things and to evoke testimony that could be favorable
- 56:07to your case. Because at the end of the day,
- 56:13you might be really close, even if you just ask
- 56:15another follow up question. to an evasive answer
- 56:18from getting a real golden nugget that you can
- 56:20use, or really good admission, or really clean
- 56:23sound bite. Now once you've finished and you
- 56:28take your deposition, your new attorney is really
- 56:33important to review the transcript. You're going
- 56:35to get that transcript back. You're going to
- 56:38want to mark it up, get different pens, highlighters,
- 56:41colors. I strike my filler words, I say and a
- 56:44lot or okay before asking a question. And at
- 56:48the end of the day, the goal is a clean worker.
- 56:51So it's really good to put pen to paper striking
- 56:56that out because it keeps in the back of your
- 56:58mind for the future to not use those words. And
- 57:02then in other instances, maybe see where some
- 57:04of your questions were a little off or a little
- 57:06funky and see. when the witness might have given
- 57:09you something that you should have followed up
- 57:10on. A lot of times, we're not listening or thinking
- 57:13about our next question. I'm victim to it, and
- 57:16it happens all the time. And that's why it's
- 57:18really important to see and listen what the witness
- 57:20gives you, because they might have given you
- 57:23something great. And if you followed up on it,
- 57:26you clawed it, you really don't know what you're
- 57:31missing out on. So learn from those mistakes.
- 57:34I mean, it's all about reps. It's just about
- 57:36doing it. You know, you kind of learn through
- 57:38every deposition. Sometimes you have an awful
- 57:40one. Sometimes you have a good one. And there's
- 57:42a 99 % chance it's never going to see the light
- 57:45of day anyway or be played at trial. So we just
- 57:48kind of move on. Keep getting those reps in.
- 57:51And hopefully, this gives a little more some
- 57:55tools and insights of taking depositions for
- 57:59new attorneys. All right. That concludes it.
- 58:13All right, Tyler. We do have quite a few questions
- 58:15if you'd like to get into. Starting off early
- 58:21on, Christopher Rose asked, how do you feel about
- 58:24a short depot dialed into key points and not
- 58:27running all day just to verify already sworn
- 58:29testimony and discovery? Yeah, I think that's
- 58:34great. I think sometimes we spend a little too
- 58:37much time. wasting time on overexpansive depositions.
- 58:42And at the end of the day, it's really just what
- 58:44you want to get out of it. If you know that's
- 58:46really all you need for a short depot just to
- 58:48verify discovery. For instance, if you get some
- 58:51responses and maybe there's some hesitation into
- 58:55whether those are actually what the party is
- 59:01portraying happened, it might be fruitful to
- 59:04take a short locked in deposition. Yeah, I don't
- 59:09see any issue with that. All right. And Heather
- 59:15asks, is it proper to use a prior transcript
- 59:18from the same witness example, a PMK from a company
- 59:21to challenge credibility of a witness in a separate
- 59:25case concerning the same corporation? It's proper.
- 59:31However, again, kind of going back to strategizing
- 59:34how you want to use your deposit or want to use
- 59:36your exhibits. So using that prior transcript,
- 59:39for instance, maybe for some impeachment that
- 59:42might come up during the depo, maybe it's fruitful
- 59:45to not show that and save it for trial. Have
- 59:49them locked into one thing and then in the trial,
- 59:51you'd show the prior transcript, get it introduced
- 59:53and challenge credibility that way. Or if you
- 59:58think If you think it would be beneficial to
- 1:00:00bring up during the deposition, perfectly good.
- 1:00:04It's a prior sworn statement of the witness,
- 1:00:07so it would be proper. Christopher Rose asks,
- 1:00:12why don't you use crash instead of collision?
- 1:00:17Crash is good. Crash just might be just as good
- 1:00:20as collision. I like that. I'll use that. All
- 1:00:26right, and let's see. Shireen requests if you
- 1:00:30can give some tips on effectively dealing with
- 1:00:32hostile, harassing, um, opposing counsel and
- 1:00:35constant speaking, objections and coaching. Yes.
- 1:00:40So in terms of dealing, I mean, I'm kind of,
- 1:00:45you know, a younger baby attorney and a lot of
- 1:00:47times I'll get opposing counsel on those other
- 1:00:49side that's a veteran and tells me they've been
- 1:00:51practicing law for X amount of years and they're
- 1:00:55giving a lot of speaking objections and witness
- 1:00:57coaching. I found, personally, best practice
- 1:01:00is to not engage them as much as possible. And
- 1:01:05what I mean by that, with one simple statement,
- 1:01:09trying to be a little passive with them. Council,
- 1:01:11I appreciate your speaking objections, which
- 1:01:13are not proper. However, I would just like to
- 1:01:15conduct my deposition. I appreciate you not doing
- 1:01:18that. Otherwise, we might have to suspend this
- 1:01:20deposition. Because you don't want to be fighting
- 1:01:22back and forth with them on the record. And the
- 1:01:24reason that is, is because if it... ends up going
- 1:01:27to a judge where there's a motion to compel testimony,
- 1:01:31that judge is not only going to read harassing
- 1:01:34opposing counsel, but they're going to see you
- 1:01:36fighting back with them and giving them fuel.
