Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 200 - Will Próspera Survive Its Own Success? | Erick Brimen
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 200 of the Free Cities podcast. Yes, 200.
- 0:38Who'd have thunk it? We've been here for four years pumping out Free Cities content every week
- 0:43for 200 weeks. Anyway, before we get in to the 200th episode, the Free Cities conference.
- 0:52what a week I'm back just about and as per normal I arrived back home with the kids being back at
- 1:02school and everyone being ill now myself included I can already feel that I'm losing my voice
- 1:07that's what happens when the kids go back they just basically mix all their germs together
- 1:12after the summer and we as parents yeah we suffer the worst of it anyway the conference
- 1:18what can I say what a week that was four days inside an actual free city for many of you I
- 1:26would imagine that was the first time and we've been talking about it for so long it finally
- 1:31happened to everyone that came up and said hello and there were a lot of you many thanks indeed
- 1:37genuinely meeting listeners in person is the strangest and the best part of doing this because
- 1:44you spend all year talking into a microphone in a room on your own and occasionally with other
- 1:50people but not that much and suddenly there are 300 people who know exactly what you've been
- 1:56banging on about all this time. I also got up on stage and did a talk at last which I've been
- 2:03meaning to do for a number of years and I enjoyed myself as anyone that was there saw. I hope I
- 2:09didn't offend too many people but it did seem to go down well even with Mr Joe Quirk who took a bit
- 2:16of a battering from me all in good spirit of course for those asking where's the conference going next
- 2:22well it was announced that the conference will be back in Prague next year the Free Cities Conference
- 2:292027 will be the 28th to the 31st of October back at the wonderful Empire Hall four days put it in
- 2:38the diary now early bird tickets go quickly and of course I would rather you heard it here than
- 2:44found out in March when the price has gone up right episode 200 well there's something rather
- 2:53neat about where this has landed because this podcast started in Prospera four years-ish ago
- 3:01that's where the whole thing began 200 episodes later well here I am again in the same place
- 3:08obviously with lots more buildings and other things this time recording with well the one
- 3:14person connected to this project that I had somehow never sat down with until this moment
- 3:20that's Eric Brimman of course founder and CEO of Prospera itself it seems like I've spoken to
- 3:27everyone else related to Prospera just not him well that's all changed now what do we talk about
- 3:34Well, it's a pretty long one. You'll be happy to know. We talk about the press and what Eric does when a documentary crew gets it wrong.
- 3:43We talk about whether the legal protections actually saved Prospera through four years of a hostile government.
- 3:49I know that's what many people think. Or maybe it was just the election that saved Prospera.
- 3:54Hear what Eric has to say about that. We talk about the village next door and the people in it who didn't ask to have a city built next to their village.
- 4:03Also, I asked, would Prospera survive without Eric? And the big question, one I've been thinking
- 4:10about a lot recently, which is, it's not what happens if Prospera fails, but what happens
- 4:16if it's successful? Does Prospera become something completely different, something we're not expecting
- 4:23as more and more people become interested? And certainly something that the founders don't want.
- 4:29all the important questions here on the free cities podcast i hope you enjoy this rather
- 4:35poignant episode for number 200 prosper is of course the biggest thing in the space right now
- 4:42i would say certainly at the charter cities end at least and i hope i provided you with a good
- 4:49source of info hot off the presses as we say right time to say thanks to my long-standing
- 4:56sponsor Veritas Villages. They've been here through thick and thin. Veritas Villages build
- 5:03freedom communities across Latin America off power natural water orchards gardens and neighbours who chose the place for the same reasons that you would Their newest one is Veritas Village Atenas in the hills of Costa Rica Central Valley
- 5:22about half an hour from the airport at San Jose and phase one went on the market just a few weeks ago.
- 5:29There's also now a live availability tool on their website so you can see what is actually left in say Atenas or in their Coronado village in Panama or Playa Pacifica in Nicaragua.
- 5:44You don't need to fill a form.
- 5:46Wait for someone to call.
- 5:47You can just see what plots are left.
- 5:50Have a look at VeritasVillages.com forward slash free cities.
- 5:55Don't forget to mention us.
- 5:56Right.
- 5:57Value for value people.
- 5:58These are the individuals who support the show directly.
- 6:02I've not done one of these for about three weeks because I had to record all the shows over the conference in advance.
- 6:09So I owe a few of you a mention rather than the usual top five.
- 6:14I had a look at the top five and there were people under the top five who really should have been in the top five if I'd have looked at it on a week by week basis.
- 6:21So I did it over the month and it's a top eight now, not a top five.
- 6:25many thanks to OGs in order, Anon Anon, Henry, Justin Bianchi, Shadrach, Darcy, Christopher
- 6:33Albanese, A.N.T. and Matthias. You are the OGs. Funny thing happened in Prosper 2. I met
- 6:42some subscribers. Some of them wanted to remain anonymous. Some of them didn't. I met the legendary
- 6:47Christopher Albanese. That's right. Hello, Christopher. It's surprising how many people
- 6:52knew his name because he gets a mention every week on this show but what you don't know about
- 6:58Christopher Albanese is he had one of the most fascinating jobs that I've ever discovered and
- 7:04I asked him if we could do a podcast on it sometime and he's kind of said yes but I won't tell you
- 7:08what it is yet I will reveal all if I ever get that sorted but thanks to all the subs and to all
- 7:14the streamers if you're listening on Fountain or any podcast 2.0 app you can stream sats straight
- 7:20to the show while you listen and no advertiser asked you to do that many thanks you just did it
- 7:25and I thank you for that I really do right a few comments that we've missed over the weeks hypno
- 7:33talking about the poly carp nakamoto episode which still gets lots of views we're up to
- 7:3915 000 views now on youtube with that one one of my favorite episodes good to discover poly and the
- 7:48Archibelago project I've been running a node for years and I agree that sovereign servers
- 7:53is where it's naturally going I had an RPI 3 and RPI 4 and now running start OS on an older Dell
- 8:01PC with 32 gigabytes of RAM not sure exactly what that means I need to go back and listen to that
- 8:06episode again but well done Hypno anyway right Devin says why should you find this episode worth
- 8:13your time this is the Dominic Frisbee episode from a couple of weeks ago if you ask me
- 8:17engaging chemistry timothy ellen and dominic frisbee share a sharp often cynical yet witty
- 8:24perspective on global affairs making complex economic and geopolitical topics entertaining
- 8:30rather than dry do you know what i think that's an ai that's just that's classic ai isn't it it's
- 8:37like there's sort of like um attention farming there but if it's not devin thank you i i agree
- 8:44We did have good chemistry on that episode.
- 8:46Rev Hoddle, also about the same episode, the potential of more gold.
- 8:52Going into circulation is one of the least concerning aspects of gold's use as money.
- 8:58Transportability, verifiability and securability are much more problematic to me.
- 9:03True, they are.
- 9:04What I liked about that episode was in the way that Dominic describes gold is that it does have such a massive history in the human psyche.
- 9:13and you could never sort of like deny that and i think that's why it will always be relevant at
- 9:18least in our lifetimes anyway right and on and on well talking a lot of people liked the dominic
- 9:25frisbee episode all fiat currencies will eventually have hyperinflation it's just a matter of time
- 9:30yeah dominic doesn't didn't think that they necessarily have to i think i'm with you on
- 9:36that one and on and on but uh time will tell right bartholomaeus great conversation fyi efrat
- 9:44fennigson talking about the polycarp nakamoto episode again plan for decentralization right
- 9:51that was the main comments i'd missed out time to hand over to the episode 200 episodes in we are
- 10:00back where it all started in Prospera. So why don't you just grab your finest chair,
- 10:06maybe a cigar to celebrate our 200th episode and just sit back, relax and enjoy my conversation with
- 10:13Eric Grimmen.
- 10:20A fairly good entry point might be the ABC film that went out recently The one from the ABC Australia
- 10:32Because I watched it last night and I get a bit disappointed every time something comes out now.
- 10:40Because I could have predicted every single scene in that film.
- 10:45As you probably could as well yourself, you know.
- 10:47It followed a very simple trajectory.
- 10:50It took all the normal talking points.
- 10:52It didn't push any real boundaries, I didn't feel,
- 10:55even though a lot of people were saying it was pretty neutral.
- 10:57I didn't think it was neutral at all.
- 10:59I thought it came in with the billionaire utopia
- 11:02and it ended up on Trump basically, you know,
- 11:07spun the election for Honduras so that the prosperer could carry on existing,
- 11:12which seemed a bit rich.
- 11:14But I think that the whole subject of PR and, you know, the media and rumours and all this stuff is a big issue, is a big thing.
- 11:27And I'm wondering what your current view on it is, because I think about it a lot.
- 11:35And I don't know whether there's a correct way to do this.
- 11:38but certainly the the amount of like misinformation and what you would call bad press even though i
- 11:48think probably bad press is quite good press as well i know that and especially when you read some
- 11:52of it it reads like a manifesto for something pretty good it's just that they the way they
- 11:57report on it they're kind of assuming you think it's bad so what is your current kind of opinion
- 12:03on what's going on in the in the media sphere with regards to prosper what people think about
- 12:08it outside of our world etc well look for sure mainstream media will tilt towards a negative spin
- 12:18um but the biggest risk a project like this has is becoming irrelevant and not being top of mind
- 12:27because the facts of the project will always speak louder than the false allegations
- 12:35to people who could, in fact, benefit from and contribute to the project.
- 12:42So to be put on the radar, as long as the stories are not just 100% fake and negative,
- 12:49but to be put on the radar, you know, on the neutral, even slightly negative,
- 12:54can generally be turned into a net positive.
- 12:59Indeed, a lot of the narrative that they assume everybody's going to take as a bad thing
- 13:05to a subgroup of people who know how the media works.
- 13:09They will see past it and through it and be like,
- 13:13huh, maybe something interesting is happening
- 13:14because ABC traveled from Australia to Roatan
- 13:18to think about the, it elevates the importance of the project.
- 13:24And that I think is critically important
- 13:27because far too often, given the nature of what we're after,
- 13:31people simply don't believe that it's actually happening that is the first challenge that it's
- 13:38real and that it's actually happening and it's and it's better to be real and controversial
- 13:43than to not exist and be irrelevant i'm gonna have to put that back on that didn't last very
- 13:49long did it i'm already super hot um i agreed and i was playing around um this morning just looking at
- 13:58previous um you know media occurrences referencing prosper over the last year and then over a year
- 14:08ago i was trying to work out whether anything was changing i think it's getting better or whatever
- 14:11and certainly the the only thing that turned up because it's a pretty it was a pretty chaotic set
- 14:16of data but there's a big difference between english and spanish speaking number one spanish
- 14:20speaking is often negative often the english speaking is it's kind of like 50 50 currently
- 14:27That's what you're running at is 50-50, which is pretty good, actually.
- 14:31It's surprisingly impressive.
- 14:33I mean, given the state of mainstream media and just global ideology, unfortunately, to have 50-50, it's pretty impressive.
- 14:42What did you think of the ABC one, then, you personally?
- 14:45You know, I saw a short version of it, enough to understand where it was going.
- 14:49and also to identify that there were some gross mischaracterizations,
- 14:54which we spoke proactively with the crew about and said,
- 14:58look, our only hesitation is that you will spin things and lie.
- 15:05You can highlight things you think are negative, but you must say the truth.
- 15:11And so we got our legal team on it.
- 15:14They received a letter with the facts as shared with them
- 15:18and as amply substantiated and they're they're currently in a period of time
- 15:23where they have an opportunity to fix it or else fail or else face legal action
- 15:28and that part of what we have chosen to do across the board right we with outlets that that are credible and seem to come in good faith After discussing our concerns and our intended path ahead
- 15:44where if they defame or intentionally mislead, we will take legal action,
- 15:49we are on the side of giving them a shot.
