Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Beyond the ROE Trap: The Superiority of ROIC
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine a company that is practically falling apart, like
- 0:04teetering right on the absolute edge of bankruptcy.
- 0:07Right, it happens all the time. Yeah.
- 0:09But now imagine pulling up its financial scorecard and seeing a
- 0:12return on equity of, well, 100%, yeah, or even higher.
- 0:17Which just sounds like a massive typo.
- 0:18Exactly. You would assume a number that
- 0:20high means the business is just printing money.
- 0:23But it is not a typo. Today, we're unpacking why Roe,
- 0:28the metric that, you know, even Warren Buffett once called his
- 0:30absolute favorite, can secretly lie to you.
- 0:34It's a paradox that catches a massive number of people
- 0:36completely off guard. I mean, you open almost any
- 0:39finance textbook and Roe is usually right there in chapter
- 0:431, right? Like the gold standard?
- 0:45Yeah, it is treated as the definitive measure of business
- 0:48health, but the root of the problem is what ROV
- 0:51fundamentally measures. It only looks at what the
- 0:53shareholders money makes. So it's the equity part?
- 0:55Exactly. It focuses purely on the equity
- 0:58portion of the business, which means it completely ignores the
- 1:02the hidden risks of how that business is actually funded.
- 1:04OK, let's unpack this, because that's the mission of our deep
- 1:07dive. Today we are going to look at
- 1:10the mechanical flaws of this widely beloved metric, how
- 1:14management teams actively exploit those flaws to create
- 1:19like optical illusions. They absolutely do.
- 1:21And more importantly, we're going to explore the metric that
- 1:23our sources say true investment masters rely on instead, a
- 1:27metric called Return on invested Capital, or ROIC.
- 1:30What's fascinating here is to really understand how the ROV
- 1:33trap is set, we need to look at the engine of a business versus
- 1:37how that engine is financed. Our sources provided a really
- 1:41relatable scenario that perfectly illustrates this
- 1:44disconnect. Yeah, let's walk through that
- 1:45scenario. So we have these two friends,
- 1:46Xiao Wang and Xiao Lee. They both decide to open up
- 1:49bubble tea shops in the same city.
- 1:51They are competing in the exact same market.
- 1:53First we have Xiao Wang. He's been saving up for years
- 1:56and he uses 1,000,000 of his own money to open a shop.
- 2:00Just his own cash. Yep, he works hard and at the
- 2:02end of year 1 he makes 200,000 in pure profit.
- 2:06So if we calculate his return on equity, it is straightforward.
- 2:10Right, he made 200,000 on a 1,000,000 investment.
- 2:13Exactly. So his Roe is 20%.
- 2:15Which is, you know, a very respectable return.
- 2:17A business consistently generating 20% on its equity is
- 2:20doing really well. But then we have his friend Xiao
- 2:22Li. He also wants to open a shop,
- 2:25but he only has 100,000 of his own money, so he goes to the
- 2:28bank and borrows 900,000. He now also has 1,000,000 to
- 2:33open his shop. Fast forward one year after
- 2:37paying off the interest on that massive bank loan, Shao Lee has
- 2:40made 100,000 in profit. This is where it gets crazy,
- 2:44right? Now purely looking at RO E, the
- 2:47math gets wild. Shao Lee made 100,000 in profit,
- 2:50and because RO E only looks at the money he put in his 100,000
- 2:54in equity, his Roe is an incredible 100%.
- 2:58Yeah. So on paper, just looking at
- 3:00that single metric, Xiao Lee looks like an absolute business
- 3:03genius compared to Xiao. Wang wait, let me play devil's
- 3:05advocate here for a second. Xiao Lee still generated a 100%
- 3:09return on his money. He did so as an investor.
- 3:11Looking at these two shouldn't I only care about what my specific
- 3:15dollar does? If I give him a dollar and he
- 3:18gives me another dollar back in a year, why should I care if he
- 3:21borrowed from a bank to make it happen?
- 3:23Because you have to price in the risk and Roe turns a blind eye
- 3:27to risk. Let's look at the actual
- 3:29business operations here. Both of these bubble tea shops
- 3:33utilize the exact same amount of total resources to operate for
- 3:37the year. Right.
- 3:37They both had 1,000,000 in capital working for.
- 3:40Them exactly, but what did they actually generate from that
- 3:431,000,000 in resources? Well, Xiao Wang generated
- 3:45200,000. And Xiao Lee only generated
- 3:48100,000. When you strip away the
- 3:50financing, Xiao Wang actually has the superior business model.
