Latest / Deep Dive / Democracy vs. Competence: Who Should Have the Power to Vote?
Transcript
- 0:00I want you to think for a second about how many times you've
- 0:03heard this specific phrase. You know, democracy is the worst
- 0:07form of government, except for all the others.
- 0:09Oh yeah. I mean, it's ubiquitous, right?
- 0:11You hear it in political debates, or you read it in op
- 0:15eds, or maybe you even use it yourself to just sort of shrug
- 0:18off a really frustrating news cycle.
- 0:20Yeah. Exactly.
- 0:21It functions almost like, well, a thought terminating cliche.
- 0:26It's this comforting little safety blanket that just shuts
- 0:29down any further debate about how we actually govern
- 0:32ourselves. That is exactly you hear that
- 0:34line, you nod, and you just move on.
- 0:37But what if our cultural reliance on that idea is
- 0:40entirely, like, fundamentally misunderstood?
- 0:43That's the big question. Right.
- 0:45So welcome to this deep dive. Today's mission is a massive 1.
- 0:49Honestly. We are going to rigorously
- 0:51examine our cultural blind faith and democracy.
- 0:53It's a big topic to unpack. It is.
- 0:55And rather than just giving you a reading list right now to say,
- 0:58we've pulled together a really fascinating stack of sources.
- 1:02We've got historical research, medical journals, university
- 1:07briefings and some deeply provocative political
- 1:10philosophy. Yeah, the goal is basically to
- 1:12figure out if we are evaluating democracy based on how it
- 1:15actually functions in the real world or, you know, based purely
- 1:19on how we just wish it worked. Right.
- 1:21Exactly. But I think we should
- 1:23acknowledge right out of the gate that merely posing that
- 1:26question makes people really uncomfortable.
- 1:28Oh, absolutely. I mean, one of our sources, it's
- 1:31a briefing from an event at the London School of Economics.
- 1:34It specifically highlights this exact stigma.
- 1:37Really. Yeah.
- 1:38It points out that those who dare to challenge the necessity
- 1:41of democracy, they're almost immediately branded as
- 1:43extremists or, you know, dangerous ideologues.
- 1:46Man, I feel that. I mean, questioning democracy
- 1:49usually feels like insulting someone's grandmother.
- 1:51Yeah, you're just not to do it. You're expected to treat the
- 1:54system as completely sacred. But to figure out if it actually
- 1:59deserves that sacred status, I think we first need to correct
- 2:03the historical record on its most famous defense.
- 2:05Which brings us right back to that quote you started with.
- 2:08Yes, because the historical analysis we reviewed this is by
- 2:11Richard M Langworth, it reveals a massive surprise.
- 2:14This blew my mind. Yeah, when Winston Churchill
- 2:16delivered that famous worst form of government line, you know, in
- 2:20the House of Commons back on November 11, 1947, he was not
- 2:24actually inventing the phrase. Wait, he didn't come up with it?
- 2:28No, Churchill explicitly said in that speech, and I quote, it has
- 2:32been said that democracy is the worst form of government.
- 2:35That's why. He was quoting an unknown
- 2:37predecessor. Exactly.
- 2:39The man we all credit with this ultimate defense of democracy
- 2:42was essentially just acting as the publicist for some unsourced
- 2:45aphorism. Wow.
- 2:47OK, so if Churchill didn't originate it, what did he
- 2:50actually originate? Well, language research details
- 2:54that, and conceptually it is much more interesting.
- 2:56I think back in 19 O 9, Churchill defined democratic
- 2:59politics as insurance. Insurance.
- 3:02Yeah, insurance against dangers from abroad and dangers at home.
- 3:06OK. But the way he envisioned the
- 3:09actual mechanics of that insurance is what really struck
- 3:11me. The 1944 speech.
- 3:13Yes, in 1944 he gave a speech painting this highly specific,
- 3:18very visual picture of what he considered the foundation of
- 3:21democracy. He described the the little man
- 3:25walking into the little booth with a little pencil, making a
- 3:28little cross on a little bit of paper.
- 3:29I love that quote. Notice how physical and
- 3:31localized that imagery is. Right.
