Latest / Shiny New Object - a Marketing Podcast / Episode 279 / Caroline Cockell / Student Roost / Marketing Director
Transcript
- 0:00Caroline Cockell: This generation, they value
- 0:01authenticity. They value creativity and purpose. We need
- 0:06both security and sharpness of data, but also we need the
- 0:10nuance of our own instincts.
- 0:18Speaker: Are you a fitness loving foodie? Then defy snacks
- 0:20is for you. Defy offers real high quality chocolate you love,
- 0:23combined with functional ingredients, giving you as much
- 0:26as 26 grams of protein per bag. So you can be both a little bit
- 0:29bad and a little bit good at the same time as a female owned
- 0:33brand, defy dedicates a portion of its profits to other women
- 0:36owned businesses currently sold in the US. You can find us on
- 0:40defy with an eye snacks.com, and follow us on social at defy
- 0:44snacks.
- 0:51Tom Ollerton: Hello and welcome to the shiny new object podcast.
- 0:54My name is Tom Ollerton. I'm the founder of Automated Creative,
- 0:58the creative effectiveness ad tech platform, and this is a
- 1:01weekly podcast about the future of data driven marketing. And
- 1:05it's the absolute joy of mine to record this every week with one
- 1:09of the leaders in our industry who can help shed light on
- 1:12what's coming next, what is their shiny new object and why
- 1:15that is powerful for data driven marketing. I'm on a call with
- 1:20Caroline Cockell, who is marketing director at Student
- 1:24roost. So Caroline, for anyone who doesn't know who you are and
- 1:27what you do, could you give us a bit of background?
- 1:29Caroline Cockell: Of course, absolutely yes. Hi Tom. It's
- 1:31really, really great to be here talking to you. I would say I'm
- 1:36a career marketer. I have done nothing but marketing my entire
- 1:40career. I went to uni to study it, and did what a lot of us
- 1:43did, and started right at the bottom, essentially cold
- 1:46calling. I was trying to sell people video conferencing
- 1:49equipment. However, I have had the joy of working for some
- 1:54brilliant and diverse companies. I've worked in marketing roles,
- 1:58advertising roles, planning strategy. I've done a bit of
- 2:01agency side, a bit of client side, lots of client side, in
- 2:05fact. And I've worked in sectors such as travel, hospitality,
- 2:10FMCG, retail, I feel like I've done a bit of everything. I did
- 2:14a little bit of a stint as a consultant and a digital
- 2:17marketing trainer at one point as well, while my daughter was
- 2:19little so... but now I am director of marketing for
- 2:23student accommodation brand Student Roost, and I've been
- 2:26there for four years, and it's hugely exciting, because it's
- 2:32such a young, dynamic audience that we are obviously marketing
- 2:36to it. It makes for a very interesting job as a marketer.
- 2:40Tom Ollerton: And can you just give an overview of student
- 2:42roost for anyone who's like, not UK based and might not be
- 2:45familiar?
- 2:46Caroline Cockell: Yes, absolutely. So we are a it's
- 2:50known as purpose built student accommodation. So we effectively
- 2:54provide private halls for students. We've got 55
- 2:58properties across 20 cities, over 20 cities in the UK, and it
- 3:04is nothing like what student accommodation looked like when I
- 3:07was at university. These accommodations provide students
- 3:11with everything from gyms and cinema rooms and karaoke suites
- 3:16and lots of lots of kind of events and well being
- 3:20activities.
- 3:21Tom Ollerton: Are there karaoke suites, are you kidding?
- 3:23Caroline Cockell: I'm not kidding.
- 3:24Tom Ollerton: Because I was when you said it's nothing like uni,
- 3:26I was like, yeah, it's gonna be different. But karaoke is that?
- 3:30Is that necessary?
- 3:31Caroline Cockell: Honestly, it's wild. We're all about well
- 3:34being, it's all about having a fantastic time at university and
- 3:39being able to build connections and friendships, and that
- 3:43doesn't happen sitting in your ensuite bedroom. It happens when
- 3:47you're enjoying events with friends and meeting new people.
