Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / 2025 Recap w/ Matt Odell: Gold's Run, DAT Reckoning, Quantum FUD + 2026 Predictions
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, OK.
- 0:27I say when we sell. All right, we are back.
- 0:34It's the last trade. We have Matt Odell in the studio
- 0:38with us today. Matt, thank you for joining us
- 0:40on the week of Christmas. We appreciate it.
- 0:42How are you doing? Pleasure.
- 0:43Merry Christmas. I'm, I'm excited to have Matt on
- 0:47because I didn't share with you guys or him that there's been
- 0:50all this like narrative around OG's dumping.
- 0:53And I wanted to ask him specifically if can you please
- 0:56just stop selling his Bitcoin because this fucking price is,
- 1:00you know, killing everyone. God I wish I had eight.
- 1:04I wish I had 80,000 Bitcoin to sell at 100K.
- 1:07That would have been fucking dope.
- 1:08Yeah, what? What would you be doing right
- 1:10now if you if that was the case, Matt?
- 1:13Yeah, I mean, I'm definitely, I would definitely wouldn't be on
- 1:15this show. I look, I think, I think that's
- 1:20all it's it's I think your audience knows it's we kind of
- 1:25said that in tongue in cheek way, but I we hear that
- 1:30narrative every all the time. It's been ever ever since I've
- 1:33been in Bitcoin. The Ogs are dumping on you.
- 1:37You know, it's a Ponzi. You, you're, you're buying their
- 1:40bags. I don't think that's new for
- 1:44this cycle. I think what's different is the
- 1:47size, just the absolute numbers, But that always goes up.
- 1:51Like unless Bitcoin fails like that will just always go up and
- 1:54it'll be always bigger and bigger size.
- 1:57I think there is a good argument that they finally had liquidity
- 2:02to do it in bigger sizes. But once again, I think you
- 2:05could have made that argument three years ago, right?
- 2:07There was more liquidity than the three years before that.
- 2:10So I don't think I think there's a little bit too much, too much
- 2:16emphasis placed on that. And part of it is because on
- 2:19social media, Bitcoin transactions are public and
- 2:24saying, you know, oh, this 40,000 Bitcoin just moved to
- 2:27Kraken or whatever gets you, you get a lot of retweets on that.
- 2:32Yeah, it's, it's a good point too, because like you can't, you
- 2:35can't win either way with, with either of the narratives, right?
- 2:37Because it's like if, if none of them were selling, then people
- 2:40would say like, oh, Bitcoin's so concentrated with the, you know,
- 2:43the oldest, largest holders. And so like, you know, in either
- 2:47direction, you know, there's going to be critics about it.
- 2:50But like, I agree with you, I think it's one, it's already
- 2:52been happening, you know, each cycle and sort of like
- 2:55continuously throughout Bitcoin's history.
- 2:57But it's natural and it's, I would say it's like genuinely
- 3:01healthy for the market for there to be continued distribution
- 3:04into the future. I did hear a theory that I did
- 3:09not verify that and I'm not a tax attorney.
- 3:15Fortunately that a bunch of people did move to Puerto Rico
- 3:21in 2015 and supposedly you have to season your assets for 10
- 3:26years to get 0 cap gains, 0 federal cap gains.
- 3:31And so that's also position that might change in the future
- 3:36depending on what administration exists.
- 3:38So to be able to reset your cap gains, sell now, not pay cap
- 3:43gains, rebuy in actually makes a lot of logical sense.
- 3:48So I, I think that was probably part of it.
- 3:52But then, yeah, I mean, this is natural and healthy.
- 3:55We, we, you, you want to see this as a, as a new money is
- 3:58being adopted by the world. This is exactly how supply gets
- 4:01distributed. Older sellers want to live their
- 4:04life. They want to pay for things.
- 4:06They want to buy a new house, a new ranch or something like
- 4:08that. And, and new people come in and
- 4:11I'll, I'll say on the ETF side specifically, it's been pretty
- 4:16like it's probably the single, one of the single most bullish
- 4:20fundamentals of this year is how, how receptive the market
- 4:24has been to the Ecfs and, and, and how much they've been bought
- 4:27at scale in such a quick amount of time.
- 4:31What would you say this isn't? I don't want to say it's a hot
- 4:34take, but it's something that doesn't get discussed a lot.
- 4:37And I think we were Brian and I recorded on Monday and it was
- 4:40like working through this thesis of I do feel strongly that we
- 4:43haven't been in a bear market like independent.
- 4:46Of In a bull. In a bull.
- 4:47Market, yeah, in a bull market, we've been in a bear market.
- 4:49And like, I guess the three main anecdotes I would look at are
- 4:54gold to Bitcoin ratio, the anecdotal adoption from peers
- 5:01and if you want to get more empirical is like talking to
- 5:04hardware manufacturers and and they're purchasing, you're
- 5:09right. Like that'd be a signal for net
- 5:10new buyers. And then the forget the last one
- 5:16is like the, the basically that the volatility drives in that
- 5:19new adoption, like the reflexivity and that the reason
- 5:22why it had this price appreciation, it's very similar
- 5:24to gold. It's not like retail buying
- 5:26gold. It's sovereigns.
- 5:26This price appreciation has been some sovereign, some
- 5:29institutional. But it's what you said, it's the
- 5:31ETF flows, but that's not necessarily retail.
- 5:33That's people that have brokerages that knew of Bitcoin
- 5:36for 15 years and didn't want to do anything outside of just buy
- 5:38it through Fidelity. Why I'm bringing that up is
- 5:41because if that's kind of the market structure that we've
- 5:43lived through, then if you have people selling because of
- 5:47liquidity and then you have to your point, whether it's
- 5:50seasonal selling, but also whatever the hell is going on
- 5:54and what potentially happened in October 10th with like there's
- 5:57somebody out there selling in the market that that's really
- 6:00where we're at. And the outside relevance to
- 6:04that is the looking at golden equities, right?
- 6:08Like that's what is the curious part of all this is golden
- 6:10equities are ripping and BTC sitting like in this range.
- 6:14That's the best rationale I've been able to come up with a
- 6:17like, what the hell is going on? Which also sets up a very
- 6:19bullish opportunity moving forward, if that's even nearly
- 6:22right. Yeah.
- 6:24I mean, I think there's a couple things there that I think you
- 6:28hit on that I agree with. First of all, I've been a psycho
- 6:32believer mostly because I've been in Bitcoin for 12 years and
- 6:37we kept on the four year cycles and I've had a very reasonable
- 6:42approach to whether or not the cycles would die.
- 6:45Is I, I want to see it if if the cycles actually don't play out,
- 6:48then the cycles are dead or we moved on to a different cycle,
- 6:51some kind of liquidity cycle or something like that.
- 6:54I think we're probably close to calling the cycles dead just
- 6:57because it wasn't a traditional bull market this year.
- 7:00I mean, no matter how you cut it, but the big one to me is is
- 7:03priced in gold. I mean we didn't hit a new gold
- 7:05all time high. So that's unexpected there.
- 7:10I still think there could be an argument that maybe due to, you
- 7:15know, just the maturation of the Bitcoin market and different
- 7:20access points, particularly ETFs and stuff like that, maybe it
- 7:23gets elongated. So maybe it becomes like a five
- 7:26year cycle or something or six year cycle and and maybe next
- 7:29year's supposed to be the bull market.
- 7:30But that also feels like cope. But but overarching how I'm
- 7:35looking at it is I think we're basically in a global depression
- 7:40right now and retail is poor. I don't think the people just
- 7:45don't have money. I think market participants are
- 7:50spooked. I think it's very chaotic times
- 7:53we're living in that is kind of being papered over.
- 7:58And as a result, large allocators are going to safe
- 8:02haven place. And that makes that lines up
- 8:06with why gold and silver are ripping and why they're at all
- 8:09time highs. But I also think that lines up
- 8:12with why the S&P 500 is at all time highs, because it's really
- 8:14the mag 7 that's at all time highs and carrying the rest of
- 8:17the S&P 500. And I think market participants
- 8:20are rightfully thinking of those top seven companies, top ten
- 8:25companies as basically safe haven plays.
- 8:27Like I think Google is a relatively safe play if you're a
- 8:30large allocator, Apple, maybe to a lesser extent NVIDIA, but I
- 8:34don't think the US government's going to allow these things to
- 8:36fail, right? And I think market participants
- 8:38are pricing that in as well, while not wanting to go into
- 8:41something that doesn't have cash flow, something like a gold or a
- 8:43silver while Bitcoin being young, still being young is not
- 8:49being treated as a safe haven asset.
- 8:52And that kind of makes sense. Like if you don't hold self
- 8:54custody Bitcoin, I think it's really easy to think of it as a
- 8:58high risk tech stock play. Like I the reason I think a
- 9:01Bitcoin is a safe haven is because it's so tangible in self
- 9:04custody. But if you never actually feel
- 9:06that, if you never actually see the core value prop of Bitcoin
- 9:10as being able to spend and save it without permission, then I
- 9:13think it's really easy to think of it as a risk on asset.
- 9:16And then the last piece you mentioned, which is a lot of
- 9:21trading nowadays because we live in this digital world of social
- 9:24media and like people used to like joke around about the 24
- 9:27hour news cycle. Like now it's like a 2 hour news
- 9:29cycle. Like we really live in a
- 9:31momentum world and it feels like something broke in October.
- 9:37Specifically in the shit coin markets.
- 9:40And that chart, if you look at the chart, I'm not a big chart
- 9:43guy, but if you look at the chart of gold, silver, S&P 500,
- 9:46Bitcoin, you can literally see October 10th when the shit coin
- 9:50market had its apocalypse. And I think the rumors are true
- 9:54that at least one big market maker.
- 9:56I mean, the big rumor is Wintermute got absolutely
- 9:59wrecked on that on that day and has been unloading Bitcoin
- 10:03because that's like the only thing they have of value to to
- 10:06liquidate. So I think it's a combination of
- 10:09all those things. But I will say that I thought I
- 10:13would always be happy with Bitcoin at 88 K, but seeing gold
- 10:17and so silver, silver sparked particularly, it's like what is
- 10:20like Bitcoin silver to silver silver, like it's ridiculous.
- 10:24I don't it's it's really hard to wrap your head around it and it
- 10:27feels like a kick in the nuts. And I think that's part of the
- 10:29reason why people's attitudes are just, it feels like a deep
- 10:33bear market, even though we're in, we're not really in one.
- 10:37Yeah, the theme of this pod, it won't get the click, so we can't
- 10:40use it. But as a I'm tired boss, because
- 10:42that's why I was glad for you to, to come on so we can just
- 10:45like catch up on everything that's going on.
- 10:47Because like, how much can you just keep talking about with
- 10:50price sitting at 80 to 100K and you got like every bank stepping
- 10:53into the into BTC and the price is like relatively flat.
- 10:57I need to find that that chart you reference because I think I
- 11:01shared it. I think maybe shared we're
- 11:03looking at it with Marty. I think that might be why Marty
- 11:05didn't end up showing is because he might have gotten blown up in
- 11:07the shit coin markets and he's trying to figure out.
- 11:09Oh, serious note, though, that is a huge aspect that most
- 11:12people don't remember in 22. The only reason we knew FTX blew
- 11:16up was because the leak financials, whoever leaked the
- 11:20audit, and then that's when they had the run and basically
- 11:22everything else fell apart. So right now, nobody's out there
- 11:26speaking up or incentivized. But if something like that
- 11:28happens, that's when everyone tide goes out and you find out
- 11:31who's naked and if you're actually Bitcoin is secure.
- 11:37I will say also though like you, you kind of alluded to this
- 11:40Michael, like the bank stepping in, whether it's the, you know,
- 11:43progress on the, the regulatory front, all the M&A that we've
- 11:48seen over the past several months.
- 11:49Like it does feel like, you know there is some sort of hand off
- 11:53going on in terms of, you know, in past cycles, you know,
- 11:58entering a bear market like those, those deals or excitement
- 12:04around the industry completely disappeared, right?