- 1:01:39So it's just kind of politely remind them that
- 1:01:41it's improper and hopefully they kind of puts
- 1:01:44them in their place that, hey, this lawyer knows
- 1:01:46that what I'm doing is a little overboard and
- 1:01:50hopefully they settle down. All right, and have
- 1:01:57another question. Jean asks, what do you say
- 1:02:01to cut out, when you say to cut out, okay, and
- 1:02:05other words, can you do that with what you turn
- 1:02:08in and use in court as the transcript? I would
- 1:02:14caution against that. For instance, I assume
- 1:02:17you mean like if you were to play it at trial
- 1:02:19or something or maybe put it before a judge,
- 1:02:22whether it's an emotion or attached to emotion.
- 1:02:25I think you really do want to put exactly what
- 1:02:28was said down, just so there's no speculation
- 1:02:31from the other side that there might have been
- 1:02:33some foul play. So at the end of the day, you
- 1:02:38can cut it out if it's maybe some informal, you
- 1:02:41know, letter or something. But I think best practice
- 1:02:43is you kind of got to copy and paste the exact
- 1:02:46question, exact answer. All right, thank you.
- 1:02:52And let's see, we have Quite a few more questions.
- 1:02:57What suggestion do you have when a depot is limited
- 1:03:00to two hours in a, I guess in this case, it was
- 1:03:03a California Lemon Law case and the witness is
- 1:03:06being evasive and or wasting time with unresponsive
- 1:03:08answers? So. In that circumstance, I would again
- 1:03:17kind of refer back to your toolbox of what you're
- 1:03:20entitled to and. You're entitled to his best,
- 1:03:22most honest testimony. And if he's still giving
- 1:03:25you a lot of evasive questions, you gotta remind
- 1:03:28him of the time deadline. Excuse me, you gotta
- 1:03:30remind the witness the time deadline. Look, I
- 1:03:33only have you here for two hours. This is my
- 1:03:35chance to get your testimony. My question is
- 1:03:38this. If they're still giving you evasive, sir,
- 1:03:41yes or no, X, Y, Z. still giving you really evasive
- 1:03:46responses after all that and not being straightforward
- 1:03:49with you, you can caution them, I might have
- 1:03:52to go to the judge and compel you to be deposed
- 1:03:54again for an extended amount of time because
- 1:03:56you're not giving me what I'm entitled to. And
- 1:04:00hopefully that speeds things up and gets you
- 1:04:03through it on time. All right. And Kaz asks,
- 1:04:11how do you balance getting good deposition testimony
- 1:04:14versus alerting the other side to weaknesses
- 1:04:16they can fix for trial? That's a good question.
- 1:04:20You know, I think it really goes into planning
- 1:04:23for the deposition of kind of what you want to
- 1:04:25signal to the other side. For instance, do you
- 1:04:28really want to signal your theory about maybe
- 1:04:32some code violation that they're not aware of?
- 1:04:35and ask them about that during the deposition,
- 1:04:37or do you want to kind of save that for trial?
- 1:04:40Again, I think at the end of the day, this is
- 1:04:44just my own personal opinion, it's kind of better
- 1:04:46to get everything out there in deposition. So,
- 1:04:50you know, you have some sort of format for trial,
- 1:04:53because when you put that witness on the stand,
- 1:04:56you're going to want to know what they're going
- 1:04:57to say. And so if you're saving something, and
- 1:05:01this is your chance to depose them and find out
- 1:05:03what they think about it, they might give you
- 1:05:06something completely off the wall at trial and
- 1:05:09you have no record or prior testimony for them
- 1:05:12to impeach with. So it's really a strategy question.
- 1:05:17And at the end of the day, if you're signaling
- 1:05:18it to the other side, I don't think that's a
- 1:05:21bad thing either. It's like you kind of want
- 1:05:23them to know your theory and what you're running
- 1:05:25with in most circumstances. So they can properly
- 1:05:29evaluate your case when you're making your demands.
- 1:05:36All right, thank you. And we have a couple more
- 1:05:39here. How can you properly admit deposition testimony
- 1:05:43in the context of a trial for impeachment purposes?
- 1:05:48So, well, if it's for impeachment purposes, it
- 1:05:51doesn't have to be per se admissible, right?
- 1:05:54But if we're trying to get it admitted for its
- 1:05:57truth, for instance, OK, you're going to have
- 1:06:02to, well, one, is it a party? whose deposition
- 1:06:05you took to. It's also a witness that you ask
- 1:06:09questions under oath to. Okay. And, you know,
- 1:06:14under the code, you're allowed to designate deposition
- 1:06:17testimony for the time of trial. We have the
- 1:06:19code section. I think it's 20. Don't quote me
- 1:06:22on this. Don't rely on this 2025 .620 subsections.
