Latest / James O'Brien Daily / Britain’s big bet on North Sea gas
Transcript
- 0:02This is a global production.
- 0:06Hello, and welcome to another installment of my daily podcast, full of the best bits of news, discussion and discoveries from my LBC show.
- 0:18We begin, I think, inevitably, with the decision by Andy Burnham.
- 0:22And I don't think anybody gets a prize for seeing this on the horizon, but it has now or it will later today be fully formalized.
- 0:31One of the two fields that have become quite totemic, quite controversial, I think it's fair to say, one a gas field and the other an oil field.
- 0:43It is the gas field that will get the go ahead today.
- 0:46In a move that will provoke enormous amounts of anger among climate campaigners and quite possibly among Labour MPs as well.
- 0:58It will fall to the Energy Secretary, Miette Fanbole, to make the announcement later today alongside the Chancellor.
- 1:05They'll do it in Aberdeen, which is, of course, where jobs are being hemorrhaged as reliance upon fossil fuels is diminished as a consequence of accelerated, hideously dangerous climate change.
- 1:17And this approval for drilling will be seen as a major boost for that industry.
- 1:22Even Cami Bay did not manage to win a by election in that neck of the woods, because the industry is absolutely suffering as a consequence of what I think is best used as a shift.
- 1:37As a shift.
- 1:39Sometimes I sit here and I think, let's not have a big rail today.
- 1:43And then another little voice in my head kicks in and says, well, no, maybe we should have a big rail.
- 1:47And just because you haven't managed to fully pick a side yet, doesn't mean that it isn't actually quite easy for everybody else to fully pick a side.
- 1:53I love the word pragmatism.
- 1:55I like the word compromise.
- 1:56I think most human relations involve pragmatism and compromise in the, in this world.
- 2:03I think the, the truly the best kind of politics involves compromise and pragmatism.
- 2:08If you can form a consensus, if you can form a consensus, or at least a plurality, a vague majority, then you're going to press forward in a lot more peaceful and safe fashion than you are if you, if
- 2:26you impose things on people.
- 2:29But you're never going to please, as the saying goes, all of the people all of the time.
- 2:35It isn't going to make much difference to anything that, that, of course, is relevant.
- 2:40I mean, the percentages that are involved in this, it will.
- 2:43I mean, some critics suggest it's going to meet about 2% of our gas demand for roughly 10 years.
- 2:50When fully operational, it will run up to 6% of North Sea gas production, which sort of makes me wonder why we bother and then I remember one of the great lessons that we have learned of Vladimir Putin's illegal
- 3:06invasion of Ukraine is European dependence upon gas, upon Russian gas, something that has really been hideous in its consequences for the entire west and the Ukrainian people.
- 3:19Long before Donald Trump vilely betrayed the Ukrainian people, it was clear that the West's dependence upon Russian gas undermined, to a degree, but not entirely undermined sanctions and enriched Putin.
- 3:37Even before Trump decided to unilaterally rip up the sanctions that he had himself enacted just a few weeks ago in memory of his former colleague and ally, Lindsey Graham.
- 3:48Remember, if you want to know what Vladimir Putin wants, just have a look at what Donald Trump is doing.
- 3:53Even before Trump did that, it was clear that over reliance, or even reliance at all upon gas was deeply problematic.
- 4:01Deeply problematic.
- 4:05It was already passed by the Tories and held up by the courts.
- 4:10It was pretty clear that Andy Burnham was not going to be enacting the mandate that Labour came to power with in 2024, a promise not to grant any new licenses.
- 4:21And I can't shake the notion, for all the talk of pragmatism and compromise, I can't shake the notion that this is a terrible mistake.
- 4:34I can't quite shake the notion for all the talk of dependence upon Russian gas and all the talk of, well, we move very quickly towards a more sustainable system, but, you know, we're not going to get there in
- 4:46time.
- 4:46And in the meantime, this is, you know, a tiptoe in the wrong direction for the right reasons.
- 4:57And I can't shake the conclusion that it's actually all a terrible mistake.
- 5:02Some of the things that we are not told about anything, like often enough regarding the climate crisis, make it pretty clear that really burning any more fossil fuels at all makes an already catastrophic system worse.
- 5:17It is impossible to avoid the burning of fossil fuels in the world as it is currently constituted.
- 5:23But the decision to drill for, I mean, again with reg to Donald Trump, you know, anybody who still thinks he is anything other than a depraved menace needs their head examining, actually, I mean, literally needs their head examining.
- 5:37And, and, you know, when the man who is responsible for betraying the Ukrainians for lying to the American people for all manner, we'll have a little look later at some of the most, I mean, the most extraordinary public
- 5:48collapse of, of the man.
- 5:49So when he says, drill, baby, drill, and you cheer, you are absolutely ridiculous.
- 5:57You, you are as, as thick as mints.
- 6:00You have fallen for yet again, the lies of a man who has been unveiled as a liar.
- 6:05Revealed to be a liar who cares about nothing but self enrichment for the umpteenth time.
- 6:11And yet I've got this tiny little voice in the back of my mind that says things like, well, they're going to spend the money on accelerating sustainability.
- 6:19The tax revenues that are raised from this will actually be put towards accelerating the redundancy of fossil fue.
- 6:26We are reliant upon gas, or the west in general is reliant upon upon gas drilling or gas supplies in ways that have rendered our support for the Ukrainian people less clear and less pure than we would like them
- 6:45to be.
- 6:46And the numbers involved are not that significant.
- 6:50I probably need a little bit of help there.
- 6:53Rosebank, I think would exacerbate or magnify all of the reservations that I'm currently describing if they were to go ahead with that and a final decision has not been made.
- 7:04But again, using, I mean, how do we feel about the idea of using the tax proceeds from fossil fuel extraction to fund green projects?
- 7:13I think if I was a fan of football ification and I like the current government, until I don't.
- 7:20You know, you just need a little reminder of what the alternative is.
- 7:26Then listen to people describing essential theft from the public as wealth creation.
- 7:31Or cast your mind back to Liz Truss and have a look at what Cami Badenok is currently trying to promise because there ain't a lot of difference.
- 7:38I I gotta tell you, have a look at what happened in the care homes during COVID if you want to know how a certain type of politics responds to a certain type of crisis.
- 7:50So I like the current government and if I were a football ification victim, I would be defending the decision that they've made.
- 7:58But I can't.
- 8:00I don't see how anyone who is conscious of the the broader climate crisis can be comfortable about this or.
- 8:09Or enthusiastic about this.
- 8:10The only thing, weirdly, that gives me pause is, is the knowledge that we, unlike the United States of America, we are not governed by stupid people.
- 8:22Not anymore.
- 8:24We have been in recent years.
- 8:25More on that in the next hour when we return our attention to care homes during COVID But we are not governed by stupid people.
- 8:34And the pragmatic reasons for doing this possibly outweigh.
- 8:42How can they outweigh the concerns?
- 8:45How can they outweigh the concerns?
- 8:47That's what I want you to tell me.
- 8:48Really.
- 8:50I can tell you what the Greens are saying.
- 8:52Let's look for a sensible one.
- 8:53Caroline Lucas Government support for drilling at Jackdaw takes a wrecking ball to any pretense of UK climate leadership and pulls fuel on an overheating world.
- 9:01And for what she says, and she generally knows what she's talking about, it's equivalent to just two months of UK gas demand.
- 9:09It creates just 27 direct jobs and it has no impact on energy bills.
- 9:14Claims that it's much cleaner than importing are misleading.
