Latest / No Way Out / Diversity Through Freedom: OODA Loop, Constructal Law & Meritocracy | Adrian Bejan, PhD
Transcript
- 0:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right.
- 0:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Today we're going to mix up thermodynamics, the flow, the constructal law, with DEI merit uh hierarchy and some sport.
- 0:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And to help us with that is our guest who came back from episode 14.
- 0:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're so thrilled to have Professor Adrian Bejan back with us from Duke University to talk about his new book.
- 0:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh Professor, I think we've had a lot of new listeners since episode 14 join us.
- 0:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can we go back and just revisit a little bit about your history and maybe a little bit of the constructor law before we dive into what you talk about in your new book about Moots, you got something?
- 0:56Mark McGrath: Oh, yeah, we have to, I think it's important to tell you, Professor, that you were the first Romanian born, first native-born Romanian that we had on the show.
- 1:06Mark McGrath: And since we've spoken to you last, we had two more.
- 1:08Mark McGrath: We had Tib and we had uh uh Dr.
- 1:11Mark McGrath: uh Mihhaela Elieru.
- 1:13Mark McGrath: So so uh we've had three Romanians and you were the first.
- 1:16Mark McGrath: So just so you just so you know.
- 1:20Adrian Bejan, PhD: I broke through the uh glass ceiling, you know, the glass ceiling, yes, that's right.
- 1:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: I stuck my neck out, I fell off the limb, all these things thanks to Brian.
- 1:30Adrian Bejan, PhD: In fact, uh this is the first interview that I'm uh uh giving uh for this new book of mine.
- 1:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh very, very thrilled, uh thrilled, thrilled, yeah, grateful for being uh included.
- 1:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well you are sticking your neck out on this one, diversity through freedom, right?
- 1:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you're a you're a maverick.
- 1:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you I think uh after reading the book, I think you made it clear that not everybody shares your view on this.
- 1:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that correct?
- 1:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: Well, uh I'm not so sure.
- 1:56Adrian Bejan, PhD: Even the enemies of freedom are using the F word all the time, claiming that they're the liberators and the defenders of uh of uh freedom, uh democracy.
- 2:08Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh look at the DPRK, the Democratic People's Republic of Korea.
- 2:13Adrian Bejan, PhD: I mean, they claim uh to be to be the uh freedom warriors.
- 2:17Adrian Bejan, PhD: I think that the the the true um defenders or free individuals are everywhere, except that most of them are keeping quiet.
- 2:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: And they're keeping quiet because unlike Adrian, they uh have not lived the difference.
- 2:31Adrian Bejan, PhD: The difference.
- 2:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: That is, I tell my students, listen, you can learn this, you can learn this, you even a trade.
- 2:38Adrian Bejan, PhD: But along the way, read a few things from the past and and perceive the difference between having access to electric power and uh not having access.
- 2:48Adrian Bejan, PhD: Having access to uh light uh meaning uh light fixtures, meaning a longer work day, and not having access, meaning having to be like uh these uh writers from the past who wrote by the candle, and only one candle, because the candle was expensive.
- 3:05Adrian Bejan, PhD: All these things know the difference and account your blessings that ahead of you, older than you, were um generations and generations of creative people, most of them uh peasants, creative people who invented everything from uh the little hut to the ditch in which to dump the sewage.
- 3:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: All these things, all these things were the mothers and fathers of the affluence that we take for granted.
- 3:31Adrian Bejan, PhD: And the the the the biggest, the most notorious culprits of indifference are the children of uh affluence, uh meaning the those born in this country.
- 3:43Adrian Bejan, PhD: There's one way to to shape them up.
- 3:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: First is to encourage them to join the military.
- 3:50Adrian Bejan, PhD: That is where that is where the uh um the let's call it the the uh the difficulty of uh of living is uh and the discipline are taught.
- 4:02Adrian Bejan, PhD: And the military also takes you all over the globe for you to see people not as fortunate as every single American.
- 4:09Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh then when you come home, tell others to count their blessings and to be more realistic about uh the importance of every day that they live in this amazing country.
- 4:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I appreciate that.
- 4:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose and I have served overseas, uh, both of us in different parts of the world.
- 4:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I agree with you 100%, but not all Americans can join the military.
- 4:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think 25% of our population is actually fit mentally and physically to join.
- 4:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But there is something else they can do.
- 4:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They could they could do what?
- 4:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They can join sport, right?
- 4:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, sure.
- 4:40Mark McGrath: They could play hockey and beat Canada and Italy.
- 4:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah.
- 4:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: Look, Canada is uh is small potatoes compared with the USSR at the at the at the top of their strength in uh 1980, where whenever it was that was a um a monumental event, um it was it happened in the right time at the start of the Reagan years, at a time when um through uh I think misguided American policy, the uh enemies of freedom were were winning, such as the invasion of Afghanistan, the um this Muslim invasion of uh Iran.
- 5:14Adrian Bejan, PhD: It was one uh one um like dropping the ball in basketball, you know, fumble, one fumble after another.
- 5:22Adrian Bejan, PhD: Anyways, uh uh wisdom wisdom is not distributed uniformly or over a population.
- 5:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: That's why I vote for the uh person who knows the difference between uh easy and difficult.
- 5:38Adrian Bejan, PhD: And my father was uh basically rescued from a village shoeless by the Romanian army in the early 1920s, and put in school, and uh meaning from the village put in school, and they made a uh uh veterinarian for the cavalry of the army out of him, a highly gifted individual.
- 5:58Adrian Bejan, PhD: In fact, I think I'm uh a reincarnation of my father, totally, totally, of course, anti-communist, but also anti-fascist.
- 6:06Adrian Bejan, PhD: He did not he wanted people to be left alone, to create and to pursue peacefully entrepreneurship and the helping of other people.
- 6:15Adrian Bejan, PhD: You could not do that under communism.
- 6:18Adrian Bejan, PhD: You simply could not do it.
- 6:19Adrian Bejan, PhD: Anyway, both of my my parents were in prison, sorry, not in prison, much worse.
- 6:24Adrian Bejan, PhD: They had been disappeared, but they didn't come home in broadlight, daylight.
- 6:29Adrian Bejan, PhD: My mother was tortured with uh sleep deprivation for six full days in order to spill the secrets that she did not know.
- 6:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: The atrocities of um totalitarian state are not even a mystery.
- 6:43Adrian Bejan, PhD: They never crossed the m the minds of people who were are the babies of uh of affluence in a free country.
- 6:50Adrian Bejan, PhD: People need to talk about these things.
- 6:52Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's about time that the few like me who are still around talk about them.
- 6:58Adrian Bejan, PhD: I mean, and by the way, academia is uh is just a bastion of ignorance, you know?
- 7:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 7:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, again, we're grateful that you're here.
- 7:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh your new book, I'm gonna share a screen share of it right now, uh Diversity Through Freedom.
- 7:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you sent us an advanced copy.
- 7:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Really appreciate that, the connection that uh you're talking about with your background, your orientation coming from uh communist uh Romania, your background with with sport and and how you found sport as a way out of that.
- 7:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I believe that's the way you describe that.
- 7:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh your experience on a national basketball team.
- 7:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've known the story you shared with shared uh the story with us in the past.
- 7:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And now you're connecting something that I think it could could be controversial.
- 7:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't I don't disagree with your your view on this at all, but the connection between DEI and potentially communism, which is fantastic.
- 7:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I think but you're you're you're using first principles, you're using the constructive law, uh, you build on a lot of these things.
- 7:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I do want to I mean I have many, many questions, but I again I don't want to uh uh dictate the direction and flow of all this, but I do want to go back to something we talked about the first time you were on here briefly today, uh where you talk about the misuse of uh entropy, um, maybe uh uh a little bit more defining uh the way you define the second law of uh thermodynamics with irreversibility, and of course um uh the connection to the first uh principle or the um uh the first law of uh thermodynamics and again what you have with the constructor law.
- 8:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So can you just briefly talk about what you bring up in the book about the misuse of entropy?
- 8:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, that uh okay, you're referring to chapter two, which is about jargon or the um common sense.
- 8:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: By the way, I wrote this book two years ago when I started to look for a publisher, and that was um one year before uh Donald Trump decided to use common sense in his campaign.
- 8:50Adrian Bejan, PhD: And I was flattered by the fact that uh he brought attention to the importance of of um speaking a street language as opposed to uh hoiti toite uh um um you know recent uh inventions in language.
- 9:06Adrian Bejan, PhD: Entropy is is, in my opinion, an educated opinion, unknown to those who speak the word.
- 9:12Adrian Bejan, PhD: Entropy has a precise definition, internomics, that's my specialty.
- 9:17Adrian Bejan, PhD: And I don't throw that word around at all because it's not useful, because I know that the not even my students, most of them don't get it.
- 9:26Adrian Bejan, PhD: Don't get it.
- 9:27Adrian Bejan, PhD: Um and I'm not going to start a discussion or explanation with you.
- 9:31Adrian Bejan, PhD: There is a uh the the word entropy is misused in the context of say a disorder and um and the direction of meaning the time arrow.
- 9:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: Time arrow meaning the direction of time.
- 9:45Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's kind of funny.
- 9:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: They're talking about the direction of time, not uh asking themselves, hey, what do you mean by time?
- 9:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: You know, what is time?
- 9:52Adrian Bejan, PhD: Ask me a little bit later, I'll I'll tell you.
- 9:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh so no, there is jargon thrown all over the place.
- 9:59Adrian Bejan, PhD: And um what's been happening in science during the past 200 years is that as education became more and more available, meaning uh kids like my father uh uh admitted to school, they became intellectuals out of parents and grandparents who did not go to school.
- 10:19Adrian Bejan, PhD: And all of this has created a uh an elite in every country, uh not just the advanced ones, elite that is educated and uh thicker and thicker, thicker and thicker.
- 10:31Adrian Bejan, PhD: And in this elite there are more and more stripes, stripes of educated people.
- 10:36Adrian Bejan, PhD: Some know the biology, others know economics, others know physics, others know to the point that those who know engineering, which is actually the oldest of the sciences, are are treated as second class academics because you see engineers sometimes tend to get their hands dirty where they know how to change a car tire or how to hold a wrench, you see?
- 10:58Adrian Bejan, PhD: And so the today, the so-called the science establishment is uh uh tribal separated into uh families or cubicles according to titles.
- 11:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: Biology here, physics over here, uh, and even in engineering.
