Latest / Politics with Paul / Are a Majority of Americans Politically in the Middle? w/ Shannon Watson | Politics with Paul #63
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul Podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04politics and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08We have another great guest episode for you today.
- 0:11If you're new, no matter who my guest is, I always give the disclaimer that I do not take a
- 0:15stance for or against a guest's political views or groups they support, but that's not gonna be
- 0:20an issue today.
- 0:21Today, we're tackling this question.
- 0:24Are a majority of Americans really in the middle?
- 0:27It could seem like more and more people are out on the extremes and that incessant fighting is
- 0:32an inescapable reality, and there are a lot of loud voices that predominantly drive political
- 0:38discussion.
- 0:38Some people would even argue that there are few Americans truly in the middle, but many
- 0:42Republicans, Democrats, and independents have voiced disapproval of this politics as usual
- 0:47approach.
- 0:48So what characteristics make somebody part of this political middle?
- 0:53Is it just about political beliefs, and what impact can they make on politics in overcoming
- 0:58division?
- 0:59That's what my guest today, Shannon Watson is here to talk about.
- 1:03Shannon is the executive director of Majority in the Middle, a Minnesota based nonprofit that
- 1:08describes itself as an objective outside force for systemic change to improve transparency,
- 1:14participation, and civility within political and civic life.
- 1:19She's also a communications consultant with Casper Corcoran and was previously the senior
- 1:24director of government affairs and policy with the Medical Alley Association, the vice
- 1:28president of public affairs of the Saint Paul Area Chamber of Commerce, an election
- 1:32campaigner, and the founder of Definitely Someday.
- 1:36Now let's talk about this political middle.
- 1:39Please welcome Shannon Watson to the show.
- 1:41Shannon, thanks for coming on.
- 1:42How are you?
- 1:43Absolutely, Paul.
- 1:44I'm great.
- 1:44How are you?
- 1:46I'm I'm doing okay, and thank you for for coming on here.
- 1:50So I like to sort of get to the beginning of things for people before we get into the meat
- 1:56of things.
- 1:56That's fair.
- 1:57You have a lot of experience in the political realm, so it will be difficult to cover at all,
- 2:03but give us a condensed version.
- 2:05How did your experience lead you to this study and work regarding the political middle of
- 2:10America and working past division?
- 2:13You know, it's it's probably foundational to my life.
- 2:17I blame my parents.
- 2:18Blame them or give them credit depending on the day for this work because my dad is what I've
- 2:26started calling a legacy Republican, somebody who's been a Republican for a very long time.
- 2:31And my mom is a Democrat or a Libertarian depending on the day and the issue.
- 2:36And so I grew up obviously in a very mixed political household.
- 2:43My parents both had sort of politically adjacent jobs.
- 2:46My my dad was a police officer, and then he he worked his way up from patrol cop all the way
- 2:51up to chief of police.
- 2:53And my mom was a was a freelance journalist, and she owned a publishing company for a while.
- 2:59So so very politically adjacent jobs, if not inherently political.
- 3:04So they were, you know, they were members of two different parties, which meant we got all
- 3:10of the door knockers.
- 3:11We got all of the lit.
- 3:12We got all of the, you know, the television commercials and and, you know, newspaper
- 3:19articles and, you know, voting as soon as you're 18 was a given in my family.
- 3:26Actually, my very first vote was a primary, and my dad was like, I need you to go vote and vote
- 3:32for this person because it was a judge that he liked working with very much and wanted to keep
- 3:38his seat.
- 3:39So, yeah, it's kind of that.
- 3:44And then this trend that we've been seeing over the last, I don't know, maybe ten, maybe twenty
- 3:50years now, of people who who don't wanna be in relationship with people who they don't vote
- 3:56the same as.
- 3:59You know, it used to be that that people would be nervous or upset if their child was thinking
- 4:04of marrying someone of a different religion, and now somebody of a different political
- 4:10persuasion has sort of taken over, that.
- 4:14And so, this idea that you can't be in relationship with somebody is completely
- 4:19foreign to me because every day of my life, I have watched it.
- 4:23They had they just celebrated fifty five years of marriage.
- 4:27Oh, nice.
- 4:27Congrats.
- 4:28Right?
- 4:29And so, you know, they they still go vote together even when they think their their votes
- 4:35are gonna cancel each other out, which I guess is another reason, like, it's important for
- 4:39them to both go because, you know, they have to cancel each other out.
- 4:43So, so yeah.
- 4:45So that's that's kinda where it came from.
- 4:47And, I helped start majority in the middle in 2020.
- 4:54That was a response to, that was the first debate between let's see.
- 5:01It would have been 2020, so it would have been then president Trump and then candidate Biden.
- 5:06And I didn't watch that particular debate.
- 5:09I didn't need to.
- 5:09It wasn't gonna change my vote.
- 5:13But I watched social media afterwards and I saw a lot of what I expected to see.
- 5:17A lot of people on the right saying, you know, oh, the candidate from the left is terrible.
- 5:20And a lot of people on the left saying, oh, the candidate on the right is terrible.
- 5:24But the one thing I saw that didn't expect was the number of people who I consider to be very
- 5:33political people.
- 5:35They have either served in office or run for office or been campaign staff or, you know,
- 5:40worked at the capital.
- 5:43Very political people saying, this is this is this is gross.
- 5:49It's too much.
- 5:50I don't like it.
- 5:51I'm out.
- 5:53And the number of people who have been opting out of politics has been worrying me for a very
- 6:01long time.
- 6:02And so in 2020, was like, okay, we have reached a tipping point.
- 6:05If even these people are like, this is this is enough.
- 6:09And so put the brand together, put a you know, convened a table and and started working on it.
- 6:14And I didn't necessarily know what we were gonna do at that point.
- 6:19But since in the five years since we've we've identified some structural things and some,
- 6:26relationship things and some math things, that we think get in the way of, working together.
- 6:33And so we've been we've been doing that ever since.
- 6:37Gotcha.
- 6:38Yeah.
- 6:39The thing you're talking about with your parents, definitely heard of that being a lot
- 6:45more common back in those times.
- 6:49You look at data that some people have cited or people are not only getting upset that their
- 6:55child may marry somebody who's not the same party, but just the fact that they won't even
- 7:01they look to not even move to the same neighborhoods.
- 7:04They purposely look to see.
- 7:06Is this like mean, obviously, that's that's not helping anything, but I just can't even imagine
- 7:10that being, like, so forefront of your mind that you're just if you find some place that's
- 7:18really nice to live, you really like it, but then all of a sudden you find out, well, if
- 7:21you're a republican, then a bunch of democrats there, or if you're a democrat, then you find a
- 7:25bunch of republicans there.
- 7:26This is like so you're really not gonna move to that place just because of that.
- 7:30But, obviously, that sounds crazy to us, but for some other people, that that's not so
- 7:35crazy.
- 7:35Well yeah.
- 7:36And that's the thing.
- 7:36Like, you know, us sorting into in groups and out groups.
- 7:40I did some research on this a couple of years ago.
- 7:44And as it turns out, and this makes me feel really good about some of our divisions, is
- 7:49that forming in groups and out groups and doing that division is a very human thing.
- 7:55It's part of our evolution.
- 7:56It's part of our psychology.
- 7:58And so it's really important to know like, we don't just divide.
- 8:03We don't look for people who think like us and look like us and act like us and value the
- 8:09things that we do.
- 8:10We don't do that out of malice all the time.
- 8:13We generally just do it's just part of being human.
- 8:17And so, yeah, those those really harmonious neighborhoods that you're talking about when
- 8:23when everybody moves to places where, you know, you you agree with all of your neighbors or,
- 8:29you know, you're like the one outlier, those those can be great until they become echo
- 8:35chambers, and that's kind of what they've been been becoming.
- 8:39So that big sort has been an issue for a while.
- 8:43Yeah.
- 8:43That that great sorting out that we've seen since the nineteen sixties.
- 8:48It's and in some ways, it's still going on.
- 8:51Mhmm.
- 8:53But, I mean, that that is also true too.
- 8:54It is partly human, and and and we do have to acknowledge that to to some extent.
- 9:00It's just obviously making people aware of that and why it's such a big problem, obviously, is
- 9:05is part of the whole
- 9:07Yeah.
- 9:07And to know I guess.
- 9:08Yeah.
- 9:08And to know that we we sort of naturally do it, and so we have to actively undo it.
- 9:16Yeah.
- 9:16No.
- 9:16Absolutely.
- 9:17Well, you've worked in campaigning on local and statewide campaigns on both sides of the aisle
- 9:23as I saw on your LinkedIn in several states.
- 9:26Mhmm.
- 9:26Kansas, Minnesota, and somewhere else, I think.
- 9:28Colorado.
- 9:29Yeah.
- 9:29Mhmm.
- 9:29Colorado.
- 9:31As well as in several policy advocacy roles.
- 9:34So with those experiences, did you witness a particularly high level of divisiveness and
- 9:40polarization?
- 9:41And whether or not that was the case, what are some examples?