- 9:17If you add in the impact of burning the gas, the difference is marginal.
- 9:21Extracting more from the North Sea adds more to the total amount of fossil fuels burned globally.
- 9:27The science is clear.
- 9:28We can't afford to burn the reserves we already have, let alone develop new ones existed and approved.
- 9:33Global oil and gas reserves already far exceed what we can safely burn if we're to stay below one and a half degrees centigrade.
- 9:40And that figure of one and a half degrees centigrADE is.
- 9:44I mean, the latest UN United nations report show us that it's almost impossible to exaggerate the peril that we're in.
- 9:53It's so bizarre that the people who are telling lies about the riots in France this weekend being somehow caused by immigration are precisely the same people who pooh, pooh the possibility of states actually collapsing under the weight of
- 10:07continuing climate change.
- 10:09The pressure that's going to be brought to bear, particularly upon liberal democracies, where people are free to protest, is going to be absolutely immense.
- 10:19And here it is.
- 10:22Here we have it.
- 10:24Here we have it.
- 10:25They've gone there.
- 10:26They have announced that they are to drill in the North Sea for gas.
- 10:32And I just want to know what you think about it.
- 10:35James is in Aberdeen, appropriately enough.
- 10:37James, what would you like to say?
- 10:39Good morning.
- 10:40A little bit nervous, so thank you for having me.
- 10:41It's only me.
- 10:43And just simply by dint of being.
- 10:44In Aberdeen, you know more about this.
- 10:46Subject than I do, so I'm a little bit torn.
- 10:49As I said to your researcher on the phone there, I think from an energy security point of view, this is the right decision we've made, but it sets a really bad environmental precedent that we have to have a
- 11:01serious conversation about.
- 11:03This is going to provide gas into UK homes, and the Energy Secretary was right, it's going to.
- 11:0890% of what's produced is going to fuel and heat our homes in the UK immediately.
- 11:14It's a very quick project to get on board.
- 11:17But the other drilling that companies are looking to do isn't for gas, it's for oil that will be sold in the international market.
- 11:24And this is, you know, it sets a dangerous precedent.
- 11:28And I just, you know, the government was Never in an easy position here.
- 11:32But, you know, it leaves a lot of people like myself very torn on.
- 11:35What to do next and what we haven't had yet.
- 11:39And to be fair to them, they haven't made the announcement yet.
- 11:41But what we haven't had yet is the sort of guillotine that would comfort you, the idea that, yes, we are doing this, but that's it.
- 11:51Yeah, and that's exactly it.
- 11:54It's that pragmatic, it's been pragmatic, it's being able to see how this project is going to help the uk.
- 12:00And you look across, we look across the North Sea to Norway where you said earlier about, you know, we've done one last year project for each country.
- 12:08You know, Norway is still massively drawn.
- 12:09They're still going out there and looking for new wells, looking for new opportunities and, you know, we're going to rely on them more and more.
- 12:16And this is, this is, this is why I'm torn.
- 12:18I'm sure there'll be lots of others out there, you know, across the UK with the same issue.
- 12:22You know, we're going to need gas for a number of years to come.
- 12:25We're going to need to get it somewhere you're getting from our own shores is, you know, better than I think,.
- 12:31I think, I think you're nailing it and you managed to steer clear of the politics of it, which is not a requirement for the program today, far, far from it.
- 12:41But I think to set things up, it's helpful and you understand some of the key distinct, most obviously between gas and oil or between Jackdaw and Rosebank.
- 12:51So as I understand it, what we're really looking at here is pipelines into UK homes and businesses that will have a sort of 10 year lifespan and which will reduce dependency on others.
- 13:04And although it's far from perfect, it's not significant in the great scheme of things, even in the context of climate catastrophe.
- 13:13But Rosebank would be a different proposition entirely.
- 13:16And your worries are built upon the idea that this is the first step in a journey rather than the last step of the last journey.
- 13:25Absolutely.
- 13:26And it's that almost like slippery slope that if we allow more oil that more commercial is not going to have that same impact where these companies are going to stop, where they kind of go, well, you've allowed us
- 13:36to drill here, let us do a little bit more there, a little bit, a little bit elsewhere.
- 13:40It's just that kind of political pressure.
- 13:41That may be led from this, just to help me out if you can.
- 13:45And if you can't, then just say, but people who are of the view.
- 13:50And I think this is perhaps contingent on confusing gas with oil, which is why this distinction is so important.
- 13:56The argument that gas is sold on the international market, it's not our gas.
- 14:01This idea of it somehow being piped directly into British homes and businesses is false.
- 14:09Can you pop that balloon?
- 14:11I can pop it a little bit.
- 14:12I mean, the gas field is, you know, due east of Aberdeen.
- 14:16It's going to flow into the uk.
- 14:18We are connected to Europe.
- 14:19It's an interconnected, you know, we're interconnected with our European colleagues.
- 14:23You know, the pipeline is going from Norway to the uk.
- 14:25We go to the Netherlands, we go to Belgium.
- 14:27You know that some of that gas may end up in Europe.
- 14:29But at the same time, if we are having disruptions to our flows, we get gas from Europe.
- 14:34It's a give and take scenario.
- 14:36And ultimately, you know, this isn't gas that's been sent off to a far off country.
- 14:41Know, someone outside the world, you know, this would be used by our, ourselves or European allies.
- 14:46You're gonna forgive me for this because I just once again saw a little echo of Brett.
- 14:50I heard a tiny little echo of Brexit.
- 14:52It's gravity.
- 14:53It is more to the benefit of the people that are nearest to it.
- 14:57Absolutely.
- 14:58So you don't leave the market that's on your doorstep and the gas that's on your doorstep is preferable to the gas that isn't.
- 15:03And as long as we need gas, it's better to get it from our doorstep than from thousands or hundreds of miles away.
- 15:10Absolutely.
- 15:11Because when you have that liquefied natural gas coming from previously Qatar, it's coming on a boat, there's a lot of extra carbon miles being spent on that as it gets transported to us.
- 15:22So yes, it's absolutely more preferable.
- 15:24Okay, thank you.
- 15:26I don't know what you were nervous about.
- 15:27That was an absolutely first class contribution, giving yet more credence, if it were needed to my frequent boast that we get the very, very best callers in the history of phone and radio on this program and of a
- 15:40challengable position.
- 15:40But it is, I think, a pertinent one or at least a very easily understandable one.
- 15:46And it is a sort of expert.
- 15:48Led.
- 15:52Version of what I was clumsily trying to set out, that it is a big deal potentially, but not a big deal actually.
- 15:59And I don't know if that sounds like a fellow trying to have his cake and eat it, but I Think the facts support the position.
- 16:05James, thank you.
- 16:050345-606-0973 is the number you need.
- 16:10So if they were to announce Rosebank bank, then the conversation would be very different.
- 16:15James's brilliantly expressed position being that this makes me worry more about them announcing Rose Bank a little further down the road than.
- 16:23Than I was.
- 16:24Than I was yesterday.
- 16:25The.
- 16:25The manifesto was clear.
- 16:27The 2024 pledge from labor was a promise not to grant any new licenses in the North Sea.
- 16:34They didn't think they would have to make a decision on.
- 16:37On Jackdaw or on Rosebank.
- 16:39But it was the fact that the approval was held up by a judge on a technicality that moved them back into the legislative space.
- 16:48I think this stuff is really important.
- 16:50There'll be an awful lot of people with incredibly strong opinions who don't actually have the basic building blocks of understanding this.
