Latest / Your Mic / A Big Audience is Not a Strategy
Transcript
- 0:00Look at all the people you can reach.
- 0:02Yeah, that's the pitch.
- 0:05Not who they are, not whether they need you, not what surrounds your message.
- 0:09Just look at all those people.
- 0:12By that logic, you should open your next office in the middle of Times Square.
- 0:18People all over the place.
- 0:20Congratulations.
- 0:21Let's get the slow clap.
- 0:25Marketing solved.
- 0:27Never mind whether any of them actually want what you offer.
- 0:30Never mind what it costs to get their attention.
- 0:33Never mind whether they can even hear you over everything else competing for it.
- 0:37But hey,
- 0:39The people, am I right?
- 0:41When somebody sells you radio on audience size, ask them to describe the environment your money is buying, not just the headcount.
- 0:50We're talking about the actual commercial break, the surrounding ads, the programming, the placement, and the case for why the people you need will notice, care, and act.
- 1:01Because you're not buying a census.
- 1:03You're trying to accomplish something.
- 1:06And your nonprofit's mission or your company's growth strategy, they deserve way more thought than, well, there's a shit ton of people over here.
- 1:21Welcome back to Your Mic.
- 1:23My name is Freddy Cruz, founder of Speak Podcasting.
- 1:26We build media empires for institutions, medical orgs, doctors, nonprofits, and the like.
- 1:32If you want to get a conversation started, tap the link in the show notes.
- 1:37And here's the deal.
- 1:39I spent years in radio.
- 1:42Now I produce podcasts.
- 1:44So I'm definitely not confused about which side of the microphone pays my bills.
- 1:50But I am very interested in what happens when somebody uses a big audience number to avoid a smaller, more important question.
- 2:02Who specifically are you even trying to reach?
- 2:06Not long ago, I saw a pitch telling business owners on LinkedIn that if their customers live nearby, maybe they should buy radio instead of producing a podcast.
- 2:17The reasoning?
- 2:18No.
- 2:19Radio already has listeners.
- 2:24Cute.
- 2:25And Times Square already has pedestrians.
- 2:29That does not settle where you should spend your marketing budget.
- 2:33You still need to know whether the people are relevant, whether the environment suits the message, and what it will take to even get noticed.
- 2:41Imagine somebody advising you to move your business.
- 2:44New York.
- 2:45Biggest city.
- 2:47That's where you belong.
- 2:49You'd likely have questions, right?
- 2:53If you're in my hometown, I'm in the greater Houston area, you'd have questions about the neighborhood, the rent, access, competition, hello, moving out of Texas to New York because somebody recommended them based on numbers alone.
- 3:05You'd want to know whether your customers are actually there.
- 3:09You would never sign a lease because somebody waved a population chart at you.
- 3:13So why on God's green earth would you sign a media proposal that has not answered the equivalent questions?
- 3:21Now let's imagine for a second, your ad lands halfway through a seven-minute commercial break on the radio.
- 3:28An example, not a claim about every station.
- 3:31Before you, there's going to be a lawyer yelling at the top of his lungs about a settlement.
- 3:37After you, a fast food restaurant selling a combo meal.
- 3:41In between, your nonprofit gets 30 seconds to explain why its work deserves somebody's support.
- 3:48Or your company gets 30 seconds to make a complicated service sound relevant to a person who may or may not have any role in buying it.
- 3:57Now, can that commercial work?
- 4:02Maybe.
- 4:03But the station has listeners has not answered the question.
- 4:09What does the proposed schedule reach?
- 4:13How often, in what context, with what message, and what evidence would justify renewing it?
- 4:21Show me the neighborhood my ad is moving into, not just the population of the city.
- 4:27Now, if I tell you that producing a podcast automatically delivers you ideal customers, call bullshit immediately.
- 4:36By the way, I'd never tell you that.
- 4:39And that means you would not have to ever call bullshit on me.
- 4:43But seriously, if somebody were to tell you that, definitely call bullshit on them.
- 4:54That's because a microphone is not a targeting strategy.
- 4:58Neither is a station's coverage map.
- 5:01Your podcast needs a defined listener, an editorial purpose, a distribution plan, and a next step.
- 5:09But when those pieces are in place, we're talking about a completely different proposition, not squeezing your organization into somebody else's interruption, but
- 5:17We're talking about building a conversation around something the people you need already have a reason to care about for a nonprofit.
- 5:26That might mean helping prospective donors understand what their support makes possible, how the work happens, and what the organization has learned.
- 5:34We're going to be talking about how the work happens.
- 5:35For an enterprise company, it might mean helping a specific kind of buyer understand a difficult decision before they ever speak with your sales team.
- 5:44That is the comparison I want on the table.
- 5:47Not, which option has the bigger crowd?
- 5:50And please, let's retire this idea that if your customers live 20 minutes away, the strategy is practically written itself.
- 5:58A major donor can live 20 minutes away and still need more than 30 seconds to understand your work.
- 6:04A purchasing director can live 20 minutes away and never encounter the schedule you bought.
- 6:10A person can hear your ad repeatedly and never need your service.
- 6:16Proximity does not establish intent.
- 6:19Audience size does not establish fit.
- 6:23And availability does not establish attention.
- 6:26Those are separate questions.
- 6:28Make the person selling you the plan, answer them separately.
- 6:38Before you approve the proposal, finish the sentence.
- 6:41We are trying to reach these specific people, help them understand this specific thing, and give them a reason to take this specific action.
- 6:51Then make the seller who's trying to get you to buy radio explain how the plan does that.
- 6:57Okay?
- 6:58But not just the radio seller.
- 7:00I'm talking about the podcast producer as well.
- 7:03Yeah.
- 7:03Yeah.
- 7:04Us.
- 7:05My company.
- 7:06Me.
- 7:06Speak podcasting.
- 7:08Okay?
- 7:09If the best answer is still, look how many people.
- 7:13You've not been given a strategy.
- 7:15You've been shown a crowd.
- 7:18Your mission needs the right people to care enough to do something meaningful, not a population chart.
- 7:25A plan.
- 7:27Hey, if you want to get a conversation started about your industry's next favorite podcast hosted by you, let's get a conversation started.
- 7:35Tap the link in the show notes.
- 7:37Thank you so much for listening to this episode of Your Mic.