Latest / Ensombl Advice Australia / The Aged Care Conversation #2
Transcript
- 0:00The Ensemble podcast is intended for professional financial advisors. This content is created in partnership with our sponsor NMMT Ltd. ABN 42058 835 573 AFSL 234 653 and is limited to publicly available information.
- 0:15Before acting on any general advice, you should consider whether appropriate and obtain financial advice from a qualified financial advisor. Ensemble does not hold an AFS license and does not provide any financial advice or services or endorse any general advice. If a PDS or IM exists, you should obtain a copy and review it thoroughly before making a decision.
- 0:38Welcome to our three-part series on aged care, where we explore why aged care is becoming such an important advice conversation. Across the series, we'll unpack how aged care has changed, the client conversations advisors need to be having earlier, and how advice practices can adapt to better support clients and their families.
- 1:01I'm Sarah Leslie, co-founder of Aging with Grace Advisory, and I'll be your host for the series. Join me and our expert guests to explore the practical steps advisors can take to navigate this evolving area of advice.
- 1:17North is one of Australia's leading RAP platforms for super and pension, recently ranked number one for advisor proposition and retirement in the latest NMG Advisor Wealth Survey. North is purpose-built to help advisors confidently prepare clients for and guide them through retirement. With market-leading retirement solutions, flexible managed portfolios and integrated digital technology, North supports clearer conversations, scalable advice and better retirement outcomes.
- 1:44Backed by disciplined governance and continual innovation, North partners with advisors who are serious about growing their practices and their clients' wealth.
- 1:52Welcome back to the Aged Care Podcast Series. In this episode, we're talking about budgeting for care, but not simply in terms of care fees or accommodation costs. I think the bigger question for advisors is, how do we fund, how do we build future care needs into retirement planning in a way that's realistic and practical and client focused as well? Absolutely.
- 2:17So today I am joined by Ben Hillier from AMP and we're going to explore how advisors can think more about retirement spending and lifetime income, liquidity, aged care and some of the emotional decisions that might sit behind the numbers too. So thank you so much for joining me today, Ben.
- 2:38My pleasure. Great to be here, Sarah. Thank you. So I guess one of the things that's really critical and we find is, and maybe starting with a bit of a big picture question, is do you find that aged or think that advisors are still treating aged care as something separate from retirement planning rather than a part of the retirement journey?
- 3:01Yeah, it's a good question. And look, because it's a thorny issue that sort of is so much uncertainty is when it's going to happen, how long they're going to need care, what are the costs, in fact, what's the framework going to be at that point in time. It sometimes does get parked into a, I wouldn't say too hard basket, but in a different basket to be dealt with later and hopefully,
- 3:25or hopefully not at all. But you're exactly right, I think, in the inference of your question. It really is something that is going to affect us all pretty much if we're lucky enough to live long enough and that, yeah, we will have diminished capabilities and care is very likely in our futures.
- 3:43And I think it is something that it's a challenge, not just for us as advisors, but it is also the clients that either just want to defer it and just assume that it's something we can deal with later. And what we find that that often creeps up on us and it's not always the case that we can defer those thoughts and planning for that.
- 4:02I know in our call when we caught up previously, we talked a lot about that spending needs change quite significantly over retirement. And I think I'd really love to get some insights from you about what you think advisors might be approaching it right or wrongly about that assumption around sort of flat, consistent levels of income over time. Yeah, it's an interesting one because the –
- 4:30So pretty much every sort of projection that you're modelling software of choice or the one you're forced to use, shall I say, they're pretty much always going to project flat real income. So income that keeps pace with CPI inflation usually. Some even increase it by wage inflation. That's more perhaps in the super fund land.
- 4:53But generally, we've got projections that just show flat income. It looks fantastic, but it does not match real-life spending needs and observed behavior. And so even people who have plenty of money, this isn't about people spend less over time because they don't have the money. They actually spend less because their needs change, their capacity, their desire to spend money changes. And, of course, the categories, the things they're spending money on
- 5:22does change a fair bit over time. I mean, the data clearly shows if you track the same consumers in a longitudinal analysis, and we've done some of this analysis in Australia but also overseas, and it's pretty clear that,
- 5:37that people spend less in real terms. Now, sometimes that's quite deceptive because, of course, inflation is happening. And so people typically are having expenditure that rises in nominal terms, i.e. maybe they spent $60,000 last year and they're going to spend $61,000 or $62,000 this year. But inflation might be a little bit higher than that. So what we're actually seeing is people spend less
- 6:04less in real terms by about 1% or 2%. And that still implies, you know, if you think about it, if inflation is 2% or 3%, their dollars per week they're spending. So it seems to them like they're spending more and more each week, each month, each year, but it's actually they are spending less. And have a look at the categories that people spend. It's actually there's some quite big differences between on the wealth levels of the client as you'd expect.
