Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / SWM 040 – What happens to our souls when we have sex?
Transcript
- 0:43Hello, my name is JD and I blog over at UncoveringIntimacy.com. I was going through the questions I got in February and March, and I came across this one that I kind of wanted to dig in a bit more because I started writing a response to it and it turned into basically an entire blog post. And as I've been doing this year, I'm turning most of my blog posts into podcasts as well. So I thought I'd address this here as well.
- 1:09So they're asking questions about, is there an interaction of souls when we have sex? Is it an act of worship to God or Satan? You know, should we pray during sex? It had all these things to do with spirituality and sex. So rather than lump it in with all the other questions, I thought I'd spend some time digging into this because I think these are issues that a lot of Christians are confused about.
- 1:31But first, I want to let you know about a couple of things that have been going on. The first is that for those of you who are supporters, we've made a change to the forum.
- 1:39You can actually now respond directly to the emails that you get from the forum and it will post it right in the thread. So it's a lot easier to interact. People seem to be using it a lot and loving it. And it's great.
- 1:51If you're not a supporter and you're interested in the forum, check out our page at uncovering intimacy dot com slash donate. And if you think, oh, I don't have enough money to give. You know what? Actually, the vast majority, I think 78% of our supporters give $5 a month or less. So anything that you want to help us with, we definitely appreciate it. That simple $5 a month from all those people that actually pays for the majority of our expenses every month.
- 2:21The other thing is on Instagram. One of the problems that almost every blogger, podcaster or whatever has with Instagram is that when you post images and write a comment, you can't post links to anything. So I can never post a link to the blog that people can click on. You're only allowed one link in your entire Instagram account. And that's basically on your profile.
- 2:45So what I did is I built a page that actually automatically grabs all the images that I have in my account in Instagram and relinks them properly.
- 2:56So if you click, if you're in Instagram and you see a link that you'd like to be able to click on and wish you could instead of typing the whole thing out, all you have to do is click on our profile, follow the link to the website.
- 3:06And, um, there you'll see all the last 20 posts with the links intact. So if you follow us on Instagram, maybe check that out. If you don't follow us on Instagram, maybe you should.
- 3:17Uh, the link is just Instagram.com slash uncovering intimacy. And if you want to see the page that I built, it's at uncovering intimacy.com slash Instagram.
- 3:27All right. Uh, that's it. Uh, let's get on to this big question. This person writes, what do you think of the claim that when you have sex within marriage, it's an act of worship to God.
- 3:43But when you have sex outside of marriage, it's an act of worship to Satan that either way is an act of worship to one or the other. He said, he just read this on another website.
- 3:54Also, what's your belief about what's happening spiritually during sex? Obviously two bodies are becoming one flesh. Scripture makes that pretty clear.
- 4:00What about souls? What about spirits? My understanding is that soul equals the mind slash personality and the spirit equals the internal part of every person.
- 4:09But some people use the term soul and spirit interchangeably. Are souls slash spirits commuting together during sex? Are souls slash spirits mingling together during sex?
- 4:18Do souls slash spirits become one for a time during sex? Or is that even a biblical concept since it says one flesh and not one spirit slash soul?
- 4:28It kind of sounds like Eastern philosophy.
- 4:30And where is God in the midst of all this? Yes, it's a ministry and I understand that marriage slash intimacy is a picture of Christ's love for his church, but I wonder if my and others' understanding could be more complete.
- 4:41Also, if both the husband and the wife are believers and we both have a mind, soul, spirit of Christ, 1 Corinthians verse 2, and the spirit of Christ, the Holy Spirit, is something different happening during sex between believers?
- 4:58For instance, communion with one another spirit, facilitated by the Holy Spirit.
- 5:04Another somewhat related question, should Christians pray during sex? Not before, not after, but during.
- 5:09If a married couple is wanting to become as intimate as possible, the two best things to do to increase intimacy are praying together and having sex together.
- 5:18Then should these routinely be combined?
- 5:21What about praise and worship during sex?
- 5:23I've heard of people singing the doxology right after orgasm.
- 5:27At first I thought this sounded a little unorthodox.
- 5:29Actually, I admit it sounded downright crazy.
- 5:31But this could just be because of my upbringing and the idea is starting to grow on me.
- 5:37Thoughts?
- 5:38Alright, so I see three main topics here.
