Latest / The Morning Rundown / Court Green Light on Deportations, the Iraq Exit, and a Record $3B Gift
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I am on my second coffee, and my brain is still
- 0:18[Maya] buffering.
- 0:19[Maya] Medium roast, zero personality.
- 0:22[David] That's the most honest sentence anyone's said before 9:00 AM.
- 0:25[Maya] I try.
- 0:26[Maya] Welcome to the Morning Rundown.
- 0:27[Maya] I'm Maya, that's David, and we've got a big one today.
- 0:31[David] We do.
- 0:32[David] Three stories, and they all sneak up on the same question.
- 0:35[Maya] Which is?
- 0:36[David] When government moves fast or steps back entirely, who's left holding the
- 0:40[David] bag?
- 0:41[Maya] Ooh, okay.
- 0:42[Maya] So the Supreme Court is in there.
- 0:44[David] Yep, a brief order on deportations.
- 0:47[Maya] Brief, how brief?
- 0:48[Maya] Like a couple of sentences brief?
- 0:50[David] Brief enough that we'll spend real time on what it didn't say
- 0:53[David] and on what the justices wanna hear about in December.
- 0:56[Maya] Then there's Iraq and somebody else picking up the security job.
- 0:59[David] Exactly, and the people closest to it aren't all calm about it.
- 1:03[Maya] So no victory laps on that one.
- 1:05[David] And then a private donor drops a record $3 billion on higher
- 1:09[David] education.
- 1:10[Maya] Wait, really?
- 1:11[Maya] $3 billion from one giver?
- 1:13[David] Hold that thought, Maya.
- 1:14[David] I want you fresh for it.
- 1:15[Maya] Fine, fine.
- 1:17[Maya] So anyway, who decides and who pays?
- 1:20[Maya] Let's start with the biggest legal story of the day, the Supreme
- 1:23[Maya] Court and deportations.
- 1:25[Maya] Okay.
- 1:26[Maya] So Tuesday, the Supreme Court let the administration resume deportations to countries
- 1:31[Maya] that aren't even named in a person's removal order, for now.
- 1:34[David] "For now" is doing a lot of work there.
- 1:37[David] NPR reported it's a brief order.
- 1:39[David] No reasoning at all.
- 1:41[Maya] Wait, really?
- 1:41[Maya] Nothing?
- 1:42[Maya] No explanation?
- 1:43[David] Nothing, just the result, which is pretty normal for emergency orders, honestly,
- 1:47[David] but it leaves everybody guessing.
- 1:49[Maya] Right.
- 1:49[Maya] So what does it actually mean for a regular person caught up
- 1:52[Maya] in this?
- 1:53[David] Say someone's order says deport to country A.
- 1:56[David] Under this policy, the government can send them to country B instead,
- 2:00[David] a place they may have never lived in.
- 2:02[Maya] Oh, a lot of people changing their travel plans without a vote.
- 2:05[David] Not how I'd put it, but sure.
- 2:07[Maya] Is this a handful of people, or are we talking big numbers?
- 2:11[David] NBC's coverage gave some context.
- 2:13[David] It said thousands have been sent to third countries since January 2025,
- 2:17[David] including South Sudan, Eswatini, and Rwanda.
- 2:20[Maya] Those are not exactly next-door neighbors.
- 2:24[David] No, but NBC also cited a Migration Policy Institute estimate of about
- 2:28[David] 15,000 third-country deportations in 2025, mostly to Mexico.
- 2:33[David] So the far-flung destinations get the headlines, while the most of the
- 2:36[David] count was somewhere much closer.
- 2:38[David] And keep in mind, that's an estimate of the past, not a
- 2:40[David] forecast.
- 2:41[Maya] Okay, but this isn't the final word, is it?
- 2:44[David] No, the Court will hear full arguments in December, and the questions
- 2:48[David] it handed the parties are telling.
- 2:49[Maya] Such as?
