Latest / The Morning Rundown / Pennsylvania's Measles Fight, a 100-Million-Barrel Oil Release, and an Early Flu Surge
Transcript
- 0:00[Maya] Three numbers walked into my inbox this morning, and I don't trust
- 0:17[Maya] any of them yet.
- 0:18[David] Huh, only three?
- 0:20[David] Your inbox is usually a crime scene.
- 0:23[Maya] Fair.
- 0:24[Maya] I'm Maya.
- 0:24[Maya] This is the morning rundown, and David is here to check my
- 0:27[Maya] math.
- 0:28[David] Somebody has to.
- 0:29[David] Mine is a measles count, a barrel count, and an early flu
- 0:34[David] season.
- 0:35[Maya] Wait, flu already?
- 0:36[Maya] It's barely sweater weather.
- 0:38[David] I know, hmm, and the oil one is a big round number,
- 0:41[David] the kind that looks great in a headline.
- 0:44[Maya] Big numbers are great at sounding like answers.
- 0:47[Maya] You know what I mean?
- 0:48[David] Right.
- 0:48[David] The question is always what the number actually does once it leaves
- 0:52[David] the headline.
- 0:53[Maya] So anyway, let's start with the story where the count itself is
- 0:56[Maya] the argument.
- 0:57[Maya] Measles in Pennsylvania.
- 0:59[David] Yeah, and the fight there is over what gets counted at all.
- 1:03[Maya] Okay, so the latest tally out of Pennsylvania is nine hundred and
- 1:07[Maya] seventy-seven cases across thirty-nine counties.
- 1:10[Maya] The Hill reported that, and it describes the worst outbreak the state's
- 1:13[Maya] seen in over thirty-five years.
- 1:15[David] Thirty-five years, and that's just cases.
- 1:18[David] What about hospitals?
- 1:19[Maya] About a hundred and ninety-five hospitalizations and five reported measles-associated deaths.
- 1:25[David] Five.
- 1:26[David] Hold that number because it's about to get slippery.
- 1:29[Maya] Slippery how?
- 1:30[David] Well, the state health department put out an update around September twenty-ninth.
- 1:34[David] It had nine hundred and three confirmed cases and four deaths.
- 1:37[David] So the totals keep moving, and each update replaces the last one.
- 1:41[Maya] Right.
- 1:41[Maya] So if you're quoting a number from a week ago, you're already
- 1:44[Maya] behind.
- 1:45[David] Totally.
- 1:46[David] And that same state update said only four cases, under one percent,
- 1:49[David] were among vaccinated people.
- 1:51[Maya] Wait, really?
- 1:53[Maya] Four?
- 1:53[David] Four out of nine hundred and three.
- 1:56[David] That only describes who got counted, so I'd stop there.
- 1:59[Maya] Okay, that's a pretty lopsided picture.
- 2:02[Maya] Now, the fifth death, a Reuters brief from October second, says it
- 2:06[Maya] was an unvaccinated Lancaster County resident and that all five Pennsylvania deaths
- 2:10[Maya] this year were unvaccinated people.
- 2:13[David] And then Reuters adds the kicker.
- 2:15[David] The CDC has confirmed only two measles deaths nationwide this year.
- 2:19[Maya] Two nationwide versus five in one state.
- 2:23[David] Yep, and that gap is the whole fight.
- 2:26[David] Governor Josh Shapiro and HHS Secretary Robert F.
- 2:29[David] Kennedy Jr.
- 2:30[David] are arguing over the true death toll.
- 2:32[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 2:33[Maya] How do you argue over how many people died?
- 2:36[David] Fair, but the reporting doesn't settle it.
- 2:38[David] The discrepancy between the state count and the CDC count is real.
- 2:42[David] Neither source I've seen explains why the numbers differ, so I'm not
- 2:45[David] gonna guess who's right.
- 2:46[Maya] Fine, but as a listener, what do I want out of that?
- 2:50[David] One standard written down, applied the same way everywhere, and dated so
- 2:54[David] you know which update you're reading.
- 2:56[David] Whatever definition counts a death, publish it.
- 2:59[David] Then nobody has to take a politician's word for it left or
- 3:01[David] right.
- 3:02[Maya] That's the boring answer, and I like it.