- 16:57So the reason why they are so totemic is because they had already been passed.
- 17:02And the judge steps in after labor came to power and said, no, they can't go ahead.
- 17:06Which means it goes back to government to decide whether or not they press pause on stuff that was already happening or whether they add the stuff that was already happening to the stuff that they had promised wouldn't happen.
- 17:17It's a little bit more complex than some of the coverage allows, which is how I think you end up in a position where you can simultaneously argue it's a big deal and not a big deal until Rosebank.
- 17:29When that decision comes out, then the conversation changes.
- 17:33But the conversation we're having now, I think we can safely say is.
- 17:37Is illuminating and important.
- 17:39I should shut up and listen to some of the.
- 17:41Sorry, Steve's in Portsmouth.
- 17:42Steve, what do you want to say?
- 17:44Is it Portsmouth or Plymouth, Steve?
- 17:46Portsmouth, definitely.
- 17:48Are you sure, mate?
- 17:48Can you just stick your head out the window and check?
- 17:50Because apparently it's very easy.
- 17:52My brother did exactly that when he had a girlfriend in Plymouth and drove to Portsmouth three times, three separate weekends.
- 17:57It's a very easy mistake to make.
- 17:58Although, obviously, if you're a party leader giving a speech in one of those cities, you should probably be a little bit more on the ball than your brother was that day.
- 18:06What made you pick up the phone?
- 18:09Yeah, yeah.
- 18:10I think the.
- 18:11Your question on your.
- 18:13Your own answer to is probably a good one.
- 18:15Is it important in the big picture?
- 18:18I'd say no, it's not important at all.
- 18:19It's a bit of sound and a bit of fury, but spiking the guns of the Oil funded parties is probably a good idea.
- 18:25Yes.
- 18:25But I work in the renewable sector.
- 18:27Most of the time I project I'm at the moment isn't but normally I am and I'm on the infrastructure building side of things.
- 18:33And if you go back to.
- 18:35I know 200 years ago we had a canal network and that's how most bulk goods were moved around.
- 18:40And then we've got railways and the canals have faded away.
- 18:43And that's what's happening with energy right now.
- 18:45UK GDP about 2.5% is to do with fossil fuel extraction.
- 18:50About 4% or slightly under 4% is renewables.
- 18:53So it's already 150% bigger industry sector than gas and oil.
- 18:58If you look at the.
- 18:59Every five minutes updated.
- 19:01What is the grid made of right now?
- 19:03This very second?
- 19:0480% of what's coming through the wires is not made from oil or gas.
- 19:08It's made from other sources.
- 19:09All of them low carbon and zero carbon.
- 19:11And that is changing every week.
- 19:13Every month that gets a bigger and bigger fraction.
- 19:16So the question shall we do more oil?
- 19:19Shall we do more gas in 10, 15, 20 years?
- 19:21This is redundant.
- 19:23So it's sounding for your e right now.
- 19:25But real life is we're not going to be using oil and gas to anything like the same extent we do now in less than a generation from now.
- 19:33We're building the infrastructure right this second.
- 19:36But it is still in a utilitarian sense.
- 19:40Good to go ahead with Jack Dor now.
- 19:43I think so.
- 19:44Yeah.
- 19:45Even as someone who works in 000% of Total Global.
- 19:50Yeah.
- 19:50But that cuts both ways doesn't it?
- 19:51That's also an argument for not doing it because it's such a negligible number but negligible globally.
- 19:58Probably on balance better.
- 20:01I just think that you will look back on this in five, 10 years we won't even remember it.
- 20:07The energy that's coming through your light bulb now.
- 20:09Yes.
- 20:09Is not made of coal or oil.
- 20:11Is 18% two minutes ago of gas.
- 20:15I was just looking at the screen.
- 20:17And everyone can do that.
- 20:18Remind us what the website is.
- 20:19All these dozens.
- 20:20There's grid energy or national grid.
- 20:22You can just see what is Google Grid energy mix.
- 20:26I don't know if you can answer this.
- 20:28Why is.
- 20:28Why is energy not cheaper then now.
- 20:30Given that because we privatized it in the 90s.
- 20:32So.
- 20:33No.
- 20:33Yeah.
- 20:34So they're still charged even though it's costing considerably less to generate it.
- 20:38They're still charging what they charged when it was coming out of the ground.
- 20:42The electricity coming Off a wind turbine.
- 20:44That's wealth creators you're attacking there, Steve.
- 20:47Stop attacking the wealth creators.
- 20:48There's no growth without the wealth creators.
- 20:51When my dad worked for the CGB and then later on the national grid, that money was.
- 20:56You paid your gas bill, sorry, electricity bill, and that money circulated within the British economy, but now it doesn't, and now it's extracted, as with everything else, wealth extraction.
- 21:06It's almost like the conversation we had about Thames water yesterday.
- 21:09But everyone needs to remember we need to look after the wealth creators, some of whom may be leaving the country, in which case it's a disaster and we must demand even less tax of them.
- 21:18So a big deal, but not a big deal.
- 21:20Or rather not a big deal.
- 21:22We're in a transition.
- 21:23The transition's happening whether people understand it or like it.
- 21:25All the arts graduates who write a.
- 21:27Newspaper,.
- 21:29You've done it.
- 21:31You, me there right now.
- 21:34You came on and you said.
- 21:35And I let it pass because I'm trying to interrupt a tiny bit less.
- 21:39You came on and you said, yeah, I suppose that's quite a good question that you asked, actually.
- 21:43And then you end it, having just sort of opened up with that left jab, you just end it with the right hook about all the arts graduates writing for the newspapers.
- 21:50I literally have a column in a newspaper today.
- 21:53I'll have you know, Steve in Portsmouth, that my philosophy degree is technically a Bachelor of Science.
- 22:00If I was Kemi Badenot.
- 22:02Yeah, yeah.
- 22:03Well, that is.
- 22:04I mean, most anyone who sat it has got a slightly better grade than I have.
- 22:07If I was Cami Badenot, my BSc.
- 22:09In Economics would qualify me to describe.
- 22:11Myself as a scientist.
- 22:12I'd be deciding I'm a scientist as.
- 22:15Much as she, of course, is an engineer.
- 22:17Steve, thank you.
- 22:18And again, you know, it's not quite the political bum fight that many people are keen to have, but it might just be the truth.
- 22:26Time for a short break now.
- 22:27Afterwards, the best callers in the business.
- 22:38Thomas is in Lambeth.
- 22:39Thomas, what would you like to say?
- 22:41Hi, good morning, James.
- 22:43I agree with some of what the previous caller said around the technical aspects.
- 22:47You know, this isn't loads of emissions, but the point is the politics.
- 22:50It's approving new oil and gas, as you said, James paves the way for projects in the future and that makes this government look terrible.
- 22:58This is supposed to be a government that is about clean energy, is about attacking climate change, is about supporting countries around the world that are suffering the climate crisis right now.
- 23:08And that is not what.
- 23:10Is not what this looks like and it's not what the government promised in 2024 when young people like me, I'm 23, you know, elected them.
- 23:16So I'm not happy with this decision.
- 23:19I think the technical arguments are here and there.
- 23:22You know, I've heard lots of people talk, get really into the weeds.
- 23:26I don't think it's about the technical specific.
- 23:28But if they don't, if they don't announce Rosebank, and even if they did, they can still defend themselves against breaking the promise not to issue any new licenses, then your argument is slightly hollowed.
