Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing the Employee Who Keeps Saying I Need a Decision
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've covered a lot of employee archetypes on this show — the credit hoarder, the meeting addict, the one who says everything is not my job. But there's one type that flies under the radar because they seem so cooperative, so conscientious, you almost don't notice the pattern until you're drowning in their questions. Luna: The employee who asks you for a decision on every single thing, right? I feel like I've had a few of those. Lucas: Exactly. And here's the thing, Luna — if you're a first-time manager, this person can actually feel like a relief at first. They're checking in, they're not going rogue. But after a few weeks, you realize you're the one making the decisions that they should be making, and your calendar is now full of five-minute huddles that are really just them asking for your blessing. Luna: And that's exhausting. But it's also a signal, right? Like, maybe they're not lazy — maybe they're scared to get it wrong. Lucas: That's a key insight. Before we dive in, let me mention something quick. This show, and the whole Fexingo network, is ad-free and listener-supported. A small group of you already chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's honestly what pays for the editing, the hosting, the whole operation. If you've gotten value from our episodes — maybe this one helps you with a tricky employee — that's a great way to keep it going. Luna: Yeah, it really does make a difference. We don't have sponsors breathing down our necks, which is why we can talk about real situations like this. Lucas: Right. So let's get into the psychology of this. The first thing to understand is that this behavior is often trained — by the manager. Think about it: every time the employee asks a question, you answer it. You've just reinforced a loop. They ask, you give the answer, they feel safe, you feel needed. But you've also taught them that their own judgment is not trusted. Luna: So you're basically saying we create the monster we then complain about. Lucas: In many cases, yes. There's a concept called 'learned helplessness' — when people repeatedly find that their input doesn't matter, they stop trying. But there's also a subtler version where they've learned that asking is the path of least resistance. It's actually safer to ask than to decide, because if they decide and get it wrong, they're exposed. If they ask and you decide, well, they followed your orders. Luna: That's a real cost-benefit analysis for them, even if they don't consciously think about it. Lucas: Exactly. So the fix is to make deciding more attractive than asking. And that starts with a technique I call 'decision framing.' Instead of just answering the question, you reframe the question back to them with a specific structure. For example, an employee comes to you and says, 'Should I send the client the proposal with the revised pricing?' You don't say 'yes' or 'no.' You say, 'What do you think the right call is, and what's the one thing you're unsure about?' Luna: Oh, that's good. You're forcing them to commit to a position before they get your input. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the first step — getting them to state a recommendation. But you have to be careful not to turn it into an interrogation every time. You need to build a system. A practical approach is to set 'decision rights' with the employee. You sit down with them and explicitly map out: 'These are the decisions you can make on your own, these are the ones you bring to me for information, and these are the ones that need my approval.' Luna: So you're creating a decision-making hierarchy. That's really concrete. Lucas: Yeah. And you want to write it down. I've seen this work beautifully with a marketing coordinator I managed years ago — let's call her Priya. She was brilliant, but she came from a very top-down culture, so she asked about everything from the color of a button to the wording of a subject line. We did this exercise, and I gave her the green light on anything under a certain budget or that didn't affect a major client. Within a month, her questions dropped by maybe 80 percent. Luna: That's a huge shift. But what about the other 20 percent? The ones she still brought up? Lucas: For those, I used the next tool: the pre-mortem. When she came with a decision she was hesitant about, I'd ask her to imagine it's six months from now and her decision went horribly wrong. What would have caused that? That forces her to think through the failure modes herself. Then she'd often realize she already knew what to do, or she'd come back with a specific risk she wanted me to weigh in on. That's a much better conversation than 'what do you think?' Luna: The pre-mortem is a classic, but using it in real-time like that is smart. It turns anxiety into analysis. Lucas: And the third piece is the feedback loop. When they do make a decision on their own, you have to acknowledge it. Not with a parade, but with a simple 'I saw you made the call on the vendor, and it worked out well — what was your reasoning?' That reinforces the behavior. But you also have to be okay with them making mistakes. If you swoop in every time they make a wrong call, you've undone all the training. Luna: That's the hard part for a lot of managers — letting them fail a little. But if the stakes are low, it's the perfect learning opportunity. Lucas: Right. And that's where you have to ask yourself: is your own anxiety driving the dynamic? If you're a micromanager, even subtly, your employee will pick up on that and be terrified to act. I've seen managers who complain about this but then also send a flurry of follow-up emails after a decision, questioning every detail. That sends a loud signal: 'I don't actually trust you.' Luna: So it's a two-way street. You have to give them the space to own the decision and live with the consequences. Lucas: Exactly. And one more nuance: sometimes the employee is asking because they genuinely lack the information or authority to decide. That's a different problem — it's not learned helplessness, it's a gap in role clarity. So you need to distinguish between 'I don't know what to do' and 'I'm not sure I'm allowed to decide.' The decision rights conversation handles the second. For the first, you can coach them on how to gather information themselves. Luna: Like, teach them to fish rather than giving them the fish. But also, how do you handle it when the question comes in Slack or email, not in person? That's where I see it get out of hand. Lucas: Great point. Async communication is a breeding ground for this. People feel less pressure to commit when they can just ping you. I've had employees ask me things in Slack that they clearly knew the answer to. My rule now is: if the answer is easily findable or if it's within their decision rights, I don't answer directly. I'll reply with 'What would you do?' or 'Check your decision rights document — what does it say?' It takes a bit more effort upfront, but it breaks the habit. Luna: And it also models that they should think before they ask. I love that. Lucas: There's also a deeper layer here, and it's about the employee's career trajectory. If you keep making their decisions, they never develop the judgment they need to get promoted. So when you step back, you're not just saving your own time — you're investing in their future. I've had employees thank me years later for pushing them to decide on their own, even when they were uncomfortable at the moment. Luna: That's the kind of legacy a manager leaves. Not the projects, but the people they built up. Lucas: Exactly. So let's summarize the playbook: first, make a decision rights map. Second, use decision framing and pre-mortems in the moment. Third, create a feedback loop that rewards independent decisions, and be comfortable with small failures. And fourth, check your own anxiety and communication patterns. That last one is often the hardest. Luna: And if it's a chronic issue, do you escalate to HR or is that too far? Lucas: I'd say only if there's a performance gap that doesn't improve after a few months. If you've done the coaching and they still can't decide on anything, that might be a fit issue. But in my experience, most people just need the structure and the permission. They'll surprise you. Luna: I think that's a hopeful note to end on. People want to be trusted — sometimes they just need to be told it's okay to decide. Lucas: And that's the job of a manager: to create conditions where they can. Thanks for listening, and remember, if this episode helped you think through a management challenge, consider supporting the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. We'll be back next week with another real-world leadership scenario.