Latest / Humanise The Numbers - for ambitious accountants in practice / Stacey Barr of PUMP Academy
Transcript
- 0:05Paul Shrimpling: Welcome to the Humanize the Numbers podcast series.
- 0:08Paul Shrimpling: Leaders, managers, and owners of ambitious accounting firms sharing insights, successes, and issues that will challenge you and connect you and your firm to the ways and means of transforming your firm's results.
- 0:22Stacey Barr: I think sometimes asking people where they want to go, where they want that to steer that raft to can be a little confronting if they've not reflected on that before.
- 0:33Stacey Barr: But you know, you know how humans tend to be more um like we're very hardwired to avoid things rather than pursue things.
- 0:40Stacey Barr: So we're we're we're much more motivated by risk than we are by um possibility, I think.
- 0:48Stacey Barr: Uh so sometimes it can really help to flip it 180 degrees around.
- 0:53Stacey Barr: And rather than asking them what goals do you have, where do you want to go, just say, what are we trying to make sure never happens?
- 1:01Stacey Barr: What's your worst nightmare?
- 1:02Stacey Barr: What do we want to move away from?
- 1:03Stacey Barr: What's going on now that's driving your baddie that you just don't like, you wish it was different, you want it to go away.
- 1:09Stacey Barr: And they'll find that much easier to talk about.
- 1:12Stacey Barr: And then once you get them talking about that and articulating it, you just then turn that 180 degrees back again and you're getting closer to what the goals might be.
- 1:21Paul Shrimpling: Because you're listening to this podcast, it's logical that I assume you want a better accounting firm, a more human accounting firm, a firm that achieves greater results through numbers.
- 1:34Paul Shrimpling: And it's on this podcast with Stacy Barr of Pump.
- 1:37Paul Shrimpling: Stacy's an expert in KPIs.
- 1:40Paul Shrimpling: She's delivered processes and methodologies to help businesses all over the world improve how they use KPIs.
- 1:49Paul Shrimpling: I hope you enjoy this skill-based insight practical breakthrough discussion with Stacy Barr.
- 1:59Paul Shrimpling: Let's dive into the podcast now.
- 2:01Stacey Barr: I am Stacy Barr.
- 2:03Stacey Barr: Hello.
- 2:04Stacey Barr: I'm also the creator of Pump, which is a methodology used all around the world about KPIs and evidence-based strategy.
- 2:13Stacey Barr: And so what I do with a bunch of wonderful licensees I have around the world is we help leaders get their strategy meaningfully articulated, much easier to communicate and get the organization aligned to and measured and monitored so they can achieve it better.
- 2:29Stacey Barr: That's what I do.
- 2:30Stacey Barr: And I do love that, but my dirty little secret is I love riding motorcycles.
- 2:38Stacey Barr: Uh, and I started that about six years ago.
- 2:40Stacey Barr: And I go on road trips and I go on day trips, and I have in the last two years started not racing, but tearing around the track on a motorcycle, and that that is um just it blows my mind.
- 2:54Stacey Barr: I just love it.
- 2:55Paul Shrimpling: Oh right, wow, wow.
- 2:57Paul Shrimpling: Uh so what's the biggest uh biggest trip on the motorbike then, Stacey, you've done?
- 3:02Stacey Barr: Eight days.
- 3:03Stacey Barr: Um wow and oh, it was wonderful actually.
- 3:05Stacey Barr: I I have a friend who I do the road trips with, and she and I um took the long way down to the Blue Mountains, which are just west of Sydney in Australia.
- 3:14Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 3:15Stacey Barr: Um beautiful location.
- 3:17Stacey Barr: We did some hiking while we were down there, which which we needed to get a bit of time off the bikes, but you know, when you when you're on a motorcycle, you go the long way everywhere.
- 3:25Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 3:26Paul Shrimpling: Brilliant, brilliant, love that.
- 3:27Paul Shrimpling: And so um, I don't know how many motorbikes you've got, so I'm just gonna go with you.
- 3:31Paul Shrimpling: What's your favorite motorbike?
- 3:33Paul Shrimpling: Just because I know this, I know there's some motorbike addicts on the uh in the listener crew just because they're active customers of ours as well.
- 3:41Paul Shrimpling: So I just they'll be they'll be itching to know what the what the what your favourite bike is.
- 3:46Stacey Barr: Oh, my favourite bike is my Jacati Super Sport 939, and I love it because it's a sport bike and it's also very comfortable.
- 3:54Stacey Barr: I can ride it all day long.
- 3:56Paul Shrimpling: Right, brilliant, brilliant.
- 3:57Paul Shrimpling: Thank you for that.
- 3:58Paul Shrimpling: Thank you for that.
- 3:58Paul Shrimpling: Okay, so um the reason I was so keen to get you on the podcast because you're gonna bring this evidence-based KPI view of the world, uh, which by the way is what accountants are uh uh turned to by all of their clients for.
- 4:18Paul Shrimpling: Uh, but you're gonna hopefully uh challenge the status quo on that, and we can um we can get some key insights that will help every accountant, help every one of their clients.
- 4:27Paul Shrimpling: So, to start with, my first question is uh for you, Stacy, given your experience in this space, what does the phrase humanize the numbers mean to you?
- 4:40Stacey Barr: I um it's a really important question, you know.
- 4:43Stacey Barr: I think it very early in my career that question became quite relevant.
- 4:47Stacey Barr: I um I was hired into my first corporate job as a measurement consultant because the the my manager um who hired me uh saw in me um not only the technical kind of numerical skills, and I'm not from an accounting background, I'm actually from uh mathematical statistics background, so research statistics.
- 5:07Stacey Barr: He saw that, obviously, it was on my resume, but he saw something else in me that I didn't realize was there at the time.
- 5:13Stacey Barr: And he said, I had this way of just understanding people and having an empathy for them.
- 5:20Stacey Barr: And I think bringing those two things together has been vital in the work that I do.
- 5:24Stacey Barr: And if I were to bring it down to one thing, to me, in the work I do, humanizing the numbers is to take the threat out of them for people.
- 5:31Stacey Barr: Uh to help people feel like they are tools in their hand and not rods for their back, that they are information and feedback and power to help them make better decisions rather than the numbers making decisions about them or on behalf of them.
- 5:47Stacey Barr: I think that's really a st it's a it's a really big tension um in in the markets that I work with.
- 5:54Paul Shrimpling: All right.
- 5:54Paul Shrimpling: So there's already uh loads to unpack there.
- 5:58Paul Shrimpling: Uh but I love the um what was the phrase again?
- 6:00Paul Shrimpling: There's the tools and the rods.
- 6:02Paul Shrimpling: Not rods for the back, but tools for Tools in your hand.
- 6:05Paul Shrimpling: Tools in your hand, not rods for your love.
- 6:07Paul Shrimpling: I love that.
- 6:08Paul Shrimpling: I love that.
- 6:09Paul Shrimpling: Um and it's about taking the threat out.
- 6:13Paul Shrimpling: Unpack that for me.
- 6:15Paul Shrimpling: And if you can, just point to a a story with a client or a business leader where that that we can understand what you mean by taking the threat out.
- 6:26Paul Shrimpling: Um, because numbers really are threat.
- 6:29Paul Shrimpling: You know, we live in challenging challenging times, but um go on, unpack that for me because I think that's fascinating.
- 6:36Stacey Barr: I think the the story I'll share will not well, it may.
- 6:40Stacey Barr: I I I'm not I don't know a lot about how accounting firms are run, but I think we could definitely draw a parallel.
- 6:45Stacey Barr: I um when I was uh a measurement consultant for this organization, I started working for like my job was to help all the managers measure things better.
- 6:54Stacey Barr: The safety manager was one of those people I was helping, and he'd been tracking various safety statistics for the organization for years, and uh wanted to see if he could get some more insights out of them.
- 7:07Stacey Barr: So I did that.
- 7:07Stacey Barr: I took those numbers that he was tracking and I showed those numbers in a way they'd never seen them before.
- 7:14Stacey Barr: They were used to looking at them in the typical financial way, like this month compared to last month, percentage variance, differences like that, this month's compared to the same month last year.
- 7:22Stacey Barr: I showed it to him in a time series graph.
- 7:24Stacey Barr: And the time series graph showed that absolutely nothing had changed in the last two years.
- 7:31Stacey Barr: And I presented this to him thinking I was sharing some marvelous insight and revelation that they'd never seen before.
- 7:37Stacey Barr: And he was furious.
- 7:41Stacey Barr: He he he in front of everyone told me I didn't know what I was doing.
- 7:45Stacey Barr: It was absolute, absolute idiocy what I was showing him.
- 7:48Stacey Barr: And I kind of left the meeting and just thought, my God, what happened?
- 7:52Stacey Barr: What happened was I threatened him.
- 7:54Stacey Barr: I had I hadn't said to him, look at this great insight.
- 7:57Stacey Barr: I had said, uh, you've done nothing, mate, for the last two years.
- 8:01Paul Shrimpling: Yes, right, okay.
- 8:03Stacey Barr: So people can often feel like numbers are evaluating them in some way.
