Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Winter Guide for Electric Vehicles
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep dive. You know, electric vehicles are
- 0:12everywhere now, but as soon as the temperature drops, that one
- 0:16big question comes up again. It always does.
- 0:18Are modern EVs actually ready for a serious winter?
- 0:21I mean, for real snow, mountain roads, that kind of thing.
- 0:25It's pretty much the make or break question for a lot of
- 0:27people, isn't it? For so long, EVs were seen, as
- 0:29you know, great little city cars for the summer.
- 0:32Exactly. So our mission today is to cut
- 0:35through some of that anxiety. We've gone through the research
- 0:38and we're going to figure out if today's electric cars can handle
- 0:41a deep freeze as well as a gas car or maybe even better.
- 0:44And I think the answer might surprise some people.
- 0:46The sources we looked at are pretty clear on the top line
- 0:49summary. Driving an EV in the winter is
- 0:53well, it's no longer a problem. No longer a problem.
- 0:56That's a bold statement, it. Is, but the tech has come a long
- 0:59way. The real difference, and this is
- 1:01what we have to focus on, is the battery system.
- 1:05It's just more sensitive to the cold than an internal combustion
- 1:08engine. OK, but before we get into the
- 1:10battery anxiety, let's talk about some of the physical
- 1:13advantages, because those are often overlooked, right?
- 1:16EVs aren't just tiny cars anymore.
- 1:19Not at all. The days of the small quirky
- 1:22electric car are basically over. You can get battery powered
- 1:25SUV's, sedans, crossovers, whatever you need.
- 1:28So. If you're a skier, you need
- 1:30space for gear for the family. There's an EV for that.
- 1:33You don't have to compromise. No compromise.
- 1:35And what's really fascinating is how the basic design of an EV
- 1:39gives it this inherent advantage in slick conditions.
- 1:44You're talking about traction and stability.
- 1:46Exactly. A lot of modern EVs are designed
- 1:48with all-wheel drive, but it's not the old mechanical AWD.
- 1:52They'll often have a motor for the front wheels and a separate
- 1:54one for the back. Or even one for each wheel in
- 1:57some cases. Right.
- 1:58And that allows for instant, super precise power delivery to
- 2:01whichever wheel has the most grip.
- 2:03It makes them incredibly good on ice or slush.
- 2:05And then there's the big one, the battery weight.
- 2:07We usually think of weight as a bad thing for efficiency.
- 2:10But in winter, it completely flips the script.
- 2:12It becomes a huge asset. An EV can be, what, 200 to 300
- 2:17kilograms heavier than a similar gas car?
- 2:20All of that is the battery, and that extra mass literally
- 2:24presses the tires down onto the road surface.
- 2:27You get more friction, which means more traction.
- 2:30So it's just pure physics giving you a better grip.
- 2:33Pure physics and where they put that heavy battery is key.
- 2:37It's installed as low as possible in the chassis Which.
- 2:40Lowers the center of gravity. It drops it way, way lower than
- 2:44a traditional car. That makes the vehicle
- 2:46inherently more stable, less likely to slide out on a
- 2:49slippery corner. So yeah, in terms of just
- 2:51controlling the car in snow, the design has some very clear
- 2:54advantages. That's genuinely reassuring.
- 2:56But now we have to tackle the main source of that anxiety,
- 2:59range loss. The cold hard truth is that your
- 3:02range will go down. It will.
- 3:04All the studies agree on this. You should probably just
- 3:07mentally prepare to lose somewhere between 10 and 30% of
- 3:09your range in cold weather. OK, wait. 10 to 30% is a huge
- 3:12window. If I have a car that's rated
- 3:14for, say, 300 miles, losing 90 miles is a big deal.
- 3:18Is that 30% a worst case scenario?
- 3:20That's a really important question because no, it's not
- 3:24the same for every car. The technology makes a massive
- 3:27difference. The biggest energy drain, as we
- 3:29sort of touched on, is heating. Right, The car has to create its
- 3:33own heat. It can't just use waste heat
- 3:35from the motor like a gas car. Because there isn't really any
- 3:38waste heat. The electric motor is incredibly
- 3:40efficient, maybe up to 90%. So all that energy goes to
- 3:44moving the car. There's not enough leftover to
- 3:47warm up the cabin, or that this is crucial to keep the battery
- 3:51itself in its happy temperature zone.
- 3:53Which is what about room temperature?
- 3:55Pretty much between 20 and 40°C is the ideal operating range.
- 4:00The car has to use battery power just to keep the battery warm
- 4:03enough to work efficiently. This is where we get to that
- 4:05deep dive nugget, the difference between manufacturers.
- 4:08Our sources point to a study from recurrent auto at -7°C and
- 4:12the variance is huge. This is the proof point.
