Latest / Surrounded / 1 Israeli vs 20 Pro-Palestine (ft. Rudy Rochman) | Surrounded
Transcript
- 0:00If historical connection and indigeneity alone
- 0:03trumps whatever people are already there,
- 0:05then all modern people,
- 0:06but that's what you're saying I'm saying it trumps
- 0:09the idea that we're colonizers and foreign people.
- 0:11ICE agents right now are currently being trained by the
- 0:13IOF on the tactics to use against civilian populations.
- 0:16They might have different uniforms,
- 0:18but the ideology is exactly the same.
- 0:20We always talk about the two solutions.
- 0:21One's the solution to,
- 0:22but most of the Israelis,
- 0:23they're looking for a third solution,
- 0:24which is ethnic cleansing,
- 0:26I don't getting everyone out of here.
- 0:27That's what they want to do.
- 0:29It's been more than 2 years since October 7th when Hamas attacked Israel,
- 0:34killing over 1200 innocent people and taking hundreds of hostages.
- 0:38The war that followed has devastated Gaza,
- 0:40killing over 70,000 Palestinians.
- 0:43Peace now rests on a ceasefire that many believe will not hold.
- 0:48So where do we go from here?
- 0:49From Jubilee Media this is Surrounded where one
- 0:52brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:55I'm your host John Regalado,
- 0:56and today we are facing the divide head on.
- 0:59I'm here in the center with our featured guest
- 1:01Rudy.
- 1:02How are you doing?
- 1:03I'm good.
- 1:03How are you?
- 1:04I'm good,
- 1:05thanks for being here.
- 1:06Are you ready to jump into the debates?
- 1:07Always ready.
- 1:08All right,
- 1:09debaters,
- 1:09are we ready to begin?
- 1:11All right,
- 1:11let's get into it.
- 1:13I'm Rudy Rochman.
- 1:13I'm a Jewish and Israel rights activist,
- 1:15and today I'm surrounded by 20 pro-Palestinian activists
- 1:18who completely disagree with me.
- 1:20My first surrounding claim is that Israel is not committing apartheid or genocide.
- 1:27All right,
- 1:27if you would like to be the first debater,
- 1:29please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:34How's it going?
- 1:35Good.
- 1:35How are you?
- 1:36So,
- 1:37before I start,
- 1:38I want to lay some groundwork.
- 1:40I want to start with a working definition of genocide,
- 1:43some legal and historical examples,
- 1:45and then I want to demonstrate Israel's intent,
- 1:47their policies of genocide,
- 1:49and then the results.
- 1:51So in terms of a working definition of genocide,
- 1:53it would be to destroy it with the intent to destroy a group in whole or in part.
- 1:57Some historical illegal analogies that I think are analogous to the case of Gaza
- 2:02is the case in Bosnia,
- 2:03where the Bosnian Serb army killed 8000 men and boys.
- 2:07This was ruled to be a genocide by the ICJ.
- 2:10Another 30,000 women and children
- 2:12were forced to flee.
- 2:14This was done so to facilitate an ethnic cleansing,
- 2:16so murder under the laws of war
- 2:18to,
- 2:19uh,
- 2:19motivate a population to be ethnically cleansed.
- 2:22In terms of Israel's intent,
- 2:23Benjamin Netanyahu said it,
- 2:25uh,
- 2:25plainly and clearly.
- 2:26Last year,
- 2:27under testimony with the Foreign Affairs Committee of the Knesset,
- 2:30he said,
- 2:30we're destroying more and more houses.
- 2:33Sooner or later they'll have nothing to go back,
- 2:35uh,
- 2:35to go back to.
- 2:36Our problem right now is just finding a country that's going to take,
- 2:40uh,
- 2:40the Palestinian refugees.
- 2:41So
- 2:42they're murdering Palestinians in Gaza en masse
- 2:45to attempt to,
- 2:46uh,
- 2:47bring about the demise of the Gaza population,
- 2:50create conditions unfit for human
- 2:52existence by decimating civilian infrastructure.
- 2:55Uh,
- 2:55etc.
- 2:55Now,
- 2:56in terms of a policy,
- 2:57we can look to the Where's Daddy program,
- 3:00uh,
- 3:00that's being used by Israeli intelligence through a Lavender AI system where
- 3:05they spot
- 3:06what they suspect to be low-level Hamas operatives,
- 3:09bomb them when they're at home with their family.
- 3:11So you can't claim Hamas is using
- 3:13Palestinians as human shields when most
- 3:15of what Israel's actually doing is targeting
- 3:17who they suspect to be low-level Hamas operatives when they're with their family.
- 3:21This is backed up by the demographic data.
- 3:24pointed to the fact that over 1300 families' bloodlines have been wiped out in Gaza.
- 3:31Sometimes as much as 4 generations of Palestinian families are being wiped out,
- 3:35sometimes as large as 14 members of a Palestinian family is being wiped out.
- 3:38So,
- 3:39again,
- 3:39we have policy,
- 3:40and then we look to the effects.
- 3:4265 doctors wrote in The New York Times in a guest opinion essay.
- 3:46Doctors that are,
- 3:47um,
- 3:47observing in Gaza,
- 3:49they're participating,
- 3:50they're,
- 3:50they're volunteering in Gaza.
- 3:52We don't.
- 3:52International journalists in Gaza.
- 3:54So the extent to which our international testimonies are often from these doctors,
- 3:58paramedics,
- 3:58and nurses,
- 3:59what they described,
- 4:00so let me,
- 4:01let me,
- 4:01let me,
- 4:01sure,
- 4:02you,
- 4:02you said a lot of things.
- 4:03Yeah,
- 4:03yeah,
- 4:03sure,
- 4:03go for it.
- 4:04So first of all,
- 4:05I'm against the murder of any individual person living in Gaza.
- 4:08I see Palestinians as my family,
- 4:10as my cousins.
- 4:10If I see another individual who's,
- 4:13let's say from America or a Palestinian,
- 4:14I will automatically feel more connected to a Palestinian.
- 4:17We have mostly the same ancestry.
- 4:19We're connected to the same land,
- 4:20and our descendants will be.
- 4:21Eternally connected to one another.
- 4:23So whenever I see a Palestinian innocent life taken,
- 4:26that is a horrible tragedy.
- 4:27But you got something wrong from the very beginning
- 4:29that genocide is the intent to eliminate a population.
- 4:32Now you might not be successful.
- 4:34They were not,
- 4:34they were not successful in many cases with Nazi Germany,
- 4:38with the Armenians,
- 4:38but it was the intent to try to eliminate the population.
- 4:42Now,
- 4:42so can I ask you then,
- 4:43let me,
- 4:44let me,
- 4:44do you,
- 4:45do you think that the Bosnian Serb army did not commit genocide in Serbia,
- 4:48or I think if the intent was
- 4:50Eliminate the entire population,
- 4:52then it would be a genocide if the intent is to
- 4:55kill a lot of people in order to do ethnic cleansing,
- 4:57which is another thing,
- 4:58which is also problematic.
- 4:59OK,
- 5:00so that's,
- 5:00you're saying ethnic cleansing,
- 5:01not genocide.
- 5:02No,
- 5:02I'm not saying what's going on is ethnic cleansing.
- 5:04I'm saying that there are individual politicians
- 5:06who support the idea of removing Palestinians.
- 5:08I'm not talking about individual politicians.
- 5:09I'm talking about Benjamin AI,
- 5:10which
- 5:10would be ethnic cleansing,
- 5:11and I'm against that.
- 5:13And you agree that the quote I cited earlier would be,
- 5:15would be the intent for ethnic cleansing,
- 5:17right?
- 5:18The way that you sourced it.
- 5:19It would be,
- 5:19but I don't think that that's actually what he said.
- 5:22We should,
- 5:22we should fact check it and see the whole entire entire context.
- 5:25If we find,
- 5:25if we find of Israel,
- 5:27if we,
- 5:28if we find that Bibi Netanyahu has the intent
- 5:30to remove all the Palestinians from Gaza,
- 5:32I am against it.
- 5:33And you would say that's that would be ethnic cleansing.
- 5:36Absolutely great.
- 5:36So now,
- 5:36now that,
- 5:37now that we're,
- 5:38now that we're agreeing that there's,
- 5:39there's a difference between ethnic cleansing and genocide,
- 5:42and that I'm against both,
- 5:43let's talk about the claim of it being genocide.
- 5:45Now,
- 5:45when we look at 2.2 million people.
- 5:48Living in Gaza,
- 5:49and max number is 70,000 by Hamas records,
- 5:52which we know Hamas is constantly lying of how many people are dying.
- 5:55For 70,000 people to have died.
- 5:57Also,
- 5:58this is in the past two years,
- 5:59there are 5000 people who are dying from natural causes every year,
- 6:02which is also included.
- 6:03The Hamas number,
- 6:04the natural causes are not included.
- 6:05That's false.
- 6:06If natural causes were included,
- 6:08if natural causes were included,
- 6:09militants see excess death among youth and among elderly.
- 6:13You don't see that with the demographic data.
- 6:15The demographic data is actually directly.
- 6:17From Hamas Israeli airstrikes,
- 6:18it's directly from Hamas.
- 6:20It's the Gaza Ministry of Health,
- 6:21which has been reliable is Hamas.
- 6:23OK,
- 6:23so,
- 6:24so they've been reliable in every other armed conflict
- 6:26seeks to kill civilians is giving you your information.
- 6:29Why the Israeli military,
- 6:31if the Israeli military was operating under the laws of war,
- 6:33they would know how many Palestinian civilians have died,
- 6:37people are being killed,
- 6:37only 70,000 to the max number.
- 6:39That is a small amount of people and very clearly not a genocide.
- 6:42Rudy,
- 6:42we've got flags up.
- 6:43You've been voted out by the majority.
- 6:45Please return to your seat.
- 6:51Hello salam
- 6:52Shalo.
- 6:53How are you?
- 6:53Come on Taliu.
- 6:55How are you doing?
- 6:56Good.
- 6:56How are you?
- 6:56Manish maha?
- 6:56I'm very good.
- 6:59Uh,
- 7:00for a moment
- 7:01I,
- 7:01uh.
- 7:03Wanted to believe that you really wanted peace.
- 7:06For a moment,
- 7:06I really
- 7:07almost believed
- 7:09that you wanted the Palestinians to go back to Palestine.
- 7:12But then when you ridiculed
- 7:15and you belittled 70,000 deaths,
- 7:18and you're saying that's just a small percentage for 1.2 million.
- 7:22That is
- 7:24Outrageous.
- 7:25That is not what I said.
- 7:26That's what I've heard you say.
- 7:27No,
- 7:28what I said is it's not a genocide because if it was a genocide
- 7:30we'd see the intent and the actual murder of a lot of people,
- 7:33and I started for the deaths,
- 7:34I started with one person dying that's Palestinian is horrible.
- 7:37OK,
- 7:38so remember everything that I said.
- 7:40Palestinians are my family.
- 7:41If any Palestinian dies,
- 7:42that's horrible.
- 7:43But if we're talking about we are seeing right now,
- 7:45what we're seeing right now
- 7:47is,
- 7:47and I hope I'm wrong,
- 7:49is a great act.
- 7:51Sadly
- 7:52we've seen.
- 7:53The president and
- 7:55Benjamin Netanyahu
- 7:56going out and saying we have to buy social media,
- 7:59we have to influence influencers,
- 8:01we have to work on the young Americans and young Westerners so we can
- 8:05win the battle of the public opinion.
- 8:08Unfortunately that's what I'm seeing right now.
- 8:10You having this
- 8:11soft attitude while
- 8:13serving
- 8:14in the Israeli army while people were getting killed.
- 8:17I'm a Palestinian.
- 8:18I'm not an anti-Semite.
- 8:19I'm a Semite.
- 8:20I'm not anti-Jewish.
- 8:21I have so many Jewish friends,
- 8:23but as long as it's legal,
- 8:24I'm going to go out and say every day I'm anti-Zionism
- 8:28because I'm anti-apartheid,
- 8:29anti-genocide,
- 8:30anti-ethnic cleansing.
- 8:32You know,
- 8:32the people here are labeled today as pro-Palestinians,
- 8:36as if it's something it's given.
- 8:37We're not just pro-Palestinians because Palestinians,
- 8:40we're pro
- 8:41equality,
- 8:42justice,
- 8:43we're anti-racism.
- 8:44If Jewish,
- 8:45Jewish people are going through the same,
- 8:47we will be pro-Jewish people as well.
- 8:49Trust me.
- 8:50So do you condemn the attacks of Jews all around the world,
- 8:52including by Palestinians?
- 8:53Absolutely.
- 8:54Any innocent person that's been attacked without a justified reason,
- 8:58my faith tells me what is a justdemnified reason.
- 9:00If they're not trying to kill you,
- 9:01if they're not trying to fight you,
- 9:02a Palestinian commits,
- 9:04blows up a bus,
- 9:04is that,
- 9:05is that justified?
- 9:05You cannot put this.
- 9:06I'm just asking because you said justified.
- 9:08No.
- 9:08When I say when
- 9:09you served in the army,
- 9:10yeah,
- 9:10yeah,
- 9:11but can you answer that real quick?
- 9:12Absolutely,
- 9:12I can answer that.
- 9:13Can you condemn that?
- 9:14Absolutely.
- 9:14I'm telling you,
- 9:15I condemn the killing of any innocent soul.
- 9:17That's what my faith is telling me to do.
- 9:19Thank you.
- 9:19All right,
- 9:20so now when you are
- 9:22trying to say that I am trying to
- 9:23Promote peace and justice.
- 9:25Why don't you join a movement like Breaking the Silence?
- 9:27Have you heard about them?
- 9:28Of course I heard about them.
- 9:29So why don't you join them,
- 9:30please.
- 9:31So Breaking the Silence is an organization that takes some truths,
- 9:35adds on a lot of lies,
- 9:36and does everything in order to be tokens as Jews
- 9:39and as former soldiers who get paid by foreign entities.
- 9:42Well,
- 9:42there's a new movement of people who aren't the tokens on either side.
- 9:46There's individual.
- 9:46Palestinians who are tokens as well who will sell
- 9:48whatever the Israeli government wants of individuals who are
- 9:50proud and who are strong and who want to
- 9:52see a future where their people coming together.
- 9:54You said you're not an anti-Semite,
- 9:56but you're an anti-Zionist.
- 9:57Does that mean that you're against the idea that might
- 9:59be people have a right to live in this land?
- 10:01I,
- 10:01I'm against the idea of what Zionism is doing.
- 10:04No,
- 10:04Zionist,
- 10:04Zionism is an idea.
- 10:05The idea,
- 10:06I'm asking,
- 10:07are you against the idea that the Jewish
- 10:08people have a right to self-determine on their?
- 10:10Ancestral homeland.
- 10:11I don't,
- 10:11you know who else did not have that problem?
- 10:13I don't.
- 10:13I just told you,
- 10:14OK,
- 10:14you know who you're not an anti-Zionist.
- 10:15You know who else the current conflict,
- 10:17you know who else.
- 10:18You know who else did not have a problem with Jewish people coming to Palestine?
- 10:21A lot of Palestinians.
- 10:21A lot of Palestinians.
- 10:23They opened their doors.
- 10:24They opened their homes.
- 10:25Look it up to come home.
- 10:25Mohammed Hadid,
- 10:26the father of Bellah and Ji Hadid,
- 10:27what is the story?
- 10:29His family opened their doors,
- 10:30their homes for a for a Jewish family only.
- 10:33To come back and say,
- 10:34you know what,
- 10:35this is our house now.
- 10:35You cannot come back again.
- 10:36You won't see me condemning Palestinians as a whole.
- 10:39You won't see me trying to delegitimize or to demonize Palestinians.
- 10:42You kept calling it Yehodah and Samara.
- 10:43You don't even call it Palestine.
- 10:45Historically that region is the way Palestinians were kicked out of their homes,
- 10:48the way a genocide Jews were kicked out,
- 10:50the way a genocide happened in Deir Yassin.
- 10:52Do you know what Deir Yassin is?
- 10:53Of course I know.
- 10:53You know what happened in Deir Yassin?
- 10:54That's a genocide.
- 10:56A genocide would be the intent,
- 10:57OK,
- 10:58for a population to eliminate another population.
- 11:00What happened what you had in 1948 is a conflict between
- 11:03two peoples where people got kicked out on both sides,
- 11:05and I'm against that.
- 11:06We also want to hear from him,
- 11:07of course.
- 11:08So you know the problem with the,
- 11:10with the claim that,
- 11:11oh,
- 11:11Palestinians left by themselves,
- 11:12they fled.
- 11:13I didn't That's,
- 11:13that's,
- 11:13that's ridiculous when people say that,
- 11:15you know what,
- 11:16the government that you're supporting,
- 11:17the army that you're defending,
- 11:19that is what they're saying.
- 11:20They're saying Palestinians left by themselves.
- 11:22Some people say that,
- 11:22some people don't say that.
- 11:23Oh believe me,
- 11:23that a lot of people are saying that that there are Palestinians who chose to leave,
- 11:26and there are many Palestinians that were forced to leave this.
- 11:28There's more nuance we need to add to the conversation,
- 11:30but there are also many Jewish villages that were displaced as well.
- 11:33That's,
- 11:33that's,
- 11:33that's not what happened.
- 11:35That is what happened.
- 11:36Why were there no more Jews in Jerusalem or in the Argan?
- 11:38These are the militias that the terrorist
- 11:40militias that killed so many Palestinians.
- 11:42Those need to be read what happened in Dery Yassin.
- 11:44There,
- 11:44yes,
- 11:44I know what happened in Deassin,
- 11:46and I know what happened in many other communities of Palestinians,
- 11:48and I'm for Palestinians to be able to reunite with Israel,
- 11:52but you're looking at individuals that are in the context of a war and then blame.
- 11:55Blaming it on the whole idea of our whole collective having rights to this,
- 11:58the thing is that you cannot just,
- 11:59if Trump says I'm not anti-immigrants,
- 12:01we don't believe him.
- 12:01We look at what happened in the bring into the situation.
- 12:04You have to look at what's happening on the ground.
- 12:06You have to look at what's happening in Gaza.
- 12:08You have to look at in our civilization,
- 12:11we're saying that Gazan were given warning to
- 12:13leave their homes before they get bombed.
- 12:15This is true.
- 12:15This is the most ridiculous thing I've heard.
- 12:17Well,
- 12:17I was in Gaza and I saw this happening with my own eyes.
- 12:20I'm just shocked that you're defending that again and defending.
- 12:22It's actually.
- 12:22What happened,
- 12:23does that mean you're saying it's OK?
- 12:24No,
- 12:25it's not OK that we were in war,
- 12:26but no,
- 12:26no,
- 12:27it's OK to say to someone,
- 12:28Hey,
- 12:28I'm bombing your house tomorrow.
- 12:29Get out of here.
- 12:30So let's add some context.
- 12:31If Hamas is shooting rockets from a house,
- 12:33that also Palestinian families are living there and it's not propaganda.
- 12:36This is you saying propaganda to things I witnessed with my own eyes.
- 12:39Before I witnessed it.
- 12:40I saw proof.
- 12:41Now I witnessed that.
- 12:42You cannot tell me it's propaganda because you were not there during the war in Gaza,
- 12:45and inshallah one day we will both be able to go back in Gaza.
- 12:47But during the war you were not there.
- 12:49This is what happened.
- 12:50When Hamas is shooting rockets from a house onto Israeli
- 12:52civilians targeting Israeli civilians and Israel warns the Palestinians did
- 12:56not start in I don't think it started on October
- 12:5975 years and it didn't start in 1948 either.
- 13:02So the fact that you're pushing Palestinians,
- 13:03the fact that I'm not pushing anybody,
- 13:05not you.
- 13:06I'm not,
- 13:06I'm talking about myself.
- 13:08I'm representing Palestine.
- 13:09I'm representing Israel.
- 13:11That's we represent those peoples,
- 13:13but don't say you.
- 13:14You can say they are or Israel is.
- 13:16If something bad is happening.
- 13:17I'm defending a movement.
- 13:18I'm defending an ideology,
- 13:19and then if you are for the Palestinians,
- 13:22I'm not seeing you as Hamas,
- 13:23OK?
- 13:24I'm seeing you as a doctor in front of me,
- 13:25as my cousin in front of me that has a connection to this land,
- 13:28and we need to be able to build together.
- 13:30I would love,
- 13:30I would love to believe this,
- 13:32but the reality does not let me,
- 13:34doesn't give me a chance to believe what's happened.
- 13:35Well,
- 13:35the younger generation has still a heart that's not so darkened,
- 13:38and we will be able to build something better.
- 13:40And then we have to pause here.
- 13:41You've been voted out by the majority.
- 13:43Please return to your seat.
- 13:51How's it going?
- 13:51Good.
- 13:52How are you?
- 13:53Good.
- 13:53So,
- 13:54um,
- 13:55I'm actually half Lebanese,
- 13:57and uh you probably can't tell the reason is cause my mom's from Taiwan,
- 14:01which explains why I look like Bruce Lee's gay son,
- 14:03but that's neither here nor there.