- 12:06Like people retreated from their stance around getting involved
- 12:11with digital assets or Bitcoin, and we're seeing the opposite of
- 12:14that right now. Like, despite what the price has
- 12:16done sort of, you know, past six months or so, like the the
- 12:20banks, the fintechs, traditional sort of institutional incumbents
- 12:24are still, you know, putting their chips on the table, making
- 12:27moves to the space because one, they've seen the client demand
- 12:30and they know that assets are leaving their platforms to get
- 12:32exposure in other ways if they don't offer it.
- 12:35And so like all that stuff is move moving in One Direction,
- 12:38which is like extremely constructive and positive, which
- 12:41is just very different from sort of like past entries into a
- 12:45proverbial bear. When it comes to holding
- 12:47Bitcoin. Securely Peace of Mind starts
- 12:49with architecture on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 12:52distributes control across three independent regulated key
- 12:55holders and a two of three quorum.
- 12:58No single point of failure, No pooled or omnibus exposure.
- 13:01Segregated client titled faults. You retain full legal ownership
- 13:06while on Ramp coordinates security, compliance and
- 13:08operational workflows behind the scenes.
- 13:11It's strength of money delivered through the simplicity of one
- 13:14both the institution custody is the foundation for everything.
- 13:17We build sound infrastructure that distributes counterparty
- 13:19risk and provides fault tolerant resilience with clear audits and
- 13:22institutional controls. And now on Ramp is piloting
- 13:26flat, predictable pricing, making best in class Bitcoin
- 13:30custody and financial services more accessible now than ever on
- 13:34ramp strength of many simplicity in one.
- 13:37To learn more, check out on rampbitcoin.com.
- 13:40Yeah. I mean, maybe this is a good
- 13:42segue into we talked about this a lot, like how many people are
- 13:47actually holding spot Bitcoin today.
- 13:50And when this thing rallies, it's going to be very spiteful
- 13:53and people are going to be very upset.
- 13:56Between ETFs, digital asset treasury companies and
- 13:59everything else that's hanging out there, people that are
- 14:02around in 20/17/2020, a lot of people have been shaking out of
- 14:05the market, whether it was blocked by FTX selling digital
- 14:09asset treasury companies gold. And so you're going to see the
- 14:13market take the longest path. And then when it rips,
- 14:15everyone's going to be off sides.
- 14:16And we already see this now with the sentiment because people,
- 14:18it's just kind of like dead out there.
- 14:22So the question to Matt is how are your dad dad trades this
- 14:26year going? I mean the joke is because most
- 14:33people suck at trading. Like 99% suck at trading.
- 14:36We're just waiting for that one listener who's rotates his
- 14:38entire position into gold and then we'll start ripping.
- 14:42I you, you mentioned DATS, which a horrible acronym.
- 14:47I don't know Bitcoin treasury company, digital asset treasury
- 14:49companies, because now they have like a theory of mid Z cash
- 14:53ones. I think that's also part of the
- 14:56reason why sentiment is, is so bad right now is because, you
- 15:02know, in 2017, Ethereum was born.
- 15:04Like I guess in 2015 or 20/14/2017 was like really
- 15:08Ethereum's big year. We had like the Bitcoin Cash
- 15:12stuff, like Bitcoin was a little bit chaotic.
- 15:14Icos were happening. It seemed like, I mean, at least
- 15:19from my perspective, it seemed like I was a crazy person or an
- 15:21idiot and I was sidelined and I was missing out on all these,
- 15:24you know, generational games. And then the water came out and
- 15:28they all got wrecked. And from that we had like this
- 15:32beautiful Bitcoin only Bitcoin maximus culture that kind of was
- 15:36born. And that to me, that was like
- 15:37the start of the the good old days.
- 15:39And they always joke around like you don't, you don't know you're
- 15:42in the good old days until after the good old days pass.
- 15:45And I think that the final, but it was, it was it's time
- 15:50sensitive, like it was never going to last.
- 15:51Bitcoin was going to continue to mature and that was going to
- 15:53disappear. But the final nail in the
- 15:56coffin, I think was the Bitcoin treasury companies.
- 15:59And why do I say that? Because between 2017 and maybe
- 16:03let's point to earlier this year or late last year, it was like
- 16:07we all got rich together and we all got poor together.
- 16:10And like you just had this great community that that was crazy
- 16:14with you and now it's like everyone's getting poor on
- 16:18different things and rich on different things.
- 16:20And it just splintered everybody.
- 16:22And so that's how you end up in a situation where we're what I
- 16:26think like 3035% down from all time highs, but some people are
- 16:30down like 95% because they had like a leveraged metaplanet
- 16:34position and it was leveraged on top of leverage and the water
- 16:37came out and they got absolutely wrecked.
- 16:40So I think that's part of the reason for the, the significant
- 16:44negative sentiment. And I also think that's probably
- 16:46part of the reason why we didn't go up as high as people
- 16:49expected, right? Because I think a lot of the
- 16:52retail that wasn't poor came into the treasury companies.
- 16:56They thought of it as like a time machine.
- 16:57This is something we see with investors all the time.
- 16:59They think they missed out. So they add additional risk on
- 17:03trying to catch up, probably catch up and they inevitably get
- 17:08wrecked. And I think think that was part
- 17:09of it. And I, I, and, and, and we just,
- 17:15it, it just, it took, it took a lot of the wind out of the sails
- 17:18of people buying Bitcoin, buying actual Bitcoin and, and moving,
- 17:22moving the price floor up because of that.
- 17:25It's a good recap on some of the sentiment and culture because
- 17:29something you just hit on is you reference like everyone in it
- 17:33together. So when it's down, you're down
- 17:35and then you're have memes about being down and then when it goes
- 17:38up, you're up together. You hit on 30% down and 80 or
- 17:4299% down. You didn't hit on the people
- 17:45that made money, right? That are like rich behind the
- 17:47scenes that got into whatever any of these deals exited.
- 17:51But then also the quote UN quote influencers that got involved
- 17:55because now they can't say anything because they basically
- 17:58shepherd folks into this like, you know, Slaughteringhouse.
- 18:03So you have like to your point, different lanes that everyone's
- 18:06in versus like everyone's just along this underlying asset.
- 18:09And so it's created kind of like a structural from a cultural
- 18:11perspective, fragmentation. We don't have to go deep on the
- 18:15Dats, but I do have to bring. I just brought it up because we
- 18:18have listeners that listen every week, but then they keep
- 18:20commenting in the the YouTube comments about like how sailor
- 18:26lives rent free and that like we're idiots.
- 18:28And I'm like, guys, we're just trying to help you like not lose
- 18:31your shirts. It has nothing to do.
- 18:32But they listen every week. So I just wanted to make sure we
- 18:34touched on how how positive and constructive Dats are for the.
- 18:38I mean like sailors. Sailors selling his own stock
- 18:41for cash right now so. I didn't send you this.
- 18:45Last night. I was, I don't know if you guys
- 18:48seen this. I'm I'm shocked and bringing it
- 18:50up, but I was scrolling Twitter and there was a first time I've
- 18:53ever seen a strategy B strategy with the B.
- 18:57Like a a business intelligence ad.
- 18:59A business intelligence ad and I was like, is this how desperate
- 19:03is this? Like a back, this is like a
- 19:04roundabout way to market to retail and equity because like
- 19:08everyone knows they don't have a business intelligent product
- 19:10that's has any competitive mode or value.
- 19:14Yeah, it's very interesting what's going on over there.
- 19:17I yeah, I don't know. I mean, you mentioned like the
- 19:20people that exited, like I just don't think there actually were
- 19:24that many people that did. I think, I think part of the
- 19:28reason sentiment is down and the fracture of the community is
- 19:31that all these like BS tier influencers, low A tier
- 19:36influencers, like all joined boards.
- 19:39They like all joined the treasury Board.
- 19:42Almost everybody did, which is fucking insane.
- 19:44And then started showing you their stock.
- 19:47Like they made a potentially, they made comp like they got
- 19:49like a salary that they got some, you know, you know, they,
- 19:54they, they, they got some bread out of.
- 19:57And the worst part was like, they pretend like, oh, this is
- 19:59good for Bitcoin. I'm doing it for Bitcoin.
- 20:00It's like, no, look, you're doing it to, you know, to get
- 20:04your bread. You're doing it to, to, to get
- 20:06get a payout for your years of Twitter posting.
- 20:09It's fine, just admit what it is.
- 20:12But I think a lot of, you know, these guys also invested in the
- 20:15stocks and stuff and there was maybe a one month, 2 month
- 20:19period where like the M Nas were really ripping and I bet you a
- 20:24lot of them doubled down rather than actually taking profits.
- 20:27I think. I mean, I was skeptical on a lot
- 20:30of that and publicly skeptical on a lot of that.
- 20:32But even I thought like, they were going to have like, at
- 20:36least one good pump out of it. You know, then the pump never
- 20:39came. Like, they were all like setting
- 20:41up for the bull cycle that never arrived.
- 20:45And then the water all got pulled out.
- 20:48So I think a lot of people, lot of people got wrecked.
- 20:51And that also adds more downward Bitcoin pressure because I think
- 20:55there's been a lot of eyes on whether or not like Sailor sells
- 20:58his Bitcoin, which I think is, you know, I think it's probably
- 21:01overstated. And you know, they're well
- 21:04capitalized, especially now that he is stacking dollars.
- 21:07So I don't really think, I don't expect, you know, a complete
- 21:10failure of MicroStrategy to bring down the rest of market.
- 21:12But what people don't realize is a lot of the holders of the
- 21:15treasury companies were leveraged themselves.
- 21:17And so when their margin calls come due, what do they have to
- 21:20sell to to to meet that margin requirement?
- 21:23They have to sell Bitcoin to cover that, which brings Bitcoin
- 21:26down, which brings their treasury company further down.
- 21:28And you have this vicious negative feedback loop.
- 21:32Yeah, we've seen that you referenced sometimes.
- 21:38So like the notion of pattern recognition, it matters being
- 21:43alive in this space. And there's every couple years
- 21:48you reference the Icos and then there was like Defy in that
- 21:51summer and then the DAC crazy. You just there's always
- 21:53something that comes out of nowhere you can't expect and it
- 21:56just steals people's bitcoins. So like that's just helpful if
- 21:59you, you know, if you're, it's truly they just take takes
- 22:01people's Bitcoin because people also don't recognize if you're
- 22:03not buying Bitcoin with your dollars, you're buying this.
- 22:05It's still the same thing whether you're selling it or
- 22:07converting. But then I think we both came to
- 22:09this independently because I I heard you reference it.
- 22:11I think I shared internally that I knew it was a scammer or
- 22:15didn't make any sense when it started when I started thinking,
- 22:18am I missing out? Am I crazy?
- 22:19Because that was the ICO stuff like when IC OS were ripping.
- 22:22You're just looking at it like, do I get in and those white
- 22:25papers were floating around in 17 and you're like, do I you
- 22:27know the Excel spreadsheets and you're putting allocations and
- 22:30then you feel crazy for a little bit until the market falls out
- 22:34and you're like, Oh yeah, that was better just to stay in cold
- 22:36storage and relax. And that was like the aha moment
- 22:40is like, yes, don't even touch the stove because once you touch
- 22:43the stove, that's when or not touch the stove.
- 22:44But once you like put your bags, you you load your bags, even
- 22:47partially, you just become a bag holder and then you go down with
- 22:51the ship because people hate to invest in something and then
- 22:53tell you that they were wrong. Yep, no, I think there's a lot
- 22:58of similarities cycle to cycle. Once again, I don't know if this
- 23:01is an actual cycle. It's it's just a really, it's
- 23:04been a it's been a weird year. It's been a, it's been a very
- 23:08weird year. That chart, you did pull up the
- 23:10chart. It's crazy.
- 23:11Like you look at the I mean there, I think there there could
- 23:15be an alternative timeline where the shit coin casino doesn't
- 23:17blow up like crazy and you know, we're sitting at new all time
- 23:22highs right now. But then also, you know, shit
- 23:26coins are like they'll be around forever and people like doing
- 23:30degenerate things and it's always going to be a case.
- 23:33You just have to you have to play this game.
- 23:35This is such a long term game and there's so much survivorship
- 23:38bias. You only see the winners.
