Latest / The Teaching Table / Change Management in Higher Education: Part Two
Transcript
- 0:02Maggie Grady: Welcome to the CATT Teaching Table Podcast, where we explore innovative teaching methods and dynamic educational strategies.
- 0:09Maggie Grady: Hosted by the University at Buffalo's Office of Curriculum, Assessment and Teaching Transformation, otherwise known as CATT, and supported by the Genteels' Excellence in Teaching Fund.
- 0:19Maggie Grady: This podcast is dedicated to highlighting the journeys toward educational excellence.
- 0:24Maggie Grady: I'm your host, Maggie Grady, Instructional Innovation Project Manager for the Office of Curriculum, Assessment and Teaching Transformation.
- 0:32Maggie Grady: Today I'm joined by Tyler Bauer, UB's Organizational Change Management Specialist.
- 0:37Maggie Grady: Okay, so let's move over a little bit and talk about how change also shows up in departmental or program shifts, like curriculum revisions, assessment changes, and new accessibility practices.
- 0:50Maggie Grady: These are changes that have strong values behind them, but also have real workload implications.
- 0:57Maggie Grady: When you're supporting change like that, how do you approach building buy-in?
- 1:03Tyler Bauer: When it comes to change and buy-in, I usually like to talk about two types of changes.
- 1:08Tyler Bauer: There are imposed changes, which are usually something where it feels like it's forced upon us.
- 1:14Tyler Bauer: It's sudden, it's quick, and it's usually saying, you have to do this now, and now you have to embrace it.
- 1:19Tyler Bauer: Usually, we get anxious and we get angry by that.
- 1:22Tyler Bauer: And then there are intentional changes, which are usually where we're involving people throughout the process, and we're hearing their feedback as we go into it.
- 1:31Tyler Bauer: We want to make sure everyone's voices are heard to make sure that this is efficient moving forward.
- 1:37Tyler Bauer: Obviously, when I'm describing those two types of changes, people then assume, well, intentional changes are the best.
- 1:44Tyler Bauer: I mean, that's what we try to aim for, and that's true.
- 1:47Tyler Bauer: But the truth is that in our setting, sometimes imposed changes are just a natural part of conversations, or we didn't mean to make them imposed.
- 1:55Tyler Bauer: For instance, let's say an example could be from the SUNY system: we find out there's a new policy from SUNY, and the next thing you know, we find out about it and say we need to get this accomplished within the next week, and we need to make sure it's mandated moving forward.
- 2:11Tyler Bauer: That might make us really angry and anxious, and we could sit here and say, they don't understand what's going on, or any of those different pieces.
- 2:19Tyler Bauer: But in reality, what SUNY did is they formed a committee of maybe close to 50 people.
- 2:24Tyler Bauer: They sat down, they hashed this out, they spoke to other universities, and they spoke to experts here at our university for them to come up with this new policy.
- 2:33Tyler Bauer: So for them, this was intentional.
- 2:35Tyler Bauer: This was not something that was imposed.
- 2:37Tyler Bauer: And that's the problem that I think happens a lot here in higher education: we think everything is imposed, when in reality there's been a lot of thought put into a lot of these different areas.
- 2:48Tyler Bauer: So that's something I tell people about buy-in: take it with a grain of salt.
- 2:53Tyler Bauer: Let them understand that this is something that's going to grow; it's not something that just came out of nowhere, and it wasn't a random thought.
- 3:01Tyler Bauer: All people have a strong sense of control, and with that sense of control, we tend to predict the future.
- 3:07Tyler Bauer: Because we're predicting the future, we set expectations.
- 3:10Tyler Bauer: So an example would be like, hey, Maggie, do you want to come to a party tonight that I'm throwing?
- 3:16Tyler Bauer: Automatically, in your mind, you're creating expectations of what that party would be like.
- 3:21Tyler Bauer: How many people are there?
- 3:22Tyler Bauer: Am I going to talk to anyone?
- 3:24Tyler Bauer: What should I wear?
- 3:25Tyler Bauer: All these different things go through your mind in order for you to predict what's going to happen next.
- 3:31Tyler Bauer: The tricky part with this is that when we set those expectations, if we go to that party and it doesn't meet our expectations, we're upset.
- 3:39Tyler Bauer: But if it does meet our expectations, we're happy.
- 3:42Tyler Bauer: So if we know that exists, if we know that people naturally make those expectations, when we talk about changes, this is where we can set the expectations of what this looks like.
- 3:52Tyler Bauer: A common error that I see is you'll have someone trying to get buy-in from others and say things like, this is going to make your life ten times easier.
- 4:01Tyler Bauer: Ten times easier means something different for every single person.
- 4:05Tyler Bauer: You set an expectation in others' minds, and you don't know what that expectation was.