- 3:33Churchill is focusing entirely on the process.
- 3:36He elaborates that it is absolutely essential this
- 3:38individual does this without fear.
- 3:40Without any form of intimidation or victimization and in strict
- 3:45secrecy. It's not about grand political
- 3:47theory for him at all. It's about the procedural safety
- 3:49of the individual citizen expressing a choice.
- 3:52OK, let's unpack this for a second.
- 3:53Because that image of the little man with a little pencil is
- 3:58incredibly romantic. It really is.
- 4:00It paints this beautiful, humble picture of civic duty.
- 4:04But that romanticism makes me wonder something.
- 4:07What's that? Is this deeply ingrained
- 4:10emotional attachment to the idea of the voting booth exactly what
- 4:16blinds us to the actual real world flaws of the system?
- 4:21Like, do we love the romance so much we just stopped looking at
- 4:24the results? Honestly, that romanticism is
- 4:27undeniably powerful. In fact, it is so deeply
- 4:29embedded in our culture that we actually find professionals
- 4:32actively trying to force this political model into an entirely
- 4:36non political, highly technical environment.
- 4:38Which is a perfect transition to a very unexpected environment.
- 4:41The hospital. Yeah, this part was fascinating.
- 4:43We dug into the Journal of the American College of Radiology,
- 4:46of all places, and found a letter from a doctor, Arnold C
- 4:48Friedman. And ironically, he actually
- 4:50quotes that fame misattributed Churchill line.
- 4:53He does? Yeah.
- 4:54And he uses it to argue that academic radiology department
- 4:57should be run democratically. Right.
- 4:59So he is pushing back against the standard operational
- 5:03structure of a hospital department, which, you know, is
- 5:06traditionally very top down. The department chair makes the
- 5:09calls. Right.
- 5:09And Doctor Friedman argues that having chairs dictate policy
- 5:14leaves the faculty feeling completely disempowered, and
- 5:16that in turn ruins department morale.
- 5:19So to fix morale, he literally proposes bringing the political
- 5:23voting booth into the radiology department.
- 5:26It's so strange to think about. It is.
- 5:28He wants open debate on policies.
- 5:30He wants elections for department chairs every two to
- 5:33four years. Term limits recall power.
- 5:35And playfully, he adds, a rule of no campaigning.
- 5:38Yeah. But think about the actual
- 5:39mechanics of what he's suggesting here.
- 5:41He wants medical professionals to resolve departmental
- 5:44direction through a majoritarian political process.
- 5:47OK, but on the same topic, we did find a counter perspective
- 5:51on Langl's blog from another physician, a doctor, Michael
- 5:55Calm. Right Doctor Calm essentially
- 5:57compares democracy to the science of medicine itself.
- 6:00Right arguing both are incremental, they're evolving,
- 6:04and they're specifically designed to avoid authoritarian,
- 6:07one-size-fits-all solutions. I mean, I see the surface logic
- 6:11there. Nobody wants a medical dictator.
- 6:13Sure, but let's ground this in reality for a second.
- 6:16If I am a patient getting an X-ray, do I want the doctors in
- 6:19the hospital taking a majority vote on which imaging machine
- 6:22protocol is best to use? Probably not.
- 6:25No, I just want the absolute top most qualified expert in the
- 6:30hospital to make the unilateral call.
- 6:33Doctor Friedman's proposal seems to assume that open debate and
- 6:37majority voting inherently yield the best technical results.
- 6:40And that, that is the exact logical leap we need to
- 6:43scrutinize. Friedman's letter relies on this
- 6:45deeply held assumption. Which is what?
- 6:47The assumption that participation automatically
- 6:49creates empowerment and that empowerment automatically leads
- 6:52to better policies, I see. But this specific assumption
- 6:56that participating in a process inherently improves both the
- 6:59outcome and the people participating?
- 7:01That is exactly what modern political philosophers are
- 7:03aggressively dismantling right now.
- 7:05Which brings us to a much darker, much more challenging
- 7:08perspective. Yeah, buckle up.
- 7:09This assumption that participation is universally
- 7:12good leads us right into the core of Jason Brennan's fierce
- 7:18philosophical critique in his book Against Democracy Brennan.