- 6:31But the upper quartile Australians who are most likely, of course, to be getting financial advice, it's pretty consistent. They spend about 50% of their expenditure on living expenses, food, your living expenses, accommodation rates, insurances, those sorts of things.
- 6:52They spend about 40% on lifestyle expenses at the start and then the remaining 10 on health. And then what we see happen is that the health expenditure doubles, something like that, over time. And as a result, the lifestyle expenditure decreases. Yeah.
- 7:10It's not particularly surprising that those two things are in lockstep, in opposite, that once your health needs increase, your mobility is decreased, your energy levels, your ability to simply get around, of course, you're not going to be travelling as much. You're not going to be going out as much. It does correspond to...
- 7:29Yeah, I think that's really fair to say that most of us, when we've worked in that retirement space, you do always talk to and see in reality those active years of retirement. And we do see there's larger expenditure when people are in that stage of life. And perhaps it's more of a shift instead of simply asking, will the client need more money later or less money later? It's more, what will they be needing that money for? So I think what I'm hearing from you is that the
- 7:58the amount won't necessarily change, obviously, taking into account the effects of inflation and things like that, but more so where that spending gets attributed to actually changes quite significantly over the years. And I think that's a really important point because sometimes we think we approach sort of care needs as, oh, there's a separate bucket I need to be worried about and concerned about. And, of course, look, we need to be prudent, but we can count on –
- 8:27to at least the reasonable extent. We can count on the money we were spending on lifestyle, on travel and entertaining and eating out and those sorts of things. We can pretty safely assume that our capacity to spend that money on lifestyle will decrease in line with our need to spend it on care. And so it doesn't necessarily need to be always a separate bucket of money for those needs. It's just a reallocation, as you point out.
- 8:52I think it probably lends itself to a change in how that's communicated and the conversations we are having because I know that really resonates with what we say day to day with our clients at Ageing with Grace is that families who start to be more involved, they often experience that their care costs do have a sudden increase. But the reality is that when you are looking more closely, those other categories are reducing.
- 9:21The challenge is that clients don't always perceive it that way. They don't necessarily see that there is that shift and they feel that care costs is actually a new pressure, but really it's that the overall retirement spending picture is shifting and just where it's been allocated to. Yeah, there's a myth floating around called the retirement smile, the retirement spending smile. I haven't heard this one. Have you not? Yeah.
- 9:49Look, it's actually based on some US data. So there's a couple of things about this, right? And we do see this in Australia. I see it on Superfund websites and all other places. And basically, it's got the retirement spending goes like this. It sort of starts here, it falls through retirement, and then it increases.
- 10:06There's two really, really important caveats to that study. And it's a real study and go look it up. But the two caveats are, number one, the smile is based on not level of spending, but the change in level of spending. So the axis is not dollars, it's percent.
- 10:24and here's zero the smile is all below zero i.e the smile shows that you're actually decreasing spending consistently throughout retirement because all the time through retirement you're spending is decreasing it's always below zero but the rate it changes the rate it decreases changes sometimes it's decreasing faster than other times it's decreasing but it's always decreasing in real terms so that's
- 10:51Point number one. And also caveat number two, it's based on American data where health expenditure, you know, they don't have the same safety nets that we have in Australia. And so assuming your clients have Medicare and access to at least certain levels of free care or means-tested care, we don't see that smile in Australia. We actually see a fairly consistent decline in real spending through the retirement.
- 11:18But you're right, it might not be perceived by clients because they just suddenly say, oh, my goodness, there's all these new costs. They're not countering the decline in other expenses. Yeah.
- 11:29And for those of you who are tuning in who don't have the visual or haven't been able to create that in your head, where Ben's describing the smile is talking about a timeframe and a graph and really that higher, the line dipping down in the middle to reflect that smile over time. I think it's probably the terminology. I've seen those graphs many times and depicted that way but just haven't necessarily had it attached to the retirement smile as a term.
- 11:58I guess one of the other assumptions is, and you touched on it just briefly there, which was the challenge that the idea of government-funded and government-funded care will cover everything. And I think this is, and especially with some of the changes we've been seeing, it is a misconception that,
- 12:20Families assume that government-funded care means that it will cover most, if not all, of what they need. But the reality is, and especially with all of the changes, that it's actually often much more complicated than that. And obviously, it's not a lot of complicated.
- 12:36I think from your perspective, how do you see that we as advisors can help our clients with the gap, funding that gap or understanding how to fund that gap between government support and what they may still need to fund themselves? Yes.
