Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Joel Toppen
Transcript
- 0:04Out of the street corners. They scream. You knew it was coming.
- 0:08You've been waiting for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now
- 0:12they scream at you, the sirens, their hysterical wail, tearing through the
- 0:16white noise of the city, and you run. You run to pick up
- 0:20those things that can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days
- 0:24when they still loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn
- 0:27to your shelf of games. You only have room for five. Five Games
- 0:34for Doomsday. Five Games for Doomsday is a show in which board game personalities
- 0:41are thrust into a cabin in the woods to outrun an oncoming disaster, but
- 0:45can only take five of their games with them. But which will they choose?
- 0:49My guess this week is a pastor, game designer a digital game implementer.
- 0:53He works at a church at a Native American reservation, also helping people
- 0:56deal with addictions in the gaming world. He's the designer of Navajo Wars and
- 1:00commanche Era. My guest this week is Joel Toppen. Welcome to the cabin,
- 1:03Well, glad to be here. So my first question is how difficult
- 1:07was it for you? To pick the five games to take to the cabin.
- 1:11It's pretty difficult because I have too many games already, and whatever game
- 1:17I'm playing at the moment is usually my favorite. So and as a gamer,
- 1:23you can find simply to war games or do you branch out into other
- 1:26areas? Oh no, I'll play just about anything. You know, if
- 1:32it's fun, I'll play it. You know, if it's a strategy game,
- 1:36I ball over the place. In terms of playing Euros, that sort
- 1:40of thing. I enjoy it. Often. Often when Americans talk about board
- 1:47games, they will often talk about playing games at their church and you know,
- 1:49being in the church basement and all of that, And it seems to
- 1:53me often it's an excuse for the priest or the pastor to sort of play
- 1:57games and consider it work. Is the same with you. Do you play
- 2:00amongst your community? Yeah, we do. In the winter time, Montana
- 2:06has a really long winter, and a lot of times the weather isn't conducid
- 2:09to being outdoors. You don't really really want to be out it. It's
- 2:13not that fun, the snow isn't It's romantic for a few minutes, but
- 2:15after that it gets old pretty quick. So during the long winters, we
- 2:21get a gaming group together maybe once a week we'll do a strategy game,
- 2:25and it's just a good way to have community and hang out with people,
- 2:30really, And I always imagine Montana, you know, from I guess Malboro
- 2:37adverts, where there's lots of mountains and open sky and not a lot of
- 2:42population density where you are. Is that a correct description or am I am
- 2:47I over romanticizing it? Yeah, it's it's I live in a rural community
- 2:52on the Blackfeet Indian Reservation, so the population here is pretty small. I
- 2:55think we got maybe five six thousand people in my town, and the reservation
- 3:00at large is a fairly small population community. Now, in the summer,
- 3:06because of the tourist explosion at Glacier National Park, which is like thirteen miles
- 3:10down the road, there's a lot of people in the summertime, so there'll
- 3:15be traffic on the highways and things will look fairly normal. However, in
- 3:20the winter time, like now, it's not unusually driving down the highway and
- 3:23not see another vehicle for ten to fifteen minutes. And it's very typical for
- 3:30people in tourist areas. The people who actually are resident in tourist areas to
- 3:35kind of be fairly resentful of the tourists. Is that the case there?
- 3:39Or are they heartily welcomed. We have a love hate relationship with them because
- 3:46well, our economy depends on it, so you know, we need to
- 3:50be nice to these people. But then you also got to put up with
- 3:53the nonsense that a lot of times tourists bring. And so this is something
- 3:59I'm cognizant of when I'm traveling. I do a lot of tours overseas with
- 4:04church groups, and so I try not to be the ugly American when I
- 4:09go to places. And so, yeah, we have a love hate relationship.
- 4:14Not all tourists are bad. It's just that the bad ones tend to
- 4:16really stick out like a sore thumb. So let's go back to the beginning
- 4:20then, So when did you grow up and what effect do you think it's
- 4:24had on the person you are today. Well, I grew up as actually
- 4:29as a pastor's kids, so I've been around the church all my life,
- 4:33and so I think it was one of my It was one of my youth
- 4:39pastors when I was a teenager introduced me to the game risk it some youth
- 4:44event or something or had us over to dinner or something. I don't remember
- 4:46the exact circumstances, but that was my first exposure to strategy games like this,
- 4:54and it was a very slippery slope from there to discover you know,
- 4:58Access and Allies. And one of the things I enjoyed doing is a hobby
- 5:02was building plastic model kits and model railroads were something I was into. And
- 5:08I remember at the hobby store where i'd get models and parts for my train,
- 5:14there would be this section of games and they weren't computer games, and
- 5:17I was intrigued by that, how do these games work if they're not a
- 5:20computer game? And this is you know, early nineteen nineties, and so
- 5:27that was really my first exposure. So after this you know, youth event
- 5:30where I played Risk, and then I thought, I'm going to get one
- 5:32of these games. So I ended up buying Access and Allies. And then
- 5:35next thing I know, I've got Mark Herman games like Golf Strike, you
- 5:40know, because the Golf War had just happened, and yeah, I got
- 5:43into it pretty deep, pretty quick. So I got into games fairly late
- 5:48in life, relatively speaking, and so I sort of walked into a ready
- 5:53made game group in a city where there were people who'd been steeped in this
- 5:58stuff for years, and so my entrance into the gaming world was fairly uncomplicated.
- 6:02I would have the games explained to me. I wouldn't have to wade
- 6:05through sort of you know, books and books of rule books. How did
- 6:10you especially you know, stuff like Mark Herman games. Were you just an
- 6:15exceptionally bright kid or was the learning curve difficult? There was a learning curve,
- 6:21certainly. I guess I'm a bit of a geek. I spent a
- 6:27lot, a significant amount of time in my high school teaching myself how to
- 6:30program, like visual basic and things like that, just as a hobby.
- 6:34Just I just like to do stuff. So I've never found it that difficult
- 6:38to learn how to play games simply by reading the rule book. So I'm
- 6:44usually the guy that gets designated to read the rule book and teach everybody else.
- 6:48And so, as you said, you grew up in a religious household,
- 6:53and you're you know, you're a pastor. Now, were there ever
- 6:58any moments as a kid where you felt restricted by being in a religious household?
- 7:04You have doubts about your faith, you felt like rejecting it, or
- 7:08was it always a sort of close relationship with God for you growing up,
- 7:12Oh for sure. Yeah. No, I'd say for a good ten year
- 7:15period. I had some significant doubts and pretty much walked away from it for
- 7:23a considerable period of my life before returning to really really to my roots.
- 7:29And so yeah, there was there was definitely time when I had to investigate
- 7:33for myself and discover for myself what, you know, what am I?
- 7:39What am I going to choose to believe and do with my life? And
- 7:45how do you come back to God? Well, that's that's interesting to put
- 7:49it that way. I think it was. It was in nineteen ninety nine.
- 7:55It was in a moment of well, I wouldn't say crisis, but
- 7:59there was this there was a key moment where I had an intense it was
- 8:03an intense encounter with God. It was an awareness that He is real,
- 8:09that he hadn't left me, and that I was the one that had really
- 8:13left him, and that I needed to make some changes in my life,
- 8:16that the trajectory of my life at that point was going to take me to
- 8:20a really dark place, and had already started to do that. Nowadays we
- 8:26call it mental health crisis or whatnot. We didn't have the terminology for it
- 8:31then, but I was already drifting down pretty dark road, and in that
- 8:37moment, I made the decision to commit my life back to serving the Lord
- 8:43Jesus and make him the most important thing in my life. And funny you
- 8:48should mention that in the context of gaming, because that was one of the
- 8:50things I put on the shelf for a while to focus on developing my relationship
- 8:56with God above everything else. And so I put everything else aside for quite
- 9:01some time before, and once once I'd really established that healthy relationship, then
- 9:07you know, gaming became, you know, something I enjoyed to do in
- 9:11my leisure, and you know, it was something that He allowed to come
- 9:16back into my life in a healthy way. I guess that's a good way
- 9:18to put it. And I've written this question later on in the notes,
- 9:22but it feels like a good time to ask it now. And you kind
- 9:26of you kind of hinted at something. How do you know God exists?
- 9:31Yeah, that's a that's a good question. How do you know exist?