- 8:07Stacey Barr: Sometimes it's overtly, sometimes it's designed into the performance management system in organizations.
- 8:12Stacey Barr: So they're used in their performance appraisals and reward and recognitions based on the numbers.
- 8:17Stacey Barr: Other times, and most times it's actually covertly, and it's a situation just like that with the safety manager that looking at the numbers is saying something really bad about me the person.
- 8:28Paul Shrimpling: But this but isn't that I guess part of the point of uh tracking the right numbers and sharing them in the right way is to bring transparency to like you say, help you make better decisions.
- 8:40Paul Shrimpling: There's a point to it.
- 8:41Paul Shrimpling: You know, one one of my challenges with lots of firms of accountants that we work with is you know that uh uh analysis paralysis, loads of numbers, but there's nothing happening as a consequence of those numbers.
- 8:51Paul Shrimpling: We've got 24 KPIs, but yeah, yeah, but you know what what changed in the last time we were looking at these is the is the key thing.
- 8:59Paul Shrimpling: So um what's um what what's needed, Stacy, to A identify the right KPIs, and I know that's a very broad question, and then after we've gone through that one, I want to know, all right, and what's the um what's the best way to then have those numbers influence a decision?
- 9:20Paul Shrimpling: Different question.
- 9:21Paul Shrimpling: But let's go with A.
- 9:22Paul Shrimpling: You know, what's the what's the process for identifying the right KPIs?
- 9:29Stacey Barr: It's to it's to put the brakes on that question, what should the KPIs be?
- 9:35Stacey Barr: We've actually got to step back a fair bit, in fact, and say, why do we even want the KPIs?
- 9:41Stacey Barr: You know, what is it we're trying to change?
- 9:43Stacey Barr: What difference are we wanting to make in the world around us?
- 9:45Stacey Barr: What impact are we trying to have?
- 9:46Stacey Barr: What do we want to be different to how to how it is now?
- 9:51Stacey Barr: We we call them goals, right?
- 9:53Stacey Barr: Goals, objectives, you know, priorities.
- 9:56Stacey Barr: Um and no matter what we call them, what they are describing is a result that we would like to be different.
- 10:04Stacey Barr: And once we're clear about that, then we can start talking about the KPIs or the numbers.
- 10:11Stacey Barr: But getting clear about those results is actually a lot harder than people think.
- 10:16Stacey Barr: Um, not everybody is into goal setting.
- 10:19Stacey Barr: Um, if they're not, then I I think it's it's sort of not much different to just being on a raft being carried along with the tides and the currents and not really having much influence over the direction that you go in.
- 10:30Stacey Barr: Um, but when we do have goals and and where they are very, very common, there's still a big mistake that people make with them and it's how they write them.
- 10:37Stacey Barr: They're not specific enough.
- 10:38Stacey Barr: They they want to sound sophisticated, they they feel like they're supposed to use business type language when they write those goals.
- 10:47Stacey Barr: So they end up full of what I call weasel words, you know, like let's be more effective and efficient and let's be resilient and and let's um have more diversity and uh um we need to have a much more sustainable kind of practice, you know.
- 11:01Stacey Barr: All of these words sound great, but they actually don't mean anything.
- 11:05Stacey Barr: Um well that well, they do, but they only have meaning when you know the specific context they're being used in.
- 11:10Stacey Barr: So we try to get away from those words, get much more specific, and then, then, then, then we are clear enough to go, yeah, I can imagine what the world would be like around me if this was happening.
- 11:21Stacey Barr: If this result was real, this is what I'd see, this is what I'd hear, this is what people would say, this is what we'd be able to touch that isn't currently there, whatever.
- 11:28Stacey Barr: Now we're at the point where we can start having the measurement conversation.
- 11:32Stacey Barr: Because what KPIs or good measures are is really uh quantifications of evidence of those results.
- 11:40Paul Shrimpling: And and isn't there something in there about the threat or the fear?
- 11:44Paul Shrimpling: Because if we get really specific, then we're creating um a level of clarity where there's nowhere to hide in terms of determining whether we achieve it or not.
- 11:56Paul Shrimpling: Is that is that fairly?
- 11:59Stacey Barr: Oh, it's very fair.
- 12:00Stacey Barr: And and it's kind of a challenge, really, because it can go one of two ways.
- 12:05Stacey Barr: Um the way we don't want it to go is for that clarity about the results that really matter to suddenly feel really frightening to people, like I don't we don't actually believe we can influence that result.
- 12:18Stacey Barr: So if we start measuring it, the measure is just gonna prove that we can't make it change.
- 12:22Stacey Barr: We've got to stay away from that kind of thing.
- 12:24Stacey Barr: And and that can be by making the goal uh something that really is within the circle of influence of the people that are gonna, you know, be trying to achieve it and therefore measuring it.
- 12:35Stacey Barr: But um sometimes we can't do anything about that.
- 12:40Stacey Barr: There's just sometimes there are just people who are not ready to know the truth.
- 12:46Stacey Barr: I can't quite handle the truth yet because it is too threatening for them.
- 12:50Stacey Barr: It's like I have to say it, right?
- 12:52Stacey Barr: I've got to call it out because it's real.
- 12:54Stacey Barr: And and it's really important to know when you're working with somebody like that, because you can't push them down the track of um of coming up with KPIs, because you're just you're just making them feel even more scared and more defensive and less resourceful and less capable of moving in the direction of achieving their goals.
- 13:13Stacey Barr: But generally, the way we really want this to go is that we start the conversation with the people who own those results, who are going to own the measures, who are going to use those measures to make better decisions.
- 13:24Stacey Barr: And the idea is to guide them through the thinking process.
- 13:27Stacey Barr: So they're making all the choices along the way.
- 13:29Stacey Barr: They're choosing what the results are, they're choosing the best words to articulate them, and they're choosing what evidence is most relevant to them, and they're choosing which measures are the best quantifications of that evidence.
- 13:39Stacey Barr: So they involvement really matters.
- 13:42Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, they build them rather than having them inflicted on them.
- 13:46Stacey Barr: Yeah.
- 13:47Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, okay.
- 13:48Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, it's I the the reason if you can see me wincing a little bit statement because I had uh just two conversations in the last 24 hours.
- 13:58Paul Shrimpling: The the the conversation with a business owner before this discussion, um, saying, Oh, we need we need someone to uh better hold us to account because we're just to use your phrase, we're just wandering around on this raft with the tides.
- 14:11Paul Shrimpling: Um and and and I go, Great.
- 14:14Paul Shrimpling: Well, if we're gonna have an accountability process, we need to know where you want to take the damn raft, quite frankly.
- 14:20Paul Shrimpling: So, you know, let's have that, and all credit to him.
- 14:23Paul Shrimpling: He said, Well, that's not about me, that's about me and my two fellow leader managers.
- 14:29Paul Shrimpling: Um, we need to do that together.
- 14:30Paul Shrimpling: And it's like, absolutely right.
- 14:32Paul Shrimpling: So I'm so I'm I'm marginally reassured that I'm I'm adopting the right process there.
- 14:37Paul Shrimpling: Um, the other conversation though was with eight managers that uh we're in a uh sort of training development program with, and um we're all on a Teams call.
- 14:48Paul Shrimpling: So, look, we're going into this next session in a few weeks' time, and we're gonna talk about goals.
- 14:52Paul Shrimpling: And I could see all their faces go, oh, duh, do I know?
- 14:56Paul Shrimpling: Um and it's like, well, I'm gonna have to deal with that in the session.
- 15:01Paul Shrimpling: It was what wasn't wasn't right to deal with that um uh energy downgrade because we're talking about goal.
- 15:07Paul Shrimpling: What is it about these are managers and leaders on a career path who ostensibly don't want to take goals seriously.
- 15:15Paul Shrimpling: What am I what am I doing wrong, or what do I need to do better when I get in a room with them in two or three weeks' time, do you think?
- 16:16Stacey Barr: That's um that's a brilliant question.
- 16:18Stacey Barr: Uh the um I I think sometimes um asking people where they want to go, where they want that to steer that raft to can be a little confronting if they've not reflected on that before.
- 16:33Stacey Barr: But you know, you know how humans tend to be more um like we're very hardwired to avoid things rather than pursue things.
- 16:41Stacey Barr: So we're we're we're much more motivated by risk than we are by um possibility, I think.
- 16:49Stacey Barr: Uh so sometimes it can really help to flip it 180 degrees around.
- 16:54Stacey Barr: And rather than asking them what goals do you have, where do you want to go, just say, what are we trying to make sure never happens?
- 17:01Stacey Barr: What's your worst nightmare?
- 17:03Stacey Barr: What do we want to move away from?
- 17:04Stacey Barr: What's going on now that's driving your baddie that you just don't like, you wish it was different, you want it to go away.
- 17:10Stacey Barr: And they'll find that much easier to talk about.
- 17:12Stacey Barr: And then once you get them talking about that and articulating it, you just then turn that 180 degrees back again and you're getting closer to what the goals might be.
- 17:22Paul Shrimpling: Love that.
