Latest / Bloomberg Law / Trump Knocked Off the Ballot in Colorado
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: In an unprecedented and stunning decision, the Colorado Supreme Court
- 0:15Speaker 2: has barred Donald Trump from the state's March fifth primary
- 0:19Speaker 2: ballot by a narrow vote. The court found that the
- 0:22Speaker 2: former president's actions inciting the January sixth attack on the
- 0:26Speaker 2: US Capitol make him ineligible to run again under Section
- 0:31Speaker 2: three of the fourteenth Amendment. That's a post Civil War
- 0:34Speaker 2: era provision of the Constitution that Ban's insurrection is from
- 0:38Speaker 2: holding public office. It's a little surprising that some of
- 0:41Speaker 2: Trump's rivals for the Republican presidential nomination, like Chris Christy
- 0:46Speaker 2: and Nikki Haley, denounced the decision.
- 0:49Speaker 1: I do not believe Donald Trump should be prevented from
- 0:53Speaker 1: being president United States by any court. I think he
- 0:56Speaker 1: should be prevented from being president United States by the
- 0:58Speaker 1: voters of this country.
- 1:00Speaker 2: So I want to say this in the hands of
- 1:01Speaker 2: the voters. We're going to win this the right way.
- 1:04Speaker 2: We're going to do what we need to do. But
- 1:06Speaker 2: the last thing we want is judge just telling us
- 1:07Speaker 2: who can and can't be on the bunt. Trump's campaign
- 1:10Speaker 2: immediately said it would appeal the decision to the US
- 1:13Speaker 2: Supreme Court joining me is Harold Krant, a professor at
- 1:16Speaker 2: the Chicago Kent College of Law. Is there any precedent
- 1:20Speaker 2: at all for this ruling?
- 1:22Speaker 3: There's no direct present for the Colorado Supreme Court ruling.
- 1:26Speaker 3: And this issue has raised so many complicated constital issues
- 1:30Speaker 3: that were the only the US Supreme Court can resolve
- 1:33Speaker 3: the challenge once and for all.
- 1:35Speaker 2: Let's start with the text of the fourteenth Amendment doesn't
- 1:40Speaker 2: actually define an insurrection or spell out what it means
- 1:43Speaker 2: to engage in insurrection. Yet the Court upheld the trial
- 1:47Speaker 2: judge's conclusion that the January sixth assault was an insurrection
- 1:52Speaker 2: that Trump engaged in that insurrection. Is that a big
- 1:56Speaker 2: jump for the court?
- 1:57Speaker 3: I think the jump is more about who gets to
- 1:59Speaker 3: make the call as to whether President Trump engaged insurrection
- 2:03Speaker 3: or not. The definition of insurrection has to be balanced
- 2:06Speaker 3: with free speech rights, and the question is whether President
- 2:09Speaker 3: Trump was just using the torque to rally the troops
- 2:13Speaker 3: or was he actively engaging in inciting imminent violence. And obviously,
- 2:17Speaker 3: the Colorado Court not based upon a healing but based
- 2:22Speaker 3: largely upon the transcript of the January sixth Congressional investigation
- 2:27Speaker 3: held that President Trump's talk went over the line to
- 2:30Speaker 3: actually cite imminent violence and not just to speak more
- 2:35Speaker 3: generally about the importance of being vigilant and showing their voice.
- 2:40Speaker 3: In my view, I think the Colorado Supreme Court had
- 2:42Speaker 3: a very persuasive decision on that ground that there was
- 2:46Speaker 3: in fact more than just talk, but rather the talk
- 2:50Speaker 3: was inextricably linked with imminent action on that day to
- 2:54Speaker 3: stop the electors from certifying Joe Biden as the next president.
- 2:59Speaker 3: But the real question, my mind is who makes that call.
- 3:02Speaker 3: Is this to be made after a trial? Is this
- 3:05Speaker 3: to be made after an evidentiary hearing? And we don't know.
- 3:09Speaker 3: And that's the thicket that the Colorado Supreme Court has
- 3:12Speaker 3: entered into.
- 3:13Speaker 2: The lower court who decided that there was an insurrection
- 3:17Speaker 2: and that Trump engaged in that insurrection. There was a
- 3:20Speaker 2: week long trial about that right, So there was a.
