Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Navigating Immigration Challenges in the Engineering Sector
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to another episode of the Engineering Influence Podcast by the American
- 0:09Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:10I'm Katharine Motley, Vice President of Tax and Workforce Policy.
- 0:14Today, I'm really pleased to be joined by Alan Perkins, who is a partner with
- 0:18Tonkon Torp LLP, and he chairs their business immigration practice.
- 0:23Alan, welcome to the podcast.
- 0:25Thanks, Katharine. So we are talking about immigration policy today because
- 0:29this is such a key issue for the engineering industry.
- 0:32We know from looking at data, for example, from the Bureau of Labor Statistics
- 0:37at the Department of Labor, that the engineering workforce has been at full
- 0:41employment for several years running now.
- 0:44We also know from our own ACEC Research Institute that over half of our member
- 0:50firms report that in the past couple of years, they have turned down work specifically
- 0:54because of workforce shortages.
- 0:56So, of course, like all other employers, engineering firms turn to American
- 1:00workers first, as they are required to do.
- 1:04But sometimes there aren't qualified Americans available.
- 1:07And so at that point, engineering firms sometimes turn to foreign nationals,
- 1:11particularly people who have studied engineering at U.S. universities.
- 1:15We also know that half of engineering master's degrees awarded by U.S.
- 1:21Universities over the past several years have been awarded to international students.
- 1:25So it's a really important part of the labor force. And so we are going to talk
- 1:30to Alan, who first was connected to ACEC by an ACEC member firm,
- 1:35when we worked together on a letter to President Biden about a year and a half
- 1:39ago, looking at different pieces of the immigration system and where some changes
- 1:45or upgrades could be made.
- 1:47So, Alan, here we are. We are, you know, a year and a half later,
- 1:50we have a new president coming, returning to the White House,
- 1:53who may have a different kind of take on immigration policy than what we've seen the last few years.
- 1:59We were interested by President Trump's comments that he made during the campaign
- 2:04about awarding green cards to any student who earns a degree from U.S. universities.
- 2:11I mean, what are your thoughts about that idea? Yeah, it sounded really nice,
- 2:17but big picture wise, it's pretty unlikely that he would be able to do that
- 2:23because it really needs Congress.
- 2:25And at least in the news, we heard that there was a lot of pushback from members
- 2:31of Congress against that idea.
- 2:33And we've got a set number of green cards that are available each year in the
- 2:38statutory law and everything's kind of set in place. So there's really not a
- 2:43way for the executive branch to do it on their own.
- 2:48So really it's going to be a question of how Congress may feel about that and
- 2:52how much he really, really is going in that direction.
- 2:57And I think a lot of what we'll talk about today is, you know,
- 3:03how much are we going to go back to Trump 1.0, the first administration?
- 3:07And I think we know there are, you know, there are new influences with this new administration.
- 3:15So you've got Elon Musk and Stephen Miller, the more restrictionist side and
- 3:21maybe the more tech and engineering friendly side.
- 3:24So we will see with time what plays out. Definitely.
- 3:30And it's interesting because, you know, we had seen coming out of the Trump
- 3:34administration, as you as you said, 1.0, some rules, proposed rules that would
- 3:39have really restricted the use of H-1B visas.
- 3:42And whereas just yesterday, the Biden administration finalized a rule trying
- 3:47to put in place, keep in place some proposals that they had to try to make the
- 3:52system work more efficiently.
- 3:54I'm curious what you think about whether some of those proposals that were finalized
- 3:59yesterday, will they, do you think they will stick around or do you think the
- 4:03incoming administration might try to go back to their ideas from 2020? Yeah.
- 4:08Yeah, that's a toughie. A lot
- 4:10of this is always tough, and I wish I had my crystal ball worked better.
- 4:14But the rule yesterday is supposed to go into effect on January 17th.
- 4:20And I need to take a better look at some of the law relating to administrative
- 4:26rules and this final rule, whether it's going to stick, whether Congress can
- 4:30do something at the beginning of the year to get rid of this rule.
- 4:34But the Biden rule, I'll call it, it has some good things and some stuff that
- 4:39actually is a little bit more on the enforcement side.