- 2:50[David] First, whether lower courts even had the jurisdiction to order nationwide relief.
- 2:55[David] Second, whether the policy is legal at all or whether it violates
- 2:59[David] due process or the Torture Convention.
- 3:01[Maya] Huh.
- 3:02[Maya] So the jurisdiction question is almost its own fight.
- 3:05[David] It is.
- 3:06[David] A lot of the executive authority argument lives right there.
- 3:09[David] Who gets to stop a policy across the whole country, and how
- 3:12[David] fast?
- 3:13[Maya] And why does that matter beyond this one case?
- 3:16[David] Because if the answer is that lower courts can't, then the pace
- 3:19[David] of any challenge changes.
- 3:21[David] If they can, a single ruling can freeze a policy everywhere.
- 3:24[David] That's the tension the justices flagged.
- 3:26[Maya] So it's really two questions: Is the policy lawful, and who gets
- 3:30[Maya] to say so?
- 3:31[David] Right, and those can get separate answers.
- 3:33[Maya] Fair.
- 3:34[Maya] So what's the administration's actual argument?
- 3:37[Maya] Because I wanna hear it straight.
- 3:39[David] Simple version, if a receiving country gives assurances it will treat people
- 3:43[David] properly, that should be enough.
- 3:45[David] The executive branch does the diplomacy, and courts shouldn't second-guess every promise.
- 3:49[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 3:50[Maya] There's a real logic to that.
- 3:52[Maya] Foreign policy is the president's lane.
- 3:54[David] Totally.
- 3:55[David] The counter is whether a promise from a government is worth much
- 3:58[David] when nobody gets to check it.
- 4:00[Maya] And that's what the dissent was about?
- 4:02[David] Partly.
- 4:02[David] NBC News reported that the three liberal justices dissented from the unsigned
- 4:06[David] order, and the order blocks an appeals court ruling.
- 4:09[Maya] What did the appeals court say?
- 4:11[David] That the process was unlawful because people weren't given a real chance
- 4:14[David] to raise safety concerns before being sent to another country.
- 4:17[Maya] Okay, so that's the core.
- 4:18[Maya] Not whether the government can deport, but someone gets to say, "I'll
- 4:22[Maya] be in danger there."
- 4:23[David] Right, and to be fair, that's an appeals court view.
- 4:26[David] The Supreme Court hasn't said the appeals court was wrong on the
- 4:28[David] merits.
- 4:29[David] It just paused that ruling while it sorts things out.
- 4:32[Maya] Got it.
- 4:33[Maya] Interim.
- 4:33[Maya] Argument still coming.
- 4:35[David] Exactly.
- 4:35[David] Though politically, nobody's waiting until December.
- 4:39[Maya] Yeah, Shocker.
- 4:40[David] The Guardians live coverage on Wednesday had Democratic lawmakers saying Congress must
- 4:44[David] step in after the ruling.
- 4:46[Maya] Which, sure, that's a legitimate lane.
- 4:48[Maya] If you don't like how the law works, Congress can change the
- 4:51[Maya] law.
- 4:52[David] Yep, though whether anything moves in a divided Washington is a separate
- 4:55[David] question, and I'm not holding my breath.
- 4:58[Maya] Speaking of which, the US stepping back from places is a whole
- 5:01[Maya] other story today.
- 5:02[Maya] The military just announced it is out of Iraq.
- 5:05[David] Yeah, that one's bigger than people realize.
- 5:08[David] Start there.
- 5:10[Maya] Okay, so the Iraq piece.
- 5:11[Maya] CNN reported the US military announced on Wednesday that the withdrawal of
- 5:16[Maya] its troops is complete.
- 5:17[Maya] That ends a 12-year mission to fight the Islamic State group.
- 5:21[David] 12 years.
- 5:22[David] That's longer than some of the kids who will be reading about
- 5:24[David] it in history class have been alive.