- 4:10Tyler Bauer: So now let's say the project was successful and it was only four times better.
- 4:14Tyler Bauer: You didn't reach their expectation because you said it was going to be ten times better.
- 4:19Tyler Bauer: So we need to be very clear when we're trying to get buy-in: what are the expectations that we're setting?
- 4:25Tyler Bauer: That goes back to when we talked a little bit about success and how we measure it.
- 4:30Tyler Bauer: What does success look like when we actually launch this and it comes to fruition?
- 4:36Maggie Grady: Okay, so in a practical sense, how do you help a project leader map out stakeholders and understand what different groups need?
- 4:44Tyler Bauer: That's actually one of my favorite parts of working with individual project leaders.
- 4:48Tyler Bauer: The reason why is because we really have to understand the processes that go into what exactly we're trying to change.
- 4:55Tyler Bauer: So let's say we're announcing some sort of initiative.
- 4:58Tyler Bauer: My goal then would be to meet individually with that project leader or with a team and walk through the entire process together to understand who it is impacting throughout the process.
- 5:09Tyler Bauer: Then we basically write those people, or the group names, down so that now we have every single person who's going to be impacted written down on a list.
- 5:17Tyler Bauer: These are the people that we need to talk to.
- 5:19Tyler Bauer: Once we know that, then we also think about the nature and organizational structure within higher education.
- 5:26Tyler Bauer: So not only are you talking with those individual people, who are their supervisors?
- 5:30Tyler Bauer: Who do they report to in any type of way?
- 5:32Tyler Bauer: Because they need to make sure that they're impacted.
- 5:35Tyler Bauer: So now we have to put those people's names down too.
- 5:38Tyler Bauer: Once we have all these written down, we then write down: what is the change for that individual, what is not changing, and what do they need to know?
- 5:46Tyler Bauer: That then helps build out essentially what exactly we need from a stakeholder analysis and needs-gap analysis.
- 5:52Tyler Bauer: We then try to map this out for us to think, all right, these are our people that we know are going to be impacted.
- 5:59Tyler Bauer: These are the people we know we have to have a conversation with, or they need to know how this is going to be, or they just need to know from a high level because they just need to be aware.
- 6:09Tyler Bauer: So now we can actually get to the strategy piece where we can actually build something.
- 6:14Maggie Grady: How do you help teams distinguish between resistance that needs support versus a real risk that needs a completely different plan?
- 6:24Tyler Bauer: So there are five different mindsets, and I want to be very clear: we go through all these different processes, so we don't want to label someone as a certain mindset and that's it.
- 6:34Tyler Bauer: This is based on research from Prosci.
- 6:36Tyler Bauer: The first mindset is victim.
- 6:37Tyler Bauer: The victim mindset is usually someone who says, you know, these types of changes, they always happen to me.
- 6:43Tyler Bauer: It's always me that's impacted.
- 6:45Tyler Bauer: They don't understand all the stress that it puts on me, all the different work that I have.
- 6:50Tyler Bauer: And you know what?
- 6:50Tyler Bauer: I have so much going on.
- 6:52Tyler Bauer: I feel as if they just don't understand exactly what's going on, and they make me feel as if I don't even matter.
- 6:58Tyler Bauer: It just leads down this pipeline, and they just keep going.
- 7:01Tyler Bauer: Once they're done talking to you, they'll go to the next person and start that whole thing again.
- 7:06Tyler Bauer: They don't really have resistance toward the change; it's more subjective.
- 7:10Tyler Bauer: It's not the actual thing that we're trying to implement.
- 7:13Tyler Bauer: It's usually something along the lines of the emotional piece they have in regard to feeling like they're losing something.
- 7:20Tyler Bauer: So if we're interacting with people like that, it's important for us to validate emotions because, at the end of the day, that's what they're looking for.
- 7:28Tyler Bauer: They're looking for someone to validate those types of emotions in order for us to move forward.
- 7:33Tyler Bauer: The second is a critic mindset.
- 7:35Tyler Bauer: Critic mindsets are usually the people who go like this: you know, I reviewed your 50-page document, and I noticed on page four you missed a period at the end of that sentence.
- 7:45Tyler Bauer: Therefore, if you are not thinking about and focusing on the finer details in regard to this document, how are you focusing on the finer details when it comes to the change?
- 7:54Tyler Bauer: So they take something objective and try to nullify the entire experience.
- 7:58Tyler Bauer: They are usually vocal.
- 7:59Tyler Bauer: Both critics and victims are vocal.
- 8:01Tyler Bauer: When you work with a critic, critics are usually the ones who are able to pick up on your risks early on.
- 8:07Tyler Bauer: Usually, what I tell people is, when you're working with someone who has a critic mindset, make sure you try to bring them into the fold of figuring out how we can actually attach this to a project.