- 12:53Yeah, it's really important to get across the changes. I was at a recent event, happened to be on ensemble as well, and we asked the audience how aware are they of the changes to the funding that came in last year.
- 13:10And it's fair to say that there was not a large number of advisors who were fully across the changes, and in fact, some were brave enough to admit that they weren't aware that the changes had occurred. And so, look, there's no shame in that, that they are new and they are complex, and if you're not a specialist in this space, you might not be across them. But look, in summary, certainly the non-clinical costs that they –
- 13:38You would expect that a lot of your clients will be asked to pay more for those costs, right? For me, when I'm asked about these changes, I would summarise it in two things. The bad news is there's more means testing for an entire
- 13:55So then it will create out-of-pocket costs to a greater degree for clients who can afford them. But the good news is they're means tested. And so there is still support, a strong safety net for those clients in Australians who don't have the means. But where there is capacity to pay, we would expect to see an uplift.
- 14:15And with the role that cash flow modelling can play in showing clients the difference between what is funded and what they need to pay privately, and I guess also looking at some of the planning opportunities that we might have of how we can create consistent ways for helping them to fund clients.
- 14:35out-of-pocket costs, whether it's at home or in residential care. What role or how do you see advisors' opportunities for them to help modelling that gap or potential there? Yeah, look, retirement advice is becoming more and more sophisticated and more sophisticated.
- 14:55You know, sometimes I use the analogy that too often we've been putting clients on a, you know, trying to solve all their needs with a single-legged stool and account-based pension. And that doesn't provide a very stable existence. It's difficult to just have a single bucket to be able to be meeting all your needs. And I talk about the five L's of needs in retirement. So liquidity, liquidity.
- 15:22living, lifestyle, later, and that later might be in clear-age care, and then legacy. And it's difficult to have all of those needs met out of a single strategy or single solution. Far better to have greater levels of compartmentalization and deliberate purpose about how we meet client needs. And I think that has a strong range of benefits.
- 15:49If you actually have specific plans, strategies, and even solutions in place for each specific need and also addressing each of the risks in retirement, then that gives your clients a greater peace of mind that, yes, we're going to be okay. And they actually can afford to spend more. The last thing we want to do is for them to be worried about changes like the aged care.
- 16:11or other uncertainties of retirement and underspend. And we do see that time and time again. People just don't have the confidence to enjoy their retirement during those active years you referred to, Tito.
- 16:23We've got the twin challenges of making sure that people are confident to spend and really, really enjoy those active years, but with the peace of mind that there is sufficient cash flow for the needs in the passive and trial year. Yeah. And I do, I really love that, the five L's, and I think it's something that can help give advisors a more structured way to think about those competing retirement needs.
- 16:49When it comes to aged care, and I'm curious to know where you see that sitting in that framework, because I guess it's mostly would be considered in a later need, but also I guess it also fits into that liquidity, lifestyle expenses, and even that legacy box as well. What are your thoughts there?
- 17:11Yeah, look, I opted against a separate bucket for care on purpose, and that's because of that conversation we've already had. But it's often a movement from lifestyle expense to care expense, and that could come earlier or later. It's a one-way, unfortunately. It's a fairly one-way flow of reallocation of needs and expenses.
- 17:35As important as to say, we can't underestimate the uncertainty of care and there will be some uncertain costs. We also don't want to overestimate the impact of funding care in that it's unfortunately typically quite short in duration. We're talking about residential care. You're talking about two and a half years.
- 17:55on average that someone might be in that situation or needing high levels of care as a side point but the actions will tell us that the you know life expectancy is ever increasing but that that frail period isn't really significantly increasing and so yes it's uncertain we don't know when it's going to happen we don't know what it's going to look like exactly but it's
- 18:19It doesn't last forever. And as I say, there are means-tested supports in place. And so, yeah, for me, there's a few things that are really, really important that should give advisors and their clients peace of mind that aged care funding needs will be met in the future. Number one, you want to ensure that your living expenses are covered no matter what.
- 18:41Ideally, that's through a combination of things like the age pension and some sort of income that simply is never going to run out. I favour an innovative retroning income stream, sometimes called an IRS, to do that for a couple of reasons because it maximises the amount of income you can get from an amount of capital. It never runs out. But it also will increase your eligibility for the age care – sorry, eligibility for the age pension –
- 19:06But similarly, it can increase your eligibility for support under similar aged care means testing frameworks. And so there's that double benefit. So your baseline expenses are met no matter how long you and your spouse live. That's a really important point.
- 19:23Then you look at your next need, which is your lifestyle. And as mentioned, you can reasonably confidently assume that you're going to have a transition from lifestyle to care. And so there is going to be some funding for that. Of course, it's wonderful to have a residential home paid off. It gives us a lot of flexibility, not just if we need to sell it, but there are other ways to access the equity in the home.
