Latest / Deep Dive / Beyond Migration: Unlocking Australia's Hidden Talent
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine for a second that you're you're drafting a team of
- 0:03absolute All Stars. OK, I like where this is going.
- 0:06Right. So you spend years scouting,
- 0:09You're looking for the smartest, the most highly educated, just
- 0:13incredibly driven people from literally every corner of the
- 0:16planet. Only the top tier.
- 0:18Exactly. And you bring them all to 1
- 0:20country, you drop them right into the biggest, most
- 0:23economically dynamic cities. And then, and here's the kicker,
- 0:27you just bench a massive chunk of them.
- 0:29You just leave them on the sideline.
- 0:30Yeah, you just leave them sitting there.
- 0:32Specifically the women, by the way, and specifically the ones
- 0:35with, you know, specialized middle tier skills.
- 0:37Which is wild. It sounds completely absurd,
- 0:40right? Like, why would anyone do that?
- 0:41But that scenario is exactly what is happening in one of the
- 0:45world's most advanced economies right now.
- 0:47It really is a baffling contradiction, and the data
- 0:50we're looking at today to understand this comes from a
- 0:532023 OECD report. It's titled Regional
- 0:57Productivity, Local Labor Markets and Migration in
- 1:00Australia. Which is a bit of a mouthful.
- 1:03Yeah, it's a very academic title, but the data inside is
- 1:06incredible. It relies on this massive stack
- 1:09of information, primarily the OECD regional database, the
- 1:13municipal migrant database and the Australian Census.
- 1:17So we have a really solid foundation here.
- 1:19Totally. And visually, if you want to
- 1:21picture it, imagine this dynamic map of Australia, right?
- 1:24And it's layered with all these demographic heat maps.
- 1:27We're zooming all the way down from the vast Outback into
- 1:31really granular local labor markets.
- 1:33Right, because we're not just looking at states.
- 1:35Now, economists call these Essay 4 regions.
- 1:38Basically, they're areas defined by how people actually commute
- 1:41and live their daily lives, rather than just, you know,
- 1:44arbitrary political borders drawn on a map.
- 1:46I love that. OK, because if you're catching
- 1:48up on global talent trends, or if you're trying to understand
- 1:51the actual mechanics of brain gain, or honestly, if you're
- 1:54just insanely curious about how modern economies function, when
- 1:58you strip away all the political talking points, you are in the
- 2:00exact right place today. Definitely.
- 2:03Because while this data is focused entirely on Australia,
- 2:05Australia is like it's the ultimate global case study for
- 2:09this. It really is.
- 2:10What's happening there completely fractures our most
- 2:14basic foundational assumptions about education, about
- 2:18employment, and just how human capital integrates into a new
- 2:22country. So OK, let's unpack this.
- 2:24We have to start with the sheer, undeniable scale of the
- 2:28situation. Right, because the numbers are
- 2:29huge. They are massive.
- 2:31Australia is this incredible statistical outlier.
- 2:35In 2019, 30% of the Australian population was foreign born.
- 2:39Yep, almost one in three people. And you know, to put that 30%
- 2:42into perspective for you, the OECD average for foreign born
- 2:46populations across its member countries is just 14%.
- 2:49Wow. OK, so they're at more than
- 2:51double? More than double the average,
- 2:52Yeah. And if we look at the
- 2:53traditional major migrant receiving nations, they aren't
- 2:57even close to Australia like Canada is at 21%.
- 3:00Which feels high normally. Right, it does.
- 3:02Germany is at 16%. The United Kingdom and the US
- 3:05are both down at 14%. So who even beats Australia
- 3:08then? Anyone.
- 3:09Out of all the OCD countries, the only one with a higher share
- 3:12is Luxembourg. They're sitting at 47%.
- 3:15Oh well, OK. Luxembourg is tiny, though.
- 3:18Exactly, Luxembourg is this unique microstate with massive
- 3:22cross-border daily commuting. People live in France or Germany
- 3:25and work in Luxembourg. So for a large, sovereign,
- 3:28continent sized nation, Australia's numbers are just
- 3:31completely unprecedented. And it hasn't always been this
- 3:34high, has it? Like this wasn't the case 50
- 3:36years ago. No, no.
- 3:38The demographics have been radically engineered over a
- 3:41relatively short period. Back in the year 2000, that
- 3:43number was 23%. OK, so in less than two decades
- 3:47they added seven full percentage points.
- 3:50That is wild. It's massive.
- 3:52We are talking about fundamentally rewiring the cash
- 3:55flow and the human infrastructure of an entire
- 3:58nation. The report highlights that in
- 4:00just the 2016 to 2017 financial year alone, migrants generated
- 4:05112 billion Australian dollars in total personal income. 112
- 4:10billion. Yeah, which is 13% of the entire
- 4:12national income. So at what point if nearly one
- 4:16in three people in the country is from somewhere else, at what
- 4:19point does migrant policy simply become national economic policy?
- 4:24That's the exact right question. The line between the two has
- 4:27completely dissolved. They are one in the same now.