- 15:52And when and if they choose to do defamation, then we'll pursue it.
- 15:58And we've actually been somewhat successful against big outlets.
- 16:02whether you New York Times, Bloomberg, you know, these are institutions that will have had to retract themselves.
- 16:10And I think that's not the cheapest approach, but it might be the sort of best approach if you can afford it.
- 16:18Because not engaging is somewhat unrealistic.
- 16:22As I said, there's a way to thread the needle where the net is positive because it's relevant.
- 16:28And engaging with everybody, it's also not worthwhile.
- 16:31So if you pick serious outlets that have something to lose, if their reporters just go off rails, gives us somewhat of a balanced position, I think.
- 16:41I looked at the YouTube version of that ABC one and it's such a disaster.
- 16:47You see the misinformation on the top of the screen and then the comment section, which is just even worse.
- 16:53And I wouldn't say it's disheartening because I look at it and I think it doesn't matter.
- 16:58this thing's happening this thing's going ahead is actually going to win because it's a good ideas
- 17:03win in the end but it really is tiresome seeing people just doing the same thing over and over
- 17:10again and coming in in the case of there were two big ones of channel 4 and abc this this in this
- 17:16last 12 month period and they they even pretty much interviewed the same people they interviewed
- 17:21ivan you uh you know and and the narrative followed this literally looks like the australians
- 17:27just looked at that film and went okay well it's we can contact this guy we can contact you know and
- 17:31they did the same thing and the only difference with the abc one was the trump connection which
- 17:36i thought that was i thought there was some missing from some proper misinformation there
- 17:41because tell me if this is right you'll know this um they interviewed a guy near the end and he said
- 17:48that um trump intervened in the election which meant that prospera survived okay but i was aware
- 17:56I wasn't aware that Nasrallah was actually anti-Za anymore.
- 18:02Is that true or not?
- 18:03I know previously he was on the sort of socialist team,
- 18:08but then he kind of split away, didn't he?
- 18:10In the lead up to the election,
- 18:12I remember hearing that he was actually more open to the idea.
- 18:18I think the public record of what he said over time is available.
- 18:23I rather refrain from commenting too much on Honduran politics.
- 18:28I think that he, as others, are legitimately interested in making sure that whatever project is going to emerge can do so with legitimacy and being a positive development for the country.
- 18:45And when all they have are the innuendos or false allegations, it gives them pause and concern.
- 18:53but so far 100% of the people that come with concerns engage do their own
- 19:01research leave at worst neutral and generally more often than not realizing
- 19:06that it's a net positive and then sort of finding themselves in an awkward
- 19:10position because they might have said something against the project before they
- 19:13knew where they can't necessarily go out and fully endorse it for political or
- 19:17other reasons but deep down they know that it's a good thing and uh you know at a minimum neutral
- 19:25and in some cases find ways to support what what i found the difference between the spanish-speaking
- 19:30media and the english and the english-speaking spanish focused on sovereignty they they their
- 19:36big their big attack vector was it's taking away sovereignty the english speakers were all tech
- 19:43billionaires and you know and both of them are well as far as i can understand pretty indisputably
- 19:50wrong on both counts not least when they call prosper a billionaire paradise or whatever they
- 19:57call it they often do i mean i know i know i don't say i know many billionaires but i certainly know
- 20:03some rich people who would choose not to live in prosper of all places it's not the place that
- 20:07they would instantly think this is my paradise you know but but it's interesting that that that's the
- 20:12the two ways the sovereignty which once again i think you can indisputably say is incorrect is
- 20:20that right of course yeah and i mean it's not only incorrect it's quite literally the opposite
- 20:26you know but but it does take a deeper understanding of what sovereignty even is where it comes from
- 20:31and how it gets exercised and to understand that what prospera does in partnership with governments
- 20:39is to enable a greater exercise of individual sovereignty
- 20:43by the citizens as opposed to the opposite, right?
- 20:47But I think these two themes
- 20:50are a reflection of where the cultures are and come from.
- 20:54In Latin America, there is a colonial history
- 20:57where once the countries here secured independence,
- 21:01it is kind of their precious, most valuable thing.
- 21:04And anything that could threaten it
- 21:07is automatically a big risk.
- 21:09And so those who want to attack a project
- 21:12know that those are the soft spots
- 21:14and the thing that people react most aggressively to.
- 21:18So that is how they're going to attack it.
- 21:20In the English speaking, I think that unfortunately,
- 21:24the lashing out against the extremely wealthy tech billionaires,
- 21:31it's a reflection of tendency towards socialism that we're seeing.
- 21:37And so obviously they are the target.
- 21:40and when culture is detached from deeper philosophy
- 21:47that understands how value creation is a virtue,
- 21:53then they'll use that as an angle of attack.
- 21:55But if you double or triple click
- 21:58and you see who's ultimately promoting these attacks,
- 22:02you'll see a uniform group of individuals
- 22:06with an ideology that is fundamentally collectivist
- 22:09and they have a different worldview
- 22:11than that which we seek to amplify,
- 22:14which is to empower the individual
- 22:15to seek their maximum potential
- 22:18and to be able to benefit from it
- 22:21through voluntary trade, right?
- 22:23I mean, and that doesn't need to be a political label.
- 22:25It's just a worldview of individualism
- 22:28versus collectivism
- 22:30and we're amplifying the former
- 22:31and they want to amplify the latter.
- 22:33It's interesting.
- 22:34I mean, it's the part I have the hardest with
- 22:37in talking to you know like my normie friends say about anything like this and it's surprising how
- 22:44deep it runs that the um the fact that somehow by by pursuing individual rights you're doing
- 22:52something bad it's quite astonishing you know i i come from a what i would have said was a pretty
- 22:57open-minded culture and it took me a while to realize because i had to sort of choose my word
- 23:04words wisely when I described, say, a private form of governance. And even now, when I think
- 23:09about it, I know, whoa, that sounds, that sounds crazy. Who's gonna, you know, and in fact, in the
- 23:16ABC film, you'll know the guy, I hadn't heard of him before, what was his name? They interviewed
- 23:23a guy who was an economist, Fernando Garcia, right? They interviewed this guy, Fernando Garcia.
- 23:30and he said oh the libertarians want the state that wants the states of the world in their current
- 23:37form to disappear and he was talking about in he was talking about the state of politics in
- 23:43honduras as if it was this utopia saying and and obviously we we all knew that that it wasn't the
- 23:52greatest place to live and what what was happening here was potentially at least showing a better way
- 23:58yet people were defending the state or defending the status quo,
- 24:05even though it was bad.
- 24:07I think it's worth qualifying when you say people are defending the state.
- 24:11Again, you've got to go and see at the source who's defending the state.
- 24:15And you'll see that people like this individual who is part of the machine
- 24:19and has lived off of it will defend it.
- 24:23And there's a mixture of incentives and ideology that lead a person such as that to, I think, actually believe what he's spousing in part because he depends on it.
- 24:35It's also worthwhile recognizing that this emergence of anti-capitalism, anti-free markets does have some legitimacy in it that in a lot of what we think are free market economies, there's actually a lot of cronyism that happens.
- 24:52And that when individuals or companies can enrich themselves truly at the expense of the general population because they are leveraging coercive powers of governments to do so, it is right and proper to reject that.
- 25:08And it's not okay.
- 25:09It's immoral.
- 25:11It's coercive.
- 25:12And we should also stand against it.
- 25:14And too often, I think people that defend individual liberty don't acknowledge that what is being performed in a lot of these economies is not true free market capitalism.
- 25:28It's a hybrid at best with a lot of socialism embedded.
- 25:33And that what people don't like is not the freedom.
- 25:36It's the coercion part of it.
- 25:38but walking them through to understand that at the source
- 25:43of that injustice that they perceive
- 25:46and sometimes are direct victims of
- 25:48is not a free market entrepreneur.
- 25:50It's a coercive government that through any number of means
- 25:54is imposing a product or a service or disallowing competition If they not taking through that they just associate it to what on the surface And obviously statists are going to blame the quote greedy
- 26:07tech billionaire or entrepreneur. But at the source, it's really the coercive power of the
- 26:14state that is being weaponized to enrich unscrupulous business owners or leaders.
- 26:21And this is, you know, I know that the Genesis story is not the most relevant here since you've
- 26:26talked to so many people, but on a personal level, for me, that's what clicked at some point.
- 26:32I didn't get to these ideas based on some libertarian ideology or even through philosophical
- 26:40books or economic books. It was a very firsthand experience of how I saw my country of birth
- 26:50supposedly having a combination of democracy and capitalism, actually still having a tremendous
- 26:57amount of poverty with wealth concentration and me likewise feeling that something is off,
- 27:02like this is wrong, right? It can't be that a few control so much and that others don't even
- 27:09have the opportunity to compete. But I didn't have the language nor the understanding that
- 27:15at the source of that injustice is not the business person.
- 27:19I mean, they can be complicit, but in reality, it's the use of coercion, which is in the
- 27:24hands of government as we currently have them structured.
- 27:28So I guess I sell that to, on the one hand, say it's not surprising, but I think there's
- 27:34a bit of hope because this is not ideological.
- 27:38It's not that complicated.
- 27:40But until it's put into words and people can have the mental model that clicks, it's
- 27:45it feels like a battle of ideology.
- 27:48It's in fact something very pragmatic, very practical.
- 27:51It's not about libertarianism or socialism.
- 27:54It's just about justice and whether or not you like to have things imposed upon you
- 28:00or if instead you want to have choice.
- 28:03And when you take it out of the political conversation
- 28:05and you bring it down to this very basic set of facts,
- 28:09I think most people ultimately get it.
- 28:11Do you know why the libertarian utopia meme grew so fast?
- 28:18I mean, I've only been following Prospero for like four years.
- 28:22And obviously, there are lots of libertarians who believe in Prospero.
- 28:26But in the sense that, and I'll always use Morizan as an example,
- 28:32it's built on libertarian principles,
- 28:34and no one's ever heard of Hopper inside Morizan.
- 28:38And the service is good, so people go there.
- 28:40And that's the long and short of the model is here's a product.
- 28:46I'm offering it to you.
- 28:47Do you want it?
- 28:48Yes.
- 28:48All right.
- 28:49Let's sign an agreement and let's work together.
- 28:52So where did all the libertarian stuff come from?
- 28:55Was that there or did that come accidentally?
- 29:00Look, at least as it relates to Prospera, we have many members on the team that are definitely
- 29:08or where, I think their ideology has evolved in part as a result of the project, historically
- 29:15libertarian leaning, right?
- 29:16And I think in a traditional paradigm of how government is structured, if you want individual
- 29:24liberty and free markets, then you lean libertarian.
- 29:28What Prospera has sought to do is kind of alter a bit the paradigm, right?
- 29:32And consider the possibility that it need not all be in that continuum of, say, left to right, collectivist versus individualism in a traditional public government structure.
- 29:46That if you introduce a new dimension, right, of public versus private, and you have a tremendous amount of choice, it kind of doesn't matter so much, right?
- 29:59And the best analogy I can think of is the hotel industry.
- 30:04Does it really matter that some hotels are basically all-inclusive, right?
- 30:09You pay a bigger price and then everything comes included versus some other alternative
- 30:16that gives you the bare minimum and then you got to pay for everything extra.
- 30:21It doesn't matter because you have choice.
- 30:23If you like the all-inclusive, you go to Sandals.
- 30:25And if you want the bare minimum, maybe you go to a hostel or something that just gives
- 30:29you a bed and the rest you buy out on the street.
- 30:33Obviously, the challenge is when you have no choice, right?
- 30:36And so once you add that dimension of true choice, these labels stop meaning as much
- 30:42because you are no longer bound by, limited to a coercively imposed system.
- 30:50You have choice.
- 30:51And in that choice, why not have a city-scale project
- 30:55that feels more collectivist?
