Latest / Pensions Perspectives / The future of pension trusteeship: In good hands?
Transcript
- 0:00[MUSIC PLAYING]
- 0:06Perspectives Podcast.
- 0:08I'm your host, Luna Fadayel, a scheme actuary
- 0:11and relationship manager.
- 0:13Now, today we're discussing something
- 0:14that's at the very heart of the pensions industry,
- 0:17are pension schemes really in good hands?
- 0:20And I ask that question because trusteeship
- 0:22is evolving very quickly.
- 0:25Our In Good Hands survey, published earlier this year,
- 0:28found that about half of UK DB pension schemes
- 0:31have at least one professional trustee on the board.
- 0:35It also found that corporate sole trustee appointments
- 0:38continue to grow, and also that expectations on trustees,
- 0:42whether professional or lay, are arguably the highest that they
- 0:46have ever been.
- 0:48Is all this change translating into better governance, better
- 0:52decision-making, and, more fundamentally, better outcomes
- 0:56for members?
- 0:57To help explore that, I'm joined by three guests today
- 1:01who see trusteeship from different angles.
- 1:03Sir David Walmsley, who is the director of trusteeship,
- 1:07administration, and DB regulation
- 1:09at The Pensions Regulator, Jenny Gibbons,
- 1:12who's head of pensions governance consulting at WTW,
- 1:16and Hazel Kendrick, who is WTW head of strategic relationships
- 1:20and co-author of our In Good Hands survey.
- 1:23Welcome to all three of you.
- 1:24It's lovely to have you in the studio today.
- 1:27HAZEL KENDRICK: It's great to be here.
- 1:28LUNA FADAYEL: Now, before we get into the discussion itself,
- 1:31I'd love to start with a little bit of a scene setter.
- 1:34So for listeners who may not know
- 1:35you, what's the part of trusteeship
- 1:38that you spend most of your time thinking about?
- 1:41David.
- 1:42DAVID WALMSLEY: It's a good question.
- 1:44I mean, trusteeship is everything at the moment,
- 1:47but there's a huge focus on it from the regulator,
- 1:49from DWP with the consultation, which should be coming out soon.
- 1:53And part of my role, I guess, is thinking
- 1:57about the trustee of tomorrow.
- 2:00What is required for better outcomes?
- 2:03Part of my role is also pension reform.
- 2:05So I'm looking at CDC, super funds, surplus return,
- 2:10amongst other things.
- 2:11I'm constantly looking at tomorrow's risks.
- 2:16And the trustees today focusing on making sure
- 2:20that they're ready for tomorrow's risks
- 2:22and have the skills and the knowledge to tackle them.
- 2:25LUNA FADAYEL: OK, Jenny.
- 2:28JENNY GIBBONS: So I spend a good portion of my time thinking
- 2:31about the aspects of trusteeship that
- 2:35aren't written down on pieces of paper
- 2:37by way of policies and processes.
- 2:39So it's the softer dynamics in terms
- 2:43of how a trustee chair sets the tone, how
- 2:47we make sure that all the voices are heard in a trustee meeting,
- 2:51how we go through the decision-making process
- 2:53in a sufficiently thoughtful and diligent way.
- 2:56So it's those non-written down aspects of trusteeship
- 2:59that I spend a lot of time thinking about.
- 3:01LUNA FADAYEL: And Hazel.
- 3:03HAZEL KENDRICK: I'm very fortunate having
- 3:04worked in the industry for over 30 years.
- 3:07I've worked with countless trustee boards,
- 3:09and I get to speak to hundreds of professional trustees
- 3:12every year.
- 3:14And I think about the role of the professional trustee
- 3:17every single day.
- 3:19And I'm a real advocate for a professional trustee
- 3:22appointment, because with a professional trustee,
- 3:24you get the scale, you get the experience,
- 3:29and you also get expertise.
- 3:31And in my opinion, the best professional trustees
- 3:35are excellent networkers, extremely well connected
- 3:38with our industry.
- 3:40And I like to think about the friendships
- 3:42we've all got in the industry and how
- 3:45we help each other to make sure we deliver better outcomes.