- 4:30So how did they get there? Because it couldn't have just
- 4:32been an accident. Definitely not.
- 4:34To understand how they got here, you really have to look at the
- 4:37historical evolution of Australian policy, because up
- 4:40until the 1970s, migration to Australia was almost entirely
- 4:44European. Right, the whole post war boom.
- 4:46Exactly. And the objective back then was
- 4:48incredibly blunt. It was just ensure constant
- 4:51population growth. Just get people in.
- 4:53Yeah, the philosophy was essentially just to get bodies
- 4:56into the country to build out this really sparse continent.
- 4:59But then the paradigm shifts. A massive shift over the last
- 5:02few decades, the government transitioned from driving that
- 5:05sheer population growth to operating a highly selective,
- 5:09surgically targeted visa system. The modern system is points
- 5:13based and it heavily relies on employer sponsored visas.
- 5:16It explicitly targets individuals with specific
- 5:19skills, qualifications and English language proficiency
- 5:22that the government deems immediately beneficial to the
- 5:25national and regional labor markets.
- 5:28OK, let's unpack the mechanics of that point system for a
- 5:31second, because I don't think most people realize how granular
- 5:34it gets. It isn't just like a lottery
- 5:37where you put your name in a hat and cross your finger.
- 5:39Oh, not at all. It is a rigorous audit of your
- 5:42human capital. An audit.
- 5:43I like that word for it. That's really what it is.
- 5:45An applicant is awarded points based on age, typically favoring
- 5:49individuals in their prime working years.
- 5:51So like 25 to 32. Because they have the longest
- 5:55runway to contribute to the tax base.
- 5:57Exactly. It's very calculated.
- 5:59You get points for your level of English proficiency.
- 6:02You get points for your educational qualifications,
- 6:04obviously with higher degree scoring more, but most
- 6:08importantly, you are assessed against a skilled occupation
- 6:11list. So if you're a registered nurse
- 6:14or a software engineer or a specialized mechanic and
- 6:17Australia has a projected shortage in that specific field,
- 6:21you get priority. Right.
- 6:23They're plugging specific holes in the economy.
- 6:24Yep. But if you have, say, an art
- 6:27history degree, no matter how brilliant you are, you simply
- 6:30won't accrue the necessary points unless an employer
- 6:33specifically sponsors you. It's so interesting.
- 6:36It's like looking at a corporate board.
- 6:38If you have a board of directors and a third of the members are
- 6:41external hires brought in specifically because of their
- 6:44resumes, they aren't just, you know, new additions hanging out
- 6:47in the background. No, they're running the show.
- 6:49Exactly. They are fundamentally defining
- 6:51the company culture and steering the corporate strategy and this
- 6:55economic targeting. It's completely changed the
- 6:57demographic makeup of the country too, right?
- 6:59Absolutely it has, because the selection is based on skills
- 7:02rather than geographic origin. Now the demographic have totally
- 7:06inverted. Today Asian born migrants
- 7:10constitute the largest group in almost every single state.
- 7:13Wow. Every state.
- 7:14Almost all of them in New South Wales, Victoria and the ACT.
- 7:19The ACT migrants from Asia make up over 50% of the local migrant
- 7:24population. That's a huge shift from the pre
- 7:261970s European wave A. Total shift, the old European
- 7:30dominant demographic, only really remains in places like
- 7:33Tasmania, where it sits at about 40%.
- 7:35OK, so if a country is bringing in this massive 30% influx of
- 7:40highly targeted talent, the next thing we have to figure out for
- 7:43this deep dive is where this talent is physically going.
- 7:47Because Australia is geographically massive, it's a
- 7:51continent. It is huge, yeah.
- 7:53But they aren't just spreading out evenly across the Outback or
- 7:56repopulating small rural towns, are they?
- 7:58Not even a little bit. They are heavily, heavily
- 8:00concentrated. Migrants overwhelmingly cluster
- 8:03in large metropolitan regions. Like which ones?
- 8:06We're talking about cities with more than 1.5 million people, so
- 8:09greater Brisbane, Melbourne, Perth, Sydney. 7 out of 10
- 8:14foreign born individuals in Australia live in these large
- 8:17metropolitan regions. Wait, 70% of all migrants are in
- 8:20the mega cities? 70?
- 8:21How does that compare to the people who were actually born in
- 8:24Australia? Well, only one out of two native
- 8:28born individuals live in those same large metros.
- 8:31So 50% of natives versus 70% of migrants.
- 8:35There's a wild skew. It is the clustering is so
- 8:38intense that in these large metropolitan regions, migrants
- 8:43make up 40% of the total local population. 4 out of 10 people.
- 8:47Four out of every 10 people you pass on the street in these
- 8:49cities were born in another country.
