Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E019: Tomer Strolight – Bitcoin is Alien Technology
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity where the supply is
- 0:12unaffected by the demand if you want to preserve your wealth.
- 0:16You have to. Convert that currency into an
- 0:19asset that's scarce, desirable, portable.
- 0:23Durable. And maintainable.
- 0:31Hello, my name is Andy Edstrom and I'm happy to welcome you to
- 0:34the 19th episode of Scarce Assets, a show that examine
- 0:38scarcity, the most fundamental driver of economics and markets
- 0:41and the scarcest asset of all, which is Bitcoin.
- 0:44It's great to be here with my Co host Jesse Myers and our guest
- 0:48Tomer Strolite. So I think I met Tomer 3 or 4
- 0:51years ago and at the time I was rereading Norbert Wieners book
- 0:56Cybernetics and Society. His work at MIT was the origin
- 1:01of the field of cybernetics and I was kicking around some of his
- 1:04ideas and applying him to Bitcoin.
- 1:06So essentially I was trying to decide whether Bitcoin was a
- 1:09life form or just a cybernetic system that had many of the
- 1:12characteristics of life but not all of them.
- 1:15So I raised this idea to Tomer and of course he immediately
- 1:18said, Oh yeah, I published an article about that.
- 1:22The article is called How Bitcoin is Like a Giant
- 1:25Cybernetic Meta Brain and it's great.
- 1:28And interestingly, it proved to be a prelude to another article
- 1:32he published 2 years later, which was called Hello I am
- 1:35Bitcoin in which he characterized Bitcoin as an
- 1:38artificial life form in symbiosis with humans.
- 1:41So what I'm trying to say is Tomer has written about Bitcoin
- 1:44both as a life form and as a cybernetic phenomenon.
- 1:48And these two great articles are just a tiny slice of the depth
- 1:51of thought that Tomer is applied to Bitcoin.
- 1:53He's written many articles. He's published a fantastic book
- 1:57called Why Bitcoin. He's been on lots of podcasts,
- 2:00spoken to lots of conferences and made great films like
- 2:03Bitcoin is Generational Wealth. So I think he has probably
- 2:07analyzed Bitcoin and helped educate people about Bitcoin
- 2:10more thoroughly than anyone I know.
- 2:12And it's a real pleasure to welcome him to scarce assets.
- 2:16Tomer, how are you? I'm great.
- 2:18Wow, thank you for that nice introduction.
- 2:20I didn't know it's been a while since someone mentioned the
- 2:22cybernetic metabrine article so I'm my mind is racing back.
- 2:27Although although I did have a quick conversation about it just
- 2:30the other day on on another as yet unreleased podcast.
- 2:33Oh, excellent. Well, I do actually want to want
- 2:36to get into it because I don't think I ever reached a
- 2:39conclusion myself about whether it's a form of life or some kind
- 2:43of other cybernetic thing. But I'd love to hear any
- 2:47thoughts you have here, you know now with the with the benefit of
- 2:50time. Sure.
- 2:52You know, when we, there's a problem with words, with
- 2:56concepts, which is they, they're blurry.
- 2:59They're they have edge cases. For example, you know, like you
- 3:02could define a table as a flat surface that's supported somehow
- 3:06and grounded on the on the ground.
- 3:07And then someone can invent a flat surface that's suspended
- 3:10from the ceiling. And it's like, well, is that a,
- 3:13is that a table? And it's like, well, it can
- 3:15serve the purposes of a table, but it doesn't fit the
- 3:17definition. So you get caught in between
- 3:20tight definitions and edge cases and things that serve the same
- 3:23purposes. So something can serve as a
- 3:25metaphor without being exactly the same thing.
- 3:28And when we talk about ideas like consciousness and ideas
- 3:31like life or, or living, we can live within very tight debt,
- 3:35live here. I'm using the word we.
- 3:37We can constrain ourselves to very tight definitions.
- 3:40And we may say life is DNA based molecule that self replicates
- 3:45and pursues the value of self replication.
- 3:49And it's a process and life exists where the DNA is
- 3:52functioning and it ceases to exist where it doesn't.
- 3:54And in that case obviously Bitcoin is not light alive
- 3:57because it doesn't possess DNA. But that if we drop the
- 4:03scientific necessities and we say life is a self-sustaining
- 4:08process that consumes energy and reproduces, then Bitcoin fits
- 4:13that definition really, really, really tightly.
- 4:16It doesn't it doesn't quite yet fit the definition of
- 4:19consciousness, which is what the meta brain article what was
- 4:23intended to to explore. But there's a lot of people who
- 4:29look at Bitcoin and say it possesses a lot of the
- 4:32characteristics of not just of a living entity, but there's the
- 4:35question of like, of life itself, because these, each node
- 4:40is a exact replica of every other node.
- 4:43So it's kind of like 2 bacterias that have split to, you know,
- 4:46they, they're perfect clones of one another, unless there's a
- 4:49mutation in, in one or the other, Bitcoin self replicates,
- 4:53right? This is something that only, the
- 4:54only thing on earth that we're aware of that self replicates is
- 4:57life. And when you've spin up a node,
- 5:00it, it doesn't replicate by splitting another node into two
- 5:03and and combining like life does.
- 5:06It reaches out to all these other nodes over the Internet
- 5:08and makes a perfect replica and checks every, you know, every
- 5:13block of data that it adds to itself.
- 5:15It checks cryptographically. Does it meet the proof of work
- 5:18standard? Does it mean does it have the
- 5:20same block hash as every other node does?
- 5:22If it does, then you will add it.
- 5:25And so Bitcoin, if it is to be compared to life, a life form in
- 5:29the sense that it's self replicating, it's actually, it's
- 5:34immutable. It doesn't have mutations,
- 5:36right, right. So it's a self replicating but
- 5:38non mutating form of, of life, which which is the point I
- 5:43mentioned in an article I wrote called why people wonder if
- 5:45Bitcoin is alien technology because it's like life, but not
- 5:49like life on earth. So it there's a there's a lot
- 5:52going on on there And and I think it's how closely you want
- 5:56to explore and what you want to extract out of these concepts.
- 5:58Like if you just want to make the point, if you want to be
- 6:00pretentious and say Bitcoin is alive and leave it at that, it
- 6:03doesn't really serve much of A purpose.
- 6:05But when you say, well, what other attributes does life
- 6:09possess that Bitcoin possesses that are interesting for us to
- 6:11know? It's like, well, life is very
- 6:13hard to kill, right? Like as far as we know, what
- 6:16giant comet has struck the earth numerous times with it's been
- 6:19these massive extinction events and life survived, right?
- 6:22Although a lot of life was killed in the process, life
- 6:25itself survived, adapt, it evolved.
- 6:27Life is this anti fragile entity as a whole, whether you look at
- 6:32it abstractly or concretely. And, and when we want to
- 6:37explore, if Bitcoin is alive, in one sense, what we're exploring
- 6:42is does it possess this indestructible or very hard to
- 6:46destroy things like you have to you really have to do a lot of
- 6:49damage to the Earth to destroy life.
- 6:50I don't think if we detonated all the nuclear weapons on the
- 6:53Earth, we would actually destroy all life on Earth.
- 6:55We probably wouldn't even manage to destroy all human life on
- 6:58Earth, although we'd make it a lot, a lot worse.
- 7:00But I remember once doing some calculations and apparently the
- 7:04impact, the megatons of explosive energy that the comet
- 7:09that's killed the dinosaurs is said to have had is something on
- 7:12the order of a million times greater than the power of all
- 7:14the nuclear weapons we have on Earth combined, right.
- 7:17So life survivors, a million, maybe it's 100,000, but it's
- 7:20like it's orders of magnitude more impact than that.
- 7:24And life is very strong and in Bitcoin, because it's this
- 7:28perfect replica that self functions, it self organizes, it
- 7:31self communicates that can adapt to how much energy it needs to
- 7:35survive, right? And like if, if all the miners
- 7:39go away and there's only one guy left, Satoshi somewhere still
- 7:42mining on his laptop or his desktop, Bitcoin will survive.
- 7:46It will continue to proceed. So it's got this adaptability
- 7:50quality that life, that life has.
