Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / What Are Animals Legally, and Can They Have Rights?
Transcript
- 0:03Hello everyone, welcome to today's CLE. What
- 0:07is an animal legally and can they have rights?
- 0:11I am Grant Wilson, the executive director at
- 0:13Earth Law Center. I've worked the last 13 years
- 0:17around the world to create new legal innovations
- 0:19that give nature and animals a voice and rights.
- 0:23And today we're going to talk about how the law
- 0:25defines animals and how that is beginning to
- 0:28change around the world. I'm going to go ahead
- 0:31and share my screen with you. And let's dive
- 0:33in. As you know, you can include questions in
- 0:36the chat. I'm sure a lot of interesting things
- 0:38are going to come up. And my slides here will
- 0:40load in just a moment. There's a great play and
- 0:48historical fable. There we go. Called The Animal's
- 0:51Lawsuit Against Humanity. It was written 1 ,000
- 0:53years ago. It was an Islamic tale, later translated
- 0:57into Hebrew, the order of a Christian king. It's
- 1:01been touched by all the Abrahamic religions.
- 1:04And it's a story in which animals sue humans
- 1:06for their poor treatment. And they go to the
- 1:09court of the spirit king, and they begin to have
- 1:11an argument, which essentially boils down to,
- 1:16are humans superior to animals? The humans say,
- 1:20of course we're superior. God made us superior.
- 1:23Animals are property. You walk on four legs.
- 1:25The animals rebut. God made you a steward of
- 1:28the animals, not the master. We're not just property.
- 1:31We have our own rights. And yes, we walk on four
- 1:33legs because we're adapted perfectly to eat the
- 1:35grass on the ground. The humans say that humans
- 1:38have culture and you don't. Humans have souls
- 1:41and you don't. And humans have free will and
- 1:43you don't. The animals reply, animals have culture
- 1:47too. Have you seen a crow play rugby with a stick?
- 1:50And we have souls. That's ridiculous to think
- 1:52it's just humans. And okay, maybe you're the
- 1:54only animal with free will, but look what you
- 1:57do with it to the planet. Mic drop. And this
- 2:00is a thousand years ago that this story came
- 2:03to life. And a thousand years later, we were
- 2:05having the same exact discussion in the context
- 2:08of the law. Are humans superior to animals? Are
- 2:12animals our property? Do we own them? Are humans
- 2:16separate from the natural world or are we part
- 2:19of it? And these ethical and philosophical foundations
- 2:23are essential and inform the entirety of our
- 2:26laws and how we treat animals and jurisdictions
- 2:29worldwide. That includes my favorite animal,
- 2:32the octopus. I just want to show you a video
- 2:34of an octopus dreaming. Just enjoy this for a
- 2:37second. a beautiful animal, but what is the octopus
- 2:57in the eyes of the law? And here's an assortment
- 3:01of some different animals, all of which I love
- 3:03in one way or another. Of course, I'm in the
- 3:05bottom right with my best friend forever, Saber
- 3:07the dog. And so my question to you is, what are
- 3:11these things? You can say, well, they're animals.
- 3:13How does the law define an animal? The answer
- 3:17is that it really depends. It really depends.
- 3:20There's all these different legal classification
- 3:22of animals. One animal might be very well protected,
- 3:25one animal treated like literal trash, which
- 3:30I'll talk about in a moment. So let's just give
- 3:32a few examples here. An invasive species, this
- 3:37is a fox down there. If you're an invasive species
- 3:40in Australia, You can be killed according to
- 3:43customary methods, which typically means you
- 3:46can be trapped in a horrifically painful fox
- 3:49trap and be sold to the government for $10 a
- 3:51head. That's your life if you're a fox, your
- 3:53property for sure. If you're poultry in the United
- 3:58States, if you're a little chick, you're excluded
- 4:00from the Animal Welfare Act. You have no protections
- 4:02under this law. You're allowed to, it should
- 4:05say humane, humanely slaughter them according
- 4:07to traditional methods. In practice, six billion
- 4:10male chicks are cold, killed at birth per year,
- 4:14often ground alive in a giant machine because
- 4:17they are treated as waste, because they can't
- 4:19lay eggs. So if you're a little chick, you're
- 4:21treated essentially as waste with no voice or
- 4:23no animal welfare act protection of your own.
- 4:29Vermin or pest is very similar. You can control
- 4:32a mouse with in accordance with standard methods.
- 4:35I love mice. They clean each other. They play
- 4:37little games. They have family units. It's a
- 4:40traditional standard method to put down a glue
- 4:42trap in which they suffer horrifically for 24
- 4:44hours. And that's because you define a mice legally
- 4:47as a vermin or pest. And so you can do things
- 4:49in accordance with customs to them. And that
- 4:51is totally legal. If you're an invertebrate species,
- 4:56if you're an octopus, legally you're not an animal,
- 4:59quote, under the Animal Welfare Act. I just released
- 5:02a TEDx talk about this very topic. And these
- 5:05laws meant to protect animals in laboratory settings
- 5:08and other federal facilities do not even apply
- 5:12to an octopus. So an octopus is literally not
- 5:16an animal under the law. And in a laboratory
- 5:20setting, you can do with it whatever you please.
- 5:23If you're an endangered species, you're actually
- 5:25a little bit better off. This is a lynx because
- 5:28there are laws that protect endangered species.
- 5:31You often have to protect its habitat. You have
- 5:33to do an analysis of impacts to endangered species
- 5:37before certain projects. If there's going to
- 5:39be a review and environmental impact assessment,
- 5:43you often look at endangered species impacts.
- 5:47A dog is so well -off compared to every other
- 5:50animal. They are often considered companion animals,
- 5:53sometimes trustees. We'll talk about that. They
- 5:56are even sometimes considered a member of your
- 5:58family legally in jurisdictions such as New York
- 6:01and British Columbia. And of course, the human
- 6:05is the ultimate protected animal, a rights holder.
- 6:09We have rights. And legally, what is an animal?
- 6:13There's all these different classifications that
- 6:15says what an animal is under the law and how
- 6:17you can treat it. It can be poultry, endangered
- 6:19species, invasive species, vermin, and vertebrate,
- 6:22and they are all treated differently. But none
- 6:25of them, none of them have rights. None of them
- 6:28have legal rights. Humans have legal rights.
- 6:31We're the only animal with universal rights recognition.
- 6:34And everything else, this means its legal classification
- 6:37is what? It is property. Because under the law,
- 6:42you have rights, or you are a thing that is owned
- 6:45by another. And we know this because there were
- 6:49once many classifications of humans who were
- 6:51the property of others. It was horrific. We have
- 6:55changed that system in most or all the world.
- 6:59And we are still living with the scars and the
- 7:02injustices from that horrific system today. Will
- 7:06we go through a similar transformation in our
- 7:08treatment of animals or of nature? Well, that
- 7:11is beginning to happen slowly worldwide. And
- 7:16the point I want to make about animals, we explored
- 7:18what they are under the law already, a pest,
- 7:21not an animal like the octopus. They can be a
- 7:24pet, then they have some protections, wildlife,
- 7:27livestock can be treated horrifically. These
- 7:29are what animals are under the law. There's a
- 7:31list, you have a classification, and that dictates
- 7:34exactly what humans can do to you. They're all
- 7:36property. In reality, What are animals? Well,
- 7:41culturally and scientifically and emotionally,
- 7:44we know them to be sacred. To some, they are
- 7:46kin or relatives. They are sentient beings like
- 7:50the octopus. They have feelings. They have families.