- 14:06The first time I was exposed
- 14:08to what Israel was capable of was the summer of 2006 with the 33 day war in Lebanon.
- 14:15There was a firefight that took place between
- 14:17the southern border and northern border of Israel-Lebanon.
- 14:20Hezbollah snuck it over.
- 14:22They killed 8 IDF soldiers,
- 14:23kidnapped two.
- 14:24And hoping that they would get 4 Lebanese prisoners in return.
- 14:27And how did Israel respond?
- 14:29They decided to blanketly carpet bomb the airports,
- 14:32highways,
- 14:33block the port,
- 14:34civilian infrastructure.
- 14:36One of those was my aunt's home.
- 14:38She's not a Hezbollah member,
- 14:40she doesn't live in a military base.
- 14:42And I also remember at that time,
- 14:43my cousins were vacationing in Lebanon,
- 14:47and they told me horror stories about how they were trapped in a basement
- 14:50as hellfires raining on them.
- 14:52There was no electricity because Israel had bombed the power stations there.
- 14:56They had little water and fuel because Israel had shut off the water and fuel supply.
- 15:00Does this sound familiar?
- 15:01And not only that,
- 15:02they had a friend of theirs
- 15:04whose grandmother was being transported
- 15:06from the south to the north in an ambulance,
- 15:09a marked ambulance with the sirens blaring off to escape
- 15:12the bombing that was going on in the south,
- 15:14and it got blown up,
- 15:15it got attacked.
- 15:16The IDF denied that it happened.
- 15:19So,
- 15:20in that war birthed what's known as the Daa doctrine.
- 15:23Even the IDF general at the time,
- 15:25Eisencott,
- 15:26had said,
- 15:27we will apply destructive force.
- 15:29And
- 15:30it doesn't matter.
- 15:31Everything a civilian village is a military base,
- 15:34and this is what we're seeing today in Gaza is the Dahiya doctrine on steroids,
- 15:38and there is intent
- 15:39to push them out.
- 15:40There wasn't genocide in Gaza because they weren't trying
- 15:42to push out the Lebanese out of Lebanon,
- 15:44but they are doing that in Palestine.
- 15:46OK,
- 15:47so
- 15:47even though this is not a conversation about Lebanon,
- 15:49we can talk about that as well because it's obviously related to
- 15:51Israel and the PLO were very much so involved during that war,
- 15:54and along with Hezbollah and a lot of
- 15:56different issues that was happening in Lebanon.
- 15:58If you want to go into a country that you're about to
- 16:00go to war with because Hezbollah is constantly shooting rockets onto Israel,
- 16:04attacking Israeli civilians,
- 16:05killing Israelis,
- 16:06so is the PLO with a lot of terrorism,
- 16:08hold up,
- 16:09if,
- 16:09if they're doing that at that time,
- 16:11OK,
- 16:11then the first thing you need to do is to remove the transportation capabilities
- 16:15of the other army to remove the airports in order to
- 16:18be able to take out Hezbollah and to end the war.
- 16:21What you're all saying of the horrible stuff that happened.
- 16:24That I'm sorry you had any family member that passed away.
- 16:26Palestinians are my close cousins,
- 16:28but other Arabs are also my cousins.
- 16:29We both descend from Ibrahim,
- 16:31from Ishmael and Yitzhaq,
- 16:32so we're all family in this region,
- 16:34and it's horrible what happens to war.
- 16:35The conversation we need to have now is what can we
- 16:38do to remove that and to stop us from happening,
- 16:40because the consequences of us stop using collectively the shame.
- 16:43I'm not the civilian population.
- 16:44I'm not pause here.
- 16:46Their flags are up.
- 16:47You've been voted out by the majority.
- 16:48Please return to your seats.
- 16:55How's it going?
- 16:55Good.
- 16:56How are you?
- 16:57Not bad.
- 16:59I want to talk about your claim,
- 17:00which is that Israel's not committing a genocide in Gaza.
- 17:03Earlier during
- 17:04uh one of the previous debaters,
- 17:05you said that the definition of genocide was to eliminate a population.
- 17:09Is that still your definition?
- 17:11OK,
- 17:12so you recognize that that is not the definition of genocide.
- 17:14That is partially,
- 17:15mostly the definition of genocide.
- 17:16OK.
- 17:17Do you,
- 17:18do you want to know what the full definition of genocide is?
- 17:20And you're gonna say intense.
- 17:21Right,
- 17:22yeah,
- 17:22of course,
- 17:22that's part of it,
- 17:23but that's not,
- 17:23that's not,
- 17:24that's not the qualm I have.
- 17:25It's the intent to destroy a population in whole
- 17:28or in part.
- 17:29OK,
- 17:30so
- 17:30you use the evidence of Israel not killing more Palestinians
- 17:33as evidence that it's not a genocide,
- 17:35but
- 17:35the Germans didn't kill every Jewish person.
- 17:37You agree that there was a genocide against the Jewish people,
- 17:39not the intent was not to kill in part of the Palestinians either.
- 17:42That is why it's not a genocide.
- 17:43Or in part.
- 17:45Every action that Israel does is to prevent civilian casualties from being killed.
- 17:48How do you adjudicate whether a government intends to
- 17:51eliminate in part or in whole a population,
- 17:53right?
- 17:54So if
- 17:54every time that there's an attack against a Hamas site,
- 17:57not against a civilian area that doesn't have Hamas,
- 18:00but specifically
- 18:01a Hamas site that is shooting rockets onto
- 18:03Israeli civilians and Israel does everything to.
- 18:05Warn the population there to leave by phone calls,
- 18:08by text messages,
- 18:09by leaflets,
- 18:09sometimes sent 72 hours before.
- 18:12We can see the intent here is to minimize civilian casualties.
- 18:15And just to be clear,
- 18:16so this is an example of what Israel does in order to have civilians die
- 18:21at large or as part.
- 18:22I understand.
- 18:22Just to be clear,
- 18:23the reason you're saying that is because if they didn't do this,
- 18:26which by the way,
- 18:26this is recorded.
- 18:27It's actually a funny standard that you give to Israel
- 18:30that if they give drop leaflets before bombing somebody that they are,
- 18:33uh,
- 18:34proactive and that they're trying to save civilian life.
- 18:36That's actually required by international law.
- 18:37So it's the bare minimum.
- 18:40And I just want to make clear,
- 18:41I just want to make clear if they didn't do that,
- 18:42if they didn't do that,
- 18:43you would say that,
- 18:43well,
- 18:44clearly that's intent to kill civilians,
- 18:45right?
- 18:46Not necessarily,
- 18:46but OK,
- 18:47so wait,
- 18:47wait,
- 18:47so,
- 18:48so then why,
- 18:48why are you so no,
- 18:49because that's important.
- 18:50There's a firefight,
- 18:51OK.
- 18:52And in the moment there's no ability to send leaflets or warning
- 18:55and people get killed in the process,
- 18:57then there are situations where not warning doesn't make it a genocide.
- 19:00So here's an example when certain situations,
- 19:02I know that,
- 19:02you know,
- 19:03you're,
- 19:03you're at college and you're on the media and everything else,
- 19:05but I actually went to war.
- 19:06So there's certain situations that develop live
- 19:09where Hamas pops out of nowhere,
- 19:11starts shooting at IDF soldiers,
- 19:12there's a gunfight,
- 19:13there are people who are civilians who are killed,
- 19:15and that is not a genocide because they didn't.
- 19:16Warn.
- 19:17That's why not,
- 19:18not warning doesn't make it a genocide either.
- 19:20If the intent is to kill people,
- 19:22then it is a genocide.
- 19:23I'm assuming that you're talking about when safe zones are,
- 19:26are bombed,
- 19:27when refugee camps are bombed,
- 19:28leaflets are safe zones are safe shows Hamas entered,
- 19:30and then they're no longer safe,
- 19:31right?
- 19:31Wait,
- 19:32which shows that Israel's not trying to commit a genocide,
- 19:34right?
- 19:34If you,
- 19:35if you
- 19:35made that point that Israel is dropping leaflets,
- 19:37which shows that they're not intending to commit a genocide,
- 19:39supposedly if they didn't drop leaflet.
- 19:41That would be
- 19:42showing intent to kill a commit a genocide.
- 19:43False.
- 19:43I just explain why that's the case.
- 19:45There are situations that your point lies,
- 19:47then your point,
- 19:47this is a,
- 19:48this is,
- 19:48I don't know how well versed you are in debate.
- 19:50That's called a fallacy of infallibility.
- 19:52If your point,
- 19:52if your,
- 19:53if your position cannot be proven wrong,
- 19:55then it is an illegitimate argument to make.
- 19:58proven.
- 19:58But let me,
- 19:58no,
- 19:58no,
- 19:59let me,
- 19:59no,
- 19:59let me,
- 19:59no,
- 19:59no,
- 20:00no,
- 20:00because this is,
- 20:00this is important because let me,
- 20:02you can,
- 20:02I will give you everything that it can.
- 20:04I will give you prevent civilian casual.
- 20:05Casualties.
- 20:06That is a proof that shows that his intention is not to kill Palestinian civilians.
- 20:10Do Palestinian civilians get killed?
- 20:11I'm going to give you an example.
- 20:12No,
- 20:12I'm gonna finish my point now.
- 20:13No,
- 20:14no,
- 20:14you want to finish your point.
- 20:15You want to finish your point because you've interrupted
- 20:17me and you don't want me to say there.
- 20:20Do you want to hear Al-Mawasi is an example of
- 20:22a refugee camping without being dropped by your own standards,
- 20:26by your own standards,
- 20:27by the world standards,
- 20:28by the world standards,
- 20:29they're not.
- 20:31It's tax season,
- 20:32so people are thinking about money.
- 20:34Here's something most people don't think about until it's too late.
- 20:37Getting your credit over 600 could save you about
- 20:40$2000 the next time you finance a car.
- 20:42With Kickoff,
- 20:43users with credit under 600 grow an average of 86 points,
- 20:47just by paying on time.
- 20:49Transparent,
- 20:50affordable plans start at just $5 per month.
- 20:52What I like about it is how it prioritizes building consistency.
- 20:56No credit check required,
- 20:57no hidden fees,
- 20:58and zero% interest.
- 21:00You can sign up from your phone in just minutes.
- 21:03Start building credit with Kickoff now and get your first month for as little as $1.
- 21:08That's 80% off the normal price when you go to getkickoff.com/surrounded today.
- 21:14That's kickoff without the C.
- 21:16Get KIKOFF.com/surrounded.
- 21:20You must sign up via get kickoff.com/surrounded to activate offer.
- 21:22Offer applies to new Kickoff customers first month only,
- 21:23subject to approval,
- 21:24offer subject to change.
- 21:24New car financing based on 2025 Chevrolet
- 21:25Silverado MSRP with $10,000 down payment and 5-year
- 21:27financing for subprime borrowers versus those over
- 21:28600 nationwide APR average for new cars.
- 21:30Actual savings and financing factors may vary.
- 21:31So Experian,
- 21:31April 2025.
- 21:32A first year credit score impact of plus
- 21:3386 points between August 2024 and August 2025.
- 21:35The Kickoff credit account users who started with a score below 600 are paid on
- 21:37time and had no delinquencies or collections added
- 21:38to their credit profile during that period.
- 21:38Late payments may negatively impact your credit score.
- 21:39Individual results may vary.
- 21:40Thank you to Kickoff for sponsoring this episode.
- 21:43Let's get back to surrounded.
- 21:44My next surrounded claim is that anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism.
- 21:48If you would like to debate this claim,
- 21:50please get to the chair in +321.
- 21:58All of this is to sow chaos and distract from the focal point.
- 22:02We are opposed to an occupation
- 22:05imposed on the occupied people.
- 22:08If I'm opposed to that occupation,
- 22:10I'm opposed to the ideology of that occupation,
- 22:13which is Zionism.
- 22:15Therefore,
- 22:15I'm not against
- 22:17the people that supposedly tie themselves to that identity.
- 22:20I'm against said identity.
- 22:22So if I'm against
- 22:23Zionism,
- 22:24it should be very clear I'm against anyone who supports it,
- 22:27whether they're Jewish or not,
- 22:28because you mentioned Christian Zionism,
- 22:30you're obviously opposed to that,
- 22:31so am I,
- 22:32because I'm not about this person or that person.
- 22:34If there was a Muslim Zionist,
- 22:36I would be opposed to them.
- 22:37It's the ideology,
- 22:39not the person.
- 22:40In the actual,
- 22:41in my opinion,
- 22:42most Zionists are Christians,
- 22:44Christian Zionists,
- 22:44yes,
- 22:45you can go ahead,
- 22:46but all of this is a smokescreen to distract from the focal point.
- 22:49It's very sad that you have so much pain in your heart and have gone through so much
- 22:53that someone speaking in front of you
- 22:55that actually has compassion and is genuine in front of you have to see
- 22:57it as tactics or that there's an objective or that there's a motive.
- 23:00There isn't.
- 23:01OK,
- 23:01I see you as my family,
- 23:02like I've said before,
- 23:03these are not just and these are not over and over.
- 23:05We need to hear it over and over and
- 23:07over because we're denying it and we're rejecting it,
- 23:09and that exists on both sides.
- 23:10I say it to Israelis all the time.
- 23:12I debate Israeli extremists all the time.
- 23:14We need to be able to transcend.
- 23:16Now let me explain why.
- 23:18Let me,
- 23:18there's no this extremist that why Zionism is a form of anti-Semitism,
- 23:22right?
- 23:22There are many ways that someone can be against the population,
- 23:25including the Jews.
- 23:25Hitler wanted to kill all of the Jews.
- 23:27Some Nazis wanted to just kick Jews out.
- 23:30Some Nazis wanted to have Jews there,
- 23:31but just give them different rights.
- 23:32There are different ways of being anti.
- 23:34Jewish people.
- 23:35One of the ways of being anti the Jewish people is to be against the idea
- 23:38and the movement of our right to live in our ancestral homeland.
- 23:41If someone,
- 23:42why do you have the exception to say,
- 23:44I have a right to do this,
- 23:45I have a right to do that.
- 23:46Like,
- 23:46where does that exception come from?
- 23:48Why do you have the,
- 23:49the indigenous arguments of any
- 23:50indigenous people's rights to self-determination,
- 23:52which is part of the it's not debunked.
- 23:54We,
- 23:54it's actually been proven.
- 23:55A lot of people even here claimed to be Jewish,
- 23:57and you know your ancestors are Jews as well,
- 24:00from that land.
- 24:01We come from the civilization.
- 24:02Both of us,
- 24:03the Jewish people,
- 24:03are indigenous.
- 24:04That is the civilization you actually descend from,
- 24:06and you opted out by either converting to
- 24:08Christianity or Islam or Arabized over time,
- 24:10and we have another identity that my ancestors,
- 24:13which is not my ancestors that I can't speak to.
- 24:1560%.
- 24:16Maybe they were Palestinian,
- 24:17maybe they were this,
- 24:18maybe they were that Palestinian ancestry,
- 24:20according to genetic studies that have been done over the decades,
- 24:23shows that they descend from the Jewish population.
- 24:25And in cities like Yata,
- 24:26Yafa,
- 24:26Swat,
- 24:27Hebron,
- 24:27Shrem,
- 24:28if you go to East Jerusalem,
- 24:30those.
- 24:30The Population of Palestinians is up to 90 to 80%.
- 24:33Again,
- 24:33like I said earlier,
- 24:33you can find publications like Nature,
- 24:35American Journal of Human Genetics,
- 24:37studies done by Hebel,
- 24:38by Nebel,
- 24:39by Hammer,
- 24:39by Behar.
- 24:40These are very clearly proven that Palestinians descend from there,
- 24:43and so do the Jewish people.
- 24:44If the Jews want to live in their ancestral homeland,
- 24:47that is a form of decolonization movement.
- 24:49All of this is a moot point that could be debunked with a 12th Google search.
- 24:53Someone distracts the folks.
- 24:54Google it actually gave all the sources.
- 24:56You've been voted out by the majority.
- 24:57Please return to your seat.
- 25:08April 2025,
- 25:09the IOF forces made a complete blockade.
- 25:12No food aid,
- 25:14no shelter,
- 25:15nothing getting in Gaza.
- 25:17There has been 470 people,
- 25:19mainly women and children,
- 25:20that have died from severe malnourishment,
- 25:23and it's expected to be 10,000 of these people who died from severe malnourishment.
- 25:27It's been declared a famine
- 25:29in Gaza,
- 25:30famine.
- 25:32There has been journalists.
- 25:33This is the highest amount of journalists that we've ever seen die.
- 25:36270 journalists have been targeted,
- 25:39killed.
- 25:40This is more than we've seen in World War One,
- 25:42World War Two,
- 25:43the Civil War,
- 25:44the post 9/11 wars,
- 25:45all combined.
- 25:47You made two points.
- 25:47No,
- 25:47no,
- 25:47no,
- 25:48this is,
- 25:48I'm,
- 25:48I'm,
- 25:48these are my points to say this is what happens under a Zionist regime.
- 25:52So this is what happens during war.
- 25:54If we look what
- 25:56I'll let you finish your,
- 25:57I'll let you finish two points.
- 25:58You starve a population.
- 26:00I didn't do anything.
- 26:01OK,
- 26:01don't you,
- 26:01I'm sorry.
- 26:02OK,
- 26:03so we can we can talk about the Israeli government right now.
- 26:05It's me and as human beings that are talking about the situation,
- 26:08right?
- 26:08No,
- 26:09I don't support people being starved and people dying and people suffering.
- 26:12I understand why things are happening,
- 26:13and I'm trying to focus on that in order to
- 26:15change it from happening so that people don't die anymore,
- 26:17not just using selecting instances of Palestinian suffering
- 26:20when it fits an agenda in.
- 26:21In order to manipulate that starvation,
- 26:2347 are you talking about the thousands of Palestinians that
- 26:26died in the Syrian civil war by the hundreds of thousands
- 26:28I'm talking about the people that are in Gaza right now
- 26:30that are not having Palestinian they are living in tents.
- 26:32Only Palestinians,
- 26:33Palestinians when it comes to Israel do like to talk about them.
- 26:36Why don't you talk about other Palestinians that are suffering as well?
- 26:39Let's 197.
- 26:40Let's talk about the famine and the,
- 26:42and the block of buildings.
- 26:44The reason why aid was blocked,
- 26:45which I'm not for,
- 26:46is because Hamas was stealing all of that food.
- 26:49Yes,
- 26:49yes,
- 26:49yes.
- 26:50Hamas was stealing that food,
- 26:51killing other Palestinianst you think you should let
- 26:53more food in instead of blocking it?
- 26:56Where's the logic I think should have been done.
- 26:57Here's,
- 26:57here's a legitimate criticism.
- 26:59Israel create a safe zone.
- 27:00What Israel could have done is to remove the population from
- 27:03where Hamas when they'd come out from the food aid,
- 27:05they'd all be shot in the same place on the same day.
- 27:07The one day people would come in with a shot in their arm,
- 27:10everybody,
- 27:10because it was a game.
- 27:11We have Hamas shooting Palestinians.
- 27:13OK,
- 27:14it's the ISIS-backed video games that are happening that
- 27:16Netanyahu has already agreed to flags are up.
- 27:18You've been voted out.
- 27:26Well.
- 27:28I think
- 27:29criticizing a regime is not criticizing identity.
- 27:31That was a point that was already brought up.
- 27:33But I have a question for you.
- 27:35Do you agree with the current strategy with the board of peace in order to bring
- 27:39stability to the Gaza region?
- 27:40I don't.
- 27:41Um,
- 27:41what,
- 27:41what are some of the criticisms that you have of that?
- 27:43So first of all,
- 27:43I,
- 27:44I completely agree with you that criticizing a regime is not anti-Semitic.
- 27:47Like I said earlier,
- 27:47I don't know one Israeli doesn't criticize the Israeli government.
- 27:50That's not anti-Semitism.
- 27:52That's not anti-Zionism either.
- 27:53When you're against the right for the Jewish people to live there,
- 27:55that's when it becomes
- 27:56anti-Semitic.
- 27:57Now when it comes to the board of peace
- 27:59and Trump's policies and trying to create the French Riviera
- 28:02in,
- 28:02in Gaza and all these things,
- 28:03we are on the same page that this is horrible.
- 28:05There should be no imposition
- 28:06of the United States,
- 28:07Qatar,
- 28:08Saudi Arabia,
- 28:08or any foreign entity coming into this land.
- 28:10This is the land of the Israelis and the Palestinians,
- 28:12and we have to create one civilization for both where we have equality in this land.
- 28:16And so it's a democratic state,
- 28:17a one-state solution.
- 28:18Yes,
- 28:18one civilization I call because one state implies
- 28:20you don't believe the current political system,
- 28:21which you don't believe that Jewish or there needs to
- 28:23be a Jewish identity that's central to the governance.
- 28:26Of course I do of Israel.