- 23:41I mean, if they don't back Rosebank, your argument's completely hollowed out.
- 23:45Even if they do, they can still be a government that has kept a pledge not to grant any new licenses in the North Sea.
- 23:52That's true, but that's not in the spirit, is it?
- 23:54You know, and everyone knows that's a.
- 23:55Great way of putting it.
- 23:56And it's not what their own MPS are saying.
- 23:58I mean, you know, I think there'll be a backlash over there.
- 24:00This we know that.
- 24:02It won't lower bills, it won't deliver jobs.
- 24:04It's not going to get us out of those fossil fuel markets that we were embedded in.
- 24:07That's got to be.
- 24:08But if the priority, if we confine.
- 24:12The conversation to what is being announced today, then what would the backlash actually be about apart from Vibes?
- 24:20Well, politics is based on vibes.
- 24:24Some politics is based on vibes, not all politics.
- 24:26The politics that we try and vainly to engage in on this program occasionally is not based on Vibes.
- 24:32It's why we note it when it is something that feels counterintuitive or cognitively dissonant, it's a big deal and not a big deal at the same time.
- 24:39If we confine ourselves to the facts and leave the vibes out of the conversation, then there isn't a great deal here to object to.
- 24:50Well, listen, you know, this has been Shell lobbying has got into, you know, the government to approve on this.
- 24:57You know, if we look at Ed Miller bound a few years ago, he was saying this was climate vandalism.
- 25:01This quote has been so faced a lot.
- 25:03That's still true.
- 25:03It's more true.
- 25:04You know, a few years ago the International Energy association, the big group of countries observer on energy, said we don't, we can't have any more oil and gas if we're going to keep 1.5 degrees limit alive.
- 25:17And that's not being followed here.
- 25:19So, you know, it doesn't matter how Small.
- 25:21The amount is.
- 25:22It is about principles.
- 25:24And anyway, it doesn't, it doesn't help our economy.
- 25:27So.
- 25:27So on either argument, it's not worth it.
- 25:30You know, we've just had a summer of heat waves, wildfires, 2,000 people died from.
- 25:35In their homes.
- 25:36I work in the nhs.
- 25:37I work in just a minute.
- 25:39And we're seeing this.
- 25:40Yeah, sorry, I shouldn't have interrupted you there when you were talking about what.
- 25:44No, it's not okay.
- 25:45You're doing a much more important job than I am and you see the consequences a lot more clearly than I do.
- 25:51But again, at risk of sounding like a kind of a doughty defender of the government, which I'm happy to be in some contexts, but I don't think I am being on this one.
- 26:02I think I'm being a defender of pragmatism because the gas that will be used would be used, if you see what I mean, the volume of gas.
- 26:10It's simply a question of whether or not it's going to come from our doorstep or whether it's going to come from Qatar.
- 26:15And you are arguing, I think, that we should continue to take it from Qatar until we don't need to anymore.
- 26:21And the government is arguing, well, no, let's not do that.
- 26:24Let's take it from our own doorstep until we don't need to anymore.
- 26:26Anymore.
- 26:27Which is why the last caller's comment about the accelerating, accelerated redundancy of fossil fuels was so I found so persuasive.
- 26:36Well, I don't think it's a binary choice like that, you know.
- 26:40So where else can it come from?
- 26:41All of the businesses and homes that are currently dependent upon gas, where else can they get it from?
- 26:48Well, I don't think we need to invest in buying lots more gas.
- 26:51I mean, we can invest, for example, the government.
- 26:53I'm going to go full Paxman.
- 26:55I'm going to go Paxman on you, mate, Mate.
- 26:57I'm going to answer the question, where does it come from?
- 26:59If it comes from Qatar or it comes from our doorstep, which do you back?
- 27:04I don't back either.
- 27:05I have to green, clean, green energy.
- 27:08Yeah, well, I do too, but at.
- 27:09The moment, at the moment, if I.
- 27:10Turn on that tap over there, then it's the only way I can heat my house.
- 27:14And that gas has got to come from somewhere.
- 27:15Where's it going to come from?
- 27:17Well, 2% of gas demand is being made by this, so it mostly is coming from abroad anyway.
- 27:222% better than before then.
- 27:24But, but the point we're talking here, as we agreed at the start, was that this is about the overall politics now.
- 27:29I.
- 27:30I understand.
- 27:30I think we're all agreeing with each other just from slightly different angles and.
- 27:34And it's all about how much weight you place on the messaging.
- 27:37I think that's a kind of a more generous and useful word than vibes, isn't it?
- 27:41It's the messaging and that, that observation that if everybody, if they certainly, if they give Rosebank the green light and every other economy on the planet sort of feels, well, we can have.
- 27:50Britain has been kind of leading on this, or at least it' the pack, they're having another one, then why on earth can't we have one last massive fossil fuel project and then.
- 27:59Then we're toast?
- 28:00Yeah, I'd agree with you anyway, you know, as we keep saying, it's a really small amount of gas demand, it's not going to improve our economy, it doesn't deliver many jobs through the supply chain or on the gas
- 28:10platform itself and it looks really bad.
- 28:12You know, that is the point.
- 28:14This government should not be approving it.
- 28:15I mean, I've got a small stat for you, James, which is 36 million tonnes of carbon over the lifetime of this project.
- 28:23That's 20 million cars.
- 28:24It's, you know, it's a small amount of gas, but the impacts are massive.
- 28:28And I don't think people want a lot more summers like the one we've just had.
- 28:32No, but that is not more than.
- 28:34Would I see what you mean, the transporting it.
- 28:37I mean, I don't know what the figure would be if we took exactly the same amount of gas from overseas, from the Middle east, in fact, and it would probably be higher, but not necessarily.
- 28:47And of course you would simply come back quite correctly and say, well, both figures are far too high.
- 28:52And speaking of Thomas Point, here is the headline from the New York Times.
- 28:56It's interesting.
- 28:58The British government greenlit a natural gas project in the North Sea, defying a pledge to halt new fossil fuel extraction.
- 29:06So that's what I meant by a technicality.
- 29:08They haven't technically broken the manifesto pledge, but if you construe the pledge as halting fossil fuel extraction, rather than a pledge not to grant any new licenses, as opposed to rubber stamp the resurrection of a license that had
- 29:25already been granted and then stymied by a court case because the paperwork was filled in incorrectly, then they have.
- 29:32So.
- 29:33And you know, the New York Times is not.
- 29:35It ain't what it used to be, but it's certainly not one of the propaganda outlets that Donald Trump has both encouraged and fermented.
- 29:47So that's how it looks, looks.
- 29:49Has Andy Burnham got enough goodwill stored?
- 29:51This as.
- 29:52As Thomas reminded us, you can't leave the politics or indeed the vibes out of these conversations.
- 29:56Has he got enough goodwill stored with people like me?
- 30:00We put the Burnham Optimism barometer to bed on Monday.
- 30:03I'm beginning to wonder whether we need to resurrect it, but perhaps with a slightly more scientific.
- 30:09Shaking their heads at me, because I don't do any work on this.
- 30:12The idea of someone having to add up all we're not doing.
- 30:14Eleanor's made an executive decision.
- 30:17We're not you to going gov, she said, without a comma.
- 30:20She's not saying we're not you gov, she's saying we're not you gov.
- 30:24We're not you gov.
- 30:25Because all you have to do, right, I got an AO level in statistics, by the way, grade E.
- 30:30All you have to do is add up all the votes and then divide them by.
