Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Lessons - Finding Product Market Fit & Scaling In A New Industry | Yosef Martin, CEO & Founder of Boxycharm
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the lessons episodes of Success Story.
- 0:13These lessons episodes will be shorter clips from past guests, accomplished value community
- 0:19members, and myself.
- 0:21In each short episode we'll feature concise and insightful actionable conversations and
- 0:27tactics providing you with real-world strategies and tips to help you achieve your personal
- 0:33and professional goals.
- 0:34If you're seeking a no-nonsense approach to growth and progress, you've come to the right
- 0:38spot.
- 0:39Settle in, take notes, and enjoy.
- 0:43When you started off, you didn't have any experience in beauty, and I want you to just
- 0:46comment on what a lot of people think is, find a way to monetize your passion or find
- 0:51a way to monetize the things that you know best.
- 0:53And even when you're talking before, when you work in an industry or a vertical for
- 0:56so long, it's really easy to start a business in that industry because you know it so well.
- 1:01You came in with nothing.
- 1:03When you're launching something and you're creating the category was somewhat defined
- 1:07but not really and you're creating a new product and a new category, how do you know that
- 1:13you're moving in the right direction?
- 1:15Because it's not intrinsically motivated because of a passion for makeup and beauty.
- 1:20You have to have external motivators and validators at the business moving in the right
- 1:23direction or you would give up.
- 1:25For sure you'd give up because you'd be like, I don't get this, it's not working.
- 1:28And you probably have a lot of self-doubt too because you're like, I'm probably not
- 1:31getting it because I don't know beauty and I'm missing the mark on something.
- 1:35You launch it.
- 1:36How did you keep it moving?
- 1:37You know, I think there's a plus and minus in both, right?
- 1:41The fact that I didn't understand the beauty industry, I see it more of a bigger plus than
- 1:46a minus.
- 1:48If I was a consumer, I would have been in another box, there were many boxes, I mean,
- 1:522014 was the year of the boxes and most of our competitors, at least their boxes were
- 1:56curated by women.
- 1:58And I had to be the one pushing it almost all the way to the end, eventually I found
- 2:02the right people to take over.
- 2:05But it was tough.
- 2:06The part where it's easy to understand that an outsider is going to be the trailblazer.
- 2:13I was the outsider.
- 2:14And I just did not think like the consumer that apply makeup, I thought as a person that
- 2:20want to understand what the consumer wants.
- 2:21And you find out that the consumer have different opinions and different days.
- 2:26And technically, when I would do it, I would just do focus groups and I would have my team
- 2:33there.
- 2:34At first, we had nothing but women working for me.
- 2:36And I would just have them all asking, what do you think about this?
- 2:39What do you think about that?
- 2:40What do you think?
- 2:41You'll figure it out fairly quickly at what works, what doesn't work.
- 2:45But one thing I did understand is that looking at the item right now, you understand very
- 2:51quickly what's trending.
- 2:52Okay, so you can say, okay, this category is trending, anything it's going to say holographic
- 2:57highlighter in 2017, that's the thing or 2016, that's the thing everybody wanted, right?
- 3:02Get it as soon as you can, it's a it's a fact, it's going to go away, but now don't buy
- 3:06it tomorrow because you can get stuck with this.
- 3:08So you understand the fight you've seen already enough and you know what's trending, right?
- 3:12But you also understand that it's only a particular consumer that's going to want to use it.
- 3:17But what you don't understand at first is that there is a difference between receiving the
- 3:21product and there's a difference between viewing the product on Instagram before people
- 3:25receive the product.
- 3:27And if you're a person who uses that, you would probably think mostly about, I like it
- 3:33and I don't like it.
- 3:34That is the end part of the of the logistic process.
- 3:38They received it and now they're going to give their opinion.
- 3:40You need to get them excited when they see the image on social media.
- 3:44That part is completely different than trying it.
- 3:46So at first I was asking the team to try the product and tell me what they think.
- 3:52And the results were not always great because they would love the product, but when you put
- 3:57it on social media, the product was too small and people didn't apply perceived value
- 4:01when they saw something small on social media when they received it.
- 4:04The comments were positive, but by then you already get trashed for selling them small
- 4:08items.
- 4:09So then you said, okay, and that's just one example for many things like, okay, we need
- 4:12to go and just have them look at the item and say, what would you think if you see this
- 4:16on social media?
- 4:17Okay, now get to try it.
- 4:18You have to break it down into two parts.
- 4:21And it was all trial and error based on, I mean, it was because of blood that was shed
- 4:26over mistakes that we made, right?
- 4:28We would buy an item that was very, very small, but very expensive because there was pearls
- 4:32from Europe to people and people hated that, but when they got it, they liked it, but
- 4:37it was too late.