- 3:04[Maya] Boring means checkable.
- 3:06[David] Meanwhile, people are voting with their arms.
- 3:08[David] The Hill says more than forty-nine thousand MMR doses went out in
- 3:11[David] August.
- 3:12[Maya] And a typical month?
- 3:13[David] To about twenty-five thousand.
- 3:15[David] So August was roughly double, and September is at fifty-three thousand so
- 3:19[David] far with the month not even finished.
- 3:21[Maya] That's wild, right?
- 3:22[Maya] Fear moves people faster than a campaign does.
- 3:25[David] Maybe, but a spike in shots doesn't fix the plumbing.
- 3:28[David] The Guardian reported that most Pennsylvania counties don't have their own health
- 3:32[David] agencies.
- 3:33[Maya] Hmm, so who's tracking it in those counties?
- 3:35[David] The state mostly, which is the point.
- 3:37[David] Thin local capacity means slower tracing and a harder time reaching people.
- 3:41[David] The Guardian also says some specific population groups have low vaccination rates,
- 3:45[David] and officials expect this to spread.
- 3:48[Maya] So the counting problem and the capacity problem are tangled.
- 3:51[David] They are.
- 3:52[David] If a county can't count quickly, it can't respond quickly either.
- 3:56[Maya] What does that look like for a family in one of those
- 3:58[Maya] counties?
- 3:59[David] The reporting doesn't get that granular, so I won't invent a scenario.
- 4:02[David] My read, not The Guardian's, is simple.
- 4:04[David] Where vaccination is low and the local office is thin, an outbreak
- 4:08[David] is harder to get ahead of.
- 4:09[Maya] And I'll say it, this doesn't need a villain.
- 4:12[Maya] It needs a local health office that can pick up the phone
- 4:14[Maya] and a number everybody trusts.
- 4:17[David] Agreed.
- 4:17[David] That's measles for now, and the totals will keep moving.
- 4:20[David] Next up is energy and a very large number of barrels.
- 4:24[Maya] Let's get into it.
- 4:25[Maya] Sh, sounds better than breaking off knights' heads.
- 4:29[David] The G7 nations agreed on October second to put a hundred million
- 4:33[David] barrels on the market, and the AP says diesel is part of
- 4:36[David] it.
- 4:36[David] That last part matters.
- 4:38[Maya] Wait, I thought the whole thing was just crude.
- 4:40[Maya] Strategic reserve, open the tap.
- 4:43[David] Crude and diesel both.
- 4:44[David] The AP report says the International Energy Agency coordinates it.
- 4:48[David] It starts immediately, and it runs over four months.
- 4:51[Maya] Four months.
- 4:52[Maya] Okay.
- 4:53[David] Right, and over four months is a schedule, not a single drop.
- 4:56[Maya] So it's a steady pour, not a flood.
- 4:59[David] And the diesel is front-loaded.
- 5:01[David] A substantial chunk goes out in the first twenty days.
- 5:04[Maya] Twenty days?
- 5:05[Maya] That's fast.
- 5:06[Maya] Why the rush on diesel?
- 5:08[David] Because diesel just hit record highs in the US.
- 5:10[David] That's the pain point.
- 5:11[David] Truckers, farmers, anybody moving anything, it shows up in the price of
- 5:15[David] everything on the shelf.
- 5:16[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 5:17[Maya] You can feel that at the grocery store.
- 5:19[David] Totally, and there's a political wrinkle.
- 5:21[David] Some Republicans had urged a diesel export ban.
- 5:24[David] Basically, keep our fuel at home.
- 5:26[David] But the deal pledges no export restrictions among its members.
- 5:30[Maya] Huh.
- 5:30[Maya] So the instinct on the right was lock the doors, and the
- 5:34[Maya] deal goes the other way.
- 5:35[David] Right, and I think the deal has the better logic.
- 5:37[David] You fix a shortage with more supply, not with walling off the
- 5:40[David] market.
- 5:41[David] Price controls and export bans tend to make shortages worse because producers
- 5:45[David] stop wanting to produce.
- 5:47[Maya] So the conservative case here is basically let the market work?
- 5:51[David] Basically.