- 4:43They put more in that, you know, actually the Trump team might not be so opposed
- 4:48to in terms of making sure that certain things are compliant and enhanced,
- 4:55if you want to call it that,
- 4:57penalties for noncompliance.
- 5:00But there were a few things that are in there, like extending CAPGAP from October 1 to April 1.
- 5:08That gives more additional time for regularly processed cases.
- 5:13They codified deference, so providing deference to previous USCIS decisions
- 5:20where the facts are the same in the cases.
- 5:23But, yeah, there's more in there about inspections as well, including potential
- 5:29inspections by USCIS after a case is filed but before it's decided.
- 5:35Like, they can come in and do an inspection. So, that's interesting.
- 5:41So, there are some changes there as well.
- 5:45Specialty occupation, I, for the most part, liked the changes to the definition. Yeah.
- 5:52And one key thing they did get in there is saying that normal doesn't mean always.
- 5:58And what I mean by that is a lot of arguing the H-1B specialty occupation is
- 6:02about what's normally required by the occupation, industry, the employer.
- 6:09And under Trump 1.0, when we saw the RFE rates go up to like 60 to 80 percent
- 6:15for these cases, one of the things that they like to push back on was say,
- 6:19well, this isn't a normal requirement because you don't always require it.
- 6:24So this regulation says, you know what, normal means what it normally means, which isn't always.
- 6:30And so it's nice to see that in there. But some of the themes of Trump last
- 6:36administration proposed regulations, could they come back?
- 6:40Yeah, it's possible, for sure. And again, this is the Musk versus Miller,
- 6:46if you want to call it that, the restrictionist versus more employer-friendly.
- 6:50We'll wait to see how it plays out. But one of the things
- 6:53that I think worries me most that we saw right at the end in December 2020 was
- 7:00a regulation that I believe was set aside that increased the levels for the
- 7:06prevailing wage government survey that is most often used for these cases,
- 7:11and it was significant increase across the board,
- 7:16that could really impact employers.
- 7:20The leveling would go up markedly under that prior regulation.
- 7:25So that's one of the ones that's super concerning to me.
- 7:29And so does that mean that an employer who hires someone using an H-1B visa
- 7:34would have to pay higher wages to those people. Yeah.
- 7:39So it's a bit detailed, but there's also a way to use under the existing regulations
- 7:46and even under that proposal to use private surveys.
- 7:50So something like Radford or whatever, these private surveys that meet government requirements.
- 7:59So there was always that possibility that you might be able to reach out that way.
- 8:02But the OES wage survey published by Department of Labor is the survey used,
- 8:09you know, 95% of the time, it seems.
- 8:12And that would have been a significant increase and really would have been a
- 8:19challenge for employers because you do as an employer have to pay the greater
- 8:23of the prevailing wage, in this case,
- 8:26looking at the OES wage survey,
- 8:28or the actual wage, which is the internal wage paid to similarly situated workers.
- 8:34So that's kind of a biggie.
- 8:38Another is tying wage to the H-1B lottery.
- 8:42That's one of the other themes that has been discussed and looked at back then.
- 8:48And that one's problematic as well, just philosophically. the idea right now
- 8:54is most folks feel that the law says, you know, this should be random.
- 9:01This is, you know, there's nothing that says this in the statute about these
- 9:06selections going that way.
- 9:08And their argument is, well, we have the room to do it within the statute.
- 9:13But the concept is what's most concerning if they move that way and really saying,
- 9:20well, the people who are paid the most are going to be in the front of the line kind of thing.
- 9:25And, you know, engineers are probably in there somewhere, but they're not the
- 9:28highest and they're certainly not the lowest.
- 9:31And you can imagine there are a lot of worthy H-1B specialty occupation professionals
- 9:36that may be in the lower ends of these occupations.
- 9:40So that's one of the ones that concerns me as well, for sure.
- 9:47And then finally, just whether it's in a regulation or not, the increased scrutiny
- 9:53of the specialty occupation argument, I think we're going to see it come through.
- 9:59So, you know, you mentioned whether it's in a regulation or not,
- 10:02and we definitely saw in the last Trump administration, you referred a moment
- 10:08ago to the requests for evidence, the RFEs, some of the longer processing times,
- 10:14sort of tools that the administration has at its disposal.
