Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Fidelity’s Chris Kuiper: Bonds Are Broken & Bitcoin’s 4-Year Cycle Is Dead
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity where the supply is
- 0:12unaffected by the demand. If you want to preserve your
- 0:16wealth, you have to convert that currency into an asset that's
- 0:21scarce, desirable, portable. Durable.
- 0:24And maintainable. Welcome back to Scarce Assets
- 0:32from On Ramp Institutional. This week, we're joined by Chris
- 0:36Kiper, Vice President of Research at Fidelity Digital
- 0:39Assets. Excited to have Chris join us
- 0:41for this one as we relaunch On Ramp Institutional.
- 0:44In this conversation, we dug into a lot of things that are
- 0:47timely for many cycles now, at least the past two people were
- 0:50saying that institutions were coming, they're here, they're
- 0:53allocating. We found out it wasn't true, it
- 0:55was still early, but this time around we dig into why advisors
- 0:59are now showing up as the leading cohort in the 13 F
- 1:02filings for the Bitcoin ETFs, showing that they actually are
- 1:06allocating in size to Bitcoin. We also discussed why the old
- 1:11four year cycle no longer explains bitcoins behavior and
- 1:14what to look out for going forward and also how to think
- 1:18about portfolio allocation and bitcoins role within a
- 1:21traditional portfolio, especially with bonds as a
- 1:24potentially impaired asset class and on ramp.
- 1:27We help institutional allocators, advisors, family
- 1:30offices allocate to Bitcoin confidently.
- 1:33Our architecture is built on multi institution custody which
- 1:36removes single points of failure and gives you a durable
- 1:39foundation for long term Bitcoin exposure.
- 1:42Whether your firm is starting from zero and needs advisory
- 1:45services or you have exposure through the spot Bitcoin ETFs
- 1:49and want a more direct and conservative approach from a
- 1:52team that is laser focused on Bitcoin, we can help you.
- 1:56For qualified investors, the Bitcoin on ramp Bitcoin Trust
- 1:59offers security like exposure with in kind delivery, multi
- 2:02jurisdiction custody and direct ownership of your Bitcoin and an
- 2:07advisory team that will help equip you and your investment
- 2:11committee with clear frameworks to avoid the pitfalls that have
- 2:13trapped investors in the past cycle.
- 2:16If your organization is evaluating Bitcoin or is already
- 2:19at scale and ready to allocate further, let's talk.
- 2:22E-mail me Jackson at on rampbitcoin.com or book a
- 2:25consultation at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 2:28Welcome back to Scarce Assets, Chris Kuiper.
- 2:32Great to see you this morning joined by my Co host as well,
- 2:35Michael Tanguma. For those who are not familiar,
- 2:38Chris is the Vice President of Research at Fidelity Digital
- 2:41Assets, really leading the firm's research on Bitcoin and
- 2:44digital assets. He's also a friend of the firm
- 2:47on Ramp here. And this show, for those who are
- 2:49not familiar is really the reboot of on Ramp Institutional.
- 2:52So we're excited to be launching on Ramp Institutional this week
- 2:55with Chris. And for those who are not
- 2:57familiar, we're just focused on advisory services, investment
- 3:00solutions built around multi institution custody.
- 3:03And I think this conversation with Chris will be incredibly
- 3:05informative. It'll give institutional
- 3:07allocators, advisors really the firepower ammunition to have
- 3:11conversations with their clients, their investment
- 3:13committees. And so, Chris, really excited
- 3:16for this conversation. Thank you for joining us today.
- 3:18How are you doing? Great to be here.
- 3:20Thanks for having me and doing well.
- 3:23Yeah, super, super excited to have you on Chris.
- 3:25Obviously one of the the the brightest minds in the space.
- 3:28We think that meet, you know, try to find Bitcoin and then
- 3:31leading at Fidelity Research, who's obviously been notable
- 3:35leading in this space around education and helping, you know,
- 3:38the market get exposure in the right way.
- 3:41So no shortage of exciting things to talk about.
- 3:43I think the first podcast you you joined kind of coined at
- 3:48least in the lexicon that we published a bunch around Invert,
- 3:51always invert. And it's kind of a good mental
- 3:53model to to look at I think the world and where we're at today.
- 3:59Yeah, I think a great place to start is pulling up the Bitcoin
- 4:03price. Just a minute here because first
- 4:06of all, we are long term oriented allocators and really
- 4:10Bitcoin is meant to be a long term investment.
- 4:13You shouldn't be necessarily trading this thing around
- 4:16performs best if you have 510 or longer time horizon typically.
- 4:20That said, I think it's worth pulling the price up because it
- 4:23really informs the start of this conversation around 2025 and
- 4:29comparison to previous what used to be the four year cycle.
- 4:32I'm curious, Chris, if just the market structure and
- 4:36participants in the market has fundamentally changed the four
- 4:39year cycle. I'm looking at this on ramp
- 4:42terminal right now and you can see that the Bitcoin price is up
- 4:4515% year to date. And so you'd think if you
- 4:48compare that to 2021 or 2017, we're we're lagging pretty
- 4:52significantly, but things I think have changed.
- 4:55But what are your thoughts here? So one of the ways to look at
- 5:00this is the cycle since the having so the four year cycle
- 5:03and yes we are we're lagging greatly on that.
- 5:06If you look at a chart like that, the other chart you can
- 5:09look at there for cycles is starting from the the deepest
- 5:13draw down and we were tracking the other cycles from there
- 5:17pretty closely. And then just in the past few
- 5:19months we've started to lag there as well.
- 5:20So one of the things I think that that is responsible for
- 5:23that is the exchange trade products they pulled for forward
- 5:27a lot of demand. If you remember it was the
- 5:29classic by the rumor sell the news.
- 5:32A lot of people ran the price before they were approved.
- 5:36And then of course the halving was after that.
- 5:38So normally historically gains come right after the halving.
- 5:40And so a lot of the games games came with the ET PS right before
- 5:45the halving in this cycle. So that's what makes it look
- 5:47like we're lagging sometimes. But in reality, we're not
- 5:50lagging maybe quite as much. But I do think the four year
- 5:54cycle is dead in terms of four years because we're we're
- 5:57already past that, right? And we haven't got the euphoric
- 6:00blow off top that we've had in the past cycles, at least
- 6:04historically, right? Our signals don't show that,
- 6:07MVRV don't doesn't show that. And even just the sentiment and
- 6:11the games don't don't show that. That euphoric blow up top
- 6:13happens at the very end of the four years.
- 6:15It's compressed in just a few weeks.
- 6:17And there's just this incredible run.
- 6:19And we've just seen grind higher, consolidate, grind
- 6:22higher, consolidate, which has been very interesting.
- 6:24So I personally think the four year cycle is dead, but I don't
- 6:28think cycles in this space are dead in general, if that makes
- 6:31sense. It makes a ton of sense.
- 6:34I guess, you know, zooming out from just Bitcoin cycles in a
- 6:37lot of ways are tied to just investor sentiment and you know,
- 6:42people over leveraging themselves and deleveraging.
- 6:44You see that quite a bit in just the economy and traditional
- 6:47asset classes. And I think that'll continue to
- 6:49persist. I would agree with you there.
- 6:51And it does seem like though the four year cycle has
- 6:53fundamentally shifted or potentially is no longer
- 6:57something investors need to be thinking about.
- 6:59I'd be curious because you touch on it a little bit, just we're
- 7:02about 18 months after the Etps have been launched.
- 7:06It's been as far as I've seen the most successful financial
- 7:10products or at least Etps ever launched.
- 7:13The demands been insatiable and it really speaks in my mind to
- 7:16just the a lot of the red tape and barriers to access that had
- 7:21existed previously with advisors, with institutional
- 7:24allocators and even actually retail investors.
- 7:27I think the 13 F show that it's still largely a retail market,
- 7:30but I'm curious how the past 18 months of kind of have they
- 7:36exceeded expectations, lagged expectations with the launch and
- 7:40appetite for the Bitcoin ETFs? Certainly exceeded.
- 7:45We had some internal numbers or guesses of what we thought the
- 7:49flows would be when these things launched and they far exceeded
- 7:53our expectations just on the research side.
- 7:55I'm not talking about our product side or anything like
- 7:57that, but absolutely blew it out of the water.
- 8:01If you combine all of these together, you know, you had Eric
- 8:04on the show. I listened to that episode,
- 8:05great episode and and he just ticked down like all the ways
- 8:08these things have have been the best performing exchange traded
- 8:12product ever in the history of all of these things.
- 8:15So to me there's just no doubt about it like that doesn't
- 8:17happen by accident. There has to be the an actual
- 8:21demand behind that. So even US who had a very
- 8:25optimistic idea like we suspected there was this pent up
- 8:28demand, there's pools of capital that would would allocate to
- 8:31this that were trapped and they could only allocate through this
- 8:34vehicle way more than we would have thought.
- 8:37So you mentioned like the the 13 F filing.
