Latest / Bloomberg Law / Florida's Strict Abortion Ban & Google Deletes Data
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 1: Florida's very conservative Supreme Court upheld the state's fifteen week
- 0:14Speaker 1: abortion ban, which now allows one of the nation's strictest
- 0:18Speaker 1: abortion bans to take effect on May first. In the state.
- 0:22Speaker 1: It makes abortion illegal after six weeks, before most women
- 0:26Speaker 1: know they're pregnant. But in a sort of split decision,
- 0:30Speaker 1: the court allowed a referendum that will let the state's
- 0:33Speaker 1: voters decide in Florida whether they want an amendment to
- 0:37Speaker 1: the state constitution allowing abortion until viability. With abortion now
- 0:42Speaker 1: on the ballot in Florida, Democrats are seeing a chance
- 0:45Speaker 1: to flip the state in the presidential election. The future
- 0:48Speaker 1: Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump, who often boasts about appointing
- 0:53Speaker 1: three of the justices who voted to overturn Roe v. Wade,
- 0:57Speaker 1: didn't want to talk to reporters about the Florida to ruling,
- 1:03Speaker 1: while President Joe Biden denounced the Florida ruling, calling it
- 1:07Speaker 1: outrageous and promising to codify Roe v.
- 1:10Speaker 2: Wade and as mag officials are calling on and not
- 1:13Speaker 2: for a national ban on the right to choose in
- 1:15Speaker 2: every state I promise you for the Democratic Congress, Tom
- 1:19Speaker 2: and I will make Rovy Wade the law of the
- 1:21Speaker 2: land again.
- 1:22Speaker 3: I promise.
- 1:24Speaker 1: Joining me is healthcare attorney Harry Nelson of Nelson Hardiman
- 1:28Speaker 1: Harry tell us about the Florida Supreme Court's decisions on Monday.
- 1:32Speaker 4: Then the repeal of Roe v. Wade in the DABS case.
- 1:36Speaker 4: Florida had had in place a fifteen week ban on
- 1:40Speaker 4: abortion that Governor Discentis proposed while the Supreme Court decision
- 1:45Speaker 4: was pending. In twenty twenty three, a much more restrictive
- 1:49Speaker 4: six week ban was passed by the Florida legislature, but
- 1:53Speaker 4: the Florida Supreme Court had briefly delayed its going into
- 1:58Speaker 4: effect while looked at the question of whether there was
- 2:00Speaker 4: a constitutional right to privacy that included a right to
- 2:04Speaker 4: abortion in Florida. And so what happened this week is
- 2:07Speaker 4: that the Florida Supreme Court essentially ruled by a four
- 2:10Speaker 4: to three vote that a proposed constitutional amendment that would
- 2:15Speaker 4: guarantee the right to abortion that it could go to
- 2:18Speaker 4: the ballot. But at the same time, it essentially did
- 2:22Speaker 4: not find that the existing state constitution included a protection
- 2:27Speaker 4: of the rights to abortion as part of the privacy right.
- 2:29Speaker 4: So in other words, the Florida Supreme Court basically allowed
- 2:33Speaker 4: the new six week band to go into effects, but
- 2:36Speaker 4: it also decided to allow the voters of Florida to
- 2:40Speaker 4: decide whether to amend the constitution. So we have these
- 2:43Speaker 4: kind of parallel decisions that are extremely confusing about how
- 2:47Speaker 4: Florida is grappling with abortion.
- 2:49Speaker 1: Yeah, because they didn't have to issue the decisions on
- 2:52Speaker 1: the same day. Do you think that they were trying
- 2:54Speaker 1: to placate the supporters of abortion or just that they
- 3:00Speaker 1: were even handed.
- 3:01Speaker 4: I mean, I do think they're wrestling with both their
- 3:05Speaker 4: personal beliefs about, you know, how far the right of
- 3:08Speaker 4: privacy extends. And we can see that it's a very
- 3:11Speaker 4: conservative court, you know, that was six to one in
- 3:14Speaker 4: finding that there was this right to ban abortion, but
- 3:18Speaker 4: at the same time recognizing that the ultimately, you know,
- 3:21Speaker 4: the constitutional process of Florida allows for the voters to
- 3:25Speaker 4: change the constitution. So I think they were trying to
- 3:28Speaker 4: sort of find a pass through that both expressed their
- 3:32Speaker 4: personal beliefs about how far abortion rights and privacy rights
- 3:37Speaker 4: go and also acknowledged, you know that there is a
- 3:40Speaker 4: process in place for their personal judgments being overridden by
- 3:44Speaker 4: the voters.
- 3:45Speaker 1: So the privacy clause in the Florida Constitution states, quote,
- 3:49Speaker 1: every natural person has the right to be let alone
- 3:52Speaker 1: and free from governmental intrusion into the person's private life.
- 3:56Speaker 1: How is that not protective of abortion rights? Right?
- 4:01Speaker 4: Obviously, we've had a number of state supreme courts that
- 4:04Speaker 4: have found that part of the right to privacy right,
- 4:08Speaker 4: which is really something that was not recognized until the
- 4:11Speaker 4: last sort of one hundred and twenty one hundred and
- 4:14Speaker 4: forty years, but did the right to privacy includes the
- 4:16Speaker 4: right to be left alone from the government and to
- 4:18Speaker 4: have personal autonomy over all kinds of choices, including healthcare choices,
- 4:23Speaker 4: including the right of a woman to terminate a pregnancy.
- 4:27Speaker 4: So we definitely have seen many many supreme courts, state
- 4:31Speaker 4: supreme courts take this issue on and find that implied rights.
- 4:34Speaker 4: And of course we also have a number of state
- 4:37Speaker 4: supreme courts that have either explicitly said so California did that,
- 4:41Speaker 4: Michigan did that, and a handful of restrictive states that
- 4:44Speaker 4: said our constitution absolutely does not include it. I mean,
- 4:48Speaker 4: I think this question of the right to privacy has
- 4:51Speaker 4: been a kind of a question that hasn't been fully
- 4:54Speaker 4: resolved globally. Right there still are seemed to be tensions
- 4:57Speaker 4: on both sides about how far how far go than
- 5:00Speaker 4: about the competing right of the unborn child on one
- 5:02Speaker 4: side and the rights of a pregnant woman on the
- 5:05Speaker 4: other side.
