Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / A Discussion of the Rule of Law and Judicial Independence with Former U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to a discussion of the rule of law and
- 0:06judicial independence with former U .S. Attorney
- 0:09General Alberto Gonzalez. I am Dira Imam, president
- 0:13of the Beverly Hills Bar Foundation, and I'm
- 0:16honored to be here today to introduce your moderator
- 0:18for this program that promises to be such an
- 0:21important and fascinating discussion. But first,
- 0:24I want to encourage you to learn about the foundation
- 0:27and the good work that we do. We host programs
- 0:29like today's to educate our profession about
- 0:32critically important issues including protecting
- 0:34the rule of law, judicial independence, and access
- 0:37to justice. We host an annual writing competition
- 0:40for law school journal articles about the rule
- 0:42of law issues, but our largest project is that
- 0:46for more than 50 years we have been providing
- 0:49scholarships to law students who are committed
- 0:51to practicing public interest law after graduation.
- 0:54We would be grateful for your support for this
- 0:56next generation of leaders. and staff will be
- 0:59dropping the donation link into the chat. And
- 1:03now I am delighted to introduce our moderator,
- 1:06Vince Farhat. Vince is my colleague on the Foundation
- 1:09Board, and we also previously served together
- 1:12on the BHBA Board of Governors. He is a former
- 1:15assistant United States attorney who served in
- 1:18both the major fraud section and the Civil Division
- 1:22of the US Attorney's Office for the Central District
- 1:25of California. including under Attorney General
- 1:28Gonzalez. Until recently, Vince practiced law
- 1:32full -time as a partner at Jeffer Mangels Butler
- 1:34and Mitchell LLP, where he chaired the White
- 1:37Collar Defense and Investigations Group. As of
- 1:41this school year, he now splits his time between
- 1:43the firm and his position as a visiting associate
- 1:46clinical professor of law at Loyola Law School
- 1:49here in Los Angeles, where he teaches legal research
- 1:52and writing, white collar defense, and investigations
- 1:55practice, and ethical lawyering. When Attorney
- 1:58General Gonzalez so generously agreed to do this
- 2:01program with us, we knew immediately that Vince
- 2:03was the ideal interviewer. And now, I'll turn
- 2:07the program over to him. Thank you. Thank you,
- 2:09Deira. Very kind, thank you. So good afternoon,
- 2:13everybody. I wanted to start by properly introducing
- 2:16our special guest. Alberta Gonzales is the Dean
- 2:19of Belmont University College of Law. And under
- 2:22his leadership and under his guidance, Belmont
- 2:24was fully accredited by the American Bar Association
- 2:28in 2016. This was after graduating its first
- 2:31class just two years before, so it was a record
- 2:34accomplishment. Dean Gonzales attended the United
- 2:37States Air Force Academy. He received a Bachelor
- 2:40of Arts from Rice University and his law degree
- 2:43from Harvard University. Dean Gonzales was nominated
- 2:47by President George W. Bush and confirmed by
- 2:50the United States Senate as the 80th Attorney
- 2:53General of the United States in February 2005.
- 2:56He served as Attorney General until September
- 2:58of 2007. Dean Gonzalez has held a number of other
- 3:03very senior government positions, including he
- 3:06served as a justice on the Texas Supreme Court.
- 3:10He was Texas Secretary of State. He was general
- 3:14counsel to the governor of Texas, and he was
- 3:16counsel to the president of the United States.
- 3:19And before entering government service, Dean
- 3:22Gonzalez worked as a partner at the Houston law
- 3:25firm, Vincent and Alkins, a top firm. So Dean,
- 3:28thank you and welcome, and thank you for joining
- 3:30us today. Thanks for having me, Vince. I'm looking
- 3:33forward to this. This will be an interesting
- 3:34discussion. You've presented some very interesting
- 3:37topics for us to ponder. Well, try to keep it
- 3:41interesting. But I guess, you know, first, I
- 3:43really want to talk about, really, you are a
- 3:46Republican. You've served in higher ranking positions
- 3:50in Republican administration. Yet it's a matter
- 3:53of public record. You endorsed Kamala Harris
- 3:56in the 2024 election due to concerns about rule
- 3:59of law. First question is, why did you endorse
- 4:02Ms. Harris? Because of concerns about the rule
- 4:06of law. Listen, I... I am a lifelong Republican,
- 4:11but when people ask me today, you know, what
- 4:14are you? Are you still a Republican? What I tell
- 4:16them is I'm a Bushy. I support the policies that
- 4:22President Bush championed, that I had a role
- 4:25in protecting. I'm very proud of our service.
- 4:30It was imperfect. I first admit that we've made
- 4:33mistakes. If you don't believe, if you believe
- 4:37you're not... going to make mistakes at this
- 4:39level. You have no understanding or appreciation
- 4:42how difficult these decisions are. So we were
- 4:45imperfect, but we did our best, particularly
- 4:47in the war on terror and taking some controversial
- 4:50steps in trying to protect America. So yeah,
- 4:56the reason I've learned a lot from my service,
- 5:00and I know how powerful the office of the presidency
- 5:04is. and why it's important to have someone with
- 5:07great integrity in that office. And I just felt
- 5:11that Kamala Harris would be a better choice.
- 5:14I knew that I would have some concerns and questions
- 5:17about her policy positions, and that's understandable.
- 5:21I had questions about some of Bush's final decisions,
- 5:25some I didn't agree with, but of course we carried
- 5:27them out. But that's the reason why I decided
- 5:30to support Ms. Harris. And what were the specific
- 5:36issues or the concerns that you had as you were
- 5:39evaluating the candidacy of the Republican nominee?
- 5:43What was it that specifically caused you to say,
- 5:46look, I want to go with rule of law as opposed
- 5:49to necessarily ideology? What did you see in
- 5:53that candidacy that gave you pause? Well, if
- 5:56I could list just a few. How about this was a
- 6:01convicted felon. How about inaction during the
- 6:07riots of January 6, when President Trump was
- 6:13still president and could have taken steps to
- 6:16protect the Capitol and those defending the Capitol
- 6:18and members of the Senate and members of the
- 6:20House? How about multiple bankruptcies of his
- 6:25companies, the Trump companies, over his years
- 6:28as a businessman? How about the multi -million
- 6:32dollar judgment for sexual abuse involving Gene
- 6:36Carroll? So these are just some examples of why
- 6:43I had concerns about the character of this individual.