- 8:40So I, I find this really interesting because yes, you can
- 8:44say they still seem very retail because anyone who's not filing
- 8:49A13F is under the 100 million. So you can assume they're
- 8:53smaller than that. But if you look at other ET PS,
- 8:57like the percentage of of the dollar amount captured in the 13
- 9:01F filings is, is also not that high either.
- 9:05And the number of firms at launch is way higher than any
- 9:09other exchange trade product that is launched.
- 9:11So if you look at other, in other words, you look at other
- 9:13exchange trade products when they launch, how many people
- 9:16filed those 13 FS? It was maybe a few dozen or
- 9:19something and we've got I don't know how many now for the the
- 9:22Bitcoin ETP, so very notable there.
- 9:25The other thing that's interesting in the latest one
- 9:28with the data is advisors are now the top category.
- 9:32And I think that's very significant.
- 9:34We can talk about why that is because it used to be hedge
- 9:37funds and of course there's still some very big hedge funds
- 9:39on there. But to me, the, all the 13 F
- 9:42filings from the hedge funds, I'm not in this world.
- 9:45So I, I don't know all about it, but to me, most of those were
- 9:48doing the bases trade. So it's just an, an arbitrage.
- 9:52It's not the same as a conviction in long only holding
- 9:56this position in a portfolio or a client portfolio.
- 9:59So I think that's a big one. And then of course, you saw a
- 10:03big endowment, a big name endowment on the list there.
- 10:06And that's very notable to me. That's a lot of signal because
- 10:10pensions, endowments, foundations, that is one of the
- 10:13the institutional investor segments that has been the
- 10:16lowest allocated. So we've done five years of
- 10:19surveys in the past and those categories, those endowments and
- 10:23pensions foundations, they were always low to mid single digits
- 10:26in terms of what percent of our respondents said they were
- 10:29allocated to digital assets, the lowest by far of any other
- 10:32group. And so the fact that you're now
- 10:34seeing them, you're seeing a big name that removes a lot of the
- 10:37career risk for others. You know, these first movers are
- 10:39always the hardest to get to do this and it'll be interesting to
- 10:43see going forward if we if we see some more follow suit now.
- 10:47Yeah, the the pensions and endowments interesting 'cause I
- 10:50think it, I saw this morning Harvard's positions top five in
- 10:55their portfolio and it's greater than Google and I believe in
- 10:57NVIDIA. So it's pretty significant.
- 11:00One thing just to go back to on the just kind of like adoption
- 11:05in the past, the cycles, the thing that I haven't been able
- 11:08to reconcile is it feels like a lot of retail and the demand
- 11:13that we've seen in the blow off tops around this time ultimately
- 11:16come from reflexivity. Just the, the notion of a
- 11:19constrained supply and too much demand.
- 11:22And there's market forces on, you know, the having coupled
- 11:25with the price appreciation naturally has more buyers than
- 11:28sellers. And it feels like right now, my,
- 11:31my take is that that will, that will happen eventually because
- 11:34give us a fixed supply, infinite, you know, amount of
- 11:37demand, but it's just been elongated.
- 11:40And I don't know if it's because of the options market and
- 11:43institutional plumbing that has come in, if it's natural,
- 11:47because we've hit these new price points and there's a lot
- 11:50of flow coming out from holders that have been unfolding for,
- 11:53you know, almost a decade, because we've seen this like
- 11:57also demand from whether it's the ETFs or treasury companies.
- 12:02So I'm just curious how you think about that because my
- 12:04personal take is that we're just seeing these like cycle
- 12:08elongated and we're going to come back with that volatility,
- 12:10at least in some respects, it's just getting pushed out.
- 12:14But I haven't thought that deeply about it to to form a
- 12:17great take. It's just a take.
- 12:20No, I'm in a similar position to you #1 I do think the
- 12:25infrastructure and the build out of all these derivatives markets
- 12:27does dampen volatility. And you can look at traditional
- 12:31finance proxies. So for example, commodities.
- 12:34Commodities didn't used to be an investable asset class.
- 12:36It wasn't until the 90s that they actually became
- 12:39institutionalized. And then there's a lot of
- 12:41academic research that you're exposed to and you go through
- 12:44with like the CFA program and all this stuff in tradfy world
- 12:47where they show empirically that when you get derivative markets,
- 12:51options, futures and you get these deeper liquid markets on
- 12:55top of something that will dampen the volatility.
- 12:58Because you're bringing in all these other players, people who
- 13:01like volatility, people who want to sell volatility, who want to
- 13:03buy volatility. So that does dampen it down and
- 13:07it gives people exposure to the asset.
- 13:09It gives them a levered way to to get exposure.
- 13:12So I do think that's one factor. The the other factor though is
- 13:16exactly what we've been seeing and in writing about.
- 13:18There's an analyst on our team, Zach, who published a report on
- 13:22the ancient supply, quote UN quote, it can be any threshold
- 13:27you want to make it. I think in this, this first
- 13:28report, he made it 10 years and it shows that the new coins
- 13:33coming into the ancient supply cohort, that threshold because
- 13:37every day that goes by, more gets added.
- 13:39More coins on average are being added to that cohort. 10 years
- 13:43of being inactive or more, more coins are being added to that
- 13:47cohort than new coins now being released from the the network.
- 13:52And to your point, that's exactly true.
- 13:54What we've been seeing too, where it's we see, we can see
- 13:58empirically all the demand from the Bitcoin treasury companies
- 14:02and we can see the demand from the exchange traded product.
- 14:05And that demand dwarfs all the new Bitcoin that is created
- 14:09every day, every week, every month.
- 14:11So the question is, where's the extra supply coming from?
- 14:14Who's selling? And to your point, yes, we see
- 14:16in the on chain data, it's these very long term holders that have
- 14:19been selling. And if you look at a report,
- 14:21he's got dots and then also bars of like how much has moved.
- 14:26And in the last cycle those original investors, early
- 14:29investors, they sold into the rally.
- 14:32This cycle they're selling even more heavily into the rally.
- 14:35And of course it is just coin movement.
- 14:37So you might get some people just moving coins, not selling
- 14:39it obviously, but you see it anecdotally.
- 14:42We saw the press release about a company that helps someone, an
- 14:46early investor, liquidate 84,000 Bitcoin.
- 14:49So we're seeing it anecdotally. We're seeing the market absorb
- 14:52it and that's who's selling. The question is at some point
- 14:56you would think those original holders have to get exhausted.
- 15:00Like anyone who wants to sell it around 100K is going to be done.
- 15:03You know, like the press release said, for the estate planning
- 15:06purposes, they're going to be done selling whatever amount of
- 15:09stack they want until we get to a new high price point and then
- 15:12maybe that induces more people to sell.
- 15:14But eventually you would think you start to see that supply
- 15:17demand imbalance and the price squeeze higher as a result of
- 15:21that. But again, who knows?
- 15:23We'll see. No, I think it's an important
- 15:26notion you shared because it's a truly elegant system that I
- 15:29think a lot of individual investors and institutional
- 15:31investors will look at the market forces and believe you'll
- 15:34end up with a centralized supply, you'll end up with
- 15:37individuals. But over empirically over 15
- 15:39years, we've seen that supply get distributed because
- 15:42naturally people realize realize their gains for number of
- 15:45reasons. And so I think it's important
- 15:47fact that this is just a natural part of Bitcoins distribution
- 15:50cycle and mechanism. And it's a great thing.
- 15:54It's a great thing to see it distributed amongst other
- 15:56parties and and it should be expected and somewhat welcomed
- 16:00in my opinion because it's showing it's going along in this
- 16:03adoption, adoption journey just like everything else.
- 16:09Yeah, all very interesting points, Chris.
- 16:11I'd love to go back to some of the earlier points you made on
- 16:13the 13 FS because we've heard for a long time that advisors
- 16:19were coming, you know, traditional finance was stepping
- 16:21in, the institutions are here. Like these narratives go back at
- 16:25least one cycle, maybe 2. But I would say it, you know, we
- 16:29finally have gotten to that point in 2024 in particular and
- 16:32now in 25 with the ETFs, the other products that have been
- 16:37brought to market. And you mentioned something that
- 16:39was interesting on the advisors now being the largest cohort of
- 16:43filers. We'd love to dig a little bit
- 16:45deeper there and better understand the significance of
- 16:48that. You also juxtapose that to the,
- 16:52the hedge funds were previously the largest buyer and and they
- 16:55typically or the largest filer rather.
- 16:58And to your point, there could be basis trades, they're
- 17:00typically not seeking long term strategic asset allocations that
- 17:04could be more tactical or more of a trade.
- 17:06So how do you think about the advisor showing up in a bigger
- 17:09way and general thoughts there? And then I guess going forward,
- 17:14like what are you hearing from advisors in terms of interest
- 17:17and questions around Bitcoin? So I'll take that last part
- 17:21first. And it's funny you asked that
- 17:22because I don't know if this is coincidental or what, but just
- 17:25in the past few weeks here, I've had multiple conversations with
- 17:31advisors, wealth advisors, Rias who've been reaching out to us
- 17:35and they're all saying the same thing.
