Latest / Under The Pallet Wrap / Episode 20 - Would You Rather - Supply Chain Edition
Transcript
- Keith: Welcome to Under the Pallet Wrap episode 20, another landmark. Can you believe it? Last time we did a bit of a 10 episode reflection. Today we're going to have a bit of fun. We're going to play a supply chain edition of the Would You Rather game. We're going to put some questions to each other. We don't know the answers. We'll see how they go. Should be quite fun. So, to no further ado. Dan Culverhouse: Mm-hmm. We made it. Keith: What's first question on our list then? Dan Culverhouse: All right, here we go. So would you rather have a CEO who understands operations but interferes constantly, or one who knows nothing about operations but leaves you alone? Keith: I would rather have a CEO who knows nothing about operations, to be honest. Put the trust in me to get on with it. A CEO who knows a lot about operations but interferes constantly all day leads me to believe they don't know everything about operations or hiring for operations. Dan Culverhouse: I Well, I g yeah, either that or if they understand operations are interfering constantly, they definitely think I don't know anything about it because they feel it's necessary to interfere all the time. Even if you do know, you should know that actually a good operations leader doesn't want interruption. They just want to get on with it. So ⁓ yeah, I I I think as an operator you would definitely rather they just stayed out of it. Keith: Yeah, it's one or the other. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: And ⁓ you know, whether they know about it or not, or you know, they're experiencing it or not, I would definitely feel if they were constantly interfering, it would certainly give me the impression that they didn't believe in what I was doing or they didn't trust me. ⁓ which yeah, would be ⁓ not a great scenario to be operating under, I think. But ⁓ so yeah, so I honestly this one's quite easy, isn't it? Leave us alone, we know what we're doing. Keith: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, they are, but don't trust you, don't trust themselves. I think there should be more CEOs who are ops-based. I'd say that much, but a good one would leave you to it. Dan Culverhouse: But you would ⁓ yeah, I I I I agree that you know, there's definitely a degree of frustration when you have a a CEO who really just doesn't get it, doesn't understand. ⁓ and yeah, great that they leave you alone, but you know ultimately there's gonna be some questions about the cost or about, you know, certain things. So, you know, it's all very well say they leave you alone, but they're still gonna have questions, right? And if you're having to constantly explain why things are the way they are, it would be frustrating. So I think ultimately there is a benefit in having a CEO who gets it. but ⁓ but yeah, but you definitely wouldn't want them interfering 'cause they give you a a clear indication they don't think you're capable if that's what they're doing. But ⁓ but it'd be nice to have a CEO that understood what you were doing. So Keith: Well, if you can make them understand and they learn something from it that's equally beneficial I mean I've had a lot of CEOs who ops ops isn't their strong point. That's okay Here's one. Would you rather have a warehouse manager? So you're their manager who hits every KPI bit destroys morale or One everybody loves who consistently misses the numbers Dan Culverhouse: No. Well, if I was the CEO it would definitely be the first one. 'Cause you just want to hit the numbers, right? But ⁓ but I guess Keith: Yeah I don't think they can hit the numbers if morale is... Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Well well they wouldn't c they wouldn't continue to, right? Because they'd destroy morale sooner or later, they wouldn't have any people to do it with. So I think you can you can do more with somebody who is, so we say, popular but maybe not dealing with things. ⁓ I think it's probably easier to coach somebody up than it is potentially to turn somebody who Yeah, who who who's I guess got no emotional intelligence and just is a dictator, it's very hard to soften that I would suggest. So I think I think if I was given the choice I would I'd like to start with the person that is that people love to be around, love to work with, but is not hitting the numbers 'cause I think you can coax them up to ⁓ to make that performance come much easier than Getting somebody to become liked who's not liked. Keith: I think so. mean to counter that I would possibly you know try and work with the one who was hitting the numbers and find out where the issues were in his or her management techniques. I think that can be coached too. I'm sure some of the issues would be accompanied by some complaints along the way as well so you'd get a little bit of an awareness of their management style. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, the challenge I guess with You know, because i i it i ⁓ i it's interesting. I w I've worked in an operation where there was two operational leaders, we ha we ran a region each, and you know, I'm quite an empathetic leader, although I wouldn't put put myself in the situation where ⁓ everyone loved me but I didn't hit the numbers. I don't think I was like that. People generally liked working for me, but I generally hit the numbers too. ⁓ but he was very much a command and control guy. So he got good performance, but ⁓ I always felt that If anything ever went wrong, they wouldn't be there for him. You know, so you know, I think in this scenario you can have someone who's hitting the numbers, hitting the numbers, but everyone hates working for him. And then when something goes wrong, they just let they just let it go wrong because they'd like to see him suffer. Whereas, you know, the guy that struggles but everybody's backs and has got you know, enjoys having around, they they'd be there for him, right? Or her. Keith: Yeah. Yeah, ties in with the culture discussion last week, doesn't it, about setting expectations and working with both types to make them as effective as they can be. That's the happy path answer anyway. let's throw in another question. ⁓ Would you rather deal with one enormous operational crisis every year or 10 small problems every single day? Dan Culverhouse: Mm. ⁓ well I'm not sure I can remember there ever been a day where I didn't deal with us ten small problems at least. So ⁓ That just feels like a day job. Keith: ⁓ I was like, well, I want to know what the massive operational crisis was. mean, if it was just through circumstance, everyone else was dealing with it like Covid. OK, fair enough. But if they're avoidable. That's not my approach. I would prefer to work on the 10 daily, but reduce them. Focus on fire prevention. So hopefully we'd never get the big. disasters. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, is it the same ten issues every day? Or 'cause that that would be annoying. Keith: It was the same issues 10 days ago. I mean what's going on there? Dan Culverhouse: If w you know, I mean having you know, I've been through some pretty serious crises. ⁓ and and not things like I I I see COVID something like that as something different 'cause that's kind of like everybody's going through it, right? But I I've I've had a a a couple of ⁓ things that have happened through my career where an operation has really kind of ran into a brick wall and it's taken Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: a Gantuan effort. I mean one of them in particular took months to correct. And it was one of the hardest things I've ever done. And I definitely do never don't ever want to have to do that again. ⁓ and I'll take the ten problems every day to rather than have to go through that again because I think it changed me forever. I think there are certain things I I can't go it happened to Singapore. I don't like that country anymore because of that. Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: Because I have to I every time I go there I come out in a cold sweat thinking about it. So it's ruined the whole place for me. But ⁓ so you know, that definitely had quite a serious mental effect on me for quite and it was quite some years ago now. So ⁓ and it's still the thought of it sends a shiver down my back. So ⁓ I'm gonna take the ten small issues and just hopefully they're not the same ten every day, 'cause that would be irritating. Keith: I'll take the 10 issues a day in a startup environment. That's what I'd say. Just bring it on. Like you, I've been through a series of disasters. They just happened to be there because the business was growing so fast. It's just not good on the stress levels, is it? you know, everyone's screaming for answers. It's chaos. Dan Culverhouse: Sure, yeah. Keith: It's not the best place to be so I'd rather deal with you know, I'll deal with them I have to everyone does but I'll take the 10 with the view that I'm Reducing them over time and I'm at a start-up Yeah Dan Culverhouse: Sure, yeah. And there's no doubt, there's no doubt, Keith, that going through those big kind of challenges, those big crises, you learn a hell of a lot. You know, you go you you you know, you go through and you take a lot of that with you into the next thing that you do to make sure it doesn't happen again. Whereas these little these little problems, you know, you'll overcome them but you know, they're they're they don't really, I guess, register in the same way. So, you know, there's definitely something Keith: They do change your life, they do change your approach. Dan Culverhouse: about being a seasoned operator, you don't get to look as old and ugly as we do, having not been through a few of these crises. But ⁓ you know, and I think from a learning perspective, you learn so much more when you when you're pushed to the limit. You know, I mean I I've I I I've definitely been pushed beyond my limit on a few of these. ⁓ but but you you you know they make you what you are. I think they make you more successful in the long run because you've experienced what terrible really looks like. ⁓ and it does drive you to make sure you don't ever do that again. Keith: They help you preempt. Yeah. Absolutely, they help you preempt and also guide your own teams through the similar type of, well, relative levels of stress that they're going through. It helps you become a much more empathetic leader ⁓ and more of a problem solver, more of a team player. All of the good things, it helps you become. You question yourself, you learn from it, it changes you. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. It does. Keith: Hopefully you get out the other side better. But I don't wish it on my team, that sort of stress. ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: No, absolutely. A and I think it it's one of those things that I I I can't there was a good book I read once about resilience. ⁓ and it talked to I can't remember what it was called off the top of my head, but ⁓ I remember it was saying about how people who are talented ⁓ and have all the skills, you know, they can go a long, long time without ever really being tested because they find it easy, you know, like they're very intelligent. They're very intuitive or whatever it is. So they don't really come up against major challenges. maybe for a long time, but then eventually it will happen. And what you realize is that you've got somebody in your team that ha has got no it sounds terrible, no backbone. They just haven't got that resilience to fight through when things go completely to shit. ⁓ you know, most of us have done it a number of times and you know. it it's not that rare ⁓ in operations to have to go through something big. But these people who find this stuff easy, let's say, and go through many, many years maybe of of not ever having that. So if you had, you know, in this scenario that we're talking about, if you just had these ten things coming up every day, different things, little things, so you just fixed them. I don't think you build that resilience to when if something ever did go horribly wrong. that you would really know how to handle it. Whereas I think if you've gone through a few bigger things that really test you, I think it builds a resilience in you and a and a an ability to stay calm in the face of adversity and see through it, you know, rise yourself up and see past the immediate. Whereas lots of little problems, I just don't think you necessarily ever build that muscle or that skill of resilience, which is ⁓ there's a lot to be said for having a resilient ⁓ team. ⁓ around you. Keith: Absolutely, absolutely not one crisis a year. So what question have you got next then? Dan Culverhouse: No. Alright, am I gonna go? Is it my turn? Let's have a look. ⁓ that's a bit similar to the last one. Would you rather be known as the leader who always delivers or the leader who built an operation that no longer needs them? Keith: My whole ethos is built around the second. I'd rather build ⁓ capable, independent, self-sufficient teams. I've got no interest of being the ⁓ leader that everybody goes to. I've been there, I've done that. It was a nice buzz at the beginning, it was crippling to everybody by the end. ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: Now I've let go a lot of any sort of egotistical drivers to building teams. So 100%. My whole thing is about being invisible. Not invisible to the leaders to the C level, ⁓ but. building capable teams for the day to day. I don't want to be held back by the day to day that the team are capable of managing and yeah I think it should you know rather than a lot of the work I do now is based on removing that sort of thing from operations. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Well, I think ⁓ we talked about this in ⁓ that episode we did about succession planning, right? That the you know, that you know, ⁓ I think in the early days you get a bit of a rush from being the boss and ⁓ everybody needing you and you feel very important. but I think you learn quickly that that's a curse, not a not a you know, it's it's it's not a a medal of honour, it's a curse because if it can't run without you then Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: It can't run without you and that means you've got to be there. ⁓ so I think every leader that has reached a certain maturity will know the key is to have it set up so it can operate without you. ⁓ that doesn't mean that you're not needed anymore or you're never around, but it just means that when you Yeah, when you wanna go away for the weekend or ⁓ you know, take the day off, you don't need to be on your phone all day. ⁓ you don't need anybody ringing you up. So I think ⁓ Keith: No, you need it on more complex stuff. Absolutely. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, absolutely. ⁓ a good leader needs to get over the egotistical kind of feeling of being ⁓ wanted and needed every minute of the day and enjoy seeing your operation flourish with other people at the helm and you just having that watching brief. I think there's nothing better than that feeling. Nothing better. Keith: Yeah, you use your brain elsewhere driving a team forward. You'd hope. ⁓ Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Yeah. So that's quite an easy one. All right, I got a better one here. But this one, this one will get you this is gonna have some conversation. Would you rather go back to paper based stock cards forever or fully automate with a zero human oversight? So fully automated, no people around, or it's stock cards forever. This is a horrible one. Keith: Well, with no oversight, who knows what could go wrong. ⁓ But that doesn't sound very exciting. Dan Culverhouse: It's true. It's true, you wouldn't really be involved, right? I guess it'll still be it'll still be your operation. Keith: Well, unless there's problems all the time, but well, unless ⁓ there's a lot of problems caused by the lack of oversight, you know, the fact that everything was automated and the inputs weren't really reviewed closely enough. So your whole day, I mean, there's no staff to manage, but your whole day is spent fixing automation issues. That'd be a terrible existence. I'd rather work on building skills in a more paper based environment with the hope that one day I would be able to implement some efficiencies. The question doesn't allude to that. Both would have their limits in terms of variety and challenge in the end. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Yeah, well you know, I I I love a bit of automation. ⁓ and ⁓ you know, I've had some great experience of implementing ⁓ you know automation solutions, never with zero human ⁓ oversight. I and I I s I think that's pretty difficult to get to. but ⁓ I would definitely I definitely like the challenge of being able to create an operation that would run without the necessity of people you know kind of manipulating it and keeping it going. Interesting I was reading an interesting article this morning actually about but the problem with systems and automated solutions is they they're designed for the perfect scenario. And that's why it always needs so many people is because you very rarely get the perfect scenario and therefore you need to constantly intervene to ⁓ to help it through because it's not quite the perfect scenario all the time. So I think actually creating a fully automated operation with zero human involvement. I mean, the closest I've seen is a full pallet thing where it just had a couple of maintenance guys and it was just four pallets in from a factory. Full pallets out and even the trucks were auto loaded. ⁓ and this this was twenty odd years ago as well. It's quite pressing. but it was a very, very simple operation. You know, you never broke down a pallet or anything. But ⁓ So yeah, I think I think I'd I'd have to go with I'd have to go with it. Y y yeah I I'd need the people. So I'd have to go with the paper based, but yeah, i it's one of those kind of it's so po it's so polar opposite. It's the honor the honest answer is neither, to be honest. Keith: I'd like Yeah, you'd end up not enjoying both. the... Yeah, I think my proper answer is in between the two. I'd like to take the paper-based operation and build the automated one. And then the two extremes of that would not serve much interest for very long. I'd like the... I like the building part. I don't like the ticking boxes. I wouldn't want to get paid to just walk in and... Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, lawyers. Yeah. Keith: make sure the robots are performing yeah having a look at a few spreadsheets and ⁓ saying good morning to the maintenance man who you realize hasn't turned up to work for three years nothing ever goes wrong so yeah Dan Culverhouse: Review the KPIs. Yeah. Yeah. Although although I can remember working in a warehouse with stock cards, you know, no systems and literally having to write out the pick lists and then, you know, cross off the stop and then rub that out and add one in. It was a ball ache of a job. I mean God, it used to drive me crazy. You know, and I always remember when we first implemented the system how incredible it was, 'cause I didn't have to flip through the cards, pull it out, write down, right, take a palette from there and put it into that location and rub it out and add it to the pick face. You know, my God, it was a lot of work. You know, I mean, ⁓ y you'd have to say an entirely paper based operation these days I don't think would survive. I don't think you could afford it. So many people. Keith: No, too much idle time, too much money spent and resources. I think that the killer with it is just that if you had no scope for improvement, you lose your purpose. Certain people would lose their purpose in doing that. And my purpose is to improve and to build capabilities. for me, I really like Groundhog Day if nothing could change in both cases. I remember I used to ask... Dan Culverhouse: You couldn't reaffit it enough. Keith: team members sometimes just as a general conversation topic would you take a million pounds a year just to pull staples out of ⁓ documents every day someone would drop the pile to you you take the staples out there was no explanation you just had to do it nine to five every single day for one year the prize was a million pounds would you do it Dan Culverhouse: Ha ha ha. If I only had to do it for a year, maybe. But if that meant that was it, I had to do that forever long. For one year. Having had a job where it was almost that boring where I had to stick Spanish labels on onto ⁓ onto onto toiletries. I did that for about a month and that that was bad enough. But so it's hard to know ⁓ it's hard to know. But no, I definitely was not. Keith: Yeah, you only have to do it for one year. I've had a few. But you weren't getting a million for it, that's the difference. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, definitely not. Yeah. Keith: That's funny what motivates us. mean for a million for one year, yes, I'm all over that one. It's funny when some people say, no, I would not do that. Really? What would you need to be paid to do that? ⁓ at least a hundred million. Really? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Don't believe it. Keith: It's one year. Yes, it's mind-numbing. You can throw in a few caveats. Like, yeah, it's also you listen to the same album on Loop the whole time you work there as well, just to make the challenge a little bit harder. You're listening to Wham! Greatest Hits on Loop. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. I was gonna say it depends whether get to choose that album. Yeah. Agado. ⁓ Keith: No, you don't get to choose the album someone else does yeah Yeah, someone else chooses it and it's just random. It's random It comes out what what you push you push the button and out comes the album and that's what you've got to listen to for the year And you take it or leave it on that day Dan Culverhouse: He definitely wouldn't make a yeah, you you There's some high risk in that. ⁓ Keith: There is, I think I'd just say yes, but the year's my limit. So I'll ask another question. Whilst we're talking about serious topics, I might as well ask another serious question. And connected to the automation, would you rather staff your entire warehouse with extremely enthusiastic but painfully literal minded robots? Dan Culverhouse: obviously not gonna be. Keith: Well we're very experienced humans who refuse to any technology newer than a clipboard. Dan Culverhouse: Ha ha ha. Keith: ⁓ it's a hover question. Dan Culverhouse: I love the literal minded robots. Like those any other kind of robot, really. I mean, they are pretty literal. I mean they kind of do what they're told. They don't really ⁓ interpret. I guess well maybe if they got a bit of an AI brain, ⁓ and some of those chat G P T ⁓ conversations go a bit go a bit off the loop. But ⁓ God, what would I Keith: Yeah. you have to say exactly the same, the right prompt. Yeah, otherwise off they go and do exactly what you told them to do. So you get to know them, wouldn't you? You get to know them. I think there's a lot of people that would choose that. I think a lot of people would choose that option. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. You yeah, you'd learn. You'd well I I think ⁓ ultimately it would be the easier choice, right? Because I think you're right, you would learn the prompts that you needed to give to get them to do what they would do. And of course they would do it all day once you've told them. you know, so it would be probably easier, although probably not very interesting. Whereas I think Keith: Yeah. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, working with a bunch of people who knew what they were doing, but y it was just you and a clipboard and you know, then it would continue to have its challenge. It's a bit like the previous question, really, isn't it? But I think it'd be more interesting for certain. And and you got a bunch of people around you, right? Some people that you can actually have a conversation about what you had for dinner last night, or the movie you watched at the weekend, or you know. So you might not have all the tools and that, but at least you've got some human Yeah, you know, experience that you can actually you know, 'cause you you can't really have a conversation about ⁓ the last episode of Game of Thrones with a bloody literally minded robot. ⁓ yeah. So that's never gonna happen. So I think it would be ⁓ whilst it would be less difficult or less stressful maybe, I don't know. Actually, I don't know if I even agree with what I'm saying there. I think it would be stressful because I think the Keith: If it's anything like Gemini in my car driving back from Scotland the other day. Gemini, what's the quickest route? Why is there a traffic jam ahead? There's a traffic jam because of a build up of cars. Dan Culverhouse: Thank you for that. ⁓ Keith: I know. It made us laugh. But yeah, I think both would be really good management challenges, to be honest. Most frustrating in their own ways, but both an interesting experiment. I'd take on either or, because I think there'd be some challenges in getting the prompts right with those robots. It would be like a comedy show in the beginning, if they all acted exactly what you said. Dan Culverhouse: You probably have some for rather hilarious outputs. Keith: In the end, think it's almost like the world is your oyster because you could get to know them a bit like Vince, guest the other week. You get to know their capabilities and set them and ⁓ off they go and create some wonderful things. Whether you get an amazing amount of joy. When you achieve what you want to do in the end, there's no one to share that joy with, there? So it's. So yeah, I think you could have fun. But then also with the people who know everything, what a coaching opportunity that would be to try and almost create like an artisan supply chain with people who know so much. But I mean, we're talking, they don't even want to use Excel. So interested to see how they come up with their analysis. But I'd like to go back in time. to the days before computers into warehouses. I'd love to do that if I had a time machine. I'd love to see like Ford Motors they had machinery, they had process, but I'd love to see Ford Motors in the thirties or something. How did they manage efficiency and what would it look like now compared to the tools we have? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. It probably wasn't that efficient, right? The reality is it wasn't that efficient compared to what we Yeah, yeah, I it worked. But did you never work in a a in a completely unsystemized warehouse then? Have you not? Am I just that little bit older than you that make means that I did? Keith: When I came up with the production line, didn't they and stuff like that, but. No, I've worked in one. No, no, no. I probably have. I've worked somewhere where there was ⁓ no automation. There was obviously all the management systems, etc. So mean, everything was, you know, everything had locations and, you know, you had a pick list and everything like that. But there wasn't any sort of automation. It was very much hand to eye picking and packing, checking. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Interestingly, when yeah, when when I went first went to the Middle East, we had so we had operations pretty much all over the ⁓ the Gulf. ⁓ some very big, but some markets were were pretty small, like Bahrain, ⁓ and that were quite quite small markets. ⁓ and I remember going into those warehouses and they had no locations. So this was clothing. So it's all hanging garments, like stacked sort of Keith: But that was okay. That was quite efficient. Dan Culverhouse: on three stories ⁓ of ⁓ you know kind of rack supported mezzanine and ⁓ so there's a lot of stock in there. I remember talking to them. So they had a system that told them how many units they had of each SKU, but had no locations. And the guys just knew where everything was. You know, because they they put them away, they did it every day. So when they used to get the pick lists come through and they'd print them off. They would just go and get them. You know, there was no location as to where they were. They just knew where it was. I mean, it was insane. I mean it was just Keith: Yeah, I've worked in that sort of environment. Big sellers in the middle. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: You know, and there's thousands and thousands of SKUs though. It's not like it's just it's it's incredible. These guys, they're just, ⁓ yeah, yeah, that's on the third floor at the back. Yeah, I'll go and get you one. Keith: Interesting because you can't quite measure the waste. Everyone says it's efficient but the first thing you want to do as an Ops Director is test that. Because you know there's wasted time, wasted movement. You just want to calculate how much there is. When you start looking at the cost per unit and stuff it's the sort of thing you start digging into isn't it? But I've worked places where things were alphabetical. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah yeah. I don't think it was official. Yeah. Keith: I mean they're very much the first places I've moved towards the places I've moved quickly to stock stocktake. Psycho County. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, yeah, absolutely. But but I tell you what though, y you know, when when you have people that are working in that kind of environment, it's incredible what they know in their head, what the the knowledge that they keep in their head. Just things like part numbers. Yeah, people can just reel off what the part number was, right? You know, I mean I mean I mean and I guess it goes back to when like before we all had mobile phones, that we used to remember everybody's phone number. Keith: And if you couldn't... Dan Culverhouse: You know, and you used to be able to drive most of the round the country and work out where you were going without GPS. Whereas now it it's just unfathomable that you would know that. But I think when you don't have the tools, your brain adapts to being able to hold that inf incredible amount of information as to where things are, who does what part numbers and yeah, it's inc you know it's incredible. Keith: I I was talking to someone the other day about this with GPS. Do you think there was a lot more people getting lost? Pre-GPS? There must have been. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. There must have been a lot more people you pull up, you just someone walk in their door and go, excuse me, do you know where I think that obviously happened a lot more. And I can remember, you know, going on driving holidays with my parents. Yeah. I can remember the arguments my parents used to have on holiday when they were driving and my mum would be navigating with a map and my dad would be going nuts 'cause we're going the wrong way. I mean that it's a very strong memory growing up. That just wouldn't happen anymore. Keith: I remember people putting over to us. So yeah, ⁓ they don't now, but they do sometimes. Dan Culverhouse: 'Cause it's like you just put it in the GPS and you might swear at Google a bit because it's like, Why is it taking me down here? But ⁓ but at the end of the day we're just slaves to follow that blue line now. So Keith: Yeah, yeah, so yeah, I'd like to go back to a time machine is the answer there, but I'd like to see what I could do with that team, but I think I get very frustrated with the clipboard brigade. Yeah, yeah, if they thought they knew everything. My first question would be, there no way this could be a bit more efficient than ⁓ you're working currently? It'd be some interesting conversations, but it would be a good. Dan Culverhouse: Especially if they thought they knew it all. That that that definitely makes it you know, it's Ha ha ha. Keith: a coaching experiment. I'd like to manage that team. It might not last too long there to be honest though. Okay let's have another one. You've got one? Dan Culverhouse: It definitely would. Definitely would. I got one. I'm gonna do one. Would you rather have a brilliant planner who cannot communicate or a brilliant communicator who cannot plan? Keith: Well, I'd want to know what the brilliant communicator was actually telling me. Dan Culverhouse: He's telling you he has no idea. He's very good at telling you, he has no idea what's going on. ⁓ Keith: Okay, okay. Yeah, that would be really helpful for about five minutes. So I think I would work with the planners communication. The good planner and how to communicate better, i.e. let's build a dashboard together rather than. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, but he can't communicate though, so he wouldn't be able to create it. So you'd have all the information that he just wouldn't be any good at telling ya. Keith: Yeah, but I've worked on similar projects before to try and translate even my own mind what's in my mind onto paper and what's in other people's minds, know, great minds get this onto paper. I've worked on a lot of those projects so I'm quite optimistic that I could get the I could work on the communication of the good planner. I don't really see the benefit of having a bad planner, good communicator. Dan Culverhouse: Which is easier then? Keith: Maybe he could help with the training. Dan Culverhouse: Well I get well well here's a question then. So which is harder to to teach people? Something that's kind of logical and technical like planning, or something which is behavioural, which is communicating. I I would have said teaching someone to plan was a lot easier than teaching someone how to be a good communicator. Keith: Good point, good challenge. Is everyone equipped with those skills? I think you can work in both areas. I think there's probably better jobs for the communicator. Or not better jobs, but something that really... Utilizes his communication skills with their communication skills that that would be what I'd ask them about that They really wanted to be a planner look at the blind spots and try and help build their expertise But it might be they've got a more effective way of utilizing their communication skills in a different different role Dan Culverhouse: So you want to have secret answer number three. Yeah. You and secret answer number three is tell them they're in the wrong job and put someone else in there, right? ⁓ Keith: I've done that before switch people who clearly had different skill sets with their consent obviously they were looking for someone to do that you know I'd have the conversation with the bad planner and just say what do you really want to do they communicate it clearly so Dan Culverhouse: Well, absolutely, yeah. Yeah, yeah. But well yeah, he'd be very good at telling you what he really wanted to do. But I mean, you know, how you probably say ⁓ I just really want to get good at this planning. Help me, Keith, help me. Right. Keith: I would help them. would help them. But yeah, we start with looking into quite how inaccurate the existing planning was and and yeah. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. To some degree I guess some of this depends on you, right? It it's like how do you think you'd be better at teaching someone how to communicate or how to plan? You know, and I guess to some degree it's not really about them, it's about you, isn't it? And and where you think you'd be better at at at bringing somebody up to speed on. Which means I'm probably gonna change my my answer and say actually I'd probably be better getting a brilliant planner who couldn't communicate 'cause I could probably ⁓ you know, I consider myself to be a pretty good communicator. ⁓ I'm definitely much better at the human side of things than I am of sitting in front of screens coming up with numbers. ⁓ so I could probably enhance somebody's ability to communicate better than having this wonderful communicator who was just terrible at Excel and ⁓ and ⁓ working out how to plan stuff. Keith: You'd have to see, yeah, I think the proof would be in the pudding, wouldn't it, as part of both journeys. Whose career could you elevate? I think you could elevate both people's careers by helping the communicator find a role that's more suited to them, where they'd be an asset. Because I don't think they'd enjoy the planning part of them really struggling. Dan Culverhouse: So not bad. Keith: And then the person who lives for planning, think, yeah, you can help them be a communicator. It doesn't mean building them into a confident extrovert. It's just giving them the tools to communicate what everybody else needs to know. I think that would be achievable and enjoyable. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. It's interesting what you say about you know, ⁓ about career wise, 'cause you kinda think if someone's very good at communicating, expressing themselves, they've probably got a brighter future than just a a geek technocrat that can't communicate. I think it'd be much harder for them to Keith: Well I think they've both got a spectacular career but different roles. ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: You are the eternal optimist. Keep ⁓ yeah, very you know, one is ⁓ as you say, the technical genius path, if you like. And the other one is the yeah, I guess the the the people, maybe the politician or ⁓ I don't know, maybe not a politician. It's not a good career. Keith: They might combine well. You know, they might combine well. Absolutely. Now. I've got a question that I have some experience of, so. ⁓ Give me a second. Where's it come from? Yes, would you rather have? ⁓ no, just a second. Give me a second. What's that question again? Dan Culverhouse: Not the supplier based on the moon. Keith: It was based on a system based on whatsapp Dan Culverhouse: ⁓ yeah, that's down the bottom, yeah. The smoke signals one. Keith: ⁓ yeah. Would you rather negotiate your next big contract entirely via smoke signals or run your entire supply chain through a WhatsApp group with 400 unread messages? Dan Culverhouse: That is definitely an out there question, Keith. ⁓ my God. Keith: Yeah, a good one. I'll throw that into the next interview I do. Dan Culverhouse: Well, on the basis I don't read smoke signals. You asked this in an interview, right? Keith: No, I will throw that one into the next interview I do. There's no right or wrong answer. It's just interesting to hear what people have to say on this one. I did work with a management system that had been constructed out of Slack Dan Culverhouse: ⁓ I was gonna say y that's very cruel to make some differences. So I think Yeah. Keith: Instead of just getting an order management system, just, well, it had some interface. It had like API calls with various things. So it would be populated with tracking numbers and stuff. And it worked to explain, you could look up certain information around the order process and, you know, everything was sort of message based. Dan Culverhouse: How does that even work? Keith: tick box space so you could you could sort of look at the each approval step you knew what step had been covered in the flow what you couldn't do was extract reporting your information from it and it was it's insane but genius Dan Culverhouse: Mm. Yeah, yeah. But Keith: I don't know why it was allowed to be but it was. ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: ⁓ yeah, it there's part of me thinks I'd love to see that and part of me thinks I don't ever want to see that. But yeah, I guess my immediate thought on this is like, well, I'd the first thing I'd have to do is learn how to read smoke signals if we were gonna do it that way. ⁓ so at least I know how WhatsApp works and ⁓ Keith: I'm actually thinking I wouldn't mind negotiating by smoke signal or in simplistic terms. Yeah, no confrontation, straightforward, tell me what you need and we'll agree. don't, know, people aren't going to try and pull the wool over your eyes using smoke signals, you're not going to waste your time, are you? So I think I would definitely be up for negotiating by smoke signal. ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: Silly non confrontational, isn't it? I mean it's The language needs to be fairly simple. Think it would take a long time. Keith: Well, it wouldn't because sometimes the negotiation process takes months because of this back and forth, nitpicking, people being determined to win. I'd rather negotiate peacefully over the campfire with a smoke signal or a peace pipe. Dan Culverhouse: You'd have to be some distance away, be able to see it. So you wouldn't be with them. I mean you'd be far Keith: Well doesn't have to be does it? It doesn't have to be across valleys but you know we... Dan Culverhouse: We need to be far enough to be able to see the you know, the the the language of the smoke, if you know what I mean. I mean you know, they're kinda Keith: Sure, but the language would likely be very simplistic. Yes, no, high, low, simplistic. It would have to be. So I think that might help negotiations. So many negotiations have sleight of hand and nuance, don't they? And tricks. I think if you're using smoke signals, no, there's transparency. There's no real way of ⁓ hiding your true intentions. So. You know, not to take it as literally as making a smoke signal, just a basic, basic language. I think you can get fairer deals. You can make multinational deals without speaking each other's language. So I think that that's what I'd rather do that to have a whole operation running on WhatsApp is destined to crash. You don't have any data to improve. You're bound by this stupid process, this system. And ⁓ so I would rather negotiate. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, and and I guess Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I thi I think yeah, w when I read the question fully, 'cause I kinda like I would like to do something through smoke signals or on WhatsApp. You kinda think, Well, WhatsApp, obviously, but even if it was a mess. But obviously they're two very different things. The negotiating a contract, it's got a finite period of time, right? It might be a little bit frustrating, a little bit difficult to get it right and get it clear, but you're gonna get there and then it's done. Keith: We'll just make six. Dan Culverhouse: running an entire supply chain for the foreseeable future on something as chaotic as WhatsApp group with loads of messages that don't ever get read. That sounds like a complete disaster. You know, I yeah, I I'd go for the smoke signals. As much as I think ⁓ I'd have to learn how to do the smoke signals first, but I think that would be all right. I think compared to trying to run an operation through the chaos of WhatsApp. Keith: I think you can pick that up pretty easily. You'd never switch off. You'd go home and there'd be another 500 messages the next morning. It would just be impossible to get on top of. Dan Culverhouse: That that irritating ping so much so often in a day. Yeah, I think I'd have to agree that just doing a a some bizarre thing on all right. You wrote this question and it's a little bit out there. but it makes me smile. So ⁓ would you rather have a supplier based on the moon? So fantastic prices. Keith: Yeah. very very hard to mistake proof. Okay. Dan Culverhouse: But a three day light speed lag on every email that's communicated. Or one that's next door who simply never ever replies. That was a great one. I love that. Keith: I'd have the supplier on the moon Dan Culverhouse: Would you? Keith: I think if you've got a partnership you can rely on and trust. It doesn't matter where they are. It doesn't mean they're less efficient. It doesn't mean you don't get what you need. I mean, it depends what you're waiting on. mean, obviously it's very frustrating to have suppliers. You need to ask multiple questions. You're in a place you wouldn't get delivered. ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. It's all right until something's not working. And then it would be a very frustrating experience. At least they might have the might you know, the one next door they might never reply, but you can go round there. Y you can just walk next door and go look at it for yourself. You know, you're not gonna fly out to the moon, huh? Keith: Yeah. ⁓ but they might hide. Well, they might not be open to that. That's the point. I worked with a carrier once who were down the road on the same industrial estate. I asked for a tour. They said no. They said, can after peak. I said, no, I want to see it during peak. I want to see it at full volume. No, no, no, no. We'll arrange it for a quiet period. That asked more questions of me than... than someone saying, look, we're far away, but we'll pay for a trip for you to come any time. We'll answer any question you have. Never appealing to me. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, no, look, I can I can see that at least it's consistent. With the guy on the moon, you know, you have a consistency. You know, you've got to wait, you've got to be patient, but you're always gonna get a response, you know. It it seems like everything would take a long time to get resolved. But I guess if the next door one just never responds to you anyway, it doesn't really matter, you know, that they're close by. If you can't get in there to kick him up the backside to say, That's my bloody email. Keith: forever the fubbing you off ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: Then yeah, the predictability of the the moon guy probably would ⁓ w would in the long run help. But ⁓ yeah. Neither are very good though. Keith: be a better partner. Yeah, now we're taking away all the obvious facts like what's the cost of shipping, et cetera. We're not going into those intricacies, but just in terms of the supplier and their response time. I don't really, yeah, I'm not really keen on suppliers who never respond. I just think it's rude. ⁓ yeah, does that also mean that, Dan Culverhouse: Well it is. It certainly has a lack of care. Keith: Yeah, lack of care, not willing to improve the service, not willing to take the opinions on board. I don't think I'd like working with suppliers like that to be honest. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Go on then, you're next. Keith: Okay, the next question is... That means time man, sorry. Would you rather tell your biggest customer no today, or tell them sorry three months from now? Dan Culverhouse: think that's easy. I think it's now today. Keith: Tell them the truth. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I I think you have to be honest and if you if they ask you for something you can't deliver, then you have to s you have to go politely decline rather than lead them down the path and then go, Yeah, I did my best but it's it's not happening Unless, of course, you said to them, Look, I don't know if I can achieve this, but let me have a go and then it's okay to go, you know what, we've been trying, we can't we can't deliver it, sorry. But if it's if if it's literally as polar as that is either if you don't know you can do it Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: You have to say no now or try and then let ⁓ down in a few months' time, then absolutely, hundred percent. Straight in no. Keith: We've all worked with those partners where where the sales guy says everything's possible but when you actually get into the implementation a lot of what is said is is is not within the model at all and That's very frustrating, but they didn't say yeah, they said yes to get their contract for you to do but They didn't necessarily know it wasn't possible But I wish I had said it wasn't Dan Culverhouse: Mm. Commercial over promise. Keith: possible. But yeah, like you say, if someone wants to create something a little bit groundbreaking with you, says, look, we work with you on a project, you can be a pilot, we can work with this together, we'll try and do what we can do. And then eventually you start realising the restrictions and they say, sorry, I think we're going to have to work with this or that or what we've got. That's a different relationship to someone saying everything's possible. And then three months later saying actually it's not. So there's a slight nuance there. But ⁓ in general, I'd rather be straightforward. I'm very straightforward. So I'd rather people straightforward with me. This is my user story. This is a list of things I need. Can you do it? No, I can't. I'd suggest you go to this company instead. Or we're here if you need us down the line. Yeah, I'd rather that. I think that goes without saying. So should we have another question to end on? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, absolutely. These guys are much better set up. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I I like that. Well, if this is going to be the last one, then there is only one question it can be. And we're a little bit early in the year to be do talking about this, but it has to be Would you rather run Santa's entire worldwide Christmas Eve delivery in one night? So the whole planet, zero delays, or manage a warehouse that gets exactly one order per day, every day of the year, for one single paper clip and nothing else, ever. Keith: I do the Santa's job because there'll be a lot of planning throughout the year. There'll be lots to keep you occupied. It's not just that night. So that's the misnomer in that one. It's not just that night. You've got a lot of preparation to do. It touches on so many things. Logistics, resourcing, warehousing, ⁓ sustainability, supply and demand. Dan Culverhouse: Mm. Keith: ⁓ I think it's an interesting undertaking. It's a bit like working on a major event once or twice a year. Shipping an individual paper clip might be for some people, but it sure as hell isn't for me. Dan Culverhouse: Well, I I I think this this tells a million stories about personality, right? You know, I think that if if if if you're the sort of person that would say, ⁓ just a nice, easy life, just ship a paper clip every day, easy, easy money, that works for me. And maybe that's the sort of person that is just like, Yeah, you know, this goes on in the background, but then I can go away and live my life, do