Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Secure Distortions, Bad Therapists, Complex Trauma, and Child Violence
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners, I thought I would answer some upper tier patron emails.
- 0:04I'm working my way through those, so let's get to it. Upper
- 0:07tier patron Jordan. She wrote in and said, I was watching your reactions
- 0:11to Love is Blind and listening to your hypotheses about the different couples. A
- 0:16couple of times you tentatively expressed that you were surprised about calling and Matt saying
- 0:21yes at the altar. As a person with an insecure attachment style myself,
- 0:26I could see all the indicators that they would indeed say yes, and they
- 0:30did say yes. It made me think that folks with secure attachment styles like
- 0:34yourself may have distortions as well. From my perspective, your assertions were vastly
- 0:40underestimating how even destructive conflict can foster intimacy. Can securely attached folks still be
- 0:47prone to cognitive distortions? End of email. Yeah, the short answer is
- 0:53absolutely, and I hope I never said otherwise. One that too. I
- 1:00don't know anyone who is, in my conceptualization of attachment style completely securely attached
- 1:07all the time. I don't even think that's what the theory suggests itself,
- 1:14So to say that somehow securely attached individuals are constantly seeing the world in an
- 1:22undistorted way is of course nonsensical. I as someone who I would say has
- 1:30at least five toes in the secure camp. Absolutely, I distort things all
- 1:36the time, But I'm not sure if what you're talking about is a distortion
- 1:42per se in the way that I use distortions. Distortions I'm using. It's
- 1:46a schema based lens that we look through and we see something that most people
- 1:52would not see, Like, for example, with borderline individuals, they will
- 1:57text someone or just say, a preoccupied individual they text their partner and their
- 2:01partner doesn't text them back immediately. They're at work. Most people would interpret
- 2:07that as well, they'll get back to me when they need to. But
- 2:10someone who's preoccupied will see that as a sign of rejection or they're being cheated
- 2:15on or something like that. You know, that's a distortion. But everyone,
- 2:19even if you're not preoccupied, even if you don't have significant schemas,
- 2:23will distort based on emotions, right, Like, well, I'll just tell
- 2:28you one example just popped into my head. Is one of the clearest indicators
- 2:31of my mood. What mood I'm in is how bothered I get when the
- 2:36dogs start barking randomly. When I'm in a good mood and the dogs start
- 2:40barking randomly, it's delightful, or at the very least it doesn't get under
- 2:46my skin. But when I'm in a bad mood, even just a slightly
- 2:50bad mood, and they start barking like it, it's like nails on a
- 2:53chalkboard. I'm just like, oh my god, dogs like quit it.
- 2:57So would you call that a distortion? Yeah? Maybe, But at the
- 3:00real least I'm you know, affected, everyone is. But what you're talking
- 3:05about is I think is that I was watching the show a reality show,
- 3:10and one of the couples calling in Matt. I thought that Colleen was going
- 3:15to say no at the altar, and you thought that calling in Matt would
- 3:20say yes. They both did say yes at the altar, and I was
- 3:23surprised by that. I wouldn't call that a distortion necessary. I mean,
- 3:27unless you can make some cases to what you're talking about there, I would
- 3:30just call that like I just predicted wrong, you know, and you predicted
- 3:35right. So yeah. The other thing is that insecurely attached individuals, they're
- 3:42not distorting all the time, and I hope I haven't made that connection.
- 3:45I hope I haven't said that insecurely. You know, people with more than
- 3:49five toes in the insecure camp that they are the only ones or they're prone
- 3:53to constant distortion. No, that's not that it's mainly schema based, really,
- 3:59is what I I mean. Definitely attachment triggering is a part of it.
- 4:02But yeah, I think I hope that clears it up all right.
- 4:05This next emails from upperture patron Raymond from the Netherlands. He says, Hey,
- 4:10doctor Honda, I just wanted to inform you about the pineapple on pizza
- 4:15thing here in the Netherlands. Pizza Hawaii existed at least since the nineties.
- 4:20When I grew up. It was actually my favorite pizza. I'd like to
- 4:24also inform you about some other things that apparently surprised you a lot in one
- 4:29of the podcast episodes that you were talking about, which is that Americans are
- 4:32viewed as fake by people in other countries. I cannot speak about other European
- 4:38countries, but here in the Netherlands it is definitely a thing that Americans are
- 4:41considered to be fake by most Dutch people. I think it is actually one
- 4:44of the most commonly considered downsides or criticisms on the US from people living here,
- 4:48alongside the lack of welfare state, the abundant gun ownership, and some
- 4:54very aggressive military interventions in the past by the US government. Of course,
- 4:58whenever I tell people that one day I would like to emigrate to the US,
- 5:01which I visited once with my parents, one of the most common ways
- 5:05people will react to me is, but American people are so fake, as
- 5:09if to say, how can you possibly want to live with those people?
- 5:12Both your emotional expression and social conventions are perceived as exaggerated and overly nice by
- 5:17Dutch people, and of email, Yeah, I've heard that before by various
- 5:21different European peoples and by Asian countries as well. I've heard it from Chinese
- 5:27people that Americans are that way, and yeah, yeah, I could see
- 5:30that. I think that there is a fakeness to the small talkie how you're
- 5:35doing I'm doing fine, or have a good day, or smiling at a
- 5:41stranger, and there's not really intention there to actually interact, you know,
- 5:46like you could get on a bus, a public bus, and someone could
- 5:51smile at you or look in your direction and say good day, and then
- 6:00you could return by thinking, oh, well they're actually interested in me,
- 6:04they care, So then you might actually say, well, actually I'm looking
- 6:09for someone to help me with this one thing, and then the American is
- 6:12like, oh, no, go away, I was just being fake nice.
- 6:15I wasn't actually being nice, you know. So I could see that,
- 6:19and I've heard that from other people. So it must be a thing
- 6:23about Americans for sure, But I don't know. I just kind of wish
- 6:27that people didn't stereotype that severely, because to call like, all Americans fake,
- 6:33three hundred and fifty million people, they're all fake. Like my mom
- 6:38is very nice to people and very smiley and very eye contact you with people,
- 6:42and she actually means it. So she's American through and through, born
- 6:46in Kansas, and she's not fake at all. I would like to think
- 6:49of myself as not being particularly fake. I mean, maybe there's a difference
- 6:56in the way that I will act in public ors. I don't know,
- 6:59But call all Americans fake, I don't know. You know. A similar
- 7:02thing is with Seattle. People will say people in Seattle are cold. They
- 7:08call it the Seattle freeze, where they move to Seattle, and they try
- 7:12to make friends and no one will be their friend. And I, you
- 7:15know, it must be kind of a thing. I've looked into the research
- 7:19on this, and there's not a lot of good research on it. But
- 7:21there's no evidence saying that, suggesting or demonstrating that people in the Pacific Northwest,
- 7:28in the Seattle area have any noticeable differences in personality. There might be
- 7:32different conventions, I suppose, but people in Seattle are not more introverted,
- 7:36for example. There's no data to demonstrate that. You'll see all sorts of
- 7:42things being said about people from Seattle, and a lot of the things I
- 7:46just they just don't register. They don't resonate with me at all. I
- 7:51find people in Seattle to be warm and nice and open and friendly and willing
- 7:57to do things. And I'm born raised in Seattle. Almost everyone I know
- 8:01is from Seattle. And I'm a nice person, and I like to do
- 8:05things, and I like to make new friends, and I like to interact
- 8:07with new people, and I'm same with my friends. And so I don't
- 8:11know. It must be a thing, because if so many people are talking
- 8:16about it, then it must it must be a misunderstanding or some kind of
- 8:20like sometimes I wonder if people moving to Seattle, you know, they're transplants.