- 3:48And I love when I see a really effective professional trustee
- 3:51who is working that influence, and bringing
- 3:56in expertise at the right time for the right reason.
- 4:00LUNA FADAYEL: And that's quite interesting.
- 4:02So the three bits that you touched on actually
- 4:05will help form this conversation.
- 4:07So let's dive into those areas a little bit more.
- 4:11So starting first with one of the biggest
- 4:14changes that we've seen over the last decade, even the last five
- 4:18years.
- 4:19And that's professional trustees have
- 4:22moved from being relatively unusual appointments to becoming
- 4:25a mainstream part of the pensions landscape.
- 4:29But has the growth of professional trustees
- 4:31been the cause of better governance, or simply
- 4:34the consequence of increasing complexity?
- 4:38[INDISTINCT]
- 4:46done a huge amount to uplift standards of governance,
- 4:50because if we wind back a few years,
- 4:54I feel like without that industry experience,
- 4:59there was a huge amount of reliance on advisors.
- 5:02And fortunately, advisors are very high quality
- 5:04in our industry.
- 5:05But just by having that professionalisation of trustees,
- 5:08you've got several voices who are
- 5:11able to interact at the level of nuance and high complexity
- 5:16and sensitivity.
- 5:17So I think from that point of view,
- 5:19there has been a real uplifting in standards of governance.
- 5:22HAZEL KENDRICK: Yeah, I agree, because when I look
- 5:24at the professional trustee firms,
- 5:27I'm hearing on a regular basis that as the appointed trustee
- 5:33have a problem that's emerged at a board meeting
- 5:35or for the strategy, and I'm not 100% clear or I don't feel like
- 5:39I have the most expert experience in that area
- 5:43because it's such a huge, broad role now we all know,
- 5:45I love seeing that bench strength,
- 5:48which in the organisations where they've got very established
- 5:51strong communication networks, again,
- 5:53these connections and friendships,
- 5:54it's who else that I'm working alongside inside my organisation
- 5:59has experience, and that really helps drive, I think,
- 6:03strong expertise and I hope drives better member outcomes.
- 6:08DAVID WALMSLEY: And I guess for me, just looking back
- 6:11over the last five years, the industry has
- 6:14got much more complex.
- 6:16There's a lot more to think about.
- 6:18And the professional trustees have
- 6:20brought an awful lot of experience and knowledge
- 6:23to this.
- 6:24You re a really good point about the challenge in the advisors.
- 6:27I think the pensions industry was led by a lot of advisors.
- 6:31Advisors made decisions, and that really
- 6:33must go back to the trustee.
- 6:34The trustee is the accountable person
- 6:37and must make all the decisions for that scheme
- 6:39in members interest.
- 6:41And whilst we're talking about professional trustees,
- 6:43we really must remember the member-nominated trustees
- 6:47who bring an awful lot to the governance structure.
- 6:51They have that corporate memory and some of the best
- 6:55interactions I've had.
- 6:57Even in my past role as a covenant advisor
- 6:59was with the member-nominated trustees who really understood
- 7:03the business and the covenant.
- 7:06So I think there's an awful lot they bring to the table.
- 7:09LUNA FADAYEL: I think that's right.
- 7:11I think it's all about having almost a diversity of people
- 7:15on the board who can bring those different lived
- 7:17experiences to the scheme and which
- 7:21will effectively lead to those better member outcomes.
- 7:24HAZEL KENDRICK: I would add to that just the appointment
- 7:27of a professional trustee.
- 7:28It shouldn't be at the expense of that diversity in my opinion.
- 7:32It's really important that boards keep that under watch
- 7:34and look and see, have we got the right diversity?
- 7:37Do we have the right structures to hear, challenge, and work
- 7:41with that challenge in a constructive way?
- 7:44LUNA FADAYEL: Yeah, and I think that's what I'm hearing.
- 7:46I'm hearing that greater professionalisation can bring
- 7:49benefits, but only if it's balanced with independence,
- 7:52challenge, and accountability at the centre of that
- 7:56decision-making process.
- 7:59Now, in reality, governance is ultimately
- 8:02delivered by people, not organisational charts.
- 8:06So let's talk about what makes a trustee board truly effective.