- 4:38It gets me.
- 4:39So we had to learn through those, through those mistakes and that was, that was the thing.
- 4:44If you keep chasing the perfect kind of improving and exciting the consumer with a better product,
- 4:51then you're going to win.
- 4:52And Elmi understands something.
- 4:53So for the business model, when you're shipping out these boxes, is the, is the opportunity
- 4:59for the consumer because they get, rather, is the excitement for the consumer because
- 5:02they see it on social and they like getting something new and it's like exciting.
- 5:06Or is there actually like a dollar value?
- 5:09So is there a margin that you're taking advantage of when you put it in the market?
- 5:12Let me break it down a bit more about the concept, right?
- 5:14And how do you get more, more than a million members by the time we exit paying members?
- 5:20The reason you grow so much, this is one, it's a discovery concept.
- 5:24There are two types of subscriptions, physical subscriptions.
- 5:27One is replenishment, the other one is discovery.
- 5:30So replenishment is, I don't know, your vitamin supplements, you need a, my, my company.
- 5:34Yeah, exactly.
- 5:35So that's something that you know you're going to get and you're getting it and that's
- 5:38it.
- 5:39You're not going to take a screenshot.
- 5:40Look, I just got my razors again, you're not going to do it, right?
- 5:43You have to really create awareness by yourself every time.
- 5:47It's actually different because people don't know what to receive.
- 5:50And if they're happy, they're going to take a picture and they're going to go and post
- 5:52this and they're going to bring awareness for you for free.
- 5:55That happens in my case, that was a discovery.
- 5:58What we did was we went on the full size and we made sure that the price ratio was about
- 6:04four or four and a half to five times, sometimes six times.
- 6:07So you pay $25, but the retail value is about $150.
- 6:12So now there is that, there's the price, there is the, the surprise element and there
- 6:18is a matching with your personalization that works every time.
- 6:23And those are the reasons, it was a couple reasons why they get excited.
- 6:26It's kind of a surprise every month for themselves, awesome deal that they got.
- 6:30Now two reasons for them to brag and subscribe and bring more subscribers and build your
- 6:34awareness.
- 6:35It's kind of like the rich get richer.
- 6:36You have 10,000 subscribers, less pictures on Instagram, you have a million get more.
- 6:42And that was the reason we were able to scale consistently because we focused on the fact
- 6:47that they needed to get excited when they opened the box.
- 6:50And you architect it, you architected a little bit of that FOMO.
- 6:53So because you found bigger products that were Instagramable and I also love, we're going
- 6:57to talk about like your influencer marketing strategy and your growth strategy, but you
- 7:01architected a little bit that FOMO so that when people saw it on Instagram, then they're
- 7:05like, now I want to, I want to see what's coming and what's new and then you architected
- 7:08a little bit of virality and I know that you were doing lives at some point, but you
- 7:12were like, you were hyper focused on like influencer marketing on social.
- 7:17Did you run?
- 7:18I can't remember if you ran paid as well.
- 7:19Did you run a lot of paid?
- 7:20At the end before we sold, we started, I think we, not for the most, not for a lot of
- 7:24money.
- 7:25Most of those years, no, only at the end when we went through a process about to sell
- 7:29the business, it was time to start learning how to do performance, paid marketing on Facebook.
- 7:35We got to 100 million plus in sales close to 200 without really putting any money in
- 7:41marketing.
- 7:42That's insane.
- 7:43I mean, we did money marketing, but influencers not paid and it was working because again,
- 7:50your biggest piece of marketing is your product and if you can create millions of views, many
- 7:56millions of views through influencers and through your members, that's all it takes.
- 8:01If you didn't sell your product, it's because your product didn't sell itself.
- 8:07Then you get a work on everything else.
- 8:08So while we put, when we put the product, so our growth was as far as more like 20 million
- 8:14a year, 50 million a year, 100 million, 100 plus, 200 plus, 400 plus.
- 8:19That's how we, and then that's when we exit the company.
- 8:22And it was consistently growing because it was laser focused on the fact that we want
- 8:26to make sure that the experience is going to be great and the product would sell itself.
- 8:31And a set of influencer marketing that today everybody knows and do, what we, what I, what
- 8:38we actually were able to build was a tight community, but not a community in the terms of
- 8:46just saying, oh, we have a community.
- 8:47No, no, no, no, no, what does it really mean a community?
- 8:51A community is a group of people with the same interest in the same space activating together.
- 8:58When you take that and you said, okay, what is my space?
- 9:00Where is my space?
- 9:01We found that there, you can have your space say on your, on your IG page or your Facebook page,
- 9:08but we found, we found a much better space.