- 19:52And expect to see more solutions and strategies come to market in coming years, more flexible ways to access that equity, besides just a reverse mortgage, for example, allowing, for example, couples to age in place or one spouse to stay in the home, but still tapping into that equity. We have such large...
- 20:14stores of residential equity in Australia relative to international comparisons. And it's really crazy of us not to be better utilising those assets. So for me, if you have those three things, a lifetime income stream, including the age pension,
- 20:32allocation for your living expenses, lifestyle expenses that can help create the uplift and then the peace of mind of a home that really a lot of the funding possibilities covered. Yeah. And we tend to use that sort of approach here from a long-term planning of that layering of different income sources and then there's also, I forget what we're talking about in terms of the cash flow requirements
- 21:02there's those large one-off expenses as well. But that's not always where we see the gap is the large one-off cost. It is those things that build up over time and those things that can be transient. So when we're looking at keeping people at home longer, we find that there's increasing costs which are somewhat government subsidised, but things like transport and cleaning and gardening. And obviously with the recent changes, a lot of those sorts of
- 21:29incidental expenses, the nice-to-haves aren't as funded from the government, so there is still more of a reliance on individuals funding that. And then there's those larger ticket items where, you know, if we do have to look at funding a RAD and have the capacity to do that versus it being funded from cash flow. So, yeah, the other thing which is often –
- 21:52There's not a lot of familiarity with these new style of solutions, but we are seeing at North a greater take-up of these deferred IRAS solutions, so innovative for time and income stream deferred. So just for those who might not be familiar, you can park your money in one of these, and it'd be a modest amount. It has zero income test while it's deferred, and you could defer it fairly indefinitely. So there's no income test.
- 22:20It has a reduced and it can be as low as zero asset test. You can get that down to zero. There's no minimum drawdown requirement. And so I literally can park there. And yet it's in a tax-free environment. You can invest it however you like typically. And so on a platform, for example, you could invest it for growth and it could be there to fund.
- 22:43a DAP or other sort of out-of-pocket costs into the future. And in the meantime, you're getting this peace of mind. It's actually helping you on Centrelink eligibility and there's no requirement to draw down. So there's new strategies and solutions available to advisors that can really be tailored for all sorts of situations. Yeah.
- 23:07And I think from when we were talking about this solution and there's different ways that it can be put together and one of the key things that you were intimating was the earlier that we start planning for that, it doesn't have to be when aged care is on the horizon but,
- 23:24But these can be tools that could be leveraged really early in the retirement planning journey, even before retirement or when transition to retirement is being considered. So that you're actually positioning yourself well for down the track and that it's also more of a…
- 23:43It is a retirement planning piece, but it's also bringing the potential for having to fund aged care, that conversation ahead of time too, and actually starting to introduce that earlier in the conversation as well, would you say? Yeah, exactly right. But even more powerfully, you talk about bringing things forward. To me, the ideal situation is you actually get your clients so confident.
- 24:06in their today and in their tomorrow, that legacy, that final ill, you can actually have a conversation much earlier about that. And for me, that's a wonderful conversation to bring forward if we can manage it. We think about the beneficiaries who are likely to be inheriting money
- 24:26when they're in their 60s and even 70s, it's not particularly useful. And it certainly would be a lot more helpful when the beneficiaries are raising their children, struggling to get into a first home, paying school fees, that sort of thing. You've got the twin benefit of...
- 24:46of helping your beneficiaries, your kids and grandkids perhaps when they need it more. But the clients, the retirees themselves get to enjoy the enjoyment. They get to see the effect that their legacy is having as opposed to it's a bit crass perhaps, but you just decide to give with a warm hand instead of a cold one.
- 25:07I think when we were chatting, I actually really loved that. I was curious about the design of what North had put together and really came back to my question was around, well, where did the structuring of it and what drove coming up with a solution like this? And I'll let you answer because it was something that really resonated with me around what you've seen historically has been happening and what the shift is.
- 25:36is and what we've, you know, one of the outcomes that might come from it, which is in part what you just were talking about then. Yeah. I mean, we call it My North Lifetime, but we didn't actually set out to be solving for longevity risk, which is what people typically would think is the main purpose of what we've delivered. It's not about longevity risk at all. It's about adequacy risk, i.e. people just having enough to spend confidently. Yeah.
- 26:05My journey in this space started 10, 15 years ago or something at other funds where I analysed how much people were inadvertently leaving behind from their suku when they passed away. And it was about 90% on average people are leaving them. Extraordinarily high, a lot higher than we would have expected. Yeah.