- 3:23Speaker 3: Week long trial. It wasn't with cross examination that there
- 3:26Speaker 3: was evidence of the information that was presented, so it
- 3:30Speaker 3: was a kind of mini trial. And you know, one
- 3:32Speaker 3: of the other background issues in this case is in
- 3:35Speaker 3: coluttal law, as another states, not all there's an ability
- 3:39Speaker 3: to have an expirited challenge to somebody who's on the
- 3:42Speaker 3: ballot as being inappropriate. And of course that's the context
- 3:45Speaker 3: in which this arose is and Publican voters decided that
- 3:49Speaker 3: the Secretary State should not allow President Trump on the
- 3:52Speaker 3: ballot because he wasn't qualified. And the issue in most cases,
- 3:56Speaker 3: you're not qualified because of residentiary qualifications long enough, because
- 4:01Speaker 3: your age is wrong, you're under thirty five, so forth,
- 4:04Speaker 3: and so on. An easy and an expedited decision just
- 4:08Speaker 3: to make those kinds of judgments to decide whether should someone
- 4:11Speaker 3: stay on the ballot. In this case, though, it's so
- 4:13Speaker 3: complicated because the question of whether there was an insurrection
- 4:17Speaker 3: and whether President Trump inside of the insurrection stuff can't
- 4:22Speaker 3: be decided under these kinds of streamlined treatments. So again
- 4:26Speaker 3: it raises the question of whether both the Colorado intendness
- 4:30Speaker 3: and should this be the way that we decide whether
- 4:33Speaker 3: someone does engage in insurrection. So the quick abbreviated five
- 4:37Speaker 3: day hearing was largely based upon January sixth committees notes,
- 4:43Speaker 3: and those were comprehensive, But in a normal state of things,
- 4:47Speaker 3: you won't have that kind of record to rely upon,
- 4:50Speaker 3: which raises the question again it should be court in
- 4:54Speaker 3: this expected proceeding be the entity to determine whether a
- 4:58Speaker 3: candidate has engaged in an insurrect.
- 5:00Speaker 2: Section three doesn't mention the presidency, and the Colorado Justices
- 5:05Speaker 2: broke from the trial judge on this one key issue
- 5:08Speaker 2: which makes the difference. They reversed her decision that the
- 5:13Speaker 2: insurrection ban applies to every office except the presidency. Where
- 5:18Speaker 2: do you stand on that?
- 5:20Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, I think that the Carlos Supreme Court
- 5:23Speaker 3: was on very strong ground in rejecting the Trial Court's
- 5:26Speaker 3: decision that all other officers of the United States are
- 5:30Speaker 3: covered by the insurrection clause except for the President. To
- 5:32Speaker 3: be sure, the president is not named explicitly, but the
- 5:36Speaker 3: president is an officer in the United States in common parlance.
- 5:39Speaker 3: The president does take an oath to uphold the Constitution
- 5:43Speaker 3: like other officers. And indeed, one of the principal reasons
- 5:46Speaker 3: for the fourteenth Amendment was to prevent people like Jefferson Davis,
- 5:50Speaker 3: who was the President of Confederacy, from ever being able
- 5:53Speaker 3: to hold office again. And under the Trial Court's reasoning,
- 5:57Speaker 3: Jefferson Davis could have run for president, and that just
- 6:01Speaker 3: seems to be so far afield from what the framers
- 6:05Speaker 3: of the Fourteenth Amendment thought that I think it's on
- 6:08Speaker 3: very weak round. So I think on this particular issue,
- 6:11Speaker 3: the Chilote Supreme Coy at the far stronger decision.
- 6:16Speaker 2: All seven justices were appointed by democratic governors. It was
- 6:19Speaker 2: a four to three ruling, and the three justices who
- 6:22Speaker 2: dissented did so on procedural grounds, and they each presented
- 6:27Speaker 2: a different legal argument in their opinions. Do the descents
- 6:32Speaker 2: offer a sort of framework for arguments that Trump can
- 6:35Speaker 2: make to try to overturn the ruling?
- 6:38Speaker 3: The arguments were connected in this sense. The question really focused,
- 6:43Speaker 3: in different language, on whether a challenge to a ballot
- 6:48Speaker 3: listing is the proper procedure to determine whether someone engage
- 6:53Speaker 3: in insurrection. Viewed at the most sort of global level,
- 6:57Speaker 3: the question is whether them the fourteen is self executing,
- 7:02Speaker 3: and by that we mean can any voter trigger a
- 7:06Speaker 3: question as to the authorization the qualification under the fourteenth Amendment,
- 7:12Speaker 3: or rather, does Congress have to set a procedure out
- 7:15Speaker 3: in which the question of insurrection and qualification can be measured. So,
- 7:20Speaker 3: for instance, in eighteen seventy, the Congress did pass an
- 7:24Speaker 3: Insurrection Act under which the attorneys of the United States
- 7:28Speaker 3: could go to court to challenge the ability of a
- 7:31Speaker 3: former Confederate officer to serve a federal office. That was
- 7:35Speaker 3: repealed in nineteen forty eight. And so the question would
- 7:38Speaker 3: be whether we have to await another congressional sort of
- 7:41Speaker 3: decision as to how to enforce the terms of Memdent fourteen,
- 7:47Speaker 3: Section three. And that's the very fraught issue which has
- 7:51Speaker 3: obviously never been clearly determined one way or the other,
- 7:54Speaker 3: because there is a kind of logic to the sense
- 7:57Speaker 3: that we should wait for Congress to tell us how
- 8:00Speaker 3: to enforce this provision, as opposed to just individual voters
- 8:04Speaker 3: triggering an election board to make this very complicated decision
- 8:09Speaker 3: based upon almost no precedence whatsoever. I should also add
- 8:13Speaker 3: that Congress does have a criminal provision which provides for
- 8:17Speaker 3: disqualification from office as well for aiding insurrection, but that
- 8:21Speaker 3: course is complete with all the protections of the criminal trial.