- 30:57If everybody signs up for that, why not?
- 31:00It's going to Sandals, right?
- 31:01And obviously you see Scandinavian countries
- 31:04where they do have a lot of freedoms,
- 31:06but you pay a ton of taxes
- 31:07and you get a much thicker stack of services So I think that the libertarian meme comes because a lot of people that have been affiliated with Prospera had the emergence of this vision come from the frustration of a coercive government
- 31:26and the libertarian ideology that results from it.
- 31:30And that's just the way it is.
- 31:32I, for one, I don't consider myself a libertarian in a traditional sense because we're building
- 31:37outside of that paradigm.
- 31:38Of course, I strongly believe in individual freedom.
- 31:42And I think in the end, that's probably one of the most important human virtues that we should aspire for.
- 31:49Because nothing can really emerge through virtue unless you have true individual liberty.
- 31:57If you don't have choice, even if you're doing the right thing, if it's worse, so what?
- 32:02You mentioned then that you reckon a few people on the project, their idea of they were libertarians, it's evolved somewhat. Can you tell me how it's evolved? I'm very interested in that. So what is the evolution beyond say, I don't know, I'm not a libertarian either. So I don't necessarily, I can't quote all the libertarian rules. I know, roughly speaking.
- 32:25But what would the evolution be?
- 32:28What has that person arrived at?
- 32:31And has he got a name?
- 32:32Well, look, I think a libertarian is very preoccupied
- 32:38of making sure that government is as small as possible,
- 32:41that it does the least possible, that taxes are minimized.
- 32:46And that is because in the paradigm of how governments
- 32:49have traditionally existed, maybe that is the best
- 32:52or the least bad of the structures.
- 32:54But once you transcend and think of governance as a service, and you decouple the service from the institutions of government, and you introduce the possibility that at least part of the stack of the governance services are done in some sort of public-private structure, then you start to think of it more as a service.
- 33:18And just like with any other service, some providers are going to be very integrated and others are going to be minimalistic.
- 33:24And so it stops mattering so much how much of the stack is included in whatever price they're going to charge for the service of governance.
- 33:35And what matters more is that we change the paradigm and introduce in the provision of governance services alliances that work, partnerships that work between the so-called public sector and the private sector.
- 33:50And I will add, you know, it is somewhat irresponsible might be too strong of a word, but not refined enough to say things like private governance.
- 34:05Because unless you define what governments do, you can easily put it all in one bucket.
- 34:13And for some of those layers, the idea that those services will be in the hands of a private
- 34:19and for-profit company is repulsive and dangerous.
- 34:22For example, unless you're very well-read and understand anarcho-capitalism and how
- 34:28insurance companies might neutralize the threat that private armies will take over, you will
- 34:34go straight to East India Company and say, whoa, we have tried that.
- 34:37And that did not work out because many parts of the East India Companies of the world, indeed,
- 34:42I wouldn't support, right? I mean, the individual rights transcend profit motive of a company,
- 34:49even if they have the coercive power. So if you put it all in a bucket, it's very hard,
- 34:54even for reasonable people to swallow that pill. But if you start to decouple and you, you know,
- 35:00slice the layers of what governments do and you say, hold on, okay, assume that you put up to the
- 35:07side say national defense and assume you put off to the side you know the the public justice system
- 35:15and assume you put off to the side you know national diplomacy and and a lot of these things
- 35:19that people do in fact associate with the sovereign powers of a nation state and you say let's just
- 35:27talk about like commerce like how to do business right not your culture not family laws not the
- 35:35territory, just how you engage in commerce, right? The trade of good and services in a manner that
- 35:40maximizes the collective wealth creation. And how much innovation do you need to do at that level
- 35:47today when there is a very well-proven system that has worked pretty much everywhere that is tried?
- 35:54And so if you bring it down to just that part of the stack, now you have a bigger space to discuss
- 35:59what's a big deal in terms of doing a public-private partnership, right? I mean,
- 36:03I mean, you have companies running airports,
- 36:06and airports you might argue are extremely sensitive
- 36:09both for security reasons, for safety reasons,
- 36:12for all sorts of reasons that just running
- 36:14the day-to-day rules and the enforcement thereof
- 36:18is not nearly as controversial.
- 36:23So I think the evolution to your point of why libertarians I think that Join Prosper transcend the typical political label is because we realize that in the end we creating
- 36:34a new paradigm in which the label doesn't matter as much because you have choice, you
- 36:38have competition, and we're seeking to align the incentives of what makes the private sector
- 36:45very efficient with the quality control that a government that is representative in nature
- 36:54can do better than if you have an East India company type of setup.
- 36:58Do you personally, do you think it's a brand new paradigm?
- 37:03In its current form, yes.
- 37:08Elements of it have been done before, and perhaps every part of it has been done before.
- 37:13But packaged the way that Prospera has done it, I think it's innovative and brand new.
- 37:20The idea that what emerged out of Hong Kong or what created Hong Kong versus what Hong Kong was,
- 37:27if you separate those two things, obviously what gave birth to Hong Kong can be extremely controversial.
- 37:33Opium wars, it was from what imposed a big colonial power kind of saying, this is not mine, I'm going to run it.
- 37:39And that way to get there, I wouldn't support, at least not in modern era if you can avoid
- 37:44it.
- 37:45But that you now have a special jurisdiction with international best price.
- 37:49Obviously, the proof is in the pudding.
- 37:51So is there a way to get to a similar outcome, but through voluntary agreement where the
- 37:58nation state actually is significantly better off from the start and where you're leveraging
- 38:05where a representative government at the nation state level has a very fair and perhaps uniquely
- 38:12valuable role to play and a private partner that is going to run things very efficiently.
- 38:19And if structured in what we at Prosper call the socioeconomic development enterprise,
- 38:24where its profit is derived not from individualized transactions, but through a collective
- 38:31of economic development over time in a given territory,
- 38:36then I think it hasn't been done this way before.
- 38:40You've had public-private partnerships
- 38:42for critical assets and infrastructure.
- 38:45Obviously, you've had highly differentiated
- 38:47special jurisdictions like Hong Kong and Dubai.
- 38:50But merging those two things in modern era
- 38:52has not been done before.
- 38:54Something I was thinking about this morning
- 38:56with regards to the partnership with the government
- 39:00is Prosper's just been through a big four-year cycle of, you know, a bad government.
- 39:10So the bad relation with government, let's say.
- 39:14What I was thinking about this morning was,
- 39:15do you think that the legal protections worked?
- 39:21Or do you think the government just changed?
- 39:24Because I've, when it, I'll tell you why I ask.
- 39:28I've thought, great, this proves the model.
- 39:30This is amazing. Like the socialists wanted to come in and shut you down and actually Prosper is still here and things are happening. Great. Proves the model in one sense. But then also, if you look at it, there was a regime change, which was arguably something separate. And I'll be honest, I think, I don't know about you, but I breathed a sigh of relief.
- 39:54it was almost like it was like a very close football game it was two all and and someone
- 39:58won in in the last five minutes and it's like look we can celebrate but but we were lucky if
- 40:04you see what i mean what do you think about that in terms of the the regime change which has
- 40:09obviously been favorable with indisputably so how much do you think the legal protections on
- 40:17prospera etc would have have worked in in a sense how much can we say that they've worked
- 40:23I think they're fundamentally necessary, but substantially insufficient by themselves.
- 40:32You must have them, but they're not the silver bullet.
- 40:37I think what we are learning by building is that politics, which gives rise to a particular
- 40:48administration is complicated, multidimensional, and that there is, in a weird way, a tremendous
- 40:57amount of value as an instrument of peace preservation for various interests to kind
- 41:06of battle it out through a political process.
- 41:09Because what is the alternative?
- 41:11The alternative, it's a lot of violence and civil wars all the time.
- 41:16The only way you can drive change is by killing the other guy.
- 41:20You know, that I think net net will result in far more value destruction.
- 41:24Now, of course, I'm not celebrating what happened in absolute terms, but as a continuum of a
- 41:31model that has to mature and perfect how it partners, how it communicates the partnership,
- 41:40and what it prioritizes at various cycles of development from idea to, you know, 20 years later,
- 41:48a city-scale project that everybody recognizes, let's say, as successful.
- 41:52It's been very valuable.
- 41:55I mean, there's no other way to go through what we're going through and see it from the inside than going through it, you know.
- 42:03I think the jury's still out.
- 42:04I mean, obviously, I'm very optimistic about the current administration and, let's say, solving the dispute not only amicably, but in a manner that results in something that potentially is far better than would have been had there not been a dispute.
- 42:21You know, it's like you're putting the model to the test.
- 42:24You need to, if you're astute and you have a long-term perspective and you are committed to true value creation, not political ideology, okay, as I believe we are.
- 42:33then we have in our hands an opportunity to emerge out of a controversial face stronger and better than ever before and that we could have ever been safe seven years after we started because we started building in 2020.
- 42:48And I think, you know, when we achieve that, that will be a massive accomplishment and way more valuable than, say, having found what we think it's a silver bullet.
- 42:57I don't think there's anything that is a silver bullet.
- 43:01I think you have to contend with the fact that everywhere there is multiple layers of
- 43:06interest with varying degrees of power and influence.
- 43:11It's not static.
- 43:12But directionally, there are different types of groups that play a different role in the
- 43:17politic as it's generally applied, at least in democracies.
- 43:21And that to succeed with a long-term project that will be around for multiple administrations,
- 43:28You have to go deeper than what's at the surface in an electoral cycle, because behind that, upstream from the politicians and whatever is popular in a given 10 year cycle, there are other dynamics of influence and interest.
- 43:46And those are the ones you have to align with.
- 43:48Right. That's like your roots have to go deeper than just surface level politics.
- 43:53Did you have you thought what Prospera might look like now if the election had gone a different way?
- 43:58Candidly, it would probably still be very similar to where we are right now.
- 44:09I think that the, again, removing political labels and thinking of the actors involved,
- 44:18you know, that really move the levers of influence.
- 44:22I think ultimately they have utilitarian objectives to reach.
- 44:30They might wrap it around a certain ideology that can be popular and convenient and get
- 44:38them to power, especially in a population that unfortunately is largely poor and it's
- 44:44easy to weaponize against those who have a lot more than they do.
- 44:49but ultimately, especially in a second cycle where the massive arbitration that we are engaged upon
- 44:58will almost certainly be decided, right? I mean, I think they fairly well knew that during the first
- 45:03four years, you know, these are seven-year arbitration proceedings. Unfortunately, they take
- 45:08too long. But in the second cycle, that thing's going to be decided. And massively increasing
- 45:14physical hostilities would have just sealed the deal for them to almost guarantee lose that
- 45:19arbitration. And so, you know, not that political actors are rational in a traditional economic way,
- 45:28but they have their own rationality. They want to stay in power. They ultimately want to keep
- 45:33enough people satisfied for them to remain in power. And if possible, for them to claim certain
- 45:39victories, they obviously want to add to their political points. So the win-win outcome would
- 45:45have been a negotiated resolution. It would have had different colors and flavors and labels.
- 45:52But ultimately, unless they wanted to end up with a massive claim against them, which would have
- 45:58made their lives super hard to finance public affairs and all that, a settlement is always
- 46:03what was going to make most sense. And that's the path that we're seeking to optimize for right now.
- 46:09I didn't realize that until I looked into it last night. But is it true that the previous
- 46:14government actually left Ixit the the arbitrary so was that presumably that was them trying to say
- 46:21well look even that doesn't matter then like anything anything that any way that any legal
- 46:26way that you would like to strong arm us doesn't matter anymore the the constitution is
- 46:33unconstitutional the Ixit is it doesn't matter you know we're not even in it anymore is that is
- 46:39that true I didn't even there's a lot of the whole story that I missed while it was happening I think
- 46:43So the prime administration did withdraw from the ICSID convention allegedly larger because of the Prospera suits although in reality we just one of like 16 that were filed
- 46:57Ours was the largest and perhaps most well-known,
- 47:00but they clearly made a pivot when it comes to respecting or not contracts and obligations
- 47:06because, you know, you have 16 different organizations from Scandinavia to locals.