- 5:06Speaker 1: My favorite part of this that is facetious. A majority
- 5:10Speaker 1: of the justices said the voters didn't understand that the
- 5:14Speaker 1: privacy clause extended to abortion when they added to the
- 5:18Speaker 1: state constitution in nineteen eighty.
- 5:21Speaker 4: Yeah, it's I mean, it's really interesting, right, like privacy.
- 5:25Speaker 4: I don't know how they come to that decision. Obviously,
- 5:27Speaker 4: privacy is a much broader set of rights, about the
- 5:32Speaker 4: right to be you know, not monitored and have your
- 5:35Speaker 4: life intruded on, about the right to travel, and about
- 5:38Speaker 4: the right to live in the way that you want.
- 5:39Speaker 4: So I think it's confusing to understand how they came
- 5:43Speaker 4: to this, you know, definitive conclusion that abortion wasn't explicitly
- 5:47Speaker 4: contemplated or somehow was outside of privacy. As I said,
- 5:52Speaker 4: we already had multiple state supreme courts who have found
- 5:55Speaker 4: the opposite, And so how they sort of determined what
- 5:58Speaker 4: was in the mind of Florida voters is a mystery
- 6:00Speaker 4: to me.
- 6:01Speaker 1: And also in twenty twelve, Florida voters rejected an amendment
- 6:05Speaker 1: that would have exempted abortion from constitutional privacy protection. So
- 6:10Speaker 1: there were all kinds of indications they overturned decades of
- 6:13Speaker 1: legal precedent with this decision, didn't they? Because back in
- 6:18Speaker 1: nineteen eighty nine the Florida Supreme Court ruled that it
- 6:22Speaker 1: did apply to abortion.
- 6:23Speaker 4: Yeah, so they absolutely reversed that. And this was obviously
- 6:27Speaker 4: a major shift from the Florida Supreme Court's own previous
- 6:30Speaker 4: rulings on the state constitutional privacy right. It has not
- 6:33Speaker 4: escaped noticed that. I believe all but one of the
- 6:37Speaker 4: justices on the Supreme Court currently are appointees of the
- 6:40Speaker 4: current governor, who's taken a much more conservative position on this.
- 6:45Speaker 4: But yeah, clearly this is a major shift from the
- 6:49Speaker 4: way that the Florida Constitution was understood by its own
- 6:52Speaker 4: Supreme Court for a long time.
- 6:53Speaker 1: Does the argument they use that the past abortion cases
- 6:57Speaker 1: had been wrongly decided based on this overbroad interpretation of
- 7:01Speaker 1: the privacy clause in a state constitution, Is that similar
- 7:05Speaker 1: to the argument that the Supreme Court made in overturning
- 7:09Speaker 1: Row well, it's.
- 7:10Speaker 4: Look, in the case of the US Supreme Court decision
- 7:13Speaker 4: and the Federal Constitution, we do not have a explicit
- 7:17Speaker 4: right to privacy right. So in the US Constitution, over
- 7:21Speaker 4: a series of cases involving things like contraception and the
- 7:25Speaker 4: right of an interracial couple to marry, and the decision
- 7:28Speaker 4: over gay marriage, we had the Supreme Court of the
- 7:31Speaker 4: United States wrestling with finding a right to privacy. The
- 7:35Speaker 4: famous language was in the penumbra, meaning like sort of
- 7:38Speaker 4: hidden away or implied in the Fourth Amendment right of
- 7:42Speaker 4: the Bill of Rights the Federal Constitution to be free
- 7:44Speaker 4: from search and seizure and onreasonable government intrusion. So here
- 7:48Speaker 4: in the case of Florida, we have a much more
- 7:50Speaker 4: explicit reference to privacy right. Most of the state constitutions
- 7:54Speaker 4: were written at a much later period where privacy was
- 7:58Speaker 4: already an explicit concept. So in some ways there was
- 8:01Speaker 4: more room for conservative justices at the federal level to
- 8:05Speaker 4: question whether previous Supreme Court justices had gone too far
- 8:09Speaker 4: and been too aggressive in reading in a privacy right
- 8:13Speaker 4: and implying it without even the word privacy there. But
- 8:16Speaker 4: this is a more aggressive decision because privacy is very
- 8:20Speaker 4: clearly part of this state constitution, and it's hard to
- 8:24Speaker 4: see how a right to determine the management of a pregnancy,
- 8:28Speaker 4: including to terminate it, is not an essential part of privacy.
- 8:32Speaker 4: But obviously these justices appear to have been moved by
- 8:35Speaker 4: the sort of competing interest of the embryo of the fetus,
- 8:40Speaker 4: you know, of the privacy rights other than the rights
- 8:42Speaker 4: of the mother. So I think that's where this decision
- 8:45Speaker 4: comes down. But it's clearly more aggressive and more conservative
- 8:48Speaker 4: than the US Supreme Court's decision in my view.
- 8:51Speaker 1: And Harry, why is the sixth week ban able to
- 8:54Speaker 1: go into effect now that they've ruled on the fifteen
- 8:56Speaker 1: week ban?