- 9:47You know, a lot of the races that I worked on were, like, local, like county commissioner or
- 9:57city council.
- 9:58Those are the ones that I kinda cut my teeth.
- 10:02My mom ran for state senate early on in sort of my political career, that's where I learned
- 10:07about door knocking.
- 10:08Both of my parents have had since they left those politically adjacent roles, they have
- 10:14both run for run for office independently.
- 10:17They have both lost, one by 46 votes and one by 17 votes.
- 10:22And if you think they don't remember those numbers, you're wrong.
- 10:24Yeah.
- 10:25Yeah.
- 10:26So so I did a lot of of working at that that local level.
- 10:31And in many states, the the local offices are generally nonpartisan, And that's that's one of
- 10:42the reasons I think I gravitate towards those towards those those campaigns.
- 10:48The last the not quite the last campaign I worked on, but the last really partisan one.
- 10:58In 2010, I went back to Kansas and and worked on a congressional campaign in Kansas fourth
- 11:09for a guy named Raj Goyle, who had been a state senator in Kansas senator or representative?
- 11:16I don't remember.
- 11:17Sorry, Raj.
- 11:19But in the in the state house in Kansas and then was running for for congress in a district
- 11:25that was three to one Republican.
- 11:27I mean, is the South Part Of Kansas.
- 11:29This is the congressional district that I grew up in.
- 11:33It was the it was an open seat for the first time in, like, twenty some years.
- 11:37And we wound up losing, but that's okay because all the democrats lost in twenty ten,
- 11:44basically.
- 11:46We lost to a a new a guy who was new to politics at that time.
- 11:51This is first time he'd run for office.
- 11:53His name is Mike Pompeo.
- 11:55Maybe you've heard of him.
- 11:56Yeah.
- 11:58Yeah.
- 11:58Small world.
- 12:00Right.
- 12:02Boy, if I only knew now now what I didn't know then.
- 12:05Anyways, the thing that was really interesting about that particular race, so 2010, we were we
- 12:14were working up to the primary.
- 12:16There were two candidates on the Democratic side.
- 12:19So there was Raj, and then there was this other guy who was sort of one of those perennial
- 12:24candidates who who didn't really get a lot of attention or support or whatever.
- 12:29But we still, like, were running to win.
- 12:33And then the, the Republican field had five different candidates in it.
- 12:38So Mike and and four challengers, and he wound up winning the primary.
- 12:42But in the run up to the primary, our ads for that, for that race were enormously positive.
- 12:54Like, the TV ad, they were glorious.
- 12:59And they were they were really great.
- 13:01And so when I and the other field organizers, when we would be door knocking, we heard so
- 13:08much.
- 13:08Oh, yeah.
- 13:08We like that guy.
- 13:10You know, because his his ads are really good.
- 13:12Like, they're really nice.
- 13:14And we like that.
- 13:16So, you know, we appreciate that.
- 13:19And so our campaign was very, very positive.
- 13:23Until about two in the morning, day after the primary, we started going negative, when we had
- 13:32that candidate.
- 13:35That was something I was super opposed to, made me very much an outlier in that in that
- 13:40campaign.
- 13:42But it was partially because I was at the doors, and that was the thing that people were
- 13:48commenting on was the positivity that was coming from our campaign.
- 13:54And I was like, you are gonna destroy all of this goodwill that we get for running those
- 14:00positive ads and not doing the fighting, mudslinging, whatever that was coming from the
- 14:06other side of the field because they were in, you know, like, a real campaign, trying to get
- 14:12through that primary.
- 14:14So I don't know.
- 14:17I think that's that's one of the things that I you know, it was just well, let's see, 2010,
- 14:23that's fifteen years ago.
- 14:25I look back at that with an enormous amount of nostalgia.
- 14:29And every time I can get my hands on a candidate, pointing to, you gotta say what you
- 14:36want to do, what vision that you have for, you know, your role or for your constituents or
- 14:45whatever.
- 14:46Like, it really needs to be, like, something that you're for, just you're against that other
- 14:53guy or the other side or whatever.
- 14:56And I think that's one of the things that, you know, my my research, the the physiological
- 15:04reality is that happy people are hard to motivate, is one of the reasons that we don't
- 15:13really lean into a lot of that kind of messaging.
- 15:17Like, it feels good.
- 15:18And, oh, isn't that nice?
- 15:21But it's really hard to get people to act while they're feeling good.
- 15:25People generally
- 15:26complacency.
- 15:27Exactly.
- 15:30The best way to get people to act and in a political campaign, that's either vote or
- 15:34donate or, you know, volunteer or, you know, wave a sign or whatever is to to activate fear
- 15:45and anger and point it at the other side so that people feel like if I don't go vote,
- 15:52something bad is gonna happen.
- 15:56And that's disappointing.
- 15:58Yeah.
- 15:59Yeah.
- 15:59It it is it is unfortunately, you know, people do all that what you call negative campaigning
- 16:05because it works.
- 16:07It works.
- 16:07And people are just overly obsessed with winning.
- 16:10Now, obviously, yeah, you don't wanna run a campaign to to lose, but it is just an
- 16:16unfortunate one of those short term individual incentives for people and for specific
- 16:21campaigns that's even though it erodes our political discourse because it benefits a
- 16:29specific campaign at that time to do it, they're going to do it.
- 16:32It's it's that's unfortunately what helps a win and regardless of whether it's a very even
- 16:39district or if it's a lopsided Republican, lopsided Democrat.
- 16:43But what about more were there any more particularly I know you talked about some of
- 16:51the people who went door to door that really Mhmm.
- 16:53It really resonated that that positive stuff.
- 16:55Was there another campaign that was a lot more consistently positive in terms of, like, the
- 17:02collaboration, or was that more of the norm that you experienced?
- 17:07You know, there are there are two campaigns that I liked a lot.
- 17:10I didn't actually I didn't get to work on either of these.
- 17:14But John Higginlooper, who is now a senator in Colorado, when he was running for governor at
- 17:26at that same time during that 2010 cycle, he had these ads that were great about how it
- 17:34whenever time he he sees a negative ad, it makes him feel icky, and he wants to take a
- 17:39shower.
- 17:40And so it was this this ad of him keep like, the whole thing was him going in the bathroom
- 17:45with, like, with different clothes on because he had to take a shower.
- 17:48Because, like, the negative ads make him need to take a shower.
- 17:51And so, like, the whole thing was him walking in and out of the bathroom to take a shower.
- 17:55And I thought that was great.
- 17:57So he he did he did well, not embracing the sort of negativity.
- 18:06And then the other one was Spencer Cox, who is the current governor in Utah, who has been
- 18:14getting some attention since the Charlie Kirk assassination and, Governor Cox, founded the
- 18:22Disagree Better movement at the National Governors Association when he was the chair of
- 18:27that group.
- 18:29But he and his opponent in 2020 made an ad about, you know, keeping things positive and,
- 18:37you know, standing up for democracy and, like, not slugging each other.
- 18:41And they did the ad together.
- 18:43And so, like, that was that was great.
- 18:47Now, I give those guys a lot of kudos for doing that.
- 18:53And I give any, any candidate kudos for trying to keep it positive when they can.
- 19:02At the same time, candidates candidates themselves are almost never the problem.
- 19:09It is the the groups that are designed to divide us, and I would even put the, you know,
- 19:16the business units of the Republican Party and the Democratic Party and, you know, the DNC and
- 19:22the RNC and the D triple c and the SRCC or whatever that is.
- 19:29Because because the groups that are designed to divide us and need to motivate all those voters
- 19:38to give money and to vote and to get out for their candidates, They put a lot of time and
- 19:44effort into dividing us, and it's not just during campaign season anymore.
- 19:50It's all the time.
- 19:52I mean, I imagine you get the the fundraising emails.
- 19:57I mean, the ones that drive me the most crazy are the fundraising emails for, like, you know,
- 20:01a state representative who you need to donate in April to fight the Donald Trump agenda.
- 20:10Okay.
- 20:10State representative, you need to stay in your lane.
- 20:13Yeah.
- 20:14Yeah.
- 20:14And state Democratic committee, quit it.
- 20:18Yeah.
- 20:19Yeah.
- 20:19There's there's a lot more in politics than just Donald Trump.
- 20:23And, yeah, that's got kinda speaks to that whole nationalization of politics.
- 20:28That's that's an interesting point you made about I had to think about how much I I agree
- 20:33or disagree with it.
- 20:34The the point where you said it's almost never the candidates, and it's the groups.
- 20:39Now certainly, groups are objectively, they are a problem.
- 20:44But I never really thought about it.
- 20:46Was like, well, how much are the candidates?
- 20:49I'd have to think about that some more.
- 20:52And I mean, there are, of course, outliers, And there is a there is a recognition that you want
- 21:01the candidate to go high in most cases.
- 21:06And sometimes there are well, Ken oh, this is embarrassing.
- 21:14What's Ken's last name?
- 21:15Ken.
- 21:19For?
- 21:20The DNC chair.
- 21:22Ken.
- 21:24Oh, now I'm forgetting it.