- 3:50So it's just such a huge part of uni life, isn't it? It's not
- 3:53just about the education, it's about it's about the
- 3:58relationships you build and the life skills you develop. So
- 4:00we're kind of all about that.
- 4:01Tom Ollerton: And what's it going to be like 20 years hence,
- 4:03if karaoke roomsare the norms now?
- 4:06Caroline Cockell: I dread to think.
- 4:08Tom Ollerton: Helicopter pads or something submarines.
- 4:11Caroline Cockell: We've literally just built one that's
- 4:13got a rooftop running track, so yeah, I mean, anything's
- 4:15possible.
- 4:16Tom Ollerton: So I'm really interested, and glad you did
- 4:21that, like hardcore phone based selling bit, you know, because
- 4:24it means that you've got that full understanding of everything
- 4:27from the kind of brand building top end marketing piece all the
- 4:31way through to the hard line rejection dealing with doing
- 4:37that phone stuff. So it's a really interesting and broad
- 4:40career there. But I'm curious to know, with the level of
- 4:43responsibility that you have, there gonna be times when you
- 4:46get overwhelmed. So how do you deal with that?
- 4:49Caroline Cockell: I mean, yeah, absolutely. I think we all get
- 4:52overwhelmed, and I don't even know that it comes with
- 4:54responsibility. I just think it comes with being human.
- 4:56Sometimes we are probably not good at saying no all the time.
- 5:01So for me, overwhelm comes from that feeling of really not
- 5:06knowing where to start. So if you've got a very long list of
- 5:10things that you've got to tackle, and you're staring at it
- 5:13and have no sense of where to begin, that's where the
- 5:16overwhelm kicks in. For me. And I find myself, if I don't, if I
- 5:21don't tackle it, I just work kind of frantically and jump
- 5:24from task to task, and I end up crawling to the weekend
- 5:28exhausted. And I think we can all relate to that feeling. But
- 5:31actually, it was weirdly becoming a mum that made me
- 5:33realize that there is a much better way when you're looking
- 5:36at somebody else's overwhelm and in the mind of a very busy,
- 5:41effervescent seven year old. When my daughter's overwhelmed,
- 5:44I know exactly what to tell her to do, and sometimes you've got
- 5:46to turn that on yourself. So the kind of things that I it's kind
- 5:52of three things, really. One is take yourself out of the
- 5:55situation. So when I am feeling overwhelmed, there is no point
- 5:58me just staring at the list, trying to figure out where to
- 6:00start and panicking. Take yourself out of the situation,
- 6:04change your scenery, go for a walk, make a drink, go and chat
- 6:08to your partner, if you're working from home or whatever
- 6:10that is, just walk away from it for a bit, and then when you do
- 6:14come back, I think, minimize distractions. So it's really
- 6:18important to tune back into what you were trying to achieve, and
- 6:20that's really hard when emails are popping up and teams is
- 6:24pinging and WhatsApp is going and LinkedIn messages are coming
- 6:27through, we're so available. In this day and age with all of the
- 6:31technology, I think you have to kind of close all your tabs and
- 6:36put yourself on Do Not Disturb and reprioritize, and once
- 6:39you've done that time blocking in your diary and stick to it,
- 6:43just create the space to, you know, tackle that reprioritized
- 6:48list without letting other things come and, you know,
- 6:52hijack your list and add more into it. And, yeah, it's funny
- 6:56that I only really learned this through helping my daughter
- 7:00through her own overwhelm. I think I've probably spent too
- 7:03long just trying to juggle everything and exhausting
- 7:05myself. So yeah, that's, that's, that's my top tips, I suppose.
- 7:09If you're feeling overwhelmed, how do you get back on track.
- 7:16Tom Ollerton: Right. So tell me more about how you do this with
- 7:19your daughter, like she's go look, just take yourself out of
- 7:23the situation, turn off the slack.
