Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Jodi Arias - (Chapter 1)
Transcript
- 0:00So Berto. For the past fourteen years of this podcast, almost fifteen people
- 0:05have been asking us to cover the case of Jodi Arias. Yeah, every
- 0:11couple months, someone would email or comment saying, please do a psychology of
- 0:16Jodi Arias, Please please cover this case. And before a few months ago,
- 0:22when I started looking into the Casey Anthony story, I would have had
- 0:26really just no knowledge at all. Maybe i'd kind of did at one point,
- 0:30but certainly not at the front of my mind. In fact, when
- 0:33you first asked me about it a few weeks ago, because I had heard
- 0:36about it and I had watched something about it, but I first I got
- 0:38confused, and I was like, oh, yeah, she killed her kids.
- 0:41And then on the drive home, I was like, wait a minute,
- 0:43no, that's that other thing. Yeah. I started to go down
- 0:47a rabbit hole. And at first I thought, well, how about I
- 0:51just watch one documentary, right, I'll just watch one one hour documentary.
- 0:57The case can't be that complicated review. And at first, you know,
- 1:00I'm taking my notes and thinking about things and pulling things over as I do.
- 1:04And then I started to just obsess on this case and I found and
- 1:11for those of you who know the case and we're following the trial in twenty
- 1:15thirteen. You know, how fascinating how many twists and turns there are in
- 1:21this case, not only just the murder itself, the nature of the crime,
- 1:23the trial, the prosecutor, Jodiariis Arius's behavior, people around her.
- 1:30It just so many different details that are just mind blowing. I mean,
- 1:34if you had ten percent of the details of this case, it would still
- 1:40be a fascinating story. So I had all this free time this week.
- 1:45I was gonna get some chores done. I was maybe going to maybe see
- 1:49a movie. But I have just been for literally sixteen hours a day.
- 1:56This is all I've been doing. Late at night one or the more.
- 2:00I'm watching, you know, because the trial was recorded, like the Depth
- 2:02Herd trial, and it's all on YouTube. And there's so many things that
- 2:08happened in this trial. And it was long too. I mean, Jody
- 2:13Arius herself is on the stand for eighteen days. Eighteen days sees on the
- 2:17stand, and there's so many things that happened, and so many details and
- 2:23so many weird aspects. And so let's get into it. What do you
- 2:27say, Let's do it. This is the Psychology and Seattle Podcasting your host,
- 2:30doctor Kirk Conda, and I've been obsessed with the Jodi Arius case.
- 2:34Who are you brut? My name is and I raise and train transcendental meditating
- 2:40menphisis. So this case has so much to say about psychology as well.
- 2:46The Casey Anthony story, which we reviewed recently, had some things to say
- 2:50about psychology, but not nearly as much as this case. There's lots of
- 2:53data to pour over. The psychological evaluations and testimony about her at the trial,
- 3:00her behavior during the investigation and during the trial, all recorded all on
- 3:06YouTube, and the interviews. Yeah yeah, So in a nutshell for those
- 3:10who don't know, just kind of people who may have forgotten some of the
- 3:14details, I'm going to run through a semi quick summary of what happened in
- 3:19this case. It's a little long, but because there's a lot of little
- 3:23details. But I'm guessing this these episodes, Burdo, are going to be
- 3:27several episodes long. You and I tend to talk at length anyway, and
- 3:31so just kind of sit back and get ready for a multi part I'm just
- 3:36taking a guess. So, in a nutshell, Jody Arius and Travis Alexander
- 3:42had had an intense dating relationship that reportedly was only about five months long,
- 3:49where they were public with their relationship, the detense part, the official part,
- 3:55the official part right where he was not officially dating other people. He
- 4:00was seen with his friends with her, you know, because later on he
- 4:06would see her secretly or away from his friends, that kind of thing.
- 4:11But so during this relationship, very intense, lots of love, lots of
- 4:15a testament of love, lots of lust, lots of sexual attraction, lots
- 4:19of togetherness. Both very much in love with each other. They are in
- 4:25their late twenties ish around I think she's around twenty six, he's twenty nine
- 4:29or something around there. Yeah, Jody became obsessed with Travis. She was
- 4:34jealous while she was with him. She hacked into his phone, hacked into
- 4:41his email, hacked into his Facebook. And this is before she started stalking
- 4:46him, you know, this is just this is when they were together and
- 4:48he's not dating anyone else. She would claim that he cheated on her,
- 4:53but that claim could be lumped into a lot of things that she claimed.