- 47:13I was going to say, sorry to butt in. Were they all connected with the same? Why were they looking for arbitration?
- 47:20Well, for various claims of expropriation or violation of contractual obligations by the state.
- 47:27Some might have been energy generators that had a price and one didn't pay.
- 47:31Right, but to do with the ZEAs, for example.
- 47:34No, no. Of the 16, probably maximum two or three might have had something to do with the ZEA regime.
- 47:43The vast majority of them didn't have anything to do with the legal system.
- 47:48It had to do with a pivot in public policy that those that filed the claim felt was a
- 47:56violation of contractual obligations or legal obligations by the state towards them.
- 48:03But to your point of exit, they withdrew.
- 48:07arguably it was a moot issue because there are several other ways by which a private investor
- 48:14in Honduras could nevertheless end up in exit arbitration so it was probably you know 60%
- 48:20a political move and maybe they thought they could gain some advantage by it but this administration
- 48:26has rejoined I think and that's a that's a move to be celebrated ultimately you know one of the
- 48:33most powerful ways for a state to project confidence to investors is for them to agree
- 48:39that if there is a dispute, a neutral third party will hear the case and adjudicate it.
- 48:46And that's what Ixit is all about. And there are other forums in which an investor in a state can
- 48:51arbitrate, but Ixit, as far as I understand, it's the most well-known and the one that has the
- 48:57the most successful record. And it's not always pro-investor, by the way.
- 49:02It turns out that generally speaking, if you end up in arbitration, given how costly it is and how
- 49:09long it takes, there must have been quite outrageous actions by the state because it
- 49:15doesn't make financial sense for an investor to just go file an arbitration. So more often than
- 49:20not, there's a there there on the claimant side. But it seems quite fair. Now, even if a state
- 49:29wants to ignore the ruling, given the way the international financial system works,
- 49:36those claims have real economic value. And you can look at countries like Venezuela,
- 49:42who attempted to just completely ignore rulings and over time have to pay. Argentina is another
- 49:49for example, it might take longer than the claimant would like.
- 49:53But as markets do, then there's a secondary market to sell the claim.
- 49:57And, you know, you can get pennies on the dollar.
- 49:58It depends on the specifics, but it can be from single-digit pennies to 60 cents on the
- 50:04dollar, right?
- 50:05And then the other person is specialized in the collection side, and they don't mind waiting
- 50:09five years through all sorts of legal and interesting procedures to get paid.
- 50:13So, as I said, it's insufficient by itself, but it's essentially necessary to have strongly legal protections that includes being part of a neutral dispute resolution mechanism.
- 50:26What do you think is the most powerful aspect of prosperous nature that allows it to protect itself from that kind of event?
- 50:38to say someone well i mean there aren't that many like in a way if you look at the the pitfalls of
- 50:44running prosper there's only a few ways it can go wrong one is nobody turns up one is it gets
- 50:50shut down by the government and yeah that's pretty much it really it fails economically and then
- 50:56dissolves or the government come in and shut it down so with regard to the government side
- 51:01And what's the best thing you have, which other projects could potentially learn from, that means that you protect yourself the most from that outcome?
- 51:15It's to abandon the notion that there's any one thing that you can and need to do.
- 51:20And if you do it, you're fine.
- 51:21It's multidimensional.
- 51:24It's dirty and hard.
- 51:26And there isn't a one size fits all.
- 51:29You know, different countries are going to have different power structures.
- 51:34And I think we're starting to sort of map out the phenotype of, let's say, the real
- 51:39politic behind the scenes and how interests are ultimately at play.
- 51:44But there isn't a silver bullet.
- 51:47I think in the aggregate, though, there's a combination of things that have to be part
- 51:51of the ingredients.
- 51:53I think first and foremost, you have to be a good faith actor seeking to create real
- 51:57value and for the local population Right In some cases maybe through monarchies or others or corrupt governments you know maybe an operator that truly is seeking to build an enclave for foreigners with zero benefits to a local population
- 52:12they could get away with it, maybe.
- 52:14But even then, I think a monarch has to face its subjects and you have to show that there's
- 52:22a benefit for them, but certainly in a democracy.
- 52:24So first and foremost, you better be building a project that fundamentally seeks to, and
- 52:29over time, in fact, creates value to the constituents of that government.
- 52:35Number two, you need to have the legal protections and the stacks of contracts and international
- 52:41treaties that apply.
- 52:42And that's a complicated stack of options that you can add to each other.
- 52:48We've mapped out about 10.
- 52:50And obviously, if you have all 10 of them, great.
- 52:52But you've got to have some.
- 52:54Otherwise, it's probably not worth it.
- 52:55And then you have to, and I'm not saying we've done a great job at all of these, but part
- 53:01of the processes enable us to learn is you got to map out and align the interests of
- 53:08multiple stakeholders that are way below the surface of what you normally see in politics,
- 53:14right?
- 53:14Everything from the substantial economic interest groups of the country to the grassroots
- 53:20organizations that exist to advocate for something they care about.
- 53:24You know, you kind of got to map them, understand which ones are legitimate because we have never nor would say do business or transact through illegitimate means, right?
- 53:34Whether it's corruption or just something that's fundamentally misaligned with the basic premises of, say, individual liberties.
- 53:42But mapping that and trying as best as possible to align the nature of the project and its success with the legitimate intentions of those groups.
- 53:52that's where that's the hardest part and i think that if it's not a silver bullet but if you wanted
- 53:59to out of these three categories point to one that is the thing that makes it or break it
- 54:03is that because you can have everything else sorted but if everybody actually sees you as a threat and
- 54:10does not want you eventually they're not going to care about the other stuff yeah i think i agree
- 54:15with that and that brings me on to one of the questions that i've never i've never felt like
- 54:20anyone's answered well enough for me and this is most probably because there is no answer to this
- 54:27talking about crawfish rock for example what where do the rights of people who live in crawfish rock
- 54:36where do they stand with regards to if they decide i don't want a large city built next to my
- 54:43to my village say um because obviously you know they have a in a sense that i mean with if it's
- 54:52pure property rights you're talking about i'm not sure what what that legality of it is i'm kind of
- 54:56looking for the moral answer it's the one the one part of my my conclusion has always been look
- 55:02sometimes shit happens like there are there isn't an answer to this that there you can't you can't
- 55:08please everyone but you can please 95 of people and the crawfish rock one is a is a bone of
- 55:14contention and it also is because so many of the western media when they come in there
- 55:18use that as a as a sort of and i know the story is about who really cares over there and what's
- 55:25been going on and stuff but let's just assume that there isn't a genuine because i think there is i
- 55:30think there if you're a crawfish rock resident there is a genuine um reason to be pissed off
- 55:36If you like your village as a nice fishing village, say, and you don't want to potentially have a big city next to you.
- 55:41So what would your answer be to that?
- 55:44Well, I think the first thing is to recognize that in theory, property rights exist as black and white.
- 55:50In practice, they exist in a continuum of, let's say, a collective understanding and agreement that certain rights are to be respected.
- 56:01So it's not a sharp line.
- 56:03I mean, you can write it as a sharp line, but clearly it isn't.
- 56:06And you can see this, forget Crawfish Rock first.
- 56:09I can go to New York City, go to any, you know, say U.S. planning and zoning.
- 56:14I mean, whatever happened to property rights, if you can't do with your property what you
- 56:19want, as long as you're not verifiably creating negative externalities on those around you.
- 56:24I mean, you have very wide areas where somehow we've accepted that you own the property,
- 56:30but you can't really exercise full liberty upon it.
- 56:34Zoning and planning is a perfect example.
- 56:37And so, you know, in some ways you could argue that when there's structure,
- 56:41there's a less conflicting pathway through which to resolve those differences.
- 56:49And in the absence of that institution, you know, you have kind of what you get here, right?
- 56:53Which is both good and bad.
- 56:55The second thing is that even if you accept
- 56:59that property rights are kind of a fuzzy concept
- 57:01and that requires some sort of collective agreement,
- 57:07that you're never going to, as you say, please everybody.
- 57:10And that is where as dangerous as the concept of democracy is it useful to some extent right Because if you acknowledge that you can convince absolutely everybody you got to
- 57:22have an alternative mechanism by which to say, well, look, we've reached a threshold
- 57:26above which, you know, it's legitimate, even though some people don't like it.
- 57:32And that is where, you know, consultation processes go through.
- 57:35That is where, you know, if there are institutions of adjudicating just how far the property
- 57:41rights go, you go through a democratic type process. Fortunately, we very comfortably clear
- 57:50any reasonable standard of, say, popular support, even within Crawfish Rock. When we did a
- 57:56consultation, a town hall, open forum consultation to Crawfish Rock, before we started moving any
- 58:04there something like 85% of the adults showed up and almost unanimously voted in favor of a project
- 58:12being done. Does that mean that that is the end all be all? Of course not, because opinions change,
- 58:18because people have criticisms about, oh, well, but you didn't invite, I don't know, CNN to
- 58:23monitor the thing. There's all sorts of things that can happen over time. So
- 58:27the entry point of having public legitimacy is never a fixed target. But if you're a good faith
- 58:34actor and you understand that, you do as we have tried to do. And obviously, there's enough people
- 58:41in the village, very few, but they fit the prototype of what some NGOs are looking for
- 58:49in order to justify their fundraising and make themselves appear as if they're helping people.
- 58:53And so they get a lot of attention.
- 58:56But any good faith journalist that goes and perhaps incognito goes and talks to people,
- 59:03the vast majority of Crawfish Rock is happy with what is happening and could happen here.
- 59:08Because there's no negative externality and there's no threat that it will change their lifestyle
- 59:15if they want to live and continue to live exactly as they are.
- 59:19Like there's nothing that we can even do, even if we wanted to, to change that.
- 59:23Well, apart from, obviously, this area will evolve.
- 59:29If you go 30 years into the future.
- 59:30Right, but nobody's going to force them to sell, right?
- 59:32So you might say the temptation to sell will go up exponentially because now they can get
- 59:37a million dollars for their half acre lot, whereas 20 years ago it was worth nothing.
- 59:41Let's just say, right?
- 59:43Gerrymandering or whatever.
- 59:44If they sell, it's their choice, right?
- 59:47Now they have a million dollars with which to build somewhere else if they want to.
- 59:51If they don't want to, they don't have to.
- 59:54I suppose the reason I ask is, for example, I live on a remote farm.
- 59:59And if someone came to a neighboring field and said we're going to build tower blocks here, I wouldn't want that.
- 1:00:07And I appreciate there's nothing I can do about it really except move.
- 1:00:11I can complain, but I also know that some battles are worth fighting.
- 1:00:15and sometimes you know it's just bad luck that you've entered this situation um you might need
- 1:00:22to find the the upside the upside might be you wait a few years and then your property's worth
- 1:00:26a lot of money like you mentioned there um but i'm that's the part that i always get stuck at is
- 1:00:32somebody in crawfish who's a i don't know a 65 year old woman who enjoys sitting on the harbor
- 1:00:39every evening and doesn't want loads of big buildings next to her but like i say i've made
- 1:00:45my piece with it i just was interested to hear what your position was because my piece is look
- 1:00:50life is like that sometimes like no one's no one people are trying to work within the law trying to
- 1:00:57work within you know they're competing interests even within an individual right i started by saying
- 1:01:04they're legitimate institutions that help adjudicate where the boundaries of property
- 1:01:08rights are at because you can write them black and white but in reality they're going to be fuzzy
- 1:01:12but even with an individual they're competing interests you know that 65 year old lady might
- 1:01:17have kids and grandkids and i bet you that part of what she wants is for them to live a more
- 1:01:22prosperous life as well or at least have more opportunities than maybe she had whether they
- 1:01:26pursue them or not to have the option and so you know you have the trade-off of being able to look
- 1:01:31at 360 degrees and see nothing but grass or trees versus only being able to do it at 180 degrees
- 1:01:39because if you look back, you start to see some buildings,
- 1:01:42but have ocean views.