- 5:42The first is, is sex an act of worship?
- 5:45The second is, what are souls and what happens to them when you have sex?
- 5:49And the third is, should you pray during sex?
- 5:52Let's start with, is sex an act of worship?
- 5:54Just to remind you of the question, he wrote,
- 5:56What do you think of the claim that when you have sex within marriage, it's an act of worship to God,
- 6:01but when you have sex outside of marriage, it's an act of worship to Satan.
- 6:04That either way, it's an act of worship to one or the other.
- 6:08And apparently he read this comment on another website, but he didn't tell us which one.
- 6:12So we kick this around a bit in our supporters forum, and many said kind of the same thing,
- 6:17that everything we do is an act of worship, whether we're giving worship to God or to Satan, knowingly or unknowingly.
- 6:23And I happen to agree with this.
- 6:24This is why I get very frustrated when people say, you know, doctrine doesn't matter.
- 6:28It matters because in everything we do, we're either drawing closer to God or away from him.
- 6:34That said, I don't think it's as simple a distinction of sex within marriage is worship to God and sex outside of marriage is worship to Satan.
- 6:43Frankly, I'm not sure with our sinful nature that we can ever have a pure kind of worship of God situation.
- 6:48I think it's probably always tainted by sin in some way.
- 6:52I do think that we have more potential to have it worshipful to God in marriage than outside.
- 6:57And I think any sex outside of marriage, though marriage is kind of difficult to define biblically, any sex outside of marriage is against God's will.
- 7:09But I think in those situations, there are those who are being self-sacrificing, loving, and caring, even when they're having sex outside of marriage or aren't married.
- 7:19And those are still godly attributes.
- 7:22So even though they don't realize they're reflecting God in those situations, I'd argue that those are partially honoring God, even while they dishonor him by their actions.
- 7:33You know, by having sex in the context of not a committed relationship.
- 7:38So in the same way, we can have kind of quote-unquote godly sex within marriage, but be focused on our own selfish desires rather than sharing love or having sex out of guilt rather than out of a love for a spouse.
- 7:53And in those ways, we're really honoring a split from God rather than worshiping God.
- 7:58So I think we have a lot of variations of gray rather than a clear black and white.
- 8:03Now, I would imagine that's kind of a frustrating answer for many.
- 8:06It's frustrating for me.
- 8:07I tend to be very black and white in my theology, as some of you may have noticed.
- 8:12But sin is one of those things where we all sin almost all the time, if not all the time.
- 8:17And if there's any black and white about it, then it's all black.
- 8:22That said, I think being cognizant of who is this worshiping is a great idea.
- 8:28We should be more focused on does this honor God or not.
- 8:31And to that end, I don't want people thinking, oh, well, I'm married, so I don't need to think about it anymore, or that all married sex is godly.
- 8:40So that's my answer to the first part.
- 8:44The second one is this whole concept of what are souls and what happens to them when you have sex.
- 8:50So Christianity is split all over the map on this.
- 8:52However, I think most of it has been heavily influenced by society and media rather than the Bible.
- 8:58It's been going on for centuries, so much so that most people can't tell you why they believe what they believe about souls.
- 9:05They don't know where they learned it or where it came from.
- 9:08For example, many Christians still believe in soulmates, for which there is absolutely no biblical evidence.
- 9:13The concept of soulmates came from one of Plato's stories called The Symposium.
- 9:17It's actually a story written within another story where Plato tells of human beings created by the gods with four arms and four legs and two heads.
- 9:32And these humans were so powerful that the gods were scared that they would take over.
- 9:36So the gods split the humans in half, male and female, with only two legs, two arms, one head,
- 9:41so that the humans would spend their entire lives searching for their soulmate, the one that they've been split apart from,
- 9:46so they could feel whole again rather than fighting the gods.
- 9:50So Plato comes up with this story, and people hear it, and it's around the same time, you know, Greek and Roman kind of era,
- 9:58and it somehow made its way into Christianity, and now we have pastors preaching about soulmates and things like that,
- 10:05and blog posts from Christian authors about soulmates.
- 10:08And they'll pull a couple of verses kind of out of context to support this idea, but there's really no biblical standing for this.
- 10:16Similarly, you know, we have this idea of an immortal soul that comes from mythology as well, and also has no biblical basis.