- 17:23Paul Shrimpling: Um so what are we 40 minutes into a conversation, and I've got oh, KPI is a change management tool that people are afraid of.
- 17:34Paul Shrimpling: Um and actually the way to overcome the fear is flip it 180 degrees.
- 17:39Paul Shrimpling: Let's talk about what they want to avoid at all costs, what they're really concerned about.
- 17:46Paul Shrimpling: Um, they have to participate in that conversation clearly, so they're the the and act they're actively involved, and then when we've got some clarity around that, we can flip it and then start to turn it into a KPI number, which is a goals focus rather than a you know, is that pain and gain thing, isn't it?
- 18:05Paul Shrimpling: Let's talk about the pain that you want to avoid before we talk about the gain that you want to achieve.
- 18:09Paul Shrimpling: Have I understood that right?
- 18:11Stacey Barr: Yeah, I think so because often um well, A, the pain is so much easier for us to talk about and identify with.
- 18:19Stacey Barr: I mean, that it's the pains that wake us up at 2 a.m.
- 18:21Stacey Barr: and stop us from getting back to sleep, not the gains.
- 18:24Stacey Barr: Um, but the pains are a very, very good clue for what the gains should be.
- 18:29Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 18:30Paul Shrimpling: Cool, cool.
- 18:31Paul Shrimpling: Uh so got to be specific and measurable, uh, KPIs.
- 18:35Paul Shrimpling: What what what evidence have you got that uh KPIs really make a difference to a manager or a business, Stacey?
- 18:43Paul Shrimpling: So I'm trying to unpack a little bit about pumping your organization and the impact you're having, but I'm trying to get to some evidence-based insights around, yeah, yeah, you get smarter on KPIs and it pays off.
- 18:54Paul Shrimpling: What can you share with us in terms of anecdotal, story-based or and statistic-based insights on that?
- 19:01Stacey Barr: I can give you anecdotal stories and uh you'll have to take take it on my word that it's these anecdotal stories are so typical of what I hear all the time.
- 19:12Stacey Barr: Because measuring the impact of measurement in organizations that are new to measurement is so hard.
- 19:18Stacey Barr: If I was gonna do that, if I was gonna give you quantitative evidence that measurement makes a difference, there are there are two things I would I would try to measure for you.
- 19:27Stacey Barr: And when I say what they are, you'll understand why the data is so hard to collect for it.
- 19:31Stacey Barr: So, number one would be they would um you know, the users of the measures would suddenly be achieving their goals so much quicker than they had in the past.
- 19:41Stacey Barr: You know, we often set annual goals, five-year goals, quarterly goals.
- 19:45Stacey Barr: They would be achieving them much sooner.
- 19:48Stacey Barr: That would be the one thing.
- 19:49Stacey Barr: So it's a time-based KPI, that one.
- 19:52Stacey Barr: Uh, and of course, I can't get the data for that because nobody is recording how long it takes them to achieve their goals in the past.
- 19:59Stacey Barr: So it's kind of difficult.
- 20:01Stacey Barr: The second thing though, um Paul, would be what proportion of their goals they're able to achieve or at least make some progress on.
- 20:09Stacey Barr: Like we we tend to just do the planning, have some goals, and then throw around a few anecdotes at the end to say, oh, whether we achieved the goal or all the good reasons why we didn't didn't, but we don't actually quantify our ability to achieve goals.
- 20:22Stacey Barr: So that would be the other thing I'd be measuring.
- 20:24Stacey Barr: And and having good KPIs is a catalyst to achieve both those things because KPIs give us what nothing else can.
- 20:33Stacey Barr: There are no other anecdotes uh or um hearsay or stories or or anything that can can be as convincing as a as a number.
- 20:41Stacey Barr: Humans are not very good at tracking things through time, right?
- 20:46Stacey Barr: We're we're kind of more immediate.
- 20:48Stacey Barr: We we can't tell how much something has changed over the last two to five five years.
- 20:54Stacey Barr: We also uh have biases in where we put our attention.
- 20:59Stacey Barr: So often there'll be things numbers can tell us that we never can see with our eyes or ears, just by kind of hunting around and finding out.
- 21:06Stacey Barr: So numbers give us kind of like a well, you I said I like motorcycles, right?
- 21:11Stacey Barr: So I like working on motorcycles as well.
- 21:14Stacey Barr: Um we can't work on motorcycles with our bare hands, right?
- 21:19Stacey Barr: We can't.
- 21:20Stacey Barr: We need spanners and screwdrivers, ratchets.
- 21:23Stacey Barr: Um sometimes you need a hammer.
- 21:26Stacey Barr: You don't want to ever use a hammer, but maybe sometimes you so the tools are helping us do with that motorcycle what we can't do any other way.
- 21:37Stacey Barr: And that's what numbers are like in our business.
- 21:39Stacey Barr: They they do things for us that we can't do any other way.
- 21:41Stacey Barr: The anecdotes that tell me that this is all true, that measurement really does make a difference, is how excited I see people when I've just facilitated them through creating their first meaningful KPI that they feel incredible ownership of.
- 21:55Stacey Barr: They go, yes, this is what this is about.
- 21:58Stacey Barr: This is what matters to us, and yes, we really want to make this thing shift.
- 22:02Stacey Barr: And they go and they get the data and they put it in a graph and they get so excited to see signals and and to make clearer decisions.
- 22:09Stacey Barr: So they're the kinds of stories I hear over and over again.
- 22:12Stacey Barr: Um, and yeah, they're unfortunately they're the subjective anecdotal stuff.
- 22:16Stacey Barr: Well, maybe not unfortunately.
- 22:18Stacey Barr: I'd I'd like it to be quantitative as well, but the stories still do matter.
- 22:22Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 22:22Paul Shrimpling: I love that you've got that measuring the impact of measurement.
- 22:25Paul Shrimpling: It's like that that Satan almost flips your brain out a little bit, doesn't it?
- 22:28Paul Shrimpling: And then you go, how how hard could that possibly be?
- 22:30Paul Shrimpling: Well, clearly very hard.
- 22:32Paul Shrimpling: Um but I you know I I I revert to um the uh which you may be familiar with the the lock and lay them uh research, you know, 300 plus studies on goal setting uh that clearly shows it works, and it only works if ultimately it results in specific measures that guide and influence you.
- 22:53Paul Shrimpling: Decision making.
- 22:54Paul Shrimpling: So there's you know, there is if anyone's like itching for uh away from the anecdotal, we'll get into the deep research by Locker Leyden, which is okay, it's a little bit old now, but it's still referenced by anyone who writes anything and does any research on goal setup.
- 23:08Paul Shrimpling: Um, but there was there's a in in your anecdotal story, you suggested that someone would get excited about a single KPI, as opposed to what I see with lots of accountants who want to talk KPIs with their team and maybe talk about KPIs with their customers, their clients, uh, want KPIs for everything, uh, which then moves us away from focus, maybe.
- 23:37Paul Shrimpling: So, can we can you we just dive into your knowledge or experience in and around, you know, less is more on the KPI front?
- 23:45Paul Shrimpling: Or so what how do you how do you decide what are the right numbers?
- 23:48Paul Shrimpling: Yes, attached to goals.
- 23:50Paul Shrimpling: So I'm no one repeating myself on that question.
- 23:53Paul Shrimpling: Um, and you know, how many?
- 23:56Stacey Barr: Um okay, two-part answer to this.
- 23:59Stacey Barr: I'll I'll come straight up with a number for you three to five for anyone person or team.
- 24:04Stacey Barr: You you just can't improve more than that.
- 24:06Stacey Barr: Now, um 40x, um Franklin Covey's four disciplines of execution, they write about this and I love it.
- 24:12Stacey Barr: They talk about wigs, wildly important goals.
- 24:15Stacey Barr: And they they say that you really, they would say only have one or two.
- 24:20Stacey Barr: Because uh there, I I don't know if they did research, but I think they have found that if you have if you have uh one or two goals, you're likely to achieve both of them almost with certainty.
- 24:35Stacey Barr: If you've got three to five goals, or three to ten, I can't remember now, um you're likely to achieve maybe half of them.
- 24:45Stacey Barr: But if you've got more than ten, you're not gonna achieve any of them.
- 24:50Stacey Barr: So the more goals you have, the fewer you're gonna achieve.
- 24:54Stacey Barr: And I think that's um that's you know, pretty, pretty uh Yeah, you're diluted your efforts, you're diluting your energies, aren't you?
- 25:01Paul Shrimpling: Yeah.
- 25:01Paul Shrimpling: So you know that common sense would say that that that makes sense.
- 25:05Stacey Barr: So that's but to get to that oh sorry, this is the second part of what I was gonna say, Paul, is that to get to that the the two or three that really matter most, um I like to use uh what I call the should can will test.
- 25:20Stacey Barr: Should we really improve this?
- 25:23Stacey Barr: Is question one.
- 25:25Stacey Barr: So you might have 10 goals.
- 25:27Stacey Barr: You'll ask should can will of all of all 10 of them.
- 25:31Stacey Barr: Should we really achieve this?
- 25:33Stacey Barr: Well, okay, maybe it's a yes, maybe it's a no, but it's probably a yes, right?