- 1:01:44With the added benefit of maybe her kids and her grandkids
- 1:01:48are going to have more options and more freedoms as a result,
- 1:01:52whether they choose to live there or not.
- 1:01:54And so it's fuzzy.
- 1:01:56It is at least the way, let's say, in a very personal way, right?
- 1:02:02Because I recognize the challenge.
- 1:02:07and also it's kind of against my own principles and values to impose things
- 1:02:13upon others you know that's kind of what I believe so how do I live with it you
- 1:02:18know I live with it by saying well look are you are you fundamentally doing
- 1:02:21something good not by my standards but in general standards do the vast
- 1:02:26majority of people that have some stake in it
- 1:02:30formally or otherwise, do they support it?
- 1:02:33And then are you willing to be flexible
- 1:02:35so that within reason,
- 1:02:37if you're gonna get from A to B,
- 1:02:38sometimes there's a more optimal way to get there
- 1:02:41that is not a straight line
- 1:02:42if you wanna take into consideration
- 1:02:44the opinions and desires of others.
- 1:02:46And so if you're willing to be a bit flexible,
- 1:02:48and we are,
- 1:02:49then I think you check all the boxes
- 1:02:51of both doing something fundamentally good
- 1:02:53and in a manner that respects the integrity
- 1:02:57of legitimate concerns of others.
- 1:02:59And I don't know that you can do much better than that, because I think the alternative
- 1:03:02is what nothing ever changes.
- 1:03:05There's no development, no growth, no improvement.
- 1:03:07And, you know, if we were already in a context where there is a lot of individual liberty
- 1:03:13and prosperity, it would be one thing, but we're not, right?
- 1:03:16I mean, we're not in that context.
- 1:03:17And I think, well, there's a tremendous amount of need and upside.
- 1:03:22And so something has to change.
- 1:03:24and change is not often, not always welcomed,
- 1:03:27but there's ways to drive change.
- 1:03:29As I mentioned, that you can tick some boxes
- 1:03:31and then it's more than ethical.
- 1:03:34I think it's desirable.
- 1:03:37I think that is actually the conclusion I came to was,
- 1:03:41there is, it's a case of, you know,
- 1:03:44is it, I'm not going to, the greater good's the wrong word.
- 1:03:47It's, am I doing my best?
- 1:03:50And am I thinking of everyone possible?
- 1:03:53and other than that there is no utopian way of doing there's no there's no perfect way to do it
- 1:03:59so i would assume internally we have sort of a win all we have several paradigms but one is try
- 1:04:05to do things that are win all approaches right where where we win where the direct counterparty
- 1:04:11wins and where reasonable third parties that we can think of and have some stake in it even though
- 1:04:17they're not on the negotiating table they also win and i think you know if you if you if you use
- 1:04:22that as a guiding principle more often than not you're going to end up on the right side the problem
- 1:04:26the problem is and this is where i see it all the time is that when you if someone wants to take a
- 1:04:31dig at prospera especially in the media in the western media it's such an easy one and it's very
- 1:04:37hard to communicate a a sort of a feel-good way of saying what you've just said because basically
- 1:04:47at the end of the day that the answer to that question is we do our best but sometimes you can't
- 1:04:52please everyone but that that that that seems to back up the the the the kind of cries of ngos
- 1:04:59saying well people are getting disenfranchised you know and it's very hard to communicate that
- 1:05:03i i don't think that you can um prevent that narrative but what you can do is amplify the
- 1:05:13good things that are being done. And I think most people can then judge and say, well, okay,
- 1:05:19some people claim less than ideal conditions, but look at all these optimal things and positive
- 1:05:24things that are being done. And now, to be honest, I always resisted that, you know, sort of
- 1:05:32public PR, do good things to appear good. I've always felt there was something disingenuous in it.
- 1:05:39but I must admit
- 1:05:42I obviously see the utility in it
- 1:05:45and I guess the way I'm coming to terms with it is
- 1:05:50it's not that you fake doing good things
- 1:05:53just for the PR value
- 1:05:55though that works in the short term
- 1:05:57and a lot of companies, a lot of groups
- 1:05:59do just that and sort of they win the PR battle
- 1:06:03but if you understand
- 1:06:07that there is a value for value exchange
- 1:06:09in a politic where public opinion matters, and you do believe that you can do better by fronting
- 1:06:16some of these, say, social efforts that eventually were going to be addressed, but that you can
- 1:06:22accelerate, and you do it in the context of value for value, that it's perfectly fine. In fact,
- 1:06:28it might be the necessary thing to be more public about it. And that is something where we have
- 1:06:32miserably failed from the beginning. But I think more and more, and maybe if you follow
- 1:06:38our social media and our own, what we make public, we're trying to shine more light on
- 1:06:44the things that are happening anyways, that are good and people would generally recognize as
- 1:06:48positive, and maybe being more proactive about contributing in some areas of, let's call it,
- 1:06:55for lack of a better word, social needs, where we can contribute in a manner that
- 1:06:59has a positive return for the project, both financially, morally, and from a public opinion
- 1:07:07perspective yeah something else something else i was um thinking about this morning and ended up
- 1:07:15talking with um oliver about was the fact that most recently i've been thinking not about
- 1:07:24the failures of these projects and the pitfalls of them failing but but more the pitfalls of them
- 1:07:31succeeding and i mean this goes back to well because a lot of people don't think about it a
- 1:07:36A lot of people spend their When you fighting a battle you know which is basically the story of prosper is a is also a fight of recognition of being allowed to exist of all these kind of things you focus on
- 1:07:49the win or you focus on the smaller wins but you never think about the success and actually the
- 1:07:55success of a project like this is going to be a massive it's going to be a huge undertaking because
- 1:08:01is prosper going to survive as in the prosper that you know the prosper your vision of prosper say is
- 1:08:08xyz right when there's a hundred thousand people living here and there's a lot more input from
- 1:08:14you think all these people with all their ideas and all what you know does that's the more
- 1:08:21interesting thing i think is to wonder does it survive that does prosper survive that what does
- 1:08:27it become at that point well it's worthwhile maybe introducing a distinction of what prosper is and
- 1:08:33isn't the way you're describing it sounds very much like a singular place and location right like
- 1:08:39a city right like a city that i meant i meant actually i was i meant the the i well i know
- 1:08:44ideology is the wrong word i meant the reason that prosper exists so the reason it exists is because
- 1:08:50you know maybe it goes back to what we were saying what we're talking about at the start that really
- 1:08:55All this is, is a project which makes a better place to live than over there.
- 1:09:00I went to Babson College and everybody there studies entrepreneurship.
- 1:09:04But I focused my major in development economics.
- 1:09:08For me, Prosper is just an economic development project.
- 1:09:10It's a tool by which to lift people up and accelerate wealth creation.
- 1:09:16That's all it is.
- 1:09:16I mean, we can go at length about philosophy and tactics.
- 1:09:20But when it's all said and done, it's an economic development tool and strategy.
- 1:09:25And that happens all over the world all the time with various degrees of success or failure
- 1:09:31and obviously costs.
- 1:09:33And generally, it's a niche that has been controlled largely by multilaterals and governments
- 1:09:38and charities.
- 1:09:40And as a result, often when they are really involved, there's negative externalities of
- 1:09:45destroying market forces and creating dependencies.
- 1:09:47I mean, look at Poverty Inc. and Africa and many terrible examples in Latin America as well.
- 1:09:54But fundamentally, what you're trying to do is to create conditions for countries and for people to do better over time.
- 1:10:04And it's not just an altruistic thing.
- 1:10:06And I think maybe that is our core innovation, okay, which ultimately helping people reach their potential sounds very altruistic.
- 1:10:16And indeed, when you have no way to internalize the positive externality of doing that, all
- 1:10:24you have is altruism.
- 1:10:26But what if you could invent a business model where you are able to internalize the positive
- 1:10:34externality of creating generalized prosperity?
- 1:10:38And that's fundamentally what we're doing.
- 1:10:40Because if you crack that nut, then the best dynamics of self-interest, the profit motive, get activated to do something that is truly, let's say, the well-being of a common population, not just of a particularized customer.
- 1:10:58Yes, I mean, you ultimately transact on a customer-by-customer basis, right?
- 1:11:03But the nature of governance services is that the positive externality tends to exceed,
- 1:11:10over time, the transactional value.
- 1:11:13So the problem has been that we haven't had a business model that can monetize that aggregation
- 1:11:19of positive externality.
- 1:11:20So therefore, you end up with, say, public and for politics institutions as opposed to
- 1:11:25private and for-profit institutions offering the service of governance. So what happens when we
- 1:11:30succeed? Well, hell, I think we would have demonstrated a better way to drive economic
- 1:11:34development that is not so controversial when it's all said and done. It's a public-private
- 1:11:39partnership, and it's not at the expense of some of the fundamental, let's say, institutions at the
- 1:11:46level at which they remain legitimate, at least in my book, for, let's say, nation-state to exist,
- 1:11:51but enabling a partnership for the other area you know going back to the stack of all the layers of
- 1:11:57what governance is where it makes perfect sense to partner with a private provider would the um
- 1:12:03it it's go 50 years in the future what would be the thing that you would most like to survive
- 1:12:09that 50 years would it be the contract would it you know like what would what would set what would
- 1:12:14set prosper apart in 50 years time when it's a thriving metropolis say or whatever i mean maybe
- 1:12:20Maybe I'll answer a different question, and hopefully in less than 50 years, but certainly
- 1:12:25by 50 years from now.
- 1:12:28A telltale sign that what we're after has succeeded will be something along the lines
- 1:12:35where in the future when governments, from time to time, governments will recognize that
- 1:12:41a new city is required, right?
- 1:12:43Or that there's an urban development need.
- 1:12:46And that just as sometimes they do RFPs for say public private partnership for an airport or a bridge or a road the first RFP they going to do is for governance services They going to say look our urbanization is one where we want to catalyze new developments
- 1:13:05And instead of defaulting to some public and political institution figuring it out,
- 1:13:11they're going to do an RFP and they're going to designate a general area and companies
- 1:13:17like Prospera or Bechtel or Jacobs, and then many others that we can't imagine right now,
- 1:13:22will submit bids to say, well, here's how we propose to set up the governance layer of that
- 1:13:29future city project. And here is beyond governance what we're prepared to do. And that could include
- 1:13:35infrastructure investments. It could include real estate development projects that catalyze
- 1:13:40sort of a minimally viable ecosystem of activity. When that happens, we'll know that the paradigm
- 1:13:46has shifted. And with that shift in paradigm, the acceleration in prosperity is unimaginable,
- 1:13:52because right now that is the fundamental thing that's holding back prosperity across the world.
- 1:13:58And I don't mean just from, oh, let's lift poor people up. I mean limiting cutting edge innovation,
- 1:14:04right? It is governance in the end that is the biggest limiting factor and can be, and often is,
- 1:14:10like in the US and in other places, often is net-net and accelerant to human prosperity.
- 1:14:16So how do you get the best of governance by getting the best of the public and the private sector to work together?
- 1:14:24I think the paradigm looks something like that.
- 1:14:27Is there something that you would consider was a symbol of failure in the future as well?
- 1:14:34Something quite, you know, I mean, how would you decide, okay, this isn't working?
- 1:14:40This isn't working?
- 1:14:41Yeah.