- 6:47I have to admit, I've only met Donald Trump once,
- 6:52so I can't say that I'm an expert or I know him
- 6:55that well. And I think it was... I can't remember
- 7:00the name of the person who had this saying that
- 7:03reputation is what men and women think about
- 7:06you, but character is what only God and the angels
- 7:11know about you. So, you know, I can't say for
- 7:15sure about this person's character, but you look
- 7:18at the track record and it certainly gives you
- 7:20some indication. You know, some people who are
- 7:23supportive of the president would say, look,
- 7:25we had a presidential administration once before
- 7:28with Donald Trump. They will say the world didn't
- 7:30end. There was not a complete erosion of the
- 7:35rule of law and have said that, you know, that
- 7:38concerns were overblown, that maybe people should
- 7:42not have approached this and said that this will
- 7:45be a constitutional crisis or some sort of constitutional
- 7:49apocalypse if the man is reelected. We are now
- 7:52about a year in, almost a year in, to this new
- 7:56administration. And as you look back in this
- 7:59last year, have your rule of law concerns been
- 8:03realized? If so, in what way? I don't know if
- 8:08all of my concerns have been realized or the
- 8:11concerns of others have been realized, but I
- 8:13think it's fair to say that there has been an
- 8:17erosion. of confidence in the rule of law because
- 8:21of systematic attacks on institutions, Department
- 8:28of Justice, and we'll talk about that being one
- 8:30of those. So that is of great concern to me.
- 8:36But I think most of us had some idea. that this
- 8:41is the path that this administration, this president
- 8:45would take. What has been more surprising and
- 8:49much more disappointing is the inaction by our
- 8:53Congress. From my perspective, I think the framers
- 8:56envisioned that the Congress would be the most
- 8:58powerful branch in our government. And they've
- 9:03been listening in action. And I think that inaction
- 9:07has allowed this president to do things that
- 9:12it would have been unimaginable during the time
- 9:16that President Bush was in office. And from a
- 9:19whole host of things, like not exercising their
- 9:23oversight with respect to confirmations and allowing
- 9:27recess appointments or appointments we'll talk
- 9:30about, I suspect, at the Department of Justice,
- 9:34the use of force and not not respecting the role
- 9:42of Congress in terms of the use of force and
- 9:44the commitment of U .S. forces around the world.
- 9:48So it's been troubling, and there's no indication
- 9:53that it's gonna slow down. Again, I'm not in
- 9:56the administration, so I don't know what their
- 9:58thinking is, what their current plan is. A lot
- 10:01of speculation about what may be coming down
- 10:03the road. Some speculation about whether even...
- 10:07President Trump is gonna leave at the end of
- 10:09the second term, which I think is kind of out
- 10:12there, but I hope that's not the case. So yes,
- 10:18there are some things that I think that we're
- 10:20seeing that I'm worried about. One final thing
- 10:24I'll just mention that we may get into, and that
- 10:26is it appears the Department of Justice is being
- 10:29used to impose retribution against people that...
- 10:36that I think President Trump feels he was offended
- 10:40by. And one of the most disappointing things
- 10:43as head of the Department of Justice, I know
- 10:46how hard our prosecutors work at the Department
- 10:48of Justice, and I commend you, Vince, for your
- 10:51service, but the notion that those individuals,
- 10:55those investigators and prosecutors who are successful
- 10:58in prosecuting the January 6 rioters, that...
- 11:03those prosecutors and investigators were fired
- 11:05for doing their job well. And then to make it
- 11:08even worse, pardons those individuals who were
- 11:12actually convicted of assaulting police officers
- 11:15and assaulting our Capitol. So that's been disappointing.
- 11:19And these are all things that really gave me
- 11:21a great deal of concern. Understood. So let's
- 11:24pivot to the question of retribution or weaponization
- 11:28of DOJ. We've heard a lot about, we've heard
- 11:30that phrase, weaponization of DOJ. I wanted to
- 11:34start the topic by base touching with you. During
- 11:37your time as attorney general, were there policies
- 11:41or standards in place that the department tried
- 11:44to follow to avoid the perception of political
- 11:47prosecutions? What was done in that regard? There
- 11:51was a set of policies that were in place after
- 11:54Watergate, limiting contacts between the White
- 11:58House and the Department of Justice with respect
- 12:01to prosecutions. investigations and prosecutions.
- 12:05Obviously, there are communications that have
- 12:07to occur between the White House and the Department
- 12:10of Justice with respect to budget issues and
- 12:12policy development. But with respect to investigations
- 12:16and prosecutions, there's been this policy, this
- 12:19practice, put in place about limiting contacts.
- 12:22communications only between the White House counsel
- 12:25and the deputy attorney general or the attorney
- 12:27general with respect to an ongoing prosecution
- 12:30investigation or prosecution. And that's been
- 12:34standard since Watergate. I can't tell you the
- 12:38number of times that I had conversations with
- 12:40President Bush, who is very interested in a certain
- 12:43case or matter. And I would tell him, as much
- 12:47as I felt comfortable telling him, but reminding
- 12:49him how important it was. that he not get involved
- 12:53in an investigation or prosecution because it
- 12:57would hurt him, it would hurt the presidency
- 12:59to create this appearance that in fact he was
- 13:04putting his thumb on the scale because everyone
- 13:05at the Department of Justice, of course, works
- 13:08for the President of the United States. And so
- 13:10that was a practice that we followed. And I tried
- 13:14to be very, very disciplined in ensuring that
- 13:19lanes where people in doing their work stood
- 13:23in their lanes. I'll give you an example, if
- 13:24I may. When I was the attorney general, Chris
- 13:27Christie was a U .S. attorney in New Jersey,
- 13:31and he prosecuted the son of someone in the Trump
- 13:36family. And that person went to prison, that
- 13:41person got sick, and the family asked for this
- 13:48person to be released so that person could go
- 13:54home as a sick person. And so Chris calls me
- 13:58and says, you know, I don't think this person
- 14:01should be released, but I want to know what you
- 14:03think. And I told him, I said, Chris, this is
- 14:06your case. You prosecuted this case. You know
- 14:09the facts here. I don't. I'm not going to tell
- 14:12you what you should or shouldn't do here. Exercise
- 14:15your best judgment. This is why you are confirmed.
- 14:18The Senate has confidence in your judgment. You
- 14:20need to exercise your good judgment. And so I
- 14:22guess that was an example, maybe not a good one,
- 14:25of maintaining lanes and understanding that that
- 14:30reinforces confidence of the American public
- 14:34that the administration is going to look at the
- 14:36facts and make the best judgment with respect
- 14:39to... what we needed to protect the rule of law.
- 14:42Got it. You know, there seem to be competing
- 14:45narratives of weaponization that we see in our
- 14:49legal and political discourse. Supporters of
- 14:53the administration will argue that it was the
- 14:56Biden administration that first weaponized DOJ
- 14:58by indicting the former president to keep him
- 15:01from returning to office. And supporters of the
- 15:05president's administration contend that current
- 15:07leadership of DOJ is restoring what they consider
- 15:10to be an equitable balance to law enforcement
- 15:13policies. On the other hand, opponents of the
- 15:15administration argue that the Trump administration
- 15:18has utilized DOJ by investigating and indicting
- 15:22political opponents, and they argue that it's
- 15:25a dangerous new precedent. As you look back now,
- 15:29the fullness of time, how do you weigh the case
- 15:32on these competing narratives of DOJ weaponization?