- 26:26Exactly right. And why? Well, it's not because they planned to. It's not because they wanted to leave as much of their super as possible to their kids. That's what was happening inadvertently. They weren't spending because it's entirely rational. You don't know how long you're going to live. You don't know what the investment returns in the future are going to be. And so we're prudent. There's another myth floating around and people blowing all their super so they can join an age pension. That's nonsense.
- 26:50That doesn't happen to any significant degree at the bottom end perhaps when they didn't have much super to start with. But by and large, most people are actually spending less than they actually can afford to because they have what we call furrow, the fear of running out. And so for me, we launched My North Lifetime to stop furrow, to give people the confidence to spend.
- 27:14It's not about long 0D residual. I'm thinking they're going to live to 105 or anything like that. It's just simply they want to know that they can spend confidently and these sorts of strategies allow them to do that. And the wonderful thing we're seeing at North is clients with an IRA strategy as part of their portfolio are spending 60% more than the non-lifetime clients because they've...
- 27:38overcome that fear of running out. They're spending more confidently on themselves, maybe on their beneficiaries. They're getting more age pension as well, which is lovely. And so that's absolutely the fundamental driver.
- 27:50Yeah, and look, I definitely, frontline advisors, see it time and time and time again where it doesn't matter how many ways you illustrate it to certain clients and maybe it is certain demographics of clients that they will always have a fear that they're going to run out. Even when they've got significant wealth, that's always, they still want to see it re-demonstrated and the outcome hasn't changed yet.
- 28:15But you can't change that inherent thing that's in them. It's one of those things that's really difficult to shift, that fear that they will outlive their money. And it's really one of the leading questions when clients come to us for retirement planning is, how much do I need and will I have enough? Am I going to outlive my money? You know, the burning questions that people have.
- 28:36That's right. And if we talk about lengthening life expectancy and stuff, people think, oh, that doesn't apply to me. It's not longevity risk that they fear. And longevity risk is separate from the fear of running out of money. You've got people who are unhealthy and are certain they're going to die by the age of 75, but they're still afraid of running out of money at 74.
- 28:59And they still think that when they ask, you know, 74, they're not going to spend all the remaining money just in case they live to 76 or 77. Yeah. So it's not about living a very, very long time, but it's just simply giving people a confidence they're not going to run out no matter when that might come. Yeah.
- 29:18We've had a philosophy for many years in the business which was live for today but provide for tomorrow. And it's more around go out there and live and enjoy yourself today, not at the sake of tomorrow. As in, don't go and put it all on black, for example. But it's also not at the sake of future enjoyment. So it's got to be a trade-off of you're not compromising your enjoyment today because you've got that fear. But it's also not compromising the future by going for bust or going for...
- 29:47So it is that sort of fine balancing act. Yes. I think we've touched on the three L's, which I do really like about that because I do think from an aged care perspective, it does really come back or sorry, the three L's or five L's, isn't it? That it really does.
- 30:08touch on there's so many aspects of that, you know, liquidity, living expenses, reduced lifestyle spending and that legacy planning. And I know that a lot of those things and especially the legacy planning can be really emotional. People do have that thing that they want to preserve today.
- 30:28their home or protect the inheritance, which is understandable, but sometimes it can conflict with their own care and comfort. How do you see clients being able to balance up that, their choice and the dignity and keep maintaining that today with the legacy tomorrow or even that enjoyment and that fulfillment of being able to hand it over early and have that living legacy where they actually get to support family and see their
- 30:54see the enjoyment of it while they're here rather than it being when they're gone. Yeah. I mean, look, we do see pretty stark differences between generations and also between ethnicities and different ethnic backgrounds have different approaches and, you know,
- 31:10some European, for example, would absolutely sacrifice a lot of their enjoyment and comfort to give as much as possible. And that would be a measure of success for them to pass on as much of a legacy as they could and all power to them. We are seeing clearly, though, that the trend and research is that people are less and less wanting to leave as much as possible to the next generation. Of course, most parents would, of course, love to,
- 31:39to support their children how they can. But the research for me clearly shows, of course, they want to leave the family home to the kids, some other assets. For me, by and large, the research says super is there and is generally seen as designed to support themselves. And if there's some left, sure, but they don't have a specific bequest motive from their super generally, unlike, say, the family home or maybe investment properties or other assets.
- 32:07Things that have got those more emotional attachments to them. Yeah, exactly right. But having said that, like I was referencing before, I think it's most important is your client is your client, not the beneficiaries and sure look after their needs according to your client's wishes.
- 32:27But, you know, I do this with my own mother. I'd be encouraging her to just enjoy as much as you can. I'm still trying to convince her to take a business class, international trip. She hasn't yet. Yeah. Sometimes as advisors we...
