Latest / The Film Hobbyist / ParaNorman (2012): A Comprehensive Look at Bullying
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We are sitting here in a nook of my attic room.
- 0:36I've opened the windows. It's a damp October
- 0:39day outside. It rained this morning. It'll probably
- 0:44rain again tonight. But the air is pleasant,
- 0:48and a breeze is blowing, ruffling my navy blue
- 0:52curtains. I'd prefer it to be a little drier,
- 0:56but it'll do just fine. I'm sure you saw our
- 1:00neighbor's house on your way here. They get really
- 1:04into decorating for Christmas and Halloween,
- 1:06largely with those inflatable lawn ornaments.
- 1:10They cover the entire lawn, and just when I think
- 1:13they've hit capacity, they add more. It's almost
- 1:16like they're breeding. They started decorating
- 1:19for Halloween right after Labor Day, adding something
- 1:23new every day until it was officially fall when
- 1:26everything came out. Or at least, I thought it
- 1:30was everything. I think the blow -up of the pterodactyl
- 1:34fossil on the T. rex skull is new. We are not
- 1:39a big Halloween family, which shouldn't surprise
- 1:41you. We're very into costumes and candy, my husband
- 1:45actually makes some, and we love being out with
- 1:49our neighbors, but we're not really into scary
- 1:52things. I'm very interested in horror as a concept.
- 1:57I think it's a really powerful genre to explore
- 2:00important cultural conversations. I just have
- 2:04a pretty low scare tolerance. Not non -existent,
- 2:08just pretty low. My husband's is even lower.
- 2:12I dislike cruelty in films. He can't stomach
- 2:16it at all. And our kids are pretty sensitive
- 2:19to suspense and scary imagery. They don't like
- 2:24that house with the lawn ornaments, because some
- 2:27of them are murderous statues that cackle with
- 2:30shining eyes. I get it. I was that way too. I've
- 2:36always loved the sublime, beauty's flip side,
- 2:39the dark glory of skittering leaves under a full
- 2:43moon, but that thrill was enough for me. I never
- 2:47needed that night to be filled with anything.
- 2:50And when it was, well, it was all too real. I
- 2:54have a number of memories of being unable to
- 2:57sleep after watching particular movies, and still
- 3:00more of seeing things in the dark, a problem
- 3:03that plagues me to this day. When The Haunting
- 3:06of Hill House came out, I read an article about
- 3:09the ghosts that they hid in the backgrounds of
- 3:11each shot and proceeded to see them every time
- 3:15I woke to feed my baby at night for about a week.
- 3:18Put that in reasons why I can't watch that show.
- 3:22But these days, my scare tolerance is higher.
- 3:26I was an early fan of Stranger Things. though
- 3:29season three took things too far for me, and
- 3:32I watch the occasional light horror, mostly the
- 3:35gothic ones with happy endings. And I'm grateful
- 3:38for that, because it means I can watch absolute
- 3:42marvels such as Laika's 2012 film Paranorman,
- 3:46directed by Chris Butler and Sam Fell. Leica,
- 3:51if you aren't familiar, is a stop -motion animation
- 3:54company that deserves to be spoken of in the
- 3:57same breath as old -school Pixar and Studio Ghibli.
- 4:01Of the five films they've released, two of them
- 4:05are on the fluffy side, but every single one
- 4:08is a masterclass in animation, craftsmanship,
- 4:12and innovation. They've pioneered a method of
- 4:163D printing characters' faces as a way to smoothly
- 4:20and precisely render emotions to create some
- 4:24of the most dynamic and specific stop -motion
- 4:27character work ever. They use stop -motion to
- 4:31create flowing water for Pete's sake. They're
- 4:35most known for their first film, Coraline, a
- 4:38full -blown horror movie aimed at kids. A pitch
- 4:41-black fairy tale where a girl is treated to
- 4:44a possible perfect world, as long as she's willing
- 4:47to sew buttons on her eyes. Paranorman, thankfully,
- 4:52is more in the Amblin camp of kids' adventure
- 4:56that happens to coexist with a horror story.
- 4:59where the scares mostly wrap up at the end of
- 5:02Act 2, beginning of Act 3, as the story heads
- 5:05into an emotionally powerful conclusion. But
- 5:09the scares of Act 2? Well, they can be pretty
- 5:13horrifying, especially when the sun first goes
- 5:16down. Frankly, I almost turned off the movie
- 5:20the first time it got there, and I realized I
- 5:23might not want to watch it in the dark. These
- 5:27scares are absolutely necessary to set the stakes
- 5:31of the story. I wouldn't change them. And I also
- 5:37wish that there was a weird time -travel -y way
- 5:40for 10 -year -old me to watch this movie without
- 5:43collapsing into a terror -induced panic. Because
- 5:47I think I would have felt seen by this film.