- 5:52[David] More supply and open borders for fuel instead of the government deciding
- 5:55[David] who gets it and at what price.
- 5:57[David] That's my view, and to be clear, the sources don't settle that
- 6:00[David] argument.
- 6:01[Maya] Hmm, fair.
- 6:02[Maya] But a hundred million barrels sounds enormous, and you were skeptical of
- 6:06[Maya] big numbers earlier.
- 6:07[David] I was.
- 6:08[David] Euronews ran the math.
- 6:10[David] Spread evenly, it works out to roughly eight hundred and thirty thousand
- 6:13[David] barrels a day.
- 6:14[Maya] Which sounds like a lot until you...
- 6:16[David] Until you remember how much the world burns every day.
- 6:19[David] And here's the bigger catch.
- 6:21[David] Euronews points out that strategic crude releases don't immediately become extra diesel.
- 6:25[Maya] Wait, really?
- 6:26[Maya] Oil is oil, no?
- 6:28[David] Crude has to get refined.
- 6:29[David] It sits in storage, it has to move to a refinery, and
- 6:32[David] the refinery has to turn it into diesel.
- 6:34[David] So Euronews says the price impact depends on release speed and refining
- 6:38[David] conversion.
- 6:39[Maya] So it's like handing someone a bag of flour when they're hungry
- 6:42[Maya] for bread.
- 6:43[David] It's actually good, yes.
- 6:45[David] And to be fair, the package also covers higher refinery output, so
- 6:48[David] they're not ignoring the bread part.
- 6:50[Maya] Okay, that's something.
- 6:52[Maya] Why is it all happening now, though?
- 6:54[David] Al Jazeera's summary says global energy prices have soared because of the
- 6:57[David] U.S.
- 6:58[David] and Israel's war on Iran and Russia's war on Ukraine, two wars
- 7:02[David] hitting supply at once.
- 7:04[Maya] Yikes.
- 7:05[Maya] So the release is a patch on a much bigger problem.
- 7:08[David] A real patch, but yeah.
- 7:10[David] Euronews also says this followed pressure from Washington and a call between
- 7:13[David] Macron and Trump over that possible export ban.
- 7:17[Maya] Okay, so the big question: Will drivers feel it soon?
- 7:21[David] Honestly, I can't tell you.
- 7:23[David] None of the sources I've seen give a price forecast.
- 7:25[David] The speed matters, the refining matters, and the wars are still going.
- 7:29[Maya] Ugh.
- 7:30[Maya] So the answer is watch the pump and don't hold your breath.
- 7:33[David] And watch is the right word.
- 7:35[David] The two dials are how fast the release moves and how much
- 7:38[David] of it turns into product.
- 7:39[David] The sources don't give us either answer yet.
- 7:42[David] I'd also keep an eye on that higher refinery output piece, since
- 7:45[David] that's the bread part.
- 7:46[Maya] So what would a good sign even look like?
- 7:49[David] I'd say watch diesel first.
- 7:51[David] If the front-loaded part works, that's where we'd see it.
- 7:54[Maya] And if diesel just sits up near those record highs?
- 7:57[David] Then it's a sign the pour isn't turning into product fast enough
- 8:00[David] or the wars are swamping it.
- 8:02[David] Either way, one week of prices proves little.
- 8:05[David] I'd want a trend, not a headline.
- 8:07[David] For a driver, the honest answer for now is wait and watch,
- 8:10[David] not plan around a drop.
- 8:12[Maya] Fair enough.
- 8:13[Maya] Okay, last one is closer to home and a little more practical.
- 8:16[Maya] Flu season is starting early in parts of the country.
- 8:19[David] Oh, I've got opinions on that.
- 8:21[David] Go.
- 8:22[Maya] Okay, flu.
- 8:23[Maya] And this one I can actually act on before lunch.
- 8:27[David] Which is rare for a news segment.
- 8:29[David] Go.
- 8:30[Maya] The Washington Post ran a piece on October fourth with a pretty
- 8:33[Maya] direct headline about thinking of your flu shot right now.
- 8:37[Maya] The summary line says flu is surging unusually early in some parts
- 8:41[Maya] of the Western United States.
- 8:43[David] Early like a little ahead of schedule, or early like doctors are
- 8:47[David] checking their calendars?
