Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You Were Hired During a Downturn
Transcript
- Lucas: So here's a scenario we've been getting a lot of questions about lately. You were hired in 2023 or early 2024, the labor market was still kind of shaky, and you accepted an offer that was maybe ten or fifteen percent below what you would have gotten a couple of years earlier. Now it's 2026, the market has recovered, your company is doing fine, but your salary hasn't moved much. You feel stuck. Luna: That's such a specific feeling. It's like you're being penalized for timing. Lucas: Exactly. And the fix sounds simple on paper: just ask for a catch-up raise. But it's actually one of the harder asks to make, because you're not asking for a promotion or a bump for new responsibilities — you're saying, my salary is out of line with the market, and I want you to fix it. That puts the burden on you to prove it. Luna: And it can feel awkward, because your manager might hear it as, I think I'm underpaid, which can feel like an accusation. Lucas: Right. So the strategy is to make it about data, not about your feelings or your bills. And the first step is to actually find out what the market is paying for your role right now. Not what you think it pays, not what Glassdoor says vaguely — I mean real data. Talk to recruiters, look at comparable job postings, reach out to a couple of peers in your industry, maybe anonymously. You want a range, not a single number. Luna: And you should probably look at roles with similar scope, not just the same title. Because titles are messy. Lucas: That's a great point. A marketing manager at a 50-person company and a marketing manager at a 500-person company are different jobs. So your benchmarks should match your actual responsibilities, team size, budget, all of that. Once you have that range, you can figure out your gap. Let's say you're at ninety thousand, and the market range for your role is ninety-five to one-ten. Your gap is five to twenty thousand. That's your negotiation zone. Luna: So you're not going in with a demand, you're going in with a number that has backing. That feels more manageable. Lucas: It does, but you also need to think about timing. And this is where a lot of people make a mistake. They ask in February, right after the annual review cycle, and the manager says there's no budget. But the real issue is that the budget for the year was already set. You want to initiate the conversation a few months before the review cycle, or at a moment when the company is clearly doing well — maybe after a big client win or a great quarter. That's when managers have more room to advocate for you. Luna: So it's about reading the room and the calendar. Got it. Lucas: And before we get into the script, let's take a quick step back. This is exactly the kind of conversation we love helping people prepare for on this show. And if you've found these episodes useful in your own career — whether it's prepping for a tough talk with your boss or just thinking through a move — we'd really appreciate it if you'd consider supporting us. It's what keeps the show independent and free for everyone. You can do that at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Even a small amount makes a real difference to us. Luna: Yeah, we're a small team, and it genuinely helps us keep making these episodes. Lucas: Alright, so back to the catch-up raise. Once you have your data and your timing, the next step is to frame the conversation. You don't want to lead with, I deserve more money. You want to lead with, I've been in this role for a couple of years, here's how my responsibilities have grown, and here's what the market is paying for this level of work now. That's a much more compelling case. Luna: And you should also have a list of your accomplishments. Not just a vague 'I did a good job' but specific things you delivered. Lucas: Absolutely. Quantify wherever you can. If you led a project that increased efficiency by twenty percent, say that. If you managed a budget that grew, say that. You want to show that you're not just asking for more because the market moved — you're asking because your value to the company has also moved. And that's a crucial nuance. If you're performing at the same level as when you were hired, the market adjustment is a harder sell. But if you've grown into a more senior version of the role, you have a stronger case. Luna: So it's almost like you're combining a market adjustment with a mini promotion pitch. Lucas: Exactly. And that's what I'd recommend aiming for. You might not get a title change, but you can ask for a salary that reflects your current level of contribution. And here's a specific example that came up in a recent conversation I had. A friend of mine, a marketing manager, was hired in early 2023 at eighty-five thousand. The market was rough, so she accepted. By 2025, she was managing a bigger team and a larger budget, but her salary had only moved to ninety-one thousand. She did the research, found that the market range for her role was now one hundred to one-twenty, and she went to her manager with that data, plus a list of everything she'd delivered. She asked for a fourteen percent adjustment, to one-oh-four thousand. It took three conversations over two months, but she got it. Luna: That's a great success story. What made the difference, do you think? Lucas: I think it was the combination of the data and her manager's ability to go to HR with a strong business case. She also made sure to frame it as an investment in retaining someone who was already performing well, rather than a threat that she might leave. Though, to be fair, she did mention that she'd been approached about other roles, which she didn't have to do — but it signaled that the market was real. That's a fine line to walk, though. You don't want it to feel like an ultimatum. Luna: Right. So the takeaway isn't 'threaten to leave'. It's 'here's my value, here's the market, can we close the gap?'. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the kind of conversation that can work even if your manager initially says no. Because you're not burning a bridge. You're making a case, and if they can't do it now, you're leaving the door open for them to review it at the next cycle. That's actually a big part of the skill: not getting a yes, but getting a 'let's revisit this in six months' — and then holding them to it. Luna: That's a good point. So what do you do when they say no? Lucas: First, don't accept a flat no without understanding why. Ask what's driving it. Is it budget, is it the timing, is it that they don't think your performance justifies it? If it's budget, ask when the next budget cycle is and what you can do to strengthen your case. If it's performance, ask for specific feedback and a plan to get there. If it's the market data, ask what data they're using. You want to turn the no into a list of conditions you can work on. Luna: And you should probably follow up in writing after the conversation, just to summarize what was discussed and any agreements. That's a professional habit. Lucas: Yes, that's a great tip. Send a brief email: 'Thanks for meeting with me, I understand the budget constraints, I'll check back in October as discussed.' That way it's on record. And if they don't follow through, you have a reference point. But also — and this is the part that's hard to hear — if you've made a solid case and the answer is still no, with no clear path forward, that may be a signal that your company doesn't value you at the market rate. And that's information you can use, even if it's not the outcome you wanted. Luna: So it's not the end of the story. It's data for your own career decision-making. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the bigger picture here. Asking for a catch-up raise is about more than the money. It's about aligning your compensation with your value, and it's a skill you'll use again and again. Whether you stay or leave, you'll have the confidence of knowing you made the strongest case you could. Luna: I think a lot of listeners are going to take notes on this one. It's such a practical approach. Lucas: I hope so. And if you try it, let us know how it goes. We'd love to hear your stories.