Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use Office Pet Peeves to Build Trust
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I've been thinking about something that bugs me every single day at our open-office layout — the sound of someone aggressively crunching ice from their water bottle. Luna: Oh, the ice cruncher. Right up there with the person who eats an apple like they're punishing it. Lucas: Exactly. Now, conventional wisdom says you keep those annoyances to yourself. Don't be the complainer. But I came across a study from last year in the Journal of Organizational Behavior that suggests the opposite — sharing small pet peeves can actually build trust with your colleagues. Luna: Wait — so complaining about the loud typist next door makes people like you more? That feels risky. Lucas: Counterintuitive, right? The study looked at 400 knowledge workers across tech and consulting firms. They found that coworkers who admitted minor annoyances — within reason — reported 23 percent higher mutual trust scores than those who kept a completely professional, filter-on facade. Luna: Twenty-three percent — that's not nothing. What's the mechanism? How does griping about the broken Keurig make someone trust you? Lucas: The researchers point to what's called 'benign violation theory.' It's the same reason we laugh at someone tripping on a sidewalk — the brain categorizes a small breach of the expected as non-threatening. When you say, 'Ugh, the printer always jams on page three,' you're signaling, 'I'm not performing for you. I'm real.' And that vulnerability invites reciprocity. Luna: So it's a kind of low-stakes disclosure. Like the office version of admitting you still watch The Office reruns. Lucas: Exactly. But the key word is 'benign.' If your pet peeve veers into personal criticism — 'I hate how Sarah clears her throat' — that's no longer benign. It's a violation without the lightness. The study found that complaints about shared systems, physical environment, or universal workplace quirks built trust. Complaints about specific people eroded it. Luna: That makes sense. I've definitely had moments where a teammate vented about the slow VPN and I felt closer to them. But I've also been on the receiving end of a complaint about a colleague's communication style and just felt awkward. Lucas: Right. So the boundary is: is this a 'we' problem or a 'they' problem? The shared thermostat, the coffee that tastes like ash, the meeting that could have been an email — those unite. The 'that person always interrupts me' — that divides. Luna: And timing matters too. I had a friend at a startup who tried this too aggressively. She'd open every one-on-one with a complaint — 'Ugh, the Slack notifications are out of control' — and it quickly made her seem negative overall. She lost credibility. Lucas: That's a great caution. The study also tracked frequency. Once per interaction — maybe twice — any more and the perception flips from 'relatable' to 'drain.' There's a sweet spot. You want to signal authenticity, not chronic dissatisfaction. Luna: So what's the practical playbook? Let's say I want to try this tomorrow. I'm in a stand-up with my team. What do I do? Lucas: I'd suggest a three-question litmus test before you speak. First: is this annoyance about a thing or a person? If it's a person, stop. Second: is it low stakes? The broken mug warmer is fine. The fact that the project timeline is slipping — not a pet peeve, that's a real issue to escalate. Third: can I say it with a slight smile or a shrug? If you're genuinely angry, it won't land as benign. Luna: I like that. 'Can I say it with a shrug?' That's a good gut check. I'd add one more: is this something that at least two other people probably also notice? Shared annoyances bond; niche ones isolate. Lucas: Yes. The communal nature is what builds the trust. You're essentially saying, 'We're in the same boat.' And that's powerful in a workplace where everyone is trying to project competence and control. Luna: It reminds me of something I read about the most effective teams at Pixar. They have this culture of 'plussing' — building on ideas without judgment. But they also have a tradition of griping together about the cafeteria food. It's a release valve that reminds everyone they're human. Lucas: Exactly. And that kind of informal bonding is hard to replicate in fully remote settings. You lose the water-cooler moments. So if you're remote, you have to be more intentional. Maybe a dedicated Slack channel called '#small-annoyances' or starting a video call with, 'Okay, before we dive in, what's one tiny thing that bugged you this morning?' Luna: That's a great idea. I've seen teams do 'rose, thorn, bud' check-ins, but the thorn is usually a real problem. A 'pet peeve' check-in would be lighter — and maybe more bonding because it's so trivial. Lucas: Right. And the beauty is, it's low risk. If you try it and no one bites, you're just the person who mentioned something silly. You haven't damaged anything. But if it catches on, you've created a small trust ritual. Luna: I wonder if there's a generational angle. I've noticed younger colleagues are more open about sharing quirks and annoyances. They'll post memes about slow Wi-Fi in the team chat. Older colleagues might see that as unprofessional. Lucas: That's a real tension. The study didn't break out age, but I'd guess the effect holds across generations if the content is right. The older worker might bond over the squeaky office chair instead of the Wi-Fi. The key is calibrating to your audience. Luna: So the meta-skill here is reading the room — knowing what's 'benign' in your specific culture. In a law firm, admitting you can't stand the binder system might be too close to work criticism. In a design agency, it might be exactly right. Lucas: Exactly. And you can test with a tiny one. Mention the temperature. 'Is it just me or is the AC freezing?' If people nod and smile, you've got your opening. If they look at you like you're odd, you pull back. Luna: I'm going to try this. I have a one-on-one later with a teammate I'm still building rapport with. I might lead with a shared gripe about the coffee machine. Lucas: That's a smart move. And if it helps you think through career decisions like that, you know, we keep this show ad-free because of listeners who find value in it. If today's episode was worth a coffee to you, that's the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a way to keep it going. Luna: Yeah, it's a small way to support something you use. And we really appreciate it. Lucas: So to wrap the main thread — using pet peeves to build trust is about being strategically human. You don't need to be the perfectly polished professional. A little shared annoyance, delivered right, can make you more approachable and more trusted. Luna: I think the biggest takeaway for me is that it's not about complaining more — it's about complaining smarter. Pick your spots, keep it light, and make sure it's a 'we' thing. Lucas: Exactly. And next time you hear someone crunching ice, maybe just smile and say, 'You know, that sound is my kryptonite.' You might make a friend. Luna: Or an enemy, depending on how attached they are to their ice. But I'll take the risk. Lucas: That's the spirit. Thanks for the conversation, Luna. Luna: Always a pleasure.