Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Why Can't Christians Agree on "True Christianity?"
Transcript
- 0:00We understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheists in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the
- 0:19truth, it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand
- 0:23on a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking, feels so much more happiness. Truth Usian
- 0:32wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and
- 0:39start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. I
- 0:56wanted to start with something that kind of relates to the topic at hand today.
- 1:02This whole that's not true Christianity claim that is everywhere. I'm seeing it
- 1:07all over the place, and it's complicated. I'm going to talk about this
- 1:12in a bit with doctor Chrissy Stroup, who has written a lot about these
- 1:17claims by some moderate progressive Christians that the bigots and the Christian nationalists they're not
- 1:23practicing true Christianity. They've betrayed Christianity, They've perverted and distorted Christianity, They've
- 1:32misrepresented the whole religion. Is that true, and of course the answer is
- 1:40nope. But this morning, and I don't really know why I did it,
- 1:46I decided to go and check some of the reviews of the books that
- 1:52I have written. And I have written five of them, and I've narrated
- 1:57all of them. And so I went to audible dot com and I just
- 2:00happened to pull up my autobiography Dconverted, and I clicked on reviews, and
- 2:07there he was, the Christian named Steve. He said, I'm a Christian
- 2:14with an interest in apologetics. A year or so ago, I started looking
- 2:20into the atheist world view. Now I have to stop already, Steve,
- 2:27Atheism is not a worldview, he said. I've listened to his podcast and
- 2:32wanted to give his book a read for research purposes. Now what this tells
- 2:38me is that he was making a list of all the reasons I am full
- 2:42of crap. Steve said, I'm not impressed at all. He bases his
- 2:46deconversion on poor reasoning and a distorted idea of what Christianity actually is. Oh,
- 2:54I got it wrong again. That's not true Christianity, he said.
- 3:00While Seth is a gifted narrator, he nonetheless blasphemes the God who made him.
- 3:08The final section asks what reaction did this book spark in you? And
- 3:14Steve said, the book didn't make me angry, rather sad that Seth didn't
- 3:19have a better Christian foundation before he started questioning his faith. It's easy to
- 3:23fall away from a shallow, superficial version of Christianity. As he says in
- 3:30the beginning, he was never really saved. That's not what I said,
- 3:34Steve, But he says, I pray God would draw Seth to himself and
- 3:39grant him repentance and faith in Jesus Christ. What I said in the introduction
- 3:46was that Christians look at me, the apostate, the exvangelical, and they
- 3:52say, there's no way that he would have ever left Christ if he really
- 3:57knew Jesus. So he was never true Christian to begin with. That's the
- 4:02claim that's made by the apologists. It's not what I said. I never
- 4:06said I was never really saved. I guess let me do a self serving
- 4:12plug. By the way, you may not know that I have narrated twelve
- 4:15I think twelve audiobooks. The five that I have written de Converted was my
- 4:20autobiography than Sacred Cows is a lighthearted romp around the world as we examine some
- 4:29of these bizarre human rituals that people still do today. I narrated the ghost
- 4:35Stories audiobook Confessions of a former Fox News Christian and Christianity made Me Talk like
- 4:43an idiot, that released, I think three years ago. But I've also
- 4:46narrated for other people, other activists and educators out there. Doctor Abbi Hafer,
- 4:53the not so Intelligent designer, three books for doctor Joshua Bowen, the
- 4:58seriologist did the Old Testament Endorse Slavery? And then volume one and two of
- 5:04the Atheist Handbook to the Old Testament. Two books for doctor David Madison,
- 5:10former theologian and minister now Heathen. He has the books Guessing About God and
- 5:16Ten Things Christians Wish Jesus Hadn't taught, a fiction book with secular themes by
- 5:24Lee Bervin called The Kafir Project. And finally the book by psychologist doctor Hector
- 5:29Garcia called Alpha God The Psychology of Religious Violence and Oppression. And he does
- 5:35a great job of exploring why the God of the Bible, the God of
- 5:41the Koran, etc. The gods who were written about by male primates seem
- 5:47to look and think and act like male primates, and how all of this
- 5:53roots to our evolution. It's really a fascinating ride. Anyway, if you're
- 5:57one of those people who likes to listen to audiobook books when you're out and
- 6:00about, that's how you digest your books. I would love the chance to
- 6:03read to you. Just go to audible dot com and then type Seth Andrews
- 6:09in your search engine and all those audiobooks will pop up. Is that twelve
- 6:14one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight,
- 6:16nine, ten, eleven, twelve, thirteen Holy Schnikes thirteen audiobooks?
- 6:23Okay, what were we talking about? Oh yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 6:27this idea of what is true Christianity. I'm surrounded by casual cultural Christians,
- 6:34so often very good people, but you know they're Christians. That's how they
- 6:39identify. I think they're like most homes. Is it an average of three
- 6:44Bibles in the American home? I can't remember the statistic, but we live
- 6:48in a culture where people own Bibles, but they don't ever read them,
- 6:53and they certainly don't know what's in them. So if they need education on
- 6:57the Bible, they often have to ask the atheist. Because we're usually statistically
- 7:03in fact, we are more Bible literate than the vast majority of Bible believers.
- 7:10But the Christians that I'm surrounded with, they go to church, they
- 7:14have the Christian T shirt, maybe listen to some Christian music, but they
- 7:18there Jesus is just love and light, goodness, charity, compassion. It's
- 7:27this hippie Jesus. You can just picture them in your mind. You know.