- 5:51And maybe it would have given me hope. I have
- 5:57ADHD. This is fairly new information in my life.
- 6:01I was only diagnosed a few years ago, which is
- 6:05a pretty common story. ADHD diagnoses, especially
- 6:10for adults, have been on the rise in the wake
- 6:13of the COVID shutdown. This mostly gets attributed
- 6:16to an increase in therapy speak and day -to -day
- 6:19life, or a desire for a medicalized optimization
- 6:22of our brains, or just for how scrolling on TikTok
- 6:26has changed thought patterns. I can't speak for
- 6:30everybody, but I know that's not the case in
- 6:33my life. I first realized I was weird in early
- 6:39elementary school. I remember the first day I
- 6:44realized things had changed when I burst into
- 6:47tears of frustration at a game and a fellow student
- 6:50called me a crybaby. Though I had started the
- 6:54year as normal, I was now something else, deeply
- 6:58unpopular. I got along with some of the boys
- 7:02all right, but the girls scorned me for reasons
- 7:06that I could never really understand. I found
- 7:10out years later that my teacher, an acquaintance
- 7:14of my family, could largely be held responsible.
- 7:17There was an assumption that I would be like
- 7:20a quiet, rule -conscious, thoughtful older sibling
- 7:24of mine. Instead, I meandered through hallways
- 7:28singing to myself, had very big feelings, and
- 7:31excitedly blurted out answers instead of raising
- 7:34my hand and waiting. And so, this teacher was
- 7:38overly strict with me, a fact observed by both
- 7:41my parents and the older sibling. I guess they
- 7:45were good at teaching, because the other kids
- 7:48learned there was something wrong with me. I
- 7:53was bullied pretty badly throughout my elementary
- 7:56school years. It would range from snide little
- 7:59laughs, to being held down and mocked to my face,
- 8:03to a signed declaration of hate for me. And though
- 8:08my parents were incredibly supportive, the cognitive
- 8:11dissonance of their insistence that I was wonderfully
- 8:15made on purpose while my peers made it very clear
- 8:18that there was something wrong with me was overwhelming.
- 8:23I'm grateful to finally have words. to no longer
- 8:27be at war with myself. Yes, my brain is wonderfully
- 8:31made to be different, not wrong, just different.
- 8:36There's so much peace in that revelation, but
- 8:41that doesn't change the scars on my psyche. Paranorman
- 8:47is not a film about neurodivergence, well, not
- 8:50directly, we'll get into that, but it is a film
- 8:53about Bullying, frankly, one of the most comprehensive
- 8:57works I have ever encountered on the subject.
- 9:00It outlines and discusses bullying's many forms
- 9:03and causes and some possible solutions. It tells
- 9:09the story of 11 -year -old Norman Babcock, who
- 9:12can talk to dead people. Not in the traumatized
- 9:16way of Haley Joel Osment in The Sixth Sense,
- 9:19or in the detective -therapist style of many
- 9:22protagonist mediums of screen and page. No, Norman
- 9:27talks to dead people as ordinarily as any other
- 9:30kid talks to his community. He has an especially
- 9:33good relationship with the ghost of his dead
- 9:35grandmother, sticking around because of her unfinished
- 9:38business to take care of him. But he also greets
- 9:42the ghosts of his New England town with all the
- 9:45neighborly camaraderie one would expect from
- 9:48a good kid. Unfortunately, the living members
- 9:52of his community do not receive him with the
- 9:55same goodwill. We learn several assumptions they
- 9:59make about him. That he's mentally ill, that
- 10:02he's making it all up to get attention, or that
- 10:05he is just a freak, and thus deserving of scorn.
- 10:09His living neighbors eye him with suspicion.
- 10:12His classmates mock him and deface his locker.
- 10:15His teachers don't have time for him. And his
- 10:18father berates him for not behaving like kids
- 10:21his own age, even if, as Norman points out, he
- 10:25also complains about kids his age being into
- 10:27bad things. There are a lot of movies about weird
- 10:32kids who get bullied. That doesn't make this
- 10:34film special. What does is what else this film
- 10:38understands. Bullying is not just a childhood
- 10:42problem, it's a broader societal ill. Norman
- 10:48lives in Blythe Hollow, an old New England town
- 10:52founded by Puritan settlers, notable for a witch
- 10:55trial that occurred in 1712. Six townspeople
- 10:59brought the accusation to their local leader,
- 11:02who found the witch guilty and hanged her. Local
- 11:06legend has it that the witch cursed the seven
- 11:09townsfolk to die horrible deaths and then rise
- 11:12from their graves, their souls eternally damned.