- 9:35It says in the Bible that He's put eternity in our hearts. There's something
- 9:37inside of us that just knows that there's something more than this, and it's
- 9:45one of those things. I can only put it this way, that you'll
- 9:46know it when you when you encounter it, that there's there's something real here.
- 9:50This isn't this isn't some fantasy, this isn't some made up thing.
- 9:54It's it really is real. And when I had that encounter with God,
- 10:01it was there was just an intense awareness that he was real and I could
- 10:05I could sense here I'm not sure how to put it into words what I
- 10:11experienced, but within I could hear him speaking to me within and and speaking
- 10:18to the very things that I needed spoken to. And it's something that comes
- 10:24beyond me. It wasn't my thoughts that were, you know, self generated.
- 10:28It was definitely it was definitely one who knew me intimately and was external
- 10:35to me. And yeah, it's it's pretty wild. Once once you know
- 10:39that that he is real, then then your face with the choice, well
- 10:45what am I going to do with that? And that's where you know,
- 10:48what I've decided to do with my life comes into play. And so you
- 10:52seem fairly sure on this, what is your feeling about? So so I'm
- 10:56someone who doesn't have religion, for instance, how how do you sort of
- 11:01deal with that on an intellectual basis, something that you're so sure of that
- 11:05other people are equally sure of. On the other side, Oh yeah,
- 11:11for sure, I understand that, you know, there's there's people that are,
- 11:15you know, totally convinced of things that are false. So that's one
- 11:18of the things that I have actually wrestled with is, you know, how
- 11:22can I be sure that you know, I'm not you know, the one
- 11:24who's who's deceived. And that's where you have to make the decision. I
- 11:30don't think you're ever going to, you know, be one hundred percent certain
- 11:33about about some things in the degree to the degree I think that that some
- 11:39people want. I've just made the decision to follow what has you know,
- 11:45been made clear to me by what I believe to be God. And I
- 11:50think that you know, there are there are people that are certainly convinced of
- 11:56different belief systems, and I try to be respectful of that while maintaining my
- 12:03own faith. So yeah, no, absolutely, So your first game then,
- 12:09is this is the one that sort of stands out on your list to
- 12:15me as something that one of these is not like the others, right,
- 12:18And this is War the Ring. And so my first question to you,
- 12:24because wargamers, and especially someone like you who makes wargames, you know,
- 12:28wargames tend to be very jealous of their definition of what a wargame is.
- 12:33Is this a wargame? You know? I would tend to say yes,
- 12:39because it's it is very much a game of conflict, although you can win
- 12:45without conflict necessarily as the Free peoples. So in the game, you're you
- 12:48have to play the Free People's or you play the shadow Forces being sarn in
- 12:54his allies, the Free People's being you know, like the Elves, the
- 12:58dwarves, men of the West and so forth, and so Sarron can only
- 13:03really win through conflict, either by you know, corrupting the Ring bearer or
- 13:07by you know, a military conquest. And I kind of feel like,
- 13:13in my experience with the game, it's fifty to fifty over which option you
- 13:16should go out. You kind of have to take it on the basis of
- 13:18what's happening in the game, what strategies you should pursue. But it's absolutely
- 13:24game about conflicts. So I don't know how you don't call it a war
- 13:28game. I mean, it's not a hex encounter game. But there's plenty
- 13:33of war games that aren't hex encounter games. So wargames don't need to be
- 13:37tied to an actual event, a realistic war on Earth in history. Well,
- 13:43no, because then you threw out the whole sci fi genre. I
- 13:46mean, you know, Space Empires four X by GMT, for example,
- 13:50I would call that a warglink game. I mean, it's it's definitely a
- 13:52game of conflict. But there I think there's going to be other examples in
- 13:58the high pathetical realm where what was that other game that GMT did. There's
- 14:03one where you have these spaceships and you're shooting at each other, and I
- 14:09can't remember the name of it. Now, same designers Space Empire's four X,
- 14:13but I can't remember the name of it. Anyways, you know,
- 14:16obviously it's not a historic conflict, but it's clearly, you know, conflict
- 14:20is happening. And so how well does this game convey Tolkien's worlds? Do
- 14:28you think? I feel like it gives you the full experience of the trilogy
- 14:33in now, depending on how experienced the players are, it could take you
- 14:37six hours to play the whole thing, or it could take you like three
- 14:39hours to play the whole thing. To me, I feel like you can
- 14:43do the whole thing in like three hours, but it feels like you have
- 14:46gone through the whole trilogy. So you could sit and watch the movies for
- 14:50twelve hours, or read the books over three months, or you know,
- 14:54play this game for three hours and get the feel for it. It's quite
- 15:00a it's quite immersive. Really, it's it's a great narrative experience to play
- 15:05the game. And so I've played it quite a lot, and I usually
- 15:11play the Free Peoples because I just like to be fro do. I guess
- 15:13I'm from I'm from the countryside in England, so I feel sort of like
- 15:18a Hobbit. And so is the game balance? Do you think does?
- 15:24Does it come down to the wire every time? I feel like more often
- 15:28than not it has in my experience with the game. And it might sound
- 15:35weird coming from a past, but I like playing sorrow. I like being
- 15:39the agent of chaos once in a while, So yeah, it comes down.
- 15:43It comes down to the wire in just about every game. And I
- 15:48think, yeah, I think only one time I was one time I was
- 15:52playing The Free People's Only one time have I won a military victory with the
- 15:56Free People's and that was because my opponent made a really bad mistake. So
- 16:03I want to move on there and talk about your your day job, and
- 16:07so, as I said in the intro, you work as a pastor on
- 16:10a Native American reservation. And I guess my first question is is because Native
- 16:15American reservation is a phrase that just sort of is banded about, and I
- 16:22kind of realized when I was writing up the notes for this show, I'm
- 16:25not entirely sure I know exactly what that means. Can you explain for me
- 16:30and the listeners? What is a Native American reservation? Okay, yeah,
- 16:36for sure, it's complicated. If you have Canadian listeners, they have something
- 16:40similar north to the border. I think they call them reserves up there,
- 16:45a Native American reserv. I've lived among Native American people for most of my
- 16:49life. Let me just give you a little background. We moved to a
- 16:53gallop, New Mexico when I was a teenager, and so pretty much from
- 16:57the age of sixteen on, I was put into a community that was consistent
- 17:03primarily of Navajo Indians, and the people that I've lived among, by and
- 17:08large, most of them prefer to be called Indians. Some people prefer the
- 17:12term Native American. North of the border, I think they prefer First Nations
- 17:18or just Indigenous. It depends on the community. So if I say Indian,
- 17:22please listeners understand where I'm coming from. That's what people here tend to
- 17:26call themselves. I've lived among the black Feet for eight going on nine years
- 17:32now, and what I can tell you is that American Indian tribes differ vastly
- 17:37from one another. Another will be some areas of similarity, but in terms
- 17:41of culture and lifestyle, there can be vast differences between Navaja and Blackfeet,
- 17:48for example, there's quite a few differences culturally. Now a reservation that reservations
- 17:53were created back in the eighteen hundreds as a way to I think what the
- 17:59United States government was trying to do, right or wrong, was trying to
- 18:04create an environment for what the government felt to be, you know, a
- 18:11civilization that is behind the curve in terms of where they are technologically, knowledge
- 18:18wise, and so forth with the rest of you know, the people flooding
- 18:21the North America from Europe. One to catch them up and so putting them
- 18:26on reservations, could you know, try to settle them down and civilize them.