- 28:27So how,
- 28:27how could it be a democratic regime
- 28:30if everybody has autonomy and equal rights,
- 28:32if one ethnicity is prioritized over all of this question on it.
- 28:35This is an honest conversation.
- 28:36I'm happy we're having it.
- 28:37So first of all,
- 28:38there are non-negotiables for the Jews and non-negotiables for the Palestinians.
- 28:41For the Palestinians,
- 28:41it's the right of return and freedom from the river to the sea.
- 28:44That creates a problem to today's Jewish non-negotiables,
- 28:47which are
- 28:48full economic,
- 28:49political,
- 28:49and military control over the land.
- 28:50Jerusalem is the capital and the 3rd temple is built.
- 28:53Now,
- 28:53how are you going to have these two things that are non-negotiable?
- 28:55For both.
- 28:55Well,
- 28:56the idea of Palestinians returning to the land
- 28:59makes a demographic problem and a cultural problem.
- 29:01Today,
- 29:01a lot of Palestinians hate Israelis.
- 29:03They wouldn't want to live in Israel.
- 29:04That is such an overgeneralization.
- 29:06I have to stop you.
- 29:06A lot of Palestinians,
- 29:07just to say to the camera,
- 29:08what this is advocating for is an ethno-state that prioritizes one
- 29:12particular population over those that already had words into people's hands.
- 29:16I did not say that there were priorities of individuals.
- 29:18There's a,
- 29:19there's a collective that are indigenous to land.
- 29:21It will be,
- 29:22we'll let you continue.
- 29:22Yes,
- 29:23let me finish.
- 29:24The truth to the camera as soon as you're done with this bulls 16 million people,
- 29:27Jews in the world,
- 29:29right?
- 29:29Those are the descendants of 2.5 tribes.
- 29:31There are 9.5 tribes that are missing as a part of that number.
- 29:34We were 12 tribes once upon a time.
- 29:35That population today that still identifies a part of the
- 29:38Jewish people are 100 million outside of the 16 million,
- 29:41and half of them want to make aliyah to move to Israel.
- 29:43So we would have 50 million Jews coming back to the land of Israel,
- 29:46Palestinians also returning.
- 29:47A lot of things have to happen before that day happens where we change the culture,
- 29:50we create freedom of speech,
- 29:51which does not exist in Palestine.
- 29:53Palestinian societies,
- 29:54we change the structure of education,
- 29:56and once we have something that we can both live together,
- 29:58we can have our aspirations together.
- 30:00Now,
- 30:00are you,
- 30:00are you a Palestinian?
- 30:01Can I,
- 30:02can I,
- 30:02can I I'm just asking one question.
- 30:03I want to understand.
- 30:03I'm not Palestinian,
- 30:04no,
- 30:05and I don't believe that identity gives credibility to those arguments.
- 30:07It shows that someone's speaking as a fan or as a player.
- 30:09No,
- 30:09it,
- 30:10it,
- 30:10whoa,
- 30:11a fan or a player,
- 30:12are you pro-Palestinian or are you Palestinian?
- 30:14I don't think that we should view this as a fucking sports game,
- 30:16dude.
- 30:16I'm starting to curse profanity.
- 30:17I'm sorry,
- 30:18sorry to curse.
- 30:18It's not a sports game.
- 30:19I can recognize an atrocity when I see it because I believe.
- 30:22Is October 7th an atrocity?
- 30:24I,
- 30:24I believe that any innocent life that has died is something that 7th atrocity
- 30:27any innocent life that dies needs to
- 30:29be condemnable so much for recognizing atrocities.
- 30:31I just said any innocent life that dieth needs to be an ademnable.
- 30:34All I'm saying is it is an insane point to say that being anti-Zionism
- 30:38means you're anti-Semitic because you're spitting in
- 30:40the face of Jewish voices for Palestine.
- 30:42You're spitting in the face of Jewish voices for peace.
- 30:44All of these are people that recognize their identity as Jewish people that
- 30:48can also call out atrocities when they see it because they don't.
- 30:51I don't believe that just because they have a shared ethnicity means
- 30:54they need to endorse an ethnostate
- 30:56that is brutally killing people indiscriminately.
- 30:58They can recognize when they see something that is
- 31:00a human rights failure and advocate against that.
- 31:03What I want to make clear real quick,
- 31:04and I'll,
- 31:04I'll let you speak.
- 31:05I will completely and I'll let you respond after to your next claim,
- 31:07OK.
- 31:08There are populations within all peoples
- 31:10that turn against their own.
- 31:12There are individual Palestinians,
- 31:13let me finish.
- 31:14Yes,
- 31:14there are,
- 31:15there are tokens who side with their oppressors in order
- 31:18to try to be accepted in the modern world.
- 31:20Palestinians oppressing Israelis when Israel's
- 31:23controlling the region side with the
- 31:24world that hates the Jewish people and hates Israel and are attacking
- 31:27and in order to be accepted military in the Middle East that
- 31:30is backed by the most powerful regime in the entire world.
- 31:33So what are you talking they're supporting also
- 31:35Egypt and they're supporting other places because the,
- 31:37the intent of the United States is to create
- 31:39conflict in that region and to profit so that you
- 31:40and your country can go and profit over here
- 31:42because that money goes straight to US weapon companies,
- 31:44which I'm against.
- 31:45I do not want the involvement.
- 31:46We have to pause.
- 31:47We've got flags up.
- 31:48Can you return to your seat?
- 31:55So
- 31:55I want to do something.
- 31:57I want to
- 31:58start with good faith,
- 31:59OK.
- 32:01This issue
- 32:02gets all of us seated.
- 32:03I can,
- 32:03I can recognize that,
- 32:04me myself included,
- 32:05so I'm not trying to
- 32:07do a gotcha.
- 32:07I'm not trying to be offensive.
- 32:09I want to first recognize that you are someone who is separate from
- 32:13the,
- 32:14you know,
- 32:15precondition of
- 32:16Israeli rhetoric of never ever,
- 32:18uh,
- 32:18recognizing
- 32:19Palestinian identity or existence.
- 32:22I think you're doing it
- 32:23in a.
- 32:24Strategic way,
- 32:25but I want to recognize that you've moved the bar a little bit,
- 32:28so that's commendable to,
- 32:29to an extent,
- 32:31but you fail to recognize the pain that's not in front of your face.
- 32:33You say you see your Palestinian,
- 32:35you know,
- 32:35comrades,
- 32:35your cousins that are sitting here,
- 32:37but not the ones over there.
- 32:38So your claim was anti-Zionism,
- 32:40OK,
- 32:41anti-Zionism
- 32:43is,
- 32:43I,
- 32:43I'm gonna make my claim anti you said anti-Zionism
- 32:46is anti-Semitism.
- 32:48But you constantly come back to this idea
- 32:51that
- 32:52people who are anti-Zionists don't want Jews to be in Israel,
- 32:56but that's not what anti-Zionism is.
- 32:58Anti-Zionism I'm not finished with my claim.
- 33:00Anti-Zionism
- 33:01is that Jews should not have supremacy
- 33:04when they are there.
- 33:05So,
- 33:06and,
- 33:06and when you,
- 33:07when you're discussing anti-Semitism,
- 33:08what I really struggle with,
- 33:10and I want to bring up Peter Beinart,
- 33:11I don't know if you're familiar with him,
- 33:12but he is a Jewish scholar,
- 33:14and I,
- 33:14I really recognize.
- 33:16That he is doing something important,
- 33:18which is bringing the voice back
- 33:19to why Jews should be against this in the first place
- 33:22and why when they're not,
- 33:23it creates conditions of anti-Semitism.
- 33:25I believe your efforts
- 33:26are more anti-Semitic because you're creating a monolith of the Jews.
- 33:30You are saying Jews are never capable
- 33:32of committing such violence.
- 33:33Jews are always the victim in the book of Esther,
- 33:36in the book of Esther,
- 33:37when Puram,
- 33:38the celebration of Puram,
- 33:39right?
- 33:39It's,
- 33:40do we,
- 33:40can we recognize
- 33:41that 7.
- 33:435000 Gentiles were killed by the Jews.
- 33:45The Jews commit that atrocity?
- 33:47They didn't.
- 33:47So this wasn't in the book of Esther.
- 33:49This didn't happen.
- 33:49No,
- 33:49the Jews did not commit atrocities because
- 33:51Jews are not capable of committing atrocities.
- 33:53Jewish individuals are capable,
- 33:55of course.
- 33:55What about the collectivism.
- 33:57So Israel is not a Jewish collective.
- 33:58You just keep saying that Israel is a Jewish collective.
- 34:00It's not.
- 34:01Israel is the country of the Jewish people.
- 34:04Would it be hypothetically capable of doing something wrong?
- 34:06Absolutely.
- 34:07Has it also done other things wrong?
- 34:09Yes,
- 34:09I'm not talking about that the.
- 34:10is not capable of doing things that are wrong.
- 34:12Do you recognize that when you say every Israeli criticizes
- 34:16the Israeli government to show that criticism is not anti-Semitism,
- 34:19um,
- 34:19but here's the issue
- 34:22you're not criticizing,
- 34:22you're demonizing in Israel,
- 34:23in Israel,
- 34:24a Jewish person
- 34:25can say,
- 34:26I don't believe in God,
- 34:27but if you want to be part of the Knesset,
- 34:28you cannot be anti-Zionist,
- 34:29so you can't actually
- 34:30question
- 34:31the system from within.
- 34:32You cannot question the anti-Semitism,
- 34:34there are 3 D's in order to recognize them when it comes to Israel.
- 34:37If you demonize.
- 34:38The Jewish people,
- 34:39if you delegitimize our existence,
- 34:42and if you're holding a double standard,
- 34:43I'm making an assumption,
- 34:44I might be wrong.
- 34:45Every person here looks like they're anti-Zionist.
- 34:48I let you communicate,
- 34:49I'm going to address the actual point,
- 34:51which is the claim
- 34:52that anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism.
- 34:53If you're trying to delegitimize the Jewish people's
- 34:56right and claim to the land and existence,
- 34:58if you're trying to demonize us and make us
- 34:59seem as monsters and take out all contexts to make
- 35:01it seem as Israel's the worst thing in the world
- 35:03and now connected to other problems in the world,
- 35:05if you're trying to hold a double standard.
- 35:06where you care about some Palestinians,
- 35:07but not all Palestinians.
- 35:09You are an
- 35:10anti-Semite.
- 35:10I wasn't going to get passionate.
- 35:12I did,
- 35:12so I'll apologize for that.
- 35:13I'll come back when it comes to I want to address that.
- 35:15So.
- 35:16No,
- 35:16I'm not moving forward.
- 35:17I'm finishing the point.
- 35:18Zionism is the idea.
- 35:19This is why definitions are important.
- 35:21Zionism comes towards Zion,
- 35:22which is Jerusalem,
- 35:23and the idea that we have a right
- 35:25to return and self-determine on this ancestral homeland,
- 35:28to be against this idea,
- 35:29to be anti-Zionism
- 35:31is against the idea that the Jewish people should have a right to.
- 35:33To self-determine,
- 35:34that is anti-Semitic.
- 35:35Now,
- 35:35if you're against certain policies the government is doing,
- 35:38the treatment of Palestinians,
- 35:39the suffering of Palestinians,
- 35:40that is not anti-Zionism,
- 35:42that is being pro-Palestinian talking.
- 35:43We have to differentiate those points.
- 35:45When I'm saying that anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism is by defining Zionism,
- 35:48and you know who gets to define Zionism?
- 35:50The Jewish collective,
- 35:51the Jewish people.
- 35:51And if you're going to source me,
- 35:53individual Jews that you can hold on a handful who unfortunately,
- 35:56due to the trauma that we face and the
- 35:58generational trauma that has been projected onto our people,
- 36:00then end up.
- 36:01with an oppressive world that always blames the Jewish people for all problems.
- 36:04That is not a source of reference.
- 36:05There are individual Palestinians who also hate all the Palestinians,
- 36:08and they're not the people I'm going to source
- 36:09to talk for the Palestinian people to identify something.
- 36:11You're in your claim,
- 36:12anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism.
- 36:14I'm going to make an assumption that every person around us is an anti-Zionist.
- 36:18Here,
- 36:19can you identify one anti-Semitic rhetoric that someone has said?
- 36:22There's delegitimization of our identity,
- 36:24saying,
- 36:24oh,
- 36:24no,
- 36:24it was originally the Canaanites,
- 36:25it wasn't the Jews.
- 36:26You guys aren't the real Jews.
- 36:27You guys are converts.
- 36:28All.
- 36:28Semitic points.
- 36:29Then there's demonization.
- 36:30Oh,
- 36:30you guys are monsters and you kill indiscriminately,
- 36:32you carpet bomb.
- 36:33Then there's holding double standards where you don't
- 36:35care about actual genocides happening in the world.
- 36:37You don't care about Palestinians dying in other cases.
- 36:39You only care about using them when they can be used as a.
- 36:41That is called anti-Semitism.
- 36:43So what you have just done
- 36:45is identify all of the things that everyone has around you,
- 36:48has done around you-Semitic points,
- 36:49OK.
- 36:50And you are recognizing that something has been done wrong to you.
- 36:53Can anyone around us say that?
- 36:57Rudy is doing something wrong to us.
- 36:58Yes,
- 36:58they can,
- 36:59but,
- 36:59but they're not putting this label on you that because of that,
- 37:02then all your points fail.
- 37:03You have the sense,
- 37:04you have the sense that people are being anti.
- 37:07There are points that we agree on flags up.
- 37:08You've been voted out by the majority.
- 37:10Please return.
- 37:17Please
- 37:20Uh,
- 37:22let me give it to you.
- 37:23You're a good debater.
- 37:25There is no doubt about that.
- 37:27You've been trained very well
- 37:28to talk about this
- 37:30by yourself,
- 37:30but
- 37:31this is the problem.
- 37:32The problem is that you're trying to give
- 37:34yourself the right to define what's Zionism,
- 37:36and you're not giving us the right to define what do we mean by being anti-Zionist.
- 37:40When we say we're anti-Zionists,
- 37:42we do not
- 37:43present any hatred toward any Jews or any Jewish people or any community.
- 37:47What we're trying to say,
- 37:48we're against what the Israeli government is doing.
- 37:50That's what we mean.
- 37:52So if we're going to try to fight for hours to define what do you mean by Zionism,
- 37:55what do I mean by anti-Zionism,
- 37:57what we're trying to say is that the
- 37:59Israeli government that you're part of it,
- 38:02part of the IDF,
- 38:03part of the Israeli
- 38:06community that you're defending what they're doing,
- 38:08we are completely against what this government is doing.
- 38:12You're trying to defend what they're doing in Gaza.
- 38:14You're trying to justify and give excuses.
- 38:16That's,
- 38:16that's
- 38:17outrageous for us.
- 38:17We don't accept that.
- 38:18So Doctor,
- 38:19you did something that's very important that I think that we can
- 38:21transcend the conversation is by understanding
- 38:23what we're saying rather than terms.
- 38:24The reason why I'm.
- 38:25Saying that anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism is
- 38:27that because I'm giving a very specific
- 38:29definition of Zionism,
- 38:30which is the official definition
- 38:32and the definition that historically was and currently is
- 38:34that the Jewish people that's not what we mean.
- 38:36Exactly.
- 38:36This is why we need to have a conversation of what do you truly mean?
- 38:39When I say I'm a Zionist,
- 38:40I'm not talking about suffering of Palestinians.
- 38:42I want Palestinians to be able to return.
- 38:44I want Palestinians to be able to live.
- 38:46No,
- 38:46no,
- 38:46my actions are actually working to that.
- 38:48I work with Palestinian leaders in Gaza
- 38:50and in the West Bank to actually.
- 38:51Change the situation.
- 38:52You are a blasing Palestinians for what's happening with us.
- 38:54I'm not blaming Palestinians for what's happening to us.
- 38:56I actually blamed the US government for their foreign aid.
- 38:59I blame the British for what they did into our country.
- 39:01And I would like to see us being able to transcend,
- 39:03but what you are doing is so important
- 39:04because everyone who's listening can realize we
- 39:06need to understand what we're actually saying.
- 39:08If you're condemning the suffering of Palestinians,
- 39:10that is not being anti-Zionist.
- 39:12And for if you're miscommunicating that,
- 39:14and Israelis are hearing you saying,
- 39:16I'm an anti-Zionist,
- 39:17let's.
- 39:17Ask you what you truly mean by that.
- 39:19And if we mean different things,
- 39:20then let's put those words to the side and actually care about what we mean.
- 39:23What is a future vision that we can live
- 39:24together in this land that includes both of us?
- 39:26What,
- 39:27what,
- 39:27what the Israeli government is trying to do right now is
- 39:29to push for criminalizing any criticism of the state of Israel,
- 39:32any,
- 39:33any criticism of the government Israel doesn't criticize the Israeli government,
- 39:36but Americans are not having that right.
- 39:38See,
- 39:38Americans nowadays are realizing what the Middle Easterns and the
- 39:41Palestinians have been dealing with for the past 75 years.
- 39:44You know,
- 39:44which is the reason there are dictatorships in the
- 39:47Middle East is to protect the state of Israel,
- 39:49whether you believe it or not,
- 39:50that's what,
- 39:51that's what people believe,
- 39:53you know.
- 39:53So there was no dictatorships before the state of you know,
- 39:55you know who's the second receiving of American and US aid after Israel?
- 39:59Egypt Egypt.
- 40:00Why is that?
- 40:01You know why the Sisi is put in place.
- 40:02Why is that?
- 40:03That's what the
- 40:04people of the Middle East believe.
- 40:05We're going now,
- 40:06now Americans,
- 40:07now Americans are coming to realize,
- 40:09hold on.
- 40:10You're attacking my freedom of speech.
- 40:11You know how many people lost their jobs,
- 40:14lost their
- 40:15school or education because they're criticizing the
- 40:17actions of the government of Israel.
- 40:18There's absolute freedom of speech in Israel,
- 40:20OK,
- 40:20whether you're Palestinian or Israeli,
- 40:22you have the right to say what you want.
- 40:23So there is freedom.
- 40:25It's not the same all over what you're talking about in Gaza,
- 40:27where Hamas doesn't allow people to talk or in the
- 40:29Palestinian Authority controlled areas talking about where they don't allow.
- 40:32We're trying to define what we're doing by anti-Zionism,
- 40:35OK,
- 40:35but I'm,
- 40:35I'm not in the US,
- 40:36so I'm not here to and we've actually agreed that we have.
- 40:39To remove all
- 40:40military investments and investments and control of the United States
- 40:44and other European countries into the Middle East because they
- 40:46are the ones who plagued us to be in the cont happened to Rabin when he tried to put that
- 40:50he was assassinated because he wanted to separate our land,
- 40:53which you would agree that is against that,
- 40:54right?
- 40:55Do you think that we should have two states?
- 40:56We shouldn't divide this land.
- 40:57The problem is that we always talk about the two solutions.
- 41:00One state solution to,
- 41:01but most of the Israelis,
- 41:02they're looking for a third solution,
- 41:03which is ethnic cleansing.
- 41:04I don't getting everyone out of here.
- 41:06That's what they want to do.
- 41:07And there's a.
- 41:08Fourth solution where Palestinians also want to ethnically cleanse the Jews.
- 41:11We can talk about extremist opinions on both sides,
- 41:13but if you and I,
- 41:14the majority of you,
- 41:15do you believe that there should be one civilization,
- 41:17the reason I don't use one state is because the current political
- 41:19system that we have with the Knesset is completely corrupt and horrible,
- 41:22and we have to create something new that is
- 41:23a republic that people have a right to defend,
- 41:25but something new.
- 41:26Do you believe in one civilization for both of our people?
- 41:28If it's equal rights,
- 41:29yes,
- 41:29if it's fair,
- 41:30if it's just,
- 41:31yes.
- 41:31So let's there's no apartheid.
- 41:33Well,
- 41:33if,
- 41:33if Palestinians and Jews agree to have a one-state solution,
- 41:36it will be.
- 41:37It won't be a Jewish state.
- 41:38It will be a Jewish state.
- 41:39So that's,
- 41:39you're asking what I'm looking at my,
- 41:40my vision for it,
- 41:41it cannot be a Jewish state.
- 41:42Why not?
- 41:42What is a Jewish state that's a problem for you?
- 41:44Because it's not a democratic state.
- 41:46If it's,
- 41:46it's,
- 41:46but it could be both.
- 41:47It could be both,
- 41:48right?
- 41:48What do you mean?
- 41:49Why would it not be a democratic to be secular?
- 41:52Sure,
- 41:52but you could have also a culture of a country,
- 41:55a Chinese state,
- 41:55a Japanese state is going to be Japanese by its culture,
- 41:57but a Jewish state will have rights for Jewish
- 42:00people more than the rights of others believe more.
- 42:01That's what happened that's what happened to
- 42:03Palestinians who live under the Israeli rule.
- 42:06Living in Israel,
- 42:07they don't have to serve in the army.
- 42:08They don't have to do a lot of things that they talking to them.