- 7:30He's got the long white robe and his hands are outstretched and there's the
- 7:34soundtrack of a Pure Flicks movie playing in the background, and he says,
- 7:40come to me, my children, I will shower you with my unconditional divine
- 7:45love and protections. And that means all of you, every single one of
- 7:51you, including the same people that yahweh kick the shit out of Throughout the
- 8:00Old Testament, thirty nine Bible books of smiting, just all kinds of smiting
- 8:07going on. So sure, you've got the New Testament, which is a
- 8:11softer cell, two hundred and sixty chapters of supposed love and light. It's
- 8:16easier to swallow, but you still have to set that against the nine hundred
- 8:22plus chapters of the Old Testament where God gleefully breathes in the aroma of burning
- 8:28human flesh. And this is the same God as Jesus. At the Triune
- 8:35God, the Holy Trinity, there's Yahweh, Jesus and the Holy Spirit.
- 8:37And that's always fun to watch the apologist explain this. Well, they are
- 8:41one in three and three and one. They are absolutely unique and different while
- 8:45being exactly the same. That's always fun to listen to. But what we
- 8:50can take from that is that Yahweh and Jesus are the same deity. The
- 8:54Father is the son, the son is the Father. Somehow they're the one.
- 8:56It's freaky, but that's how they pitch it. So Jesus is not
- 9:00off the hook. Jesus is there in the war room, as most of
- 9:05the Bible is about dominionism and conquest against the same people that these moderate Christians
- 9:11today keep telling us Jesus loves unconditionally. What is Christian nationalism. It's a
- 9:20declaration that everything belongs to God, and that's rooted in Scripture Psalm twenty four.
- 9:26The earth is the Lord's and everything in it, the world and all
- 9:30who live in it. And we see God claiming his property at the end
- 9:37of a sword. Throughout most of the Bible, you got the conquest of
- 9:41Bishan. That's the book of numbers. What is that sixty cities. God's
- 9:46army goes in. They just crush everybody, They destroy and exterminate the population
- 9:50of sixty cities. Those are now Yahweh cities. God is love. The
- 9:56Israelites are conquering the Midian Nite. They kill everybody, and then they divide
- 10:01all the plunder that belongs to God. The lands of Canaan, those belong
- 10:05to God. So this loving deity smashes his way into Jericho, the city
- 10:11of i Maketta, Libna, Lashish, egg Lon Hebron, God's army cutting
- 10:18off the heads of kings and shipping them out, murdering pregnant women and raping
- 10:24the virgins that they kidnap. Right, the biblical God of the Old Testament.
- 10:31How could somebody who owns one of those Bibles and reads those verses say
- 10:33that that is not true Christianity. Now, if we see a religion as
- 10:41an expression, and you have moderated out a lot of the hate and death
- 10:45and murder and pain, and you know, all that stuff, and you've
- 10:48got a different version, maybe for you that's true Christianity. But you don't
- 10:52get to conveniently just wipe away, whitewash the millions of corpses that Yahweh left
- 11:01in his wake because he was not a God of love, but instead was
- 11:05a god of jealousy and rage and dominion. You can see the rift in
- 11:13the church even and often especially in certain denominations over which interpretation of the Bible
- 11:20is true Christianity. The hardliners see the anti gay verses, God's executing the
- 11:28homosexual because he or she is an abomination under God, and their sermons resonate
- 11:35today God wanted gays dead, then God probably wants gay's dead today, and
- 11:43they've got chapter and verse that they can cite. And then I've got all
- 11:46of these progressives who are saying, my Jesus would never judge gay people.
- 11:52John Pavlovitz, you're killing me. Pastor Pavlovitz continues to assert that Jesus never
- 11:58condemned LGBT people. But Jesus and Yahweh are exactly the same deity. Hebrews
- 12:09says, Jesus Christ the same, yesterday, today and forever, unchanging,
- 12:13including attitudes about non heterosexuals. And then you've got Jesus's man Paul, that
- 12:20beloved and admired apostle Paul. He's writing in the Book of Romans, chapter
- 12:24one, and he's speaking specifically about gay people, talking about how God gave
- 12:31them over to the sinful desires in their hearts regarding sexual impurity for the degrading
- 12:39of their bodies with one another Verse twenty six. God gave them over to
- 12:43shameful lusts. Even their women exchanged natural sexual relations for unnatural ones. In
- 12:52the same way, the men also abandoned natural relations with women and were inflamed
- 12:58with life for one another. Men committed shameful acts with other men and received
- 13:05in themselves the due penalty for their error. In fact, if you bounce
- 13:11down to the bottom of chapter one of Romans, it talks about how they
- 13:15deserve death. Now, whether you see this as a physical death on earth
- 13:20or eternal death in hell, it's still punishment. It is still condemned,
- 13:26it is still a negative. And Paul is a representative of an ambassador for
- 13:31a bullhorn four the message of Jesus Christ himself. It could be argued that
- 13:39he's the most important apostle because it is believed that Paul was the author of
- 13:45thirteen New Testament books. Well, you can't just write that off and say,
- 13:50well, Jesus loves everybody and would never condemn gay people because his number
- 13:56one, the right hand man, Paul, is out there, I mean
- 14:00gay people. And in some ways it's become comical. Over here, you've
- 14:05got these often lovely people who have opened their arms and their homes and their
- 14:11buildings and their cultures and their churches to everybody. We are not interested in
- 14:16judgment because our Jesus does not judge. He's a God of love. So
- 14:20there's a place for you. Many churches now are bringing in LGBT clergy.
- 14:26Take the pulpit, stand on stage, share your expertise, your perspective,
- 14:31your humanity. That's true Christianity. That's what Jesus was about. Love and
- 14:35light and acceptance and goodness. And over here the Bible literalists are about to
- 14:41have a heart attack. Well, that's not true Christianity. You guys are
- 14:45practicing a false faith, bunch of wishy washy mamby pamby permissive types. You
- 14:52are mingling with the unwashed. If you call yourself a Christian but you participate
- 14:58in this set schewelled deviance, well I say this in love, but you're
- 15:03gonna burn and fires so hot that God's gonna have to install special filters in
- 15:11the clouds to keep the rising stanch of your burning flesh from stinking up paradise.