- 7:27Caroline Cockell: It's slightly different, isn't it? So my, my
- 7:30seven year old, is incredibly full of energy. She has a very,
- 7:33very busy little mind, and she can find it that very difficult
- 7:39just to focus on a task that she doesn't want to do, so that
- 7:44could be getting undressed, or it could be doing her homework,
- 7:47or whatever it might be. And the thing with her is that if I keep
- 7:51pushing, she will just get very overwhelmed and start screaming
- 7:54rather than doing what she needs to do, or she'll just kind of
- 7:58run away from it. And actually, it's that running away, that
- 8:00makes me think it's much better to take her out of the
- 8:03situation, do something she enjoys, with the promise that if
- 8:06she does this thing she enjoys for a second, then we'll come
- 8:09back and do what she's been asked, and she's much happier to
- 8:11do it then, because you kind of framed it and given it a little
- 8:14a little bit of a boundary. So yeah, there's a lot we can learn
- 8:18from our kids.
- 8:19Tom Ollerton: So I wonder if the kid analogy can help with the
- 8:23next question, which is, what is your bit of advice for data
- 8:28driven marketers that you find yourself sharing most often?
- 8:32Caroline Cockell: Okay, so this, for me, and it actually kind of
- 8:36links a little bit to what I was going to talk about later on as
- 8:39well, is that I think it's about mastering both the art and the
- 8:42science of marketing. I think it simply comes down to making sure
- 8:48that the science of collecting, analyzing data, doing the
- 8:53research, creating and testing hypotheses, and you have to
- 8:57balance that with the art that comes with intuition and
- 9:01interpretation and creativity and innovation. I think the
- 9:05challenge with marketing is always that we are dealing with
- 9:09human behavior, and it is not black and white. There are gray
- 9:12areas, there is nuance. And so to be a better data driven
- 9:17marketer, I think you have to get as comfortable with that
- 9:20nuance and the art and of marketing, as you are with the
- 9:24black and white of the data, we can find comfort sometimes in
- 9:27data, but what it doesn't necessarily do is immediately
- 9:31jump out at us with that kind of creativity, or that kind of
- 9:37there is that gray that we have to somehow find in all of that.
- 9:40So yeah, I think that is the secret to being a better data
- 9:43driven marketer. Get comfortable with the bits that you can't
- 9:46find in the data, too.
- 9:47Tom Ollerton: Brilliant. Okay, so your shiny new object is
- 9:52finding the intersection between data and instinct. So what do
- 9:59you mean by that? Why is that your shiny new object?
- 10:01Caroline Cockell: Okay, so it's something that I am really
- 10:04fascinated by, and I think it's become much more apparent the
- 10:08longer I've worked in this brilliant career we call
- 10:11marketing. So the intersection of data and instinct, it's why
- 10:16the balance is especially critical, particularly now when
- 10:21a lot of us are marketing to much younger generations that
- 10:24are much more savvy, I work for a student accommodation
- 10:28companies we've established, and my core audience are Gen Z, and
- 10:34I have become painfully aware of two things. One is that I am
- 10:39getting older and keeping up with this wonderful dynamic
- 10:43audience is getting much harder. And two, when it comes to this
- 10:48generation, they value authenticity, they value
- 10:51creativity and purpose. And I think that we need both the kind
- 10:57of security and sharpness of data, but also we need the
- 11:01nuance of our own instincts and getting the balance right in
- 11:06that is key, and that's where that art and science comes in
- 11:09that I was talking about a little bit earlier.
- 11:17Tom Ollerton: This episode of the shiny new object podcast is
- 11:21brought to you in partnership with madfest, whether it's live
- 11:24in London or streamed online to the global marketing community,
- 11:27you can always expect a distinctive and daring blend of
- 11:30fast paced content, startup innovation pitches and
- 11:33unconventional entertainment from madfest events. You'll find
- 11:36me causing trouble on stage, recording live versions of this
- 11:39podcast and sharing a beer with the nicest and most influential
- 11:43people in marketing. Check it out at www dot madfest
- 11:47london.com.