- 8:51And just for context, the OECD average for migrant share in
- 8:55large metro regions is just 15%. OK, so if they're all crammed
- 8:59into the cities, which means the flip side of this has to be a
- 9:02massive rural disparity. The contrast is incredibly
- 9:06stark. Only 18% of Australia's migrants
- 9:09live outside metropolitan areas and if you compare that to
- 9:12locals, 33% of native born Australians live outside those
- 9:15metros. And when we look specifically at
- 9:18designated remote regions, the migrant share drops to just 12%,
- 9:22while native born individuals make up 24%.
- 9:25So it halves. Exactly.
- 9:27And if we zoom into that essay, four data, those local commuting
- 9:30zones we talked about earlier, you see the extremes even more
- 9:33clearly. In primarily rural SA-4 regions
- 9:37in the southeast, the migrant share hovers around just 8%. 8%
- 9:41compared to 40% in the cities. Even higher in some places.
- 9:45In the highly urbanized SA 4 regions of Sydney and Melbourne,
- 9:49it spikes to over 50%. Over 50%.
- 9:52That's incredible. I want to visualize the
- 9:54mechanism behind this clustering for a second, because on paper,
- 9:58if you're looking at a spreadsheet, you might think why
- 10:01not move to a quieter area where housing is cheaper?
- 10:04Right, the cost of living argument.
- 10:05Exactly. But let's look at the reality of
- 10:08moving across the globe. If you, the listener, are
- 10:11packing up your entire life and moving to a country where you
- 10:13know absolutely no one, you are incredibly vulnerable.
- 10:17Extremely. Think of it like trying to start
- 10:19a fire. If you put one log in the middle
- 10:21of a frozen field, it's just going to sit there and freeze.
- 10:25But if you take that log and put it in a massive bundle of dry
- 10:28kindling where there's already a spark, it catches instantly.
- 10:31That is a great analogy. Economists actually referred to
- 10:34that bundle of kindling as agglomeration advantages.
- 10:37Agglomeration advantages, OK. Yeah.
- 10:39And it is the primary driver of these settlement patterns.
- 10:43When a highly skilled migrant arrives, they need a deeply
- 10:46diversified labor market. A rural town might have, you
- 10:49know, one major employer. Like an agricultural hub or a
- 10:52mine? Exactly.
- 10:53Maybe a mining operation, but if you are a specialized financial
- 10:57analyst or a biomedical researcher, there's simply no
- 11:01market for your labor there, right?
- 11:03The town doesn't need a biomedical researcher.
- 11:05Precisely. But a city with 1.5 million
- 11:08people that has a massive dynamic economy with dozens of
- 11:12sectors. It offers better job
- 11:14opportunities, higher wages and a deep talent pool that attracts
- 11:17multinational companies. And then of course those
- 11:20companies attract more migrants. It becomes this totally self
- 11:22reinforcing loop. But it's not just the corporate
- 11:24jobs, right? It's the human infrastructure,
- 11:27too, Like life outside of work. Oh, the human infrastructure is
- 11:31arguably just as critical. This is the concept of Co ethnic
- 11:34networks. Co, ethnic networks.
- 11:35Yeah, when a migrant drops their bags in a new country, they need
- 11:39immediate, highly specific knowledge.
- 11:42Like, how does the rental market work here?
- 11:44Which schools are good? Where can I find a grocery store
- 11:47that sells the specific ingredients I know how to cook
- 11:49with? Steph, you can easily Google if
- 11:51you don't know what you're looking for.
- 11:52Exactly. Large cities already have
- 11:55established communities. These networks provide informal
- 11:58job referrals, microlending within communities, and just a
- 12:01general buffer against the initial culture shock, which is
- 12:04huge. It's vital.
- 12:06Moving to a rural SA-4 region with an 8% migrant population
- 12:10means operating without any of that critical infrastructure.
- 12:13It's just too risky. OK, so the clustering makes
- 12:16complete logical sense. The mechanism is sound, The
- 12:18kindling is in the cities. But now we have to look at who
- 12:22these people actually are, because this is where the OECD
- 12:24data completely shatters the typical narrative around global
- 12:28migration. It really does.
- 12:30We are. Looking at a phenomena I want to
- 12:32call the education paradox. That's a perfect name for it,
- 12:35because the statistics on educational attainment here are
- 12:38truly remarkable if we connect them to the bigger picture.
- 12:43Australia has one of the highest educated migrant populations in
- 12:46the entire OECD. Let's get into the numbers.
- 12:49OK, looking at the core working age demographic, so individuals
- 12:54aged 25 to 64, almost 60% of the migrant population in Australia
- 13:00has attained A tertiary education.
- 13:02Wait, 60% have a university degree or higher?
- 13:04Yep. 60%. How does that compare to the
- 13:07native born population? The locals.
- 13:10Only about 40% of the native Australian population has
- 13:13attained tertiary education. Oh wow.
- 13:15And to give you a global baseline, only about 40% of
- 13:18migrants in other OECD countries are tertiary educated.
- 13:21So the education gap between migrants and locals in Australia
- 13:25is 20 percentage points. They are 20 points higher.
