Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Jonathan Kay
Transcript
- 0:00This podcast is brought to you by Grand Gamers Guilds. If you like innovative
- 0:03games with fascinating themes in premium production, then you'll love the games from Grand
- 0:08Gamers guild. Find out more at grand Gamers Guilds dot com. Out of
- 0:17the street corners, they scream. You knew it was coming. You've been
- 0:20waiting for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now they scream
- 0:24at you. The sirens, their hysterical wail, tearing through the white noise
- 0:29of the city, and you run. You run to pick up those things
- 0:32that can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days when they
- 0:36still loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn to your
- 0:39shelf of games. You only have room for five. Five Games for Doomsday.
- 0:49Five Games for Doomsday is a show in which board game personalities are thrust
- 0:53into a cabin in the woods to outrun an oncoming disaster, but can only
- 0:57take five of their games with them. Which will they choose? My guest
- 1:02this week is a former lawyer and current journalist. In his career, he
- 1:04has helped launch The National Post in Canada, editor in chief of The Walrus
- 1:08and editor on the online publication Collette. He's an avid board gamer. With
- 1:12Joan Moriarty, wrote the book Your Move, an examination on how games reflect
- 1:18our society. My guest this week is Jonathan K. Jonathan, Welcome to
- 1:21the Cabin. Hi, how are you? I'm excellent. So my first
- 1:25question is how difficult was it for you to pick the five games to take
- 1:27to the cabin. It was pretty difficult because I took your premise seriously.
- 1:36So there's plenty of games that just seem like, Wow, this is the
- 1:41greatest game ever, and then like a week later, you're like, wow,
- 1:45that what did I ever see in that game? So I tried to
- 1:49pick games that really, like, after six months or a year in like
- 1:56a post apocalyptic hell where there was nothing to do except play games, I
- 2:02would still be interested in those games because they have enough texture and depth that
- 2:07I would still be interested in them and giving nothing away. But your list
- 2:09is one of the heaviest lists of games that I've seen on this show.
- 2:15Are you buying Nature a super heavy gamer? Yeah? So, and this
- 2:23has been an issue because here in Toronto, I used to have like a
- 2:27pretty wide gaming circle where we play like heavy games and some I know party
- 2:34games. I don't know part like you know code words. And and then
- 2:43as some people in the circle, including me, started to migrate toward heavier
- 2:46games, like we kind of lost people who were there for the casual gaming.
- 2:53And so now I think a lot of heavy gamers have this issue where
- 2:58even if they live in a big city, there's just like not that many
- 3:00people they know who play super heavy games. And what is I get the
- 3:06impression from the from the outside, you know, with snakes and lattos and
- 3:09things like that, that Toronto is a is a vibrant gaming city. Is
- 3:15that true? I mean yes and no, what you it depends how you
- 3:21measure it. So like in terms of board game cafes, big cities,
- 3:28in terms of per capita don't always have a lot of board game cafes because
- 3:30this real estate is so expensive, right, Like it's very hard to set
- 3:35up a board game cafe when you're paying twenty thousand dollars a month storefront rent
- 3:39or more if you're in New York City or something like that. In a
- 3:44way, like sometimes I travel through the Midwest and I'll go, you know,
- 3:47to a fairly like small small city and it'll have a bunch of board
- 3:52game cafes, in part because you know, if you can rent a big
- 3:55storefront for fifteen hundred a month, you know you might be able to make
- 4:00that back with five dollars table play and three dollars lattes and stuff like that.
- 4:09I have found, because I travel a lot to tournaments that you often
- 4:15get the highest density board gaming culture in like small college towns, you know,
- 4:23places like Toronto. It's just there's so much there's so many other things
- 4:27to do. It's like, you know, we we have we like every
- 4:32three months, we have a big board gaming convention here. It's called TABS
- 4:36Toronto Area board Game Society, and you know, only we get a couple
- 4:40of hundred people and once a year we get maybe a couple of thousand when
- 4:43we like there's an annual event that's big. But for a city of like
- 4:46three or four million people, you know, that's that's not a lot of
- 4:48people. And it strikes me I've spoken to a lot of people, and
- 4:54it seems to me I spend to a lot of Americans. And this is
- 4:59sort of going on from this. The board gaming tends to not be such
- 5:02a coastal thing. When you think of the big coastal cities in America.
- 5:06A lot of the publishers come from sort of Middle America on the fly in
- 5:11the flyover state. Is this similar in Canada, Well, it's a little
- 5:15different. So in the United States because I'm into heavier games, and especially
- 5:20wargames, a lot of wargaming culture is focused. This is a generalization,
- 5:28but like I would say, the typical heavy board gamer is somebody who like
- 5:33maybe had someone in their family who served in the military, maybe in World
- 5:36War Two, and like grew up playing big like World War two or Civil
- 5:44wars in games in like a big suburban basement in places like rural New England
- 5:49or the Midwest, or like down the Atlanta Coast, Virginia, like places
- 5:56where there often was like a big sort of military culture and military families and
- 5:59stuff. This is a generalization, Like I love wargames, and I'm the
- 6:03furthest thing from somebody who you know it comes from a long line of soldiers
- 6:08or whatever. But I find that heavy gaming kind of takes root in its
- 6:16thickest form in like those big suburban basement areas where you know, middle class
- 6:26you know, sometimes near college town, so you can get critical mass of
- 6:30like smart people who want to play these games, not so much coastal and
- 6:35but I mean so part of it is just like tournament culture. Tournament culture
- 6:43tends to be based on affordability. So like in the United States, the
- 6:47places I go to tournaments are are Albany, Indianapolis, Cleveland. You know,
- 6:54none of these are like glamorous destinations. Like when I went to Albany
- 6:59recently, the hotel util I stayed and it was seventy five dollars a night.
- 7:01Because that's what a lot of board gamers want to play. They're not
- 7:03spending a lot of time in their room. They're just in a in a
- 7:06windowless conference room playing games. It doesn't make sense to go to New York
- 7:11City and spend three hundred dollars a night for a hotel. And so a
- 7:15lot of the tournament clustering takes place Inland, in like second and third tier
- 7:21markets, And I mean that often is where you find a lot of the
- 7:26gamers. And you know, here in Canada, there's there's a big tournament
- 7:29coming up at the time we're recording this in Niagara Falls, you know,
- 7:33like popular tourist destination, but definitely like not an expensive one, So,
- 7:41yeah, you're not board gaming. You're not going to a lot of glam
- 7:44destinations. I remember I was talking to the guys who run board game Geek,
- 7:49and this is a couple of years ago when they were starting like getting
- 7:53more events going, and it was kind of funny they were gonna they were
- 7:57thinking, I don't know if they did it, but they were thinking of
- 7:59doing a board gaming cruise and I was like, well, that's really expensive.
- 8:01How you can get people to pay for that? And they said,
- 8:03no, no, no, we're going to do. Sometimes cruise companies have
- 8:07what's known as a relocation cruise, yeah, which is where the ship just
- 8:11like travels across the Atlantic because the company has to move the boat from one
- 8:15port to another and it doesn't stop anywhere, and they're like on choppy seas
- 8:20and there's no sight seeing and all the gamers are like below deck just playing
- 8:24games. So like, to me, that kind of epitomizes the sort of
- 8:28economy class, anti glam nature of bord game, Like, even when you're
- 8:33on the high seas, you're kind of like in cruise quarters type thing,
- 8:39and does that sort of part of the thing that attracts me to gaming is
- 8:43it's sort of wilfully anachronistic in a digital age. Is that element of sort
- 8:48of a lack of pretension, a desire not to be cool but to sort
- 8:54of, you know, sit in the basement of a ship or some weird
- 8:58community center in some little time no one's ever heard of it. Does that
- 9:01appeal to it? Yeah, the anti snob factor appeals to me. I
- 9:07like the fact, you know, there's a very anti glam I mean sometimes
- 9:11a little annoying, like some of these board game niches where and it combines
- 9:16with the anachronistic thing where like I recently signed up for this electronic board gaming
- 9:20tournament because a lot of these sort of hipster bricks and mortar board gamers,
- 9:28like during COVID, they had to adapt to digital technology because but they still
- 9:33like have the old habits. So like one guy was like a tournament and
- 9:37I had to to register. I had to like print out the form and
- 9:41then fill it in by hand and then mail it to him and like say,
- 9:45send him a check for seven dollars and fifty cents, like like you
- 9:48were buying something out of a comic book in nineteen seventy five, and I'm
- 9:52not sure if the gaming culture attracts people like that, but or if it's
- 9:58kind of like a chicken and egg thing and maybe the culture turns people into
- 10:01hipsters. What I do know is there's like a lot of sort of a
- 10:07crafting culture. I mean, we know this about like role playing games where
- 10:09people are into miniatures, but you also see this like in the war gaming
- 10:13space. It's incredible, how what a high percentage of the people I meet
- 10:20are like into woodworking and crafting. So if we're not doing this on video,
- 10:24but if you were, you'd see, like behind me, I have
- 10:26all these dice towers that were made by people I've board gained with, and
- 10:31one is in the shape of a sixty millimeter World War two era American mortar
- 10:35with like incredible detail, and it's a dice tower, like you know,
- 10:39you put dice in it, and you can make a dice tower out of
- 10:41like aluminum foil if you want it. Like it's not but someone went to
- 10:46the trouble of doing this, and there is you know, as you suggest
- 10:52a kind of like old. I don't want to call it hipster because that
- 10:56suggests a certain age group and a lot of these people are older. But
- 11:00like again, you meet people who even when they play the game, like,
- 11:05they're very focused on the physical components of it. Again not rocket science,
- 11:11but like even though you know, cardboard would the art because otherwise,
- 11:16if we weren't into that kind of thing, we'd probably all be playing video
- 11:18games. So yeah, so let's go back to the beginning. Then,
- 11:24So you grew up English speaking and Jewish in Montreal. Were you conscious of
- 11:30that growing up? Or I assume Montreal is fairly easy to grow up being
- 11:35English speaking. Montreal is a weird place because so I don't want to call
- 11:41like the Anglophone community in Montreal in late twentieth century like a diaspora community,
- 11:46but I kind of felt a little bit like that in the sense that like
- 11:50a lot of diaspora communities become more culturally pure than their antecedent communities. So
- 11:58like the English community at least like in kind of the it was called west
- 12:03Mount still called west Mount, this enclave, like you know, a way
- 12:05it was kind of some of the habits of mind and the cultural aspects of
- 12:09like kind of more English than actual Merry Old England because kind of like the
- 12:15culture sort of ossifies a little in that colonial outpost, and so yeah,
- 12:20there this Montreal is a largely Francophone city, not as Francophone as Quebec as
- 12:24a whole. So I was like a Jewish minority within the Anglo population of
- 12:31Montreal, which was itself a minority within the larger French Quebecua culture, which
- 12:37is itself a minority within Canada. And Canada of course it's a little pipsqueak
- 12:41of a country compared to the United States. So I kind of like just
- 12:45had grew up taken for granted, you know, being like it wasn't like
- 12:50I was persecuted or anything like that. It was just you know, like
- 12:54like a lot of I don't know, comedians and pundits and cultural commentators or
- 12:58whatever. I kind of grew up in an environment where I felt kind of
- 13:03like an observer to a larger culture on several different dimensions, language and religion
- 13:07and geography, which I don't think there's any question that that kind of shaped
- 13:13my career path and my interest as I was, I just became like very
- 13:18analytical and was always conscious of my ability to critique some larger culture, right
- 13:26because you know, if you if you don't have to show up at at
- 13:30Grandma's Easter dinner every year. It's it's much easier for you to be a
- 13:33candid analyst of lost culture. And if you know, if you're not a
- 13:39Francophone, it's much easier to be like kind of a outside neutral observer of
- 13:43Francophone Quebecua culture. And that just kind of shaped my personality and the sort
- 13:48of career path I took. And so you you were your son of journalist
- 13:52Barbara Kay. She was a sort of fairly well known columnist in Canada.