- 7:21Gives this blind faith a name. He calls it democratic
- 7:25triumphalism. Democratic triumphalism.
- 7:27OK, It's this widespread, almost religious belief that democracy
- 7:31deserves 3 cheers. The first cheer is that
- 7:34democracy is instrumentally good, meaning it functions well
- 7:38as a tool to get good results. OK.
- 7:40What are the other two? The third cheer is that it is
- 7:43intrinsically good, like an end in itself, a uniquely just way
- 7:47to organize society. Well, you skip the second cheer.
- 7:49Ah, right. It's that second cheer that
- 7:51Brennan really targets the idea that democracy is arrestically
- 7:54good the lesser. Politically.
- 7:56Yeah, meaning the actual process of participating in politics and
- 7:59nobles us and educates us as citizens.
- 8:02OK, got it. To understand why Brennan
- 8:04attacks this, the text contrasts 2 wildly different historical
- 8:08views on the psychology of the voter.
- 8:11We have John Stuart Mill on one side versus the economist Joseph
- 8:14Schumpeter on the other. OK, break those down for me.
- 8:17So Mill had this very optimistic hypothesis.
- 8:21He believed that getting an ordinary citizen, say a 19th
- 8:24century factory worker, involved in politics would fundamentally
- 8:28broaden their mind. Right Mill thought it would be
- 8:30like a fish suddenly discovering there is a whole world outside
- 8:34the ocean. Exactly that.
- 8:35Engaging in the democratic process.
- 8:37Wood Forest this factory worker to look beyond their own
- 8:40immediate selfish interests and actually consider the common
- 8:43good of the nation. Yes, Mill viewed political
- 8:46participation as an educational tool, but Joseph Schumpeter
- 8:49argued the exact opposite. What do you say?
- 8:51Schumpeter posited that entering the political field actually
- 8:54causes a citizen to drop to a lower level of mental
- 8:57performance. Yeah, his argument was at the
- 9:01moment we start arguing about politics, we lose our grip on
- 9:04rationality and we start acting in ways that are infantile and
- 9:07primitive. OK, so the fundamental question
- 9:09here is really about human behavior.
- 9:11Precisely. Is political participation like
- 9:15going to the gym for your brain, building your civic muscles like
- 9:18mill thought? Or is it more like road rage,
- 9:20where an otherwise perfectly normal, polite person gets
- 9:23behind the wheel of a car and suddenly turns into a screaming
- 9:26monster, just like Schumpeter suggests?
- 9:29Well, according to Jason Brennan, who backs his argument
- 9:32with over 60 years of empirical data from psychologists,
- 9:36sociologists and political scientists.
- 9:38Oh wow, 60 years. Yeah, and the data overwhelming
- 9:42shows that Schumpeter was right. Political participation does not
- 9:45typically educate or ennoble us. So it is road rage.
- 9:48Yeah, it tends to stultify and corrupt us.
- 9:50It doesn't make us better neighbors.
- 9:52It actually makes us civic enemies, ma'am.
- 9:54If political participation is basically intellectual road
- 9:57rage, we really have to look out the windshield and ask what kind
- 10:01of drivers are actually out there on the road?
- 10:03Who are the people wielding this power?
- 10:05Right, and Brennan categorizes voters into 3 distinct species
- 10:10to explain this, and the names he gives them are incredibly
- 10:14telling. What are they?
- 10:15He calls them hobbits, hooligans and Vulcans.
- 10:18OK, let's examine the mechanics of each archetype.
- 10:20We will start with the Hobbits. So Hobbits are citizens who are
- 10:24mostly apathetic and completely ignorant about politics.
- 10:27Just living their lives. Exactly.
- 10:29They lack strong or fixed opinions on major issues, They
- 10:33don't study the social sciences. They essentially just want to go
- 10:36about their daily routines, tend to their own gardens and ignore
- 10:40the noise of the outside world. And Brennan notes that in the
- 10:43United States, the typical non voter is a Hobbit.
- 10:46Yeah, OK, then we have the hooligans.
- 10:49If hobbits are ignoring the game, hooligans are the rabid
- 10:53sports fans of politics. That's the perfect analogy.