- 15:36Well, first of all, let me... just say that a
- 15:39political actor can and should be investigated
- 15:43and prosecuted if, in fact, they have engaged
- 15:46in wrongdoing. But the key is whether or not
- 15:49that person has, in fact, engaged in wrongdoing.
- 15:56Excuse me. From my perspective, I worry that
- 16:01you begin with the public statements from the
- 16:04president about retribution. and that he is your
- 16:10retribution, he told his supporters. And then
- 16:14you see actions like going after James Comey,
- 16:17going after John Bolton, going after Letitia
- 16:20James. And it may be at the end of the day, the
- 16:25case can be made if they engage in wrongdoing.
- 16:28But it's the rhetoric leading up to this, and
- 16:31then putting these individuals up. through these
- 16:35ordeals that cause one to wonder whether or not
- 16:38this is nothing more than just retribution. And
- 16:42I think that's harmful to the rule of law. It's
- 16:45harmful to the Department of Justice. I think
- 16:47it's created great sadness in the Department,
- 16:54employees of the Department of Justice, where
- 16:55morale has to be very, very low. Because as you
- 16:59know, Less than 1 % of the people that work at
- 17:02the Department of Justice, there are over 100
- 17:03,000 people that work there. Less than 1 % are
- 17:06political appointees. Over 99 % are career people.
- 17:10They go to work day in and day out, irrespective
- 17:12of who the attorney general is, irrespective
- 17:14of who the president is. And so the politics
- 17:16for them is secondary to their work on behalf
- 17:20of the American people. And I'm assuming that
- 17:25the concern also is the impact of public confidence.
- 17:29in the justice system, if you could speak to
- 17:31that, these competing narratives of opposition
- 17:33and what that does to public confidence? Well,
- 17:36there's no question about it because these conflicting
- 17:41narratives do cause confusion. They sow confusion,
- 17:44I think, in the minds of the American public.
- 17:46And they worry whether or not is justice being
- 17:51being weaponized, is justice being politicized.
- 17:54And I believe that's dangerous to have the American
- 17:58public not have confidence in our criminal justice
- 18:01system because that undermines the rule of law.
- 18:05And without the rule of law, Vince, We don't
- 18:08have a democracy. We don't have a United States.
- 18:12It is one of the things I think that makes America
- 18:14unique. And it's one of the things that has stood
- 18:17the test of time. And I think slowly but surely
- 18:21we're seeing some erosion in that. Yeah, none
- 18:25of us have crystal balls, but if you think ahead
- 18:28to the next administration, do you think there'll
- 18:30be a return to norms? where these lanes are observed
- 18:34and these norms are followed, or do you think
- 18:37it's the new normal? Well, obviously it's going
- 18:40to depend upon the person we elect as president
- 18:43of the United States. If that person is a person
- 18:45of integrity and with an understanding of history
- 18:49and respect for human dignity, I think that person
- 18:52is going to push the administration towards the
- 18:59old ways. not be a person that is pursuing retribution.
- 19:06I'm hopeful it's going to be somewhat, one of
- 19:07the things I really admired about Barack Obama,
- 19:10I didn't agree with some of his policies, but
- 19:14hope and change. He had a very optimistic, hopeful
- 19:17vision for America. Americans respond to a positive
- 19:20vision. They respond to someone who says, listen,
- 19:26I've been at the other side of the mountain.
- 19:27I know what is possible in this great country.
- 19:30You come with me and I will take you to a better
- 19:32place. Now, the journey is going to be difficult
- 19:34at times, but you stay with me and we're going
- 19:38to achieve greatness together. So I think that
- 19:41positive vision is very, very important. And
- 19:44I think someone who has that kind of positive
- 19:45vision hopefully will be successful in the next
- 19:48election. And hopefully that person is going
- 19:50to be respectful of the separation of powers
- 19:53and things like federalism, separation of powers,
- 19:56rule of law. These are all things that are very
- 19:59important in what makes America, America. And
- 20:02I'm hopeful that we'll see that again. So you
- 20:05touched on, when you mentioned retribution, the
- 20:07cases of Comey, James, former National Security
- 20:11Advisor Bolton. We don't have time to really
- 20:13dive into the details of those cases. We have
- 20:15included materials in our compendium for CLE
- 20:19credit talking about these cases. But I want
- 20:22to touch on one issue that underlies the Comey
- 20:26and the James cases. And that goes to the appointment
- 20:28of United States attorneys. the case involving
- 20:33Mr. Bolton, the Comey and James cases didn't
- 20:37appear to go through what we would consider regular
- 20:40channels. So the president publicly called for
- 20:42their prosecution. He appointed an attorney who
- 20:45had been his personal attorney, Lindsey Halligan,
- 20:48to serve as the Eastern District of Virginia
- 20:50U .S. attorney. Comey is challenging Halligan's
- 20:53appointment and one of his motions to dismiss.
- 20:56And separate and apart from that, we've seen
- 20:57a raft of motions to disqualify U .S. attorneys
- 21:01brought by defense counsels. Most recently, just
- 21:04last week here in our district, in the Central
- 21:06District of California, Judge Michael Seabright,
- 21:09who is a Bush nominee, ruled that Bill Assali
- 21:12was unlawfully serving as acting U .S. Attorney
- 21:15here in the Central District. So I'd like to
- 21:18start by asking, during your time as Attorney
- 21:21General, were there policies, standards in place
- 21:24relating to the nomination of U .S. Attorneys,
- 21:27and what were those policies? How did you manage,
- 21:30how did the administration manage that process?
- 21:33People may not understand that with respect to
- 21:37appointments like U .S. Attorneys, U .S. Marshals,
- 21:43Members of the Senate, members of Congress. have
- 21:47a significant say, at least they did during the
- 21:48Bush administration. I think before that, and
- 21:51I suspect since afterwards, if there's a vacancy,
- 21:55say with respect to a U .S. attorney, what we
- 21:58would do as a Republican administration, we would
- 22:02contact the local Republicans and get names for
- 22:05people that might qualify to serve effectively
- 22:09as a U .S. attorney. One of the things we'd look
- 22:12at, of course, would be judgment, experience,
- 22:14but also because this would be an opportunity,
- 22:18quite frank, and I'm being very honest here,
- 22:20to credential someone who then might rise up
- 22:22to do something very significant in our government
- 22:27in Washington or perhaps in the respective state.
- 22:31And so we would gather those names. And oftentimes,
- 22:34if we didn't have the support of the home state
- 22:36senators, we could not get a U .S. attorney,
- 22:41even a nominee, a hearing, much less confirmed.