- 25:37Stacey Barr: The next question is can we achieve this?
- 25:41Stacey Barr: And in other words, do we have enough influence to really affect this?
- 25:45Stacey Barr: Is it within our circle?
- 25:49Stacey Barr: Not our circle of control.
- 25:50Stacey Barr: I don't like talking about that because um not much is is truly within our control, but is it within our circle of influence?
- 25:56Stacey Barr: Can through our actions and decisions we make some definite impact on this?
- 26:00Stacey Barr: That could be a yes or a no.
- 26:02Stacey Barr: And the third question is will we?
- 26:04Stacey Barr: And the will question is actually the hardest one to answer because it means you've got to you've got to be very honest with yourself.
- 26:11Stacey Barr: Have you got the resources?
- 26:13Stacey Barr: Have you got the time and resources to dead set commit to to improving it?
- 26:18Stacey Barr: Because it's not going to improve on its own.
- 26:20Stacey Barr: It's not gonna improve it just because you're monitoring it, it's not gonna improve it just because you tell everybody in your practice it matters and they should do something about it.
- 26:27Stacey Barr: It's only gonna improve if you dedicate time and resources to it, and that means taking time and resources off something else.
- 26:33Stacey Barr: So should can will is how you arrive at those one or two goals.
- 26:37Stacey Barr: And for those one or two goals, then then you're probably gonna end up with three to five KPIs.
- 26:43Paul Shrimpling: Okay, okay.
- 26:44Paul Shrimpling: So just so that I I've I'm hard wiring this in the right way, I just want to sense check.
- 26:49Paul Shrimpling: So should we is about is this goal, is this KPI attached to that goal relevant to us in our situation?
- 26:55Paul Shrimpling: Um, can we is about can we influence it?
- 26:59Paul Shrimpling: And I've got a question on that in a second, and then will we is about commitment, time and resource.
- 27:05Paul Shrimpling: So so brilliant.
- 27:06Paul Shrimpling: So can we is can we influence resources, people, tool, whatever, in order to actually achieve the uh the KPI, the goal.
- 27:16Paul Shrimpling: Um isn't there something in there about belief as well, Stacey?
- 27:20Paul Shrimpling: I there's you know, um if um if people don't believe they can, they're never gonna be committed, are they?
- 27:26Paul Shrimpling: So I'm I'm uh it just triggered something often because it it's um doesn't matter how good, what tools, what resource, all the rest of it, if the belief isn't there, nothing's gonna happen.
- 27:38Paul Shrimpling: I mean, I might be wrong with that.
- 27:40Stacey Barr: I never thought about that.
- 27:41Stacey Barr: Never thought about bringing belief into that, but I I I agree with you that it is absolutely relevant.
- 27:48Stacey Barr: And I do agree with you that it is under that um can question.
- 27:52Stacey Barr: Because can is a belief.
- 27:55Stacey Barr: Can I do this?
- 27:56Stacey Barr: Do I believe I can do this?
- 27:58Stacey Barr: If there's no belief there, then no, I can't do it.
- 28:00Stacey Barr: So yeah, I I I 100% doubt that.
- 28:03Stacey Barr: All right, then.
- 28:03Paul Shrimpling: Well, let me go down that avenue a little bit further, then, because it comes out of the lock and lather research.
- 28:07Paul Shrimpling: This, which is if you've got um finite, limited uh time and resource, the can we is about having a realistic goal.
- 28:18Paul Shrimpling: And if it's realistic, so we build belief.
- 28:20Paul Shrimpling: If it's realistic, more likely that we can influence it as well.
- 28:24Paul Shrimpling: If we've got uh um less finite boundaries, for example, um, we've got in the next 13 weeks we want to achieve this goal.
- 28:33Paul Shrimpling: Here's two KPIs, and if we do the activity to drive those KPIs, we'll hit that goal.
- 28:38Paul Shrimpling: So that's a finite timeline.
- 28:40Paul Shrimpling: There needs to be some realism around that.
- 28:43Paul Shrimpling: So, for example, I've just started swimming again, and my uh 100 meter time is averaging um one minute and 52, and so I'm going, all right, by June, fairly limited amount of time because I only swim once or twice a week.
- 28:57Paul Shrimpling: Uh, can I get that down to um 130?
- 29:02Paul Shrimpling: Wow, that feels um unrealistic.
- 29:06Paul Shrimpling: But if I can get it to 140, I'd be delighted.
- 29:09Paul Shrimpling: Right, okay, and so I'm being more realistic because the timeline is limited.
- 29:13Paul Shrimpling: But if I go, oh, by the end of the year, can I get it to 130?
- 29:18Paul Shrimpling: Well, yeah, maybe I can, but maybe I'll have to swim twice a week, every week or year, and it's driving and influencing my decision making.
- 29:26Paul Shrimpling: And and Loch and Latham's research point to the fact that when you've got uh it's further away and means much more things can change, therefore, we can be more ambitious, which influences our thinking, and therefore also influences our belief levels so that we actually step into the space.
- 29:44Paul Shrimpling: Uh so I'm just voicing um insights, trying to fold it into this framework around should we, can we, um will we?
- 29:51Paul Shrimpling: So um there's I I always think of smart, you know, the smart framework, specific measurable A is for is it achievable or ambitious?
- 30:01Paul Shrimpling: Well, it depends on the time frame.
- 30:03Stacey Barr: It's achieved achievable.
- 30:05Stacey Barr: And I think um uh everything is achievable if you have um the resources and the time available.
- 30:16Stacey Barr: Okay.
- 30:17Stacey Barr: And like you're actually adding another layer in here, Paul.
- 30:20Stacey Barr: So there's the should can will, which are questions that we ask to decide if a goal is a priority enough to bother measuring and improving.
- 30:28Stacey Barr: But what you're talking about, you're adding another layer, which is targets.
- 30:32Stacey Barr: And when it comes to targets, the targets attached to the KPI, right?
- 30:35Stacey Barr: So you told you you told us your baseline 100-meter time.
- 30:40Stacey Barr: You also told us what a target might be, and you started talking about the time to achieve it.
- 30:46Stacey Barr: This is where belief comes back into the equation, I think, uh, and and resource, of course.
- 30:51Stacey Barr: But one of the things um I encourage people to do when they're starting to set those targets for their KPIs is to to not think so much about achievable, but to think more about uh trajectory.
- 31:09Stacey Barr: And so I never generally set just a single target for a KPI, like by the end of the year, I'll take um what's it gonna be?
- 31:17Stacey Barr: 20 seconds off your 100 meter time.
- 31:19Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 31:20Paul Shrimpling: What I would 22, I think.
- 31:22Stacey Barr: Yeah, well, there you go.
- 31:23Stacey Barr: That's a lot.
- 31:23Stacey Barr: That's a lot.
- 31:25Stacey Barr: So um so my my my lap times around my favorite track on the motorcycle are about kind of um, they started out being about a minute 30.
- 31:35Stacey Barr: And then in the first year I got them down to about a minute 20.
- 31:39Stacey Barr: And then trying to get it down below that is taking so much time.
- 31:43Paul Shrimpling: Marginal gains.
- 31:44Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 31:45Stacey Barr: Yeah, you got you the harder it, the harder, um, or the closer you get to your end goal, the harder it is to achieve it.
- 31:51Stacey Barr: So, what is a target trajectory?
- 31:53Stacey Barr: Generally, I would say it's three targets.
- 31:55Stacey Barr: So it could be that in six months' time, you've taken uh five or ten seconds off your hundred meter time.
- 32:02Stacey Barr: And really, you're picking something, you know, is pretty easy, pretty predictable, won't take you changing much at all to get to get that.
- 32:11Stacey Barr: And and why that's important, that first target, is that it builds our belief.
- 32:16Stacey Barr: It bolsters this feeling that we do have influence, that we can affect a change in this thing.
- 32:23Stacey Barr: It also teaches us what kind of change we can get for the effort that we thought it was going to take.
- 32:28Stacey Barr: So standing on the shoulders of that first target, a next harder target actually isn't quite as scary anymore.
- 32:36Stacey Barr: So the second target is something a bit more challenging.
- 32:40Stacey Barr: Um, it's still giving yourself enough time to achieve it.
- 32:43Stacey Barr: Um and you almost believe you can, you know, but achieving that first target is what really makes you think, yeah, let's go for it.
- 32:52Stacey Barr: I'm motivated, I feel like this is really something worth pursuing.
- 32:56Stacey Barr: But you sometimes you can set a third target, which is what we often call the stretch target, the one that is so far outside of your comfort zone, of your belief system, of your resource availability.
- 33:08Stacey Barr: But the reason for setting the stretch target is not to hit it, but to stretch you further than you otherwise would have gone.
- 33:17Paul Shrimpling: I love that.
- 33:18Paul Shrimpling: I love that.
- 33:19Paul Shrimpling: Uh, and it's and it connects with some of the work that we do, some of the firms and some of the managers and leaders that we work with in terms of oh, okay, let's uh let's go after low-hanging fruit, build a sense of belief, and then do a reset.