- 10:56Hooligans do consume political information, but they do it in a
- 10:59highly biased, very privable way.
- 11:03Right. They cherry pick data that
- 11:04confirms what they already believe, and they aggressively
- 11:07reject any evidence that contradicts their team.
- 11:10For a hooligan, their political affiliation isn't just an
- 11:13opinion, it is a core part of their identity.
- 11:16Because of that, they tend to despise their opponents, viewing
- 11:19them not just as incorrect, but as stupid or genuinely evil.
- 11:24Honestly, I'm sure every listener right now can picture a
- 11:26hooligan from their own family Thanksgiving dinner.
- 11:29Or, you know, there's social media feed.
- 11:31Oh, without a doubt. And the really frightening part
- 11:34of the text is the observation that most regular voters,
- 11:37activists and actual politicians falls squarely into the hooligan
- 11:41category. Yeah.
- 11:42Which leaves us with the third category, the Vulcans.
- 11:45The ideal, right? The Vulcan is Brennan's ideal
- 11:48archetype. A Vulcan thinks scientifically
- 11:51and rationally. They are self aware of their own
- 11:53biases and only as confident as the empirical evidence allows.
- 11:57They are completely dispassionate.
- 11:59But the crucial caveat here is that no one is perfectly a
- 12:01Vulcan. Exactly.
- 12:03It's an ideal that doesn't actually exist in pure form in
- 12:06the real world, so looking at the data, we are left with a
- 12:09voting pool that is overwhelmingly dominated by
- 12:12oblivious hobbits and raging hooligans.
- 12:15Which leads Brennan to a highly controversial take away.
- 12:18What's that? If the electorate is made-up of
- 12:20hobbits and hooligans, he argues that decreasing voter turn out
- 12:24isn't actually a crisis at all. Wait, really?
- 12:26Yeah. In fact, he suggests that
- 12:29ideally, most people simply wouldn't worry about politics
- 12:32and would fill their days with art, music or celebrity gossip
- 12:35instead. OK, here's where it gets really
- 12:38interesting, because I have to push back hard on Brendan's
- 12:40logic here. Let's hear it.
- 12:41Telling people to just go focus on art or gossip ignores a
- 12:46massive reality. Isn't it A profound privilege to
- 12:50just be a Hobbit? That's a fairpoint.
- 12:53Right. Like if the law is being passed,
- 12:54don't negatively impact your daily life if your basic rights
- 12:58aren't up for debate. Sure, you can afford to ignore
- 13:00politics. But what if you don't have that
- 13:02luxury? It's true.
- 13:04I want you, the listener, to really think about this.
- 13:07Is tuning out of politics a sign of a healthy society or is it a
- 13:11necessary tactic for self preservation because the system
- 13:14has become too toxic to engage with?
- 13:17That is a very serious challenge to Ron's framework, and it's one
- 13:21we really have to wrestle with. It is undeniably A privilege to
- 13:25tune out, right? But Brennan's argument doesn't
- 13:28ignore the marginalized. It actually tries to protect
- 13:30them by looking at the macro level.
- 13:32How so? Well, he asks us to consider the
- 13:35alternative. If we force everyone to
- 13:38participate, we are forcing a massive pool of apathetic
- 13:41hobbits and deeply biased hooligans to make the decisions.
- 13:45OK, so, he asks, does the privilege of tuning out outweigh
- 13:49the systemic damage caused when uninformed people impose
- 13:52terrible policies on the very groups who can't afford to be
- 13:55hobbits? I see.
- 13:57Because a bad vote doesn't just impact the person casting it.
- 13:59A bad vote imposes a reality on innocent bystanders.
- 14:02Exactly. And that is the philosophical
- 14:05pivot point. If the majority of drivers on
- 14:07the road are reckless or blindfolded, how can we possibly
- 14:10justify the damage they do? Which brings us to Brennan's
- 14:13ultimate challenge. If democracy is structurally
- 14:16flawed because of human psychology, what if we replace
- 14:19it entirely? OK, to understand how Brennan
- 14:22intellectually justifies tearing down democracy, we really need
- 14:26to understand a fundamental philosophical distinction he
- 14:30makes. It's between instrumental value
- 14:33and procedural value. Yeah, the text uses a brilliant
- 14:37simple analogy for this. Think of a painting.