- 42:10Have you spoken to any of those people,
- 42:12Palestinians who live as Israeli citizens who don't have to serve
- 42:14in the army and don't have to be 3rd class citizens.
- 42:17They're not 2nd or 3rd class.
- 42:18They are equal citizens.
- 42:19I don't,
- 42:20I don't in the West oblivious or you're lying.
- 42:21I'm sorry,
- 42:22I have met many Palestinian friends,
- 42:24Israeli Arab friends that are living in this kindly talking softly,
- 42:26but either you're lying or you're oblivious,
- 42:28or I'm actually someone who lives in this land and I'm getting
- 42:30away from the narrative of just demonizing to see what's happening there?
- 42:33Are you in a bubble projection?
- 42:35Maybe.
- 42:36What do you mean what you're saying,
- 42:38brainwashing people have equal rights in the line of Israel.
- 42:41You're talking out loud and you're denying things that exist.
- 42:43No people in Israel,
- 42:45whether you are Palestinian or identify as
- 42:47Israeli Arab or whatever you identify with,
- 42:48if you're not Jewish,
- 42:49you have equal rights.
- 42:50I am having lunch with people after this who are who are Israeli citizens,
- 42:53but they're Palestinians,
- 42:54and what differences do they have in their rights?
- 42:56Oh,
- 42:57they talk a lot about how they're mistreated all the time.
- 42:59You said about rights.
- 43:00I disagree with Ms.
- 43:01Freement.
- 43:01It might be individual cases.
- 43:03We can talk about that,
- 43:04but talk about rights.
- 43:04You said that they're different rights and they're 2nd and 3rd class citizens.
- 43:07What rights are different?
- 43:08That technicality,
- 43:09they don't have the same protection.
- 43:10Of course they have the same.
- 43:11What is the different protection?
- 43:12don't.
- 43:13What is the protection I have that an Israeli Arab doesn't?
- 43:15You can sing and say whatever you want.
- 43:17They can sing and say whatever they want.
- 43:18Actually,
- 43:19I can't go to the Temple Mount and be able to sing my songs,
- 43:22and they're able to.
- 43:23Let's say a Palestiniana decide to say,
- 43:25you know what?
- 43:26I support Hamas.
- 43:27Is he allowed to do that?
- 43:28No,
- 43:28he's not.
- 43:29I mean,
- 43:30you support an organization.
- 43:31I'm not to kill.
- 43:32I'm talking as you an Israeli.
- 43:33You can say that if someone here came to
- 43:35the United States where you're currently living and said,
- 43:37I support
- 43:38ISIS,
- 43:39what do you think would happen to them?
- 43:40But that's equal for all of them.
- 43:41What's equal regardless of all of them,
- 43:43regardless of their faith,
- 43:45regardless of their ethnic if someone supports Hamas,
- 43:46there'll be a problem.
- 43:47In Israel,
- 43:48a Jewish could say it differently Jewish than a Palestinian,
- 43:50if not the same.
- 43:51Yes,
- 43:51it is.
- 43:51You know what they're saying if they're actually plotting to do something,
- 43:54I'm not saying plotting.
- 43:55OK,
- 43:55you're saying freedom of speech.
- 43:57You mentioned freedom of speech,
- 43:58of Israeli Arabs who openly support Hamas.
- 44:00You can go to Tel Aviv University.
- 44:02You can go to Hebrew University.
- 44:04You can see them,
- 44:04supporting Hamas,
- 44:05and nothing happens Salah has been put in prison because of that.
- 44:08There's so many because people they were a part or supporting
- 44:10or in connection to because of the words that they say.
- 44:14What we're what we're debating here,
- 44:16those words is I want to Israeli Jews have the
- 44:18same rights as the Palestinian Israeli Palestinian Israeli Arabs,
- 44:21Palestinian Arabs,
- 44:22they have the same rights.
- 44:23They have the same rights.
- 44:24People who live,
- 44:25we have to do more than them because we have to
- 44:27serve in the army I'm sorry for giving this example.
- 44:30I don't want to say it,
- 44:31but.
- 44:32Let's say a certain ethnicity here in America says
- 44:35all of us have the same rights and opportunities.
- 44:37It's not,
- 44:38it's not the case.
- 44:39OK,
- 44:39but why do you keep using examples of other
- 44:41places rather than talking about our own home?
- 44:44We're talking about,
- 44:44we're talking about the,
- 44:45the to get a closer,
- 44:45it doesn't understand the original colonizers,
- 44:48white people who took this land,
- 44:49who took black slaves and brought,
- 44:51because that's what you're talking about,
- 44:52and brought them into the society here,
- 44:53and the relationship between the half has nothing
- 44:55to do with peoples who are native to.
- 44:57This land together and other people coming in and causing us to fight one another.
- 45:01What's your ethnic background?
- 45:02Where are your parents' grandparents,
- 45:03where do they live?
- 45:03My ancestors come from Israel.
- 45:05No,
- 45:05no,
- 45:05before,
- 45:06after that,
- 45:07when we were displaced from,
- 45:08where was it?
- 45:09OK,
- 45:09on my mother's side of Morocco and Algeria,
- 45:11my dad's side,
- 45:11Poland and Belgium.
- 45:12That is the displacement that we went through.
- 45:14You're kind of half,
- 45:15half,
- 45:15yeah,
- 45:15I'm Ashkenazi Palestinian.
- 45:17Palestinian Palestinian Jews have different rights than someone who's
- 45:21never been to I mean a Palestinian Jew.
- 45:23A Jewish person who lived in Palestine before the established Israel.
- 45:26So today they're Israeli citizens.
- 45:28What I'm trying to say,
- 45:29there's a big difference between the rights of
- 45:32a Jewish who came from Poland
- 45:34and Germany
- 45:35and had no connection to the land with someone who lived there all their lives.
- 45:39Well,
- 45:40first of all,
- 45:40the Jews that were displaced doesn't mean that they don't come from this land.
- 45:43As Palestinians who are now born 2nd,
- 45:453rd generation in Chile,
- 45:46in America,
- 45:47in Jordan and other places,
- 45:48they also have a connection to the land.
- 45:49We're not.
- 45:49erase it because they had a displacement out of their home.
- 45:51I'm against kicking people out.
- 45:52We're talking about right now the fact that they had a displacement.
- 45:55It doesn't disconnect them from the reality of
- 45:56the matter is you not considering what's happening,
- 45:58let me,
- 45:59I would appreciate not considering Ashkenazi Jews as foreigners.
- 46:02When the state of Israel was created,
- 46:04every single citizen of that state,
- 46:05whether Jewish or not Jewish,
- 46:07had equal rights Jews.
- 46:09What about the Ethiopian?
- 46:10How do you see them?
- 46:11I see them as my brothers and sisters being treated.
- 46:13Actually,
- 46:13my main project that I'm doing in my life is bringing back.
- 46:16The rest of the tribes of Israel in Africa,
- 46:18not just the Ethiopians,
- 46:19but the Igbos in Nigeria why we're having a debate if we agree on everything.
- 46:21We're talking about,
- 46:22you are presenting,
- 46:23you came to present a point of view of an Israeli government and the Jewish people.
- 46:26I'm not here to present a view of the Israeli government.
- 46:27You're falsely communicated.
- 46:29That's what they did.
- 46:29I'm here to represent my own positions,
- 46:31which many Jews and many Israelis believe in,
- 46:34that we can be able to live together,
- 46:35and the definitions that we have are very,
- 46:37very important because you're saying you're not against the right
- 46:39for the Jewish people to self-determine on the social homeland,
- 46:41which makes you.
- 46:42Not an anti-Zionist,
- 46:43which makes me,
- 46:44no,
- 46:44I am an anti-Zionist.
- 46:45That's not what I believe in Zionism definition exactly.
- 46:47And that's why it's important to what I'm trying the definitions
- 46:49what I'm trying to make you understand that people who are here
- 46:52who say we are a Palestinian is,
- 46:54no,
- 46:54but I'm defining myself.
- 46:55I'm talking about myself.
- 46:57Everybody's here
- 46:58who says I'm anti-Zionist,
- 46:59they are anti-apartheid,
- 47:01anti-genocide,
- 47:02anti-ethnic cleansing,
- 47:03anti the brutal treatment of the Israeli government of the Palestinians,
- 47:07anti-colonization,
- 47:08anti.
- 47:08Confiscating of lands,
- 47:10anti all kinds of racism and inequality
- 47:12that's happening in Palestine to the Palestinians.
- 47:15That's what we define by saying we are anti-Z Zionism.
- 47:18That is not a racist,
- 47:19that's not anti-Semitic,
- 47:20that's nothing that has to do with the Jewish faith.
- 47:22It's all about the actions and the
- 47:24atrocities that the Israeli government is committing.
- 47:26That's what we mean.
- 47:27I'm against apartheid genocide,
- 47:28so you're an an anti-Zionist colonization settlements,
- 47:31which is not good,
- 47:32we are proud of you now,
- 47:33which is not taking place.
- 47:35There,
- 47:35OK.
- 47:36And when you are saying that you're an anti-Zionist,
- 47:38to be anti-something,
- 47:39you have to know what that something is.
- 47:41And as a doctor,
- 47:42as someone who's very intellectual,
- 47:43as someone who lived in this land,
- 47:45has experience,
- 47:45knows other Jews,
- 47:46you should know that Zionism existed before anti-Zionism,
- 47:49and Zionism is the idea that we have
- 47:50a right to self-determine on that ancestral homeland.
- 47:53The way,
- 47:54the way you and your fellow
- 47:55Jewish and Israeli citizens historically and currently,
- 47:57and,
- 47:58and raise the flag of Zionism,
- 48:00that's what makes us.
- 48:01we are anti-Zionist.
- 48:02No,
- 48:02that's what's happened.
- 48:03What I'm telling you now,
- 48:04I'm here right in front of you is that Zionism only means the
- 48:06idea that it should have a right to live in this land,
- 48:08and I'm against the suffering of Palestinians.
- 48:10I'm against everybody else.
- 48:11No,
- 48:11not at the expense.
- 48:12Why are you always blaming the Jews and Israelis as the expense?
- 48:16No,
- 48:17because you see it as a zero-sum game.
- 48:19There's a good guy and there's a bad guy.
- 48:21What about the,
- 48:21what about the communities of Israel that were destroyed?
- 48:23We've got to pause here.
- 48:24We're out of time for this claim.
- 48:26Please return to your,
- 48:27your seats.
- 48:29My final surrounded claim
- 48:31is that Jews are indigenous to the land of Israel.
- 48:34All right,
- 48:34if you would like to be the first debater,
- 48:36get to the seat in 321.
- 48:45Hi,
- 48:45it's nice to meet you.
- 48:46Likewise,
- 48:46how are you?
- 48:47Doing well.
- 48:48Um,
- 48:48yeah,
- 48:48so I'd like to know more about,
- 48:50um,
- 48:51why you believe that and where that comes from.
- 48:54So when I make a claim about the Jewish people,
- 48:56it's never against
- 48:57another population.
- 48:58When I'm saying that the Jews are indigenous to the land of Israel,
- 49:01it's where we come from.
- 49:02If you dig in the land,
- 49:03you find our history.
- 49:04This is the land that our ancestors have come from.
- 49:06We've maintained a constant presence
- 49:08and thankfully we were able to come back to that land freely.
- 49:11Sure,
- 49:11would you identify yourself as a Zionist?
- 49:13So let's say that there are many different thought leaders
- 49:15that were involved in the modern political movement called Zionism,
- 49:19and that there are many different Branches,
- 49:20the right wing Zionism,
- 49:21left wing Zionism,
- 49:22secular Zionism,
- 49:23religious Zionism,
- 49:24even Christian Zionism,
- 49:25which
- 49:25I'm completely against.
- 49:26But the fundamental idea of Zionism,
- 49:28which comes from the word Zion,
- 49:29which means Jerusalem,
- 49:31is the idea that the Jewish people should have a right
- 49:33to self-determine on their ancestral homeland of Judea slash Israel.
- 49:36So do I believe that the Jews should have a right to come back home?
- 49:39Absolutely,
- 49:40I do.
- 49:40Sure.
- 49:41So I was also wondering why,
- 49:43because this is a debate about pro-Palestine versus pro.
- 49:46Israel,
- 49:46I was also wondering why you believe that indigeneity plays a role in pro-Israel,
- 49:52like actions.
- 49:53For sure.
- 49:54So,
- 49:54to define indigeneity first,
- 49:56if the United Nations actually defined it for
- 49:58what is widely accepted in academic spaces,
- 50:01which is that your identity is the pre-colonial identity
- 50:04that was born and rooted to a particular and
- 50:06specific piece of land that is essential to that people's
- 50:09identity and way of life,
- 50:10they've maintained a constant presence.
- 50:12In that land,
- 50:13and they collectively identify with this term.
- 50:15And the reason why it's so important to speak about this
- 50:17is because there are a lot of people who claim to
- 50:19be pro-Palestinian who use Palestinian struggles in order to try to
- 50:22delegitimize my ancestral connection and my rights to live there.
- 50:26So I'm for the right for other people to live there as well.
- 50:29But when people are trying to delegitimize who I am in the collective
- 50:32that belongs here as well,
- 50:33that's when I have a problem.
- 50:34OK,
- 50:35so here's sort of where I'm coming from.
- 50:37From what I understand about Indigeneity,
- 50:38it is a concept,
- 50:39just like
- 50:40intelligence,
- 50:41love,
- 50:42which means that it can be essentially defined by what it is,
- 50:45but not necessarily,
- 50:46it's more difficult to define what it isn't.
- 50:48My understanding of indigeneity that it has relation against colonialism.
- 50:52Also,
- 50:53similarly,
- 50:53my understanding of Zionism is that,
- 50:55especially through settler action,
- 50:57we know that it is a colonial project.
- 50:59So,
- 50:59it's very difficult for me to understand how
- 51:01you can be both indigenous and the colonizer.
- 51:04So I look at Zionism as an anti-colonial movement,
- 51:07a movement that the previous colonizers that were here were the British,
- 51:10firstly being the Romans that colonized the land,
- 51:12renamed it to Palestine,
- 51:13and kicked out the majority of the Jewish people.
- 51:16Then we have the Byzantine Empire,
- 51:17we have the caliphates,
- 51:18we have the Ottomans,
- 51:19and eventually we have the British.
- 51:20Does that have any say on the Jewish Palestinians who exist,
- 51:23who are not afforded full citizenship?
- 51:26What happens to them?
- 51:27Because Palestinians are a monolith and we understand.
- 51:30Not receiving full citizenship.
- 51:31And well,
- 51:32if you're a Palestinian,
- 51:33then you don't have full citizenship in the state of Israel,
- 51:35right?
- 51:35So we're talking about now the consequences have happened after
- 51:38the British were here and the way the British colonized.
- 51:40Do you think that,
- 51:41let me just,
- 51:41do you think that their citizenship is a direct action of the British?
- 51:45No,
- 51:45I think that the division of the land is a
- 51:47direct consequence of what the British did to our populations.
- 51:50Let me explain where that comes from.
- 51:51OK,
- 51:52we have to pause there.
- 51:53You've been voted out by the majority.
- 51:54Please return to your getting good.
- 52:01Hello.
- 52:01Hi,
- 52:02how are you?
- 52:02I'm good.
- 52:03How are you?
- 52:03Good,
- 52:03good.
- 52:04So I wanna start with,
- 52:05um,
- 52:06something I wrote that you said.
- 52:07You said
- 52:08return of the people to the land and indigeneity is pre-colonial identity.
- 52:13You were identifying.
- 52:14The Jews being indigenous,
- 52:16and that's why they
- 52:17were not practicing colonialism.
- 52:19It's,
- 52:20it was pre-colonial.
- 52:21Would you agree with how I described your sentiments?
- 52:23So the idea that the Jews should have a right
- 52:24to return to their ancestral homeland is a decolonization movement,
- 52:28not a colonization movement.
- 52:29Now we can criticize certain policies the government has,
- 52:32the IDF has,
- 52:32and I might even agree with certain things.
- 52:34There's a lot of criticism that I have of the current structure,
- 52:37but by its nature,
- 52:38it is an anti-colonial decolonization movement.
- 52:40So there are
- 52:42words.
- 52:43Hebrew that were used pre the creation of the state of Israel,
- 52:46that mean to settle,
- 52:48to colonize.
- 52:49And they were used in the correspondence of Ben-Gurion,
- 52:52De Lehi,
- 52:52and it was very clear that they were using language.
- 52:55It's to settle,
- 52:56to colonize.
- 52:57If they believed themselves to not be colonizers,
- 53:00why were they directly using this language back then?
- 53:02Back then,
- 53:03what that term meant was development of land.
- 53:05So if you read Hertzl's writing,
- 53:07he talks about that the native inhabitants are the Jewish people.
- 53:10There are other Inhabitants,
- 53:11what we call today as Palestinians who live there,
- 53:14and we should live together with them,
- 53:15and the use of the term colonization then,
- 53:17because obviously today it's not a popular word,
- 53:19we're all against this idea,
- 53:20then meant development of the land.
- 53:22So you have to also understand the context in which words are being used,
- 53:25because words are sounds coming out of our mouths and
- 53:27the meanings recognize that right now because the world,
- 53:31the West has now recognized that colonialism is bad,
- 53:34we are saying,
- 53:35oh,
- 53:35we don't identify with that language.
- 53:37That language meant something back then,
- 53:38and it was used for.
- 53:40reason,
- 53:40and it means you dissociating,
- 53:42you dissociating yourself or Israel dissociating
- 53:44itself from that language does not erase
- 53:46the preconditions that it existed,
- 53:48the plan that it was trying to achieve.
- 53:50The plan that it was trying to achieve is
- 53:51to bring back sovereignty to the indigenous population.
- 53:54When you dig in this line,
- 53:54you find Jewish history.
- 53:56This is where we come from.
- 53:57Now,
- 53:57there are individuals that use the term
- 53:59colonization because then it was very popular,
- 54:01and it didn't mean go and exploit another population,
- 54:04take away their resources,
- 54:05exploit it back to a motherland.
- 54:06That's not what it meant,
- 54:07and that's what it.
- 54:08Today
- 54:08and so back then it meant the development of land.
- 54:11We both agree development of land is exactly
- 54:13colonial language and it's being used today consistently.
- 54:16This language,
- 54:16if you are an indigenous person and you want to develop your land,
- 54:18that's not colonization.
- 54:20It is colonization or not colonization people existed in that
- 54:22land prior to you going to develop that land,
- 54:25they are also indigenous Jews had a constant,
- 54:26the Jews had a constant presence,
- 54:28and I didn't make an argument against Palestinian have a concept.
- 54:30I'm not making an argument against Palestinians.
- 54:32I'm making an argument that the Jews with Palest inindigenous Arabs,
- 54:35with Christ.
- 54:36For that,
- 54:37and they existed for that coexistence to development meant erasing all of that,
- 54:41meant erasing their identity of indigeneity as well.
- 54:43It was just Jewish in what I was saying,
- 54:45Jewish supremacy.
- 54:46This is what I was saying in my previous point.
- 54:48OK.
- 54:48The way that the British colonized every
- 54:50single region is they divided and conquered.
- 54:52We can see the consequence of that between Pakistan and India.
- 54:55We can see that in Afghanistan.
- 54:56We can see that in Nigeria,
- 54:57between the Igbos,
- 54:58the House of Fulani,
- 54:59and the Yoruba,
- 55:00and we can see that absolutely where they convinced the Israeli
- 55:04population.
- 55:04Palestinians,
- 55:05the Arabs and Muslims were all their enemies holed up,
- 55:07and they convinced the Palestinian Arabs that the
- 55:09Jews were just an extension of European colonialism,
- 55:11which you're falling into.
- 55:12And unfortunately we fought a war in 1948 for which I was not there,
- 55:16and the consequences of that war and the several wars
- 55:18that happened after is the situation that we're in today.
- 55:20So you're saying that the British had a plan of colonization and that Ben-Gurion,
- 55:25Herzl,
- 55:25and every person,
- 55:27or Shamir,
- 55:28the leader of Lehi,
- 55:29who actually reached out to Hitler to work with Hitler.
- 55:33To
- 55:34start,
- 55:34you're,
- 55:34you're laughing.
- 55:35Maybe you're not familiar with it.
- 55:36I'm very familiar with the with the Zionists reaching
- 55:38out to the Nazis in order to get them
- 55:40to let the Jews leave so that they wouldn't
- 55:42kill the leader who became the prime minister of Israel
- 55:46had correspondents reached out to Hitler and asked
- 55:50for my enemy to work with me
- 55:51to take over the land of Palestine,
- 55:53to take over the ones controlling the mandate of Palestine at that time,
- 55:58not,
- 55:58not the Nazis,
- 55:59the legs,
- 56:00the Lehis were willing.
- 56:01To work with the Nazis,
- 56:02they were not willing to work.
- 56:04They were trying to get their people out of what was being controlled by the Nazis.