- 8:24They're like tech people for Microsoft or one of the other companies Amazon,
- 8:28and they are trying to make friends and it's hard. It's hard to make
- 8:33friends in a new town. It's hard to maybe date in a new town.
- 8:35And they bump up against kind of a laxadaisical attitude from maybe Seattle lights
- 8:43that they interpret as being cold, but it's actually not being cold. Or
- 8:48they invite Seattle lights to do things that Seattle lights don't typically want to do
- 8:54generally speaking, like let's go to the beach or so, I don't know,
- 8:56I'm just trying to think of something that is Seattle light wouldn't be that
- 9:00prone to doing. They get blown off because of that, and then they
- 9:03just conclude that all people from Seattle are cold. I don't know. I
- 9:07just think that these generalizations are kind of veiled xenophobic ideas. Americans are pretty
- 9:13privileged, So I don't really I don't lament for people bashing Americans. Really,
- 9:18you know, it's and you know it is legit to criticize America and
- 9:24our federal government for as you say, aggressive military engagements that weren't great and
- 9:31were horrible in a lot of ways, Vietnam, Iraq, other places.
- 9:35Right, So I get it, but I didn't vote for those people that
- 9:39did those things. Let's put it that way. You know. I didn't
- 9:43support those things. I marched against those things, and somehow I'm lumped in
- 9:46with the whole thing. I don't know it. It just doesn't seem like
- 9:50it's very fair. But you know, like I said, people do this,
- 9:54and there's probably some truth to all of it, all right. In
- 9:56the six emails from Upture Patron from Hong Kong, she says, my partner
- 10:01cheated on me and then blamed it on me because I had borderline persone order
- 10:05and I couldn't handle the truth. My therapist encouraged me to break up,
- 10:09although I told her I wanted their relationship back. However, my life coach
- 10:15suggested that I stopped seeing myself as a victim and I shouldn't improve myself to
- 10:18get my partner back. Shouldn't the therapist be my ally and help me reach
- 10:22the goal of getting my relationship back? Is it inherently wrong for someone with
- 10:26borderline personize order to stay in a hurtful relationship. Is it clinically bad for
- 10:31someone with borderline personage order to repair the relationship with their partners after being cheated
- 10:35on? End of email? Well, I don't know what is going on
- 10:39in the therapy session or with your life coach, just based on what you're
- 10:43saying here, these are problems, So let me comb through this. You
- 10:48were cheated on. That's not okay, that's awful. No one can blame
- 10:52me for it. You say that you suffer from borderline persone order, my
- 10:58conflict and relationship tension reduced the quality of the relationship for your partner that led
- 11:05them to making the unfortunate choice to cheat. Perhaps, but that doesn't mean
- 11:09you're to blame for the cheating, of course not. The individual made those
- 11:13choices and they are fully responsible for making those choices. You're a partner,
- 11:20so that's one number two. You say that your therapist encourage you to break
- 11:24up. I don't know what exactly happened in the session. Maybe the therapist
- 11:28would refute that description, but no therapists should be unless it's something really obvious,
- 11:35like you're about to be killed or something, or there's massive bodily harm
- 11:41at risk, which This does not constitute No therapists should be suggesting anything regarding
- 11:48this. They shouldn't even be thinking these kinds of things, Like I purged
- 11:52myself of the arrogant notion years and years ago that I somehow knew what's asked
- 12:00for clients along those lines. So the fact that if your therapist did suggest
- 12:05or encourage you to break up, that is a huge problem that a therapist
- 12:09would do that, especially when you're saying that you don't want to like who's
- 12:15it? And then your life coach says that you need to stop seeing yourself
- 12:20as a victim. What I do not understand this phrase she sees herself as
- 12:26a victim. I've never understood what the fuck people are talking about when they
- 12:31use that phrase. And really it's a huge red flag of someone who has
- 12:35no idea what they're talking about, and it's just victim blaming. Like no
- 12:41one wants to see themselves as a victim. I mean, I suppose some
- 12:43people will fake being a victim, or will fake that they've been harmed in
- 12:48ways that they weren't. But you were cheated on of course, you're going
- 12:56to see yourself as a victim. The love of your life, your attachment
- 12:58figure, your person who said they wouldn't do things like that completely betrayed your
- 13:05relationship, and that's going to absolutely tweak anyone, let alone someone that has
- 13:11borderline personality. So seeing yourself as a victim. Now again, I don't
- 13:16know what actually happened in session. You might be distorting it, you might
- 13:20be mis remembering, maybe there's a misunderstanding. But any professional or anybody who
- 13:24just tells you to break up or tells you to stop seeing yourself as a
- 13:30victim, I just it just raises major questions as through their competent competency level.
- 13:35And the other part of this is, like your life coach suggests you
- 13:37should stop seeing yourself as a victim and that you should improve yourself to get
- 13:41your partner back. I mean yish. So you ask, shouldn't the therapist
- 13:46be your ally and help you reach your goal? Yeah, as long as
- 13:50the goal isn't abhorrent or an ethical or unhealthy. There's nothing wrong with wanting
- 13:56to recover after infidelity. That's a known thing, that's known healthy thing to
- 14:01want to do. It's not always possible, but it's absolutely possible to do.
- 14:05And then you say, is it inherently wrong for someone with borderline to
- 14:09stay in a hurtful relationship. No. No, In fact, I would
- 14:13guess that well. I would say all of us are in relationships that are
- 14:16hurtful from time to time. It's just a matter of degree and how you
- 14:18want to live your life. Now, is there a conversation there around some
- 14:22people with borderline putting up with things that they deserve to not put up with.
- 14:28Yeah, but you know, as long as that's not happening. And
- 14:31then you ask, is it clinically bad for someone with porderline to repair their
- 14:33relationship after being cheated on? No, it's not clinically bad. It's not
- 14:37bad. It's not bad ethically, it's not bad morally. There's a lot
- 14:41of good that can come from that. It's up to you, of course,
- 14:45but you know that if your partner who cheated on you is up for
- 14:48it, there's you can be stronger because of it afterwards, you know,
- 14:52all right, let's take a break. We get back more emails. We're
- 14:58back from the break. This is another email from upartier Patron Raymond from the
- 15:03Netherlands. I won't read his email because it was long, but I did
- 15:05read it. Raymond, and you said a lot of nice things, and
- 15:09I am I feel very warm inside from all the nice things that you said.
- 15:15All right, This next emails from anonymous upartier patron. She says,
- 15:18my therapist says that I have complex PTSD resulting from sexual abuse from my master's
- 15:22thesis advisor during graduate school and electrical engineering. I stayed to finish my master's
- 15:28degree because I had a National Foundation mount money that was awarded to me,
- 15:35so I felt trapped. You usually talk about complex PTSD from childhood trauma.