- 18:33Now it's it's considered racist to talk in these terms, but I don't
- 18:36know how to explain the history without explaining that that's I think the motive that
- 18:41the US government was trying to do, well, we don't have in the
- 18:44eighteen hundreds, right, and so, yeah, back then are different from
- 18:48now, for yeah, So what they were trying to do, I think
- 18:52was trying to civilize what they felt to be a Stone Age civilization, and
- 18:56what they ended up creating was at the beginning not a whole lot different from
- 19:00a prisoner at war camp where the Indians were not permitted to go off the
- 19:07reservation. So when you hear someone use the phrase, oh, so and
- 19:08so has gone off the reservation, it tends to mean someone's gone rogue or
- 19:12gone crazy, and that term comes from that they weren't permitted to leave the
- 19:18reservation. It was almost like it was a pow camp, and the Indians
- 19:25were promised that they would be taken care of, that the government would provide
- 19:29for their needs so they don't have to rely on hunting wild game that we
- 19:33teach them how to farm. The government says, well, we'll teach you
- 19:37to do the things that we do and what they what ended up happening instead,
- 19:42of course, was there's a tremendous amount of corruption in the Bureau of
- 19:47Indian Affairs that was in charge of this, and so the Indians weren't given
- 19:52what they promised on, you know, on the one hand. Instead,
- 19:53what they ended up having was you know, contact with diseases for which you
- 20:00know, their people didn't hadn't developed centuries of immunities or the ability to fight
- 20:04off. So there was just catastrophic population loss among the native peoples, even
- 20:15those living on the reservations. So the reservations begin to shrink in size for
- 20:18two reasons, you know, population shrinkage due to disease and death starvation even
- 20:26and also because more you know, white people are flooding the continent and want
- 20:30access to more land resources. So well, these Indians aren't doing anything with
- 20:34this land, so we'll just take what we want. And that's basically what
- 20:37happened. Well, as time goes on, I think I heard one Native
- 20:42American put it this way, a reservation is kind of like a pow camp
- 20:47where the guards just left, and that's kind of what happened. So fast
- 20:52forward, it's a long history between the eighteen hundreds and now. But fast
- 20:56forward, and what we end up with is each tribe, federally recognized tribe
- 21:02usually has a government or some sort of government institution that functions with a degree
- 21:07of autonomy, so they're still subject to federal regulations and federal laws. I
- 21:15understand it, and I might be wrong about some details here, because this
- 21:18gets really complicated really quick, but they tend to have their own tribal law.
- 21:25So if I, as a non tribal member here break the law,
- 21:30a tribal officer police officer, you can detain me, but will usually bring
- 21:37a cross deputized sheriff deputy or state trooper who's cross deputized, or if it's
- 21:44severe enough, a FBI agent to deal with the rest, because they don't
- 21:48the tribal officer doesn't have jurisdiction over me, a non tribal member. So
- 21:53it gets really really complicated these you got these jurisdictional boundaries and stuff. What
- 21:59is it like living on a reservation. It's almost like living on an in
- 22:02another country within a country. So as soon as you come on the resh,
- 22:07you're kind of you're subject to reservation law, which is going to be
- 22:11so parallel to the state and federal law that you in most cases aren't going
- 22:15to recognize the difference. It's not going to feel different except that you know
- 22:21the police officers, you know, drive a different vehicle than you know the
- 22:25other agencies, and you know there'll be a few few different nuances. Like
- 22:30during COVID, it was much more noticeable because there was stricter regulations in order
- 22:37to protect the population. Tribal government really stepped up its regulations, especially in
- 22:44places like Montana, uh in order to safeguard the population because Native people were
- 22:49more at risk during COVID and and loss significant population compared to the non native
- 22:55populations in our state. So I know that it's quite a lot of information
- 23:00and I'm just scratching the service, but I don't want to boil your listeners.
- 23:03That's basically what it's like living on a reservation. And so you said,
- 23:10you've lived amongst Native peoples for most of your life. Did you get
- 23:14this was the job you do now? The family business? Essentially? Not
- 23:18really. We were in Gallup, New Mexico, which is not on a
- 23:22reservation. It is surrounded by the Navajo Reservation, which is the largest reservation
- 23:27in North America. Largest federally recognized tribe I think is one of the Cherika
- 23:33bands, but the second I think is Navajo. I could be wrong,
- 23:37and I could have transposed those. It's really close. They have I think
- 23:40half a million, No, it's more than that. I think. Yeah,
- 23:45it's over half a million enrolled members, and they surround the reservation is
- 23:51huge. It surrounds naval nations, bigger than some of our states actually,
- 23:56and it surrounds the city of Gallop. So our church was in a fairly
- 24:00sized community in New Mexico, and it was multicultural. We had a lot
- 24:03of Indigenous people, we had Hispanic Latino, White Asian people were moving to
- 24:10the community, so we had quite a few Filipenal people in our church.
- 24:12So I kind of grew up in an environment that was multicultural, and over
- 24:18the years, I just kind of, in my heart felt a burden to
- 24:22come alongside of, you know, Native people and try to live life from
- 24:27you know, their point of view and from their perspective, and basically learn
- 24:33a lot of the things that I hadn't learned living among a population that was
- 24:38purely homogeneous. So that's kind of where it came from. And I guess
- 24:45God just really directed it on my heart to you know, to come alongside
- 24:49and live among Native people. Kind of I don't know to make that my
- 24:55specialty is the right word, but I don't really know what else to call
- 24:59it. And since I've lived with Native people more than I have really now
- 25:03with white people, I almost feel like I wouldn't fit in in a non
- 25:07Native community, even though you know, by blood, I'm not one of
- 25:11these white guys that says that my great grandmother was a Cherokee or some such
- 25:17nonsense that gets bandied about. I have no Native you know, connection other
- 25:21than interest and what I feel to be the direction of God. And so
- 25:26you're a pastor in a Native community and one of the things. And whether
- 25:33this is just crass kind of orientalism or not, I'm not sure, but
- 25:37there is a lot of sort of native religion in the public consciousness, in
- 25:41popular culture. Is there a conflict between Christianity and Native religion? Well,
- 25:48I would say there's a conflict between Christianity and every religion, because fundamentally,
- 25:52that's what Jesus says. You know what the Bible depicts in the New Testament
- 25:56is that God says, you know what the Old way has got you this
- 26:00far, but now here is my son, and you need to listen to
- 26:03him. So, you know, that's kind of the worldview from which I
- 26:06live. Within the Navajo community, I would say the Navajo community is far
- 26:11more connected to the ancient religion of the Navajo people, what we went call
- 26:19traditional religion. I think that that's usually the terminology that a Navajo person would
- 26:25use. Now among the Blackfeet, one of the things that happened that was
- 26:30really tragic. It caused way more harm than good. I think it was
- 26:33President Grant, actually US Grant, that decided that the Bureau of Indian Affairs
- 26:41was hopelessly corrupt, and so his administration thought, what, you know,
- 26:47how can we improve this? And so what they did is they began to
- 26:51an experiment to put the tribes that were on reservations give custody of them to
- 26:57different church groups in an effort to because the churches won't be corrupt, right,
- 27:03what could possibly go wrong there? So they thought it was a good
- 27:08idea. You know, in the beginning, everybody kind of had this grand
- 27:14vision of, yeah, well, we'll teach them about about God and about
- 27:18our ways and everything will be wonderful. But up. What you ended up
- 27:22with was just another form of corruption develops like what the BIA had in maybe
- 27:29in a secular way, now it's now it's got a spiritual connotation to it.
- 27:33And so a lot of Native people in Canada and the United State,
- 27:36because Canada followed a similar policy, were I don't know if Christianized is the
- 27:42right word, but they were. And I don't think forcibly converted is quite
- 27:48correct either, but it flies pretty close to that. And one of the
- 27:55really unfortunate things that happened was Native families were broken up. Part kids were
- 28:00forcibly take taken from their families and brought to boarding schools that were run by
- 28:06these churches in order to you know, educate them, modernize them, civilize
- 28:11them, whatever. And the abuses that occurred at these schools were compel them,
- 28:15compel them to believe in Christ, yes, pretty pretty much, in
- 28:18addition to other things, compelled them to adopt European Western ways. And so
- 28:26it was. It was a pretty brutal process from which I don't think any
- 28:32of the Native peoples have fully recovered. Most of the uh difficulties and challenges
- 28:40that we face on the reserves in Canada and the reservations in the United States
- 28:45among the indigenous population. Is has its roots in the fact that the families
- 28:51were broken up, and so some of these parents they never never see their
- 28:55kids until their kids were all grown up and sent back from school, many
- 28:57of which never did. There's they find mass graves at some of these schools
- 29:02where you know, kids were killed through abuse or disease or whatever, buried
- 29:07parents never notified, and so there's some really horrible things. And because the
- 29:11churches were put in charge of these things, it has a tendency to taint
- 29:21Christianity with this brush. So let's talk about the elephant in the room.