- 32:43Clients have the capability of doing that, but it's almost us giving them permission. You know, it's saying, oh, I hope you're booking yourself up the front of the plane. And they kind of go, oh, I hadn't thought about that. And it's because they've got that fear in them. And it was like, they don't need our permission per se, but they need our encouragement sometimes to enjoy themselves and travel in comfort rather than it being at the sake of their comfort today for people.
- 33:12providing for that legacy as well, which I don't think any of us would really prefer our parents to be travelling uncomfortably if they've got the means to do it comfortably for our benefit, I think. No, I mean, look, I really, in a period, I've been trying to convince my mum to just spend more and she got to a point where she says, oh, I've got nothing. I don't need to spend more. I've got everything I need. I said, what are you talking about? You love to travel. Why don't you travel more? She goes, oh, I can't afford it. I'm like...
- 33:42People trap themselves into sort of logic paths that are hard to break. And, you know, last year I think she did four international holidays. Yeah. Did she have a plus one for you? No, she goes. She takes her friends and she does all sorts of things. She's taken some of her grandkids on trips.
- 34:01Yeah, she's well into her 80s now. Yeah. And she will start slowing down. But I think we'll all be successful. We're going to help our clients and our family to really enjoy retirement as much as possible.
- 34:15And look, I'm sitting here smiling away because I think about hearing stories like that. And the greatest gift that we can have are the memories that we can create. So going on those family trips and having those moments as they do, our parents will inherently get older and they will slow down and...
- 34:35that those opportunities to go and enjoy those moments and go and have those experiences and those shared experiences, that's a lifetime of memories and no amount of money can buy that when those moments are no longer an opportunity to be had. So, yeah, I think they're really important to incorporate and to encourage clients to have. I think that's a good – I want to spend a moment maybe thinking about where –
- 35:04then there's those sorts of things that are planned and encouraged. But there's also hidden costs. And we have touched on previously about when people, when families first start thinking about aged care, they focus in on what the obvious fees are. But reality is in practice that,
- 35:22There are many costs that sit around that care journey. And when we're looking at modelling and thinking about those costs, what are some of the hidden costs that you think they should be thinking about when they're planning for their future? Yeah.
- 35:37I mean, yeah, there's obviously the actual health expenditure, the direct clinical care, et cetera, that's sort of what comes to mind. But there's the assistance around the home of doing things that you previously were doing yourself and can no longer do, the cleaning, the cooking, just mobility. There might be modifications for the family home to make it accessible for a
- 35:59a walker or a wheelchair or other devices. And sometimes that does actually require a different place, but yeah, you just can't handle the front steps or the upstairs bedroom anymore. And so there can be some, some transitional costs of a capital nature that,
- 36:16that can sort of creep in. So, yeah, it's important to take stock about what they all can be. Like I said before, it's important to be aware, but not necessarily alarmed. As long as you do have some of those building blocks and sort of reserves or strategies in place, it's not something to necessarily – you don't need to –
- 36:38you know, have a million dollars parked for just in case, but it's still prudent to make sure some of those hidden costs or unexpected costs are capable. Yeah, and thought about ahead of time because I think some of those things can be, we see it all the time, it happens, they're an afterthought, whereas if they had been a forethought and they are preventative things as well, so those things like crab rails and ramps and, you know,
- 37:06getting more support around the home. And I think sometimes those hidden costs can be, yes, we've got, and I think that we have a really huge amount of government funding that is available. The challenge is that the wait times at the moment are really long, even when you have got approval. So getting the approval and getting the assessment is one thing, but then also getting the actual funding physically available to you and then finding the supports.
- 37:33So sometimes it's that planning for private support while you're waiting for that more formal care and that can come at a cost. But it's also something that means that those things don't have to be delayed and delayed.
- 37:49They're practical expenses that can promote wellbeing and safe living at home as well. And I think we're just generally seeing a lot of family support being out there and
- 38:04Do you think there is such a thing as sort of care inflation and factoring that in to costs? And we talked about inflationary pressures and the cost of living increasing. What about the rising cost of care? Is that running at a different rate to other lifestyle expenses that we have?
- 38:24Certainly, if you're not specifically related to care, but ASFA have a look at their retirement income standards for both comfortable and modest. And you do see those when they have a look at the basket of goods and services.
- 38:41needed by retirees, you actually do see that they have been rising faster than inflation. It's a transparent sort of methodology they have. You can go and have a look at how many meals out per week and how many overseas trips and how many cats and whatever else are in that budget. But certainly that has been rising faster than inflation because of the inflation.