- 17:37And it's some version of this. We know we have to get educated
- 17:40in this space. Our clients are asking.
- 17:43This isn't going away. So we're starting our journey
- 17:46now because we feel like we're behind.
- 17:48Can you help us? Can you help us get up to speed?
- 17:50And they are, they are literally starting at at square one.
- 17:53I just had a like a digital assets one-on-one conversation
- 17:56and presentation with a, a very big advisory firm.
- 17:59I won't say the name. So that's interesting of where
- 18:03they're at and what they're saying because they're now
- 18:06recognizing this isn't going away.
- 18:08We have to deal with it and they're finally taking some
- 18:10action. It's big enough to move the
- 18:12needle for them either from a portfolio perspective for
- 18:15returns and and all the benefits that Bitcoin could give their
- 18:19clients, but also just from a risk competitive standpoint, if
- 18:22their competitors are going to be doing it, people are going to
- 18:25go go to their competitors. And of course, the big tailwind
- 18:30behind all of this, as you might know, is the boomer generation
- 18:34retiring, passing, passing on their assets.
- 18:37And I forget what the data is, but there's it's, it's a very
- 18:39high percentage of children who do not stay with their parents
- 18:44financial advisor. And, and I think it's kind of
- 18:46like you don't go to your father's Barber.
- 18:49It's like, I don't want the same haircut my dad had.
- 18:51So for whatever reason, people don't want to go to the same
- 18:53financial advisor their parents had.
- 18:55They want to be different and, and of course, digital assets
- 18:58are going to be a big part of that in my opinion, because as
- 19:01you know, the younger generation is digitally native.
- 19:03They're much more receptive to this.
- 19:05They have the time and, and the, the horizon and the, the wealth
- 19:08to deal with this. I personally think the advisor
- 19:12space is the, the lowest hanging fruit or the path of least
- 19:16resistance for adoption right now because A, it's a massive
- 19:19pool capital B, the infrastructure is already there.
- 19:24Before they did not have easy 1 button solutions like the
- 19:28exchange traded products. Now they have multiple channels.
- 19:31For example, Fidelity is, is integrated into our wealth
- 19:35platform now of Fidelity digital assets.
- 19:37So there's another channel as well.
- 19:39For a lot of these people, the stigma has been removed, the
- 19:42career risk has been removed and it's going to be client driven.
- 19:45So I think that's a big force. And then the other thing is
- 19:50again, as an example, this this major firm we were just talking
- 19:53to, we found out they technically do allow clients to
- 19:58get exposure to Bitcoin, but it's there's like half a dozen
- 20:02or more hurdles or checklist they have to go through.
- 20:06Biggest one, it's still non solicited.
- 20:07So they can't sell it, they can't recommend it.
- 20:10They have to have either like net worth or income level
- 20:13thresholds or age or appropriate risk levels.
- 20:16However, they determine that so. There's a lot of hurdles to
- 20:20still overcome, but I think over time that that will go away and
- 20:24and that's OK that they're there because the fact that they're
- 20:26even there is is helpful. And it's just a matter of
- 20:31getting them educated and comfortable with these things to
- 20:32remove some of those hurdles that they still have up on
- 20:35these. Yeah, it's an amazing anecdote
- 20:38at the the first step to recovery is admitting you might
- 20:41have a problem and you know, the realization that maybe they they
- 20:45should get educated on it because it's not going away.
- 20:48We've heard similar anecdotes to your point on whether it's
- 20:50compliance or just like getting the approval to offer them up is
- 20:54a is a still a barrier. But then the other side into
- 20:58your point where Raas, specifically the emergent banks
- 21:02and Raas I see is like really big opportunities because they
- 21:05run like private businesses, they have the incentive to bring
- 21:09assets AUM back on platform, right.
- 21:13So the thing that doesn't really get talked about a lot is
- 21:16Bitcoin mean close to a $2.5 trillion market, give or take
- 21:20where we sit. And about a trillion of that
- 21:21sits in these hardware devices offline.
- 21:24And they've sat there for a very long time and people feel
- 21:26increasingly uncomfortable and they want to bring them back
- 21:28into the financial world. But there's no mechanism for
- 21:31that, whether in kind, you know, contribution, bringing them onto
- 21:34a custody platform or a banking solution.
- 21:36And this is still very foreign to a lot of the tratified world.
- 21:40And we hear a lot of the stable coin fervor and obviously
- 21:42there's a lot happening to stable coins, but that's going
- 21:45to be a very, I don't want to say commoditized game, but it's,
- 21:48it's the movement of assets versus the aggregation of
- 21:50assets. And then that growth that I
- 21:52think most advisors still don't, they're starting to appreciate.
- 21:55It's like it's the fastest growing asset of all time.
- 21:57If you bring it on platform, you're going to be able to build
- 21:59in U.S. dollar terms, whatever that that growth is going to
- 22:02achieve in the coming years. Yeah, absolutely.
- 22:07A lot of interesting points there as well.
- 22:09The Chris, I looked it up while you were speaking and so the
- 22:12number is about 80% if people are curious about the next
- 22:16generation choosing not to use their parents financial
- 22:19advisors. So I can imagine that is a big,
- 22:22you know, it's a big catalyst for advisors wanting to get
- 22:25educated because they recognize, to your point, that while there
- 22:29is a lot of, if you look at the, the nominal number of ownership
- 22:33of Bitcoin by older generations, baby boomers and jacks, they
- 22:36have more money. So they, they do own Bitcoin.
- 22:39But in terms of volume of purchases, Gen.
- 22:42Z millennials far outpace those generations.
- 22:45And so I can imagine, a, to your point, if they're not getting
- 22:49smart on Bitcoin and their, their clients are asking them
- 22:52about it, Well, the clients are going to start asking their, you
- 22:54know, their competitors about it, which is a problem.
- 22:57And B, if they're not up to speed and educated and speaking
- 23:01the same language about what the children are interested in, in
- 23:04many cases, these would be like 20-30 year old, 40 year old
- 23:06children, then they're, they're not going to have a relationship
- 23:10with the advisor either. So I think that is maybe one of
- 23:13the underappreciated things about Bitcoin being so early in
- 23:16this all where it's $2 trillion asset class 15 years later, we
- 23:21have a lot of ways to go here. It's, it's still very early for
- 23:25Bitcoin and the portfolios are going to change.
- 23:28And that kind of ties into the next topic I wanted to discuss
- 23:31with you is you'd mentioned before we hit record the idea of
- 23:34bonds being an impaired asset. I would love for you to explain
- 23:38that topic and then we could discuss maybe in these advisor
- 23:42conversations that you're having, how are they starting to
- 23:44think about and how do you speak to them about portfolio
- 23:48allocation as relates to Bitcoin?
- 23:50Where does it fit in? How do they think about it in
- 23:52that context? Yeah, I'll take the later part
- 23:56of that question first, which is for us, we've been pretty
- 24:00consistent or at least I'd say very consistent in advocating
- 24:04that Bitcoin is best understood as a monetary asset, an aspiring
- 24:08store of value. And so whenever you think of
- 24:12Bitcoin, especially as an advisor or institutional
- 24:14investor, whatever you think of it, whatever you've heard of it,
- 24:17you owe it to your yourself, your clients, your fiduciary
- 24:20duty to just look at it on a pure investment basis and, and
- 24:24just look at the stats, look at the characteristics of it.
- 24:28So it has a low positive correlation to every major asset
- 24:31class, even other real assets like gold, commodities, real
- 24:35estate. It has at least historically, an
- 24:37asymmetric risk reward, so much higher upside than downside.
- 24:42The the return is obviously absolutely fantastic.
- 24:45But then of course, people look at the volatility and get
- 24:47scared. But again, as a professional
- 24:49investor, you should be looking at risk versus reward, right?
- 24:53Things like sharp ratios, certina ratios.
- 24:56So if you just take down all those things, you would say this
- 25:01at least deserves some attention.
- 25:04It it ticks all the boxes of what traditional finance would
- 25:07say, which is to add a non correlated or low correlated
- 25:10positive returning asset that can increase my risk adjusted
- 25:14returns. Like that is the Holy Grail of
- 25:16all portfolio management. So I think that's one thing to
- 25:20just look at on a, on a base level.
- 25:22And maybe for, for some, the answer is still no, this doesn't
- 25:26make sense. But at least you've done the
- 25:28work and you've, you have a reason for it and you're not
- 25:30just pushing it aside and just saying like, oh, hand waving and
- 25:34saying volatility in a vague way or something like that.
- 25:37In terms of your the first part of the question, the role of it
- 25:41in the portfolio, this is where you get into the idea of having
- 25:47a non sovereign asset in your portfolio, something that a lot
- 25:52of people think of as an insurance policy against
- 25:56currency debasement, preserving your purchasing power, perhaps a
- 26:00a put to our insurance policy against fiscal or monetary
- 26:03policy error, if you will. So that's another way to extend
- 26:07this as into the actual economic reason, not just the statistical
- 26:11reason. And I was talking about this
- 26:13with Yuri and Timmer here at Fidelity, who is a great macro
- 26:17guy who found his way into Bitcoin, but he's been a
- 26:20Fidelity over 3 decades now and has been covering macro for that
- 26:24period of time. So he's very well versed in all
- 26:27the major tried 5 macro stuff. And he's the one that brought up
- 26:30this idea of we're so used to the standard 6040.