- 15:18Oh yeah, I don't know why the drawl kicks in when I start
- 15:22to do the preacher thing. Well maybe I do, actually, because now
- 15:26I come from thirty one flavors of Christianity. Dad was an ex Lutheran.
- 15:31Mom was Pennycostal. I went to a Baptist school. We attended Baptist churches,
- 15:37Assembly of God churches, and hardcore Pennycostal. In fact, when I
- 15:41was in junior high, we went to this one little Pennecostal church in a
- 15:43suburb of Tulsa. The pastor's name is Billy Wheeler, and he was like
- 15:48a lot of pastors that we heard when I was growing up. And the
- 15:52more passionate they got, the more they would start to do that Josh Fuorstein
- 15:56voice, you know, that typical pastor voice, the John Hagey voice.
- 16:02So the Lord, the Lord came down to me in a vision, in
- 16:04a dream, and he told me, he told me, Billy Wheeler,
- 16:08you need to go forth and spread my word. They all do that most
- 16:14of them. You don't hear quite as much of it these days. Maybe
- 16:18the Jolosteins are doing their own riff on it, But he's a sort of
- 16:22slip into that. It amuses me anyway. The Pentecostal preacher disagrees with the
- 16:27Baptist preacher, disagrees with the Assembly of God preacher, disagrees with the Lutheran
- 16:32preacher, disagrees with the Catholic priest. I think I've told the story about
- 16:37Bishop Carlton Pearson. We could call him a megapastor. We had a massive
- 16:41church here in town called Higher Dimensions. He was the real thing. He
- 16:45was on television and he was a household name in Christian circles. All of
- 16:49a sudden, he came to a realization that no moral God would have ever
- 16:56created hell. He just thought that this makes no sense. It makes no
- 17:00moral sense, it doesn't make sense in the context of any of Jesus's greatest
- 17:04teachings. I don't buy it, And so he tells his church, I've
- 17:10had an epiphany here. I think Hell does not exist. And you should
- 17:14have seen the churches who were the same denomination. They turned on him and
- 17:19they shut his career down and destroyed his reputation. He lost his church and
- 17:26spent most of the rest of his life on the fringes of Christian society.
- 17:32He insisted he was a true Christian. His critics insisted he was not.
- 17:38You could make this a game show, just call it true Christianity question Mark,
- 17:47and invite a whole bunch of people, not even Apologists, everyday mainstream
- 17:51Christians, contemporary Christians. Toss them in a big auditorium and asked them some
- 17:56basic questions and allow them to ask questions of each other. And you can
- 18:02start by taking the Baptists and put them all in a section over here.
- 18:06Just put the Baptist and just ask them, okay, what's true Christianity?
- 18:10Is it the Southern Baptist Church, the Independent, the New Independence, the
- 18:15Free Will Baptist, some other form of the Baptist Church. And they start
- 18:19to squabble and point and freak out. And then you have them give an
- 18:25opinion about the Pentecostals, the Assemblies of God, the Gideons, the Lutherans,
- 18:30the Episcopals, and then they weigh in on each other, and the
- 18:33noise level goes up, and before you know what, it's thunderdome. Then
- 18:37you try to get calm, you bring everybody back down to an even keel,
- 18:41and you ask the next question, what's the proper translation of the Bible
- 18:47if you're going to practice true Christianity. Well, the old school hardliners jump
- 18:52in and say, the King James Bible. How can you even ask the
- 18:56question? Of course, it's the KJAV, And somebody else says, no,
- 19:00it's the New King James Bible. No, it's the Christian Standard,
- 19:07the CSB, the English Standard Version, the New American Standard, Revised Standard,
- 19:14New Revised Standard, the New Living Translation, the NIV, the New
- 19:18International Version. No, it's the New International Reader's Version, which is the
- 19:25NIRV, the Message Bible with concordance. It's awesome to watch these people using
- 19:33the word revised to describe a book that's supposed to be absolutely in errant and
- 19:41the unchangeable truth. This is an authoritative word from God. It is without
- 19:48error revised. It's awesome. These followers of the God who is not the
- 19:57author of confusion? How much time do they spend accusing other Christians of being
- 20:03confused? I stumbled upon a piece that was published on CNN. This was
- 20:11aired first in twenty twenty three from John Avlon show. It's called Reality Check,
- 20:18and he was talking about how Christian nationalism is not Christianity, and already
- 20:25I'm starting to set my jaw right. But he had Amanda Tyler on.
- 20:30She's with the Baptist Joint Committee. She is founder of Christians Against Christian Nationalism.
- 20:36Aman is a friend. I've had her on this show. I love
- 20:38her. I think she is a great ally in the fight for state church
- 20:41separation. We work together to that ends, believing there's a place for all
- 20:48of us. I appreciate the egalitarian version of the faith that she practices,
- 20:53but it's so frustrating to listen to Christians distance themselves from the fire fundamentals of
- 21:00their faith. Here's a clip. Christian nationalism is not Christianity. Christian nationalism
- 21:08is a political ideology and a cultural framework that tries to merge our identities as
- 21:15Americans and in Christians, and in the process it threatens Americans democracy. It
- 21:22distorts America's promise of religious freedom for all, and importantly, to me and
- 21:27to thousands of other Christians, it distorts Christianity, sometimes beyond recognition. And
- 21:36that's because it takes Christianity's central message, which is a gospel of love,
- 21:42and turns it into a false idol of power. H Is that really true?
- 21:51Do the egalitarian, loving kind, compassionate, open hearted Christians get to
- 21:57simply look at the dominionist, the Christian nationalist, the people who are living
- 22:03in a culture of god excused cruelty and just write them off and say,
- 22:08well, they got it wrong, because that's not our faith. It's not
- 22:11an accurate representation. I want to talk about this with doctor Chrissy Stroop.