- 4:58And during the trial, his friends told him that they were concerned about her
- 5:02obsessiveness. And we'll get into the details. But eventually the friends tell him,
- 5:09look, you shouldn't be with her, and that prompted Travis to begin
- 5:15to think about leaving her. And then a couple months later he did actually
- 5:17break up with her and he moved on, but she still held on.
- 5:20She stalked him, she begged to see him. He would most of the
- 5:25time push back, but some of the times would give in and they would
- 5:28see each other and they would have sex, or they would have phone sex
- 5:30or something. And this was a tumultuous time, which we'll go into detail
- 5:33later. Then he is planning on going to Mexico, potentially with another woman,
- 5:39and she knew about this. He told her about it. He was
- 5:42open about it, and she became enraged. She seemingly around this time,
- 5:46or maybe before this time, but this situation really solidified it. She seemingly
- 5:53allegedly made a plan to kill him at this point, and the plan involved
- 5:57making it seem like she never even went to his town because he didn't live
- 6:00in the same state, even she lived in California. She lived in California,
- 6:03he lived in Arizona, Yea. And so it was probably a relief
- 6:06for him, right because it went from this constant kind of worry and then
- 6:11okay, now she's far right. And she had originally moved to Arizona to
- 6:17be with him because after they broke up, because she wanted to be near
- 6:20him and presumably stock him more easily. But then she moved back to California.
- 6:26And then at this point she made a plan to kill him and make
- 6:30it seem like she never even went to Arizona. She apparently convinced him to
- 6:36see her and for him to allow her to come over. She did one
- 6:41day she had and we'll get into the premeditation and the plan that she had
- 6:46for an alibi and all this stuff. And she goes to his house on
- 6:48June fourth, two thousand and eight. They had sex, They took pictures.
- 6:53He takes a shower, she took She takes pictures of him in the
- 6:57shower. She attacked him, and she accidentally took a few pictures with the
- 7:01camera, one of which is a seemingly a clear indication of her feet and
- 7:08the blood and his body. She apparently stabbed him twenty seven maybe more times.
- 7:14He crawled away outside the bathroom. She seemingly got on top of him
- 7:18and slid his throat and deeply, and you know from ear to ear.
- 7:23Yeah, they were saying like he was nearly decapitated. Yeah. And then,
- 7:27by the way, we're going to get in some details, not a
- 7:30lot, but occasionally. And then she shot him in the head, and
- 7:33she dragged his body back into the shower, stuffed him in the shower,
- 7:36and then quickly attempted to clean up the entire house. There was blood everywhere
- 7:42because she was attacking him throughout the throughout. Basically, I think he lives
- 7:46in a house with two other roommates at least, and he lived in the
- 7:49master bedroom and it had a master bathroom, and so they were in that
- 7:54area of the house and there was blood all of the bedroom and master master
- 7:59bedroom, Master bad. She left and went to her her current boyfriend's place,
- 8:05and acted like nothing happened. A few days later, friends were worried.
- 8:09They basically broke into his bedroom and found the body. There was a
- 8:13police investigation and they immediately started questioning her. She acted in a very odd
- 8:20banner and the police. When the police were talking to her, and when
- 8:24the press were talking to her, she acted very nice, very sweet,
- 8:28very odd. She lied several times. There was a trial, lots of
- 8:33testimony about PTSD and memory and borderline abuse, pedophilia, sex, etc.
- 8:39And like I said earlier, she testified on the stand for eighteen days,
- 8:41And that's just some of the details of the trial, which of which there
- 8:45are many, And it was highly unusual for her to testify, let alone
- 8:48for that long, right, But she did claim self defense, and she
- 8:54did claim that he was abusive, which gave her reasons to believe that she
- 8:58needed to defend herself and also gave her, according to her, the trauma
- 9:05that led to her not remembering, you know, some of the events.
- 9:09And in order to make that case, she's the only one that can provide
- 9:13any kind of witness to that, So otherwise it would be a hard defense.