- 23:40Quick question because Jackson has a bunch of he he prepped
- 23:43very heavily for this. I told not to because Matt will
- 23:45not look at your notes. I'm just joking.
- 23:48But I do want to ask one thing to put you on the spot.
- 23:50What is an example of an A tier influencer versus a beer AB tier
- 23:55influencer? Can you give us you feel
- 23:57comfortable giving an example of that?
- 23:59Because I I thought they were all like C tier but.
- 24:04You don't have to. I mean, I, I mean, I think
- 24:08Sailors probably an A tier influencer.
- 24:11I think Mallard's with XXI is probably an A tier influencer.
- 24:17I think Dylan Leclair with Metaplanet was probably an A
- 24:21tier. And then I think everyone else
- 24:23wasn't pretty much. And it's like every and you even
- 24:29saw with the treasury companies, right.
- 24:30It was like I'm joining like Arange, we're like doing
- 24:34Brazilian micro strategies. Like what the fuck?
- 24:37Like what are you doing? You know, we're like, I don't
- 24:41know, similar scientific. It's like, are you kidding me?
- 24:44But they can't get access to our capital markets, Matt, like they
- 24:47can't get access to Bitcoin. And for the narrative, narrative
- 24:51wise, right, It's like narrative wise on the Bitcoin maximalism
- 24:55culture, Bitcoin only culture. It's like, what's the difference
- 24:57between Semler and Solana? Like how like I, I don't know
- 25:03how you can really justify it. At least with Solana, I think
- 25:07that you can do things with it, I guess, right?
- 25:09Like you can be a degenerate and, and, and do decks things or
- 25:14like buy tether or something, but it's just, I think, I think
- 25:19it broke the culture. I think it very much broke the
- 25:23culture and it is what it is. It was probably going to happen
- 25:26regardless, like I said, but at the end of the day, that was
- 25:29that was the nail in the head of the of the online Bitcoin
- 25:33culture at least. Yeah, one of the funny things
- 25:38about all that conversation is the whole narrative around can
- 25:43access. You cannot access Bitcoin right?
- 25:45Like, oh, we need an equity structure, a debt structure to.
- 25:48Invest in every country. Is is crazy, like once you
- 25:52actually think a little bit more about it?
- 25:53Because on face value, I can understand why some people could
- 25:57perceive that to be true, but it's just a matter of creating
- 26:02new parameters or investment mandates to allow it to allocate
- 26:06directly into Bitcoin. Like it's not, We have this
- 26:09conversation early on in the business.
- 26:11It's like trying to explain to an institutional allocator, oh,
- 26:13does Bitcoin fit into a, a venture type of investment?
- 26:16Is it a real asset? Is it, you know, how do you
- 26:19think about investing in Bitcoin?
- 26:20And the answer is, well, you just think about it as its own
- 26:23asset class. It's really not that hard.
- 26:25And so I think one of the biggest issues with all of this
- 26:27is you don't necessarily need to, you don't necessarily need
- 26:31to try to fit Bitcoin into an existing bucket.
- 26:33You can allocate to it directly. And we're actually seeing that,
- 26:36right, but more so through the ETFs in the US.
- 26:39But to think that we all of a sudden need a bunch of companies
- 26:42to provide equity exposure to the underlying asset is just
- 26:46very flawed thinking in my opinion.
- 26:48Well, I mean, no, I mean it was, it was just a lie like that was
- 26:52that was the big lie, right? The big lie was I am joining the
- 26:56board of this treasury company because I want to sell Bitcoin
- 27:00to institutions. But the only reason the treasury
- 27:02company wanted a podcaster on the board in the 1st place is
- 27:05because retail was the market. The entire market was retail.
- 27:09If you, if you, if you look at and, and this is, this is just
- 27:13the case, probably probably MicroStrategy the least so.
- 27:17But even then, when you, when you look at how Sailor presents
- 27:20himself and his public appearances, it's all for
- 27:23retail. It's almost overwhelmingly for
- 27:25retail. You know, you like retweets, the
- 27:28MicroStrategy podcast and everything, like everything is,
- 27:31is you'll never sell your Bitcoin.
- 27:32It's all for retail. And, and that that was just the
- 27:39reality of the situation. Like they pretended it was for
- 27:41institutions because they had to in terms of the narrative, but
- 27:45they were focused on retail. And if you look at the best
- 27:48calls this year, it was actually institutions fading it, right?
- 27:54It was Jim Chanos. Everyone made fun of Jim when he
- 27:57came out and he was like, I'm going short Microstrategy's M
- 28:00NAV and they were like, but it's already under 2.
- 28:02Like how much lower could it go? Fucking nailed that trade.
- 28:05He went long Bitcoin short MicroStrategy harvested the loss
- 28:10of M NAV premium Sailor played right into it dumping
- 28:13continuously dumping common during the whole process.
- 28:17And then the other one, which is what conspiracy theories are
- 28:20made of of JP deleveraging their books on MicroStrategy and
- 28:23spring. They've nailed that one too.
- 28:27They were right. I mean, there's I think there's
- 28:30a decent argument that they helped cause how quickly it
- 28:34unravelled. But if they were like looking at
- 28:36their books and MicroStrategy sitting at a huge premium and
- 28:40they have a bunch of, they have a bunch of holders that are
- 28:43holding large leverage positions, like it makes sense
- 28:46that you want to deleverage that risk and you want to reduce that
- 28:48risk on your books. That's what they were known for
- 28:50during the last financial collapse.
- 28:52Fortress balance sheet. Yeah.
- 28:55I mean, look, the dad holders are down.
- 28:58We don't have to keep layered on.
- 29:00The point though, was just to call just, I mean, we're
- 29:03recapping, but also I think they will come back in some respect
- 29:08to the bitcoins price and to the the extent somebody listens and,
- 29:12and just like really does their diligence, they never made any
- 29:15sense. But the last heuristic that I'll
- 29:17leave you guys with, unless you have something else is that you
- 29:19generally know something's a scam or a cult if you need a
- 29:22community, because the investments don't generally need
- 29:25communities. They happen organically.
- 29:28You don't have to like try to propagate 1.
- 29:31And so that's like one of those flags that you kind of you were
- 29:33referencing about you have to get an influencer to to
- 29:36propagate or amplify your business.
- 29:40I mean they will come back because Bitcoin is going to come
- 29:43back like Bitcoin is unless quantum unless.
- 29:47Quantum And then we were wrong and it was really gold.
- 29:49It was really the trade with gold I.
- 29:51Mean we could talk about that, but I mean we probably look, I
- 29:56think people should stay amble stack sets, learn how to hold
- 30:00actual Bitcoin and use real Bitcoin.
- 30:02But like we could be close to the bottom of some of these
- 30:06Bitcoin treasury companies just because they've been absolutely
- 30:10hammered and I think a lot of investors are questioning
- 30:13Bitcoin itself and they hold Bitcoin and Bitcoin will
- 30:16perform. Now, the question, as I think
- 30:18you have to actually ask yourself as someone who's
- 30:22already listening to a Bitcoin show, if you're listening right
- 30:24now, is do they outperform Bitcoin, right?
- 30:28Because that's the opportunity cost.
- 30:30They'll look great on paper. Even if they just go back up
- 30:33with Bitcoin, will those premiums happen?
- 30:35Because that's how you should actually be thinking about these
- 30:38things, is you are taking additional risk over holding
- 30:43spot Bitcoin, holding real Bitcoin.
- 30:45And that additional risk should be rewarded with some kind of
- 30:48premium in the future. And I really question the
- 30:51ability of the smaller ones to actually be able to accrue any
- 30:55kind of real premium. There's an argument that a
- 30:58company like MicroStrategy that has 650,000 Bitcoin will figure
- 31:01out a way to harvest yield off of that or, you know, leverage
- 31:04their position somehow to make real substantial gains.
- 31:09But the smaller ones, like they're just zombie companies
- 31:12that hold a real asset. Yeah.
- 31:16If you use the analogy of the the ICO going back to that,
- 31:18right, like a lot of those Icos just never got anywhere close to
- 31:21recovering to where they previously were in 2017.
- 31:24So I think it's fair to say, Matt, what what you just said, I
- 31:27think is incredibly accurate, right.
- 31:29Like there's going to be assuming Bitcoin comes back,
- 31:31which we could talk about Quantum for sure.
- 31:34But I think we're all quite bullish going into the the long
- 31:37term here. Assuming Bitcoin does come back
- 31:40then yeah, I mean, some of these companies are going to are going
- 31:43to look strong, but some of them are just never going to come
- 31:45back at all. And so that's where I like, I
- 31:47wonder how much retail interests are actually will be in the
- 31:50future because so many people came in and that like May, June
- 31:54timeline where things were just like crazy.
- 31:57Everyone was like fervishly bullish on the treasury
- 32:00companies. And a lot of people got wrecked.
- 32:01And I don't know if they're going to want to ever park
- 32:03Capital back in some of those trades.
- 32:06Yeah. I just wonder how much new
- 32:08retail really came in. I think we just didn't really
- 32:11see a retail surge. And I think part of the reason
- 32:13is because everyone's poor. I think it's just I really do
- 32:17think we're just in a quiet global depression.
- 32:20The one aspect I would mention it well, two things.
- 32:23First, the fact that you said assume bitcoins coming back is
- 32:26like the most bullish fucking fundamentals is how bearish
- 32:31sentiment is right now. Like literally on a Bitcoin
- 32:33show, you work for a Bitcoin company and and we're just we're
- 32:37caveating Bitcoin recovering well.
- 32:41Some people don't think that it's going to happen, so that's
- 32:43why I had to say. That fair enough and then the
- 32:45second the second thing is the shareholders of the ICO
- 32:49promoters actually did quite well like EO says Block 1 is
- 32:52still one of the largest holders of Bitcoin period.
- 32:55It's just you got no rights to that Bitcoin as an ICO
- 32:59participant, which ironically you don't actually have rights
- 33:02for a lot of these treasury companies, but you kind of, do,
- 33:05you know, it's like a little bit wishy washy there, but you're
- 33:08still a shareholder of the company that's holding the
- 33:10Bitcoin. Let's before, because there's a
- 33:13lot of recap stuff, but this just popped up because Matt's
- 33:17not on Twitter and I I was looking in this deal.
- 33:21I think it's a very like prescient note.
- 33:24I guess you had somewhere it says Bitcoin's been running for
- 33:2617 years at a protocol level. No transaction has ever been
- 33:29blocked. No coin ever sees.
- 33:30Not enough people appreciate the magnitude.
- 33:34I think this is important to tie into this like narrative that's
- 33:37happening in Quantum. But before going there, we
- 33:39brought something similar up when it comes to stable coins
- 33:41because that's like obviously the, you know, block chain of
- 33:44this year, everyone's excited about it.
- 33:46And when you really breakdown the mechanics of stable coins,
- 33:49like obviously they provide value and moving dollars around
- 33:52the world, but the reality is how much counterparty risk, how
- 33:55much mechanics go into that. And it really brings the light
- 33:58like the elegance of Bitcoin that there's no intermediary and
- 34:01you can move billions of dollars without any counterparty.
- 34:03And so that aspect, I think from like all this narrative, whether
- 34:07it's MSTR, that's ETFs, it gets lost on most people because it's
- 34:12still a speculative exposure for most.
- 34:15And when you start talking about like this narrative quantum and
- 34:19the, the, the notion of changing soft hard fork.
- 34:23And just like the, I don't know if aloofness is the right word,
- 34:26but like the, the casualness of like, we can just change things
- 34:29really quickly and it's not a big deal.
- 34:31And we can freeze people's coins and others are like, yeah, of
- 34:33course we can do it. It's, it's just, it makes zero
- 34:36sense. And so maybe we can just touch
- 34:39on that because I think that's, that's something that a lot of
- 34:41people honest or honestly, this ties into why most, it's so hard
- 34:45for people to get exposure to Bitcoin.
- 34:47Because think about it, if the hardcore people that have been
- 34:50around forever cannot wrap their heads around Quantum, how the
- 34:54hell can we expect everyone else to ape into BTC as their store
- 34:59of value moving forward? It's.