- 5:27[Maya] Ouch.
- 5:27[Maya] Totally true, though.
- 5:28[David] And the Pentagon wants this read as a tidy handoff.
- 5:32[David] Fox News reported that spokesman Sean Parnell called it the formal end
- 5:35[David] of Operation Inherent Resolve in Iraq and a shift to an Iraqi-led
- 5:40[David] security effort.
- 5:41[Maya] Meaning Baghdad is in charge now.
- 5:43[David] Fully.
- 5:44[David] Parnell said responsibility for ISIS remnants and Iran-aligned militias rests with Baghdad.
- 5:50[David] The US keeps providing targeted training and intelligence support, but not troops
- 5:54[David] on the ground.
- 5:54[Maya] Wait, how many troops are we even talking about by the end?
- 5:58[David] Roughly 1,500 US and coalition personnel per CENTCOM, and most of them
- 6:03[David] were at Erbil Air Base.
- 6:04[David] Forces started leaving federal Iraq last October, so this was a slow
- 6:08[David] walkout, not a sudden one.
- 6:09[Maya] Okay, so the administration's case is pretty simple.
- 6:12[Maya] Mission done, Iraqi step up, and we stay useful from a distance.
- 6:17[David] Right.
- 6:17[David] And if you're a conservative who's wanted the US out of open-ended
- 6:20[David] deployments for years, that's a real argument.
- 6:23[David] Twelve years is a long time to be somewhere.
- 6:25[Maya] Mm, but-
- 6:27[David] But the people living next door to the problem sound less relaxed.
- 6:31[Maya] Go on.
- 6:32[David] The AP-based report carried by The Washington Times says Kurdish officials are
- 6:36[David] anxious, mostly about losing US air defense systems.
- 6:39[Maya] Why air defense specifically?
- 6:41[David] Because of what they just went through.
- 6:43[David] The Kurdistan Peshmerga Ministry said the region faced more than a thousand
- 6:47[David] drone and missile attacks during the recent US-Iran conflict.
- 6:51[Maya] A thousand?
- 6:52[Maya] That's not a bad week.
- 6:53[Maya] That's a siege.
- 6:54[David] And now the umbrella is leaving.
- 6:56[Maya] And what does that look like around Erbil?
- 6:58[Maya] That's where most of the personnel were, right?
- 7:00[David] That's what CENTCOM said, yes.
- 7:02[David] Erbil Air Base hosted most of those roughly fifteen hundred.
- 7:05[David] I haven't seen anything in the reporting we have that says what
- 7:08[David] fills the air defense gap, and that's exactly what the anxiety's about.
- 7:12[Maya] So on paper, the handoff is clean, and the one thing the
- 7:15[Maya] neighbors are watching is the one thing leaving.
- 7:18[David] That's the tension in one sentence.
- 7:19[David] Training and intelligence support continue, but air defense is a different kind
- 7:23[David] of help than training.
- 7:24[Maya] And who's celebrating?
- 7:26[David] Iran-backed groups.
- 7:27[David] They celebrated the exit per that same report.
- 7:30[Maya] Of course they did.
- 7:31[David] Meanwhile, efforts to disarm Iraqi militias have had little success so far.
- 7:36[David] So the Pentagon's handoff goes to a government that hasn't managed to
- 7:39[David] rein in those groups.
- 7:40[Maya] Mm, that's the part that sticks with me.
- 7:43[Maya] Baghdad now holds a responsibility it hasn't shown it can carry.
- 7:47[David] Oh, hang on.
- 7:48[David] There's a counterweight.
- 7:49[David] Fox News reported Iran's economy is still crippled by sanctions and a
- 7:53[David] US blockade.
- 7:54[Maya] So Tehran's hurting.
- 7:56[David] Few options, the report says, now that its control over the Strait
- 7:59[David] of Hormuz has slipped, though that's a live blog snapshot, so it
- 8:03[David] could look different by dinner.