- 26:33We're so used to bonds being the anchor to the portfolio.
- 26:37But, and again, this isn't a recommendation, but just a
- 26:40question that people should be considering and asking
- 26:42themselves. He said.
- 26:45If you've got fiscal deficits as far as the eye can see and that
- 26:48doesn't seem to change, at what point do you ask the question,
- 26:52are bonds an impaired asset class?
- 26:55And right now we are in a five year drawdown for the general
- 26:59bond market, one of the longest ever.
- 27:02And if you look at bonds on a historical basis and, and look
- 27:06at their drawdown in real terms, inflation adjusted terms during
- 27:11the high inflation period, the stagflation period, the 70s and
- 27:1380s, bonds had a real drawdown of 50%.
- 27:18And so people, people don't realize like that's what you,
- 27:21what you can bring home and eat, right, the real return.
- 27:25And so you think you're, you're getting safety and an anchor and
- 27:28bonds, but you're actually not. And so his question was, at what
- 27:33point do people start thinking with the 6040, I need to
- 27:36diversify away from the 40 into alternative assets, not the 60
- 27:40because the traditional attitude is, oh, if I want to go into
- 27:43alts, I take it out of my quote, high risk bucket equities to
- 27:47fund it. At what point do you say though,
- 27:50I'm going to start taking it out of this potentially impaired
- 27:53asset class and start funding alternatives like Bitcoin or
- 27:57even other things, which I I thought was a really interesting
- 28:00idea that is not being talked about enough?
- 28:05Absolutely. I'm quite curious about that as
- 28:06well because you mentioned just the economic case for Bitcoin,
- 28:11right. You, you can point to the fiscal
- 28:13conditions of the country, you can point to monetary policy.
- 28:16And it's kind of interesting because I feel like a lot of
- 28:20these, a lot of the themes that people in the Bitcoin space talk
- 28:24about were once considered very fringe or kind of out there as a
- 28:28related to kind of bringing that into traditional finance and
- 28:31thinking through, you know, sharp ratios, portfolio
- 28:34construction and whatnot. And I'm, I'm curious, is that
- 28:36still the case these days? Is it still like when you bring
- 28:40up currency, just debasement, is that a term that advisors are
- 28:44familiar with or do you kind of have to explain these things
- 28:47Still genuinely curious about that.
- 28:49And then how is that idea of bond bonds as an impaired asset
- 28:54class landed? Is that like a radical idea to
- 28:57many advisors? It depends on the advisor for
- 29:01sure. But yes, I would say still very
- 29:03radical. They're still not thinking about
- 29:06currency debasement. You know, of course, we are
- 29:08privileged to live in Western world in the US where we have
- 29:11the, the world reserve currency. So it's a little bit like asking
- 29:16a fish what is water? You ask a financial advisor or a
- 29:19financial person like what is money or what is currency?
- 29:21The basement. It's like, what are you, what
- 29:23are you talking about? And of course they're, they're
- 29:25basing their heuristics on, on, on the priors.
- 29:28Like we've been in a bowl, a bond bull market for 40 plus
- 29:33years. It's worked out great for them.
- 29:35All their clients are happy. It's done exactly what they
- 29:38wanted it to do and expected it to do.
- 29:41So why would they change, right? There's no, there's no incentive
- 29:45to change yet at this point. And so that is what makes it
- 29:48very difficult to try to get people to see.
- 29:51And again, I'm not rooting for this or saying it will
- 29:54absolutely happen. I'm just saying people need to
- 29:56think about are there massive structural changes that are
- 30:00going to happen that will affect you and your portfolio?
- 30:02And if so, what's the best way to protect against that?
- 30:07And it doesn't mean you have to go all in on something.
- 30:09It just means like what's the the most capital efficient way
- 30:12to protect against that. And I think that's what deserves
- 30:15the question and attention. So that's the way I try to frame
- 30:18it, like try to angle in there, but it is difficult to your
- 30:21point. So many of you are familiar with
- 30:23On Ramp for the work that we do directly with individuals, for
- 30:27people who are looking to protect their Bitcoin for
- 30:29themselves, their families, for the long term.
- 30:32You may not be familiar that we launched On Ramp Institutional,
- 30:35which is the area of a firm focused on financial advisors,
- 30:40institutional allocators such as pensions, endowments, family
- 30:44offices. And this arm of the firm is
- 30:47really equipping institutional allocators with a trusted team
- 30:52that can provide advisory services, guidance, and just a
- 30:57framework for navigating the space.
- 30:58Because ultimately, there have been so many losses, there has
- 31:02been no shortage of counterparty risk, and there's been so many
- 31:05distractions beyond Bitcoin. And so if you are within an
- 31:09organization that is looking to better understand Bitcoin or you
- 31:13find yourself being the one who's champion Bitcoin
- 31:15internally, but you need an external organization to provide
- 31:19some air cover, provide some education and research, we are
- 31:23really the firm to do that. So please get in touch with us
- 31:25at on rampbitcoin.com. You can also e-mail me direct
- 31:29Jackson at on rampbitcoin.com. Happy to have a conversation.
- 31:33Would love to meet you since you're a listener to the show.
- 31:35So don't be a stranger. Reach out and we'll see how we
- 31:37can help you out. Thank you.
- 31:39Chris, curious how gold fits into that, you know, with gold
- 31:42sitting at close to all time highs into that story, because I
- 31:48think gold has a similar notion in, in camps of the gold bugs.
- 31:54And it's a it's, it's an alternative asset And the 6040
- 31:57is the 6040. But the, the gold markets and
- 32:01what's happening can't go unnoticed in the same way
- 32:03Bitcoin can. And curious and they're, they're
- 32:07two sides of a different or the same coin, just different types
- 32:10of trades. 1, you know, operates a little bit more like an
- 32:12equity, but just curious like how that narrative goes.
- 32:15And I guess the other part is how was the experience been with
- 32:18individuals versus like institutions?
- 32:20Because institutions, I feel like there's a lot of inertia
- 32:23and people, nobody ever gets fired for first sticking with
- 32:26the status quo. But we see this, I know in the
- 32:29day-to-day with peers and probably folks you talk with in
- 32:33real terms, the portfolio is not keeping up with what it costs in
- 32:38day-to-day living, whether it's the house, insurance, the car,
- 32:42the vacation, you know, bonds, appreciate it, whatever the
- 32:45number is in real terms. And then you look at the S&P,
- 32:49people are starting to feel it because of the level of
- 32:51debasement that's occurred. Just curious like how that
- 32:54mosaic starts to frame some of these conversations over time.
- 32:58People are definitely feeling it, right?
- 33:00Anyone who's been in the market for a house or anyone who has to
- 33:04manage a household, if prices, prices have gone up 25 to 30% on
- 33:10average in the last five years, that that has to be felt by the
- 33:13average person. But on the other level of say,
- 33:16institutional investors, you're exactly right.
- 33:18There's so much inertia there because they have committees,
- 33:22because they have career risks. Look at their incentives like
- 33:25the old adage, show me the incentives, I'll show you the
- 33:27outcome. Their incentives are I stick my
- 33:30neck out, make a very contrarian play here.
- 33:33If it does, great, maybe I get a little bit of that reward or
- 33:37promotion, or maybe they do get some compensation based on that.
- 33:42But if it goes against them, they're out of a job.
- 33:44Which risk reward here? Yeah, like a little reward, but
- 33:47a lot of risk to take that on. And interestingly, I'll, I'll
- 33:50share another anecdote here. I went to a pension event and
- 33:53there was someone there. Of course, they won't name
- 33:56names, but the they were one of the very early investors in
- 34:00digital assets with a pension fund in the United States.
- 34:04And it's obviously been the best performing asset in their entire
- 34:08portfolio. And even with that, they still
- 34:12get heat and they still get a lot of Flack for this.
- 34:15So it's like even if you did the right thing, you're still
- 34:19getting penalized for it at this at this higher institutional
- 34:22level. And so that's why we see
- 34:24anecdotally and in our data or survey data, any institutional
- 34:28investor that has more of an individual at the helm is going
- 34:30to be a lot more adopted to this.
- 34:33So think like single family offices, certain Rias, obviously
- 34:37high net worth individuals, hedge funds, all of those are
- 34:42well up the adoption curve compared to the big institutions
- 34:47that have committees and governance and all those things,
- 34:49which is obviously necessary and good for them.
- 34:52But the flip side is they're going to be slower to move.
- 34:55Now this also squares the the circle of like, how can so many
- 34:59people say they have exposure, but we're still at quote, only a
- 35:03$2 trillion asset class for for Bitcoin.
- 35:06And the reason is a lot of people in the number of firms or
- 35:10institutions can say they have exposure.