- 22:17She is a friend of mine who is an exvangelical and activist has done a
- 22:22lot of writing about Christian nationalism and the rising fervor out there to essentially turn
- 22:30us into Gilead. Will have her take on true Christianity next before we continue.
- 22:42Next up on my speaking roster, I'm going to Los Angeles, California,
- 22:48May the nineteenth. I've been invited by the Center for Inquiry West and
- 22:55so mark your calendar for that, and then the Secular Student Alliance Conference in
- 23:00June. I'll be in Denvern June twenty ninth, Saint Louis in July,
- 23:04Dallas, Houston, some others. All the details with links Seth Andrews dot
- 23:11com slash events. I'm going to speak to somebody who has a lot of
- 23:18commentary written out there, published out there about the Christian right, about evangelicals
- 23:26on the move in this country, and about alliances with religious people. Doctor
- 23:33Chrissy Stroup. By the way, what's your doctorate in? You had studied
- 23:38in Russia? Right, as I recall, I did study the Russian language
- 23:41in Russia, and then after I graduated with my PhD, I taught at
- 23:45a Russian university for a while in Moscow, the Russian Presidential Academy of National
- 23:49Economy and Public Administration, or it sounds even better in Russian Rassiskay Academia or
- 23:56Rodnos Dudson SLUSBI pre president. Well, that's why the Soviets and now the
- 24:02Russians, you know, love acronyms so much. It must be fun to
- 24:06say Russia in today's climate with Ukraine going on in Putin out of control,
- 24:11and does everybody go, what in the hell, why would you ever go
- 24:12there? Do you ever hear that when people ask yes? And you know,
- 24:17back in the sort of heavy days of twenty sixteen, in twenty seventeen
- 24:21on Twitter, when Louise Mensch was a thing, and she was for a
- 24:25time sort of a darling of American liberals because she was an anti Trump conservative.
- 24:30She and some of her minions I would call them, you know,
- 24:33her online hangers on accuse me of being a Russian spy, whereas they actually
- 24:37have no background in this field whatsoever. It's interesting to watch the right wing
- 24:42worship of strong men, or what they see as strong men. We've seen
- 24:45it with Trump and they see it with Putin. A Putin kicks ass,
- 24:49he takes what he wants, big man kind of thing. It's weird watching
- 24:53these, you know, Jesus followers who then flip and go. But God
- 24:59also kicked ass and took what he wanted. They seem to admire Putin.
- 25:03It's terrifying. Yeah, I saw the admiration for Putin. It's certainly not
- 25:07universal among conservative evangelicals. I mean for some there has to be some ambivalence
- 25:12now with the war, in particular God and Country, the new documentary produced
- 25:18by Rob Reiner. It's really well produced, I mean from a technical point
- 25:22of view, from a storytelling point of view. It has a lot of
- 25:26Christians on camera, many of whom I have had on my show, Doctor
- 25:30Christen Dumay Andrew Whitehead. I think someone I'm trying to remember. But whenever
- 25:37I have spoken to them and they say, well, these people overhear the
- 25:41Christian nationalists. They are idolators. They distorted Christianity because Jesus is only goodness
- 25:49and Jesus would never judge, and Jesus doesn't need a state church. I
- 25:55asked them this question. I say, in the Bible, God gave Adam
- 26:00over the earth. The entire Old Testament is nothing but tribal wars, dominionist
- 26:06wars for land and resources, and at the end of the whole Biblical story,
- 26:11the non compliant get annihilated. If you read the Bible. Christianity is
- 26:18a dominionist religion. And when I have mentioned this to my Christian interlocutors,
- 26:26they kind of blink at me and say, well, you know, these
- 26:29are challenges, These are lively discussions that we in the church have been having,
- 26:33and you know, these are things that sometimes we don't always have the
- 26:37answers to, but they remain good questions. And that's all I get.
- 26:40I've never gotten a good answer. I follow that closely because you know,
- 26:44it kind of bothers me to no end. And the way I look at
- 26:48it, I don't want to deny that progressive, inclusive liberations forms of Christianity
- 26:52are really Christianity. I would just like those people to understand and admit that
- 26:57they're not the only forms of Christianity. And I get that sometimes they may
- 27:03want to have internal debates with other Christians. I don't think that a movie
- 27:07aimed at general audiences is a good form or venue for that, especially when
- 27:12we don't get the context that that is what is happening. We have so
- 27:17many people in God and country stating that Christian nationalism, it's just politics,
- 27:22it's idolatry. Well, look things like idolatry, heresy. They are categories
- 27:27that only make sense from an internal Christian perspective, within an internal Christian framework.
- 27:33And Christianity, like any religion, is a complicated cultural system. To
- 27:38borrow a phrase from the anthropologist Cifford Garretts that I think virtually nicely religions are
- 27:42cultural systems, right, so a cultural system is big enough to contain internal
- 27:48tensions, contradictions, contestation. I think the problem with sort of the national
- 27:55conversation about Christianity and politics in the United States is that storial choices are being
- 28:00used to make theological arguments without telling readers or viewers that that's what they are
- 28:07doing. And so we then end up with a theological perspective on Christianity in
- 28:11the public sphere rather than a historical, anthropological, sociological perspective in which we
- 28:17have to say, look, they're all Christians, okay, and they disagree
- 28:21with each other, and these ones actually support human rights and that's great,
- 28:23and these ones don't, and these ones have more power, and we need
- 28:26to be aware of that. And it isn't helpful in doing that to make
- 28:32the theological move of dismissing the fundamentalists and the biggots from Christianity. And it's
- 28:37also just completely a historical and empirically wrong. I mean, they represent what
- 28:41Christianity has mostly been. It has mostly been in bed with imperial power and
- 28:45colonization and dominion and conquests and authoritarian rule since at least the fourth century.