- 39:03some of the specifics associated with aging. And you raised the point about that waiting period. I'm not sure if your listeners are how aware, but the average waiting period for a care at home package is now over 12 months. And so it really is important to have some flexibility in the plan and be able to accommodate those waiting periods.
- 39:29Absolutely. And I think the things that I've been seeing really prevalent lately is that even when you get into the MyAgeCare system, because there's a grading about the...
- 39:44how acute your need is, they are prioritising things, but it's even the wait time just to get the assessment in the first place. And so somebody who could have a high need or if you're a medium need, you just have to wait it out until your ticket comes up to actually get the assessment to see if you're eligible in the first place and then the wait time starts when you've got that approval as well. So we're really talking when we're seeing 12 months for the funding to be
- 40:1412 to 18 months when you take into account the wait time to actually get the assessment in the first place just through the system. It would be remiss of me not to mention we've recently bought a lifetime income stream, a lifetime pension to market at A&P that actually is designed for specifically that particular need there. So it pays income for life.
- 40:35But once someone becomes eligible for medium to high level care, so level five to level eight, it'll actually increase their income payments immediately by 20%. So you're not having to wait for the package to actually be assigned. As soon as you're eligible, the payments arise. And so I think and hope that,
- 40:52more of these sorts of funding mechanisms will come to market to provide greater peace of mind to accommodate the changing nature of retirement spending to better match the funding for the need. Yes.
- 41:08And I think I do really, that approach of having it underpinning a lifetime annuity and giving that certainty, helping to remove that fear of running out of money and just really as that, considering it as part of that baseline or that layering effect.
- 41:27can really help with some clients with planning for those later care needs. And hearing about that solution from you, that's something that I was, my ears pricked up. I thought, oh, that's a really interesting one that eligibility, just eligibility alone for a home care package might provide that solution.
- 41:49it gives that uplift and not having to actually have the funding there. So that would make a really big difference. There's a lot of people who, I mean, even with the changes, having to put their hand in their pocket anyway. So for things that are not clinical care costs, which are
- 42:05100% covered by the government and then you start moving down if you're a partially funded or self-funded aged care recipient or retiree, that the amount that you have to put your hand in your pocket for the things that aren't considered clinical care, this would be a really big boost in those scenarios. So yeah, that's interesting.
- 42:27That's exactly why there's a real need there and a level of uncertainty. It won't pay for everything, but it's something that helps. It's, again, about giving people the confidence that there's strategies in place for their needs to be covered, not just for current needs, but into the future.
- 42:51Yeah, I think it's a really powerful thing to have that there because it's not just the financial aspects of it. It is underpinning the emotional side of how they can handle that, whether it's now or down the track as well. Rounding that out, I think, is there anything that you feel that advisors should think about with that balancing act around having flexible capital, secure income,
- 43:18future care needs and, you know, any thoughts about bringing that together? Maybe I'll finish back where I sort of started a while ago and that is, you know, there's a Nobel award-winning economist, Jan Tilbergen, who talked about you can't solve multiple problems with a single solution.
- 43:39you can't do it efficiently and so you're going to be making trade-offs. And so trying to solve everything with just one strategy, like an account-based pension, you're not putting in place an optimal satisfaction of each of those different needs and addressing each of the risks that retirees face. And so, you know,
- 43:57you know, layering the income as we've discussed, having reserves in place like the family home and, you know, other assets and then just having a more disciplined and specific approach for each of the needs, I think will go a long way to giving your clients the peace of mind and in reality to be able to, you know, sort of flex with differing spend needs as they occur through retirement, you know, up to and including aged care.
- 44:25That's great. And what I might do is just even move on just to residential aged care and some of the accommodation decisions. It's been widely quoted that the national average for a RAD is around $470,000. But the final number obviously being higher or lower depending on the location, provider, it's always a six-figure contract.
- 44:50financial decision. I'm more commonly saying around the $600,000 or $700,000 mark, but it does vary. So for a lot of families, that almost immediately has to bring or does bring the family home into the conversation. Is there things that advisors should be thinking about when they've got uncertainty there from a planning perspective when they're setting out, that there's anything you can give insights on that?
- 45:19I expect you can get better insights than I can. But for me, there's typically not just one avenue to go down. Yes, the RAD is a lot of money. It's a confronting figure and typically will involve the family at home.
- 45:38But not everyone will be going into residential care. A rat is not the only way you can pay for that. You can pay the rental with a dab. There will be a trend more and more to in-home care. That's certainly the policy direction and where the funding will more and more go. And I think that's where there's an alignment there of...
- 45:59community expectations and retiree desires that will sort of go into place. And even the uncertainties of, you know, will both spouses be alive at that point in time? Will one of them still be remaining in a family home?