the things I wanna do with this ticking around in the background. So I can kind of understand it. Doesn't really work for me. But for me, you know, the satisfaction of delivering Santa's worldwide demand in a night, you know, and as you say, you've got a whole year of planning, getting yourself ready, testing, trialing things, and then that sense of achievement of of getting to Christmas Day, you're going, Santa, we did it. We've achieved it. All the kids are happy. There's no ⁓ you know, no missed deliveries and no ⁓ you know, that would be brilliant. You know, I think you the achieved sense of achievement you'd get from delivering a project of that scale, of that magical kind of ⁓ feeling would be is unbeatable, right? And I think you and I have both we've never we've never run Santa's ⁓ supply chain, but we've run some, you know, done some big projects, transformation things that have really made a difference. And you can't beat it, right? You come out the other side and go, We did that. We achieved, we absolutely did it. Keith: That global scale, yeah. Yeah, it didn't happen before and now and it happened Yeah, and I think with my continuous improvement Background it would keep me so occupied looking at what went wrong. What could be done better? How many missed deliveries were there? many late deliveries? How many wrong toys all of these things? ⁓ would like I would like to yeah, I'd love to work on Santa's sustainability project. How do we reduce the carbon footprint of the operation? Dan Culverhouse: It's the most amazing thing. How many children did you traumatize? Keith: which extends far beyond his grotto when you consider, we know the elves make these toys but there's a lot of industry that goes into making all these plastic toys so I would love to work on that whole project full-time. I don't think I'd ever ever get bored of it so that's what motivates me. I think I seek projects like that to be honest. I seek these crazy projects. Dan Culverhouse: ⁓ yeah, that is huge. It would be exciting. I think it says it says things. ⁓ well, I think it says so much about about who you are, right? I ⁓ you know, you you love a challenge. You love to be able to be see something that people say it can't be done and just get in there and find a way and deliver it or, you know, take something and turn it into something incredible. You know, I think that that's what you've done in your career, that's what I've been doing in my career, and I think Keith: Yeah. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I I I've got no interest in ⁓ you know, it's always been one of those things when I've when I've kind of been looking at jobs in the past, it's like, you know, i do they just want somebody to steer the ship or they want somebody to ⁓ you know, to rebuild this aeroplane while we're flying it, you know, 'cause that's exciting and that'd be really interesting. It really engages you and and the sense of achievement is amazing. Whereas, you know, you can have this very glamorous job that you just float around ⁓ I just board. pants off me. It's never been Yeah, exactly. That's that's the we wouldn't work for Keith: Yeah, I miss the paper clip, you know, great, you know, you know, you know everything. There's nothing to test you. know everything. You know all there is about shipping paper clips. Good for you. But yeah, you know, like you say, building a plane while you're flying it because you have to because you're entering an asteroid field that you haven't encountered before. So you have to adapt. That's exactly what excites me. ⁓ You need a bit of everyone in the world, but yeah, certainly. Is Santa's looking? I would put my name forward for that job. think it would be brilliant. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, yeah. Cool. Well I have one one more question. It's not a woody rather, but it's just a ref you know, we're on twenty episodes. ⁓ I think both you and I feel really proud of what we've done over the last twenty episodes. I think episode twenty things have changed and moved on quite a bit since episode ten. What's your hope for the next ten, then? What do you want to happen? Keith: Yeah. I want to start ⁓ forming a bit of a community if possible. People putting their questions in. More guests. The guests have been brilliant. I really want to have guests on that are just fascinating people. We've been lucky. We've had some really fascinating people. We set out to do a podcast on supply chain, but I think we both realised quite quickly that we like to be tested and we like to learn and we like to learn on air. Dan Culverhouse: They have Keith: So anyone who's coming from a completely different angle to us, I welcome them on board. I don't want to have any answers. I like the look of astonishment on a guest's sometimes when you put something across to them and say, no, that's not how my world works. That's a great moment for me. So yeah, building the podcast into something that everybody wants to listen to. That's my objective. What about you? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. That would be cool. Yeah, I I I think that you know, going from ten to twenty was about bringing in guests and I think that's been brilliant. I completely agree with what you're saying that ⁓ you know it it's been some fascinating conversations. ⁓ and I definitely want more of that. And I think, yeah, it's trying to find people that you wouldn't expect to come on ⁓ and do something. ⁓ yeah, I definitely want more engagement. I want a community. ⁓ and I think It's i yeah, and we absolutely can do this. I would like us to do one in the same room one day. ⁓ Let's go and sit down together and do an episode where ⁓ you know, where we were like a traditional podcast where we all sit in the same room as opposed to ⁓ you're in London, I'm in Stratford. But ⁓ but yeah, so ⁓ that that that I really I really want to do that. I think that would be fun. Keith: ⁓ dear, it's a realistic ambition to be honest. Dan Culverhouse: But ⁓ I just wanna keep being challenged and keep learning something new and taking it forward. And I want to see more people listen ⁓ and engage. But ⁓ but I have to say, you know, when we started this, we really didn't know what was gonna happen, where it was gonna go. It's a lot of fun. and ⁓ you know, it's the h one of the highlights of my week every week and I don't know that me makes me a little bit sad, but it is. I really enjoy these conversations and it's it's ⁓ it's good fun and You never quite know what we're gonna end up talking about, so ⁓ it's always good. Keith: No. ⁓ That's part of the fun isn't it? Like what subjects are going to be for example 23 to 30? No idea but that's part of the fun. So much to talk about always. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, it is. It really is. Yeah. Well, we've done twenty, my friend. And ⁓ here's to the next twenty. And ⁓ onwards and upwards. But for everyone else, we'll see you next week. Keith: See you next week. Like, share, subscribe and comment please. Dan Culverhouse: All that good stuff. Especially comment. We want to know what you think. Even if you don't like it, it's okay. Keith: Yes, especially. See you next week.