- 35:01We believe it is, but there's still a large gap for most, and
- 35:05this is a huge. This is an easy example of that.
- 35:08Yeah, I mean, a couple of things here.
- 35:10First of all, I posted that on Noster or screenshot it.
- 35:13What's that shared to shared to X?
- 35:16Noster is an open protocol for speech and identity.
- 35:19You can think of it like the Bitcoin version of Twitter.
- 35:24And the easiest way to join Noster is to download Primal in
- 35:27your favorite App Store. But I yeah, the quantum thing,
- 35:34first of all, talking to large capital allocators like it is
- 35:37something that's on top of people's minds and no one
- 35:40understands it. I don't really understand it
- 35:42either. But I think it's, you know, you
- 35:44can think of it as like a magic computer that breaks
- 35:47cryptography and it's theoretical and we haven't
- 35:51actually seen it in, you know, used in any practical way.
- 35:56But one of the scary things about quantum is that there's a
- 36:00strong incentive specifically for governments to be doing
- 36:04quantum research in secret behind the scenes because you
- 36:07can, you can, you can potentially break encrypted
- 36:11messaging and other things that rely on cryptography of your
- 36:14adversaries, right? So specifically the Chinese or
- 36:17the Americans. And on top of that, the, the,
- 36:23the relatively correct belief, I think that that AI leaps have
- 36:27pushed, you know, innovation timelines across the board where
- 36:31we, you don't really know what, what could happen in five or ten
- 36:34years or 15 years. Now there's a couple of
- 36:36different pieces here on the quantum side.
- 36:39The first piece is like, will my Bitcoin be stolen?
- 36:42I don't think that's a real fear.
- 36:44I think if you're using the best practices in terms of custody
- 36:49and you're using said what addresses that are hashed and
- 36:53you're not reusing addresses, you're, you're pretty well
- 36:56protected against quantum in the next 5 to 20 years or something
- 37:00like that. Now, I don't think that's a
- 37:05reasonable answer for people like if you're like a large
- 37:08allocator, you're thinking about like allocating $10 million and
- 37:10you're like, oh, I don't really think it's that big of an issue.
- 37:12No, they want like tangible solutions, right?
- 37:14And so I think what we what we need to do as on a protocol
- 37:19level is offer people a, you know, even more hardened kind of
- 37:23quantum resistant address type that people can choose to go to
- 37:27in an opt in basis. I think that will help at least
- 37:30on the narrative side. I don't know how important to
- 37:32that is, but might as well do it.
- 37:34It doesn't really hurt. Then the second piece is like
- 37:37this fascination beyond what happens to the particularly
- 37:41vulnerable Bitcoin that is not in the newer address type.
- 37:46And those are the older coins. And meme wise, the best way to
- 37:49look at it is like Satoshi's coins, right?
- 37:51Because Satoshi has like a million of them and then there's
- 37:53like 4 million others. But he's, he's the creator of
- 37:57the protocol. And that's a lot of Bitcoin.
- 38:00And it's this really, really weird fascination about not
- 38:03allowing that to get dumped on the market.
- 38:08But I think it's, it's very, very short sighted and I think
- 38:11as a community or as a stakeholders, because it's
- 38:16supposedly communities are scamming, according to Michael,
- 38:18as, as stakeholders of Bitcoin, I think it's important that we
- 38:21nip that in the bud because the key value prop of Bitcoin is
- 38:24that at the protocol level, no funds have ever been seized.
- 38:28No fund, no transaction has ever been blocked.
- 38:30Now, yes, people can always coerce you into giving them your
- 38:33private key. Governments can come and raid
- 38:35your house, put a gun to your head, threaten you with jail
- 38:38time, take your, take your Bitcoin private key physically.
- 38:40We can't avoid that, but on a protocol level, the fact that
- 38:43this thing's been running for 17 years without any protocol level
- 38:46seizures or any protocol level censorship is the fundamental
- 38:50value that and that is insane that that was that, that we've
- 38:54been successful with that. Like I don't think people really
- 38:56appreciate how amazing that is that that's we, we don't see
- 39:00anything like that in the digital realm.
- 39:01We've never seen anything like that in the digital realm.
- 39:04And so you're kind of it's, it's a classic example where the
- 39:07quote UN quote cure is worse than the disease, right?
- 39:10You're throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
- 39:12And I just, I'm not like I the, the big thought process I tell
- 39:16the people is like, OK, so like sailor has 650,000 Bitcoin.
- 39:19What is more likely is what is Is it more likely that that some
- 39:24genius creates a magic computer that steals Satoshi's Bitcoin?
- 39:28Or that the US government steals sailors Bitcoin?
- 39:31And in and and why? And in that situation, will we
- 39:35freeze the Bitcoin if the US government stole sailors
- 39:37Bitcoin? No, and we definitely wouldn't
- 39:39preemptively steal it. And why would, if the Navy Seals
- 39:43or Delta Force or whatever figured out where Satoshi was
- 39:46and charged him with money laundering and raided his house
- 39:49and forced him to give him the million Bitcoin and then put it
- 39:53in the SPR, would most of Bitcoin Twitter be cheering that
- 39:56on? But God forbid someone comes up
- 40:00with a magic computer and takes a million Bitcoin that way like
- 40:03that. Just, it's just like there's a
- 40:04complete, there's, there's a complete lack of logic there.
- 40:09And at the end of the day, I think you just, you let it be.
- 40:12We put an opt in, we put an opt in address type.
- 40:16We add protections going forward, which I which I'm very
- 40:19confident we will have. I think there's very strong
- 40:21consensus on it. We don't touch the old coin.
- 40:25If it gets stolen, it gets stolen.
- 40:26If it gets spent, it gets spent. If tomorrow Satoshi moved his
- 40:29Bitcoin, was that quantum attacker or was that Satoshi
- 40:31being like, I'm going to move my Bitcoin because you guys keep
- 40:33threatening me that you're going to take my Bitcoin?
- 40:36Like if he wanted to burn it, you could have sent it to a burn
- 40:38address. He did it.
- 40:40Yeah. So I was going to say a couple,
- 40:43couple bit lot there, but a couple things off the bat, like
- 40:47the notion of like, you know, the random person creating the
- 40:50quantum computer in their basement, like that's not even
- 40:52really like a realistic path, right?
- 40:54Like the whatever a theoretical quantum computer looks like with
- 40:58the whatever it is like million stable qubits like that will
- 41:05require such an insane amount of, you know, capital
- 41:08expenditure, energy infrastructure that it really
- 41:11could only come from like the Chinese government or the US
- 41:14government. And in that scenario, like, are
- 41:16they just going to market dump the coins if they were to even,
- 41:19you know, go through with some sort of action?
- 41:22That's that's one side. The other thing I was going to
- 41:26say about all of this is like the Matt, I'd be curious if you
- 41:29could like opine a little bit around like the work that has
- 41:32been going on for years around this stuff.
- 41:34Like it's not like the development community hasn't
- 41:37been thinking about this. And I think that's the problem
- 41:39with some of the more recent discourse that's a little bit
- 41:42more on the the fear mongering side of like imminent threat
- 41:45that, you know, the timelines have compressed whatever, you
- 41:48know, however you want to phrase it.
- 41:50But there aren't, there is people thinking about this and
- 41:52there's work being done and there's potential dips.
- 41:55And like there is a path similar to what you described where, you
- 41:58know, you have a new address type and you give people time to
- 42:00to migrate and, you know, probably err on the side.
- 42:04I would agree with you. Like, I don't think you can, you
- 42:06can do anything to those more vulnerable coins without sort of
- 42:11sacrificing some ethos of, of the network and, and why it
- 42:13exists. But maybe just for the audience,
- 42:15like where are we in terms of some of those dips that exist?
- 42:18And like why I guess, you know, why is it important to know that
- 42:23just because if you do end up in this like fear mongering stage
- 42:26like that can be counterproductive to the
- 42:28existing work that's already been going on.
- 42:30Yeah. I mean, I think there's a couple
- 42:33of things here. First of all, you said like what
- 42:35would the attacker do with the million Bitcoin?
- 42:37Maybe they create a debt, you know, like maybe we can trade it
- 42:40publicly. We'll compete with micro
- 42:42strategy. Quantum Debt.
- 42:44I I mean, you, it's really hard to see how there's a bunch of
- 42:48startups, by the way, that could potentially in collaboration
- 42:52with the government, you know, find this magic computer.
- 42:59But like it's hard for them to monetize quantum in any kind of
- 43:02real way except for attacking Bitcoin or espionage against
- 43:05foreign governments. Like there's only really two
- 43:08obvious ways of and, and like you said, once they have it,
- 43:12like are they going to tank the price of Bitcoin or they're
- 43:14going to try and monetize their investment to the fullest in
- 43:18terms of quantum research? Yeah, this has been top of mind
- 43:21for years, like for a long, long time.
- 43:25In the most recent term, it's like early fall, there was a
- 43:29there was a big quantum focus event with top developers in the
- 43:33space at Presidio Bitcoin in San Francisco.
- 43:38Blockstream Research released a great paper like last week.
- 43:42I think a lot of the alarmist tendencies are twofold.
- 43:45First of all, it's great for engagement.
- 43:47People want their star to rise so they, you know, create create
- 43:52panic and rage. I think the second thing is if
- 43:56your obsession is to block, to freeze Bitcoin preemptively,
- 44:00steal Bitcoin preemptively. By the way, the only way you can
- 44:03do this is preemptively. Like you can't do it after the
- 44:05fact. In terms of stopping someone
- 44:07from taking someone's Bitcoin that's already vulnerable after
- 44:11the fact. You have to do it preemptively.
- 44:13If that's the goal, then there actually is probably a little
- 44:16bit of a rush. If the goal is to, to, to slowly
- 44:21and conservatively move to improvements, then there's not
- 44:24that much of A rush. Like we're in a very good spot
- 44:26right now, particularly if you're using Bitcoin with best
- 44:30practices. And, and I, I, we have to be
- 44:35very careful because if you're rushing, if you, if we move
- 44:40everybody's Bitcoin, if we tell everyone they have to move their
- 44:43Bitcoin to a novel new signature scheme that's supposedly quantum
- 44:47resistant, otherwise their coin gets stolen.
- 44:52Like that can be an attack vector in itself, like that
- 44:55could have a back door. We could completely fuck that
- 44:57up. We can ruin the entire Bitcoin
- 44:59experiment right there and then. So you have to be very careful
- 45:02and deliberate. But if the, if the concern is
- 45:05we, you know, we're going to have to give people five years
- 45:07time, 10 years time to do this, blah, blah, blah, Then you start
- 45:10to feel, you start to feel the rush and you start to feel the
- 45:13panic because they want to freeze people's Bitcoin.
- 45:15So I think that's where it, a lot of it comes from.
- 45:18It's not actually from people worrying about their own
- 45:20Bitcoin. But once again, I'll repeat like
- 45:23when has anyone like who, who buys Bitcoin and is concerned
- 45:28that someone else's Bitcoin is going to get stolen and then
- 45:31might get sold? It's like a ridiculous concept.
- 45:33Imagine buying gold and being like, Oh well, a war might break
- 45:36out and the Russians might steal Chinese gold and dump it on the
- 45:40market. That's insane.
- 45:41Like you do you mind your own fucking business and let the
- 45:46market dynamics play out as the market dynamics play out.
- 45:49Earlier this year, people were cheering on that the strategic
- 45:51Bitcoin reserve was going to be seeded with stolen Bitcoin.
- 45:54No one was like, let's fork out that Bitcoin.
- 45:59So OK, we set the stage really nicely because I didn't know if
- 46:03we're going to go here and this is a little bit, I'm not going
- 46:05to say I believe this, but I'm not going to say I don't believe
- 46:07this was a non zero chance. I don't say this is coordinated,
- 46:11but there is a narrative that's come up the past six months
- 46:13around this. And it it all the way to Ray
- 46:15Dalio, I believe, like citing quantum as an issue for his
- 46:18investment thesis in Bitcoin. And we already discussed human
- 46:23incentives when it comes to the economics.