- 56:07If you have a hostage taken by,
- 56:10if you have someone that takes a hostage,
- 56:11you're going to negotiate with them to get them out of there.
- 56:14So the Zionists,
- 56:14wait,
- 56:15let me finish my point because I'll let you finish.
- 56:16I just want to ask,
- 56:17you didn't let me finish.
- 56:17You were speaking the entire time.
- 56:19You asked the question and I get to answer.
- 56:20OK.
- 56:21You talked about the fact that the Zionists
- 56:23had relations and contact with the Nazis.
- 56:25This is true.
- 56:26The Nazis had colonized and not colonized,
- 56:28occupied.
- 56:29Yes,
- 56:30the Nazis had occupied the European area
- 56:33and the Jews were under their authority.
- 56:35So the Zionists wanted to get the Jews out of there so that they wouldn't be killed.
- 56:38No,
- 56:40I'm talking about the Nazis in Europe.
- 56:42They had taken control over Europe,
- 56:44and the Jews realized that they would be killed.
- 56:46So the Zionists tried to negotiate
- 56:48to get the Jews out.
- 56:49This has nothing to do.
- 56:50You're mixing a whole bunch of things to come to.
- 56:54Sorry,
- 56:54we have to pause.
- 56:55You've been voted out by the majority.
- 56:56Please return to your seat.
- 57:06So it sounds like a lot of what you're seeing is revisionist history.
- 57:10It's actually so funny that you call Zionism a decolonial movement.
- 57:15When you needed the Zionists needed the sponsor
- 57:17of a colonial empire like the British and today
- 57:21cannot exist
- 57:22without a settler colonial state and an empire like the United States.
- 57:26Without these two things,
- 57:28that project would not have been possible.
- 57:30There's a reason why Theodore Hertzl had to petition to the Ottomans,
- 57:33to other European powers until the Balfour Declaration was issued.
- 57:37And if you look at that declaration,
- 57:39out of the 28 articles in there,
- 57:4177 of them focused on the rights of Jews
- 57:44and didn't even mention the word Palestinians,
- 57:46it mentioned
- 57:47the non-Jewish population.
- 57:49And with that revisionist history,
- 57:51why do we forget about the Arab revolt in 1936,
- 57:54which the British squashed while they let
- 57:57the Zionists develop their own proto-state.
- 57:59They had arms,
- 58:00they had a paramilitary,
- 58:01they had a parliament.
- 58:02Palestinians weren't allowed to have that,
- 58:04and if they did,
- 58:05it was squashed.
- 58:06So you can't just say
- 58:08colonization is just words.
- 58:10Logically,
- 58:11that's colonization.
- 58:12There's no one denying that there is a Jewish history in Palestine.
- 58:15No one is saying that Jews can't or shouldn't live there.
- 58:18But there's a difference between coming
- 58:20and living and coexisting versus coming and drawing borders and maintaining it
- 58:25through guns,
- 58:26through iron walls,
- 58:27which Jabatinsky mentioned.
- 58:29That doesn't sound indigenous.
- 58:30And speaking of indigeneity,
- 58:32if you are so indigenous or you claim to be indigenous,
- 58:35why
- 58:35did they bomb the orange trees in Jaffa,
- 58:38just as you see the olive trees being burned in the West Bank.
- 58:41And with all of that said as well,
- 58:43why are the houses that were destroyed,
- 58:45if you were so
- 58:46decolonial,
- 58:47why were they destroyed and rebuilt with European style architecture?
- 58:51Why do many Israelis participate in Eurovision?
- 58:53Why do they identify more with Europe?
- 58:55That doesn't sound indigenous to me,
- 58:56a lot of questions.
- 58:57Let me try to answer.
- 58:57So first of all,
- 58:58Salam Alekramatala Barakatu Mohammed,
- 59:00it's nice to meet you.
- 59:01I'm glad to be able to speak.
- 59:03You're funny.
- 59:03It's the truth,
- 59:04you know,
- 59:04I'm from that land,
- 59:05OK?
- 59:06We are,
- 59:06we're both actually from this land,
- 59:08and I don't hate you.
- 59:09And the idea of,
- 59:09the idea of me,
- 59:10the.
- 59:10The idea of me greeting you respectfully is something that is
- 59:14clearly making you laugh
- 59:15because it's uncomfortable or it's new,
- 59:17and I think that there's,
- 59:18it doesn't shock me.
- 59:18Let me,
- 59:18let me finish my saying.
- 59:20I think there's a new generation that's being formed that
- 59:22live in the land that recognize each other's suffering,
- 59:24identity,
- 59:25and want to build something further.
- 59:26Now let me be able to answer your claim the suffering is.
- 59:29I'll let you go off on like 3 minutes of many different claims.
- 59:32I'm going to try to get back to all of them.
- 59:33There's a lot that you said there.
- 59:34So first of all,
- 59:35why is it an
- 59:36anti-colonial decolonization movement like we said,
- 59:40the Original
- 59:42population,
- 59:42the first peoples of the land are the Hebrews slash the Judeans,
- 59:45slash the Israelites.
- 59:47We were colonized by the Roman Empire.
- 59:49They renamed our land Palestine.
- 59:51It is a foreign term that actually came from the Philistines
- 59:54that were a pre-Greek population from the island of Greece,
- 59:57not actually the ancient population that you come from,
- 1:00:00because actually most Palestinians descend from Jews that
- 1:00:03were converted to Christianity and Islam over time,
- 1:00:05mixed in with other Arabs who poured in,
- 1:00:07who created the post-colonial identity called Palestine.
- 1:00:10In now I see Palestinians as native to the land,
- 1:00:12as having a right to the land.
- 1:00:14Now what happens with the British colonizing the area?
- 1:00:17They forced our peoples to see each other as enemies.
- 1:00:20And why did they write the Balfour Declaration?
- 1:00:21They wrote that in order to give the impression to the Arab world,
- 1:00:25including the local Palestinians,
- 1:00:26to think that the idea of Zionism was an extension of European colonialism.
- 1:00:29And by the way that you're speaking,
- 1:00:32they still did their job.
- 1:00:33And the same way many Israelis or Jews think that all Palestinians,
- 1:00:36all Muslims,
- 1:00:37all Arabs are a bunch of terrorists.
- 1:00:39would show that the British did their job.
- 1:00:41Why?
- 1:00:41Because they appointed Hajmin al Husseini,
- 1:00:43the Grand Mufti in Jerusalem,
- 1:00:44who actually met with Hitler,
- 1:00:46who was great friends,
- 1:00:47diatribe,
- 1:00:47who was great friends with Hitler.
- 1:00:49This was not a person that was appointed by the Palestinians.
- 1:00:52This was a person that was appointed by the British.
- 1:00:54Why?
- 1:00:55Because they wanted to convince both of our peoples
- 1:00:57that we were extensions of each other's demise.
- 1:00:59Now
- 1:01:00why did Herzl and other individuals reach out to the Ottomans?
- 1:01:03Cause the Ottomans were controlling the land at the time.
- 1:01:05Of course,
- 1:01:05if there's a colonizer,
- 1:01:07you would try to negotiate to try to.
- 1:01:09Get your land back.
- 1:01:09And when the British eventually took that land,
- 1:01:11well,
- 1:01:12they tried to speak with the British.
- 1:01:13The fact that you can go and criticize certain things that were done wrong
- 1:01:17during war of
- 1:01:18orange trees being destroyed or homes being uprooted or a certain style,
- 1:01:21I mean,
- 1:01:21you're speaking that's not war,
- 1:01:22that's that's destruction.
- 1:01:24Let me.
- 1:01:25You're everything you just said is,
- 1:01:26let me,
- 1:01:26let me,
- 1:01:27let me finish my point.
- 1:01:28That you're debunked you're speaking in English.
- 1:01:30I wouldn't say that because you're speaking in
- 1:01:31English that you're not from that land.
- 1:01:32So because a lot of Jews had an experience here,
- 1:01:35a lot of Jews had an experience in Europe and came back which was not.
- 1:01:38Knowing,
- 1:01:39I didn't say it's your fault.
- 1:01:40Knowing architecture,
- 1:01:41you just knowing,
- 1:01:43knowing architecture because he met with Hitler,
- 1:01:44we have to be blamed for that.
- 1:01:45It makes no sense.
- 1:01:46I did not blame you.
- 1:01:47I did not blame you for anything.
- 1:01:48So why did you bring it up?
- 1:01:49Knowing architecture,
- 1:01:50because this is exactly what the British did in
- 1:01:52order to make the perception of the Jewish people
- 1:01:55being that everyone like Hajj Main al Husseini
- 1:01:58supports Hitler and wants to kill Jews.
- 1:01:59And what I'm saying is that not all Palestinians believe that.
- 1:02:01And this is what we have to break free.
- 1:02:03Now.
- 1:02:03You talked about the architecture,
- 1:02:04really.
- 1:02:05I mean,
- 1:02:05a lot of the Jews had an experience in Europe,
- 1:02:07so that was the architecture.
- 1:02:08That they had access to where they're from.
- 1:02:09That's where they had an experience in.
- 1:02:11That's where they're from genetically,
- 1:02:12historically,
- 1:02:13anthropologically.
- 1:02:13So why are they not allowing DNA tests in Israel.
- 1:02:16They do allow DNA test in Israel.
- 1:02:17That's a DNA company called My Heritage,
- 1:02:19which is an Israeli company.
- 1:02:20They don't allow certain companies that go and sell your information.
- 1:02:23That's the difference.
- 1:02:24These are anti-Semitic points that you read on Reddit or somewhere online,
- 1:02:27but there are DNA companies that are based in Israel.
- 1:02:29Look up my heritage,
- 1:02:30you know,
- 1:02:31fact check this.
- 1:02:31There are DNA companies in Israel.
- 1:02:33There's no problem with doing DNA.
- 1:02:34And if you do DNA on Ashkenazi Jews,
- 1:02:36which aren't even the majority of the.
- 1:02:37Population of Jews in this land,
- 1:02:39it is completely descendants from the land of Israel.
- 1:02:42We had experiences externally just like you were born in America.
- 1:02:45The fact that you were born outside,
- 1:02:46I wouldn't say that you come from anywhere else other
- 1:02:48than the land that me and you both belong to.
- 1:02:49Ethnically,
- 1:02:50my parents and grandparents were born in Palestine.
- 1:02:53My grandfather's cousin's house 2 days ago,
- 1:02:55do you know what happened to it?
- 1:02:562 days ago from when we recorded this,
- 1:02:58it was destroyed
- 1:02:59by American funded bulldozers
- 1:03:02on his house.
- 1:03:03You talk about,
- 1:03:04oh,
- 1:03:04there has to be a future with our Palestinian cousins.
- 1:03:06What future when you.
- 1:03:07Destroying my grandpa's cousin's house where 24 people were living in that house.
- 1:03:11Where are they supposed to go now?
- 1:03:13Where are they?
- 1:03:13Tell me,
- 1:03:13where,
- 1:03:13where do you want them to go if you want a future with this,
- 1:03:15where do you want them to go?
- 1:03:16That is a colonial tactic to destroy a home and uproot it,
- 1:03:21and then who knows what's going to happen.
- 1:03:22It'll be rebuilt by someone else because that has been the end goal of Zionism,
- 1:03:26which is to have as few Palestinians as possible with as many Jews as possible.
- 1:03:31That might be the goal of some Zionists.
- 1:03:32No,
- 1:03:32that's not,
- 1:03:33that's not Zionism spectrum,
- 1:03:34left wing,
- 1:03:35right wing.
- 1:03:36You're speaking,
- 1:03:36it's a fact.
- 1:03:37spectrum speaking to me at this spectrum of fascism.
- 1:03:39No,
- 1:03:39it's a spectrum of decolonization,
- 1:03:40and it's in any form of decolonization in any population,
- 1:03:43there are individuals that are bad individuals.
- 1:03:45Now I don't know what happened to your family,
- 1:03:46and I'm sorry that that happened.
- 1:03:47It's on my Instagram.
- 1:03:48Anybody could watch it.
- 1:03:49Sure,
- 1:03:49so you came and destroyed someone's house,
- 1:03:51not me.
- 1:03:52They destroyed someone's house.
- 1:03:53That's a very important thing because the whole entire
- 1:03:54time you're saying you all about things that no,
- 1:03:56it's not exactly,
- 1:03:57it's not all about me.
- 1:03:58And it's not all about you're wearing is not a cultural and what
- 1:04:00our ancestors wore long before Palestinians actually
- 1:04:04took it from the Iraqi population.
- 1:04:06We wore.
- 1:04:06Like it wasn't always there and you just added the Hebrew
- 1:04:09and all of that to suras for thousands of years.
- 1:04:11The Druze have it,
- 1:04:12the Bedouin have it.
- 1:04:13A lot of Middle Easterners have
- 1:04:15their sura or kaffiyeh,
- 1:04:16different words under different languages that represents our
- 1:04:19culture and our connection to this land.
- 1:04:20And if you were wearing a kaffiyeh,
- 1:04:22I would seize you as a cousin.
- 1:04:23I would see you as an ally,
- 1:04:25not being you saw me as a cousin,
- 1:04:26you wouldn't be building walls.
- 1:04:27You wouldn't be destroying my grandfather's house,
- 1:04:29not you.
- 1:04:30Now people you are defending would not be doing that.
- 1:04:32Let me talk about destruction of homes.
- 1:04:34There are two reasons as to why.
- 1:04:36There's no justification for any destruction.
- 1:04:39There is no justification for occupation.
- 1:04:42There is no justification.
- 1:04:43It happens for none of it as well.
- 1:04:45Whenever a house,
- 1:04:45I don't know your situation,
- 1:04:47so I'm not going to speak on yours.
- 1:04:48Whenever a house,
- 1:04:48there's thousands more like,
- 1:04:50whenever a house is built illegally on a territory that they do not,
- 1:04:53this is a settler narrative.
- 1:04:54This is a settler narrative.
- 1:04:55Homes have also been destroy You don't have a
- 1:04:57right to illegally who determines who owns what land?
- 1:04:59Who determines that?
- 1:05:00There's the Palestinian Authority and there's the Israeli government,
- 1:05:02which are all byproducts law in this land.
- 1:05:05If you was created by white European colonizers if you were to
- 1:05:09go into the home of another Palestinian and build up a house,
- 1:05:12that house would get removed.
- 1:05:13If a Jew goes into your house,
- 1:05:15that's not what's happening.
- 1:05:15If a Jew that goes not what's happening.
- 1:05:17The house has been built there,
- 1:05:18a house.
- 1:05:18My family has been there for generations.
- 1:05:20Jews and Palestinians who build illegally,
- 1:05:23their house gets removed.
- 1:05:24See,
- 1:05:24even the term legal define.
- 1:05:26Another addition.
- 1:05:27If you morality,
- 1:05:28if it's not the same legality own the property,
- 1:05:30do not own the property.
- 1:05:31OK,
- 1:05:31pause here.
- 1:05:32You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:05:33Please return to your seat.
- 1:05:43I like your keffiya.
- 1:05:45Thank you.
- 1:05:46It's really nice.
- 1:05:48Taken from my culture.
- 1:05:50OK,
- 1:05:51so can you talk to me about this idea that you have of you being indigenous?
- 1:05:55Um,
- 1:05:56do you believe in the Torah?
- 1:05:58OK,
- 1:05:58wonderful.
- 1:05:59So in the Torah,
- 1:06:00it talks about how the Israelites went to the land of Canaan.
- 1:06:05Do you agree with that?
- 1:06:06And in the Torah,
- 1:06:07it talks about how
- 1:06:08the Israelites shall go to Canaan and slay
- 1:06:11the.
- 1:06:12People there with the sword and then take over that land.
- 1:06:15Do you agree with that?
- 1:06:16OK,
- 1:06:17so in the Torah,
- 1:06:17it talks about Abraham,
- 1:06:19who came from the land of Ur,
- 1:06:21not from the land of Canaan.
- 1:06:22Canaan is modern day Palestine.
- 1:06:24So if I,
- 1:06:25a Palestinian,
- 1:06:26take a DNA test,
- 1:06:27which I have,
- 1:06:29my DNA comes back almost entirely Canaanite.
- 1:06:32OK?
- 1:06:33If an Ashkenazi Jew takes that same DNA test,
- 1:06:36their DNA comes back entirely European.
- 1:06:39So talk to me about.
- 1:06:41How you think this is an indigenous,
- 1:06:43your people are indigenous.
- 1:06:44So I love how you brought up the Torah.
- 1:06:46And so since we're using the Torah,
- 1:06:47let's go from the beginning.
- 1:06:48OK.
- 1:06:49So you have Noah,
- 1:06:50Noah,
- 1:06:51who has the ark and has several children.
- 1:06:53One of those children is called Shem.
- 1:06:55Shem becomes the father of the Semites,
- 1:06:57right?
- 1:06:57All the Semitic peoples are descendants from Shem.
- 1:06:59Then there's another son called Ham.
- 1:07:01Ham has eventually a descendant called Kanaan,
- 1:07:03who was born in Africa.
- 1:07:05Eventually the Canaanites descend from Africans who were living at that region.
- 1:07:09The Canaanites eventually take the land of
- 1:07:11the descendants of Shem,
- 1:07:12which are the Hebrews.
- 1:07:14The descendant of Shem is Ever.
- 1:07:15The descendants of Ever are the Iram,
- 1:07:17the Hebrews.
- 1:07:18The Canaanites actually take the land of the Hebrews,
- 1:07:21which causes the Hebrews to be displaced.
- 1:07:23That is why Abraham is born in displacement.
- 1:07:25He's actually the first Zionist.
- 1:07:27He's the first Jew returning to his ancestral homeland and being able to live there,
- 1:07:31but doesn't yet have control over the land because the Canaanites still control.
- 1:07:34Fast forward two generations later to the 12 tribes with Joseph.
- 1:07:38They end up in Egypt,
- 1:07:39they spend time in slavery,
- 1:07:40and eventually hold up and eventually they come back again to their
- 1:07:43ancestral indigenous land of the Hebrews that the Canaanites had taken over.
- 1:07:47And then there are 3 conditions for the Canaanites.
- 1:07:49Either you live with the rule of law,
- 1:07:51you fight us,
- 1:07:52or you leave.
- 1:07:53Some left,
- 1:07:53some decided to live with the rule of law of accepting the seven laws of Noah,
- 1:07:57no idolatry,
- 1:07:58no killing,
- 1:07:58no stealing,
- 1:07:59no immoral sex act,
- 1:08:00and those who didn't went into war.
- 1:08:02So now you talked about DNA.
- 1:08:04There's no such thing really as Canaanite DNA.
- 1:08:06Found
- 1:08:08individual.
- 1:08:08Let me,
- 1:08:08let me,
- 1:08:09let me just,
- 1:08:09no,
- 1:08:09no,
- 1:08:09no,
- 1:08:10the,
- 1:08:10the,
- 1:08:10the source is not factual source.
- 1:08:12I everything is you go on and this non-factual Jubilee will source
- 1:08:16all of those facts for us and for all the people listening.
- 1:08:18I'll let you they're gonna that.
- 1:08:20There's no such thing as DNA.
- 1:08:21No,
- 1:08:21I didn't say there's no such thing as Canaanite DNA.
- 1:08:24OK,
- 1:08:24OK,
- 1:08:24so let me,
- 1:08:25yes,
- 1:08:25let me explain
- 1:08:26how a DNA test would you say that I am canaanite you find descendant,
- 1:08:30descending from Canaan what I'm gonna answer where
- 1:08:33Palestinians.
- 1:08:33That's exactly what I'm going to answer.
- 1:08:35Look into the ground and you find bones.
- 1:08:38They are assuming that this is not a Hebrew population,
- 1:08:40that this is a Canaanite population.
- 1:08:41Why?
- 1:08:42Because people are using the Torah and saying,
- 1:08:43oh,
- 1:08:44before it was the land of the Hebrews,
- 1:08:46it was Canaanites,
- 1:08:47but before it was Canaanites,
- 1:08:48it was the land of the Hebrews.
- 1:08:50So people are assuming that the DNA found in that area has to be Canaanites.
- 1:08:53Now it might be that you descend from that population that had come into the
- 1:08:56land and taken the land of Hebrews and were idolaters and actually horrible people,
- 1:09:00right?
- 1:09:01You have a Samson and Delilah.
- 1:09:03I'm Palestinian.
- 1:09:04I'm descended,
- 1:09:05descending from horrible people.
- 1:09:06I'm not saying that you're a descendant of horrible people.
- 1:09:08You're intentionally putting words in order to try to demonize me.
- 1:09:11What I'm saying about my,
- 1:09:11what did you say about the Cannonite?
- 1:09:13If you did your DNA,
- 1:09:13I think your DNA would actually come Jewish,
- 1:09:15the same way that the Jews who had an experience in Europe comes up Jewish.
- 1:09:19I agree with you that my ancestors are Jewish,
- 1:09:21correct?
- 1:09:22Correct.
- 1:09:23So
- 1:09:23what you are saying,
- 1:09:24that you have a territorial claim to the land of Israel,
- 1:09:28is basically like someone from,
- 1:09:31let's say America or a.