- 30:34The number of people who voted and.
- 30:36We'd get a much more reliable average, in this case, the mean as opposed to the mode or the median.
- 30:43That's.
- 30:43I know that's not how polling works, but I invented the Burnham Optimism Barometer.
- 30:47I get to decide the rules.
- 30:49But sometimes a caller sows a seed like that, they sow a seed in.
- 30:53The mortar of my mind and it subsequently starts growing.
- 30:57And I've had that today.
- 30:58Is it really?
- 30:59Because everyone can look at this.
- 31:00You can go to National Grid Live or you can go to grid watch.co.uk and you can literally watch in real time where all of the energy we're using is currently coming from.
- 31:11And it's often wind at the very.
- 31:13Top of the list.
- 31:14And yet how.
- 31:15I mean, again, we're back to Donald Trump and his epic idiocy complaining about wind, which is currently provoking, providing.
- 31:21Let me get this right, about 28 of, of all the energy that we are currently using, nuclear on about 14.
- 31:29And then the, the, the fossil fuels, if you like, or most obviously the.
- 31:34Gas is still quite high.
- 31:35It's on 23%, but it's going.
- 31:39And so you look at that, you.
- 31:40Look at what wind is producing and.
- 31:42What other carbon neutral or biomass sources are producing, and you think, why have the prices not plummeted?
- 31:48And if he's right, and the answer.
- 31:50Is simply because privatized companies will charge what they can charge and the profits will continue to be absolutely enormous.
- 31:57You sit here and you think, yeah, you know Maybe I'm not left wing enough.
- 32:02Maybe they are.
- 32:03This is what they mean when they talk, oh, you've got to look after the wealth creators.
- 32:06Do not reduce energy bills because that would reduce dividends and payouts for shareholders.
- 32:11I'm just looking at the numbers and you can look at them as well.
- 32:13Everybody can.
- 32:15And trying to make sense of them.
- 32:16David is in Aberdeen.
- 32:18I like it.
- 32:18That means you know more about this subject than I do.
- 32:20What would you like to say, David?
- 32:22Good.
- 32:22Good morning, James.
- 32:23Yes, I was in the industry from 1975, when I was very young and I was in through until two years ago, and I had to ring in just to correct one bit of misinformation, because there's a huge amount
- 32:34of misinformation.
- 32:35Let me guess what it is.
- 32:36Are you going to tell me that Rose Brank is not just oil?
- 32:39I am, yeah.
- 32:40Because I did.
- 32:40I've got quite a few texts pointing that out, so I'm happy to clarify.
- 32:44It will also be gas if it.
- 32:45Goes out ahead and so is pretty much every oil field that ever was.
- 32:49Yes, because you don't just get oil, you also get gas.
- 32:53And in Rosebank's case, it would be about 21 million cubic feet of gas.
- 32:57A day, which is.
- 32:59It's significant.
- 33:00What's going to come out of Jackdaw.
- 33:02What a cubic feet for Jackdaw.
- 33:03Do you know, I'm just missing that.
- 33:04I don't know, but I know that, that, that is.
- 33:07That is a gas field.
- 33:08Yeah, purely.
- 33:09Sure.
- 33:10You know, that was.
- 33:12That was.
- 33:12You know, there's a lot of misinformation, but.
- 33:14But I feel as long as we do need these oil and gas products, then it's madness not to produce it in our own backyard.
- 33:23The effect on the environment of shipping it from places like the Far east and so on is negative.
- 33:30But we don't talk about that a.
- 33:32Lot, is the country so.
- 33:33Well, that's the main argument that we've been making this morning.
- 33:36But when it comes to the oil, the arguments are different.
- 33:42We're not personally as reliant.
- 33:44This country is nowhere near as reliant on oil as it is on gas, for example.
- 33:47So the argument, the geographical proximity argument doesn't really apply to oil.
- 33:53No, it doesn't.
- 33:53But for me, the Cotton Mist.
- 33:57Well, it's a point.
- 33:58It's one of the many that, to.
- 34:00Be fair, you said it's madness not to do it from our own doorstep, but the stuff that's coming from our own doorstep, if it's oil, isn't used in the house behind the door.
- 34:09What it is doing.
- 34:10What it is doing is producing 70 pence out of every pound of profit goes to the UK government.
- 34:15And are we that wealthy that we can afford to walk away?
- 34:18And then the climate change argument is the response, isn't it?
- 34:21And it doesn't matter how wealthy we're going to be if we can't inhabit the parts of the planet that will be uninhabitable soon unless we change course pretty violently.
- 34:28No dispute about that.
- 34:29But I think the key point is, as you said earlier, pragmatism.
- 34:32As long as.
- 34:33As long as we as a country need oil and gas or need the products from it.
- 34:38Need the need the revenue.
- 34:39And a world without.
- 34:41You shouldn't gloss over the.
- 34:42That.
- 34:42Sorry.
- 34:43Because you use the word disinformation.
- 34:45I don't think there's been any on this program.
- 34:46You can't gloss over that use of the word need.
- 34:49We don't need oil.
- 34:53Well, try living in a world without oil products.
- 34:56No, no, that's fine, but not on anything like the way.
- 34:59If you're looking at energy supply, energy bills, energy infrastructure, there is a world of difference between gas and oil.
- 35:05And it's actually disinformation to elide the too.
- 35:09Well, the industry talks in terms of boils, barrels of oil equivalent or boe.
- 35:14So this is because people conflate or separate the oil and gas, but actually it comes up together out the ground.
- 35:23So you don't get one without the other.
- 35:24Well, you do, you absolutely do at Jackdaw.
- 35:27You do, you do in terms of you don't get oil without gas.
- 35:30I appreciate it, but you just said again, if we're going to be alert to disinformation.
- 35:34You just said you can't get one without the other way.
- 35:36You categorically can at Jackdaw, which is why it's such a different property proposition.
- 35:40Yeah.
- 35:40To Rosebank.
- 35:41And, and it's why you, you today at least, and on this program, you're in a bit of a minority when you say we should crack on with Rosebank because it is a measurably different proposition.
- 35:51Well, I don't.
- 35:52What I see in this is, is revenue for the, for the government.
- 35:57Are we that wealthy we can afford to do without.
- 35:59Well, then we must nationalize.
- 36:01Yes.
- 36:01Why not?
- 36:03Because the government's revenue is just the tax take on top of the profits that are made by the companies.
- 36:07So I mean, I salute your altruism when you're, when you're put payer first.
- 36:12But the Money that the government would make is a fraction of what Shell and even Equinor would make.
- 36:18Well, I think that that would come down to the, to the economic.
- 36:21The economists would tell you, you know the reality about that.
- 36:25Well, I don't need the economists.
- 36:27The companies are going to make more money out of this extraction than the government is.
- 36:32Well, if they're taking.
- 36:33So the shareholders and the shareholders and the recipients of dividends are going to be considerably better off as a consequence of these decisions, especially Rosebank, than the treasury would be.
- 36:45So, I mean, again, your argument stands, but nowhere near as powerfully as I think you're suggesting.
- 36:52Well, just the income to the government is over 70 pence in the pound of each pound of profit.
- 37:01So I would argue there that the government is making more out of it than the Shell.
- 37:05Depends, doesn't it, how much money has been spent in getting it out of the ground in the first place?
- 37:09Because that's the.
- 37:10That's the bottom line, if you like.
- 37:12Or the balance sheet.
- 37:14For the entire company.
- 37:16For the entire company.
- 37:18Okay.