- 13:28A massive 20 percentage point difference in favor of the
- 13:31migrants. This is the largest gap of its
- 13:33kind in the OECD. It is not the normal global
- 13:36dynamic at all. Because usually it's the other
- 13:38way around, isn't it? Often, yes.
- 13:40If you look at continental Europe and the United States,
- 13:44the data shows that migrants there actually have lower
- 13:47average educational attainment than the native population.
- 13:50Australia has completely flipped the script.
- 13:52That is fascinating, and I'm assuming this applies to the
- 13:56bottom end of the education spectrum as well, like fewer
- 13:59people without high school diplomas.
- 14:00Yes, the data is inverted there too.
- 14:02Only 12% of Australian migrants have less than a secondary
- 14:05education. For the native born population,
- 14:08it's nearly 20%. So they are beating them at the
- 14:10top and they have fewer people at the bottom.
- 14:13Does this hold true across all those different SA-4 regions we
- 14:17talked about? Yeah, from the rural areas to
- 14:19the cities. It holds true everywhere, though
- 14:21the regional variations are pretty fascinating.
- 14:23The ACT. The ACT.
- 14:26Which is essentially the governmental hub of Camber,
- 14:28right? Exactly.
- 14:29The ACT has the highest share of tertiary educated migrants in
- 14:33the country at a staggering 77%. 77%.
- 14:38Almost 8 out of 10 migrants in that region hold advanced
- 14:40degrees. That is basically a whole city
- 14:43of PhDs and master's degrees. It really is now on the other
- 14:46end, WA has the lowest share in the country at 51%.
- 14:50OK, 51 percent is the lowest. Right, but the crucial context
- 14:53here is that even WA's lowest share of 51 percent is
- 14:58incredibly high by global standards.
- 15:00Right, because the OECD average is 40, so their worst region is
- 15:04still beating the global average by 11 points.
- 15:07Exactly. Now it makes sense that the ACT
- 15:09would be so high, given that government centers require
- 15:12armies of policy analysts and specialized consultants and
- 15:15legal experts. But what this really shows us is
- 15:18the raw effectiveness of that points based visa system we
- 15:21talked about earlier. It's working exactly as
- 15:23designed. Right.
- 15:24The government set the parameters, they demanded
- 15:26extremely high qualifications, and as a result they have
- 15:30engineered this deliberate brain game.
- 15:33They're actively draining the top tier talent from the rest of
- 15:36the world and depositing it into their own economy.
- 15:39It is a profound success in terms of importing human
- 15:42capital. They have built an incredibly
- 15:44deep bench of highly educated workers.
- 15:47Which brings us to the most jarring contradiction in this
- 15:50entire deep dive. There we go.
- 15:52Right? Because if a country
- 15:53successfully imports a population that is 20 percentage
- 15:57points more educated than the local population, and those
- 16:01brilliant minds are all clustering in the most
- 16:03economically dynamic mega cities.
- 16:06A 4% National Employment gap is weird, but I imagine it gets
- 16:11diluted in the aggregate. You would think so.
- 16:13If they're all clustering in Sydney and Melbourne, those
- 16:16cities must be absorbing them perfectly, right?
- 16:18They should be absolutely dominating those local markets.
- 16:21You'd think so, but that's where the data gets truly bizarre.
- 16:25In inner Melbourne, the gap isn't 4%, it's 17%.
- 16:29Wait. 17. Percent, 17%.
- 16:32There is a 17 percentage point penalty if you are a migrant in
- 16:36inner Melbourne, despite being part of the most educated
- 16:38demographic group in the entire country.
- 16:40That is exactly what the data reveals.
- 16:43Despite their vastly superior education levels, migrants in
- 16:47Australia have a lower overall employment rate than the native
- 16:50population. I just, I cannot wrap my head
- 16:53around that. Let's look at the national
- 16:54numbers again. So nationally, the native
- 16:56employment rate is 76%, while the migrant employment rate is
- 17:0072%. OK.
- 17:02So that creates the four point national gap.
- 17:04Right. But as you just noted, it is
- 17:06highly geographically skewed. The employment gap is at its
- 17:10absolute worst in the southeast of the country and in the large
- 17:14urban centers where the migrants are most densely clustered.
- 17:17How does that even happen? Is it just a mathematical supply
- 17:21issue? Like are there simply too many
- 17:23highly educated migrants flooding into one city, creating
- 17:26a bottleneck where there aren't enough high level jobs to go
- 17:29around? That is a really common
- 17:31assumption, but agglomeration economics usually dictate that a
- 17:35massive influx of talent creates jobs.
- 17:37Right, the kindling. Effect exactly when you cluster
- 17:40highly educated people, they start businesses, they innovate,
- 17:43they demand complex local services.
- 17:46The fact that inner Melbourne has a 17 point gap suggests a
- 17:49severe structural failure in integration.
- 17:51Something is broken in the machine.
- 17:53It's very broken. The local labor market is
- 17:55failing to absorb them at the rates their qualifications
- 17:59suggests they should be. And interestingly, the data
- 18:03notes that in only one out of five SA 4 regions do migrants
- 18:07actually have higher employment than natives.