- 33:31Paul Shrimpling: And the resets are now let's be a little bit more ambitious, but still in the realms of achievable.
- 33:36Paul Shrimpling: And so I've just I've written, well, if um uh five to ten seconds in six months is the build belief one for me.
- 33:44Paul Shrimpling: Um, maybe the next one is five to ten seconds in three months, so I've just changed the timeline rather than the quantum.
- 33:52Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, um, and then the the the um uh uh let's call it ambitious.
- 33:58Paul Shrimpling: The ambitious one is uh 20 seconds in the next three months.
- 34:02Paul Shrimpling: That's wild.
- 34:03Paul Shrimpling: That is absolutely wild.
- 34:05Paul Shrimpling: Now I have swum at at my I've never been a great swimmer at peak at 1.30.
- 34:11Paul Shrimpling: I have done that, I know I can do that.
- 34:14Paul Shrimpling: Um but it was in races 10 years ago when my shoulder worked.
- 34:18Paul Shrimpling: Um so there's that in the back in the back of my head is well, hey, you're 10 years older and you and your shoulders knackered, so that might not be we'll see.
- 34:26Paul Shrimpling: Um because there are limits, but I love that build belief, um, bit of a stretch, then big stretch, which change your thinking, um which you might not achieve, but you'll move yourself further forward than you otherwise would have done, maybe.
- 34:42Stacey Barr: Um that's it.
- 34:44Stacey Barr: And you have fun doing it.
- 34:45Stacey Barr: It's not so much about setting these targets in stone and then judging yourself by whether you hit or miss them.
- 34:50Stacey Barr: I love the phrase reach for targets.
- 34:55Stacey Barr: I hate the phrase, hit targets.
- 34:58Stacey Barr: And what do we talk about in business all the time?
- 35:00Stacey Barr: I've got to hit that target.
- 35:01Stacey Barr: We really want the team to hit that target, you should hit this target.
- 35:04Stacey Barr: Hitting targets is not what it's about.
- 35:06Stacey Barr: Targets need to be motivating to work, and the only way they can be motivating is if we play with them, if we use them to help us learn about what it takes to make change happen and stand on the shoulders of each improvement that we make and go a little bit further.
- 35:21Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 35:22Paul Shrimpling: So that that that then lends itself to uh uh another uh topic that I'm always challenging people on, and I'm not sure I'm doing it as well as I could, so I'm hoping you'll be able to influence this as well.
- 35:34Paul Shrimpling: Is uh so we've we've had a conversation with our team member or our client uh around goals, we've helped them focus through the should can uh will process.
- 35:46Paul Shrimpling: Um, so we've narrowed it down to one or two, maybe three, and then we're unpacking the specific measurable KPIs that then drive us to that goal, which for me uh Stacey, there's uh two types of numbers there's outcome and uh input, you know, input and output.
- 36:08Paul Shrimpling: There's the input or activity or causal KPIs, and then there's the output result um effect as a consequence.
- 36:17Paul Shrimpling: Um, do you want to just give us your thoughts on um whether we should be zeroing in on output numbers or input numbers?
- 36:26Stacey Barr: The um the challenge I've always had, I totally hear you, Paul.
- 36:30Stacey Barr: Um, it's not gonna sound like I'm agreeing with you to start with, but look, give me a chat to get there.
- 36:37Paul Shrimpling: Okay, I'll go with it.
- 36:38Paul Shrimpling: I'll go with it.
- 36:39Stacey Barr: Yeah, yeah, just yeah.
- 36:40Stacey Barr: You can do what you like with it.
- 36:42Stacey Barr: They completely reject it if you want to.
- 36:44Stacey Barr: Um inputs and outputs are difficult to talk about because one person's inputs is somebody else's outputs, uh, and other people's outputs are other people's inputs.
- 36:54Stacey Barr: So it sounds too binary for me.
- 36:56Stacey Barr: I've struggled with it.
- 36:57Stacey Barr: So what we've always done in my work is we've we've really just built a cause-effect map of the and we call them results, we'll call them goals, but in our language we call them results because we're not talking about actions here.
- 37:11Stacey Barr: Actions definitely are the things we have to do to affect to make it a result different.
- 37:16Stacey Barr: But um but but a map, a causal map of results helps uh us understand um oh, what's a good metaphor here?
- 37:29Stacey Barr: It's kind of like the the story of our business or the story of our hobby or our sport and all the different pieces in it that play a role and how the relationships they have to each other and understanding that bigger picture and and the organic, maybe organic's not the right word, but the that interrelatedness of it all is really powerful and important because it's too easy just to get myopic and focus on one or two KPIs, not understanding the consequences they have on other KPIs, or how there's leverage from a different set of KPIs that could be helping you out.
- 38:04Stacey Barr: So building that map is is an important thing.
- 38:08Stacey Barr: Look, um, I am more than happy to share this um with you.
- 38:12Stacey Barr: Maybe it's best to put it in the show notes because no one's gonna remember it from a conversation.
- 38:17Stacey Barr: But I've got an article on my website about a thing called a results map, which is the visual of exactly what I'm talking about.
- 38:24Stacey Barr: Now, a lot of people look at that and they get blown away.
- 38:27Stacey Barr: The first reason they get blown away is they go, oh my God, that looks complex.
- 38:30Stacey Barr: But once they understand how it works, they go, Oh my god, this is this is it.
- 38:36Stacey Barr: This is the clarity that I've needed.
- 38:39Stacey Barr: So mostly, of course, results maps are used to help tie different teams together and align them to the strategic direction of the larger clients that we have, the government agencies, the nonprofit organizations, whatever.
- 38:52Stacey Barr: But I have a results map just for me in my business.
- 38:55Stacey Barr: So it can work on both levels.
- 38:57Stacey Barr: You could build a little results map for your swimming.
- 38:59Stacey Barr: Um, I may admit to you that I've built a little results map for my motorcycle track days to try and get my lap times down.
- 39:07Stacey Barr: But the clarity helps you think through what are all the different moving pieces here that have got to move in unison and in synergy so that I can get that end result that I want.
- 39:17Paul Shrimpling: All right.
- 39:18Paul Shrimpling: So I just want to turn that into maybe a practical, relevant discussion for an accounting firm who's listening into this.
- 39:24Paul Shrimpling: So we we we talk about a um interrelated, I guess we'd call that a map, interrelated map.
- 39:31Paul Shrimpling: Um, every every leader, manager of a team of an accounting firm want to achieve what we call sustainable results.
- 39:39Paul Shrimpling: Of course they do, you know.
- 39:40Paul Shrimpling: Yes, they want to grow and then they want to grow again.
- 39:43Paul Shrimpling: Grow what?
- 39:44Paul Shrimpling: Well, that's personal to each individual firm.
- 39:46Paul Shrimpling: So we're not necessarily dive into that detail.
- 39:48Paul Shrimpling: But they want sustainable success.
- 39:50Paul Shrimpling: Well, common sense suggests that you can't achieve sustainable success unless you've got client loyalty.
- 39:58Paul Shrimpling: Well, client loyalty breaks into okay, we've got to deliver a quality service or quality report, whether it be tax returns, audit report, annual accounts, whatever it is.
- 40:08Paul Shrimpling: Uh, we've got to do it in a timely way, and we've got to do it uh with care, i.e., the client feels in all the interactions that they feel looked after and therefore trust you.
- 40:19Paul Shrimpling: So there's three inputs to client loyalty, um, but there's the team have to deliver on that, and then there's inputs into the team from the managers that have to, and I'm just wondering, am I in the right space here in terms of building this interrelated map?
- 40:36Paul Shrimpling: And so we can influence one thing, but if it downgrades another, because we're investing more time in that than we are in that, and in an accounting firm, Stacey, typically people are massively invested in time and resources in doing the technical work of accounts, and they play down the fact that we should have more conversations more often with the clients to build a stronger relationship so that they stay loyal.
- 41:00Paul Shrimpling: Well, actually, the client needs both.
- 41:02Paul Shrimpling: Oh, and by the way, they need it on time.
- 41:04Paul Shrimpling: Uh, and so uh, but when they when we look when we do a time challenge, just show me how much time in the working week you've invested in talking to your clients.
- 41:13Paul Shrimpling: And they go, Oh, not very much.
- 41:15Paul Shrimpling: Well, okay.
- 41:16Paul Shrimpling: Um so I'm in the right space, am I, in terms of that relational, interrelated.
- 41:22Stacey Barr: And your story even brings out another truth here, which is I think can often be the elephant in the room when people are trying to build this stuff, is that all of these things are in a tension or a balance with each other.
- 41:36Stacey Barr: It's not about maximizing all of them.
- 41:38Stacey Barr: You can't have a business where everything's maximized.
- 41:41Stacey Barr: You have to figure out what your trade-offs are going to be.
- 41:43Stacey Barr: So, are you an accounting firm that wants to be known primarily for your precision and accuracy?
- 41:52Stacey Barr: And then you position yourself that way and you don't ignore the client relationship stuff, but you take a different approach to it so that it's not drawing on too much of your bandwidth and and sort of robbing you from that that that positioning that you want to have around accuracy.