- 13:58Was it was it inevitable that you would enter the family business? Do you
- 14:01think? So? My mother by present tense, she's in her eighties and
- 14:09still a popular weekly columnist at the National Post newspaper, even though she's obviously
- 14:16older than me. I actually entered the journalistic profession first. So I became
- 14:22a full time journalist at the National Post in nineteen ninety eight. And then
- 14:26she I kind of helped introduce her, like she always has been a great
- 14:31writer and has has strong opinions, and it's just a much more natural like
- 14:37columnist than I ever was, because she's an It's like a tombstone I once
- 14:43read in a cemetery it said often wrong, never in doubt, which is
- 14:48such a wonderful summary of what it takes to be a good columnist, because
- 14:52not everyone is. You can never be right all the time. But to
- 14:56be a good columnist you have to be certain of your opinions at the time
- 15:00you write your column. I mean, I live in Germany, and that
- 15:01seems indicative of everyone who lives here. To bail it, well, it's
- 15:05it's human nature. But like you know, especially to be a columnist,
- 15:09you can't be wishy washing. So yeah, but four years after I became
- 15:15a columnist, excuse me, after I became an editorial writer at the National
- 15:18Post, I introduced her to the op ed editor at the time, a
- 15:22woman named Natasha Hassen, who's still very successful ended the business, though not
- 15:28at the National Post, and my mother followed me into the professions as a
- 15:35pundit, and she's been doing that for I guess more than twenty years now.
- 15:41So it's like kind of an interesting and I think kind of inspiring example
- 15:45of somebody who fairly late in life. You know, she was already I
- 15:50think into her sixties, kind of just developed a new career and is now
- 15:54an extremely well known broadsheet columnist in Canada, And so when did games into
- 16:00your life and what were some of these formative gaming experiences. Dungeons and Dragons
- 16:10was a formative gaming experience when I was I mean the usual age, I
- 16:12was like, you know, young Sheldon age or a little older, like
- 16:17twelve, thirteen, fourteen, which seems really like odd for me to say
- 16:21because as an adult, like I have no interest in role playing games at
- 16:26the time. RPGs you know I've played. I don't know if these titles
- 16:30will resonate with listeners, but like Gamma World, Top Secret Traveler, a
- 16:36science fiction version of Dungeons and Dragons, I guess where you you know it's
- 16:41role playing game, it's you inhabit fictional persona in some you know, sword
- 16:48and sourceery universe or sci fi universe. And after a couple of years of
- 16:55that, someone introduced me to wargames, which just kind of like connect with
- 17:00me. And then I think this is a usual pattern where then like marriage,
- 17:07kids, a lot of stuff happens. It's all blur, and like
- 17:12for twenty years I didn't touch games at all, and then maybe when the
- 17:17kids were old enough to sleep through the night, and I could get back
- 17:21into hobbies. Someone said, Hey, there's this game called Sellers of Caten.
- 17:23Do you want to try it? And I was like, wow,
- 17:27this is a fun game, and I got into Euros and then then that's
- 17:32when I rediscovered a lot of the war gaming that I did when I was
- 17:34younger, And like when I go to tournaments, especially the older crowd like
- 17:40my age, it's a similar pattern, Like there were big time war gamers
- 17:44in college or earlier, and then real life happened, and then maybe in
- 17:51their forties or fifties, they started to rediscover the hobby and often with a
- 17:56new passion, Like in the same way if you go to tennis club or
- 18:00sports club, like the most passionate players are the ones who are middle aged
- 18:03tax because you know, because they're the ones who are like rediscovering their passion
- 18:07for something. And it's they're not jaded because you know, they're NCAA players
- 18:12in their late twenties whose talents are fading. They're just they you get that
- 18:17with gaming, Like, sometimes the most passionate devotees are people my age.
- 18:22Do you think it's a nostalgic thing, an attempt to sort of reclaim lost
- 18:26youth? I mean, you're talking to somebody who probably tries to reclaim lost
- 18:38youth several times a day, but it's usually like through sports or at the
- 18:44gym, Like when I do there's this workout called Orange Theory. It's like
- 18:51one of one hundred different workout regimes, and you go to this thing and
- 18:53you do like treadmill and rowing, and I like, I get like a
- 18:57big rush if I can outperform some college kid who's next to me on the
- 19:00rowing machine and stuff like that, and then like for fifteen minutes, I've
- 19:03recovered lost youth. I think that's I think every middle aged guy, like
- 19:11in some way is trying to recover lost youth. I don't think it's through
- 19:17gaming though. I think gaming is more like if sort of age is sort
- 19:25of like operates as the vertical access here. I see my gaming experiences as
- 19:30kind of horizontal, like moving me into a different phase state. And this
- 19:37goes to your earlier question about why I'm into heavy games. I like heavy
- 19:41games because they create a universe, so like a detailed wargame, much like
- 19:47role playing games. I don't play role playing games, but this is a
- 19:48more explicit functional role playing games. Is they create a different universe. And
- 19:53when I play, there's this game called Advanced Squad Leader, which is my
- 19:56big passion. For the hours that I'm playing that game, I'm in that
- 20:03other universe. So, and that universe is a kind of like ageless fictional
- 20:08universe because it's it's a universe you're creating with your opponent, and that universe
- 20:15it's like a wormhole. It opens up when the game starts and it closes
- 20:18when the game ends. So I would I would maybe put it more from
- 20:22psychological terms, the realm of escapism rather than the realm of recapturing last youth.
- 20:30So let's move on to that then, because ASL is your first game,
- 20:33and I've recently started dipping my toes into war games. But ASL scares
- 20:41the life out of me is as involved in intimidating as his reputation would suggest.
- 20:51Yeah, so, by the way, and just so, among advanced
- 20:56Schalator players, we often use the akron ASL. If you enter ASL into
- 21:00a search engine, I think often the first hit is American Sign Language.
- 21:06So from here on in when I say ASL, obviously I'm referring to Advanced
- 21:11Squad Leader, which it distinguishes itself from Basic Squad Leader, which was a
- 21:15popular game system in the I guess in the eighties. I think it started
- 21:21maybe in the late seventies, but in the eighties when and then they added
- 21:25all these refinements and an enormous level of complexity and turned it into Advanced Squad
- 21:33Leader, which and so these days when people say Squad Leader, they're typically
- 21:37talking about Advanced Squad Lier, although there are some devotees who still play Cold
- 21:41War era Basic Squad Leader. Yeah, so Advanced Squad Leader the rule book
- 21:51if you want to add everything. So this is a tactical level war game
- 21:55where you're simulating World War Two, but like you know, not on the
- 22:00level of divisions or battalions or regiments. It's like individual squads, you know,
- 22:07company level combat in small towns in Europe, you know islands in the
- 22:12Pacific during World War Two. It's there are counters in the game that represent
- 22:18in some cases individual human beings like leaders, and individual weapons like machine guns
- 22:22and stuff. So it's a very geographically it's a very low level of representation.
- 22:27It's a hexagon based game. So Eachecks I think is abstracts forty meters
- 22:33of real estate with and so you know, when you start playing, it's
- 22:38like basic you know, German American or German Russian combat over a small town,
- 22:44and then they had tanks and then they added artillery, and then they
- 22:47had air support, and then oh, let's let's have night combat, and
- 22:51we'll have twenty pages of rules about that, and we'll have rules for deep
- 22:56snow so we can simulate you know, finish Russian. I'm bad and you
- 23:00know nineteen thirty nine and oh beach landings, you know, so we can
- 23:04do and depending on how you define the rule book, because the rule book
- 23:08has all these appendices, there's something like four or five hundred pages of rules
- 23:11to this game, like footnoted with errata and all kinds of indexes and charts.
- 23:21So when people are discussing the rules to the game, like a third
- 23:26party observer could mistake it for a conversation by like lawyers. Because even the
- 23:32rules themselves are written in a very in a way. It's super anachronistic because
- 23:36these days the trend if you're creating a euro game, the first thing you
- 23:40do is you go out and get somebody to do like a really pops and
- 23:44buzzes rules video, so no one has to teach the rule book, like
- 23:48you have the rule book in the box. But I even like, I
- 23:52pride myself on being pretty good with rules. But like when I pick up
- 23:55a new game, the first thing I do is I watch the video,
- 23:56then I read the rules because often reading the rules so me too, because
- 24:00words don't convey ludological concepts very well at all. Yeah, and you can
- 24:04get somebody who says, Okay, this looks complicated, but it's easy.
- 24:08And this looks easy, but it's complicated, and like they kind of give
- 24:11you a sort of overview of the rules before you read the rules and advanced.
- 24:15While to my knowledge, there's no video that explains the rules. And
- 24:18if you made a video, it would be like twenty hours long or something.
- 24:22I mean, the game is there that much serve space in YouTube?
- 24:26That's the question. I think it would break YouTube because billions of people would
- 24:32be walking to learn this's incredibly complicated. I actually, I mean it's funny
- 24:37you say that, because when I got into video production, I started writing
- 24:41a kind of basic primer on this and I quickly abandoned it because it's just
- 24:49it's not the kind of game that you can really do, like you kind
- 24:53of have to get into the game by knowing somebody else who's already into the
- 24:56game. Like if they're there were no existing core of people who already played
- 25:03ASL, no one will play ASL because there'd be no one to It's kind
- 25:07of like you know these ancient programming languages, like you know, Cobol or
- 25:11whatever it like, and they say, well, you know who's who's going
- 25:15to fix the code, and they always say dead or in Florida. You
- 25:18know the guys who wrote this code or dead or in Florida. And ASL
- 25:22is a little bit like that. I mean, we're not all dead,
- 25:22we're not all in Florida. But it's the same kind of thing where to
- 25:27understand the game you kind of have to get into a group of people who
- 25:33have been playing it. I guess I've been playing it for I've been playing
- 25:36it for ten years in a serious capacity, and I'm at most tournaments,
- 25:40I'm a like relative newcomer. They're some of the guys I've played regularly with
- 25:45have been playing the game for more than thirty years, and even they will
- 25:49sometimes get stumped on rules and they'll have to like a tournaments will have to
- 25:55convene like a little council of elders. I'm not on that so yet,
- 26:00but you know it. You know, in a tournament, everybody knows who
- 26:06those elders are, uh, and they make a rules determination. So it's
- 26:10yeah, it's not like scrabble or something where the rules are fairly straightforward.
- 26:14So what is the delight in ASL? My friend Andy Beaton once put it
- 26:25in a good way. He he and he's a guy who, like,
- 26:26you know, he has a works at a bank, and he has,
- 26:30you know, lots of stuff going on in life. But he said,
- 26:34it's the only thing I do in life that consumes all of my brain.
- 26:40And I think that's like a feature that a lot of people would consider a
- 26:45bug. So you know this they used to they used to describe like artificial
- 26:51intelligence or supercomputers. They'd say, you know, these are these are entities
- 26:56that, if they're playing a game of chess, will keep thinking about the
- 27:00best chess move even if the room is on fire. You know, they
- 27:03lack the human awareness and meta knowledge to know that like, okay, go
- 27:08off task to save yourself. But for a lot of ASL players, I
- 27:14think that's a feature. I don't think we would stay if the room is
- 27:17burning. But like I've been in in ASL games where like we finished the
- 27:25game and we both realized, like, wow, we're incredibly hungry, we
- 27:26haven't eaten in twelve hours, and hey, this, you know, this
- 27:30room is eight degrees like it like all of our senses have kind of been
- 27:36turned off because we're one hundred percent enmeshed in this game because it's so complicated
- 27:40and it tells a story. So, you know, we focused a little
- 27:44on the complicated nature of ASL and other heavy games, but the other thing
- 27:51I like about them is that they often tell a story. And so like
- 27:56a good Advanced Squad Leader game to me is it's kind of like a good
- 28:00game of Command and Colors or maybe some of the other games we're going to
- 28:03discuss. It tells a story. There's a beginning, there's a middle,
- 28:07there's an end, and then in Advanced Squad you have these things called scenarios,
- 28:11and scenarios are based on a real historical battle, and the forces,
- 28:18the abstracted forces and the abstracted terrain and the abstracted victory conditions are all based
- 28:22on a real historical predecessor scenario that happens sometime between nineteen thirty nine and nineteen
- 28:29forty five, And when you play the scenario, it's not going to be
- 28:34the same as the real historical outcome in the battle, but it will tell
- 28:38a story in the same way that the real historical battle told a story.