- 9:18I'm guessing, you know what I mean. Yeah. The Associated Press
- 9:22reported that the case was a quote unquote circus and a runaway train. The
- 9:26case grew into a worldwide sensation as thousands followed the trial via a live unedited
- 9:33web feed. Thinking back, Brot, I mean, in twenty thirteen,
- 9:39might this have been the first big internet trial. It's a good question,
- 9:43because that is that is a big deal. Like live stream. You know,
- 9:48OJ was live, but it was on TV TV, it was on
- 9:52what it was CNN or something probably I don't know, court TV on cable
- 9:56or something. Question, but it was live and it was a preview of
- 10:00things to come. But yeah, it was interesting that that's like live stream
- 10:03on the internet, right, Yeah, And it really just raises this question
- 10:07as to whether or not that's a good thing. I mean, during the
- 10:11depth heard trial, there were all sorts of questions from people including me,
- 10:15It's like, why does this have to be public? But what the courts
- 10:20and what the judge ultimately said in saying that this will be allowed to be
- 10:24televised is that in a high profile case, there's a greater risk of the
- 10:30public believing things that aren't true about what happened behind closed doors, and so
- 10:35it's better to just show everyone what happened. Paul shenanigans because Number one really
- 10:43Jodiarius, the well known celebrity public figure. President Jody Arius, and number
- 10:48two talk about making it hard for another for a retrial or if there is
- 10:54an appeal, you know, like any anytime you need more jurors, Like
- 10:58who's not going to have known about it in all the details? Yeah,
- 11:01but I kind of get it because in a democracy leaning society, openness of
- 11:09information usually is better than doing things behind closed doors. Not in all cases,
- 11:15of course, But the challenge is that as a society we should be
- 11:20trying to advocate and really changing a culture such that publication of these details doesn't
- 11:26harm any individuals, like you know, people involved or bullied online. And
- 11:31I think it's fine if you if you know, you want to record it,
- 11:35make it accessible through the library system or whatever. I just think that
- 11:37making it like a big public live stream spectacle is grotesque. But that's my
- 11:43opinion. Well why what's grotesque about it? Well, I mean, first
- 11:46of all, it's I feel it's naive to think that a large percentage of
- 11:52the viewers aren't watching it for entertainment purpose, And I just I feel that
- 11:58that's gross, Like that's gross that that would be entertainment. And look,
- 12:01I was a participant in the OJ watching like I watched that trial. I
- 12:03don't I wouldn't describe what I was doing as entertainment. It was more like
- 12:07self flagellation for sure, But I wish it wouldn't have been something I could
- 12:11have watched. It had no bearing in my life. All it did was
- 12:15damage me. All it did was hurt me. I don't think the public
- 12:18good is served by broadcasting things like this live where it's just literally giving people
- 12:22like a salacious look into like horrible, horrible human behavior. Then why are
- 12:28we talking about it in this podcast because we have a channel about psychology and
- 12:31this is like righte with psychology, it's just we're not But that's my point.
- 12:35It's like, if you can transform this as an opportunity into bad or
- 12:41good, then that is dependent on the content providers and the audience. So
- 12:48like, for instance, with the Depth Herd trial, you know, if
- 12:50you just would have asked me, do you think it's a public good that
- 12:54we film and live stream the Depth Herd trial, and I guess also the
- 13:00Jody Aris trou I would initially say, no, what what would be the
- 13:03point in that? There's not it's not necessary. But when I watched the
- 13:07Depth Herd trial and now I guess watching the Jody Arius trial, it gives
- 13:11me and others a chance to highlight what we can learn from it. And
- 13:16I think there's a lot to be learned from both trials. I agree.
- 13:18I'm simply stating that, and like I said, so let's make it available.
- 13:22I think it's the spectacle that I'm opposing, not the fact that the
- 13:26data is available. It's like, for example, with with Senate here in
- 13:30Congress hearings, I'm all for it, like absolutely, broadcast the heck out
- 13:33of that right. The public needs to know that is in the public interest
- 13:37interest. I guess I would need to hear more good reasons why private individual's
- 13:41trial and families trial is so important that everyone must see it live streamed on
- 13:46the internet. Yeah. I think a greater argument could be made about the
- 13:50depth herd trial. I mean that was a civil case. Yeah, there
- 13:52was no crime fair enough, whereas this one. You're like, well,
- 13:56I mean you have someone that ultimately was found guilty of first degree murder,
- 14:03and does this person deserve that kind of dignity or privacy? And you could
- 14:09probably say not necessarily. There is something that I actually don't think is helpful.