- 18:10And where are those regions? These are mostly highly rural
- 18:13areas in WA, the NT and QLD. So let me get this straight.
- 18:18In the Outback, in the rural mining towns where there are
- 18:22hardly any migrants, they are actually out employing the
- 18:25locals, yes, but in the sophisticated mega cities where
- 18:29they specifically cluster to use their specialized degrees, they
- 18:33are trailing the locals. Massive.
- 18:34By 17 points in some places. This doesn't happen by accident.
- 18:37The system is fundamentally failing to utilize the very MVPS
- 18:42it just drafted. It represents a massive pool of
- 18:44untapped potential and, you know, to figure out exactly
- 18:47where the gears are grinding, we have to look much closer at the
- 18:50underlying demographics. Let's do it.
- 18:51Let's pull it apart. Because a 4% national gap is a
- 18:54blended average, when you pull it apart, you find this massive
- 18:57structural divide. We have to talk.
- 18:59About the gender divide here, because this is where the
- 19:01pipeline is really, really leaking.
- 19:04It is. The employment gap is incredibly
- 19:06skewed by gender. When economists isolated the
- 19:10data for men, the native migrant employment gap almost entirely
- 19:14vanished. Really.
- 19:15How close is it? It is just .5 percentage points.
- 19:19Native men and migrant men are employed at virtually the exact
- 19:22same rate. So the male migrants are
- 19:24integrating into the workforce exactly as the visa system
- 19:27intends, yeah. Florida State, which means
- 19:30migrant women are bearing almost the entire statistical weight of
- 19:33this gap. Oh wow.
- 19:35For women, the native migrant employment gap is massive.
- 19:39It is over 8 percentage. Points.
- 19:41Eight points just for the women. Just for the women, and this
- 19:44holds true in almost every single essay 4 local labor
- 19:47market across the country. There are only a few highly
- 19:50rural exceptions, like the wheat belt in WA and the Outback in
- 19:54Queensland. Everywhere else, the gap is
- 19:56overwhelmingly driven by females.
- 19:59So if these highly educated women are stepping out of the
- 20:01workforce, it makes me wonder. What the actual friction point
- 20:06is like, are they applying for all these jobs and facing
- 20:09systemic discrimination at the interview table?
- 20:11Because if so, that is a catastrophic failure of the
- 20:15corporate sector. That is a crucial distinction to
- 20:17make, and the data clearly states that the root cause of
- 20:20this gap is not higher unemployment.
- 20:22Wait, it's not unemployment? No.
- 20:24It is lower labor force participation.
- 20:26OK, let's unpack the exact mechanics of those two terms for
- 20:29the listener. No, because they sound
- 20:31interchangeable. You know, unemployment versus
- 20:33participation. But economically, they paint
- 20:35entirely different pictures. They are completely different
- 20:38metrics. The unemployment rate strictly
- 20:41measures the percentage of people who do not have a job but
- 20:44are actively searching for one. Right.
- 20:46To be counted as unemployed, you have to be in the arena.
- 20:49You are sending out resumes, you are attending interviews.
- 20:52You are available to start work immediately.
- 20:55You want to work, but the market is rejecting you.
- 20:58Exactly now. The labor force participation
- 21:01rate, however, measures the percentage of individual who are
- 21:05either employed or actively looking.
- 21:07It's a whole pool of potential workers.
- 21:08Yes, if you are not actively looking for a job, say if you
- 21:13are a full time parent, if you went back to school, or if you
- 21:17simply got so frustrated by the friction that you stopped
- 21:19trying, you drop out of the labor force entirely.
- 21:22You're just gone from the stats. Right.
- 21:24You are no longer counted in the unemployment statistics because
- 21:27you aren't participating. So migrant women aren't just
- 21:30getting rejected at higher rates at the interview table, they're
- 21:32actively stepping out of the formal labor market.
- 21:35Or perhaps they're never even entering it when they arrive.
- 21:38That's what the number suggests, yeah.
- 21:40The data shows that migrant women's participation rate
- 21:43hovers between 66 and 69%. OK.
- 21:46And Native women. Native women's participation
- 21:48rate is between 73 and 77%. That's a huge difference.
- 21:52It is that massive gap in participation is the engine
- 21:56driving the overall employment disconnect.
- 21:58Think about the sheer amount of human capital sitting on the
- 22:01sidelines here. The visa system targets the
- 22:05smartest, most highly educated women from across the globe.
- 22:09They go through this rigorous, highly competitive points
- 22:12process. They beat out thousands of other
- 22:14applicants. Exactly.
- 22:15They uproot their lives, they arrive in these dynamic cities,
- 22:18and then they exit the formal economy.
- 22:21Why? What is the actual economic
- 22:24mechanism keeping them out? The economic literature points
- 22:27to a highly complex, interlocking web of friction
- 22:30points. The most immediate one,
- 22:32honestly, is the staggering cost of childcare in major
- 22:35metropolitan areas like Sydney and Melbourne.