- 28:45And my judgment of the scenario the quality of a SNAr because everyone debates,
- 28:49like there's thousands of ASL scenarios, just as there's thousands of real World War
- 28:52two battles on which they're based. My basis for judging is this a good
- 28:57scenario? Does it a compelling story? Because if it's just a bunch of
- 29:02random abstracted fighting units, you know, like shooting and moving and stuff like
- 29:07that, and doesn't really tell a story, then to me, that's that's
- 29:11not gripping. So it's a combination. These are related factors. Your brain
- 29:17is one hundred percent engrossed in the narrative, and that narrative has like on
- 29:22almost cinematic quality of like a beginning, of middle, and end. And
- 29:27I tell people, and I think I wrote this in the book that I
- 29:30co authored, it is a crowd sourced form of storytelling crowdsourcing. The crowd
- 29:37in question is two people, and it's impossible for you to tell this story
- 29:41by yourself. If you want to tell a story about a World War two
- 29:45battle, you know, make a movie, write a book. But you
- 29:48know you can sit down with another player, and because that other player is
- 29:55controlling one side and you're controlling the other side, out of the adversarial tension,
- 30:00out of the narrative checks and balances that come from one side who wants
- 30:07one side to win and your side you want the other side to win.
- 30:10Out of that tension comes a crowdsourced form of storytelling, which would be impossible
- 30:15for either one of you to do individually. And then at the end of
- 30:18the game, you've created this movie together. And there's this curious sense of
- 30:22intellectual intimacy because the only people in the world who will ever see that movie
- 30:29is you and the other person. And so sometimes, like I'll go to
- 30:32lunch or dinner with somebody who have just played an ASL game with for six
- 30:34seven hours. I mean, I've been to tournaments where we've had fourteen hour
- 30:38games. I remember there's this guy, Paul Chamberlain. We played the scenario
- 30:41called Maggot Hill. There's a Pacific scenario that was like ten PM or something.
- 30:47We started it in the morning, it was, and we then we
- 30:52went out and had a late dinner, and it was like there was this
- 30:53curious sense of intellectual intimacy because like I remember almost every move from that scenari
- 31:00It's like still in my mind, Like I forget the names of my sister's
- 31:03kids, but I remember every move from that scenario that we played in Cleveland
- 31:07was ten years ago, because it was like this compelling film and that film
- 31:11will never be shown in any movie theater, but it's shown in my brain
- 31:17and it's shown in his brain, and we're the only two people planet of
- 31:21seven billion people where the only people who've seen that movie. That's what I
- 31:23like about ASO. Do you think a feeling of ownership over your game experiences
- 31:30is vital to a profound gaming experience. Yes, although it's interesting because sometimes
- 31:40you're at a tournaments and you'll hear other people try to explain what happened in
- 31:44the scenario, and often like so, a typical thing in tournaments is like
- 31:49you'll all stop playing at about eight am on a given day, and then
- 31:52like a typical scenario may take like four or five six hours. Some of
- 31:56the morning scenarios are a little shorter, so like around one or two,
- 31:59people are starting to pack up and go get lunch and prepare for their afternoon
- 32:02scenario, and you'll see people sort of drift around the room and start talking
- 32:08about the scenario. And usually it's the people who lost who are the most
- 32:12voluable because they're often complaining about their bad luck or their errors in judgment.
- 32:21And there's a couple people who shall go unnamed, who are particularly well known
- 32:28for like going into extravagant detail about like some of the very fine grain elements
- 32:35of the game and how a critical diar roll or a critical decision turned the
- 32:42wheel of fortune against them. And I could not be more bored by these
- 32:45stories because in this because in my mind, I find my own narrative of
- 32:51the game I played like super compelling and memorable, and it may be like,
- 32:54if I live to one hundred and fifty, I may still remember some
- 32:57of these games. I couldn't be more bored by other people's stories because it's
- 33:04kind of like they're talking about scenes from a movie I've never seen and never
- 33:08will see, And so they're just to my to me, it's just random
- 33:12crap. They're just like we're setting random details and who cares. It's like
- 33:16someone telling you their dreams. Right, it's the dullest thing imaginable, and
- 33:21that dream may have like have life changing consequences for them because they inhabited it.
- 33:28But to me, it's, uh, yeah, as you say,
- 33:30it's it's not relevant. And by the way, I've probably been on both
- 33:35ends of that conversation, Like I mean, they're probably if my friends are
- 33:37listening to this, so like, oh, Josh, like I was the
- 33:40guy who was talking for twenty minutes of some scenario oil laws Like it's you
- 33:44know, because we kind of like, as human beings, when something interests
- 33:46us, we kind of just like this is Unfortunately the basis for like the
- 33:52dullness of most marriage conversations is like, well, you'll never believe what happened
- 33:57to me at the bagel shop, right, Like it's stuff that happens to
- 34:00us we think is interesting. But that I would say, this junction between
- 34:07assumed interest and actual interest is heightened in the board gaming space because you're talking
- 34:12about stuff that literally never happens. You're talking about like a completely fictional universe.
- 34:16So if somebody describes stuff that happened in a movie, like, at
- 34:21least theoretically, I could go see that movie and see what they're talking about.
- 34:25But when it comes to someone telling me about some game they just played,
- 34:29that movie has never come back, so it's unusually boring for third parties
- 34:35to hear about it. So I want to move on there and talk about
- 34:38you as a journalist. So you studied metallurgical engineering, and then you went
- 34:42on to practice law, and then you decided to enter journalism as a profession.
- 34:47How difficult was it to enter journalism from a different field? Both easy
- 34:55and very difficult. And it's easy in the sense that journalism is an uncredential
- 34:59t So they're famous journalists who never graduated from high school. And there are
- 35:05people with PhDs who tried journalism or complete failures. So it's not like I
- 35:10mean interestingly, Well, at the time, my parents would have used a
- 35:17different adverb interestingly. I spent a lot of time studying engineering and law,
- 35:24which are both credentialed professions, and then ended up in a profession that I
- 35:31literally could have joined out of high school. Although I think the best journalists
- 35:40are people who've had life experiences who aren't just you know, they worked for
- 35:45the student newspaper in college, they graduate with a police side degree, they
- 35:49spend six weeks traveling through Western Europe, and then they come back and they
- 35:52start working for a newspaper. It's hard to have an interesting perspective on the
- 35:58world. It's not possible, well, but it's harder if that's your experience
- 36:02that you're bringing to your journalism, as opposed to you know, somebody who
- 36:13has seen the world has studied something specific in life. In my case,
- 36:19it was engineering thermodynamics. I was a computer programmer, you know. I
- 36:24worked in Australia, I worked in Japan, I worked in Northern Canada,
- 36:29I worked at a research lab. You know, I got a grounding in
- 36:31science, and then I was a tax lawyer in New York. You know,
- 36:35at the time, I didn't think, oh, wow, this is
- 36:37going to be amazing fodder for my future journalism career. But that's kind of
- 36:42how it ended up. And so you we were on the finding staff the
- 36:47National Post. How exciting was it to be at the birth of something like
- 36:52that. I mean, it was exciting in retrospect. It's kind of weird
- 36:57because starting a large broadsheet newspaper from scratch in nineteen ninety eight, which is
- 37:04when the National Post started up, is kind of like starting an internal combustion
- 37:12engine based car company from scratch in twenty twenty four. It's an industry that
- 37:19it still exists. I mean newspaper. I subscribe to a newspaper that arise
- 37:24in my doorstep every day. Not a lot of people do. The industry
- 37:29still exists, but there's no question that it's on the decline. And it
- 37:32was already kind of the writing was already kind of on the wall in the
- 37:36late nineties and certainly by the early two thousands. So it was exciting for
- 37:43me to start a career in journalism. It was exciting to start a new
- 37:45newspaper, but it was a kind of surreal feeling because it was I think
- 37:50a lot of the people were sort of like, well, you know,
- 37:53if you're thirty years old, I was around I think thirty years old at
- 37:57the time, Like a lot of us starting families, mortgages. You know,
- 38:01you're thinking like that, I did I just sign up for a buggy
- 38:05whip factory, right, And and like sure enough, the National Posts like
- 38:10a lot of newspapers, not like like probably all newspapers started economizing and shedding
- 38:16jobs. And I think if you look at the statistics the number of full
- 38:22time journalists including those newspapers today compared to the late nineties, it's I think
- 38:30as something like a third or a half of what it was in terms of
- 38:32total total payroll. So it was exciting, but it was also I was
- 38:38nervous, and you know, a lot of people didn't make it. A
- 38:42lot of people. There was a lot of staff cuts, not just at
- 38:49the National Post, at every newspaper, and unless you had made yourself essential
- 38:54and we're at the top of your game, you were going to lose your
- 38:57job. So it was exciting but also nerve wracking and from a career perspective,
- 39:01risky. I mean, I went from a tax lawyer on Park Avenue
- 39:06in New York. If I'd stayed there like it just you know, if
- 39:12you're half decent at that kind of job, you can make a good living,
- 39:15uh and retire comfortably. I went from from from that to working in
- 39:23a suburban cubicle office in Toronto for like half the money. And why because
- 39:36you know, why do why do birds fly south? For the summer right
- 39:38for the winter. Like it's just there was something in me that I needed
- 39:43to write and and I am to the limited extent I have any useful career
- 39:49advice for people, it's it's that the thing that you should be doing in
- 39:52life and not know, this doesn't work out for everybody, but like do
- 39:59a ought experiment, like if somebody gave you ten million dollars and you didn't
- 40:02have to work, how would you occupy your time? And there's a lot
- 40:07of people listening to this to say, well, you know, I would
- 40:07design board games, or I would become a chef, or you know.
- 40:13In my case, the answer was I would write. And you know,
- 40:19I used my weekends and my evenings and free time. I was always writing.
- 40:22I was seeing all these wonky freelance submissions to all these publications, and
- 40:29that was just the thing that I was kind of like destined as a big
- 40:32word. But in a way I feel like I just I had to do
- 40:38it, and I was lucky it worked out like it was. I just
- 40:42had a lot of good luck because there was nothing for ordained about the fact
- 40:49that I was able to hang on in the profession. Like when I started
- 40:52writing in the late nineties, I had a very low like not surprisingly,
- 40:57I wrote like a lawyer, because for two years when I was practicing law
- 41:02in New York, I was I was literally writing memoranda about internal revenue code
- 41:09provisions for for you know, for our clients. And that writing style you
- 41:15will not be shocked to learn it's not like a particularly vibrant, pocative style
- 41:22that like, you know, you get letters to the editor like, oh
- 41:24please more articles from John k about related party transactions and cross border deals like
- 41:31it's this. I had to unlearn how I wrote as a lawyer, and
- 41:37and one of the reasons I was lucky was in those days, newspapers could
- 41:43still invest in people like me and say, well, you know, his
- 41:45writing sucks, but like maybe in a year he'll be okay. You know,
- 41:47he went to a good school, and you know, maybe maybe maybe
- 41:53he'll redeem himself. But like, you know, when I started hiring people
- 41:59just ten years later, I didn't have that time horizon. I was hiring
- 42:05people who had already demonstrated that they were good mainstream writers on their blogs or
- 42:13other proof of concept. So when I was hiring people in the two thousands,
- 42:19I wasn't hiring people I could train. I was hiring people who already
- 42:22could write, Whereas this is one of the many pieces of good luck I
- 42:27had in getting into the profession. I was hired at the tail end of
- 42:31the journalism age where large entities would still hire people to train them. And
- 42:39that kind of I'm sure it exists in some places, but it's rare.
- 42:45And so you went on to edit the Walrus but you left the publication.
- 42:50Why was that? And do you think that atmosphere still pertains to that publication
- 42:57and journalism in a way? Why to context? Uh? So this is
- 43:04this is probably gonna sound dull to anybody who's not in the small fish pond
- 43:07of Canadian journalism. But the National Post and the Walrusts were in many ways
- 43:14like opposite publications. So the National Post was well and is conservative, or
- 43:20at least what passes for conservative in Canada. Uh. And I was always,
- 43:24I would say, like more liberal. That's the word we use.
- 43:29We didn't use the term progressive, although I guess you'd use that word now.