- 7:53They feel emotion. They have memories. They recognize
- 7:55themselves in mirrors. To some, they are ancestors
- 7:59of people. They are rights holders in a few jurisdictions,
- 8:04as I'll mention. They are souls. They are teachers.
- 8:07They are living beings. So my question is there's
- 8:11the definition of what an animal is in law and
- 8:14then there's what we know animals are in reality
- 8:17because our cultures understand them to be these
- 8:21things because we know in our hearts they are
- 8:23more than just property. So how do we bring those
- 8:26two worlds together and how would it work from
- 8:28a legal perspective? That's what we are exploring
- 8:31together today and you can call this question
- 8:36More simply, how do we align the law with life?
- 8:42Right now, the law treats all of nature as property,
- 8:45a commodity, a thing, a resource. How to create
- 8:49legal structures that recognize nature and animals
- 8:51as more than this. And there is a group of legal
- 8:56movements happening all over the world that does
- 8:58just this. And these are some of them. Multi
- 9:01-species justice, animal rights, the rights of
- 9:04nature, the idea that nature has fundamental
- 9:06rights just as humans do. Legal guardianship,
- 9:09giving nature a voice through legal guardians
- 9:11to speak for it. A duty of care to animals and
- 9:15on and on. So these are movements that are developing
- 9:19in different jurisdictions. There's test cases,
- 9:22there's pilot projects, and we're going to explore
- 9:24a few of them around the world. 15 or so years,
- 9:32and especially the last five years, there's been
- 9:34a rapid proliferation of what I call earth law
- 9:37or eco centric law. They are laws that do just
- 9:41this align our legal structures with the laws
- 9:44of nature. And they are growing precipitously
- 9:48across the world. This is from a great site called
- 9:51the eco jurisprudence monitor that shows the
- 9:53development of these fields. And why is this
- 9:56happening? I believe there's a realization that
- 10:00we are not going to be able to solve the environmental
- 10:02crisis so long as we commodify all life on the
- 10:07planet. And there's beginning to be an emergence
- 10:10of an ecological jurisprudence that shows new
- 10:13ways of the legal treatment of nature and begins
- 10:15to at the same time not only change the law but
- 10:19create a cultural respect for nature that transforms
- 10:23along with the law. And a lot of these cases
- 10:27involve rights of animals. Some are just plain
- 10:30old rights of nature. Now, Ecuador in 2008 amended
- 10:34its constitution to say that nature has rights
- 10:37in Ecuador. It's the first country to do this
- 10:41anywhere in the world. Since then, there's been
- 10:45a diversity of other approaches to rights of
- 10:48nature. So in Ecuador, everywhere in Ecuador
- 10:51is an ecosystem with rights. Other jurisdictions
- 10:55started to say that specific groups of animals
- 10:57have rights. So for example, in Argentina, they
- 11:02said that there's a chimpanzee there that has
- 11:04rights, a right to freedom. It was released from
- 11:07a zoo in horrific conditions. And so my question
- 11:12to you is, How might this work in practice? How
- 11:17might this work? I think when you start imagining
- 11:20that animals have rights, you start thinking
- 11:22of slippery slope arguments. Well, if animals
- 11:25have rights, does that mean that insects have
- 11:27rights? Does that mean I can't kill a fly? Does
- 11:28that mean I can't have a pet? Does that mean
- 11:30I can't hunt? And I think the role of lawyers
- 11:33in this space is to solve these. challenging
- 11:36questions and there's answers to all of these
- 11:39and to show to guide societies towards better
- 11:42ways of living in harmony with nature that respect
- 11:45animals as more than just things. So let's dive
- 11:49into a little bit about what this means just
- 11:52with a couple of examples. So this one is fun
- 11:57because it just happened this year. There are
- 11:59two communities in Peru that recognize the rights
- 12:02of stingless bees. Really cool, you can look
- 12:06it up. There's articles in People Magazine and
- 12:08The Guardian celebrating the first rights of
- 12:10an insect anywhere in the world. The organization
- 12:13I run, Earth Law Center, worked on this case.
- 12:16They passed local ordinances and they say that
- 12:19Amazonian stingless bees and their habitat are
- 12:22subjects of rights. Okay, you say what rights
- 12:25might they have? Well, they define the rights
- 12:27in the law. They say they have rights to exist
- 12:30and maintain healthy populations. They have a
- 12:32right to live in a healthy environment, a right
- 12:35to restore and regenerate habitat, to fulfill
- 12:38their ecological role as pollinators, and a right
- 12:42of legal representation of their interests. It's
- 12:48not only about rights, but it's about responsibilities
- 12:50as well, because with rights comes responsibilities
- 12:53or duties to the rights holder. And so alongside
- 12:57the rights of the bees are inversely duties.
- 13:01the municipality and the people who live in this
- 13:04area to recognize and support these rights and
- 13:08specifically it says that the municipalities
- 13:10of Satipo and Nauta have a duty to protect and
- 13:14restore bee habitat and promote native flowering
- 13:17plants and ecological corridors. Okay so a couple
- 13:21things about this law. Note that it does not
- 13:24address the rights of each individual bee and
- 13:27so this is different than often human rights
- 13:31or our own personal rights and freedoms, where
- 13:33if my rights as an individual are violated, I
- 13:37can seek redress for that in the courts. There
- 13:39can be a lawsuit, for example, in which I enforce
- 13:42my personal rights and liberties. But the way
- 13:45this law is framed, it's not about the rights
- 13:47of each individual bee. You could kill a bee
- 13:50in this scenario, but it's the right of the collective
- 13:54population to thrive, to be healthy in relation
- 13:57to the habitat. Now you might ask, is this any
- 14:00different than what we have right now? And it
- 14:02is. I won't go into a long critique of traditional
- 14:06environmental law, but the main difference between
- 14:10rights of nature type laws and traditional environmental
- 14:13type laws is that the traditional environmental
- 14:16type laws are typically rooted in the idea that
- 14:20we can maximumly exploit nature with limited
- 14:25protections. They're often a threshold approach.
- 14:29How much can we take from nature until it collapses?
- 14:32Traditional environmental laws are often emergency
- 14:34room laws that kick in once a species or ecosystem
- 14:37is almost extinct or lost and protects them and
- 14:40raises their level of protection a little bit
- 14:42so they're still sort of in that gray area. And
- 14:47they also fail to give nature any sort of voice
- 14:51itself in the law. And, you know, just looking
- 14:54at this, this is very different than what these
- 14:55types of what type of law does, where it's about
- 14:57the right to be healthy, not to prevent collapse,
- 15:00not to prevent extinction, but a right to be
- 15:02healthy in relationship to the larger ecosystem
- 15:05of which bees are a part. And I anticipate this
- 15:11law will also advance towards a legal guardianship
- 15:13framework, which is something that's emerging
- 15:15around the world where ecosystems are actually
- 15:18given legal guardians who speak on their behalf.
- 15:22And this basically gives nature a voice in society.
- 15:26So for example, if there's a child that can't
- 15:29represent its own interests or a corporation
- 15:32that is not a living entity, so how can it speak
- 15:35for itself? For the child, they're often given
- 15:39a guardian ad litem to represent their interests.
- 15:41For the corporation, there's a board of directors
- 15:43or a corporate attorney. And so what if nature
- 15:46had someone speaking for them as well? There's
- 15:49actually examples of this in Columbia. where
- 15:52guardians of the Atrato River, A -T -R -A -T
- 15:55-O, Atrato River, are legally responsible for
- 16:00upholding the rights of this river. And also
- 16:03with various ecosystems in New Zealand, Aotearoa
- 16:06New Zealand, where a mountain, Mount Taranaki,
- 16:10or a river, the Wanganui River, are legally persons,
- 16:13and there are legal guardians that speak on their
- 16:17behalf. So this is sort of a foundation of a
- 16:22larger paradigm shift in Peru that's very exciting.