- 22:45Homestay centers had a great deal of say in terms
- 22:48of who the president would nominate and hopefully
- 22:52ultimately get confirmed as a U .S. attorney.
- 22:55And obviously what we looked at, we looked at
- 22:57experience and we looked at judgment. Those are
- 23:01the two things that we looked at. Obviously education
- 23:04was important. And that's what we looked at in
- 23:11making a nomination. And hopefully, that person
- 23:15would do well in the confirmation hearing. And
- 23:17as a general rule, again, with Homestay Center's
- 23:20support, they would be confirmed. So the disqualification
- 23:24motions, there have been some in Nevada, New
- 23:26Jersey, and California. Apparently, when we look
- 23:29at these cases, they involve situations where
- 23:31the attorney general has selected someone to
- 23:34serve as what's called the first assistant US
- 23:37attorney. So they can automatically fill a vacancy.
- 23:40And we hear we read about first assistant, acting
- 23:43U .S. attorney, interim U .S. attorney. I think
- 23:46to those who haven't served in DOJ, it's a little
- 23:48confusing. Can you just give us a quick tutorial?
- 23:51What is the first assistant U .S. attorney, and
- 23:54what's the difference between an interim and
- 23:55an acting? Well, I've served in DOJ, as head
- 24:00of DOJ, and it's confusing to me at times, quite
- 24:02honestly. The first assistant is, as the name
- 24:05implies, the number two in command within a specific
- 24:09office, and if the U .S. attorney is unavailable
- 24:12or the position is vacant as a general rule,
- 24:15that person makes decisions for that office.
- 24:19The difference is with respect to a vacancy,
- 24:24the AG can make an appointment. That is called
- 24:28an interim appointment, and it's for 120 days.
- 24:34And after the 120 days, that person is out. An
- 24:39acting U .S. attorney is someone who by statute,
- 24:42this is under the Federal Vacancy Reform Act,
- 24:46who by statute, it can be the first assistant.
- 24:50And so being the first assistant is important
- 24:52because if you're the first assistant, you're
- 24:54automatically gonna qualify to be the acting
- 24:58U .S. attorney. And that I think is for a period
- 25:00of 210 days. And so those are the major differences.
- 25:07The AG appoints as an interim attorney, the AG
- 25:11makes that appointment. With respect to the acting
- 25:13attorney, U .S. attorney, that is something that's
- 25:17a presidential appointee. And the length of time
- 25:19of service is longer as an acting versus a...
- 25:24an interim. The confusion comes from the fact
- 25:26that sometimes an administration will try to
- 25:29combine the two with respect to one individual
- 25:31and sometimes the times called for in those two
- 25:38statutes get conflated and it can be somewhat
- 25:42confusing. I think what's very important for
- 25:45your viewers to understand though is that this
- 25:48is a way for an administration to avoid Senate
- 25:51scrutiny of someone serving as a U .S. attorney
- 25:55or in that position. And one of the things I'm
- 25:58very surprised about is that the Senate is not
- 26:02screaming about the fact that they're prerogative
- 26:05to say grace over the qualifications of someone
- 26:09serving as a U .S. attorney, either on an interim
- 26:12basis or an acting basis, that that person is
- 26:14qualified. But we're not seeing that. The Senate
- 26:19is missing in action. And as a result, the president
- 26:22is able to, relying on these two statutes, put
- 26:26people in place. And that's some of the confusion
- 26:30that you're seeing and why some of these appointments
- 26:32are being challenged in the courts. And this
- 26:35goes back to your point that you made earlier
- 26:37about the inaction of the Senate, the failure
- 26:40to engage in advice and consent. When you were
- 26:43serving as attorney general and serving in the
- 26:45Bush administration, was there ever a time where
- 26:49you sought to meet and confer, you didn't get
- 26:51consent, so somebody was appointed on interim
- 26:53basis as a recess appointment? I mean, does this
- 26:56have precedent in recent history, or is this
- 26:59really unusual what's going on in the current
- 27:02Trump administration? Well, there's only precedent
- 27:07in having an interim U .S. attorney or having
- 27:09an acting U .S. attorney because vacancies occur.
- 27:12Sometimes people die. Sometimes people get incapacitated.
- 27:16And so there is a need to have someone in that
- 27:18position. But I think seeing it at this level
- 27:22and to this degree, I think is unusual. And again,
- 27:26the most... disappointing thing for me, from
- 27:29my perspective, surprising thing, is the fact
- 27:32that the Senate is allowing this to happen because
- 27:35they could do something to prevent this from
- 27:38going forward. Well, and you mentioned, you know,
- 27:41death and the Federal Vacancy Reform Act. It's
- 27:43interesting, in Judge Seawright's order, he disagreed
- 27:47with the government's reading of the FVRA. He
- 27:50ruled that the at -issue provision really only
- 27:52applies if the previous U .S. attorney had passed
- 27:54away or resigned or was incapacitated. But it's
- 27:58notably his order calls for Mr. Assali to continue
- 28:01as the first assistant U .S. attorney, which
- 28:05effectively leaves him in the top slot. How does
- 28:07that work? How does one sign pleadings in that
- 28:13role? How does that work? Well, because that
- 28:16is a top spot in the office. And so he does have
- 28:20the authority to do that. So it's as simple as
- 28:21that. And I think you're right. I think it raises
- 28:24questions in the minds of a lot of people about,
- 28:26well, what difference does it make? I mean, he's
- 28:29still there. And that raises a good question.
- 28:34Yeah, what difference does it make? So it doesn't
- 28:35just completely flout the authority of the Senate
- 28:38in the oversight of, you know, who's serving
- 28:43these positions. And obviously there are a lot
- 28:46of great people in the local office working hard
- 28:48every day to try to do justice, every case, one
- 28:51case at a time. And I wonder the effect it might
- 28:54have on our career prosecutors and civil attorneys.
- 28:59when they see this sort of turmoil? Well, you're
- 29:01absolutely right. I think for the most part,
- 29:04the work is going to get done. These are well
- 29:07-qualified, well -determined individuals whose
- 29:11job is to prosecute wrongdoing. Nonetheless,
- 29:14it is somewhat disruptive to have all this going
- 29:21on because leadership in an office like that
- 29:27can be very, very important. Now, it will continue,
- 29:30but nonetheless, it's distracting to have all
- 29:34this going on, this uncertainty about whether
- 29:36or not the person at the top, does this person
- 29:39really have the authority to act on behalf of
- 29:42that office. And it raises, from the defense
- 29:45perspective, concerns and constitutional questions
- 29:48about the authority to supervise cases and whether
- 29:52a defendant's been properly, you know, been afforded
- 29:55due process and whether those cases should be
- 29:57indicted. or dismissed? Well, it certainly gives
- 30:00the defense something to argue, that's for sure.