- 15:39Can you elaborate more on complex PTSD from adult trauma, from young adult trauma
- 15:45and of email. Yeah, well, at some point I'm going to do
- 15:48a deep dive on complex PTSD. Half the reason why I want to do
- 15:52is because I want to get into the literature because I feel like the literature
- 15:56is kind of all over the place, and especially online discussion and also the
- 16:03lay person's discussion about complex PTSD. I'm glad that people know about it,
- 16:07but there just seemed to be a lot of misunderstanding around it. And so
- 16:12to answer your question, yeah, I absolutely do usually refer to complex drama
- 16:18referring to early childhood abuse, but absolutely adults can experience complex drama. Anyone
- 16:25of any age can experience complex drama and thus develop complex PTSD. Originally,
- 16:30the word complex and I'm sure I'll get into this when I do the deep
- 16:33dive eventually, but originally, at its core, the word complex it just
- 16:38means that PTSD is presenting in a complicated manner, and thus the treatment needs
- 16:44to be complicated as well, because quote unquote, simple PTSD might be that
- 16:49you were in war, or you were in a car accident, or you're
- 16:56a first responder at nine to eleven, for example, and it's this discrete
- 17:02event that happened to you and would be absolutely difficult. I mean, we
- 17:06don't equate simple PTSD with easy PTSD can be just as debilitating as any sort
- 17:11of complex PTSD, but it's a discrete event. It's a set of memories
- 17:18experiences that through PTSD treatment and through recall and narrativesing of the events for the
- 17:26client, it's pretty easily encapsulated into a narrative. You know, I was
- 17:33I arrived at nine to eleven, and I saw dead buddy bodies on the
- 17:37ground, and there was blood and there was one person that was heavily injured
- 17:41and my friend died. You know, you can talk about it. Whereas
- 17:47when you go through ongoing trauma from your father or from your master's thesis advisor,
- 17:55it's really complicated because the I don't know, but I'm guessing that he
- 18:00groomed you, and that he made you do things that you didn't want to
- 18:03do inside or made you act like you did want to do them. You
- 18:07know, there's a lot of self shame involved in complex trauma. Often the
- 18:12victim often feels like they're to blame partially, if not fully, for having
- 18:17even participated in it. That kind of thing, So it complicates the trauma,
- 18:22and thus it complicates the presentation. For someone with simple PTSD. Let's
- 18:26say they get in a car accident and they come into my office and we
- 18:30work on exposure therapy to cure them of their PTSD. The individual, you
- 18:36know, as long as they don't have some other kind of trauma, they're
- 18:40going to react to me in a way that will not interfere with treatment.
- 18:44Whereas someone with complex PTSD comes into my office and say they were sexually assaulted
- 18:49and abused over ten years by their father. Well, through transference, they're
- 18:53going to start to be suspicious and afraid of me, maybe even I to
- 19:00seduce me because of some complex around that. That's not very common, but
- 19:03you know what I mean, there's a lot of different reactivity from individuals with
- 19:07this complex trauma, and thus they present in therapy in a very complex way.
- 19:11And you know, we could, I could start working on the PTSD,
- 19:15but they might actually be really triggered by something that I said, or
- 19:19the way that I looked or something, and thus they we might ninety percent
- 19:25of time just be talking about their distortions about me. And that's pretty complicated,
- 19:30right, It's a lot more complicated than just talking about a carc in
- 19:33it. So that's what we mean by in a nutshell, that's what we
- 19:37mean by in the beginning, at the core of complex trauma. But eventually
- 19:41the term started to refer to basically ongoing attachment figure abuse in which you feel
- 19:48trapped, and thus it complicates the trauma because of that, and thus the
- 19:52presentation it is complicated in therapy, and the treatment has to be complicated as
- 19:56well. But you absolutely went through complicated trauma, right. You were traumatized
- 20:03by someone who's supposed to protect you. You were traumatized by someone who was
- 20:07in authority over you over three years. Right, they were in control of
- 20:11your life for three years. You were traumatized in a particular way. Like
- 20:15I said, you were probably made to act like you were into it or
- 20:19that you were okay with it. You probably had to push your selfhood into
- 20:23the back, into the backgrounds just so you could cope with the situation,
- 20:27to protect yourself. So yeah, that's absolutely what we would consider complex trauma.
- 20:33But really it doesn't matter what we call it. When people come into
- 20:36my office, I don't think of people in terms of those labels. I
- 20:40think of them in terms of their specific experiences. I think more in terms
- 20:42of schemas, honestly, because it's much more descriptive. It's much more helpful
- 20:48to treatment when I because you can go through complex trauma and develop any number
- 20:52of different types of syndromes. Because of the complex trauma, there are so
- 20:56many different schemas that can be developed. Right, you could develop a schema
- 21:00where you believe that everyone's going to hurt you. You could both develop a
- 21:03schema where or a schema reactivity in which you feel like you deserve to be
- 21:07harmed. You could develop a schema where you feel like you have to take
- 21:10care of people, or that you don't matter in life, or that people
- 21:12are going to abandon you. You know, there's a lot of different flavors
- 21:15to this. So just knowing complex trauma or even a semi diagnosis of complicated
- 21:22PTSD complex PTSD's it's not super helpful. I need to know ground level what
- 21:30the specific manifestation of the trauma is to that individual, right, so I
- 21:36don't really care what label we put to. You go on to say in
- 21:38your email, can you also talk about how women and how women in a
- 21:42mostly male field are not respected. Not only did he abuse me, but
- 21:47he also made it feel like I was only valued for my looks and not
- 21:51my intellect. It was. It has affected me at later jobs, especially
- 21:56since I have always been the only female in my department. I am continually
- 22:00struggling with my abilities and confidence in the workplace. End of email. Yeah,
- 22:04this is atrocious. It's a well known studied fact of certain fields like
- 22:12electrical engineering, for example, which is what you're in. And yeah,
- 22:18we live in a misogynist society. And whenever you have a group of men
- 22:22who don't have to face their misogyny and their sexism. Then the sexism will
- 22:30run rampant and they will encourage each other. And yeah, it's awful.
- 22:36It's just so idiotic too, and I'm so sorry you're going through that.
- 22:40And this is part of the complicated nature of the trauma, right, You
- 22:42were traumatized in a way that although at your core you know that you're a
- 22:48good person and you know that you're smart, and you know you're worthy,
- 22:49but you were treated in a way that is very complicated. You're treated It
- 22:55might not have been explicitly said to you, but you were treated in a
- 22:57way that demonstrated that you don't add and that you're not smart, and you're
- 23:00not competent in electoral engineering, and that your only worth of life is how
- 23:07attractive you are to men and what use you can give them in terms of
- 23:11sexual satisfaction and gratification. That is a even though at your core you know
- 23:17that's not true. You've been treated like that for so long because you were
- 23:19trapped that that teaches you a lesson that makes you wonder if if those messages
- 23:26are true, right, And so you know, I'm glad you're in therapy
- 23:29and I'm just yeah, I'm just so sorry. You're going through that all
- 23:33right. Sext emails from up to your patron, Daniel, he says a
- 23:37man I dated and fell in love with, broke up with me, then
- 23:41he came back, then he ghosted me, and then he tried to return
- 23:44again, and that time I did not take him back. Sure bring being
- 23:48broken up with hurt and I wanted him back. But what hurt more is
- 23:52when he tried to come back again. What could be causing his reactions and
- 23:57why? Why does it hurt so much? I've noticed this pattern from past
- 24:02romantic relationships and even platonic friendships. I should note that my mom did this
- 24:06to me at one point as well, when I was a teenager during my
- 24:08parents divorce. And to be mail, well, I'm sorry Daniel that that
- 24:14happens. That's rough. I don't know what's happening, and I don't if
- 24:18I heard from the two of you, I don't know what I would think.
- 24:22But the bottom line is it just sucks to be dumped. It sucks
- 24:26to be treated in a way that makes it feel like you don't matter,
- 24:29like like you're not good enough. Right, it's just the worst to just
- 24:33to be I mean, there's someone I hate to use these words, but
- 24:38to be discarded by someone that you love, that once loved you, to
- 24:45just be like thrown away. Yeah, it's heart wrenching. It it's the
- 24:49worst. That's why there's so many sad songs on the radio. I mean,
- 24:53we've all been there and it's painful. So you know, you say,
- 24:59why is it hurts much? Scientifically attachment wise, it's because we are
- 25:03desperate. We evolved to couple and to want to establish secure attachments. We
- 25:10don't feel right unless we do have secure attachments. We have a lot of
- 25:14emotions that motivate us. You know. The one way to look at it
- 25:18is that when you have a three year old child and they are separated from
- 25:25their parents. Let's just talk about two hundred thousand years ago in the African
- 25:29place of seeing Savannah, and the three year old child somehow gets separated from
- 25:33their parents, you know, the three year old human, and they evolved.