- 11:15Adrian Bejan, PhD: My colleagues from let's say electrical engineering uh don't know who I am, okay?
- 11:20Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, as if they don't read the the news or they don't watch your show.
- 11:24Adrian Bejan, PhD: They simply don't, because I'm not an electrical engineer.
- 11:28Adrian Bejan, PhD: I'm an electrifying engineer.
- 11:32Speaker 2: That's true.
- 11:34Adrian Bejan, PhD: Whatever.
- 11:34Adrian Bejan, PhD: The point that I'm making is that jargon is good for those few who belong in this particular locker room.
- 11:43Adrian Bejan, PhD: Okay, and so uh forget about entropy.
- 11:47Adrian Bejan, PhD: Or for that matter, energy is another word that also has a definition.
- 11:52Adrian Bejan, PhD: Energy is measurable.
- 11:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: By the way, entropy by itself means absolutely nothing.
- 11:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: Nothing.
- 11:58Adrian Bejan, PhD: And in uh thermometics there's a definition for entropy change.
- 12:04Adrian Bejan, PhD: Entropy change can be measured, and yes, entropy change, also known as under certain more special circumstances, entropy generation or entropy production, it's a it's a uh number you can uh you can measure or calculate, is a uh measure of irreversibility, meaning that not all things that go one way, one way, equally um bad, equally uh uh lossy or a penalty to you, or dissipative, not equally like friction, you know.
- 12:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: You can have a low friction, that's a low, small number of entropy generation versus intense friction.
- 12:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: That's uh that's uh that's really bad news.
- 12:47Adrian Bejan, PhD: So that the so it's important here.
- 12:49Adrian Bejan, PhD: Entropy, the word by itself nothing.
- 12:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: But entropy change is a quantity with a precise definition, and it is a measure that quantity, a measure of the uh destruction, churn, useful work or useful power.
- 13:04Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh just like uh I'll give you an example of in uh street language, a waterfall.
- 13:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: A waterfall steadily because it keeps flowing and falling is uh is uh generating entropy because it is destroying, destroying the power that could have been extracted by a smart person, maybe a gardener, who would then stick a uh water wheel uh in the middle of that jet and extract power in order to uh do something with that power, like uh drive a pump or uh drive one of these electric generators to light up his house.
- 13:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: By the way, every light bulb that uh burns and creates uh light that is destroying uh, yes, just like the waterfall, destroying electric power.
- 13:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: So everything, by the way, we are all guilty of entropy generation, every single one of us, using the electricity, but also destroying the work uh encapsulated in the food that we consume.
- 14:05Adrian Bejan, PhD: And we destroy that visibly through our movement, through our noise, the way the noise we make, through the fact that we lose body heat uh right now.
- 14:15Adrian Bejan, PhD: All of that is loss after loss after loss.
- 14:18Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's one-way flow, also known as the destruction of uh something useful, and that destruction uh has a measure called entropy generation.
- 14:30Adrian Bejan, PhD: In the early half of meaning first half of my career, yes, I started a field called the entropy generation minimization, which is the wisdom of calculating these losses, and even a deeper wisdom of doing something with the uh with the architecture so that those losses are mitigated, if not eliminated.
- 14:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: And this is how I got this idea of about the constructive law, which is that uh while uh educating students and colleagues, especially younger colleagues, of uh what to do about avoiding uh penalties that are avoidable.
- 15:08Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh it occurred to me, Adrian, uh wait a minute, you're okay, fine, all this entropy, blah, blah, but this is all about changing the drawings, changing the configurations, changing the image.
- 16:20Adrian Bejan, PhD: And bingo, image is nature, image is uh surroundings, image is uh all I know.
- 16:28Adrian Bejan, PhD: All I know.
- 16:29Adrian Bejan, PhD: In fact, without uh perceiving uh image and sound, I am as good as a marshmallow or some, you know, yeah, knock on wood.
- 16:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, Professor, you've given us a lot of uh ideas to go back in the archives and look at destruction and creation, something that we talk about quite a bit with the connection to Observer at the Side Act Loop from John Boyd.
- 16:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you just triggered another thought here that the uh image that's something from the environment.
- 16:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Would you say that's true?
- 16:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh image.
- 16:59Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes, yeah, because we're not we're not alone.
- 17:02Adrian Bejan, PhD: Every single one of us is embedded or encapsulated in um in his uh niche, niche, like this room here where um my family by the way, did let me show your people.
- 17:13Adrian Bejan, PhD: This is all my books there under my window chronologically.
- 17:17Adrian Bejan, PhD: I wrote all of them from left to right.
- 17:19Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah.
- 17:20Adrian Bejan, PhD: And um, but I don't I'm not a book writer.
- 17:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: I'm actually a writer of scientific uh articles, and uh every once in a while I sit down and say, ask myself, hey, what is uh the idea that connects uh Adrian's most recent publications during the past four years?
- 17:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh it occurs to me that um during those most recent years I changed my mind about something.
- 17:45Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes, that's right, um Brian.
- 17:47Adrian Bejan, PhD: You write that you challenge the importance of changing your own mind.
- 17:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, you you challenge d dogma and and your own assumptions.
- 17:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that's true to uh that's what I understand.
- 17:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Before we go any further, and and since we're on the topic of defining a few things, and w I do want to come back to time here in a moment, but chapter twelve, you you write about lack of freedom and you have key definitions in there.
- 18:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to go through these because they're very important to our listeners, uh, and I think they're important to Moose and myself.
- 18:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and the first one is freedom.
- 18:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you have design, rhythm, uh, information, purpose, selection, and a time arrow, which you already brought up.
- 18:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you kind of walk us through what those why we need to understand a common definition of what those mean and what they are, what those definitions are to you?
- 18:29Adrian Bejan, PhD: Well, freedom is part of uh nature, nature, because without freedom there is no change.
- 18:34Adrian Bejan, PhD: No change.
- 18:35Adrian Bejan, PhD: In fact, uh we perceive only things that change.
- 18:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: Things that don't change, uh good luck with them.
- 18:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: They uh put you to sleep if you're dumb enough to concentrate on them.
- 18:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: What really if what really and by the way, that was uh what I just said is the message from my preceding book called Time and Beauty.
- 18:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: Okay, I'll uh leave that um uh to the side.
- 19:00Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh so change is the uh the perception frame, something to change something, anything changes that has freedom to change.
- 19:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: So freedom is the is the word, the d is a descriptor if you want.
- 19:16Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's not jargon because everybody knows the difference between uh being able to change and uh not being able to change, such as being able to uh escape from a prison and not being able to escape from a prison.
- 19:28Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh and then that is important if you are uh curious about what changes can be made, and then what is the direction of those changes that may be useful to you and your children, or your students, or your compatriots.
- 19:45Adrian Bejan, PhD: And this is very, very important.
- 19:48Adrian Bejan, PhD: And um um and of course the joke, it's a it's a bitter kind of laughter, is that uh that it is not appreciated.
- 19:58Adrian Bejan, PhD: The word is not uh is not appreciated for what I just said, it is uh spoken as a slogan, as a uh opportunity to for I would say some politicians, especially those who are uh enemies of freedom, to beat themselves in the chest as being um liberators and uh defenders of the common man.
- 20:19Adrian Bejan, PhD: And no, they're the opposite of that.
- 20:23Adrian Bejan, PhD: I'll tell you what they are ideologues in their own uh lives lucky enough to uh to uh find themselves in positions of power and uh please themselves with the thought that they are in fact helping their countrymen.
- 20:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: But that's that's a pipe dream as history has shown time after time.
- 20:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: You know, Hitler and uh Stalin and uh Charlescu and Romania are just recent examples.
- 20:47Adrian Bejan, PhD: By the way, the list will the list will get longer and longer.
- 20:50Adrian Bejan, PhD: Just read the news every day, um Maduro the other day.
- 20:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: The point, but the history is full of these things, full of these things that uh there are some people, uh, by the way, it's not just at the at the top of a uh uh country, it's at the top of anything.
- 21:06Adrian Bejan, PhD: For example, a university or a school.
- 21:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: All of a sudden there's a one of these, uh let's call uh ideologues who uh is the number one and very powerful, and um he or she acts uh out of honest belief that uh he or she, the individual, uh, knows what is best for his fellow man.
- 21:27Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 21:29Adrian Bejan, PhD: I'm I I know the exact I have the exact opinion about myself.
- 21:33Adrian Bejan, PhD: I do not know.
- 21:34Adrian Bejan, PhD: This is my father the veterinarian, I do not know what goes through the brain of the dog.
- 21:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: I don't know what the dog is going to do.
- 21:45Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh I know dogs, I know dogs, the dogs talk to me, but they don't tell me what they're gonna do next.
- 21:53Adrian Bejan, PhD: And the same with a chicken, and the same with whatever you want.
- 21:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: You know some things if you're educated, such as the dog will come to you when the dog is hungry, and on and on.
- 22:06Adrian Bejan, PhD: But other things, other things, good luck with that.
- 22:10Speaker 2: Right.
- 22:12Adrian Bejan, PhD: Meaning, listen, uh I have in the uh in the book the course from Clint Eastwood, man's got to know his limitations.
- 22:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 22:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's move on to design and rhythm.
- 22:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you call them sisters, and this is the first time I saw rhythm as a as a um Did I get that right?
- 22:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, that's right.
- 22:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So design would be can you can you walk us through that?
- 22:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because rhythm is very important to the way we talk about how living systems interact with the external world.
- 22:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So can you help us break that down a little bit?
- 22:35Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, right.
- 22:36Adrian Bejan, PhD: The so-called design, which means configuration.
- 22:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: By the way, design of the the Latin word means drawing.
- 22:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, or a sign.
- 22:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: A sign uh sign small simple drawing with a message.
- 22:52Adrian Bejan, PhD: That is what drawing really means.
- 22:56Adrian Bejan, PhD: All right, so the design, the simple thing with a message is expressible as an image or as a sound, meaning a rhythm, a rhythm, a uh musical note or get it?
- 23:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: That's it.
- 23:11Adrian Bejan, PhD: So when people talk about space, space and time, this is the jargon in physics.
- 23:17Adrian Bejan, PhD: I am from From the village, you see.
- 23:19Adrian Bejan, PhD: Literally, my my father's uh uh village uh where he grew up in the home, the uh the floor was dirt.
- 23:30Adrian Bejan, PhD: Eaten dirt.
- 23:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: There was no parquet, no cement, no wood, just dirt, okay.