- 8:10So imagine you walk into a trustee meeting
- 8:13for the very first time.
- 8:15What is it that you see in the first 20 minutes that
- 8:18really differentiates the board as a high-functioning board?
- 8:24Let's go to Hazel.
- 8:25HAZEL KENDRICK: So I think I get a sense of a team dynamic
- 8:29within the first two minutes of any meeting, but especially
- 8:32a trustee board meeting.
- 8:34And I really like it when I observe trustee boards where
- 8:38they've clearly got that rapport with each other,
- 8:41even if there's newer trustees that have come into the team.
- 8:44And getting that team dynamic, that social capital
- 8:48flowing from the moment you have new team members joining
- 8:53your team as a trustee board.
- 8:54So for me, that is a very strong sign of a high-performing
- 8:57trustee board.
- 8:59LUNA FADAYEL: And Jenny, you've had
- 9:00your fair share of walking into boards
- 9:02and assessing exactly this.
- 9:04So are there examples of behaviors that you can share?
- 9:07JENNY GIBBONS: Yes, a tremendous privilege of my job
- 9:10is that I get to go and work with a number
- 9:13of different trustee boards, and I love this question,
- 9:16I love that, because you do get an idea
- 9:18within 20 minutes of what you're seeing in front of you.
- 9:21So perhaps some of the things that we can look out
- 9:25for are, I mean, first of all, are all the trustees there?
- 9:27And have they very clearly read their meeting packets
- 9:30and prepared appropriately?
- 9:31That's baseline necessary for effectiveness.
- 9:36But there's a couple of things that
- 9:39help you get under the skin of a high-performing trustee board.
- 9:44One of them is a real sense of continuous improvement.
- 9:48So when we do a board effectiveness
- 9:49review, interestingly, some of the very best trustee
- 9:53boards I've ever worked with have that real sense of,
- 9:56how can we do better?
- 9:58Give us examples of places where we can move forward
- 10:02a couple of steps in a way that actually some trustee boards who
- 10:05aren't operating at that level are asking themselves.
- 10:08So that continuous improvement is definitely something.
- 10:11And then another one, which I think is really interesting,
- 10:14is how the board deals with conflict.
- 10:19And I don't mean conflict in a strong sense,
- 10:21I mean a difference of opinion.
- 10:23And the very best trustee boards,
- 10:25they don't just observe that there
- 10:27are different opinions around a table
- 10:30and understand and count them, but they
- 10:34work to understand what's behind the difference of opinions
- 10:38and really understand it before coming to a consensus view.
- 10:41And it's surprising that isn't always the way
- 10:46that decisions are made and conflicts are ironed out.
- 10:48So there's a couple of little things.
- 10:50DAVID WALMSLEY: It's a red flag for me
- 10:52when-- and I've been in many trustee meetings
- 10:54where they've said to me, we have never
- 10:56disagreed about anything.
- 10:57JENNY GIBBONS: Yes.
- 10:58DAVID WALMSLEY: Really?
- 10:59JENNY GIBBONS: Yeah.
- 11:00You haven't tried hard enough then, yes.
- 11:02DAVID WALMSLEY: Absolutely.
- 11:03I'm really glad you started this with asking about the trustee
- 11:07board, because, yeah, it really is
- 11:10about the board and the collective capability
- 11:13of that board.
- 11:15There isn't any such thing as that super duper amazing trustee
- 11:20who can do everything.
- 11:21They just do not exist.
- 11:23So when I really think about how a board is effective
- 11:27and how they high performance, really
- 11:31understanding that agenda.
- 11:33Is the agenda clear?
- 11:35Is there data and statistics attached
- 11:39so people can make decisions?
- 11:40But then just observing that board,
- 11:43it's the chair's role to make sure there's inclusion.
- 11:46And that diversity of thought and voice and opinions
- 11:50to really explore issues and get everyone's views
- 11:54to come to the best outcome for the members.
- 11:58So it is that inclusion and the diversity of thought
- 12:02and really challenging the advisors.
- 12:04The advisors are there to advise.
- 12:06It's the trustees role to really challenge and have
- 12:11the confidence and the knowledge to challenge
- 12:15what they're being advised.