- 37:18I mean, and I mean, so just sort of press pause on climate concern.
- 37:24That's what we're going to do.
- 37:25Just press pause and hope for the best.
- 37:28Hey, listen, I mean, thank you.
- 37:30It's a point.
- 37:31It's a valid point.
- 37:32Time for a short break now, but when we get back, we'll be moving our focus to another huge story from today's news agenda.
- 37:38Gender.
- 37:47What word would you use to describe the next conversation?
- 37:53It's mad how fast we move on, isn't it?
- 37:56You know, I think of Hillsborough and the long, torturous path that led to even a vaguest semblance of justice for the dead at Hillsborough.
- 38:08You think back to the sun newspaper's hideous lies, hideous lies about what happened that day and the way that none of the people responsible for them, up to and including Margaret Thatcher's press secretary, Bernard Ingham, who I think
- 38:21went to his grave insisting that the lies were true, that normal people don't get justice, do they?
- 38:30Grenfell Tower, you think of Grenfell Tower.
- 38:33I.
- 38:34I am aware of what happened at Abervanna.
- 38:37I don't have a great depth of knowledge about how avoidable that tragedy was, whether or not malfeasance or incompetence contributed to that disaster 60 years ago.
- 38:50And you will have other things on this list as well.
- 38:52The infected blood scandal, things that killed people and were to varying degrees, varying degrees presided over by people who are supposed to protect us.
- 39:10So Hillsborough, it would be South Yorkshire Police and then the government of the time, they're sort of supposed to protect us and they failed and covered up with the infected blood scandal.
- 39:24Similarly, you know, health professionals, but not directly the government.
- 39:31I don't know, Grenfell, you know, the Kensington and Chelsea Council hideously, hideously remiss in its treatment of that building and it's heedlessness of the warnings being issued by people who lived in it and who lived in the community.
- 39:48But did that trail go all the way back to Downing Street?
- 39:51I mean, directly back to Downing Street?
- 39:55Probably not.
- 39:57You consider the care homes think about.
- 40:01Do you know, sometimes I like clips, sometimes I don't.
- 40:04I don't want to hear Matt Hancock's voice today.
- 40:07Do you want to hear Matt Hancock's voice?
- 40:09Do you want to hear Matt Hancock talking about the protective ring that he was putting up around care homes?
- 40:16Look to camera, look somber, look serious.
- 40:19Protective ring?
- 40:19Ring.
- 40:20A Boris Johnson government claiming to protect vulnerable people.
- 40:24How funny does that sound in retrospect to you?
- 40:28Our very own sort of Timu tragedy.
- 40:30No, that's Nigel Farage.
- 40:32But our very own narcissist stroke sociopath charged with protecting the country from a rampant and rapacious lethal virus.
- 40:46No, I don't want to hear his voice.
- 40:47Sorry, I don't know whether that is appropriate or not because I don't know whether anyone is surprised by what emerged yesterday.
- 40:56We talked about it at the time and so desperate were we to feel protected by the people charged with protecting us that some of us, albeit briefly, even had warm words to say about Matt Hancock.
- 41:10I know what you're thinking.
- 41:11I didn't.
- 41:12James.
- 41:12Yeah, me, I did.
- 41:14I had warm words to say about Matt Hancock because you sort of wanted to believe that the people stewarding us through this catastrophe were fit for purpose.
- 41:24How many people do you think died in care homes after hospitals discharged infected patients without adequate protections?
- 41:31Do you know?
- 41:32Have you seen the story yet?
- 41:34Have you found the figure as it landed properly?
- 41:37When with you, 43,000 residents.
- 41:44The most vulnerable people in our society, the people who we are often told by politicians to care about more than we do, the people who deserve the most protection and the most financial support from the state.
- 41:5843,000 of them died.
- 42:01Oh, and listen, it's impossible to know who would have done anything anyway.
- 42:05But what is absolutely clear is that 25,000 patients were discharged from hospitals into care homes in the space of a month in a bid to free up hospital beds.
- 42:18And a lot of them, we will never know how many had the virus which meant the minute they got into the care homes, they were isolated, abandoned and alive.
- 42:30Not my words.
- 42:31The words of the inquiry chair, Baroness Heather Hallett, who reported yesterday that these people's lives were sacrificed to save the nhs.
- 42:41A formation of words I'm not entirely comfortable with, because I think there's a third option where you could have saved the NHS or protected the NHS and not sacrificed tens of thousands of lives.
- 42:54And.
- 42:57And I don't want to have a particular polemic today.
- 43:01I don't want to.
- 43:02I mean, Matt Hancock is very much yesterday's news.
- 43:06Boris Johnson is still paid a fortune by newspapers, who today boast about how hard they work to make sure that.
- 43:12Let me read you directly from the Daily Mail.
- 43:14The Daily Mail campaigned for care home residents to be allowed to reunite with their loved ones during the pandemic, describing it as shameful that they were being deprived of visits by cruel restrictions.
- 43:24Wow, that's good.
- 43:25Daily Male.
- 43:26That's strong.
- 43:27What.
- 43:27What have you done to the guy who was in charge of the whole thing at the time?
- 43:30Oh, well, we've hired him as a columnist on half a million pounds a year.
- 43:33James.
- 43:36See what I mean about ordinary people when these characters start clutching their pearls and.
- 43:43And claiming concern?
- 43:44You've literally given Boris Johnson hundreds of thousands of pounds a year as a reward in ascending for his doomed premiership.
- 43:55And he was in charge.
- 43:58Literally in charge.
- 44:00He was the peak of the pyramid, the top of the pile in the government responsible for the thing today that you are.
- 44:09I'm not going to say pretending I'm sure that your.
- 44:13Your woe is authentic, but it's a little bit odd, is it?
- 44:17Isn't it, to roll out the red carpet for the bloke in charge while wringing your hands and gnashing your teeth at what he did.
- 44:27So good job.
- 44:27I didn't finish that sentence four minutes ago because I was going to say, I'm going to try and steer clear of the politics of this one and I can't.
- 44:33Turns out I can't.
- 44:34I don't want to hear Matt Hancock's voice and I despise the fact that all of the people responsible for presiding over the country at the time have waltzed away more or less scoff free, worse, in many cases, literally
- 44:49rewarded, elevated and enriched as a consequence of the offices they used to hold.
- 44:54I suppose we should be grateful that the best Matt Hancock could hope for was a plate full of kangaroo testicles on I'm a Celebrity.
- 45:01Get Me out of Here.
- 45:02Boris Johnson, by contrast, as I say, rewarded immensely by precisely the media outlet that today is claiming to care deeply about what was done to residents of care homes.
- 45:17And that's all I want to do, actually.
- 45:19I do want to leave the politics behind.
- 45:21I don't want to talk about Matt Hancock or Boris Johnson anymore.
- 45:24I want to talk about your mum or your dad or your nan or your husband or whoever it is.
- 45:31I just want to spend some time today remembering what it was like.
- 45:36And the question I would like to ask, which I think I asked you at the time, but I haven't asked you since.
- 45:44Did you know Kate's in Middlesbrough?
- 45:48Kate, what made you pick up the phone?
- 45:50Oh, hi, James, I'm such a big fan.
- 45:52Thank you so much for having me.
- 45:54So I worked in a care home throughout the pandemic and it was just about the most destroying experience of my life.
- 46:03It was horrible.
- 46:06I can only imagine.
- 46:07I mean, literally, I can only imagine.