- 8:25Speaker 3: And Jack Smith, the Special Council has not charged President
- 8:29Speaker 3: Trump under this section, whether he's chosen other provisions to
- 8:32Speaker 3: charging with. So we do have a process now implicitly
- 8:36Speaker 3: in order to determine whether someone's engage in inturrection, and
- 8:39Speaker 3: therefore disqualified, but that has not been pursued, and so
- 8:43Speaker 3: the major question I think looking under all of this
- 8:47Speaker 3: is whether, again under different formats, whether this Colorado election
- 8:53Speaker 3: challenge with the appropriate vehicle for determining whether or not
- 8:58Speaker 3: a insurrection indeed took place, which would lead to the
- 9:02Speaker 3: disqualification of the candidates.
- 9:05Speaker 2: Coming up next echoes of the controversial Bush v. Gore decision.
- 9:09Speaker 2: I'm June Grosso. When you're listening to Bloomberg, I've been
- 9:11Speaker 2: talking to Professor Harold kran to the Chicago College of
- 9:14Speaker 2: Law about the Colorado Supreme Court barring Donald Trump from
- 9:19Speaker 2: the state's March fifth primary ballot in an unprecedented ruling.
- 9:24Speaker 2: The Colorado Chief Justice, in a dissenting opinion, said the
- 9:27Speaker 2: ruling was premature because Trump hasn't been criminally convicted of insurrection.
- 9:33Speaker 2: But he hasn't even been charged with insurrection, so there
- 9:36Speaker 2: are factual determinations to be made as well as legal determinations.
- 9:42Speaker 3: Right, I mean, I think that that's to me. There's
- 9:44Speaker 3: one other issue that the Colorado Justice is mentioned, but
- 9:47Speaker 3: I think the overarging issue is who should make this
- 9:50Speaker 3: decision as to whether President Trump engaging insurrection and under
- 9:54Speaker 3: what circumstances. And it's at least odd if not been
- 9:58Speaker 3: consistent with the Constitution to say that this incredibly important
- 10:01Speaker 3: decision is made on an expedity basis, without a jury,
- 10:05Speaker 3: and without be on so many of the safeguards of
- 10:08Speaker 3: a criminal trial. Now, if indeed the framers of the
- 10:12Speaker 3: amendment thought that that was appropriate, so be it. But
- 10:16Speaker 3: you'd have to have, I think, in my mind, pretty
- 10:17Speaker 3: clear evidence that that's what the framers had in mind,
- 10:21Speaker 3: rather than this sort of expedited hearing that took place
- 10:25Speaker 3: in this case. The other issue that was raised in
- 10:28Speaker 3: descent was want to due process, that this is not
- 10:32Speaker 3: a full and fair trial, and the former president did
- 10:35Speaker 3: not have those kind of procedure protections before being thrown
- 10:38Speaker 3: off the ballot. I don't think that argument's going to
- 10:40Speaker 3: hold up at all. I think the real issue is
- 10:43Speaker 3: not one of protecting former President Trump, but one of
- 10:47Speaker 3: protecting the electorate. And so I think the extent that
- 10:51Speaker 3: the Sensing Justice made this point in the case, the
- 10:54Speaker 3: real argument should be substituted is we want to make
- 10:57Speaker 3: sure we've a very careful process before we deny the
- 11:00Speaker 3: will of the people. And so to the extent that
- 11:03Speaker 3: there were concerns about this truncated process that would go
- 11:08Speaker 3: to making sure we have full and adequate protection for
- 11:11Speaker 3: the electorate, not for the individual who's seeking office. But altogether,
- 11:15Speaker 3: I think it's a very close case, not because of
- 11:18Speaker 3: whether or not there's interrupting gaging the insurrection, and there
- 11:21Speaker 3: was no dissenting justice on that point, but rather on
- 11:24Speaker 3: the question is this the form, Is this the time
- 11:28Speaker 3: to make the determination in each of the states as
- 11:31Speaker 3: to whether from the vision insurrection, because obviously that's just
- 11:34Speaker 3: going to lead to a different result in different states
- 11:37Speaker 3: and would undermine the ability, I think, to have a
- 11:41Speaker 3: fair and impartial process to proceed upon the determine whether
- 11:44Speaker 3: pent President Trump shouldn't be be on the ballot for
- 11:46Speaker 3: the primary which is starting in Reason Carlado.
- 11:50Speaker 2: During early March, Trump's campaign immediately said that it would
- 11:54Speaker 2: appeal the decision to the Supreme Court, the US Supreme Court.
- 11:58Speaker 2: That's no surprise, even the Colorado Court anticipated that is
- 12:02Speaker 2: this a case that the justices almost have to take?
- 12:06Speaker 3: I think so. I mean, I think the Colorado Court
- 12:08Speaker 3: knew that this was important, that their decision was going
- 12:11Speaker 3: to lock in the decisions of other states, because even
- 12:14Speaker 3: if some states said no and some states said yes. Effectively,
- 12:18Speaker 3: former President Trump would be off the bout in enough
- 12:20Speaker 3: states as to change the election resultant through the election
- 12:23Speaker 3: that their turmoil. So the Court recognized that, and I
- 12:27Speaker 3: think the US Supreme Court is really their hand is forced.
