Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.48🎙️ Public Inquiry -Bespoke Economic Modelling Week 2 Day 2
Transcript
- 0:00There were four emerging trends today, the lack of adequate
- 0:04environmental information, economic modelling, the
- 0:07admissibility of the 95 files, and the timetabling on the
- 0:12opening of day two, week two, we were straight back into the
- 0:15discussion about the legitimacy of the economic modelling based
- 0:19on the non existent, 2016, Phantom report and the lack of
- 0:24complete environmental information from dfi. Listen to
- 0:28the last two podcasts for details about these points. The
- 0:34lack of environmental information the PAC remind us
- 0:36all that they'd requested the department many times over the
- 0:40last year, had they submitted all the appropriate information
- 0:43needed for the PAC to carry out the work, and the department
- 0:47asserted they had, the Commission said they did not
- 0:51have the power to force the department to release
- 0:53information. It's clear PAC can do nothing, that they are bound
- 0:57by procedures. Might I mention that through all of this, the
- 1:02silence from the departments was noteworthy the 95 files, another
- 1:08point that came up almost in passing is worth highlighting.
- 1:13It emerged that an employee of cleaver Fulton Rankin dalradian
- 1:17solicitors submitted a response to the trans boundary
- 1:21consultation, which was considered by DFI as an
- 1:25objection and given to the PAC in the list of objectors, and so
- 1:30were invited to make a further statement of evidence which
- 1:34Delray didn't
- 1:35use to submit new environmental information.
- 1:39This was not the intended function of the process, and
- 1:42should have been rejected by PAC as its new environmental
- 1:46information, which has not been consulted on, but it was
- 1:50accepted by the PAC. It begs the question, Why did PAC accept the
- 1:56objection as being legitimate and not a conflict of interest?
- 2:00Why the DFI allowed the submission of the objection in
- 2:03the first place to PAC
- 2:06economic modelling
- 2:09from what's been presented so far, some of the economic
- 2:12projections feel quite optimistic and a bit removed
- 2:16from real world conditions. It raises doubt about how much
- 2:21weight can reasonably be placed on those models without clearer
- 2:26evidence to back them up. And I certainly believe these figures
- 2:31cannot be trusted as presented by dalradian right now.
- 2:36Aside from my untutored beliefs, it was
- 2:38interesting to note that the economics expert, Mr. Burgess,
- 2:43representing
- 2:44fodc, seems also
- 2:46not to have confidence in the financial projections as
- 2:50presented by dalradian, presenting several reasoned
- 2:55arguments over the past few days. To quote one, the only
- 2:59reason this looks like a very productive investment is because
- 3:03of the high value of gold. Pointing out the majority of the
- 3:07higher value will go out of the country, back to the
- 3:10shareholders. Connor Fagan, counsel for fodc, went on to
- 3:16ask, where is the profit going? How will it benefit Northern
- 3:21Ireland. How will it benefit the council? How will it benefit the
- 3:24community? Nothing we have heard actually addresses this. One
- 3:31other noteworthy event was Sean Clark, Sinn Fein Councillor mid
- 3:36Ulster District Council attended and spoke passionately how
- 3:39mining was neither wanted nor needed, that there was plenty of
- 3:43employment in the rural areas best he had ever seen. And he
- 3:47also spoke about the very real fears from existing successful
- 3:51companies in the area being unable to employ people, and
- 3:54that people would be head hunted from these companies by the
- 3:57mine. Lastly, the Commissioner asked us to contribute to
- 4:03updating the timetable they expect now, to try to get
- 4:07through seven questions a day, which would mean that the PI
- 4:10will be considerably lengthened. And we were given a number of
- 4:13choices around this, either tack extra days on at the end, have a
- 4:19summer break and come back at the autumn, breaking up the
- 4:23questions into blocks, or finishing out the social
- 4:26economic questions and restarting next year in tandem
- 4:30with the new leave year for employees. When all of this was
- 4:35being trashed out, I was wondering quietly to myself, if
- 4:39the PAC is already aware of the untrustworthiness of the
- 4:42financial modelling which has been demonstrated again and
- 4:46again over the past four days. Would that information alone not
- 4:51be enough to refuse the planning app permission? It would solve
- 4:56the timetabling dilemma, in a way I feel. Sorry for the
- 5:00commissioners. They've been out manoeuvred, hung out to dry, but
- 5:04still must stick to the process. But the issues that have been
- 5:08raised here about those very processes may well be the sword
- 5:12they fall on. One has to wonder, are they been made scapegoats by
- 5:17the department? This really is an extraordinary situation,
- 5:21which ought to be placed at the minister's door. That's all for
- 5:25now. I'll see you on Thursday. You.