- 46:26And so we talked about like the influencers and at the end of
- 46:29the day, there was economic incentives to do something that,
- 46:33you know, kind of fractured the the reality of some of these
- 46:36people and what they were about. So I'm prefacing that because if
- 46:39we look at what's happening today, in this past, call it 18
- 46:43months with ETFs and even Sailor, there's a centralization
- 46:47of BTC happening with a certain number of economic actors.
- 46:49We can call it BlackRock, Coinbase, maybe it's future JPM,
- 46:53Fidelity. And the point being is it makes
- 46:57sense on a trajectory perspective, if Bitcoins going
- 46:59to double or triple in price, if they sit on 25%, let's call it
- 47:0420% of the BTC today, that that would rationally be 30 to 40% in
- 47:09that future state. And if this narrative persists
- 47:13and everyone's economically or theoretically economically
- 47:16inclined to fork Bitcoin because we're afraid that somebody's
- 47:20going to dump our bags. And again, we don't care about
- 47:22the underlying, we just don't want our bags.
- 47:24That's like the, the, you know, it's always the, the solution.
- 47:26They create the problem and the solution.
- 47:29That is something that is interesting to me because this
- 47:32was coming up probably 6 months ago.
- 47:33I was having a conversation around like the fork wars and
- 47:36like B cash. And you know the the gentleman
- 47:40that is a friend, he was explaining how like Trace Mayer
- 47:42at the time saved his ass because he's like hey, in these
- 47:45like forums if you dump your B cash today, you can get .5 BTC
- 47:48at the time. And so, but this is the problem
- 47:52with giving up rights to your asset when you go into a third
- 47:56party custodian in an omnibus fashion or even an ETF, because
- 48:00they're going to make the decision for you.
- 48:02And it's already been called this past week by very notable
- 48:04people that like, well, this is not going to be a fork.
- 48:06They're not going to give you the option.
- 48:07We're just going to go to the thing that's quantum resistant.
- 48:10Like this is this early, that's already being talked about.
- 48:13And so I'm just curious like how you see that potentially playing
- 48:17out? Because part of this discussion
- 48:18was like, if you're a nation state and you're sitting on the
- 48:20right coin, you're holding it, you're like, well, I'm just
- 48:22going to dump all the fork and, you know, sell the the wrong
- 48:26Bitcoin, right, The thing that forked over.
- 48:28And so I think it's just an interesting angle because I
- 48:29definitely believe there's a non zero chance that, you know, 10
- 48:32years from 2017 when the original fork happened where we
- 48:35could see something like that. And this is the very early
- 48:38stages of that narrative beginning.
- 48:40Yeah. I mean, I think there's 22
- 48:41concerns here I have, right. I think the first concern is
- 48:45that we panic rush into insecure crypto.
- 48:51Crypto being cryptography, not shit coins.
- 48:54And I think it's important to realize that there's like this
- 48:57is so far above most of our heads.
- 49:00There's like 20 people. There's like 20 people that can
- 49:03like figure out, you know, novel new crypto schemes and whether
- 49:09or not they're secure or not. And even among those people,
- 49:11like the really way you find out if things are secure is by
- 49:15testing them over time. So it's not like that's not like
- 49:18the most easy process and it's why it should be opted in slowly
- 49:21and, and be very deliberate and very careful about it.
- 49:24So that's the first concern. And then in terms of the, the,
- 49:30you know, stealing, I, I'm not going to say freezing, it's
- 49:32stealing people's Bitcoin preemptively.
- 49:35Is it such a slippery slope? Like where, where does it end?
- 49:38Like do you if we can freeze vulnerable if we can, if we
- 49:44imagine saying like Bitcoin censorship resistant, except for
- 49:46the creator of Bitcoin, we stole his a million Bitcoin.
- 49:50If if you can do that, then why does North Korea have Bitcoin?
- 49:54Are we going to are we going to freeze North Korea's Bitcoin?
- 49:56Should we freeze the CCPs Bitcoin?
- 49:58Should we are terrorists using Bitcoin?
- 50:01Should we freeze their Bitcoin? If you're China, should we
- 50:05freeze micro strategies Bitcoin? And I think because of that, I
- 50:11think that fork will fail. I think it it probably, I think
- 50:16it's better for the industry if we just nip this in the bud
- 50:19quickly. But I think actually push comes
- 50:22to shove, like actually the time, like if this, if there was
- 50:25a fork presented, I think a lot of large allocators would be
- 50:30very hesitant about making a decisive move because bitcoins
- 50:36value is that it's a neutral asset that doesn't require
- 50:39trusted third parties. If we if, if, if, if you see the
- 50:44creators Bitcoin get frozen, like how safe is your Bitcoin,
- 50:48right? And I think people actually
- 50:50sitting down and thinking about this question will probably
- 50:52hedge themselves and they won't market dump one side, right?
- 50:58So like for instance, BlackRock, you know, they, they're holding
- 51:03it on behalf of the ETF holders, right?
- 51:06So it's not actually their Bitcoin, right?
- 51:08They're a fiduciary that's holding Bitcoin for their
- 51:10shareholders. Are they going to market dump on
- 51:15this type of fork if there's any type of questionable if, if
- 51:19there's any question in their mind of if it's the right
- 51:21decision, they probably won't, they'll probably sit tight, I
- 51:23think in that situation. And so then really kind of the
- 51:29market gets determined on the edges, right?
- 51:32And I think there's actually probably a lot more conviction
- 51:36on the side of property rights in in, in Bitcoin land.
- 51:40And one of the key things we have going for us on Bitcoin is
- 51:44that so much of the supply was distributed early to like very
- 51:47ideologically minded people. So I that are holding self
- 51:52custody, that can easily participate in this type of
- 51:55market that don't have to deal with boards that don't have to
- 51:58deal with fiduciary responsibility, that don't have
- 52:00to deal with potential liability from their actions.
- 52:03They can just make a decision and then all of a sudden it kind
- 52:07of looks similar to the B cash situation where you had a bunch
- 52:11of companies that had boards that had fiduciary
- 52:13responsibilities, that had potential liability concerns and
- 52:17teams of lawyers or whatever that were on the B cash side
- 52:19that didn't have conviction. And then you had the original
- 52:23chain of Bitcoin that was a lot of individual ideologically
- 52:26minded holders that had a lot of conviction.
- 52:29And that side was the side, that one, right?
- 52:32Yeah, I guess the the push back there would be and this is the
- 52:34way it was posited was that it would be much more hectic and
- 52:38chaotic to have basically 2 coins out there with an asset
- 52:41managers. And I mean part of the S1 is
- 52:43you're giving up all those rights to the issuer to to pick
- 52:46whichever for. Yeah, I mean that will suck for
- 52:48them and it would be fucking hilarious.
- 52:50I mean, that would be the the best part about the best part
- 52:53about the situation would be, and this is what I said about
- 52:56the non stuff too, which is like fortunately, like mostly behind
- 53:01us. But if they forked, it would
- 53:03have been great to see like the the large corporations have to
- 53:08deal with it, right? Like they're going to.
- 53:10It would suck for the users. It would suck for the
- 53:12shareholders and what not, who would learn a hard lesson on
- 53:18custodial risk. But it would be at least
- 53:21entertaining to to watch the chaos that unfolds.
- 53:23And of course, they don't want to see a fork, which is also
- 53:25probably why they shouldn't push it in the first place and might
- 53:28not even support it in the first place.
- 53:30Because like I said, I think there's pretty strong consensus
- 53:35that, OK, let's add very reasonable more quantum hardened
- 53:40crypto into Bitcoin and give people opt inability there the
- 53:43consent. I do not see consensus on
- 53:46freezing people's Bitcoin. And I think it just hurts us
- 53:49from a narrative point of view in the short term.
- 53:51But it's probably doesn't even matter that much.
- 53:53I just talk about it because people are curious about it.
- 54:01So we're not forking. I think they'll be forks in our
- 54:04future. Like absolutely.
- 54:07I also think it's interesting here, right?
- 54:09Because it, it does show that the whole soft fork versus hard
- 54:13fork thing was a little bit of a narrative SIOP propaganda thing
- 54:18because like technically proponents of this call this a
- 54:21soft fork because it is at the client level backwards
- 54:25compatible. But like, if a soft fork
- 54:29includes freezing the creator's Bitcoin and stealing it, like,
- 54:32is it really backwards compatible?
- 54:34Like, why not just hard fork? And I, I think that probably
- 54:39will open up a lot of people's eyes if they keep trying to push
- 54:42that narrative that it's, you know, a no risk, quote UN quote
- 54:46soft fork. Like a soft fork could just as
- 54:47easily result in a chain split as a hard fork.
- 54:49If anything a hard fork might be more less risky because at least
- 54:56like pre emptively you're like OK in a year there's going to be
- 54:58two chains and people can decide.
- 55:03Give us a lot to think about man.
- 55:05It's just funny because I feel like 6 months ago that the big
- 55:08conversation online was about core and knots and, and maybe
- 55:11that's still is the case, but it seems like it's muted compared
- 55:13to the quantum conversation now. And my gut instinct is that
- 55:20people are kind of looking for a reason to point to as to why
- 55:24this year shaped out the way that it did, right?
- 55:27And so I didn't really hear much about Quantum six months ago or
- 55:31at the start of the year. I didn't hear anything about it.
- 55:33And nothing's changed at the fundamental level for Bitcoin
- 55:36yet. I think expectations and
- 55:39sentiment is just so much in the gutter and people are grasping
- 55:42at narratives now to explain why that's the case.
- 55:46I mean, that's just like my left bell curve take.
- 55:49I I don't think anything necessarily changed from 6 to 12
- 55:53months ago. And if anything, it's just like
- 55:55the, the soup du jour of what can we get people worried about
- 55:59get them to sell their Bitcoin. And I don't know, I mean, I, I
- 56:03don't know much about it. I learned a good bit from this
- 56:06conversation, but I I particularly don't think that
- 56:08this is something that everyone needs to get their panties up in
- 56:11a bunch about and sell all their Bitcoin.
- 56:15It's the last remaining FUD, right?
- 56:16Like they they, you know, the Fudsters have really run out of
- 56:20narratives to to fuck Bitcoin. Like, well.
- 56:22This one is. The last remaining money.
- 56:24It's existently recycled. Yeah.
- 56:27Well, yeah, go. On I think, I think something
- 56:31hit me last night. I don't know how true this is,
- 56:33but it feels like it would happen.
- 56:34We're just going to end up with a a plethora of like quantum
- 56:37shit coins that are going to come out post this.
- 56:40We already have them. They're they already exist like
- 56:42this was this did happen in previous cycles, like this is
- 56:45not. They just never really had that
- 56:47much. I mean, what people don't
- 56:49realize by the way is like Ethereum and Solana, all these
- 56:52account based models are way, way, way more vulnerable to long
- 56:56range quantum attacks than Bitcoin is too, because they
- 56:59basically reuse addresses from a bitcoins point of view.
- 57:01That's like they reuse addresses by design, which is crazy.
- 57:06I will just say like on the independent, like on the larger
- 57:08capital allocator side, behind the scenes, we heard this
- 57:11question a lot previously, like 10:30.
- 57:15We heard this question so much that we put a blog on 10/31 in
- 57:18January of this year on Quantum and basically about how, you
- 57:23know, the best devs in the world are working on it.
- 57:25And we're not too concerned about it.
- 57:26And we kind of faded it, but we wanted A blog post out there so
- 57:30that we could just answer people like really easily, like, oh,
- 57:33here's, here's something tangible.
- 57:34You can go read. I, I, what I do think is
- 57:40fascinating, if you want to compare from six months ago, is
- 57:43it does seem like 6 months ago there was a concern you had like
- 57:48people that are, were pro Bitcoin soft forks.
- 57:52They wanted, you know, covenants or CTV and all this other stuff.
- 57:55And then you had the ossifiers. Like people like, oh, Bitcoin
- 57:58never should change ever. I mean, sailors specifically in
- 58:02response to someone said the first rule of Bitcoin should be
- 58:04do no harm. And now the Ossafire camp is
- 58:08like, let's freeze the creator's Bitcoin in a in a contentious
- 58:12quirk. It's like been a complete flip
- 58:14in less than a year, which is pretty crazy.