- 12:30Speaker 3: I think they have to take this case and have
- 12:32Speaker 3: some kind of expedity decision as to who should make
- 12:36Speaker 3: the call as to whether or not the candidate had
- 12:39Speaker 3: engaged in interaction and therefore is not qualified under the ballot. Clearly,
- 12:44Speaker 3: whether a candidate has residenty requirements, whether a candidate is
- 12:47Speaker 3: thirty five or not, those kinds of issues can be
- 12:50Speaker 3: determined quite easily by a state election board. But on
- 12:54Speaker 3: the question of insurrection, I think maybe we need a
- 12:56Speaker 3: different process in the absence of Congress, and the Court
- 12:59Speaker 3: will determine is there a process absent a congressional structure,
- 13:03Speaker 3: and if so, what that process will be for determining
- 13:07Speaker 3: whether or not the candidate engaged in insurrection after taking
- 13:10Speaker 3: an over as an officer in the United States?
- 13:13Speaker 2: Doesn't the Supreme Court usually have to accept the facts
- 13:16Speaker 2: of the case below, and here both the lower court
- 13:20Speaker 2: and the color Supreme Court said he did engage in
- 13:24Speaker 2: an insurrection.
- 13:26Speaker 3: Yeah, I don't think there will look at the facts
- 13:28Speaker 3: of the case to determine whether or not what the
- 13:29Speaker 3: standard is under Bradenburg versus High or something in terms
- 13:33Speaker 3: of what he is incitement, you know. I think rather
- 13:36Speaker 3: what the court will do is simply try to figure
- 13:39Speaker 3: out who has the right to make that determination. And
- 13:44Speaker 3: the issue is whether, in part whether Fourteenth Amendment in
- 13:48Speaker 3: this respect is self executing, or whether or not Congress
- 13:51Speaker 3: has to create the procedure, and the only procedure that
- 13:54Speaker 3: is created so far is a trial, and disqualification will
- 13:58Speaker 3: follow on the heel of a successful trial.
- 14:01Speaker 2: The Supreme Court, as we've discussed, has a conservative supermajority
- 14:05Speaker 2: with three justices appointed by Trump. Is there anything you
- 14:09Speaker 2: can conclude from that lineup that tells you about how
- 14:13Speaker 2: they'll approach the case.
- 14:16Speaker 3: My guess is they won't touch the question of whether
- 14:20Speaker 3: President Trump engaged in insurrection. They have, of course questions
- 14:24Speaker 3: of the presidential immunity that is before the court right now.
- 14:28Speaker 3: But rather what they will do, and I would guess
- 14:31Speaker 3: if I had to, is that they will decide that
- 14:34Speaker 3: whatever the proper procedure is to determine whether someone engaged
- 14:38Speaker 3: insurrection that this process is wanting and therefore cannot stand.
- 14:44Speaker 3: But of course, at the same time, they will be
- 14:46Speaker 3: forced to make a call as to what the proper
- 14:49Speaker 3: process would be and whether or not it's up to
- 14:52Speaker 3: Congress to set the guidelines for in kind of inquiry
- 14:56Speaker 3: that would be this qualification.
- 14:58Speaker 2: This what's the twenty twenty four residential election basically in
- 15:02Speaker 2: the hands of the Supreme Court again, like Bush v. Gore,
- 15:06Speaker 2: which remains one of the most controversial decisions in US history,
- 15:11Speaker 2: and the country right now is more politically divided.
- 15:15Speaker 3: Than it was then, absolutely, and how this plays out
- 15:19Speaker 3: politically overall is a critical issue. Well, this emboldened supporters
- 15:23Speaker 3: of Trump to think that former President Trump is not
- 15:26Speaker 3: getting a fair shake. Will they come out and droves
- 15:28Speaker 3: to support him, And will this pressure the US Supreme
- 15:33Speaker 3: Court to make a decision on behalf of former President Trump? Again,
- 15:38Speaker 3: I don't think the issues are clear cut, and I
- 15:40Speaker 3: do think that the Court may try to find a
- 15:43Speaker 3: middle ground by saying that the analysis was partially correct
- 15:49Speaker 3: by the PLOT Supreme Court, But the inquiry that led
- 15:53Speaker 3: to that decision is simply the inappropriate inquiry to kick
- 15:57Speaker 3: somebody off the presidential ballot. I think they will say
- 16:00Speaker 3: that the law the Constitution applies to ex President Trump,
- 16:04Speaker 3: but that to determine whether he engaged an insurrection, at
- 16:08Speaker 3: the minimum, you need to have a full evidentiary hearing,
- 16:11Speaker 3: and perhaps even more than that, we need to have
- 16:13Speaker 3: a criminal trial. You know, the US Supreme Court really
- 16:16Speaker 3: could try to down the middle type of decision by
- 16:20Speaker 3: being empathetic to the Colorado Supreme Court, but yet holding
- 16:24Speaker 3: that this is not the kind of process that was
- 16:28Speaker 3: envisioned by the framers of the fourteenth Amendment.