- 16:27I mentioned in Ecuador, this was the first country
- 16:30to constitutionally recognize the rights of nature
- 16:33and has been applied to animals. A lot of people
- 16:36ask me... Grant, if you're going to implement
- 16:39the rights of nature, it's going to be a disaster.
- 16:41Every little animal is going to sue every human.
- 16:43There's going to be thousands or tens of thousands
- 16:45of lawsuits. Society is going to shut down our
- 16:48industrial efforts to create regenerative economies.
- 16:57We're trying to do good here. We're going to
- 16:58fail as well. We're not going to be able to do
- 17:00anything. The world's going to stop. And I say,
- 17:02calm down. Rights of nature has existed in Ecuador.
- 17:07for almost 20 years, since 2008, and there's
- 17:11a whole body of jurisprudence in the courts for
- 17:14what rights of nature means in practice. So okay,
- 17:17phew, we already have a playbook because it's
- 17:19happened in Ecuador. There are over 20 constitutional
- 17:23court cases in Ecuador that explore the rights
- 17:26of nature, and there are many others in lower
- 17:29courts. And there's some lessons that have been
- 17:32learned. I'll get to these sharks in a second.
- 17:35A few lessons of what rights of nature has meant
- 17:37in Ecuador. One is that instead of considering
- 17:42very localized harms to one small area, maybe
- 17:45where there's a mining project or some sort of
- 17:48development, you have to consider environmental
- 17:50impacts to the whole larger system. So you have
- 17:53to consider large interconnected systemic health
- 17:57of nature rather than very small areas. That's
- 18:00one lesson from Ecuador. Another lesson is that
- 18:05we have to start implementing the precautionary
- 18:08principle, which essentially says, puts the onus
- 18:13on the exploiter or the polluter to show that
- 18:15their activity will not, let's say, violate the
- 18:17rights of nature instead of putting the onus
- 18:19on the environmentalist to prove the inverse
- 18:22of that. And they've also shown that certain
- 18:26ecosystems should just not be exploited by certain
- 18:29activities. And one of those is the Galapagos,
- 18:34where there are amazing sharks there, hammerheads
- 18:37and others. And there was a significant amount
- 18:40of shark fishing going on. And there was a case
- 18:45involving the shark fishing in the Galapagos
- 18:47brought to the courts in Ecuador. and they basically
- 18:50said this violates not only the rights of the
- 18:52sharks as individuals but the right of the entire
- 18:55ecosystem around the Galapagos and they find
- 18:59for reparations the industries involved and the
- 19:02idea of the reparations is to make the ecosystem
- 19:04whole once again. And this is one of many cases
- 19:08in Ecuador on the rights of nature and how it
- 19:12relates to animals. Another was about one individual
- 19:17animal named Estreita. a little wooly monkey.
- 19:21And this case is interesting because it was about
- 19:24one wooly monkey named Estreita. And a lot of
- 19:29these cases I'm talking about the sharks, the
- 19:31bees, it's a whole population of animals that
- 19:33are at issue here, but this was one animal where
- 19:37she was taken from the wild, she was removed
- 19:39from her habitat, she was brought into some horrible
- 19:42conditions in someone's home, and there was a
- 19:45lawsuit for the rights of Estreita in Ecuador.
- 19:47So the question in this case became, well, what
- 19:50about one animal and not the population? What
- 19:53happens then? And what the court said in this
- 19:57case is a couple of interesting things. One,
- 19:59they determined that the rights of animals really
- 20:03depend on what animal they are. So the rights
- 20:06of a dog is going to be different from the rights
- 20:08of a monkey, is going to be different from the
- 20:10rights of a bee. How do you determine what rights
- 20:13these animals have? My kind of shorthand is all
- 20:17animals have a right to fulfill their role in
- 20:20the community of life. So that kind of takes
- 20:23an ecological perspective of animal rights. But
- 20:27they also said that each individual animal has
- 20:30rights in the sense that they are part of this
- 20:32larger whole. So they said in this case Estreita,
- 20:36the monkey, is part of this larger community
- 20:39and her individual presence in that community
- 20:41is valuable to their survival. So they said this
- 20:44individual monkey even itself has rights in this
- 20:48case. Now that isn't always the case. I said
- 20:51in the case of the bees, I think This law is
- 20:54agnostic as to whether you kill a bee in the
- 20:57rights of this monkey. They determined that that
- 20:59specific monkey was more important to the whole
- 21:01population. So this kind of gets into a question
- 21:04of what role does one animal serve in the larger
- 21:07whole. You can debate all these things. Did this
- 21:11court get it right? Is this consistent? Where's
- 21:13the line you draw? But I guess the point I want
- 21:15to make is that Courts at the highest level are
- 21:17having these discussions about what it means
- 21:19for nature to have rights and animals to have
- 21:21rights in practice, and they are developing a
- 21:24jurisprudence to indicate what that means. I'll
- 21:28give another example. In the Pacific, there is
- 21:31an indigenous treaty, He Waka Putanga Moana,
- 21:36and this was signed by indigenous leaders in
- 21:38the Pacific that basically acknowledged whale
- 21:41personhood, the idea that whales are persons.
- 21:44There are many indigenous creation stories understanding
- 21:48that humans are relatives of whales, that there's
- 21:51a sacred relationship or kinship with whales,
- 21:54and that whales are family members. So how can
- 21:58the law treat a family member, a relative, an
- 22:01entity from which humans came, kin, however you
- 22:05interpret it, to be just property or a thing
- 22:09when there's this sacred kinship with this animal?
- 22:13And so in the Pacific, there's a treaty recognizing
- 22:17that whales are, quote, persons under the law.
- 22:20They have personhood. They have rights. And there
- 22:22are now efforts by many of these indigenous peoples
- 22:25to implement the personhood of whales through
- 22:28different national laws, protected areas. And
- 22:32basically, what if whales were persons just like
- 22:35humans? And I think we all know that corporate
- 22:38personhood showed you can really do anything
- 22:40with the law. Corporations are persons? Sure,
- 22:43why not? Persons means in that case the capacity
- 22:47to bear rights or duties. It doesn't say you
- 22:50need some biological presence. Personhood means
- 22:54the capacity to bear rights or duties. So corporation
- 22:57is a person. A human is a person. Why not a whale?
- 23:05This little chart just shows again this idea
- 23:10that There's rights of nature, there's rights
- 23:14of individual animals, which we'll talk about
- 23:16a little more in a minute, because there is case
- 23:18law where individual animals are determined to
- 23:20have rights, kind of in a stronger way than we've
- 23:22even discussed. But kind of in the middle of
- 23:24those two worlds is this idea that populations
- 23:27of animals have a right to exist and thrive.
- 23:32So a couple key takeaways, then we're going to
- 23:34dive into the United States a little bit, because
- 23:36I think we have a lot of US lawyers here. So
- 23:41animals are legally things. They have some protections
- 23:45depending on their classification. If they're
- 23:47a pest, not many, endangered species, okay, a
- 23:49little more. A research subject, not many. You're
- 23:53pretty well off if you're a dog. Sadly, if you're
- 23:56an endangered species, and of course, if you're
- 23:58a human, the ultimate rights holder of the animals,
- 24:01you're in great shape legally, comparatively,
- 24:04of course, because lots of humans face horrible
- 24:06conditions too. There are animal rights, and
- 24:11then there are rights of nature, which is about
- 24:13the whole ecosystem. Animal rights can be more
- 24:15about an individual animal, but there's convergence
- 24:17in some cases. Quickly to answer the question
- 24:23of how do you know the difference, is this an
- 24:25animal rights case or rights of nature case?