- 21:26Right.
- 21:26Okay.
- 21:27Anyway, you know who I'm talking about.
- 21:28Yeah.
- 21:28Sorry, Ken.
- 21:29I can't remember your last name at the moment.
- 21:31I couldn't remember John McCain's name the other day.
- 21:33So like, I I have a I have a thing about names.
- 21:36But anyways, so anyways, he actually came out and said, role his role as party chair when he
- 21:45was here in Minnesota was to punch down so that the candidate could stay on the high road.
- 21:51Like, he he sees that as his job to punch down and sort of get in the fray so that the
- 22:02candidate can take the high road.
- 22:03And I would say that is true at in many, many states and at many, many levels.
- 22:10Most people just aren't willing to say it out loud.
- 22:13Yeah.
- 22:15That's an interesting way to put it.
- 22:17Like like you said, a little bit ago, just the whole basically, every day is campaigning
- 22:23season.
- 22:24Is there is more.
- 22:25Yeah.
- 22:25Which is disappointing.
- 22:27No more.
- 22:27Yeah.
- 22:28And, obviously, unfortunately, you'd like to find a way to to curb that, but then then that
- 22:33runs into, well, is this a First Amendment issue?
- 22:36You're are you in infringing on freedom of speech if you try to say, okay.
- 22:39Well, there's no gonna be no campaigning in these particular times.
- 22:43You have to do it in these particular times.
- 22:45So then you have to contend with all those little things that all these all these reforms,
- 22:50if you will, that you'd really like to see and that you think might be a really good idea, but
- 22:54then how actionable are they?
- 22:56How how how feasible are they?
- 22:58And and, unfortunately, that that simies a lot of this a lot of these attempts to try to make
- 23:05our political discourse better.
- 23:07Right.
- 23:07But speaking of making political discourse better, I did mention earlier that you are the
- 23:12executive director of majority in the middle.
- 23:15And I gave a brief description of the organization, but, obviously, since you are the
- 23:19one representing them, wanna hear more from you.
- 23:21What are some more of the details on the goals of majority in the middle and what exactly the
- 23:26group does, and what are some of the things you have done?
- 23:28Gotcha.
- 23:29So we have a couple of different bodies of work.
- 23:33Our flagship project is what we call the state of bipartisanship report, and this is something
- 23:37that a lot of the stuff that we're doing, sort of piloting in Minnesota and seeing what works
- 23:43and what doesn't with the goal of being able to replicate that in other states as as it would
- 23:50be applicable.
- 23:51And then we'll get to congress in, like, twenty years.
- 23:56So we look at the authorship of different bills in Minnesota and contrast that with what bills
- 24:07are getting hearings.
- 24:09So in some states, legislators are limited by the number of bills that they can introduce,
- 24:15and like all of the bills get hearings.
- 24:17In Minnesota, you can introduce as many bills as you want, which means Minnesota's on a bi
- 24:24biennial system, so it's like a two year cycle.
- 24:28Last two year cycle, which was '23 and '24, there were, I wanna say like 11,000 bills
- 24:37introduced over that two year period.
- 24:39And Minnesota is also a part time legislature.
- 24:42So January through May, the first year, and then generally February ish through May the
- 24:49second year.
- 24:50So not all year round, but 11,000 bills, and that, had dwarfed wildly, the other years
- 25:00prior.
- 25:01Like, there was a huge spike in the number.
- 25:05And and then so this year is the first year of of a two year biennium, and they're already at
- 25:107,000 ish bills.
- 25:13So I expect we're gonna we're gonna hit that 11,000 again, which makes counting them all
- 25:20kind of a challenge, but that's okay.
- 25:21That's okay.
- 25:22So anyways, so what bills get get heard, not necessarily by subject, but more like which
- 25:31ones are a 100% Democrat led bills, which ones are Republican led bills, and then which ones
- 25:38are are bipartisan bills.
- 25:41And by doing that, we uncovered a whole lot of what we called hidden bipartisanship kind of
- 25:48happening behind the scenes that nobody was really paying attention to, nobody was really
- 25:52talking about.
- 25:53There was significantly more bipartisan bills than I thought there would be the first year
- 25:59that we did this in '23.
- 26:02This year, the so in '23 and '24 in Minnesota, the DFL is Minnesota version of the Democratic
- 26:13Party, so Democratic Farmer Labor Party.
- 26:16Democrats had a trifecta.
- 26:18They controlled the house, they controlled the senate, they controlled the governor's office.
- 26:21So they had all the power.
- 26:24And in '25, the governor is still a Democrat, obviously.
- 26:32The state Senate is controlled by the Democrats by one vote, 34 to 33.
- 26:40And the house of representatives is tied at 67 each, which was really interesting.
- 26:48Yeah.
- 26:49The day after election day, a lot of people wanted to talk to me because I had spent about
- 26:54three years prior walking around the capital talking about bipartisanship and everybody's
- 26:58sort of patting me on the head.
- 26:59Oh, that's a cute idea.
- 27:00And then suddenly it was like, okay, wait, how is this gonna work?
- 27:04Because now we have to.
- 27:07So that has made for a very interesting situation in that any bill has to be bipartisan
- 27:13to get through our house of representatives.
- 27:15So that's super interesting.
- 27:18Okay.
- 27:18So that's the state of bipartisanship report.
- 27:20We also have some work that we do on the local level, again, with those nonpartisan offices,
- 27:26whether it's school board, city council, county commission, park board, know, mayors, those are
- 27:34all in Minnesota legally nonpartisan offices.
- 27:37They're not what I would always call functionally nonpartisan, but we're we're doing
- 27:42what we can to keep those as nonpartisan as as we can.
- 27:47And some of that has to do with structure and some of it has to do, again, with sort of your
- 27:54thing about free speech.
- 27:56You know, political parties can make endorsements just like any other group in
- 28:02nonpartisan offices.
- 28:04I don't necessarily think it's always a good idea though.
- 28:07But you can't ban it because, again, it's not constitutional.
- 28:14California tried in the 1980s and it's not constitutional.
- 28:19So part of that has to do with, you know, how do nonpartisan candidates sort of present being
- 28:28a nonpartisan candidate?
- 28:30How did how does that functionally work?
- 28:32And then how do you talk to voters about that in a way that doesn't make it seem like you're
- 28:36trying to hide something?
- 28:38So there's a lot of elevating of of people who have done this well in this work.
- 28:42We do a lot of support groups amongst elected officials.
- 28:47And then sort of this underlying thing that we do is just kind of being a space for people in
- 28:56the middle.
- 28:57And people are like, oh, okay.
- 29:00Well, so this is just this is the moderates group.
- 29:03And I'm like, well, actually, yes and no.
- 29:08So we have figured out that there are sort of three groups of people who consider themselves
- 29:12to be in the middle, and we let people self select.
- 29:15You know?
- 29:15If they wanna come to the table, they are welcome.
- 29:19So there are some moderates, you you're either on the right or the left, but you think of
- 29:23yourself as towards the middle.
- 29:25So, you know, you're moderate, you say you're in the middle.
- 29:28There are also people, full disclosure like myself, who hold some policy positions that
- 29:34align with the right and some policy positions that align with the left.
- 29:38I used to say that I'm not on anybody's team because I don't really belong on either team.
- 29:44Now I say I'm on everybody's team because I can find things to do to agree with pretty much
- 29:49everybody.
- 29:50Also, can think find things to disagree with with pretty much everybody, but that's okay.
- 29:54So so that would put me in the middle.
- 29:58And then there are people, and this was the one that was most surprising to me.
- 30:03People who come to the table because they believe that even though they're super firmly
- 30:09in their positions and their values and all of those, That governing, not necessarily
- 30:18campaigning, but governing after you win is about the coming together and the collaboration
- 30:25and finding a way through these policy things.
- 30:29And that puts them in the middle, which that was the group that I was most surprised to have
- 30:34them sort of self self identify.
- 30:36But of all the groups that I think are gonna change the world, I think that one probably has
- 30:44has, the most potential.
- 30:47There there's so many things I wanna wanna tie from from that answer.
- 30:52That was a lot.
- 30:52No.
- 30:52No.
- 30:53No.
- 30:53No.
- 30:53No.
- 30:53That's perfectly fine.
- 30:54But the the thing about the the bipartisanship report, I mean, it is true a lot of times, you
- 30:59know, you know, back to that whole negativity sells kind of thing.
- 31:03Yeah.
- 31:03There are so many bills that really don't have a whole lot of dissension on it, or they might
- 31:09have, like, a little bit of nooks and crannies, but there's not that people need to hash out
- 31:13the details on, but they're not, oh, this is there's a left side of the argument.
- 31:17This is the right side of the argument.
- 31:19It's just they just don't get all the fanfare, and they're not usually, like, wides wide
- 31:25scoped bills.
- 31:26But I I I have to look into that some more.
- 31:31I have this webinar that I I do.
- 31:33It's about helping people get their client if they have clients that are interested in seeing
- 31:40Bill succeed or or to see them killed, like, lot of the different things to think about it
- 31:45in that regard so you can help out your clients.