- 42:08Stacey Barr: Or you may want to be an accounting firm where you are known for um just being so approachable and make make your clients feel smart when they come to see you.
- 42:18Stacey Barr: And so if that's your position, you still need the accuracy, sure.
- 42:22Stacey Barr: But you're gonna put more effort into um that conversation that you have with your clients.
- 42:28Stacey Barr: Very well-crafted conversations, being able to have that empathy and really hear what your clients are struggling with and being at the ready to respond to them or to do something for them that puts them at ease and helps them feel like they are making good decisions or whatever.
- 42:43Stacey Barr: So it you balance, you find the balance that works for you, I guess.
- 42:47Paul Shrimpling: Please forgive this brief interruption.
- 42:48Paul Shrimpling: Stacy and I are talking about KPIs, goals, sustainable success.
- 42:53Paul Shrimpling: If you want to dive deeper into a brief business breakthrough that you can read in the time it takes to drink a cup of tea or coffee about KPIs and sustainable success, check out the URL link in the show notes.
- 43:07Paul Shrimpling: Let's get back to the discussion with Stacy now.
- 43:10Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, I I've written balance, but I've also written uh focus and priority.
- 43:16Paul Shrimpling: But what I never thought we'd get here on this discussion, by the way.
- 43:19Paul Shrimpling: But actually, what you've just given me is a bridge between sort of the goals KPIs conversation in that um you know relational map of the influencers and the KPIs, and it connects with what your firm stands for, which is that core purpose.
- 43:36Paul Shrimpling: So, why why why do you exist in business as a as a as a firm?
- 43:42Paul Shrimpling: Um, then starts to influence your goal priorities and therefore your KPI focus and therefore what you actually deliver.
- 43:51Paul Shrimpling: Um, who'd have thought we'd have got from build a bridge between KPIs and purpose?
- 43:56Paul Shrimpling: I love that.
- 43:57Paul Shrimpling: Love that.
- 43:58Stacey Barr: Well, look at the name of your podcast, just humanize the numbers.
- 44:01Stacey Barr: You can't not talk about the I love the fact that we're doing this.
- 44:07Paul Shrimpling: Good, me too, me too.
- 44:08Paul Shrimpling: So let's um let's talk about something else then, because yeah, um if I there isn't a firm of accountants on the planet who doesn't measure some KPIs, some numbers every month, and doesn't maybe measure some numbers every quarter, and doesn't measure and track some numbers every year.
- 44:29Paul Shrimpling: So the yearly numbers look like profit and loss and balance sheet numbers, maybe some other KPIs in there in the marketing and sales space, uh people development space, maybe even.
- 44:41Paul Shrimpling: Because they're required to by their institutes.
- 44:44Paul Shrimpling: My question in this space is what's the right cadence to ensure that you perform on your KPIs?
- 44:54Stacey Barr: Ooh, you even use the word cadence.
- 44:57Stacey Barr: I like that word.
- 44:58Stacey Barr: Often it's frequency.
- 45:00Stacey Barr: How frequently should I be reporting and measuring this?
- 45:03Stacey Barr: Cadence is a really important thing.
- 45:06Stacey Barr: There isn't one right answer.
- 45:09Stacey Barr: You can't know your profit and loss until the end of the financial year when it's properly calculated.
- 45:17Stacey Barr: So you can't monitor that any more frequently than annually.
- 45:22Stacey Barr: So that's the appropriate cadence for that.
- 45:24Stacey Barr: Does that mean you've got to wait 12 months before you know if you're going to be profitable or not?
- 45:29Stacey Barr: Of course not.
- 45:30Stacey Barr: There are other things you can monitor monthly that, you know, just a simple look at revenue and costs would give you a feel for where that's headed.
- 45:41Stacey Barr: The trends in costs and the trends in revenue are really important as well because they will tell you are we heading in the right direction toward a profitable end of year or are we not?
- 45:53Stacey Barr: Or is it looking like it's same old, same old?
- 45:56Stacey Barr: And there could be other things that you want to track even more frequently because they are, I call them drivers, I guess, but you you mentioned before this this input-output cause-effect kind of relationship, things that are important to track weekly that might drive the revenue.
- 46:12Stacey Barr: And that weekly cadence might be a discipline in uh approaching new potential clients or learning the art and the skill of converting potential clients into actual clients and looking after the clients that you have.
- 46:29Stacey Barr: And these are things that you could monitor on a weekly cadence.
- 46:32Stacey Barr: So the cadence, um, you don't really know what it's going to be until you know what you're measuring.
- 46:38Stacey Barr: Um measuring more frequently, I think, is better generally than measuring infrequently because uh the looking at the the change in a KPI over time, you get much more reliable uh signals with more data, with more measure values, with in other words, a higher cadence.
- 46:59Stacey Barr: But some KPIs will not lend themselves to that where you simply do not have the data that frequently.
- 47:06Stacey Barr: It's either too expensive or it's illogical, it just doesn't exist, so you can't measure that frequently.
- 47:10Stacey Barr: So cadence is a decision that comes after you've decided what um what the KPI actually will be.
- 47:17Paul Shrimpling: Okay, all right.
- 47:18Paul Shrimpling: And this is where you know, because we're in that humanize the numbers space.
- 47:21Paul Shrimpling: So if it's and it's easy to look at this from a team member uh perspective.
- 47:26Paul Shrimpling: So I I use a phrase which is I think um it doesn't matter what your sport is, but let's talk team sports, whether it be, you know, mine's rugby, as everyone on this podcast knows.
- 47:37Paul Shrimpling: Um uh football, netball, hockey.
- 47:40Paul Shrimpling: Uh we're in the middle of the uh Winter Olympics as we record this.
- 47:43Paul Shrimpling: So it could be ice hockey, um uh could be team.
- 47:47Paul Shrimpling: Uh I'm I'm I'm obsessed with the biathlon having uh died so that that's and then there was this team biathlon race, which I've invested an hour and a half in my life completely obsessed, thinking, oh, I wish I was 20 years younger, I'd like to do that.
- 47:58Paul Shrimpling: Um uh every game has got a timeline attached to it.
- 48:04Paul Shrimpling: So a rugby match is uh 80 minutes, two halves of 40 minutes.
- 48:10Paul Shrimpling: Um, we've got to play the game in that time.
- 48:12Paul Shrimpling: Um, I always think the working week is the timeline for the game called work for all of our team members, and that's why I've got this obsession around we've got to work out, and you've used the phrase which, or the word rather, which I think is key here, is um the KPIs that drive the performance of a week so that everyone in the team feels a sense of achievement.
- 48:34Paul Shrimpling: Which, if we dive into the Sorato research on enthusiastic employee with 13.7 million employee surveys, suggests that actually feeling a sense of achievement is key to a highly enthusiastic team, of course.
- 48:47Paul Shrimpling: Um, so we've got this weekly game being played called work, whether you're on a two-day week or a four-day week or a five-day week, whatever it is.
- 48:54Paul Shrimpling: Um, and therefore, I've just got if we've got weekly drivers and work them out connected with the goal that's relevant to us and the firm and the team, and we can see how it's interrelated, uh, we'll have a whole series of weekly signals which will influence our decision making.
- 49:14Paul Shrimpling: Uh, that sounds really powerful to me.
- 49:17Stacey Barr: It is very powerful, very powerful.
- 49:19Stacey Barr: Um, you got me thinking about a um a webcast uh that my team and I ran uh last year called Um Four Measures of Progress, Four Types of Progress Measures we talked about.
- 49:34Stacey Barr: And you gave some examples there of one of the types of progress measures we call a quota measure.
- 49:40Stacey Barr: And quota measures are really good for team, teams, for individuals to set those weekly behavioral goals, like how many uh new prospective clients will I reach out to, or how many current client conversations will I will I have.
- 49:58Stacey Barr: And maybe the team's aiming for five or ten of those each.
- 50:02Stacey Barr: And and then they actually do them and they count them up and they compare them to how many they were hoping for, and then you've got your quota measure.
- 50:08Stacey Barr: And those quota measures can be, when they're used in the right way, can be a very healthy way to drive some of those performance measures of client engagement, client retention, new client conversion.
- 50:27Stacey Barr: But I I mentioned the word healthy when they're used in a healthy way because you I think we all have heard the horror stories of quota measures used in uh, say, call centers, where they've got to get through so many calls in a in a day, and they end up not doing any quality work at all and doing more damage to the bottom line rather than driving it in a positive way.
- 50:49Stacey Barr: So it has to be a healthy use of measures like the quota measures.
- 50:52Stacey Barr: So yeah.
- 50:53Paul Shrimpling: No, it's um we spend uh a good chunk of our time talking about strategic health with all the leadership teams we work with.
- 51:01Paul Shrimpling: Yeah.
- 51:01Paul Shrimpling: Uh not strategy, strategic health.
- 51:04Paul Shrimpling: Of course, there's a sustainability element to that.
- 51:07Paul Shrimpling: So there's also, because we've touched on it in this discussion, there's we've got to maintain psychological safety across the team for them to feel that they can perform in this space.