- 9:11We found a space that's actually their space that they gathered together already just to talk
- 9:15about us. That was on Facebook groups and they created, they created that themselves.
- 9:19Now, they, when I found out in 2017 that our Facebook groups, it's just something on Facebook,
- 9:25at the time they call it forms, it was, it was nice because I just wanted to hear the sentiment.
- 9:29So I joined them and they said, look, it's only women are allowed.
- 9:33And at that time, nobody knew who I was.
- 9:34I was private on my accounts and they told them, I'm the founder, a boxy chairman.
- 9:38I just want to hear the sentiment.
- 9:39They were really excited that I joined.
- 9:41And then they said, oh, listen, or the owner of boxy charm came and they were posting this
- 9:45and everyone wanted to hear me.
- 9:47So then I said, this is my super charmers.
- 9:50Those are the, those are the most advocated consumers.
- 9:53They call each other charmers on the forms.
- 9:56They said, we need another moderators.
- 9:57We need another two charmers to be moderators.
- 9:59Coming, I was saying, this is it.
- 10:02I didn't even know that happens.
- 10:03This is kind of like a, a backroom door to, to group of passionate people.
- 10:07Of those passionate people you have.
- 10:09Most passionate people.
- 10:10And then I hit me and said, the community is not about the size of your community.
- 10:15It's about the passion of your community.
- 10:17How can I amplify the passion?
- 10:19And then I'm going to amplify their numbers.
- 10:21So I said, here is my space.
- 10:23So I said, look, guys, you know what?
- 10:25I'm going to let you know before anybody else what's going to be next month in the box.
- 10:28It's going to be a sneak peak.
- 10:29We usually used to do on our platform sneak peak on the first of the month.
- 10:33I'm going to give you two weeks before that.
- 10:36Everyone wanted to join those groups.
- 10:37And I announced it on our pages on Instagram.
- 10:41You saw three forms turning to nearly 60 or 80 forms.
- 10:46Any so many other makeup forms and groups asking me to join them just to let them know what's there.
- 10:54No problem because there are many charmers over there.
- 10:57And then I ended up having at the end submitting information to about 100 forms every month.
- 11:02The largest boxy charm form at that time I noticed was more than 90,000 people.
- 11:07In one form and my goal was to
- 11:11gather them all together, all those passionate members.
- 11:15And make sure that they're going to be discussing together.
- 11:17That is their activation.
- 11:19That's where you activate them together.
- 11:21And I would say, well, check my Instagram.
- 11:24I would have them all moved to my Instagram page.
- 11:26Everything outside of the boxy charm page.
- 11:29Make sure that it's going to be kind of like the underground parts,
- 11:32not the regular channels.
- 11:33So they'll feel they're special.
- 11:35Come into my Instagram page.
- 11:36I'll show you something no one's going to see it.
- 11:38It's going to be behind my back.
- 11:38That's going to be a sneak peek.
- 11:39Go in and check it out.
- 11:41Now they connected on Instagram.
- 11:43So now those two friends that were talking on Facebook now they get to see each other's Instagram page.
- 11:48Now they're friends because of boxy charm because there's 12 of how that was creating kind of like
- 11:55it's a very tight community of people that became so close to each other
- 12:00over a boxy charm.
- 12:01That was the common denominator.
- 12:02And they were so passionate that you get to a point
- 12:05that the community was so solid that when I needed to launch a new product
- 12:10it was a quarterly back in subscription box.
- 12:13I announced it twice one time on on boxy charm Instagram page and one time on the forums.
- 12:19I told them in a month and a half there's going to be a new box.
- 12:22It's going to be quarterly coming.
- 12:25The site crashed.
- 12:26I expected about 40,000 buyers and I thought I'm going to sell 20,000 boxes.
- 12:30I wanted to sell out quick.
- 12:32We had about 200,000 people clicking the checkout page on the second we opened it up.
- 12:36We told them 9 a.m. September 1st, 200,000 people take my money.
- 12:42We added 30 million dollars just like that into a revenue stream in a second from two posts
- 12:46because there was an infrastructure.
- 12:48There was a community.
- 12:50Everyone spoke about that.
- 12:52And it was really important for me the momentum
- 12:55because we had a competitor coming at the same time with their innovation.
- 12:58I wanted to make sure that I'm going to take the entire conversation away from them.
- 13:03And I had to go and make sure that it's going to be on that date.
- 13:06So development team couldn't really complete the site testing to make sure the site crashed.
- 13:12But it's okay.
- 13:14Mission accomplished.
- 13:15All of them subscribed for the following box because we didn't have enough boxes for them.
- 13:21And no one heard about the other companies new innovation.
- 13:25We just took away the discussion in the space.