- 10:19Outside of a regulatory process, without having to go through a regulatory process.
- 10:23And I'm really intrigued by the contrast you're drawing between the more restrictionist
- 10:29members of the administration team and the more sort of tech side of the administration
- 10:35team who might be more open.
- 10:36And I'm interested to see whether the administration goes back to that tightening
- 10:43of requiring so much more information for what used to be pretty standard renewals of an H1PV.
- 10:49Do you think we might see some of that again? We certainly might.
- 10:53And it just depends on how this all plays out. But Trump 1.0 definitely,
- 10:59as those of us who are in the game remember, was not business friendly with
- 11:05respect to business immigration.
- 11:07And it's quite possible we could head back that direction for sure and see really
- 11:14increased request for evidence RFE rates.
- 11:18I think before they were in the 60 to 80 percent at their height.
- 11:22It seemed like every time you filed an H-1B petition, even an extension,
- 11:27you just expected to get pushback and requests for additional information,
- 11:33which took a lot more time and cost employers a lot more money.
- 11:39The RFE rates have been far lower under the Biden administration.
- 11:43So there really could be some pushback and lengthens processing times,
- 11:49makes the process more difficult.
- 11:51And for restrictionists, they feel that that's a success in terms of reducing
- 11:58the amount of inbound immigration.
- 12:01It is an interesting idea, though, because, you know, at the same time,
- 12:05we have data that shows that not enough students are studying engineering.
- 12:09And as I mentioned earlier, there are a lot of people who come from other countries
- 12:13to study at U.S. universities.
- 12:15And I know our members, one of our members some years ago said to me,
- 12:20you know, it doesn't make any sense to educate someone here and then send them
- 12:24home to work for our competitors.
- 12:26When if they wish to stay, that's obviously a choice, not a not a requirement.
- 12:30But if someone wants to stay and contribute to the U.S.
- 12:33Economy and a U.S. employer, why are we sending them home to contribute to our competitors?
- 12:39And I always thought that was a really interesting perspective. Yeah, yeah.
- 12:44You'd think we'd want the best and brightest and the folks who are educated
- 12:47here to be able to stay if they want.
- 12:51And like you said, it's very tight labor market. And I think especially with
- 12:57the infrastructure bill, Inflation Reduction Act, there's just a lot going on
- 13:02and the need for engineers has increased considerably.
- 13:06So the workers have to come from somewhere. Yeah.
- 13:09That's right. And as I often tell people, you know, it takes a long time to
- 13:13make an engineer. You don't educate, train an engineer in a year or two.
- 13:17It's a long process because of the immense responsibilities that they have when
- 13:23it comes to designing our infrastructure, when they're designing the bridges
- 13:27that we all drive across and the water systems we rely on, energy systems.
- 13:32You know, we are looking to them to have a high level of expertise.
- 13:36And so it is something that requires a lot of education and training.
- 13:42Yeah. And, you know, a lot after the education, the training to get that license
- 13:47to be an engineering training.
- 13:49And there's just a lot that goes into it that may start when folks are on their
- 13:54OPT or STEM OPT employment authorization and then they hope to be able to continue. now?
- 14:00Absolutely. So I know that at ACEC, we are going to be making sure our members
- 14:06are well aware of what's happening, both on the legislative front and on the regulatory front.
- 14:11You referenced earlier that Congress will have, each time an administration
- 14:16ends, they have the opportunity to kind of look back for a certain period of time at regulation.
- 14:20So we'll see whether the rule that was finalized yesterday will be included
- 14:26in that Congressional Review Act process or not. So we will make sure that our
- 14:31members are well aware of everything that's going on here in D.C.
- 14:35But from your perspective, working directly with employers, what do you think
- 14:39engineering firms need to do to kind of be ready for possible changes in this whole process?
- 14:45Yeah, there's just going to be a lot going on. And we expect that there are
- 14:50going to be executive orders maybe on January 20th that just start coming out.
- 14:56So that's what we're expecting. We're expecting that we'll be sending a lot
- 15:01of alerts out to clients to let them know about these changes.
- 15:05But I think folks should have regular strategy check-ins with their immigration
- 15:12counsel and stay up to date on alerts that way.
- 15:17But also look at each case individually in terms of what can be done.