- 1:06:28Don't correct me if I'm wrong. But So when you
- 1:06:32notice your deposition, you're noticing the intent
- 1:06:34to play it at trial, which comes in for its truth
- 1:06:38absent any objections that are ruled upon by
- 1:06:41the judge prior to trial. So it's good in your
- 1:06:43notice to include that if you do think this is
- 1:06:46something you're going to use at trial. But I'll
- 1:06:53give a quick thing. For impeachment purposes,
- 1:06:55you would honestly just, the judge is gonna have
- 1:06:58a binder of all the depositions in that case,
- 1:07:01pretty much. And assuming that witness's depositions
- 1:07:04in that binder, along with counsel having a copy
- 1:07:08of it, you're gonna say to the witness, sir,
- 1:07:10you recall taking a deposition on this date and
- 1:07:12time, right? What you told me was the truth.
- 1:07:14You knew you were sworn under the penalty of
- 1:07:16perjury. And then you're gonna ask the court
- 1:07:18to read from their depot transcript for impeachment.
- 1:07:24And then that's how it would work. All right,
- 1:07:31so we have two final questions. Jeff Thomas asks,
- 1:07:37when is it appropriate to read into the record
- 1:07:41or ask witnesses to read this document into the
- 1:07:44record? Yeah, that's a good question. I don't
- 1:07:50know if there is a per se, a per se guideline
- 1:07:56on reading in versus having the witness read
- 1:07:59it. I kind of do it based on preference. If it's
- 1:08:02a really long narrative section, for instance,
- 1:08:04I'll have them read it to themselves, ask them
- 1:08:06afterwards. Do you finish reading? Do you understand
- 1:08:09what you read? And then ask questions. But for
- 1:08:12instance, if it's like a tight code section or
- 1:08:14maybe a small statement, I'll read it into the
- 1:08:17record. Just if I really want a good snippet
- 1:08:21of what we're talking about. So like for instance,
- 1:08:23if it's a tight vehicle code section of You know
- 1:08:29Drivers making the left -hand turn without a
- 1:08:31solid arrow having to do need to yield oncoming
- 1:08:34traffic before me in that time I'll probably
- 1:08:37just read that into the record and then ask if
- 1:08:40they understand that they're familiar with that
- 1:08:41rule then ask my questions so we have kind of
- 1:08:44a clean record of what we're talking about with
- 1:08:47the rule is that they know that rule and then
- 1:08:50that they didn't follow it. Great, and then final
- 1:08:56question from Shannon. Suspending deposition
- 1:09:00is more extreme of a remedy. At what point is
- 1:09:03it necessary? Tips to help getting a hold of
- 1:09:05the depot before it gets to that point? Yeah,
- 1:09:08great question. Yeah, that's that really is the
- 1:09:11last resort and hopefully doesn't come to that.
- 1:09:15Again, the tips are. being as patient as possible
- 1:09:21with maybe a harassing opposing counsel or an
- 1:09:24evasive witness. If it's a witness who is just
- 1:09:28being completely evasive and kind of being a
- 1:09:32weasel and not getting what you want, you kind
- 1:09:35of got to make judgment calls with them and keep,
- 1:09:38I kind of do a one, two, three technique with
- 1:09:41my questioning where I'll ask a straightforward
- 1:09:44yes or no question and. You know, they give me
- 1:09:48something completely off the wall that's not
- 1:09:50yes or no. Say, sir, it's a yes or no question.
- 1:09:52My question is this, or then evasive. And then
- 1:09:57say, sir, I appreciate that response. I really
- 1:10:00am just looking for a yes or no question or a
- 1:10:03yes or no answer or I don't know. And based on
- 1:10:08what you testified to, I'm entitled to that answer.
- 1:10:11And if they're still being evasive, You can do
- 1:10:15little other techniques where they might say
- 1:10:17yes, but XYZ to move to strike everything after
- 1:10:21yes, that kind of signals to them like I'm being
- 1:10:27evasive or I'm being difficult. Those are some
- 1:10:30like little techniques. But again, if they're
- 1:10:32being really evasive the entire time, that's
- 1:10:35not a terrible thing for you because it does
- 1:10:37make them look like not a great witness. Now,
- 1:10:41when it comes to opposing counsel and handling
- 1:10:43them, I think kind of, as I mentioned earlier,
- 1:10:46the best practice is to be polite, also be affirmative
- 1:10:51that you do know the rules of the deposition
- 1:10:53and that witness coaching is improper and that
- 1:10:56council, this cannot keep happening. You have
- 1:10:58to let me take my deposition. I don't want to
- 1:11:00go before a judge and have them read all of this
- 1:11:03improper harassing comments from you. You can
- 1:11:07say stuff like that and maybe give them like
- 1:11:09a one, two, three strikes you're out type of
- 1:11:11thing or use your best judgment. But again, I
- 1:11:15would refrain from arguing on the record as much
- 1:11:17as possible and let them know when what they're
- 1:11:21doing is improper and move on. Great. So that's
- 1:11:28all for questions today. Thank you again, Tyler,
- 1:11:31for taking the time to educate our members. And
- 1:11:33thank you so much to our audience for sharing
- 1:11:35the time with us. Have a great day, everybody.
- 1:11:37Great. Thank you. Have a good day.