- 3:53Oh, I see. Yeah, he is extracting twice as
- 3:56much value from the exact same amount of resources.
- 3:59Xiaoli's secret isn't a better product.
- 4:01Or, you know, better marketing or more efficient operations.
- 4:04This. Secret is just financial
- 4:06leverage. Exactly.
- 4:07Taking on that much debt artificially inflates his
- 4:09returns on paper. So explain the mechanics of that
- 4:12hidden risk. How does that leverage actually
- 4:14come back to bite him? It is all about the margin of
- 4:17safety. Let's say there is an economic
- 4:19downturn or a major new competitor opens up across the
- 4:23street. Something that hits sales.
- 4:25Right. And both shops see their sales
- 4:27drop by, say, 20%. Xiao Wang's profit shrinks, but
- 4:32he still has a profitable business.
- 4:33He survives the downturn. Because he owns it outright.
- 4:36Exactly. Xiao Lee, however, still has
- 4:39fixed hefty interest payments on a $900,000 loan.
- 4:44If his profits drop, that interest expense just consumes
- 4:47everything. Wow, one bad month and that
- 4:50leverage crushes him. The bank calls the loan and he
- 4:53is facing bankruptcy. Yet right up until the moment he
- 4:56goes under, his Roe might still look fantastic.
- 4:59Just because his equity base is so small.
- 5:01Precisely. That fundamentally changes how
- 5:03you look at a balance sheet. I mean, if Roe is this easily
- 5:06manipulated by the debt structure, we clearly need a
- 5:08metric that doesn't care where the money comes from.
- 5:10We really do. Looking at our sources, this is
- 5:12where return on invested capital comes in ROIC, because it treats
- 5:15the capital structure as completely agnostic, right?
- 5:18That is exactly it. We want a metric that measures
- 5:21the actual engine of the business, independent of whether
- 5:23management chose to finance that engine with cash, bank loans or
- 5:27bonds. So let's deconstruct the ROIC
- 5:30formula, because the mechanics of how it strips away the noise
- 5:33are fascinating. Let's start with the top half of
- 5:36the fraction, the numerator. Right, the Nopat.
- 5:38Yeah, NOPAT, net operating profit after tax.
- 5:41NOPAT is crucial because it gives us the pure operating
- 5:44profit of the business after taxes but strictly before paying
- 5:48any interest on debt. It makes me think of an analogy.
- 5:51Using NOPAT pad is like timing a sprinter's raw speed on an
- 5:55indoor track. Oh, I like that.
- 5:57Yeah, it entirely removes the effect of a massive tailwind.
- 6:00We just want to know how fast they can actually run under
- 6:02their own power. We don't want to know how fast
- 6:04the wind pushed them. That is the exact dynamic.
- 6:07By ignoring the interest payments in this specific
- 6:10calculation, you only see the core earning power of the actual
- 6:14operations. Regardless of the funding.
- 6:16Right. Whether they are funded entirely
- 6:18by shareholder cash or entirely by massive bank debt.
- 6:22No, Pat shows you how good the company is at actually making
- 6:25bubble tea, building cars, or selling software.
- 6:28So that's the top half, the pure performance.
- 6:31Now when you look at the bottom half of the formula, the
- 6:33invested capital, you are adding up the equity and the interest
- 6:37bearing debt. Which makes sense.
- 6:38We want to look at all the money.
- 6:40Exactly. But there is a twist in the
- 6:42sources that seems counterintuitive.
- 6:44You actually subtract the cash. Wait, why do we deduct cash from
- 6:47the total capital? Subtracting the cash is the
- 6:50detail that really separates a surface level analysis from a
- 6:53professional. 1 We have to strip out the idle money.
- 6:57Idle money. Yeah, think about a massive tech
- 7:00company that has billions of dollars just sitting in a bank
- 7:02account or in short term investments, right?
- 7:04That money is not being used to buy inventory or build data
- 7:08centers or hire engineers. It's just lying flat.
- 7:11It's basically a rainy day fund. It's not actually operating
- 7:14right. If we include that massive pile
- 7:16of idle cash in our calculation, it artificially inflates the
- 7:20denominator. Which would lower the overall
- 7:22return rate. Exactly, making the core
- 7:24business look much less efficient than it actually is.
- 7:28By subtracting that idle cash, we isolate the exact specific
- 7:32amount of capital that is actively working day in and day
- 7:35out on the factory floor to generate that operating profit.