- 43:31I was more progressive than my colleagues, most of my colleagues at the
- 43:35National Posts, especially in the editorial board. And this h this magazine called
- 43:43The Walrus, which based in Toronto kind of like has sort of more of
- 43:46like a black turtleneck arts and activism type vibe to it, and certainly much
- 43:52more progressive. And so I went from being like the house liberal the National
- 44:00Post to the house reactionary at the Waas. The thing is, what I
- 44:07quickly learned is the side that's winning in the culture war has has more effective
- 44:15tools to enforce their orthodoxy. So at the National Post, because like you
- 44:19know, conservatism is probably on the losing end of most culture war issues,
- 44:22you know, it pitches a broader tent because I can't afford to be too
- 44:27orthodox, and so the National Post, like there was just I was able
- 44:30to get along. You know, there's libertarians and there was like Burky and
- 44:35conservatives, and there were centrists, and you know, it's like there's more
- 44:43spirit of debate and discussion and that kind of thing. And then but when
- 44:49I went to the Wares, it's just like, you know, for those
- 44:52who follow the current culture war like, they'll know that maybe on the progressive
- 44:58side of things, there's just like a much more orthodox approach to what the
- 45:01correct view on whatever happens to be trending on Twitter is so I'm just a
- 45:07contrarian by nature, which suited me at the National Post because again, like
- 45:13you know, in Canada, to be anything close to conservative is just naturally
- 45:17to be contrarian, Whereas you know at the Walls that it's not even politics,
- 45:23that that personality type just didn't really fit in as well with the more
- 45:30orthodox stayed kind of treehouse of Canadian arts and letters. I was treated very
- 45:40well there. I was able to write what I want, but like eventually
- 45:44it just this, I think the strains showed on both sides. Particularly you
- 45:51know, Canada went through kind of national struggle session, if you will,
- 45:57over issues connected toous issues and like all sorts of stuff with race and gender
- 46:05in recent years. But like beginning in twenty seventeen, which is when I
- 46:07quit, this happened to coincide with the one hundred and fiftieth anniversary of Canada's
- 46:14creation in eighteen sixty seven, So there was like a lot of sort of
- 46:17public lamentations about Canada's historical sins, which which are real, like it's not
- 46:22shouldn't airbrush Canada's historical sins, But things got to kind of like almost a
- 46:28religious level where like people were going on the CBC and like just bursting into
- 46:32tears, and it became like a kind of mix between in sort of i
- 46:37don't know, like a Pentecostal prayer session and a communist struggle session, and
- 46:42like things got really dramatic and it was just way over the top. And
- 46:45as somebody who was editing a magazine that was on the left, I was
- 46:49sort of expected to be a good soldier and I didn't. I didn't.
- 46:52It's not in my personality to do that, and so yeah, so I
- 46:58quit. And at the time I quit, I thought, well, okay,
- 47:00that's you know, I had a good run two decades in journalism.
- 47:07I'll just spend that time freelancing for you know, Atlantic and the New Republic,
- 47:13which which I did at the time. And then like, you know,
- 47:15I'm a ghost writer of books and I'll write books. I'd write book
- 47:20under my own name, so you know, I can make a living doing
- 47:22all that stuff. And it was just by happenstance that I got recruited by
- 47:25Quillette, which, like at the time I quit the Walrus, I had
- 47:30never even heard of Quiet, so that it wasn't like I jumped off one
- 47:34ship to board another. It was like I jumped off one ship and swam
- 47:37around and then got picked up by another. On the brink of civil war,
- 47:51the president of Carmonia has been given five letters from an assassin, each
- 47:55mark to the day. If the president does not meet the assassin's demands,
- 48:01they will be dire consequences leading to his death. Five letters, five threats,
- 48:09five days to die. Each player is dealt a secret card outlining their
- 48:15allegiance to the president. Safe or assassinate, all the while Carmonia is in
- 48:20turmoil. Find the assassin while leading the country through a number of difficult missions.
- 48:24However, view of the assassins sabotage, betray and secretly maneuver the game
- 48:34in your favor, resulting in the assassination of the president and the destruction of
- 48:39Carmone just don't get called. Patriot is a semi cooperative board game of social
- 48:46deduction, betrayal, and strategy for one to six players. You could get
- 48:52it now Grand Gamers Guild Dog card and so let's go on to Quillette.
- 49:01Then what is the aim of Quillette and how well do you think it's achieving
- 49:07the so Coilette is an Australian based publication, and sorry, I not maybe
- 49:13as familiar as I should be with your listenership. So if there's people listening
- 49:16to this who are just primarily like thinking, what are they going to go
- 49:22back to talking about advanced squadalier, that was awesome, I'd like, I
- 49:29don't presume to know how much they're interested in these sort of journalistic and culture
- 49:31issues. But Quillette was founded I think twenty fifteen, so shortly before I
- 49:38showed up by an Australian woman who's publisher and my boss. Her name is
- 49:45Claire Layman, editor in chief. Hi boss, if you're listening, she
- 49:53is, I would say, like me simultaneously, both a disaffected conservative and
- 50:01a disaffected progressive, like in the sense that we're kind of alienated from some
- 50:09of the dogmas on both sides of the spectrum. And I know that's like
- 50:13a very trite thing to say. You know, people start up a new
- 50:15sub stack, and it's like for people who don't want to be told what
- 50:17to do by either the left or the right. Like there's all kinds of
- 50:20people running around claiming to be centrists or you know, radical contraerns and stuff
- 50:25like there's all sorts of like labels people put on this. I do think,
- 50:31you know, Quilette's been now been around for I guess eight almost a
- 50:37decade. I guess it has it has earned the right to say those things
- 50:43because in an age when people are defined by their enemies, like we are
- 50:47disliked by rabid conservatives and we're disliked by rabid progressives or rabbits, right,
- 50:53Like that's like say strident you know, rabbits to derogatory work. So like,
- 51:04you know, during the COVID pandemic, we infuriated our conservative readers by
- 51:09standing up for vaccines and refusing to like run articles about the miracles of ivermectin
- 51:17and stuff like that. And we had no real interest or patients with Donald
- 51:25Trump, I mean just in general, like the sloganeering of partisan politics,
- 51:30either in Australia or the United States or Canada, Like, isn't we don't
- 51:34really write about that stuff. We're more interested in technology and academia and what
- 51:38my boss often refers to as like the forces that lie upstream from politics,
- 51:45so ideology and culture, and so often these things find their way into mainstream
- 51:50political discourse, starting online or in the Academy or whatnot, And I kind
- 51:58of liked the idea of a publication that internalized my own contraryan tendencies, both
- 52:06in regard to conservative dogma and in regard to progressive dogma. And I saw
- 52:12both up close. Like I was at the National Post and there were issues
- 52:15where like, you know, I remember two thousand this is going back awhile,
- 52:20but like I think it was two thousand and five, two thousand and
- 52:24six, I wrote an article for the National Post, again conservative publication.
- 52:29I think the headline was Confessions of a former Iraq Warhawk, where like I
- 52:35wrote about how, yeah, I was like the sort of jingoistic support of
- 52:38the Iraq war. And now I kind of like realized that a lot of
- 52:40what I said was stupid and that kind of thing you weren't supposed to say
- 52:45in conservative circles. And then I wrote a full page thing about like global
- 52:50warming, I'm saying, like conservative I think the title was something like global
- 52:55warming denialism is hurting the conservative brand something like at least at the time,
- 53:04and in those circles, you just absolutely were not allowed to say. This
- 53:07is when people are still like still going nuts about how how how Gore was
- 53:10gonna, you know, send us all back to the Middle Ages by destroying
- 53:15industry and stuff like that. And then when I was at Uares, I
- 53:20kind of like, you know, whatever is the opposite of what I just
- 53:22said, I did that. Soquilette is a place where you can just say
- 53:30all these things, Like you can say, hey, global warming is real,
- 53:32ivermect them doesn't really work. You know, vaccines are pretty safe.
- 53:38But you can also say like things like, hey, biological sex is real.
- 53:45You know, there are serious problems with DEI programs in many cases,
- 53:52not all cases, but in many cases, like you can you can question
- 53:57pseudoscience on both sides of the political spectrum. And you'd think that that would
- 54:01be something you could do at like most media outlets, but it's it's actually
- 54:07not, or I mean often you can, but like you get in trouble
- 54:10for doing it. And I wanted a place where I wouldn't be fighting with
- 54:15my colleagues and making life difficult for my colleagues like when I was at the
- 54:17waas like as much as I fought with my colleagues, like I also was
- 54:22cognizant, like I'm making life tough for them, right because you know,
- 54:25I'm here, I'm this guy is saying like, oh, I say what
- 54:28I want, I believe what I want. I'm my own guy, like
- 54:30just you know. But on the other hand, like I was often working
- 54:34with people who had professional commitments that kind of required them to like tow the
- 54:40line a lot of issues, like you know, they were trying to become
- 54:43an assistant professor, or they were like on some government panel toward grants,
- 54:46or they the Wallrus itself was like looking for grants, either from the government
- 54:52or from charitable foundations, and like there was just all these constituencies on,
- 54:58you know, on the sort of institutional progressive side of the Ledger that we
- 55:05had to keep happy. And part of being an editor in chief is like
- 55:08being an adult and realizing that and keeping your mouth shut. And that's just
- 55:14not my personality. So, you know, I still sometimes get asked about
- 55:17leaving The Walrus, and I would say it was like almost more of a
- 55:20personality thing than a political thing. Like I was kind of a sort of
- 55:23say anything manchild working among like more adult minded people who just had to keep
- 55:36various constituencies happy because they knew that in the tiny treehouse of Canadian Arts,
- 55:40and letters, like, you just have to tow the line on a lot
- 55:44of stuff, and that's just something I'm not capable of doing. So your
- 55:49next game, then, is a popular game. You're dispensing with any kind
- 55:54of smooth segus. You're just like, okay, segus are just dishonest.
- 56:02Let's just move on. I've got notes. It's fine. So Terraforming Mars.
- 56:08Why are those bloody take that cards in the game? And do they
- 56:12add anything? So what do you mean by take that card? So they're
- 56:15the cards that you play that directly effect your opponent. Oh yeah, I
- 56:20remember playing it once and being frankly appalled when someone killed all of my algae.
- 56:25Yeah, so you're ted you're primarily talking about asteroids, right right,
- 56:30Because okay, so again I don't know your listenership that well, but like,
- 56:36if it's ninety people who've played Terraferring Wars are like, I think people
- 56:42will be familiar with it. Yeah, so okay, So Terrifring Wars again
- 56:45one of the most popular eurogames. And yeah, so it's interesting you say
- 56:51that because one of the reasons people like Terriferring Mars and Euros in general is
- 56:57it's a kind of solitaire that has occasional social aspects to it, like,
- 57:07you know, for those who haven't played it, like you're building up cities
- 57:09and forests on this map of Mars, and sometimes you're doing it in a
- 57:13way that like, you know, you block out your opponent terms in terms
- 57:15of a good city position. And but like the promise of the game,
- 57:22like the promise of many eurogames, is a kind of like, hey,
- 57:24just this is a sort of building game. It's not like a war game.
- 57:29You do your thing. It'll be fun. I'll do my thing,
- 57:31we'll chat, you know, we'll compete for cards and maybe jockey for position
- 57:36on this map, but like in general, we'll just kind of do your
- 57:38thing and then bam, you play this card that's like an asteroid card that's
- 57:44like kill five plants in your opponent's tableau or something. And I have played
- 57:51it a number of times and it's interesting the react. A lot of times,
- 57:52the reaction is like yours because it feels like a betrayal. It's like,
- 57:55hey, wait a sec I know that that's a real card, and
- 58:00you know, I'm looking at the card and that's the effect on the card.
- 58:01It kills my plans but like that's not in keeping with the spirit of
- 58:05the game. The spirit of the game is like we're supposed to kind of
- 58:08all be doing parallel solitaire, and it's like you've just gotten up from your
- 58:14solitaire deck and just like messed up my solitaire deck, which is like this
- 58:19super antisocial thing to do, and a lot of people don't like it.
- 58:23And by the way, there's this card interfering Mars called Protected Habitat which prevents
- 58:29you from doing that. It's like you put this big dome over all your
- 58:30algae and disgusting plants and then asteroids can't effect it. It's kind of like
- 58:39unrealistic. But so your algae keeps breeding in its little pools, and so
- 58:46often I will only adopt a kind of so called green strategy interfering Mars if
- 58:52I have that cart, because then I know my opponent can't kill all my
- 58:57lichen and algae and stuff. But it's what's interesting, is there I think
- 59:05there's an add on for terra forming Mars that makes the game more of a
- 59:08conflict based game. I've never played it, and it's interesting. Most of
- 59:14the people I've played it, In fact, all of the people i've played
- 59:16it don't play with that add on because I think they recognize that it's that's
- 59:23just that's not the spirit of the game. Like there's all kinds of debates
- 59:28and boardgaming circles about you know, this module, this add on, this
- 59:30extension, is it worth it? Does it add to the game? And
- 59:35the answer is always the same. These extensions and add ons, I mean
- 59:39they're commercial ventures, right, Like you play, pay fifty bucks for the
- 59:43game, and then you pay thirty bucks for like some kind of module.