- 24:28All this comes down to legal drafting. It's whatever
- 24:31you put in the law. If you put into a law, Nature
- 24:34has rights, and this includes populations of
- 24:36animals in relation to their ecosystem. Okay,
- 24:38that's the rule, and courts enforce that, and
- 24:40they know how to because there's been a lot of
- 24:42jurisprudence showing how this works, a lot of
- 24:44case law. If a law says that each individual
- 24:47whale is a person and its individual rights could
- 24:50be violated, like if you bring a boat too close
- 24:54to it or have sonar that annoys or words to the
- 24:59whale, If you hit the whale with a vessel, if
- 25:03you hunt a whale illegally and that individual
- 25:05whale has rights, okay, you can put that into
- 25:07a law and you define what that means and there's
- 25:09consequences. So I think if anything, corporate
- 25:12personhood has shown us that the law is whatever
- 25:14we say it is. And of course, if you recognize
- 25:17the rights of animals and the constitution, everything
- 25:19trickles down from there. If you don't, if you
- 25:22put it in a national law and it's not in the
- 25:24constitution, you have to tread a little more
- 25:25carefully because you can't run afoul of the
- 25:28constitution. And if it's a local law, you have
- 25:31to be even more careful because the higher levels
- 25:33of law ultimately dictate what you're doing.
- 25:36But this is where good legal drafting comes into
- 25:39play. I have run into a lot of cases where people
- 25:41are writing rights of nature laws, whatever it
- 25:43may be, and they're poorly written. In some cases,
- 25:46they're illegal. and they can be overturned.
- 25:49So I think if you're interested in this space
- 25:51and you're training up and know how do we give
- 25:53animals a voice in law, careful legal drafting
- 25:56and understanding the legal nuances of these
- 25:59spaces are important. And then I wanna emphasize
- 26:03the importance of culture and ecology and spiritual
- 26:06traditions in this movement. In some places,
- 26:10there's kinship with animals such as with the
- 26:12whales. And how can we create legal structures
- 26:15that reflect our own relationship with nature?
- 26:18What do you believe nature to be? Is it sacred
- 26:21to you? Is it where you live? Is it a refuge?
- 26:24Is it your home? And how can the law harmonize
- 26:28with your own cultural and ecological understanding
- 26:31of nature? And then what rights do animals have?
- 26:34We looked at the rights of bees, but I also said
- 26:37that in Ecuador, they said that different animals
- 26:39have different rights. I would say if there is
- 26:42anything that's a universal right of all animals,
- 26:45whether it's the individual animal or the whole
- 26:48population, if there's any such thing as a universal
- 26:50right of all animals in all situations, I would
- 26:54say it's a right to basic dignity. So even if
- 26:57you're involved in animal agriculture, even if
- 27:00it's a pest or it's the bees, it's your dog,
- 27:05if it's one animal or the population, I don't
- 27:07care. My belief is that all animals have a right
- 27:11to basic dignity, and that can mean different
- 27:14things, but it sure is different in a higher
- 27:16floor than what we give to animals that are pests,
- 27:20nuisance species, and so forth. All right, I'm
- 27:24going to take a quick look at some questions
- 27:25here, and then keep rolling through. Oh, looks
- 27:29like this is something else, so let's keep rolling
- 27:32through. Okay. I don't know, here's the Q &A.
- 27:36Okay, a couple of questions. Do you consider
- 27:38animal rights above plant rights? Well, there's
- 27:41what I consider and what the jurisprudence says.
- 27:47Just riffing off that last point, if animals
- 27:49have a right to basic dignity, I think those
- 27:52rights might be quote above plant rights because
- 27:56part of the right to basic dignity would incorporate
- 27:59the reality that animals feel pain, and you could
- 28:03argue plants feel pain. I think I would not consider
- 28:09the rights of anything truly separate, though.
- 28:11I would consider plants and animals to be in
- 28:13a complex relationship, and plants have rights
- 28:16in the sense that they have a right to be part
- 28:21of a healthy complex interconnected ecosystem.
- 28:25And that their individual rights I would treat
- 28:27a little bit differently. So, you know, I come
- 28:30from the Pacific Northwest, there's a long line
- 28:33of deforestation and clear cutting there. Do
- 28:37I believe we shouldn't clear cut a single tree?
- 28:39No, I think that's preposterous at this place
- 28:42we are in the world. And we use timber for all
- 28:45sorts of things, including many things that are
- 28:46good for the world and society. Do I think that
- 28:50a forest has a right to be healthy and that each
- 28:52individual tree contributes to that in some way?
- 28:54Yes. Do I think that the animals that live in
- 28:57the forest have a right to be in relationship
- 28:59in a healthy ecosystem with those trees? Yes.
- 29:02So it's hard for me to separate them, but I do
- 29:05think there's some interesting nuance to explore.
- 29:12I've not followed Jackie and Shadow. I'm interested
- 29:14to do that. What about octopuses, whales, wolves,
- 29:17everything, bees? And yeah, this is, I guess,
- 29:22let me bring up the point in this question about
- 29:25business rights. People might respond, well,
- 29:30humans have economic rights, businesses have
- 29:32rights, they legally are incorporated to maximize.
- 29:36profits. They have a fiduciary duty to their
- 29:38shareholders. I'm a property owner. I have a
- 29:41property right. This again is where good lawyering
- 29:44comes into play. So let me just give you an example
- 29:46of the property right. I have a property right.
- 29:49If you're going to give nature right, that's
- 29:50a takings. This is my property. I can do with
- 29:52it what I want. I would actually, if I was in
- 29:55control of the new law of whatever land, I would
- 29:58not Say that humans don't have property rights.
- 30:01I would not strip you of your land I would say
- 30:04that humans have property rights. Okay, you have
- 30:06a right to exclude you have a right to habitat
- 30:10to inhabit a land But you also have a reciprocal
- 30:16duty back to the land and that gets back to what
- 30:18I said about the bees with with the communities
- 30:21these communities have No, that's too far back.
- 30:25These communities have a right in Peru, oh no,
- 30:28here it is, to protect and restore bee habitat
- 30:30and promote native flowering plants. So what
- 30:33if as landowners we had a duty of reciprocity
- 30:36back to the land? All right, we can exclude,
- 30:39we can build, we can live there, we can raise
- 30:41our family, but we have a duty to restore native
- 30:43biodiversity. We have a duty to protect the land
- 30:46from harmful chemicals. We're in a reciprocal
- 30:50relationship with the land and our land rights
- 30:52framework can be modernized to reflect that.
- 30:55So all of which just goes to say there are ways
- 30:58to reimagine all areas of the law so that we
- 31:01can live in a harmonious relationship with nature
- 31:03and our own rights can be fulfilled and corporate
- 31:06rights can be fulfilled and corporations can
- 31:09profit. work around the world and they can make
- 31:15their shareholders happy, but they can do so
- 31:17in a way that respects the rights of nature as
- 31:19well. This is just another fun little innovation
- 31:24in the space of animals and the law. Everyone's
- 31:27talking about AI. There are new innovations whereby
- 31:31animal communication can be understood. with
- 31:36AI to at least some extent. I think it would
- 31:38take some level of human hubris, we're good at
- 31:41that, or take some level of human hubris to really
- 31:44believe we can actually communicate with animals
- 31:46in some sort of native way. But there is AI technology
- 31:51undergoing where we can decode what some animals
- 31:54are saying. And you can imagine a whale speaking
- 31:58in its language and making an indication that
- 32:01a certain vessel is harassing it. or even a bird.