- 16:31Speaker 2: But we'll see the conservatives on the Court are textualists,
- 16:36Speaker 2: So do you think they'll analyze this by looking at
- 16:40Speaker 2: the language of the fourteenth Amendment.
- 16:44Speaker 3: The language in this case is simply not clear. No
- 16:46Speaker 3: one can say for certain that the language forces a
- 16:50Speaker 3: particular outcome. The Court will be grappling with the history
- 16:52Speaker 3: of the fourteenth Amendment. That has to be center of
- 16:55Speaker 3: any kind of analysis. And we know the issue that
- 16:59Speaker 3: the Congress was what to do about all of those
- 17:02Speaker 3: Confederate officers to make sure they didn't resume positions of authority,
- 17:07Speaker 3: and this clause was aimed the preventing that. And the
- 17:11Speaker 3: question is how the Court can make sense of that
- 17:14Speaker 3: without agreeing with the Kalorado Supreme Court. And I think again,
- 17:18Speaker 3: the way they can try to put those two competing
- 17:22Speaker 3: sort of vectors together is by saying absolutely, that's what
- 17:26Speaker 3: Congress intended through the fourteenth Amendment, but it's failed after
- 17:31Speaker 3: appealing the eighteen seventy Insurrection Act of giving another procedure
- 17:36Speaker 3: that is adequate to make that inque possible.
- 17:40Speaker 1: And so I had I.
- 17:41Speaker 3: Guess now that's what I would think that US Supreme
- 17:43Speaker 3: Court would say.
- 17:44Speaker 2: Is this a case where Clarence Thomas should recuse himself
- 17:49Speaker 2: because his wife was at the ellipse et cetera.
- 17:54Speaker 3: Well, that's obviously a tough question. He hasn't shown much
- 17:57Speaker 3: interest in accusing himself previously, and of course it's not
- 18:01Speaker 3: a question of whether the insurrectionists engaged insurrections whether President
- 18:06Speaker 3: Trump did, which is analytically distinct. But yes, I think
- 18:08Speaker 3: that in an other world, Justice Thomas would recuse himself.
- 18:12Speaker 3: But my guess is he want in this case?
- 18:14Speaker 2: Thanks Hal. That's Harold Crant of Chicago Kent College of Law.
- 18:18Speaker 2: Coming up next, a new Texas law makes illegal immigration
- 18:22Speaker 2: a state crime. I'm June Grosse when you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 18:28Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 18:35Speaker 4: Cendebel four is now law in the state of Texas.
- 18:39Speaker 2: Senate Bill four allows police in Texas to arrest migrants
- 18:43Speaker 2: to illegally cross into the country and empowers local judges
- 18:47Speaker 2: to order them to leave the country. On Monday, Republican
- 18:50Speaker 2: Governor Greg Abbott signed the bill into law.
- 18:53Speaker 4: The goal of Cinebel four is to stop the title
- 18:58Speaker 4: wave of illegal entry into Texas. It creates a criminal
- 19:03Speaker 4: offense for illegal entry into Texas from a foreign nation.
- 19:06Speaker 2: The law challenges the federal government's exclusive enforcement of immigration laws.
- 19:11Speaker 2: Less than twenty four hours after the signing, civil rights
- 19:15Speaker 2: groups in Texas's largest border county filed the lawsuit, calling
- 19:19Speaker 2: the measure an unconstitutional reach over the US government's authority
- 19:23Speaker 2: on immigration. Joining me is immigration law expertly On Fresco,
- 19:27Speaker 2: a partner at Honda Knight, tell us about the law
- 19:30Speaker 2: leon and what it does well.
- 19:32Speaker 5: The law does two things. So the first one, which
- 19:35Speaker 5: is not controversial, devotes more money toward border security, and
- 19:40Speaker 5: that's permitted, and nobody thinks that that isn't in terms
- 19:43Speaker 5: of border security resources for their officers, et cetera. There
- 19:48Speaker 5: is some question about some border barriers that the money
- 19:51Speaker 5: is fun things to see whether those border barriers are
- 19:54Speaker 5: going to be deployed in an unconstitutional manner, But that's
- 19:57Speaker 5: one aspect. The more controversial aspect is three new state
- 20:02Speaker 5: law offenses that are created by the statue. One is
- 20:06Speaker 5: illegal entry from a foreign nation, the second is illegal
- 20:10Speaker 5: re entry, and third is refusal to comply with an
- 20:14Speaker 5: order to return to the foreign nation. And so here's
- 20:17Speaker 5: how basically this is going to work. Texas will now
- 20:20Speaker 5: have the authority to have its officers arrest people that
- 20:25Speaker 5: it things have illegally crossed from Mexico into the United States. Now,
- 20:30Speaker 5: what's interesting is the law doesn't require a visual in
- 20:35Speaker 5: order to arrest the person, so it could be that
- 20:37Speaker 5: the person was here a week or two. And then
- 20:40Speaker 5: this is where that's going to get complicated, is it's
- 20:42Speaker 5: almost certain they're going to get some of those wrong
- 20:44Speaker 5: if they actually make arrests like that. But let's say
- 20:47Speaker 5: they only limit the arrest the people they visually seen
- 20:51Speaker 5: entering illegally. The next step is those people can be
- 20:54Speaker 5: arrested and charged for a misdemeanor and the way it
- 20:57Speaker 5: will work is they will go into a court hearing
- 21:01Speaker 5: where the judge will say, look, you don't have to
- 21:03Speaker 5: have this criminal conviction, but what you have to agree
- 21:07Speaker 5: to do is to go back to Mexico and then
- 21:10Speaker 5: we'll just call it even and there won't be any conviction.