- 51:18Paul Shrimpling: And so if KPIs take them out of that, they're going to be unhealthy.
- 51:21Paul Shrimpling: If they take them out of psychological safety, they're going to be unhealthy.
- 51:25Paul Shrimpling: Um, you know, we'll get some leaders who are pushed back and go, Well, in this woke world we now live in, we can't achieve what we used to achieve when in my day, um, because everyone's a bit soft now.
- 51:35Paul Shrimpling: Um, do you do do you buy that?
- 51:40Stacey Barr: Oh, I I don't know.
- 51:41Stacey Barr: I think I think every generation goes through something that they can blame previous generations for and disconnect from previous generations.
- 51:49Stacey Barr: I try not to get into it.
- 51:51Stacey Barr: I think it I think we um being healthy with you know, looking after people in a healthy way in the workforce.
- 52:02Stacey Barr: Uh I think there are things that have just always been true about that, is um respecting that that everyone's got something to contribute, assuming that everyone is doing their best, and setting up the clarity of direction and the support systems to make it easier and possible for everybody to do that at the same time as getting something personal out of it.
- 52:24Stacey Barr: You know, the the old what's in it for me might be professional development, it might be uh feelings of satisfaction, it might be who knows.
- 52:32Stacey Barr: But I think that there are some true things that are that are always there.
- 52:35Stacey Barr: And if we keep our attention on those um and get less distracted by all the labels we give different things in different generations.
- 52:43Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 52:43Paul Shrimpling: No, I think that's a that's a fair pushback.
- 52:45Paul Shrimpling: And you've just made me think about um if the only KPI, and and again, I'd like your view on this, if the only KPIs that attract and measured are about business performance, a team member can go, well, that's all right for you, but it's not necessarily alright for me, as opposed to in their work lives, in your firm, in your team, yes, there are KPIs that are about the firm's performance.
- 53:10Paul Shrimpling: Maybe, and this is where I like um uh you know, Ron, I don't know if you come across Ron Baker's book, um Measure What Matters to the Customer, which I think is a profound piece of writing, is um let's have KPIs that matter to the client because they're the paymas general.
- 53:24Paul Shrimpling: So, yes, let's look at KPIs for the firm, KPIs for the customer, and you can't leave out KPIs for you as a human being on your career pathway, whatever that looks like.
- 53:36Paul Shrimpling: Let's look at that, which might show up in their appraisals, and then we've got what you talk about the balance, is maybe um well placed in terms of building a highly enthusiastic uh team of people committed to the numbers as opposed to um resisting what needs to be done to achieve the numbers.
- 53:56Stacey Barr: Yes, to everything you just said, Paul.
- 53:58Stacey Barr: And if everybody is involved appropriately in the choice of the goals and the measures, and involved in the use of those measures to um make make better decisions and be part of collaborative improvement, then I think we do have um uh um a business that is is truly having um uh a human-centered approach to its strategy.
- 54:24Stacey Barr: Um absolutely.
- 54:26Stacey Barr: Uh one of the one of the tools that we use in our approach, um we call it a measure gallery, but it's actually a bit more than that.
- 54:34Stacey Barr: You're not gonna like if you really want to adopt KPIs, you're not gonna have every single person in the firm sitting around crafting KPIs.
- 54:42Stacey Barr: You're just gonna have a few people that will spend a little bit of time doing it on behalf of everybody else.
- 54:47Stacey Barr: But um when they get to a certain point where they've gotten clear about the goals and they've got some draft KPIs worked out, what what we what we generally do is have this measure gallery where it can be a fun thing.
- 55:02Stacey Barr: Like I'm I'm like thinking about it in the smaller companies that I've worked in, which will be more akin to what an accounting firm's probably like, is they would have um uh a little, you know, like the what do you call?
- 55:15Stacey Barr: I I've worked online for so many years now.
- 55:17Stacey Barr: It's just like a little recreation room or somewhere where people might make a cup of tea and sit down and you know, the employees might chat with each other while they're having a break.
- 55:23Stacey Barr: I don't know.
- 55:24Stacey Barr: A room like that.
- 55:24Stacey Barr: And and they kind of lay out their thinking that they've done, like how they arrived at the goals, what their their measure design template looks like, how they got to the KPIs.
- 55:34Stacey Barr: And they just have a chat, they put some cupcakes out and some fresh coffee, and they just invite people to from the whole firm just to drop in, and even some of their customers, they can invite customers as well, to drop in and just have a look at the thinking and remark on it, give some ideas, have some input into it, make some suggestions, and the team will take all of that on board and improve those KPIs.
- 55:55Stacey Barr: Suddenly, those people that weren't there in the room when the KPIs were being developed, but were there nibbling on their cupcake and having a coffee and chatting about it, suddenly have buy-in and ownership.
- 56:05Stacey Barr: And then that that buy-in and ownership can be right across the firm without too much effort.
- 56:12Stacey Barr: And then you really do get the input from people about what should be measured so they believe in the measures and own them and really want to contribute to to you know to reaching targets.
- 56:24Stacey Barr: Um yeah, it's just uh it profoundly changes things in such a simple way.
- 56:29Stacey Barr: Really easy way to to bring the humans and the numbers together.
- 56:36Paul Shrimpling: The reason I'm um shaking my head is just that that fits with the methodology for building out a set of values and behavioral standards for the firm.
- 56:44Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, um, and if if the people aren't involved in that, it's and they're just inflicted on them, that they it just becomes wall art or something on the website, doesn't mean anything.
- 56:54Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, but um Doug in our team, who's uh really strong in this space, has worked with multiple teams, is you know, they um they identify the few who work in detail on behalf of everyone else in and around the values and behavioral standards.
- 57:08Paul Shrimpling: Doug actually gets the whole team to vote on who should be in that group.
- 57:12Paul Shrimpling: The leaders don't get me wrong, they have an influence on that as well.
- 57:16Paul Shrimpling: Um, but there's that there's you just build that sense of ownership because you're inviting them into the process, they're commenting, making suggestions, and so on.
- 57:24Paul Shrimpling: And um, because you've got to use your language, that their input, they believe in the outcomes and um um commit, and so therefore, the uh the likelihood of you will achieve those KPIs goes up.
- 57:39Paul Shrimpling: Um stunning.
- 57:40Paul Shrimpling: Uh Stacy, you've really unpacked a few really important, I think, practical ways of uh helping uh leaders managers work on KPIs with their team and their customers for that matter.
- 57:53Paul Shrimpling: Um my sort of penultimate question is what do you think the you've worked with how I don't know how many, lots of people in this KPI space.
- 58:05Paul Shrimpling: What are the key skills associated with the people who are best at helping KPIs come to life so that the firms, the teams achieve those KPIs?
- 58:17Paul Shrimpling: What are the key skills that those people have?
- 58:23Stacey Barr: Well, uh there's technical skills, but there's some other left left of center kind of skills that they need to have as well.
- 58:31Stacey Barr: They they do need technical skills, right?
- 58:33Stacey Barr: Like um KPIs has always been something that people just brainstormed or or went uh and asked Google, now we're getting AI to design them for us, and we we're still not ending up with the ones that really matter.
- 58:47Stacey Barr: There is a deliberate thinking process to getting the and we've talked about some of them today.
- 58:52Stacey Barr: We've talked about um uh you know making goals really crystal clear in the way they're articulated.
- 59:00Stacey Barr: We've talked about being very clear about the evidence and then quantifying the evidence and the should can well, we've talked about a few of them, but there is a methodology, a proper approach to this.
- 59:08Stacey Barr: So that not going any further into that, there is the technical skill of being a performance measurement professional that matters.
- 59:16Stacey Barr: But what else do they need?
- 59:17Stacey Barr: I think these are the more interesting things.
- 59:20Stacey Barr: They need to be bold enough to ask the scary, dumb questions.
- 59:25Stacey Barr: So if their uh their boss has said, here's a goal that we have, I want you to go away and measure it, chances are they're not gonna understand really what that goal is about.
- 59:40Stacey Barr: But generally, employees are too scared to ask because they will feel like they've been ignorant or they're dumb, they've somehow not paid attention when they should have, and they don't want to be in that position that's threatening.
- 59:54Stacey Barr: So a good measurement practitioner, a good KPI person isn't scared of that.
- 59:59Stacey Barr: They go, Hey, what on earth do you mean by sustainability?
- 1:00:02Stacey Barr: Help me understand.
- 1:00:04Stacey Barr: When you wrote this goal and had put that word sustainability in there, tell me what came to life in you, you know, they'll have a really good way of doing that.
- 1:00:12Stacey Barr: Another good quality that they'll have is they will be non-judgmental as part of their personality, is accepting and open, and they won't ever try to make anybody feel wrong, judged negatively in any way.
- 1:00:29Stacey Barr: That's so important.
- 1:00:30Stacey Barr: And again, it comes back to that tension between people and numbers, and in my world, how threatened people can be by anything to do with numbers.
- 1:00:38Stacey Barr: So they've got to really not make people wrong.
- 1:00:42Paul Shrimpling: And it's that sense of psychological safety again, isn't it?
- 1:00:45Paul Shrimpling: Psychological create a psychologically safe space.