- 29:30You know, how do you how do you reconcile Christianity with this? And
- 29:33my answer to that is, well, in any kind of any kind of
- 29:38contacts, you're going to have authentic and inauthentic. And what happened there is
- 29:44is completely contrary to the teachings of Jesus and what it's it is exactly what
- 29:51I would call inauthentic Christianity. And so one of the things I find is
- 29:56a challenge in my life is too with my life, not with my words,
- 30:00convey what real Christianity looks like. If God is real and Jesus,
- 30:07the spirit of Jesus, resides within me, then there should be some tangible
- 30:11evidence of that in my life. And that's what I seek to do with
- 30:15my life, is to demonstrate that. And are you so? I mean,
- 30:22you have two aspects that are different. Firstly your wife. Secondly,
- 30:27you're Christian. Are you part of the community or are you a sort of
- 30:32tolerated outsider. No, I don't think you can. Well, you can
- 30:36be a tolerate outsider, but you won't get very far. It takes a
- 30:40long time to really build relationship in the community. And I kind of feel
- 30:45like like we have done that here. My wife grew up in New Mexico
- 30:49among Native people and so we just kind of fit in. And one of
- 30:55the things that I found is a useful practice is you know, in any
- 31:00any kind of environment, anytime I go in the room, I'm usually only
- 31:03the white the only white guy in there, right, And one of the
- 31:07things I found to be helpful is just make up your mind. You know
- 31:11that everybody in this room accepts you and they like you, and if they
- 31:14don't like you, then they're just mistaken. And so if I think if
- 31:17you treat people like that, and you interact with them like you know what,
- 31:19they like me for me, and you know I'm their friend and I'm
- 31:26not those people from the past. I'm not that person. I think that
- 31:30that helps to break down some bearers, and so people can get to know
- 31:33me and not look at me and see my whiteness and see that white person
- 31:38who is abusive or mean or racist to them. They get to see maybe
- 31:45another side of European culture that is in the hostile to them. So I'm
- 31:52not just an ambassador I think for christ I think I'm also an ambassador for
- 31:56European people in a sense, because you know, people that look like me
- 32:01have done a lot of harm to the community. And so another aspect of
- 32:07your job is helping people with addiction. How do you go about doing that?
- 32:15Well, if I ever find out, I'll let you know. It's
- 32:20very much a work in progress. It's an endemic problem, and it's not
- 32:24just a Native community. It's a huge problem in Montana where drug and alcohol
- 32:31addiction is is become so prevalent. And what sort of things are we talking
- 32:37about. We're no longer talk just talking about alcoholism. We're talking now about
- 32:44the opioid epidemic has reached here. Methamphetamines, fentanyl, you name it,
- 32:50it's here. And so just broadly speaking, statistics on the reservation are those
- 32:55I'm more acquainted with than those at the state level, and so the reservation
- 33:00tends to be worse than the state level, but not by a huge majority.
- 33:05Here at the on the reservation, I think the number of babies born
- 33:08that are drug effected is hovering between fifty and sixty percent, which means the
- 33:15mom used drugs while pregnant with their child. And we're not just we're not
- 33:19talking about marijuana. We're talking you know, methamphetamine, opioid, et cetera,
- 33:25cocaine, what whatever people can get a hold of. So it's a
- 33:30widespread problem and it's affecting, you know, the structure of society to the
- 33:37degree that I see it as an existential problem that if it's not face and
- 33:43dealt with, I don't know if the tribe as we now know it will
- 33:45exist in fifty years if something isn't changed, Because we experience a tremendous amount
- 33:52of death, and most of those deaths, if you take drugs and alcohol
- 33:58out of the equation, they don't have it, and sometimes I suppose there's
- 34:02a lot of violence and things that are directly connected to alcohol and drugs.
- 34:07Right, Yeah, I've lost count of as how many unsolved murders we've seen
- 34:14and experienced here in this community since I moved here eight and a half years
- 34:17ago. Again, almost all of it drug, drug and alcohol related.
- 34:23So you have, you have all the violence, the dysfunctional home, child
- 34:28abuse, all of it that goes with that. So how do we treat
- 34:31that? How do we how do we administrate to that need? And one
- 34:36of the things that we do is is it's very similar to AA or NA
- 34:39Alcoholics Anonymous or narcotics anonymous. We have a faith based take on that that
- 34:47basically starts with acceptance, you know, accepting that your life is My life's
- 34:52out of control. I'm powerless to control my tendency to do the wrong thing.
- 34:54My life is unmanageable. But I believe that there is a power greater
- 34:59than me that can help me. And we believe as Christians, we believe
- 35:02that that that's Jesus, and so we can make the choice to commit ourselves
- 35:08over to His care and control, and from there we start to work the
- 35:12twelve steps so twelve step programs have been I think the most effective, at
- 35:16least in my experience, to helping people to face the what is causing them
- 35:25to turn to drugs and alcohol. It treats the deeper need than just the
- 35:30addiction. So that's basically how we go about it. I mean, in
- 35:37your experience, is it the drugs and the alcohol or is there some underlying
- 35:44cause that the prompts people to seek escape from life? Yeah, it's always
- 35:51something something else. There's something, a trauma that happened, you know,
- 35:57a death in the family, the loss of somebody is a huge factor that
- 36:02will cause someone to just they just want to numb the pain, and so
- 36:06that's what they turn to. But with some of these drugs, like opioids
- 36:10or methamphetamine, it can chemically like rewire your brain and do just extraordinary damage
- 36:17to you. So then it kind of almost becomes you know, something has
- 36:22to be you know, treated chemically, but it starts with something that's underlying.
- 36:28So it's a little bit of both. And so I've known doctors in
- 36:31my life and I'm always struck by I'm always surprised at how people who deal
- 36:39with death on a regular basis are able to kind of face the world to
- 36:45keep themselves afloat. How do you do it when you're confronted with you know,
- 36:52not only drug addicts, but the damage that drug addiction can cause.
- 36:58How do you stop it? Weighing you dime? Yeah, that's that's an
- 37:02ongoing that's an ongoing work in progress, because if you're not careful, you
- 37:07can get to the place. I remember one there's been a couple of times
- 37:10where we've had a spate of deaths, this bang bang bang, where I
- 37:15you know, do enough, you know, a couple of funerals a week
- 37:19for people, and it can wear you down. Like there was a month
- 37:23where there's a like there's a death every single day of that month, and
- 37:30towards the end of the month, you just find yourself like numb, like
- 37:32I don't even feel anything. So what I do A couple of things,
- 37:37A couple of things that helped me, And one of them is, of
- 37:40course the hobby. Just being able to put my mind to fruitful use in
- 37:47another direction. And I know, I might know that might sound strange to
- 37:52play a war game to get my mind off of death. That sounds kind
- 37:54of kind of ironic, But I also live in one of the most beautiful
- 37:59areas of world world. I'm physically active, so I like to go out
- 38:01and hike. I hiked like three hundred miles in Glacier National Park last year,
- 38:07just taking advantage of the beautiful terrain and the physical exercise going out and
- 38:15seeing nature. In the wintertime, I'll strap my skis on, go cross
- 38:17country skiing or snowshoeing, something to just get outside and enjoy nature. That's
- 38:23another way to help, you know, keep myself mentally healthy. So we'll
- 38:30move on to your next game, which is this gets picked well, this
- 38:35system gets picked a lot on this show. This is Commands and Colors Napoleonics.
- 38:39So firstly, why is the commands and colors system so good? You
- 38:45know? I keep asking myself that question because, you know, one of
- 38:49the things I'm trying to do, I'm trying to minimize my collection down to
- 38:52what you know, I actually play, as opposed to what I might someday
- 38:57play. And I find myself keep gravitating back to the commands and colors,
- 39:01Ancients and Napoleonics. And I spent the last couple of years reading Charles Oman's
- 39:10history The Peninsular War volumes I'm down to the last volume now, and I
- 39:15love the battle depictions that in his writing. And as I'm reading the Battle
- 39:22with depictions, I'm thinking about how this works in Commands and Colors, and
- 39:27every time I play Commands and Colors Napoleon, itics, I'm like, you
- 39:30know what, this game is so simple and yet it gets so many things
- 39:32right. It just feels like the period in question without all of the weight
- 39:38of rules and a rata that you end up with with more complex systems,
- 39:45Like I can bring this thing out and I realized that it you know,
- 39:47it warps the battlefield to fit the system, but the overflow of the battles
- 39:53and everything that happens in the game, it just feels so like it nails
- 39:59the history so well with such a simple rule set. I found myself playing
- 40:04it probably more than any other single game system. And is it because there's
- 40:13many different The only one I'm familiar with is because I'm a nerd, I'm
- 40:16familiar with Battle or the Fantasy version of this. But is it a system
- 40:21that can be walped to any time period and any kind of battles? Yeah,
- 40:27you know, I don't know. That's one I don't have. I
- 40:29had Memoir forty four. I gave it away to a teenager. He'd been
- 40:34looking for it and he was just getting into strategy games. I'm like,
- 40:36this thing sat in my house for ten years and I don't hardly ever play
- 40:39it, so I gave away all my memoir stuff. Memoir was okay.