- 28:52And you know, people will say, oh, well, okay, but
- 28:55that was Constantine, and that was Saint Augustine maybe making some compromises, okay,
- 29:00you know what, It's also very much there in Paul and before you
- 29:03say, ah, yes, but not Jesus. It's in Jesus too,
- 29:06right, Like the impulses to do this thing, this idea that you are
- 29:10working towards the Kingdom of God and ultimately sort of apocalyptic violence to bring it
- 29:15into being. It's all there in the texts. Every niche I'll bow,
- 29:21every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord. Right, that's a prediction about
- 29:23the future. And the people who don't do that willingly will go to Hell
- 29:27and be burned forever, which is an invention of the New Testament, right,
- 29:32And in Jewish practice and in the Hebrew scriptures, you don't have hell,
- 29:36And yeah, you do have those narratives of conquest and genocide, but
- 29:40you also have some really humane things like provisions among the ancient Israelites who are
- 29:44taking care of the poor for debt, forgiveness for that sort of thing.
- 29:48So this whole sort of Old Testament bad New Testament good narrative that a lot
- 29:52of people like to fear around also doesn't hold water and also doesn't really work
- 29:56for any kind of Christian because they still have to be saying that their sort
- 29:59of their building on Judaism, right, even if some of them don't want
- 30:02to say they supersede it because super Sessionism, of course, is very anti
- 30:06Semitic theology, which is the idea that you know, Christianity not just grew
- 30:10out of Judaism but replaced it. Doctor Robert P. Jones wrote a book
- 30:14about the hidden roots of white supremacy in Christian nationalism. Do you want to
- 30:19speak to that? Sure? I respect Robert Jones and PRRI. They do
- 30:26a lot of really important research on religion and politics in the United States,
- 30:30and he's absolutely right that you can't understand American conservative Christianity without understanding that it's
- 30:38very much based in racism and slavery. And obviously this is something that more
- 30:45recently a lot of white evangelicals who want more respectability have sort of tried to
- 30:51erase or cover up, or they'll say, well, look, we're the
- 30:52same evangelicals as those ones who were abolitionists back in the day, which is
- 30:56not true at all. I mean, very American egelical Church is much more
- 31:00a product of slaveholder Christianity from the annecy Bellum South than it is anything that
- 31:04has anything to do with the second grade Awakening. But you hear a lot
- 31:07of evangelicals say no, No, evangelicals were historically abolitionists. Yeah, some
- 31:11of them were, but not really the ones who had much influence on one
- 31:15you know where we are today. And even those ones were by and large
- 31:18racist, like Abraham Lincoln. They didn't think a black man could be the
- 31:22equal of a white man. And even evangelical institutions founded founded by abolitionists,
- 31:29like Wheaton College in Illinois, which incidentally is where a lot of major commentators
- 31:33on evangelicals come from. Michael Gerson and Sarah Poiam Bailey at the Washington Post
- 31:38and Elizabeth Dios at the New York Times their graduates of Wheaton. I think
- 31:42that's important to know. Now. Wheaton likes to point out that they were
- 31:45founded by abolitionists, but Wheaton has only ever had one tenured African American woman,
- 31:52and maybe only one tenured African American person, I'm not sure, but
- 31:55certainly only one tenured African American woman in their entire history as a college,
- 32:00and they recently fired her even though she was tenured, because she expressed solidarity
- 32:05with Muslims. So there are forms of American Christianity that resist this. Obviously,
- 32:09the Black Church right, which also has its roots in the Antebellum South
- 32:14and enslavery and in resistance to slavery and white racism. But white American Christianity,
- 32:20you just can't extricate it from the history and present realities of racism in
- 32:23the United States. I'm watching God in Country, and I need your counsel
- 32:30because I'm watching it and I'm trying to see maybe a moderate Christian I don't
- 32:36know, somebody who is fluctuating. Maybe they voted for Trump once, but
- 32:39they're genuinely grieved, and they're not educated about state church separation. Maybe they're
- 32:45not aware of the consequences, and so they go, fine, I'll watch
- 32:50the documentary and I can see how it might be compelling and perhaps even move
- 32:54them away from extremism, away from Gilead. And I think that's a good
- 33:01thing. But is that the tool in the toolbox we should be using.
- 33:07Is it problematic? Well, I don't think it's the right kind of tool
- 33:10necessarily to do that. Maybe for the sake of argument, we can admit
- 33:15there might be a very tiny handful of people out there who might watch this
- 33:19and think, oh yeah, because phil Visher and David French and Russell Moore
- 33:23told me not to be a Christian nationalist. They just won't vote for president
- 33:28in twenty twenty four. They're not going to vote Democrats, let's be honest.
- 33:30And I don't think that you can really reach people at scale that way.