- 1:14:43Well, I mean, if I and a critical group of people just give up,
- 1:14:49I think there's no failure until you give up.
- 1:14:51I mean, you can crash a whole bunch of rockets, a la SpaceX,
- 1:14:55and as long as you stay with it
- 1:14:56and eventually figure out how to land the damn thing,
- 1:15:00you will eventually succeed.
- 1:15:01There's no doubt in my mind that the model is the way of the future.
- 1:15:05The exact contours of where the boundaries are,
- 1:15:08I think those are being drawn.
- 1:15:10more so than by just hypothesizing around it, by people trying it.
- 1:15:15And if they're good faith actors, I think eventually they'll understand where the boundaries are and how to optimize.
- 1:15:21And there's not going to be a one size fits all model.
- 1:15:24The key is to change the paradigm, right?
- 1:15:26That governance can be provided as a service in partnership between governments and the private sector.
- 1:15:32That is the key.
- 1:15:34How much of the governance stack is done in that partnership?
- 1:15:38I think we have yet to define exactly where optimal is.
- 1:15:43We know what is too controversial to be viable, right?
- 1:15:46When anybody thinks it's the full stack, it's certainly not viable right now.
- 1:15:51And I don't know that it will be in the next, say, 100 years.
- 1:15:54I don't know beyond that, but it probably is irrelevant for my lifetime.
- 1:15:57But certainly the boundary can evolve in the next few decades.
- 1:16:01but somewhere there's a boundary
- 1:16:04and that above that, it's perfectly reasonable.
- 1:16:08In fact, it would be stupid of a government
- 1:16:10not to pursue it through a public-private partnership.
- 1:16:13That's the key.
- 1:16:13Just like with the four-minute mile,
- 1:16:15goes from impossible to done for the first time
- 1:16:19to now a bunch of people do it
- 1:16:20to now it's the minimum standard.
- 1:16:23Like if you can't do that,
- 1:16:24you're not even worth being a contender.
- 1:16:27So right now, governments are facing a lot of hardship,
- 1:16:31research constraints, capability constraints. There is a growing human population. There is an
- 1:16:38increasing need for good governance. And the way we're doing it has substantial limitations.
- 1:16:44As we prove a far better way to do it, I think in the next 10 to 20 years, I don't think it'll
- 1:16:50take much longer, we'll go to a click where obviously if you're not doing this, you're not
- 1:16:55trying hard enough. Another thing me and Oliver spoke about this morning was that
- 1:17:00when you look at the major projects,
- 1:17:03and I'm including his project in Georgia back in the day,
- 1:17:08all of them have someone who's quite obsessive about the project and does it.
- 1:17:16And I think it's fair to say in Prospero, you're that person.
- 1:17:19And I know there are plenty of other people that have done all kinds of stuff.
- 1:17:23Right, right, there are.
- 1:17:24But the truth is, if you really were brutally honest, you're that guy.
- 1:17:30in this project.
- 1:17:31What I wonder, and I asked Oliver this,
- 1:17:33I said, if Eric left, would the project fail?
- 1:17:38I won't tell you what he said, but what do you think?
- 1:17:41It depends when.
- 1:17:43I would like to believe that there's enough people
- 1:17:46at the ready to substitute whatever value
- 1:17:48I bring to the project.
- 1:17:49But I think as with a lot of ventures in an early stage,
- 1:17:54if the founder is not there, it could fall apart.
- 1:17:58So I think we still have let say a high level of key man risk in technical terms And I not super happy about it but it won always be that way And I don think it will take much longer for that risk to be neutralized at least as it relates to a particular location
- 1:18:16How much of your role do you feel comfortable relinquishing?
- 1:18:22Or do you think it's important to be that obsessive founder guy until the day you drop?
- 1:18:28No, I hope not.
- 1:18:30And I think I will always be involved in some dimensions,
- 1:18:34but there's a big difference between being involved
- 1:18:37because you want to versus the project needing it, right?
- 1:18:40And maybe you're better than most in some dimensions,
- 1:18:42but the existential, the viability of a project
- 1:18:47needs to go beyond depending on its founder
- 1:18:50when it makes sense.
- 1:18:51And that's a very fuzzy concept.
- 1:18:53I can't say I've been the best delegator in every dimension, but I do think that it's maybe out of necessity or maybe out of higher pain tolerance.
- 1:19:09There are certain aspects of what this venture requires that quite clearly have benefited or needed my direct intervention.
- 1:19:18And it is not, say, running a hotel or even doing master planning, and that's a big spectrum of very operational to very much high-level planning.
- 1:19:29I don't think I – I know I'm not and probably never will be, say, world-class at any of that stuff.
- 1:19:34But there's a dimension at the frontier of trying to solve the fundamental necessity of making this and projects like this work, which is in the statecraft department, which is in the figuring out in the politic as it largely exists in the world today.
- 1:19:52How do you fit this into that?
- 1:19:56And it's messy.
- 1:19:57And I couldn't tell you right now that we've figured it out.
- 1:20:02I can tell you that we're on our way and I know more than I imagined even existed in fields of knowledge now than I did 10 years ago.
- 1:20:13And frankly, I think the industry is very early in even like most people don't know what they don't know in this domain.
- 1:20:21And so I'm not worried for, say, job security when it comes to what this project will need and that I can contribute more than my interest, like what I can contribute to the project.
- 1:20:35And let's call it a movement of people that actually want to make the world a better place, both for individuals at stake and then for the broader human race.
- 1:20:46um yeah i'm i'm not sure i was alluding to the fact that you might lose your job
- 1:20:54more to the fact that going back to what i was saying about the six the the the thing to think
- 1:21:00about is when prosperous succeeds not when it fails because when it's and i i feel like i mean
- 1:21:06i've been following it a few years and i've spoken to a lot of people i what i see now is
- 1:21:10the nature of it is it's a rather decentralized blob of of things happening but it's driven
- 1:21:18by an individual as well and which is obviously very important but that means that the decentralized
- 1:21:25nature often has to get no you can't yes you can no you can't yes you can what's important
- 1:21:32apparently i mean and this is well apparently because we don't really know is that someone
- 1:21:38needs to be quite resolute about where the thing is going.
- 1:21:43And I would say that's normally when I'm having conversation, people refer to you.
- 1:21:49Look, I think in some ways, this is not that different than a venture, a startup venture
- 1:21:56of sorts.
- 1:21:57And in the relationship between the founder or the founder team and the venture throughout
- 1:22:02its history, even when it goes well past startup stage, in some cases, for some reason, I can't
- 1:22:08say I've mapped out exactly why in some cases, you know, the founder is no longer involved,
- 1:22:13doesn't need to, and the company thrives very well. Let's say Apple, for example, and Apple
- 1:22:18for the longest time was very dependent on Steve and he left and the thing crashed and he came back
- 1:22:23and, you know, it started growing. But it seems like at least for a while he was able to leave
- 1:22:29behind to Tim and now the new CEO. But other companies, you know, still are very strongly
- 1:22:35founder-led, whether it's Oracle or Meta or Google or whatever. What is it they call themselves?
- 1:22:42Meta. I don't know.
- 1:22:44Alphabet. They have a very strong founder personality involved. And I guess there's no
- 1:22:55formula that has proven itself to always be right under all circumstances. In some cases,
- 1:22:59you need a strong founder that stays for a long time. In others, they start, they exit,
- 1:23:05and they go and do other things.
- 1:23:06And I'm not sure what it will look like
- 1:23:08in the case of Prospera,
- 1:23:11other than I hope that the model gets replicated
- 1:23:13and that regardless of,
- 1:23:17let's say in a success case for Prospera
- 1:23:19what that means for the role of the founder,
- 1:23:23that there are multiple successful projects around the world.
- 1:23:26It strikes me as a hard thing to move on from.
- 1:23:29It's not like you build a new model of governance
- 1:23:32and then sell it and move on.
- 1:23:34It's like you're kind of married to the idea
- 1:23:38of a new model of governance, right?
- 1:23:39You would have thought.
- 1:23:41What does Prospero now, as we sit here now,
- 1:23:44is this what you expected it to look like when you go back?
- 1:23:48at this point forget what you think it's going to be i mean i i i was hoping to be much further
- 1:23:56along by now probably 10 times further along uh in a certain dimension the one that is easy to
- 1:24:04envision when you think of building a city scale project because you're seeing buildings and people
- 1:24:09and that but there's another dimension that i didn't even consider fully in the beginning or
- 1:24:15or I did, but at a very superficial level.
- 1:24:18And in that dimension, I've seen tremendous amount of progress,
- 1:24:23you know, statecraft and just kind of understanding the world.
- 1:24:25I'm not even saying solving it,
- 1:24:27just knowing that there are walls and boundaries
- 1:24:30and then trying to make sense of it.
- 1:24:32But no, I would say that we're much further away
- 1:24:37from where I was hoping to be now,
- 1:24:40seven years into the project since we started building this building,
- 1:24:43actually, in May 2020.
- 1:24:45Directionally, yes, a lot of what we have here was one way or another part of the vision.
- 1:24:53The specifics, as in which industry in particular has found a higher value niche here, I could have told you from the beginning.
- 1:25:03Sure, like healthcare, right?
- 1:25:05Because such a highly regulated industry, it follows that if you have more optimal regulations, that you have arbitrage value for all involved.
- 1:25:14and so clearly that's proven to be true.
- 1:25:19Did I know that Brian Johnson was going to do gene theft?
- 1:25:21No.
- 1:25:23Maybe that was relevant for a period of time
- 1:25:25and it won't be the thing that matters five years from now.
- 1:25:28What do you think will matter five years from now?
- 1:25:33That we don't get stuck in just a niche
- 1:25:39and that it isn't simply about accelerating those
- 1:25:46that are already at the frontier of innovation and wealth creation.
- 1:25:50What will matter is that we prove that you can have a diversified economic hub,
- 1:25:59for lack of a better term, where there is direct participation
- 1:26:03from both local and foreign, sophisticated and basic,
- 1:26:09you know, cutting edge and traditional industries.
- 1:26:14Because in the end, the idea of having, say,
- 1:26:20industry-specific industrial parks, that has been done before.
- 1:26:23And undoubtedly, if you pick a niche and give it some key advantages,
- 1:26:29it will make a huge difference.
- 1:26:31enough to be a prosperous niche of something.
- 1:26:35What hasn't been proven quite yet
- 1:26:38is that you can be horizontally diversified
- 1:26:42and that if you focus on just some core basic governance services,
- 1:26:47you will have multiple niches
- 1:26:48and you will have a rather broad spectrum of people benefiting.
- 1:26:55And I think ultimately a project of this nature
- 1:26:58needs a social license to operate, regardless of what the contracts say.
- 1:27:04And in a democracy, that license to operate comes from the population
- 1:27:09realizing that they, as a constituency, stand to benefit.
- 1:27:16It's fine, and I think it's welcomed for non-nationals to participate.
- 1:27:21I mean, it's fantastic.
- 1:27:23And over time, people become part of the local community, right?
- 1:27:27And it takes some time.
- 1:27:28You can even become a national if you want, like in the United States, a melting pot, and you become an African-American or Indian-American or Italian-American.
- 1:27:36There's always the American part.
- 1:27:38I think in projects like this, you'll have a similar dynamic.
- 1:27:41But it's absolutely critical to ensure that it is in alignment with the political currency that sustains the political system upon which you are going to be dependent upon unless you want to take a different route of, say, wars or civil disorders.
- 1:28:01And that's definitely not what Prosper is about.
- 1:28:03and as far as the grand plan goes I I mean correct me if I'm wrong it involves obviously
- 1:28:13Prospera here at this part expanding the physical part the mainland part
- 1:28:18them becoming very much connected and what what about the wider world implications of Prospera
- 1:28:26the platform the place the governance model I know that I haven spoken about that for a while but that was always part of the plan was to have a network of Prospera
- 1:28:41Are those all still things that are a part of the big plan?