- 59:46And if you can keep selling people modules, you can you know, you
- 59:50can make a lot of money, which is fine, That's that's how capitalism
- 59:52works. But it's always to me the same thing is like does the module
- 59:58If you're buying the module or extension, it means you like the original game,
- 1:00:01right, and so the original game has something about it that you like.
- 1:00:06And the question always is does the extension module accentuate and bring out and
- 1:00:10is it loyal to that thing that you like or is it just kind of
- 1:00:15this like separate thing that distracts you from the thing you like about the game.
- 1:00:20And there are some modules and extensions that I really like according to that
- 1:00:24principle, and there are some that I hate because they just add a sideboard,
- 1:00:30so there's a regular board and the extensions like oh look there's the sideboard,
- 1:00:32and on the sideboard we compete for like you know, unicorn points,
- 1:00:37and you know you find unicorns on the board and these spaces that were and
- 1:00:39it's like, wait a second, this is just like this has nothing to
- 1:00:42do with the game. This is just like this add on thing and in
- 1:00:47teriforing Mars and other games when they try and make it more of other eurogames,
- 1:00:52when they try and make it more of a combat theme. The reason
- 1:00:54I don't like it, it's it's not that I don't like wargames. I
- 1:00:58love wargames. But when you take a Euro game and try and turn it
- 1:01:00into a war game, you're you're destroying what you like about the game.
- 1:01:05And and so yeah, it doesn't add variety to the game. It compromised.
- 1:01:10It's like turning a drama into a comedy, right. Yeah. And
- 1:01:15so loads of sort of midway eurogames come out every year, and most of
- 1:01:22them get played for a couple of weeks and then sort of disappear below the
- 1:01:27surface. Again, this one really took off and still has a loyal following,
- 1:01:34why do you think this one was one of the ones that's stuck.
- 1:01:37It's hard to say, like take it. Take a game like Puerto Rico.
- 1:01:44People still play Puerto Rico. It's one of the most popular. You're
- 1:01:49like, if you look at these despite the incredibly politically incorrect theme, which
- 1:01:52I find unsettling. I say, even I because like, I've just spent
- 1:01:58twenty minutes droning on about what a contrariy and am I don't really like Puerto
- 1:02:05Rico that much, and yet I love terraforming Mars. And what's interesting is
- 1:02:12among my hardcore board gaming friends the last year or so, they've really gotten
- 1:02:17into this game called Arkanova, which I've played maybe half a dozen times.
- 1:02:22And I do not like Arcanova. And if you ask me, what is
- 1:02:24it you like? So someone one my friends is like, why do you
- 1:02:28hate Arknova? And I said, oh, it's this stumb game. It's
- 1:02:30like, you know, you're you're putting all these like hexagons, there's like
- 1:02:35zoo exhibits on this map and you have to collect all these cards and a
- 1:02:37tableau. It's so stupid. And they're like, well, you just describe
- 1:02:43terrorforming. You literally just described terraforming Mars, which you were constantly bugging us
- 1:02:47to play, so like, why do you like one and you don't like
- 1:02:51the other? And I really have no explanation because terraforming Mars and art like,
- 1:02:57I don't know the origin story of ark Nova, but for those who
- 1:03:00played it, like, it's obvious that ark Nova was influenced by terrifying Mars
- 1:03:05and having like a parallel tableaux building and map building and you know, tiling
- 1:03:12a map type subplots in the game. But I love one, and I
- 1:03:20won't say I despise. I'll play ark Nova in a pinch. But partly
- 1:03:24it's the theme Like ark Nova, you're running a zoo and like it gets
- 1:03:30very sort of like, oh, you know, you bring in an educator
- 1:03:34and then the scientific research. Like a lot of time people play the game
- 1:03:37is like, well, when do I get to feed the elephants? And
- 1:03:39it's like, no, no, it's not about feeding the elephants. It's
- 1:03:40like, it's about bringing in an elephant conservationist people educate local NGOs about the
- 1:03:46value of elephants, which like they, I mean, it sounds dumb,
- 1:03:51but they the designer integrated this kind of thing in a very clever way,
- 1:03:54and it's a good game, and it's very popular among a lot of my
- 1:03:58friends boor gamers whom I was. I just don't like the game, and
- 1:04:00I can't really explain why I could play Terrifying Wars all day and ark Nova
- 1:04:08feels like a chore, you know. Like I again, I co authored
- 1:04:12this book about board games, and so I've tried to think hard about what
- 1:04:15it is about games that I like and don't like. But you do have
- 1:04:18to like at some level, be humble about how much this analytical spirit brings
- 1:04:24you. Like at some level, there's just like some games and you can't
- 1:04:27really explain it you like and don't like and Terrifying Wars. I love the
- 1:04:32project building, Like I think some of the ingredients are ingredients that all good
- 1:04:39games have, Like all eurogames have this thing where like there's ten different things
- 1:04:45you want to do at the same time, but you only have resources to
- 1:04:47do like three or four of them, right, And that kind of anxious,
- 1:04:50nervous tension about like, oh what am I going to do? And
- 1:04:55when do I stop trying to do this project? When do I cut bait
- 1:04:58on that? And when do I go double or nothing on this one,
- 1:05:00and Terriforing Mars has that, and all eurogames have that. So but that's
- 1:05:06a necessary but not sufficient ingredient of a good game, right because ark Nova
- 1:05:10also has that. So it's it's kind of like a romantic partner, like
- 1:05:15there are necessary but not sufficient ingredients, and you can't always explain why one
- 1:05:21works and one doesn't. So I want to move on now to your book.
- 1:05:28So, around the beginning of the twenty tens, you wrote a book
- 1:05:30about conspiracy theories called Among the Truthers, and then in twenty seventeen. The
- 1:05:39I think why why QAnon was so fascinating for me is that so often conspiracy
- 1:05:45theories dealt with events in the past, whereas QAnon was a conspiracy theory that
- 1:05:50was developing in real time. People were baking Donald Trump's speeches the minuit he
- 1:05:57stopped talking. I mean, could you when you wrote that book of conceived
- 1:06:00of anything quite so bizarre as q andon. No, So you know,
- 1:06:06I still often get asked about this book about conspiracy theories that well, I
- 1:06:11researched it, and I guess two nine twenty ten. It was published twenty
- 1:06:14eleven kind of as a It was marketed to some extent as like a tenth
- 1:06:18anniversary on the tenth anniversary of nine to eleven, because my central case study
- 1:06:23was was nine to eleven truthers. The qan On thing is different because what's
- 1:06:32in the late twentieth century conspiracy theories, the the archetypal conspiracy theorist was like
- 1:06:41a kind of solitary nut who like had a whole room full of documents,
- 1:06:48like they're they're literally JFK conspiracy theorists who when they died, like the coroner
- 1:06:55found them like literally like buried in rooms full of documents like that. They
- 1:06:59were all kind of book worms and and then like you know, they'd self
- 1:07:01publish these books, these leaflets. Like it was very solitary exercise. And
- 1:07:05then the Internet changed all that, and but it changed it in two at
- 1:07:13least two different waves. So at the time I wrote my book, the
- 1:07:15way the Internet changed it was kind of like through video. So instead of
- 1:07:20like spending five years writing a book that no one's going to read, you
- 1:07:24could create a video like loose Change yea that that millions of people are going
- 1:07:28to watch, and you could I enthusiastically watched at the time, Oh well,
- 1:07:33that's you're a bigger man than me for admitting that. I thought,
- 1:07:38well, I was, I mean I was kind of I was kind of
- 1:07:39seventeen at the time, and I thought it was hugely fascinating. Oh okay,
- 1:07:42well then you're off the hook. I mean seventeen year olds. I
- 1:07:44mean, it's probably probably more wholesome than a lot of things that seventeen years
- 1:07:46you're watching. Uh, but like you could propagandaze people through video and you
- 1:07:53got these you know, for lack of a better term, like celebrities within
- 1:07:59conspiracy subculture, sure like Richard Gage or lucred West red Kowski is that his
- 1:08:03name? I forget his name who not always but largely through through through video.
- 1:08:13Alex Jones was like he should his name should have been the very first
- 1:08:16name that I dropped. It was like, you know, kind of one
- 1:08:19to many media forms, so's you know, Alex Jones wasn't primarily filmmaker,
- 1:08:24but it was kind of you know, video channels and basically turning the Internet
- 1:08:30into mass media and propagandizing people. And that was kind of the climate in
- 1:08:34which I wrote my book. But what happened is I would say that kind
- 1:08:42of again, for lack of a better term, like celebrity conspiracist subculture kind
- 1:08:47of devolved into more way more of like a crowdsource thing, and like qan
- 1:08:53on as an example of this, Like there was there was no like one
- 1:08:57central ringleader to my knowledge who made the QAnon thing go absolutely viral, and
- 1:09:04like without him continuing to feed it, it would have, like you know,
- 1:09:09it would have died out. It was more of like this kind of
- 1:09:13febrile hive mind, and it was more participatory, like people would just kind
- 1:09:16of chime in on Reddit forums and all this crap. And this is something
- 1:09:20that I didn't really write about. I mean, I wrote about it a
- 1:09:24little bit because it was sort of emerging at that time. But every time
- 1:09:30I get interviewed on the subject, like the premises, oh, conspiracy theories
- 1:09:34are growing and it's becoming a bigger problem. It's like one of these things
- 1:09:38that's always getting bigger. And even at the time of the jfk assassination,
- 1:09:41people were talking about how like conspiracy theories were just growing or growing and growing,
- 1:09:45which I mean, in a sense is true. There's just more conspiracy
- 1:09:48theories and there's more avenues for propagating them. But it's also the case that
- 1:09:51we have more avenues for debunking them, Like you know, Alex Jones is
- 1:09:57a disgraced figure now in part because people use the Internet to like build a
- 1:10:01case against it. So so the Internet has cut both ways. So yes,
- 1:10:09QAnon, I mean, it's it's crazy given the premises they have.
- 1:10:13It's it's crazy how popular it got. On the other hand, I often
- 1:10:17will see somebody, you know, on on social media discrediting somebody their views
- 1:10:28on COVID or on politics or whatever. It's saying, hey, why we
- 1:10:30listen to this, why we listen to this guy? He's he's a QAnon
- 1:10:34supporter, And that often, I mean, in some context that's a badge
- 1:10:40of honor, but in most mainstream contexts, that will then be used to
- 1:10:43discredit the person's views on like whatever ivermectin or whether Donald Trump went the election
- 1:10:48in twenty twenty, or you know, a whole host of other things.
- 1:10:56And so the Internet, which is it's been around for decades now, it
- 1:11:00has a mature conspiracist culture, but it also has a mature anti conspiracist culture.
- 1:11:06And it's you know, it's that thing that like you know, Ali
- 1:11:14travels halfway around the world, while the truth is still putting on its clothes.
- 1:11:17But I have seen enough effective debunking of conspiracism on the Internet to make
- 1:11:27me uncertain of in the long run, like which way the pendulum wi ultimately
- 1:11:32swing. And so with conspiracy theories, once you peel back enough layers of
- 1:11:39the onion, do you eventually get with with Ever, with every conspiracy theory,
- 1:11:43do you eventually get to the Jews? Did it? No? You
- 1:11:47often do, but uh, like I mean to be fair, like a
- 1:11:57lot of conservative conspiracy theories in the post nine to eleven era where like,
- 1:12:02you know, there's going to be this uh this time when like the Muslims
- 1:12:08take over the United States and implement Sharia, and like, I wouldn't say
- 1:12:12these are kind of like philo Semitic conspiracy theories, but they certainly were,
- 1:12:16Like we're an anti Semitic conspiracy theories. There is Lamophobic conspiracy theories. You
- 1:12:21know, you have a lot of historically, I've had a lot of like
- 1:12:25conspiracy theories about the Masons and the illuminating. It is absolutely true that a
- 1:12:29lot of these like kind of crossover into anti Semitism. And I think the
- 1:12:34protocols of the Elders of Zion, which is like this notorious anti Semitic forgery
- 1:12:42and hoaxed document kind of did create a template for people. What you do
- 1:12:49see is, I would say, the template isn't always about Jews. The
- 1:12:53template, and I talked about this in the book, is like and it's
- 1:12:56kind of very dull, Like this is why I said, like, originally
- 1:12:59I'd set out to write a book kind of catalog and conspiracy theories, but
- 1:13:01they always kind of end up being the same thing, and that the central
- 1:13:04idea is that there's the small cabal of secretive super evil like literally evil like
- 1:13:14evil from an action movie villain type people who are cackling away trying to either
- 1:13:20slaughter everybody in the world or more commonly monopolize all the resources in the world,
- 1:13:26especially gold and oil. Those figure prominently in conspiracist lore, and they
- 1:13:32have control of politicians and especially journalists, and everybody has been corrupted by their
- 1:13:41power and their influence. And this narrative is just repeated endlessly in conspiracy subculture,
- 1:13:48and you just kind of swap out who the villains are, like often
- 1:13:51it's Jews, But I mean, I think I described this in the book.