- 7:38The sources refer to this as finding the true profitability
- 7:41gene of the business. I love that phrase.
- 7:44Yeah, it's like finding out how strong the company's DNA
- 7:46actually is without any accounting, makeup or fancy
- 7:49lighting. Exactly.
- 7:50So now we have our baseline. ROIC shows us the true engine.
- 7:55But here's where it gets really interesting.
- 7:57What I found super revealing in these sources is how management
- 8:00teams actively exploit the blind spots of Roe.
- 8:04Oh, they definitely do. I mean, taking on debt to run
- 8:06the operations is just one way to juice the returns, but what
- 8:09if a company wants to manipulate the math itself?
- 8:12You mean attacking the denominator of the Roe fraction
- 8:14directly? Yes.
- 8:16How does that work? Well, that brings us to massive
- 8:19share buybacks. The sources explicitly highlight
- 8:22companies like Starbucks and Boeing doing this.
- 8:24They aren't just using debt to build new stores or design new
- 8:28airplanes. They are actively borrowing
- 8:31money to buy back their own stock from the open market.
- 8:34Let's breakdown the mechanics of how that actually works, because
- 8:37it sounds counterintuitive to the average person.
- 8:40Like how does buying your own stock inflate your apparent
- 8:44financial success? It all comes back to the core or
- 8:46Roe formula. Net income divided by
- 8:49shareholders equity, right? When a management team takes
- 8:52company cash, or worse, borrowed cash, buy shares from the market
- 8:57and retires them, that equity is effectively erased from the
- 9:00balance sheet. Wow.
- 9:01Yeah, they are actively shrinking the bottom number of
- 9:04the fraction. And mathematically, if you keep
- 9:07the top number at the profit roughly the same, but you
- 9:10aggressively shrink the bottom number, the overall percentage
- 9:13just skyrockets, yes. In fact, if a company is
- 9:16aggressive enough with debt funded buybacks, they can shrink
- 9:19that equity down so far that it mathematically becomes a
- 9:22negative number. Hold on, let's unpack that.
- 9:25How can a massive publicly traded company have negative
- 9:28equity? It's.
- 9:28Wild, isn't it? That sounds like the definition
- 9:31of being fundamentally bankrupt. It is a quirk of modern
- 9:34accounting. Remember that equity is simply
- 9:36total assets minus total liabilities, OK.
- 9:40I'm with you. If a company takes on a mountain
- 9:42of debt which immediately increases their liabilities, and
- 9:46uses that cash to buy back and retire their own stock, the cash
- 9:50leaves the company, but that massive liability remains.
- 9:54Oh wow. They execute this maneuver year
- 9:57after year. Eventually their total
- 9:59liabilities exceed their total assets.
- 10:01The equity calculation turns negative.
- 10:03That's crazy. And when the denominator of your
- 10:05Roe fraction is near 0 or technically negative, the Roe
- 10:09calculation goes to Infinity. It becomes a completely
- 10:13meaningless absurd figure. So you could see an Roe of 300%
- 10:17or 500%, but the business hasn't actually improved its operations
- 10:20one single bit. Exactly, it is pure financial
- 10:23engineering. They are just moving numbers
- 10:24around on a spread sheet to trigger bonuses tied to ROV
- 10:27targets. But ROIC catches this light of
- 10:30hand. It does because ROIC is, as the
- 10:33source describes it, steady as a mountain.
- 10:35Steady as a mountain. Right, ROIC doesn't care if
- 10:38management is playing games with the share count because the
- 10:41invested capital formula adds that newly acquired debt right
- 10:44back into the denominator. So it balances out.
- 10:48Exactly. The total capital employed
- 10:50remains a true reflection of the resources the company is using.
- 10:54The ROIC will tell you exactly what the underlying operating
- 10:57efficiency is completely immune to the buyback distortion.
- 11:01If we connect this to the bigger picture, this leads right into
- 11:04what the sources call the ultimate danger for unwary
- 11:08investors. Value trap.
- 11:10Exactly the value trap. This is the scenario where you
- 11:13see a stock that looks incredibly cheap.
- 11:15It boasts A wonderfully high Roe, but it has a very low ROIC
- 11:20underneath. We really need to understand the
- 11:21psychology of why the market gets fooled by this.
- 11:24Right. Why do people fall for it?
- 11:26Well, an investor will be screening for stocks and see a
- 11:28mature company, maybe a well known legacy brand trading at
- 11:32what looks like a deep discount. Looks like a bargain.