- 11:16And so Blythe Hollow has become a sort of lesser
- 11:20Salem, Massachusetts, a town that thrives on
- 11:23witch -themed tourism to sell their bars and
- 11:27casino and small theme park. Except it's not
- 11:31just a local legend. It's history. And after
- 11:35his eccentric uncle dies, it's Norman's responsibility.
- 11:39He must intervene to stop the Puritan zombies
- 11:43from rising from the grave and tormenting his
- 11:46town. This movie understands that prejudice is
- 11:52bullying. Singling out someone for their differences
- 11:57and harming or ostracizing them is bullying.
- 12:01Mob justice is bullying. But this film really
- 12:05singles out how injustice acted by the state
- 12:08is also bullying. It's highly recognized that
- 12:13the townspeople followed their local judicial
- 12:15procedure to condemn the witch. She wasn't lynched.
- 12:19She was sentenced in a courtroom and hanged.
- 12:22They followed their laws. And the laws were bad.
- 12:28This film doesn't just let that commentary stay
- 12:31in the past, as if the Puritan governments were
- 12:34unique in systemic injustice. There's a police
- 12:37officer in this movie, played for comic relief,
- 12:40who at one point, as someone is shooting at oncoming
- 12:43zombies, takes the weapon and shouts, What do
- 12:46you think you're doing firing at civilians? That
- 12:49is for the police to do! Which is a very aware
- 12:53thing to put in a children's movie in 2012. Even
- 12:58beyond these, Paranorman understands that bullying
- 13:01is a persistent state of the human condition.
- 13:06As Norman's classmate Neil says, You can't stop
- 13:10bullying. Bullying is part of human nature. If
- 13:13you were bigger and more stupid, you'd probably
- 13:16be a bully too. It's called survival of the thickest.
- 13:21If there is one blind spot of this movie, it's
- 13:24that it assumes bullies can only be stupid or
- 13:27ignorant. which is rich if you've ever spent
- 13:31any time around academics. There are a ton of
- 13:34bullies with PhDs. But this statement is uttered
- 13:39by a preteen boy, so I'll cut it some slack.
- 13:42Okay, so this movie portrays the breadth of bullying.
- 13:47That would be pretty impressive. There are a
- 13:50few movies that cover the relationship between
- 13:53peer bullying and grander systemic bullying as
- 13:56well. But this movie goes even farther. It asks
- 14:02why. Why is bullying such an untamable feature
- 14:07of human nature? The film's answer is fear. All
- 14:14of the bullies are afraid, and that's why they
- 14:18lash out. First, there are the bullies who are
- 14:22insecure, hyper -aware, and afraid of how other
- 14:26people perceive them. Represented here is Norman
- 14:30and Neil's bully Alvin, a wannabe skater goth
- 14:34kid sporting a very period pair of long plaid
- 14:38shorts with a pocket chain, a stud bracelet,
- 14:41and a set of gauges. Production on this film
- 14:44began in 2009, which the fashion design supports,
- 14:47and I definitely knew this kid in high school.
- 14:50But the point is that Alvin's behavior is incredibly
- 14:54consistent with insecurity. He's always bullying
- 14:58Norman with an audience, dudes who are definitely
- 15:02policing that he's mean enough. There's a sequence
- 15:05after school where he's attempting to breakdance
- 15:08to impress a couple of girls. Very funny, as
- 15:11his moves are lamer than the Australian Olympian
- 15:14ray gun, which Norman accidentally interrupts,
- 15:18prompting Alvin to go after him. We also see
- 15:22Alvin trying to graffiti his name all over a
- 15:25bathroom stall. literally trying to promote his
- 15:29own name. This is played for laughs as he misspells
- 15:33his name every single time. The point is that
- 15:37Alvin would not be bullying Norman if he wasn't
- 15:40afraid about how other people thought of him.
- 15:45That's a mostly subtextual reason for bullying,
- 15:48but there are a couple of other more overt reasons.
- 15:53During a school play reenactment of The Witch
- 15:56Trial for its 300th anniversary, Norman has a
- 15:59vision of the townspeople and screams in front
- 16:02of the whole audience, The dead are coming! His
- 16:06father, who has already complained about Norman's
- 16:09behavior, lectures him all the way home and tells
- 16:12him that he is no longer allowed to talk to dead
- 16:15people. It's a horrible conversation, filled
- 16:19with all the kinds of things that kids remember
- 16:21forever. His dad goes inside in anger, and Norman's
- 16:26mom turns around and says, You know, sometimes
- 16:30people say things that seem mean because they're
- 16:34afraid. Norman rebuts that his dad shouldn't
- 16:39be afraid of his own kid, to which she explains,
- 16:43He's not afraid of you. He's afraid for you.