- 31:47So it kind of made me think about that.
- 31:49I'll have to look into your bipartisanship report that'll help make that webinar robust.
- 31:55And then the thing about the the functional nonpartisanship, unfortunately, yeah, it's it's
- 32:03definitely true.
- 32:04Like in Nebraska, for example, the it's a unicameral in Senate, but and, yeah, they're
- 32:09nonpartisan, but are they really nonpartisan?
- 32:13And and you and you also unfortunately have some groups that are, you know, call themselves
- 32:17nonpartisan, like nonprofits, but a lot of times they do still pew towards the right or
- 32:23towards the left.
- 32:24So Yeah.
- 32:25Yeah.
- 32:25And it's a whole party ideal audiology difference, but, you know, you do see that
- 32:30becoming a little
- 32:31bit
- 32:31more aligned where you have to be a conservative if you're a republican, you have
- 32:36to be a liberal if you're a democrat.
- 32:38Yeah.
- 32:38But, you know, that's that's that's
- 32:40a whole to be that there were, you know, liberal republicans and conservative democrats,
- 32:45and, you know, everybody was able to find things that they agree on across party lines.
- 32:52As the permission that we have, as voters give for people to be sort of ideologically mixed
- 33:02and still get our vote?
- 33:04As that has shifted, I think that has shifted the positions of people.
- 33:09And then also the people who are willing to run for office right now.
- 33:12Like, you know, was an event here in Minnesota earlier this week and former governor Polenty
- 33:20was was on the the panel.
- 33:25He was talking about how he himself is probably not conservative enough to get through a
- 33:31primary.
- 33:31If he was to run for office in Minnesota, he's a Republican.
- 33:35If he was to run for the Republican endorsement in Minnesota, he's probably not conservative
- 33:41enough to get through right now.
- 33:44And this is the last statewide office that Republicans held, was when he was in the
- 33:51governor's office like twenty years ago.
- 33:54So it's interesting know, what you allow is what will continue, and what you, yeah, what
- 34:05you punish is like, that has an effect too.
- 34:10Yeah.
- 34:10You hear I mean, there's there's so many examples for both Democrats and Republicans
- 34:15that are like that in various states.
- 34:17My my state, Florida, once the poster child of being, you know, a purple state.
- 34:23Now not so purple anymore, but but yeah.
- 34:28Healthy competition's always good for politics.
- 34:31One party government doesn't help out anybody.
- 34:33I I don't have to take a side to say to say that.
- 34:36Right.
- 34:37That was actually something that we were talking about with our with our report and the
- 34:40analysis of, you know, how does it how does it differ when the power structure is that
- 34:45different?
- 34:46And what I kept reminding people was that the opposite of a Democrat trifecta is not a
- 34:52Republican trifecta.
- 34:54Like those two that's not the opposite.
- 34:56The opposite of any trifecta is actually what we've got going on in Minnesota right now,
- 35:01which is a tie.
- 35:02And it is like, you know, every citizen in Minnesota, state representative has exactly the
- 35:10same amount of influence as everybody else's representative.
- 35:15Like, that's a big deal.
- 35:17Like, talk about pure representative democracy is is everybody has sort of the same the same
- 35:24bite at the apple, and I I actually love that.
- 35:27Yeah.
- 35:28That that that's a good point.
- 35:29Right now, Minnesota is maybe the purplest of of states arguably.
- 35:34Yeah.
- 35:34But speaking of being, you know, very purple, you kinda you kinda touched on this already,
- 35:40but maybe flesh it out just a little bit more.
- 35:43So I'm thinking about when back when I was in grad school, how one of the many debates that
- 35:48we examined was whether there was a political middle in America, and if so, how large it is.
- 35:54Then also, are independents really independent, or do they just lean one way or the other?
- 35:58Then whole I mean, those are you know, there's there's too many things to cover in in in both
- 36:05those debates.
- 36:05But all that to say to set up this questions, I I wanna know what your take is.
- 36:11So what and and, again, you you kinda touched on it a little bit already, but what makes
- 36:15somebody part of this political middle of America?
- 36:18And I don't know if you can really do this, but what would if you can, what's a rough
- 36:23percentage or number of people that you think fit your description of a political middle in
- 36:28America?
- 36:29Yeah.
- 36:30Okay.
- 36:30I'm gonna screw this up because I can't find the exact thing.
- 36:34But oh, yes.
- 36:35I can.
- 36:39Nope.
- 36:39Nope.
- 36:40I can't.
- 36:40So anyways, well, this is gonna be a good opportunity for your listeners to do a deep
- 36:45dive into Gallup.
- 36:46So Gallup does their political ideology.
- 36:51Pew also has some really interesting political ideology, stats.
- 36:56But Gallup does their thing every year, and they measure the, the number of Americans who
- 37:02say they are members of Democratic party, Republican party, or they're independent.
- 37:07And I think it was twenty twenty or twenty twenty two was the first year I think it was
- 37:12'22.
- 37:13Was the first year that more people identified as independent than did with a member of one of
- 37:21those two major parties.
- 37:23Now, if you looked at those independents, most of them, you know, when they're asked further
- 37:27questions, they usually still lean one way or the other, but they classify themselves as
- 37:34independents.
- 37:37I classify myself as independent.
- 37:40Number one, I need to for my job, and it legitimately reflects my ideology closest.
- 37:52The But the way that people vote isn't necessarily always their their the way they're
- 38:02willing to label themselves.
- 38:03Hey.
- 38:03Sorry about that.
- 38:04My the recording on my decided to not play nicely, so we had to finagle with things a
- 38:11little bit here.
- 38:12But, Shannon, anyways, you were saying about Gallup and Q Research.
- 38:15Must be a a good place for a commercial break or something.
- 38:20Yes.
- 38:21Okay.
- 38:21Yeah.
- 38:21Right?
- 38:21So Gallup every year figures out they they do a survey of of how people identify themselves,
- 38:29Republicans, Democrats, something else, or independents.
- 38:32And I think it was 2022 where the first time was the the number of Americans identifying
- 38:38themselves as independent exceeded the number of people who said they were a Democrat or a
- 38:43Republican.
- 38:44And one of the things that this tells me is, number one, that there's a reason that people
- 38:50don't wanna be identified with one of the parties and whatever that is.
- 38:55It may be that they have started ticket splitting.
- 38:58It may be that they are unhappy with candidates.
- 39:00It may be that we've got a new generation coming on.
- 39:04And I will say like Gen Z, and I'm not Gen Z, I'm Gen X.
- 39:09But Gen Z is they're not a fan of labels, which is something I'm learning.
- 39:15And they're not, you know, labels in their relationships, labels in their workplaces,
- 39:21labels in all these things.
- 39:22They don't they don't seem to like labels.
- 39:25So so as they have become voting eligible and identifying with political party, a lot of them
- 39:32aren't doing that.
- 39:34And that being said, if you have somebody who is is generally voting with you generally
- 39:45voting And they still don't wanna be identified as a member of your party, to me is a brand
- 39:50prob like, that's a marketing issue for the two major parties for the two major parties.
- 39:58Yeah.
- 39:59And if you know, always hear one party conveniently talk about the branding issues of
- 40:04the other party, and then the other party completely ignores their branding issues and
- 40:08talks about the other party, which is obviously very unfortunate.
- 40:13But at the same time, also, I was thinking about when you were talking about how people
- 40:19vote with the the choices they have available, not necessarily liking them.
- 40:23It it makes me think about the old V.
- 40:27O.
- 40:27Key Jr.
- 40:28As a for those at home who don't know, he's very a famous political scientist, one of the,
- 40:33really, the earliest ones in terms of the modern, quote, unquote, study of political
- 40:38science.
- 40:38He lit he was his heyday was like the fifties, sixties, but his quote was might be slightly
- 40:44paraphrasing, but if people only have rascals to choose from, they're certain to pick a
- 40:48rascal.
- 40:49Now I'm not trying to not trying to say that they're all rascals here.
- 40:53I'm just saying the point is sometimes it is it can seem even if they lean one way or the
- 40:57other.
- 40:58Sometimes people say they're just Yeah.
- 41:00Really more hardcore Republican or Democrat than they want to admit, but sometimes it is
- 41:05just because of the choices that they get.
- 41:08So I mean
- 41:09As independents, if if they don't, engage in the political party apparatus of of, you know,
- 41:17getting, people on the ballot.
- 41:21So like in Minnesota, have endorsement, know, we have precinct conventions and all of that,
- 41:28but there's also a primary.
- 41:30And what I tell people, I have a hard time, like I cannot some of my work has to do with
- 41:38getting people who are sort of in the middle back engaged again, impartially to affect what
- 41:47candidates they see on their ballot, because so many people are like, I don't like either of
- 41:51these choices.
- 41:51They go to the ballot in November and they're like, I don't like these choices.
- 41:54Well, part of that is because you're not getting your voice heard and you're not getting
- 41:59engaged far enough upstream to get the kind of candidate that you want.