- 11:54So I love this tension between you yourself getting older, and
- 11:58you're dealing with this like endless supply of young people
- 12:01that's getting bigger and bigger, and you address the
- 12:05needs of authenticity and purpose from this audience. So
- 12:08how are you using data and instinct to make sure, as you
- 12:11get older, and they say the same age, that you are able to
- 12:14deliver your marketing with authenticity and purpose?
- 12:17Caroline Cockell: So that really gets into the kind of
- 12:19practicalities of this idea for me in that actually we need data
- 12:25to inform authenticity. That is absolutely true. They have a
- 12:29very keen eye for it. They do not want just personalized
- 12:33advertising. They want brands that align to their values. And
- 12:38I think that whilst the data can tell us lots about their
- 12:40preferences. I believe that it is our instinct that help us to
- 12:45navigate the kind of emotional, cultural, ethical nuances that
- 12:50resonate with the younger generation. So if we use the
- 12:53data to find the trends, but then we can use some of that,
- 12:57the gut and instinct to create messages that feel genuine. And
- 13:02I guess when I talk about kind of gut and instinct, I do feel
- 13:11like it's come from this idea that we have become a world
- 13:15that's quite kind of obsessed with data. And I think that
- 13:19instinct probably has a bit of a bad rep, because it isn't
- 13:23provable. And I'm not suggesting that we should rely on instincts
- 13:28alone, but I think instinct isn't like a mystical force. It
- 13:33comes from years of experience, the accumulation of knowledge,
- 13:39and it comes from an ability to empathize with our audience, and
- 13:43that empathy is really hard to find in the data. That's the
- 13:46gray. And I think so for me, in kind of trying to create
- 13:52authentic brand messaging or authentic brands, we have to be
- 13:57able to use that kind of human behavior and understanding of
- 14:01lived experiences that other people have had. To inject the
- 14:05data with the power of of our of our experience and our
- 14:09understanding of people.
- 14:11Tom Ollerton: There's so much stuff in there, and it reminds
- 14:13me of an interview that I did for a book that I'm writing on
- 14:17data and creativity with a lady called Tiffany Rolfe, who is the
- 14:21chief creative officer? I think something like that in RJ, in
- 14:25the US. And she said, as marketers or marketing people,
- 14:30we have a very limited data set, which is our own experience, as
- 14:35you say. But that data set gets bigger as you get older. I
- 14:39thought, brilliant. Of course, it does. So I thought that was
- 14:42quite a nice way of like referring to what you're you're
- 14:45talking about, and your gut instinct actually should get
- 14:49better as you get older, if you stay attuned to these cultural
- 14:53and emotional elements that you're talking about. But what I
- 14:56love is that you're talking about instinct comes from.
- 14:59Empathy. So if you're curious about your audience, you're
- 15:02curious about these cultural and, like, emotional shifts,
- 15:05then you will have a view of their experience become
- 15:09empathetic, and then you can actually make marketing comms
- 15:12that that talk to those things. So what I would love to know is
- 15:16that you have, like, an example of when you've done that, when
- 15:18you've taken data to identify trends and then done the gut
- 15:23driven piece to produce work that has worked.
- 15:26Caroline Cockell: Oh, absolutely. I mean, so when I
- 15:28first started where I'm working right now, I think that we'd,
- 15:35and I say we as a brand, the brand had got a little bit
- 15:37bogged down in the way things had always been done so
- 15:42relatively new sector actually, probably pbsa has only been
- 15:45around for 15 or so years.
- 15:47Caroline Cockell: Purpose built student accommodations only been
- 15:48Tom Ollerton: Sorry, what was that anagram?