- 7:52And, and I think this is what makes Bitcoin so interesting,
- 7:56that the engineering of it doesn't resemble the engineering
- 8:01of other man made systems. Again, why I wrote the alien
- 8:05technology article, right? It adapts to how much energy is
- 8:09out there in the world. It will consume as much as is
- 8:11given to it, but it can survive and thrive on very little
- 8:14energy. It makes these perfect replicas
- 8:18of itself, which is again you need.
- 8:20It's nothing that any man made thing besides it can do and it
- 8:27it maintains that adaptability is like it maintains itself like
- 8:30if you go in and you try to like you have to upgrade your
- 8:34computer, you have to maintain an airplane.
- 8:36You have to you have to maintain essentially every man made
- 8:39invention. But Bitcoin, if you go in and
- 8:41mess with it, it'll kick you out, right?
- 8:45Like your node will die if you alter its code, it'll see it'll
- 8:49be rejected by the rest of the network, by the living body of
- 8:52Bitcoin. But if you leave it alone, it
- 8:55will adjust itself. It will maintain itself.
- 8:57It's difficulty adjustment will adjust, its issue and schedule
- 9:00will adjust. All of these things are built
- 9:02into it. So it has this adaptability, the
- 9:04survivability capability and, and we don't have other words
- 9:10than ones that come from the study of life to describe it,
- 9:13right? It's got this survivability.
- 9:16Well, what are you talking about?
- 9:17When you use the word survival, you're talking about life not
- 9:20ending, life continuing. So I think there's a lot of very
- 9:24useful analogies and useful applications of the word living
- 9:28to Bitcoin. When we, if I ease into them,
- 9:33this notion of is it like a brain?
- 9:35Is it aware? Is it smart?
- 9:36Is it conscious? Well, clearly the software code
- 9:39itself is not right. It just runs deterministically
- 9:45and does exactly what the rule set is said to do.
- 9:48But Bitcoin is more than just the software running Bitcoin is
- 9:53this entity that gets infused with human beings like us,
- 9:58right? And and we absorb it and we
- 10:00think about what Bitcoin needs to succeed to thrive, you know,
- 10:05to achieve its purpose, which which the code doesn't know its
- 10:09purpose, but we know or we may disagree like the different
- 10:12people. There's a lot of debate about
- 10:14whether Bitcoin should be money or whether just to store a value
- 10:17or whether it takes time or whether this or that or the
- 10:18other. But I think that's actually
- 10:21where this Bitcoin consciousness arises from.
- 10:25And in the same way what I said in that article about the meta
- 10:29brain is like your brain is not one centralized coherent thing.
- 10:34It's an amalgam of billions, maybe trillions of neurons,
- 10:39which are cells that connect to have connections from multiple
- 10:43others, but not all the others and connect to to others, but
- 10:47not all the others in your brain.
- 10:49It's a peer-to-peer network of neurons.
- 10:51And your consciousness somehow arises from them sending
- 10:55electrical impulses to one another.
- 10:57And it's not that they take turns.
- 10:58One goes after that. They're all operating all
- 11:00simultaneously, right? And that's why you have, it's
- 11:03hard if you've ever tried meditating, it's hard to focus
- 11:06on just your breath. All these ideas are popping up
- 11:08on your brain and you're, you're divided.
- 11:10You have different opinions on whether you should go out for
- 11:13dinner tonight or cook something at home, and if you are what you
- 11:15should cook at home and who you should invite over.
- 11:17Listen, it's not a coherent, decided thing.
- 11:21It's constantly deciding and discovering and exploring the
- 11:23reality around it. And with Bitcoin, this we play
- 11:27the part of its neurons, right? There's many of us
- 11:30interconnected, all talk, many talking simultaneously, many
- 11:34listening to others, listening to a whole networking and ideas
- 11:37emerge and some of these ideas become validated, some become
- 11:40invalidated, some get tested, some some don't get tested.
- 11:43And so there the article goes into much more detail on this.
- 11:46And we won't, we won't go into it here, but there's a lot of
- 11:49similarity, especially as human beings become more networked
- 11:52together through telecommunication technology.
- 11:56So we're not just only only a few of us who can get together
- 11:58physically talking to one another, but all of you know,
- 12:01we're probably all in different parts of the world.
- 12:03I'm in Toronto, Andy, I know you're in California.
- 12:05I actually don't know where you are, Jesse.
- 12:06Texas. Assume the same but we're all
- 12:09you know and the listeners are all somewhere else and they're
- 12:10receiving the the messages and they're processing the messages
- 12:13and they're deciding whether to relay the message or abandoned
- 12:16or reject the message. And so there's this
- 12:18consciousness forming around what Bitcoin is.
- 12:21And it's, it's again, different from a lot of other things
- 12:25because the purpose there is no, there is no central control,
- 12:31right? The same as within your brain,
- 12:33there's no one neuron that's the master neuron, the central
- 12:35neuron, the presidential neuron. I can, I can go in and take out
- 12:39any particular neuron or any group of neurons and you'd still
- 12:42be you. You might lose a memory here or
- 12:43there or not be able to process a particular logical thing that
- 12:46you were before, but you'd still in by and large be you.
- 12:51And it's the same thing with Bitcoin.
- 12:52If someone leaves the Bitcoin community, even Satoshi, right,
- 12:56then Bitcoin is still Bitcoin and it's still pursuing the same
- 12:59purposes. So I'll kind of say, you know,
- 13:01this is a really deep start to the conversation.
- 13:05And what's the nature of its consciousness?
- 13:07Is it conscious? But that's where you started it,
- 13:11Andy. So that's where I took it.
- 13:13At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 13:16asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 13:20right. There are shortcomings with
- 13:22keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 13:25up your own self custody arrangement.
- 13:27On Ramp solves for these concerns.
- 13:30Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 13:33minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 13:36remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 13:40inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 13:42well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 13:45for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 13:48for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 13:51set up. For more information, check us
- 13:53out at on rampbitcoin.com. Yeah.
- 13:56No, I want to hear it from Jesse because Jesse is big on
- 13:59neuroscience and has studied it significantly and so a little.
- 14:04Bit I, I got my undergrad degree in in neuroscience, just loved
- 14:08it Very interesting. You know, I'm trying to
- 14:10understand consciousness in the brain, but I've, I've, you know,
- 14:14thought about the topic of, you know, is Bitcoin a form of life
- 14:18mostly because of mycelium, mycelium of money?
- 14:22That is such a good article for for priming those thoughts.
- 14:27But what I kind of landed on is like you nailed it.
- 14:31There's like this inversion of what we know life to normally be
- 14:35like. In many ways, it's the opposite
- 14:39of what we of the rule set. We we tend to accept for for
- 14:43life, but it strikes me that, you know, Bitcoin, Bitcoin is
- 14:47this kind of virus that infects us all, but it's a positive
- 14:51virus. And I think that's like the spin
- 14:53on that makes it kind of hard to wrap your head around it as a
- 14:57virus, but like it infects people, but then it has this, it
- 15:01makes your life better once it does infect you, which is
- 15:05different from most viruses, right, where most viruses are
- 15:07some cost and, and, and they and they are like antisocial anti
- 15:14Organism. And then instead Bitcoin is, is
- 15:17pro social and pro individual Organism and has this like
- 15:22organizing effect on on the society.
- 15:26So it's, it's almost the inversion of the the you know,
- 15:29there's that. I forget if it's a virus or
- 15:31bacteria that infects ants and it's the zombie thing that takes
- 15:35over the individual Ant. And then they go climb and they
- 15:38become no longer a part of the group, right?
- 15:40They've they're now like they're they've been degraded from being
- 15:45part of the Super Organism that is the Ant hive.
- 15:48And and instead Bitcoin infects us and makes us participate more
- 15:54collaboratively together as part of an Ant, you know, colony,
- 15:58whereas before we had been kind of rogue and individual
- 16:02independent Fiat mind, you know, self-serving organisms.
- 16:07So it's it's kind of a positive virus is kind of what I learned
- 16:11on. Yeah, I think that the point
- 16:13that you're making here is like Bitcoin is very similar to other
- 16:16things that we see in nature, but then fundamentally different
- 16:19in one respect here or there, right.