- 14:13Yeah, absolutely, Yeah, I said, I tend to agree.
- 14:16But when I hear lawyers and judges advocate for it being public, along with
- 14:24a lot of other things like the hearings or the actions of Congress badge cams,
- 14:30it's like, Okay, do we as a public misinterpret or use the
- 14:35data to harm other people? Yes, but that doesn't necessarily mean we become
- 14:41an information blocking state, do you know what I mean? But you know,
- 14:46and we'll get into that later. In terms of why was this case
- 14:50so salacious and so interesting? Why is it so interesting to me? I
- 14:54mean, did you find it really interesting? Yes, fascinating, compelling,
- 14:56bizarre, all of the above. Yeah, And there's a lot of theories
- 15:01that we'll get into. Is to I think why that is for us?
- 15:05The Toronto Star wrote that with its mix of jealousy, So they're talking about
- 15:11the case with its mix of jealousy, religion, murder, and sex.
- 15:13The Jodi Arias case shows what happens when the justice systems becomes entertainment. Also,
- 15:20she was the most hated woman in America around the same time that Casey
- 15:24Anthony was the most and Jody was convicted and sentenced to life in prison and
- 15:33she is still there. So Berto, I want to pause there and say
- 15:39that the rest of this episode is just going to be for patrons of the
- 15:43podcast. This isn't what I usually do with our episodes, but I feel
- 15:46like if my efforts and sometimes I gauge whether or not something should be a
- 15:52deep dive by how much effort I put into it. Sure, and this
- 15:56is one of those episodes where I put a lot of effort into it,
- 16:00and I just wondered if I would, you know, if I could reward
- 16:03the patrons for actually being a patron, we could not be doing any of
- 16:07this stuff. Bert, the microphone that you're speaking into, the microphone,
- 16:11I'm speaking into, the computer screen I'm using here, so many the chair
- 16:15you're sitting in, so many things involved in this podcast. The visual I
- 16:21have is everything you just alluded to our actual patrons, Like there's a little
- 16:23patron here I'm talking into and I mean some of our long term patrons have
- 16:29been long enough that you could actually attribute that microphone to one one particular patron.
- 16:33It's probably like two or three that about that chair. But so yeah,
- 16:38the rest, and I'm this is going to be a multipart or so
- 16:41I think what I'm gonna do is every part will have a free portion that
- 16:45will intro with and then we'll launch into the rest. So if you want
- 16:48to listen to this episode, I'm gonna in this episode at least I've been
- 16:52to start the chronology of everything, which is pretty interesting. I'm gonna go
- 16:56through Jody Arius's childhood, a little bit of Travis's child it as well,
- 17:00and then go through the events, the relationship, the love bombing, the
- 17:06stocking, the actual murder. And so if you want to hear it,
- 17:11become a patron of the podcast. But I go on to patreon dot com
- 17:14then you can hear this episode and hundreds of other of our best episodes of
- 17:18all time. Why should people become patrons Brno, they should do it because
- 17:23the information contained within the patron world is magical, mystical, never before seen
- 17:29in the history of humanity. And we have episodes too. Plus they can
- 17:34be part of supporting this, which is great. Like I am a patron
- 17:37of several things, like my own things that I follow, and it feels
- 17:41great because I know that I'm I like their content and I'm a little part
- 17:47of making that content survive. So you know, you get this personal reward
- 17:51of feeling like you're helping the thing you like survive. Yeah, that's great.
- 17:55When I become a patron of things or contribute to them directly. You
- 18:00know, they're usually small outfits that I know exactly where the money is going,
- 18:04right, you know, when you give money to NPR or something and
- 18:08I'm not saying you shouldn't, but you know it's a large organization. You
- 18:11don't know exactly well. When you give money to us, it literally is
- 18:15directly paying my bills. That's exactly where it's going. It is paying my
- 18:21bills so that I don't have to get another job, right, I don't
- 18:25have to work at the university anymore. And that's the thing you feel like.
- 18:27It's similar to when you kickstart a thing that you really care passionately about
- 18:33that you're like, I want this to succeed, and anything I can do
- 18:36to help to succeed, let's do it. Yeah. Yeah, So if
- 18:41that doesn't convince you, then nothing else will. And take care of yourself
- 18:45because you deserve it.