- 33:35And here's the thing. These hardcore Trump supporting Christian nationalists, they do
- 33:37go to church. They go to churches for the most part that are probably
- 33:42incubating their Trump support and telling them to vote Trump or vote Republicans. And
- 33:46they're reading, they're consuming stuff online, probably being told in church as well
- 33:51that oh that Russell Moore, he's a totally woke sellout. Now David French
- 33:55woke sellout. We don't need to pay attention to these people. So I
- 34:00think they're not going to reach them. And I think that any benefit that
- 34:04might come from this tiny number of people that might be reached in this way,
- 34:07and I do think that it seems pretty clear that must be a goal
- 34:09of the filmmakers. I think it's a naive goal, if a noble one,
- 34:14but yeah, I think any good that might be done by that is
- 34:15going to be outweighed by the way the film just whitewashes Christianity and even evangelicalism
- 34:22by letting the not all evangelicals, people who are indeed partly responsible for creating
- 34:28this monster, but now they want to distance himself from it by simply letting
- 34:30them do that without providing any context on things like how Russell Moore, who
- 34:36for a long time was a big wig in the Southern Baptist denomination and now
- 34:38he's editor in chief of Christianity Today, and he left the Southern Baptist Convention
- 34:44amid fallout over child sex abuse scandals, and he was someone who was very
- 34:49much supporting abuse survivors. That's good, right. He certainly has some humane
- 34:52impulses. This is why they see him as two woke though, I mean,
- 34:57it's a big part of it. But he's still very much a supporter
- 35:00of what he used to call biblical patriarchy, now they call complimentarianism. He's
- 35:04still a man who has called feminism a heresy and a problem in the church,
- 35:07and I don't think he's ever disavowed those comments, even though they were
- 35:09made some years ago. He hasn't changed his view on gender hierarchy. He
- 35:15just wants to do it in kinder, gentler way, and that's always going
- 35:17to lead to abuse, so they're whitewashing these people's reputations. They're elighting all
- 35:22the lines between people like Russell Moore and David Princh who are still far right
- 35:27waying conservative Christians who do harm Christology is harmful to women, queer people,
- 35:32minorities. They're alighting all the differences between them and then the people like Bishop
- 35:37William Barber and Kristin Cobez Dumey and others who are more inclusive. And I
- 35:44think that if this film had been done with more context to distinguish between those
- 35:47people and had included more voices, I'm not saying, don't include any never
- 35:52Trump evangelicals, but just include some more robust critics of evangelicalism as well,
- 35:58some well informed expangelicals for example. Or let someone who's just known on the
- 36:04atheist circuit, like you've already got s died on the film, let him
- 36:07say some things about Christianity and not just about how the Christian nationalist vision is
- 36:12totally bonkers when you actually look at the founding history and the historical documents that
- 36:15we have from that time. But they clearly wanted to sell a certain narrative.
- 36:19And I think one of the goals for that narrative is yet they think
- 36:21that they're actually going to convince some evangelicals to leave the Christian nationalism behind.
- 36:27I just don't think that's going to happen, and I don't think that if
- 36:30a few people do it, it's worth the cost of just reinforcing Christian privilege,
- 36:34which is exactly what gives Christian nationalists so much cover and power and prestige
- 36:37in the first place. We've got a dismantle Christian privilege in this country.
- 36:42And you can keep some of those voices in there. You can keep that
- 36:45narrative as a part of it, but don't make it your overarching narrative.
- 36:47Bring in more voices, bring in some critics who can say, look,
- 36:50okay, Russell Moore is saying some nice stuff now, but look you're still
- 36:52a very anti woman, and look what he did in the past. There's
- 36:57none of that. And if you include that, I think you have a
- 36:59good film. You've mentioned David French, opinion columnist for the New York Times
- 37:04a few times here what's the deal with French? He was included as an
- 37:09enemy of Christian nationalism, and he was lined up with all these other much
- 37:13more modern progressive, egalitarian minister types. But he's problematic. Why well,
- 37:20because he has basically the same theology as pro Trump evangelicals, and he's been
- 37:25an important figure in the conservative movement for a long time. So you can
- 37:29say not as much as Russell Moore, but you can say that David French
- 37:32also helped to create the problem that now he's sort of attacking but without wanting
- 37:37to revise his views on say, queer people at all. He's also derided
- 37:42by your mainstream evangelicals these days as woke, so he's just he's absolutely not
- 37:45going to reach them. They already consider him one of the bad guys.
- 37:51He's not the only one whose reputation is being whitewashed this way in the film.
- 37:55I just think he's probably the best known one. Certainly people who didn't
- 38:00grow up evangelical, he would have the whitest name recognition. But look,
- 38:04there's also Rob Shank who was a hardline lobbyist for Christian right issues for such
- 38:08a long time, and he's the one who kind of like breaks down crying
- 38:12realizing that one of the big theologians that he studied in grad school was a
- 38:15Nazi who wrote theology to justify the Nazi project, and he was never told
- 38:21that. Then he turns around and kind of says that he doesn't even want
- 38:24to call Christian nationalism evangelicalism anymore, even though he's just given us the perfect
- 38:29example of how they're compatible. Right, Evangelicals literally teach Nazi theologians in their
- 38:32seminaris. But so you know he's there, Russell Moore's there are people with
- 38:37last name recognition, phil vischer Sky Tothani. There's a lot of conservative Christians
- 38:42in this film who are able to whitewash their own reputations, and just the
- 38:46film totally ignores that there still they still want a band abortion, they still
- 38:52don't want queer people to have rights, or at least they're iffy on that
- 38:55The Godden Country is the kind of documentary that I might consider or if I
- 39:00had an opportunity, and if they expressed genuine interest, might expose my religious
- 39:06friends and family too. It's almost like a Gateway film. And now you've
- 39:10got me thinking, is that dishonest? Because they misrepresent what Christian nationalists are,
- 39:16which is a form of true Christianity. But I see it resonating,
- 39:21at least emotionally with them as they're like, wait a minute, the humanity
- 39:24of these people rejects hate and bigotry, at least on the surface. The
- 39:29messaging is this, Plus they hear the state church separation stuff from a constitutional
- 39:34attorney. Blah blah blah. Part of me wonders if it might serve as
- 39:37a kind of gateway film to the discussion. Am I just childish? Because
- 39:43I can be I can be very reductive. You know what do you think?
- 39:46No, I'm not going to say you're being childish in that much.
- 39:50Tell me I'm childish. Just let me have it, Let me have it.