- 12:16LUNA FADAYEL: So it's not so much the trustee
- 12:18having that technical knowledge.
- 12:21It's more about having the confidence to be
- 12:23able to understand and use their judgments to what they're
- 12:26hearing and to challenge that and come back to them.
- 12:30DAVID WALMSLEY: And that's the simple question, why?
- 12:34JENNY GIBBONS: And the chair does a huge amount
- 12:38to facilitate that tone and that culture.
- 12:45The minute someone is made to feel foolish for having asked
- 12:50a question, it's game over.
- 12:52That's a huge risk.
- 12:53So the chair is such an important guardian
- 12:56of that precious thing that is psychological safety,
- 13:00inclusivity amongst the board.
- 13:03LUNA FADAYEL: And Hazel, you do some recruitment
- 13:06exercises of professional trustees,
- 13:09and when you run those processes,
- 13:11is there anything you think is undervalued in that selection
- 13:16process?
- 13:18HAZEL KENDRICK: I think that there is a tendency no matter
- 13:23what the size of the scheme, for schemes
- 13:26to go with very well known people in industry,
- 13:29and that's no bad thing.
- 13:30We've got some incredible talent in senior trustees that
- 13:34have been in our industry for the decades
- 13:37that I've been in the industry for.
- 13:39I think it's really important for organisations or trustee
- 13:43boards looking to bring in fresh talent to be open to a wider
- 13:48pool of professional trustees.
- 13:50And in some cases, some boards want
- 13:52that independent, not connected to a professional trustee firm.
- 13:56So that's also another angle.
- 13:58But it's really-- I always encourage the selection panel
- 14:03to be open minded about exploring
- 14:07other competencies and other types of experience
- 14:11within the pension sphere, ideally, but not all boards.
- 14:15If we look at the master trusts, a lot of-- some of them--
- 14:18one master trusts in particular is very happy
- 14:21not to have any pensions expertise on its board,
- 14:24because the executive has a lot of pensions expertise
- 14:26and they are looking for that different level of challenge.
- 14:29But I think we can learn a lot from that model.
- 14:32LUNA FADAYEL: And that goes back to what
- 14:33David was saying as well about that diversity
- 14:35and having those different viewpoints on the board
- 14:37is just absolutely key.
- 14:38And although I quite like the image of having a superhero
- 14:41trustee in my head, the cap and a mask,
- 14:43it's not about that one trustee.
- 14:45It's about having that board come together.
- 14:47HAZEL KENDRICK: I find it very refreshing when you meet a board
- 14:50and they look at themselves and they say, well, we've
- 14:53got such and such a person.
- 14:55He's a fantastic investment, industry heavy,
- 14:58so-and-so with the covenant background,
- 15:00so-and-so with the legal background.
- 15:02Actually, where's our gap?
- 15:03Our gap is on, and then they name that gap.
- 15:06For me, that makes it also very helpful for that selection
- 15:09process, because then you can also brief the market
- 15:13and get the market to help you put
- 15:15in place the correct candidates for the opportunity
- 15:18to improve the member outcomes in that environment.
- 15:21LUNA FADAYEL: Yeah.
- 15:22JENNY GIBBONS: And just an extra layer,
- 15:24as if there weren't already enough factors that
- 15:27could go into finding the right person to fill a gap is not just
- 15:31the experience that they have and the kind of industry
- 15:35that they've worked in, but also their way of contributing
- 15:38to group situations.
- 15:39So imagine we had a apparently diverse group of individuals
- 15:45who were all analysts and finishers, we'd have a very--
- 15:52we can imagine the way that trustee board would operate
- 15:55conversely, if we had a board that was stacked full
- 15:57of innovators and strivers.
- 15:59Imagine what that trustee board would operate like.
- 16:01But actually, if we have a board which
- 16:05doesn't have key components from the full spectrum of behaviors,
- 16:09you can see where it might show up in the job
- 16:12that we're asking trustees to do.
- 16:14So we do need some innovators who
- 16:16are looking around the next corner and scanning the horizon.
