Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Post-IPO Companies Buy Back Shares Above IPO Price
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's a moment a few months after an IPO when the founders look at their stock chart, see it dip below the IPO price, and start asking the CFO the same question. Are we buying back shares or not? Luna: And usually the answer is, not yet. But we're seeing a growing number of post ipo tech companies do it anyway, even above the IPO price. Why would they do that? Lucas: That's exactly what we're digging into today. And before we go deep, a quick note from us. This show is ad-free, and that's thanks to listeners who support us. If you find these conversations useful for what you're building or running, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps keep the lights on and the episodes coming. Luna: Yeah, honestly, a tiny gesture goes a long way for an independent podcast like this. Lucas: Absolutely. Now back to buybacks. The classic logic has always been that you buy back stock when it's cheap, when your own shares are the best investment you can make. But a lot of post ipo companies are doing the opposite. They're buying back shares at or above the IPO price, often within the first year of going public. Luna: What's an example we can actually point to? Lucas: Let's use a recent one. Say a software company IPO'd at twenty-five dollars a share, popped to forty in the first week, and then drifted back to twenty-eight. Instead of waiting for further lows, the board authorizes a fifty-million-dollar buyback. The stock is still twenty percent above the IPO price, and they're buying. Luna: That's interesting. So they're not waiting for a bargain. They're sending a message. Lucas: Right. And the message is, we believe in the long-term value of this company, and we're putting our money where our mouth is. It's a signal of confidence that management thinks the stock is undervalued, even if it's above the IPO price. Because the IPO price itself is often set conservatively to ensure the deal gets done. Luna: So they're saying, the IPO price was a floor, not a ceiling. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a powerful narrative for the market. But there's a real cost. When you buy back shares above what the company sold them for during the IPO, you're essentially returning capital to shareholders who bought in earlier, and you're spending cash that could have gone into R&D or acquisitions. Luna: That's the tension, isn't it? You're signaling confidence, but you might be underinvesting in the business. Lucas: That's the core trade-off. And it's not just about the cash outlay. There's also the earnings per share math. When you reduce the share count, earnings per share goes up mechanically. That can make the stock look cheaper on a price to earnings basis, which can attract more buyers. Luna: So even if the underlying business doesn't improve, the buyback makes the numbers look better. Lucas: Precisely. And that's why some skeptics call buybacks a financial engineering trick. But for a young public company, it can be a legitimate way to offset dilution from stock compensation and employee stock purchase plans, which are critical for attracting talent. Luna: Right, because every time an employee exercises an option, the share count increases. A buyback can net that out. Lucas: Exactly. So you're not just signaling to investors, you're also managing your dilution. And that's a pragmatic reason why a CFO might push for a buyback even above the IPO price. It's not just about the stock price, it's about the share count. Luna: But what happens when the stock falls after the buyback? You've spent cash and the signal didn't work. Lucas: That's the risk. And we've seen that play out. Look at Roblox, for example. It's down over twenty-five percent in just the past five days. If they had announced a buyback last week, they'd be sitting on losses and a lot of questions from shareholders. Luna: So the timing matters. You don't want to be buying when the stock is about to fall off a cliff. Lucas: Right. And that's why some companies tie their buybacks to a formula, like a price to sales ratio or a percentage below the 52-week high. That way, they only buy when the stock is relatively cheap. But the signal is weaker when the market knows you'll only buy at a discount. Luna: So there's a delicate balance between sending a strong signal and protecting your capital. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the decision to buy back above the IPO price is so interesting. It's a deliberate choice to prioritize the signal over the price. And it can work, especially if the market was skeptical about the company's growth prospects. Luna: Can you think of a real-world case where it did work? Lucas: Sure. Let's talk about a company that IPO'd back in 2024. The stock popped, then faded. The board authorized a buyback at a price that was above the IPO price but below the peak. The market read it as confidence, the stock stabilized, and then the company reported strong earnings. The buyback was seen as a turning point. Luna: So it was a catalyst that helped reset the narrative. Lucas: Exactly. But it could have gone the other way. If the earnings had missed, the buyback would have been seen as a waste of cash. So it's a bet on your own execution. Luna: What about the tax angle? In the U.S., there's a one-percent excise tax on buybacks, right? Lucas: Yes, that's been in effect since 2023. So when you buy back shares, you pay a one-percent tax on the value of the repurchase. That's another cost to consider. It's not huge, but it does eat into the benefit. Luna: So the math has to work even with that tax. Lucas: Right. And for a company that's not generating much cash flow yet, that one percent can feel like a bigger deal. That's why some post ipo companies prefer to wait until they have more predictable cash flows before initiating a buyback program. Luna: What about the alternative? Why not do a dividend instead? That's the more traditional way to return cash to shareholders. Lucas: Dividends are a promise. Once you start paying them, the market expects you to keep paying them. A buyback is more flexible. You can do it when you have excess cash and stop when you don't. For a young company that wants to retain flexibility, a buyback is often the better choice. Luna: So it's less of a commitment. Lucas: Exactly. And that's consistent with the growth mindset of most tech companies. They don't want to be locked into a dividend policy that might not make sense in a downturn. Luna: But even with a buyback, you're locking up cash. What if a better acquisition opportunity comes along? Lucas: That's the opportunity cost. And that's why some boards put strict limits on buyback amounts, like authorizing only a certain percentage of market cap or a specific dollar figure. That way, they retain the ability to make acquisitions or invest in R&D. Luna: So it's about balance. You want to send the signal without painting yourself into a corner. Lucas: Right. And that's the art of capital allocation. It's not a black and white decision. It depends on the company's cash position, its growth prospects, and the market's view of its stock. Luna: What about the current market? We're seeing some big moves. Amazon is up almost sixteen percent in five days. That's a huge move. Would you expect a company like that to do a buyback anytime soon? Lucas: Probably not. When your stock is ripping, there's no need to buy back shares. You'd be paying up. But for a company like Roblox, which is down over twenty-five percent in the same period, the calculus is different. They might see an opportunity to signal confidence and support the stock. Luna: So the buyback decision is often countercyclical. You buy when others are fearful. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why we see more buyback announcements in selloffs than in rallies. But the tricky part is, if the market is telling you that your stock is falling for a reason, you might be catching a falling knife. Luna: So what's the takeaway for a CFO of a recently public company? Lucas: The takeaway is that a buyback above the IPO price is a high-conviction move. It says we believe in our story, and we're willing to put our capital on the line. But it's not a substitute for strong fundamentals. If the business doesn't deliver, the signal fades fast. Luna: And if the business does deliver, it can be a great way to build trust with the market. Lucas: Exactly. So when you see a post ipo company buying back shares above the IPO price, don't just nod along. Look at the cash flow, the growth rate, and the dilution. And ask yourself if the signal is backed by substance. Luna: That's a great way to frame it. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. And to our listeners, if you found this useful, maybe share it with someone who's trying to make sense of buybacks. We'll be back tomorrow with another conversation on the business side of tech.