- 23:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: That was poor Romania in the 1920s.
- 23:43Adrian Bejan, PhD: Poor doesn't mean stupid, or quite quite the opposite.
- 23:48Adrian Bejan, PhD: The poor really know the difference between right and wrong, or useful and not useful.
- 23:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: Anyway, so um so no, I don't talk about space and time.
- 24:01Adrian Bejan, PhD: I talk about yes, uh designs or drawings, or movies for that matter, and the rhythm, because because the movie itself is designed in time, you see, changes in time.
- 24:15Adrian Bejan, PhD: So you see, even though they're different, meaning music is not to be confused with with a painting or with still art, they uh two go together because of change, change.
- 24:27Adrian Bejan, PhD: So the so-called still image, after the still image, after the still image becomes obviously cinematography, but it is nature itself, nature itself.
- 24:38Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh that is the complete story, the complete uh discipline, if you want, to uh respect yourself as an intellect.
- 24:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: But if you're in my position as an educator, wow, that is that is the secret to share with your students, because your students are the best citizens on this planet.
- 25:00Adrian Bejan, PhD: They have not been indoctrinated sufficiently.
- 25:04Adrian Bejan, PhD: They are the ones with whom you have a chance, a chance of having a conversation, a discussion, uh, a uh let's say for them an eye-opening session.
- 25:17Adrian Bejan, PhD: That is in fact the the uh the happiness moment in life for me.
- 25:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: But I think it is the same for them, the same for them.
- 25:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: It is a fact as I look back at my career, because students are in contact with me.
- 25:31Adrian Bejan, PhD: This week I'm uh talking to you.
- 25:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: You're my first uh uh interviewer, but three students want to talk to me on Zoom.
- 25:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: These are students from decades ago.
- 25:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: And um and one of them, gee, I can brag about this.
- 25:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: One of them is the senior vice president at Blue Origin, Jordan Charles, was my undergraduate student, very much a constructive design author of scientific journals.
- 25:56Adrian Bejan, PhD: And he's gonna draw by on the on next Monday.
- 25:59Adrian Bejan, PhD: The point next Monday.
- 25:59Adrian Bejan, PhD: The point is this.
- 26:00Adrian Bejan, PhD: The point is this.
- 26:01Adrian Bejan, PhD: What the student takes from the classroom, I'm talking from the university, if that student is lucky enough to uh to uh to uh encounter a free man, the student takes okay, several things, but the most important one is the memories of the professor.
- 26:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: The professor, not the memories or the memorizing of the textbook.
- 26:27Speaker 2: Right.
- 26:28Adrian Bejan, PhD: And by the way, most textbooks are not written by the professor who is lecturing, unlike uh unlike my textbooks, my courses.
- 26:35Adrian Bejan, PhD: I never taught I never taught out of somebody else's book, okay?
- 26:40Adrian Bejan, PhD: Right.
- 26:40Adrian Bejan, PhD: I never did.
- 26:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You also bring up information uh where you combine a design and rhythm that conveys a message.
- 26:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the way I understand that is both design and rhythm provide some type of information to the observer.
- 26:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that is that correct?
- 26:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, yeah.
- 26:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: Look, I have an advantage over many others, especially English speakers.
- 27:01Adrian Bejan, PhD: Manon is a um is a Latin uh descendant, meaning it's from the Latin language.
- 27:07Adrian Bejan, PhD: And these words that we throw around in academia in science are um mostly of Latin origin or if not of Greek origin.
- 27:17Adrian Bejan, PhD: And um you know uh uh these uh two uh let's call them cultures were very smart, they uh borrow from each other.
- 27:26Adrian Bejan, PhD: So Greco-Roman is their name not only in wrestling but also in science and in uh technology for that matter.
- 27:34Adrian Bejan, PhD: So the the words, the the words you just spoke, uh tell me what they mean.
- 27:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh in science, by the way, many people violate what I'm going to tell you next.
- 27:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: In science, uh words have meaning, meaning, and one word has one sense.
- 27:53Adrian Bejan, PhD: One sense.
- 27:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: So information.
- 27:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: Tell your viewers uh to question when they hear this word, just like uh oh, run away from entropy.
- 28:04Adrian Bejan, PhD: I told you that's the first thing you should do.
- 28:05Adrian Bejan, PhD: But information, it sounds common, it's information.
- 28:09Adrian Bejan, PhD: No, information is a verb informu informare, which literally means to give form, to give shape.
- 28:18Adrian Bejan, PhD: And you get information when you when you see a sign signum, which means design, meaning you're you're being shaped up for encountering the sign.
- 28:31Adrian Bejan, PhD: And the shaping up is called uh information on the fact that you're being informed.
- 28:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes, it's the same thing.
- 28:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: Design in nature is all around, and it's running like a movie in the 3D from left to right and from heaven to the earth to uh yeah, to inform you, to make to make your brain more at peace or more a part of the surroundings.
- 29:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think this connects well to and I introduced you to uh Professor Rob Gray and and Alex uh Saram, one of the basket, a basketball coach, right?
- 29:07Adrian Bejan, PhD: And the reason for that is they're familiarization.
- 29:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: They're responding to me, yeah.
- 29:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I mean, they're familiar with ecological dynamics, which is about affordances or opportunities for action, for connection.
- 29:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna throw this out to Moose here in a second, but we talk about outside information as being the environment or one of those elements of the environment.
- 29:23Adrian Bejan, PhD: And I think I call it the niche, the niche, like the nest of the bird or the the the gallery of the worm.
- 29:30Adrian Bejan, PhD: Just a second, the worm is not underground because the worm is blind or stupid.
- 29:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: The worm finds shelter in the gallery and the nest to lay its eggs.
- 29:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh yes, in the gallery, uh it is lubricated, is the niche.
- 29:49Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's not good for me to be in such a tight place, but that is that is excellent for this particular being.
- 29:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: So get used to the idea that uh the biology, I hope they listen or watch your show, should uh revise its uh its pages.
- 30:06Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's not about the uh the naked animal here or the naked uh Homo sapiens over here.
- 30:13Adrian Bejan, PhD: There's no such thing as naked anything as the is the the so-called uh animal in its uh immediate uh surroundings called the niche.
- 30:23Adrian Bejan, PhD: Niche.
- 30:24Adrian Bejan, PhD: I I don't know whether I said this to anybody, but uh my wife, who by the way should be interviewed some sometime, maybe not at my funeral.
- 30:33unknown: Okay.
- 30:35Adrian Bejan, PhD: She uh 1986, uh she said uh let's go to Africa.
- 30:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: We've been yeah, we've been going there ever since, almost annually, to see what I'm telling you.
- 30:47Adrian Bejan, PhD: To see life untouched, but also you see uh local people resembling the uh simple lives that I was sketching earlier, talking about my my parents, and appreciate the difference, quote unquote, the difference.
- 31:03Adrian Bejan, PhD: There are these people who predict the future and uh all these other things, all the way to uh invading Mars and yes, if you know the past, you're not surprised by the uh creativity of some very special individuals who are willing to climb out on a limb and fall, and then climb again.
- 31:24Adrian Bejan, PhD: This is uh the uh the reality, the reality is uh is worth uh uh worth knowing.
- 31:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So one last definition before we maybe move on to sport and merit and the physics of flow and the freedom and and diversity in DEI.
- 31:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That last thing I want to go back to.
- 31:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You brought it up time.
- 31:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you spend just a couple minutes on explaining what you think time is or what time ought to be?
- 31:52Adrian Bejan, PhD: I did not hear you well.
- 31:53Adrian Bejan, PhD: Explain what?
- 31:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: Time.
- 31:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: You brought up the time.
- 31:56Adrian Bejan, PhD: Oh yeah, sorry, time.
- 31:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: Here I go back to my preceding book called Time and Beauty.
- 32:00Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, time.
- 32:01Adrian Bejan, PhD: The uh these uh specimens of the uh Homo sapiens did not have a wristwatch, you know, and uh clocks.
- 32:11Adrian Bejan, PhD: No, they had they had brains and um there's like just like any uh any animal, they were able to perceive change, change.
- 32:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: And when language appeared as a natural artifact for the uh for uh the bipedal ape, words were uh spoken to describe the difference.
- 32:33Adrian Bejan, PhD: Words such as now and before, or uh young and old, for uh past and future.
- 32:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: These are very different.
- 32:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: This is called dichotomy, like the difference between one and two, or white and black, you know.
- 32:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: And in Greek, which is the oldest of these written languages that uh civilized uh the West, there are others older, but I'm talking about Europe here.
- 32:56Adrian Bejan, PhD: In Greek, all these words, this dichotomy comes under a chapter or a headline called chronos, which means time.
- 33:06Adrian Bejan, PhD: And yes, the difference between uh before and after is uh speaks of direction.
- 33:11Adrian Bejan, PhD: Because the the after doesn't come again, you see.
- 33:15Adrian Bejan, PhD: Get it?
- 33:16Adrian Bejan, PhD: That's direction.
- 33:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 33:17Adrian Bejan, PhD: Direction or directionality.
- 33:19Adrian Bejan, PhD: So, starting with the bipedal ape, and with the occurrence of language, just like a writing much later, came this this uh this language full of words, full of words that were uh describing directionality of change, directionality of change.
- 33:38Adrian Bejan, PhD: And the name for that is is the passing of time.
- 33:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: So time, uh to those who were born yesterday, is jargon.
- 33:47Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, the kid.
- 33:49Adrian Bejan, PhD: The kid was really curious, kid.
- 33:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: I should ask, what what is time?
- 33:53Adrian Bejan, PhD: What is time?
- 33:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: You know, what do you mean, uh daddy, what is or mommy, what do you mean by time?
- 34:00Adrian Bejan, PhD: I know that kid.
- 34:02Adrian Bejan, PhD: I was I was that one, and my parents got so sick of me, this is I was very small, nowhere near going to school.
- 34:11Adrian Bejan, PhD: And my parents were uh so sick of it that uh my father showed up one day with uh with a four-volume stack of the uh dictionary of the Romanian language, and he said, bang on the door.
- 34:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: Well, after you after you go to school, if you have these questions, just look them up here.
- 34:30Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, so okay, uh I was kind of a uh a um what do you call it?
- 34:36Adrian Bejan, PhD: Um there's a word for uh uh I was bothering my parents with uh with to me there are important questions like what do you mean by this?
- 34:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: Right.
- 34:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: Or why why such a word?