- 46:09How soon did you realize that you were being left up the proverbial creek without a paddle?
- 46:16So the first time.
- 46:18So we didn't have any PPE for the first maybe 3 months.
- 46:22No masks nor, you know, anything.
- 46:28And my friend owned underwear company and she started making those masks just so that we had something thing to wear.
- 46:36I mean, we were desperate.
- 46:38So we had these like makeshift sort of underwear masks on our faces.
- 46:43And ambulance arrived into our care home.
- 46:46Now, this was a really close knit.
- 46:48It was a big care home, but everybody was really close.
- 46:52An ambulance came and the two people who got out to discharge this lady were in full sort of hazmat suits.
- 46:59Oh, my life, that's terrifying.
- 47:01Fine.
- 47:02And we were in.
- 47:04That's like something out of a film.
- 47:05Are you sort of thinking, oh, we'll be all right.
- 47:07We've got these lovely knicker masks.
- 47:09We're going to be okay.
- 47:11They're better than nothing.
- 47:12The one that I was wearing that day had like kiss prints on.
- 47:14It was like a jaw.
- 47:16And as these people arrived with this lady, this poor lady, and I mean, my goodness, she looked really, really gravely ill.
- 47:24And.
- 47:25And myself.
- 47:26And the nurse said, does this person have Covid?
- 47:28And they said, said, I'm so sorry, we don't know.
- 47:32She hasn't been tested, but we've got nowhere else for her to go.
- 47:36And you have a stereo.
- 47:37Wow.
- 47:38And they were behaving as if everybody had Covid, which is why they were dressed like something out of 28 days later.
- 47:43Exactly right.
- 47:44And the comparison between the two of us was just phenomenal.
- 47:48This lady came into our care home and subsequently gave not Gave.
- 47:54No, I know, but she was positive for Covid.
- 47:59And that's how Covid entered our care home for the first time.
- 48:03And we went on to lose so many of our residents that we just loved.
- 48:09We loved so much.
- 48:10And some of them were.
- 48:11We just thought, we're healthy.
- 48:13They all had dementia, but they were healthy and thriving, and they died as a consequence.
- 48:23And to watch Matt Hancock and the government on the podiums each night saying that they were putting a protective ring around care homes.
- 48:31We were saying, where.
- 48:33So you were in the moment just.
- 48:34Just marveling, watching, goggling at the telly, going, what the hell?
- 48:38What planet is he on?
- 48:40What country is he governing?
- 48:41We didn't have the basics.
- 48:44We didn't have the very basics.
- 48:46And every morning they would send this tirade of information, of things that we should be doing, but we didn't have ppe.
- 48:52So what was the point?
- 48:53We.
- 48:54We couldn't.
- 48:55But then the other element to it, James, was some of the families just didn't understand.
- 48:59They'd be reading the papers and they would be said.
- 49:01They would be turning up at the doors, and we were almost barricaded in the care home, and they were insisting on seeing their loved ones, which we understood, but we couldn't let them in.
- 49:12This is terrifying.
- 49:13I mean, I was across a lot of it at the time, but something about the way you're telling this story now is brand new.
- 49:22It feels brand new to me.
- 49:23And this juxtaposition, this contrast between what we were being told and what you knew was happening is extraordinary.
- 49:30This is it.
- 49:31And nobody was talking about the realities of it.
- 49:33That was the problem.
- 49:34And we were facilitating for a lot of people their last goodbyes with their loved ones on iPads.
- 49:41And we knew that the person had sometimes hours to live and they were gasping for breath, and we.
- 49:46We were holding up an iPad with kind of underwear, masks on.
- 49:52It was.
- 49:53It really was.
- 49:55It was heartbreaking.
- 49:56It was awful.
- 49:57And the families.
- 49:58I just felt so sorry for the families.
- 50:02Everything would have been worse for everybody if people like you hadn't been doing what you do.
- 50:07I want to say that.
- 50:08I want to make that point because I think you're probably still traumatized by what happened to you, and yet you.
- 50:14You were fighting.
- 50:15The good career was in dementia.
- 50:16I had to leave, James.
- 50:17I couldn't do it anymore.
- 50:18I just left.
- 50:20I'm sorry.
- 50:21When the pandemic was over, I couldn't do it.
- 50:23And.
- 50:23And I know many, many incredible people who worked in the field felt the same and did the Same.
- 50:30But we all really stepped up during that point.
- 50:33We covered shifts that we would, you know, ridiculous shifts.
- 50:37And one lady, she, she slept at the, at the, the home for probably two weeks.
- 50:42She never went home.
- 50:43She had kids.
- 50:45The sacrifices that people made in those care homes.
- 50:49And then obviously when Partygate came out,.
- 50:52It doesn't bear thinking about.
- 50:54Just another kick in the teeth.
- 50:55Yeah.
- 50:56Or as some right wingers still like to say, just, just Boris Johnson having some cake.
- 51:00It was.
- 51:00Oh, I tell you what.
- 51:02And I hear it all the time.
- 51:03Do you still.
- 51:03I'm sorry.
- 51:04You know what?
- 51:04You weren't here on this program.
- 51:06People have forgotten about it.
- 51:07You are so incredible.
- 51:09No, no, that's not why I said that.
- 51:11I just.
- 51:11I'm aware of the fact that some people on this station still pump the line, some Boris Johnson cheerleaders on this radio station still punt the line that he lost his premiership because he had some cake, not because he
- 51:21presided over the catastrophe that the, the apocalypse that you're describing.
- 51:25But, but is it fair?
- 51:27I mean, could things have been done better and, or differently?
- 51:30Is it fair to trace this back, back to Hancock and Johnson, in your view?
- 51:35In my view, they did not take it seriously enough in the slightest.
- 51:39And the fact that Hancock then went on to do I'm a celebrity was just absolutely apparent.
- 51:43Was it?
- 51:44And I was.
- 51:45Oh my.
- 51:46Can you.
- 51:46Because it was proof that he hadn't ever taken it seriously enough or he hadn't taken on board.
- 51:51There was no apology, there was no, there was no thank you so much to everybody who stepped up and there.
- 51:57Was no accountability, self interest and self protection at every return and, and possibly almost hesitate to remind you of this, but I, but I know you'll be aware of it when Boris Johnson actually suggested they could let the
- 52:10bodies pile high, maybe.
- 52:13Maybe they did.
- 52:14Yeah.
- 52:15Well, absolutely they did.
- 52:18Then there was no question and, and people were dying in their droves in our one little care home and, and no one seemed to really, really acknowledge it.
- 52:29Does it make any difference to see this inquiry establish what you knew to be true?
- 52:34Does it help?
- 52:35Does it help?
- 52:36I think so.
- 52:37Good.
- 52:37Because people have forgotten, everyone's forgotten, and even, even worse, a lot of people minimize it and it's got such, it's had such a massive effect for so.
- 52:47Many generations and a lot of, I mean, I don't quite understand and today is not the day for examining it.
- 52:53But, but a lot of the people who have profited from the chaos and the division and the madness of the last years were, were sits in hand in hand with.
- 53:03With vaccine skepticism or Covid denial or all manner of conspiracy theories regarding that period.
- 53:10And yet, I mean, we did it.
- 53:11We just talked to people like you at the time and couldn't make head nor tail of people who were claiming that it was being exaggerated or that the government was trying to control us, or the simple reality of
- 53:25the experiences of people like you.
- 53:26Kate, thank you for what you did.
- 53:28Seriously, I don't know that you and your colleagues get thanked enough for what you did, but thank you for what you did.