- 40:45I feel like it does okay at World War two, but it's something about
- 40:50ancients in Napoleonics medieval and Samurai the more recent one and Tricorn from Compass Games.
- 40:58I feel like Borg has matured the system to where it really can model
- 41:05those historic battles quite well. And again, it's so stinking elegant. It
- 41:12does a lot with a little, so I think that it can. But
- 41:15I've been less impressed with say, Memoir forty four, and I haven't played
- 41:21the Fantasy one, but that's one I would probably buy if an opportunity,
- 41:25you know, present itself. It's I think it's just been out of print
- 41:29forever. As someone who is I would term myself wargame curious. I can
- 41:35I wouldn't. I wouldn't deign to recommend the game to a war game designer,
- 41:37but I think Battlelore is absolutely fantastic. Yeah, I mean, I
- 41:43like, I'll enjoy playing like Battle or battle Cry the Civil War version,
- 41:49which is a less mature. I feel like he could do a few tweaks
- 41:52to it to make it more mature, like Napoleonics or Ancient So it's just
- 41:57a little bit of it just needs a little touch of chrome. But yeah,
- 42:01I really admire what he's done with his various different systems. I haven't
- 42:05played the World War One version, but again, shelf space has become an
- 42:10issue, so I've kind of slowed down my acquisitions. So I want to
- 42:15go on there and talk about you as a designer. So what made you
- 42:19go into the world of game design. A couple of things. I had
- 42:24been developing games for GMT and Compass, and so I got to see design
- 42:30from the developer's point of view, and especially after working like with Ted Reiser
- 42:36and some of these others, are like, you know, these guys can
- 42:37do it. I can do it. No, I'm just kidding. It
- 42:42was a desire to see a topic that I was interested in come to fruition.
- 42:46I just want to see if I could do it. And I was
- 42:52reading a book Blood and Thunder by Hampton's Sides about the Navajo interestingly enough,
- 42:57and it just maybe as I was reading the book, I was like,
- 43:00you know, I think there's a game design here, and I think I
- 43:05think I could do this, and so it just kind of became this a
- 43:07little bit of a challenge. And then when my initial you know, publication
- 43:12attempts were you know, met with a little bit of resistance because the topics
- 43:16really off the beaten path. You know, it's not Stalingrad or Battle of
- 43:20the Bulge, so why should we publish it? Uh, it almost became
- 43:24sort of like a challenge, Oh, you don't think I could do this?
- 43:28So, you know, I kind of dug my heels in, like
- 43:30we got to We're going to do this. So I became pretty stubborn and
- 43:34fixated on I want to I want to get this done because I really feel
- 43:37like there's a design here and I think that there's a story to be told
- 43:38that people might be interested in. So I think that's kind of what nudged
- 43:45me in that direction. And so you you designed it seems to me that
- 43:52you use the Native American milieu, for want of a better terms, as
- 43:58an inspiration. Are these the kind of games you want to get out there
- 44:04to have people explore. I think that that I think I opened up,
- 44:08I cracked something open that other people are pouring through. So I see lots
- 44:12of new games now on this topic, and I think that the you know,
- 44:15Naviho War has gone through two printings, commentary is up for another printing.
- 44:20So I think it proved to that publisher and GMT was awesome to me.
- 44:23I'm still very grateful that they published the design. They were reluctant at
- 44:30first, and I understand it. I mean, it's really an unusual topic
- 44:35and I'm an unknown quantity as a designer, and for them to have,
- 44:37you know, the trust in me to do it, I just can't speak
- 44:43highly enough of them for that. But I don't want to be like type
- 44:46cast into that. Well, these are the games I do, and this
- 44:49is only what I'm gonna do currently. My occupation now has me so busy
- 44:57that I just I don't have time to get it into design like I did
- 45:01when I was just an assistant pastor, and so since moving to Montana,
- 45:07I just haven't had time to dedicate to design. So I have a number
- 45:10of design ideas on the shelf awaiting just me having the time to dig in
- 45:16and develop it into a into a game to be published. I have a
- 45:21couple of games on the you know, native American genre, but I also
- 45:24have games on modern day warfare that have you know, yet to be designed.
- 45:30Games on the Middle East, the Israeli Palestinian conflict, for example.
- 45:34It's something I'm deeply interested in. I've spent a lot of time in that
- 45:37country, and so I have some design some design ideas. I just don't
- 45:42have time to flesh it out that but someday I hope, hope to be
- 45:45able to do that. And if you could put your finger on what a
- 45:49Joel Toppin design is, what would that be? And may be pretentious on
- 45:54my part, but I tried. I don't want to take what someone else
- 45:57has done and reskin it. So I wanted to be, you know,
- 46:00something innovative, and I will be honest. The game Navajo Wars I drew
- 46:08some inspiration from. I like how Martin Wallace does a lot with a little
- 46:14in his games, and so I kind of wanted my game to feel like
- 46:20a Martin Wallace design, where there's you know, I'm doing more with with
- 46:24a little bit. So I'm using abstraction in a in a really good way.
- 46:29I don't think I achieved that because I felt like Navajo Wars ballooned into
- 46:32a more complex design that I set out to make it to be. But
- 46:37the core mechanics of the game, I kid you not, those those are
- 46:42things I literally I felt like God gave me those ideas because there's nothing else
- 46:51out there that was like it. And the similar similar with with Commanchariah.
- 46:55The idea is when I got stuck on something, I just pray about it,
- 47:00an idea would come to me that that met the solution. So,
- 47:04you know, giving credit where credit's due, I really got to hand it
- 47:10to the Lord. He was the one that really gave me the idea for
- 47:15naw A Wars in particular. So you should be giving Jesus fifty percent of
- 47:20your royalties. Absolutely. Yeah. And so you when when we were sort
- 47:27of talking over email about arranging this, you seemed to put your work with
- 47:35Vassal a bit more forward than your actual designed games. So what what is
- 47:42Vassal for the listeners? And what is it that you do with Vassal?
- 47:45Oh? Okay, Vassal is It's been around for a long time. It
- 47:50was originating virtual ASL so Advanced Squad Leader is an awesome tactical game for Multiman
- 47:55Publishing. I started playing the ASL when I was a junior in high school.
- 48:01I self taught myself how to play ASL, and so there was like
- 48:06this virtual ASL way to play online. And then the guy that wrote the
- 48:09software, it's a Java based software to play ASL line said well, you
- 48:14know what, this is a really versatile system. Why don't we make this
- 48:16so you could, you know, design this around any board game. So
- 48:21it's kind of this sandbox program where you can make a digital version of nearly
- 48:27any kind of board game so that you can play it online or play it
- 48:30by email. And nowadays I think there's more people playing online live over the
- 48:36server than by email. So that's that's what Vassal the software is. You
- 48:39get at vassalengine dot org. The software is free. The modules, most
- 48:45of them, I think there's a few specialized cases where a company's selling them.
- 48:51I don't Decision Games or one of these is doing that, but most
- 48:54of the modules are free and on that website, and so this is where
- 48:59I connect to a GM. He was I was doing Vassal modules for some
- 49:01of their games and they were gracious enough to let us, you know,
- 49:04take and digitalize some of their games. And and then I found myself on
- 49:07playtest teams play testing a game that you know, it is too expensive to
- 49:13make a physical prototype for, but we can make a digital prototype so we
- 49:15can play it and play test and get it ready for print. And it
- 49:19became this mechanism that is greatly expedited game production. Uh. And that's that's
- 49:25really how I connected with GMT, got into the development and other things.
- 49:29And now making Vassal modules for playtest teams is something that I do sometimes they
- 49:35need a rush job, something done this week for this playtest group, and
- 49:38so they paid me a stipend to produce modules and and get the stuff,
- 49:45uh, you know, out there for the public to be able to use.