- 16:50This is a fairly nuanced take for any movie,
- 16:53let alone one aimed at kids. That the adult bullying
- 16:57you has become a bully because of their love.
- 17:02Norman's dad wants him to be accepted into society.
- 17:07He's very aware of how the townspeople look at
- 17:11and talk about him. He is scared for his son.
- 17:15He doesn't want his son to be rejected. And so,
- 17:19out of both this love and this fear, he becomes
- 17:23a bully. I mentioned earlier that this film isn't
- 17:29about neurodivergence. It isn't. But it is. ADHD
- 17:35is a new term, but was documented as far back
- 17:38as 1798. Autism was fully codified in 1911, but
- 17:44you don't have to look far to find examples of
- 17:47similar symptoms and expressions throughout history.
- 17:51Frankly, a lot of individuals labeled as eccentrics
- 17:55and town weirdos display symptoms common with
- 17:59one diagnosis or another, some of which tabulated
- 18:03onto myths of magical others. This is especially
- 18:07relevant to this story, as these kinds of diagnoses
- 18:11are pretty heritable. They travel in families.
- 18:15Pretty sure all three of my kids have ADHD. The
- 18:19youngest is too young for it to be official.
- 18:22Norman is not the only member of his family who
- 18:26is bullied and othered. That includes his uncle
- 18:30Pendergast, outcast by his town, shunned by his
- 18:35family, even attacked by Norman's lovely classmate
- 18:38Neil, who throws hummus at him. Uncle Pendergast
- 18:43can also talk to ghosts. And if you pay attention
- 18:48to the details of this film's story, you can
- 18:51put some pieces together that the two of them
- 18:53are not the only family members who share this
- 18:56trait. I had lovely parents who didn't have words
- 19:03for what was going on in my brain, but absolutely
- 19:06accepted all of my weirdness. I used to talk
- 19:10out the stories I was writing while walking back
- 19:13and forth in front of my house. My parents preemptively
- 19:16told the neighbors that it was part of my novel
- 19:19writing process. They never told me to stop.
- 19:24But lots of other neurodivergent kids don't have
- 19:28that kind of understanding parent. And it's not
- 19:32too dissimilar from how Norman's dad treats him.
- 19:37We get one other overt explanation for the source
- 19:40of bullying. Shortly after Norman's conversation
- 19:44with his dad, he's trying to get up the courage
- 19:47to take on the responsibility his uncle has given
- 19:50him, to try and stop the witch's curse from releasing
- 19:53zombies onto his town. He talks with his grandmother
- 19:58about how to handle his fear, and she says, there's
- 20:02nothing wrong with being scared, so long as you
- 20:05don't let it change who you are. This is what
- 20:10happened 300 years ago. Some townspeople who
- 20:15had pretty high moral standards were so scared
- 20:18that it let them change them to do a horrible
- 20:21thing. I do not want to spoil this movie for
- 20:25you. Please watch it if you can tolerate the
- 20:28scares. But I will say The Witch is in a far
- 20:32more vulnerable situation than the movie at all
- 20:35indicates in the first half. The circumstances
- 20:38around her hanging are surprisingly dark for
- 20:41a kid's movie. And in what is the film's boldest
- 20:45choice, she's called out for being a bully too.
- 20:50The curse she inflicted on the townspeople and
- 20:53Blythe Hollow itself was not benign. As she was
- 20:58being bullied, she let her fear of her bullies
- 21:02change her to become a bully herself. This is
- 21:07highly interrogated in Act 3 of this film. It's
- 21:11astonishing. I've never been able to watch that
- 21:15finale and not burst into tears at how honest
- 21:18and vulnerable it is, especially now that I have
- 21:23vocabulary to understand it all. There's a concept
- 21:28called rejection sensitivity. It's a phenomenon
- 21:32of ADHD, the kind of thing that happens when
- 21:35someone who struggles with emotional regulation
- 21:38experiences frequent or intense social rejection.
- 21:43It can lead to an overreaction to rejection or
- 21:46perceived rejection. Like, if I'm trying to make
- 21:50a new friend and they cancel our plans, even
- 21:53if I know that they had very good reasons, it's
- 21:57really hard to not feel like they don't actually
- 22:00like me. Rejection sensitivity has an even greater
- 22:05expression called rejection sensitivity dysphoria.