- 21:13Speaker 5: If the person refuses to do that, then the person
- 21:17Speaker 5: will be charged and placed in prison for up to
- 21:20Speaker 5: six months under this Texas offense. And then what Texas
- 21:24Speaker 5: actually says is if they refuse to comply with a
- 21:29Speaker 5: condition that says after this release they have to go
- 21:33Speaker 5: back into Mexico, then they can actually be re arrested
- 21:37Speaker 5: and charged with a felony that would put them in
- 21:40Speaker 5: prison for up to twenty years. And so this raises
- 21:43Speaker 5: a whole bunch of questions such as what happens if
- 21:46Speaker 5: the person's asking for asylum and they just get ensnared
- 21:50Speaker 5: in this web in Texas. Would they actually have to
- 21:53Speaker 5: leave the country and lose their asylum claim or would
- 21:58Speaker 5: they be able to have some sort of way through
- 22:00Speaker 5: this without having to potentially phase twenty years in prison.
- 22:04Speaker 5: And that is pretty much the most egregious unresolved aspects
- 22:09Speaker 5: of the Texas law But the main sort of complaint
- 22:13Speaker 5: is that we have gone through this before with Arizona
- 22:17Speaker 5: doing something very similar, and at the end of the day,
- 22:20Speaker 5: the Arizona law being stricken down as being an illegal
- 22:24Speaker 5: state law encroachment into federal immigration enforcement.
- 22:28Speaker 2: Crossing between ports of entry is already a crime under
- 22:32Speaker 2: federal law, isn't it aren't federal agents supposed to be
- 22:35Speaker 2: arresting migrants for that.
- 22:37Speaker 5: Absolutely, crossing the border illegally is a criminal offense under
- 22:42Speaker 5: federal law. It's a misdemeanor. The problem is the federal
- 22:46Speaker 5: government does not have anywhere near the resources it needs
- 22:50Speaker 5: to prosecute every single person who did this. We're on
- 22:54Speaker 5: paced currently to have something like three point six million
- 22:59Speaker 5: unlawful border crossings in twenty twenty three, twenty twenty four,
- 23:03Speaker 5: and what that would mean is you'd have to have
- 23:05Speaker 5: prison space, prison beds to put those people into custody,
- 23:11Speaker 5: and there's nothing like that. So what the federal government
- 23:14Speaker 5: does is it only prosecutes people who are either criminals
- 23:18Speaker 5: who have re entered the United States or people who
- 23:21Speaker 5: are doing some other dangerous thing like drug smuggling or
- 23:25Speaker 5: something else while they're crossing the border. But just a
- 23:28Speaker 5: simple first time border crosser very rarely gets prosecuted at
- 23:34Speaker 5: the moment for unlawful entry in between the ports of entry.
- 23:38Speaker 2: Couldn't the border agents turn them around and send them
- 23:41Speaker 2: back across the border.
- 23:43Speaker 5: So this depends on their Title forty two. That was
- 23:47Speaker 5: happening systematically, which was pretty much any person who entered
- 23:51Speaker 5: unlawfully through the ports of entry was being pushed back
- 23:55Speaker 5: into Mexico. Now there isn't a law or that requires this.
- 24:01Speaker 5: Certainly the federal agents can volunteer this offer and say, look,
- 24:06Speaker 5: we're going to put you in CDP's attention. Then we're
- 24:09Speaker 5: going to put you anice attention. Do you really want this?
- 24:11Speaker 5: Wouldn't you prefer to just go back into Mexico? And
- 24:14Speaker 5: sometimes people do take that what's called voluntary return option
- 24:20Speaker 5: back into Mexico, But more often than that, people instead
- 24:23Speaker 5: ask for asylum and wait whatever time they have to
- 24:27Speaker 5: wait temporarily in custody to get processed through that so
- 24:30Speaker 5: that they can enter the United States while their asylum
- 24:33Speaker 5: cases tending didn't.
- 24:35Speaker 2: Homeland Security Secretary Alejandra Majorcis say that people who arrive
- 24:40Speaker 2: at the border without using a lawful pathway will be
- 24:44Speaker 2: presumed ineligible for asylum.