- 8:58Speaker 4: I mean, this was a decision of the Florida legislature, right,
- 9:01Speaker 4: So when Governor Destantis proposed and the Florida Legislature enacted
- 9:05Speaker 4: the fifteen week ban, it appears that they chose that
- 9:08Speaker 4: time period because that was the law that was from
- 9:10Speaker 4: Mississippi that was before the Supreme Court. They tried to
- 9:13Speaker 4: match that law so that if that law stood, they
- 9:16Speaker 4: could pass it. And that law went into effect in
- 9:18Speaker 4: July of twenty twenty two, a few weeks after the
- 9:21Speaker 4: Supreme Court decision. But it became clear that the trend
- 9:25Speaker 4: among pro life advocates was for a much more restrictive time. Obviously,
- 9:30Speaker 4: those weeks between six and fifteen are massive difference. So
- 9:33Speaker 4: they came back. The Florida legislature came back and passed
- 9:37Speaker 4: a much more restrictive law. And the only reason it
- 9:39Speaker 4: hadn't gone into effectings was because of this older Florida
- 9:43Speaker 4: Supreme Court rulings that there was a right to privacy
- 9:46Speaker 4: here that prevented it. So it required the Florida Supreme
- 9:50Speaker 4: Court to come back revisit the issues you know in
- 9:53Speaker 4: this week, I mean make a different decision really to
- 9:56Speaker 4: revise their understanding of privacy so that the six week
- 9:59Speaker 4: ban could take effect and few.
- 10:02Speaker 1: Women realize that they're pregnant at six weeks.
- 10:06Speaker 4: Right, The difference between six weeks and fifteen weeks in
- 10:09Speaker 4: a woman realizing that she's pregnant, let alone making a
- 10:12Speaker 4: decision about whether to carry the pregnancy or whether to
- 10:16Speaker 4: terminate it is obviously those are crucial, crucial weeks. As
- 10:21Speaker 4: you say, you know, the likelihood is that many women
- 10:24Speaker 4: will not even realize that they're pregnant, let alone comes
- 10:28Speaker 4: to that kind of a decision in that time period.
- 10:31Speaker 4: So this is something that is it's practically a ban
- 10:34Speaker 4: on abortion when you make the time period that short.
- 10:37Speaker 1: And this decision has an effect outside Florida because it
- 10:41Speaker 1: was a place where women seeking abortions in other states
- 10:46Speaker 1: with more restrictive abortion laws came to get an abortion.
- 10:51Speaker 5: Yeah.
- 10:51Speaker 4: Absolutely, the whole issue of having Florida as a at
- 10:55Speaker 4: least still somewhat permissive jurisdiction for women who moved, you know,
- 11:01Speaker 4: with alacrity, who could move fairly promptly to come and
- 11:04Speaker 4: travel to the state was a good option for all
- 11:07Speaker 4: of the adjacents Southeastern states. I do think that this
- 11:10Speaker 4: decision is yet another driver for that those women that
- 11:15Speaker 4: will lead towards more use of medication and telemedicine. And
- 11:20Speaker 4: you know, I think this pressure will take away the
- 11:23Speaker 4: travel option to Florida at least until this the voters
- 11:26Speaker 4: of Florida have a chance to decide about whether to
- 11:29Speaker 4: sort of re it in state a longer option. And
- 11:31Speaker 4: I think it will move more people, more women to
- 11:34Speaker 4: utilize telemedicine and utilize medication which can be shipped into
- 11:38Speaker 4: the state, you know, whether the states approve of it
- 11:41Speaker 4: or not.
- 11:41Speaker 1: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Lawn Show. I'll continue
- 11:44Speaker 1: this conversation with healthcare attorney Harry Nelson, and we'll talk
- 11:48Speaker 1: about that ballot measure on abortion, which Florida voters will
- 11:52Speaker 1: decide on in November. I'm June Grasso. When you're listening
- 11:55Speaker 1: to Bloomberg. Florida Supreme Court issued to rulings on abortion
- 12:01Speaker 1: on Monday. One will allow the states six week abortion
- 12:04Speaker 1: band to go into effect, while the other will let
- 12:07Speaker 1: voters decide on a proposed ballot measure in November that
- 12:11Speaker 1: will protect access to abortion up until viability, which is
- 12:15Speaker 1: considered to be around twenty four weeks into pregnancy. Abortion
- 12:19Speaker 1: on the ballot could have major political implications. In every
- 12:23Speaker 1: state where abortion rights have appeared on the ballot, the
- 12:27Speaker 1: side of abortion rights has won, including in conservative states
- 12:31Speaker 1: like Kentucky, Ohio, and Kansas. I've been talking to healthcare
- 12:35Speaker 1: attorney Harry Nelson of Nelson Hardiman Harry. The ballot measure says,
- 12:40Speaker 1: in part that no law shall prohibit penalized delay or
- 12:44Speaker 1: restrict abortion before viability or when necessary to protect the
- 12:49Speaker 1: patient's health, as determined by the patient's healthcare provider. It's
- 12:54Speaker 1: pretty broad, isn't it.
- 12:56Speaker 4: Yeah, the ballot measure basically has the concept of fetale
- 13:00Speaker 4: ability built in, which I believe is understood to extend
- 13:03Speaker 4: to over twenty weeks, so essentially allowing women in the
- 13:07Speaker 4: first two trimesters more or less to have the option
- 13:11Speaker 4: of abortion. So it is a fairly broad and liberal ruling.
- 13:15Speaker 4: It would essentially give definitely a period of at least
- 13:18Speaker 4: eight plus the maybe nine weeks longer than the fifteen
- 13:22Speaker 4: week option, which is something that the pro choice advocates
- 13:26Speaker 4: have been wanting just to give women more time to
- 13:30Speaker 4: make choices. So yeah, it's a fairly liberal, permissive constitutional
- 13:35Speaker 4: amendments that will be before Florida voters on the ever ballot,
- 13:39Speaker 4: and it will be interesting to see how that plays
- 13:41Speaker 4: out alongside the presidential election and all the other really
- 13:46Speaker 4: very important decisions that Florida voters have to make this year.
- 13:48Speaker 1: Well, Republican lawmakers are arguing that it will allow abortions
- 13:53Speaker 1: late in pregnancy.
- 13:54Speaker 4: It's absolutely true. I mean, look, when going back to
- 13:57Speaker 4: the medication abortion option for a minute. You know, the
- 14:00Speaker 4: the approval for mes apristone, which we were talking about
- 14:03Speaker 4: only a couple of weeks ago when Spreme Court heard
- 14:05Speaker 4: argument only is allowed to be used up to eleven weeks.
- 14:08Speaker 4: So this is definitely certainly a much broader issue, and
- 14:11Speaker 4: you know, it'll be interesting to see how voters react.