- 15:23Most important, though, that we're hearing a lot right now is advising on maybe
- 15:29international travel right now is something that you should be thinking about holding back on,
- 15:36especially right around the inauguration or immediately thereafter.
- 15:40So there may be travel bans for specific citizens of specific countries.
- 15:46And the last thing we would want is for people to be outside the country.
- 15:50And then you get that notice where 48 hours from now, citizens of X,
- 15:55Y, and Z countries cannot enter the United States.
- 15:59So that's a possibility. So being aware of international travel,
- 16:04plus there could be changes coming very soon with respect to how visa applications are handled.
- 16:11And folks are used to the post-COVID environment and things have been a whole
- 16:17lot nicer and gotten more back to routine and normal.
- 16:20But I expect that this administration may go back to policies like requiring
- 16:29interviews for each visa applicant,
- 16:32whereas the Biden administration has relied more on electronic review of extensions
- 16:41or renewals, I should say,
- 16:43of visas and permitted what they sometimes call a dropbox procedure that avoids an interview.
- 16:50You unless they call you in separately.
- 16:53So those kinds of niceties might be going away, and we would likely see increased
- 17:01wait times for visa appointments, potential increased scrutiny.
- 17:08So folks might be stuck abroad waiting for their visas to come through for a longer time.
- 17:14There's something called administrative processing that they aren't going to
- 17:18approve you right away. You go into limbo land.
- 17:21And so there may be an increase in administrative processing as well.
- 17:26So those things for international travel, applying for visas, more immediately,
- 17:33a reminder to your non-citizen employees to be sure to carry evidence of their
- 17:39status in the United States, their legal status.
- 17:43So it's not just the passport and visa.
- 17:46A lot of people think it's the visa stamp and the passport.
- 17:49But there is other documentation that really definitively says what your legal
- 17:55status is and how long you stay. Most often, that's the form I-94 that's issued by Homeland Security.
- 18:01So it's important that folks carry that documentation with them as we hear about
- 18:08mass deportations that are coming.
- 18:13And also increased employer I-9 tune-ups might be in order.
- 18:23So there might be more enforcement coming. I have heard that ICE might be gearing up for that.
- 18:30So not only the mass deportations, but also increases in employer enforcement
- 18:37may be coming as well. So doing an I-9 tune-up is probably a good thing.
- 18:44So yeah, those are my immediate tips for what may be coming.
- 18:49But thinking well ahead and getting a game plan for folks and a strategy for
- 18:56each employee, extending people who are already here as early as possible and
- 19:02not waiting to the last minute.
- 19:03Like for an H-1B, you can apply up to six months in advance.
- 19:08So maybe starting a couple months earlier than that and making sure the case
- 19:14is filed as early as possible is really a prudent thing to do.
- 19:19And starting green card processes maybe earlier than employers would have thought of before.
- 19:26Because usually it's a big commitment, time and money-wise on the part of employers.
- 19:32And so they want to make sure that there's a good fit with the employee a lot of times.
- 19:37But given the increased processing intents we're already seeing with DOL,
- 19:43coupled with what we know the
- 19:45administration is saying, like requiring workers to go back to the office.
- 19:51Things like DOL funding coming from Congress.
- 19:56Increased demand for DOL processing, we could see additional slowdown on the
- 20:03DOL side as well with respect to labor certifications for green card applications. expectations.
- 20:08So thinking about earlier starting processes is probably prudent.
- 20:15So it sounds like the best thing that employers can do right now is make sure
- 20:20they check in with their immigration lawyers and see kind of where they stand with their workforce.
- 20:25And as you said, with their firm generally in terms of those potential audits.
- 20:30Yeah. And then next year, as the changes come through.
- 20:34They could be pretty fast and furious, January, February, but they may just keep coming regularly.
- 20:42So getting those updates will be important.
- 20:45Well, this will definitely be a time with a lot of activity and a lot for firms to think about.
- 20:51So Ellen, thank you so much for joining us today and for sharing your expertise
- 20:55on this really important subject. Yeah, thanks, Catherine.
- 20:59So this has been another episode of the Engineering Influence Podcast.
- 21:02Thank you for joining us and we hope that you will be sure to subscribe to our
- 21:06channels. We'll look forward to talking with you next time.