- 10:23You know, the Bible is very clear that immortality belongs only to God.
- 10:27You know, 1 Timothy 6 verse 15 to 16 says that, and it's conferred to us only upon the second coming, and only to believers.
- 10:341 Corinthians 15 verse 54 is the verse for that one.
- 10:39The Bible tells us that the dead know nothing, they see nothing, they don't even love.
- 10:43You know, Ecclesiastes 9 verse 5 to 6.
- 10:48Jesus said nobody has been to heaven yet except for Jesus, and that's John 6 verse 4 to 6.
- 10:55So, if nobody's been to heaven, then how can there be immortal souls that have already gone to heaven?
- 11:02It also says that the dead in Christ, so the believers, will remain dead until Christ comes again,
- 11:07and they are raised as part of the first resurrection.
- 11:10That's in Daniel 12 verse 2 and Revelation 20 verse 4 to 6.
- 11:14If you want all these verses, you don't have to write them all down.
- 11:17You can just check out the blog post, and I'll have them all there.
- 11:19But this teaching of souls and what is the status of a soul, is it immortal and mortal?
- 11:28Some churches teach, as the questioner states in his own question, that the soul is a separate part from the body.
- 11:34The Bible teaches us something different.
- 11:36It teaches us that the soul is a combination of the body and the spirit of God.
- 11:41You know, we have Genesis 2 verse 7, which is the first time the mention of a soul comes up.
- 11:46And it says,
- 11:47And the Lord God formed man of the dust of the ground and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and the man became a living soul.
- 11:54So, in other words, a soul is the body plus the breath of life or the spirit of God.
- 12:01So, if your body dies, then so does your soul.
- 12:04It's not mortal, as I said earlier.
- 12:08However, it will only exist again upon the second coming, when the breath of God re-enters your renewed body.
- 12:17Daniel 12 verse 13 says,
- 12:19But you, go your way till the end, for you shall rest, and will arise to your inheritance at the end of days.
- 12:26Daniel was very clear about this theology.
- 12:28He knew exactly what was going to happen when people died.
- 12:30And he said in Daniel 12 verse 2, which I mentioned earlier, he wrote,
- 12:37And many of those who sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, some to shame and everlasting contempt.
- 12:43You know, Daniel knew that while you're dead, nothing happens.
- 12:49Your soul isn't off traveling to heaven because Jesus said no one has been to heaven.
- 12:53It's not an angel because those are separate created beings.
- 12:56Angels are not deceased humans.
- 12:58It's not looking out for its loved ones.
- 13:02When Lazarus died, Jesus said that he slept.
- 13:05You know, John 11 verse 11b says,
- 13:08Jesus said to them,
- 13:10Our friend Lazarus sleeps, but I go, then I may wake him up.
- 13:14Lazarus wasn't singing praises in heaven.
- 13:18Psalm 6 verse 5 says,
- 13:20For in death there is no remembrance of you in the grave who will give you thanks.
- 13:24They're talking about God.
- 13:25You know, he wasn't thinking.
- 13:28Psalm 146 verse 3 and 4 say,
- 13:31Do not put your trust in princes, nor in a son of man, in whom there is no help.
- 13:36His spirit departs, and he returns to his earth.
- 13:39In that very day his plans perish.
- 13:42So in other words, when the spirit leaves, he's dead.
- 13:46You know, he's not remembering anything of his life here on earth.
- 13:49And Ecclesiastes 9 verse 5 says,
- 13:54For the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing.
- 13:58They have no more reward, for the memory of them is forgotten.
- 14:02So Lazarus was dead, waiting to be woken up, you know, in quotes, as all dead people are.
- 14:081 Thessalonians 4 verse 16 to 17 says,
- 14:13For the Lord himself will descend from heaven with a shout, and with the voice of an archangel,
- 14:17and with the trumpet of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first.
- 14:21Then we who are alive and remain shall be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air.
- 14:27And thus we shall always be with you, Lord.
- 14:30So we have all these verses that tell us, you know, this is what happens when you die.
- 14:34You sleep, you wait for Christ to come back again.
- 14:37Nothing else is happening.
- 14:38And you know people don't understand it because, frankly, usually the pastors don't understand it.
- 14:43If you go to a funeral, you pay really close attention to the pastor.
- 14:47Most of them betray the fact that they have no idea what's happening to the recently deceased.