- 25:37A child evolved initially to get upset, to scream, to yell out
- 25:45and say where's mommy, where's daddy, and maybe to cry to wail to
- 25:49alert so the parents nearby will run and get the kids so the kid doesn't
- 25:53get eaten by a panther, which would happen back then and still to this
- 25:59day some extent, but so that the child doesn't need to be told to
- 26:04have that emotion, doesn't need to be told to cry, doesn't need to
- 26:07be told to whale. The child innately, instinctually does that. Then if
- 26:12the parents don't show up, though, the thinking goes is that eventually the
- 26:18strategy emotionally is that the child's better strategy at that point is to shut down
- 26:25and wait for their parents to find them, because if they run around screaming,
- 26:30then predators will find them and eat them. So there's that trade off
- 26:34right in the beginning. What we as humans do when we lose someone close
- 26:40to us is to yell and scream and fight to try to get that attachment
- 26:45back, And in relationships we do this by trying to convince them no,
- 26:51no, no, don't break up with me. We need to all change,
- 26:55or you're not looking at it correctly, or that was just a bad
- 26:59patch. Well we'll do better and we'll go to a couple of stairs.
- 27:00Okay, that's that first phase. That's the wailing fighting phase. The second
- 27:06phase is depression, is sadness and shutting down. The idea goes is that
- 27:11and pain right, and just demoralization, no motivation, no optimism, And
- 27:18the theory is the hypothesis John Bowlby and others put forth that children evolved and
- 27:25humans evolved this mechanism that in the beginning, when we lose our attachment figures,
- 27:30when we're just you know, hunting and gathering on the African savannah two
- 27:36hundred thousand years ago, if we just lost our attachment figures, they're probably
- 27:42nearby, so we should wail and scream, because they probably hear us and
- 27:47come to us. But if it's been a while and we've already wailed and
- 27:49screamed, they're probably not within earshot, and thus it's a tradeoff. We
- 27:56could continue to scream and whale because what if they're still looking for us,
- 27:59But it's actually more advantageous to shut down because the likelihood of being eaten by
- 28:06a predator goes up the longer we are away from our our kin. And
- 28:11also there's probably a good chance that our kin isn't around to even hear us
- 28:15anyway. So the strategy is to shut down depression, no motivation, don't
- 28:21move, just get under a bush and wait, and then hope hopefully eventually
- 28:26someone will find you. And so we go through these these emotions when we
- 28:30get dumped, right, we bargain, we get upset, we try to
- 28:33fight, and then eventually we get demoralized and it hurts, and no motivation.
- 28:38What's the point in living, what's the point in dating anymore? It's
- 28:42it's a normal reaction that we have. It's the same that we have to
- 28:47loss, like a divorce or a death, or the loss of a job,
- 28:52or loss of an ability. You know, if you suddenly lose the
- 28:56ability to walk or something, you go through similar kind of emotions. And
- 29:02yeah, it hurts. It's it's normal. So that's a short answer as
- 29:07to why it hurts so much. It's human to hurt. And then you
- 29:11said that you know what's causing his reactions? You know, why did he
- 29:15break up with you and then come back and then ghost to you and then
- 29:18try to return. I don't know. I mean, there's a billion answers
- 29:22to that, and even if I had a lot of data, I might
- 29:26still not know why. You know, dating and romantic love it just it's
- 29:33fucking weird. I mean, how do you explain it? And when we're
- 29:38in it, like me, and my wife. We have a good relationship,
- 29:41and I don't walk around questioning things because because everything's fine. We tend
- 29:47to ask questions when we get dumped. We also don't tend to ask questions
- 29:51when we dump other people. We're like, well, I know why I
- 29:55dumped him because da dada. But when we get dumped, that's when all
- 29:57the questions start coming up. But we don't know the answer to any of
- 30:00the questions. We don't like, why, why why has my wife not
- 30:03dumped me? I don't know the You know, she might have an answer
- 30:08to that, but it'd be very amorphous and very metaphorical in terms of the
- 30:14answer. There's no there's no concrete answer to that question. So there's no
- 30:18concrete answer as to why he's doing this and why he's dumping you and why
- 30:21he's ghosting you. Like, it's just hard to know. I mean,
- 30:25maybe he's a selfish bastard, or just maybe he's confused. I don't know.
- 30:27There's a million different reasons as to why that would be. Ben.
- 30:32You also say basically that this is a pattern from past or magic relationships and
- 30:37also platonic relationships. You're wondering why that is, well, hard to know.
- 30:41Sometimes it could just be the sort of people you hang out with the
- 30:45age group, right, Like, I don't know how old you are,
- 30:48Daniel, but if you were eighteen, I would say, well, you
- 30:52know, you're eighteen, and if you're hanging out with other eighteen year olds,
- 30:55this this kind of par for the course. Not always, but there's
- 30:57not a lot of stability in dating at eighteen. But if you were older
- 31:03than maybe I'd say something different. I don't know, but it's possible that
- 31:07if it's a pattern that there are two avenues in therapy you want to look
- 31:11down. One is am I picking people to try to recreate a past relationship?
- 31:18Am I sniffing out that individual that will do this to me subconsciously because
- 31:22I'm trying to recreate a past relationship that kind of looked like this. So
- 31:25that's one question you want to explore. The second is am I doing something
- 31:30in the relationship once we're in a relationship that is subconsciously actually encouraging this recreation
- 31:37to happen anyway, Because if you see something happening over and over again in
- 31:41your relationships, then the common denominator is you. Now you could just have
- 31:45bad luck, like I said, it could have nothing to do with your
- 31:49personality and your traumas. But anytime you see a pattern, like how come
- 31:56everyone I date and have you end up everyone I end up in a long
- 32:00term relationship with? How come they always end up working too much and cheating
- 32:06on me? Or I don't know? Or how come they always end up
- 32:09falling into an addiction? Or how come they always end up just shutting down
- 32:15their emotions and becoming completely cut off from me or whatever? It's who knows,
- 32:21you could have just had some bad luck that happens. You know,
- 32:24dating is luck. There is so much luck in dating. There's so much
- 32:30luck, and we tend not to recognize that. It's a roll the dice.
- 32:35It's a numbers game. Sometimes you meet the one in high school,
- 32:40the very first person you ever date could be the one. Or it might
- 32:45take it forty years to find the one. It's and it's what's the difference.
- 32:50There luck sometimes that, but sometimes it's also you. It's them as
- 32:58well, because it's not like you're completely to blame for what they did.
- 33:01But you might be, like I said, either sniffing them out to begin
- 33:06with and or coaxing them subconsciously through projective idification to adhere to your recreation of
- 33:14past trauma. All right, stake a break, we get back more emails.
- 33:17Let's do this all right. Back from the break, let's do an
- 33:23opp These people became patrons all the way back in twenty twenty. We have
- 33:28Anna from Calgary, Alberta. We have Alexandra from God knows where. We
- 33:31have uppertire patron Heather from Newton, Massachusetts. We have Jessica from God knows
- 33:37where. Nealina Nealna from Anchorage, Alaska. We have uppertire patron Compitt.
- 33:42We have Sena from Denmark. I believe annual patron SNA. We have Syrian
- 33:49from Uptre patron Syrian from my Ireland, Yeah, Ireland, I e is
- 33:52Ireland. Angel from Tucson, Arizona or on Hell. We have Esper from
- 33:59Lakewood, Colorado. We got casse Role from Dallas, Texas. We have
- 34:04Sasha from Detroit, Catherine from God knows where. We have Kayla from Wren,
- 34:07Washington, where I was born. Alyssa from Great Britain. We have
- 34:12Christina from God knows where. We have Samuel from San Bernardino, California.