- 14:14Speaker 4: I think that it does seem that in the vast
- 14:16Speaker 4: majority of places, a majority of voters support more permissive
- 14:20Speaker 4: abortion rights. But the question of whether the language here
- 14:23Speaker 4: is broader than will attract the majority will be interesting
- 14:26Speaker 4: to see.
- 14:27Speaker 1: Well. The three female dissentis appointees on the Court dissented
- 14:32Speaker 1: on the ballot measure due to concerns that the impact
- 14:35Speaker 1: of the amendment was far greater than what voters will
- 14:38Speaker 1: be led to believe at the ballot box. They really
- 14:41Speaker 1: don't give much credence to voters. They act like voters
- 14:45Speaker 1: don't understand what's right in front of them.
- 14:47Speaker 4: Yeah, it's an interesting point. Look, I think we've seen
- 14:50Speaker 4: that voters in states like Kansas have really given a
- 14:54Speaker 4: rebuke to extremely conservative positions taken by their legislators, by
- 15:00Speaker 4: same court jurists in those states. Personally, I have more
- 15:03Speaker 4: faith in the in the voters to make themselves heard,
- 15:06Speaker 4: and we've seen that when these issues go to the
- 15:08Speaker 4: ballot box, there's far more support and it's harder for
- 15:13Speaker 4: either side frankly to engage in legislative gamesmanship or the
- 15:17Speaker 4: sort of take advantage of headcounting on particular courts to
- 15:21Speaker 4: get their way. And so from my perspective, I think
- 15:24Speaker 4: it's a good thing that we're going to the voters,
- 15:26Speaker 4: but obviously not everybody.
- 15:27Speaker 1: Feels that way, and I have to get sixty percent
- 15:30Speaker 1: for it to pass. So now, abortion rights groups in
- 15:33Speaker 1: several states are trying to put measures on the ballot,
- 15:36Speaker 1: and anti abortion groups have deployed a wide range of
- 15:40Speaker 1: tactics to keep proposals off the ballot, including challenging the language.
- 15:47Speaker 4: Yeah, it's very interesting the way that popular referendu you
- 15:51Speaker 4: know that voter initiatives have become a threat to the
- 15:54Speaker 4: pro life movement and to advocacy for more restrictive abortion laws.
- 15:59Speaker 4: And it just know the extent to which the idea
- 16:01Speaker 4: of restricting women's choices and women's rights to reproductive healthcare
- 16:06Speaker 4: access is just fundamentally unpopular and not something that the
- 16:10Speaker 4: majority of Americans want, and yet something that has succeeded
- 16:14Speaker 4: by virtue of you know, this whole legal effort in
- 16:17Speaker 4: the courts and legislatures. And so its ironic in a
- 16:21Speaker 4: way that the most democratic process we have, which is
- 16:24Speaker 4: to let voters decide at the ballot box, is now
- 16:27Speaker 4: the threat to the same people, and it definitely should
- 16:30Speaker 4: give pause to anybody who really thinks that the issue
- 16:33Speaker 4: here has political support. You know that in Republican politics nationally,
- 16:38Speaker 4: we've now seen several cycles in which excessive restriction of
- 16:42Speaker 4: abortion has been politically unpopular and costly in numerous elections,
- 16:47Speaker 4: and so it's surprising that we continue to see this
- 16:50Speaker 4: resistance to acknowledging and honoring the will of the voters
- 16:55Speaker 4: to have some level of abortion protection and access the
- 17:00Speaker 4: reproductive healthcare choices available. And it seems like it's a
- 17:03Speaker 4: decision to try to restrict this beyond what voters want
- 17:06Speaker 4: is having a political cost that was continuing to see
- 17:09Speaker 4: play out for.
- 17:10Speaker 1: Helping him speaking about the costs of going too far
- 17:14Speaker 1: in the case that got national attention where a woman
- 17:18Speaker 1: in Texas was charged with murder, arrested, and spent three
- 17:22Speaker 1: days in jail in twenty twenty two after health officials
- 17:26Speaker 1: reported her to authorities for attempting to terminate her pregnancy.
- 17:30Speaker 1: She's now suing the Star County District Attorney's office for
- 17:34Speaker 1: more than a million dollars, claiming the fallout from the
- 17:37Speaker 1: case has changed her life forever.
- 17:40Speaker 4: Lazelle Gonzalez, she's doing the prosecutors now, saying that they
- 17:44Speaker 4: knowingly misrepresented the fact in order to arrest her and
- 17:48Speaker 4: charge her, and that they caused significant harm to her.
- 17:54Speaker 4: That's quite a fascinating case about sort of how local
- 17:59Speaker 4: prosecutors may have gone much too far in the way
- 18:02Speaker 4: that they really made the spectacle of this poor woman
- 18:06Speaker 4: having her spend time in jail, publishing her mugshot in
- 18:09Speaker 4: the paper, I mean, putting her private medical information into
- 18:13Speaker 4: the newspapers. And so, you know, just another chapter in
- 18:17Speaker 4: this is our case where she is now going after
- 18:20Speaker 4: them and essentially alleging that they violated her rights in
- 18:24Speaker 4: the way that they went after her for criminal liability
- 18:26Speaker 4: for her decision to take medication abortion. So it's just
- 18:32Speaker 4: yet another example of this like crazy back and forth,
- 18:35Speaker 4: chaotic situation wherein where literally, you know, a private healthcare
- 18:39Speaker 4: choice that this woman made led to such an extreme reaction,
- 18:44Speaker 4: and the.
- 18:44Speaker 1: District attorney was investigated by the state bar of Texas
- 18:48Speaker 1: over his handling of the case, and they reached a
- 18:51Speaker 1: settlement so that his office could continue prosecuting cases. The
- 18:55Speaker 1: settlement conditions included a twelve hundred and fifty dollars fine
- 18:59Speaker 1: and a year year long probation of his legal license.