- 32:04If there's a bird, they have distress calls.
- 32:06Can we understand what those distress calls are?
- 32:09And for example, if there's a law that says you
- 32:12can't harass, quote, harass, like the Endangered
- 32:15Species Act, can't harass a bird that's endangered,
- 32:18maybe those bird calls can be interpreted and
- 32:21decoded and even introduced into the courts.
- 32:24This brings up some interesting questions of
- 32:26the standards of evidence. There's the Dow bird
- 32:28standard and other standards of evidence. Can
- 32:32you introduce evidence from AI that decodes animal
- 32:35communication to prove some point in the courts?
- 32:38And possibly is the answer. Possibly if, for
- 32:42example, you can replicate whatever you did with
- 32:45the AI to decode the animal communication, the
- 32:47courts would look at that and say, OK, you did
- 32:49it twice and it came up at the same thing. Maybe
- 32:51you are actually decoding the animal communication.
- 32:54Is it verifiable? Is it accepted by the industry?
- 32:58Blah, blah, blah. Once you can decode animal
- 33:02communication, there's a lot of fun stuff you
- 33:03can do with it. Could you give a deposition maybe?
- 33:08Could you give animals their own board seats?
- 33:10And what does the animal want? Well, we've helped
- 33:11to code that with artificial intelligence. Could
- 33:14you enforce rights of nature laws? There's a
- 33:16lot of interesting stuff to do. So just to know
- 33:18that the work I'm talking about on the rights
- 33:21of nature. rights of animals is on the very,
- 33:24very cutting edge of the legal system. So of
- 33:27course, what's on the cutting edge of technology,
- 33:30artificial intelligence. So we're both on the
- 33:32cutting edge in our own ways. Of course, we're
- 33:34talking to each other and there's some new interesting
- 33:36things happening. And there's a lot of innovation
- 33:39happening. I mentioned... Rights of nature is
- 33:41proliferating around the world. There are over
- 33:4440 countries with some level of rights of nature
- 33:47law. And alongside that, there's all sorts of
- 33:49other ways that people are thinking, how can
- 33:50we give nature a voice in the legal system? How
- 33:53can we innovate to have laws that are harmonized
- 33:56with the natural world? People are looking at
- 33:59political representation of nature. There's an
- 34:02initiative in Kuridabat, Costa Rica. It's right
- 34:07by the capital. And they have declared bees to
- 34:10be citizens of what they call the sweet city.
- 34:14Now bees can't vote yet. They don't have all
- 34:16the powers of a true citizen, but they are creating
- 34:19zoning that is informed by the needs and desires
- 34:22of pollinators. And so they're creating an entire
- 34:25city that is basically a reflection of what would
- 34:28bees want. which is lots of pollinator corridors
- 34:32and pathways. And when they're creating these
- 34:34zoning rules, they're sitting there and asking
- 34:36themselves, like, what do the bees want? We consider
- 34:39them citizens. And they are beginning to engage
- 34:41in urban planning based on this understanding
- 34:44of what bees want. So that's kind of political
- 34:47representation. I actually have like 10 ways
- 34:50I've thought of where animals could vote. I'm
- 34:52not going to get into that now. I think I could
- 34:55swing an election though, if all pollinators
- 34:58and insects were given voting rights, that would
- 35:00be fun. There's a whole movement to give nature
- 35:04board seats. This started in the United Kingdom.
- 35:08The group I run, Earth Law Center, worked with
- 35:09another called Lawyers for Nature to advise a
- 35:13company called Faith in Nature, it's like a soaps
- 35:15company, a natural products company, to give
- 35:18nature its own board seat. So nature's literally
- 35:21on the board. We consulted with a giant team
- 35:24of attorneys at a big corporate law firm and
- 35:27said, is this even legal? Can we give nature
- 35:29a board seat? And they're like, well, how is
- 35:30nature going to sit on the board? And we're like,
- 35:32well, we could have a proxy that legally sits
- 35:34in as nature and they'd have a fiduciary duty
- 35:36to represent nature's interests. And we thought,
- 35:38well, don't they have a fiduciary interest to
- 35:40represent the board's interests? Can we do this?
- 35:43And ultimately we concluded in the United Kingdom,
- 35:46it was possible because there's a long line of
- 35:53jurisdictional authority and case law saying
- 35:55that essentially board members or trustees have
- 35:59a duty to represent the best interests of the
- 36:01company. And what does it mean to represent the
- 36:04best interests of the company? Well, we're beginning
- 36:07to look beyond quarterly returns. We're starting
- 36:09to look at annual returns and even beyond that
- 36:12multi -generational. What does it mean to multi
- 36:15-generationally represent the best interests
- 36:17of a corporation? And I would argue A company
- 36:20that's going to thrive in the future requires
- 36:23a habitable planet. I would also argue that I,
- 36:27from my perspective, I see these new laws happening
- 36:29all over the world that require us to treat nature
- 36:32with care and sometimes to even uphold its rights.
- 36:37And so if a company gives nature a board seat
- 36:39and listens to nature and begins to incorporate
- 36:41the voice of nature into all of their corporate
- 36:44culture and decision -making, I think that's
- 36:46a company that's going to thrive well into the
- 36:48future. And I would even argue they have a competitive
- 36:51advantage over another company that is not giving
- 36:54a voice to nature because the future of the planet
- 36:57is humans living in harmony with nature. And
- 37:00so they've done it. A bunch of other companies,
- 37:02especially in Europe, have now done it. This
- 37:04is a report called Onboarding Nature where you
- 37:06can read all about it. And it's really interesting
- 37:09you can go read reports from this group faith
- 37:11in nature and see how is it what does it meant
- 37:13for nature to be sitting around the table and
- 37:15how is that influenced decision making. Corporations,
- 37:20corporate law allows for a lot of legal fiction.
- 37:22So you could even put pollinators on a board
- 37:25of directors. You could put whales on a board
- 37:26of directors. And it all goes into how you write
- 37:29the bylaws, the rules of procedure. And I think
- 37:32as long as you kind of balance that fiduciary
- 37:34duty to the company, along with the fiduciary
- 37:36duty to speak as nature, there's something really
- 37:39exciting and innovative in this space. I won't
- 37:43go into all these because we've got to get to
- 37:45the U .S. but there's also the idea of IP rights
- 37:47held from nature. There's more and more things
- 37:49like earth percent where nature quote unquote
- 37:52holds IP rights to songs and every time a song
- 37:55is played nature gets a little money and it can
- 37:57spend it towards restoring its own health. I
- 38:00like the idea of nature delegations. Nature actually
- 38:03being represented in international laws and negotiating
- 38:06treaties to represent its best interests. Now
- 38:10that we're deep in rights of nature, actually,
- 38:12you know, you could even do this today. There's
- 38:15different guardians for nature that already exist
- 38:17in different legal systems worldwide. And what
- 38:20if they all got together and had a little treaty
- 38:21negotiating body? Wouldn't that be interesting?
- 38:24So we're in an age of kind of dreaming and creativity.