- 1:28:45Yes, not necessarily through Honduras, Prospera, Inc.,
- 1:28:49but in terms of a vision, for sure, absolutely.
- 1:28:52And there is such a thing as a Prosper International that it's at various stages of conversations and explorations and prospecting elsewhere around the world.
- 1:29:04And, you know, just as if I were to ask, where does it make sense to catalyze more economic development?
- 1:29:12Everywhere, right?
- 1:29:13it follows that if the key for more prosperity is better governance, then better governance has a
- 1:29:21place to go everywhere. Whether it's catch-up growth or pushing the frontier of innovation,
- 1:29:27in almost all cases, governance has either a limiting or enabling role to play.
- 1:29:33It's interesting though, because when you describe it like that, it just seems like
- 1:29:37another business model, another plan. But actually, I mean, Prosper is kind of, for many people,
- 1:29:42especially because we're here just before the free cities conference there's people coming to
- 1:29:47prosper it's like some mythical place you know that because people because of the ideas behind it
- 1:29:54they're very they're they're things that people think about long and hard and have been debated
- 1:30:01and and thought over and and now this physical manifestation exists it is like i think it's
- 1:30:08underselling it to say it's basically just a place where you create a better place than over there and then people come and everyone's happy kind of thing you know really but think about it it isn't but like there are i mean let's that might be unfair in the following way
- 1:30:24every entrepreneur that is pouring their guts at the creation that they have chosen and that
- 1:30:34they're passionate about for them that's almost like a religious act it's a sacred process of
- 1:30:40creation and anything that is done at that level of profound commitment is very very special and
- 1:30:49it's also a business. Like one thing doesn't mean it's not the other. You know, like the SpaceX
- 1:30:56example, I mean, wow, going to Mars and, you know, innovating in private space industry.
- 1:31:03It is potentially transformational for humankind, you know, extending human consciousness into the
- 1:31:12galaxies. I mean, amazing. And then at the end of the day, you're building rockets, you're putting
- 1:31:17satellites up there. You got to charge somebody so you can pay your cost. They're not one or the
- 1:31:23other. It's perfectly fine to do both. In fact, it is ideal that you have both, right? A sort of
- 1:31:28traditional, normal business model that you can have sustainability and profit. And yet that when
- 1:31:37it's all said and done, the consequence of what you're doing can be transformative. I think that's
- 1:31:42sweet spot. Otherwise, you're kind of in the think tank, la la la world, or you're just in a
- 1:31:47widgets business that doesn't mean anything to you and will improve the lives of some,
- 1:31:52but maybe it doesn't have transformational value. The funny thing is, I'm doing a talk at this
- 1:31:58event coming up, and I decided to see whether there was a difference between what I spoke about
- 1:32:04a year ago and what I spoke about in the last year. And obviously, I used AI to analyze every
- 1:32:10transcript and stuff and you know what it spat out it's so funny it said and i won't be giving
- 1:32:16away the talk but i'm going to mention it in the talk but it said a year ago you were talking about
- 1:32:21um the ideas behind free cities this is a very compact version of it it said it much better than
- 1:32:28i'm saying it and it said this year you've been talking about why can't we get good coffee why
- 1:32:33are there roosters here why are there you know like and and and i i i know it's a bit of a sort
- 1:32:39of generalization but it is true it is true I think 2026 has become the year that certainly for
- 1:32:46me as an outsider I know if someone like yourself has been following you've been dealing with this
- 1:32:50stuff for years but for me there are a number of projects not just Prospera but other ones which
- 1:32:56are now dealing with the on the ground boring things about creating these places and and and
- 1:33:032026 yeah I mean I think it will probably be remembered as potentially a turning point for
- 1:33:09many projects. I know from my experience, because I have data from my experience of speaking to
- 1:33:14people, is that it was all theory and now it's nearly all practical. Hardly ever have a theoretical
- 1:33:20conversation. That could be a factor of my own journey in this space as well, obviously. But I'm
- 1:33:27not going to frame it like that because I think it's quite interesting. What do you think? Am I
- 1:33:30drawing too many conclusions? I think directionally you're 100% right. I still perceive the industry,
- 1:33:37if we can call it that to be at a super nascent stage And I have stopped spending as much time as I used to say 10 years ago seven years ago at kind of surveying the world of projects
- 1:33:53So I don't think I'm up to the latest on every project.
- 1:33:57But I think there are still very, very, very few projects that are actually dealing
- 1:34:01with the uniquely differentiated layers of what it means to build what we're building,
- 1:34:09which is in the governance layer.
- 1:34:11Like building cities is a known craft.
- 1:34:14And, you know, cities are built all the time, you could say, or districts.
- 1:34:18I mean, and there are companies that are super great at that.
- 1:34:21And you can do better and you can call them smart or whatever.
- 1:34:24But like the building, the physical space, I think that has been innovated upon.
- 1:34:29And as always, there's the room to grow.
- 1:34:32But figuring out the statecraft dimension of this,
- 1:34:36How do you inject inside of pre-existing political systems this new idea that could easily be seen as disruptive and not in the interest of those that control the levers?
- 1:34:51That is where the creation of this space has to continue happening.
- 1:34:57It's happening, and perhaps out of ignorance, I'm not familiar with many projects that are really contending with that, for better or worse.
- 1:35:06but they're closer than ever, and there are some that are,
- 1:35:10and so that is transformative compared to five years ago.
- 1:35:16I would just, and by the way, operationally,
- 1:35:20it's easy to make the mistake which we have made
- 1:35:22to say, well, the special part of it is governance,
- 1:35:25so everything else would solve itself,
- 1:35:27and then where's the coffee, and Internet's not great,
- 1:35:30and so the boring stuff has to get done,
- 1:35:33and it's easy to neglect it when you're at the frontier of what I just described.
- 1:35:38So in our case, we've had to say, okay, we do need to actually focus on operational excellence
- 1:35:43in a traditional sense.
- 1:35:45And there are ways to do that and challenges because the best in the world at doing that
- 1:35:50are not as compatible with a frontier jurisdiction that is under political threat.
- 1:35:55And they don't want to mess with it, right?
- 1:35:56They'll go to where they feel it's stable, right?
- 1:36:00and their job is real estate development
- 1:36:02and they'll get their 25% RR no matter what.
- 1:36:05And so it's a bit of a challenge to get world-class
- 1:36:07in an unstable or perceived to be
- 1:36:10unstable political environment.
- 1:36:11And thus it follows that you kind of have to fill the gaps.
- 1:36:14But I think those are growing pains.
- 1:36:16Do you think you're finding the right people
- 1:36:18that you personally at Prospera?
- 1:36:21Look, I think we have had some of the best
- 1:36:24and brightest in the world that are deep into this space.
- 1:36:29and some of them come and go because it's tough.
- 1:36:34It's, you know, it's not pretty when you go under the hood
- 1:36:41and deal with just whatever basics, energy, water, coffees, etc., you know,
- 1:36:47and day in and day out dealing with just the crap and the inefficiencies
- 1:36:52and, you know, misaligned cultures and attacks, like, you know,
- 1:36:55fill in the blank of all the issues that come inherent in a place that has a lot of room to go
- 1:37:07when it comes to having generalized prosperity. I mean, it's that way for a reason, right? And
- 1:37:11it's mutually reinforcing that you get an outcome because of some inputs and then the inputs,
- 1:37:18it's just like a cycle, right? So we're trying to break that. But in the meantime,
- 1:37:21you are dealing with a lot of that nonsense.
- 1:37:24And some of the brightest, especially now with AI,
- 1:37:26I think our biggest competition for talent
- 1:37:28is just AI in general right now,
- 1:37:30where you can go and build amazing things,
- 1:37:32make a gazillion dollars relatively short-term,
- 1:37:35or at least that's what people think.
- 1:37:37So yeah, we've had some of the best,
- 1:37:39but we still have a lot of room to grow
- 1:37:42and developing a well-rounded team,
- 1:37:45I think it's always gonna be a challenge
- 1:37:47for something as undefined as this has been
- 1:37:52in terms of where the key success factors are.
- 1:37:55With regards to this physical Prosper location itself,
- 1:38:00long-term, are you aiming for...
- 1:38:02Who are you aiming for to come and sort of use this as their frontier?
- 1:38:08I mean, physically, people.
- 1:38:10There's a big debate.
- 1:38:12It's not even really a debate,
- 1:38:13but there are differing opinions on who you should attract to your city.
- 1:38:17There's people who say, look, we're creating a place which will be better than over there.
- 1:38:23So we want everyone to come, locals.
- 1:38:26And then there are people, and Prospero kind of, I used to think it fell into this mold.
- 1:38:30It was more like, OK, we're trying to attract, we're using our regulatory powers here to try and attract, not necessarily local Hondurans, because they're just not necessarily involved in this kind of businesses, but people who see this as a frontier.
- 1:38:44Yeah. And who, I mean, my, personally, me in the end,
- 1:38:49I ended up realizing, well, just invite everyone, mate.
- 1:38:51Really just really invite everyone But I mean I don even know whether Prosperer has been down that route yourself But what is the current sort of thinking So for attendees of the conference
- 1:39:06they will be the first, say, conference that when they drive into our project,
- 1:39:12we'll see St. John's Bay at the entrance.
- 1:39:15And that is a brand that we have conceptualized for years now
- 1:39:20and only recently said, okay, we're launching it.
- 1:39:24Because this location is built on the Prosper platform,
- 1:39:29but the location is not Prosper per se.
- 1:39:33And when you have a multi-hub vision
- 1:39:35and you want to actually compete
- 1:39:38and be great at serving some target market,
- 1:39:41yeah, you have to focus, like, what's the target market, right?
- 1:39:43And people go to places based on what they're looking for
- 1:39:46and companies, right?
- 1:39:48So we've launched St. John's Bay, and St. John's Bay is focusing primarily on young families where at least one of the adults is an entrepreneurial leader and therefore have commonality of interest with others around them and can appreciate and benefit from the ease of doing business that no matter what, Prosper is all about.
- 1:40:11Does it mean that that's all we're after?
- 1:40:12Of course not.
- 1:40:13in that definition you have all sorts of applications of being an entrepreneurial leader
- 1:40:18you can be at the cutting edge of some technology like biotech or you can just you know have a scuba
- 1:40:23shop and that's what you love to do and you know it's a business and you do it successfully
- 1:40:27but you know what people at both extremes are creators they have to deal with payroll
- 1:40:34they have to deal with uncertainty you know they celebrate far not not not far enough right and
- 1:40:42you're in the builder's mode.
- 1:40:43And so we want to build a community that is cohesive.
- 1:40:46And I think that's the commonality.
- 1:40:47And then the family element is, you know,
- 1:40:50there's just something that happens to your brain
- 1:40:52once you have an offspring and you're thinking, you know,
- 1:40:55in multiple generation sense.
- 1:40:58And again, it doesn't mean that we won't serve young people,
- 1:41:01not married, of course not.
- 1:41:03I mean, but when we think at least on the eastern side of the development,
- 1:41:07what had historically been known as a pristine bay,
- 1:41:10the resort. We want to make sure we have parks and we have a great school of the best on the
- 1:41:16island. And I think over time, it would just be a fantastic school internationally. And so we'll
- 1:41:21build a community around that. Now, why? Well, I know that jobs are not created by government,
- 1:41:31and they're also not created by simply having good rules on a piece of paper. Jobs are created
- 1:41:37by entrepreneurs and businessmen and women that set up enterprises and have to employ people.
- 1:41:42So if Prospera wants to demonstrate that when you do certain things right, you drive generalized
- 1:41:50prosperity, and for lack of better terms, prosperity still comes largely attached to productive work,
- 1:41:57i.e. jobs, then it follows that, yes, you create the platform, but then you got to bring the job
- 1:42:02creators, for them to do factories or R&D centers or scuba shops. It doesn't matter.