- 8:04[Maya] So one reading is Iran's too weak to exploit the gap.
- 8:08[David] That's one reading.
- 8:10[David] The Kurdish officials reading it differently since they're the ones who got
- 8:12[David] hit.
- 8:13[Maya] Let's put the two cases side by side because I think both
- 8:16[Maya] deserve a fair hearing.
- 8:18[David] Go for it.
- 8:19[David] The administration's case, 12 years, a mission declared finished, forces that began
- 8:24[David] leaving last October, and Baghdad in the lead with US training and
- 8:27[David] intelligence still on offer.
- 8:29[Maya] And the local case, one thousand drone and missile attacks, air defense
- 8:33[Maya] is leaving, militias that haven't been disarmed, and Iran-backed groups celebrating.
- 8:39[David] Neither side is making things up.
- 8:41[David] They're weighing the same facts differently, and the people on the ground
- 8:44[David] are the ones who live with the answer.
- 8:45[Maya] Yeah, and I'm not gonna pretend I know which way this goes.
- 8:49[David] Nobody does yet.
- 8:51[David] You got the Pentagon saying clean handoff, and you've got people on
- 8:54[David] the ground asking, "What happens the next time drones show up?"
- 8:57[Maya] Flat and serious on that one, I think.
- 9:00[Maya] Nobody should be spiking the football.
- 9:02[David] Agreed.
- 9:03[Maya] Okay, let's end on something with a bit less geopolitics.
- 9:07[David] Oh, thank goodness.
- 9:08[Maya] A very big check, like record-setting big.
- 9:13[Maya] Okay, so the check.
- 9:14[Maya] Billionaire Ken Griffin pledged three billion dollars to Carnegie Mellon.
- 9:19[Maya] I can't even picture that.
- 9:21[Maya] I can barely picture my rent.
- 9:22[David] The Wall Street Journal broke it as an exclusive on September 30th.
- 9:26[David] Forbes followed the same day and filled in the details.
- 9:29[Maya] And the university calls it the largest individual gift in higher education
- 9:33[Maya] history.
- 9:34[David] Calls it, yes.
- 9:35[David] That's the school's own claim, and the next numbers back it up.
- 9:39[Maya] Wait, back it up how?
- 9:40[David] Well, the gift passes the two billion dollar gift Phil and Penny Knight gave OHSU in 2025.
- 9:44[David] It also tops Bloomberg's one point eight billion to Johns Hopkins.
- 9:47[David] Huh.
- 9:51[Maya] So it's not even close to a photo finish.
- 9:51[Maya] Not by much, no.
- 9:54[David] A billion more than the old record holder.
- 9:55[David] A billion more than the old record holder.
- 9:57[Maya] What does a number like that mean for a school?
- 10:00[Maya] Is it just an endowment sitting in an account?
- 10:03[David] The reporting breaks it into specific pieces, so it's aimed at particular
- 10:07[David] projects, a Miami campus and money for the Pittsburgh campus.
- 10:11[David] I wouldn't call it a blank check.
- 10:12[Maya] And it's a pledge, right?
- 10:14[Maya] Pledged isn't the same as wired.
- 10:16[David] Fair point.
- 10:17[David] The reporting calls it a pledge, and the dates are plans.
- 10:21[David] So I'd treat the big numbers as commitments, not finished buildings.
- 10:24[Maya] Okay, where does the money actually go?
- 10:27[Maya] Because three billion dollars doesn't just sit in a drawer.
- 10:30[David] Two-thirds of it, about two billion, goes to a brand-new Miami campus,
- 10:34[David] thirty-five acres in Wynwood.
- 10:36[Maya] Wynwood, the mural neighborhood?
- 10:38[David] That's the one.
- 10:39[David] Forbes says construction starts in 2027, and students enroll in 2028.
- 10:44[Maya] But those are plans, dates on a slide.
- 10:47[David] Totally.