- 53:35I mean, it's immense, isn't it?
- 53:37And it's on the record, I suppose, in the way that perhaps the responsibility of some of the politicians is still evaded and eluded.
- 53:46Thank you, Kate.
- 53:46We're going to take a short break now, then you will help me illuminate this conversation with your thoughts.
- 54:00Matt's in Stockport.
- 54:01Matt, what would you like to say?
- 54:03Hi, James.
- 54:05Sorry, I am a bit nervous as well.
- 54:06This is my first time on your show.
- 54:10So.
- 54:10My mum had dementia and was in a care home.
- 54:13She had like early sign dementia.
- 54:16She was in a care home and just before hit, she had some.
- 54:21I think it was like abscesses on her stomach.
- 54:23So she had to go into hospital.
- 54:25Yeah.
- 54:26And we weren't sure if she was going to pull through or not.
- 54:28This was like the weekend before lockdown.
- 54:31All of a sudden she was taken.
- 54:34You put back into a care home and obviously she wasn't tested.
- 54:39It felt very much like they were just trying to clear the hospital out.
- 54:43Well, they were.
- 54:43I mean, they literally were.
- 54:45This is what the inquiry has established.
- 54:46Get me.
- 54:47Get me the beds.
- 54:47I don't care where they go.
- 54:48Go get them out.
- 54:49We need the bed.
- 54:50Yeah.
- 54:52The thing that I wanted to talk about is when I.
- 54:55The next time I saw my mom in person, there was.
- 55:00I spoke to a non.
- 55:01A young nurse.
- 55:02Yeah.
- 55:03Young care home worker there my mom really liked.
- 55:05And I said to her, what happened to.
- 55:08I can't remember her name now, sorry.
- 55:09But she was.
- 55:10There was this old lady there who was like everyone's nan.
- 55:13Yeah.
- 55:14And.
- 55:14And my wife loved her.
- 55:16She was a really lovely.
- 55:17And I said, what happened to that lady?
- 55:19And she.
- 55:19Oh, that.
- 55:20She's dead now.
- 55:22But then she sort of whispered under her breath to me, they're all gone.
- 55:25And so the other thing I wanted to say was that they were in this communal room together and care homes are designed like that.
- 55:36Of course they are.
- 55:37So that it's easier to manage a larger group of people and it's a cheaper way to manage them.
- 55:43So.
- 55:44So what you know it was the way the building was designed would spread Covid amongst these people.
- 55:52Did you know at the time?
- 55:54Of course.
- 55:55Like everyone knew.
- 55:56You could see it from space.
- 55:58It's logical, wasn't it?
- 55:59Like what?
- 56:00I think so, yes, but I don't.
- 56:01I mean 2020 hindsight can sometimes be a slightly.
- 56:04What did they think was going to happen?
- 56:06You know it's a.
- 56:07So no one stopped to do that.
- 56:09So you can understand how we need as many beds as possible possible.
- 56:12We've got to move the people out.
- 56:14We've got to move the old people out who aren't ill anymore but who are still frail.
- 56:17We're going to get them back to the.
- 56:18No one stopped to say shouldn't we.
- 56:21Check that they haven't got Covid first?
- 56:24No and I don't know whether they had.
- 56:26Whether they had the testing capacity but do you blame.
- 56:31I don't think you lost your mum, did you during this.
- 56:33No, I didn't lose my mom.
- 56:35She died a few years like I.
- 56:36I blame but for what happened to those people in that care home.
- 56:40Yes, I do and I'm furious about.
- 56:42Because that's.
- 56:42That was people's.
- 56:43You know Matt Hancock didn't throw a protective shield around care homes.
- 56:50He seeded it.
- 56:53He threw a protective ring about himself and.
- 56:55And around Boris Johnson and of course,.
- 56:58Yeah, they see they seeded covert in pair homes.
- 57:01They put it in there.
- 57:03Yeah, yeah, yeah but I mean that's.
- 57:04Not even an opinion, is it?
- 57:06That's just counting.
- 57:06It's a statement of fact.
- 57:08They didn't think about what they were doing.
- 57:11What was he playing at when he said that?
- 57:13What was he actually playing with his flipping dough face?
- 57:16What was he actually thinking when he.
- 57:18Said we've put a protective ring about.
- 57:19He may was the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care.
- 57:23He must have known that they hadn't.
- 57:25Done anything of the sort.
- 57:26He must have known.
- 57:27Is it one of those things where a politician has to say something that's not true because he's worried about what.
- 57:31The population might do if they had a sniff of reality?
- 57:34We've got a got to keep them calmly.
- 57:35There'll be blooming riots on the streets.
- 57:37There'll be people breaking into care homes.
- 57:39To get their mums out.
- 57:40I mean why.
- 57:41How could he have said that publicly?
- 57:43Someone wrote something down on a bit of paper immediate rise and said read.
- 57:47That out, say it.
- 57:48Yeah.
- 57:49And then.
- 57:49And it wasn't the thing.
- 57:51It wasn't just my Matt Hancock.
- 57:54It was all of them.
- 57:54All of them were saying it.
- 57:55Yeah, yeah.
- 57:56I remember listening to Michael Gove saying,.
- 57:58Oh, no, no, we.
- 57:59We've.
- 57:59What's the matter?
- 58:00We've thrown a protective ring around K Care.
- 58:02Yeah, we throw in a protective ring around care homes.
- 58:04Yeah.
- 58:06And the other thing was.
- 58:07Yeah, they probably.
- 58:08They didn't care because.
- 58:10And that's the thing that this inquiry reminds us of that.
- 58:14That it was clear at the time to everybody even close to.
- 58:17Thank you, Matt.
- 58:17I know that wasn't easy for you, but I'm really glad that you.
- 58:20That you made the effort and you remind us, of course, of the fact that these people are.
- 58:24Is Michael Gover Lord now?
- 58:25He's not a lord, is he?
- 58:26Did he put him in the head?
- 58:27He's certainly editor of the Spectator later magazine, who will no doubt be providing really, really sparkling coverage of this inquiry and making it absolutely clear who was responsible and what the Daily Mail columnists do on a day like
- 58:39today when one of their colleagues is responsible for the revelations yesterday.
- 58:43He is in the Lord's.
- 58:44Is he?
- 58:44Yeah, he got us.
- 58:45He got.
- 58:45He's in the Lord's, mate.
- 58:46He's in the Lords.
- 58:47He's fine.
- 58:47It's a protective ring.
- 58:49Sarah Vine, Michael Gove's ex wife, writing about the big story of yesterday.
- 58:54Oh, sorry.
- 58:54No, she's not.
- 58:55French rioters on the which French rioters letters.
- 58:58Bigger story than dead British people.
- 59:00These patriotic pundits there are absolutely admirable, aren't they?
- 59:05I think that's the only column in the paper today.
- 59:06But roll on Thursday or Friday or whenever.
- 59:09Poor old Richard Littlejohn is still allowed to have his one remaining column.
- 59:12No doubt he'll be going in hard on his new his colleague Boris Johnson.
- 59:16And reflecting upon how all of these characters were cheerleading for the Tory government at the time when everybody in the care home sector could see what was happening.
- 59:29Gosh, I hope you took as much from today's show as I did.
- 59:31I've said it before, but I'll say it again, the standard of contribution from our callers now is absolutely extraordinary.
- 59:39Do join us again tomorrow from 10 on LBC or right here shortly afterwards.
- 59:44This has been a global production.