- 58:18So because I know we wanted to chat on some of the biggest
- 58:21things this year and heading to next year, but one thing on the
- 58:25quantum, no, there's more like psychoanalysis on.
- 58:29You mentioned institutional allocators and in general
- 58:31narrative. I truly believe like from an
- 58:33individual perspective, most people do not want Bitcoin to
- 58:38succeed. And it has nothing to do with
- 58:40like Bitcoin has to do with things that are new and change.
- 58:43So if you change the perception of value and how it's stored and
- 58:46what does it look like, and you can't touch it, you can't feel
- 58:49it, you have to understand it. And quantum scratches that
- 58:52itches itch so perfectly. It's like all the FUD that's
- 58:55come about, it's kind of been dispelled regulation,
- 58:57administration, the quantum's that last piece and it's a ghost
- 59:01because you can never touch it. It doesn't exist.
- 59:03It's all theoretical and the thing I always gravitate and
- 59:07it's again left bell curve. But it's very like, I don't want
- 59:11to say first principle. It was very like common sense is
- 59:13like Parker has a great analogy about like payments.
- 59:16It's like if we get from zero to one in censorship resistant
- 59:19money and that's finite, we can figure out payments like that's
- 59:23the easy part. And it's like, if we can get
- 59:24there to this asset at $2 trillion and where we're going,
- 59:28it's not to say quantum to to migrate is the is the easy part,
- 59:31but like we can navigate that and there's enough economic
- 59:35incentives to do it. And so it's just a rational
- 59:37take. And then you just size it
- 59:38appropriately and then you do your diligence.
- 59:40And then if you think it's a real risk, just don't allocate
- 59:42that much money to Bitcoin. If you come to the conclusion
- 59:45that it isn't as big of a risk and you'll fix it, then you get
- 59:47to naturally. And then that's what you get
- 59:48paid for in the future. But yeah, that all this like
- 59:51kind of crazy thought of it being existential doesn't make
- 59:54any sense. Yeah.
- 59:56I mean, the last piece I would say here, which is kind of
- 59:58interesting because I've been thinking about it more lately.
- 1:00:02Is, you know, Quantum is an industry just like filled with
- 1:00:05hype, right? And press releases based off of
- 1:00:10that hype. And there's a bunch of different
- 1:00:11quantum stocks and like no one knows how they're going to
- 1:00:13monetize. And we very much live in a post
- 1:00:17truth world. Like it's really hard to see
- 1:00:19like what's real and what's not. Probably the only way to
- 1:00:25tangibly verify for yourself that quantum exists and is
- 1:00:32actually practical and it's used and can break crypto is if the
- 1:00:35early Bitcoin is stolen. Like, I don't know, like like if
- 1:00:39the US government comes down, it's like, Oh yeah, we have a
- 1:00:41quantum computer. Like do they like, I don't know
- 1:00:44if they do, oh, we broke Chinese encryption.
- 1:00:46Like did they like the Chinese might know, maybe if like some,
- 1:00:51you know, they had some secrets leak or something like that.
- 1:00:53But how would you know they actually had one?
- 1:00:56It's like actually it's, it's an interesting thought experiment.
- 1:00:59It's like you freeze that bitcoins like do you even know
- 1:01:01Quantum was reached did. We.
- 1:01:03Actually ever reach it or do we just all switch to backdoor
- 1:01:06crypto on like Signal and shit and all of our communications
- 1:01:09because the NSA finally had another chance to have backdoors
- 1:01:13and everything? I mean based on again we don't
- 1:01:16know anything about quantum but like the notion of the time and
- 1:01:19value to crack an address, I feel like there's lower hanging
- 1:01:23fruit that we haven't discussed. We don't even know.
- 1:01:25Like unknown unknowns that will be cracked and weird shit would
- 1:01:28be happening. There be a Canary in the coal
- 1:01:30mine before any of this even got close to being relevant.
- 1:01:33Well, the argument is that they wouldn't do the Canary because
- 1:01:37they would be going for bigger fish.
- 1:01:40Yeah, but the game theory there is you don't know when you're
- 1:01:42going to get to the bigger fish. So the logical thing is take the
- 1:01:44bird in the hand versus the other deal.
- 1:01:47All right, Matt, since we're on this biggest piece of noise and
- 1:01:52signal that is under discussed because we can't do dats in
- 1:01:55quantum because everyone knows that it's it.
- 1:01:57I mean any real listen I would hope understands their noise and
- 1:02:00that. Are you asking me?
- 1:02:03Yeah, yeah, from this past year like under appreciated SBR
- 1:02:08noise, OK. And then signal.
- 1:02:09Strategic Bitcoin Reserve. What a what a let down that was.
- 1:02:14So far, we still do. You think it exists?
- 1:02:17It exists. We're seizing more coins.
- 1:02:20Sylvan got the audit. We haven't, we haven't gotten
- 1:02:22the Fort Knox audit either. Like said richest man in the
- 1:02:26world. So we're going to have a Fort
- 1:02:27Knox audit and then got a black eye and left the administration.
- 1:02:30We'll doge. With also noise, but that's a
- 1:02:32different story. That was 100% noise.
- 1:02:34I can't believe people actually thought the government be more
- 1:02:36efficient. We're with pomp in, in, in media
- 1:02:41like in New York in February, he was like the the government's
- 1:02:43going to belt like he would take he was on Twitter.
- 1:02:45So this isn't like secret conversation.
- 1:02:47He would ask what's the likelihood of the government
- 1:02:52balancing, balancing the budget And everyone's like, what the
- 1:02:56fuck are you talking about? He's like, I I think it's going
- 1:02:58to happen. He's like, I can't believe you
- 1:02:59guys don't see it. It's like, what world do you
- 1:03:00live in? A lot of people believed it, I
- 1:03:04think. I think Elon believed it too.
- 1:03:07I. We need Marty Jones for that
- 1:03:09one. Though if I wanted like a home
- 1:03:10run, non zero chance call, but out there for next year, it
- 1:03:16would actually be that to catch up for so strategic Baker and
- 1:03:20reserve. Everyone I think had very high
- 1:03:22expectations. Technically it exists via
- 1:03:23executive order. We were, I think a lot of us
- 1:03:27were hoping that we were going to see something like actually
- 1:03:30put into law via Congress, which hasn't happened.
- 1:03:33It wasn't about buying Bitcoin. It was about just keeping stolen
- 1:03:36Bitcoin through like criminal investigations or whatnot,
- 1:03:41criminal seizures that happened and not selling it.
- 1:03:45But in the meantime, you know, Trump is incredibly
- 1:03:49transactional. His everyone he surrounds
- 1:03:53himself with is kind of on the take with him, right?
- 1:03:57And they've all been loading up their bags individually, right?
- 1:04:01Trump media, his his, his, his stock has been buying Bitcoin.
- 1:04:07Do you have his sons with getting Bitcoin exposure,
- 1:04:10getting significant Bitcoin exposure?
- 1:04:13You have to imagine that that like friends and other family
- 1:04:17are also in on that as well. So I think there's an argument
- 1:04:21that maybe they've been packing their bags individually and then
- 1:04:23next year is when they go hard in the paint on actually using
- 1:04:29their position of power to create upwards demand pressure
- 1:04:33on Bitcoin. And one way for them to do that
- 1:04:35is they did launch a sovereign wealth fund that bought 10% of
- 1:04:38Intel. And I think it would be an
- 1:04:41interesting play to bail, quote UN quote, bail out the industry
- 1:04:45America First style by buying a significant portion of
- 1:04:48MicroStrategy at a discount. And I think the shareholders
- 1:04:51would actually be happy about it at this point in time.
- 1:04:55So that that's the kind of an interesting scenario to walk
- 1:04:58through in your head is the SBR. Actually it wasn't.
- 1:05:02It wasn't the real driver. What the real driver was the
- 1:05:04sovereign wealth fund, and that was buying equity in the largest
- 1:05:09Bitcoin treasury company in the world.
- 1:05:12Yeah, I mean, to your point, right, Trump and the cabinet
- 1:05:16administration, friends and family, they didn't get involved
- 1:05:18in Bitcoin to lose money, right? Like that would be saying people
- 1:05:22get elected into public office and then they they just buy the
- 1:05:25wrong stocks and they don't meant millions or 10s of
- 1:05:28millions over their career. So I totally agree with you.
- 1:05:31I think we're, we're getting set up for something more exciting.
- 1:05:34I don't know if it happens next year.
- 1:05:36I mean, I could be inclined to think that, you know, something
- 1:05:39like you just laid out could happen, but I just generally
- 1:05:42don't think that you would be in a position of power.
- 1:05:44Get involved, have family working in the industry or on
- 1:05:47board seats in the industry buying Bitcoin at public
- 1:05:50companies for this all to kind of just dump in 2026.
- 1:05:55Yeah. Would you even touch on Cantor?
- 1:05:57How much underwater are they? Like a couple billion dollars in
- 1:06:00their MSTR position before? Like when the prices ripping?
- 1:06:03I think it was like 20% of their treasury was in strategy at the
- 1:06:07start of the year. It was like a crazy.
- 1:06:09Number, it was like a billion dollar position.
- 1:06:11But I think they were doing options things and stuff too,
- 1:06:13right? Like I don't know if you can
- 1:06:15just treat that as a spot position.
- 1:06:18Yeah, I don't know. And they're also holding all of
- 1:06:21Tethers treasuries, and that line of business has been doing
- 1:06:24quite well for them. It helps when you're, you know,
- 1:06:29get access to, you know, Howie, I don't know.
- 1:06:34So one thing just to call out. I I think is a little bit
- 1:06:40controversial, but I, I personally, and I'm curious your
- 1:06:42thoughts And then also what do you think like under the radar
- 1:06:44was bullish this year is the whole stable coin narrative and
- 1:06:48stablecoin adoption from like banks.
- 1:06:50And the main logic is really simple.
- 1:06:52It's just a easier way for the market to digest.
- 1:06:54There's a digital form of money and then the rails that are
- 1:06:57associated with it. We saw what tethered in for the
- 1:06:59past 10 years. I think that's like widely under
- 1:07:03discussed in the Bitcoin camp of all these banks effectively
- 1:07:06turning on, even though they went, you know, and maybe missed
- 1:07:08the forest of the trees with getting stablecoin integrations
- 1:07:11and what the plans are. There's there's a large influx
- 1:07:14of narrative we've seen the YouTube just across the board.
- 1:07:17And so I think that that'll naturally end up in inflows in
- 1:07:20BTC Mercurial's take there. And then also just like mainly
- 1:07:24like what under the radar happened this past year or just
- 1:07:28do you think is miss misappreciated for like where
- 1:07:32sets us up nicely in the coming years?
- 1:07:34Yeah. I mean, I think first and
- 1:07:35foremost, like, I mean, having having a pro crypto President
- 1:07:44Trump was a significant win over the last year of Biden and
- 1:07:47whatever Harris would have brought.
- 1:07:50I mean, we were like, we're on the verge of, you know, American
- 1:07:54Bitcoin companies getting raided by the feds and getting thrown
- 1:07:57into gulags. I mean, we had samurai that
- 1:07:59happened to samurai and them getting ending up getting jailed
- 1:08:04and sentenced was a was a leftover of the Biden
- 1:08:08administration in in a very big way.
- 1:08:09And hopefully we see Trump pardon them.
- 1:08:13But he did pardon Ross. He took off a lot of the
- 1:08:15pressure off the industry. And the big one he took off
- 1:08:18pressure on was tether, which says basically the biggest risk
- 1:08:21for tether for the last, you know, 10 years has been
- 1:08:25basically, I always called it cruise missile risk.
- 1:08:27It was like the US government like raiding them with Delta
- 1:08:29Force and making their lives miserable and seizing all their
- 1:08:33assets. And that seems like it's
- 1:08:35basically out of the picture now at this point.
- 1:08:38Meanwhile, they're on track to, you know, make 20 billion plus
- 1:08:41in profit that they've been stacking Bitcoin and gold with
- 1:08:45and they have like 70 employees like that.
- 1:08:49The store, the Tether story is pretty crazy.