- 10:47[David] Projections.
- 10:49[David] A lot can move between a pledge and a ribbon cutting.
- 10:51[Maya] Is it odd to split it that way?
- 10:53[Maya] Two billion on something that doesn't exist yet, one billion on the
- 10:57[Maya] school that does?
- 10:58[David] It's a choice with a clear shape.
- 11:00[David] Two-thirds goes to building something new, and the rest goes to the
- 11:03[David] existing campus.
- 11:05[David] I won't guess at why he split it that way, but a
- 11:07[David] new campus from scratch is a very different commitment than adding to
- 11:11[David] a place that's already running.
- 11:12[Maya] It's the difference between renovating the kitchen and building a second house.
- 11:17[David] Exactly.
- 11:17[David] And the pledge covers both.
- 11:19[Maya] Fair.
- 11:20[Maya] And the other billion?
- 11:21[David] Pittsburgh, the home campus.
- 11:23[David] Five hundred million of that goes to the School of Computer Science.
- 11:26[Maya] Hmm.
- 11:27[David] Half a billion just for one school.
- 11:29[Maya] And it gets named after Griffin.
- 11:31[Maya] Of course it does.
- 11:32[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 11:33[Maya] That's the deal with naming rights.
- 11:35[Maya] I'm not gonna guess at why he did it, though.
- 11:36[Maya] That's his business.
- 11:38[David] Agreed.
- 11:38[David] What I find interesting is the shape of the bet.
- 11:41[David] Computer science and a whole new campus both funded privately.
- 11:44[Maya] Right.
- 11:45[Maya] Think back to the rest of this episode.
- 11:47[Maya] Everybody's arguing over who decides and who foots the bill.
- 11:50[David] And here, one donor just says, "I'll build it."
- 11:53[Maya] No committee, no appropriations fight.
- 11:55[David] Well, there's a university board somewhere that's very happy this morning.
- 11:59[Maya] Somebody's sending a thank you card with a lot of zeros on
- 12:02[Maya] it.
- 12:03[David] Probably a nice one, heavy paper stock.
- 12:05[Maya] Okay, so anyway, that's the Rundown, so let's wrap it up.
- 12:08[Maya] David, you got anything to add before we go?
- 12:11[David] Just that I'm still doing the Wynwood math in my head.
- 12:13[David] Thirty-five acres.
- 12:14[David] That's a lot of mural wall.
- 12:16[Maya] Okay, quick landing.
- 12:18[Maya] David, you had a takeaway brewing during that whole donation segment.
- 12:22[Maya] I could see it on your face.
- 12:24[David] I did.
- 12:25[David] Three stories, three different kinds of decision.
- 12:28[David] Nine justices, one short order.
- 12:30[David] A president closing out an overseas mission, one donor with a checkbook.
- 12:34[Maya] And none of them stay put once they're made.
- 12:37[David] Exactly, and that's the part a headline can't really show you.
- 12:41[David] The first day is always the loud one.
- 12:43[Maya] The order, the exit, the pledge.
- 12:45[Maya] Each one is chapter one, and we only got chapter one this
- 12:48[Maya] morning.
- 12:49[David] Right.
- 12:49[David] The deportation order is interim, so December decides it.
- 12:52[David] The Iraq exit leaves somebody else holding the security job, and the
- 12:56[David] campus only exists if the builders show up.
- 12:58[Maya] Hmm, so the choice happens now, and the bill arrives later.
- 13:03[David] Exactly.
- 13:04[David] Somebody always opens that envelope, Maya.
- 13:07[Maya] And it's never the person who signed.
- 13:10[Maya] Okay, that's our show.
- 13:11[Maya] Thanks for spending your morning with us, everybody.
- 13:13[Maya] I'm Maya.
- 13:14[David] And I'm David.
- 13:15[Maya] Go refill that coffee.
- 13:16[Maya] We'll see you next time.