- 42:03So, if you have people like governor Polenty, who can't get through an endorsing convention
- 42:10because people are, you know, that's the smaller group of really hardcore, party people,
- 42:17then if you go to a primary, if the independents and the moderates don't vote in
- 42:23the primary, you're gonna have the same result.
- 42:25So, I can't necessarily in good conscience tell people who, you know, who have have sort of,
- 42:32you know, thrown up their hands and opted out of politics.
- 42:35I can't tell them to go to like a party convention, mainly because there are some you
- 42:44know, not all of them are bad, so there's a little bit of generalization going on here.
- 42:49But for me to tell somebody, hey, take your Tuesday in February, your evening, go sit in a
- 42:55high school gymnasium with all of your neighbors and argue about politics and have
- 42:59everything you dislike about politics delivered to your face for three hours on Tuesday
- 43:05evening.
- 43:06Like, they won't enjoy it.
- 43:08They won't go back.
- 43:09And also, they won't listen to me ever again because because, you know, this is exactly
- 43:14everything they hate that, you know, I've said, hey, you gotta go do this.
- 43:20Primary, voting on the other hand is you a ballot and silence, and you make your own
- 43:26choice.
- 43:27But, we we did a thing a couple years ago trying to get people to to vote in the
- 43:31primaries because literally more people go to the Minnesota State Fair than voted in the
- 43:36primary.
- 43:38Now granted, Minnesota's got a great state fair.
- 43:41But we need more primary voters.
- 43:43And and that's the thing.
- 43:44If you're if you're just showing up in November and saying, I don't like I don't like this,
- 43:50then maybe you need to get engaged a little earlier upstream.
- 43:56And I I live in a closed primary state too.
- 43:59Florida is.
- 44:00So but you you you touched on something that is a big thing that I'm trying to tackle as well.
- 44:09And I I my fiftieth episode of this podcast was about and it was just me that time, but I was
- 44:15talking about political apathy.
- 44:17And I used to be one of these people who sorry.
- 44:19For those of you who listen, if if you've heard me say this before, I'll I'm but just gonna say
- 44:24it again.
- 44:25But I used to be one of those people who when I was younger because I I voted the very first
- 44:31election I could vote in, which was back in 2012.
- 44:36And the I used to believe in this whole, if you don't vote, you don't get to complain.
- 44:43It was like, yo, if you can't do something as simple as vote, then why I don't wanna hear you
- 44:47cry and and moan about things.
- 44:49But, you know, getting older and realizing a lot of the reasons why people do it, it's like,
- 44:54okay.
- 44:55I gotta be a little bit more charitable.
- 44:58Now if you're if you are able to vote and you and you're just being lazy about it and you and
- 45:03you're you're complaining because you wanna hear yourself complain, then I don't wanna hear
- 45:08it.
- 45:08But there there are there are people who have very understandable reasons for being
- 45:13apathetic.
- 45:14Now it's if yes.
- 45:15It's not helping fix our political discourse, but you can't just blame them for it and say,
- 45:21well, you know, you're contributing to the problem.
- 45:24Yes.
- 45:24Them sitting out is a problem, but you can't just say it's their fault.
- 45:29There's there's reasonable reasons for them to, to be sitting out of elections.
- 45:37We just have to, a, we have to we have to show them how that is only going to make the
- 45:43situation worse, and b, actually work to make them Yeah.
- 45:48Feel heard in some way.
- 45:50And, obviously, that's a lot easier said than done, but it is part of that whole problem of
- 45:57fixing apathy, which is a just just let unfortunately, it lets polarization flourish.
- 46:02And, also, polarized voices want that at the same time.
- 46:07So speaking of polarization, a few weeks ago or so, I came across, and I actually asked a a
- 46:16previous guest of mine about this.
- 46:18I came across a post on LinkedIn and just the the short of it was that it lamented the use of
- 46:24the term moderate because it implied a lack of passion and inherently assumed someone's full
- 46:30ideological leanings.
- 46:32So what do you think of the term moderate?
- 46:35And is it a term that you'd use to describe yourself or majority in the middle?
- 46:40We try not to use it to describe majority in the middle mainly because and this comes from
- 46:46from people who who believe that moderate is a position.
- 46:51So like, you know, left is a position, right is position, moderate is a position.
- 46:56I don't necessarily always agree with that, but I'm very careful about how our organization is
- 47:05framed.
- 47:05And we are a five zero one(three) nonpartisan nonprofit.
- 47:08So I'm very careful about those things.
- 47:15In some of my positions, I consider myself to be a moderate.
- 47:20I have definitely become more moderate as I've gotten older.
- 47:27Mainly because I care very deeply about how people experience politics.
- 47:36I am not as much passionate about specific issues, mainly because like when I was growing
- 47:44up, not only just my parents, but I had really, really, really good friends in high school and,
- 47:51you know, we're gonna be friends till we're 90, but who is super, super conservative.
- 47:56And granted, I went to high school in the eighties and early nineties.
- 47:59I'm like, I'm doing the math on when you first voted.
- 48:02And I was like, yeah.
- 48:03I think you're born when I was
- 48:0732.
- 48:07I just turned 32 back in August.
- 48:09So yeah.
- 48:10That's about as long as I've been out of high school.
- 48:12But no.
- 48:14That's okay.
- 48:14He would during lunch, he would go, you know, some people sit in the cafeteria, some people
- 48:21sit on the grass outside, some people, you know, screw around or whatever.
- 48:25He would go and sit in his car in the parking lot and listen to Rush Limbaugh on the radio.
- 48:31And this is somebody who owns a lot of guns and is is very conservative.
- 48:41And I was I was definitely more liberal when I was in high school.
- 48:47But he and I would argue issues.
- 48:49And it was one of my very favorite things.
- 48:52And, you know, the the idea that, you know, iron sharpens iron.
- 48:56And so arguing your arguing about politics really helps both identify your own positions
- 49:06and strengthen your positions, because if you have to defend it, then you better have figured
- 49:11out how to talk about it.
- 49:15So even there got to be times, you know, later in life where he and I would be on the same
- 49:24side of an issue, I'd swap just for the fun of arguing about it.
- 49:29So through that experience, I have been able to I've been able to see unintended consequences
- 49:42and opposite sides and multiple sort of multiple perspectives on an issue in ways that
- 49:54I think was really, really helpful to me.
- 49:57But it also means I've become really pragmatic about public policy.
- 50:02And, like, well, what about this?
- 50:04And a lot less idealistic.
- 50:07So beyond just, you know, okay.
- 50:11We have really closely divided legislatures and congress, and so, you know, the ability to get
- 50:16something done that is, you know, very far right or very far left.
- 50:22You know, beyond that, just sort of being pragmatic.
- 50:25I've just I've just gotten to see sort of the different perspectives and and how I don't
- 50:34know.
- 50:35I don't know.
- 50:35Had probably as much about defeating these issues than enacting them and all the things
- 50:42you have to think about unintended consequences.
- 50:44And I I mean, you know, the creating public policy is 90% about figuring out the unintended
- 50:50consequences.
- 50:51Yeah.
- 50:53Yeah.
- 50:55Of course, some people don't yeah.
- 50:57They assume there's no unintended consequences because they think their policy is completely
- 51:01and totally objectively 100% right.
- 51:04But unforeseen consequences, and there's unintended consequences.
- 51:08Yeah.
- 51:10That too.
- 51:11Yeah.
- 51:11That that's just how how much well, and that So one of the things about being a policymaker,
- 51:21being an elected official, there's obviously been a lot of discussion about polarization and
- 51:27about partisan splits.
- 51:31And I live in Minneapolis.
- 51:33And Minneapolis is, in general, very blue city.
- 51:38Our city council has, again, technically nonpartisan, but not functionally.
- 51:46Is entirely democrats or democratic socialists.
- 51:50So, like, find the far left and then go further left, and that is basically the scale.
- 51:57But some of our local media used to talk about this partisan split between the moderate
- 52:03Democrats who are still actually pretty liberal and this group of Democratic socialists.
- 52:10And I don't necessarily see that so much as a partisan split.
- 52:14I see that as a difference between how people approach the job.
- 52:21Are you approaching it from an activist mindset where where you say, okay.
- 52:28Here's the problem.
- 52:29I have a solution.
- 52:30I'm running for office to enact that solution.
- 52:33I'm not really interested in examining the problem anymore.
- 52:37I'm not really interested in other sort of solutions or outcomes or whatever.
- 52:44And then there are the ones who I think more of as jurors or judges, where they get elected and
- 52:54then look at a problem and examine the evidence that's in front of them and then make the
- 52:58decision.
- 52:59So when you have sort of the activist mindset, you already know, and you you want to enact
- 53:05your solution.
- 53:07And people who come into office in that way, they generally see the the juror, you know,
- 53:15their counterparts that are more like jurors or judges as as being, you know, slow or stuck in
- 53:21the mud or or just not as passionate.
- 53:25And that's okay.
- 53:26It's just a different way that you that you approach the job.
- 53:29I definitely look at myself more as like a juror or a judge than an activist.