- 1:08:51And when you're talking about stable coins, they always,
- 1:08:53everyone always fades Tether. Well, at least like among suit
- 1:08:57circles in America, they fade Tether for like circle and stuff
- 1:08:59like that. But tethers, the dominant 1
- 1:09:02Tanner, there's the winner. They're the ones that are the
- 1:09:04overwhelming majority of volume usage around the world.
- 1:09:10And I think that is, you know, and at the end of the day is
- 1:09:14basically run like a small business among a couple
- 1:09:16Bitcoiners and it's all completely closely held except
- 1:09:19for like Cantor got a token 5% equity or something.
- 1:09:23So they had skin in the game. That's probably bullish as fuck
- 1:09:28for Bitcoin, I think. And that says someone who
- 1:09:32doesn't actually use Tether or have demand for Tether.
- 1:09:35But having long term bitcoins that are ideologically minded
- 1:09:40that are, that are more powerful than ever, that have a ton of
- 1:09:43liquidity and seem to be kind of investing in an ideological
- 1:09:47ways. Like there's no way you can
- 1:09:48underwrite the Rumble investment, for instance, where
- 1:09:52they invested like a billion dollars into Rumble from like a
- 1:09:56straight monetary point of view. Like you can't.
- 1:09:59There's there's no way there no, no actual financial allocator
- 1:10:05who cares about returns is doing that investment.
- 1:10:08They did that investment for influence and freedom of speech
- 1:10:11reasons and pushing tether usage and Bitcoin usage in the Rumble
- 1:10:17wallet or whatever. So there's I think there's
- 1:10:20something there that is pretty bullish.
- 1:10:25The thing to watch is, you know, if that relationship becomes too
- 1:10:29close, then what you're looking at is something that is very
- 1:10:32similar to a CBDC, but it's privately held.
- 1:10:35It's like a private bank digital currency.
- 1:10:38And the last piece I would say on that is I do think the
- 1:10:41sleeper in the stable coin conversation, particularly with
- 1:10:43gold at all time highs is Tether.
- 1:10:45Gold, which obviously does not compete with Bitcoin, does not
- 1:10:52compete with Bitcoin because it requires A trusted third party.
- 1:10:55Any real world asset requires the trusted third party because
- 1:10:58there's no way for you to natively verify on chain that
- 1:11:01that asset actually exists. And because of that, it requires
- 1:11:04permission. It could be seized, it can be
- 1:11:05blocked. We've seen Tether do that in the
- 1:11:06past. But I think that would be very
- 1:11:09interesting if that adoption gets bigger, which I expected
- 1:11:15to. But if it starts to thread and
- 1:11:16Tether U.S. dollars, tether gold usage versus Tether U.S.
- 1:11:21dollars, then all of a sudden I don't think there's such a
- 1:11:23strong argument from the US government that it like
- 1:11:25increases dollar hegemony. So that I something to watch.
- 1:11:30I think that's something to watch specifically.
- 1:11:32I think if you look at the market caps, it's like $2
- 1:11:35billion is in tether gold and like 200 billion is in Tether
- 1:11:40dollars. So it's like 100 to one
- 1:11:43difference in quote UN quote usage if that's what how you
- 1:11:46want to measure usage. So if that gap narrows, that
- 1:11:50should be interesting to watch. It's a great call you brought up
- 1:11:54because it's going to happen. Like the big thing that I think
- 1:11:57we missed on the Bitcoin side is A, how hard it is for people to
- 1:12:01wrap their heads around it. And B, the inertia momentum that
- 1:12:05gold has, like we didn't expect 30, Like gold sits at $30
- 1:12:08trillion. Might as well be like Bitcoin in
- 1:12:09the sense of most people don't know how to buy it, where to buy
- 1:12:11it, how to transact with it. That market structure is being
- 1:12:14built in real time independent of Tether.
- 1:12:16Tether's leading, but there's like World Gold Council, there's
- 1:12:18all these people doing tokenized pools.
- 1:12:20It's very similar to like the Bitcoin market structure where
- 1:12:22not everyone has their underline in self custody.
- 1:12:25It sits in these different vehicles and then people want
- 1:12:28different types of exposure and the ability to take redemption.
- 1:12:31And we look at gold at 30 trillion a day.
- 1:12:35I think we all agree it's going to, you know, increase in the
- 1:12:37future and people are going to naturally like, I think the
- 1:12:40thing that we all forget is it's it's hard to underwrite Bitcoin
- 1:12:43and it's full potential without understanding where gold went.
- 1:12:45And so people naturally have to go through gold and they're not
- 1:12:48going to want to take self custody, but they also like
- 1:12:50understand GLD is not the best product and that's going to be a
- 1:12:54huge opportunity. And then Tether about this right
- 1:12:57before from a private market participant that's public,
- 1:13:02they're easily probably the most sophisticated actor in this like
- 1:13:04world. We're talking that you can see
- 1:13:06what they're doing and I think a big part of the gold Bitcoin
- 1:13:09stacking is them understanding that the credibility of the
- 1:13:12dollars fracture, the credibility of treasuries are
- 1:13:14fractured. So ultimately whatever's backing
- 1:13:16a a dollar stable coin is going to naturally be sound assets
- 1:13:19that people recognize. So there's a second and 3rd
- 1:13:21order game they're playing with stacking gold and Bitcoin that
- 1:13:25once other people catch up to it, they're going to be playing
- 1:13:27that same game because it's just game theory.
- 1:13:29Like why would you take a stable coin if it's backed by just
- 1:13:31treasuries that are we know what's going on with the bond?
- 1:13:36Yeah, I mean, I think it's just interesting to think like Tether
- 1:13:40just came out and announced they did an investment in Speed
- 1:13:43Wallet, which is like kind of a shitty Lightning wallet that
- 1:13:47doesn't really have that much usage.
- 1:13:49But the quiet piece is that Speed Wallet actually powers
- 1:13:53steak and shakes Bitcoin merchant processing.
- 1:13:57And it's a really good, it's probably one of the best
- 1:13:59merchant integrations we've ever seen in Bitcoin, period.
- 1:14:02It's super clean, you know, it just shows you a, an inlaid
- 1:14:06invoice. It's like really easy to pay,
- 1:14:08very good UX, works really well. I, there's a world where, why
- 1:14:13did they make that investment, right?
- 1:14:15I think there's a world where maybe you can go buy a burger
- 1:14:17with Tether Gold, right? And then all of a sudden you
- 1:14:20start to think it's like, OK, so Tether Gold doesn't compete with
- 1:14:22Bitcoin, but it definitely competes with GLD and it
- 1:14:26probably competes with physical gold too.
- 1:14:28And I definitely would rather own Tether Gold than own GLD.
- 1:14:32I probably even at size rather own tether gold than physical.
- 1:14:38You know, I there's an argument. I mean, there's obviously
- 1:14:41physical is awesome, but hard to verify, hard to move, hard to
- 1:14:45transact, right? There's a lot of.
- 1:14:47You're making the case why people don't hold spot Bitcoin,
- 1:14:49by the way, because a lot of people's perception of that is
- 1:14:53what you're describing. But spot Bitcoin?
- 1:14:56Spot Bitcoin is way, way easier in those intermediate sizes than
- 1:15:01gold is. Like if you're, if you're a
- 1:15:02sovereign and you're allocating to gold, it's easier to allocate
- 1:15:05to gold than Bitcoin, right? Because you already have
- 1:15:07processes in place to verify, store, move it around and
- 1:15:13acquire it. But if you're in the middle
- 1:15:15tier, right, and you're trying, let's say you're just a random
- 1:15:18person, you want to buy 500,000 to $2,000,000 worth of Bitcoin
- 1:15:22with a gold, it's really, really difficult to buy, verify, store
- 1:15:27and do that whole process. You're going to pay significant
- 1:15:29premiums. It's going to take you a lot of
- 1:15:30time. And then if you want to transact
- 1:15:32it afterwards, if you want to sell it afterwards, it's going
- 1:15:34to be a lot more difficult in a couple clicks.
- 1:15:38Like you can just get access to Tether gold if you wanted to,
- 1:15:41right? So it's, I, it's an interesting
- 1:15:43dynamic. Like I'm not once again, I'd
- 1:15:45rather hold Bitcoin. I but to your point about gold
- 1:15:49being this massive mature asset, I mean, I think the stat is like
- 1:15:53over the last five days, gold added another Bitcoin market cap
- 1:15:57to its market cap saw that like gold is up 20.
- 1:16:00The the engagement tweet is gold is up 21 million Bitcoin in five
- 1:16:04days, which is crazy. The main signal why the market
- 1:16:09structure and four year cycles don't really matter, right?
- 1:16:12When you look at like gold, doing what gold's doing means
- 1:16:15like the emperor has no clothes. People are recognizing that the
- 1:16:18dollar's cooked. And in that world, you can't
- 1:16:20ever like forecast, like where the hell Bitcoin goes or gold,
- 1:16:24because there's no top. Yeah, that was going to be my
- 1:16:27sort of and and it was discussed.
- 1:16:29It's not that it was under discussed, but I think my sort
- 1:16:32of most bullish thing of 2025 was just the the narrative that
- 1:16:37entered the zeitgeist of the debasement trade.
- 1:16:39I think was important for people beginning to go down the path of
- 1:16:43understanding sound money, understanding how Bitcoin
- 1:16:47improves upon gold's monetary properties.
- 1:16:50And I think the greatest sort of anecdote example of that was
- 1:16:53Harvard's allocation to gold and Bitcoin.
- 1:16:55Like that is still under discussed.
- 1:16:58Like there was, I think maybe one or two write ups about it in
- 1:17:00in certain periodicals, but like really, really under discussed
- 1:17:05in the sense that, you know, it's not only that they
- 1:17:08allocated to Bitcoin, it's that they did it in tandem with a
- 1:17:12gold allocation. So so there's some understanding
- 1:17:15in that investment committee that both of these things are
- 1:17:19similar from an investment perspective, from an underlying
- 1:17:22thesis perspective. And I think that's super
- 1:17:24critical. Like Harvard is the epitome of
- 1:17:26sophisticated allocator in the world, like full stop.
- 1:17:29And so we've seen some inkling of like people, you know,
- 1:17:32following their lead, whether it's Brown or Emory or a few
- 1:17:35others, I expect that to accelerate in 26 because they
- 1:17:40are the bellwether of of sort of institutional sophisticated
- 1:17:43capital allocators. And you know, I think part of
- 1:17:47the reason why it's under discussed is because they were
- 1:17:49very quiet about it. Like they didn't do a big
- 1:17:50release around their thesis or why they did it.
- 1:17:53They just just, you know, it just happened to be disclosed in
- 1:17:57their filings. And so there was no fanfare
- 1:17:59around it. And I think that was purposeful
- 1:18:02in the sense that it's still taboo in their circles, right?
- 1:18:05Academia, their peers, their colleagues don't understand what
- 1:18:09Bitcoin is relative to crypto. Crypto there's, you know, a lot
- 1:18:12of conflation still. And so I think it's natural that
- 1:18:15they were pretty quiet about it. But as a result of that, it's
- 1:18:18really been under discussed. But I think, you know, probably
- 1:18:20the most bullish thing that happened this year in my mind.
- 1:18:23Am I correct that is their largest public position?
- 1:18:27Correct. Yeah, it's bigger than all their
- 1:18:28single name stocks in that portfolio.
- 1:18:31I love the the Harvard allocation because it dispels
- 1:18:34the whole notion that institutional allocators can't
- 1:18:37get exposure to Bitcoin. And the funny part is it's still
- 1:18:39like it's .03%. I think roughly directionally
- 1:18:43.03%. I think it'll eventually will
- 1:18:46dispel why they Coinbase won't persist as a leader for
- 1:18:51institutions on a long enough time horizon.
- 1:18:53For once a sophisticated allocator understands Bitcoin, I
- 1:18:57make the case they fully still don't because their size is
- 1:19:00severely under allocated. Why would they leave it with a
- 1:19:04trusted third party? Because if they're at 3 to 5%,
- 1:19:08how do you go to board meetings and work with your endowment and
- 1:19:10say like our counterparty is, you know, this effective bucket
- 1:19:13shop? So anyway that's more market,
- 1:19:17it's more market structure long term, but.