- 8:49[Maya] The summary says it caught doctors surprised.
- 8:52[Maya] That's all I've got, and I'm not going to invent more.
- 8:55[Maya] No case counts for me, no list of states.
- 8:58[David] Fair.
- 8:58[David] Honestly, that's refreshing after the last two stories.
- 9:01[Maya] Right?
- 9:02[Maya] No barrels, no refinery math.
- 9:04[David] Well, hang on.
- 9:05[David] There's still a numbers question hiding in here.
- 9:08[David] Every year, we treat flu like it shows up on a schedule,
- 9:11[David] and the schedule is a habit more than a rule.
- 9:14[Maya] Meaning we plan around the calendar, and the virus doesn't read the
- 9:17[Maya] calendar.
- 9:18[David] Right.
- 9:19[David] Doctors being surprised tells you the usual timing assumptions are shaky, at
- 9:23[David] least in the West this year.
- 9:24[David] I'd stop short of saying it's coming for everyone.
- 9:27[Maya] Totally.
- 9:27[Maya] One region, one report.
- 9:29[Maya] Don't panic-buy tissues.
- 9:32[David] Nobody panic-buys tissues for flu.
- 9:34[David] Soup, maybe.
- 9:35[Maya] Okay, so what do you actually do?
- 9:38[Maya] Um, the Post piece urges people to think about the shot now,
- 9:41[Maya] not in November when you finally remember.
- 9:44[David] And I'd keep it simple.
- 9:46[David] Ask your own doctor or your pharmacist what timing makes sense for
- 9:49[David] you.
- 9:49[David] They know your health history, and they know what's going around locally.
- 9:53[Maya] That's a two-minute call, or one question while you're picking up a
- 9:56[Maya] prescription anyway.
- 9:57[David] Exactly.
- 9:58[David] Not a research project.
- 9:59[Maya] And if the pharmacist says wait a few weeks, that's still useful
- 10:03[Maya] because then you've got a date instead of a vague plan.
- 10:07[David] Right.
- 10:07[David] The point isn't to rush.
- 10:08[David] It's to stop drifting.
- 10:10[David] A decision made on purpose beats a shot you forget about until
- 10:13[David] the season's already underway.
- 10:14[Maya] What if you're not in the West, though?
- 10:16[Maya] Does this even apply to me?
- 10:18[David] The summary only mentions some parts of the Western U.S., so I
- 10:22[David] can't tell you what it means for your town.
- 10:23[David] That's exactly why the local question matters.
- 10:26[David] A pharmacist or a doctor will know more about what's circulating near
- 10:29[David] you than a national headline does.
- 10:31[Maya] And if you already have a plan for later in the season?
- 10:35[David] Then mention it when you ask.
- 10:36[David] Maybe it's fine.
- 10:37[David] Maybe a little nudge it earlier.
- 10:39[David] We're not going to replace a doctor's appointment here.
- 10:41[David] We're just two people with microphones, not your clinic.
- 10:44[Maya] Okay, that's the practical bit.
- 10:46[Maya] Over to the wrap-up.
- 10:48[David] Let's do it.
- 10:49[Maya] Okay, so one line each.
- 10:51[Maya] Measles first.
- 10:52[Maya] Pennsylvania is still arguing which deaths get counted.
- 10:56[David] And until counting rules are the same everywhere, every update is a
- 10:59[David] snapshot, not a verdict.
- 11:00[Maya] Oil, big release, but crude in a tank is not diesel in
- 11:05[Maya] your truck.
- 11:05[David] Right.
- 11:06[David] Refineries still have a job to do before anyone's pump notices.
- 11:09[Maya] And flu is early, so the shot conversation with your pharmacist moves
- 11:13[Maya] up the calendar.
- 11:14[David] Three stories, three numbers, and the honest answer on each was it
- 11:18[David] depends what you're counting.
- 11:19[David] I'd call that a productive morning.
- 11:21[Maya] Fair.
- 11:22[Maya] I'm Maya.
- 11:23[David] I'm David.
- 11:23[Maya] Thanks for spending the morning with us.
- 11:25[Maya] Go grab a coffee.
- 11:26[Maya] You earned it.
- 11:26[Maya] This was the Morning Rundown.