- 30:03So you touched on DOJ independence, but before
- 30:06we go there, I wanted to, because you've had
- 30:08a unique background. You've served both as White
- 30:11House counsel under President Bush and later
- 30:14served as Attorney General, so you've got the
- 30:16perspective. And I think that there is not a
- 30:19lot of awareness, certainly wasn't on my part
- 30:21until I started preparing for this, about the
- 30:24different roles those offices have. And so if
- 30:26you could, with respect to the White House counsel,
- 30:30what is the role of White House counsel and who
- 30:33is the client? I view the client as the office
- 30:40of the presidency, not just the president, but
- 30:43the entire office of the presidency. And My job
- 30:51was to ensure that decisions made by the president
- 30:54were supported by the Constitution. And this
- 30:57became particularly important in the war on terror.
- 31:01The number one question is, what authority did
- 31:03the president have to authorize certain actions
- 31:07that were, in many cases, were controversial?
- 31:10Did the president have the authority? It began
- 31:12on 9 -11. Did the president have the authority
- 31:14to shoot down a commercial airliner heading toward
- 31:18a government building? for example. And then
- 31:21after that, did the president have the authority
- 31:23to shut down certain industries, shut down the
- 31:25airline industry, for example? And then after
- 31:28that, it became, did the president have the authority
- 31:31to house prisoners at Guantanamo Bay? Did he
- 31:36have the authority to determine that the Geneva
- 31:38Conventions did not apply? Did he have the authority
- 31:41to authorize certain kinds of interrogations?
- 31:44Did he have the authority to authorize certain
- 31:47kinds of electronic surveillance? Now, it wasn't
- 31:50Al Gonzalez providing the legal advice on those
- 31:52questions. What I did was to make sure that I
- 31:56involved the lawyers of the Department of Justice,
- 31:59CIA, Defense, State, NSA, and lawyers would come
- 32:05to my office and we would debate these questions.
- 32:07Did the president have the authority to do this?
- 32:10And as you might imagine, The discussions were
- 32:14heated. There was great disagreement sometimes
- 32:17amongst some of these issues. But at the end
- 32:19of the day, I would turn to the representative
- 32:21from the Department of Justice, and oftentimes
- 32:23it was the deputy attorney general. Sometimes
- 32:25it would be John Ashcroft, the attorney general.
- 32:27But most of the time, the deputy attorney general
- 32:30or the head of the Office of Legal Counsel or
- 32:32a representative of the Office of Legal Counsel.
- 32:35And I would tell them, OK, you've heard the competing
- 32:38arguments. You have the final word. because the
- 32:42Department of Justice is charged by statute to
- 32:45advise the executive branch, and also because
- 32:48at the end of the day, when these actions were
- 32:51going to be challenged in the courts, he would
- 32:53be the Department of Justice defending these
- 32:54actions. And so, whenever I walked into the Oval
- 32:59Office to advise the president about the scope
- 33:03of his authority, I would sometimes let him know
- 33:06about the disagreements amongst the lawyers.
- 33:09But I would always tell him, this is what the
- 33:11Department of Justice believes and recommends.
- 33:14And Mr. President, we're going to follow their
- 33:16advice. Because I thought it was important for
- 33:20protection of the president that he had the backing
- 33:23and support of the Department of Justice. And
- 33:25that's the way it would work. Again, my job was
- 33:27to facilitate. Sometimes the president would
- 33:30ask me for my views and I would share them, then
- 33:32I would quickly pivot and say, but the Department
- 33:34of Justice is the final word on this, Mr. President.
- 33:37And, and he followed their advice. So that was
- 33:41when you were as White House counsel, then you
- 33:43became, you were appointed and confirmed to serve
- 33:46as the attorney general later in the administration,
- 33:48but we were still dealing with war on terror
- 33:50issues. And now you are playing a different role.
- 33:54Yes. And still confronting these issues. Did
- 33:57the process Was it different? Did it change?
- 34:01Did your view of the White House counsels become
- 34:04different because you had this new role? Who
- 34:06was White House counsel, by the way, when you
- 34:07served as attorney general? Harriet Myers was
- 34:10a White House counsel, excuse me, dealing with
- 34:13this cough. Harriet Myers had been the staff
- 34:15secretary in the White House. I knew her from
- 34:18our days in Texas and we were good friends. So
- 34:20that relationship, by the way, I can't overstate
- 34:24how important relationships are. I tried as best
- 34:28I could to establish a good relationship with
- 34:29John Ashcroft because having a level of trust
- 34:32and understanding and being able to communicate
- 34:35freely your views about a tough legal issue is
- 34:38incredibly important. And so that relationship
- 34:43that I had with Harriet Meyers was very, very
- 34:45important. But to be quite honest with you, you
- 34:48know, when you're the attorney general, you spend
- 34:50less time dealing one -on -one on some of these
- 34:53issues because You have a team of thousands of
- 34:57lawyers, and they're the ones that go to many
- 35:00of these meetings. And they come back, and we
- 35:02have private discussions within the Department
- 35:05of Justice. And we take recommendations and sign
- 35:10off on a particular recommendation. And then
- 35:14that gets communicated back to the White House.
- 35:16So it's a much different role. I'm often asked,
- 35:18of all the things I've ever done, which one did
- 35:21I enjoy the most? You know, being a Cabinet Secretary
- 35:25is incredibly, it's a proud thing for me. It's
- 35:30incredibly cool. You're driven around in two
- 35:33FBI suburbans with agents carrying machine guns.
- 35:37You fly around the world in a G5 jet, but you
- 35:40have to go testify to Congress a lot. You have
- 35:43to deal with the media a lot. In every decision
- 35:46you make, there are winners and losers. That's
- 35:48an incredibly difficult job. I think it's probably
- 35:52one of the more difficult cabinet positions there
- 35:54is. Being White House counsel, you get to go
- 35:58work in the White House. As an American citizen,
- 36:01it doesn't get any better than that to go to
- 36:03the White House every day. And I got to advise
- 36:06on the most serious issues you could possibly
- 36:08imagine. And that's why I went to law school,
- 36:11is to be able to be involved in these kinds of
- 36:13decisions and to be able to do it during a historic
- 36:16period to work. And to do it for a man that I
- 36:19really knew, admired, and respected, it doesn't
- 36:22get any better than that. So by far, not by far,
- 36:25but I really enjoyed my service in the White
- 36:27House. We have a question from one of our participants.
- 36:34And to set up the question, it has to do with
- 36:35codes of ethics. First question is, at the Department
- 36:40of Justice during your tenure, what codes or
- 36:45what standards did AUSAs and department lawyers
- 36:48need to follow around conflicts of interest generally?
- 36:51And the next question that the viewer has posed
- 36:54is whether you view other branches like the Supreme
- 36:57Court, the judicial branch, should have similar
- 37:00codes of ethics. Well, there is a manual, DOJ
- 37:07manual. that lays out quite clearly about the
- 37:12expectations in terms of ethics of all the employees,
- 37:16but in particular investigators and prosecutors.