- 8:18Tyler Bauer: Before, you mentioned people who might be constantly tapped for projects because they are seen as the good ones.
- 8:24Tyler Bauer: Critics usually are seen as not being the good ones.
- 8:27Tyler Bauer: They're the ones that people avoid because they tend to make a lot of noise.
- 8:31Tyler Bauer: In reality, they are your best advocates when it comes to changes.
- 8:34Tyler Bauer: So usually I tell people critics are the ones that you want to work with the most in order to bring them in as part of it.
- 8:41Tyler Bauer: The third is a bystander.
- 8:42Tyler Bauer: What do bystanders do?
- 8:43Tyler Bauer: Nothing.
- 8:44Tyler Bauer: They stay silent.
- 8:45Tyler Bauer: You say, is everyone okay?
- 8:46Tyler Bauer: And that's it.
- 8:47Tyler Bauer: Then you think the meeting's all great and you kind of go about your day.
- 8:51Tyler Bauer: Bystanders are the way they are for a multitude of reasons.
- 8:54Tyler Bauer: It could be lack of trust, a lack of feeling secure, or not understanding why we're there to begin with.
- 9:00Tyler Bauer: There could be a lot of different pieces, but bystanders are the ones that can easily disrupt an entire change initiative because you don't know it exists.
- 9:08Tyler Bauer: You don't know the resistance is there.
- 9:10Tyler Bauer: With bystanders, you take something small for them to get involved with so they understand how they fit into this larger-scale initiative, and then we start building the blocks from there.
- 9:21Tyler Bauer: The fourth is a charger.
- 9:22Tyler Bauer: A charger is the complete opposite of a bystander.
- 9:25Tyler Bauer: The charger just forces things through.
- 9:27Tyler Bauer: They'll say things like, well, the president and vice president said that this is something that needs to happen, so I'm going to make it happen whether you like it or not.
- 9:36Tyler Bauer: The thing with chargers is that they might be able to launch a project, but most likely we're redoing it after a year or two.
- 9:43Tyler Bauer: Usually chargers are linked to some type of philosophy of trying to move up.
- 9:47Tyler Bauer: Therefore, if we're working with a charger, we just have to make sure they understand: your reputation is on the line when it comes to this project.
- 9:55Tyler Bauer: We can do this in a way where we can make sure everyone feels supported throughout it.
- 10:00Tyler Bauer: It's just making them understand where it comes from.
- 10:03Tyler Bauer: The fifth and last one is a navigator.
- 10:05Tyler Bauer: Navigators are those easy ones.
- 10:06Tyler Bauer: They're the ones who are doing everything right.
- 10:09Tyler Bauer: They're leading efficiently, they're making sure people cope throughout the process, and they're leading with empathy.
- 10:16Tyler Bauer: The problem is, navigators burn out.
- 10:18Tyler Bauer: Once they are known as people who are good, we constantly go back to those same groups.
- 10:22Tyler Bauer: So when it comes to navigators, we just constantly have to remind them why we're doing this to begin with, what our goal is, and how we're all going toward that together.That was very quick, but those are the five different mindsets.
- 10:35Tyler Bauer: Once again, we shift.
- 10:36Tyler Bauer: There could be a day where I get asked something and I could turn around and be like, oh, here we go again.
- 10:42Tyler Bauer: I've got to do this again.
- 10:43Tyler Bauer: I've done this so many times before.
- 10:45Tyler Bauer: I jump into that victim mindset.
- 10:46Tyler Bauer: And then the next thing you know, I'm saying, well, you know what?
- 10:50Tyler Bauer: Here's this document, just read it, get it done, and then I have to do something by the end of the day, so we're going to make sure it's done by the end of the day.
- 10:58Tyler Bauer: Now I'm a charger.
- 10:59Tyler Bauer: It's just naturally what happens over time.
- 11:01Tyler Bauer: The main reason why we bring it up is just to have awareness of where not only other people are, but where we are when it comes to these change initiatives.
- 11:10Maggie Grady: What makes communication effective when change is happening?
- 11:14Tyler Bauer: I think communication usually is assumed to be just some kind of message that goes out, when in reality it's a whole cycle.
- 11:21Tyler Bauer: We know from research there are certain messages that work well with different audiences when it comes to a change.
- 11:28Tyler Bauer: We have to tailor our messages for people to make sure that they understand how this is going to impact them in a certain way.
- 11:35Tyler Bauer: So we know from research, when it comes to communication, that people like hearing certain messages based on their role.
- 11:42Tyler Bauer: An example would be a frontline employee.
- 11:45Tyler Bauer: Frontline employees usually, when a change is introduced to them, ask first: why are we doing this?
- 11:50Tyler Bauer: Then the second question is: how does this benefit me?