- 39:52I've actually, I mean I've actually, I'd be hypocritical. I did
- 39:55because I've actually had the thought myself. But since this film exists as it
- 40:00does, I might recommend it too, for example, my mom. But
- 40:04now, if this film might be able to reach a few people and help
- 40:07them rethink a few things, I still say the rest of my criticism of
- 40:10the film stands, and I don't think that a film like this is going
- 40:14to reach people at scale. I think in the context of okay, I
- 40:17have a pre standing relationship with this person. Our relationship is not based only
- 40:22on our differences about Christianity and politics. It's based on a lot of other
- 40:27things, like this person raised me, or we grew up together, we
- 40:30have shared memories, we have shared hobbies. You know, if you have
- 40:34a relationship like that with someone, that is the kind of situation in which
- 40:38maybe over time, with patients, you might be able to sway them on
- 40:43some things that have been important to their identity but that are harmful to other
- 40:46people or even to themselves. But you know, when something is part of
- 40:50a person's core identity, it's very hard for that to change, and typically
- 40:54it doesn't change with intellectual arguments. There are very few people who are going
- 40:58to be argued out of position that are things that really matter to them at
- 41:02the core of their identity. But if you can bypass the emotional defenses by
- 41:07reaching them on a human level because of some other relationship you have, then
- 41:12yeah, maybe occasionally some people like that are going to change. I think
- 41:15a lot of evangelicals are never going to be reached, and I don't think
- 41:21a movie like this reaches people at scale, but it might be a tool
- 41:24for those of us who could reach people on a micro scale. Even with
- 41:28Rob Reiner's name attached to him, a big a list Hollywood guy. I
- 41:32don't think his name necessarily does much one way or another with evangelicals. Okay,
- 41:38so how do we balance the Christianity humanity equation? I continue with my
- 41:45guest, doctor Chrissy Stroop. Next, we're talking about true Christianity on today's
- 41:58broadcast. I'm speaking here with my guests, doctor Chrissy Strup. I am
- 42:04always pounding this drum that there are lovely, wonderful Christians in this world.
- 42:08I'm so sick and tired of people saying that all Christians are There's four billion
- 42:15of them on the planet, and I just think about the wide, wild
- 42:17spectrum of humanity, and I think, for me, it just comes down
- 42:21to humanity. You'll find this and that and everything in between. And you
- 42:24have been much more not even charitable. I think you've been just more real
- 42:30and honest about the humanity of many religious people who are lovely people. I'll
- 42:35just toss you that ball and you can do what you want with it.
- 42:37Okay. Yeah. You know, as anyone who's read much of my work
- 42:42will be aware, I advocate pluralism pretty often as sort of essential to democracy
- 42:49and well, and I tend to do that sometimes when I'm giving talks or
- 42:52that sort of thing too. I mean, I remember giving a talk to
- 42:54one atheist organization once and someone in the audience said, are we losing the
- 43:00war with organized religion? Was one of the questions in the Q and A.
- 43:02And I said, well, if you're fighting a war with organized religion,
- 43:06then yeah, you're losing it. But I'm not fighting in war with
- 43:08organized religion, right, because I don't think that's what secular advocacy should be.
- 43:13I think secular advocacy should be organized around values, certainly around separation of
- 43:17state and religion, right, that's critically important. But there are religious people
- 43:22who embrace that as well, and in many cases I think we can work
- 43:28with them, and it's better and more helpful to do secular advocacy in ways
- 43:31that sort of affect real people and aren't just sort of philosophical and semantic debates.
- 43:36So I think atheism is political, secularism is political, religion is political.
- 43:40Everything's political. So let's not pretend that we're just sort of mighty and
- 43:45above it all, and let's not just stick in the realm of abstract debate
- 43:49all the time. But let's build coalitions around shared values to do things that
- 43:53secular people and inclusive religious people of good faith upon intended, I guess you
- 44:00know can agree on. We can work together in a lot of areas,
- 44:02and so we don't have to condemn religion large or Christianity writ large or as
- 44:08long written large. We can see people as people, we can see their
- 44:10differences between different religious groups. At the same time, we can definitely oppose
- 44:15any sort of theocracy, and I think we do that more effectively by embracing
- 44:21the inevitable pluralism of a modern society. And I think embracing pluralism is good
- 44:25for democracy. How about that. I think, if I was to phrase
- 44:30it though, it would be the right of someone to be true to themselves
- 44:35and take their own journey. But the religions themselves, if they're demonstrably wrong
- 44:39and often destructive, then promoting them or celebrating them in any way, I
- 44:45mean, I don't see that as pluralistic democracy and inclusion as much as enabling
- 44:52horrible ideas. The dogmas get no quarter from me. So you're not saying
- 44:58that we've had everybody on the head and say, okay, you believe in
- 45:00Adam and Eve and Samung and I kind of think that's what God and country
- 45:05did to be honest, was pat them on the head. Well, I
- 45:07mean, I like the idea like you have a right to believe, but
- 45:12that right ends at the tip of my nose. Kind of a deal.
- 45:14It's a bit reductivet but I do like that. I'm very posed to proselytizing,
- 45:19and I mean I talk about working together. I think a lot of
- 45:21times we can put certain differences aside, and maybe for me, I'll countenance
- 45:25more theological arguments theological language than maybe some people wouldn't. I think that can
- 45:30also be okay, Well, if I can jump in though quickly. This
- 45:34is one of the reasons that I ally with Americans United for Separation of Church
- 45:37and State. Rachel Lazar is a practicing Jew and she believes in God,
- 45:43but we align in values, and I want her on our side. Yeah.