- 37:18So those are expected to be followed. There is
- 37:21an Office of Professional Responsibility. That
- 37:23office exists to ensure that lawyers meet their
- 37:29ethical obligations. And so if a lawyer strays
- 37:34from those ethical obligations that could be
- 37:36investigated by the Office of Professional Responsibility.
- 37:39And it's possible your license gets suspended.
- 37:41And so, yeah, it's something that's taken very,
- 37:44very seriously. It's not my place to opine as
- 37:49to whether or not the Supreme Court of the United
- 37:51States should have an ethics policy, although
- 37:53I will freely say that. I think it's... I don't
- 37:59know why the court wouldn't impose something,
- 38:03some kind of disclosure requirement. If you're
- 38:07willing to accept a gift, you should be willing
- 38:09to disclose the gift. Not an ethics requirement
- 38:14that you not accept certain kinds of gifts, but
- 38:16simply that you disclose certain gifts, maybe
- 38:19above a certain level. I think that would enhance
- 38:23the reputation of the court. which is suffering,
- 38:26I think, from loss of confidence in the minds
- 38:30of the American people these days. And, you know,
- 38:34that's not going to restore it all. I think the
- 38:38American people are going to look more to the
- 38:41decisions of the court. But I think having some
- 38:44kind of ethics policy is something that I might
- 38:46advise the court to consider. You mentioned the
- 38:49justice manual. I remember it used to be called
- 38:51the U .S. Attorney's Manual. That's right. We've
- 38:54included provisions of the justice manual in
- 38:57our program materials, and the justice manual
- 39:00addresses the issue of prosecutorial independence.
- 39:03It talks about DOJ being impartial and insulated
- 39:06from political influence. and that investigatory
- 39:09and prosecutorial powers be exercised free of
- 39:12partisan consideration. Those are in our materials.
- 39:15There's also a 2021 memorandum, attorney general
- 39:20memorandum that's included in the materials that
- 39:22apparently is still good law, if you will, or
- 39:25good standard, it's still on the website. It
- 39:27talks about DOJ not advising the White House
- 39:31concerning pending or contemplated criminal or
- 39:33civil enforcement actions. The president's nominee
- 39:38uh, for, um, to lead the criminal division. Tyson
- 39:42Duva testified on October 22nd at a Senate confirmation
- 39:45hearing that a new policy governing contacts
- 39:48between DOJ and the White House is forthcoming.
- 39:52Um, to be acknowledged in a follow -up letter
- 39:54that that 2021 memo is still there, but changes
- 39:58are forthcoming. And I'm wondering, as you compare
- 40:01what you've described in the Bush administration
- 40:04versus what you're seeing, in this current administration,
- 40:08how do you weigh the case on whether there's
- 40:11independence or not? I mean, you've said you
- 40:13think that they're being kind of used as a tool
- 40:16or whatnot, but how do you weigh the case on
- 40:19the differences between what you guys did and
- 40:21what's being done now in terms of respecting
- 40:24the spirit of the justice manual? Well, I think
- 40:28the Department of Justice now operates in a different
- 40:32environment. And one of the major reasons for
- 40:35that is the case of Trump versus the United States,
- 40:39which provided immunity to the president. And
- 40:44it sort of made it clear that the president of
- 40:46the United States, one way that I've heard some
- 40:49describe it, is the Supreme Court for the executive
- 40:51branch. What the president says goes. If he says
- 40:54something is lawful and can be done, then for
- 40:57the executive branch, it can be done. That is
- 41:03a big difference today. And the Department of
- 41:07Justice, someone at the Department of Justice
- 41:09may say, I don't think that's right. I think
- 41:10that's unlawful. But everyone works for the president
- 41:14of the United States. He's the chief executive
- 41:16officer. And so he can make that decision on
- 41:18his own. I wouldn't advise it. I would never
- 41:21advise a president, particularly one who's not
- 41:23a lawyer, to make legal conclusions. But he can.
- 41:28And that's what we got out of that decision,
- 41:30quite frankly. And the decisions can't be questioned.
- 41:36One example, this is an extreme example, and
- 41:38I'm not suggesting this president would ever
- 41:40do that. But it's possible, a core constitutional
- 41:45power of the president is the pardon power. And
- 41:49it's possible that an individual who's committed
- 41:52a crime wants to get a pardon and gives a million
- 41:57dollars to the family of the president. person
- 42:01receives a pardon. The court says you cannot
- 42:04go behind the motives of the reason for the exercise
- 42:07of constitutional power. That to me is, I was
- 42:14gonna say interesting. It's somewhat alarming.
- 42:21And I guess the answer is, well, the response
- 42:26should be that if that were to occur, then the
- 42:29House can try the president and the Senate can
- 42:32remove him, impeach and remove the president.
- 42:35But we've seen how ineffective that process has
- 42:38been. And so I worry about where that leaves
- 42:41us. So regarding presidential immunity, in 2018,
- 42:45during the Mueller special counsel investigation,
- 42:47you wrote a law review article, Washington University
- 42:50Law Review, that analyzed separation of powers
- 42:52issues. This was obviously before the Supreme
- 42:54Court's decision. You wrote that courts would
- 42:57most likely recognize immunity for a president's
- 43:00official conduct, but you acknowledged that the
- 43:03treatment of unofficial conduct was less predictable
- 43:06than on July 1st, 2024, the court ruled the presidents
- 43:11are immune from criminal prosecution for their
- 43:13official acts when those acts relate to their
- 43:16core powers under the Constitution, like the
- 43:19pardon power. The court also said that there
- 43:21was a presumption that presidents have immunity
- 43:24for their official acts more broadly. And Justice
- 43:27Roberts wrote that courts can't even consider
- 43:30the president's motives. So I'm curious your
- 43:33reaction to that. Did the court's decision align
- 43:37with what you predicted? Did it go farther than
- 43:39what you predicted? What are your thoughts? I
- 43:41think it went a little bit further. And it's
- 43:44funny, as I thought about it, many of the justices
- 43:47on the court today served in the executive branch.
- 43:52They understand the importance of allowing the
- 43:56president to make tough decisions without fear
- 43:58of retribution. without consequences in the future,
- 44:04without second guess, being second guessed by
- 44:06future president, without being prosecuted by
- 44:08future presidents. And so in that sense, as I
- 44:14thought about it, I thought, you know, I kind
- 44:16of, it felt like that's where I thought the court
- 44:20might go. Although going to the next step of
- 44:26not even questioning motive, to me, in the hands
- 44:32of someone with no integrity leaves a big hole.