- 35:12But the ones that have the lowest exposure, like I said
- 35:14before, single mid low digits, at least this was the case a
- 35:17couple years back. They're the big money.
- 35:20So the big gorilla in the room is like very low allocated and
- 35:24all the other smaller fish are have a higher allocation.
- 35:27So that's why you see the disparity in those numbers to
- 35:32oh, go ahead. I would say this is really great
- 35:34framing and important framing because I think what helps is
- 35:38individual see a Bitcoin price at $110,000 and will naturally
- 35:41think it's overheated. You know what's going on, but
- 35:44you're laying out the exact case on why it's still very early.
- 35:47And there's so much upside because of the, the notion of,
- 35:51I've talked about it, a lot of bitcoins ultimately been an
- 35:54emergent asset with individuals because it requires a consensus
- 35:57of one, maybe 2 if you talk to your wife about getting the
- 36:00allocation. And so to your point, you see
- 36:02the family offices and specifically the public traded
- 36:04companies are generally Alex Leachman, I think coined the
- 36:08term, the orange dictators at these companies because they
- 36:11kind of like run the firm or have a very, the governance is a
- 36:14little bit different than a traditional firm.
- 36:16And then the other side of that. But your point is, the most
- 36:19sophisticated investors that are, that are have been
- 36:22established and rewarded for thinking differently.
- 36:25Paul Tudor Jones, Stan Druckenmiller, You look at
- 36:28Swift, one of the best endowments run in the country,
- 36:30made the allocation. Harvard.
- 36:32It's happening. But at the same point, there's
- 36:34just this stigma that exists. And but that is the opportunity.
- 36:37And I think sometimes it's helpful to understand why the
- 36:39opportunity exists so you can look at it at face value versus
- 36:43like, oh, I must be missing something.
- 36:44This is too good to be true. It's just the reality of there's
- 36:46bureaucracy and there's inertia that exists.
- 36:49And that is why we're still so early and allocations are still
- 36:52so limited. Yeah.
- 36:56And and to that point as well, it's been while we have seen in
- 36:59the 13 apps, we've seen some major players step in.
- 37:02We, we named Harvard as an endowment on the recent filings,
- 37:07I think the largest endowment, university endowment in the
- 37:09country or at least in the top three or five.
- 37:12But then you've also seen some major pension funds as well.
- 37:16But to your point, Chris, these, these entities are allocating
- 37:21like a few basis points of the portfolio.
- 37:24I mean, it's still significant relative to what an individual
- 37:27or maybe just some single family offices may be able to allocate.
- 37:30But at the end of the day, you know, $100 million, two hundred
- 37:33$300 million allocation may only just be like 20 bits of the
- 37:37portfolio, perhaps even less. And so I do just want to
- 37:40emphasize the fact that while for some people may feel like
- 37:44you're kind of late to the party here or, you know, Bitcoins best
- 37:47years are behind it, it's just fundamentally a different
- 37:51market. And to a lot of Chris's points,
- 37:54there are way more advisors out there that are starting at
- 37:58Ground Zero with education than there are advisors, you know,
- 38:01let's say registered independent advisory firms that are very
- 38:04sophisticated on Bitcoin, that have Bitcoin and most of their
- 38:07client portfolios. So I would just encourage people
- 38:10that you're really not late here.
- 38:12It is a good time to be just thinking learning more about
- 38:16Bitcoin. And I would love to get your
- 38:19thoughts on this, Chris, because we mentioned at the start of the
- 38:21conversation that the four year, specifically the four year
- 38:26cycles are dead is kind of what you had said there.
- 38:29And I'm curious then like how do you think about the market going
- 38:32forward? If, if we're not really just if
- 38:37sentiments not really being driven by the having anymore,
- 38:40it's not following what we have historically seen over the past
- 38:4315 years, then what are you paying attention to?
- 38:45What should investors pay attention to to inform their
- 38:49investment thesis around Bitcoin?
- 38:51Yeah, I want to go back to the the last comment just to add a
- 38:54little more color on to get people to understand of like
- 38:56where we are with with institutions and then I'll I'll
- 38:59answer that one. I was at a a family office
- 39:04event. So it was just like network for
- 39:05family offices and there was decision makers there and and
- 39:08some of the actual families. And of course we're asking
- 39:11around. And do you have any allocation
- 39:13to, to Bitcoin or digital assets?
- 39:15It was either none at all, very little or the most common answer
- 39:20was yes, we invest in a funds like a private equity or VC
- 39:25funds that is investing in companies.
- 39:28And so my point bringing this up to give you some color is these
- 39:32institutions invest in channels and packages and things that
- 39:36they know and they already have procedures around and compliance
- 39:39around. So ironically, it's easier for
- 39:42them to do a more complicated, convoluted investment and
- 39:48structure in a fund that's investing in infrastructure and
- 39:51companies in the digital asset space than it is to just buy
- 39:54spot Bitcoin or, or an exchange traded product.
- 39:57And, and I bring that up because that also helps answer this
- 39:59question of like, why isn't the price higher or how could the
- 40:03price move higher? We haven't gotten to the point
- 40:06where people are just making the the more simple allocation to
- 40:10just. Pure exposure, they're still
- 40:13investing in all these other things, which I think is quite,
- 40:16quite interesting and telling. And I personally think there's
- 40:19just also a bit of a, a bit of AI don't want to say attitude,
- 40:25but like general idea of like if you're a family office, you're
- 40:29very sophisticated, you're used to doing sophisticated alpha
- 40:32generating strategies that the common person cannot.
- 40:36And ironically the the the bigger alpha generating is
- 40:39probably to have just been allocated to to spot Bitcoin
- 40:42over the last few years at least.
- 40:45Can I, can I add one thing to that?
- 40:48My assumption and thesis has been that the reason and we, we
- 40:53had this report that came out from early writers, which was
- 40:57about moving from a hobbyist industry to mainstream.
- 40:59And we likened it referencing whether you looked at like the
- 41:03PC computer specifically and how it was a bunch of obvious that
- 41:06used to be at meetups and put together motherboards and, and
- 41:09ultimately somebody had to commercialize a desktop
- 41:12computer. And the things that happened,
- 41:14you know, post that you couldn't really see to the future.
- 41:17And my assumption is the VC firms or the firms that
- 41:20historically had been the case. My thesis is that the pub codes
- 41:24are an example of this and the ETFs as well somewhat versus
- 41:29spot is that you're kind of pushing over the risk to these
- 41:33institutions or these other individuals because you can't
- 41:37get fired. It's something that you can't
- 41:38get fired for it. But you look at like the
- 41:40pensions in the, in Canada that went into FTX or the venture
- 41:43fund that went into FTX, they're probably OK, we made a bad bet
- 41:46because it's VC and some bets, you know, don't pay off.
- 41:49But that notion of spot custody because we had not figured out
- 41:53custody yet. And I know this is like a meta
- 41:55theme, but there's this notion that for 15 years people
- 41:58associate Bitcoin with a Ponzi because you keep hearing every
- 42:02few years that it ends up in a landfill on this little hard
- 42:06drive or it ends up in North Korean wallets.
- 42:09And I think that we don't fully appreciate that that is
- 42:13subconsciously the reason why most people are afraid to look
- 42:16at this asset and ultimately see what we're talking about here,
- 42:19Because then it means they have a problem of like, Oh my God,
- 42:21now I need, I'm under, I'm under allocated.
- 42:23I need to figure it out. And that opens up a whole other
- 42:26can of worms of like, well, who's a custodian?
- 42:28How do I make sure that it's going to last for 10 years?
- 42:30And so it's much easier to push that risk to the micro strategy
- 42:34and Sailor and you figure it out.
- 42:35I'm allocating to an equity or even the BlackRock and Coinbase,
- 42:39which we know there's, you know, significant, I want to say
- 42:42significant counterparty risk. But historically for 15 years,
- 42:45there have been problems with centralized custodians.
- 42:49And so anyway, I think that's just another component that
- 42:52exists in the substrate of individuals minds that you just
- 42:55hear in the news in these cycles keep coming back.
- 42:57And that volatility isn't just pure volatility of the asset,
- 43:00but it's a volatility of what other asset do you allocate to
- 43:03in the next day. It could actually be a 0 because
- 43:07you got the wrong custodian wrong, right, the wrong
- 43:09counterparty, not that the thesis was wrong.
- 43:11And so I think that's another component of it.
- 43:14I obviously can't prove it, but you see like SWIB and these
- 43:17other firms allocating the microstrategies and the meta
- 43:20planets of the world, like independent of their growth
- 43:23trajectory, there's still a bunch of execution risk on the
- 43:26management company when you should just be holding the
- 43:28underlying if you're already underweight it.
- 43:30And that's one of the logical conclusions I've at least come
- 43:32to is you're just pushing out that risk into other forms
- 43:35because if it goes wrong, you have somewhere to point.
- 43:38Yeah. I think from their perspective,
- 43:40they want another layer of management for to insulate them.