- 49:50And it promotes their games. At the end of the day, it
- 49:52promotes their games. So it's good for the company, it's good for the
- 49:53hobby. And so during the pandemic, the the victual board game experience really
- 50:00came to the four with board game arena. And I know wargamers and wargamers
- 50:07have been talking about Vassal for years. Was there a slight rye smile when
- 50:14the rest of the board game hobby came up to speed with something wargamers had
- 50:17been doing for you know, at least a decade. Yeah, you know,
- 50:22TTS has been around for a while, but you had to pay for
- 50:24it, and since you know, you can't get Vassal for free, I
- 50:28think most people just kind of slim that direction. TTS is pretty cool.
- 50:32I don't use it because I'm so embedded in Vassal, and I've done so
- 50:37much with the software that, you know, I don't want to teach I
- 50:42don't want to teach myself another programming language, really, So that's why I'm
- 50:46just basically stuck with Vassal. I think we're I think that there's a lot
- 50:52of people that had already been playing online. I don't think there's a rye
- 50:55smile or anything. I think it was just kind of refreshing to see people
- 51:00use what a lot of us have spent a lot of time creating, you
- 51:01know, for people to be able to use, uh, see people using
- 51:05it more. It's just I think it was all overall good for the hobby.
- 51:10So your next game then is another Commands and Colors, and this is
- 51:13Ancients, So how does this differ from the Poleonics. It's a little bit
- 51:17more simple. If you're going to learn a like a Richard Boord game system,
- 51:23you if you started like with Ancients, Uh, there there are some
- 51:28some big differences in terms of how the game works, but it's going to
- 51:31have a similar feel, but it's less Uh, there's less chrome with it.
- 51:37So I think it's it's maybe one rung down in complexity from Napoleons.
- 51:42But again, it does a remarkable job of depicting the flow of what we
- 51:46think about ancient warfare. And so to what degree with historical games, is
- 51:54it about putting yourself in the shoes the attraction I guess of putting yourself in
- 52:00the sandals of the people back then. Yeah, there's something about I think
- 52:08that this is what attracted me to these kinds of games, especially historical conflict
- 52:14simulations. Above all was you know, when you read a book about something,
- 52:19you want to watch the movie, and sometimes when you watch the movie,
- 52:21you want to read the book and vice versa, try to understand it
- 52:23better. And I feel like games provided just another dimension of that tendency to
- 52:30want to explore something further. And I'm kind of a hands on sort of
- 52:36learner myself. So I think that it's it's fun for me to read a
- 52:39book like from Adrian Goldsworthy and then set up Commands and Colors Ancients and play
- 52:45it out on there and just just kind of get a feel for what you're
- 52:49reading, and it just kind of gives you a sense of, Hey,
- 52:53this is what it might have felt like or looked like, and it might
- 52:58deepen, you know, what we think we understand about this pretty murky,
- 53:02admittedly murky period of history. And so, do you have a particular faction
- 53:09you like to play in Commands and Colours Ancients? No, I'll play anything,
- 53:15So you're not You're not drawn. You're not drawn to Greece as opposed
- 53:19to Rome. No, not, not one over the other. Really,
- 53:24I mean, if I'm playing, I'd like to play Alexander the Great.
- 53:30I think I'd probably prefer to play the Macedonians to the Persians, but it's
- 53:34not by a huge margin. I'll play, you know, the Romans against
- 53:37Hannibal, or Hannibal against the Romans. I don't really have a dog in
- 53:43the fight, so to say, so, I want to broaden the conversation
- 53:46out now to to sort of war games in general and sort of what their
- 53:52their purpose is. Whenever I get a sort of war game designer on this
- 53:55show, I like to I like to talk about this because I've my journey
- 54:01with wargames has has has been quite a long one, and my attitude has
- 54:06changed a lot over the sort of time I've been into games. But what
- 54:09would you say is the main purpose of a wargame? Well, it depends.
- 54:16I mean, it's different from person to person. To me, it's
- 54:21a it's a it's a medium of entertainment. It's it's a way to,
- 54:28you know, play a game that exercises the mind. And how do I
- 54:34put this, There's a natural tendency in us to want to compete with one
- 54:39another, deal with our natural competitiveness in a healthy way. So I think
- 54:46that it's an entertainment of form a form of exercising our mind and challenging one
- 54:55another, and yeah, treating that natural tendency to want to compete. Now,
- 55:04it can be an amazing educational tool, and I don't think that that's
- 55:09its primary function, but I think I tend to use it in that way.
- 55:15I mean, I will learn more about a topic by reading a book,
- 55:19and then playing the game. Then I would just simply by reading a
- 55:22book and certainly by watching it, you know, a movie about it.
- 55:25Even documentaries are usually pretty, you know, shallow, so I I kind
- 55:32of tend to look at it as a way for me to explore, you
- 55:37know, what might have happened, Why did the commanders make the choices that
- 55:40they make. I can more easily understand Bobby Lee's predicament at Gettysburg by setting
- 55:47up Mark Kerrman's Gettysburg game and pushing around some counters than I can by spending
- 55:52you know, a month reading you know, Steven Sears book or some other
- 55:57you know, fantastic author, And sometimes even by walking the battlefield, as
- 56:00valuable as that is, just by setting up the game and playing through you
- 56:06get a better appreciation of, Okay, why did they have to Why did
- 56:10he feel like he had to make this decision? Wargames introduce you to the
- 56:16theoretical possibilities of alternate outcomes, but that in itself can help you explore better
- 56:23and understand better what happened and why and so. How important in a wargame
- 56:30is historical fidelity if it's dealing with a real conflict, is it paramount that
- 56:36they get the history right. I think it's important that they get the potential
- 56:42right. Some people get very rigid about this. Well, there's one designer
- 56:46in particularly, I'm not going to name him, but on Twitter, you
- 56:49know, he's mentioning about how, you know, historically this happens. So
- 56:52if the game doesn't show that, then it's not a historical game. And
- 56:55I'm like, well, then why would I want to play it? You
- 56:59know, if the outcome is always going to be this, and what do
- 57:00I want to play it? I mean, it might be useful to see
- 57:04something replayed in front of you. There's marginal value in that, but I
- 57:07think that it's important that the game show what could have happened. I mean
- 57:14Gettysburg, to pick on that one could have been quite different if just a
- 57:19couple of choices on both sides were different. You know, what if me
- 57:22didn't hasten his guys down the road and decide to concentrate at Gettysburg. What
- 57:28if Reynolds didn't show up when he did, would the cavalry have backed off
- 57:31and yielded the ground. There's there's so many things that could have worked out
- 57:37a little bit different. I think that to be a good game, it
- 57:40has to allow for the potential for alternate outcomes based on you know, what
- 57:45is theoretically possible to the commanders at that time. And do wool games glorify
- 57:57wall Do they promote aortion with conflict or are they neutral? That's that's a
- 58:05great question. I love that question because I'm a lot of contradictions here.
- 58:09I would consider myself a military store in and at the same time a pacifist,
- 58:16so well, I study war and war making equipment. I'm very much
- 58:22against going to war. It should be something only at the most, you
- 58:25know, it's a last resort. Every other option should be explored. So
- 58:31I'm someone who opposes war. But the reason I pose war is because I've
- 58:36studied it. So I feel like like wargames can serve as that cautioned tear
- 58:42out. Now, some war games, I think, will glorify war to
- 58:46a degree and can make it seem more glamorous than it is, or make
- 58:54it seem glamorous when it isn't. It's ugly, and some games maybe portray
- 59:00its ugliness. You know, those games are going to take things out of
- 59:04balance. But I think on a whole they can serve certainly as a cautionary
- 59:09tale as to what you know certainly could have especially you know, modern day
- 59:15hypothetical conflict games, I think certainly serve as a cautionary tale, like you
- 59:22know, this is this is the road we don't want to trail down.
- 59:24Here's why. So maybe we are leaders could be advised to make good decisions
- 59:30now because of that. And so my initial issue with wargames was that I
- 59:37felt queasy in the sense that if I was playing a Second World War game
- 59:42of a Second World War battle, there are actual people who live on the
- 59:45actual world whose actual grandparents or great grandparents died in that conflict, and it
- 59:53felt funny to me to be moving around figures on a board that are real
- 1:00:00people who really died. And yet my perspective has changed on that over my
- 1:00:05time in gaming. But do you understand people who look on wargames like that.
- 1:00:12I didn't at first, but I've come to understand that a little bit
- 1:00:16better. I think the game. There was one game in particular that I
- 1:00:22didn't particularly enjoy because of what I know about its outcome and some of the
- 1:00:29things that happened there. It was actually from a series of games I really
- 1:00:35enjoy. But there's one in particular that you know what I've set up.