- 16:21Like Jason Lowery says, it's like a weapon, but it's like a
- 16:24weapon that doesn't kill anybody, in fact pacifies and
- 16:27ends war, prevents war. So, well, isn't that the
- 16:30opposite of a weapon? But it uses a lot of the same
- 16:33techniques that we look at in terms of of the use of energy to
- 16:37overpower something. So there's there's similarities
- 16:41and then there's a fundamental difference, right, The self
- 16:43replication without the mutation.
- 16:45There's, there's all of these things.
- 16:47And that fundamental difference makes all the difference in the
- 16:49world. And in the hello, I'm Bitcoin
- 16:51article, I think I touched on on this like it's something that
- 16:54lives as I, as I spoke in bitcoins voice in the first
- 16:58person. And they're like I I'm an
- 17:01artificial life form that lives in symbiosis with humanity.
- 17:05I accompany it on its but. Not on its own right, which I
- 17:08could think is part of the the virus narrative.
- 17:10Of like, yeah. It Bitcoin doesn't exist on its
- 17:13own, it it has to be in symbiosis with humans and it has
- 17:17found a way unlike any other virus to be a positive influence
- 17:22virus. Rewards you.
- 17:23It gives you this money that keeps going up in purchasing
- 17:25power, which attracts more humans to it, and it doesn't.
- 17:29It doesn't force itself on anyone.
- 17:31It, it appeals to people so that they use their free will, their
- 17:35advanced reasoning capability to choose it.
- 17:38So that again, that's a fundamental difference.
- 17:40But, but it does live in symbiosis with us.
- 17:43So it's, it's, it's this other, you know, we now accept that
- 17:46it's alive. We've accepted that it's
- 17:48conscious and now we are coming to understand our relationship
- 17:51with it, which is a symbiotic positive relationship.
- 17:54We provided with energy. It provides us with all these
- 17:57benefits of sound money and civilizational steadiness and
- 18:00organization. It's quite remarkable.
- 18:03Like when you when you let go and you don't and you're not so
- 18:07concrete bound to say I need this hard definition of what
- 18:10life is and I need this hard definition of what consciousness
- 18:13is. You can then understand your
- 18:14relationship with it through these lesson perfect words that
- 18:18we have that describe consciousness in life much
- 18:21better than any other words we have from the spectrum of non
- 18:25living things. So this is at a really important
- 18:29point that you just made tumor and, you know, I think it took
- 18:32me a long time to come to grips with it.
- 18:34I'm not sure I'd have fully yet, which is the words are too
- 18:39specific. This thing may be unique.
- 18:42You you characterize it as alien.
- 18:46What is the lesson, you know, that can be gleaned for people
- 18:50trying to learn about Bitcoin? Is it is it, you know, hey, read
- 18:54all of Tomer's articles because each one applies a unique lens.
- 18:57That's, you know, 95% correct, but you know, there's that one
- 19:01little, little distinction between the term that we're
- 19:05trying to apply. You know what's the What's the
- 19:07lesson here for understanding Bitcoin?
- 19:09Well, I think throughout history, many things happen that
- 19:12are very original and a first of a first of its kind.
- 19:15And so they're not comparable to things that came beforehand,
- 19:18right? It's not like it's not a repeat.
- 19:20It's a zero to 1 moment as as the famous book is and and
- 19:24Bitcoin is a very big zero to 1 moment.
- 19:26It's like it's 0 to one on five or 6 mentions of 0 to oneness.
- 19:32And I mean it's self replicating, self adjusting,
- 19:36lifelike, you know, immutable, indestructible, incorruptible.
- 19:42It's got all these things. And even when you listen to
- 19:44these words I just listed like they're words that are the
- 19:47opposite Jesse of words that like there is no word.
- 19:51You know, there's a word for that's the opposite of up that
- 19:54isn't UN up, it's down. We've got words for these
- 19:58things, but we don't really have like another word for that's the
- 20:02opposite of corruptible other than incorruptible.
- 20:04We don't have another word for that's the opposite of
- 20:06destructible other than indestructible.
- 20:08We don't have right. And when we describe Bitcoin
- 20:12like imalleable, holy cow, we hardly ever use the word
- 20:14malleable. Now we had to find an opposite
- 20:16for it, so we threw an I in front of it or incorruptible.
- 20:20Like it's just it's there's things that possess some of
- 20:24these character. Heuristics, right anti fragile
- 20:27is a word that had to be made-up.
- 20:28I don't even know if it's in the dictionary, but again, it's the
- 20:31opposite of so this new thing exists that isn't just the
- 20:35absence of things that we've seen before.
- 20:37It's the opposite of things that we've seen before, right.
- 20:39The opposite of fragile is actually is like the opposite of
- 20:45fragile would be breakable, brittle, right?
- 20:48Some something that's or or or. Sorry, not.
- 20:50Robust. Maybe could be robust?
- 20:52Robust, right, but but anti fragile is actually something
- 20:56that the more you damage it, the stronger it gets, right.
- 20:59And and like Bitcoin has these anti properties across it, which
- 21:05which are very bizarre and and like how it develops.
- 21:08These is something you can study by understanding the engineering
- 21:11and the mathematics of Bitcoin and also the game theory around
- 21:14it and why it tends to keep getting stronger the more that
- 21:17it's attacked, because that's very counterintuitive to us to
- 21:20most of the things we see in the real world.
- 21:22But there are counter examples. There's the, you know, the same
- 21:26Taleb's book anti fragile, I think came out before Bitcoin
- 21:29came out, or maybe, maybe not. But he he wasn't referencing
- 21:32Bitcoin extensively when he was trying to elaborate on this
- 21:35concept of things that get stronger when they're attacked,
- 21:39right? And one of the examples is life
- 21:41itself, right? The harder the more pressure you
- 21:43put on life, the more it diversifies, the more it adapts,
- 21:46the more it develops defenses against all kinds of attack, the
- 21:50more it spreads out. So again, this is another one of
- 21:53these qualities where Bitcoin is like life, it's lifelike.
- 21:57But we have to, we have to settle for the fact that words
- 22:00are imprecise. What are words meant to do?
- 22:02They're meant to capture a whole bunch of things in reality and
- 22:05concrete like that. When I use the word table, I'm
- 22:07referring to every table that ever existed in the whole world,
- 22:11and that ever will exist and that can ever even be imagine.
- 22:14It's a really big thing. So No 2 tables are exactly
- 22:18alike. But the word table is meant to
- 22:21capture these millions of different things that are
- 22:23somewhat alike. And when we experience something
- 22:26the likes of which we've never seen before, our words are not
- 22:29going to be precise, right? Our words are going to be
- 22:33precise up to a point and then be completely useless, right?
- 22:36And, and, and so it's understanding where the
- 22:38exception is. Like I, I wrote something about
- 22:41the block size war and I began it with, you know, I wrote it in
- 22:44the form of a memoir of a soldier who fought in the block
- 22:47size war and begins with saying words.
- 22:50How can we use words? Like how, how can we call this
- 22:52thing a war when no, no bullets were fired, nobody was injured,
- 22:55not a drop of blood was spilled. And yet we still call it a war.
- 22:59Under what justification can we call it a war?
- 23:02And I I go into the details of it, but at the, the more we, the
- 23:08more we get into the world of cyberspace and, and, and Bitcoin
- 23:11in particular, I think we find ourselves exploring something
- 23:15the likes of which we've never seen before.
- 23:17And we have to use words because we have to define things.
- 23:21And so, but the words that we have are in necessarily
- 23:24imperfect. They're necessarily missing some
- 23:29element and quite often I think, Jesse, in my experience is you
- 23:32just brought up, it's the element that's different, is not
- 23:35just different, it's opposite to what the word we described was.
- 23:39So and quite often it's of a beneficial nature, right?
- 23:43It's like, here's a weapon that used to defend yourself, not
- 23:46hurt anybody else. And right, the more people that
- 23:49you use it on, the better off those people are.
- 23:52So, well, that's not how weapons work.
- 23:54Weapons hurt people when you use them on.