- 43:45But to your point, they might unknowingly or unknowingly be
- 43:48taking on additional risk by doing that, then yeah.
- 43:53I forget who it was is. Oh, go ahead, Chris.
- 43:55No, go ahead, I. Was just going to say to your
- 43:57point about the, the family offices and some of these
- 44:00institutional portfolios you'd mentioned in anecdotes for, you
- 44:04know, people are looking for alpha generating strategies and
- 44:07they tend to overcomplicate things and in some part of good
- 44:11reason, right. There's a lot of funds out there
- 44:13that deliver on their absolute return or risk adjusted return
- 44:16targets and beat their benchmarks.
- 44:19But at the same time, Bitcoin is really not something that needs
- 44:22to be overly complicated or sophisticated.
- 44:25And so I, I do think that there is this friction point with a
- 44:30lot of these allocators because to your point, they're looking,
- 44:34they're, they're not used to holding the benchmark in many
- 44:37ways, right? They're looking for strategies
- 44:39that will do something sophisticated to outperform or
- 44:42maybe they're not even looking to outperform a benchmark, but
- 44:44they look to protect some sort of downside, right?
- 44:46There's all sorts of different strategies out there.
- 44:50And with Bitcoin, it's something that we look to do as a firm is
- 44:54really share the idea that the the alpha is to your point,
- 44:57Chris having a long term allocation of Bitcoin and the
- 45:02alpha is in the custody in the infrastructure, right.
- 45:04Like you guys do great work at Fidelity.
- 45:06I think we do great work here at on ramp.
- 45:08And so the idea is that if you can have a long term allocation
- 45:11to Bitcoin and you can secure it for the long haul because many
- 45:14people haven't been able to do that, you are in some ways
- 45:16generating alpha. You are able to enjoy in terms
- 45:21of your portfolio gains, you're able to enjoy that appreciation
- 45:24over the long term. And so I think that's what a lot
- 45:26of people are still missing is there really is alpha in just
- 45:28having spot exposure and having a good infrastructure partner.
- 45:33Yeah, I was thinking this the other day of there's three
- 45:37major, major decisions or, or hurdles people have to get over
- 45:43to reap the full benefit of Bitcoin, or at least potentially
- 45:46I should say. And we are so focused on #1
- 45:49because that's where everyone's AT.
- 45:50And it's somewhat the hardest, which is number 1, is just to
- 45:54develop a thesis and, and get on board and say, I'm going to
- 45:57allocate whatever percentage to this.
- 46:00And that's like 90% of my time. But to your point #2 is then
- 46:05don't get scared out of it or conversely, don't completely
- 46:09sell it when it goes up 100% and said maybe think about
- 46:13rebalancing that. You have to give it room to run
- 46:17in and stay convicted. So #2 is holding it like, OK,
- 46:21I've allocated now I'm actually going to hold it.
- 46:23I'm not just going to view this as a trade.
- 46:24It's going to be a core position.
- 46:26And then the third major, major thing is securing it for the
- 46:29long term and not messing that up because then all your work
- 46:32from the previous two steps is just completely lost as well.
- 46:36Yeah, I think not to, you know, blow too much smoke, but that is
- 46:40a fundamental reason why fidelity is best in class in
- 46:43this industry. It's where the arm ramp was
- 46:45founded on is the research and education is the most important.
- 46:48It feels like the least important, but it actually is
- 46:51the most because if you don't have the understanding
- 46:53confidence, conviction in the underlying over the the past 15
- 46:58years, a lot of institutions that have effectively been exit
- 47:00liquidity, they come in at market tops and then they get
- 47:03left holding bag and sell. We saw MASA and soft make is a
- 47:05great example, I think back in 2017.
- 47:07It requires a heavy level of confidence to understand kind of
- 47:11like the allocation sizing, how you think about timing,
- 47:14volatility. And so there's very few
- 47:16businesses in the world still. That's how early we are.
- 47:19They go very deep including BlackRock because BlackRock
- 47:21launched an ETF. But as you guys know, it takes
- 47:25years to deeply understand this and be able to educate the
- 47:27market. And you can't come in in six
- 47:29months, 12 months, 24 months and produce best in class material
- 47:33content that can get institutions up to speed because
- 47:36this is a very deep and nuanced asset class.
- 47:40And so it just requires that level of education and in
- 47:42generally that's a time in the market product.
- 47:45If you're enjoying this episode, please leave us a like a
- 47:48comment. Please subscribe or rate 5 stars
- 47:51on your podcast player. All this helps a bunch.
- 47:55We spent a lot of time reaching out to guests to prepare for the
- 47:59episodes, record them, edit, distribute, you know the drill.
- 48:03So if you have just a few seconds here and you're enjoying
- 48:06the episode, please leave a comment, leave a like subscribe
- 48:09if you haven't done so already. It goes a long way.
- 48:12It helps to get our content out there.
- 48:14It helps more people to find this message.
- 48:17It also helps us to grow the show to bring on more guests so
- 48:20we can continue to add value to you.
- 48:22So thank you for being here. And if you don't mind, please
- 48:24leave us a like a comment subscribe rate 5 stars.
- 48:28Really appreciate it and hope to show up every single week and
- 48:32deliver a lot of value. And thanks again for being here.
- 48:36I appreciate it. Love to go back to we went on a
- 48:39bit of a tangent, but it was it was a worthwhile tangent.
- 48:42Go back to Chris. Your thoughts on so for your for
- 48:46your cycles are dead. So now what are you paying
- 48:48attention to going forward? What what do you pay attention
- 48:52to? What do you communicate to
- 48:53advisors and institutional allocators on how to think about
- 48:56Bitcoin and the, you know, the tailwinds or potential headwinds
- 48:59for the asset? Yeah, so the four year cycle I
- 49:03think is dead and like it's not going to happen like clockwork.
- 49:06You know, everyone likes to look at the the yearly candles,
- 49:09green, green, green, red, green, green, green, red.
- 49:12Could it happen again in the pattern repeat.
- 49:14Sure. There's there's cycles and
- 49:15everything, but if something looks that easy and that
- 49:18identifiable, I I tend to think not.
- 49:20It's like the old market adage. The market's job is to inflict
- 49:25the most pain or discomfort on the greatest number of people.
- 49:29So. To, to what we were talking
- 49:31about earlier before recording like this year seems so, so
- 49:34weird and odd because we always want to match it up to
- 49:37historical patterns. But I think that's the point of
- 49:39the market, right? It's going to, it's going to do
- 49:41what you least expect. It's going to inflict the most
- 49:44pain. And so I think cycles will
- 49:47continue, though I'm not in this camp of people saying the
- 49:50exchange trade products and the institutionalization, the
- 49:53treasury companies have changed everything.
- 49:54And we're, we're never going to see these deep bear markets
- 49:57again. I, I don't think so.
- 49:59I mean, if, if the stock market can easily go down 30% or or
- 50:03more in a general run-of-the-mill correction bear
- 50:06market, Bitcoin's definitely going to do more than that.
- 50:10It's incredible to me how low volatility is today in Bitcoin
- 50:14compared to the fact that we've hit new all time highs twice
- 50:18now. So I think Bitcoin Vols all the
- 50:20way down to like 35 realized Vol 30 day Vol stock market fix it
- 50:26at 15. But historically it's at least
- 50:2820 or so. So you're telling me that that
- 50:31bitcoins not even going to be double the volatility of the S&P
- 50:35over the next few years? I I would think not at least
- 50:38personally, but in terms of looking out longer term, a lot
- 50:42of this is just is just noise and cycles.
- 50:44And for me, the biggest long term framework I use macro
- 50:49framework is, is just simply liquidity.
- 50:53How much liquidity is out there? How much money printing is out
- 50:55there? You can look at global M2 broad
- 50:57money supplies. What we look at, you look over
- 51:00that at A at a long enough time horizon.
- 51:02And I'm not talking about some of these people that match up
- 51:04the charts or they do like a certain lag period.
- 51:08I think, I think that gets dangerous.
- 51:10Anybody can play play those games and that'll probably get
- 51:13you in in trouble. But just looking at a long
- 51:16statistical analysis, we find global M2, the changes in global
- 51:20M2 to the change of Bitcoin price statistically significant
- 51:24for sure. And a very high R-squared of 80
- 51:27to 90 or more. So 90% of Bitcoins price move
- 51:31can be explained by changes in the money supply.
- 51:34And it's a bit of a, a simple tautology like like if you're
- 51:38going to measure Bitcoin in dollars and the amount of
- 51:41dollars goes up, you're, you just have a ratio here, right?
- 51:43So you would think over time, dollars going up more than the
- 51:48amount of Bitcoin going up, that ratio is just going to naturally
- 51:51change. It doesn't have to obviously,
- 51:53but you see how simple that framework can be.
- 51:56So if I look at the, the macro environment right now, we wrote
- 52:02at the beginning of the year, at least I, I did for my section,
- 52:04why isn't anyone talking about stagflation?
- 52:06So this was very early January of this year.