- 46:16As I mentioned, there are other ways. I mean, the government's own home equity scheme is actually exceptional value. Obviously, that doesn't give you a lump sum to pay a RAD, but it can certainly be very effective at helping with a DAP. And, yeah, there are...
- 46:35in my mind, very good reverse mortgage solutions in the market. And I expect to see even more solutions, more flexible equity release solutions come to the market. That's a very obvious place. And certainly you'd expect something I personally and people will be investigating and,
- 46:56I think providing greater support to retirees. So, yeah, it's not only one choice you have with a RAD. It's confronting, but don't be overly alarmed that you've got no choices.
- 47:11And I think it really does. It is that intersection or that where financial and the emotional sides of these decisions, they just absolutely collide in that space. It's, you know, the family home isn't just an asset. It's very rarely just an asset because it represents so much for the senior. It's about them, their independence and power.
- 47:37in part their identity, there's all the memories and the family histories. And when we were talking earlier about legacy, legacy isn't always just about a number and an amount. Sometimes it is the physical asset and the family home is something that they –
- 47:53a lot of seniors do want to pass that over. So when, if it, they are deciding around renting or add out or, you know, selling it, keeping it empty, even it's really, or just, they're not just making a cashflow decision or a,
- 48:09an asset-based decision, it is that really emotional decision and often they're feeling under pressure. So I think that's where earlier advice and also understanding their options can really make a difference for families and allow them just to have a moment to pause and take a breath and actually not feel like they're cornered when they've got all of those other aspects of that decision to be considering as well,
- 48:39well beyond just a financial, simply a financial one. I think obviously we've talked a lot about cash flow and the importance of modelling this early and starting the conversation early before the fall, before the hospital stay, before, you know, ideally we should be starting this before the, you know, before the incident that means they might be just thinking about selling the home, I should say, and that there's urgent care required.
- 49:08I think some of the things that you've talked around, modelling those cash flows and that essential piece gives you the opportunity to stress test things, modelling things like home care and how they might be funding that, residential care and the different accommodation options. And when you've got couples...
- 49:28We can't pretend to know when those things are going to happen, but I think it's a lot to carry for families. So I think it's the key message here that having aged care modelled early and always a part of any retirement plan, not just added on when the crisis occurs or thoughts on that.
- 49:51I think it's worth having a conversation from the start and it's obviously worth involving the kids, right? Because, you know, in a lot of cases, as you well know, the decisions may well be being made by the children or in conjunction with the children.
- 50:11So I think having a conversation about this is the possibility that might happen, this is the effect, and these are the strategies we have in place to at least take the financial pressure away from that situation. As you point out, it's going to be an emotional decision for all sorts of reasons that have nothing to do with money. So let's at least make sure that money is not a significant area of concern at that point, adding to the burden.
- 50:38Yes. And so I think my practical takeaways that I've heard today are not to assume government funded care will cover everything and look at some modelling the gaps that the gap that clients might need to fund themselves and
- 50:56Avoid treating retirement spending as it's one flat line or the retirement smile. Thinking about those clear buckets as well, that liquidity, living, lifestyle, later and legacy. I really love the five elves. And also to think about stress testing, what home care and residential scenarios might look like. And discussing with the family, the family home before it becomes an urgent decision to
- 51:26And most importantly, is starting these conversations early. And so that gives families the opportunity for more proactive planning and clients a lot more choice too. So Ben, if I had for the listeners here and people tuning in, if they had one message that you would really love them to take away from today's episode, what would you want that to be? Yeah.
- 51:54I think like Luke was just trying to say just now, you know, when it comes down to it, retirement and care is about so much more than money. Let's make money the least important, least pressing, least urgent, least complex part of the retirement so that on the one hand they can be enjoying the active years, but when they're part
- 52:20The frail years come that at least money is not the concern. That takes advisor preparation, planning with your client and putting in place the strategies to give everyone peace of mind. Yeah, I think that's excellent and great advice and guidance to take away there.
- 52:40I think I'm taking away from this that just making sure that we don't consider aged care to be a separate event that sits outside of retirement planning, that it is a part of the retirement journey. And from your thorough example, one of our goals should be to make clients not afraid of what the future costs of care is and afraid of running out and help them do planning to make sure that they're more confident
- 53:10of enjoying retirement now and preserving those choices that they might want to have later. So I think when families plan early, they only have so many more options. And also, having from an advice perspective, doing that earlier modelling and asking better questions will mean that they do start to think about those five L's and before there is a crisis point and be able to proactively plan as a family. So
- 53:38Ben, thank you very much for joining me today and thank you to everyone listening as well. We look forward to you joining us again for the final episode in our aged care podcast series. Thank you. Thanks all.