- 11:35Right, They look at the ROA and see a robust 30 or 40% return.
- 11:40They think they found a hidden gem that the rest of the market
- 11:42has mispriced. But that high ROA is entirely an
- 11:46optical illusion. Completely created by the exact
- 11:49leverage and buyback tricks we just discussed.
- 11:52The scorecard looks great to the shareholders, but underneath the
- 11:55hood the actual engine is suttering.
- 11:58Why does a company resort to this, and how does the trap
- 12:01eventually spring on the investor?
- 12:03Usually, a company resorts to these tactics because their core
- 12:06business is fundamentally deteriorating.
- 12:09They can no longer grow their profits by selling more products
- 12:13or expanding into new markets. So they manufacture the growth.
- 12:16Exactly. They take on debt to shrink the
- 12:18share count, artificially boosting their earnings per
- 12:21share and Roe. But it is a business running on
- 12:24a treadmill of debt. And what happens if the
- 12:26treadmill speeds up? If the treadmill speeds up even
- 12:29slightly, say, interest rates rise, making their debt more
- 12:32expensive, or there's just a minor dip in consumer demand,
- 12:35they fall off. Because the margin of safety is
- 12:370. Exactly when that mountain of
- 12:40debt eventually matures and has to be refinanced at higher
- 12:42rates, the optical illusion completely shatters.
- 12:45The numbers catch up to them. Right.
- 12:48The core earnings aren't strong enough to cover the new interest
- 12:50payments, the ROV plummets back to reality, and the stock price
- 12:55collapses. That is a brutal trap.
- 12:57That is how the value trap springs.
- 12:59You buy in thinking you're getting a great business at a
- 13:02discount, only to realize the core business has been quietly
- 13:06eroding beneath layers of financial makeup for years.
- 13:09This completely reframes how you look at a company's health.
- 13:12I mean to summarize the core narrative from our sources
- 13:15today, Roe is ultimately a metric for accounts.
- 13:19Well said. It is a rearview mirror look at
- 13:21what the shareholders technically made on AER which is
- 13:24easily distorted by leverage. But ROIC is the metric for
- 13:28business operators. It is for the true investors who
- 13:31want to strip away the financing noise and see if a company score
- 13:35operations are genuinely creating wealth.
- 13:37And that leads to the ultimate goal.
- 13:39You know, the final piece of the puzzle that the text lays out.
- 13:42It is about finding the Holy Grail of capital allocation.
- 13:45The Holy Grail. Yeah, you don't just want a
- 13:47company with a high ROIC today. You are searching for those rare
- 13:51businesses that can maintain a high ROIC over long periods of
- 13:54time and crucially, possess the runway to continue reinvesting
- 14:00their earnings back into the business at that same high rate
- 14:03of return. That combination, high returns
- 14:05on capital and high reinvestment rates, is the mechanical engine
- 14:08of how true lasting wealth is compounded.
- 14:11It really is. The ultimate wealth compounding
- 14:13engine. Well, if this deep dive sparked
- 14:15your curiosity and you want to access more Advanced Research
- 14:18applications and our latest published personal intelligent
- 14:22multi agent deep value intelligence.
- 14:25Welcome to explore and join Deep Values dot AI community.
- 14:28It's a great resource. Also track total market
- 14:30temperature. Welcome to search and download
- 14:32iOS app Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store.
- 14:35If you'd like to access wider topics including life and
- 14:37investing philosophy, please subscribe to our sister channel
- 14:40Deep Values. Don't forget to like this video.
- 14:43Much appreciate it. And as always, keep in mind that
- 14:46all analysis today is based on publicly available sources and
- 14:49may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 14:53All contents from this channel is for educational and research
- 14:56purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 15:00Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 15:02decisions. Awesome.
- 15:04We've covered a lot of ground today exploring the mechanics of
- 15:08debt buybacks and how optical illusions are built on balance
- 15:12sheets. We really did.
- 15:13We know it's incredibly hard to find a business with a
- 15:15consistently high ROIC, but I want to leave you with a
- 15:18question to Mull over, not just about the companies you study,
- 15:21but about your own trajectory. I love this part.
- 15:24Ask yourself in your own life, where career are you relying on
- 15:28the leverage of quick tricks and superficial optics to boost your
- 15:30apparent success? Or are you doing the hard
- 15:33foundational work of building a high ROIC engine of genuine
- 15:37repeatable skills? Something to think about as you
- 15:40navigate your own growth. Until next time.