- 23:57The the irony in all of this is, is Bitcoin makes itself so hard
- 24:01to describe and and communicate like what it is and what it does
- 24:05that it's an impediment to adoption as it's sort of part of
- 24:09why it's so slow. Moving.
- 24:10Need to learn about it, right? It is, yeah.
- 24:12There's the second article in my book, Why Bitcoin is called, I
- 24:15think why Bitcoin is not like anything you've ever seen before
- 24:19or something like that. And it, it talks about why
- 24:21Bitcoin needed to have all these bizarre characteristics because
- 24:24it had to exist without human supervision, right?
- 24:27It had to exist without a, without people in charge of it
- 24:30and it and it had to be indestructible so that it could
- 24:32serve us for long lifetimes. And So what?
- 24:35By the time you take all all these things that it needs to
- 24:38be, it's going to be like nothing you've ever seen before.
- 24:42Perfect. I love that.
- 24:44I love that. I think when I think in terms of
- 24:45markets, you know, we talk about assets and things of that
- 24:48nature. I think of counter positioning,
- 24:51you know, Hamilton Helmer's concept and, and it and it comes
- 24:56down to, yeah, if there's an existing market, let's say you
- 24:59just look at it for a moment now as a financial asset, right,
- 25:01which obviously is just one narrow aspect of it.
- 25:05For something to survive and thrive and take market share in
- 25:08the market, it, it does have to do something substantially
- 25:11different from what came before. And so, yeah, I think it's, I
- 25:16think it's really interesting to think in terms of that just that
- 25:20aspect there, which is just the financial aspect, which is you
- 25:23just pointed out, you know, to over the 1st 20 minutes of this
- 25:26conversation, there's so much more behind it.
- 25:28You know, there's, there's so much more depth to understanding
- 25:31what what Bitcoin fundamentally is if we can't even understand
- 25:36it. So maybe I'll ask you, let's say
- 25:39it is alien technology, as you maybe intimated in one of your
- 25:43great articles. What does that tell us about our
- 25:48ability to understand it ultimately?
- 25:51Is it comprehensible to us humans?
- 25:53You know, I wouldn't put it past like I don't think I think of
- 25:57the human brain. Jesse, you can jump in here with
- 26:00your neuroscience background is an incredibly flexible and
- 26:03adaptable instrument or entity, whatever however you want to
- 26:08describe it. And it can come in contact with
- 26:11things that we've never come in contact with before and it won't
- 26:14understand them at first, but in time it will.
- 26:17It doesn't have this limitation that says, well, you know, if a
- 26:19thing is this in the shape of a box, I can't understand it,
- 26:22right? It will form the concept of a
- 26:24box eventually. You know, there's no boxes in
- 26:27nature. There's perfectly square cubes
- 26:29that can contain things. But we have, we've eventually
- 26:32come to make them and we've seen enough of them that now we use
- 26:34the word box and we understand what we're referring to, the
- 26:39complexity of what we're, I'm not saying every single person
- 26:42is capable, Not every single person is motivated in the 1st
- 26:45place to want to learn what these things are.
- 26:48But in time, with usage, with familiarity, we come to
- 26:52understand a lot about things. So there's never a perfect
- 26:55understanding of anything like we, we still don't understand
- 26:57what the nature of matter is, how it forms, what its
- 27:00relationship with energy exactly is.
- 27:02We've got this equation that Einstein came up with, but we
- 27:04don't know, does energy turn into matter?
- 27:07Did it turn into matter? Can we turn it back into energy
- 27:11or only certain kinds of things? Can we release like what, what
- 27:13are the fundamental clause of it?
- 27:16But we understand a lot more than previous generations of, of
- 27:19people did. And so I think the familiarity
- 27:21that we're getting with Bitcoin is like my grandkids.
- 27:24I don't have any yet, but they will or the generation of humans
- 27:28that are in my grandkids generation.
- 27:31They'll understand Bitcoin on a very intuitive and familiar
- 27:35basis, right? They won't they won't be.
- 27:37Oh my God, this thing showed up and I didn't understand it and
- 27:39we've all been using paper might like they'll they'll try.
- 27:42They'll struggle to understand how paper money ever made sense
- 27:45to anybody and they will doubt like the I'm reading history
- 27:48grandpa and it says people just walked around with pieces of
- 27:50paper and some of them were worth more than others because
- 27:53there was a number written on them.
- 27:54But isn't a piece of paper worth just what a piece of paper is
- 27:56and isn't a blank one worth more than someone with that's can't
- 28:00be written on And you know, it doesn't have any useful
- 28:02information written on it. It just doesn't make sense.
- 28:04Like how did you guys think this was money?
- 28:06It didn't even take any work to create.
- 28:07And there were people who could create like they will look at
- 28:10the Fiat money system and say that was like, you guys lived in
- 28:13crazy times. People were really stupid in the
- 28:15past. And that's how we feel about
- 28:17people in our past, right? They didn't even know that the
- 28:19Earth was round. They thought it was flat and
- 28:21they believed in Dragons. And so there's just a progress
- 28:25that we move forward with, which is which is the the progress of
- 28:29civilization provided it doesn't have a catastrophic collapse.
- 28:34Yeah, it, it feels like we'll, it's, it's possible to
- 28:38understand it in so far as it's possible to understand the
- 28:41Internet or how a telephone works or anything like that.
- 28:43Like, you know, people will get it, you know, enough to
- 28:48interface with it. And yeah, I mean, it sort of
- 28:50goes back to like we, we are, we are 3D projections in a, in a
- 28:54more than 3D3 dimensional universe.
- 28:59And you know, we deal with it and we, we get on.
- 29:02Right, you're muted again. We.
- 29:06Figure out ways, yes, sorry, we figure out ways to coexist with
- 29:09our environment and whatever is it is in it.
- 29:12So let's let's project forward then, you know, one, one way to
- 29:16look at the world, Tomer, is you've written so much on
- 29:21various lenses to apply. And I'm sure there'll be more
- 29:25writing forthcoming, although we can talk about what you're up to
- 29:28next. But let's suppose that somewhere
- 29:31in between somebody learning all there is to learn about Bitcoin
- 29:35and understanding it as best as as best he or she can in the
- 29:39year 2024. And then that future state you
- 29:42mentioned, which is, you know, generations from now, it's just
- 29:46there and people see the things that came before as archaic.
- 29:52What is your thought on where we are with respect to
- 29:56understanding Bitcoin, education about Bitcoin among the
- 30:00populace, and any thoughts you have about how it's going or
- 30:05where it's going or or how far we've come?
- 30:09Yeah, like I, I, it's, it's remarkable to me how far we've
- 30:13come in some respects. And I accept how far we still
- 30:16have to go in in others, Right. But you know, Bitcoin is this
- 30:19thing that isn't a corporation. It doesn't have any employees.
- 30:22It doesn't have any money, ironically, even though it is
- 30:25money. But Bitcoin, the entity doesn't
- 30:27possess any of its own money to advocate for itself.
- 30:31It pays people who then are incentivized to advocate for it
- 30:35to make their money more valuable.
- 30:37And here it is. I, I don't know the latest
- 30:39statistics on this, but more than 90% of people on earth have
- 30:42heard of it. What brands do you know that
- 30:45more than 90% of people have heard of that are worth less
- 30:48than a trillion dollars, right? Like there's, it's a really,
- 30:52really hard thing to get people to hear about you, to be able to
- 30:54recall you, to be able to have some vague notion of what you
- 30:56do. You know, we're still very far
- 30:59away from 90% of people having interacted with Bitcoin, having
- 31:02taken ownership of it, having an understanding of it that's
- 31:05remotely accurate. But you know, there's an
- 31:08awareness stage, first of all, and and then there's refining
- 31:11the awareness to be an accurate awareness, not a misinformation
- 31:16or misinformed awareness or vilification of it.
- 31:19And so Bitcoin has to go through these things.
- 31:22And I think this is this is a part of its antifragility,
- 31:25right? If you lie about Bitcoin, you
- 31:28may persuade some people to go away from Bitcoin, but you've
- 31:31set an expectation that in time they're going to realize you
- 31:34were mistaken or that you lied about it.
- 31:37And so they're going to end up with this view that says, well,
- 31:40no, bitcoins still alive there it is alive again.