- 15:49Tom Ollerton: What are the data sets that you use to make sure
- 15:51around for about 15 or so years, and so the the marketing sort of
- 15:55strategy was very much rooted in what we've always done, and
- 16:00there wasn't a lot of innovation going on. And one of the the
- 16:04kind of downsides to this was that it had become very
- 16:08promotionally driven, very kind of price driven. And again,
- 16:13understanding this audience that I'm talking to students Gen Z,
- 16:13you're on the right track with your your own data driven
- 16:17price is really important. They're very price sensitive. Of
- 16:19marketing? So I'm just curious to know, like as a business,
- 16:21course they are, but actually it is not top of their list when it
- 16:26comes to how they're making their decisions, because they
- 16:30expect more from their brands. And so for us, needing to find
- 16:35this emotional connection was the way that we were actually
- 16:39going to be able to sort of sell more efficiently, more
- 16:43effectively and and, you know, convince people to move from
- 16:48that kind of consideration list into the into buying what is a
- 16:52very High Value, complex purchase decision, they're
- 16:56effectively signing up to probably their first ever
- 17:00tenancy agreement. So it's a big decision, and so I could see
- 17:04that there actually wasn't a lot of data. There actually wasn't a
- 17:09lot to tell us what was actually making a difference. But what we
- 17:14knew from talking to customers was that actually they didn't
- 17:18have the why. They didn't understand why choose Student
- 17:22roost over somebody else. You've got accommodation available in
- 17:27in the same city by somebody else. What's the difference? And
- 17:31it became apparent that we needed to connect on an
- 17:35emotional level with this audience. And it's funny, just
- 17:39going slightly off, off track here or off piece with something
- 17:44that I was reading earlier this week, there was a great article
- 17:48on LinkedIn by the CEO of grocery insight, and it's been
- 17:52years since I've been in FMCG or retail now, but he was talking
- 17:57about Asda, and talking about how shopping Asda's isles, it's
- 18:01become overrun by branded promotional point of sale. So
- 18:05the ends of the aisles are covered in the supplier brands.
- 18:10And for me, that's an example of where on paper, more commercial
- 18:14money is propping up the sales, money from the suppliers, but in
- 18:19turn, it's turning off customers because they don't know why shop
- 18:24at Asda anymore, because there's very little of Asda left. It's
- 18:28just the brands on the shelves. And I found that really
- 18:33fascinating, because it's that it's that same premise, that
- 18:37it's very easy to get kind of caught up in the price element,
- 18:41especially when you're talking about a price sensitive
- 18:45audience. But it doesn't mean that that audience don't need to
- 18:50feel the why, the the why this brand. How does this brand
- 18:54connect to my values? And so, yeah, that's, that's kind of why
- 18:59this, this, this kind of is a constant questioning in my head.
- 19:03How do we always get back to the why? The kind of the purpose,
- 19:04what are the data points that are important to you to make
- 19:08the empathy with the audience?
- 19:13sure you're doing a good job?
- 19:24Caroline Cockell: It's really poignant at the moment because
- 19:27there is a lot of conversation in my sector, and I'm sure in
- 19:31many other sectors, about the sort of, maybe overspending in
- 19:36the bottom of the funnel, in kind of Google, PPC,
- 19:39particularly. And what we found over the last few years is the
- 19:44more that we've invested in our brand, the more that we have
- 19:48invested in communicating through a kind of video first,
- 19:52more emotional advertising approach and paired that with
- 19:56consideration marketing that kind of takes people on the
- 20:00journey to conversion, the less we need to spend at the bottom
- 20:05of the funnel to actually convert it. So the you know,
- 20:09we're spending a lot of time looking at, okay, we're getting
- 20:13lots of people to the website, but are they the right people?
- 20:17What is the quality of that traffic? Are they doing the
- 20:21right things on our website that show us that they have intent,
- 20:26and the more that we have invested in understanding our
- 20:30audience and driving the brand, the lower our CPA becomes.
- 20:34Tom Ollerton: So you've given me some practical examples of where
- 20:38instinct fits in. But given that this is your shiny new object, I
- 20:43would really love to know about any other examples where that
- 20:48data and instinct pieces work really well for you.