- 52:09And the impetus for this was inflation had roared up to 9, a
- 52:14little over 9% CPI and we were coming back down and everyone
- 52:17said we've got inflation under control.
- 52:19And I said, we've seen this, this movie before in the, in the
- 52:2270s and 80s where people think, Oh yeah, inflation was high back
- 52:26then. Like it was just a homogeneous
- 52:28high inflation period. No, there was actually 3
- 52:30distinct waves. And so I was just asking the
- 52:33question. I said this isn't necessarily my
- 52:34base case, but it deserves some probability or some weighting of
- 52:40what happens if inflation is coming down.
- 52:42But it's just going to be another wave.
- 52:44And now we see the Fed cutting into inflation that's actually
- 52:49ticking up. So of course, they're leaning
- 52:51more on the labor market as the reason for the cut.
- 52:54And then you've got things like tariffs going into effect and
- 52:57what not, so that the Fed thinks labor market's slowing.
- 53:01We've got some other headwinds there.
- 53:03Maybe we do see a somewhat stagflationary environment
- 53:06again. And if inflation comes back, the
- 53:09other big factor that we found has a very high R-squared to to
- 53:13Bitcoin is inflation expectations.
- 53:16So again, it doesn't necessarily have to to actually manifest,
- 53:20but if people think inflation is coming back and get worried
- 53:24about it, that's the other thing that's going to drive Bitcoin
- 53:26over the medium to long term. Yeah, I think there was 2
- 53:29interesting points there that stood out to me.
- 53:31The first was agreed. It is kind of an odd time from a
- 53:35certainly from a volatility perspective, Chris, not only as
- 53:39you pointed out a Bitcoin but also in equities as well.
- 53:42And one of the things that I think people get hung up on is
- 53:46that volatility is bad, right. Like we had a report last fall,
- 53:52it was really focused on volatility of Bitcoin relative
- 53:55to other asset classes. And there's a perception that
- 53:57volatility is bad because most traditional assets exhibit more
- 54:01downside volatility than upside volatility.
- 54:04So just because you know, Chris is saying that he expects
- 54:08volatility to be higher than what it is in Bitcoin going
- 54:11forward doesn't necessarily mean well, you did say as well you
- 54:14expect correction. So there will be downside
- 54:16volatility, but also means Bitcoin historically has
- 54:18exhibited a lot of upside volatility has typically more
- 54:21good days and bad days when you look at volatility there.
- 54:25So that's I think one thing that typically falls short,
- 54:29especially for people who are entering the space, you know,
- 54:32new to Bitcoin and they just look at the high volatility, but
- 54:35they don't fully understand kind of the picture of how the
- 54:37performance skews. And then the other thing as well
- 54:40as I always just find it kind of humorous, the money supply thing
- 54:46kind of in 2020 when I started to dig more into the macro, the
- 54:50fiscal and monetary story and global liquidity and all that,
- 54:54it made a lot of sense to me intuitively that you would want
- 54:57to own the asset that performs best in an environment where
- 55:01credit expands indefinitely, inflate, you know, money supply
- 55:04expands indefinitely. But it is so interesting to me
- 55:08going back to earlier in this conversation where you mentioned
- 55:11the term currency debasement or I'm sure even just M2, a lot of
- 55:15advisors, a lot of people don't even look at M2, right?
- 55:18They, they've learned about it in an econ class in, in college
- 55:22or, you know, finance class, and then they don't really think too
- 55:25much about the money supply. Maybe that's changing, but it is
- 55:27remarkable to me that you can look at global M2 and you cited
- 55:3280 to 90% R-squared. A lot of the price movement of
- 55:35Bitcoin is simply explained by global liquidity.
- 55:38And so we're in an environment where that isn't necessarily
- 55:40going to change. And I just it, it's always
- 55:43remarkable to me. It's not not to say that's the
- 55:45only thing that impacts Bitcoin, but maybe people need to kind of
- 55:48like come back to first principles and, and understand
- 55:51more deeply what's, you know, what's moving the markets at a
- 55:54macro level of muscle and a micro.
- 55:57Yeah, that, that is one of we touched on before.
- 55:59One of the hardest things and one thing I have tried to show
- 56:05people to, to get this point across is price something like
- 56:08the SP500IN gold. And of course you can do this
- 56:11easily with with charting stuff nowadays and it's like it hasn't
- 56:14moved in decades, right. And of course, you, you maybe
- 56:17you should take the total return to account for dividends and
- 56:20cash flows to be fair. But Even so, it, it's like, wait
- 56:24a minute, I could have held just this non cash flowing assets,
- 56:29this inert metal and, and done just as well.
- 56:31And Michael, you asked about gold earlier, so we can get to
- 56:34that. But obviously we view them the
- 56:37same, the same way in terms of their monetary properties and
- 56:40and store value and hedge against potential currency
- 56:43debasement. But investors aren't doing that
- 56:46as much. I'll steal from from Yuri and
- 56:49Timmer again, where he's he says he views gold and Bitcoin
- 56:53different players on the same team.
- 56:55And a lot of times it hands the baton back and forth.
- 56:57So if you look historically, gold makes a move up, Bitcoin
- 57:00follows usually in a much bigger way.
- 57:04And then they take turns consolidate and moving back up
- 57:06again. So it'll be interesting to see
- 57:08what happens with with gold again.
- 57:10Again, back to my point of potential rising probability, I
- 57:14should say maybe still low, but rising probability of, of
- 57:18stagflation and higher inflation for people.
- 57:21And then I do want to go back to your first point, Jackson, on,
- 57:23on that report you put out, because it's one that I, I love
- 57:26to cite. And I know Mark Connors, who,
- 57:29who put out the term, you know, good cholesterol, bad
- 57:32cholesterol, there's good volatility, bad volatility,
- 57:35Absolutely love it. I, I asked him if I can use it.
- 57:37He said sure. I, so I, I shamelessly have
- 57:39stolen it because that one really resonates with advisors.
- 57:42And my favorite chart to show is if you look at the distribution
- 57:46of returns for the S&P, it's a pretty normal distribution in
- 57:50that shape that, that, that bell curve shape up, it's slightly
- 57:54skewed to the right. So there's a positive mean.
- 57:57So every month, if you look at it on a monthly basis, the the
- 58:00stock market's going to go up a percent or two, maybe down a
- 58:03percent or two. And the Bitcoin is like
- 58:05completely flipped inside out of that.
- 58:07There's very few occurrences in the middle.
- 58:10So it's either on a month to month basis going to go up a lot
- 58:13or down a lot. But to your point, historically
- 58:16at least, there's been a lot more positive occurrences on the
- 58:19right side. So you have more good volatility
- 58:22than bad. And that is one of the most
- 58:25underappreciated characteristics of Bitcoin, in my opinion, for
- 58:29the traditional finance space, because it completely flips on
- 58:32its head everything you've ever been taught about it, which is
- 58:36risk equals standard deviation. And there's good reason for
- 58:40that. The old adage stocks take the
- 58:42escalator up, the elevator down. The reason traditional finance
- 58:46is so, so enamored with, with volatility is because it's
- 58:51almost always happening when things are crashing, right?
- 58:54So they see volatility, you can almost assume bad things are
- 58:58happening, things are crashing, right?
- 59:00But you look at Bitcoin, you see volatility, like, wait a minute,
- 59:02there's, there's more volatility on the upside, on the good side.
- 59:05How does that work? And then all of a sudden you
- 59:07realize, oh, you can actually harvest that volatility.
- 59:09You can rebalance, you can pair that back.
- 59:12So I think more advisors need to be aware of that potential
- 59:18amazing characteristic of of Bitcoin that is not evident in
- 59:21any other asset class that they own guaranteed.
- 59:25Yeah, I think it's a great point.
- 59:26And also bringing up the gold aspect is simply from like this
- 59:33notion we'll be playing a little bit more into on RIP
- 59:35institutional, on sound money renaissance, right?
- 59:38Like these concepts we're talking about if you go back,
- 59:40you know, hundreds of years, like there was a base currency,
- 59:43it had a certain amount of inflation and then everything
- 59:45was measured against it. And to Jackson's point, going
- 59:48back to first principles, there's X amount of Bitcoin,
- 59:50there's X amount or infinite amount of monetary units that
- 59:54are continuingly created. So you look at if you have
- 59:57certain fundamental properties of Bitcoin that are fundamental,
- 1:00:01you would say, well, then the price, if I can underwrite this,
- 1:00:04the price should go up, it should increase in some value.
- 1:00:06Now I have to figure out like, what's that number?
- 1:00:08I think one of the key aspects is it's been looked at as a risk
- 1:00:11asset. So we talked about the two to
- 1:00:13three percentage in a portfolio, but whether it's personal or
- 1:00:16institutional. And that naturally skews people
- 1:00:19to be like, I can forget about it because if it's only 2 to 3%,
- 1:00:23it may go up, it may not, but it's not really going to impact.
- 1:00:25And I think this notion of sound money renaissance starts to
- 1:00:29change that 40% in the bonds allocation.