- 22:09where rejection and perceived rejection can have
- 22:12a huge impact on someone's behavior, leading
- 22:15to people -pleasing, obsessive behavior, depression,
- 22:19self -inflicted isolation, self -punishment,
- 22:23or worse. I'm grateful for the words. It's really
- 22:30helped me try and heal those scars on my psyche.
- 22:35But I would be lying if I said I didn't get anxious
- 22:39when someone in leadership over me reaches out
- 22:41for a meeting. That horrible sinking feeling
- 22:45that I'm about to be lectured again about how
- 22:48I talk too much and need to be more quiet and
- 22:50still or how I'm not following the rules or that
- 22:53I just need to apply myself more. I expect to
- 22:58be rejected, to disappoint, to be alone. So does
- 23:05Norman. Which is funny, because less than ten
- 23:10minutes into this movie, as Norman is cleaning
- 23:12Alvin's graffiti from his locker, so is Neil
- 23:16from the other side of the hallway. Neil is bullied
- 23:20by his peers for many things, as he lists out,
- 23:23I'm fat, and my allergies make my eyes leak,
- 23:27and I sweat when I walk too fast, and I have
- 23:30a lunchbox with a kitten on it, ooh, and I have
- 23:33irritable bowel syndrome. He's insulted by his
- 23:38older brother. He's cast as the tree in the school
- 23:41play, probably because of his size, even though
- 23:45he's already memorized everybody else's lines.
- 23:50He understands what it is to be bullied, and
- 23:54he really wants to be Norman's friend. But Norman
- 23:57is so used to being rejected that he tells Neil
- 24:01he likes to be alone, which isn't true. Norman
- 24:06is... always happy to spend time with his grandma
- 24:09and his dead community. He just assumes the living
- 24:14will always reject him, and out of his fear of
- 24:17rejection has allowed himself to change, to isolate
- 24:22himself. But Neil doesn't give up. He believes
- 24:28Norman and asks him to help him connect with
- 24:31his dead dog. They all play together. He stands
- 24:35up to his brother when he insults Norman. He
- 24:39tries to make new plans to hang out with Norman.
- 24:42He immediately jumps into action when he knows
- 24:45Norman is in trouble. He tries to stick by his
- 24:48friend, even as he yells at all of his companions
- 24:51to leave him alone. Neil has to be physically
- 24:55dragged away. And yet, Norman isolates himself.
- 25:01A protective measure from bullying, refusing
- 25:05help from others, insisting he's better alone.
- 25:09He lets himself be changed. Thankfully, he realizes
- 25:16it. In the stunning third act, which I really
- 25:19do not want to spoil for you, Norman realizes
- 25:22that he's spent so long focusing on the bad people,
- 25:26the ones who bullied him, that he'd almost forgotten
- 25:29the good ones who were there. And that reaching
- 25:32out for connection, for communication, is utterly
- 25:36transformative. We can't really stop bullying.
- 25:41It is an unavoidable part of human nature. But
- 25:45we can do our best to not let our fear change
- 25:48us. A task best achieved by remembering what
- 25:53is good. When I was 10, in the midst of the grand
- 26:00brain shifts of a preteen girl, I had my first
- 26:03depressive episode, probably brought on by rejection
- 26:07sensitivity dysphoria. I thought I didn't have
- 26:12any friends. Nobody liked me. My parents, who
- 26:18loved me very much, wanted me to see good things.
- 26:23They say I did have friends. That I did have
- 26:26people who cared for me. But I couldn't see it.
- 26:32I know I never would have been able to watch
- 26:34this movie. At this age, I walked out of the
- 26:37Emperor's New Groove in the first ten minutes,
- 26:40where the protagonist we're told to root for
- 26:42is a bully. That was too intense of an experience
- 26:46for me. But I think I needed a movie like this.
- 26:52I needed to believe that there were people out
- 26:55there who liked me, that both my pain was real
- 27:00and that there was some way I could find peace
- 27:03in living. When I watch this movie, I remember
- 27:09that broken child still inside me. My pain is
- 27:14seen, is honored, and I am filled with hope.
- 27:19Thinking of the friends who I didn't know were
- 27:22months away. The friends who taught me to feel
- 27:25safe in community again. Who didn't let me reject
- 27:29them out of a protective instinct. Who stood
- 27:32by me even when I moved away. And who I'm still
- 27:36friends with. They were the good ones there for
- 27:40me. They liked me for all my weirdness. And thank
- 27:48you, too, for liking spending time with me. and
- 27:54helping me feel a little less alone. Thanks for
- 28:01coming.