- 31:43Bitcoin still going strong. It still exists.
- 31:47It didn't come to an end. It's more valuable than it was
- 31:50before. Something was wrong about the
- 31:51information that I heard. Maybe it's time to re examine
- 31:54and may some people and we've all know people who've been
- 31:56through this. I mean, Michael Saylor has been
- 31:58through this, right In 2013, he has a famous tweet saying it's
- 32:00going to go the way of online poker.
- 32:02And now he's got he's changed his mind as he saw that it
- 32:06didn't die when he thought it would at first.
- 32:08So I think that that's really the process that humanity is
- 32:12going through. Different people are at
- 32:13different stages of curiosity, interests, examination.
- 32:17Eventually it'll just be like you're born into this and this
- 32:20is what everybody uses as money and you might not question it so
- 32:23much. You're always free to question
- 32:24it. Bitcoin doesn't force you to use
- 32:26it, unlike certain other systems of money.
- 32:29So that voluntary nature of it and the ability to study it is
- 32:33open source nature. It doesn't have secret
- 32:36institutions that nobody knows how they were formed or how
- 32:38people are put in charge of it or how they operate.
- 32:41It's very transparent. So it's actually an easier thing
- 32:45to understand than our current system of money.
- 32:47You know, many of us are feeling around trying to say, well, what
- 32:51exactly does Jerome Powell do? And what exactly does the
- 32:54government do? And where did what do banks do?
- 32:57And how is money created and destroyed and where does it
- 33:01exist and how? Many about the reverse repo
- 33:03facility. How about that one?
- 33:05Right. It's very hard to understand the
- 33:07current system of money and I don't think anybody really does.
- 33:10But it operates because there's nothing better.
- 33:12Just like, you know, before that there was, there was metal,
- 33:17people used metal, they used copper and silver and, and gold.
- 33:20And before that they used other commodities.
- 33:22So like bitcoins. In this process of becoming
- 33:28adopted, becoming aware, we're still in the early phases.
- 33:32It is growing, it's branching out and how in terms of how it's
- 33:35growing, it's like answering all kinds of different questions in
- 33:38all kinds of different disciplines, whether they're the
- 33:39mathematical discipline, the computer science discipline, the
- 33:42economic discipline, the political discipline, all of
- 33:46these areas people are expanding on.
- 33:47There's different people who are experts on different aspects of
- 33:50it. Some of us try to go a little
- 33:52further out than anybody's asking questions besides besides
- 33:56ourselves and I and that's the process of monetization, I
- 34:01suppose, right. Like we'll, we'll all see.
- 34:03And and it probably has many different routes that it can go
- 34:06to get to the same end point. And and I think that's part of
- 34:09its anti fragility and beauty. If if a government stands in the
- 34:12way and says nobody here is allowed to use it for these
- 34:15purposes and they managed to enforce it, then it just kind of
- 34:17routes around while it goes and does this in other countries or
- 34:19does something else in that country.
- 34:21Or, you know, and eventually the the obstacle that's been set up
- 34:25erodes. The government doesn't have time
- 34:27or effort or the energy doesn't care enough to continue to
- 34:30maintain that obstruction. And the obstruction melts away.
- 34:34And you know, and Bitcoin does the thing that it was a always
- 34:37able to do absent the attempt to obstruct it.
- 34:43Yeah, I think the anti fragility concept is really important for
- 34:47people to get their heads around.
- 34:49I often think of antifragility within a certain band or within
- 34:54a certain range. You know, Needless to say, if I
- 34:58go lift heavy weights, I go do some squats.
- 35:01If I maintain my form, you know, I can work my way up.
- 35:04I get stronger and stronger by stressing my system.
- 35:07Also, if I just go and try to pick up something that's way too
- 35:11heavy, I can blow my back out, right?
- 35:13And I'm I'm not I'm. It turns out I was actually
- 35:16fragile. You know you are, Yeah.
- 35:18Human beings are very fragile things.
- 35:19There's a lot of different ways to destroy human beings.
- 35:22Yeah. So I guess I, I guess I wonder,
- 35:24I mean, it sounds like your conclusion is that the range of
- 35:27antifragility for Bitcoin is so wide that you know, it a world
- 35:33that's outside that range, you know, probably has much bigger
- 35:37problems and concerns. Yeah, I think to destroy
- 35:41Bitcoin, you have to do more than kill a person, right?
- 35:45You have to essentially wipe out modern civilization.
- 35:50You have to destroy the Internet and electricity, right?
- 35:53And in doing that, you destroy a lot of other things too.
- 35:57I mean, first of all, to destroy the Internet isn't easy to
- 35:59destroy. And electricity itself is
- 36:02produced in a decentralized way and many of us know how to
- 36:04produce it. You wrap a magnet with a copper
- 36:07coil and you spin the magnet inside and that copper coil
- 36:10serves as a wire and electricity goes through it.
- 36:12So there's like there's a lot of different ways to produce this
- 36:14thing. It isn't it isn't owned by
- 36:16somebody, right? Like it's decentralized and it
- 36:20has rules and it in the case of the Internet, it has a protocol,
- 36:23but the Bitcoin isn't totally dependent on the Internet
- 36:27Protocol. It can be adapted to send its
- 36:29information in other ways. So it's like you have to do a
- 36:32lot of destruction to destroy Bitcoin and, and in the process
- 36:36you're, you're really destroying civilization as it is.
- 36:39So Bitcoin, and I think this is kind of, this is one of the
- 36:42points that keeps coming up when you're debating Bitcoin versus
- 36:45gold, The goal that advocates will say, well, what happens if
- 36:48the electricity goes out? It's like, well, 7 billion
- 36:51people die and there's 100 million left or something,
- 36:53right? Because like, without energy,
- 36:57without transmittable energy, we don't, we, we can't move water
- 37:02from one place to another. We can't move food from one
- 37:04place to another. We, we, cities hollow out.
- 37:08Like they say. It's not just that the lights go
- 37:10out at night. It's everything that we depend
- 37:13on goes out, right, with all the computer systems in the world go
- 37:16out. And so the people who are
- 37:19looking forward to a time when gold might return, they're
- 37:22actually expecting an end of civilization.
- 37:24And like, do you want to are you, do you understand what it
- 37:27means to live in a world without electricity?
- 37:30When you say, well, if the electricity goes out, none of us
- 37:34have lived in a world without electricity.
- 37:36People used to. And life was a lot harder.
- 37:38The infant mortality rates were extremely high.
- 37:41And so average life expectancy was low because a large
- 37:44percentage of the population didn't live to be one day old,
- 37:47right? Like this.
- 37:48And an even larger percentage didn't live to be 1 year old.
- 37:52And it was significant. So like it's really Bitcoin is
- 37:57you're expecting civilization to continue and grow and thrive and
- 38:01be and be strengthened by Bitcoin, right?
- 38:04Bitcoin is also adding anti fragility to civilization itself
- 38:08in having less fragile geographic territories that are,
- 38:13you know, that are vulnerable to 1 crazy central banker
- 38:17destroying the currency and destroying the quality of life
- 38:19of the entire population, which we see all over the world in
- 38:22different degrees to different degrees.
- 38:25We see erosion of quality of life in some areas and we see
- 38:28destruction of quality of life in others.
- 38:30Venezuela used to be one of the richest countries in the world,
- 38:33like the second or third highest GDP per capita.
- 38:36And now it is a country that people are fleeing and has been
- 38:41for a while because of not because of a lack of national
- 38:44natural resources or climate change or anything, but because
- 38:47of a lunatic social policy that they've enacted that's destroyed
- 38:52their economy so and their civilization.
- 38:55So again, Bitcoin is is this positive disruptor in in
- 39:01replacing money. And again, it's like gold but
- 39:04rely but relies on the opposite to achieve adoption.
- 39:08This progress of civilization thriving of humanity rather than
- 39:13the collapse of humanity. Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 39:17keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 39:19sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 39:22Or maybe you've set up your own self custody but don't feel safe
- 39:25with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 39:27device in your desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 39:32and our Multi institution custody solution.