- 14:41A painting has procedural or intrinsic value.
- 14:44It is an end in itself. You value it simply for existing
- 14:47and being beautiful, regardless of what it does, right?
- 14:50Conversely, consider a hammer. A hammer has instrumental value.
- 14:54It is purely a means to an end. You do not value a hammer for
- 14:57its intrinsic beauty, you value it because it effectively pounds
- 15:00in nails. Right.
- 15:01And if it stops pounding in nails, you get rid of it.
- 15:04Exactly. Brennan argues that we treat
- 15:06democracy like a beautiful painting, but in reality it is
- 15:09just a hammer. It's simply a tool designed to
- 15:11generate just and efficient policies.
- 15:13And if we can engineer a better hammer, you know, a tool that
- 15:15gets better results for society, we have a moral obligation to
- 15:19pick up the new tool. And the specific new hammer he
- 15:22proposes is a system called epistocracy.
- 15:24Epistocracy. Which literally translates to
- 15:27the rule of the knowledgeable. Yes, an epistocracy distributes
- 15:31political power based on competence and skill, rather
- 15:34than simply granting it to everyone equally.
- 15:37It sounds so intense. It does, but this isn't just
- 15:40abstract theory. The text details several real
- 15:43world mechanisms for how an epistocracy could functionally
- 15:46operate. OK, let's walk through how these
- 15:49would actually work, because some of these are wild.
- 15:51OK, first, there is restricted suffrage.
- 15:54Under this model, the legal right to vote isn't a
- 15:56birthright. You are only permitted to vote
- 15:59if you pass a rigorous competence process or prove you
- 16:02are sufficiently well informed. OK, what's next?
- 16:04Then there is plural voting. In this model, everyone gets one
- 16:09basic vote, much like our current democracy, but citizens
- 16:12who can prove a higher level of education or political knowledge
- 16:16are granted additional extra votes.
- 16:18Wait, I remember reading that John Stuart Mill, our optimist
- 16:21from earlier, actually supported this specific idea, right?
- 16:24He did even he saw the appeal of it.
- 16:26Wow. OK, what else?
- 16:28Then we have enfranchisement lotteries.
- 16:30This completely flips the script.
- 16:32By default, absolutely nobody has the right to vote.
- 16:35Nobody. Nobody.
- 16:37Right before an election, a random representative slice of
- 16:40the population is selected. These pre voters are then
- 16:44essentially required to earn the right to cast a ballot by
- 16:47participating in mandatory competence building exercises.
- 16:50Oh wow, so they study the issues, prove their
- 16:53comprehension, and only then do they vote on behalf of the
- 16:56country. Exactly.
- 16:57And finally, there is weighted voting.
- 17:00In this scenario, everyone goes to the polls, but alongside your
- 17:04ballot you take a political knowledge quiz.
- 17:07Later, a mathematical algorithm weights the impact of your vote
- 17:10based on your objective score on that quiz.
- 17:11The more knowledgeable you are, the heavier your vote counts.
- 17:14OK, I have to step in here because my alarm bells are
- 17:16ringing so loudly right now. I get it.
- 17:18This sounds incredibly elitist. When I hear rule of the
- 17:21knowledgeable, I immediately picture an arrogant,
- 17:24disconnected expert dictating my life.
- 17:27Just because my doctor knows vastly more about human health
- 17:30than I do doesn't mean he should have the legal authority to ban
- 17:33me from ever eating a cheeseburger, Right?
- 17:35Competence in a subject doesn't equal the moral right to rule
- 17:38over someone else. And Brennan actually anticipates
- 17:42that exact visceral reaction. He calls this the Expert Boss
- 17:46fallacy. The expert boss fallacy.
- 17:48Yeah, the text provides a great modern example to illustrate
- 17:52your point. Just because a fitness celebrity
- 17:54like Shanti knows exactly how to get cut ABS doesn't mean he has
- 17:57the authority to break into your house and force you to do
- 17:59burpees. Yes.