- 38:27We're testing different examples of this. Some
- 38:30work really well. Others have been tested and
- 38:32don't work as well. We've learned in the United
- 38:35States that if you're a local government and
- 38:37you do rights of nature as a law, You need to
- 38:39be very careful of being preempted by higher
- 38:42levels of law. So this kind of movement in the
- 38:44US has kind of evolved. But if you're interested
- 38:47in this space, there's something for everyone.
- 38:50If you're a family lawyer, practice family law,
- 38:53well, how can we extend the idea of representing
- 38:55the best interests of the child into the nature
- 38:57world? If you're a corporate attorney, well,
- 38:59how can we give nature? a board seat. How can
- 39:02we consider nature's voice in all decision -making
- 39:04to the corporation without running afoul of our
- 39:07bylaws or corporate statutes? If you're a constitutional
- 39:11lawyer, well how can we give nature rights and
- 39:13how's that going to work and how do we balance
- 39:15nature's rights with other constitutional rights
- 39:17holders? How's that going to work? If you're
- 39:19an IP lawyer, how can nature hold IP law? So
- 39:22I really believe there's no area of law in which
- 39:25someone can't have their voice heard in this
- 39:27space and innovate in some way. I really think
- 39:30it's everyone if Contract law. Okay, there's
- 39:32these nature guardianship bodies that already
- 39:35exist. How do we formulate contracts with them?
- 39:37And is anything different than your typical contract?
- 39:40Do we need new laws? New laws establishing how
- 39:43contracts work, where nature is one of the parties.
- 39:47So if you're out there and you're like, this
- 39:48world is so far afield from what I do, actually,
- 39:52I would challenge anyone to find a field of law
- 39:54that doesn't have some opportunity for innovation.
- 39:58All right, we're gonna talk the last 15 minutes
- 40:01and then a couple questions about the United
- 40:03States. We're gonna go back to animals. I've
- 40:05kind of veered into the world of nature a little
- 40:08bit more. So we're gonna talk about animals specifically.
- 40:11There is some really interesting innovation happening
- 40:13in the United States. In fact, the origins of
- 40:18the rights of nature movement and it's kind of...
- 40:20Western law form, date back to Sierra Club versus
- 40:24Morton, which is over 50 years old, a Supreme
- 40:27Court case in which Justice Douglas, in a dissent,
- 40:31a famous dissent, said nature itself should be
- 40:34able to have standing in a court of law. He was
- 40:38the dissent he lost, but it was a really powerful,
- 40:40amazing moment in the history of the Supreme
- 40:43Court. And this idea has kind of stuck around
- 40:45in the United States. And I believe despite us
- 40:48not necessarily having the reputation as the
- 40:51world's most environmental protective country.
- 40:56We've long innovated, Clean Air Act, Clean Water
- 40:58Act, and Danger Species Act. These were all innovations
- 41:01in the United States that later proliferated
- 41:04around the world. And I still think this is a
- 41:06great place to innovate on ecological laws for
- 41:09animals, whether it's local, state, or even national.
- 41:12So I'm excited about some stuff happening in
- 41:14the United States. Animals are treated as property
- 41:19in the United States, full stop. But let's talk
- 41:23about a few ways that's starting to bend a little
- 41:25bit. In criminal law, where you abuse animals,
- 41:29and there's animal cruelty statutes in every
- 41:31state, animals are still treated as things or
- 41:35property, but there's a growing understanding
- 41:38in the animal law community to at least understand
- 41:40animals as victims under the law. Let's stop
- 41:44considering if you... shoot someone's dog or
- 41:47abuse a cat that this is just harm to property.
- 41:51You know, it's the same as crashing your car
- 41:53into someone's mailbox. It's not. These are living
- 41:56species. They have emotions. They feel pain.
- 41:58There are companions. We're talking about companion
- 42:01animals. And so there is a growing vernacular
- 42:04and sometimes even legal recognition that animals
- 42:09are victims. It's not just damage to property.
- 42:12And that alone is a really good foundation to
- 42:14build for. Trust law, trust law. Pet trusts are
- 42:25just full stop on the forefront of ecological
- 42:27laws emerging worldwide. I think some of you
- 42:32know about trust, but how a pet trust works is
- 42:35that an animal instead of an individual or a
- 42:41cause is the beneficiary of a trust. And there's
- 42:46been a lot of litigation over this. You've heard
- 42:48of people giving like, oh, someone gave $100
- 42:50million to their dog. Can they do that? But there's
- 42:53actually laws in a lot of states specific to
- 42:55pet trust because people love their pets and
- 42:58gosh darn it, they want to give their inheritance
- 43:00to their pet to make sure they're cared for.
- 43:03And that wasn't clearly allowable before. So
- 43:05we're going to pass laws to make that allowable
- 43:07because traditionally you cannot have as the
- 43:10beneficiary of an estate something that's just
- 43:12quote property. So they started creating pet
- 43:15pet trusts and there's you know look in your
- 43:17state might have a law about pet trusts in your
- 43:19state and I think this is interesting because
- 43:24it again shows that animals while property are
- 43:26beginning to go into a different lane where especially
- 43:29with companion animals are treated as something
- 43:32more. There's some rules about pet trust I'm
- 43:35just going to give you the low the low down rule
- 43:37about pet trust you want to create a pet trust
- 43:39there's there's just something you got to do
- 43:42don't do it this way. Don't do it this way. There's
- 43:46a gift in this Helmsley case where they left
- 43:48$12 million to the trust of a dog named Trouble.
- 43:51And they challenged this trust. And eventually,
- 43:54the courts reduced the trust from $12 million
- 43:56to $2 million. Who challenges the trust? Of course,
- 43:59it's the kids and stuff who say, why you left
- 44:01all your money to our pet dog? And what do you
- 44:03hate me? And, oh, I just really love the dog.
- 44:07The issue with this case is that the court felt
- 44:10it was overfunded. In the pet trust, you can
- 44:13describe what does the dog get? What do you do
- 44:15to the dog? Do you give it daily walks? Do you
- 44:18groom it? Do you give it the best dog food? Do
- 44:20you give it amazing toys? What's the money being
- 44:22spent for? In this case, the court said, well,
- 44:26okay, you're spending this money for all these
- 44:27things. That's not going to cost $12 million.
- 44:29No way we're going to give $10 million to the
- 44:32family. You just need $2 million for that, for
- 44:34what you described in the trust. The lesson there
- 44:37is if you give a big fat gift to a dog or a cat
- 44:42or a companion animal in a pet trust and you're
- 44:45like I want my dog to have 10 million dollars
- 44:4720 million dollars what you got to do is define
- 44:49what that money is going to be spent for and
- 44:51it has to be a reasonable expenditure of that
- 44:54money so if you say okay they're going to have
- 44:56five personal security guards they're going to
- 44:57have grooming six times a day they're going to
- 44:59have filet mignon it's going to be cooked by
- 45:01the world's best chef okay the court says okay
- 45:03well you wanted all these things you're right
- 45:05you do need 30 million dollars But if you give
- 45:0830 million and they have kibbles and bits and
- 45:10go on one walk a day, the courts might not uphold
- 45:12it. So if you're trying to give all your money
- 45:14to your pet, which I think is a fun way to go
- 45:17out, just make sure you include enough detail
- 45:20so it is upheld by the courts. So that's in the
- 45:23US. So we talked about Criminal law, animals
- 45:28are kind of becoming victims. We're making pet
- 45:30trusts that are kind of showing, okay, maybe
- 45:32animals can be beneficiaries of trusts. There's
- 45:35actually a little movement now to say that, hey,
- 45:38why can't dogs can be beneficiaries of trusts?