- 4:15It shows that the design of the thermal system is everything.
- 4:18At one end you had the Jaguar I pace, which lost only 3% of its
- 4:22range. Only 3%?
- 4:23That's nothing. Almost nothing, but then on the
- 4:26other end the VWID .4 lost a full 30. 30 The difference is
- 4:32staggering. So what is the tech that
- 4:34separates a 3% car from a 30% car?
- 4:37In a word, the heat thump. OK, explain that.
- 4:41A lot of the most efficient EVs use a heat pump.
- 4:45It works like your home's air conditioner, but in reverse.
- 4:48Instead of using a simple electric coil to generate heat,
- 4:51which is like a toaster, it just burns through energy.
- 4:54The heat pump is much smarter. It moves heat around.
- 4:56Exactly. It extracts whatever warmth it
- 4:59can find from the outside air, from the motor, from the battery
- 5:01itself, and concentrates it inside the cabin.
- 5:04It might use only a third of the energy of a simple resistance
- 5:07heater. So if your car is relying on
- 5:09that old school resistance heater, you're going to see a
- 5:11number closer to that 30% loss. That's almost always the case,
- 5:15yes. That simple heater is just
- 5:16constantly drawing down the main battery.
- 5:18Makes sense. So what about protecting the
- 5:20battery pack itself? What do manufacturers do?
- 5:22Well, it's kind of like they give it a factory installed
- 5:24winter coat. The whole pack is wrapped in
- 5:27insulation and more importantly, there's an electronic
- 5:30temperature management system that's always running.
- 5:32To keep it in that 20 to 40° sweet spot.
- 5:35Right, it automatically heats or cools the battery to keep it
- 5:39optimal, which is essential for performance and for the
- 5:42batteries long term health. The sources also mentioned
- 5:45special antifreeze. I thought EVs didn't need
- 5:48antifreeze? Well, they do, but not for the
- 5:50reason you think. That fluid circulates through
- 5:52the system to cool the battery and motors in the summer, but
- 5:56it's also used to heat them in the winter.
- 5:58If it froze, it could cause huge damage, so they use a special
- 6:02antifreeze to keep that whole thermal loop working even when
- 6:05it's well below 0 outside. OK, let's switch to what the
- 6:08driver can do. What are the best strategies to
- 6:10maximize those miles when it's cold?
- 6:13The easiest thing right off the bat is to use eco mode.
- 6:16Pretty much every EV has one. And that just smooths out the
- 6:19power delivery. It does, which is great for two
- 6:22reasons. One, it's more efficient,
- 6:24obviously, and two, it's actually safer.
- 6:27It makes the acceleration less jerky, so you're less likely to
- 6:31spin the wheels on a slippery Rd.
- 6:32What about regenerative braking, getting that energy back?
- 6:35Is it affected by the cold? Oh absolutely, and this is
- 6:38something you really need to be aware of.
- 6:40You should use it as much as possible of course, but a
- 6:42battery that is literally freezing cold can't and accept a
- 6:46high rate of charge. So the car limits it.
- 6:48The car throttles it to protect the battery, which means that
- 6:51for the first few miles of your drive, the car will rely more on
- 6:55its normal friction brakes. You just need to be prepared for
- 6:59that different braking feel on a really cold morning.
- 7:02Got it. Now for the biggest energy
- 7:04vampire of all, heating the cabin.
- 7:07What are the hacks? The number one secret weapon for
- 7:10winter EV driving is preheating. While it's still plugged in.
- 7:13Always, always while it's still plugged into the charger.
- 7:16That way you're using power from the grid to get the cabin and
- 7:20the battery nice and warm, not power from your battery.
- 7:23It's such a simple but brilliant tip.
- 7:25You start your trip with a full battery and a warm car.
- 7:29Exactly. And once you're driving, be
- 7:31smart about the heat targeted. Don't just blast the main cabin
- 7:35heater on full. Use the heated seats and heated
- 7:38steering wheel instead. Because they warm you up
- 7:40directly, it's so much more efficient than trying to heat
- 7:43all the air in the car. It can save a huge amount of
- 7:46energy. Let's talk gear tires.
- 7:48It's a non negotiable for winter that October to Easter rule.
- 7:52But are EV specific winter tires just marketing?
- 7:56No, they are genuinely beneficial.
- 7:58They're designed to handle that extra weight we talked about,
- 8:00for one. They're more robust.
- 8:02More robust, they're also built to handle the instant torque
- 8:05from an electric motor, which can make regular tires slip.
- 8:08And they're designed to be quieter without engine noise.
- 8:12You hear everything else, so a quiet tire makes a big
- 8:14difference to the driving experience.