- 45:49I think rejecting that is, and saying that anyone who believes in God
- 45:52can't do anything good is extremely counterproductive and reductive and just inaccurate. Sobby and
- 45:59I don't even really yea, I don't even see believing in God and doing
- 46:04lots of good things as in any way contradictory belief or non belief in God
- 46:08may be a personal thing. It's not something that we can prove one way
- 46:12or another. I'm always going to be solidly in the agnostic atheist corner because
- 46:17I don't think God exists, right, I haven't. Like Carl Sagan used
- 46:21to say, Look, I can't. I've not been shown any compelling evidence
- 46:23that God exists. So I'll operate from the hypothesis that God doesn't until I
- 46:28should see some evidence like that. Right, But it's not something that can
- 46:30be proven one way or another by science. It's just God's not an empirical
- 46:35thing. And I don't particularly have I don't love it, but I don't
- 46:37have a problem with it. And then there's also the whole issue of how
- 46:40in some religions you can also not believe in God, but you can still
- 46:44be a practicing member of the religion because it's really about community values. There
- 46:47was certain gods have been debunked. I mean, we say God in the
- 46:52nebulist watchmaker first cause deistic way whatever, something's out there floating. But if
- 46:55we look at specific religious claims, we can see well that God is fiction,
- 47:00that God is mythology, that God was borrowed from another religion who made
- 47:04up their God. So in that context we can say it's knowable because this
- 47:08specific deity with a proper name, we know that's bullshit. That's fair,
- 47:13right, I mean, all right, okay, and it certainly I'm not
- 47:19trying to be no, no, I get it, I get it.
- 47:22Okay. These are actually I think these are important conversations for those of us
- 47:25in the atheist and secular community to have it. Certainly, you can easily
- 47:30debunk the claims of Mormonism, right because this was a religion that's invented out
- 47:34of whole cloth in modern times. But is there much point in doing that
- 47:38unless you're trying to sort of help people who are questioning their Mormon faith.
- 47:43I mean, for me, just be laboring everything that's wrong with the LDS
- 47:45Church would be sort of beside the point if I want to work with some
- 47:51LDS person who is pro LGBTQ and wants the church to change its stance on
- 47:55certain things. But again, I think atheists tend to overstay the and of
- 48:00belief, and it is very important in Protestantism for the most part. In
- 48:04Protestant Christianity, I think that's where we get this intense focus on belief versus
- 48:08unbelief, whereas what a lot of what religion does is really more about bringing
- 48:13people together in community to navigate values. And yes, some religions from more
- 48:20emphasis on the false beliefs than others, or in some cases demonstrably false.
- 48:24In some cases let's say unfalsifiable. Let's be a little nicer to it.
- 48:29But of course there's no reason to believe in it's something that's unfalsifiable. When
- 48:31I look at religions, I boil it down to, in my experience,
- 48:37five determiners for why someone was or is religious and why they stay. It's
- 48:42geography, family, ritual, community, and comfort. It's hardly ever theology,
- 48:47and I think understanding the community power, the family power, the support
- 48:52structure often used insidiously I think by some religions, but understanding why people connect
- 48:59where a tribal we're a communal creature, that kind of thing. I appreciate
- 49:02your compassionate approach to religious people. I think that's it's refreshing and certainly necessary.
- 49:07And then once we share humanity, then I think we can have the
- 49:12coffee table discussion about whether or not a donkey could speak Hebrew in the Book
- 49:17of Genesis. But I think you know, you'll find very few Christians who
- 49:22believe that, and even fewer Jews. So well, okay, you'll find
- 49:23a lot of Christians actually, but still I'm not sure a majority. But
- 49:28it's in there. It bugs me, it's there. It bugs all right,
- 49:32Now we can go all night. I'm going to link to the review
- 49:36of God and Country that you wrote in the description box so that everybody can
- 49:40go back. And you just did a comprehensive you just combed through the film,
- 49:45and so I'm going to put that link in the description box, and
- 49:49let's try to rendezvous again maybe later in the year, and we'll kind of
- 49:51see what happens as we ramp up toward the election. I'm always happy to
- 49:55talk with you, sir. You're amazing. You wouldn't mind let me just
- 49:59say too that back in August, I launched a new subtact newsletter, so
- 50:04it's called the bug Bird Dispatch, and I'd love for people to follow me
- 50:07there. I will link that as well, So everything's in the description box.
- 50:12Doctor Chrissy Stroup, yours just so smart. I just want to get
- 50:15smarter. Bi osmosis, you know, I'll never speak Russian. Obviously,
- 50:20you're obviously very smart yourself, and I don't think speaking Russian is the measure
- 50:22of intelligence. It may have been an unintelligent choice to study it, and
- 50:28it's not very useful. It's certainly a stigmatized choice at this point in our
- 50:32history. Chrissy, we'll talk again. Be safe out there, and thanks,
- 50:37thank you. Se I guess this may be one of those situations where
- 50:42we see it as not a binary answer. Right doesn't fit in a cookie
- 50:45cutter. We can understand the history and even the utility of religions creating a
- 50:52support structure, culture, community, family, So we understand that, you
- 50:58know, it may have played a vital role, and non dogmatic religions might
- 51:05in some way, certainly secular religions, they're not harming anybody, and in
- 51:09fact, they might sometimes help other people. But these churches can also be
- 51:16dogmatic and wrong, teaching bad science, bad history, bad morality. I
- 51:23remember in my own life, I was trained, no matter how much we
- 51:27knew our Bible or didn't know, we were trained to distrust science and scientists.
- 51:34We embraced our own lack of worth and had to get our worth from
- 51:37God. We struggled with the idea of going to hell and burning forever.
- 51:44I remember saying the Salvation prayer over and over as a kid to keep myself
- 51:47from burning for eternity. So we can't say that that stuff is not there.
- 51:53It's not prevalent, even mainstream, certainly harmful. What's that line by
- 51:59Ingers? I love this quote. The more false we destroy, the more
- 52:05room there will be for the true. So can we understand and even sometimes
- 52:12align with religious cultures while still acknowledging that much of it is not true and
- 52:19challenging those untruths in our discussions out there. I will leave this discussion to
- 52:24you in the comments section as you debate true Christianity. Thanks for listening.
- 52:32I'll see you back here next week. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and
- 52:37Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t
- 52:42shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and
- 52:47details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The
- 52:52Thinkingatheist dot com.