- 53:38And in case anybody's wondering that that very low rumbling noise, I believe that Shannon
- 53:43Stahl snoring something.
- 53:46No.
- 53:47No.
- 53:47No.
- 53:47It is it is it is okay.
- 53:49Just in case people are like, what does that sound?
- 53:51Now but Yes.
- 53:52That's that's that's okay.
- 53:54I I had a guest one time who, her cat
- 53:57Oh, nice.
- 53:58Went across the screen, and I I I didn't even realize until it happened, like, a second time.
- 54:02I was like, oh, that's that's the cat.
- 54:05But but, to to the point about the not being as enthusiastic for lack of a better term.
- 54:15We do need some people that are like that.
- 54:18Yeah, we need more people to be less apathetic, but they don't need to be doing phone banking
- 54:23and knocking door to door and doing all this stuff, but we do at least need them to be
- 54:28paying more attention and knowing what's going on.
- 54:30So definitely can understand that.
- 54:34And going back to the point about the labels about the I'm a millennial, but the the labels
- 54:46about yeah.
- 54:47But, you know, talking about how they're really not about labels, and I that's something I talk
- 54:52about too is a lot of times these the whole thing about labels is there's just too much.
- 54:57We give them too much power, these these these labels, and it gets to a point where but it
- 55:04also it's not just that they have too much power, but also people have they all have their
- 55:13own definitions of what these things are too.
- 55:15So if I like I just asked you if you would consider yourself moderate, I could ask five
- 55:20other people what being a moderate is, and I could get five different answers.
- 55:24And that's that's partly why I don't I mean, besides just this work that I try to be as
- 55:28impartial as possible, and I want people to feel like anybody can come to anything I'm
- 55:33doing and not feel like they're having any slant because I'm not I'm not about pandering
- 55:38to anybody.
- 55:40But I just I don't personally have any use for a label either.
- 55:44So I I don't I I sometimes have people and people who obviously, people who know me, they
- 55:50they have some idea of what my politics are.
- 55:52But even then, I wouldn't tell them I'm conservative, liberal, moderate.
- 55:56It's it just it's not something that's important to me.
- 56:01I'd rather just try to be as pragmatic as possible.
- 56:06I don't wanna say I'm a pragmatist because I feel like that's kind of obnoxious.
- 56:09Some people say that they're a pragmatist, and they're really not.
- 56:12So I don't I don't wanna say that, but I try to be as pragmatic as possible.
- 56:18And but, I mean, I then again, I have my own I have my own things that I care deeply about
- 56:25too, and I have to acknowledge that I'm not necessarily pragmatic about those things too.
- 56:30But all that to say, though, I I I I get the the idea about, you know, well, of course, not
- 56:38calling majority of the middle moderate because you're a five zero one c three.
- 56:40But for you personally, there are those different considerations for you.
- 56:46So now we go back to the overall problem of political division, which obviously majority of
- 56:54the middle is trying to tackle.
- 56:57But but what do you think are two or three of the biggest obstacles that are facing these
- 57:02efforts to overcome political divisions from what you see?
- 57:05Let's see.
- 57:06Two or three.
- 57:07I will narrow it down.
- 57:08The first one is, right, there's so many.
- 57:11I know there's so many that you can
- 57:13point out.
- 57:14That there is no one silver bullet for this kind of situation.
- 57:18There's about 14 things that need to be done simultaneously.
- 57:22The first one is the division is enormously well funded in this country, and speaking as
- 57:27somebody who runs a nonprofit organization that's working against the polarization, and I
- 57:34don't even use the word unity, because that's not sort of what we're going for either.
- 57:40But for lack of a better term, you know, people who are working on Unity, or bridging, or all
- 57:46these things, not nearly as well funded.
- 57:50So that's part of the challenge.
- 57:53The second thing, and this sort of goes about what we were just talking about with the
- 57:56labels, is it may also be, and I hadn't thought about this until you started talking, it may be
- 58:04that one of the reasons that people don't want to label themselves as a member of whatever
- 58:08party or as moderate or whatever, is because that is no longer, like, just one of the things
- 58:15about us.
- 58:16That is kind of the primary thing that people are using to identify us and put us in a group.
- 58:22Yeah.
- 58:22It's like I mean, I don't know if you've seen it, like, on dating apps, which, you know, for
- 58:27my partner, I haven't been on one for years and years, but other people tell me, that, you
- 58:32know, generally, like, one of the first things that people wanna know is is who did you vote
- 58:37for in the last presidential election?
- 58:39Like, when did we start having this as our primary identification of who we are is who we
- 58:46voted for?
- 58:46Every four years.
- 58:48Not who'd you vote for
- 58:49for governor, who'd you vote for for city council, but who'd you vote for for president,
- 58:53being this thing.
- 58:54And so, like, one of the things that we encourage people to do is to, get to know
- 59:02people in in ways that have nothing to do with politics.
- 59:06You know, how can you find common ground with the guy at work who you're always you know,
- 59:11you're you're on opposite sides of politics is don't don't focus on the politics.
- 59:16Focus on you both have kids that play soccer or you both like to fish or you both collect comic
- 59:25books or, you know, whatever it is that make us who we are as human beings that doesn't sort of
- 59:35default to the political label.
- 59:38So I think backing off of some of that as to how we classify each other is another thing.
- 59:43And then the third thing, this is really nerdy, is something that we've been working on that we
- 59:49don't really talk about a lot, which is what we call structural partisanship.
- 59:54And so this has to do with the ways people are divided up and kept divided.
- 1:00:01And then the easiest way to to think about it is in, like, a legislative body.
- 1:00:06So all the Democrats sit on one side of the room and all the Republicans sit on the other
- 1:00:11side of the room.
- 1:00:12Or here in our House of Representatives, generally, the Republicans all sit on one side
- 1:00:18of this, like, u shaped committee table, and the Democrats sit on the other side.
- 1:00:22There was one co chair this year because, again, they're tied, so they had to to co all
- 1:00:29the chairs.
- 1:00:31When he was in charge of the committee hearings, he mixed up the seating and had
- 1:00:35everybody set every other, which I thought was awesome because that's that's primarily the way
- 1:00:40our senate does it.
- 1:00:41And I have watched people who have different parties, of different ideologies.
- 1:00:49I've watched them in committee, like talking about something behind their hands or giggling
- 1:00:56about something or whatever.
- 1:00:57Like, you know, legislative bodies need more giggling, I think.
- 1:01:01Because well, it's a it's a really human thing, and that's how we make a connection is that we
- 1:01:04laugh with each other and then, you know, the the chemicals in our brain start going off, and
- 1:01:08then we look at this person as somebody that we like.
- 1:01:11So so he switched up the seating.
- 1:01:15So we switched up the he told me afterwards, he's like, I was shocked by how much better the
- 1:01:23quality of the conversation was.
- 1:01:25Not only just the opportunity to say hello to somebody you're sitting next to, who you would
- 1:01:29not have acknowledged when they were sitting on the other side of the table, but also just how
- 1:01:34much better it was, because most of the times in committee, the legislators will have their
- 1:01:39phones out, they'll have their laptop screens open, they will be doing other multitasking
- 1:01:44because nobody has enough time.
- 1:01:47He said, when I put, you know, people of the opposite party on every other one, People
- 1:01:52didn't wanna have their laptops or their phones open.
- 1:01:55So they closed the covers and they put the phone down.
- 1:01:59And he said the quality of the conversation was so much better.
- 1:02:03The engagement level of people in the They were actually present in committee.
- 1:02:08And he said that was not something I'd anticipated, and that was something I didn't
- 1:02:11anticipate either.
- 1:02:12But that's the thing.
- 1:02:13Like, how do we how do we encourage people to get to know each other on a human level?
- 1:02:20You know, the other example I use, like, all the legislators, they have their their offices
- 1:02:25on different floors and in different wings based on what party they are are affiliated
- 1:02:31with.
- 1:02:32So so you don't get to see what somebody at the opposite party has on their desk.
- 1:02:38You don't get to see the, you know, the drawing that their grandkid made.
- 1:02:44You know, if somebody gets a flower delivery.
- 1:02:46I mean, you you know, it's like at at at at work, if somebody gets a flower delivery,
- 1:02:51something really good or really bad has happened.
- 1:02:54Something really good or really bad.
- 1:02:55And if you're never around peep if you're only in the performative spaces, you know, where
- 1:03:01there's a camera on you and you're, you know, doing your talking points and all those things.
- 1:03:07Like, you do not get the opportunity to just be a human being.
- 1:03:11And those relationships are really what get people over the hump of collaborating on on
- 1:03:19legislation and going after the tough problems.
- 1:03:23And so like, what are those systemic partisanship things that we can break down and
- 1:03:29encourage that relationship building and not people keep people divided all the time.
- 1:03:35Yeah.
- 1:03:38The the part about the I do like the Yeah.
- 1:03:41Space and amount so that they're they're they're the parties are dotted around.
- 1:03:47The a that I worked worked on a while ago back when I was can't remember if it when I was just
- 1:03:54volunteering for it and then when I actually worked on the campaign.