- 8:15And check your tire pressure. Always cold air causes the
- 8:18pressure to drop and that affects your safety and your
- 8:20efficiency, OK? Charging in the dead of winter?
- 8:23We know a cold battery charges slower.
- 8:26What's the best practice? The key, especially for DC fast
- 8:30charging on a road trip, is preconditioning.
- 8:32And how do you do that? It's usually automatic.
- 8:35If you use the car's built in navigation to route to a fast
- 8:38charger, the car knows what's coming.
- 8:41It'll start using a bit of energy to warm the battery pack
- 8:43up as you drive there. So it uses a little bit of
- 8:45energy on the way, but it saves you a ton of time once you
- 8:48actually plug in. Precisely.
- 8:50A warm battery can accept a much higher power flow.
- 8:53If you pull up to a fast charger with a freezing battery, the car
- 8:56might limit the speed to, say, 30 or 40 kilowatts.
- 9:00If it's preconditioned, you can hit 150 kilowatts right away.
- 9:04It can save you 20-30 minutes of waiting.
- 9:06That is a critical detail for anyone doing a winter road trip
- 9:10and any safety notes on the equipment.
- 9:12Just be careful, make sure the charting port and the cable are
- 9:16clean and dry. Any slush or ice in there can
- 9:18cause a short circuit or just prevent it from charging at all.
- 9:21Right. And what about that emergency
- 9:23kit in the trunk? Oh, you have to be prepared,
- 9:25especially in mountain regions, you need more than the standard
- 9:28kit. We're talking snow chains, a
- 9:30shovel, and definitely a warm blanket or a sleeping bag.
- 9:33Because if you get stuck, your heat comes from the battery.
- 9:36Exactly, you also want some non perishable food and water, a
- 9:39good flashlight, and a fully charged power bank for your
- 9:42phone. It's just non negotiable for
- 9:44safety. Let's shift to long term
- 9:46concerns. Does leaving an EV park outside
- 9:49in a brutal winter permanently damaged the battery?
- 9:53It's a valid worry. The general consensus is no, it
- 9:56won't cause major damage, but we should talk specifically about
- 9:59LFP batteries. Lithium iron phosphate.
- 10:01Right. It's a great battery in
- 10:02chemistry, cheaper, safer, but it really did not like the cold.
- 10:07If you have an LFT battery and it's left outside an extreme
- 10:11cold for season after season, it might age slightly faster over
- 10:14the long term. And how significant is that?
- 10:17Should people without a garage be panicking?
- 10:19No, definitely no panic. These batteries are still
- 10:22designed to last at least 10 years, but if you want to get 15
- 10:26years or more out of it, constant exposure to sub zero
- 10:29temperatures isn't ideal. If you can, maybe rent a
- 10:33sheltered spot for the worst winter months.
- 10:36And if you have to park outside, what's the golden rule?
- 10:39Don't leave it sitting there with a very low or very high
- 10:42state of charge. Keep it somewhere in the middle,
- 10:44maybe between 30 and 80%. That's just healthier for the
- 10:47battery chemistry. Looking forward, what's on the
- 10:50horizon? Is new tech going to solve this?
- 10:52It looks very promising. A lot of the research into next
- 10:54Gen. batteries, things like sodium ion or solid-state
- 10:57batteries, shows they handle extreme temperatures much, much
- 11:00better. They could potentially make this
- 11:02whole range loss conversation a thing of the past.
- 11:05That's definitely encouraging, so let's bring it all together.
- 11:08What's the final take away from this deep dive?
- 11:10Are EVs ready for winter? Yes, they are absolutely ready
- 11:14and capable. Modern EVs have real physical
- 11:17advantages in the snow that stability and traction are no
- 11:21joke. The challenge is just about
- 11:23managing energy. So you, the driver have to
- 11:25adjust your expectations. You do, except that a 10 to 30%
- 11:30range loss is normal and use the smart strategies we talked
- 11:33about, preheating while plugged in, preconditioning before a
- 11:37fast charge. The technology is already there
- 11:40to protect the car, you just have to work with it.
- 11:43Which leaves us with a final provocative thought for you to
- 11:45think about. The biggest challenge for an EV
- 11:48in winter isn't moving through the snow, but it's energy
- 11:52efficiency. So here's the question, does the
- 11:55extra weight from the battery, which gives you that amazing
- 11:57stability, ultimately cost more energy to haul around and keep
- 12:01warm than the benefit it provides?
- 12:04It's a fascinating trade off that engineers are still
- 12:06balancing. A really interesting point to
- 12:08consider as the designs continue to evolve.
- 12:11Thank you so much for joining us on the deep dive.
- 12:13We really appreciate you taking the time to explore this with
- 12:15us. If you enjoyed this, please
- 12:17follow our channel for more deep dives into the topics that
- 12:19matter.