- 1:13:58I was at this memorable conspiracist meeting. I think it was like two
- 1:14:03thousand and nine Saint Mark's Church in Manhattan, where it was a nine.
- 1:14:11It was definitely like a nine to eleven truther or conspiracy theory nut meeting those
- 1:14:15hundreds of people. But I remember there was this guy his last name is
- 1:14:20Barrett, what was his first name? He was like an he was an
- 1:14:24anti Semit. Like he got up and he gave this presentation, and the
- 1:14:31presentation he kept calling them instead of Jews, he would call them dual Israeli
- 1:14:36American citizens. I mean, and by the way, there are people I'm
- 1:14:41sure who has citizenship in both countries. But he wasn't using it in that
- 1:14:45sense. He was using it to like talk about people like me who just
- 1:14:47you know, it implies some sort of fifth column. Yeah, ideah,
- 1:14:54I mean it's like the thing is I was familiar with this guy because like
- 1:14:59I read, I knew he was an anti sim But what was really interesting
- 1:15:01is there was there was one guy who got up who called him out.
- 1:15:06And I know this guy he actually he's a guy he I forget his name,
- 1:15:12but he's the guy. He was kind of famous. He wrote the
- 1:15:15book about like a giant crocodile. It's called Megalodon or he's he's sort of
- 1:15:23like a genre novelist who who wrote a famous and I think they turned into
- 1:15:27a Hollywood movie about like a freshwater crocodile who's like eighty feet long and eats
- 1:15:30everybody. And uh, and I'd interviewed him and it was interesting. He
- 1:15:34got up and like started calling this anti Sam Waight out and saying, you
- 1:15:40know, we're all here to talk about who really did the nine to eleven
- 1:15:43attacks? And you know, we knew, we know it was like the
- 1:15:45secretive evil cabal, but it was a secret of evil cabal led by like
- 1:15:53Dick Cheney, who's who's goyish, not Jews. So stop talking about this
- 1:15:57anti Semitic stuff. You're you're discrediting the movement. It was absolutely right,
- 1:16:00Like these anti Semites do discredit the movement. And it seems weird to say,
- 1:16:06oh, you're discrediting other conspiracy theorists, because to be a conspiracy theorist
- 1:16:12is already a highly stigmatic. But you do have like this pecking order,
- 1:16:15and within conspiracy subcultures you do see people get thrown out of groups and called
- 1:16:20out and deplatformed within those already highly stigmatized subcultures because they're seen as beyond the
- 1:16:30pale. They're seen as like, you know, antisemitic or you know,
- 1:16:36like they are racist in other ways. And so there's like a kind of
- 1:16:43self policing that goes on in these movements. QAnon, I think less so
- 1:16:48because I mean it was just like so weird and unhinged that I I'm not
- 1:16:53an expert here, but you probably it probably hard to get thrown out of
- 1:16:57a q and on discussion group for saying weird things. It's essentially four Chan
- 1:17:00made sort of public, which which is kind of like the whole the whole
- 1:17:06basis of operation of a lot of these four chain groups is like to be
- 1:17:11as hateful as possible. So, uh, and this is a way in
- 1:17:15which you know, my book is obsolete because my book came out before the
- 1:17:19rise of a lot of these highly crowdsourced movements. And so you've written a
- 1:17:27book on board games. Why did you go into an area that's probably not
- 1:17:32going to sell many books? Uh, well, you just described all my
- 1:17:36books. Uh. I don't really have control about what I write about.
- 1:17:44I kind of write about what's what's interesting to me at any given time.
- 1:17:48And you know, because I like to think I'm a pretty decent writer,
- 1:17:54and I I can usually sell books that make the publishers money back and stuff.
- 1:18:00You know, I've never received, like, you know, five or
- 1:18:04six figure royalty checks. I think there are some writers who can look out
- 1:18:10and say, well, what's popular now, I'm going to write a book
- 1:18:13about AI. Everyone's talking about AI. I'm not one of those writers.
- 1:18:16If there's something that's interesting to me, I go to publishers and say,
- 1:18:20hey, I want to write a book about or games or like my last
- 1:18:26few books, I wrote a book about film exhibition. I wrote a book
- 1:18:29about the culture wars. Or I didn't write. I edited and contributed to
- 1:18:32a book it's called Panics and Persecutions put out with my colleagues, co authored
- 1:18:39a book about them as sad contributed to a whole bunch of other books.
- 1:18:44But I didn't. These are just things that I was interested in. I
- 1:18:47pitched them, and if publishers were interested, they said yes. I've been
- 1:18:53much less successful when publishers have come to me and said, hey, do
- 1:18:55you want to write a book about X y Z. Because it's very hard
- 1:19:00for me to get into as something that's like that I'm not already interested in.
- 1:19:06I mean, there are some exceptions. There's somebody who wanted me to
- 1:19:09ghost write a book about plastics, and I didn't know I was interested in
- 1:19:12plastics until I started getting into it and I was like, wow, plastics
- 1:19:15are really interesting. But that's rare. Usually it's stuff I'm already interested in.
- 1:19:19So your next game then is a bit of a cheat because you've picked
- 1:19:23a system as opposed to a particular game, though you did specify one particular
- 1:19:27game. But this is eighteen xx. What is it about eighteen xx that
- 1:19:30appeals to you. Yeah, so if if you excuse me, if you
- 1:19:38find asl obscure, eighteen xx takes it to another level, starting with the
- 1:19:45name, like, I don't know how it got saddled with this terrible name,
- 1:19:48and it's called eighteen xx because it's a game system. Like right now,
- 1:19:53my favorite game is eighteen twenty two, which is a game about the
- 1:19:57birth of the British rail system. There's eighteen eighty nine, which is about
- 1:20:04the birth of the Japanese rail system, and people are like, oh,
- 1:20:10these games are like eighteen and then two digits, So we'll call it eighteen
- 1:20:14xx, which sounds like the name of a porn movie or a porn theater.
- 1:20:18It's like, if you're eighteen years old, you can get two x's
- 1:20:23like it's it's a terrible name, it's a terrible brand, and it's a
- 1:20:28real cult. I play eighteen x every eighteen xx every day because it's a
- 1:20:34game that's particularly well suited to asynchronous play, like turn based, so like
- 1:20:39you do your turn, I do my turn. And so there's this website
- 1:20:42called eighteenxx dot Games where you'll often find me, like I'll do like a
- 1:20:47half a dozen different asynchronous games at the time, so like two or three
- 1:20:50times a day. We have to do our moves and you get alerts that
- 1:20:53say, oh, it's your time to move. And these these games you
- 1:20:57build out rail systems. It's hexagons, so it has that in common with
- 1:21:00wargames, but it doesn't really have anything else in common. So you're apart
- 1:21:05from the brutality. Of course, well yeah it actually ATX can be very
- 1:21:10brutal, but it's kind of like more stock market brutality because the way ten
- 1:21:15xx games work is you're building out railroad tracks and operating these like I mean
- 1:21:20historical railroads. The railroad tracks you build out don't have to follow historical precedent,
- 1:21:27but the way the geography of the map works is, and the way
- 1:21:30the valuation of the different routes on the map work, you're kind of encouraged
- 1:21:33to follow historical precedent. But that's only part of it. There's a whole
- 1:21:38other part, which is you're creating companies to do this, and then sometimes
- 1:21:44you're creating a shell company and moving trains and money from company to company and
- 1:21:48trying to bankrupt the other guy's company. So it's it's a combination of like
- 1:21:54track building, rail based eurogame. So Ticket to Ride might be like a
- 1:22:00an example of a kind of like more accessible, low level eurogame that a
- 1:22:06lot of people might be familiar with with like kind of a stock market manipulation
- 1:22:12investment type game like Acchoir, which is a venerable some some call it one
- 1:22:16of the first eurogames. So it's a combination of those two that where the
- 1:22:21magic happens. The other thing is, if you're interested in the history of
- 1:22:29trains and the history of rail systems and geography, you know there are dozens,
- 1:22:35maybe more than one hundred eighteen xx games that depict the historical growth of
- 1:22:41every rail system imaginable, from Asia to the Americas to europlay it. There's
- 1:22:48eighteen twenty two Africa, which is particularly which diverges substantially from historical precedent.
- 1:22:56I would say is a game that I play. And this the eighteen xx
- 1:23:05game system, is particularly difficult to explain. It's particularly difficult to explain the
- 1:23:11appeal of it to somebody, even other gamers. It's because when you're doing
- 1:23:16it, it feels like work. There's all these spreadsheets within the game that,
- 1:23:20like, you know, market prices, the valuation of companies, what
- 1:23:29trains are becoming obsolete and coming on the market, and the costing of them.
- 1:23:32There's there's auctions, especially the game called eighteen twenty two that I like.
- 1:23:35There's all sorts of auctions where you have to value dozens of different assets
- 1:23:40and it feels a lot like work. So I have this friend, his
- 1:23:45name is Joel Bryant. He actually runs another gaming podcast called Androids Dungeon in
- 1:23:50Canada, and he probably likes eighteen xx more than I do. And he
- 1:23:57was in an airport departure lounge and he saw this guy playing eighteen xx on
- 1:24:01his computer, and he walked over him to say, hey, what's your
- 1:24:05favorite eighteen xx game? And it turns out the guy was just doing work
- 1:24:09on a spreadsheet. And so the fact that my friend Joel mistook like a
- 1:24:15guy doing some kind of like quarterly sales analysis for his widget company on a
- 1:24:19spreadsheet, mistook that for this game that he and I are obsessed with,
- 1:24:25tells you a lot about like how wonky the game is, because half the
- 1:24:28game kind of looks a little like a game. There's like a map and
- 1:24:30you see hexagon stuff, but a lot of them. The game is just
- 1:24:33takes place on these kind of like ledgers and spreadsheets which just show you the
- 1:24:40cost and the profitability of different assets. And when I'm doing it, it
- 1:24:45kind of feels a little bit like some of the corporate tax stuff I was
- 1:24:48doing when I was a lawyer, Like you know, hm, this,
- 1:24:51you know, should I finance this through debt or equity? You know,
- 1:24:56I'm gonna sareholders? Am I looking for? Should I buyers sell this asset?
- 1:24:59You know what's the incomes? I'm like, wait, a sec this
- 1:25:00is this is the work that I found was drudgery when I was a tackplayer,
- 1:25:04and I couldn't wait to get out of it and become a journalist at
- 1:25:08have the pay. And yet I'm doing it willingly for no money through this
- 1:25:14obscure game system called eighteen xx. And yet I just I love it like
- 1:25:16I there are some games like ark Nova. I can't explain why I don't
- 1:25:19like it. Eighteen eighteen xx. You get a little bit of dopamine hit
- 1:25:27every time you run a train, you make money, you know your stock
- 1:25:31appreciates. Part of good game design is just managing the dopamine dopamine flow,
- 1:25:38right, and eighteen xx, for me, does a good job of that.
- 1:25:42So I want to move on there and talk about sort of your sort
- 1:25:45of life in what I'm calling alternative media, and also sort of being a
- 1:25:51contrarian in a world that seems ever ever more sort of focused on conformity.
- 1:26:00Am I am I catastrophizing about the present when I look at both the left
- 1:26:05and the right and feel that you have to you have to take every box
- 1:26:10on the checklist or you'll be exiled. So I mean the metaphor I use
- 1:26:15is cults. Right. One of the defining features of colts is you have
- 1:26:24to endorse everything they tell you. So if there's seventeen things, seventeen principles
- 1:26:29that are part of the cult, you can't say, well, I love
- 1:26:31these sixteen, but this other one forget it. That's stupid. I'm not
- 1:26:34wearing a rope. I'm just gonna wear jeans and a button down shirt.