- 16:19It's just that we don't want to hold boards stacked full of them
- 16:22so that layer is interesting.
- 16:23HAZEL KENDRICK: I think it's quite--
- 16:24you have to be quite brave, I think, as your team, your board.
- 16:28You've got to be quite brave because sometimes you
- 16:30might say, well, that person's going to be really disruptive
- 16:33and that's quite difficult. You think, oh, I'm
- 16:35going to bring this disruption in.
- 16:37And sometimes that is the right decision for a board to make.
- 16:40LUNA FADAYEL: And that's quite interesting
- 16:42the different competencies being brought
- 16:46and the innovation piece in particular
- 16:48because I'd like to move this conversation, looking ahead
- 16:52into the future.
- 16:54Over the next few years, we're likely to see a more
- 16:57consolidated landscape, more schemes reaching their end game
- 17:01destinations and also technology playing a huge part
- 17:05in governance.
- 17:07Now everyone is talking about AI and automation,
- 17:11and it feels like a good place to start.
- 17:14So how do you see technology changing the role of trustees?
- 17:19You'd like to go--
- 17:20DAVID WALMSLEY: Role of trustees or pensions in general.
- 17:25I think AI could be fundamental in bringing change
- 17:29to the industry as a whole, especially administration member
- 17:34communications, just member experience.
- 17:38And as we move forward with dashboards and people becoming
- 17:41more engaged with the pensions, there's more to do.
- 17:45So I think we have to embrace AI.
- 17:48We're certainly doing it at The Regulator.
- 17:50We're using it more and more.
- 17:52We sent out some guidance in May, I think it was this year,
- 17:58and we'll follow that up later on in the year with some more
- 18:01guidance.
- 18:03But it's a fundamental shift and that needs new skills
- 18:08on the Board of Trustees.
- 18:10So first of all your data.
- 18:12Have you got really excellent data?
- 18:14Because if you feed AI rubbish, you're
- 18:16going to get the rubbish out.
- 18:18And then just really thinking about the future of technology.
- 18:22How do you use AI?
- 18:24You need somebody who's accountable on the board
- 18:26for use, the testing, making sure that you're protecting
- 18:30against scams in the future.
- 18:33There's an awful lot--
- 18:34the industry is changing so fast.
- 18:39And that's what I said right at the beginning.
- 18:43I'm looking to the future, the new risks that
- 18:46are coming and making sure that board is set up to tackle them
- 18:50risks.
- 18:51And you can-- any board will never eliminate risk.
- 18:54It's just about understanding and being accountable
- 18:58for them so you spot risks and mitigate them faster.
- 19:02LUNA FADAYEL: Yeah, I think that's key
- 19:03because even if a board says we're not going to adopt AI,
- 19:08you can't stop your members from doing it.
- 19:10If someone typed something into Google asking them
- 19:12what their pension provides automatically,
- 19:14it will be an AI response, even if they
- 19:16haven't gone into an AI app.
- 19:19And I think trustees might need to recognize that and think,
- 19:22well, OK, if this is how our members are accessing
- 19:24information, what can we do as a board
- 19:27to ensure that the right information is getting to them?
- 19:31So even if they are not willing to adopt it straight away,
- 19:35they need to be aware that actually their members are.
- 19:38So they almost have to.
- 19:39DAVID WALMSLEY: Absolutely.
- 19:41HAZEL KENDRICK: But Luna you touched
- 19:42on their boards that are not yet willing to adopt AI.
- 19:46And David, you touched on encouraging trustee boards
- 19:52to embrace AI.
- 19:53I just wanted to second what David's
- 19:55saying there, because it's not a case of in the future.
- 19:58AI is here right now, and I feel that AI will not
- 20:04be able to replace the judgment of an experienced, professional
- 20:07human being.
- 20:09So if I was a trustee chair or a trustee board member,
- 20:13I wouldn't be worried about my position
- 20:15by embracing AI and using it to optimize efficiency
- 20:19and effectiveness, because I don't
- 20:21see AI replacing that judgment piece that I
- 20:24think the trustee side of our industry
- 20:27is very, very talented at.
- 20:28LUNA FADAYEL: Yeah, I think that's right.