- 19:03Speaker 1: He told the Associated Press, I made a mistake in
- 19:06Speaker 1: that case. We'll see if that translates into money damages
- 19:10Speaker 1: for Gonzalez. Thanks so much, Harry. As always, that's Harry
- 19:13Speaker 1: Nelson of Nelson Hardiman. Let's turn out to some surprising
- 19:17Speaker 1: admissions today in Fifth Circuit oral arguments over the Texas
- 19:21Speaker 1: law known as SB four that authorizes state officials to arrest, detain,
- 19:26Speaker 1: and deport non citizens who enter the country illegally. Joining
- 19:31Speaker 1: me is Bloomberg, Texas legal reporter Madelein Meckelberg. Was the
- 19:34Speaker 1: State of Texas on the defensive in these arguments.
- 19:38Speaker 5: They definitely were. They knew coming into the arguments today
- 19:41Speaker 5: that they were facing an uphill battle. This same three
- 19:45Speaker 5: judge panel of the Fifth Circuit just last week had
- 19:48Speaker 5: ruled to block this law while they consider the full appeal.
- 19:52Speaker 5: So I think what we saw from Texas today was
- 19:55Speaker 5: a more nuanced position on what they'd be willing to
- 19:58Speaker 5: accept from the court. At one point, remarkably, we heard
- 20:02Speaker 5: the Texas Solicitor General suggests that perhaps Texas had gone
- 20:07Speaker 5: too far in trying to pass this statute right, and
- 20:11Speaker 5: that they'd be willing to if the court decided that
- 20:14Speaker 5: they wanted to block the law from going into effects,
- 20:16Speaker 5: they asked that they still let some provisions of the
- 20:19Speaker 5: measure go into effect, specifically one that would let the
- 20:22Speaker 5: state order the removal of people who they've identified as
- 20:25Speaker 5: being here illegally.
- 20:26Speaker 1: What part of the law did they think went too far?
- 20:29Speaker 5: Well. The way that he framed that idea was that
- 20:32Speaker 5: Texas crafted this statute as a whole with the intention
- 20:36Speaker 5: of going right up to the line of what Supreme
- 20:38Speaker 5: Court precedent has allowed up to this point, which, as
- 20:42Speaker 5: I'm sure you and your listeners know, is basically one
- 20:45Speaker 5: hundred and fifty years of the federal government being the
- 20:48Speaker 5: one responsible for immigration enforcement and the border. And so
- 20:52Speaker 5: Texas was trying to take as much authority as possible
- 20:55Speaker 5: with this statute while not running afoul of that precedent,
- 20:59Speaker 5: because they knew that this law would get challenged in
- 21:01Speaker 5: the courts and that they'd end up here right now.
- 21:04Speaker 5: But it seemed that Texas was willing to allow the
- 21:07Speaker 5: court to temporarily put on hold. So that's important to
- 21:10Speaker 5: note too, Like the conversation that's happening right now is
- 21:13Speaker 5: all over a preliminary injunction. This is not the last
- 21:15Speaker 5: word on the matter. But they seemed okay for now
- 21:19Speaker 5: for most of the statute to be blocked by the
- 21:22Speaker 5: court if they could keep on the books that provision
- 21:24Speaker 5: that would let them remove people.
- 21:26Speaker 1: How did the judges on the Fifth Circuit on the
- 21:30Speaker 1: panel react to that?
- 21:32Speaker 5: It was a little bit like deja vous since it
- 21:34Speaker 5: was the same three judges that had heard this case
- 21:36Speaker 5: a few weeks ago. We had Judge Andrew Oldham, who
- 21:40Speaker 5: was the one that was clearly in support of this
- 21:43Speaker 5: law and thought it should go into effects. He had
- 21:45Speaker 5: a lot of questions and concerns for the DOJ attorney
- 21:48Speaker 5: that was there, asking about whether the court had the
- 21:51Speaker 5: authority to block this law in totality before it's been
- 21:54Speaker 5: allowed to go into effect. But the other judges were
- 21:57Speaker 5: a little more quiet. Judge Erma Ramirez hardly spoke at
- 22:00Speaker 5: all during the hearing, but we know that she previously
- 22:04Speaker 5: wanted to block the law. And I think the swing
- 22:06Speaker 5: vote here that everyone's paying attention to is Chief Judge
- 22:09Speaker 5: Priscilla Richmond, she has been on the fence in the past.
- 22:13Speaker 5: She did rule in favor of blocking the law previously.
- 22:17Speaker 5: In this case, she raised some of the same concerns
- 22:20Speaker 5: today that she did in that opinion, which is basically
- 22:23Speaker 5: this idea that President up to this point has been
- 22:26Speaker 5: that immigration is the responsibility of the federal government.
- 22:30Speaker 1: And just explain what happened last week when this same
- 22:35Speaker 1: three judge panel made a decision.
- 22:38Speaker 5: So this case has been bouncing back and forth between
- 22:42Speaker 5: the courts, and in doing so, the courts of let
- 22:45Speaker 5: the law go into effect, block the law, let it
- 22:47Speaker 5: go into effect. Last week, this same three judge panel
- 22:50Speaker 5: of the Fifth Circuit, they basically said that they were
- 22:53Speaker 5: going to allow a district court order blocking the law
- 22:57Speaker 5: to remain in effect while they paid the full appeal
- 23:01Speaker 5: of that order. So what we heard today were arguments
- 23:04Speaker 5: on the merits of the case, the appeal of the
- 23:07Speaker 5: district judge ruling. Previously, all they were doing was deciding
- 23:11Speaker 5: whether or not the law should go into effect while
- 23:14Speaker 5: they weigh this case.
- 23:15Speaker 1: And this case already went to the Supreme Court. Tell
- 23:17Speaker 1: us what happened there.
- 23:18Speaker 5: When the case got to them. They said it was
- 23:20Speaker 5: too early for them to get involved. Because the Fifth
- 23:23Speaker 5: Circuit had not issued a stay pending appeal, They issued
- 23:28Speaker 5: an administrative stay to hang the decision while they decided
- 23:32Speaker 5: on a stay pending appeal while they decided the appealed.