- 45:40Why can't wildlife be beneficiaries of trust
- 45:43as well? Why can't wildlife own property through
- 45:46a trust and manage it itself through a guardian
- 45:48that speaks on its behalf? So we're starting
- 45:50to see here there's these innovations in the
- 45:53law. often start with pets, honestly, and then
- 45:56you can kind of expand them to other rights holders.
- 45:59Desmond's law is one that I think could be expanded
- 46:02beyond pets. This one's really cool. Desmond's
- 46:06law is a law in Connecticut that allows a human,
- 46:11a law student, or a lawyer to represent a dog
- 46:15or other companion animal directly in an animal
- 46:21abuse case. And what happened was they realized
- 46:26in all these cases about animal cruelty that
- 46:29dogs weren't being properly represented. There
- 46:31was often low conviction rates. They're like,
- 46:33something's missing here. They're like, well,
- 46:35the dog itself or the animal itself in a lot
- 46:37of these animal cruelty cases, no one like directly
- 46:40representing its interests. If there's a child
- 46:43in court, they have a guardian, a lawyer directly
- 46:45representing their interests. What if dogs and
- 46:48companion animals had that as well? And so they
- 46:51did this in Connecticut. So there's all these
- 46:52cases now involving animal cruelty, where a lawyer
- 46:56or law student directly represents the animal
- 46:59involved, speaks on its behalf, advocates for
- 47:02it as an attorney. So the animal has literally
- 47:05a voice in the courts. It's what Justice Douglas
- 47:08wanted in Sierra Club versus Morton, where he
- 47:10asked, should the forest have standing? Should
- 47:13trees have standing applied to pets? But what
- 47:17if he wrote this exact same statute and said
- 47:19that Hey, all bees, all orcas, all animals, all
- 47:23ecosystems can have lawyers to speak for them
- 47:26in the courts. It'd be pretty easy to do that.
- 47:29All you do is take Desmond's law, you change
- 47:32the word animal or companion animal or dog to
- 47:36nature, the forest, old growth forest ecosystem,
- 47:40and pass the bill. And we've shown proof of concept
- 47:43through this law that this is workable. Hey,
- 47:45lawyers come in and speak for the animals. That's
- 47:48great. Could we do the same thing for ecosystems?
- 47:52And could it be law students that go in and do
- 47:54it? And would this transform their own careers?
- 47:56And they go into a good corporate law career
- 47:58and think about, you know, now that I'm earning
- 48:00all this prestige and power and I'm doing great
- 48:02work, can I get back to nature in some way? And
- 48:04hey, I did that as a law student in this new
- 48:07state statute that was passed. This is something
- 48:10could totally manifest in the United States or
- 48:12elsewhere. So something I'm keeping my eye on.
- 48:16And then I wanna turn back to kind of an original
- 48:18question. Individual personhood for animals.
- 48:23What is an animal under the law? Their property,
- 48:27their thing, their resource or something we own.
- 48:30But what if they were something more? And these
- 48:32are just a couple of examples where individual
- 48:35animals are part of movements to treat them as
- 48:39something more. There's a couple... Advocates
- 48:44behind these two movements, this is the late
- 48:46Steve Weiss on the left there, who founded the
- 48:50Non -Human Rights Project, an NGO dedicated to
- 48:53the personhood of animals. And this is Reynaldo
- 48:57Schielehele -Morris on the right, who's an advocate
- 48:59for the rights of orcas in the Pacific Northwest,
- 49:03a member of the Lummi Nation. And so let me just
- 49:06quickly talk about these two cases and I'll answer
- 49:08a couple questions and we're done. Southern resident
- 49:13orcas are an endangered species in the Pacific
- 49:16Northwest. Unlike many orcas, they live off of
- 49:20salmon. And if you know the Pacific Northwest,
- 49:23you know the salmon populations have been devastated,
- 49:26particularly by damming of rivers, but also by
- 49:29pollution. There's only 74 left in the wild,
- 49:32and one particular orca was captured. taken from
- 49:36the Pacific Northwest, like many others that
- 49:38were brought to sea aquariums and zoos and places
- 49:43to perform tricks for tourists. And I showed
- 49:48you that earlier chart, which is what is nature
- 49:51to us? And to the Lummi people, orcas are known
- 49:56as relatives. They consider them people under
- 49:59the waves. They are kin. They have a sacred obligation
- 50:04to protect them. And so when it came to this
- 50:07one orca named Scully chuck tonight, it was taken
- 50:11to the Miami Sea aquarium. They were using laws
- 50:16to seek her freedom, to bring her back to the
- 50:18Pacific Northwest that are laws for owning property,
- 50:22you know, try to buy her back. But what if the
- 50:25law understood that certain people treat nature
- 50:28as family? What if for this particular orca,
- 50:31instead of the cap door, the Miami Sea aquarium,
- 50:34making decisions on what we should do with Scully
- 50:37Chuck Tenat, who by the way was in the smallest
- 50:39orca tank in the entire world for over 50 years.
- 50:42What if we listen to her family members to determine
- 50:44what is in her best interest, just as we do for
- 50:47our own family members when they're in complex
- 50:49situations. So this kind of opened my eyes to
- 50:53the idea that nature can be family, there can
- 50:55be family law to protect nature, and there's
- 50:57been a campaign for the rights of southern resident
- 50:59orcas in the Pacific Northwest that kind of ties
- 51:01in with this one captive orca. Just to tie up
- 51:05the story, eventually a deal was reached to free
- 51:07this orca to bring her back to the Pacific Northwest.
- 51:11But she died in captivity before that could be
- 51:13manifested. But now the Lummi elders and others
- 51:16in the Pacific Northwest who tried to free this
- 51:18one orca are advancing the rights of all orca
- 51:21populations in that region. So something to keep
- 51:24an eye on. And then Happy the Elephant is a really
- 51:29interesting case where Happy was held in the
- 51:32Bronx Zoo. captive. They're happy as looking
- 51:35at a fence. And there's a lawsuit from the Non
- 51:39-Human Rights Project to try to use habeas corpus
- 51:42law to free happy as an individual. So remember
- 51:45we talked about populations a lot of animals
- 51:47and this is kind of a rights of nature perspective.
- 51:50This is about the inherent dignity of one animal
- 51:53happy. They tried to use habeas corpus law to
- 51:56free happy from this small confinement in a zoo
- 51:59and release happy to an elephant sanctuary. And
- 52:03there was a case brought, it got to the highest
- 52:05court in New York. They began to do an analysis
- 52:09and said, look, humans have personhood and rights
- 52:13because we have dignity, we experience pain,
- 52:15we have emotion, we have family. These are all
- 52:18the things that feed into the understanding that
- 52:20we have our own rights. And hey, elephants are
- 52:23really a lot the same. They can understand the
- 52:25reflection. There's a reflection test. They care
- 52:28for their young. When they get old, they chew
- 52:30up food and put it in the mouths of other elephants.
- 52:32They can't chew anymore, so they can continue
- 52:34to live. They show empathy. They're caring creatures.
- 52:37They deserve rights just as humans do. Their
- 52:39reasoning is the same. And hey, society has deprived
- 52:43rights of women, of Indigenous peoples, of Black
- 52:47people, of minorities, of immigrants, of children
- 52:49in different ways, and we've evolved the law
- 52:51over time to have a more just and comprehensive
- 52:53legal system. It is time for us to do this to
- 52:57animals. Let's start with the elephant. This
- 52:59one is a no -brainer. So there's a big discussion
- 53:03in courts. There's opposition. There's support.