- 20:52Caroline Cockell: I think probably the real shining
- 20:55example here is around speed and agility. I think we've all been
- 21:00in a position where we're so so busy, kind of focused on the
- 21:04precision of trying to prove something that we might have
- 21:07missed an opportunity. And I think a good example of that,
- 21:10particularly when we're talking about this kind of world of
- 21:13social media, is that trends on social media come and go in the
- 21:18blink of an eye, and by the time the data tells us something is
- 21:21trending or something is working well for another brand, the
- 21:26moment's probably already passed, and actually that the
- 21:31instinct that's born out of experience becomes really
- 21:33crucial here, because it is your gut that's going to tell you
- 21:37that you should be jumping on a trend. Because before it becomes
- 21:40obvious before the data is telling you that it's getting
- 21:44lots of engagement, and it allows you to stay ahead of the
- 21:48curve and remain relevant. And so for me, this is where it
- 21:53really kind of supercharges the data that you have got, if you
- 21:57can bring in some of that experience to almost be the
- 22:02trend setter rather than the follower.
- 22:10Tom Ollerton: Yeah, that's nice, and it sort of ties back into
- 22:12that idea of the older you get, the more data you have in your
- 22:15own head. Whereas, like, if you've got a 20 year old social
- 22:19media person who's like, Oh, this is the trend. You're gonna
- 22:22jump on it, whereas with 20 years more experience, might go
- 22:25well, it is just that it is a trend, and we don't need to be a
- 22:28late follower of that thing. Then, as you say, you put it
- 22:31really nicely, set those trends, set those content trends, as
- 22:34opposed to following best practice.
- 22:36Caroline Cockell: Absolutely, that's it. And I think you know,
- 22:40you do? You do need to listen to your gut. You know, as marketing
- 22:44is a profession that inevitably comes with a certain amount of
- 22:50passion and creativity, and I think that, you know, we we
- 22:55should be listening to our instincts. I'm not saying we
- 22:58should be acting on every single one of them, because that's an
- 23:01oversimplification, really, but I think listen to your
- 23:04instincts. Be ready to back it up with data, you know, and if
- 23:09the data doesn't back it up yet, don't dismiss that gut, feel
- 23:12that intuition, turn it into a hypothesis and test it, because
- 23:17quite often it is born out of the years of experience that
- 23:20you've accumulated, and there's a reason that you your gut is
- 23:23telling you that this is something to go after.
- 23:26Tom Ollerton: Brilliant. Well, look, unfortunately, we are at
- 23:29the end of the podcast. I could talk about this all day, but
- 23:33I've got other jobs to do. So if someone's to get in touch with
- 23:36you about intuition and data or anything else that we've talked
- 23:39about today, parenting tips, perhaps, where's it? Where's a
- 23:43good place to reach out to you, and what makes a message that
- 23:46you will actually respond to?
- 23:48Caroline Cockell: Oh, do reach out to me on LinkedIn, for sure.
- 23:51And I am always interested in connecting with other marketers,
- 23:58people that are interested in marketing as an art and a
- 24:03science. So I think, yeah, sorry, that was probably not a
- 24:06great answer.
- 24:09Tom Ollerton: What was wrong with that? That's great,
- 24:11brilliant. Okay, well, we'll fortunate to leave you there and
- 24:15we'll see you all next week.
- 24:16Caroline Cockell: Thanks very much.
- 24:23Tom Ollerton: Music. Hi. Just before you go, I'd really
- 24:26appreciate it if you could take the time to write a review of
- 24:30the shiny new object podcast on Apple podcasts or iTunes, or
- 24:33whatever it's called these days, or whichever podcast provider
- 24:37you use. We're at any new podcast, so it would go a long
- 24:41way for us if you could just share the Word and give us a bit
- 24:43of a support on those channels. That'd just be fantastic. If you
- 24:46haven't got time. That's also cool. And yeah, if you could
- 24:49tell your colleagues about the podcast, and also, if possible,
- 24:53don't forget to subscribe. And I'd love to hear your feedback
- 24:56if you'd like to speak on the podcast or be a guest, or you.
- 25:00You think I'm asking the wrong questions. Anything? I'd be
- 25:02super interested to hear what you think. So please email me.
- 25:05Tom at, automated creative.net that's Tom at, I'm not going to
- 25:12bother spelling it anyway. You'll work it out. Thanks so
- 25:14much.