- 23:36Speaker 1: Congratulations, I'm keeping all that straight. I see that the
- 23:40Speaker 1: Chief Judge, who most people do say is the swing
- 23:44Speaker 1: vote here, towards the end of the argument, emphasized that
- 23:49Speaker 1: states aren't permitted to remove non citizens, and the Supreme
- 23:53Speaker 1: Court decided that striking down an immigration law in Arizona
- 23:57Speaker 1: in twenty twelve. Quote it's on the books. So did
- 24:01Speaker 1: she appear to be leaning against this law?
- 24:04Speaker 5: I would say so, and that language is coming basically
- 24:08Speaker 5: directly from the order they issued last week on this
- 24:11Speaker 5: and the Arizona decision is key here, and it's what
- 24:15Speaker 5: the US government has been turning to frequently in arguing
- 24:18Speaker 5: against letting this law go into effect. But I think
- 24:21Speaker 5: that per point also raises a bigger question here that
- 24:24Speaker 5: I think a lot of people have, which is, how
- 24:27Speaker 5: is Texas actually going to enforce this law? This is
- 24:30Speaker 5: something they talked about today, and that removal proceedings specifically
- 24:34Speaker 5: because people who come to the country have certain rights
- 24:36Speaker 5: of asylum. There's processes in place from the federal government,
- 24:40Speaker 5: and it's not clear at this point how this Texas
- 24:44Speaker 5: law might impact federal immigration enforcement activities that are ongoing,
- 24:48Speaker 5: and that's something that I think Judge Richmond appeared concerned
- 24:51Speaker 5: about today too.
- 24:53Speaker 1: It appears that the writing is on the wall, but
- 24:55Speaker 1: we'll see. Thanks Madeline. That's Madeline Meckelberg, Bloomberg, Texas Legal
- 24:59Speaker 1: reporter coming up next. Why Google is deleting billions of
- 25:03Speaker 1: data records. This is Bloomberg. Google has agreed to delete
- 25:08Speaker 1: billions of records containing personal information collected from more than
- 25:12Speaker 1: one hundred thirty six million people in the US who
- 25:15Speaker 1: surfed the Internet through its Chrome web browser. It's part
- 25:19Speaker 1: of a settlement in a class action lawsuit accusing the
- 25:23Speaker 1: search giant of illegal surveillance. The lawsuit accused Google of
- 25:27Speaker 1: tracking Chrome user's Internet activity even when they had switched
- 25:31Speaker 1: the browser to the incognito setting that's supposed to shield
- 25:35Speaker 1: them from being shadowed by Google. The details of the
- 25:39Speaker 1: deal emerged in a court filing on Monday, more than
- 25:42Speaker 1: three months after Google and the attorney's handling the class
- 25:45Speaker 1: action case disclosed they had resolved the June twenty twenty
- 25:49Speaker 1: lawsuit targeting Chrome's privacy controls. Consumers represented in the class
- 25:54Speaker 1: action lawsuit will not receive any damages or any other
- 25:58Speaker 1: payments in the settlement. Joining me is data privacy expert
- 26:02Speaker 1: Austin Chambers, a partner at Dorsey and Whitney. For those
- 26:06Speaker 1: who are not familiar, tell us about the incognito browsing
- 26:11Speaker 1: mode on Google.
- 26:13Speaker 3: Google. It has the Chrome browser, and through the Chrome Browser,
- 26:15Speaker 3: it has several settings and pug up into the corner
- 26:18Speaker 3: there's the incognito mode. It's a very popular thing. I
- 26:21Speaker 3: think many people use it thinking that they're protecting their privacy.
- 26:24Speaker 3: It basically what it does is it's a tool that
- 26:27Speaker 3: Chrome makes available, and many other browsers have similar sorts
- 26:29Speaker 3: of functions. It doesn't store cookies in your browser, it
- 26:32Speaker 3: doesn't store your browsing history. So many people use this
- 26:35Speaker 3: if they just want to again sort of hide their
- 26:37Speaker 3: browsing history on a device that's maybe shared among the
- 26:40Speaker 3: family or something along those lines.
- 26:42Speaker 1: So the suit that was filed in twenty twenty, what
- 26:45Speaker 1: did it accuse Google of?
- 26:48Speaker 3: So the original suit claimed that this incognito mode was
- 26:51Speaker 3: essentially deceptive. So when users begin to use they start
- 26:55Speaker 3: a session in incognito, they would see this character. They
- 26:59Speaker 3: called him a spy. It looked like he was hidden
- 27:02Speaker 3: behind sunglasses with a little hat. They've made these disclosures
- 27:05Speaker 3: that stated that you're not being tracked, that your session
- 27:07Speaker 3: will be private, and that Google wouldn't collect any information
- 27:10Speaker 3: about you. The problem is that as people go about
- 27:13Speaker 3: the Internet, really all incognito does is prevent your browser,
- 27:17Speaker 3: that instance that you have installed on your computer of Chrome,
- 27:20Speaker 3: from collecting data about your browsing history. And it made
- 27:23Speaker 3: delete some of the cookies. But what it wasn't doing
- 27:26Speaker 3: was blocking other of Google's technologies like Google Analytics or
- 27:29Speaker 3: their ad services, all the things where they make their money,
- 27:31Speaker 3: as well as other things. So of course different parties
- 27:34Speaker 3: can also see your web traffic. Your ISP could always
- 27:36Speaker 3: see your traffic, your employer might be able to see
- 27:38Speaker 3: your traffic, and again different advertising vendors could probably see
- 27:42Speaker 3: your traffic. All these parties are of course able to
- 27:44Speaker 3: do with it what they want. And importantly, Google was
- 27:46Speaker 3: taking information about incognito browsers and they were continuing to
- 27:51Speaker 3: perform analytics and essentially track incognito users across the web
- 27:55Speaker 3: and even though the Chrome browser said that Google wasn't
- 27:58Speaker 3: collecting this information, really only that Chrome browser wasn't Google
- 28:01Speaker 3: itself was fundamentally still collecting data about all users as
- 28:05Speaker 3: they browsed the Internet using the incognitive browser.
