Latest / Comeback Files: Resilience, recovery & starting over / Stop Trying to Fix Her: How to Hold Space for Pain Without Breaking | Comeback Files
Transcript
- The hardest thing I ever learned to do was sit perfectly still while the person I loved most fell apart. It wasn’t about finding the right words; it was about resisting the urge to sweep them up. We have a collective misunderstanding about love, don’t we? Somewhere along the line, we decided that if someone is hurting, our job is to make the hurting stop. We treat pain like a leaky faucet and ourselves like plumbers with a full toolkit. You see a friend crying over a breakup, and your brain immediately starts racing through solutions. Go on a vacation. Block the ex. Buy new shoes. Tell her she’s too good for him. We want to hand her a bandage because watching her bleed makes us feel useless. But here is the truth that took me years to swallow in my own recovery: you cannot fix grief. You cannot negotiate with loss. And when you try to fix something that isn’t broken but simply being experienced, you accidentally tell the other person their feelings are wrong. They aren’t a problem to be solved. They are a human being to be witnessed. Let’s look at what’s actually here. The impulse to fix comes from our own discomfort, not their need. We are anxious. We are unsettled. And so we rush to restore order, to put the puzzle back together before the pieces have even settled. But healing doesn’t happen in the rush. It happens in the pause. There is a profound dignity in being seen, even in our messiest moments. When someone shares their pain with you, they aren’t asking for a consultant. They are asking for a companion. Think about the last time you were truly heard. Not advised. Not corrected. Just heard. That feeling of relief? That is what you can offer. It requires a kind of courage that feels counterintuitive. You have to let yourself be uncomfortable. You have to let the silence stretch out until it feels heavy. And then, you stay there. You don’t fill the void with chatter or reassurance. You just keep your presence steady. I remember sitting with my sister after she lost her job during the recession. She didn’t want to talk about the economy or her resume. She wanted to talk about how invisible she felt. I wanted to tell her she was valuable regardless of her title. Instead, I just held her hand and said, 'I’m here.' That was it. No solution. Just presence. In that quiet space, she found the strength to stand back up on her own. My job wasn’t to carry her; it was to be the ground beneath her feet so she wouldn’t feel alone in the fall. Let’s be honest. Offering advice when someone is in the thick of emotion often feels like rejection to them. It signals that you don’t trust them to handle their own experience. It says, 'I don’t want to sit in this dark room with you, so let’s turn on the light and leave.' When you offer unsolicited solutions, you are prioritizing your need for control over their need for connection. This is especially true for women, who are often socialized to be caretakers and fixers. We think we are helping, but we are actually centering ourselves. We become the hero of the story, the one with the answer. But real intimacy isn’t about being the hero. It’s about being the witness. It’s about saying, 'This is hard. I see how hard it is. And I am not going anywhere.' When you remove the pressure to perform or to get better quickly, you give the other person permission to just be. And strangely enough, that permission is often the first step toward actual healing. They don’t need you to save them. They need you to believe they can survive it, even if they don’t believe it themselves yet. Sometimes, words fail us. And that’s okay. Holding space is as much physical as it is emotional. It’s in the way you lean in. The way you maintain eye contact without staring. The way you match their energy without mirroring their despair. If they are angry, you don’t calm them down; you acknowledge their anger. If they are sad, you don’t cheer them up; you honor their sadness. There is a rhythm to this. It’s slow. It’s deliberate. It’s like walking beside someone through a storm. You don’t hold an umbrella for them unless they ask. You just walk. Your shoulder might brush theirs. You might adjust your pace to match theirs. You don’t rush ahead. You don’t lag behind. You are simply there, moving through the weather together. This physical grounding helps regulate the nervous system. When someone is overwhelmed, their body goes into fight or flight. A calm, steady presence nearby can act as an anchor. It tells their primal brain that they are safe, that they are not alone, that the world hasn’t ended. It’s subtle, almost imperceptible to the untrained eye, but it is powerful. It’s the difference between being rescued and being accompanied. Now, I know what you’re thinking. 'Sophie, this sounds exhausting. How do I do this without losing myself?' Because holding space doesn’t mean absorbing the pain. It doesn’t mean you have to take on their burden as your own. There is a difference between empathy and enmeshment. Empathy is feeling with them. Enmeshment is feeling for them, or worse, taking responsibility for fixing it. You must protect your own energy. You are not a sponge. You are a mirror. A mirror reflects what is in front of it, but it does not become the object. If you find yourself feeling drained, resentful, or anxious while listening, check in with yourself. Are you trying to fix it because they need help, or because you can’t stand the discomfort? It’s okay to say, 'I want to listen, but I need a moment to gather my thoughts.' It’s okay to set limits on the conversation. You can say, 'I can sit with you for twenty minutes, and then I need to go prepare dinner.' Honesty is kinder than false endurance. By setting boundaries, you show them that your support is sustainable. You model healthy self-care. And paradoxically, when you respect your own limits, you create more genuine space for them to be heard. You aren’t giving from an empty cup. You are sharing from a full one. In a world that screams for action, for productivity, for constant optimization, choosing stillness is a radical act of love. We are conditioned to believe that doing is better than being. That solving is better than sensing. But some things cannot be solved. Some wounds only heal when they are allowed to breathe. When you choose to hold space, you are offering the greatest gift you can give another human being: your undivided attention. You are saying, 'Your pain matters. Your story matters. You matter, exactly as you are right now, in this messy, imperfect moment.' This is not passive. It is active. It takes effort. It takes practice. You will stumble. You will want to jump in and fix things. You will judge yourself for not having the right answer. Be gentle with yourself. The comeback starts in the quiet. It starts in these small, brave moments of resistance against the cultural urge to sanitize suffering. When you stop trying to fix, you start truly connecting. And that connection is where the magic lives. It’s where people find the courage to face their demons, not because you handed them a sword, but because you held the lantern. You are allowed to be a work in progress. And so is everyone around you. Thank you for showing up today. I’ll see you in the next one. Stay soft, stay strong. I’m Sophie Fergus, signing off.