- 1:00:31We've had Jerome Blockland on the podcast and I think he's one
- 1:00:34of the first to pioneer. What he does is his 6040 and I
- 1:00:38think he's, you know, performing a lot of funds is 60% is in blue
- 1:00:41chip equities and then the other 40% is weighted heavily in gold
- 1:00:44and then some component to BTC. And I think that framing is
- 1:00:49going to change fundamentally when individuals to your point
- 1:00:51start looking at gold versus the S&P and looking at just hard
- 1:00:54assets, how they perform against assets that continue to be
- 1:00:58created. And then thinking about well,
- 1:01:00maybe this isn't just a trade of 2 to 3%, but this is actually
- 1:01:03something much greater. And then that that's the easy
- 1:01:06way to start backing into Bitcoin.
- 1:01:08And I think as I don't know if it's a community, but just the
- 1:01:11notion of Bitcoin and crypto being lumped together starts to
- 1:01:15put it into a bucket versus Bitcoin and gold should be more
- 1:01:17closely aligned to your pointing with Jordan shared, because that
- 1:01:20will open the aperture for investors to think about it in a
- 1:01:23completely different framework. Especially in the world where
- 1:01:26we're going. I think gold is going to be the
- 1:01:28the leading indicator, not only on price, which just hit all
- 1:01:30time highs today, I think over 3500 an ounce, but really in
- 1:01:33the, the understanding of sovereigns already are
- 1:01:36accumulating this thing like nobody's business.
- 1:01:38It's part of the reason behind the capital, the price rising.
- 1:01:42And so I just think that's going to be a theme that we'll start
- 1:01:45to see play out increasingly over the next 12 to 24 months.
- 1:01:47And obviously Zoltan and others have been ahead of it.
- 1:01:49We just had Luke Roman on the pod yesterday.
- 1:01:52But I think that's still taboo. And the PTJ's, PTJ and
- 1:01:56Druckenmiller camps versus in the mainstream, it's still
- 1:01:59nowhere near, you know, kind of just in the the everyday path.
- 1:02:05This is exactly the challenge we face.
- 1:02:08It's like the path of least resistance is to get people off
- 1:02:110 and say, and just, you know, think of it as like a little bit
- 1:02:14of a risk or speculative or, you know, Eric calls it like hot
- 1:02:17sauce for your portfolio. And of course they lump crypto
- 1:02:19in there. But on the other hand, you know,
- 1:02:21I personally believe like, like you, it should be viewed in that
- 1:02:25other bucket as a risk off asset.
- 1:02:28And it's like if you think about it from first principles,
- 1:02:30fundamental perspective, Bitcoin's the most risk off in
- 1:02:33terms of its characteristics. You know exactly what it's going
- 1:02:36to do. It's going to take out these
- 1:02:38blocks about every 10 minutes. You know exactly how many
- 1:02:40Bitcoin are out there, how many are created.
- 1:02:42There's very few unknowns with it versus things like equities
- 1:02:46where you don't know cash flows and all this stuff.
- 1:02:49The problem is the path of least resistance to get people to
- 1:02:52adopt it is to think of it like risk on when they should think
- 1:02:56of it like risk off. But if I pound my hand on the
- 1:02:59table all day and say this is a risk off asset, it should be
- 1:03:01viewed differently. But they just trade it and treat
- 1:03:03it like a risk on asset. Well, guess what?
- 1:03:06It's like self reinforcing. It's going to trade and look
- 1:03:08like a risk on asset to them. And so this is like the paradox
- 1:03:11we find ourselves in. And I'm not sure exactly how to
- 1:03:15get out of that other than, you know, maybe we just start to see
- 1:03:17some data points. And, and maybe we saw that with
- 1:03:19like when Jerome made the, the, the comments about potential
- 1:03:23rate cut or what was viewed as evidence of potential rate cut,
- 1:03:27Bitcoin went up a little, but the rest of crypto went up a
- 1:03:30lot. So maybe people are starting to,
- 1:03:32to get this through their heads, but I don't know how to do that.
- 1:03:36It's like, it's like if somebody's eating soup with a
- 1:03:38fork and I tell them, no, this spoon over here is designed to
- 1:03:42do that, but they just keep using the fork.
- 1:03:44It's like I don't know how to help you.
- 1:03:46Yeah, it it goes back to the chicken or egg thing.
- 1:03:48And the reality is it's kind of a crude example, but the notion
- 1:03:51of do you want to make money or do you want to be right?
- 1:03:53Because being right would say it's risk off.
- 1:03:55But if you want to just meet the market where they're at and make
- 1:03:57some money, you start with it's risk on.
- 1:03:59And that Nat, you have to get somebody off of 0 anyway
- 1:04:02possible because then they naturally will look at it.
- 1:04:05Luke had a great anecdote about his buddies and 2010 we're going
- 1:04:08down to Latin America to buy it peer-to-peer.
- 1:04:10And they finally got him to buy it in 2013 on Coinbase.
- 1:04:13And this was just him doing due diligence on a new asset.
- 1:04:16Had very small account, but he watched it for four or five
- 1:04:19years, thought it was a bubble in 1718, saw a crash.
- 1:04:24And then in 2020 he's like, wait, this isn't a bubble.
- 1:04:27This is a currency problem. And so it took seven years of
- 1:04:30him to be exposed to it to realize it's a risk off assets.
- 1:04:33So there's just a, it's a function of how do you get them
- 1:04:35there? I get one thing I wanted to
- 1:04:39touch on because it's going to come increasingly back.
- 1:04:42How do you think about like the basket of currencies that
- 1:04:45they're going to start to push to advisors?
- 1:04:46Because it kind of falls into this.
- 1:04:47You already seen it with some of these.
- 1:04:49I think yesterday Safer had a great tweet.
- 1:04:52There was like, I don't know, it's two Bloomberg terminals
- 1:04:54pages. It looked like at least 100 of
- 1:04:57ET. PS And you know you're going to
- 1:04:58see the top 10 market weighted crypto assets and how do you
- 1:05:02feel about that for the industry and kind of part of this
- 1:05:04conversation, is it helpful or is it going to because we've
- 1:05:08seen for 15 years it's underperformed.
- 1:05:10I think you've seen natural the top ten and there it always
- 1:05:13moves, right? So on ETF, XRP and all these
- 1:05:15things. Just curious how you think about
- 1:05:17that and from an institutional perspective.
- 1:05:20Yeah, I actually don't have a lot of opinion here yet, so I'll
- 1:05:24I'll withhold until maybe I do. Other than we've been very
- 1:05:27adamant of put Bitcoin in its own bucket, emerging monetary
- 1:05:32good, best understood as a monetary good and then put
- 1:05:35everything else in another bucket.
- 1:05:36And therefore you're going to have to have a different lens of
- 1:05:39there's going to be a lot more competition.
- 1:05:41You know, the, the favorite thing we like to point to is
- 1:05:43look at the top coins besides Bitcoin and three years ago,
- 1:05:48four years ago, five years ago by market cap, look at look at
- 1:05:51the list today, maybe one or two is still on that list.
- 1:05:55A lot of those don't even exist anymore.
- 1:05:57So those are the odds you're you're up against, right?
- 1:05:59You have to have way more of a venture capital lens on this.
- 1:06:03Know that there's way more competition.
- 1:06:06A lot of these don't have product market fit yet or
- 1:06:09they're still trying to figure it out.
- 1:06:11But to your point of like meeting people where they're at,
- 1:06:14I, I guess I see, I see why it happens in the the appeal,
- 1:06:17right? It's like, well, it's this is an
- 1:06:19X trillion dollar asset class. So if I want to just be neutral,
- 1:06:22I'm going to allocate X percent because that would just be like
- 1:06:26the market cap weight. So I understand why it happens.
- 1:06:29But we'll see, Yeah, we'll see how it plays out.
- 1:06:34Well. I know we're coming up on time
- 1:06:36here. Chris, is there anything else
- 1:06:38that we didn't touch on that you wanted to today or do you think
- 1:06:40we we got through all the topics?
- 1:06:43You know, I think we covered a lot of ground here.
- 1:06:45This has been a lot of fun. Thanks for having me.
- 1:06:47On excellent. Well, thank you, Chris.
- 1:06:48Really appreciate it. Great conversation.
- 1:06:51You have great insights for for people who are not familiar with
- 1:06:53your work, where would you like to send them?
- 1:06:56Yeah, all of our, almost all of our research is on
- 1:06:58fidelitydigitalassets.com. So you can sign up to receive
- 1:07:02our our research there. Just click on the research tab.
- 1:07:04It's all on our website. And then me personally, you can
- 1:07:06find me on X at Chris J Kiper. All right.
- 1:07:12Thanks again, Chris. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:07:15week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:07:18valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:07:20rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:07:22All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:07:25notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:07:27reminder that On Rat Media is for informational and
- 1:07:30entertainment purposes only and nothing should be construed as
- 1:07:33investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:07:36your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:07:38Visit onrampbitcoin.com Contact Schedule a consultation with one
- 1:07:43of our private client advisors.