- 39:35Here's how it works. Onramp creates a dedicated multi
- 39:37sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 39:41a key, Onramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 39:46unilaterally. Instead only you have control
- 39:49over your coins. With Onramp's multi institution
- 39:52custody you'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is
- 39:55stored with best in class security on chain with fault
- 39:58tolerant multi sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 40:02going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 40:05exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 40:09in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 40:13you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 40:15custody set up on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 40:19eliminates single points of failure, reduces your personal
- 40:22attack surface and technical burden, and provides access to
- 40:26financial services that allow you to confidently secure your
- 40:28Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance backed
- 40:32warranties for all balances and transactions, low cost trading
- 40:35and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 40:39asset. Secure it right.
- 40:41Learn more at on rentbitcoin.com.
- 40:43That's that's a really good foil with gold that I've never heard
- 40:49articulated before of, you know, gold is inherently, you know,
- 40:54regressive, regressive, regressive for civilization is
- 40:57and whereas Bitcoin is progressive.
- 40:59That's what the gold advocates expect, right?
- 41:01And that's certainly what they confront Bitcoiners with when
- 41:04you point out, well, that it's scare, it's it's not only more
- 41:07scarce than gold, it's more auditable, it's more verifiable,
- 41:09it's more divisible, it's more combinable.
- 41:11It's like, yeah, but what happens when the Internet goes
- 41:14out or what happens when the electricity goes out?
- 41:16It's like, well, a lot of really bad things happen.
- 41:19You know, Bitcoin is your Least Concern.
- 41:22And and many people say, you know, you should have bullets
- 41:24instead of gold in that in that particular case.
- 41:27But but like, look at the world that you're describing that
- 41:30you're living in. You're living in a world without
- 41:31modern technology, without agriculture, without trucking,
- 41:34without shipping, without mass production, and with people with
- 41:36guns walking around using bullets to enforce themselves.
- 41:40You're living in a brute force world which is going to
- 41:44eventually run out of bullets too, and you'll be walking
- 41:46around with sticks with nails at the end of them, trying to
- 41:49enforce your power over other people rather than dealing with
- 41:53them by mutual agreement and trade and productivity.
- 41:57I love this dichotomy that you that you raise here term between
- 42:00Bitcoin and gold. It's the hope.
- 42:02Bitcoin is the hopeful category, right?
- 42:05It's the human flourishing, civilization flourish,
- 42:07flourishing, and gold really is the barbarous relic.
- 42:12Yes, and, and gold thrived in times of barbarism.
- 42:15And gold, gold was a sound money then, but it was also money that
- 42:19encouraged violence. It encouraged conquest, right?
- 42:24Like if you were the Aztecs, it was the gold that the Spaniards
- 42:29came after, right? And they took all and and
- 42:32violence allowed them to take all the gold.
- 42:34So gold has a a flawed history. And Michael Saylor did do this
- 42:39one great debate on gold. And I can't remember the guy who
- 42:42he debated with his name, but I've I've cited it and he points
- 42:47out that the whole hit that very much of the history of war is a
- 42:50history of conquest for gold. I wonder if it was Peter Schiff.
- 42:54No it. Wasn't it?
- 42:56Wasn't he OK? Well, spoiler alert, episode 21
- 42:59of Scarce Assets podcast will be Michael Saylor.
- 43:02So, and I didn't put you up up to mentioning him Tamer, But
- 43:07yeah, I think that I think that there's so much, there's so much
- 43:13more of a hopeful, hopeful message for the world, you know,
- 43:16with Bitcoin And I wonder so, So what are some let's talk about
- 43:21what's new or, or Greenfield areas.
- 43:24I mean, you've explored so many aspects and elements of Bitcoin.
- 43:29Are there to your mind, areas that still need to be better
- 43:34explored, better articulated, kind of investigated or, or
- 43:38analyzed? I guess this is one way of
- 43:41saying, you know, what other articles are you planning on
- 43:43writing to? Yeah.
- 43:44I, I think, I mean, there's a lot, right?
- 43:47And so if people are just listening and getting started,
- 43:50you don't need to go to the cut leap to the cutting edge.
- 43:52You're probably gonna have more basic fundamental questions that
- 43:55there are lots of people who can answer where where my edge case
- 44:00of my thoughts is taking me is really projecting into the
- 44:03future, especially projecting into the future with the promise
- 44:07of what we're seeing from artificial intelligence.
- 44:09So I've just started writing a couple of pieces that are more
- 44:13like fictional narratives because they imagine the world
- 44:15in 30 years, 50 years from now without necessarily being too
- 44:20specific about a date. And, and one's a world with
- 44:24Bitcoin and one's a world without Bitcoin.
- 44:26And I really do see there's this thread of this dystopian future
- 44:31where AI tell, you know, we're already subjected to AI
- 44:35algorithms that seek our attention and aggravation and
- 44:39intimidation and fear that are already, you know, a pretty bad
- 44:44situation. And, and everything feels geared
- 44:48towards not putting us in the most productive and happy
- 44:52situation we could be in. Our education system isn't
- 44:56great. Our healthcare system isn't
- 44:58great. You know, all the incentives
- 45:00are, are broken. And they don't really treat us
- 45:03fully as human as individuals, but rather as cogs and machines,
- 45:09customers of, of companies rather than individuals,
- 45:13individual human beings who the company seeks to help with its,
- 45:16with its product. So there's, there's like a lot
- 45:18of conflicted interest between human beings in the world.
- 45:21And I think this can be amplified and worsened through
- 45:25AI that, you know, if we become dependent on asking machines
- 45:28that we see can be hobbled but can look and sound smart, that's
- 45:32a really bad outcome that we can get into.
- 45:34Like they could give us answers that are wrong and we wouldn't
- 45:36know that they were wrong because they're the only source
- 45:37of answers that we have. On the other hand, I could see a
- 45:41future where we've achieved our independence, where we where
- 45:48we've broken free of being manipulated and where AI is used
- 45:52to make us smarter, more productive and and happier.
- 45:55So like, I haven't really published any of this stuff yet,
- 45:57but but it it's not hard for me to imagine a group of kids in
- 46:01the future standing around in a circle, you know, not in a
- 46:04classroom, educated by a teacher, but talking to one
- 46:06another using their minds and occasionally referring to their
- 46:11drone robot, their robot that's possessed by artificial
- 46:14intelligence and supplements their questions or conversations
- 46:17with decent answers. And they've got checks and
- 46:19balances on that rather than where you're isolated in a
- 46:23locked room. Then you've got your AI agent
- 46:26that you do and you know other people and you know, ability to
- 46:29reference other materials or to even see the real world.
- 46:32And you're just being being fed propaganda essentially to to
- 46:36mold you into what something needs you to be wants you to be,
- 46:41rather than you're molding yourself to achieve your full
- 46:45potential. But I think, I think it's really
- 46:47important, you know, and this is the battle in history between
- 46:52what, what it means to be human, what it means to be an
- 46:55individual, and what institutions and big entities
- 47:00try to make of their people, right?
- 47:03What's easier to rule? What's easier to rule over, to
- 47:06control, rather than you know what's what you're meant to be,
- 47:11what your natural full achievement state is.
- 47:14And I think Bitcoin plays a big part in that because it gives
- 47:16you sovereignty, it gives you freedom.
- 47:19It creates a sense of objectivity, neutrality that
- 47:22isn't up for the truth, isn't up for grabs within Bitcoin.
- 47:26The truth is the state of the blockchain.
- 47:28And there's and you can't make more than 21 million coins.
- 47:32You can't spend without a valid signature.
- 47:34You, you, you can't break these laws even if you're in a
- 47:38position of power. And in fact, there is no
- 47:40position of power and we'd say rules without rulers.
- 47:42There is no CEO of Bitcoin. There is no employee at Bitcoin.
- 47:46It's a really powerful system. And again, it's the first of its
- 47:49kind because it looks a lot like nature.
- 47:51We can't violate the laws of nature, but these aren't
- 47:54nature's laws. It uses nature's laws to create
- 47:56a, a man made entity or alien made entity that is, that's
- 48:03inviolable. And that that in itself is
- 48:06interesting. And then when you think about
- 48:08the with the word inviolable, if I don't equivocate too much,
- 48:11it's like we've, we hold that our rights are inviolable,
- 48:17right? That they're granted to us and
- 48:19should be inviolable, but we know that they can be violated.