- 34:49Adrian Bejan, PhD: It is weird, weird, you know.
- 34:52Adrian Bejan, PhD: But it's the same in my work today.
- 34:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: There are a lot of things in uh that my my peers, I'm not talking about my colleagues, my peers at my level in uh thermosciences, they use, they speak, they write, but I realize time and after after time that the authors do not question the meaning of the words they speak.
- 35:13Adrian Bejan, PhD: Which means which means that they don't know the meaning of the words they speak.
- 35:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 35:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this curiosity is key here, challenging assumptions and and understanding the uh and this goes back to some of the things that we talk about on the show.
- 35:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: John Boyd was very specific about the language he used.
- 35:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I thank you for all that background information.
- 35:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to switch gears a little bit to something that Moose and I are closely connected to, and maybe uh we could talk about things from your past and make it uh make a connection again to the key thing about diversity, and that is high flow activities such as basketball and soccer, right?
- 35:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we've talked about this in the past.
- 35:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Our children both play basketball.
- 35:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose's children play basketball, some of them swim actually, so there's a lot of connections of flow there.
- 35:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But can you go and and talk about, and you wrote about this in your book, that athletics sports is a last bastion of the merit system.
- 36:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can we talk about that and and why you see that as being important to connecting to the physics of flow?
- 36:09Adrian Bejan, PhD: Well, because uh because nature, nature has uh has its own way, and its own way is uh that of shaping things and changing things so that those things find the greater access to uh to what's moving.
- 36:26Adrian Bejan, PhD: In the case of the uh human society, clearly the society as a whole, by the way, that's not an abstract concept, it is the multitude of all the individuals and their associations, small and large.
- 36:40Adrian Bejan, PhD: The smaller are embedded in the larger.
- 36:43Adrian Bejan, PhD: I mentioned family, but uh there are lots of families in uh Durham, North Carolina, and there are lots of cities uh this size in the United States.
- 36:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: You see, you see the uh the modular structure.
- 36:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's invisible, but it's modular of the sarcosa side.
- 36:59Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's just like the animal body, it's modular.
- 37:02Adrian Bejan, PhD: You have one body, but then you have a few uh main organs, and then inside of them a few smaller suborgans for um components, you know, blood vessel here, even though the organ is the uh muscle.
- 37:16Adrian Bejan, PhD: You get the idea, same with the skeleton.
- 37:18Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's all it's all a uh an assembly of a few large and many small.
- 37:23Adrian Bejan, PhD: And all of that thing is moving, and all of it is flowing.
- 37:27Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes, uh moving from a birth to death if you want to look uh at the bigger picture per individual.
- 37:35Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh nature is uh has a has it has its way.
- 37:40Adrian Bejan, PhD: Luckily, luckily for uh everybody, not only those who who uh uh uh were educated in athletics, luckily athletics is on display, just like the Olympics that ended last uh last evening.
- 37:56Adrian Bejan, PhD: And if you pay attention, if you pay attention, you see there uh the evolution of society in front of your eyes.
- 38:05Adrian Bejan, PhD: There are people in uh all over biology who who claim that evolution is such a slow, slow uh process that it cannot be witnessed.
- 38:16Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, you cannot witness the evolution.
- 38:19Adrian Bejan, PhD: Well, if you read my books, you can you are no longer confused what evolution is.
- 38:24Adrian Bejan, PhD: But well, okay, fine.
- 38:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: If you cannot witness the biological evolution, the least you could do is witness a short movie of it in uh in um in the evolution of uh a competition.
- 38:38Adrian Bejan, PhD: This uh Olympics has been evolving.
- 38:40Adrian Bejan, PhD: There was a great movie called Chariots of Fire, which was about the uh the uh first Olympic Olympiad.
- 38:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: There's a big difference between that and uh what you saw yesterday, and that's evolution.
- 38:52Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh well the direction is clear.
- 38:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's in the direction of providing access to more and more athletes to compete.
- 39:02Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes, in fact, this was the purpose of the uh evolution.
- 39:07Adrian Bejan, PhD: It was uh I'm quoting uh Pierre de Coubertin, the inventor of it, was to to create a truly egalitarian technique.
- 39:17Adrian Bejan, PhD: This is a quotation, imagine a quotation that's uh self-contradictory, egalitarian and elite, you see.
- 39:27Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, show that to the DEI people, okay?
- 39:30Adrian Bejan, PhD: Right.
- 39:31Adrian Bejan, PhD: Egalitarian means equal access, equal access, but merit, elite is in the same statement.
- 39:40Adrian Bejan, PhD: So access, access is important, is number one, and access gives birth to the hierarchy that we celebrate gold medal, silver medal, and so on, and inspiration for the uh still younger to uh keep training and compete four years later.
- 40:01Adrian Bejan, PhD: I mean, try to beat that.
- 40:03Adrian Bejan, PhD: By the way, Pierre de Coubertin was a let's say lucky enough the uh survivor of uh French nobility in uh around the 1870 or so when uh France lost uh the war against Prussia and lost, I think, about a million young men, imagine, had the idea that uh there's got to be an additional way to educate young men other than with a weapon in hand, meaning uh in the military.
- 40:35Adrian Bejan, PhD: And so he invented the concept of physical education in school, uh, or something in schools, something that we take for granted.
- 40:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: Except that he proposed it to the um Ministry of Education of France.
- 40:49Adrian Bejan, PhD: By this time France was a republic, and um to to institute physed in schools, and uh there was no interest in this.
- 41:00Adrian Bejan, PhD: So he crossed the channel and uh he found uh uh he found interest in uh England.
- 41:05Adrian Bejan, PhD: And it was in England that he um put his vision in practice, physed.
- 41:11Adrian Bejan, PhD: And then he said, wait a second, I need a gimmick, a gimmick with which to popularize Phi Z.
- 41:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh bingo.
- 41:23Adrian Bejan, PhD: That's how about we resurrect the Greek Olympics and so you see the Olympics is uh call it um advertising, advertising for physical education in schools at any level.
- 41:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: And um and it's been it's worked out wonderfully.
- 41:45Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh you have phys ed everywhere.
- 41:47Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh you also have phys ed in the military, meaning done uh scientifically.
- 41:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: You have universities that uh that produce uh professors of professors, university professors of physical education.
- 41:58Adrian Bejan, PhD: And it's all wonderful.
- 42:00Adrian Bejan, PhD: And of course it's a spectacle that inspires uh uh inspires uh young uh young uh men and women one generation after another generation.
- 42:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: Gee, a generation.
- 42:11Adrian Bejan, PhD: Every year you you have more uh more uh let's say uh uh young people who aspire to join this uh truly egalitarian elite.
- 42:23Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah.
- 42:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: And you'll never find a DI in uh in in in this uh kind of movement.
- 42:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: You cannot.
- 42:33Adrian Bejan, PhD: We're fans of Arsenal.
- 42:34Adrian Bejan, PhD: Did I tell you this?
- 42:35Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, no, you I think you wrote in your book.
- 42:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah.
- 42:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, Arsenal.
- 42:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: Anyway, we watch English Premier League.
- 42:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: English Premier League.
- 42:43Adrian Bejan, PhD: In addition to uh recognizing on the playing field the flow of a society, you know, the flow is everything, not just the ball.
- 42:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: In addition, from year to year, I observe with great satisfaction the morphing, the evolution of the composition of the club.
- 43:01Adrian Bejan, PhD: And the club, yes, the club is changing.
- 43:04Adrian Bejan, PhD: During the past uh, I would say uh decade, it's maximum two decades, it has become home to uh talented played players from everywhere, not just from Europe, everywhere.
- 43:17Adrian Bejan, PhD: In fact, the largest stream comes from West Africa.
- 43:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes, or from uh Europeans with West African genealogy and uh parents.
- 43:29Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh the the game is obviously a lot faster, a lot faster, a lot taller, a lot taller, a lot uh more is the word, uh persistent or with the players playing on the entire field all the time.
- 43:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: You don't have a uh a segregation of uh here's the defense, here's the middle, and here is the offense, as if uh painted in uh in uh with a steel image on a on a painting.
- 43:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: No.
- 43:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: The whole team is moving like a carpet up and down the field as required.
- 44:03Adrian Bejan, PhD: And I watch that and I know from the beginning which team is going to win, because the better teams are moving information packed, either attacking or defending, but it's the same formation.
- 44:15Adrian Bejan, PhD: Others are uh either sluggish, sluggish or breaking formation under attack, meaning they become ruptured.
- 44:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: And through those cracks, the the good attacking team uh finds access to the goal.
- 44:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What you what you're describing here reminds me of what we call the re in in team science, the reallocation of resources or reallocation of people.
- 44:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's a go anywhere type concept.
- 44:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I had not watched soccer, or I've not watched soccer uh in about three or four years.
- 44:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so I I'm probably missing out on this.
- 44:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But in basketball, we want the same thing.
- 44:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're moving away from position players to uh more positionless and high flow with motion, high motion.
- 44:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: Is that the evolution that you're seeing in all Yeah, the uh the basketball used to be like soccer because because back then when I was playing, players are not uh not as well endowed physically.
- 45:08Adrian Bejan, PhD: They're definitely not as tall.
- 45:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: And in the league where I played, there are no uh players of uh West African in uh origin.
- 45:16Adrian Bejan, PhD: The West Africans are uh statistically.
- 45:18Adrian Bejan, PhD: Taller, taller and with a higher uh center of gravity, meaning uh longer legs, and that means uh greater ability to jump.
- 45:28Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh so basketball, in my uh opinion, has evolved toward being less interesting because it is a lot faster, a lot taller, meaning the basket is for them too close to the ground.
- 45:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 45:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh and with a professional structure everywhere, including the university, these so-called student athletes uh in uh basketball and football, American football are actually professionals.
- 45:56Speaker 2: Right.
- 45:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: With that kind of uh um life, the um the players become much, much better at everything, including shooting.
- 46:06Adrian Bejan, PhD: And today basketball is just uh the team uh marches one way and uh the player, uh tall one who has the ball shoots uh from beyond the arc and uh and uh scores a three-pointer.
- 46:18Adrian Bejan, PhD: And it's boring.
- 46:19Adrian Bejan, PhD: Boring.
- 46:21Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 46:22Adrian Bejan, PhD: The fun in uh basketball is watching uh videotapes from uh say the late 60s and throughout the seven that's one way.