- 22:38Childcare. Of course, it always comes back
- 22:39to childcare. It really does for a native born
- 22:42family. Childcare costs are often offset
- 22:44by an informal extended family network.
- 22:47You have grandparents, aunts or uncles who can watch the kids a
- 22:50few days a week. Right, you have a village.
- 22:51Exactly. But migrants, by definition,
- 22:53usually arrive without that extended family infrastructure.
- 22:56Right. If you are a migrant couple
- 22:58moving from, say, Mumbai to Sydney, you are on on your own.
- 23:01Completely on your own. So when you run the sheer
- 23:04economic math of a migrant family deciding if both parents
- 23:08can afford to work, the cost of full time formal child care in a
- 23:12major city can completely wipe out a second income.
- 23:15It just doesn't make financial sense to work.
- 23:17Right, it becomes economically unviable for the second earner,
- 23:21who, due to entrenched global gender norms, is
- 23:24disproportionately the woman to participate in the labor force.
- 23:28So it's this brutal combination of urban economics and a total
- 23:32lack of human infrastructure. Yes, and that is compounded by
- 23:35cultural expectations regarding traditional gender roles that
- 23:38some migrants might bring with them.
- 23:41And then there's a systemic lack of recognizing foreign
- 23:44credentials which creates an immense psychological and
- 23:46financial barrier to re entry. And that credential issue
- 23:50perfectly transitions us to the next massive layer of friction
- 23:54because if these highly educated women, and men to a lesser
- 23:57extent, but mostly women, are stepping out of the workforce,
- 24:00it makes me wonder if a tertiary degree even matters.
- 24:02Is there something fundamentally wrong with how their specific
- 24:05education is being valued in the local labor market?
- 24:08What's fascinating here is what economists refer to as the
- 24:11credential trap. The credential trap.
- 24:14The data reveals that the employment gap isn't uniform
- 24:17across all education levels. It varies wildly depending on
- 24:21the specific tier of education a migrant holds.
- 24:24OK, breakdown the tiers for us. Where is the trap?
- 24:27Let's start at the very top and the very bottom.
- 24:30For highly tertiary educated workers, those with advanced
- 24:34university degrees, master's, pH, DS, the employment gap
- 24:38between natives and migrants is only three percentage points.
- 24:41OK. So that's relatively small.
- 24:43Very small, and for those at the very bottom, the below secondary
- 24:46educated workers, the gap is slightly higher at 5 percentage
- 24:50points. So the people with advanced
- 24:52degrees and the people who didn't finish high school are
- 24:54integrating reasonably well. They are, but then you look at
- 24:57the middle. The middle.
- 24:58For secondary educated workers, so those who finished high
- 25:01school or have middle tier vocational training and
- 25:03specialized certifications, the employment gap explodes to a
- 25:07massive 9 percentage points. 9 points Why does the middle
- 25:11struggle the most? You would think middle tier
- 25:14skills are exactly what a growing economy needs to
- 25:17function day-to-day. It comes down to the economic
- 25:19friction of transferability. Think about high level tertiary
- 25:23skills, advanced computer coding, biochemical research,
- 25:27structural engineering. Universal skills.
- 25:29Exactly. The laws of physics, the syntax
- 25:32of Python, and the mathematics of structural load are identical
- 25:35in Mumbai, London and Sydney. Those skills transfer across
- 25:39borders almost seamlessly. The local employer knows exactly
- 25:42what they're getting. Right.
- 25:44And what about the below secondary tier?
- 25:45Why is their gap only five points?
- 25:47Low tier manual labor also transfers seamlessly.
- 25:50Moving boxes in a logistics warehouse, picking fruit in an
- 25:53agricultural hub, or performing basic custodial work.
- 25:57It requires physical effort, but it doesn't require a deep,
- 26:00nuanced understanding of local regulatory environments.
- 26:03You can arrive on a Monday and be fully productive by Tuesday.
- 26:06Exactly, but the middle tier. Those secondary educated skills
- 26:10are highly, highly context dependent.
- 26:13Give me a concrete example of a context dependent skill.
- 26:16What are we talking about here? Think about an office manager or
- 26:20a local electrician, or a specialized middle management
- 26:24role in human resources. OK, an HR manager from another
- 26:27country knows the specific labor laws, tax codes, and cultural
- 26:32norms of vendor negotiation in their home region.
- 26:35A local electrician knows the specific safety regulations,
- 26:39building codes and wiring standards of their home country.
- 26:42Oh, I see. When they move to Australia,
- 26:44none of that knowledge applies. The skills simply do not
- 26:48transfer across. Borders.
- 26:49The knowledge is deep, but it's entirely local.
- 26:52It's like a universal travel adapter.
- 26:54What do you mean? Well, if you have a high end,
- 26:56extremely expensive laptop, that's our tertiary education,
- 26:59right? It has a smart power brick.
- 27:02It automatically senses and adjusts to the voltage anywhere
- 27:04in the world. You just plug it in and it
- 27:07works. OK, I like.