- 28:08Speaker 1: Google vigorously fought the lawsuit until the district judge rejected
- 28:13Speaker 1: a request to dismiss the case last August, which would
- 28:16Speaker 1: set up a potential trial. Is it just that Google
- 28:19Speaker 1: fights every lawsuit or was there anything in particular about
- 28:21Speaker 1: this lawsuit that it feared.
- 28:25Speaker 3: I think this is one of the Google I think
- 28:27Speaker 3: vigorously fights a lot of cases, especially these privacy cases.
- 28:30Speaker 3: I think they tend to create negative case law. There's
- 28:34Speaker 3: not been it's been sort of slow to develop in
- 28:36Speaker 3: the US the sort of common law or various case
- 28:39Speaker 3: law around privacy claims, especially in the advertising space. And
- 28:43Speaker 3: I think that's sort of the risk in this case
- 28:45Speaker 3: is that it's sort of exposed to an extent what
- 28:48Speaker 3: Google was doing through its other products and the ability
- 28:51Speaker 3: and capabilities they had to track users through Google Analytics,
- 28:55Speaker 3: through ads, and sort of how pervasive the web tracking was.
- 28:58Speaker 3: And it's not as simple as people think. It's not
- 29:00Speaker 3: so simple to stay private on the Internet as opening
- 29:03Speaker 3: up in browser, and I think that this is one
- 29:05Speaker 3: of those things. It's very negative, you know, for I
- 29:08Speaker 3: think their reputation and presented a risk. And obviously in
- 29:12Speaker 3: this particular claim, they were leging I think five billion
- 29:14Speaker 3: in damages. We never got to exactly whether or not
- 29:17Speaker 3: that number would hold up, but in any event, it
- 29:19Speaker 3: was a very large number.
- 29:20Speaker 1: Yeah, So now tell us. As part of the settlement,
- 29:23Speaker 1: Google has to delete billions of data records.
- 29:26Speaker 3: So Google agreed basically to four key things. The first
- 29:30Speaker 3: thing is that they had to change this this disclosure
- 29:33Speaker 3: as I mentioned, the spy guy or it's saying in
- 29:35Speaker 3: this idea that you know your session is private, So
- 29:38Speaker 3: they basically said that other people can track you, including Google,
- 29:41Speaker 3: across the internet. They basically clarified these disclosures to say
- 29:45Speaker 3: just as much that it's just your browsing history. Essentially,
- 29:47Speaker 3: it's not being stored here. They also had to disable
- 29:49Speaker 3: what are called third party cookies, which are basically advertising
- 29:52Speaker 3: tools they can track you across the internet, so those
- 29:55Speaker 3: are disabled by default. And then, as you suggested, they
- 29:58Speaker 3: have to delete the ex data that was collected from
- 30:01Speaker 3: incognito users over the years, and what's somewhat interesting is
- 30:05Speaker 3: that Google was able to identify all of the records
- 30:08Speaker 3: that were related to incognito users, which really isn't supposed
- 30:11Speaker 3: to be the case, but they were able to do it.
- 30:13Speaker 3: And this results in i think they said, hundreds of
- 30:15Speaker 3: billions of records and again a ton of work in
- 30:17Speaker 3: identifying that data and ultimately deleting it from their records.
- 30:21Speaker 1: So it's going to cost Google a certain amount to
- 30:24Speaker 1: delete that.
- 30:25Speaker 3: Absolutely.
- 30:26Speaker 1: Is this a trend, This is a settlement, but our
- 30:28Speaker 1: courts also where data collection is found to be illegal,
- 30:34Speaker 1: our courts forcing companies to delete data.
- 30:38Speaker 3: Yes, this is a trend. We've been watching for a
- 30:40Speaker 3: few years now. In particular, the FTC has been particularly active.
- 30:44Speaker 3: So the FTC is probably the most robust enforcer of
- 30:47Speaker 3: privacy laws under the general consumer protection frameworks. So over
- 30:51Speaker 3: the last few years, as they've explored different companies sort
- 30:54Speaker 3: of unfair or deceptive practices that have resulted in unlawful
- 30:58Speaker 3: data collection, the remedies that they've been seeking are fundamentally
- 31:01Speaker 3: and not just fines, but really coming in requiring them
- 31:05Speaker 3: to delete source data and beyond that, any data derived
- 31:08Speaker 3: from the source data that was collected lawfully and any
- 31:11Speaker 3: models or algorithms that were built using that data, so
- 31:14Speaker 3: relatively robust remedies. And then you know, kind of looking
- 31:16Speaker 3: forward as we look at sort of how AI is
- 31:19Speaker 3: blowing up across the industry, this is a real potential
- 31:21Speaker 3: risk for companies that are sort of building these models
- 31:24Speaker 3: and collecting data.
- 31:26Speaker 1: You know, as you mentioned, Google for the next five
- 31:28Speaker 1: years will allow private browsing users to block third party cookies.
- 31:34Speaker 1: So that's just for five years. It seems like something
- 31:36Speaker 1: you should always be able to block.
- 31:39Speaker 3: And there are there are tools that have been available
- 31:41Speaker 3: on the market for probably fifteen or more years at
- 31:43Speaker 3: this point. I'm sure many people are familiar with ad
- 31:46Speaker 3: blocker plus or you know, the similar Ghostry I think
- 31:49Speaker 3: is another popular when there's a several of these out
- 31:52Speaker 3: on the marketplace that are basically they're ad blockers, and
- 31:55Speaker 3: these are basically tools that you can install in your browser.
- 31:58Speaker 3: They run off of lists have lists of all basically
- 32:01Speaker 3: all known third party trackers, at least the common ones,
- 32:04Speaker 3: and they simply strip the code out of the website.
- 32:06Speaker 3: So if you've ever been browsing with an ad blocker,
- 32:10Speaker 3: you've probably seen the pop ups that come up and say,
- 32:13Speaker 3: you know you're blocking our ads. We can't make money.