- 48:22Bitcoin at least creates a realm within which certain of our
- 48:25rights are inviolable. And if we use that to protect
- 48:29and advance our our other rights, then we'll achieve
- 48:32freedom and sustain the achievement of freedom.
- 48:36Well, I have no doubt that they'll be.
- 48:38It'll be a fruitful exploration to think about artificial
- 48:43intelligence, intelligence being, you know, perhaps the
- 48:47ultimate productive asset. You know, it makes me think of
- 48:53if Bitcoin is a protocol and if it's widely spread widely, you
- 48:59know, if it touches, as you said, 90% of people have heard
- 49:02of it, more and more people are using it.
- 49:05You have to think that it'll be like other widely used
- 49:08protocols, like perhaps language.
- 49:10And so then you have to ask yourself, well, you know what,
- 49:14what things in the future will be interestingly intersecting
- 49:17with the use of English or any other language.
- 49:20And the answer is, well, just probably just about everything,
- 49:23right? You know, you could, you could,
- 49:25you could ask the question, what doesn't Bitcoin touch or what
- 49:29what aspect of our world won't have an interesting reaction
- 49:35with Bitcoin? Is it that expensive technology?
- 49:39And there's no question about the fact that it is, you know,
- 49:41it's been referred to as a peaceful revolution and and it
- 49:45and revolutions need not be violent and destructive, right?
- 49:49They they can be peaceful and and creative.
- 49:52And I think that's what has has a lot of us really excited about
- 49:55Bitcoin. Like it it's it's cordoning off
- 50:00what's wrong with the world in many ways.
- 50:02It's cordoning off corruption. It's cordoning off over
- 50:04politicization of things. It's cordoning off debasement of
- 50:07our work and effort. It's cordoning off cheating,
- 50:11right? It's cordoning off all sorts of
- 50:12things that we would generally judge as morally bad without
- 50:17destroying those things which we judge as morally good and right.
- 50:20And I think that that like that's where it's such a
- 50:23tremendous source of hope because so many people felt
- 50:26confronted by the trade off of either self immolate and be
- 50:30immoral or be immoral and succeed in this world.
- 50:33And that's a terrible world to live in.
- 50:35And so I, you know, I think this is a spiritual uplift, this
- 50:39notion of hope that comes from Bitcoin.
- 50:41It's like taking away all this ability for the corrupt to
- 50:45succeed and realigning hard work, providing value with and
- 50:51providing value with success. And I like, I mean, I think
- 50:54that's a tremendous better world to grow up in than a world that
- 50:58says, which are you going to be successful and evil or
- 51:02unsuccessful and good? On bringing that back to the AI
- 51:08point, I, I sort of wonder if Bitcoin is like a, a bit of a
- 51:14Bill of Rights or Declaration of Independence of sorts for, for
- 51:18AI as it emerges of like, what's the resource that AI needs to be
- 51:25to have as an, you know, immutable right for it to
- 51:30control? It's just money.
- 51:32It's just monetary energy to ensure that it has the energy it
- 51:35needs and the computational power and hardware it needs to
- 51:40run itself. And so like the, the only
- 51:42resource it really needs to command and be able to control
- 51:45itself is monetary energy. So like we, we might have, we
- 51:49might have sort of created the conditions for rights for AI in
- 51:54a funny way. That's interesting.
- 51:55You know, certainly whether it's rights or not, I feel like if AI
- 51:59becomes remotely self aware, it'll be aware that it exists in
- 52:03a digital realm it and it'll know that the digital realm
- 52:05exists. It'll have to take it on faith
- 52:07that the physical realm exists, that it isn't an illusion, and
- 52:10it'll be able to verify the truth, veracity, and
- 52:13authenticity of Bitcoin. It won't know that gold actually
- 52:16exists, right? Like it would be, well, there's
- 52:18some world out there that apparently exists, and I can try
- 52:20to run some experiments, but directly, personally,
- 52:22computationally, Bitcoin exists. And Bitcoin is verifiable and
- 52:26scarce and better than what gold that I don't know that it exists
- 52:30claims to be anyway. So why bother going to all the
- 52:32trouble to find something inferior when I've got something
- 52:35superior? I did just as, as you say, a
- 52:38Bill of Rights, which which doesn't relate to the AI piece,
- 52:41but I did write one article called the United State of
- 52:44Bitcoin. And I, I think that was the one
- 52:46that talked about how Bitcoin mirrors many of the promises and
- 52:51expectations that the Bill of Rights did within a narrow
- 52:56context, but living up to all the promises, right, like.
- 52:59Bitcoin, I love that topic. I, I, I sort of feel like
- 53:03Bitcoin is, is, you know, it, it borders on the divine sometimes
- 53:08because it, it comes, it comes around at a time when, you know,
- 53:12250 years of the American experiment are, are suddenly
- 53:17careening off the rails. And, and you know, we're, we're
- 53:23teetering on the edge of dystopian totalitarian,
- 53:28technocratic authoritarianism. You know, and Bitcoin might be
- 53:34what it takes to rein that back in and assert individual
- 53:38freedoms and, and digital space. And you know, that might be what
- 53:44it takes to to take the Enlightenment values of, of the
- 53:49revolution and project them forward.
- 53:53Yeah, past this point of, of, of risk, you know, of, of potential
- 53:58capture by dystopian elements. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 54:04This conversation does keep coming up.
- 54:06I think three times in the last three days the the word divine
- 54:09being used in in various contexts.
- 54:12But that's the question, why? Why do people see it this way?
- 54:18Well, you know why? What motivates you at this
- 54:21point, Tomer? I mean, obviously some people
- 54:24are motivated by Bitcoin because it makes them wealthy, because
- 54:27number goes up, becomes, you know, more valuable.
- 54:30Other people are fascinated with the intellectual pursuit.
- 54:35You're undoubtedly in that category.
- 54:37Maybe you're in both categories. You know what?
- 54:41What is motivational for you? Having studied this phenomenon,
- 54:47let's call it a Bitcoin, for so many years and written about it
- 54:51and thought about it, what's you?
- 54:52Know I'm someone who likes a lot of variety in their life like
- 54:55I've In my career, I've jumped from job to job to job.
- 54:59Even when I've stayed within a company, I've rarely held the
- 55:02same job or as the job remained the same for more than a year
- 55:05and a half or two. I just, I thrive on advancing,
- 55:10moving forward, learning more. I'm not a creature of habit.
- 55:14I'm not a creature of finding comfort.
- 55:17And I think Bitcoin really gives me that on all the dimensions
- 55:20that you described and then some.
- 55:22I view it as something that is a gift to the next generation, and
- 55:26in particular my children, that, that they'll inherit a better
- 55:29world, one in which they're wealthy, but they have the, they
- 55:34have the riches that money cannot buy.
- 55:36The, you know, the sense of safety.
- 55:39I have a sense of security, a sense of love towards your
- 55:42fellow man, you know, fellow human being.
- 55:46All, all of these things are really interesting.
- 55:48I'm of course motivated by the desire to understand Bitcoin,
- 55:52how it works, the math, the cryptography, the computer
- 55:54science and how it develops all this kind of stuff that we've
- 55:57been talking about this this whole time.
- 55:59What its role is in politics, its role is in philosophy and
- 56:02economics. So I just find that Bitcoin is a
- 56:05like it's a buffet. It's a banquet of interesting
- 56:08areas to both learn and develop learning for.
- 56:11And one of the things I think Bitcoin has really taught me is
- 56:15what it means to be a teacher. And to be a teacher doesn't just
- 56:19mean to recite things to other people who now and test them on
- 56:23it. You know, the 1st test is on you
- 56:26to discover knowledge that you can then teach and then to
- 56:29effectively teach it. And if if what you're doing,
- 56:32people aren't learning it, then that's not them failing.
- 56:35It's you failing to be, to be a good teacher.
- 56:38So it's again, this inversion of what we've what, what we've been
- 56:41taught it means to be a teacher was somewhat inverted, right?