- 27:08This and if you have a simple cheap flashlight, that's our
- 27:10below secondary education. It just takes standard
- 27:13batteries. You can buy those anywhere.
- 27:14It always works. But if you have a complex local
- 27:18kitchen appliance, maybe a high end blender built very
- 27:22specifically for a 110 Volt outlet in the US, that's our
- 27:26secondary education. Oh, that's perfect, because it
- 27:28simply won't plug into a 220 Volt Australian wall without
- 27:32short circuiting. Exactly.
- 27:33It'll fry the machine. To make it work you need a
- 27:35heavy, expensive transformer. And in economic terms, that
- 27:39Transformer is bridging courses, relearning local building codes,
- 27:43getting local safety certifications, and rebuilding a
- 27:46professional network from absolute scratch.
- 27:49That is the exact mechanism of the friction.
- 27:52The middle tier requires massive retraining and overcoming heavy
- 27:56institutional barriers. And that's expensive and time
- 27:58consuming. Very And often that friction is
- 28:01just too high. The cost of going back to a
- 28:03technical school just to prove you know how to do a job you've
- 28:06already been doing for 10 years is daunting.
- 28:08Many migrants look at that hurdle, they do the math, and
- 28:11they simply give up. They just step out of the
- 28:13workforce. Right, that is what drives that
- 28:15massive 9 point employment gap for secondary educated migrants.
- 28:19OK, let's zoom out a bit. We have covered incredible
- 28:23ground here. We've talked about the sheer
- 28:25scale of 30% migration, the intense clustering in megacities
- 28:30fueled by agglomeration and Co ethnic networks and this massive
- 28:3420 point education advantage we've.
- 28:35Had a lot of data. We have, and we've also dug deep
- 28:39into the structural failures, the female participation
- 28:42pipeline leaking brilliant talent through childcare
- 28:45economics and the credential trap paralyzing middle tier
- 28:48workers, right? I think the obvious question now
- 28:51for anyone listening is what is the ultimate economic outcome
- 28:56with all this friction, all these hurdles and all this
- 28:58talent just sitting on the sidelines.
- 29:00Does bringing in this massive population actually boost the
- 29:02bottom line of these regions? That is the ultimate question
- 29:05for any economic policy, and the data from the OECD is
- 29:09unambiguous. Ambiguous, really.
- 29:11Yes, despite the employment gaps, despite the lower
- 29:14participation, and despite the agonizing friction of the
- 29:17credential trap, Australian regions with higher shares of
- 29:20migrants tend to have significantly higher overall
- 29:23productivity levels. Wait, really?
- 29:25Yeah, it actually works, even with all the broken gears.
- 29:28It works definitively. The raw data shows that A1
- 29:32percentage point higher share of migrants in the local population
- 29:36is associated with higher labor productivity of roughly 1490
- 29:41Australian dollars per worker. Let me make sure I heard that
- 29:44right. You add just 1% more migrants to
- 29:47a region and every single workers productivity leaps by
- 29:50almost 1500 bucks. That is the raw association,
- 29:54yes. That's incredible.
- 29:55It is but, and this is a big but, as an economist you have to
- 29:59be careful with raw data because, as we established
- 30:02earlier, migrants are highly educated and they intentionally
- 30:06seek out agglomeration advantages.
- 30:08Right, they go to the places that are already doing well.
- 30:10Exactly, they purposefully move to areas that already have
- 30:13dynamic, highly educated wealthy economies.
- 30:16We have to adjust the data to account for that skill bias to
- 30:19ensure we aren't just seeing a self fulfilling prophecy of
- 30:22smart people moving to rich places and taking credit for the
- 30:25wealth. Right.
- 30:26You have to isolate the actual pure impact of the migration
- 30:29itself, stripping away the baseline wealth of the city.
- 30:32Exactly. But here is the amazing part.
- 30:35Even after economists adjust the data completely, accounting for
- 30:38the differences in the skill composition of workers across
- 30:41all these regions, that correlation remains incredibly
- 30:44strong. What does the number drop to?
- 30:46It roughly halves, dropping to 780.
- 30:50AUD So even when you rigorously subtract the skill bias, the
- 30:54pure act of bringing in migrants is still associated with a
- 30:57massive raw economic boost of $780 per worker to the region's
- 31:02bottom line. Yes.
- 31:04How does that wealth actually generate though?
- 31:05How does adding people expand the pie rather than just slicing
- 31:09it thinner? It is entirely driven by what
- 31:11economists call positive spillovers.
- 31:13Positive spillovers. Yes, when you inject a highly
- 31:16educated migrant into a local economy, they don't just occupy
- 31:19a desk, they change how the desk operates.
- 31:23Let's look at a concrete scenario.
- 31:24Imagine a migrant structural engineer joins an Australian
- 31:27construction firm in Melbourne. She brings a completely
- 31:30different methodology for stress testing materials that she
- 31:33learned in Singapore. OK, a new way of doing things.