- 44:37And at a time when we have a Congress and a Senate,
- 44:43if not unwilling, unable to act, to investigate
- 44:48and to possibly remove a president who is acting
- 44:54outside of integrity, I think it leaves the United
- 44:58States in sort of a... precarious position. I'm
- 45:02worried about it. Listen, President Bush appointed
- 45:08Chief Justice Roberts. I have the greatest respect
- 45:10for him. I really do. I admire him. I know he's
- 45:14how smart he is and how hard it is, particularly
- 45:17in these times dealing with these branches of
- 45:21government in making decisions. But that decision
- 45:27has created opportunity for someone without integrity.
- 45:31I'm not saying this president doesn't have integrity.
- 45:33What I'm saying is it appears that he's taking
- 45:36advantage of the opportunity to do things that
- 45:39he wants to do. Justice Jackson, in her dissent,
- 45:43made a policy argument. She criticized the majority's
- 45:47ruling as altering the balance of power between
- 45:50the three branches of government. Her point was
- 45:53by weakening Congress's oversight power and granting
- 45:56excessive authority to the courts and to the
- 45:59executive branch. That this really, Justice Jackson
- 46:03point was it actually undermined separation of
- 46:05powers by shifting excessive authority to the
- 46:08president and ironically to the courts. It's
- 46:11interesting, I'm curious what your take is on
- 46:14the point that she made about how the decision
- 46:17could alter the balance of power. Was she right?
- 46:19Was it something do we not know yet? Do we not
- 46:22have enough data points to really test your theory?
- 46:25We don't have enough data points yet because
- 46:27I'd like to see a different Congress. Let's say,
- 46:29for example, the Democrats take control of both
- 46:31the House and the Senate. I think then we'll
- 46:34have a better sense of how much this decision
- 46:37affected the balance of power. in our system
- 46:40of government. So today it appears that, oh my
- 46:43goodness, the president has all this unchecked
- 46:46power, but he's got a Congress that's controlled
- 46:48by Republicans, both houses. And so let's wait
- 46:51and see. I think it's too early to tell in response
- 46:53to your question. You mentioned pardons and you
- 46:57mentioned the January 6 pardons. I think it's
- 46:59not disputed. The president's pardon power is
- 47:01a core executive functions enumerated in the
- 47:04Constitution. Supporters of the president did
- 47:08enter the Capitol. As of January 20th, 2025,
- 47:131575 people had been charged in connection with
- 47:17the events on January 6. And as he promised during
- 47:20the campaign, President Trump did pardon or commute
- 47:24the prison sentences of most of these people,
- 47:27including people that had been convicted of assault
- 47:29and the like. I just want to understand from
- 47:32your perspective. Since the president's power
- 47:37is what it is, I'm assuming that there is a pardon
- 47:40office and there was a process. Can you provide
- 47:44just a little insight into what the process was
- 47:46for considering a pardon during your tenure in
- 47:50the White House and the Attorney General's office?
- 47:52During our tenure during President Bush's term,
- 47:55and I suspect in terms before then, there is
- 48:01a pardon attorney's office at the Department
- 48:02of Justice. And that office receives requests
- 48:08for pardons. They do an investigation. They make
- 48:12a recommendation. That recommendation comes directly
- 48:15over to the White House counsel. And so I would
- 48:18have conversations with that office directly.
- 48:23And my understanding is that that is no longer
- 48:27the case. Now requests come straight. directly
- 48:30into the White House or elsewhere, but not to
- 48:33the pardon attorney. Now, to be fair, it is true
- 48:38that at the very end of many administrations,
- 48:43even under the structure that I just described,
- 48:45there are what is called political pardons, where
- 48:48people come directly into the White House and
- 48:51make a request. And at that point, the president
- 48:54is less concerned about whether, you know, if
- 48:57I grant a pardon in this particular case, how
- 48:59is it going to affect my reelection? Well, there
- 49:01may not be reelection concerns. There may be
- 49:03less concern about, well, how is it going to
- 49:06affect my legacy? And so I think there were political
- 49:10pardons. There were some that occurred. at the
- 49:13end of the Bush administration, when I was no
- 49:15longer in government, as I believe, as I recall.
- 49:19But the usual way is the process. And the reason
- 49:23you do that is because you don't want it to appear
- 49:25that pardons are politicized. So you want that
- 49:28initial recommendation coming from a career individual
- 49:31at the Department of Justice, coming over to
- 49:34the White House, and then being presented to
- 49:36the White House counsel, and then ultimately
- 49:38to the president again. with the goal of reassuring
- 49:41the American public that the exercise of this
- 49:44constitutional power was going to be made consistent
- 49:46with certain principles and not because of political
- 49:51reasons. Do you think pardoning the January 6th
- 49:56defendants was an appropriate exercise of the
- 49:58pardon power? What do you mean by appropriate?
- 50:01How would you define appropriate? The president
- 50:02certainly had the authority to do it. Was it
- 50:06the right thing to do? From my perspective—and
- 50:08I'm not president. He has—he can choose to do
- 50:11what he wants to do. From my perspective, it
- 50:15was a betrayal to the career of prosecutors and
- 50:18investigators of the Department of Justice who
- 50:20did their job and did their job well. And so,
- 50:25you know, was it appropriate? I think it was
- 50:27wrong. I'll just say it was—I— I would have recommended,
- 50:31if I were advising the president, Mr. President,
- 50:33do not do this. It will destroy the morale of
- 50:35the Department of Justice. We've got a couple
- 50:38of questions in the Q &A, but I quickly want
- 50:41to pivot to a subject to just get your initial
- 50:43take on. President Trump has signed 210 executive
- 50:47orders so far this year. By way of comparison,
- 50:51Presidents Biden and Bush had only signed 77
- 50:54and 54 executive orders respectively in their
- 50:56first years of office. So consideration of executive
- 51:01orders, what was the process that White House
- 51:04Counsel and the Justice Department followed when
- 51:09you were serving in government? It was an iterative
- 51:14process. And it would almost invariably begin
- 51:18at the White House. We would then communicate
- 51:21to the Department of Justice. They would then
- 51:24draft an executive order for us to consider.
- 51:27And it would then go back and forth. And at the
- 51:31end of the process, the Department of Justice
- 51:33would sign off as the formal legality of that
- 51:36order. Did the president have the authority to
- 51:38issue this executive order? So that was a process
- 51:42we followed. Now, supporters of the administration
- 51:47contend that executive actions are important
- 51:49to advance the president's agenda in face of
- 51:52entrenched opposition. Opponents of the administration
- 51:55contend the president's really pushing the outer
- 51:57limits of executive power through executive orders,
- 52:00including the firing of members of independent
- 52:02commissions and the like. How do you weigh the
- 52:06case on the advantages and disadvantages of sort
- 52:08of governing through executive order like this
- 52:11administration is doing? Well, I mean, if you
- 52:13want to go fast, you use executive orders. But
- 52:16if you want to go far in really advancing your
- 52:19agenda, you do it through legislation. Why? Because
- 52:22the next president, first day, can wipe out all
- 52:25those executive orders, or Congress can pass
- 52:28legislation that overrides those executive orders.