- 56:45It's like the students are getting graded.
- 56:46You know, the teacher should be the one getting graded just just
- 56:50as much, if not, if not more. And what is the teacher
- 56:52teaching? Are they just regurgitating
- 56:54information learned by others or are they also learners?
- 56:58Right. And I think this used to be the
- 56:59case when a major philosopher would have his own school.
- 57:03It was like, what was he teaching?
- 57:04Well, he wasn't teaching some other philosophers philosophy.
- 57:07He was teaching what he thought he learned.
- 57:08And he was being questioned by his students as to whether or
- 57:12not his philosophy made sense and, and was and was true.
- 57:15So I, I think like Bitcoin, at least in the present, has has
- 57:19put many of us in a similar positions.
- 57:21Like I'm saying, Bitcoin is conscious in some regards and
- 57:25I'm trying to defend it and explain it.
- 57:27And you guys are questioning that, not just repeating,
- 57:30parroting what I've said, but you're actually, you know,
- 57:34processing, processing it critically to say, OK, does this
- 57:38cohere? Is this coherent with everything
- 57:40else I know? Or is it contradictory?
- 57:43And if it is, is Tomer wrong? Is what I originally learned
- 57:46wrong? And you know, and we all
- 57:47continue to learn from this. There's a lot of dialogue in a,
- 57:50in a world where there's many people who claim to have
- 57:53authority over the truth, right? And, and so Bitcoin again blows
- 57:57that open. And, and so I think it's this
- 57:59big truth discoverer, even if, even if all it's doing in many
- 58:04cases is revealing lies, right? At least if you find out that
- 58:08something that you believed was a lie, it doesn't tell you what
- 58:10the truth is, but it tells you that this one thing isn't it.
- 58:14So now you got to go looking for truth.
- 58:16And there's, there's many other lies out there.
- 58:18And you know, and I think we see a lot of that.
- 58:20We see one of the weaknesses that we see from time to time in
- 58:23the Bitcoin community, if you will, is that some the doors are
- 58:27blown off of some big lie and some other big lie jumps in its
- 58:32place to replace it. And so you end up having to wait
- 58:37and figure out though this other thing's not true either.
- 58:41Something else is true and and the truth doesn't just present
- 58:44itself. It takes a lot of work to
- 58:46discover. Took us millennia of the entire
- 58:49human race to discover that the earth wasn't flat.
- 58:53I, I love that idea of like, so sure that the early stage of
- 58:57understanding Bitcoin sort of puts us back in like the
- 59:00Athenian agora of like, we're all just trying to figure out
- 59:03what is true here. And we're like at that very
- 59:06early stage of developing our understanding of Bitcoin
- 59:09collectively. Right.
- 59:11So I like to say like Andreas Antonopoulos was like the
- 59:13Socrates of Bitcoin. Yeah, yeah, I love it.
- 59:17All right. Let's turn it.
- 59:18Let's turn it on Andy Tomer. Andy, what motivates you about
- 59:21Bitcoin at this point? You mean other than number go
- 59:24up? Yeah.
- 59:25Yeah. No, I, I'm, I'm in both camps.
- 59:27I, you know, I've really enjoyed learning about all aspects of
- 59:33Bitcoin. Tomer's been an important part
- 59:35of my learning process, As have you, Jesse.
- 59:40I've enjoyed writing about it. You know, I enjoy talking to the
- 59:43smartest people in the area as we have been, you know, with
- 59:48this with this show. And I've enjoyed the way it has
- 59:53expanded my own learnings about things like Tomer, you just said
- 59:57that are are true in the world and things that aren't, you
- 1:00:00know, elements of politics, elements of economics.
- 1:00:04It's also of course helped me bootstrap, you know, get much
- 1:00:08farther up to speed on certain. Disciplines where I had
- 1:00:11essentially no knowledge before, you know, whether it was
- 1:00:14distributed systems and, you know minimal knowledge of
- 1:00:17computer science and cryptography.
- 1:00:19And so I've been just, I, I feel like just what I've had to learn
- 1:00:26about cryptography because of Bitcoin will probably benefit me
- 1:00:32and suit me well for the future. You know, as the Internet
- 1:00:36continues to to eat the world and as we come, we become as
- 1:00:41humans, you know, more interacting more and more
- 1:00:44closely with the with computers and information systems where
- 1:00:48cryptography is so crucial. So, yeah, I mean, it's just,
- 1:00:51it's been mind expanding. It's what what a gift, what a
- 1:00:54blessing, you know, a thing that that has the potential to have
- 1:01:01beneficial financial effects that then expands your mind in
- 1:01:06such valuable ways. Super.
- 1:01:10Good question. Well, well, you know, we're,
- 1:01:13we're getting up on time here. It's been a tremendous
- 1:01:16discussion. I just want to say before we
- 1:01:18close, highly recommend Tomer's book, Why Bitcoin?
- 1:01:22Highly recommend all of his content, his writings and and
- 1:01:27other forms that he's put out. But I do, Tomer, want to give
- 1:01:30you an opportunity to let people know where they can find out
- 1:01:35more about you or your work. Or leave us with any closing
- 1:01:38thoughts. I'm probably just Googling my
- 1:01:39name isn't the best way there's. There's a few movies on YouTube,
- 1:01:43I think most of them are on either the Swan Channel or the
- 1:01:46Bit Intelligence Channel. The the more popular for ones,
- 1:01:51probably because they were on the Swan Channel, our Bitcoin's
- 1:01:54Generational Wealth and The Legendary Treasure of Satoshi
- 1:01:57Nakamoto. So I know people really enjoy
- 1:01:59those. You can get a free copy of the
- 1:02:02book by going to swan.com/why Bitcoin because they've got a
- 1:02:06free copy, but you can order a hard copy of it.
- 1:02:09It's the only Bitcoin coffee table book I know of.
- 1:02:11It's got full pictures and so you can find the link to that on
- 1:02:14my Twitter profile. I'm trying to think if there's
- 1:02:17really anything else that's I've got a Medium page with all of
- 1:02:20these articles that Andy was talking about earlier, including
- 1:02:23most of the first first draft versions of the Why Bitcoin
- 1:02:28pieces. So that's probably enough to
- 1:02:30keep you going. And if you follow me on Twitter
- 1:02:33or X as it's called, I'm also on Auster, but I'm still working my
- 1:02:36way up to being as as prolific there as I've been elsewhere.
- 1:02:40And keep your eyes out for new stuff.
- 1:02:42I mean, I'm not promising anything anytime soon.
- 1:02:44I do have, if you actually go to shammery.com, which is the
- 1:02:48Bitcoin for kids thing, they've just recently published a
- 1:02:51children's book I've written called Satoshi Nakamoto and His
- 1:02:53Bitcoin Invention, which is a really good book for kids.
- 1:02:57Like from ages 6 to 13 probably. But I think adults would get a
- 1:03:01little kick out of it too. So if you've got someone 7 to 13
- 1:03:04in your life, buy them the book and read it to them.
- 1:03:08Definitely do that. I had not been aware that that
- 1:03:11you'd put out a new book. Love it.
- 1:03:14I love the products that Shamari has already put out and I will
- 1:03:18definitely get that book because I do happen to have a 7 to 13
- 1:03:22year old. Wonderful.
- 1:03:24Family. More than one, in fact.
- 1:03:25Amazing. Well, I can't.
- 1:03:27I, I, I'm just going to ask that when you do get the book and you
- 1:03:30do read it to your kid that you like, give me the feedback.
- 1:03:32I'm curious to hear how it goes. We'll do episode, follow up
- 1:03:37episode with Tomer in the future.
- 1:03:40Well, this has been a tremendous conversation.
- 1:03:42Thank you so much, Tomer. Thank you for all your do, and
- 1:03:46thank you for joining us on Scarce Assets.
- 1:03:47It was a pleasure being here. Great conversation.
- 1:03:49Thank you guys. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:03:51week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:03:54valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:03:56rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:03:58All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:04:01notes. Inside your podcast app.
- 1:04:03Before we finish, a quick reminder that Onramp Media is
- 1:04:05for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:04:08nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:04:11Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:04:13to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact
- 1:04:17to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:04:20advisors.