- 34:15Jennifer from Los Angeles, Mia, from Great Britain and Jenny from North Hollywood.
- 34:22Up to your patron, Jenny from North Hollywood, California. Thanks for
- 34:24being a patron through thick and thin, y'all all right? This next email
- 34:29is from highest tier patron Anonymous from Beirut. She says, I just wanted
- 34:35to write in and say how much I enjoyed you and Rebecca covering Reddit posts.
- 34:38We consider covering more in the future. For example, I have this
- 34:43Reddit post i'd like you to look at. I don't know if you would
- 34:45cover this, but the post above was devastating to read, and I cannot
- 34:50imagine the impact this client and her boyfriend will continue to face because of the
- 34:53therapist actions. If you're insted, if you're interested, I'd love to hear
- 34:58your take on this. End of email. Yeah, so I'm going to
- 35:00read excerpts from the Reddit post here. So tldr my meaning and a twenty
- 35:07six female. So this is a post by a twenty six year old female,
- 35:13and the boyfriend is a twenty eight year old male, and the therapist
- 35:15is a thirty seven year old female. So my twenty six year old female
- 35:21boyfriend twenty eight year old male had an affair with my therapist thirty seven year
- 35:24old female. So, my boyfriend had an affair with my therapist because she
- 35:29pressured him and bad mouth me, and I don't know what to do now.
- 35:32My therapist has been very helpful in helping me better reflect on my emotions
- 35:37and better articulate my needs. After a while, I noticed that my therapist
- 35:42was acting increasingly strange. Whereas before she was very neutral and asked more pointed
- 35:46questions that allowed me to reflect on my behavior in relation to my relationship patterns
- 35:51on my behavior, whereas now she increasingly began to bad mouth my relationship with
- 35:57my boyfriend and blame me for my relationship problems. Yesterday, my boyfriend suddenly
- 36:01had tears in his eyes, and then he confessed to me that he was
- 36:05having an affair with my therapist. He cried the whole time and reassured me
- 36:08that he regrets it and doesn't want to lose me. In his words,
- 36:12my therapist put so much pressure on him that he didn't know what to do
- 36:15and couldn't say no. I guess it started when she invited him to a
- 36:20one on one session. That's when the affair began. That was months ago,
- 36:23and since then they have been meeting secretly ever since. Dear people on
- 36:28Reddit, how do I deal with this situation? Okay? And then there's
- 36:31an update here, Hello everybody, regarding my therapist. I have reported to
- 36:36her and I am in the process of suing for damages. Hopefully she won't
- 36:40have anything left after I'm done with her. The end of reddit post.
- 36:45So we can't know if this post is accurate or not. People make up
- 36:51stories on Reddit all the time. But if it is accurate, and I
- 36:54don't have any reason to believe it's not accurate, is for me. So
- 37:00if we take it as at face value, Yeah, that's awful. I've
- 37:04heard stuff like this happening before. It is atrocious. It's rare, but
- 37:08it does happen. Sounds like, you know, she was going to a
- 37:13therapist for a long time. Things were going well, which is good.
- 37:16Then the two of them, the client and the therapists, bring in her
- 37:20boyfriend to therapy, maybe as a one off session, and for whatever reason,
- 37:25the boyfriend and the and the therapists hit it off. The therapist,
- 37:30well, I guess the way the boyfriend describes it as the therapist manipulated him.
- 37:37Hard to know what that would look like It's very possible the therapist was
- 37:40in a position of power. Therapist could have used a lot of techniques to
- 37:46trick him, or to convince him or something. I don't know, it's
- 37:51hard to know. He also could have been participating you as a fifty fifty.
- 37:55But the way he describes it, it sounds pretty awful, right that
- 38:00he's crying and he's saying I regret it, and that the therapists put a
- 38:06lot of pressure on him and he didn't know what to do and he couldn't
- 38:08say no. I don't know. It's just a lot of questions. It
- 38:12could be anywhere from a psychopathic therapist who knows exactly how to manipulate people and
- 38:17used her position of power to do so. Certainly could be along those lines.
- 38:22Or it could have been more of a fifty fifty thing and or he
- 38:27pressured her. I mean, there's just no way to know. But either
- 38:30way, it's great that the poster the Unreddit reported her, because this is
- 38:37a huge sign of a problem. When therapists do stuff like this, it
- 38:43doesn't usually happen in isolation. There's this usually is the tip of the iceberg
- 38:47in terms of all the problems that the therapist has committed. It's usually not
- 38:52the first time or only time that they have done something like this, And
- 38:57yeah, they absolutely need to be reported, one hundred percent, And absolutely
- 39:00the client has every right to take it to civil court and sue the therapist
- 39:07for damages because there are damages and you know, emotional damages. There's a
- 39:13relationship came to an end because of it. So yeah, so you ask
- 39:20upper tier or highest your patron from Beirut anonymous, you're asking what I think
- 39:25about it? Pretty you know, open and shut case of a therapist that
- 39:34is terribly unethical. In my experience, these therapists have characterological problems, personality
- 39:40disorder spectrums of some sort. I've seen narcissistic therapists who will commit acts like
- 39:47this and feel justified. I've seen psychopathic therapists do stuff like this as well.
- 39:53Being a therapist doesn't mean that you don't have some problem like that.
- 39:58It also doesn't mean that you can be helpful. You know, it's possible
- 40:01that this therapist, for the clients that she's worked with, she was very
- 40:07helpful. So it doesn't mean that she was a monster constantly. It could
- 40:12mean that, but it often doesn't, So there's that. Also, therapists
- 40:16who commit acts like this are usually experiencing a lot of stress in their personal
- 40:22life at the time. Often they're going through a divorce, or they're lonely
- 40:27or some kind of despair that they're going through, and they become desperate for
- 40:31closeness. And then they have a client that they feel like maybe there would
- 40:36be a connection there, and they ignore all the warning signs and all the
- 40:42voices in their head that are telling them to not do this, and because
- 40:45they're so desperate, they're just so desperate for closeness or reassurance or power or
- 40:52something that they forego all of their training and all their ethical know how.
- 40:59So but you know, I don't know what happens specifically, but interesting Reddit.
- 41:05And yeah, if y'all want me to look at a Reddit post and
- 41:07talk about it, or you want me and Bob or me and Rebecca,
- 41:12me and burto, I'd be open to that kind of thing going on here.