- 20:30I think technology and regulation might change
- 20:33the mechanics of the role, but I think
- 20:35fundamentally it's that judgment piece
- 20:38and being able to make good decisions for better
- 20:41outcomes for members, that's always going to be there
- 20:43and that's unchanged.
- 20:46HAZEL KENDRICK: I don't know about you guys,
- 20:48but I don't actually worry about the pensions industry's
- 20:50adaptability.
- 20:52I don't worry about that because I
- 20:54think the pensions industry has got a pretty good track
- 20:56record on adaptability when there's new regulation.
- 21:00What I do worry about now is the pensions industry, the trustee,
- 21:04trustee part of our industry's ability
- 21:07to move with the pace of technological advancement.
- 21:11JENNY GIBBONS: Including the pace at which their advisors
- 21:13and providers are moving.
- 21:16Because there's been no delegation of accountability
- 21:20here from pension scheme trustees.
- 21:23So you have to keep pace.
- 21:26DAVID WALMSLEY: You do and that requires investment.
- 21:28And we've seen the consequences of lack
- 21:32of investment in administration and the issues that causes.
- 21:35So we really need to keep ahead of this
- 21:38and think about technology, AI, data.
- 21:42It's the future.
- 21:45JENNY GIBBONS: But we're not running towards robo trustees.
- 21:47That's not the future.
- 21:48DAVID WALMSLEY: Not yet, no.
- 21:50HAZEL KENDRICK: They were trailed 10 years ago
- 21:52and we're still waiting.
- 21:54LUNA FADAYEL: So with that all in mind,
- 21:56I'd like to ask you each one final question.
- 21:59So in a sentence or in a few short sentences,
- 22:04what will determine whether pension schemes are truly
- 22:07in good hands and will continue to be so five years from now?
- 22:11JENNY GIBBONS: I don't mind going first.
- 22:13So for me, it is that we've got the right connection
- 22:19between the individuals striving to be brilliant trustees
- 22:26and hold closely the members needs and outcomes with the role
- 22:34that the pensions regulator has to do
- 22:36the things that as individuals we can't see or aren't aligned
- 22:41with.
- 22:42It's the regulator meeting the trustees
- 22:46and the individual accountability
- 22:48where they finish.
- 22:50LUNA FADAYEL: David.
- 22:52DAVID WALMSLEY: So for me, it's trust and confidence
- 22:56in the system.
- 22:59In 5 years' time, hopefully people
- 23:00will be significantly more engaged in the pensions.
- 23:05We've got open banking.
- 23:06Everyone's finances will be coming together
- 23:09and people have decisions to make
- 23:11and really complex decisions.
- 23:13So yeah, I'd like guided retirement, value for money.
- 23:18So it's trust and confidence and excellence
- 23:20in communications and data.
- 23:28whether we have more consolidation,
- 23:30higher professionalism, more advanced technology,
- 23:35I think the question we should ask ourselves is, have we
- 23:38done the right thing and/or have we done enough
- 23:42to protect the member outcomes?
- 23:45LUNA FADAYEL: And I think that is true today and will continue
- 23:49to be true in 2030 and beyond.
- 23:52So David, Jenny, and Hazel, thank you
- 23:54very much for joining me today.
- 23:55It's been wonderful to have you.
- 23:57To our listeners, if you would like
- 23:59to continue the conversation, then WTW's annual pensions
- 24:03and savings conference takes place on the 17 of November
- 24:06at the Sheraton Grand London Park Lane,
- 24:09and it will unlock hidden potential
- 24:11for the benefit of members, sponsors and the economy.
- 24:15But in the meantime, thank you very much for tuning in
- 24:17to this episode of The Pensions Perspectives Podcast brought
- 24:20to you by WTW.
- 24:22I'm your host, Luna Fadayel, and I look forward
- 24:25to joining you for another conversation that matters.
- 24:27[AUDIO LOGO]
- 24:35This podcast is for informational purposes only
- 24:37and does not constitute financial advice.
- 24:40The views expressed by any hosts and guests are their own and may
- 24:43not reflect those of their employers or affiliated
- 24:46organisations.
- 24:48All content is protected by copyright.