Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Software IPOs Are Shifting to Direct Listings
Transcript
- Lucas: So earlier this week, a midsize SaaS company called Velocity Data — you might have seen the coverage — went public via a direct listing on the Nasdaq. No underwriters, no traditional roadshow, just a reference price and straight into the market. Luna: I did see that. They're a data infrastructure play, about 400 million in annual recurring revenue, growing around 25 percent year-over-year. Not exactly a household name, but the structure itself is what's interesting. Lucas: Exactly. And they're not the first — Palantir, Slack, Coinbase, all went the direct listing route in the last few years. But what I find notable is that this is happening even for companies that aren't the mega-cap darlings. Velocity Data is solid but not a superstar, and they still chose to skip the traditional IPO process. Luna: Right. The argument for direct listings has always been that they avoid the underpricing that underwriters bake in. Traditional IPOs typically leave money on the table — the first-day pop is effectively a discount to institutional investors. Lucas: Yeah, studies show the average first-day pop is around 15 to 20 percent. That's value that could have gone to the company itself. With a direct listing, the market sets the price from day one, and existing shareholders — employees, early investors — can sell immediately without lockup periods. Luna: But there's a trade-off. Without underwriters, there's no one stabilizing the stock if it tanks on day one. And you don't get the same marketing push — no roadshow means less institutional demand priming. Lucas: That's the flip side. And it's worth asking: does the market really need that priming? I mean, look at Palantir — they direct listed in September 2020 at a reference price of seven fifty, and they're trading around one thirty-seven now. But they also had a rocky first few months, dropping below the reference price before recovering. Luna: Yeah, that volatility is real. And for a smaller company like Velocity Data, without the same brand recognition, the risk of a weak debut is higher. But I think the bigger shift here is philosophical — it's about democratizing access. Lucas: How do you mean? Luna: In a traditional IPO, retail investors rarely get in at the offering price. The big institutions get the allocation. With a direct listing, everyone — including your average Robinhood user — can buy at the same opening price on the exchange. Lucas: That's a fair point. And the SEC has been supportive. They've allowed the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq to amend their rules to facilitate direct listings, including the ability to raise primary capital — which used to be a key differentiator for IPOs. Velocity Data's listing actually did include a primary component, selling new shares directly. Luna: Right, so now direct listings can do both — let existing shareholders sell and raise new money for the company. That basically removes the last structural advantage of a traditional IPO. Lucas: Almost. Underwriters still provide research coverage and analyst relationships, which some companies value. But the pendulum is swinging. I was looking at some numbers — in 2020, direct listings accounted for less than 5 percent of all U.S. listings. Last year, it was closer to 15 percent. And with the IPO window tightening for unprofitable tech companies, I think we'll see more of this. Luna: Speaking of which, the broader market context matters here. The ARK Innovation ETF — ticker ARKK — which is heavily exposed to unprofitable tech, is up about 2.5 percent over the past five days. That's a small sign of risk appetite returning, but it's still well off its highs. Lucas: Yeah, ARKK closed at seventy-six forty yesterday. That's a far cry from the one-fifty it touched in early 2021. So the market is still selective. But for a company like Velocity Data that's already profitable — they've been cash-flow positive for three years — direct listing makes sense because they don't need the underwriter's stamp of approval to attract buyers. Luna: And I think that's the key takeaway: direct listings are becoming the default for mature, profitable tech companies that don't need the training wheels. The traditional IPO is increasingly reserved for earlier-stage, high-growth, still-unprofitable companies that need the marketing and stabilization. Lucas: Or for companies that want to issue a lot of primary capital in one go — underwriters can still guarantee a certain price for a large block of shares. But for most software companies, the arithmetic is changing. The cost of underpricing — the money left on the table — is starting to outweigh the benefits of the traditional process. Luna: And for employees, that's huge. No lockup means you can sell on day one if you want. That's real liquidity, and in a tight labor market for engineers, that's a recruiting advantage. Lucas: Exactly. So we're seeing a structural shift. I think in five years, direct listings could be the majority of tech IPOs. And that changes how founders, VCs, and employees think about the exit event. Luna: It also changes how we as investors think about getting in. If there's no pop, you're not chasing a first-day gain — you're making a decision based on the company's actual fundamentals from the opening bell. Lucas: That's healthier for the market, honestly. Less of the 'pop and drop' pattern we've seen with so many hyped IPOs. Luna: Quick honest thing — and I say this because we've been doing this show for a while now, and it's literally listener supported. A handful of people chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's what keeps us ad-free and able to dig into topics like this without any sponsor pressure. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small group, but it makes a real difference. We don't run ads, we don't do sponsored segments, so it's truly listener-funded. If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, that's the way to keep them going. Luna: Anyway, back to direct listings — one thing I want to circle back to is the role of retail investors. Do you think direct listings actually help the average person get a fair shot, or are they just a different kind of game? Lucas: I think it's genuinely more democratic in terms of access. But there's still an information asymmetry. Institutional investors have analysts and models; retail investors are often trading on headlines and hype. So the playing field is more level at the starting line, but not during the race. Luna: Fair. And that's where the SEC's role in ensuring disclosure is still critical. Velocity Data had to file a full prospectus just like an IPO — it's not like they're skirting transparency. Lucas: Right. The disclosure requirements are the same. The difference is purely in the mechanism of price discovery. And I think that's actually a good discipline for companies — they have to let the market decide without a safety net. Luna: So if you're a founder listening, what's the threshold? When does a direct listing make sense versus a traditional IPO? Lucas: I'd say three things: one, you need to be profitable or very close to it — the market won't forgive a cash-burning story without underwriters to support it. Two, you need a strong brand or a clear niche so that investors can find you without a roadshow. And three, you need existing shareholders who want liquidity — if your employees and VCs are patient, the traditional IPO might still be better for raising a lot of primary capital. Luna: That's a good framework. And I'd add that you need a board and management team comfortable with uncertainty. The first day of trading could be volatile, and you have to be okay with that. Lucas: Absolutely. The CEO of Velocity Data said in an interview that the first hour of trading felt like 'jumping out of a plane and hoping the parachute opens.' But he also said he'd do it again because the alignment with long-term shareholders was better. Luna: I like that. It's a different philosophy of going public — more like a graduation than a coronation. Lucas: That's a great way to put it. And I think as more companies succeed with this model, the stigma around not having underwriters will fade. We're already seeing it — five years ago, a direct listing was exotic. Now it's a viable alternative. Luna: It'll be interesting to see if the next big wave of AI startups — the ones that are actually profitable — choose this route. Companies like the ones we've talked about in earlier episodes. Lucas: Yeah, I think they will. The playbook is being written right now.