- 18:01Exactly. Knowing the right answer doesn't
- 18:03make you the boss. But Brennan argues that
- 18:05epistocracy isn't actually built on the idea of experts being
- 18:08bosses, it is built on what he terms the anti authority tenant.
- 18:13Anti authority tenant, Yeah. The fundamental goal of
- 18:16epistocracy isn't to empower the elite.
- 18:18Its goal is to protect innocent people.
- 18:21Protect them from what? Themselves.
- 18:24Protect them from incompetence. Let's go back to the car
- 18:28analogy. Why do we legally restrict bad
- 18:32or intoxicated drivers from getting on the highway?
- 18:35We wake him to crash. Right.
- 18:37We don't do it to empower good drivers.
- 18:39We do it because we don't want bad drivers to crash into
- 18:42innocent people. OK, I follow.
- 18:44Voting functions the same way a vote is not merely a personal
- 18:48expression, it is an exercise of power that imposes decisions on
- 18:51everyone, including children, immigrants and marginalized
- 18:54groups who cannot vote. Brennan's anti authority tenant
- 18:58argues that because, as the stakes are so phenomenally high,
- 19:02incompetent voters shouldn't be legally permitted to impose
- 19:05irrational policies on the rest of us.
- 19:07So if we look at through that lens, epistocracy is less about
- 19:10granting smart people extra power and more about taking the
- 19:13steering wheel away from the hooligans before they drive the
- 19:16car off a Cliff. That's the idea.
- 19:18If democracy is a hammer currently being wildly swung by
- 19:21people who are blindfolded, epistocracy is the argument that
- 19:24maybe we should only hand the hammer to people who can
- 19:26actually see the nail. Precisely, it challenges the
- 19:30assumption that equal participation is inherently more
- 19:32moral than competent governance. Wow, we have covered an immense
- 19:37amount of intellectual ground today.
- 19:39We really have. Let's quickly recap this
- 19:41journey. We started by shattering a myth,
- 19:44discovering that Winston Churchill didn't actually invent
- 19:46the famous quote we used to shield democracy from criticism.
- 19:50Right. We examine how the romantic
- 19:52ideal of the voting booth is so culturally dominant that doctors
- 19:55actually try to democratize highly technical hospital
- 19:58departments. Which is still so wild to me.
- 20:01And then we confronted Jason Brennan's deeply unconceable
- 20:04philosophical argument that empirical data shows voters act
- 20:08more like hobbits and hooligans than rational citizens, that
- 20:11political participation might actually make us worse people.
- 20:14And that an episdocracy, a system based on competence,
- 20:18might be a vastly superior hammer for building a just
- 20:21society. Exactly, and at this point it is
- 20:23absolutely vital to remind you, the listener, that we are not
- 20:26taking a political side in this debate.
- 20:28Oh, absolutely not. We are certainly not endorsing
- 20:31the dismantling of democracy or the implementation of an
- 20:34Episdocracy. No, our goal today was simply to
- 20:38impartially unpack the profound challenging idea is contained in
- 20:42these original source materials. We just wanted to analyze the
- 20:45mechanics of these arguments and invite you to view the familiar
- 20:48concept of the voting booth through a completely new,
- 20:51rigorous lens. To make you look at the hammer
- 20:53in your hand and ask if it's really the best tool for the
- 20:56job. So as we wrap up, I want to
- 20:58leave you with a final thought experiment to Mull over on your
- 21:01own. OK, imagine future where
- 21:03completely impartial, incredibly advanced artificial intelligence
- 21:07could act as Brennan's flawless Vulcan.
- 21:10Imagine this AI could perfectly objectively score everyone's
- 21:14political knowledge and mathematically weight their
- 21:16votes without any human bias, racism, or classism whatsoever.
- 21:20If that technology existed, would you willingly surrender
- 21:23your equal democratic vote for the promise of a demonstrably
- 21:27more competent, rational, and just society?
- 21:30Or is there something intrinsically human, dignified,
- 21:32and totally irreplaceable about Churchill's little man with a
- 21:35little pencil that a knowledge algorithm simply cannot measure?