- 1:09:32White man from Europe
- 1:09:34converts to Islam.
- 1:09:35He converts,
- 1:09:36he's a Muslim now
- 1:09:37and then he says,
- 1:09:38OK,
- 1:09:38so
- 1:09:39in this land,
- 1:09:40there have been Muslims for generations.
- 1:09:42I'm going to go to this land.
- 1:09:44I am Muslim,
- 1:09:45and it is my land now.
- 1:09:47OK?
- 1:09:47So just because you are of a religion
- 1:09:51does not mean that all of your descendants have that DNA
- 1:09:54and are from that land,
- 1:09:56right?
- 1:09:57So yes,
- 1:09:57my ancestors were Jewish.
- 1:09:59They are my ancestors and they.
- 1:10:01Came from that land.
- 1:10:02I have similar DNA to them,
- 1:10:05but if someone in Europe
- 1:10:07is Jewish,
- 1:10:07that does not suddenly make them indigenous.
- 1:10:10I appreciate the point.
- 1:10:11I'm glad that we changed from you being Canaanite
- 1:10:13to originally being descendants of the Jewish people,
- 1:10:14because that's more accurate.
- 1:10:15But let me,
- 1:10:16let me,
- 1:10:16let me explain.
- 1:10:18To be a Jew is a descendant of an ancient civilization.
- 1:10:20Even if you don't believe in God and the Torah,
- 1:10:22you're still a Jew.
- 1:10:23And in order to the Torah,
- 1:10:24in order in Hebrews,
- 1:10:25and in order to become a Jew,
- 1:10:27you have to go through years of the process of adopting an identity.
- 1:10:30History of culture,
- 1:10:31yes,
- 1:10:31generations,
- 1:10:32generations,
- 1:10:32thousands of years.
- 1:10:33Now the,
- 1:10:34the Jews in Europe,
- 1:10:35which is not the majority of the Jewish people even in
- 1:10:38the land of Israel,
- 1:10:39the Jews who live in Europe had an external experience.
- 1:10:43They do not,
- 1:10:43they are not converts from Europe.
- 1:10:45They are indigenous people who went to Europe.
- 1:10:47When does it end though?
- 1:10:48If you look at other indigenous populations,
- 1:10:51Tibetans,
- 1:10:51Yazidis,
- 1:10:52Kurds,
- 1:10:52Native Americans,
- 1:10:53when a population comes from,
- 1:10:55pause,
- 1:10:56we're out of time,
- 1:10:57and so let's move on.
- 1:10:58Thank you.
- 1:11:01My next surrounded claim is that Zionism is not colonization,
- 1:11:04it is decolonization.
- 1:11:06All right,
- 1:11:06if you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:11:08get to the chair in 321.
- 1:11:15Rudy,
- 1:11:16I respect your ability to have a calm demeanor,
- 1:11:19and I think that your patience can do well for an Instagram career.
- 1:11:22I just don't understand how you can look someone in the face
- 1:11:26whose family's home has been bulldozed by the IOF
- 1:11:29and tell him that you see him as a.
- 1:11:30Cousin,
- 1:11:31that is just
- 1:11:32insane.
- 1:11:33Um,
- 1:11:33and,
- 1:11:33and I want you to be able to explain to that how you rationalize
- 1:11:37the incongruity of saying that you are here to protect people
- 1:11:40that are indigenous and living in the land
- 1:11:43while whitewashing and carrying water for a genocidal regime.
- 1:11:46So the same way that there are many Palestinians who've killed
- 1:11:49family members of mine,
- 1:11:51people of mine,
- 1:11:51I don't see all Palestinians as responsible for that.
- 1:11:54So if he's going to criticize a policy that was done against his family,
- 1:11:57I don't know the particular case that happen is against his family,
- 1:11:59but it sounds horrible.
- 1:12:01I can recognize that that's something horrible and still
- 1:12:03be able to see him as my family.
- 1:12:05What you've currently associated is that anyone who is pro-Israel
- 1:12:07and believes that the Jews have a right to self-determine
- 1:12:10must mean that they're anti-Palestinian,
- 1:12:11and that is what has been plaguing us from
- 1:12:13Able to move forward because I see Palestinians as my family.
- 1:12:16I support the rights to live in this land
- 1:12:18as equal citizens of this land.
- 1:12:20I want to believe that.
- 1:12:21I want to believe that those are your genuine feelings.
- 1:12:23I really do.
- 1:12:24I'm not going to sit here and criticize your own personal morals or ideology,
- 1:12:27but what I will say is the regime that you are justifying does not believe that.
- 1:12:31They do not see the humanity in the people that they bomb indiscriminately.
- 1:12:34I've experienced the tactics of the IDF,
- 1:12:37not because I've stepped foot in Israel or Gaza or the West Bank.
- 1:12:40But because
- 1:12:41ICE agents right now are currently being trained by the
- 1:12:43IOF on the tactics to use against civilian populations.
- 1:12:46They might have different uniforms,
- 1:12:48but the ideology is exactly the same.
- 1:12:50You permanently call an entire population
- 1:12:52a security threat,
- 1:12:53you militarize enforcement,
- 1:12:55and then you demand that those citizens are detained
- 1:12:57or removed
- 1:12:59in order to show the,
- 1:13:00the full force of that regime,
- 1:13:01whether that is Israel,
- 1:13:02whether that's the United States.
- 1:13:04So,
- 1:13:04when,
- 1:13:04when I'm seeing that done to my neighbors domestically.
- 1:13:06Whether that's migrants or citizens that are being killed in the street,
- 1:13:09or I see that in a Palestinian that is under rubble from Israeli bombs,
- 1:13:14I feel that sense that
- 1:13:16I,
- 1:13:16I,
- 1:13:16I know what humanity looks like.
- 1:13:18And when I see
- 1:13:19people who defend Israel tell me to not believe my own eyes,
- 1:13:22when I'm watching videos constantly scrolling
- 1:13:24of babies being murdered,
- 1:13:26I cannot sit here
- 1:13:27and say that you believe what you say
- 1:13:29when you say that Israel is having their best interests in mind.
- 1:13:32Sure,
- 1:13:32so there's plenty of.
- 1:13:33Agreements that I have with the Israeli government.
- 1:13:35I don't know one Israeli that doesn't
- 1:13:36disagree with aspects of the Israeli government,
- 1:13:38and we can go into those details.
- 1:13:40You said that Israel is indiscriminately bombing Palestinians.
- 1:13:42That is not true.
- 1:13:43What we see,
- 1:13:44that is not.
- 1:13:45I let you finish their statement.
- 1:13:46I just,
- 1:13:47I don't know how to allow you to just say lies like as an Israeli,
- 1:13:50OK,
- 1:13:50who served in the army,
- 1:13:52who was brought back in the reserves and was in Gaza,
- 1:13:55in Lebanon,
- 1:13:55in Syria,
- 1:13:56doing my best to prevent us from fighting and to stop the situation from continuing.
- 1:14:00Continuing,
- 1:14:00it is not true what you're saying.
- 1:14:02What you saw is Instagram reels.
- 1:14:04What you saw is videos on,
- 1:14:05on YouTube.
- 1:14:06And yes,
- 1:14:06there were horrible situations where civilians died,
- 1:14:09and that's my family.
- 1:14:10Those are my cousins that have perished due to this conflict.
- 1:14:13And that's why it gives us a greater responsibility.
- 1:14:14I'll let you finish.
- 1:14:15It gives us a greater responsibility to correct what happened,
- 1:14:18but Israel does not indiscriminately bomb.
- 1:14:20It sends leaflets,
- 1:14:21it calls phones,
- 1:14:22it does everything that it can to prevent civilians dying,
- 1:14:25right?
- 1:14:25How many long before they bomb?
- 1:14:27Hospital or how long before they bomb a school.
- 1:14:2972 hours.
- 1:14:30I've found leaflets there of 72 hours,
- 1:14:3272 hours to leave your roots in communities before we bomb the shit out of it.
- 1:14:36That's what you're saying right now.
- 1:14:37Unfortunately,
- 1:14:37Hamas has used your area in order to fight from there and
- 1:14:40has stored weapons and are using those weapons to actually attack civilians.
- 1:14:43Let me tell you,
- 1:14:43if there are,
- 1:14:44if there are someone that's robbing a bank
- 1:14:45and they hold up children as human shields,
- 1:14:47I'm gonna say that the police shooting through those
- 1:14:49kids is not something that we can justify.
- 1:14:51So I don't give a fuck what you say about oh we're gonna.
- 1:14:54We should be able to be,
- 1:14:54we should be respectful.
- 1:14:55That's why we have justification to bombing hospitals.
- 1:14:57That is the language of being respectful.
- 1:14:59If we look at the two,
- 1:15:01I said I respect you for it,
- 1:15:02but I can't do it after you're saying this right now.
- 1:15:04But I'm understanding what your motives are when you say that you worked in the IOF.
- 1:15:07There are over 2 million.
- 1:15:09There are over 2 million absolutely would not agreeing with reality.
- 1:15:13The,
- 1:15:13let's just hear the propaganda from the professional propagandist real quick.
- 1:15:16Projection,
- 1:15:16projection.
- 1:15:17Oz.
- 1:15:17We've been,
- 1:15:18you've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:15:19Please return to your seat.
- 1:15:29I'm going to start off with saying if
- 1:15:31historical connection and indigenous roots
- 1:15:35legitimizes trumping sovereignty of nations,
- 1:15:38then modern borders are meaningless,
- 1:15:41and if it doesn't,
- 1:15:42then Zionism is a political
- 1:15:44movement,
- 1:15:45and we have evidence of this as Theodore Herzl himself.
- 1:15:48Is and was an atheist.
- 1:15:50We also have quotes coming from Ben Gurion,
- 1:15:53who said,
- 1:15:53we want to expel the Arabs.
- 1:15:55We also had other people,
- 1:15:56um,
- 1:15:57who have referred to Arabs as rocks that needed to be moved throughout the land of
- 1:16:01Judea.
- 1:16:02I actually have the name of it right now.
- 1:16:05Weitzman.
- 1:16:05I also wanna say.
- 1:16:07That
- 1:16:08we wanted to look at the word of Palestine.
- 1:16:10I know you were like mentioning that this came from the Romans,
- 1:16:12actually Herodotus,
- 1:16:14the father of history,
- 1:16:15mentioned Palestine 8 times.
- 1:16:17It actually comes from a Greek word
- 1:16:18describing the coast.
- 1:16:20So this isn't a term that came from the Romans of colonizing,
- 1:16:23and we actively see
- 1:16:25Zionism.
- 1:16:28Palestine wasn't even the first option.
- 1:16:29Why did the Zionist Sixth Congress
- 1:16:32consider Uganda and Argentina?
- 1:16:34That is a colonial project.
- 1:16:36OK,
- 1:16:36so let me answer to those things because you said a lot of things.
- 1:16:39Herodotus that you're bringing up is a Greek person.
- 1:16:41The pre-Greek population in Crete were the Palestinians.
- 1:16:45So obviously,
- 1:16:46the collective that is now the Greek Empire would
- 1:16:48like to call other territories as part of.
- 1:16:50Their territory and would call that land Palestine.
- 1:16:53But the moment that that land really became called
- 1:16:55Palestine is the moment that the Romans conquered,
- 1:16:57which is,
- 1:16:58which is way,
- 1:16:59which is,
- 1:16:59I'll let you I'll let you finish,
- 1:17:01way after the Greek Empire is the Romans,
- 1:17:03and in order to insult the memory of the Jews they called that name Palestine.
- 1:17:07Why?
- 1:17:07Because that's actually also a Hebrew word which means invaders.
- 1:17:10Now I don't consider you to be an invader,
- 1:17:12but you should know that Pliishtim,
- 1:17:13Palestinian,
- 1:17:14literally in Hebrew.
- 1:17:15means invaders.
- 1:17:16Now you talked about colonization,
- 1:17:17decolonization,
- 1:17:18indigenous populations
- 1:17:19on the territory that was the indigenous population being the Hebrews,
- 1:17:23the Jews,
- 1:17:23the Israelites that was colonized by different empires.
- 1:17:25There was never a country that was built on top of it since.
- 1:17:28It was always in the hand of foreign empires until it was revived
- 1:17:31to being the land of Israel.
- 1:17:32Now I do support indigenous liberations all across the world,
- 1:17:35the Tibetans,
- 1:17:36the Yazidis,
- 1:17:37the Kurds,
- 1:17:37the Aboriginals.
- 1:17:38Now there's
- 1:17:39Different types of indigenous liberations.
- 1:17:41Some populations want a state,
- 1:17:43some populations don't want a state.
- 1:17:44So there was a sovereign state of Palestine.
- 1:17:46There was not a sovereign state of Palestine.
- 1:17:47There was a British mandate of Palestine,
- 1:17:49but there was still not a whore identified themselves as Palestinians.
- 1:17:52Sure,
- 1:17:52I don't have a problem with you identifying yourself as Palestinian.
- 1:17:54So what I'm trying to say is that there were people
- 1:17:58who actually,
- 1:17:58you don't even need
- 1:17:59technically under international law,
- 1:18:01you don't need to have a sovereign state in.
- 1:18:03In order for it to qualify as occupation,
- 1:18:05and occupation can be imposed on people
- 1:18:07who are
- 1:18:08not a part of a sovereignty but of a collective identity who have had,
- 1:18:11as you said earlier,
- 1:18:13a continuous presence on that land.
- 1:18:15I think one of the other continuous presence,
- 1:18:17and so did the Canaanites and the people who converted to.
- 1:18:20I don't want to get into that debate,
- 1:18:21but besides that,
- 1:18:22there are people who have been there continuously,
- 1:18:25and actually there is a.
- 1:18:28Plenty of ways to go about this,
- 1:18:30but there is evidence that prior to 1948 and prior
- 1:18:34to the creation of the modern day state of Israel,
- 1:18:36that there's an incredible influx of people who have converted
- 1:18:40to Judaism,
- 1:18:41for yes,
- 1:18:41there is,
- 1:18:42it's actually from South Africa.
- 1:18:43Multiple people after the fall,
- 1:18:46this they will fact check and it's written in Haaretz
- 1:18:49that they after anti-Israel publication that posts an article,
- 1:18:52you read an article and you.
- 1:18:53I don't want to get into,
- 1:18:54I don't want to get into ad hominem.
- 1:18:55Let's focus on the facts,
- 1:18:57and I'm,
- 1:18:57and to my knowledge,
- 1:18:58it is true,
- 1:18:59and it has been documented pretty well
- 1:19:01that after the fall of a South African apartheid state
- 1:19:04that people converted to Judaism and suddenly had a more legitimate claim.
- 1:19:08The fall of the apartheid state happened way
- 1:19:10after the creation of the state of Israel.
- 1:19:11What are you talking about?
- 1:19:12But I'm just saying that there,
- 1:19:12there's an influx of people that came and converted to the state anyways,
- 1:19:16I want Jews who are returning home.
- 1:19:17They are not Jews who are converting.
- 1:19:18So why don't we have the Palestinian right to return,
- 1:19:20right?
- 1:19:21So,
- 1:19:21OK,
- 1:19:22but how come it hasn't happened?
- 1:19:23And if we had a Palestinian majority,
- 1:19:25I don't think that's,
- 1:19:26that's a great question.
- 1:19:27Why it hasn't happened.
- 1:19:28The reason it hasn't happened is because my population and
- 1:19:30your population are raised to see each other as enemies.
- 1:19:33And when we have conversations,
- 1:19:34it's always the idea of Jewish indigeneity and our access to
- 1:19:37the land and our liberation means the destruction of yours,
- 1:19:39and I'm against the destruction of your people.
- 1:19:41I'm for the idea of your population as well.
- 1:19:44It's earliest founders and it has been documented,
- 1:19:47if they're all about,
- 1:19:48you know,
- 1:19:48returning back home,
- 1:19:50why is every single one of their writing about colonialism?
- 1:19:53Yes,
- 1:19:53it is.
- 1:19:54You could look at Herzl and other individuals spoke about creating
- 1:19:56a civilization with the other inhabitants who were living there.
- 1:19:59Recognize my point about Uganda and Argentina.
- 1:20:01If Palestine,
- 1:20:02if Palestine,
- 1:20:04Palestine was not the only option,
- 1:20:06which goes to show that this is a colonial project because they consider.
- 1:20:09Other states despite not having as strong of a religious claim.
- 1:20:13That's thank you for reminding me of the third claim that you made originally.
- 1:20:15So there were other options.
- 1:20:16It wasn't just Uganda,
- 1:20:17it was Argentina,
- 1:20:18Birobidzhan,
- 1:20:19Angola,
- 1:20:20and Madagascar.
- 1:20:21And this is what the world offered to the Jews,
- 1:20:23not what the Jews wanted.
- 1:20:25The Jews always wanted to go to Jerusalem.
- 1:20:26That's why we pray towards Jerusalem when we get married.
- 1:20:29Let me finish.
- 1:20:29Let me Jerusalem from when we smash the glass,
- 1:20:32I'll answer that after when we smash the glass.
- 1:20:34In our weddings,
- 1:20:35right,
- 1:20:35I'm sure a lot of you have seen movies or have been to a Jewish wedding.
- 1:20:38It represents the destruction of Jerusalem and the promise that
- 1:20:40our kids will return back home and rebuild Jerusalem.
- 1:20:42Now Uganda was proposed to the Jews by Herzl.
- 1:20:45He said,
- 1:20:45Look,
- 1:20:46I know we're being killed right now in Europe,
- 1:20:47and we're about to be killed even more.
- 1:20:49If we don't get to our land right now,
- 1:20:51at least we'll go to Uganda and then we'll go to Israel.
- 1:20:53And the Jews rejected that.
- 1:20:54This was imposed by other people,
- 1:20:56not by what we wanted.
- 1:20:57Zion is in Jerusalem,
- 1:20:59Jerusalem,
- 1:21:00which means to see peace one day we will have peace in this land.
- 1:21:03It means in the Canaanite language from and then
- 1:21:06Shalam like Shalam is the Canaanite god of dusk,
- 1:21:09and that name has been around for centuries,
- 1:21:116000 years.
- 1:21:11Hebrew Ye you will see and Shalem Salom being peace.
- 1:21:14Actually,
- 1:21:15the Hebrew language Ben Yehuda,
- 1:21:16the father,
- 1:21:17father of modern day Hebrew language,
- 1:21:19actually took many words from Arabic to revive that language
- 1:21:22because it has been dead for so many years.
- 1:21:25We were because there was no continuous existence.
- 1:21:27There was continuous was Yiddish Talmud.
- 1:21:29No,
- 1:21:29that's the spoken language.
- 1:21:30There was Ladino,
- 1:21:31there was Judeo.
- 1:21:32Yes,
- 1:21:32there's multiple other ones Creoles spoken day to
- 1:21:35day there was nobrew learned and the Torah.
- 1:21:37We learned Hamud.
- 1:21:38OK,
- 1:21:38then why did they have the JNF to
- 1:21:40to Judify the landscape by planting non-indigenous trees
- 1:21:44all throughout Palestine?
- 1:21:46So is Judifying planting something non-indigenous?
- 1:21:48No,
- 1:21:48no,
- 1:21:48no,
- 1:21:48I'm saying this is according to the JNF.
- 1:21:51They Judified the landscape.
- 1:21:52They took
- 1:21:54committees to go around the Arabic villages of the names and give them
- 1:21:57Hebrew equivalent names the same way Benjamin Netanyahu
- 1:22:00changed his last name.
- 1:22:01From Millikowski to Netanyahu last names are 200 years old.
- 1:22:04Last names are over the past 200 years.
- 1:22:06We did not have last names before.
- 1:22:08It was your name,
- 1:22:09son of your father and of your tribe,
- 1:22:11and there are other Middle Eastern peoples who have a very similar culture to that.
- 1:22:14Last name are new.
- 1:22:15So why did he go from Millikowski to Netanyahu and why did they
- 1:22:17change village names and give them Hebrew equivalent names with the modern Hebrew,
- 1:22:21which is from Arabic to revive revived the name of Israel.
- 1:22:24Like,
- 1:22:24for example,
- 1:22:25Nablus,
- 1:22:26right?
- 1:22:26You know what Nablus comes from?
- 1:22:27It comes from Neopolis,
- 1:22:29which is.
- 1:22:29Greek and Latin,
- 1:22:30which means new city,
- 1:22:31right,
- 1:22:31that the Romans renamed Archem,
- 1:22:34which was the indigenous name to Neopolis.
- 1:22:36So when
- 1:22:37you have certain territories like
- 1:22:40Al Quds going back to Jerusalem,
- 1:22:41which actually is called Jerusalem,
- 1:22:43or Safed going back to Tsvat,
- 1:22:45which is the original name,
- 1:22:46we're actually returning back to our language,
- 1:22:49the language that your ancestors spoke.