- 52:34And so I can understand the frustration. We were
- 52:37frustrated at times by Congress. And so Being
- 52:40able to sign an executive order obviously is
- 52:42much easier and much faster, but it's not lasting.
- 52:46And so if you want, one key area would be like
- 52:50immigration. There are certain things you can
- 52:52do in immigration through executive order, but
- 52:57it's not lasting. The next administration, particularly
- 53:00one of a different party could come in and undo
- 53:03all of that. Well, the administration has skillfully
- 53:06utilized the so -called emergency docket. the
- 53:09Supreme Court to get matters quickly before the
- 53:12court. And the administration has been winning
- 53:16between, by my count, 83 to 93 percent of the
- 53:18time, at least as of last month. We've got a
- 53:22case being argued tomorrow on the president's
- 53:24tariff powers, being able to impose tariffs.
- 53:28How does the emergency docket differ from the
- 53:31process that you saw when people were challenging
- 53:33the Bush administration's policies? Because I'm
- 53:35sure there was litigation and there was you know,
- 53:39concerns and court cases, right? Yes, there were
- 53:42court cases, major court cases. In fact, I had
- 53:45to walk out of the Oval Office four times and
- 53:48tell the President of the United States, Mr.
- 53:49President, the advice, the lawyers, your lawyers
- 53:51told you saying you have the authority to do
- 53:54this or that. The Supreme Court has just said
- 53:56you don't have that authority. So that was a
- 54:02concern. You know, the courts is being pushed
- 54:12to make a lot of decisions on a lot of legal
- 54:15issues. This administration has really pushed
- 54:17forward an agenda with legal implications, and
- 54:22it has really strained, I think, the work of
- 54:25the court. And the difference between the decisions
- 54:29on the emergency docket or crisis on the emergency
- 54:31docket and the merits docket is that on the emergency
- 54:36docket, Typically, certain decisions are made
- 54:39without full briefing and without oral arguments,
- 54:43oftentimes. Oftentimes, those decisions are not
- 54:46signed. There have been some rare instances where
- 54:49they are signed, but that is the difference.
- 54:55Whether or not that process will continue remains
- 54:57to be seen. Two of the members on the court worked
- 55:04for me. Brett Kavanaugh and Neil Gorsuch. Obviously,
- 55:09we put Sam Alito and John Roberts on the court,
- 55:12President Bush did, not me. I know certain members
- 55:16of the court very well, and I have confidence
- 55:18in them. At the end of the day, will I always
- 55:22agree with every decision? I didn't always agree
- 55:24with every decision President Bush made, but
- 55:26the only thing you can ask for is that people
- 55:28exercise their best judgment. in making a decision.
- 55:33I'm hopeful that's what still occurs today. So
- 55:37we're running very short on time. I wish we could
- 55:39spend time on the unitary executive, the Congress's
- 55:41executor. And maybe you'll come back for a bonus
- 55:44round, perhaps early next year. We'd love to
- 55:46have you back. I'd like to close on an important
- 55:49topic, and that's the increase in political violence.
- 55:52I don't need to go through the laundry list of
- 55:55the recent attacks, assassinations, attempted
- 55:58assassinations. In our program materials, we
- 56:00have statistics on the rise of of threats to
- 56:04bench officers. A recent NPR PBS News Marist
- 56:07poll found that nearly one third of Americans,
- 56:0930%, believe it may be necessary to resort to
- 56:13political violence to get the country back on
- 56:15track. And, you know, Benjamin Franklin once
- 56:21famously was asked, you know, what government
- 56:23have you formed? And he said, you know, ma 'am,
- 56:27a republic if you can keep it. So I'm wondering
- 56:30about your views, your reaction to political
- 56:33violence and any concerns that you have around
- 56:37that and what our institutions can do to address
- 56:40it. Well, I mean, it's certainly true that there
- 56:43is no guarantee that there will always be a United
- 56:45States of America. And that's just a fact. And
- 56:50part of the beginning of the deterioration of
- 56:52the United States of America, one sign is increased
- 56:56political violence. I worry about it. I think
- 57:00most people, virtually everyone I know, responsible
- 57:03person that I know, is concerned about it, and
- 57:06we all condemn it. In terms of what we can do
- 57:09to address it, once the rhetoric in our country
- 57:14today, in our politics today, has become so coarse
- 57:17and so divisive, Democrat, Republican, Democratic
- 57:21judge, Republican judge, us versus them. It has
- 57:29to change and it begins with our leadership.
- 57:33And the thing about it, it begins there, but
- 57:36does it really begin there? I sometimes ask myself
- 57:38because we put these people in office, we voted
- 57:42for them. So maybe it's us, maybe it begins with
- 57:44us. Maybe we should look inward in terms of how
- 57:48are we acting? How are we speaking? Why are we
- 57:51voting for people like we have in office today?
- 57:55who have led us to this place. I think Peggy
- 57:59Noonan recently wrote in the Wall Street Journal
- 58:01that we've become a nation of algorithms, you
- 58:04know, and that that's contributed in her view
- 58:07to political polarization. Well, it's certainly
- 58:10true that we do appear polarized and I think
- 58:14it's important that we understand that, you know,
- 58:18this is a great experiment, this country of ours.
- 58:21We have people of different races, cultures,
- 58:24backgrounds, values, all trying to get together,
- 58:28all trying to get along and achieve a better
- 58:31life, and we need to be respectful of each other.
- 58:35And, you know, that really begins at home, no
- 58:38question about it, but it's vital that our leadership
- 58:41reflects those values. And I'm not just talking
- 58:45about in the White House. I'm just talking about
- 58:47throughout both federal and state government.
- 58:49We need to have leaders at the end of the local
- 58:51level as well. Exercise those kinds of values
- 58:55of respect and civility and sacrifice. I think
- 58:59that's very important. Thank you, Dean. Unfortunately,
- 59:04we are basically out of time. I will ask and
- 59:08maybe perhaps in the first quarter of 2026, we
- 59:11could have you back to talk about what's happened.
- 59:15since today and also talk a little bit about
- 59:17your path to academia and what advice you would
- 59:20give to law students and lawyers today. But we're
- 59:23out of time. So thank you so much. On behalf
- 59:26of the Beverly Hills Bar Association, the Beverly
- 59:28Hills Bar Foundation, we're grateful for your
- 59:31participation today. We thank you very much for
- 59:34coming in and for being with us today. And we
- 59:37wish you a fantastic day and a wonderful holiday
- 59:41season. And we'll talk to you next year, if not
- 59:43sooner. Same to you, Fitz. Thank you. All right.
- 59:46Thank you, Gene.