- 1:19:19Here's the conversation no one wants to have.
- 1:19:21If something happened to you tomorrow, could your family
- 1:19:24access your Bitcoin? Really think about it.
- 1:19:26The C phrase hidden in your house, the hardware wild and the
- 1:19:28safe. That complex multi 6 setup.
- 1:19:31You understand it, but does your spouse do your children?
- 1:19:35Billions and Bitcoin are already lost forever because people did
- 1:19:38not plan for this moment. On ramps inheritance solution is
- 1:19:41built into our multi institution custody from day 1/3
- 1:19:45institutions. Clear beneficiary designation
- 1:19:48and professional succession planning.
- 1:19:50No technical knowledge required from your heirs, and with our
- 1:19:55new flat tier pricing starting at $250 monthly, your family
- 1:19:58won't face surprise custody costs just because Bitcoin
- 1:20:01appreciated the same predictable fee.
- 1:20:03Whether Bitcoin hits 200K or 2 million, don't leave your
- 1:20:08family's future to chance. There's strength in many.
- 1:20:10Visit on rampbitcoin.com/inheritance That
- 1:20:13is on rampbitcoin.com/inheritance.
- 1:20:16Here's what keeps Bitcoiners awake.
- 1:20:19You're still securing millions of dollars the same way you
- 1:20:21secured thousands. That hardware wallet in your
- 1:20:24drawer? Your family's entire future
- 1:20:27depends on you not losing it for getting the PIN or something
- 1:20:29happening to you on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 1:20:33removes that burden. Three independent institutions
- 1:20:36hold your keys. No single point of failure.
- 1:20:38No seed phrases to protect, no explaining complex recovery
- 1:20:42processes to your spouse. And now we're offering flat tier
- 1:20:46pricing. One predictable monthly fee
- 1:20:49starting at $250. Other Bitcoin is at 100K or 500K
- 1:20:55Plus with on rate buyer raise, you get the same institutional
- 1:20:57security with tax advantage growth.
- 1:21:00This is how smart investors protect generational wealth.
- 1:21:02Without the weight on their shoulders, there's strength in
- 1:21:05many. Learn more at on
- 1:21:07rampbitcoin.com. I'll give, I'll give the group
- 1:21:10and more importantly the listeners some hopium and you
- 1:21:14guys kind of touch on it, but not fully.
- 1:21:16I I think the hopium is that just the magnitude of the move
- 1:21:21in gold in this year paves way for a Bitcoin super cycle at
- 1:21:26some point. But the fact, the fact that this
- 1:21:29asset move like what, 15 trillion in a year and people
- 1:21:35don't think anything? Is possible anything's on the
- 1:21:37table. Is what you're saying the
- 1:21:38Bitcoin can print another couple $100,000 or even a few
- 1:21:42$1,000,000 in a given year? I don't know when that happens
- 1:21:44and what the catalyst will be, but to think that a small market
- 1:21:48like Bitcoin cannot move incredibly high in in a very
- 1:21:52short amount of time, I think is misguided.
- 1:21:55I just don't know what the catalyst will be for that.
- 1:21:57I mean, the the big reason for gold, of course, was you
- 1:22:00actually have a major sovereign bid the past three years in
- 1:22:03particular, but even more so like just relentless bid from
- 1:22:07sovereign nations and everyone thought that 2025 was going to
- 1:22:12be the sovereign year for Bitcoin.
- 1:22:15I thought that we were going to have a bright orange future.
- 1:22:19The orange man was going to usher in the orange coin.
- 1:22:21The everything was going to be great in America.
- 1:22:24Of course, we kind of got run pulled.
- 1:22:26Are you? Enjoying Are you enjoying your
- 1:22:28golden age, Jackson? No, not even.
- 1:22:31Honestly, I'm not even having any fun playing with my Bitcoin.
- 1:22:34So it's just been a disappointing year overall for
- 1:22:36the market. Yeah, I don't think that's
- 1:22:40opium. I mean, I think that's the key
- 1:22:41aspect of the thesis, the Bitcoin.
- 1:22:46I mean, Bitcoin will move when you least expect it in both
- 1:22:49directions, but it's definitely a play.
- 1:22:52It is interesting though. Like, I do think I've been
- 1:22:57thinking a lot over the years of like, when does Bitcoin get
- 1:23:01truly appreciated as a safe haven asset?
- 1:23:05And there's been multiple false starts on that.
- 1:23:08But like earlier this year was like a really bad false start.
- 1:23:11Like I just like Larry Fink was on CNBC and he's like, this is
- 1:23:15digital gold. Like this is, you know, like one
- 1:23:18of the most powerful people in finance was like, Bitcoin is the
- 1:23:21safe haven. And now Bitcoin's at 88 K and
- 1:23:25gold and silver at all time highs and just feels like, OK,
- 1:23:28does that mean we have to wait another four years or five
- 1:23:30years? I mean, I'm, I'm down to I'll
- 1:23:32wait. I'd rather not.
- 1:23:34I don't think we are waiting because in previous cycles I
- 1:23:39think at this point what is like over 2.
- 1:23:42Chad's supposed to buy a home. Man, he really wants to buy a
- 1:23:44home. It's a running theme in this
- 1:23:46deal and. That's, that's my real, that's
- 1:23:48my real hope him. But no, I mean, in previous
- 1:23:50cycles, right? Like at two years after two
- 1:23:53months, excuse me, after the peak, the price would be way
- 1:23:56lower than it is right now. And despite all of the bearish
- 1:23:59narratives, all the FUD that's being thrown out, Bitcoin's
- 1:24:02still at about $90,000. And so it's definitely showing
- 1:24:06more resilience than previous cycles.
- 1:24:08Of course, there's probably a number of reasons for that, but
- 1:24:11I just can't see a world where 2026 is like a big drawdown
- 1:24:16here. I'm not going to say like I
- 1:24:17can't see a world where things don't chop around again, but I
- 1:24:20just don't think that we're going to have a big, big bearish
- 1:24:23year in 2026. I think it's going to be either
- 1:24:25flat or it's going to be incredibly bullish.
- 1:24:27It's one of the one of those two in my opinion.
- 1:24:29Dude flat is so boring. I OK the I don't.
- 1:24:32Disagree but. Rather down or up.
- 1:24:35But anyway you brought up the four year cycle.
- 1:24:37So I, I, I did a little bit of homework before I came on and I
- 1:24:41have the numbers. If currently we're at $88,000,
- 1:24:45right? If this was equivalent to the
- 1:24:482012 cycle, we would be sitting at $3,000,000 right now.
- 1:24:53If this was equivalent to the 2016 cycle, we'd be sitting at
- 1:24:56$930,000 right now. And if this was the 2020 cycle,
- 1:25:00we'd be sitting at $326,000 right now.
- 1:25:07So I mean, I, I, I, what am I? What is my point with that?
- 1:25:12Well, first of all, I'm incredibly disappointed.
- 1:25:15That's that's the main point I have.
- 1:25:18But second of all, like, I don't know, like if everyone always
- 1:25:22wants to see like AV shaped recovery, but if we have maybe
- 1:25:28the we haven't seen all the pain yet, Like you said, we're
- 1:25:30sitting at 90K sentiments really bad.
- 1:25:33You know, if that is IF80 was actually the bottom, that'd be
- 1:25:37fucking fantastic. But who, who knows?
- 1:25:40Like maybe we, maybe we go lower first.
- 1:25:42I wouldn't. I wouldn't be so surprised if
- 1:25:44we'd go lower first. Just to put my foot in my mouth,
- 1:25:47my predictions that the Triple Crown, I think we get
- 1:25:50directionally close to triple BTC price, triple gold and
- 1:25:55triple M&A in the space next year. 18 months, 12 to 18
- 1:25:58months. I sadly thought of something and
- 1:26:01I know we have to wrap that we'll have to talk about when
- 1:26:05you come on again. Matt is me and Brian have this
- 1:26:08running. It's it's a gets pretty heated
- 1:26:11debate and I still think he's betting, but he won't bet money
- 1:26:14on it. So it kind of tells you where
- 1:26:15he's at or he won't bet Bitcoin on it.
- 1:26:17Is he believes you like crypto's dead but crypto and J coin?
- 1:26:20That's not the take. Don't, don't, don't summarize my
- 1:26:23don't summarize my take like that.
- 1:26:27OK, well, I'll summarize that. He's he he he takes that Bitcoin
- 1:26:30dominance well just could tape into the right forever and and
- 1:26:35the idea is yes, on a long time horizon things Charles is 0.
- 1:26:37But over the course of the next, call it two to five years, that
- 1:26:40this wave of orange, you know, America or whatever, is going to
- 1:26:45usher in the amount of speculation that we cannot even
- 1:26:49fathom. The point was the point was
- 1:26:51higher lows for for Bitcoin dominance from a cycle to cycle
- 1:26:55perspective, which I think we've seen like I think we've seen
- 1:26:58higher lows in terms of where Bitcoin dominance falls in sort
- 1:27:01of the the cycle when alts run. We didn't really see that this
- 1:27:06year and it it never fell below like 50%, which was my specific
- 1:27:11call. I didn't think dominance would
- 1:27:12fall below 50%. This this.
- 1:27:14Yeah, I mean, I think when you when you look at independent
- 1:27:16assets, my competitor competing monies to Bitcoin, they should
- 1:27:21all trend to zero against Bitcoin.
- 1:27:22Now the big overtime. But like if, if the big one
- 1:27:26that's been wrong so far as gold, I mean, gold and silver
- 1:27:29are just ripping like crazy. But the reason that Bitcoin
- 1:27:33dominance is like kind of a scam metric is because it's, it's not
- 1:27:36the same assets. Like if you look at the Bitcoin
- 1:27:39dominance #10 years ago, it was completely different shit.
- 1:27:41Coins were were taking up the majority of market cap.
- 1:27:45And the human condition of gambling is that, you know,
- 1:27:48they're just going to keep coming out with new ones, right?
- 1:27:51And that's probably going to be the case, I think, for at least
- 1:27:55however long. But maybe Bitcoin hits escape
- 1:27:57velocity. I think now the the real number
- 1:28:00I'm more curious is like Bitcoin versus gold and silver.
- 1:28:03Like, I think that's an interesting dominance metric.
- 1:28:07Yeah, remember everyone. It's definitely more useful.
- 1:28:10It's just funny when everyone would dance on the grave of
- 1:28:12silver, right? Like people would pull up that
- 1:28:14chart and be Bitcoin is much larger than silver by market
- 1:28:17cap. And now if you were to pull that
- 1:28:19up, silver's got a double on Bitcoin.
- 1:28:21I just also think it's funny. I know, or wrap here, Matt, but
- 1:28:24it's funny that Michael just. Yeah, I know.
- 1:28:27I was going to say Michael brought that up and then he just
- 1:28:30dipped because he had to make Christmas cookies.
- 1:28:32Yeah, but appreciate the time, Matt.
- 1:28:35It was a fun conversation. Wish you a Merry Christmas.
- 1:28:38And anyone who wants to get in touch with you, where should
- 1:28:40they find you? All my contact information is at
- 1:28:43Odell dot XYZ. Reach out you have any
- 1:28:47questions, feedback, always happy to to provide.
- 1:28:53And also if you haven't checked out nonstar, download Primal on
- 1:28:57your favorite App Store. I'm very active there.
- 1:29:00It's fun. We have an integrated Bitcoin
- 1:29:01wallet and we have a lot of big, I'm heavily involved in primal
- 1:29:05development. We have a lot of big
- 1:29:06improvements coming up in the next four or five months.
- 1:29:09So if you don't necessarily like what you see, stick around and I
- 1:29:12I think you'll enjoy it. You're going to love it.
- 1:29:15All right. Well, thanks, Matt.
- 1:29:17Merry Christmas to you and appreciate the time man.
- 1:29:19Cheers. Merry Christmas.
- 1:29:21Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:29:24If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:29:26episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:29:28app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:29:30today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:29:33Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Rat Media is
- 1:29:36for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:29:38nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:29:42Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:29:44to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:29:48to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:29:50Advisors.