- 24:47Speaker 5: That's correct, but here is how that works. So just
- 24:51Speaker 5: because you are banned from getting asylum doesn't mean you're
- 24:55Speaker 5: banned from getting something called withholding of removal. So what
- 24:59Speaker 5: happens is asylum is a discretionary form of relief that
- 25:04Speaker 5: the federal government gives by statutes that it doesn't have
- 25:08Speaker 5: to give, which gives people a path to citizenship and
- 25:11Speaker 5: the ability to earn a green card to get the
- 25:13Speaker 5: ability to bring family over. But that's not the only
- 25:17Speaker 5: way to basically save yourself. You can get this second
- 25:21Speaker 5: status called withholding of removal, which means you get to
- 25:25Speaker 5: stay in the US, but you get no other such
- 25:28Speaker 5: rights like a green card, citizenship, ability to bring family,
- 25:31Speaker 5: or any of that. And what happens is even though
- 25:34Speaker 5: there's a ban on receiving asylum for people, there isn't
- 25:38Speaker 5: a ban on receiving withholding of removal. So people if
- 25:42Speaker 5: they need a slightly higher threshold for articulating a claim,
- 25:45Speaker 5: which is called a reasonable fear standard as opposed to
- 25:49Speaker 5: the credible fear standard, which is the lower standards US
- 25:53Speaker 5: for asylum cases. If you can meet a slightly higher
- 25:56Speaker 5: standard called the reasonable fear standard, then you are permitted
- 26:00Speaker 5: to stay even if you cross in between the port
- 26:03Speaker 5: of entry, and even if you will not be able
- 26:05Speaker 5: to get asylum, you're still allowed to state to make
- 26:08Speaker 5: your withholding of removal case in the Immigration Court.
- 26:12Speaker 2: Civil rights organizations sued less than twenty four hours after
- 26:17Speaker 2: Abbott signed the law. They're challenging the constitutionality of it,
- 26:21Speaker 2: and they cite that Supreme Court case in twenty twelve
- 26:25Speaker 2: in Arizona.
- 26:26Speaker 5: Correct the ACLU sued in the Western District of Texas
- 26:29Speaker 5: in Austin, and they are suing on behalf of certain
- 26:33Speaker 5: immigrant rights groups and also on behalf of El Paso County,
- 26:37Speaker 5: and they're suing the State of Texas. Public officials saying
- 26:41Speaker 5: that at the end of the day, they need injunctive
- 26:44Speaker 5: relief from this SB four in Texas because this is
- 26:48Speaker 5: the exact same scenario as Arizona. That a state cannot
- 26:52Speaker 5: criminalize being unlawfully present, because that is a federal immigration
- 26:57Speaker 5: enforcement prerogative and it is not something that the State
- 27:01Speaker 5: of Texas can do. The State of Texas is preempted
- 27:04Speaker 5: by federal law from doing it. Now, just to give
- 27:07Speaker 5: you some composition of how this works, it is expected
- 27:10Speaker 5: that there will be three justices, you know, the liberal
- 27:13Speaker 5: three Soto, Mayor, Jackson, and Kagan, who will be sympathetic
- 27:18Speaker 5: to such a claim. And Justice Roberts also voted on
- 27:22Speaker 5: the side of the federal government and against Arizona in
- 27:25Speaker 5: the Arizona case. There will be two Justices Alito and Thomas,
- 27:29Speaker 5: who voted on the side of Arizona during the Arizona case.
- 27:33Speaker 5: And so what we do not know is what about
- 27:35Speaker 5: the remaining three new ones, Kavanaugh, Gorsitz, and amy Cony Barrett.
- 27:40Speaker 5: Are they going to side with the state of Texas
- 27:44Speaker 5: and overturn the Arizona case and say that states can
- 27:48Speaker 5: indeed do prosecutions if they're literally prosecuting the exact same
- 27:53Speaker 5: thing that the federal government is prosecuting and that's something different.
- 27:58Speaker 5: Or will they rule to keep the Arizona president and
- 28:02Speaker 5: say that this cannot be done and we're not going
- 28:03Speaker 5: to overturn that precedent. And so we will see. There's
- 28:06Speaker 5: good arguments on both sides of this. Certainly, the federal
- 28:09Speaker 5: government prosecutes drug offenses, as does state government. We'll both
- 28:13Speaker 5: do that, but by the same token, state don't prosecute
- 28:18Speaker 5: things such as failing to file your federal tax return
- 28:22Speaker 5: that's not only by the federal government, and so we're
- 28:26Speaker 5: gonna see where along the line does immigration fall within
- 28:29Speaker 5: those spectrums.
- 28:30Speaker 2: This law doesn't go into effect until March. I think
- 28:33Speaker 2: it is, so if the District Court doesn't grant an injunction,
- 28:38Speaker 2: then this might go into effect before the Supreme Court
- 28:41Speaker 2: has a chance to hear it.