- 46:29Adrian Bejan, PhD: The other one is to watch uh video tapes from the same uh period, including the eighties and nineties of NCAA games, uh and uh stop there.
- 46:40Adrian Bejan, PhD: Because for that for the game, the uh the court has become too s too small and the basket has uh become too low.
- 46:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, and that's just because of the evolution of uh the players.
- 46:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: Of the players and the the game itself.
- 46:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah.
- 46:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: Um nothing is done to slow the game down.
- 47:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That was a great perspective.
- 47:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I agree with you on many of these things.
- 47:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: One thing I want to disagree with you on, and I think uh this will make sense in a moment.
- 47:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think you mentioned that there's DE DEI has no place in sport.
- 47:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: However, today we're seeing uh men play women's sport.
- 47:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I know you write about this in your book.
- 47:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And your thoughts on this?
- 47:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's different.
- 47:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, okay.
- 47:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: That is is something uh and I have I wrote about that in, I believe, chapter five in the in this new book.
- 47:29Adrian Bejan, PhD: I showed uh I showed the uh the gaping difference between records of uh men and women in in uh sprint on land, meaning uh 100 sprint versus 100 meter freestyle.
- 47:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: And that that difference in speed is I forgot uh 15%.
- 47:48Adrian Bejan, PhD: Um yeah, meaning that there's there's a women for obvious reasons are not built to compete with men.
- 47:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: That is is undeniable.
- 47:59Adrian Bejan, PhD: And if um if a if a if a sprinter, male sprinter who does not win um the race uh among uh his quose sexuals moves over to uh compete uh on a track uh populated by women, I think in my opinion, that's uh that's uh unethical, no matter what uh you call that uh what uh person who makes the switch.
- 48:26Adrian Bejan, PhD: And by the way, as a former athlete personally, I would not be proud of the fact that I I won a competition in which my uh competitors were women.
- 48:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: I would I would not be proud at all.
- 48:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: But that's Adrian.
- 48:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh yeah, I'm just gonna read from your book right now on on just to make sure our listeners are clear.
- 48:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You write that men and women perform at significantly different levels because of different sex architecture, body size, and upbringing.
- 48:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Men have a 10% speed advantage over women in both 400 meter sprint and and swim.
- 49:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you're you're saying there is a difference, right?
- 49:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's a physical difference.
- 49:03Adrian Bejan, PhD: But that difference is enormous.
- 49:05Adrian Bejan, PhD: It is 10%.
- 49:05Adrian Bejan, PhD: 10% is enormous.
- 49:07Adrian Bejan, PhD: In sprint, the records have not changed practically at all, meaning that when they change, they change by the fraction of a second.
- 49:16Adrian Bejan, PhD: I mean, that's it it yes.
- 49:19Adrian Bejan, PhD: And it's always been this way.
- 49:20Adrian Bejan, PhD: The records in uh say the 100 meter dash have not changed uh much since Jesse Owens, Berlin Olympics.
- 49:28Mark McGrath: That not when you think about this, when you see trends like this emerge in in large groups of people supporting things like this, we're talking about evolution and entropy.
- 49:38Mark McGrath: Isn't there something in a society that can reverse and go the opposite way, not in a progressive evolution when they when they choose to do things like that?
- 49:48Adrian Bejan, PhD: Is that yeah, well, a society, uh depending on its uh luck uh of the moment, could be uh the victim of uh mistakes uh generated at the top.
- 49:58Adrian Bejan, PhD: Germany, before uh Hitler was uh at the top of uh everything science, technology, industrialization, all these things, not to mention music and art and all.
- 50:11Adrian Bejan, PhD: And then all of a sudden, all of a sudden, they have a leadership that uh was pursuing a conquest of the globe under a particular ideology, which was that of uh socialism.
- 50:22Adrian Bejan, PhD: In their case, uh also called uh nationalist socialism.
- 50:27Adrian Bejan, PhD: And that was and that uh set the Germany back for I would say two decades, because Hitler was in power only twelve years.
- 50:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: Imagine the damage that a person has done to his own people.
- 50:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: I forgot, was it two million dead, in just twelve years?
- 50:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: And then uh without American help, uh Germany would have been languishing to this day.
- 50:50Mark McGrath: Well, you you you use the example of the leash as a form of uh coercion, which I I really could relate to that uh like in a social thing, like whether it's you know, we're talking about sports or or or coercive government, you know, it it that forces that kind of collectivism forces inefficiency.
- 51:11Mark McGrath: Whereas freedom allows the the natural flow.
- 51:17Mark McGrath: And I say to somebody that lives in Manhattan, when the mayor in his inaugural address said we're gonna welcome in the warmth of collectivism, and then yesterday we were hearing a blizzard, and he says he wants everybody out shoveling snow, but you have to bring two forms of ID to shovel snow.
- 51:32Mark McGrath: But I guess that I guess the broader point, all kidding aside, well, I mean it's not kidding because it really happened, but that that kind of coercion is stifling human energy and stifling flow.
- 51:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: Well, look, uh it was very clear about uh Mam Dani from um from when he was campaigning, uh where he was coming from.
- 51:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: Very, very clear.
- 51:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh and uh meaning that uh that to me was not uh anything new, it was actually bitterly familiar.
- 52:06Adrian Bejan, PhD: The fact that people voted for him shows you that how easy it is for um for the common man to uh to uh uh fall for it.
- 52:24Mark McGrath: And to c to clarify, I mean we're talking scientifically.
- 52:29Mark McGrath: I mean, I think that's where a lot of times the things that you talk about and that Brian and I talk a lot about when we're exploring authentic science, which is always open to challenge and evolution, yeah, you can come across as sounding political, but science doesn't know politics.
- 52:45Mark McGrath: So when you see coercion in place, it doesn't matter what what you slap on it, whatever kind of political label, that there's scientific, you can critique that scientifically, and you can see that inefficiency occurring.
- 52:58Adrian Bejan, PhD: Well, uh, that was the point of uh my chapter on uh the uh the the dog on the leash.
- 53:04Mark McGrath: The dog on the leash, I love it.
- 53:06Adrian Bejan, PhD: Dog on the leash is uh is uh it's true, that's a problem of physics.
- 53:13Adrian Bejan, PhD: I wrote a scientific journal paper about it, and that's that was uh peer-reviewed by my uh my uh I'm talking about the journal paper reviewed by my peers, and it's a back of the envelope argument about the fact that uh that walking freely, uh as individuals, dog and man, consume less power than walking uh connected or uh forced to walk at the same speed.
- 53:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 53:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: The uh uh the the problem with uh with uh Mamdani and the word collectivization is uh is or why that slogan is attracts voters is because uh there's a there are things that are big such as the army, which is a collective, that um are more successful on the battlefront than the individual soldier.
- 54:08Adrian Bejan, PhD: In other words, size matters.
- 54:11Adrian Bejan, PhD: The the group defeats defeats the individual.
- 54:16Adrian Bejan, PhD: And then this is reality.
- 54:18Adrian Bejan, PhD: I'll get to it in a second, because it's not to be confused with the dog on the leash.
- 54:22Adrian Bejan, PhD: But in the mind of the uh of the uneducated, there is power and there is benefit in um in joining.
- 54:31Adrian Bejan, PhD: In joining.
- 54:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: Of course, of course, that's true.
- 54:36Adrian Bejan, PhD: If you do that voluntarily, voluntarily.
- 54:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh especially today when military is uh is a choice.
- 54:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: Um yes, to join voluntarily, which is a uh an expression of uh of selfish behavior when you join is not a bit confused with uh ending up together with uh somebody who puts on a leash around your neck.
- 55:03Adrian Bejan, PhD: See?
- 55:04Adrian Bejan, PhD: So in this as a still image is the same image, it's a collective, but the the collectivized are not are not the ones who join voluntarily, and um because it is beneficial for the individual.
- 55:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: The latter, meaning joining voluntarily, because it is beneficial to to move or to live as a group, is called economies of scale.
- 55:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: Economies of scale is a phenomenon in nature everywhere you look, and you see it in the African bush.
- 55:40Adrian Bejan, PhD: You see it every if you know history, you see it, in fact you see it in the evolution of of technology, big time, big time.
- 55:48Adrian Bejan, PhD: Supply chains, they the movers are the biggest trucks or the biggest uh cargo ships and the biggest cargo planes, because the price per unit is lower and lower, the bigger the bulk.
- 56:03Adrian Bejan, PhD: Okay?
- 56:04Adrian Bejan, PhD: But all of that is done to benefit the individual, and the individual s signs on to this scheme voluntarily.
- 56:14Adrian Bejan, PhD: The opposite is the collectivization which is imposed from above.
- 56:20Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes, it is done, in fact, quite um uh let's say intentionally by people at the top in order to to rule over a population unaware of the fact that uh they're they're being um trapped into a structure from which they cannot escape.
- 56:38Mark McGrath: When you say size matters, uh you could and and I have I want to connect a thought to another guest that we've had, but when you say it's size matters, like basically saying something could be too big, too, right?
- 56:48Mark McGrath: Like something there could be too many people or too many.
- 56:52Adrian Bejan, PhD: There's n there's no such thing as too big.
- 56:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: If it became too big, it crumbled.
- 56:58Adrian Bejan, PhD: The uh society that evolves freely, obviously, she does, no matter what you want.
- 57:03Adrian Bejan, PhD: Society will uh change itself if it has in it uh meaning the uh laws that allows it to change, to morph.
- 57:13Adrian Bejan, PhD: The laws are made by by uh people, and and if the people are wise, meaning the ones who write the constitution, then those laws are to be changed by the voters, by the elected officials.
- 57:27Adrian Bejan, PhD: What uh has not been changing at all since the get-go is Marxism or some other ideology like that.
- 57:35Adrian Bejan, PhD: And that is why every every um every uh society that's ruled by uh an ideology is uh is destined to uh to change, meaning every ideology is destined to crumble.
- 57:49Mark McGrath: So, in that we're learning here, and we're always trying to learn, what I was trying to tie it to, I was rereading a paper by another guest that we've had by the name of Bing West.
- 57:57Mark McGrath: And he wrote a paper, he worked for the Rand Corporation after his service in Vietnam, and he had written a paper called Strike Teams.
- 58:06Mark McGrath: And what he was saying was that smaller organisms, you know, anywhere from five to ten Marines or Navy SEALs or Army Rangers or whatever, was getting more effective results than an a thousand-man sized battalion.