- 1:42:09And so the math works right. And what we achieve is, say, for every entrepreneur, there's 10 local
- 1:42:17hires. First, we're in balance with the legal commitments we've made to Honduras, that at least
- 1:42:2390% of the labor force is Honduran. But it's kind of a nice ratio. I mean, some will be
- 1:42:28solopreneurs and that's fine and others will hire hundreds or thousands of people but if on average
- 1:42:33especially in the early stages we can optimize for that type of lifestyle i think this is going
- 1:42:39to be a wonderful place to live and i live here and and i think i'm part of the target market like
- 1:42:43i have a young family i'm an entrepreneur and i love sharing with others that have similar
- 1:42:50experiences right that care about how their kids are going to be raised the values and the principles
- 1:42:55that we're injecting into their beautiful little brains,
- 1:42:57the fun that we want them to have.
- 1:42:59And we also have stress and running the thing
- 1:43:02we're trying to build.
- 1:43:03And that just creates for a wonderful community environment.
- 1:43:06So St. John's Bay, we'll be focusing on that.
- 1:43:08On the mainland, it's probably gonna be a lot more industrial
- 1:43:11and say low cost labor for lack of a better term.
- 1:43:17And there we have to cater to the people
- 1:43:19who some of which are gonna live here
- 1:43:21or at least spend part of their time here
- 1:43:23as they go visit their call centers or their factories
- 1:43:26or whatever it is that they have on the mainland
- 1:43:28where energy is cheaper, land is more plentiful,
- 1:43:31access to labor is easier.
- 1:43:34And so I think that's a nice combo in the short term.
- 1:43:36Where we physically are,
- 1:43:38the beta building inside of the beta district,
- 1:43:40this has emerged as more of a bohemian,
- 1:43:45cutting edge, younger crowd,
- 1:43:47biohacker culture, robotics.
- 1:43:51And I think that's beautiful.
- 1:43:52and what we'll probably end up doing is lean into that
- 1:43:55or at least let it continue to evolve in that general flavor.
- 1:44:01The integration between this and the other,
- 1:44:03I guess it's yet to be seen, right?
- 1:44:05We happen to be somewhat physically separated, you know,
- 1:44:09just because of how things have evolved.
- 1:44:12And I guess maybe these are separate.
- 1:44:15Like maybe St. John's Bay is the young family place
- 1:44:18and everything's optimized for that.
- 1:44:19And this is where the, you know, renegades, the pioneers,
- 1:44:24you know, the young and hungry come
- 1:44:27and they are going to figure it out one way or another.
- 1:44:30Cutting edge or otherwise, we'll see.
- 1:44:32But I think the St. John's Bay,
- 1:44:35I have very high conviction around
- 1:44:36because I can see how that is financially sustainable,
- 1:44:42profitable, and how it's always going to have value,
- 1:44:46even in the age of AI,
- 1:44:47perhaps even more so in the age of AI and robotics.
- 1:44:51Like being human, you know, means something
- 1:44:55and it's analog primarily.
- 1:44:56And, you know, it requires you to share with others
- 1:45:00that are going through similar experiences,
- 1:45:02not be interacting with agents or robots all the time.
- 1:45:05Last question.
- 1:45:06We've been talking a long time.
- 1:45:08Going in the future, do you envisage being involved more in Prospera, this place, this physical place or the wider Prospera idea, the worldwide one?
- 1:45:20I don't think there should be a tradeoff.
- 1:45:22You know, as St. John's Bay evolves, according to the vision I just described, I think it will be a fantastic place to live for somebody like me for the next 10 years easily.
- 1:45:32and from there there's no reason why i cannot engage in international business and efforts
- 1:45:39you still always need a home base and and i think uh on our in a success scenario this is going to
- 1:45:46be a fantastic very differentiated for the better location but the the prosper idea the franchisable
- 1:45:55one i'm not sure that's the right word but it is that is that the part of the very big picture
- 1:46:01Has that always been something to aim for, if you see what I mean?
- 1:46:05Therefore, that's kind of what's driving all these different stages.
- 1:46:09Yeah.
- 1:46:10So Honduras Prospera Inc.
- 1:46:12obviously is very focused on getting the Honduras Prospera effort off the ground and proven.
- 1:46:19Done well, it's replicatable.
- 1:46:22And, you know, call it IP or however you want.
- 1:46:24The thing that is not the physical location, you know, can be replicated elsewhere.
- 1:46:30So it's both.
- 1:46:32You got to prove it and perfect it nail it and then scale it I guess And that what we doing right now We very much focused on if we were SpaceX again we still wanting to make sure we
- 1:46:45can land the rocket, right?
- 1:46:48Until we figure that out, you know, like everybody else can launch rockets, but we're about landing
- 1:46:52it.
- 1:46:52And in this case, it's anybody can build a physical location, anybody can start on the
- 1:46:57political side, but can you survive and thrive and be better off as a result of the controversy?
- 1:47:03That's the stage we're in.
- 1:47:04And I think we are within striking distance of reaching it.
- 1:47:08And when we do, the acceleration of this hub will grow exponentially.
- 1:47:13And the capacity for the model to be replicated will also be substantially higher.
- 1:47:19Does it mean that it's not possible without it?
- 1:47:21No.
- 1:47:22But it's always better to build and prove in success.
- 1:47:26Eric, many thanks.
- 1:47:28I'm going to leave it there.
- 1:47:29I think that's a nice place to end.
- 1:47:31Thanks for spending some time.
- 1:47:32very informative
- 1:47:34I can't believe
- 1:47:35he's taken this long
- 1:47:36to actually
- 1:47:36end up speaking to you
- 1:47:38I seem to have
- 1:47:39spoken to everyone else
- 1:47:40even
- 1:47:41even
- 1:47:41Oliver now
- 1:47:43I didn't
- 1:47:44yeah
- 1:47:44you know
- 1:47:45like he's
- 1:47:46he's
- 1:47:46a real OG
- 1:47:47right
- 1:47:48yeah he sure is
- 1:47:49he's been
- 1:47:49an inspiration to me
- 1:47:51and I was always
- 1:47:52very honoured
- 1:47:52that he decided
- 1:47:54to join our team
- 1:47:54from the early days
- 1:47:55and his wisdom
- 1:47:57and experience
- 1:47:58has been
- 1:47:59very instrumental
- 1:48:00foundational actually
- 1:48:01for how we've set up some of the legal structures
- 1:48:05and the operational structures as well.
- 1:48:08Great. Well, thanks for stopping by
- 1:48:09and hopefully do it again in a few years' time.
- 1:48:13Let's give it a bit of time for some things to evolve.
- 1:48:17But I'm always a very keen observer of the Prospera project, so thanks.
- 1:48:20Thanks for the work you're doing.
- 1:48:21I like how you, at least in my opinion,
- 1:48:27have a fairly decent balance between kind of pushing on the boundaries
- 1:48:31of the cutting edge ideas and maybe even a little bit of the controversy
- 1:48:35while keeping it grounded on the reality of what this is about
- 1:48:38and the real challenges, not just the abstractions of it.
- 1:48:43So thank you for that.
- 1:48:44Well, not to babble on too much.
- 1:48:48I've been on a journey as well.
- 1:48:50And I would say that I came in as I didn't really know shit when I came in.
- 1:48:55Peter asked me to do it because I've got a media career.
- 1:48:58And I thought at the beginning, I'll do it because I enjoy talking to people.
- 1:49:03I must admit now I at that point where I pretty I wouldn say I obsessed with it but it very important And in fact it the I think the market of living together is probably the most important market to be involved in
- 1:49:18Because, you know, I come from the Bitcoin world and I feel like I'm not battling anymore.
- 1:49:25I was going back to what we were saying earlier about, you know, when you're having the fight, you're just looking for the win.
- 1:49:30I felt like that with Bitcoin for a long time.
- 1:49:33Now I, it's just, it's boring.
- 1:49:35It's life.
- 1:49:36It's normal life.
- 1:49:37I do it all the time.
- 1:49:38Yeah, there's some teething problems with it and this, that, and the other, but we've won.
- 1:49:43And I feel like the market of living together is a kind of very similar thing.
- 1:49:48It's just much more gray area.
- 1:49:51The digital realm is black and white, very easy to navigate.
- 1:49:56But here it's like never ending.
- 1:49:59And there are no answers.
- 1:50:01Like you say, there's no silver bullet for doing this.
- 1:50:04It's an ongoing process.
- 1:50:05Well, and the Bitcoin analogy is really good because I often say we are to governance what Bitcoin is to the financial services industry, right?
- 1:50:15Like you can't focus on trying to fix finance from within the existing institution.
- 1:50:21So you do something from the outside.
- 1:50:22And if you're smart, you make it somewhat compatible.
- 1:50:24The difference, however, is that where there's a challenge that Bitcoin is a technical solution to a political problem.
- 1:50:34What we're doing is a political solution to a political problem.
- 1:50:40And, you know, you live in the world of humans and it's not as easy to just say, write it and it will work.
- 1:50:48You know, you got to deal with interests and influences.
- 1:50:51And so it's a different challenge, maybe harder in some ways.
- 1:50:57But at the same time, human nature is such that when the paradigm clicks, as with the four-minute mile and so many other examples, it spreads.
- 1:51:08And that's what keeps me optimistic.
- 1:51:12Just in one second.
- 1:51:16I was just going to say I had one more question to ask you, which was.
- 1:51:19um what what did you just say at the end then that was really i had i had something really
- 1:51:24important paradigms once they click right yeah okay is the paradigm is the paradigm governance
- 1:51:31as a service yeah that the paradigm yeah you know governance as a service in public private partnerships right yeah so that that that good to hear yeah that what So that good to hear That what we should be communicating
- 1:51:46Basically.
- 1:51:46Constantly.
- 1:51:47Constantly.
- 1:51:48Governance is a service, but it doesn't often get offered as such.
- 1:51:52No, and it's never thought of as that.
- 1:51:53I wouldn't say if you took a cross-section of my friends at home,
- 1:51:58none of them would say that.
- 1:51:59It would be the complete opposite, in fact.
- 1:52:02Yeah, that's the journey.
- 1:52:04Good.
- 1:52:04And by the way, not to criticize or anything, but saying the future of governance is private, it's a narrow sliver of it.
- 1:52:11And it will continue to have resistance because people don't understand what governance even is.
- 1:52:18I think service is a more accurate part.
- 1:52:22And truly, service can be done publicly or privately, but it tends to be better provided when it's privately.
- 1:52:28So it's sort of inherently embedded into it.
- 1:52:30Right. Yes. Good. Thank you for that.
- 1:52:32I've got to go. That's my next guest coming in now. Thank you.
- 1:52:38Right, you made it to the end of the show. So I'm going to go ahead and assume that you got some
- 1:52:45value out of this episode. If you want to help the show, please follow or subscribe right now.
- 1:52:51It takes only two seconds and it massively helps. If you've got another 30 seconds, well,
- 1:52:58leave a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
- 1:53:02Honest reviews apparently are the single best way to help new listeners find us.
- 1:53:07If you want more, you can get bonus episodes and early access to episodes on fountain.fm
- 1:53:14for the price of one coffee for a whole month.
- 1:53:18Or you can support the mission by streaming sats on any of the value for value platforms
- 1:53:23or use the Bitcoin and fiat donation links in the show notes.
- 1:53:27every contribution to the show makes a real difference believe me and one more thing if you
- 1:53:33know someone who'd love this episode share it directly with them that personal share beats
- 1:53:39every algorithm in the book all the links the community and the newsletter are in the show notes
- 1:53:44and jump on over to freecities.fm for a deep dive into all the episodes with descriptions
- 1:53:52and more that's the new free cities podcast website freecities.fm have a good week and see you next time