- 1:03:56And no, I'm not gonna say what the campaign is because I don't want anybody assuming my
- 1:04:00politics from it.
- 1:04:01This was a long time ago and I still really like the idea that the candidate I worked for
- 1:04:05was like, Hey, go ahead and sit in between the people who are not not on who are not
- 1:04:12supporting my candidacy.
- 1:04:13They have other on the other campaigns paraphernalia.
- 1:04:17And and even then, I mean I mean, I was starting to get increasingly disenchanted with
- 1:04:23with the polarization anyways.
- 1:04:25But even then, I was just like, yeah.
- 1:04:27Sure.
- 1:04:27Whatever.
- 1:04:28I'll do that.
- 1:04:28When I was younger, I definitely was a lot more opinionated and obnoxious about it about
- 1:04:34things.
- 1:04:34But even then, I I still had a lot of friends of varying political stripes.
- 1:04:41And, unfortunately, of course, like we've mentioned multiple times as being lost.
- 1:04:46Now I I I know we're running a little low on time part mostly because of the those technical
- 1:04:51issues we had.
- 1:04:52So we'll try to get through these questions.
- 1:04:55Yeah.
- 1:04:56And and then it's a fun conversation.
- 1:04:57We're going back and forth, and and that's what makes makes good podcast episodes.
- 1:05:02But we'll try to get through so I don't hold you up too much longer.
- 1:05:06You try to get through the rest of the questions I wanted to get through.
- 1:05:09So let's be more positive again.
- 1:05:11What are some of the encouraging signs you've seen lately in attempts to overcome I
- 1:05:15think there's a lot of people who are, really interested in, like and and maybe it's because
- 1:05:22we've hit rock bottom.
- 1:05:23I mean, the the political violence that has happened this summer, both here in my own state
- 1:05:29and, like with Charlie Kirk.
- 1:05:34That has that has sort of opened some people's eyes and said, okay, we yeah, we've got a
- 1:05:39problem.
- 1:05:40We gotta fix it.
- 1:05:40I don't necessarily know how we're gonna do that, but I wanna help.
- 1:05:45And so that has been helpful.
- 1:05:50You can't solve a problem until you know that there is one.
- 1:05:53So that's one thing.
- 1:05:57And so part of the rollout of the state of bipartisanship report, we did a whole bunch of
- 1:06:08press conferences around the state.
- 1:06:10We did five press conferences, which I will tell you, from an organizational perspective,
- 1:06:15that's a lot of press conferences.
- 1:06:17And we invited a lot of legislators to be part of these for the first time this year.
- 1:06:21And because one of the things that I understand is that elected officials, they have to live in
- 1:06:26this attention economy that we're in.
- 1:06:27And I want them to get credit for the things that I think are good and that's working
- 1:06:35together.
- 1:06:36And I mean, I don't know if this is a good thing, but I spin it as a good thing.
- 1:06:41The working together piece is still so sort of unusual in politics, it's newsy.
- 1:06:49And so journalists journalists, reporters will show up for that conversation and look at this
- 1:06:57weird thing of these two legislators of different parties standing next to each other
- 1:07:01and and figuring stuff out.
- 1:07:03So I see that as as being very helpful in letting the public know that, you know, not all
- 1:07:12politics is divisive and not every every legislator sees enemies on the other side of
- 1:07:17the aisle, that there is good work being done.
- 1:07:21You just have to you just have to lift it up sometimes.
- 1:07:27Yeah.
- 1:07:27And that's the obviously, we have to talk about the issues that we're having and and the
- 1:07:32dissension we're having.
- 1:07:32I mean, it's everywhere.
- 1:07:33You can't ignore it.
- 1:07:34But sometimes we don't do as well as we can to really highlight, hey, these are the great
- 1:07:41things that are happening and we can get through this.
- 1:07:44It be easy to forget that.
- 1:07:46I forget that sometimes
- 1:07:47Well, again, like we focus on the things negative and that's what motivates us.
- 1:07:54You know, in the absence, I actually have no doubt in the absence of some of this political
- 1:08:00violence, there wouldn't be nearly as many people paying attention to the work that I'm
- 1:08:04doing.
- 1:08:04I know because I did it for a few years before that, and, you know, yeah.
- 1:08:12Yeah.
- 1:08:13And I I'm not I'm naturally an anxious person anyways, and I would definitely not call myself
- 1:08:18an optimist in in a lot of ways.
- 1:08:20So it's it it it can, you know Yeah.
- 1:08:23Great on me too, but I, you know, try to think about those things that you just highlighted
- 1:08:29and all these other positive develops Yeah.
- 1:08:32Developments that we have going on.
- 1:08:34So one more question before the random fun question of the day.
- 1:08:39So on this show, we always like to and the stuff I do in general, really like to emphasize
- 1:08:45practical ways that people can employ the info that they learn on these episodes.
- 1:08:49So what are two or three actionable steps that listeners can use to overcome political
- 1:08:55division
- 1:08:55in the areas?
- 1:08:56Talked about one, which is not using people's party label to think of them.
- 1:09:04The other piece of that to remember is that being kind to a coworker who believes different
- 1:09:14things or even like is into conspiracy theories and amplifying a lot of stuff on social media.
- 1:09:22Being kind to a coworker or another parent at the soccer soccer club or or, you know,
- 1:09:30whatever.
- 1:09:31That doesn't mean you're endorsing their ideas.
- 1:09:33And so I believe it is relationships that are gonna get us out of this.
- 1:09:40And so cultivating as many relationships as we can, particularly with people who might be a
- 1:09:47180 degree difference with us or maybe 45 degree difference from us, you know?
- 1:09:52So so being open to those those kind of relationships and sort of seeking them out,
- 1:09:59that doesn't mean you have to see everybody, you know, once a week and go out to dinner all
- 1:10:02the time, whatever.
- 1:10:03It's just about being in sort of positive relationships with people.
- 1:10:08I was talking to somebody the other day.
- 1:10:10I was talking to somebody the other day.
- 1:10:11Since this this is so random.
- 1:10:14Since, like, Me Too and a lot of the a lot of the that that drama, which feels like a hundred
- 1:10:21years ago, I I I was talking to a guy who he was like, it's it's gonna be imposs like, this
- 1:10:33is going to be impossible to date because I I can't even tell a woman I like her shoes
- 1:10:39without it being, you know, potentially like, oh, no.
- 1:10:42She's gonna she's gonna be to me.
- 1:10:45And granted, that's an oversimplification.
- 1:10:47But at the same time, was a little bit of transition there.
- 1:10:51And, you know, how are we looking at people?
- 1:10:57How are we talking to people?
- 1:10:59Whatever.
- 1:10:59And so anyways, like sort of in support of that and in reflection on that, I had stopped
- 1:11:05commenting on what other people were wearing.
- 1:11:08You know, cute shoes or I like your dress or, you know, that shirt looks nice or whatever.
- 1:11:14I think we have gone too far in that direction because if you have somebody either that you
- 1:11:22know who compliments your shirt or somebody even more that you don't know, like if you see
- 1:11:28in the grocery store and somebody says, hey, that's a great shirt.
- 1:11:31That makes you feel really good.
- 1:11:33And we have subtracted out the feeling of good that somebody has noticed our shoes or our
- 1:11:39shirt or, you know, your hair looks great or whatever.
- 1:11:42And so I think I'm gonna start doing that again.
- 1:11:45So I think I'm It's just trying to bring little bits of positivity to people's day that it has
- 1:11:52nothing to do with politics.
- 1:11:54I just I feel like, you know, there's there's so much negativity in the world.
- 1:11:57We need a little more we need a little more positive.
- 1:12:01And then the third thing that I would suggest, and my friends who are still working on
- 1:12:06political campaigns hate it every time I say this, but outside of actual election season,
- 1:12:13take your yard sign down.
- 1:12:15If you have a yard sign or something else with the candidate's name on it or whatever, take it
- 1:12:20down.
- 1:12:21Because, you know, most places have a certain amount of time that legally the campaign signs
- 1:12:27can be up.
- 1:12:28And there's, again, there's this, you know, well, it's my free speech of having this in my
- 1:12:33yard.
- 1:12:33Yes.
- 1:12:35And campaign signs beyond campaign season.
- 1:12:41All they do is they visually show our differences with our neighbors, and they
- 1:12:52highlight those differences.
- 1:12:54And so, like, for the six weeks that campaign signs should be up, let's have them up, and
- 1:13:00then let's take them down and put them away and wait for the next six weeks before the election
- 1:13:06and and make our make our spaces a little less political all the time.
- 1:13:11Yeah.
- 1:13:15Definitely agree with that.
- 1:13:16I, yeah, I find it very obnoxious when people have, like, house is like Yeah.
- 1:13:22Has several things that are draped in paraphernalia.
- 1:13:25It's just like, okay.
- 1:13:26Congratulations.
- 1:13:27Let's just I just find it very obnoxious.
- 1:13:30I'll I mean, yes.