- 11:53Tyler Bauer: So if we know that those two questions are what people are asking, how do we tailor our communication to make sure we're answering those questions ahead of time?
- 12:03Tyler Bauer: When it comes to our supervisors, supervisors have a different mentality.
- 12:07Tyler Bauer: Instead of asking why is this happening as the first question, the question is: what are the expectations that you have for me and my staff?
- 12:15Tyler Bauer: If we know that's what supervisors want to know, we can tailor those messages to make sure that's what they hear.
- 12:21Tyler Bauer: Now, let's say you have leaders talking to each other about change initiatives.
- 12:26Tyler Bauer: Usually the question they ask is: what is my responsibility toward this initiative, to make sure I'm doing what I need to do for my unit to navigate it?
- 12:34Tyler Bauer: These are all different little pieces that we know from research exist when it comes to communication.
- 12:40Tyler Bauer: We also know that certain pieces of communication people like to hear from others as well.
- 12:46Tyler Bauer: So when it comes to the why and the benefit, people like to hear that from a leader.
- 12:50Tyler Bauer: They like to hear that from someone who runs a unit.
- 12:53Tyler Bauer: But when it comes to how this is going to impact me in my day-to-day work, people like hearing that from their supervisor.
- 13:00Tyler Bauer: So these are all the things we have to think about when we're starting to create some sort of communication plan.
- 13:07Tyler Bauer: If we know that all those different pieces from research and from all these different areas lead to successful change, how are we making sure that those elements can be filtered in with our specific initiative?
- 13:19Tyler Bauer: That's what we spend a lot of time talking through.
- 13:22Maggie Grady: So let's wrap it up, and I'm going to give you two quick-fire questions.
- 13:22Maggie Grady: What's one small step someone leading change can take this week to improve the chances of success?
- 13:34Tyler Bauer: If you're leading a change, something quick you can ask the impacted people, just straight up, is: what's one thing that would make this change easier?
- 13:42Tyler Bauer: The reason why is because it's quick.
- 13:44Tyler Bauer: It's something simple that you can ask.
- 13:46Tyler Bauer: It's something that's powerful as well because you're trying to enable them for success.
- 13:50Tyler Bauer: At the end of the day, you want to see them succeed, and you want to know: what are some things that I can do to make sure that you can be successful?
- 13:58Maggie Grady: Good advice on that.
- 14:00Maggie Grady: And quick-fire question number two: what's one mindset shift you hope people keep in mind when change feels difficult?
- 14:09Tyler Bauer: Change isn't just about progress.
- 14:11Tyler Bauer: It's really about the people, and it's about understanding our own emotions that go along with it.
- 14:16Tyler Bauer: If you were to think about it in that respect, it's just about trying to think: how do I have a growth mindset?
- 14:22Tyler Bauer: Sometimes these things, I can't change them, and sometimes they might be happening to me instead of with me, and understanding the difference between the two.
- 14:31Tyler Bauer: Once we can understand that, we can understand a little bit more of the things that we can control and can't control.
- 14:38Tyler Bauer: Change management in higher education is growing.
- 14:41Tyler Bauer: It's not something that is going to be going away anytime soon.
- 14:44Tyler Bauer: So if I were to give some parting thoughts, I would say something along the lines of: education has always been known for being innovative.
- 14:52Tyler Bauer: We've always been known for having to change and think about the newest additions.
- 14:57Tyler Bauer: And I think higher education is at a crossroads right now where we're going to have to change.
- 15:02Tyler Bauer: It's going to be something where all of us need to embrace a change mindset if we're going to be successful.
- 15:08Tyler Bauer: And it's not just thinking about our institution.
- 15:11Tyler Bauer: It's also really thinking about our students and how it's going to benefit our students in the long run.
- 15:17Tyler Bauer: So my parting thought is: embrace the changes that we have and make sure that you're an advocate individually and on your teams as you move forward.
- 15:26Maggie Grady: Tyler, thank you again for joining us and sharing your expertise.
- 15:30Maggie Grady: I really appreciate how grounded your approach is, especially in balancing progress with people's real workload and capacity.
- 15:38Maggie Grady: For our listeners, we will include follow-up resources and practical checklists in the episode notes.
- 15:45Maggie Grady: Thank you to our listeners for tuning in to this episode of the Teaching Table Podcast.
- 15:50Maggie Grady: If you enjoyed today's discussion, be sure to subscribe and leave us a review.
- 15:55Maggie Grady: We will be back soon with more conversations exploring the latest in teaching innovations and strategies.
- 16:02Maggie Grady: Until next time, teach well and teach accessibly.
- 16:06Maggie Grady: As always, be sure to connect with us online at buffalo.edu/catt, that's C-A-T-T, or email us at ubcatt@buffalo.edu.