- 14:52They will tell you that they're resting in the grave, waiting to be resurrected, which is true.
- 14:56They'll also tell you that they're in heaven now, which is false.
- 14:59And they'll also tell us that they're always with us, which is false.
- 15:02And a host of other things, typically all within the same talk.
- 15:06Or they'll split it up.
- 15:07They'll say one thing at the gravesite and say another thing in the sermon later.
- 15:11Or a few things in the sermon later.
- 15:13By the time their sermon is done, they've split this poor soul three or four ways, and they have him in all different places.
- 15:20And it's not that they're intending to be confusing.
- 15:22It's just that they're reading the typical funeral verses that everyone reads without actually paying attention to what they're saying.
- 15:28They're just trying to comfort their families, which I get.
- 15:31But let's not teach them bad theology in the process.
- 15:34Our comfort should come from the Bible in knowing that our loved ones who follow God are resting from all their plans and struggles in this life.
- 15:41And the next thing they will know is the resurrection.
- 15:44Christ will return, they will be raised, and they will put on immortality.
- 15:471 Corinthians 15 verse 51 to 54 says,
- 15:51So when this corruptible has put on incorruption, and this mortal has put on immortality,
- 16:19then shall be brought to pass the saying that is written, death is swallowed up in victory.
- 16:23So after all the wicked are destroyed, after the second resurrection, there will be no more death ever for anyone.
- 16:35No pain, no sorrow.
- 16:37Revelation 21 verse 4 says,
- 16:39And God will wipe away every tear from their eyes.
- 16:42There will be no more death, nor sorrow, nor crying.
- 16:45There shall be no more pain for the former things have passed away.
- 16:48Now, I feel I should address one common rebuttal to all this, is that people always ask,
- 16:53well, what about the thief on the cross?
- 16:56Now, for those who don't know, Jesus was crucified with two thieves.
- 16:59One taunted Jesus along with the crowds, and one defended Jesus.
- 17:04And according to the King James Version, it writes in Luke 23 verse 43,
- 17:09And Jesus said to him,
- 17:10Assuredly, I say to you, today you will be with me in paradise.
- 17:13And so they take from this saying,
- 17:17Oh, Jesus said, today he'll be with him in paradise,
- 17:19therefore the thief went to heaven with Jesus that day.
- 17:23But this causes a problem later on,
- 17:25when a few days later, after his resurrection,
- 17:28Jesus says to Mary,
- 17:30Do not cling to me, for I am not yet ascended to my father.
- 17:33That's found in John 20 verse 17.
- 17:35So how is it that Jesus hadn't been to heaven yet,
- 17:38if he had promised the thief that he would meet him there days ago?
- 17:41So here's what I think happened.
- 17:44I think the translator injected his own beliefs into the translation.
- 17:48That, or it's just a typo.
- 17:50You see, in Greek, Greek doesn't have commas.
- 17:55Neither does Hebrew.
- 17:56But this would have been translated out of a Greek gospel.
- 18:01So if you move just one comma, a word to the right,
- 18:05suddenly this verse aligns with the rest of scripture.
- 18:08And some translations have actually done this.
- 18:11There's a concordant literal version,
- 18:13which is a very, very mechanical kind of literal translation.
- 18:18And they wrote,
- 18:20And Jesus said to him,
- 18:21Verily to you, I am saying today, comma,
- 18:24with me you shall be in paradise.
- 18:26So it's not that he was saying,
- 18:28Oh, you'll be in paradise with me today.
- 18:29He's saying, I'm telling you today,
- 18:31you will be with me in paradise sometime in the future.
- 18:35So, just by shifting a comma,
- 18:40we have not really changed scripture.
- 18:42Arguably, we've corrected a bad translation.
- 18:45And at the same time,
- 18:46realigned the Bible with itself,
- 18:47including Jesus' own words days later.
- 18:50So hopefully that clears up some mis-understandings of what a soul is.
- 18:55A soul is your body plus the spirit slash breath of God.
- 18:59It's not separate.
- 19:00It's not immortal.
- 19:01It doesn't survive past death.
- 19:03You don't have a soul.
- 19:04You are a soul.
- 19:07So with that in mind,
- 19:08let's look back at his question.
- 19:11So he wrote,
- 19:13What is your belief about what's happening spiritually during sex?