- 1:13:31I wanna try to be a little bit more understanding, but it is just very like, what
- 1:13:35are you trying to prove here?
- 1:13:37Is is is this really about, you know, supporting your candidate or is this about you
- 1:13:42just grandstanding on what your beliefs are
- 1:13:45right now?
- 1:13:46Feel it's a I like the word grandstanding, and a little about Yeah.
- 1:13:53Making your yard about politics in a way that it doesn't need to.
- 1:14:00Yeah.
- 1:14:01And I also it just reminded me of for the twenty twelve election, like, two years after
- 1:14:08it was done.
- 1:14:10And I'm not commenting positively or negatively on him, just the fact that this his campaign
- 1:14:15sign was out.
- 1:14:16It wasn't out of house.
- 1:14:17It was, like, along the street is Ron Paul.
- 1:14:18I was just like, guys, the election the election's been over for a couple years now.
- 1:14:23Again, not not saying one way or another about Ron Paul.
- 1:14:26I would've said about any other candidate that was on that side.
- 1:14:29It's just like Yeah.
- 1:14:31I don't know.
- 1:14:32It's yeah.
- 1:14:33No.
- 1:14:33I I definitely agree with that point.
- 1:14:37And, I mean, there's I mean, I know we can go on and on about this conversation, but I know
- 1:14:42we gotta get we're we're wrapping up.
- 1:14:43But first, as I always like to end guest episodes with this.
- 1:14:46If you're new to the show, I always like to end guest episodes with fun, random, nonpolitical
- 1:14:51questions just to spice things up a bit and give a different look at the what the guests
- 1:14:57are about.
- 1:14:58Just a little bit some something different.
- 1:15:00So, Shannon, for you, today's random question of the day is, what's something about your
- 1:15:06state that you wish more people knew, especially from outside
- 1:15:10of Yeah.
- 1:15:13So I I've lived in Minnesota for about fifteen years.
- 1:15:18Well, I've lived here for fifteen years, and then I had another couple of years that I lived
- 1:15:22here for a while, and then I left and I came back.
- 1:15:24Anyways, long story.
- 1:15:26What is something that people I would like people to know about Minnesota?
- 1:15:30Alright.
- 1:15:30Well, it is very cold sometimes, and that's what most people know.
- 1:15:38I also am leaning into the patron saint of Minnesota, Prince, who who who always said, you
- 1:15:48know, the the cold people the cold keeps the bad people out.
- 1:15:52So in some ways, like, I do want to cheer on Minnesota because it has everything.
- 1:15:58I'm very much a Minnesotan by choice.
- 1:16:01Really high rates of volunteerism and civic engagement and voting and four beautiful
- 1:16:09seasons.
- 1:16:10You know, the winter lasts a little longer, but but you just you learn to dress differently.
- 1:16:16And we have these things called skyways, which connect all the buildings in the downtowns.
- 1:16:21And so, like, on the Second Floor, I mean, it's it's kinda like being a gerbil.
- 1:16:24You know, the gerbil thing, you know, where they run through the tunnels?
- 1:16:27It's kinda like that.
- 1:16:29Yeah.
- 1:16:30It it's awesome.
- 1:16:31Pretty neat.
- 1:16:32I love it.
- 1:16:33There are some people who are sort of anti Skyway here.
- 1:16:36I am not one of those people.
- 1:16:37I love it.
- 1:16:39So I get okay.
- 1:16:41Maybe it's that.
- 1:16:42Maybe it's that.
- 1:16:43That sometimes Minnesota is like living in a giant gerbil cage, but but it's great because
- 1:16:48then you get the sunshine, and you don't have to go out in the air that hurts your face.
- 1:16:54Yeah.
- 1:16:56That's that's also true too.
- 1:16:57I I I mean, I don't know if you're a sports person, but are you Vikings, twins,
- 1:17:01Timberwolves, wild fan?
- 1:17:02I'm not.
- 1:17:03I I love to go I, like, I I can walk to the twins from my apartment, and I very much enjoy
- 1:17:08actually, I can walk to the Vikings in my apartment too.
- 1:17:12I I've never been to a wolves game.
- 1:17:16I you know, I like I like going to baseball for the hot dog and the being outside and and
- 1:17:22watching the game.
- 1:17:23But I no.
- 1:17:24I'm not really a I'm not really a hardcore sports fan.
- 1:17:27I I went to Kansas State Yeah.
- 1:17:30As part of my undergrad, and I was in the marching band.
- 1:17:32Oh,
- 1:17:32okay.
- 1:17:33So there for a while, I was just following the NFL teams that had Kansas State players who I
- 1:17:38knew that those like Jordy Nelson.
- 1:17:40Okay.
- 1:17:41And, yeah.
- 1:17:44I didn't know that. Was
- 1:17:44Was a walk on at Kansas State.
- 1:17:47Yeah.
- 1:17:48Yes.
- 1:17:48I do remember hearing that, but I didn't realize it was Kansas State.
- 1:17:51And then so not no hot hockey then, I guess, is out of the question.
- 1:17:54He just showed wild.
- 1:17:55Yeah.
- 1:17:55I'd I hockey is hard for me to watch.
- 1:17:58Like, it just like, it's it's like, it happens so fast, and you're like, what is going on?
- 1:18:03I feel like a dog with a squirrel.
- 1:18:06So yes.
- 1:18:07Yeah.
- 1:18:07If if you if you go to an actual hockey game, that is one of the best sporting events to go
- 1:18:13to.
- 1:18:13I mean, I've been I've been several times.
- 1:18:15I'm Yeah.
- 1:18:16Let's say I've been to the twins.
- 1:18:18I've to the Vikings.
- 1:18:19I've been to the wild.
- 1:18:21I have not been to wolves or lynx.
- 1:18:23I've been to a soccer game here.
- 1:18:25Okay.
- 1:18:26We do have all the sports.
- 1:18:28We do have all the sports.
- 1:18:29We had, we had lacrosse for a little bit, but I don't know what happened to that.
- 1:18:33I think COVID may have eaten our lacrosse league.
- 1:18:36Yeah.
- 1:18:36Yeah.
- 1:18:37Maybe.
- 1:18:39Well, that that's that's cool, though.
- 1:18:40Probably is a lot more in Minnesota than maybe a lot of people would would would think.
- 1:18:45So for for my state, Florida, I love my state for both because of and in spite of its flaws.
- 1:18:56Well, some of it or some of the flaws, but I I I I I do think I I'm I'm perfectly fine with
- 1:19:06people making fun of Florida.
- 1:19:07I I I will do it too.
- 1:19:10I, you know, we we get it.
- 1:19:12We make fun of it all the time too.
- 1:19:13We have now we have the Florida man games going on in in in Florida that just makes fun of all
- 1:19:18the the Florida man headlines.
- 1:19:20But it does bother me when people act like they know what Florida's about when they have never
- 1:19:26been to the state, including people who have lived in Florida.
- 1:19:29That's what drives me nuts.
- 1:19:31And, also, I'm gonna cheat a little bit and give a second thing, is Florida is a lot more
- 1:19:35varied
- 1:19:36Oh, yeah.
- 1:19:37Geographically and and culturally than a lot of people realize.
- 1:19:39You go to Saint Augustine, that's different than going to Tampa.
- 1:19:42It's going different different than Miami, than Pensacola, than Tallahassee, than Gainesville,
- 1:19:46than Fort Myers.
- 1:19:47It's a very eclectic state, much more than people realize.
- 1:19:50And I wish people did realize that and just how fascinating a lot of the history is here too.
- 1:19:57But I know I know it's it's got a very meme status in in in society, but, yeah, that that
- 1:20:05those are the things those are a couple of the things I wish more people knew about my state.
- 1:20:10And I also wish that we could keep this going on, but unfortunately, we must wrap wrap this
- 1:20:15episode up.
- 1:20:16So for all of you listening at home, thank you for listening and tuning in, and thank you for
- 1:20:21bearing with us.
- 1:20:22And oh, any other links
- 1:20:25that you wanna share?
- 1:20:26Say if you're if you're interested in checking out our state of bipartisanship report, if
- 1:20:29you're really interested in Minnesota politics, it is majoritymiddle.org, and then just click
- 1:20:36on the state of bipartisanship button, and you can look at all 304 glorious pages of it.
- 1:20:42It's a lot.
- 1:20:44There you go.
- 1:20:45I was gonna put the website anyways, but I I didn't realize the the report was on there as
- 1:20:50well.
- 1:20:50So but, yeah, I will have those links up.
- 1:20:53So my links, my Facebook, my LinkedIn, my medium.com profile right on from time to time,
- 1:20:58my website, paulrader.org, my five day educational email course about how we can
- 1:21:03better mitigate polarization, my book on Amazon,
- 1:21:10your podcast.
- 1:21:11Might have missed something, but well, yes.
- 1:21:14Yes.
- 1:21:14My podcast, of course, as well on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Podcasts.
- 1:21:19Please like, comment, and subscribe.
- 1:21:20But we're gonna wrap things up here.
- 1:21:22So until next time, take care.