- 1:22:52They spoke hold on,
- 1:22:53they,
- 1:22:54no,
- 1:22:54no,
- 1:22:54no,
- 1:22:54Arabic,
- 1:22:55they spoke Aramaic as well.
- 1:22:56I'm OK,
- 1:22:57OK,
- 1:22:57can I get to my.
- 1:22:58Point first Babylon,
- 1:22:59why would they hire a committee to Judify the names of the town
- 1:23:04to if they had such a legitimate claim to it
- 1:23:06and take the equivalent Arabic names and then give it?
- 1:23:09So you're saying that the Arabs didn't decolonize,
- 1:23:11so the Arabs,
- 1:23:11are you saying that the Arabs are colonizers right now,
- 1:23:14colonized the entire Middle East and North Africa,
- 1:23:16the Palest youians do not descend from the Arabs.
- 1:23:18You descend from the same family.
- 1:23:19I would rather you not tell me.
- 1:23:21OK,
- 1:23:21I would rather you not tell me where I come from.
- 1:23:23You're going to deny that?
- 1:23:24No,
- 1:23:24I'm not going to.
- 1:23:25I just don't want to go into that.
- 1:23:26I'd rather focus.
- 1:23:27On the facts,
- 1:23:28I'd rather focus on the fact you're going into ad
- 1:23:30hominem instead of logical hominem would be an attack.
- 1:23:33I'm not attacking you.
- 1:23:34Let's focus right now.
- 1:23:35So we're talking about how
- 1:23:37they had specific committees to try and then
- 1:23:39why would they plant you decolonize the names?
- 1:23:41Why?
- 1:23:42OK,
- 1:23:42so you're saying that the Palestinians who had lived there,
- 1:23:45because you're denying the Nekba right now,
- 1:23:46because the Palestinians lived and called these their homes.
- 1:23:50Tentura was a home.
- 1:23:51OK,
- 1:23:51awesome.
- 1:23:52I'm really glad that you're doing that.
- 1:23:53So Tentura and multiple other cities all.
- 1:23:56Throughout Palestine that the people resonated
- 1:23:58with when they were forcibly displaced,
- 1:24:01as you know,
- 1:24:01750,000 of them.
- 1:24:03Why is it that they built cities on top of them and gave them
- 1:24:07Hebrew equivalent names to the Arab?
- 1:24:09I don't call that decolonization.
- 1:24:10That is textbook
- 1:24:12colonization and trying to legitimize whatever false claim that comes from
- 1:24:16Theodore Herzl and the entire rest of his group.
- 1:24:20And I'd also like to look at one more,
- 1:24:21one more thing.
- 1:24:22I have one more thing at a time.
- 1:24:24Yeah they marketed.
- 1:24:25Marketed Yaffa as the land with no people for the people with no land,
- 1:24:29but this land was abundant with people,
- 1:24:31and Palestinians have consistently been present.
- 1:24:34The Palestinian identity goes way back as well.
- 1:24:37I believe you should have a right to live in this land.
- 1:24:39And if we look at what happened in 1948,
- 1:24:41there were Jewish villages and Palestinian villages that were destroyed.
- 1:24:44That is what happens during war.
- 1:24:46Now all the Palestinian villages that
- 1:24:47were destroyed were Palestinian villages that sided
- 1:24:50with the other Arab armies from the
- 1:24:51surrounding nations around Israel that attacked.
- 1:24:53Israel in 1948 to ethnically cleanse and destroy Israel,
- 1:24:56bringing all the Jews from the river and into the sea.
- 1:24:59There are many Jewish villages that were destroyed as well.
- 1:25:01Most of the village was civilians were innocent,
- 1:25:03so many people were displaced that shouldn't have been displaced.
- 1:25:06Now we need to have a conversation on how to bring them back.
- 1:25:08But you're only talking about when Palestinians are suffering to war.
- 1:25:11I'm talking about when both are suffering to war.
- 1:25:13And when you take the names Arabs,
- 1:25:15Arabs are from Arabs are from Arabia,
- 1:25:19right?
- 1:25:19Jews are from Judea.
- 1:25:20It is very simple.
- 1:25:21Arabic language.
- 1:25:22poured into that land,
- 1:25:23Arabic names poured into that land is not from the land of Israel.
- 1:25:27So,
- 1:25:291948,
- 1:25:29Israel was attacked by all the surrounding Arab countries from Jordan,
- 1:25:33Syria,
- 1:25:34Lebanon,
- 1:25:34and prior to Israel's existence.
- 1:25:36Yeah,
- 1:25:36there were many confrontations that we had between our peoples,
- 1:25:38like in
- 1:25:39the 1930s and 1920s,
- 1:25:41the Kavon massacre where Hajinna Hosseini incited the population
- 1:25:45of Kamon to go and kill the Jews.
- 1:25:46Let's look at
- 1:25:48Palestine present,
- 1:25:49Palestine proper,
- 1:25:50whatever you want to call it,
- 1:25:50the British.
- 1:25:51Mandate.
- 1:25:52OK,
- 1:25:52no,
- 1:25:52no,
- 1:25:52no,
- 1:25:53from 1948,
- 1:25:54from prior to 1948,
- 1:25:56people lived there and were forcibly
- 1:25:59displaced
- 1:26:00by
- 1:26:00a
- 1:26:01foreign
- 1:26:02entity that had come back.
- 1:26:03I,
- 1:26:04I
- 1:26:04view it as differently.
- 1:26:05I think that they have a,
- 1:26:07I think that there is a Jewish connection to that land,
- 1:26:09and I don't think anyone here,
- 1:26:11but here's the thing,
- 1:26:11I said this earlier,
- 1:26:13if historical connection and indigeneity alone
- 1:26:16trumps whatever people are already there,
- 1:26:18then all modern.
- 1:26:20It just that trumps you're saying that,
- 1:26:22I'm just saying don't call it foreign.
- 1:26:24I'm saying it trumps the idea that we're colonizers and foreign people,
- 1:26:27and because you see me as a foreigner and other Israelis see you as a foreigner,
- 1:26:30a geneticist from Johns Hopkins says that not a,
- 1:26:33a majority of the Jewish people in Israel do not have a connection
- 1:26:37to the Middle East,
- 1:26:37and I really hope I'm fact checked on this.
- 1:26:39His name is El Hake,
- 1:26:40and he goes,
- 1:26:40he's from Johns Hopkins and is an Israeli geneticist.
- 1:26:43Many geneticists that show that actually the
- 1:26:45Jews descend from this land and Palestinians.
- 1:26:47We can go 60% of Palal.
- 1:26:48Palestinian genetics show that they descend from Jews.
- 1:26:51You can find,
- 1:26:51you can find publications.
- 1:26:53Hold up.
- 1:26:53You can find publications in Nature,
- 1:26:55in the American Journal of Human Genetics.
- 1:26:56You can find the scientists like Nebel,
- 1:26:58Hammer,
- 1:26:59and Behar.
- 1:26:59I suggest everyone looks at it and you can
- 1:27:01see that 60% of Palestinians descend from Jews.
- 1:27:03And if you go to places like Yaa,
- 1:27:05Yafo,
- 1:27:06Hebron,
- 1:27:07Shrem,
- 1:27:07East Jerusalem,
- 1:27:08places that are ancient Jewish towns that are either today are half a case study,
- 1:27:12either today or look at how the people in Hebron are being treated.
- 1:27:15They are actively being caged in by the illegal.
- 1:27:17Legal settlers on that land
- 1:27:19have their doors.
- 1:27:20You go to Kevron,
- 1:27:21the majority of Kevron is controlled by the Palestinians.
- 1:27:23The minority of Kron is,
- 1:27:24they're under a military occupation that is illegal.
- 1:27:27It was supposed to be temporary,
- 1:27:29but it's been made permanent,
- 1:27:31and then settlers are emboldened.
- 1:27:32So it's not illegal because it hasn't ended,
- 1:27:34but it needs to end.
- 1:27:35That on that were agreed upon.
- 1:27:37I don't want the IDF to be controlling of people
- 1:27:39that don't have a right to vote for that army.
- 1:27:41Wait,
- 1:27:41wait,
- 1:27:41are you saying that the settlements are illegal or not?
- 1:27:43No,
- 1:27:44I'm saying that Jewish villages are not settlements.
- 1:27:46They are.
- 1:27:46They are even referred to Daniella Whites.
- 1:27:48Daniella Whites even refers to herself as a settler.
- 1:27:51I can source you other individuals who say bad things that are Palestinians.
- 1:27:55The US government in the majority of its communications,
- 1:27:57the US government in this is the status quo.
- 1:28:00The US majority calls the settlements for you and them.
- 1:28:03Settlements are built by settlers.
- 1:28:05Settlers are foreigners.
- 1:28:06Jews come from Judea.
- 1:28:07We are not the foreign population.
- 1:28:09I don't agree with an American who just convert to Judaism.
- 1:28:13They're not just converting to Judaism.
- 1:28:14Some of them.
- 1:28:15I do.
- 1:28:15I'm not,
- 1:28:15I'm not small percentage of them do they still get a legitimate claim and have
- 1:28:19a take over the land overdigenous populations
- 1:28:21controls their culture in a different way.
- 1:28:23The way the Jewish indigenous civilization controls itself is if you
- 1:28:26go through this many year process of adopting an identity,
- 1:28:30a history,
- 1:28:30a culture,
- 1:28:30a value system,
- 1:28:31tradition,
- 1:28:32you are now part of the collective.
- 1:28:33It is not individuals that are indigenous,
- 1:28:35it is collectives.
- 1:28:36The collective of the Jewish collective identity that agree
- 1:28:38that they want to colonize illegally the West Bank,
- 1:28:42We have to pause.
- 1:28:42We're out of time.
- 1:28:43Thank you.
- 1:28:48OK,
- 1:28:48Rudy,
- 1:28:49we're down to the final section where you will
- 1:28:52look around the circle,
- 1:28:53choose somebody who either
- 1:28:55you thought you had a really good conversation with
- 1:28:57earlier and you wanna pick back up with,
- 1:28:59or somebody you haven't got to speak to.
- 1:29:00So look around the circle,
- 1:29:02select your person that you want to debate for the final 10 minutes.
- 1:29:05So first of all,
- 1:29:06thank you all for coming.
- 1:29:07I wish I can continue the conversation with all of you,
- 1:29:09but I'm going to pick the doctor to continue having a conversation.
- 1:29:17Rudy,
- 1:29:18can you tell us why you chose the doctor to debate for the final section?
- 1:29:21Of course,
- 1:29:22um,
- 1:29:22I think a lot of times our populations
- 1:29:24are conditioned to seeing each other as enemies.
- 1:29:26I don't think you see me as an enemy,
- 1:29:28and I'd like to have a conversation forward of
- 1:29:30how our peoples can be able to come together.
- 1:29:32You have a very kind spirit about you.
- 1:29:34You're genuine.
- 1:29:35You're someone who's connected to the land,
- 1:29:36and I believe you care about the peoples in that land.
- 1:29:38So I would like to speak about how we can move forward on that territory because
- 1:29:42there's no future without our peoples there.
- 1:29:44Masan claim
- 1:29:45that with the current situations
- 1:29:47we don't see a genuine desire among Israelis to achieve peace.
- 1:29:51So I agree that the Israeli government is doing nothing to change
- 1:29:54the current status quo and benefits from that status quo politically,
- 1:29:58economically,
- 1:29:59and in many ways.
- 1:30:00This is a critique that I have openly in Israel towards the government,
- 1:30:03towards extremist voices,
- 1:30:04which to me are embarrassing,
- 1:30:06the things that they're saying like Benvil and Smoltrid
- 1:30:08that are going and talking about ethnic cleansing.
- 1:30:10This is horrible and not what our culture has to be,
- 1:30:13and I always tell Israelis
- 1:30:14that the biggest one of Hamas.
- 1:30:15is not how many Israelis they killed,
- 1:30:17it's how many Israelis they turned to being just like them,
- 1:30:20hateful of an entire population.
- 1:30:22It's sad to think,
- 1:30:22and in this game we can go back and forth and play in the chicken and the egg game.
- 1:30:27who caused the Israelis to become
- 1:30:29pro genocide,
- 1:30:30pro ethnic cleansing?
- 1:30:31Is it Hamas is causing that.
- 1:30:32Hamas just started in 1986,
- 1:30:34and we have to understand that the
- 1:30:36actions of the Israeli governments,
- 1:30:38the actions
- 1:30:39of
- 1:30:40Discrimination and apartheid
- 1:30:42is
- 1:30:42what is causing us to have these conflicts and fights between each other.
- 1:30:47You have the power.
- 1:30:47You have the military.
- 1:30:48You have the money.
- 1:30:49You have the support of the whole Western world.
- 1:30:51For God's sake,
- 1:30:52you can do something different about what's happening there.
- 1:30:54We are tied.
- 1:30:55We are
- 1:30:56stuck in the corner.
- 1:30:57Our kids are being killed right and left.
- 1:30:59Our homes are being destroyed.
- 1:31:00You know what?
- 1:31:01If all what I have is just to throw a little rock at you.
- 1:31:04You have to understand where that's coming from.
- 1:31:06I understand,
- 1:31:07and I never made the claim that the Israeli hate towards
- 1:31:10Palestinians that exists comes from Hamas,
- 1:31:12that has existed since 1948,
- 1:31:14from the conflicts that we have,
- 1:31:15even from the Kron massacre in 1929.
- 1:31:17I actually go to the British that divided our people.
- 1:31:20That's where it's sourced,
- 1:31:20not me or not you,
- 1:31:22but there are ways to move forward now.
- 1:31:23You called Israel an apartheid,
- 1:31:24and apartheid is
- 1:31:25one country,
- 1:31:26one state,
- 1:31:26one civilization with different rights for different peoples.
- 1:31:29Those who are living in Israel have equal rights.
- 1:31:30There's another territory called the West Bank,
- 1:31:32Judea and Samaria,
- 1:31:33which has a different jurisdiction,
- 1:31:35just different jurisdiction.
- 1:31:37Gaza has a different jurisdiction.
- 1:31:38I'm,
- 1:31:38wait,
- 1:31:39wait,
- 1:31:39I'm against the division of this land.
- 1:31:40I want to see this land united,
- 1:31:41but that's actually the opposite of an apartheid because an apartheid
- 1:31:44would be one country with different rights for different people.
- 1:31:46Now we're talking about different territories,
- 1:31:48different jurisdictions.
- 1:31:49I don't have a right to there.
- 1:31:50They don't have a right here.
- 1:31:51It's bad,
- 1:31:52but it's not an apartheid.
- 1:31:53Now,
- 1:31:53you said something,
- 1:31:54I actually agree with you.
- 1:31:55We have the power.
- 1:31:57With that power comes the responsibility,
- 1:31:59and this is something that every Jew,
- 1:32:00every Israeli,
- 1:32:01every Zionist should listen.
- 1:32:02We have the power to correct the problems of our Palestinian family and our cousins,
- 1:32:05and we talk about Tikkun Ola and Olawie
- 1:32:07healing the world and empowering other nations.
- 1:32:09Well,
- 1:32:09we need to do,
- 1:32:10tikkun babaitimbnedo.
- 1:32:11We need to heal our own home the actions with our own cousinsi government,
- 1:32:14criminalizing free speech,
- 1:32:16uh,
- 1:32:16pushing,
- 1:32:17uh,
- 1:32:17that's not in Israel,
- 1:32:18that's in America.
- 1:32:19You're saying,
- 1:32:19yeah,
- 1:32:19but AIPAC is an extension of what's happening in Israel.
- 1:32:22AIPAC.
- 1:32:23That's good,
- 1:32:24good to know,
- 1:32:24I'm not right.
- 1:32:25America getting involved in the Middle East.
- 1:32:27I'm not for that.
- 1:32:28Now,
- 1:32:28if you,
- 1:32:29if you,
- 1:32:30you mentioned earlier about the division between the West Bank areas,
- 1:32:34Area A,
- 1:32:34Area B,
- 1:32:35Area C,
- 1:32:36you served in the army,
- 1:32:37right?
- 1:32:37It's,
- 1:32:38it's really,
- 1:32:38do you think that's,
- 1:32:39that's they have the full freedom to do whatever they want in Area A?
- 1:32:42They don't have the full freedom to do it.
- 1:32:44It's just a few miles of
- 1:32:45distance.
- 1:32:46People cannot drive out of these areas.
- 1:32:48Young people are losing hope.
- 1:32:49What do you expect from a 20-year-old boy
- 1:32:52or a 2 year-old young man who has no?
- 1:32:53To get married,
- 1:32:54no hope to get a job,
- 1:32:55to get
- 1:32:56what do you expect?
- 1:32:57No,
- 1:32:57I understand that.
- 1:32:57That's why when I look at Israelis who've become extremists,
- 1:33:00Palestinians who become extremists,
- 1:33:02I understand where it's coming from.
- 1:33:03And what are you doing about the settlers,
- 1:33:04Enough of us who in just a few months we're
- 1:33:07going to address the Jews in Judea and Samira.
- 1:33:09But just as there are extremist individuals,
- 1:33:11there are people like us who don't hate one another.
- 1:33:13You keep,
- 1:33:14you keep rejecting and refusing to use the word Palestine.
- 1:33:17I don't reject the word Palest you keep saying Judea and Sam.
- 1:33:19You keep saying that.
- 1:33:19I mean that territory has been historically.
- 1:33:22And people,
- 1:33:23I'm telling you that psychologically if you wanted to achieve peace,
- 1:33:25if you want to achieve ease,
- 1:33:28you have to also understand what your words,
- 1:33:30how,
- 1:33:30how powerful they are.
- 1:33:32When you keep saying Judea and Sam,
- 1:33:33Judea and Sam,
- 1:33:34you know what,
- 1:33:35this is what people call Palestine,
- 1:33:36those people home every time I say Judean,
- 1:33:38I say West Bank slash Judean Samira because Judean Samara is
- 1:33:41not talking about the entirety of what is Israel slash Palestine.
- 1:33:44This is,
- 1:33:44it is specifically what is today the you're implying when you use those terms
- 1:33:47that this is what happens in the Palestinian mind.
- 1:33:49Where does the word West Bank come from?
- 1:33:51It's the British that use that term.
- 1:33:52It is the common term.
- 1:33:54Palestinians was Palestinians gets in mind when you keep using those terms like,
- 1:33:57OK,
- 1:33:58we're next.
- 1:33:59They're going to come and take us,
- 1:34:00take us out.
- 1:34:00That's right,
- 1:34:01that's what comes in the mind.
- 1:34:02When Jews hear the term Palestine,
- 1:34:03they think,
- 1:34:03oh,
- 1:34:03you're trying to erase us.
- 1:34:05This is where we need to be able to accept each other's identity.
- 1:34:08I'm a Jew.
- 1:34:08I'm a Hebrew,
- 1:34:09I'm an Israelite.
- 1:34:10This land has historically to my people been called Israel slash Judean's mayor,
- 1:34:14the specific region actions,
- 1:34:15but I'm not louder than my actions,
- 1:34:16not my actions.
- 1:34:17Other people.
- 1:34:18You have accepted to serve in the army.
- 1:34:20That's causing so much atrocity to serve in the army.
- 1:34:22Well,
- 1:34:22so many soldiers,
- 1:34:23so many soldiers are rejecting and facing the consequences.
- 1:34:26That's bravery.
- 1:34:27That's bravery on their behalf.
- 1:34:29I served in the army proudly.
- 1:34:30You don't have a weak Jew in front of you.
- 1:34:31You have a prouddane warrior in front of you.
- 1:34:34To be proud of a machine that's killing people right not a machine.
- 1:34:37It is a who sends them a little text message,
- 1:34:39Get out of your house before we bombs.
- 1:34:41I'm proud to condemn certain actions,
- 1:34:43certain policies,
- 1:34:44certain things.
- 1:34:44That they do
- 1:34:45because I'm an individual first before anything else.
- 1:34:47And when there are countries all around that have
- 1:34:50constantly attacked and tried to kill our people without an IDF,
- 1:34:54we would not exist.
- 1:34:55You're the one who started.
- 1:34:56No,
- 1:34:56we're not.
- 1:34:56I mean,
- 1:34:57didn't you say we shouldn't be pointing at who started the chicken or the egg?
- 1:35:00No,
- 1:35:00and now you're saying you're starting.
- 1:35:01That's what we argue now.
- 1:35:02You're saying that these countries are coming to attack you.
- 1:35:04Imagine if,
- 1:35:06imagine if a,
- 1:35:06if a foreign country come and invaded California,
- 1:35:09you expect Texas
- 1:35:10and Nevada.
- 1:35:11invaders,
- 1:35:12the Israeli arms invaded Palestine.
- 1:35:14Invaders absolutely the indigenous people that came back to our land.
- 1:35:17They came with them when they came peacefully.
- 1:35:19We opened our doors for them.
- 1:35:21I'm sure,
- 1:35:21but when they came in 1929,
- 1:35:23it was so peaceful when they came peacefully,
- 1:35:24when they said,
- 1:35:25OK,
- 1:35:25we want to live here,
- 1:35:26we opened the doors.