- 58:22Mark McGrath: And what he was saying was that the smaller, the smaller, more agile, adaptable unit or military unit was able to flow into the the populace, the culture more effectively than the big 1,000-man battalion coming in to take an objective and destroying everything.
- 58:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: That's that's I was trying to because like as I was as I was going through this, I was thinking, uh you seem to have been hitting on that, and I didn't know if if if you had any if you had any thought about that, where where something like big brute force doesn't flow in a specific culture, in this case the the the you know the Vietnamese countryside, but what they found more effective instead was smaller smaller groups that could adapt assimilate like a chameleon sort of yeah that's uh that's again something else that uh the um um uh was made famous in the US by uh General uh Schwarzkopf, you know, in the first uh Iraq war was to delegate the decision making to the uh to the um uh to the soldiers on the small groups uh on the battlefront.
- 59:34Adrian Bejan, PhD: That is basically what they teach on uh organized sports such as soccer, is called the creativity on the spot.
- 59:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh these people who play the game are not looking on at the sideline to see what signals the coach uh is flashing.
- 59:49Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh yeah, creativity on the spot or dexterity or heads up, heads up as opposed to uh playing with the looking into the ground.
- 59:58Adrian Bejan, PhD: All these you can teach these things, you can teach them to young uh aspiring players, but then the ones who uh who uh win the game are uh those who uh who question the uh the emitted environment uh every single moment and create uh the the the the cracks and the gaps and the mistakes of the opposition.
- 1:00:20Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah.
- 1:00:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: And all of that is in my opinion, nothing new.
- 1:00:24Adrian Bejan, PhD: Nothing new.
- 1:00:28Mark McGrath: Asymmetric guerrilla warfare that we're where adaptable guerrilla thinkers can can f tap into the flow of a culture or uh or a situation better than larger groups.
- 1:00:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: Okay, and these are these are this is the language of uh the one that you quote is from the military.
- 1:00:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: I uh respect that a lot, um, but the the physics of it is that uh that the movement Yeah, that's what I want to understand, the physics of it.
- 1:00:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: Movement movement uh the organizes itself in this uh uh multi-scale fashion with uh let's call it the front.
- 1:01:06Adrian Bejan, PhD: The front that's uh that's uh advanced by uh smaller uh uh entities like uh the uh the attacker in soccer is an individual.
- 1:01:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:01:17Adrian Bejan, PhD: In uh in um in the military uh is the infantry, the uh obviously the Marines.
- 1:01:24Adrian Bejan, PhD: The point is, and by the way, and the generals are l uh at the back, or not even in the picture, the so-called commanders.
- 1:01:31Adrian Bejan, PhD: They are not on the front line.
- 1:01:34Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh is the same as in the famous game of chess, you know.
- 1:01:38Adrian Bejan, PhD: They uh the you have the peons in front and then the uh the uh more powerful pieces at the back, and those powerful pieces, yes, sometimes could jump over or through the uh front.
- 1:01:50Adrian Bejan, PhD: That is a great game because it and by the way, athletes should be taught that game because it um it teaches the um importance of uh seeing seeing uh what is in front of the front, you see.
- 1:02:04Adrian Bejan, PhD: I just came up with this.
- 1:02:08Mark McGrath: I like that because I because I guess as I was reading your work, I mean I I I was thinking of like adaptable guerrilla insurgent asymmetric warfare are people that are generally that have been successful at it are are uh uh very capable of tapping into the flow of something, whether it's a culture or religion or whatever it whatever it is, they're able to they're able to do that.
- 1:02:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: This thing with discussion or anything is is the same that okay should be happening in uh scientific research.
- 1:02:38Adrian Bejan, PhD: In scientific research, uh the uh yes, unfortunately, it is not happening much to the point that I'm a kind of a singularity.
- 1:02:47Adrian Bejan, PhD: I'm still the uh the uh that uh small thing, the the the soldier on the front line who is trying this and trying this without um in my case, without support from uh from uh from the authorities.
- 1:03:03Adrian Bejan, PhD: It looks like we just lost Mark, okay?
- 1:03:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh, he's still around.
- 1:03:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Going back to innovation, you you write that in conjunction with the idea of technique.
- 1:03:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you also say you brought this up that innovation is you know, it's innovation on the spot.
- 1:03:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So technique, can we go into that a little bit when it comes to individual performers?
- 1:03:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What you mean by that?
- 1:03:23Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, that was uh a uh uh in the chapter about uh sports evolution.
- 1:03:29Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's one thing to uh recruit uh uh the uh the uh the better built, you know, the faster by nature.
- 1:03:38Adrian Bejan, PhD: That's uh that is one way to uh to uh create a winner, but then the other way, which is worth teaching, is that the uh the coach uh is a teacher and should employ that um that opportunity uh for the benefit of uh the player or the or the team or the uh sponsoring institution.
- 1:04:02Adrian Bejan, PhD: And uh I think I show there that uh for example in sprint have a God-given ability to be fast, and but I also have a god uh god-given ability to uh run a particular way, meaning uh with a certain number of steps to the finish line.
- 1:04:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: But I show that running, and this is a very good example in female sprint, and also uh yeah, female sprint, but also in male sprint, those who run uh with uh a somewhat larger number of steps tend to run taller as opposed to keep falling forward.
- 1:04:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: And the the telegraph pole that uh that falls the fastest forward is the pole that's uh still vertical when it starts falling.
- 1:04:48Adrian Bejan, PhD: That is the fastest speed forward of the tip or of the center of gravity.
- 1:04:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: You watch it.
- 1:04:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: And then that speed forward drops down to zero when the uh pole hits the ground.
- 1:05:01Adrian Bejan, PhD: Get it?
- 1:05:02Adrian Bejan, PhD: So falling forward too far is not good for horizontal speed, you see.
- 1:05:08Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's it's good for vertical speed because you go flap and that's the end of your progress forward.
- 1:05:15Adrian Bejan, PhD: So uh there's this, I keep forgetting the name of this uh sprinter who was for 20 years the record holder in the 200 meter sprint.
- 1:05:23Adrian Bejan, PhD: Michael Johnson.
- 1:05:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: Johnson, okay.
- 1:05:26Adrian Bejan, PhD: In fact, I met him.
- 1:05:27Adrian Bejan, PhD: I met him during a um BBC or filming in um Kingston, Jamaica.
- 1:05:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: And he was famous for running uh people thought uh naturally straight up.
- 1:05:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: Straight up, and he was making uh shorter steps.
- 1:05:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: And turned out to be a lot faster than everybody.
- 1:05:45Adrian Bejan, PhD: His record was broken uh just recently.
- 1:05:48Mark McGrath: Twenty I also love one of the things I loved too, other than the leash, was the difference between how uh an aquatic mammal moves in the water, like a dolphin or a whale with uh flap, a vertical flap versus the shark or the fish that has uh like more of a snake.
- 1:06:07Mark McGrath: Like I thought that that was pretty interesting.
- 1:06:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:06:11Adrian Bejan, PhD: That uh that uh that kind of uh let's call it uh movie teaches you, in case you did not know, that mammal uh swimmers came from land.
- 1:06:20Adrian Bejan, PhD: Because uh movement on land is this way, falling forward, falling forward.
- 1:06:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: The bird itself is actually falling forward, and then falling forward.
- 1:06:30Adrian Bejan, PhD: Movement on land is is designed by God to uh fight against and defeat gravity, meaning uh to make up for the fact that the body by itself keeps falling.
- 1:06:43Adrian Bejan, PhD: So then the body has to be lifted.
- 1:06:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: So the movement is in a vertical plane, like this.
- 1:06:49Adrian Bejan, PhD: You see, in the water, all these bodies are neutrally buoyant, neutrally buoyant, and uh they rose from the bottom of the uh the shallow swamp.
- 1:06:59Adrian Bejan, PhD: So the movement was uh uh snake like, like uh the fish and the uh the um the reptiles, these uh snakes.
- 1:07:11Mark McGrath: Well that you know I I have uh as Ponch mentioned, uh children who swim, including at the Division I level, and I Think of the the dolphin kick and the and I also think of the breathing coming up and over.
- 1:07:23Mark McGrath: Like the the the mammal has to come up and get air to go back down.
- 1:07:29Adrian Bejan, PhD: By the way, by the way, so if you are a thinking athlete, that uh gives you an advantage because you uh connect with uh the animals that you observe.
- 1:07:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: And if you pay attention that you learn that yes, you have the freedom to adjust your rhythm, and that is the technique.
- 1:07:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: But if you are not that smart, then a smart coach will teach you to do these things that you and I are discussing.
- 1:07:53Adrian Bejan, PhD: There's a place for the coach on a team.
- 1:07:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: There's also a place for the medical doctor on a team.
- 1:08:01Adrian Bejan, PhD: There's also a place for uh, I'm sure, a priest on a team, or for a person to uh to help you become a better person during those very few years of opportunity to becoming a solid citizen.
- 1:08:16Adrian Bejan, PhD: By the way, this is actually the benefit of uh of uh being an athlete.
- 1:08:20unknown: Right.
- 1:08:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: To become a solid citizen without realizing.
- 1:08:24Adrian Bejan, PhD: You stay away from crime, you stay away from rape, you stay away from all the from uh smoking, from drinking, from spending sleepless nights.
- 1:08:34Adrian Bejan, PhD: You uh are educated uh without knowing the about the benefits of uh respecting others and not fouling the opponent because he'll hit you right back.
- 1:08:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: Or being nice to your uh teammates, by the way, teammates are then your brothers and brotherhood for life.
- 1:08:53Adrian Bejan, PhD: This is what you get out of sports.
- 1:08:56Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's it's priceless, it's priceless.
- 1:08:59Adrian Bejan, PhD: If parents watch this uh episode or this segment, take notice.
- 1:09:04Adrian Bejan, PhD: Um encourage your children to be uh to be competitive, yeah, and active physically.
- 1:09:11Adrian Bejan, PhD: And recognize uh the the the uh the golden hand of uh merit with and the opportunities in front of you if you are and by the way, also recognize the golden hand of discipline.
- 1:09:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: Discipline is liberating, not the leash that uh was mentioned earlier, is the complete opposite.
- 1:09:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:09:33Adrian Bejan, PhD: The discipline is uh gets a bad uh bad rap in academia.
- 1:09:38Adrian Bejan, PhD: No.