- 41:16With another email from up to your patron anonymous, she says, during
- 41:22the fourteenth Annual stream, you mentioned that you have played Dungeons and Dragons by
- 41:28yourself. I am curious as to how you played Dungeons and Dragons by yourself,
- 41:32end of email. Well, briefly, this is just my version of
- 41:37playing D and D by myself. What I will do is I will make
- 41:40I like to play the classic characters, the fighter, the cleric, the
- 41:45wizard, and the thief. That's just I grew up with that classic archetypal
- 41:52for some and I just every time I try to break out from it,
- 41:55I'm like, oh, you know, I should play a monk, or
- 41:57I should play a rain or a druid, and I just never resonate with
- 42:04those characters. And so I make four characters and I really try to flesh
- 42:09out their backstory, and it's almost like writing a novel or something where I
- 42:15make up these I imagine these characters and I actually have these go to characters
- 42:22that I play. I years ago developed this campaign for my friends, and
- 42:30I really fleshed out this one town in Forgotten Realm's feather Falls. It's on
- 42:34the map, it's in the day ends if you're familiar, and in the
- 42:38manuals they don't really describe this little town very much. And so it gave
- 42:43me a chance to really flesh it out. And the characters that I made
- 42:47up for this little town. I will pick different characters from the town and
- 42:52I will play them as characters in campaigns. If you listen to me play
- 42:59with the guys Berto and Adam and Adam on this podcast, I always do
- 43:04that. I always pluck one of the characters from the town blazon are these
- 43:07kinds of people anyway, So I make the characters. I have already have
- 43:12a backstory for a lot of these characters, and then I read the adventure
- 43:16pretty thoroughly, or I make up a scenario pretty thoroughly. So I want
- 43:22as a dungeon master, I want to understand the landscape so that I don't
- 43:27need to flip through the book and figure out what's going on. Then when
- 43:30I sit down and play, I just sit at my desk right here where
- 43:35I'm recording right now, and I begin the adventure, and I imagine myself
- 43:40at each person's shoes. So I will step into the position of dungeon master
- 43:46and imagine what I know as a dungeon master. Then a scenario like say
- 43:52that a classic opening to an adventure is the players enter a tavern. They
- 44:00have to meet with someone to give them the mission. Okay, so the
- 44:02four characters enter the tavern and say a fight breaks out. Okay, it's
- 44:07a little fun, one off, little scenario in the adventure, and the
- 44:14player characters have to react to it. So I lay out the scenario.
- 44:19Let's say, you know, two brutes come up to the player characters and
- 44:22say, we don't like your kind here, and one of them throws a
- 44:25punch at the fighter or something, and then I roll initiative, and then
- 44:30I put myself in each player's shoes. I was, Okay, the fighter,
- 44:36what's his personality, what just happened to him? What is within his
- 44:40visual field? He only has a couple of seconds to think what would he
- 44:45typically do, and so he'd be like, well, he'd probably do this,
- 44:50and then he does that thing. And then okay, the wizard.
- 44:52What's the wizard's personality, Like, what are their options? How do they
- 44:58think? And then I take an action for the WI and I just go
- 45:00around and around in that way. And it's really not that much different than
- 45:05just being a dungeon master, because when you're a dungeon master, you have
- 45:07to enter the mind of your non player characters, your NPCs. You know
- 45:12that when the two brutes walk up, if I did have four actual human
- 45:15beings I was playing Dungeons and Dragons with. I have to, as a
- 45:19dungeon master, enter into the mindset of the brute, right, and I
- 45:22have to think like the brute, and I have to only know what the
- 45:27brute would know. I can't know what I would know. I have to
- 45:30think in terms of what the brute would know, right, and act in
- 45:34terms of the brutes personality. And there are you know, hundreds of NPC's
- 45:38that a dungeon master will in body or in monsters and this kind of thing,
- 45:43So I just extend that into the players. You can almost think of
- 45:45it like I'm playing with four NPCs and there are no players. For whatever
- 45:52reason, you know, I will say that it is, you know,
- 45:54one of those tropes of being a pathetic nerd that you're playing does as of
- 46:01Dragons by yourself. You know, not only are you a pathetic nerd for
- 46:06playing does as Dragons, but you're so much of a pathetic nerd that no
- 46:08one wants to play does as Dragons with you? And okay, fine,
- 46:13But for me sometimes I just like the cleanliness of it, because, you
- 46:19know, getting a bunch of friends together to play it's kind of hard,
- 46:22and sometimes it playing by yourself. I've had some really awesome adventures by myself,
- 46:29you know, not even close to the awesome adventures I've had with other
- 46:32people. It doesn't, it doesn't. It's it's just like something to do
- 46:38late at night. If I'm into something, I haven't done it in a
- 46:43while, but talking about it now it makes me want to do it again,
- 46:47all right. The sext email is from a pier patron, an anonymous
- 46:51Up to your patron, she says, Hi, doctor up. My sister
- 46:52just started working with children ages three to eleven, and when she describes the
- 46:59kids play, or the behavior of certain kids that act out more than others,
- 47:04it sounds really violent, and my sister is struggling to identify normal play
- 47:07from play that seems to take it to a step too far. So my
- 47:12questions are, is there a normal level of violence in play among children under
- 47:16eleven years old? At what point can a child's behavior be labeled as abusive?
- 47:21At what point can one say a child is no longer innocent? I
- 47:24hate the idea of being afraid of a child, and I want to believe
- 47:28that they're they're all innocent. But I know you have said that they aren't,
- 47:31and I trust you way more than I trust my extremely limited knowledge on
- 47:35this subject. End of email. Yeah, well, I don't know if
- 47:39I've said that some children are innocent and some children are not. The label
- 47:45of innocence is a bit of a complicated thing that the word that I would
- 47:52use is that all people, regardless of age, are capable of violence and
- 47:58abuse, and it's just that some people have it much more likely that they're
- 48:05going to commit that behavior because they have had that behavior model to them,
- 48:09they've had that behavior done to them, and they have emotional regulation issues or
- 48:15behavior regulation issues that result in them being that way. So you can have
- 48:21an abusive kid and the kid would still be In my mind, I guess
- 48:24considered innocence really in a sense, now that I think about it, I
- 48:29think of everyone of every age of possessing that childhood innocence that we talk about.
- 48:35You know, when I talk about a forty five year old husband who
- 48:39is beating his wife, I don't excuse his behavior, and I think it's
- 48:45criminal and needs to stop. Absolutely. At the same time, I see
- 48:50that forty five year old man as a small, innocent human being who doesn't
- 48:55know what they're doing and could learn a new way. They were given a
- 49:00chance. So in terms of innocence, being violent doesn't negate that innocence and
- 49:07regardless of what age you are. But yeah, this is a hard subject.
- 49:12You know, when kids are abusive and violent, it's it's hard to
- 49:15deal with, both emotionally and practically, Like how do you stop a child
- 49:20from doing this? Because when it becomes a pattern, it it's hard to
- 49:24change. And I've worked with kids like this. Plus there's so much stigma.
- 49:30People will say, like, well, all kids are innocent. What
- 49:32you know, if you had a kid, for example, who was doing
- 49:36this, like your own child, or a student, say you're a kid
- 49:39or garden teacher and you had a student that was doing this, I think
- 49:44you'd find a lot of people would say like, well, just discipline the
- 49:47kid, Like what's wrong with how how come you can't manage the situation?
- 49:51Or you must be doing something wrong as a parent or as a teacher.
- 49:57And there's just not a lot of support out there want to look the other
- 50:00way, and it's I've seen it before. I've seen I've been called into
- 50:05situations like this and the problem will have been going on for years and they
- 50:12just the parents. Often it's parents that I'm involved with, and the parents
- 50:15are just completely frazzled and completely shameful of themselves. And so a lot of
- 50:22my work with these families has to do with deprogramming a lot of that shame
- 50:25because it's not going to help. But to get into specifics, and I
- 50:30could talk for a long time about this, and of course we'd have to
- 50:32see demonstrations and look, you know, look at case examples, but generally
- 50:38speaking, when we're talking, your question is, what's a normal level of
- 50:44violence for kids under eleven years old? Well, there's a huge difference between
- 50:49those aged groups, and we could break it down by maybe five categories of
- 50:54kids under the age of eleven, but really, for the sake of time,
- 50:59I'll just talk maybe like a three year old normal level and abnormal level,
- 51:04and maybe a ten year old. So for three year old children,
- 51:08it's normal for a preschool age kid to hit people, hit other kids,
- 51:15maybe even adults, right, and to throw things occasionally when they're upset,
- 51:21when they're curious, when they're riled up. For example, if they're three
- 51:25years old and they're playing with another kid and the kid doesn't share you know,
- 51:31the say that your kid, your own daughter, is playing with dolls
- 51:38and the other kid won't hand over one of the dolls. It's normal for
- 51:44your kid to punch or pull hair, or throw a tantrum or something.