- 1:00:37I've played a couple of times. Yeah, I packed it away and say,
- 1:00:42you know what, I just I don't know about this one, And
- 1:00:45that would be I think it's a new Market, no Newtown, Newtown and
- 1:00:51riscany the Battles of American Revolution from GMT games, because I know what happened
- 1:00:55to the Native people in that particular battle and as a result of that battle.
- 1:01:02And so I think when you have a relationship or personal connection with people
- 1:01:09like you're describing, you know, being in Europe, that can make that
- 1:01:15a game on that particular topic. Maybe that's ground I don't want to revisit.
- 1:01:22I don't want to I don't want to go there. So I could
- 1:01:24see where someone who was in Vietnam or lost someone close to the Vietnam not
- 1:01:31want to play a game about Vietnam or the War on Terror, for example,
- 1:01:37Afghanistan. There's some great game on Afghanistan the insurgency, but knowing people
- 1:01:44that died there bothers me a little bit. So I don't know if I
- 1:01:49want to play that one, you know what I'm saying. Yeah, And
- 1:01:52so who are the great wargame designers then, and what do they bring to
- 1:01:58this varied world? Hmm, you know Volka RUNKI. I've had the president
- 1:02:06of working with Volco. I worked with Mark Kerrman, Ted Reiser. I've
- 1:02:08worked with some really good designers, and I've worked with some of those really
- 1:02:13good designers I will never want to work with again. But I will say
- 1:02:16that Vocal of all of the designers, he was probably not probably he was
- 1:02:22definitely the best to work with and probably the one of the more challenging ones
- 1:02:27to work with because his dedication to having his rules compact and not writing anything
- 1:02:37unnecessary. He always challenged me to be concise and sometimes frustratingly so, and
- 1:02:45I felt like working with him actually made me a better writer. And I
- 1:02:51think designer myself more than any other designer. So I would say games by
- 1:02:57Volco I definitely. You know, when I see his come up on the
- 1:03:00credits, I want to explore that that there's a new guy that's been making
- 1:03:05some games from GMT. I really admire Cheerer Jerry Wright White or Jeremy White,
- 1:03:12guy that did Atlantic Chase, and he did I think the one about
- 1:03:19the Bombers, the dam Busters do little raid. I love his approach to
- 1:03:23rules writing and his game designs that tell a story. You want to talk
- 1:03:28about innovative. I see a game with his credits on it, I want
- 1:03:31to go after it. And of course I'll always have a soft space in
- 1:03:35my heart for Mark Kerrman. I mean, he's his designs. There's been
- 1:03:38a few of them I've enjoyed more than others, but by and large,
- 1:03:42you know, like Empire the Sun's one of my all time favorites. I
- 1:03:45can't remember if that made this list or not, but it would be.
- 1:03:50If it's not on the list of five, it would be number six.
- 1:03:53So your next game then is Fields of Fire. Why are you taking this
- 1:03:58one to the cabin Because I feel like if I'm going to be an apocalypse
- 1:04:02and I'm going to be in this cabin for a long time, I might
- 1:04:04actually learn how to play this game. No, it's a game that has
- 1:04:12had a difficult history because the rules are inversion. Even the second edition rules
- 1:04:17are a mess. But the third edition, I promise you, the third
- 1:04:19edition rules finally hit it out of the park. I don't know if they
- 1:04:24exist in print yet, but I have them in digital form and they're outstanding.
- 1:04:29It's an immersive game. You're a company commander of US infantry in Second
- 1:04:35World War or Korea or Vietnam, and each is a different challenge. And
- 1:04:42I feel like this game, more than any other game I've played, puts
- 1:04:46you in a position where you feel like you're leading men into battle and you
- 1:04:51care about what happens. But you've got to send these lieutenants into a place
- 1:04:56where you know they're going to get shot at and there's a chance they can
- 1:04:59get killed, and that's going to mess everything up because if your lieutenants go
- 1:05:02down, who's going to command themn Your plan goes to pieces as soon as
- 1:05:06you contact the enemy. But if you don't have a plan, there's no
- 1:05:12way you're gonna, you know, win the mission. They're the enemies out
- 1:05:16there. But when you look at the board, you see all of your
- 1:05:19pieces, You see very little pieces of the enemy. You just see where
- 1:05:23the enemy fire is coming from. And I feel like that. You know,
- 1:05:29I've never been in combat myself, but reading about it, this feels
- 1:05:32like what the guys who have been in combat have described. The enemy is
- 1:05:36there, but you don't see them like you typically do. You know,
- 1:05:40in a hex and counter wargame like ASL where you see the piece, all
- 1:05:44the pieces on the board, even if they're under you know, concealment markers.
- 1:05:47In fields of fire, sometimes you just got incoming volume of fire from
- 1:05:50a place and they're shooting your guys and you need to make it stop,
- 1:05:56and you need to put fire on them, but you got to find them
- 1:05:59first. It's just an incredibly immersive experience. And this is a This is
- 1:06:04a war game that doesn't use dice rolling, it uses cards. Is this
- 1:06:09unusual in the world of wargames or is it fairy common? Because my mind,
- 1:06:13it's the nature of a war game is a crt, right, Yeah,
- 1:06:16it's it's unusual it if you've played the game Upfront from Avalon Hill that
- 1:06:25this game's randomizer borrows heavily from the concepts from Upfront. Upfront was the first
- 1:06:30game that did anything like this where you had a deck of cards and the
- 1:06:33cards managed all of your random effects. So what Mike Burtiscelli did with Tank
- 1:06:40Duel is kind of modeled after Fields of Fire and Upfront, So Upfront's kind
- 1:06:44of like the point of origin for this concept. It's fairly unusual. The
- 1:06:48only games I see that use this now are Fields of Fire Tank Duel from
- 1:06:55GMT, and then Lock and Loads got one I think called It's a new
- 1:07:01card based one and the name escapes me now. It just came out recently
- 1:07:08and it uses a kind of a similar thing where the randomizers the deck of
- 1:07:12cards. And so, how important for you as a gamer, especially a
- 1:07:18solo gamer, how important is the story that the game tells or is it
- 1:07:24all about the juicy mechanical interactions. Okay, yeah, it's good to ask
- 1:07:29about solo gamer because a lot of people struggle with playing game solo because their
- 1:07:32approach. What they're wanting from the game experience is, you know, a
- 1:07:36competitive game experience, and so what they want of a solitaire game is a
- 1:07:41synthesized opponent. When I play game solitaire, usually what I'm looking for is
- 1:07:48a narrative experience. I want to be immersed into a topic. And so
- 1:07:54even if I'm not playing a solitaire game, I want to experience the story,
- 1:08:00even if I'm you know, wearing two different hats. And so one
- 1:08:04of the things I'm trying to do in that is, you know, get
- 1:08:09the narrative out of it and try to understand what happened or what could have
- 1:08:13happened. So to me, the narrative, the feel of the game is
- 1:08:17more important than the competitive experience. So I want to go on and talk
- 1:08:25about the future and I so you you've said that your job keeps you,
- 1:08:28keeps you busy, and has kept you away from designing. But do you
- 1:08:30have any games coming out in the future or do you have any aspirations to
- 1:08:35design something in the fho? Oh yeah, I have a huge file of
- 1:08:40things that could be but aren't. And I can't blame my job exclusively.
- 1:08:44That's a little unfair because I spend what little leisure time I do have,
- 1:08:48a lot of it goes into developing vassal modules for people. You know,
- 1:08:53if I would stop doing that, maybe I would have time to design a
- 1:08:56game or two. And so one day I hope to be able to do
- 1:08:59that. And so I'm primarily a game player, but I'm designing my first
- 1:09:08game at the moment. And after the first play test, it seemed to
- 1:09:12me that all game design really gives me is a massive sense of insecurity.
- 1:09:15But does what does game design give to you as opposed to playing? I
- 1:09:21think you nailed it a massive sense of inferiority. Designing a game, especially
- 1:09:29on a conflict or historical conflict, I think, is far more difficult than
- 1:09:32writing a book on that topic, because you have to be every bit as
- 1:09:35knowledgeable as an author of a book, while at the same time making it
- 1:09:41fun for the person experiencing your game. So it's an awful lot of work
- 1:09:46for not a whole lot of rewards. So make sure that the topic you're
- 1:09:49covering matters to you. And I see with people like David Thompson and with
- 1:09:59company like Full Circle Games, I see wargaming branching out, because it was
- 1:10:05always very much a niche sort of branching out into the broader hobby sphere.