- 1:09:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I'm I'm excited to see what comes out of the new relationship between you and the folks in the uh constraints-led approach, the ecological dynamics that preach a lot of these things, that we have to look at the individual constraints or or genetics and then design that rhythm or help them design the rhythm that uh gives them to their peak performance.
- 1:09:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Everything you're talking about today resonates well with what they shared with us on the show, and of course, on how all living systems interact and uh thrive in in an ever-changing environment.
- 1:10:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, before I ask one last question about AI, I want to uh ask a question about the following connection to the Vitruvian Man, if you don't mind.
- 1:10:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's in your book.
- 1:10:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, can can you share a little bit behind uh why the the the connection to the wheel and spoke and what you talk about here?
- 1:10:22Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, by the way, uh gymnasts uh all ages have been uh showing this cartwheel uh all the time.
- 1:10:29Adrian Bejan, PhD: In my own uh elementary school, there were classmates of mine uh doing this on the corridor, you know.
- 1:10:40Adrian Bejan, PhD: And the uh the line drawings uh on the right show how the uh the uh body falls and then how uh the second leg uh catches the fall, breaks it, and then straight straightens the body.
- 1:10:58Adrian Bejan, PhD: The the smallest number of uh legs needed to do that is two.
- 1:11:05Adrian Bejan, PhD: And then and then of course that's one thing.
- 1:11:12Adrian Bejan, PhD: Then there's the human-made wheel, which has many spokes.
- 1:11:17Adrian Bejan, PhD: And if you look at what the wheel does, the wheel is basically a repetition of the of the drawing that I made with the black lines, a repetition, except that the wheel has uh many legs called spokes.
- 1:11:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes.
- 1:11:33Adrian Bejan, PhD: And um which wheel is better.
- 1:11:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: Or meaning better for the animal.
- 1:11:43Adrian Bejan, PhD: Because people like to say that nature did not invent the wheel.
- 1:11:47Adrian Bejan, PhD: How wrong that statement could be.
- 1:11:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: Nature invented not only the wheel, but invented the lightest wheel, which is the wheel with only two spokes.
- 1:12:00Adrian Bejan, PhD: Not with with twenty spokes, eighteen of them not used, you see.
- 1:12:05Adrian Bejan, PhD: And that is the advantage of uh quadrupedal motion, sorry, bipedal motion.
- 1:12:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: Quadrupedal motion is uh the same story with uh with one wheel in front and one wheel in the back, each wheel with only two spokes, namely two legs.
- 1:12:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: And then that's why design in nature approached uh critically, meaning not as dogma, but as a as a uh let's like at the North Circus at the in Las Vegas, you're being shown tricks and then you scratch your head.
- 1:12:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: How did that thing happen because it's so incomprehensible?
- 1:12:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes, your own earth to question what goes on and question those who make these declarations.
- 1:12:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: Declarations.
- 1:12:52Adrian Bejan, PhD: I just thought of something akin to uh nature did not invent the wheel.
- 1:12:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: Of course, nature invented the wheel.
- 1:12:59Adrian Bejan, PhD: All right, I just showed you.
- 1:13:01Adrian Bejan, PhD: There are people talking about that um ideas come from uh from the collective.
- 1:13:09Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes, they even call it the wisdom of the ants.
- 1:13:12Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, the wisdom of the ants.
- 1:13:14Adrian Bejan, PhD: Last August I was when I was in uh in Africa, filmed filmed a um a colony of ants returning to their um to the nest after raiding a neighboring colony.
- 1:13:28Adrian Bejan, PhD: I mean, these uh ants are predators, they kill and eat each other.
- 1:13:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: And um, yes, and on this path, which was on a on the road, meaning there were no obstacles, on this path you saw the beaten track of the of the successful ants that were bringing uh dead bodies to their colony to eat, and then their relatives, meaning also predators, walking in the opposite direction on the same path to go and steal more, you see?
- 1:14:01Adrian Bejan, PhD: So you have a counterflow, counterflow just like the vehicles on the highway here, and uh the wisdom of the ants was such that these ants did not uh did not invent the two-lane system.
- 1:14:15Adrian Bejan, PhD: They're actually walking into each other and colliding with each other, and then wrestling one against the other to get past the other.
- 1:14:27Adrian Bejan, PhD: Wrestling and then walking on top over the other, meaning a lot slower than otherwise.
- 1:14:35Adrian Bejan, PhD: That's the wisdom of the ends.
- 1:14:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: And if you want, if you like that, you can have it, you see.
- 1:14:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: The idea is something else.
- 1:14:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: The idea is about avoiding the collision and yes, coming up with flow architectures such as the two-lane system, and yes, get to know the difference, the difference, quote unquote, because it wasn't long ago when human movement on a beaten track, in fact, we can still see it in the bush, is on a single lane.
- 1:15:05Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's called the Conga line.
- 1:15:07Adrian Bejan, PhD: And you better watch out if on the same narrow path you encounter you encounter the predator or the neighbor who wants to kill you, you see.
- 1:15:18Adrian Bejan, PhD: That is that is the wisdom of the ants.
- 1:15:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You bring this up in the context of science in your in your book, uh, that I think you say that science is not a uh it's not about the voting, right?
- 1:15:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's not about the I think you say science is not a democracy.
- 1:15:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that is that true?
- 1:15:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is it the way you look at it?
- 1:15:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: I don't hear you.
- 1:15:33Adrian Bejan, PhD: Well, you're talking about what now uh goes through.
- 1:15:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Science has uh you know, it's not about the number of votes science gets.
- 1:15:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It could be the outlier, the it's not a natural democracy, if you will.
- 1:15:43Adrian Bejan, PhD: No, not at all.
- 1:15:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: Not at all.
- 1:15:45Adrian Bejan, PhD: In fact, let me show you.
- 1:15:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: Upon the wall here, I I have a dictum from uh from uh Galileo Galileo Galilei.
- 1:15:52Adrian Bejan, PhD: Let me see if I can point to it.
- 1:15:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: Right there, right here, up above my head.
- 1:15:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: In questions of science, the authority of a thousand is not worth the humble reasoning of a single individual.
- 1:16:07Mark McGrath: From your lips to God's ears.
- 1:16:09Adrian Bejan, PhD: And he knew he knew what he was talking about because he was about to be burned to the stake, you know, for his uh for his understanding of nature.
- 1:16:20Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, this man.
- 1:16:22Adrian Bejan, PhD: And yeah, he's one of my very few heroes because he had ideas and he stuck to his guns.
- 1:16:31Adrian Bejan, PhD: And everything that came and is celebrated, you know, Isaac Newton and Euler, all these things began with him and before him um Leonardo da Vinci.
- 1:16:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes, these people who were basically symbols of individual freedom to think.
- 1:16:48Adrian Bejan, PhD: And by the way, my book, this uh book we're talking about, is about the primacy of the individual.
- 1:16:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: The individual.
- 1:16:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: The idea comes from the individual, but not from the collective.
- 1:17:00Adrian Bejan, PhD: If the idea, if the idea is good enough to spread by itself, then that idea attracts attracts a group, a group of all kinds.
- 1:17:14Adrian Bejan, PhD: But every single one is in is a volunteer.
- 1:17:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:17:18Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, and that is not a collective.
- 1:17:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: That is that is a uh like uh the stadium that comes to watch a game.
- 1:17:26Adrian Bejan, PhD: And yes, the group, if it is uh gifted, uh to practice the idea that attracted them, that the bigger group executes a project.
- 1:17:38Adrian Bejan, PhD: Maybe they build a bridge, or maybe they build a university department.
- 1:17:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: And you see here, in other words, first is the idea, later, right, later is a group and a project, something bigger, something that would not have been born without the individual who, like Galeo Gale, defended an idea.
- 1:18:02Adrian Bejan, PhD: But this is not only true, it is extremely important today, because what we're being taught is that ideas are created by the group, that the group is the mother of the idea, which is complete nonsense.
- 1:18:19Adrian Bejan, PhD: It is it is a repudiation not only of nature, it is a repudiation of the history of science.
- 1:18:28Adrian Bejan, PhD: You open any book, especially a book of science, you do not see the names of groups, you see the names of individuals, you don't see the names of groups or the names of institutions or governments, you don't see the same thing.
- 1:18:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: Even better, even better, even better.
- 1:18:45Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh the the students, all of us who went to school, remember the remember the names that uh of people who came up with ideas.
- 1:18:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: And this is why this is why uh parents use some of those names to name their children.
- 1:19:02Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes, yes.
- 1:19:04Adrian Bejan, PhD: Listen, the collective the collective is the poison, poison to creativity.
- 1:19:20Adrian Bejan, PhD: It kills the individual.
- 1:19:22Adrian Bejan, PhD: In fact, uh those who accept to be coerced into joining, those are unbeknownst to them, are abandoning their individuality.
- 1:19:35Adrian Bejan, PhD: They're they're saying goodbye to their opportunity to think for themselves.
- 1:19:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: They're waiting for things to be told, told from above, things needed by the uh head of the institute were under communist communism that is much, much, much uh simpler thing to expect because there's only one thing coming from above, you know.
- 1:20:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I wonder, is this connecting back to um collectivism drives unnatural diversity when in fact we want to have that?
- 1:20:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 1:20:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: No, collectivism is uh is the uh one uh ask one word to describe what happens in a society that's not free.
- 1:20:18Adrian Bejan, PhD: Meaning uh communism, uh fascism, it's uh but communism is the the the best uh the best uh uh let's say the uh the doctrine that has evolved scientifically.
- 1:20:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: The uh diversity there is known as the class struggle struggle, and that's the uh diversity of two.
- 1:20:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh is the under communism the oppressed versus the oppressor, or the the uh workers versus the factory owners.
- 1:20:48Adrian Bejan, PhD: In today's uh uh DEI it is the uh the uh underrepresented against the overrepresented, or the minority against the majority, or the uh obviously white versus black, or male versus female.
- 1:21:04Adrian Bejan, PhD: In every single case, one class is to be uh favored and the other one disregarded or eliminated.
- 1:21:12Adrian Bejan, PhD: So that's basically the and then uh if you realize, meaning if you have my background, then DAI, when it appeared about 15 years ago, was uh bitterly familiar.
- 1:21:23Adrian Bejan, PhD: Because I grew up, I lived under this uh kind of system where uh as I documented the book through uh the writings of uh very famous uh authors who lived under communism, the plan was to destroy, really to kill, to exterminate the so-called enemy class.
- 1:21:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: The same in under you know uh fascist uh Germany and Italy.