- 51:51It's not great when kids are violent with other kids, and of course you
- 51:54want to do what you can to curb that behavior and help and monitor.
- 51:59But it wouldn't concern me based on that description. If I saw that again,
- 52:05it would have to be occasional, and it would have to be in
- 52:08the normal range. If you've spent a lot of time with three year olds,
- 52:13you know what sort of violence is considered normal. On the plus side
- 52:19with three year olds is they're usually pretty weak, right, so they have
- 52:22a hard time inflicting a lot of damage. It's usually just really scary.
- 52:27Right, So your kid, your daughter, slaps in a very meek way
- 52:34this other girl, and the other girl starts crying, but you saw the
- 52:38whole thing. Is a pretty low likelihood that in that scenario it's going to
- 52:43leave a mark that there was any kind of physical pain. It was more
- 52:46just like, oh my god, she just hit me across the face.
- 52:51Now. Yet, if you're an adult and you slap someone across the face
- 52:55as hard as you can. It's going to leave a mark. It's going
- 52:59to be violent, violent, criminal. But when a kid does it,
- 53:01you know, if you've ever had a kid who is serving a tantrum and
- 53:06you're trying to maybe put them to bed or something, and you know,
- 53:09let's say they're two years old, and they might even hit you in the
- 53:13face, you know, because you pick them up, so they're in your
- 53:15arms and there their arms are right in your face, and they just start
- 53:19swinging at you, you know, and it's so meek and weak that it
- 53:24doesn't hurt you, right, it's not damaging. So that's the plus side
- 53:30to very young children experimenting or having outbursts like this. It's it's not going
- 53:36to leave a mark. It can be a problem. Now, what's abnormal?
- 53:40What would be concerning? Well, the dimensions to look at are frequency,
- 53:45like if it's every day, the intensity of the violent act, and
- 53:50usually we don't even refer to them as violent acts, right, but you
- 53:53know it is the things I'm describing, But the intensity of the putting hands
- 53:59on or act, like if the three year old were to try to find
- 54:04a weapon like a I don't know, like a toy car and try to
- 54:08hit someone over the head with it. That's a that's a lot different than
- 54:10just a spontaneous outburst of like give me that doll. If the child was
- 54:17premeditating the violence, like you saw the kid. You know, your daughter
- 54:22gets the doll taken away and is upset, and you see your daughter stand
- 54:25up, go over, get the car and walk back and hit the other
- 54:30girl or try to hit the other girl across that. That's premeditation. That's
- 54:36not really an outburst of behavior. It's kind of a policy of the kid
- 54:39like, Okay, I am now going to commit violence. You know,
- 54:43because the violence I was talking about earlier, it's it's outbursts, it's spontaneous.
- 54:49It's just a sudden reactivity of give me the doll, right that that's
- 54:53could be concerning, But it's a lot more concerning if the kid, in
- 54:58a somewhat calm manner, decides, yes, I am now going to commit
- 55:04violence on this other kid. You know, that raises red flags of a
- 55:07problem. Also, the length of time of the violence. For example,
- 55:14I was working with a five year old who was going through a very tough
- 55:19childhood. His parents were pretty heavily addicted to meth and I was working with
- 55:24the family, the parents and the kid, and I was when I was
- 55:30doing in home therapy and I'm at the house and the kid had a meltdown
- 55:35and started to become violent with everybody, and the parents were looking to me
- 55:39like, well, you're the therapist, can you help with this? And
- 55:42I said, well, you know, so I tried to triage the situation
- 55:45and tried to help the parents to help the child. The child was continuing
- 55:51to be violent, and five year olds, they're not going to do a
- 55:53ton of damage, but they, you know, they're getting up there where
- 55:58they can actually start to scratch your eyes out or something, you know.
- 56:01And so the five year old was just completely unhinged and just completely out of
- 56:06control, and the parents were like, what are we supposed to do in
- 56:09this situation? And so after I don't know, twenty five minutes or something,
- 56:15I eventually got to the escalation of well, let's do a therapeutic hold.
- 56:21And these are restraining behaviors by a worker like myself or a parent that
- 56:29are designed to help the child to not do these things while not abusing the
- 56:35child. Right, You're not like locking them to a bedpost or something.
- 56:39You're just you're holding them so they can't hurt themselves or other people, and
- 56:44it used as a last resort. It can be used in a lot of
- 56:47abusive ways. But in this instance, I was like, well, it's
- 56:51probably good if I could show the parents if needed this technique, and so
- 56:57I held the kid in a way that I could. It's hard to describe
- 57:02physically how you hold a kid in a situation like this, but you hold
- 57:07people, and it depends on the size difference between the holder and the hold.
- 57:12Like if I were a half to hold someone that was my size,
- 57:15there's a different sort of wrestling technique to it. But but the five year
- 57:19old, it's pretty easy, and there's a way that you can hold them
- 57:21so that you keep their hands at bay and so they can't hurt you and
- 57:25they can't hurt other people. There's also a technique to make sure they can't
- 57:29headbut because that's a thing anyway, So I was doing that and this kid
- 57:35was having a violent meltdown that lasted a half an hour and maybe another half
- 57:40an hour after that. So that's abnormal. That's concerning, right. It's
- 57:45one thing to have a doll taken away, the kid is like hey and
- 57:50smacks the other kid in a way that doesn't leave a mark, and then
- 57:53it's over. Whereas if you have sixty minutes of violent and targeting other people,
- 58:00that's obviously different. Right. Also another dimension to look at is focus,
- 58:06Like if the kid seems kind of preoccupied with violence, if there's a
- 58:09lot of talk or behaviors around violence, obviously that's a concern because, like
- 58:15I said, that's not the normal range of a three year old. Being
- 58:20violent is against spontaneous frustration essentially, Also, it's abnormal for a child to
- 58:28lack adjustment after you react to it. So in a normal situation, you
- 58:32have a three year old doll and your daughter swings at the other kid,
- 58:37doesn't leave a mark, the other kid cries and runs to you, and
- 58:42then you sit down and you say, hey, you know, little Jenny,
- 58:45you can't do that. I know that you wanted your friend to share,
- 58:50and that's okay, but let's use our words, and you know,
- 58:52you do the whole thing that you do as a parent. And then what
- 58:58in a normal situation, and at least for a time, maybe the next
- 59:02half an hour, even when frustration occurs again, for your daughter, she's
- 59:08not going to be violent because she will have retained some of the messaging from
- 59:15you around that she can't do that and that there are other things that she
- 59:17could do. You know, it kind of depends. But that's adjustment,
- 59:22that's learning, right, that's understanding and having a reaction to your reaction.
- 59:29Right. It's abnormal for kids to have zero reaction or very little indication of
- 59:36reacting to your reactions, to adjusting to how the world is working. Right.
- 59:43So obviously this is often due to trauma or witnessing violence in the home,
- 59:49being a victim of violence in the home if you're a three year old,
- 59:52or you could have a burgeoning mood disorder I've seen that before as well,
- 59:55or a temporary mood disorder. It is at least common enough to diagnose
- 1:00:01some kids with completely unbridled anger with early onset bipolar or something. I'm not
- 1:00:09a huge fan of that kind of thing, but it is done. So
- 1:00:14sometimes it's considered an early mood disorder. It might go away as the child
- 1:00:19ages and developed. And also nerdive vergence. You know, if you have
- 1:00:22ADHD, you're going to have a hard time regulating your behavior anyway, And
- 1:00:25then you add on the fact that everyone is breathing down your neck all the
- 1:00:30time and criticizing you because you're having a hard time keeping focus and your working
- 1:00:37memory isn't going so great and your mood isn't so great. And so you
- 1:00:40could be three and having that frustration and difficulty emotionally regulating, and you might
- 1:00:47have more violence than other kids will. And there are other factors as well.