- 1:00:48Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:00:48Stacey Barr: Yes, yes, yes.
- 1:00:50Stacey Barr: Sorry, interrupted.
- 1:00:51Stacey Barr: So no, no, no, you're fine.
- 1:00:53Stacey Barr: Um, and to some extent, I'm kind of making this up as I go along, you're just drawing it out of me.
- 1:00:57Stacey Barr: Um, the third thing uh is is collaboration, is knowing that you will get a better outcome when you bring people together synergistically.
- 1:01:08Stacey Barr: You'll you'll measure that part of the firm over there when you involve the people who work in that part of the firm over there in the conversations.
- 1:01:16Stacey Barr: So wanting to be collaborative.
- 1:01:18Stacey Barr: Um, those three qualities will come together at the start through the middle and at the end, all stages of the measurement process of actually using numbers to inform better decisions, because all of those things become relevant in different ways.
- 1:01:33Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, bold enough breaking more dumb questions.
- 1:01:35Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, and there's always more, isn't there?
- 1:01:37Paul Shrimpling: But I I think in in when you've got you know six sixty minutes to have a conversation is if we can get to the top layer of 20% of insight and skill.
- 1:01:46Paul Shrimpling: Um, you know, we're all going to move forward, aren't we?
- 1:01:48Paul Shrimpling: If we just implement one of those things.
- 1:01:50Paul Shrimpling: Um, so I'm I'm definitely uh itching to have a look at that sort of relational map, you know, cause-effect map that you talked about.
- 1:01:58Paul Shrimpling: So if we can uh we can get that in the show notes, that'd be brilliant.
- 1:02:01Paul Shrimpling: I'll in the show notes we'll get the lock and lay them uh link to their book and the Ron Baker, what matters most to customers, and um and you know the resources you want people to go and have a checkout around Pump, Stacey will get them in there as well.
- 1:02:17Paul Shrimpling: Um, my last question is um of everything we've covered today, what one thing do you think has the biggest impact on helping accounts professionals, whether working with their team or working with their clients, what one thing from everything we've covered off uh in this discussion uh will help them the most in um helping their team or their clients?
- 1:02:40Stacey Barr: I'm gonna say that the most important thing is getting clarity on your goals, getting clarity on the results that you really want, because that is actually the hardest bit.
- 1:02:52Stacey Barr: If you understand what you want and can articulate it in very specific, clear, measurable language, the rest of it can just fall out.
- 1:03:04Stacey Barr: I mean, that that's what um, well, you mentioned pump, that is the methodology that we use, and it starts with that.
- 1:03:10Stacey Barr: And once that's sorted, all the rest of it, everyone goes, oh wow, that's just so logical.
- 1:03:15Stacey Barr: Oh, I didn't think it would be this easy.
- 1:03:16Stacey Barr: Oh, that's the you know, right through to looking at the chart of the KPI and and making decisions from it, it all starts with getting goal clarity.
- 1:03:26Paul Shrimpling: Brilliant, brilliant.
- 1:03:28Paul Shrimpling: And so, you know, people can go to the show notes, but just in case they're itching to dive in, what's the best way of getting access to your insights, your knowledge, your the your way of working?
- 1:03:38Paul Shrimpling: Is there a URL that you want to um uh give us a shout out to that should be driving people to?
- 1:03:45Stacey Barr: The um I I launched a new website last year as the home of pump to get it away from me and and put it out as a thing on its own because it really it is global.
- 1:03:53Stacey Barr: It's been global for so long now.
- 1:03:55Stacey Barr: Um so pump.academy is that website, and there's a whole lot of stuff on there, obviously the programs that we offer, but I've um I've got uh near on 30 years worth of content that I've written.
- 1:04:08Stacey Barr: So gradually getting it off my old website and getting it in there.
- 1:04:13Stacey Barr: Um I there are a few articles that have moved across to pump.academy that relate exactly to some of the points we've made today.
- 1:04:20Stacey Barr: So I'll I'll get them across to put in the show notes as well.
- 1:04:23Stacey Barr: That's fantastic.
- 1:04:23Stacey Barr: Yeah, that would be the the place to go.
- 1:04:26Paul Shrimpling: Fantastic.
- 1:04:27Paul Shrimpling: I knew this was going to be good.
- 1:04:29Paul Shrimpling: I can't tell you how pleased we've been able to get the uh this hour together.
- 1:04:33Paul Shrimpling: And um uh uh I I I really appreciate the challenge uh on a couple of occasions.
- 1:04:39Paul Shrimpling: I think that's um uh vital that um uh we all move forward in business to better understanding how to achieve what we want for our team, what we want for our clients, what we want for our businesses.
- 1:04:51Paul Shrimpling: And I think what you shared today undoubtedly has um very well several elements that uh improve everybody's knowledge skill and hopefully the habits of using KPIs.
- 1:05:02Paul Shrimpling: Stacy, thank you very, very much.
- 1:05:04Paul Shrimpling: I've loved it.
- 1:05:06Stacey Barr: Oh, you're so welcome.
- 1:05:07Stacey Barr: I I sincerely enjoyed it.
- 1:05:09Stacey Barr: I I I was really um thrilled by just how how much our thinking intersected.
- 1:05:14Stacey Barr: It was great.
- 1:05:15Stacey Barr: If we were in a pub, Paul, I imagine we'd be talking for hours about this stuff.
- 1:05:20Paul Shrimpling: Uh we'd be drunk, Stacy, is what we would be.
- 1:05:22Paul Shrimpling: It was brilliant to talk through KPIs with Stacy on this podcast.
- 1:05:31Paul Shrimpling: One of the key things that brings KPIs to life is accountability, having them show up in regular conversations with either clients or team members.
- 1:05:43Paul Shrimpling: And the accountability process and the accountability skills is part of the development programme we call the Accountants Growth Academy.
- 1:05:52Paul Shrimpling: If you'd like to join like-minded ambitious accountants, please go to the Accountants Growth Academy link in the show notes.
- 1:06:01Paul Shrimpling: You'll find more valuable discussions with the leaders of ambitious accounting firms at humanize the numbers.online.
- 1:06:08Paul Shrimpling: You can also sign up to be notified each time a new podcast is made available.
- 1:06:14Paul Shrimpling: You're about to hear a short excerpt from a podcast discussion with Amy Spillard and John Toon of HLB, the International Global Accounting Firm.
- 1:06:29Paul Shrimpling: If you like what you're hearing about leading and managing change with the technology bias, then please go hunt out the Humanize the Numbers podcast at your favourite podcast platform or go to humanished numbers.online.
- 1:06:43John Toon: Expanding on that a little bit more, Paul, as well.
- 1:06:44John Toon: I often think that you we we operate in a world where we try to manage risk down as low as possible, you know, whether it's in In audit, whether it's around providing advice, uh, whether it's dealing with the regulators and stuff.
- 1:06:58John Toon: And I think quite often in accounting, you know, and and some of the professional services as well, we we conflate risk with not experimenting and not taking chances.
- 1:07:08John Toon: And actually, that's even more risky.
- 1:07:10John Toon: You know, you're actually increasing your inherent business risk and your strategic risk by not looking at innovation, not looking up at change as an opportunity.
- 1:07:18John Toon: You know, you do want that innovation almost to bubble up from the bottom.
- 1:07:22John Toon: But actually, what you want leadership to do is you want leadership to manage that innovation in a way that doesn't introduce unnecessary risk to the business because they have an experience of going through change, they have an experience of how how the practice wants to be your view from the outside in, whether that's you're from the client base, from potential new uh you know, new employees from the regulators, etc.
- 1:07:42John Toon: And you know, again, when you kind of look at structure around things, for me is that you know, actually implementing technology is is quite a structural thing.
- 1:07:50John Toon: You know, we're we're we're changing some of the fundamentals of the business potentially, the change management, the people management that links to that can be actually quite structured.
- 1:07:59John Toon: You can have a framework that you work to.
- 1:08:01John Toon: What you've got to be able to have though is you've got to have the willingness and the agility to say part way through a process, actually, we're in, we're in here, but we need to scrap it because it's not gonna work.
- 1:08:11John Toon: Or actually, we've made the wrong assessment and this product isn't for us, or it or it's just you know, something's not quite right here.
- 1:08:17John Toon: We also need the the ability and the agility, and I think again, this is where a lot of practices fail, is that you know, I talked a lot about vision and strategy, and when we write these documents, they get passed to a board, the board looks at them, they'd like pieces of paper to look at, and then they sign them off, and then it gets junked and it gets put in a drawer.
- 1:08:33John Toon: Like that that isn't strategy for me, that isn't vision.
- 1:08:36John Toon: This has got to be lived and breathed.
- 1:08:38John Toon: And and actually, you know, if I if I'm sitting in a practice today saying, Oh, do you know what?
- 1:08:42John Toon: I think in I don't know, 18 months or two years, you're going to be on product X.
- 1:08:46John Toon: We need to be willing enough to say, do you know what?
- 1:08:48John Toon: I've got to June and I'm four months in, and actually we're gonna move to product Y tomorrow.