- 28:43Speaker 5: If the District Court in Austin enjoins us before that,
- 28:47Speaker 5: I think you'll see a very slow path of this
- 28:50Speaker 5: case to get all the way to the Supreme Court,
- 28:53Speaker 5: and I don't think it will take a very short route. If, however,
- 28:59Speaker 5: the court in Texas says this is legal, and Texas
- 29:03Speaker 5: actually starts enforcing the law, you will see an immediate
- 29:06Speaker 5: request for a say in the Fifth Circuit, which if
- 29:09Speaker 5: the District Court doesn't enjoin it, it's very likely neither
- 29:13Speaker 5: with the Fifth Circuit, and then you'd see an immediate
- 29:16Speaker 5: request for a say in the Supreme Court. So probably
- 29:19Speaker 5: within thirty days you would see some sort of decision
- 29:24Speaker 5: by the Supreme Court whether to say this law or
- 29:26Speaker 5: not pending review. So that would happen quickly, but I
- 29:31Speaker 5: don't think it would happen quickly in the alternative side,
- 29:34Speaker 5: where if the district court in Texas or the Fifth
- 29:38Speaker 5: Circuit were to say that this is indeed preempted and
- 29:41Speaker 5: it's illegal, I think you would see this work its
- 29:44Speaker 5: way up slowly through the court.
- 29:46Speaker 2: When Abbots signed this, there were signs that read in
- 29:49Speaker 2: English and Spanish warning it's illegal to cross here, punishable
- 29:53Speaker 2: by removal or imprisonment. And he called the legislation so
- 29:58Speaker 2: extreme that it would drive my and away from Texas.
- 30:01Speaker 2: So that just means they'll cross into other states, right,
- 30:05Speaker 2: And Arizona already is so overwhelmed that the governor deployed
- 30:11Speaker 2: the National Guard to help.
- 30:13Speaker 5: Yes, there's basically two places where you can cross. It's
- 30:18Speaker 5: Texas and Arizona. Because the California border with Mexico is
- 30:23Speaker 5: pretty much all triple fence. It's a very small border,
- 30:27Speaker 5: as is the new Mexico borders, a very small border
- 30:30Speaker 5: which is basically triple fence as well. And so really
- 30:34Speaker 5: the only places that are open are in Arizona and
- 30:37Speaker 5: in Texas. And if people say that they are experiencing
- 30:42Speaker 5: these arrests in Texas, then certainly you will see people
- 30:46Speaker 5: move to Arizona. And it'll be unclear if Arizona will
- 30:49Speaker 5: pass a law similar to Texas, because of course Arizona
- 30:52Speaker 5: has to deal with the ninth Circuits and Texas gets
- 30:55Speaker 5: to deal with the fifth Circuit, so that changes dramatically.
- 30:58Speaker 5: There'd almost be no reason for Arizona to think that
- 31:02Speaker 5: they could pass the law that would be in any
- 31:04Speaker 5: way allowed to be enforced, So they'd have to wait
- 31:07Speaker 5: to see what the Supreme Court says before they could
- 31:10Speaker 5: go ahead and pass the law.
- 31:11Speaker 2: And therein there's also a question, it seems, about whether
- 31:14Speaker 2: Texas can process all these people if they do make arrests,
- 31:18Speaker 2: because some border sheriffs have expressed concerns that this would
- 31:24Speaker 2: overwhelm the local jails and courts.
- 31:27Speaker 5: That's correct. The purpose of this law would not actually
- 31:30Speaker 5: be to arrest the border crossers coming into Texas in
- 31:34Speaker 5: sort of a massive scale. It would be just to
- 31:37Speaker 5: create fear that you could be one of the people
- 31:41Speaker 5: that get stuck in this Texas web and so don't
- 31:44Speaker 5: come into Texas. And I think what they would try
- 31:46Speaker 5: to do is create enough examples to scare enough people
- 31:50Speaker 5: to try to move people out from Texas and into
- 31:52Speaker 5: other locations, and that would be their goal. But you're
- 31:55Speaker 5: correct to say that if the actual goal was to
- 31:59Speaker 5: arrest every person coming into Texas and there wasn't a
- 32:03Speaker 5: reduction based off of fear, there was no way they
- 32:06Speaker 5: could do it. They Texas would have no way to
- 32:08Speaker 5: actually arrest and detain a million people or a million
- 32:12Speaker 5: and a half people coming into Texas. But what they
- 32:15Speaker 5: could do is if they get enough stories out there
- 32:17Speaker 5: of just terrible circumstances face by people that entered Texas,
- 32:22Speaker 5: their ideal scenario would be that people stop entering because
- 32:26Speaker 5: they heard of these terrible scenarios.
- 32:28Speaker 2: Thanks so much, Leon, and you'll be back tomorrow when
- 32:32Speaker 2: we'll talk about the record numbers of migrants who are
- 32:35Speaker 2: crossing the southern border illegally and the Senate negotiations over
- 32:40Speaker 2: border policy. Thanks so much. That's Leon Fresco, a partner
- 32:44Speaker 2: at Holland to Night, and that's it for this edition
- 32:47Speaker 2: of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get
- 32:49Speaker 2: the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You
- 32:52Speaker 2: can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www
- 32:57Speaker 2: dot Bloomberg dot com slash podcast Law. And remember to
- 33:01Speaker 2: tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at ten
- 33:04Speaker 2: pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're listening
- 33:08Speaker 2: to Bloomberg