- 53:07There's a bunch of amicus briefs submitted. They're
- 53:09really fascinating to read. Eventually, the New
- 53:13York Court of Appeals, the highest court in New
- 53:15York ruled that, alas, Happy is not a person
- 53:18and cannot seek release via habeas corpus. Essentially,
- 53:22they argued that looking at the law and the common
- 53:25law in this case, there's not an indication that
- 53:27it would apply to animals or a corporation's
- 53:30persons. I don't know. It was in a headnote in
- 53:32some old case about a railroad. You can read
- 53:34it. But I think, interestingly, in this case,
- 53:37there were two judges that dissented. including
- 53:42Judge Rowan Wilson. And Judge Rowan Wilson said,
- 53:47we should recognize Happy's right to petition
- 53:49for her liberty, not just because she is a wild
- 53:51animal who is not meant to be caged and displayed,
- 53:55but because the rights we confer on others define
- 53:57who we are as a society. So I think that's an
- 54:02interesting point to land on because where does
- 54:05the law come from? Well, we made it up. What
- 54:09principles Is the law based on? Well, in terms
- 54:14of nature, it's based on our superiority to nature,
- 54:17self -proclaimed. It's based on the idea that
- 54:19we believe animals are just things or property
- 54:22that we own. The law is based on the understanding
- 54:27that we ourselves are not an animal, perhaps.
- 54:31The law is based on the understanding that only
- 54:33humans have rights and no other entities do,
- 54:35or human -created corporations. The law is based
- 54:39on the understandings that we are somehow enlightened
- 54:41or better than the rest of the living world.
- 54:45And I would say that these core principles of
- 54:48our jurisprudence, which you could call an anthropocentric
- 54:51jurisprudence, humans are the center of the universe,
- 54:54are a root cause of the environmental decline
- 54:57in the US and globally, and are a root cause
- 55:00of our horrific, horrific treatment of animals.
- 55:05But what if we had a new jurisprudence? that
- 55:08was the root of our legal system. What if it
- 55:12said that humans are part of nature, not inseparable,
- 55:16not separable from it? What if it said that all
- 55:19animals deserve basic dignity? Even if we hunt
- 55:22and fish them, what if they all had basic dignity?
- 55:26What if we own parts of nature? Sure, like the
- 55:30land that you live on, but we had a duty to get
- 55:32back to nature. There was a ethic of reciprocity.
- 55:36to the natural world in all of our laws, what
- 55:39would the law look like? Would it cause endless
- 55:43lawsuits and challenges? And would the courts
- 55:46be overwhelmed with thousands of instances of
- 55:50litigation? Or could society come up with new
- 55:54rules that allowed us to thrive economically
- 55:56and ecologically? And I think it's the latter.
- 56:00And I think we're training a new generation of
- 56:02lawyers with expertise in this space and other
- 56:05ecological innovations who are going to be able
- 56:07to transition humans to a new world in which
- 56:10we live in harmony with nature. And I think one
- 56:14day we're going to look back at our treatment
- 56:15of animals and our treatment of environment with
- 56:18the same sort of horror that we look back at
- 56:20our treatment of each other in areas of slavery,
- 56:26before women's suffrage, during World War II,
- 56:29where there were horrific crimes committed against
- 56:31humans. And I think we are one day going to figure
- 56:33this out and create a legal system that represents
- 56:37all life on Earth. And it's beginning to happen.
- 56:40So even if you don't think that's the right pathway,
- 56:42it's one that's emerging and I hope you all learn
- 56:44about it yourselves. So let me do rapid fire
- 56:49Q &A and then we'll end this session. Thanks,
- 56:52Jonathan, for acknowledging Justice Douglas,
- 56:541972. Everyone should go read that court. case
- 56:57here, Klum versus Morton. How does enforcement
- 57:00work? I think you're bringing up issues here
- 57:05of different ecosystems and species that are
- 57:09kind of interacting with each other. Like you
- 57:10help one species, then another one is harmed,
- 57:12and another moves in. I think it's not up to
- 57:16humans to achieve, quote, total harmony. but
- 57:19to allow nature to live in its own relationship.
- 57:23So if there's one species that naturally evolves
- 57:26to supplant another, that's in accordance with
- 57:28the laws of the natural world. But just in terms
- 57:32of enforcement, there's courts. I don't think
- 57:35we need to go to courts right now. I think implementation
- 57:37should really fall to governments right now,
- 57:40or let's say a local government adopts the rights
- 57:42of nature. or rights of an animal, I think that
- 57:45government should create rules and structures
- 57:47such as through zoning rules that show what this
- 57:51means in practice so we're not just litigating
- 57:52in the courts. So if you're a local government
- 57:55and you give rights to animals, I think you should
- 57:57create a playbook for what that actually means
- 58:00so we don't have to get involved in litigation,
- 58:02we're just all on the same page. How do we make
- 58:08pet rights more protective? um yeah you know
- 58:12unfortunately a lot of pet rights do still treat
- 58:14animals as property so if someone kills your
- 58:16pet you might get you know five hundred dollars
- 58:19the value of the pet um there's some exceptions
- 58:21to that like the intentional infliction of emotional
- 58:24distress or some other instances where it's like
- 58:27you are impacted emotionally or economically
- 58:30so you can recover some more money But it's rarely
- 58:34about actually the animal's own suffering. It's
- 58:36about your suffering as a result of the animal
- 58:38suffering. So I do think we need a little bit
- 58:40of more compassion in the law for the animal
- 58:43itself. And maybe there's some examples of best
- 58:45practices out there you can look for. Will I
- 58:48make the deck available? Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 58:53kindly lets me. Yes, I think we'll make the deck
- 58:55available and I know there was a lot more than
- 58:56the reading. I teach a whole summer course on
- 58:59this and I didn't want to bombard you, so I gave
- 59:01you a very light introduction, so for sure. As
- 59:06a volunteer, there's some frustration that animal
- 59:08abuse laws are never enforced. And I agree. And
- 59:10that's why I think some of these laws that allow
- 59:13young law students or law students of any age
- 59:16to get involved in enforcement could be interesting
- 59:19because it gives them experience in the courts.
- 59:22It exposes them to the empathy and understanding
- 59:25that nature and animal can be your clients. And
- 59:28it helps bridge some of this enforcement gap
- 59:30because I agree there's a lack of accountability
- 59:32there. And I'm really sorry to hear about some
- 59:34of the horrible conditions here. Is a service
- 59:38dog entitled to a higher level of protection?
- 59:41I think it just depends what the laws defining
- 59:44service dogs say. So I guess that could be in
- 59:46the American with Disabilities Act. I think there's
- 59:50rules and regulations about not bugging other
- 59:52people's service dogs because, and this gets
- 59:55to one of the challenges, because it's a violation
- 59:57of their owner's rights who has a right to protection
- 1:00:00to live a life despite their disability. So it's
- 1:00:04about them, not the dog so much. And New York
- 1:00:07treats pets as family members. They sure do,
- 1:00:09and so does British Columbia. So let's end with
- 1:00:11that strong note. There are a lot of innovations
- 1:00:14happening in the law. I'm really grateful you
- 1:00:16spent this hour for me. Please check out some
- 1:00:18of the work happening in your area. Please check
- 1:00:21out Earth Law Center. And above all, if you're
- 1:00:23involved in the law, look to innovate in the
- 1:00:26space and think about ways you can contribute
- 1:00:28to this evolution of Earth's jurisprudence to
- 1:00:30give animals the dignity they deserve. So thank
- 1:00:34you so much.