- 1:26:38People are gonna be like, no, no, like part of our thing
- 1:26:40is like you have to wear a rope. And it's like nah, but
- 1:26:41it's just, you know, it's just I look stupid. So they're like,
- 1:26:45wellther, you're out of the cult. And it's the same thing with
- 1:26:46like, you know, the example I use is like, if you want
- 1:26:49to join isis. You know, we're talking about religion, but it's like
- 1:26:54a fanatical kind of religion that's it's almost like a cult. And you say,
- 1:26:57hey, I you know, I believe in all the stuff you guys
- 1:27:00believe with ISIS, like I want to create the new Caliphate. Yeah,
- 1:27:02it's totally cool with that, but I also like believe in gay marriage.
- 1:27:06I hope you're cool with that. They're like, no, that's absolutely not
- 1:27:10cool. You have to believe everything like you can't. There's no exceptions,
- 1:27:14And it's like Oh well, then I guess you know, I have to
- 1:27:15believe, and that I don't want to compare every political movement to like,
- 1:27:20you know, an actual cult or to isis or whatever, but like that
- 1:27:25tendency to say there's this menu of things and it isn't alc cart it's like
- 1:27:30you have to believe all these things. That is something I more closely associate
- 1:27:36with religious movements, not just religious movements, but like fanatical religious movements and
- 1:27:43cults than I do with mainstream politics. You know, when I was at
- 1:27:47the National Post, as I've already told you, like it was sort of
- 1:27:50an ala carte, you know, to pick a random issue like the sex
- 1:27:55trade. Like there are conservatives who are hardcare libertarians who are like, yep,
- 1:27:59sex is absolutely fine, Like it's like an anything else in capitalism,
- 1:28:03it should be a free market. And then you have people who also call
- 1:28:06themselves conservatives, who are like are you crazy, Like I'm a social conservative
- 1:28:12and I am absolutely appalled by the idea of people buying and selling sex in
- 1:28:15the same way they would buy and sell potatoes. And those people still go
- 1:28:20to the same conservative conventions and in some cases work with the same conservative publications
- 1:28:25that to me is what I'm more used to, you know, sort of
- 1:28:28more of a classical, small il liberal tradition that said, you know that's
- 1:28:39a great thing about history, is like or the weather. It's like,
- 1:28:42you know, wait long enough and it'll change. This sort of catastrophizing I
- 1:28:48think that's your word about politics and the cultishness of it create itself created a
- 1:28:54backlash, and Quilette is part of that backlash, where you know, it's
- 1:28:57staffed by people who don't want to be told what to do by either the
- 1:29:00right or the left, and and that what's concerned. You know, human
- 1:29:05beings are tribal creatures. So what's really interesting is that, you know,
- 1:29:10Quilett's now been around for eight or nine years, which is is like middle
- 1:29:14aged by the standard of Internet media. And so I think, you know,
- 1:29:18we used to be called alternative media. Now we're called gatekeepers. So
- 1:29:21like people will send me articles about how, you know, the dangers of
- 1:29:26COVID vaccines and and all this stuff, and I'm like, yeah, sorry,
- 1:29:30that's not for us, and like they're like, oh typical from traditional
- 1:29:32media. Gatekeeper. So like, in the space of just a couple of
- 1:29:36years, I've gone from like you know, alternative upstart to you know,
- 1:29:42hide bound, traditional media gatekeeper. And I mean you might remember, like
- 1:29:48there was this thing called the IDW, the Intellectual Dark Web, you know.
- 1:29:53The New York Times wrote this. I was actually could be could be
- 1:29:55the cringiest title of a group I've ever It's terrible. I mean it sounded
- 1:30:00like the evil faction name in one of these like space space games we're talking
- 1:30:04about. And and you know, I was actually interviewed for that and quoted
- 1:30:10for that New York Times article. And when I read it now, it's
- 1:30:14like so obsolete because this is just a couple of years ago. But they
- 1:30:16were they wrote it like there's this new thing. It's called the IDW,
- 1:30:20and it's like it's like there's all these people who who are like fleeing these
- 1:30:28camps and they're creating their own little spaces. And but now when I read
- 1:30:31it, it's like, well, a lot of these people they're talking about
- 1:30:34are kind of the media they've created are sort of profitable, established media.
- 1:30:40And like, you know, for Quilette, like we're getting people like Benny
- 1:30:45Morris to write for us, who's like one of the most famous Israeli historians
- 1:30:47and you know, a couple of days ago, I interviewed Michael Powell,
- 1:30:50who's now at the Atlantic, and like there's a centrifuical and then a centripetal
- 1:30:58effect where the people who were yesterdays erretics become tomorrow's gatekeepers. And so now
- 1:31:03like when I get trolled people send me email, it's like this weird thing
- 1:31:08where it's like brackish water where I don't know whether they're trolling me because you
- 1:31:14know, they think, like I write for your alternative media and you got
- 1:31:19to get with the program, or they think I'm this hide bound gatekeeper,
- 1:31:24and so I get it from both ends now, But it shows how how
- 1:31:28quickly things change, and in a way it gives me ho. I mean,
- 1:31:32it's not nice, you know, people call me names, but that's
- 1:31:35life in the public sphere. But like every every reaction has a counter reaction,
- 1:31:43and it was inevitable that enough people were going to be pissed off about
- 1:31:47the stuff that was going on in media, like especially when James Bennett was
- 1:31:51was thrown off the op ed pages the New York Times. I think there
- 1:31:54were a lot of people who like looked at that and so, okay,
- 1:31:56there's something wrong here, and you saw people you know, very wise created
- 1:32:00her publication, and you know, you have Coilette, you have other publications
- 1:32:05that subsequently were like created in the same mold. And at first, people,
- 1:32:10you know, I would get questions like this, like, oh,
- 1:32:13you know, what's it like to create this like new thing, and it's
- 1:32:15not so new anymore. And now you're getting upstarts to upstart, like you
- 1:32:21know, yesterday's heretic becomes you know, tomorrow's orthodox thinker or establishment figure.
- 1:32:30And now I'm seeing publications. I mean, substack is a great example.
- 1:32:35There's all kinds of Sometimes I'll get a submissiont Quilette and I'll be like,
- 1:32:39no, sorry, that's two out there, like I just that's not for
- 1:32:41me. And then a week later I'll see it published on substack and it'll
- 1:32:45be like super popular. It doesn't doesn't change my decision about whether I should
- 1:32:50have accepted it. It's just if I think it was bad article. It's
- 1:32:53a bad article. But like and then the people and then I'll look in
- 1:32:56the comments and it's like, yeah, you know, Collette would never publish
- 1:32:59this article, and they're right, And that's a healthy thing. It's healthy
- 1:33:02that you have this kind of like cyclical series of green shoots coming up under
- 1:33:13the earth and challenging and displacing old media. Like there will come a time
- 1:33:17when coilette is you know, is taken over by by an upstart meeting.
- 1:33:23I hope it's not soon, but these things happen, and I think to
- 1:33:27a certain extent that's healthy because it shows that people are not willing. I
- 1:33:32mean, they might for a couple of years go along with all this tribalism
- 1:33:35and orthodoxy and stuff, but sooner or later, you know, enough smart,
- 1:33:42successful people are going to create institutions that challenge that, and then they're
- 1:33:46going to create their own orthodoxies, Like you know, every reform movement ends
- 1:33:53up creating its own orthodoxy. It's just like kind of a cyclical thing,
- 1:33:58and it's inevitable, and it's gonna happen to me. It's gonna happen to
- 1:34:00us, and it's just part of the way ideas muto. So your next
- 1:34:08game then is Commands and Colors Ancient Why this one? Why this Commands and
- 1:34:13Colors game? So for me, a board game about war should either be
- 1:34:18like really detailed like Advanced Squad Leader, or really simple and fun and beer
- 1:34:25and pretzels and Command and Colors to me is like the best example of a
- 1:34:30beer and pretzel war game that you can play in like ninety minutes or two
- 1:34:34hours. I mean, I've played Commanding Colors games that like go for forty
- 1:34:39five minutes. It's highly abstract, and you know, you have these like
- 1:34:44historical battles. There's a Napoleonics one actually in a bookshelf. If you're watching
- 1:34:49on video, which no one is, you'd be able to see it.
- 1:34:54There's a Napoleonics one. There's all kinds of add ons. The ancient ones
- 1:34:57to me is great because you can there's all these famous battles involving like Julius
- 1:35:00Caesar and stuff, and it's highly abstracted, but not so abstract that you
- 1:35:09don't get a flavor for what medieval warfare was like, so not many ancient
- 1:35:13warfare. It's like like one of the things I love history, And one
- 1:35:16of the things that military historians who cover the ancient Romans and the Greeks,
- 1:35:24one thing they constantly say is like most people in these battles die when people
- 1:35:29start to run away, because they start to run away, they break ranks,
- 1:35:31they run into each other, the shield wall falls down, they expose
- 1:35:35themselves to missile attack, the enemy cavalry comes in and starts butchering them,
- 1:35:41and then like it's a feast for crows. Like it's just like big and
- 1:35:45the game does a really good job of modeling that. And so are you
- 1:35:51going to learn like detailed information about weapons systems the way Advanced Squalider teaches you
- 1:35:57about like every minute detail about every machine gun on every tank that was using
- 1:36:00World War Two. No, However, you get a great sense of like
- 1:36:05the kind of ebb and flow of how ancient military battles, you know,
- 1:36:11heavy infantry, archers, elephants in the case of Hannibal, siege weapons,
- 1:36:19that kind of thing. You get a good sense for that. So when
- 1:36:25you're listening to a history podcast, like for me, one of the functions
- 1:36:28of board games is as a complementary good. So that when I was listening
- 1:36:33to History of Rome, which is this podcast by Mike Duncan, that's you
- 1:36:38know, there's enough nerds listening to this. They probably history nerds too,
- 1:36:42and they probably listen listen to it. I was like, Wow, I
- 1:36:45want to play board games that about ancient Rome. And then I'll play a
- 1:36:50board game and it'll make me interested in a podcast. So like my historical
- 1:36:55interests get cross fertilized as between board games and history books, and I can
- 1:37:03it sounds ridiculous to say, oh, you know, and Mike Duncan talks
- 1:37:06about this or that battle, you know, the Battle of Adrianople or whatever,
- 1:37:11it's like, oh, yeah, I really get it because you know,
- 1:37:12I played a command in college game. It's like, yeah, you
- 1:37:15know, I know what it's like to fight in that kind of battle.
- 1:37:17But like, on some level, his descriptions of that battle have more resonance
- 1:37:25because a well designed scenario and Command and Colors does kind of model like the
- 1:37:31high high level strategic decisions, you know, like the game encourages you to
- 1:37:36put your cavalry on the flanks. The game encourages you to create route paths
- 1:37:43for your troops so that when, if, and when they do run away,
- 1:37:45they don't smash into each other and your whole line collapses. They do
- 1:37:50model the inability of commanders at the time to have instant control over troops.
- 1:37:59Like like that's something thing, you know. I recently read a book.
- 1:38:01I actually wrote a reviewver for Quillette is about the Frankopressional War of eighteen seventy,
- 1:38:06which is only a century and a half ago. And even then,
- 1:38:10I mean, in the heat of battle, generals we're like riding around waving
- 1:38:14flags and stuff in order to try and command their troops. There's like a
- 1:38:18very inexact control that these commanders had. The idea, you know, modern
- 1:38:23warfare where everyone's connected by by radio or digital technology can be ordered about in
- 1:38:30the hea heat of battle. That's a new thing. So these kind of
- 1:38:33things which maybe we don't think about when we're reading history books. A good
- 1:38:38board game brings it out. And like I said to me, the best
- 1:38:42board game is either extremely detailed, like Squad Leader, or it's extremely abstract
- 1:38:45like Command and Colors. I don't particularly like games that are in the middle
- 1:38:51where it's like you're moving around battalions and regiments on like a big you know,
- 1:38:56it's like the Battle of Kursk or something, where it's not detailed enough
- 1:39:01that it's telling a sort of granular level story about like a battle for a
- 1:39:06village or something. But at the same time, it is detailed enough that
- 1:39:12like the rules are really complicated and it's not a beer and pressol game and
- 1:39:18you know you might spend six hours playing it and not finish it. I
- 1:39:24like them at the two ends of the spectrum, and that's that's why Commanding
- 1:39:28Color is an ASL. From my mind, both belong on that list,
- 1:39:31and I enjoy both of them, even though again one is highly abstracting one
- 1:39:35is highly detailed. So I want to talk briefly now about the future.
- 1:39:40So firstly, do you have any any more books that listeners can buy?