- 31:36Right. And let's say that methodology
- 31:37saves the firm 10% on raw materials.
- 31:40Which instantly makes the firm more profitable.
- 31:42Exactly, and because the firm is more profitable, they can now
- 31:45afford to hire two more native born junior engineers to take on
- 31:49a new project. Oh, I see.
- 31:50Furthermore, that migrant engineer It's housing.
- 31:53She buys groceries at local markets.
- 31:56She goes out to local restaurants.
- 31:58Her presence increases the aggregate demand for local goods
- 32:01and services, which stimulates job creation in sectors entirely
- 32:05unrelated to engineering. She's expanding the economic
- 32:08capacity of the entire ecosystem.
- 32:10Precisely diverse problem solving frameworks make native
- 32:13born workers more efficient. New methodologies spark local
- 32:17innovation. Migration increases both the
- 32:20supply of highly stilled labor and the demand for local output.
- 32:24It's a win, win. It is they create wider
- 32:27localized social and economic benefits that lift the aggregate
- 32:31productivity of the entire Essay 4 region.
- 32:34You know, to me, this is the ultimate aha moment of this
- 32:38entire deep dive. It really is.
- 32:39Because even with the devastating friction of the
- 32:42credential trap, even with the female participation gap forcing
- 32:46highly qualified women to stay home.
- 32:49Even with the localized blenders short circuiting in the foreign
- 32:52outlets. How was all of that?
- 32:53The net result of engineering this dense, diverse, highly
- 32:57educated talent pool in your cities is a wealthier, vastly
- 33:02more productive region. The friction doesn't negate the
- 33:04benefit at all, it just highlights how much more
- 33:07potential is still locked away in those labor markets.
- 33:10It reveals that as remarkably successful as the policy has
- 33:13been at generating wealth and driving productivity, the
- 33:16ceiling is actually much, much higher.
- 33:17We aren't even close to this ceiling.
- 33:19Not even close. If those integration frictions,
- 33:21the child care infrastructure, the credential Transformers can
- 33:23be solved, the economic engine would run exponentially hotter.
- 33:27So let's bring this all together for the listener.
- 33:30Australia has managed to engineer something most
- 33:33countries only dream of, a massive, highly educated migrant
- 33:37population that makes up 30% of the country, aggressively
- 33:41clustered in economic Megan cities.
- 33:43Yep, they have drafted the absolute MVPS of global talent.
- 33:47And while those migrants Dr. Massive productivity spillovers
- 33:50and billions in personal income, deep structural mysteries
- 33:54remain. Which we've explored today.
- 33:56Right. We have this jaw-dropping 20
- 33:58point education advantage over the local population that
- 34:01somehow bafflingly results in lower overall employment.
- 34:06And we've seen that this disconnect is driven by a leaky
- 34:08pipeline of female labor force participation tied to urban
- 34:12economics and the stark non transferability of middle tier
- 34:15secondary education skills. The adapters are broken.
- 34:18Exactly. The smart power bricks work
- 34:20seamlessly, the cheap batteries work everywhere, but the local
- 34:22adapters are failing. It is a labor market defined by
- 34:25profound, frustrating contradictions, but ultimately
- 34:28profound economic success. Which leaves us with a final,
- 34:31rather provocative thought to Mull over.
- 34:34If Australia is successfully importing the absolute smartest,
- 34:37most educated workers in the world, but they are still
- 34:40leaving so much of that talent, especially female talent, on the
- 34:44sidelines, it begs a critical question for the future of
- 34:47global economics and how we measure success.
- 34:50Are we measuring integration completely wrong?
- 34:53The data certainly suggests that our current metrics are entirely
- 34:56too simplistic. If we only measure integration
- 34:59by looking at a binary chart whether someone simply has a
- 35:02job, rather than whether they have a job that actually
- 35:05utilizes their 20 point educational advantage, are we
- 35:08masking a massive global brain waste right under our noses?
- 35:11It's a huge blind spot. Think about it, if a world class
- 35:14structural engineer who developed new methodologies in
- 35:17Singapore moves to Melbourne but the credential friction is too
- 35:20high, she might end up driving a ride share on a traditional
- 35:24economic report she counts as employed.
- 35:27The chart looks great. The chart looks fantastic.
- 35:29The government Pats itself on the back for a high employment
- 35:32rate. But is she truly integrated, or
- 35:36is the global economy losing out on immense, unmeasured potential
- 35:41because we are satisfied with the illusion of employment
- 35:44rather than actual utilization? When you look closely at the
- 35:47diagnostic data, you realize the traditional metrics won't show
- 35:51you that fracture. The landscape beneath the
- 35:53surface is infinitely more complex.
- 35:55It is, and that is exactly why we have to keep questioning the
- 35:58data, keep looking past the clean binary charts, and keep
- 36:01trying to understand the actual human friction that drives our
- 36:04economies. Thank you so much for joining us
- 36:06on this deep dive into the hidden Gears of the Australian
- 36:08labor market. Keep questioning, keep learning,
- 36:10and we will catch you next time.