- 1:35:27Exactly.
- 1:35:28Palestinian when you start showing the,
- 1:35:29when you,
- 1:35:29you start showing the intentions,
- 1:35:31when you brought the weapons and you start killing people,
- 1:35:34that's when people attacked.
- 1:35:35See,
- 1:35:35the difference in this conversation is that there are bad actors on both side.
- 1:35:38I'm identifying the individual bad actors on the Israeli side,
- 1:35:41identifying the bad actors on the Palestinian side and saying
- 1:35:44do not attach these bad actors to all Palestinians.
- 1:35:46What you're doing is identifying the bad actors here and
- 1:35:49saying it's all Israelis and refusing to identify all.
- 1:35:51I said majority.
- 1:35:52They came on the borders of Gaza.
- 1:35:54That's horrible and they're cheering,
- 1:35:55the things that you see death to Arabs,
- 1:35:57right and left,
- 1:35:58minority of the population.
- 1:36:00It's a,
- 1:36:00it's a great minority and it should be,
- 1:36:02it should be.
- 1:36:03It should be 0.
- 1:36:04Is it a democratic state?
- 1:36:06So why would a minority be able to control the actions of the government?
- 1:36:10Great question.
- 1:36:11This is the majority of a parliamentary system
- 1:36:13government where you have all these different parties,
- 1:36:15and in order to have power,
- 1:36:16you need to have over 60 seats out of 120 seats in order to have the majority.
- 1:36:20You don't have a 60 party seat,
- 1:36:22you have a 20,
- 1:36:23you have a 5,
- 1:36:23you have a 2,
- 1:36:24and the majority is very small.
- 1:36:25So then a party with 2 seats that is a minority has the ability to get out to.
- 1:36:30It's unfortunate.
- 1:36:30That's the reality.
- 1:36:31of the political system.
- 1:36:32That's why we've got to change things that all I'm not here to speak for Netanyahu.
- 1:36:35There's plenty of criticism that I have of Netanyahu.
- 1:36:37OK,
- 1:36:38we can talk about Netanyahu and Ben Vilas Multic and bad actors and bad individuals.
- 1:36:41What I'm talking about is how do we move forward from here.
- 1:36:44It's not going to come from the politicians,
- 1:36:45right?
- 1:36:46It's going to come from the majority of the Israeli people
- 1:36:48to accept the rights of the Palestinians to be equal.
- 1:36:50I agree with you,
- 1:36:51but you have to accept my rights to be able to
- 1:36:53be a human being here and not demonize my people.
- 1:36:54I,
- 1:36:54I,
- 1:36:55I,
- 1:36:55sir,
- 1:36:55I,
- 1:36:56I worked as a dentist in,
- 1:36:57in Bethlehem.
- 1:36:58In
- 1:36:59outside of the city of Bethlehem,
- 1:37:00next to a place called Movi Bitar.
- 1:37:03Where my patients were Jews,
- 1:37:05Muslims and Christians,
- 1:37:06and guess what,
- 1:37:07all what they care about,
- 1:37:08how much it's going to hurt to pull out a tooth
- 1:37:10when they're sitting in the room.
- 1:37:11So what's what I'm trying to tell you here
- 1:37:13that we have no problem living with each other,
- 1:37:15but not with a gun on our head,
- 1:37:17not when you're taking out my house,
- 1:37:18not when you're telling me you cannot go to work every day,
- 1:37:21not when you humiliate me on every checkpoint.
- 1:37:23You remember who you're talking to.
- 1:37:24I'm against the checkpoints.
- 1:37:25I'm against the walls that divide our land.
- 1:37:27I'm against the fact that we're currently living
- 1:37:28in you doing to become the majority.
- 1:37:30A minority.
- 1:37:31No,
- 1:37:31we're not.
- 1:37:32We're silent,
- 1:37:33a large population.
- 1:37:34I wouldn't say it's the majority or a minority,
- 1:37:36but we're a large population and we need to create a social revolution,
- 1:37:38and we in this land have to start changing the conversation,
- 1:37:42no longer demonizing one another and being able
- 1:37:44to envision a future where we live together can
- 1:37:45you also add to your activism that you guys get off the freedom of speech of America?
- 1:37:50Let us speak whatever you want to say.
- 1:37:52Well,
- 1:37:52you have to speak about that as well.
- 1:37:54I believe in freedom of speech in every country in the world,
- 1:37:57the,
- 1:37:57your government.
- 1:37:58is imposing so much restrictions on the freedom of speech of Americans,
- 1:38:02and we are not liking that.
- 1:38:03I don't think and you are losing the support of Americans because of that.
- 1:38:06I don't think Americans should have a limitation of freedom of speech unless
- 1:38:10someone is trying to invoke violence on someone and saying I'm planning to,
- 1:38:13then that's different than just saying I'm expressing an idea that I have.
- 1:38:16How many professors lost their jobs because they say they're anti-genocide?
- 1:38:19A lot of professors that went to Colombia,
- 1:38:20they're actually supporting the genocide of Jews and saying
- 1:38:23that October 7th was great genocide against Jews.
- 1:38:26I don't know where you come into genocide,
- 1:38:27that victim mentality.
- 1:38:28Nobody's after you guys.
- 1:38:30A lot of people are after us,
- 1:38:31after your actions.
- 1:38:32New York City,
- 1:38:32OK,
- 1:38:33we are 13% of the population.
- 1:38:35Over 60% of total hate crimes are targeted against Jews.
- 1:38:38Don't tell me.
- 1:38:38I sit down with the chief of police.
- 1:38:4160%.
- 1:38:41I'll tell you what,
- 1:38:42I sat down with the chief of action I sat down with the chief of police here in the city.
- 1:38:45Anti-Semitism.
- 1:38:46I'm not.
- 1:38:47I'm saying you are so much better at reporting it,
- 1:38:49OK,
- 1:38:49but better than everybody else.
- 1:38:50It's clearly I'm not saying it doesn't exist.
- 1:38:52It exists,
- 1:38:52but I'm saying that's.
- 1:38:53We heard from the chief of police of many cities around here.
- 1:38:56Guys,
- 1:38:57you need to report hate crimes against your
- 1:38:59community,
- 1:39:00of course,
- 1:39:00because this community reports it better than everybody else
- 1:39:03and collects all the benefits of reporting them.
- 1:39:05So you guys know what's interesting about anti-Semitism,
- 1:39:07the far right blames us for being the left,
- 1:39:09the far left thinks we're the right,
- 1:39:10the black supremacists,
- 1:39:11the Farrakhans were enemy number one.
- 1:39:12The white supremacists,
- 1:39:13the neo-Nazis victim mentality.
- 1:39:14It's not,
- 1:39:15it's understanding of reality you think everybody's after you.
- 1:39:18No,
- 1:39:18the extremes are always obsessed against the Jewish people.
- 1:39:21Why?
- 1:39:21Because the Jewish people have a function in this earth that we have yet to fulfill,
- 1:39:25which is to be the world's immune system.
- 1:39:27OK?
- 1:39:28We chose that responsibility.
- 1:39:29It is our mission statement of the world,
- 1:39:31and the reason why there's anti-Semitism,
- 1:39:33it is a rejection and reaction to the Jewish people failing their purpose.
- 1:39:35I think that's,
- 1:39:36that's with all due respect to what you just said,
- 1:39:38it's really a wild dream that you have that,
- 1:39:40the idea of a unity around the world is a wild dream,
- 1:39:42right?
- 1:39:43The Jewish people believe in a reality called mashir,
- 1:39:45a reality where we will have peace in this earth,
- 1:39:47people,
- 1:39:48people.
- 1:39:49Blame everything on anti-Semitism right now.
- 1:39:51No,
- 1:39:52there's a lot of anti-Semitism that exists.
- 1:39:53It's not everything.
- 1:39:54Everyone is an anti-Semite.
- 1:39:56I don't consider you an anti-Semite,
- 1:39:57OK,
- 1:39:57because we had a conversation,
- 1:39:58we understood that you define Zionism differently,
- 1:40:02right?
- 1:40:02And so I'm not what I'm not asking you,
- 1:40:04if you,
- 1:40:04if you want to tackle this issue and we go back to it,
- 1:40:06is try to understand when people are criticizing
- 1:40:09the actions of the Israeli government,
- 1:40:11when people are
- 1:40:13expecting for it to act like a civilized nation,
- 1:40:16they're not being anti-Semite,
- 1:40:17they're not demonizing Israel.
- 1:40:18Delegitimizing Israel,
- 1:40:20holding double standards.
- 1:40:21They are being no double standards.
- 1:40:22There are double standards.
- 1:40:23There are no double standards.
- 1:40:24Why,
- 1:40:24why is it OK to be double standards when we get the amount of support from America,
- 1:40:28but it's not OK when the Americans are criticizing our.
- 1:40:30What does it do to America?
- 1:40:31I'm against the US support of America when there are actual genocides happening
- 1:40:34you said and no one is talking about those things that are happening.
- 1:40:37You never said it's double standards that the US
- 1:40:39government gives $3 billion every year to Israel.
- 1:40:41I did.
- 1:40:42Well,
- 1:40:42is it a double standard or is it
- 1:40:43an intentional investment in order to control Israel?
- 1:40:45It's,
- 1:40:45it's not the same for every other country.
- 1:40:47So why?
- 1:40:48But it's not a double standard that that's,
- 1:40:49and you're,
- 1:40:50you're helping a country in order to be able to control it.
- 1:40:52That has nothing to do with double standards.
- 1:40:54Double standard would be looking at all the problems in this world and realizing,
- 1:40:57wow,
- 1:40:57there's so many people here in Sudan that have been killed,
- 1:41:00in Nigeria that have been killed,
- 1:41:01and in Israel,
- 1:41:02Palestine that have been killed,
- 1:41:03and caring about all of them,
- 1:41:05or looking at Palestinians when Hamas is killing Palestinians,
- 1:41:08I don't see any protests.
- 1:41:10I don't see any riots.
- 1:41:11I don't see any choose what to be active about certain topics,
- 1:41:14right?
- 1:41:14They choose to care about your people,
- 1:41:16my family.
- 1:41:17When it could be used against me do that?
- 1:41:19Because the world is profiting from this.
- 1:41:21The media companies,
- 1:41:22the military companies,
- 1:41:24anybody who is in the media who acts in any way to criticize what's doing,
- 1:41:28he's losing his job.
- 1:41:29That's not true.
- 1:41:29All the media companies are.
- 1:41:31Everything that you see on the media are always going against Israel,
- 1:41:34you know,
- 1:41:34I,
- 1:41:35I said that if I could just,
- 1:41:37just to redirect this a little bit,
- 1:41:38I did hear points of agreement,
- 1:41:41frustration with AIPAC,
- 1:41:42you know,
- 1:41:43uh,
- 1:41:43frustrations with Netanyahu,
- 1:41:45agreements on.
- 1:41:46You know,
- 1:41:47uh,
- 1:41:47things that you want to see change in
- 1:41:49Israel.
- 1:41:50Can,
- 1:41:51I would love to hear from Rudy and then your response,
- 1:41:53doctor,
- 1:41:53on
- 1:41:54like what changes do we want to see where there is
- 1:41:56alignment.
- 1:41:57I think the most productive way we can continue this
- 1:41:59conversation is to understand how do we change the narratives
- 1:42:02for our collectives to start seeing each other as human
- 1:42:05beings and being able to exist in this land.
- 1:42:07So that goes to the Israeli population.
- 1:42:09How can we start seeing the Palestinian identity as a
- 1:42:11legitimate identity connected to this land as their suffering,
- 1:42:14as real suffering?
- 1:42:15And how could Palestinians start to understand that the
- 1:42:17Jewish people are also connected to this land,
- 1:42:20have a right to be here when they're being attacked and suffering?
- 1:42:22That's also something to condemn.
- 1:42:24So how do you suggest that we can change the cultural
- 1:42:27View it's not just the political.
- 1:42:29You cannot put the carriage before the horse.
- 1:42:32You cannot expect people who don't have any human rights.
- 1:42:34They don't have the ability to find food or
- 1:42:36to feed their children or to protect their families,
- 1:42:39and then expect them to go into that high level of
- 1:42:43civilized social understanding.
- 1:42:45First,
- 1:42:46let them have the freedom,
- 1:42:47the ability to leave,
- 1:42:49the self-determination,
- 1:42:50right.
- 1:42:50Let them be
- 1:42:52feeling that they're
- 1:42:53safe in.
- 1:42:54Homes in their cities,
- 1:42:55in their villages,
- 1:42:56nobody's going to come and take their food.
- 1:42:58No one's going to come and bomb their homes.
- 1:42:59I am telling you just a few months ago,
- 1:43:02my friends,
- 1:43:03he has a huge amount of sheep in the Mazra Shariya,
- 1:43:07which is a town north of Ramallah,
- 1:43:09and they just came and took all the cattle that he has.
- 1:43:12This is the fear that Palestinians have.
- 1:43:15What do you expect us to do?
- 1:43:16Just sit down,
- 1:43:16be sitting ducks being shot by the Israeli soldiers?
- 1:43:19First,
- 1:43:19let's give them the right.
- 1:43:20Let's give them the sense of security and safety
- 1:43:24that Israelis are not going to come after them
- 1:43:26every time they,
- 1:43:27every chance they have.
- 1:43:28That's the first step.
- 1:43:28Israelis are not coming after all Palestinians.
- 1:43:30There's some bad actors that happen like in all populations,
- 1:43:33but this like generalization of Israelis.
- 1:43:36I lived as a kid and I saw what I.
- 1:43:38I'm looking at it from the other side.
- 1:43:40I look at it from the other side.
- 1:43:41OK,
- 1:43:41so I hear your experiences in Bethlehem,
- 1:43:44which is a house of bread in Hebrew,
- 1:43:45an ancient Jewish town.
- 1:43:47OK,
- 1:43:47so let's talk about what you were just saying.
- 1:43:49I don't agree with you entirely that they can't do anything.
- 1:43:52They can't have any conversation.
- 1:43:54No one can be seen as other than just being an extremist.
- 1:43:56I don't agree with that,
- 1:43:57but I do agree with you that Israel with
- 1:43:58the power has a greater responsibility to change,
- 1:44:00and I always talk about this,
- 1:44:02that if Israel
- 1:44:03removed Hamas,
- 1:44:04gave people freedom of speech,
- 1:44:06invested in education,
- 1:44:07in infrastructure,
- 1:44:08and job opportunities,
- 1:44:09and slowly when we saw that the population is not reacting
- 1:44:12that way to the Israeli government to remove the checkpoints otherwise,
- 1:44:15history shows what history shows us that whenever
- 1:44:17Israelis have the full power of controlling the lives of Palestinians.
- 1:44:21They're going to make their life hell.
- 1:44:22They're going to make their life miserable.
- 1:44:23I think that the Palestinians living in Israel are the
- 1:44:25freest Palestinians that are living anywhere in the world.
- 1:44:28I don't think even the Israelis want to do that strategically.
- 1:44:30They think it's a bad idea to put all Palestinians
- 1:44:32under one state demographically where they will be a minority.
- 1:44:34That's how we wouldn't
- 1:44:36agree with some people,
- 1:44:37but we wouldn't because a lot of people aren't
- 1:44:39aware that there are 12 tribes of Israel.
- 1:44:40The Ethiopians are one of the ones that were displaced
- 1:44:42of the 9.5 that have yet to come back.
- 1:44:44We want,
- 1:44:45we want to respect the intelligence of the viewers.
- 1:44:47Like this is what are you talking about?
- 1:44:49We are made up of 12 tribes,
- 1:44:50the Jewish people.
- 1:44:51This is not an idea.
- 1:44:52If they're Native Americans,
- 1:44:53they're made up of many tribes or many nations,
- 1:44:55it's also a truth
- 1:44:56because you haven't heard or don't know or aren't aware,
- 1:44:58that's something different.
- 1:44:59We're made up of 12 tribes.
- 1:45:00Today's population of the Jewish people,
- 1:45:0216 million around the world,
- 1:45:03is 2.5.
- 1:45:04There are 9.5 that you have to return.
- 1:45:06If they are to return and Palestinians are to return,
- 1:45:08there's no more demographic threat that Israelis feel.
- 1:45:11You are able to.
- 1:45:11Have full equal rights in that land with the right of return,
- 1:45:14and we're able to transcend and to move forward,
- 1:45:16but you shouldn't be speaking to Israelis who are afraid
- 1:45:19of telling you the truth or who are weak,
- 1:45:21and I shouldn't be speaking to Palestinians who are tokens are just trying
- 1:45:23to demonize other Palestinians or fans who are here to try to like
- 1:45:27use our conflict to go against one another or to gain popularity.
- 1:45:30We have a future together and it's one that includes both
- 1:45:33aspirations that we have and ending the injustice for both peoples.
- 1:45:36I reciprocate by saying that Palestinians have no problem
- 1:45:40with.
- 1:45:41Peaceful solutions that will guarantee their dignity,
- 1:45:44their ability to live,
- 1:45:45their ability to have
- 1:45:47futures they can where they can raise their
- 1:45:49children in a safe and a comfortable environment.
- 1:45:52Palestinians don't have the desire
- 1:45:54to kill or attack every Jewish or every Israeli.
- 1:45:57All the Palestinians are doing are defending themselves from those
- 1:46:00atrocities and those attacks that are happening against them.
- 1:46:03I believe strongly once the Israelis stop
- 1:46:06attacking,
- 1:46:06dehumanizing,
- 1:46:08bombing Palestinian villages and homes,
- 1:46:10Palestinians will not have a problem with them.
- 1:46:13I want you to know that
- 1:46:14as a Palestinian.
- 1:46:15I agree with most that are like that,
- 1:46:16and inshallah we'll get to that reality.
- 1:46:18All right,
- 1:46:18all right,
- 1:46:18let's stop there.
- 1:46:20Let's give them a hand.
- 1:46:23Rudy,
- 1:46:24thank you,
- 1:46:24doctor.
- 1:46:25Thank you.
- 1:46:25We are gonna record a follow-up episode
- 1:46:28to continue the conversation with these two,
- 1:46:29so stay tuned for that,
- 1:46:31um,
- 1:46:31and follow the surrounded podcast wherever you get your podcast.
- 1:46:34I wanna thank everybody who participated in this episode.
- 1:46:37If you are a viewer and you're commenting on this video.
- 1:46:39Please acknowledge the humanity of everybody here.
- 1:46:42They are being vulnerable.
- 1:46:43This is not an easy thing to do.
- 1:46:45So thank you all.
- 1:46:46Snaps to you.
- 1:46:47And stay tuned for our next episode,
- 1:46:49which will be one fitness expert versus 20 body positivity activists.
- 1:46:53Thank you for watching.
- 1:46:54We'll see you next time.
- 1:46:57In the first half was very heated.
- 1:46:59A lot of people were pointing fingers,
- 1:47:01calling each other names,
- 1:47:02speaking over one another,
- 1:47:03but the second half we actually see it changing and talking about solutions.
- 1:47:07I did have mixed feelings.
- 1:47:09He either extremely well trained
- 1:47:12to present a kinder,
- 1:47:13nicer,
- 1:47:14positive image of an Israeli soldier to gain the
- 1:47:17hearts and the minds of the American public,
- 1:47:20or he's having a change of heart of what his government is doing,
- 1:47:23and I'm hoping this is what it is.
- 1:47:25We need to understand that we are Family,
- 1:47:26we not only descend from Ibrahim,
- 1:47:28from Aboham,
- 1:47:29from Itzhak and Ishmael,
- 1:47:31but we also descend from the same ancestors a few generations ago.
- 1:47:34We are eternally linked to this land,
- 1:47:37and yes,
- 1:47:37we should criticize and talk about the things that are wrong for our people,
- 1:47:40but never in a way to demonize the entirety of the other,
- 1:47:43and we need to start listening to one
- 1:47:44another to understand what are the non-negotiables.
- 1:47:47Once the Israelis realize and understand that
- 1:47:50they are not superior than Palestinians,
- 1:47:52they don't have more rights.
- 1:47:53They have to realize.
- 1:47:55And understanding they're not above the law.
- 1:47:56They're not above the human rights laws and rules.
- 1:47:59You have to realize that if you care about Jewish and Israeli safety,
- 1:48:03you also have to care about Palestinian safety.
- 1:48:05They're connected.
- 1:48:06You cannot want Jewish safety
- 1:48:08if you want to demolish the safety of
- 1:48:10Palestinians because they're going to demand their safety.
- 1:48:13That's their right as humans.
- 1:48:14So overall I'm I'm very happy with the outcome.
- 1:48:17I'm happy that people are willing to engage with one another,
- 1:48:19and I hope that that inspires
- 1:48:20and empowers a lot of people who will watch this to do the same.
- 1:48:24Hey listeners,
- 1:48:25just want to remind you,
- 1:48:26we have episodes of the pod coming out
- 1:48:28every Sunday,
- 1:48:29so please consider subscribing
- 1:48:31wherever you get your podcasts.
- 1:48:32Thank you for your support.