Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 59
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder, true crime cases five four, three, two one one one
- 0:21one one one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm
- 0:30sure you are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so
- 0:34let's get started. The strange case of Paula Weldon Why did she disappear?
- 0:46On the first day of December nineteen forty six, a woman named Paula Jean
- 0:51Weldon arrived home after working a double shift from the school cafeteria. After hanging
- 0:58out with a roommate, Elizabeth for a bit, she dressed in what is
- 1:02described as a red Parker code in blue jeans before leaving with the phrase I'm
- 1:07all through with the studies. I'm taking a long walk. This long walk,
- 1:12as she described it, would occur on a path known as Vermont's Long
- 1:17Trail, which begins at the Massachusetts state line and travels all the way to
- 1:22the Canadian border. Despite it being mid afternoon. Her outfit told Elizabeth that
- 1:29Paula didn't intend on making a long trek and would be back probably a few
- 1:33hours later. The next person to see Paula, or someone who was wearing
- 1:38an outfit similar to that which she left in, was a man named Danny
- 1:42Fager. The gas station he owned was right across the street from the gravel
- 1:47pit near the college's entrance. From what he told investigators, the person he
- 1:53saw ran through the area sometime around two forty five pm from there. The
- 2:00next ledge sighting came from Lewis Knapp. He claimed that he stopped to pick
- 2:06up a girl who was trying to hitch her ride near the college. He
- 2:08says the two of them spoke very little during the ride, and the only
- 2:13real exchanges came when she got out near the long trail and when she slipped
- 2:17getting into his truck. The final time anyone claims to have seen Paula alive
- 2:24was just before four pm. She was apparently heading toward the trail by a
- 2:30group of people near by. One of them says they warned her of the
- 2:35dangers of going into the mountains without proper clothing, but she ignored his words
- 2:40and continued in the direction she was already heading. Night arrives and Elizabeth has
- 2:47begun to worry about her friend, but she doesn't want to create any panic
- 2:53by reporting her missing. If she'd just stopped somewhere. It isn't until the
- 2:59next morning and Paula still hasn't arrived home when she contacts the college president,
- 3:05Lewis Jones. His first action is to contact her parents in case she made
- 3:10an unscheduled trip home for the weekend. Upon learning of her daughter's disappearance,
- 3:16her mother collapses and doctors eventually confine her to bedrest. Her father, w
- 3:24Archibald Weldon, unwilling to do nothing and hope for the best, departs for
- 3:31Stamford, the city where the college is located. Upon his arrival, he
- 3:37goes about organizing volunteers for a search party to scour the mountains for any sign
- 3:42of his little girl. People from the area, including residents of the town
- 3:46and her fellow students, spend an entire day walking the mountain trail in the
- 3:52areas surrounding it, but no signs are found of where she might be.
- 3:59Frustrated with the lack of results, most of the people from the day before
- 4:03gave up, and the father calls the New York in Connecticut State Police.
- 4:09At this time, Vermont has no state force of its own, except for
- 4:14an investigator whose only contribution ends up being the raising of five thousand dollars for
- 4:18information on her whereabouts days pass without any progress beyond strained sightings of a woman
- 4:27that fit Paula's description, including one from a waitress that claimed to have served
- 4:31what she described as a disturbed woman in Fall River, Massachusetts. For whatever
- 4:38reason, Weldon leaves Stamford and isn't heard from for a day and a half
- 4:44before he arrives back in Bennington, claiming to have gone to investigate the lead.
- 4:48This strange behavior made some in the community think he had something to do
- 4:54with his missing daughter. Scrutiny of him only intensified when it came to light
- 4:59that Paula and her father weren't on the best terms with one another over a
- 5:03certain guy who was courting her To deflect suspicion away from himself. He claimed
- 5:11that this boyfriend of Paula's was the likely reason she was missing. He couldn't
- 5:15prove these claims with any hard evidence, except for his claim that he'd been
- 5:20told so by a psychic. People continued to search the area on in a
- 5:27round long trail, but winter weather eventually forced them to abandon the pursuit.
- 5:33Even the most willing parties had to admit that any remains or signs she might
- 5:38have left would be covered and no longer visible. In nineteen fifty six,
- 5:44a lumberjack made the claim that he had been in the area called Bickford Hollow
- 5:49when Paula had disappeared, even going so far as to say that he knew
- 5:55where she was buried. Upon being vigorously questioned than attorney Reuben Levine, he
- 6:01was forced to admit that he had fabricated the entire story in hopes of getting
- 6:06some notoriety. Twelve years later, when a skeleton is found in the mountainous
- 6:13area, investigators were hopeful they'd finally found Paula, but it would later be
- 6:18determined that the remains were far too old to have been the college sophomore.
- 6:24In the end, the case remains unsolved. Most people who have analyzed the
- 6:30details come up with the usual suspects for why she went missing, whether she
- 6:34became disoriented and lost and died of exposure, or that there was some boyfriend
- 6:41that she ran away with some unknown boyfriend. Other possibilities are much more ominous.
- 6:48That include an area of southwestern Vermont known as the Bennington Triangle, where
- 6:55a total of five people disappeared without a trace between the years of nineteen forty
- 7:00five. In nineteen fifty. The case, however, will likely never be
- 7:04solved, and the question of what happened to Paula that December sixty seven years
- 7:10ago may never be known.