- 1:00:57But what about a ten year old, So let's look at what a
- 1:00:59normal ten year old would like look like. Well, for a normal ten
- 1:01:04year old, you're not going to really see any violence because hopefully by that
- 1:01:07point they've learned how to regulate their impulses. And maybe sometimes there's a little
- 1:01:13bit of a concern there, like they might ball up their fists or they
- 1:01:17might, I don't know, throw a book down when they're frustrated, but
- 1:01:22hopefully they don't actually take violent action on other kids. But where it usually
- 1:01:30starts to emerge is within rough housing. Right, So you might be playing
- 1:01:34a game, kids could be playing a game, or you could be playing
- 1:01:37game, but the ten year old and the ten year old could take it
- 1:01:38too far or get too frustrated and lose their focus on not doing this sort
- 1:01:46of thing and then they lash out and hit or whatever. So within normal
- 1:01:52ten year old behavior. So see that I said, With three year olds,
- 1:01:55it's actually normal for them to be very occasionally light leave violent. But
- 1:02:00with a ten year old, it's not normal for them to be occasionally violent
- 1:02:06with other people, you know, because hopefully, like I said, they've
- 1:02:08learned. So an abnormal situation for a ten year old are again frequency,
- 1:02:15intensity, length of time, focus, lack of adjustment to reaction from other
- 1:02:19people. And by this age you might have kids who are particularly disregulated.
- 1:02:28Again, lots of modeling of violence in their life. They might be,
- 1:02:32for whatever reason, really preoccupied with violence and intimidating other people. They might
- 1:02:37have been rewarded for intimidating other people. They might feel like their only recourse
- 1:02:43is to intimidate others. They might have been bullied a lot. Right,
- 1:02:45So that's just a general rundown, and it's really you have to see it
- 1:02:51and you have to get a full assessment. And that's what I would do
- 1:02:54when I would work with kids like this, I would just want to hear
- 1:02:58from everyone. The scenario looks like, what's the what are the antecedents,
- 1:03:02what are the precursors to the outburst? Let's get a medical right up.
- 1:03:09Yet, there's just a lot of different things that you have to look at,
- 1:03:13you know, psychiatry, medications, diet, sleep, there's so many
- 1:03:16different things that you have to look at when a kid is doing something like
- 1:03:21this. But you also ask, at what point is it abusive? Well,
- 1:03:28you know, the word abuse isn't It's not a concrete line in the
- 1:03:32sand. The scenarios that I laid out, Like you have a three year
- 1:03:36old that hits the kid because of the doll not sharing. You know,
- 1:03:40on the surface, you could say that's abusive, right, But would we
- 1:03:44necessarily use that label in that situation. I don't know. I think that
- 1:03:50society tends to look at abuse is this really black and white thing, you
- 1:03:52know, like that guy is abusive and I'm not abusive. The fact is
- 1:03:58is we are all abusive. All of us have committed abuse on other people.
- 1:04:02All of us have willfully and purposely tried to cause suffering and other people,
- 1:04:09whether we framed it that way or not. If you've ever raised your
- 1:04:12voice towards your partner, if you've ever called your partner a name or criticize
- 1:04:17them in the middle of a fight in a very pointed, unfair way.
- 1:04:21That's abuse. It's verbal abuse, emotional abuse. Some of you might absolutely
- 1:04:27be able to identify physical abuse that you've committed in your life towards your kids,
- 1:04:30towards your partners, towards family members or whatever. So all of us
- 1:04:33are abusive. It's not a dichotomy. It's just a matter of degree,
- 1:04:38right. So the definition that I use for abuse is, like I said,
- 1:04:44is it willful? Is it purposeful? Does it have the intent of
- 1:04:48causing suffering and other people? And is it generally unjustified? So that's what
- 1:04:56I use as my definition. I don't really see that definition being use in
- 1:05:00literature that much, but um, but that's what I use. So can
- 1:05:04a kid, a ten year old be unjustifiably willful and purposeful and trying to
- 1:05:12cause suffering and other people? You know, yeah, kids do that a
- 1:05:16lot. So again, it's just a it's just a matter of degree.
- 1:05:20But your your question, Anonymous separate your patron is sort of like you say
- 1:05:27that you have a sister that's working with kids three to eleven, and you
- 1:05:31hear about behavior from the kids that sound abusive and sound violent, and sound
- 1:05:38abnormal, and it sounds like yours. You say, my sister is struggling
- 1:05:43to identify normal play from you know, taking it too far. And I
- 1:05:49don't know what sort of capacity your sister is working in, but hopefully your
- 1:05:54sister has a clinician or an expert that they can rely on in those situations,
- 1:05:59because you know it's important to be able to delineate and also know how
- 1:06:02to react. And then at the end of the email, you concluded with
- 1:06:09the following you said, unrelated. I found your YouTube channel and Patreon when
- 1:06:14you started following the depth V heard trial. And I think I've listened to
- 1:06:18one of your podcast or watched one of your videos every day since Your clinical
- 1:06:23experience is so vast, and I deeply appreciate the massive amount of educational content
- 1:06:28that you have, and you put a lot of it on the internet for
- 1:06:30free. Just chiming in here. So normally I wouldn't read a nice part
- 1:06:36of the email. I read it, but I don't read it on the
- 1:06:40air. But I've already started reading it, so let's continue. You are
- 1:06:45one of the only therapists I've ever watched or met that understands and applies feminist,
- 1:06:49any oppressive values and scholarship to their overall therapeutical approach. Let me reread
- 1:06:56this sentence. You are one of the only therapists I've ever watched or met
- 1:06:58that understands and applies feminist, any oppressive values and scholarship to their overall therapeutic
- 1:07:02approach. It's it's what's most missing for me when I read psychology, literature,
- 1:07:09and psycho education. Just Chammy in here. Well, I do not
- 1:07:15consider myself unique in this way. By colleagues at the university, and certainly
- 1:07:18a lot of colleagues and other areas as well, absolutely are integrating feminist and
- 1:07:26any oppressive values in their scholarship and their therapeutic approach much more so than I
- 1:07:32do. So I'm probably maybe I'm a little rare on the Internet or on
- 1:07:39YouTube or something, but I'm certainly not rare in our field, at least
- 1:07:44in my circle. Going on here, any you are amazing and the haters
- 1:07:48need therapy. So this email us to come around the time of the trial.
- 1:07:53Yeah, the haters need therapy. Watching you and listening to you,
- 1:07:58Bob Umbardo and guests prompted me to get back to therapy and really dig deep
- 1:08:02this time in therapy. Y'all helped me get here internally, and I'm so
- 1:08:06grateful. Thank you so much for being you. Ah well, that's great,
- 1:08:10anonymous up to your patron. Truly, one of the best things that
- 1:08:15I'll ever hear from y'all is that you're inspired to begin or re engage in
- 1:08:21therapy and go deep, as you say, this time, to really take
- 1:08:28care of yourself, to really investigate things, to take those risks in therapy
- 1:08:32and really look at yourself, and you know, like the next time your
- 1:08:38therapist bothers you, you know, actually taking the risk and telling you,
- 1:08:43telling your therapist that you were bothered, giving your therapists a chance to rise
- 1:08:47the occasion and so that you can benefit from learning a new behavior and having
- 1:08:53a corrective experience where your therapist actually apologizes to take responsibility. So that is
- 1:09:00um I just I just warms my heart and inspires being so greatly to hear
- 1:09:04that that you're doing that, And yeah, so thank you for that.
- 1:09:12And everyone out there, please please take care of yourself truly because you deserve
- 1:09:15it. You really really do.