- 1:10:12How optimistic, So firstly, do you think that is a good development?
- 1:10:15And secondly, how optimistic are you about the future of wargames? Yeah,
- 1:10:20you know this question has been asked as long as I've been playing games,
- 1:10:25Is this the end of the hobby? And I'm like, well, hasn't
- 1:10:29been so far, So I don't see it as a bad thing. I
- 1:10:32think that there's mechanics that the non war game strategy gaming world has that could
- 1:10:41be brought into the wargaming route. For example, I'm still waiting for a
- 1:10:45really good worker placement wargame, and I feel like there's been a few attempts
- 1:10:51that have flirted with that, but I haven't seen it happen yet. I
- 1:10:58mean, really happen at the end of the day. That Ship game,
- 1:11:01what it sees a thunder by GMT, is basically a massive worker placement game
- 1:11:05where you have fifteen hundred different workers that you're placing and then executing on a
- 1:11:11one hundred and twenty different spaces. I'm not sure that that works, but
- 1:11:16I admire that someone has kind of tried to do that. And then there's
- 1:11:20things that we do in the wargaming world that the non wargaming world's looking and
- 1:11:25says, hey, you know what, you know the CRT thing and these
- 1:11:30dice that these wargamers, maybe we could have that in our game. So
- 1:11:33there's a game that one of the guys in my church likes to play,
- 1:11:35and I really enjoy it. I like a good work replacement game, and
- 1:11:40this one uses dice and does it in a really clever way. And it's
- 1:11:44called stone Age. It's super fun. I love that game. It's one
- 1:11:48of my favorite games. He has in his collection, so I see that
- 1:11:53there's some cross pollination going on that's beneficial to the broader hobby as a whole.
- 1:12:01So your last game then is Great Battles of Alexander. So there's a
- 1:12:05The Great Battles series is quite extensive. Why is it this one in the
- 1:12:10Great Battle series? Yeah, this is the one to probably gravitate to the
- 1:12:13most. Just this might sound stupid, but I've read a lot of books,
- 1:12:18historical books, and Theodore Dodge's books on Alexander and his battles always had
- 1:12:24these old you know, there's a maps depicting the battle in the in the
- 1:12:28book itself, and I remember the first time I set this game up and
- 1:12:30I saw the battle on the on the map, I was like, man,
- 1:12:33this looks like one of the illustrations from one of the books I read,
- 1:12:38and this is so cool, And I was just gu's the one I
- 1:12:42played the most because the battles just look so cool when they're set up.
- 1:12:45I mean, everything goes to pieces and it looks chaotic within a few turns,
- 1:12:49but you know, when it's set up, it just looks so cool.
- 1:12:53And so that's that's one. I have just played the heck out of
- 1:12:57I really enjoy the GBOH series, but I feel like the battles in the
- 1:13:01Alexander set in particular, tend to be more competitive. Some of them are
- 1:13:08just you know, one sided blowouts and not all that interesting. So I've
- 1:13:13had to do some creative things to make it, you know, fun for
- 1:13:16the side that's going to lose. Alexander. I didn't have to do that
- 1:13:19as much with So Close. I want to say the GBH system because I
- 1:13:26would also probably try to take SPQR with me because those are the two games
- 1:13:30of that series I've played the most. And so what's so good about this
- 1:13:36Great Battle series? I think if you want a meteor experience than what commands
- 1:13:44and colors ancients will give you, the GBOH system will do that, and
- 1:13:48it'll show you kind of how the Romans fought and how their way of fighting
- 1:13:54was different than the Carthaginians, and how the Persian way of commanding your troops
- 1:13:59and field quite different from the command system that Alexander sat up. He didn't
- 1:14:03just have a weapon, he had a weapon system, he had a command
- 1:14:09system. And I think the system the game system that Richard Richard Bergen and
- 1:14:15Mark Herman developed models that in a compelling way. There's so much we don't
- 1:14:21know about ancient history, but what we think we know. I think that
- 1:14:26they've developed a game that will teach you quite a bit about that historic period.
- 1:14:35And so I've listened to many podcasts about Alexander the Great and it's an
- 1:14:44incredible story. I mean, how fascinating is Alexander as a character? Yeah?
- 1:14:49I think sometimes in some ways he might be overrated. He got an
- 1:14:55awful lot, you know, of good press in ancient times, and I
- 1:14:59don't think nearly enough credit is given to his father for because he basically took
- 1:15:04what his father developed and then ran with it. He didn't forge the weapon
- 1:15:11that he uses, He just used the weapon. I think there's just something
- 1:15:15about you know, that he was so young and achieved so much over such
- 1:15:18a short span of time. But he's also a reckless, reckless and flawed
- 1:15:25individual in a lot of ways that more more of the modern history historians are,
- 1:15:30you know, getting into the flaws of this Otherwise, you know,
- 1:15:35in ancient times, he's portrayed as a superhero, but we're seeing that he's
- 1:15:39a flawed superhero. And it's the flaws that make a character compelling. Then
- 1:15:45yeah, they make it makes him more human, more identifiable that maybe I
- 1:15:49could achieve a lot at a young age. I think it might be something
- 1:15:54about him that makes him more interesting as a character. So I've just got
- 1:16:00one more question then. So you're you're heading down the road to the cabin
- 1:16:05and you go around the corner and the back door of the car flyes open
- 1:16:09for the games fly out down ravine, which I'm sure there are loads of
- 1:16:14where you are into a river and a swept to posterity. Which game do
- 1:16:16you hope is sitting on the back seats of the car? Oh? Man,
- 1:16:23I would really hate to lose War the Room because I have that collector
- 1:16:27set you know, oh, the one that looks like a book. Yeah,
- 1:16:30oh, I'm very jealous. So I only break that one out on
- 1:16:36special occasions because it's, you know, it's really nice one. I would
- 1:16:41I would hate to lose that, just because every time you play War the
- 1:16:45Ring it's a different experience. It's immersive. So can never go wrong with
- 1:16:51talking. So if people want to play your games and stuff like that,
- 1:16:58how can they go about doing that? If people want to get like Navajo
- 1:17:02Wars or Commanchary I'm I'm not sure under studio. Yeah, question so if
- 1:17:05I mean, I'm not sure if you've got a great social media presence,
- 1:17:10oh gotcha or anything like that. But if people want to get hold of
- 1:17:12you, we'll play your games. How they go about doing that? Yeah,
- 1:17:16well, I'm not really on board game Meek so much anymore, not
- 1:17:19just because I just don't have a time for it. I maintain a presence
- 1:17:24on Twitter as pastor joelte and I think I'm also on Instagram as a pastor
- 1:17:31Jolt or something like that, and I've main I'm one of the moderators on
- 1:17:36GMT's Facebook forum, so I'm on their official group page quite a bit.
- 1:17:42To get my games, I think they're they're all in stock from GMT at
- 1:17:45least. Command Serie is supposed to be going to reprint soon, so it's
- 1:17:49going to be back in stock. But I'm pretty sure Navajo Wars is in
- 1:17:53stock and you can purchase it through them. It's also available on some secondhand
- 1:17:58markets if you want to pay less in retail. Excellent. Well, Joel
- 1:18:01Toppin, thank you very much. Yes, I was enjoy I enjoyed being
- 1:18:06with you, and yeah, this was fun. Thanks Ben. You can
- 1:18:10support the show in many ways. You can tell your friends, you can
- 1:18:12talk about it on social media. You can talk about it on your own
- 1:18:15blog, podcast, or video. You can support it directly by going to
- 1:18:16Patreon dot com, forward slash five g Ford for a rolling donation, or
- 1:18:20for a one off donation, hitting the PayPal link at the bottom of the
- 1:18:23website five Games for Doomsday dot com. It's these donations that keep the show
- 1:18:27going. Also, if you want to say something nice about the show,
- 1:18:30if you want to say something horrible about the show, you can contact me
- 1:18:31on Twitter at five Games for Doomsday or send me an email at five Games
- 1:18:35for Doomsday at gmail dot com. Nan, if I've managed to scramble away
- 1:18:40from the star spangled horror and three quarters of it, I'll see you in
- 1:18:44two weeks for another Five Games for Doomsday become like a big