- 19:16Obviously, two bodies are becoming one flesh.
- 19:19Scripture makes this pretty clear.
- 19:21What about souls?
- 19:22He was asking, you know,
- 19:23what happens with the soul when you're having sex?
- 19:25Are they merging?
- 19:25Are they mingling?
- 19:27Etc.
- 19:28So if we go with the understanding that a soul is your body
- 19:31and the breath slash spirit of God,
- 19:33then this really becomes a non-issue.
- 19:36What's happening to your soul?
- 19:38The same thing that's happened to your body
- 19:39because they're fairly synonymous.
- 19:41What's happening to the spirit?
- 19:42Same thing.
- 19:43It's a part of you.
- 19:44You can't really separate it.
- 19:45If you did,
- 19:46then you'd cease to be a soul and you'd be dead.
- 19:49So do souls slash spirits become one for a time during sex?
- 19:53Only in the same way that we say two bodies become one.
- 19:57And does something differently happen between believers and non-believers?
- 20:00Personally, I don't see how, whether they believe or not,
- 20:04they're still souls with bodies and the spirit slash breath of God.
- 20:09So the last part was, should Christians pray during sex?
- 20:14As in not before, not after, but during.
- 20:18So my personal thought was that you shouldn't be afraid to pray during sex,
- 20:21but we shouldn't feel compelled to.
- 20:24Except in the case that, you know, we should be praying unceasingly,
- 20:28which I think is more, our life should be a living prayer.
- 20:32So I wrote in our supporters forum this week when discussing this question that I've definitely
- 20:37prayed during sex.
- 20:38Usually it's something like, please God let her have an orgasm soon.
- 20:41Typically when she's getting really frustrated and I'm getting really tired.
- 20:46But if you're worrying constantly that you should be praying during sex,
- 20:50then you're unlikely to have a productive prayer or a productive sexual session.
- 20:55So I think there are times that we can choose to put our focus on one thing or another.
- 21:00Ecclesiastes 3 has this big litany that starts with,
- 21:05to everything there is a season and a time to every purpose under the heaven.
- 21:08Um, I think that includes prayer and sex.
- 21:12Uh, in fact, one of the lines in there says a time to cast away stones and a time to gather
- 21:17stones together.
- 21:18Um, I'm told that's a euphemism for, uh, it's a time to have sex and a time to refrain from
- 21:23having sex.
- 21:25And the next line is a time to embrace and a time to refrain from embracing.
- 21:29But my wife and I have definitely said a prayer of thanks for sex and orgasms, uh, after sex.
- 21:34Um, I can't say we've ever sang a doxology afterwards, but hey, if that's your thing,
- 21:41go for it.
- 21:41I don't think it's weird.
- 21:42It might be outside of normal behavior, but who cares?
- 21:47So hopefully that answers your questions.
- 21:49Uh, I'm sure some of you are going to have some other questions raising from this.
- 21:53Uh, this is not what a lot of churches teach.
- 21:55Frankly, a lot of churches don't really dig into this stuff much.
- 21:58Um, I'm more than willing to answer any that you might have.
- 22:01You can email me at jayatuncoveringhmsc.com or write it in the comments below.
- 22:07Um, yeah, that's it for today.
- 22:11I hope to have the rest of the February and March questions out soon as well.
- 22:16Uh, I'm trying to work through, uh, the data analysis for our last survey.
- 22:20Uh, it takes a while.
- 22:22There's a lot of data to pour through and a lot of questions.
- 22:24And this one was a little bit more complex than others since they're very gender specific
- 22:29questions.
- 22:31But yeah, hang in there.
- 22:33It will come.
- 22:34In the meantime, if you're, if you have a question that you want to ask anonymously,
- 22:38you can visit our have a question page.
- 22:41Uh, if you'd like to join in the discussions as they come in, then I invite you to check
- 22:46out our support page at uncoveringhmsc.com slash donate.
- 22:50Um, any level of support gives you access to the form and as well helps us continue to do
- 22:57this thing, continue to have the time, the resources, and, uh, cover all the costs of
- 23:03all the many types of hosting it takes to, um, host a blog and a podcast and a mailing
- 23:09list and webinars and everything else that we do.
- 23:13So for my supporters, I will see you on the forum.
- 23:16The rest of you, I'll talk to you when I get another post up.
- 23:20See ya.