- 1:21:47Adrian Bejan, PhD: They had uh the people and then the enemy of the people, the enemies of the people.
- 1:21:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: They had the uh pure race and then the not pure race.
- 1:21:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: I tell the story in uh this book about my first day of uh school, in which I was told that I was of unhealthy origin, meaning my my fate was to die because I was unhealthy.
- 1:22:09Adrian Bejan, PhD: My disease was that my parents were intellectuals.
- 1:22:13Adrian Bejan, PhD: Can you believe this?
- 1:22:15Adrian Bejan, PhD: I mean, by this is this is what was going on uh all over the eastern half of Europe.
- 1:22:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: This is a civilized uh continent, and then all over Asia, all the way to today's uh you know People's Republic of China and uh the DPRP uh in uh in uh North Korea.
- 1:22:36Adrian Bejan, PhD: There's still communism in uh Vietnam and you've got communism under the nose of the United States uh in Cuba.
- 1:22:43Adrian Bejan, PhD: This is what's going on.
- 1:22:45Adrian Bejan, PhD: So uh so yes, science is good if you take uh your God-given uh gift of uh of questioning, just questioning, and you come up with the answers yourself.
- 1:22:59Adrian Bejan, PhD: You don't have to read what I write or listen to what other people have seen, or uh to listen to folks who have lost their uh grandparents and so on, uh and the gulags and uh No, just read, read and question what you see and especially question question every single voice uh that comes from a position of authority.
- 1:23:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: Why?
- 1:23:25Adrian Bejan, PhD: Because you are an individual.
- 1:23:27Adrian Bejan, PhD: And by the way, this is the story of uh of uh the book cover.
- 1:23:33Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, the story of the book cover which you showed uh in fact show it again if you if you can.
- 1:23:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yeah, that one.
- 1:23:43Adrian Bejan, PhD: So uh two years ago I was uh with my wife in uh in um in one of these reserves and uh in front of the the Land Rover appeared this image.
- 1:24:01Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's a dead tree.
- 1:24:03Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's actually called um lead wood tree.
- 1:24:07Adrian Bejan, PhD: Anyway, it's it's a dead tree, and on it this bird.
- 1:24:13Adrian Bejan, PhD: Later I found out that this bird is a Egyptian goose, but I cannot tell from uh this uh distance.
- 1:24:19Adrian Bejan, PhD: And I said to myself, hey, that's Adrian, that's Adrian, you know, standing as I wrote in the caption for this image, stepping on dead wood, meaning questioning what's being celebrated, that's all dead wood.
- 1:24:40Adrian Bejan, PhD: What with infinite access to the blue sky of ideas?
- 1:24:47Adrian Bejan, PhD: Nice yeah, and uh and f luckily I was able to persuade uh the publisher to use my photograph because they did they had not read the book to know that uh this book comes from um from a person who uh yes is at peace with the questioning authority.
- 1:25:10Mark McGrath: Gotta challenge all assumptions.
- 1:25:12Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:25:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, I think that's a great place to wrap up our conversation.
- 1:25:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh Dr.
- 1:25:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Bejan, I think uh having you on the show is is always awesome, always our pleasure, and we thank you for joining us today.
- 1:25:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um can you tell our listeners what you're up to next, what's coming up uh after this book launch and and what your plans are for the future?
- 1:25:29Adrian Bejan, PhD: Well, uh the uh in uh today's academia, because of the internet and all these tools, uh AI is a factor of plagiarism.
- 1:25:42Adrian Bejan, PhD: Um I shy away from uh from uh well from uh talking about uh what is what I'm doing next.
- 1:25:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: But I will say a few things about that.
- 1:25:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: The point is that uh everything, including this uh book is just uh flashed on the screen, soon enough will be uh plagiarized.
- 1:26:01Adrian Bejan, PhD: By the way, the things that I uh came up with, these things about predicting design in nature, have never been refuted.
- 1:26:09Adrian Bejan, PhD: So the uh the constructor law has never been refuted.
- 1:26:14Adrian Bejan, PhD: And that means the physics of design in nature is uh here to stay, no matter what you call it.
- 1:26:21Adrian Bejan, PhD: Except that those who, while failing to refute it, are now doing this kind of work and uh calling it by other names, not constructor law.
- 1:26:31Adrian Bejan, PhD: Okay, so that's uh that's the tongue-in-cheek comment on uh on my peers.
- 1:26:37Adrian Bejan, PhD: But the answer to your question is yes.
- 1:26:39Adrian Bejan, PhD: Currently I'm working on on the fifth edition of my uh theramomics uh uh treatise, which is the most used uh theronomics uh book in English on the globe at the graduate level.
- 1:26:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: And I'm uh I'm actually uh making changes to this uh treatment to make it accessible to students who are taking theronomics as a first course.
- 1:27:02Adrian Bejan, PhD: And I am uh yes, what I'm doing is I'm talking to them in writing the way I'm talking to you.
- 1:27:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: You know, I'm explaining why entropy is to be spoken as a word only by those who know the meaning of the word, but to use other words such as irreversibility or um unintended destruction of uh available work or available power.
- 1:27:27Adrian Bejan, PhD: The wisdom of uh knowing the difference between uh using that power and then wasting it, you see, that's called engineering, is the same as in uh a military campaign.
- 1:27:38Adrian Bejan, PhD: You have a final supply of uh power from the back, it's called uh it's called supply and maintenance and uh hospitals and all these things, including uh defense against attack from the back.
- 1:27:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: There's also that.
- 1:27:53Adrian Bejan, PhD: And um and uh all these things, all these things have a a um a place in education.
- 1:28:02Adrian Bejan, PhD: And by the way, one thing that uh also has a place in education, no matter how specialized, is uh history.
- 1:28:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: Teach teach these young people history because especially in America, that is not being taught.
- 1:28:18Adrian Bejan, PhD: Lots of things are not being taught.
- 1:28:19Adrian Bejan, PhD: Mathematics education is very poor, very poor.
- 1:28:23Adrian Bejan, PhD: Latin and Greek come to mind, I think that that earlier the classics the classic classics are poo-pooed.
- 1:28:31Adrian Bejan, PhD: We're not nobody knows anything about anything.
- 1:28:34Adrian Bejan, PhD: Foreign languages are useful, but uh by default, if anybody gets learns any foreign languages Spanish, well, I have news for you.
- 1:28:43Adrian Bejan, PhD: Spanish, the language had practically zero impact on science.
- 1:28:48Adrian Bejan, PhD: Science, there's a reason for that.
- 1:28:50Adrian Bejan, PhD: It has to do with the uh the Empire of Spain, which is different than the other empires.
- 1:28:55Adrian Bejan, PhD: And um and uh so teach history.
- 1:28:59Adrian Bejan, PhD: Learn history along the way, learn foreign languages, learn them comparatively.
- 1:29:05Adrian Bejan, PhD: If you don't remember one word as you speak English, that happens to me quite often.
- 1:29:10Adrian Bejan, PhD: I remember it in the three other languages.
- 1:29:13Adrian Bejan, PhD: Yes, it's easy for me because Romanian is a Romance language.
- 1:29:18Adrian Bejan, PhD: But but but but question question every step you take and that means every word you speak.
- 1:29:27Adrian Bejan, PhD: Once again, develop the uh technique of uh questioning authority.
- 1:29:32Adrian Bejan, PhD: Oh, you don't have to question uh ver uh audibly.
- 1:29:35Adrian Bejan, PhD: You read something that was written by uh an exponent of authority with a smile, question that because, as I said a second ago, Clint Eastwood was right.
- 1:29:46Adrian Bejan, PhD: Man's got to know his limitations.
- 1:29:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, sir, I think we'll uh wrap right there.
- 1:29:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We'll keep you on the uh show for a few moments while we stop recording.
- 1:29:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thank you so much for being here.
- 1:29:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh I know there'll be next time.
- 1:29:57Mark McGrath: I want to tell our listeners, especially for someone like myself with a liberal arts background, like a Bachelor of Arts and not a science background, I I find your books are some of the best books I've ever read that help teach me actual science and be open to science uh in the way that I learned it in the in the liberal arts perspective, that's not dogmatic and promoting flow and and and inquiry.
- 1:30:22Mark McGrath: So I can't recommend your books enough.
- 1:30:24Adrian Bejan, PhD: But uh let's not put down the liberal arts.
- 1:30:26Adrian Bejan, PhD: Uh no, no, no, no, not at all.
- 1:30:28Adrian Bejan, PhD: Not mentioning the things I uh I um describe uh autobiographically is the fact that in addition to uh to a very, very uh competitive mathematics education and athletics, my parents put me in an art school in uh elementary school, and because they detected that I had an inclination toward making drawings.
- 1:30:53Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:30:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: It was that was very important, very important.
- 1:30:57Adrian Bejan, PhD: I went there for four years among kids who were uh better than I was.
- 1:31:02Adrian Bejan, PhD: I uh I developed, yes, I developed uh this uh aptitude uh to recognize a message when I see something, and then to convey it graphically, because this is Napoleon.
- 1:31:15Adrian Bejan, PhD: The exact quote uh I don't remember, but Napoleon was making fun of all sorts of people uh and was a very good writer.
- 1:31:23Adrian Bejan, PhD: He had a lot of time uh to write in exile, and um he said that uh he would uh stop uh the top general from talking and tell him uh that it would be better if he could if you if he could if he could speak with a simple sketch.
- 1:31:41Mark McGrath: Yes.
- 1:31:42Mark McGrath: Uh believe me, I'm a proponent of the liberal arts.
- 1:31:44Mark McGrath: I'll let's say I'm I'm saying with someone that with a non-engineering background, a non-technical background, I love your work specifically more than others.
- 1:31:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So thank you.
- 1:31:53Mark McGrath: Anyway, all right, Professor Adrian Bijan from Duke University.
- 1:31:57Mark McGrath: Thanks for being with us again.
- 1:31:59Adrian Bejan, PhD: Also known as Adrian.
- 1:32:01Mark McGrath: Adrian, yes, the f the first of three Romanians we've had on the show so far.
- 1:32:05Adrian Bejan, PhD: Well, no, no, no, no.
- 1:32:06Adrian Bejan, PhD: The one and only.
- 1:32:07Adrian Bejan, PhD: The one and only.
- 1:32:08Mark McGrath: That's true, that's true.
- 1:32:09Mark McGrath: All right, we'll keep you on for a moment.
- 1:32:11Mark McGrath: Thank you.