- 32:16Speaker 3: You know obviously it's impacting revenue. Please turn your ad
- 32:18Speaker 3: blocker off. So we see these sorts of things. These
- 32:20Speaker 3: the tools are relatively powerful. Another interesting piece really is
- 32:23Speaker 3: the Google itself is moving away from third party cookies
- 32:27Speaker 3: as a tracking tool, and they're moving to different different
- 32:30Speaker 3: methods of sort of tracking and delivering ads to users. So,
- 32:33Speaker 3: in one sense, even though it's only for five years,
- 32:36Speaker 3: the trend has been away from third party cookies into
- 32:38Speaker 3: alternative tracking methods.
- 32:40Speaker 1: A Google spokesperson said, the company is pleased to settle
- 32:44Speaker 1: this lawsuit, which we always believe was merit list. We
- 32:47Speaker 1: never associate data with users when they use incognito mode.
- 32:53Speaker 1: Is that true?
- 32:54Speaker 3: Certainly, the claims alleged that there was an ability to
- 32:57Speaker 3: identify or make its users identifiable. Interesting to understand what
- 33:01Speaker 3: they meant by i'd never identify users. This is something
- 33:05Speaker 3: that oftentimes in the advertising space, you don't necessarily identify
- 33:09Speaker 3: someone by name, but what you can do is track
- 33:12Speaker 3: their device or track their browser or a similar session
- 33:15Speaker 3: something like that. So it's not to say that they
- 33:17Speaker 3: know who you are and link that to a profile.
- 33:20Speaker 3: Necessarily tied to your name, but they can certainly sort
- 33:23Speaker 3: of impact your experience, and they do know how your
- 33:26Speaker 3: devices are used on the web.
- 33:28Speaker 1: Yeah, he said, we are happy to delete old technical
- 33:31Speaker 1: data that was never associated with an individual and was
- 33:35Speaker 1: never used for any form of personalization. So Google tried
- 33:39Speaker 1: to sort of downplay this whole thing, said that, you know,
- 33:42Speaker 1: the plaintiffs originally wanted five billion dollars in this class
- 33:46Speaker 1: action and they're not getting any money. But the attorneys
- 33:49Speaker 1: who represented the Google users said that this was a
- 33:53Speaker 1: major victory for personal privacy. Do you agree? Is this
- 33:57Speaker 1: a major victory?
- 33:58Speaker 3: I wouldn't characterize it as a major vigo. I do
- 34:00Speaker 3: think it's an important milestone. I think it really does
- 34:03Speaker 3: make I would say two key points. First is that
- 34:06Speaker 3: this is a case where Google was forced to change
- 34:09Speaker 3: their disclosures about how data is collected. People have to
- 34:11Speaker 3: become more transparent about their data collection practices, and I
- 34:15Speaker 3: think pushing the industry in that direction and setting that
- 34:18Speaker 3: milestone is important. And then, second, as I mentioned, requiring
- 34:21Speaker 3: data deletion, even though this didn't necessarily reach the models
- 34:24Speaker 3: or the algorithms that Google may have built using this data,
- 34:27Speaker 3: it does force companies to really think about how they
- 34:30Speaker 3: collect data and the rights that they'll have in it
- 34:31Speaker 3: long term. You know, forcing them to delete data is
- 34:34Speaker 3: still an impactful remedy.
- 34:35Speaker 1: The Planeff's lawyers valued the settlement at four point seventy
- 34:39Speaker 1: five billion dollars to seven point eight billion, and they
- 34:43Speaker 1: calculated that on the potential ad sales that the personal
- 34:47Speaker 1: information collected through Chrome could have generated in the past
- 34:52Speaker 1: and future without the new restrictions. Is that a difficult
- 34:55Speaker 1: I mean, is that calculation difficult to make? Is that
- 35:00Speaker 1: sort of.
- 35:01Speaker 5: Not?
- 35:03Speaker 3: Yeah, it does. It does seem like an interesting number. Obviously,
- 35:06Speaker 3: they you know, sort of dispute that number in different ways.
- 35:09Speaker 3: There's sort of valuing the settlement at that amount. Of course,
- 35:12Speaker 3: the users were I think the original claimant said that,
- 35:14Speaker 3: you know, the five billion dollar number came from a number.
- 35:17Speaker 3: I think that Google originally had agreed to pay users
- 35:20Speaker 3: for their browsing history, so they had, you know, set
- 35:22Speaker 3: it at some number of dollars per user, per per
- 35:25Speaker 3: time period or something like that. So interesting how they
- 35:28Speaker 3: come up with these numbers, but I think it always
- 35:30Speaker 3: involves a degree of creative accounting.
- 35:32Speaker 1: Fair enough, Thanks so much, Austin that's Austin Chambers of
- 35:35Speaker 1: Dorsey and Whitney. Google may have settled this lawsuit, but
- 35:39Speaker 1: it's still facing legal threats on the regulatory frontier that
- 35:43Speaker 1: could have a far bigger impact on its business depending
- 35:46Speaker 1: on the outcomes. During a trial last fall, the Justice
- 35:50Speaker 1: Department outlined its allegations that Google is abusing the dominance
- 35:55Speaker 1: of its search engine to thwart competition and innovation, and
- 35:59Speaker 1: a federal judge schedule to hear closing arguments in the
- 36:02Speaker 1: case on May first before issuing a ruling. Google is
- 36:06Speaker 1: also facing potential changes to its app store for smartphones
- 36:10Speaker 1: powered by the Android software that could undercut its revenue
- 36:14Speaker 1: from commissions after a federal jury last year concluded the
- 36:18Speaker 1: company was running an illegal monopoly. A hearing examining possible
- 36:22Speaker 1: revisions that Google may have to make to its play
- 36:25Speaker 1: store is scheduled for late May. And that's it for
- 36:28Speaker 1: this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you can
- 36:31Speaker 1: always get the latest legal news by subscribing and listening
- 36:34Speaker 1: to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at Bloomberg
- 36:38Speaker 1: dot com Slash podcast Slash Law. I'm June Grosso and
- 36:42Speaker 1: this is Bloomberg