- 1:39:45And secondly, if people haven't heard of Collette and they're curiosity is peaked by
- 1:39:50this show, how would you explain Collette? So Coillette is I think every
- 1:40:00publication is an outgrowth of the personality of the people who write it and edit
- 1:40:05it, and Quilette is a particularly good example of it because there's only like,
- 1:40:12there's only five of us who really work like full time at Coilette.
- 1:40:16I mean, we have hundreds of contributors. I think we published something like
- 1:40:19two thousand different authors, but in terms of like day to day editorial control
- 1:40:25over Coilette, there's only five of us at the time I'm saying this.
- 1:40:33And the best way to describe Quillette is like if you've just listened to me
- 1:40:36speak for the last Well, I don't know how you're gonna edit this sixty
- 1:40:39minutes nine minutes. However, long like Colette, is kind of an outgrowth
- 1:40:43of that. It betrays an interest in technology, has a highly analytical character.
- 1:40:49It's heterodox, it's free thinking. It's allergic to political tribes and the
- 1:41:00cult of self censorship that those tribes inflict on people. It's won key.
- 1:41:08Again. We have a lot of articles. I mean, I think this
- 1:41:11maybe is more mind influence. We have a lot of stuff about history.
- 1:41:14So lately I've been running these two long form series. One is on the
- 1:41:17Dark Ages and one is on the history of Canada. So you know,
- 1:41:23I just wrote this long book review about the Franco Pressian War. So my
- 1:41:29colleagues are more interested, I would say, in things like evolutionary psychology and
- 1:41:34the psychological effects of social media. We have a lot of stuff about the
- 1:41:38Gaza Hamas conflicts going on right now. Again, I mentioned Benny Morris because
- 1:41:44he's a historian, a well known historian that I respect, and I actually
- 1:41:47interviewed him on the podcast. Although I tell people like you know, if
- 1:41:53you're listening to me on a podcast that usually means you like podcasts, So
- 1:41:57I host the Quillette Podcast snippets of I might be putting snippets of this interview
- 1:42:02on the Quiet podcast, So give it a try, you know, go
- 1:42:08to if you're at Spotify or Apple Podcasts or whatever, just enter Collette.
- 1:42:12And actually we have a few podcasts. One is called coill et Cetera,
- 1:42:15which there's a lot of great stuff from my colleague Zoe Booth and Claire Layman.
- 1:42:21My my podcast that I usually host is called the Quillette Podcast, and
- 1:42:26I think we're up to two hundred and thirty episodes. I actually just published
- 1:42:29an episode which I think people might like, with Michael Powell of Atlantic Magazine,
- 1:42:33formerly of the New York Times. We had a great conversation and I
- 1:42:38don't typically do. In fact, I never really talk about board games on
- 1:42:43that podcast, because you know, you suddenly do to an extent, because
- 1:42:48that's how I found you were a game with I do glancingly right, like
- 1:42:53I will, I will kind of, but I like, you'll never hear
- 1:42:57me do a podcast called like What's the Best eighteen XC Game Science? Like
- 1:43:02I don't think I'd get away with that, but I will often like slide
- 1:43:08in board game stuff, because like any any subculture is a window into into
- 1:43:15the human condition, right, Like, that's one thing I've learned at Couillette.
- 1:43:18We my colleague Jamie Palmer, curated and edited these great pieces about how
- 1:43:25the culture war had destroyed the sense of camaraderie in the knitting field, right,
- 1:43:32that's knitting with a k knitting field in England, where people were at
- 1:43:38each other's throats a couple of years ago over like cultural appropriation. I don't
- 1:43:43know in terms of like what kind of camusols or anything. I mean,
- 1:43:45I don't know what it was, but it was absolutely fascinating. And that's
- 1:43:50one thing going back to your question about what Quillette is. Quiet has long
- 1:43:54form journalism. So many of the articles I write and edit are like three
- 1:43:58five thousand, ten thousand words, and typically they revolve around case studies.
- 1:44:02So, like you know, the knitting industry, we had a great investigation
- 1:44:09into you know, Canadian literary circles. You're like sort of what was then
- 1:44:14called cancel culture. I don't think people use that term anymore in Canadian literary
- 1:44:17circles. Our approach is journalistic, so we're always looking to go deep into
- 1:44:24case studies that betray a larger phenomenon in the world of ideas, which I
- 1:44:28think separates us from some substack. When I go on substack, I often
- 1:44:33see like, you know, these twelve hundred word jeremiad's about like you know,
- 1:44:39cancel culture sucks, and you know, Joe Biden sucks and or Donald
- 1:44:45Trump sucks. But it's kind of like written in a sort of general op
- 1:44:49ed style, and that's the kind of content I typically don't publish at Couilette.
- 1:44:56I'm much more like, if if you want to criticize an academic movement,
- 1:45:01you know, I'm much more interested in like publishing a piece by say
- 1:45:04a professor at a liberal arts college who's going to explain to readers what this
- 1:45:12phenomenon looks like from the inside, rather than just kind of a generalized rant.
- 1:45:15But you know, I've been known to publish. You know, I
- 1:45:19can rant pretty good myself, although I usually for for me, that's that's
- 1:45:24what Twitter is about, you know, mindless rants or for social media.
- 1:45:28You know, what you want to write. For Quilette, it's it's always
- 1:45:31better to have like a good detailed journalistic case study, which for me is
- 1:45:35the best window, much much as a good close analysis of a good board
- 1:45:40game is what we've done here is a good window into the board gaming hobby.
- 1:45:45A good analysis of like dysfunction within a professional culture, whether it's knitting
- 1:45:50or academia or plastics or whatever, is the best way to bring readers or
- 1:45:56podcast listeners into the dysfunctionalities of that world. Yeah. I mean I didn't
- 1:46:01go to Collette's for the history, but I did find the episode on Justinian
- 1:46:05a couple of weeks ago. Absolutely Justinian. Yeah, you know, we
- 1:46:11as Peter Saras, who's an English historian who wrote this fantastic. If people
- 1:46:17don't listen to anything else I've said here, go to Amazon and by Peter
- 1:46:21Saras's new biography of Justinian probably like the most important historical figure that many people
- 1:46:30have never heard of, you know, along with Diocletian, who on the
- 1:46:34Western side. And you know, I spoke to him for like forty minutes.
- 1:46:41And that's one of the things I love about Coilette is I can speak
- 1:46:44to historians about Justinian, and then the next week I can speak to Michael
- 1:46:47Powell about the culture wards surrounding Gaza. So your final game then is another
- 1:46:54big involved, very sort of very unique kind of game, and this is
- 1:47:00High Frontier. And when I was I was looking for ways to try and
- 1:47:05contact you to get you on this show. I went on your Facebook profile
- 1:47:09and find out that we only have one mutual friend in common, and that's
- 1:47:12Phil Eckland. How it's hilarious, How so funny? Unique is he in
- 1:47:18the world of board games? Do you think, oh wow, so it's
- 1:47:25incorrect as a matter of addiction to say that somebody is very unique, as
- 1:47:28you know, I have to have to bring up my pedantic side at one
- 1:47:31point. He is absolutely unique. So Phil Eckland, who have've corresponded with,
- 1:47:36and I actually interviewed him literally a former rocket scientist from Arizona, and
- 1:47:43that that training as a rocket scientist comes through a High Frontier which models the
- 1:47:46technical development of the creation of rockets necessary to travel to other planets and you
- 1:47:56know, living the dream. He just decided, you know what, I
- 1:47:58don't want to design rockets. I want to design games about rockets. And
- 1:48:01now lives in Germany, or at least he did at the time interview he
- 1:48:04did. I think he lives in Sweden. Okay, Ah, so not
- 1:48:11Arizona, and I'm like, he is a nerds nerd, like because High
- 1:48:19Frontier is about interstellar or interplanetary travel. But his game, Packed Renaissance is
- 1:48:26a masterpiece. Packed Renaissance is about you take you take the rule of like
- 1:48:31a sixteenth century European financier who's playing the markets, uh, you know,
- 1:48:38playing the Game of Thrones in Europe and Asia, minor the religious wars,
- 1:48:45and it teaches you a ton about history. But he he's brilliant because he
- 1:48:50doesn't style it as a traditional war game as many people would. So it's
- 1:48:55not like Virgin Queen or Here I Stand, which are are popular games,
- 1:49:00more of a conventional territorial control games that model the same period. He's always
- 1:49:03much more interested in, like putting you in the role of interstitial figures,
- 1:49:11so like Fenanciers, or like he has a big focus on trade and development,
- 1:49:17and so Packs Renaissance is I think a masterpiece. High Frontier is kind
- 1:49:21of a maybe you could call the eighteen xx of Space or the asl of
- 1:49:26Space High Frontier. Again, it's one of those games that like the best
- 1:49:30way to learn it is to have a friend who can teach you. Although
- 1:49:35you know, maybe more so than asl You can, like, if you
- 1:49:41have a high level game group where they like heavy games, you can teach
- 1:49:45it. You know, it's like I think heavy cardboard, if I remember
- 1:49:46correctly, does a pretty good job of it. But he is the only
- 1:49:51game designer I know because I wrote I wrote if you if you look up
- 1:49:57Quillette and Greenland he wrote, or his forget if he co produced it,
- 1:50:02or but his company that he's affiliated with produced this game about the inhabitation of
- 1:50:10Greenland. But yeah, it's filled designed the game. Yeah, so it's
- 1:50:15a brilliant, brilliant, brilliant game. And I wrote a five thousand word
- 1:50:18article for Coilette about the history of Greenland and just the history of of the
- 1:50:24Inuit more generally, and a lot of what I wrote was based on sources
- 1:50:31that were cited in the footnotes the Rules of Greenland. And I think that
- 1:50:40it's a Greenland is fairly simple compared to Pax Renaissance or compared to our frontier
- 1:50:45as Ecklundian creations, but they all have in common that like Eckland is completely
- 1:50:57obsessed with the science and history of what he's pretty so in the case of
- 1:51:00like high Frontier You're getting all these footnotes explaining about like the scientific principles behind
- 1:51:09how certain kinds of rockets work, and some of the stuff just goes over
- 1:51:12my head. I mean, like, you know, I can't design a
- 1:51:15rocket. But then and then packs Renaissance the cards themselves have flavored like this
- 1:51:19flavor text and this flavor text, and the flavor text on packs Renaissance cards
- 1:51:25is like, you know, it's like the Wikipedia entry for like some mercenary
- 1:51:30group from sixteenth century Turkey or something like. It's just super detailed. And
- 1:51:35the historical footnotes in Greenland were so dense and well written and interesting that I
- 1:51:44was like, I got to write about this. And of course, like
- 1:51:45I didn't just write it based on the footnotes, like I looked up the
- 1:51:47sources that he cited. But I can honestly say that that whole sphere of
- 1:51:55history of like you know, the settlement of of that part of the world,
- 1:52:01it's climate, I mean, all of it comes from my playing that
- 1:52:06game and and from the brilliance. So Phil Ecklund of being able to gamify
- 1:52:12that now that said, like he's done experiments with gaming where to me it
- 1:52:16didn't work. So he has these games that model like the biological development of
- 1:52:21organisms like megicauna and bios origins and stuff. And I have this friend Mike
- 1:52:27McNally who's just he's always trying to get me to like play these games.
- 1:52:30And it's like, you have to put proteins together to create like an amoba,
- 1:52:34and then the amoba combines with another ambia become and I'm like, this
- 1:52:38is stupid. I don't want to play this. But there's a whole like
- 1:52:43trio of games that he's created where you can like go from single cell organisms
- 1:52:49to you know, to human beings created in computers in the twentieth century,
- 1:52:57like in a continuous span of gaming. And there's some people who really like
- 1:53:00that. I personally find it too ambitious. I don't like it. However,
- 1:53:04it just shows that this guy is brilliant in the sense that he's not
- 1:53:08interested in creating games about things that everyone else has created games about, like
- 1:53:13the American Civil War or Stalingrad. Like there's five hundred games about Stalingrad.
- 1:53:18There's five hundred games about the American Civil War. There's not a lot of
- 1:53:21games where you take the role of like a protein strand trying to create a
- 1:53:27single cell organism, organism, and that's the kind of game he's interested in.
- 1:53:31So I've got one more question for you then, So, yeah,
- 1:53:34the the Apocalypse is starting. You're heading out of Toronto and you go around
- 1:53:40a corner. The back door of the car flies open, and four of
- 1:53:45the games flying down a ravine into a river and a swept away to posterity,
- 1:53:48which games you hope is sitting on the backseat of the car. Oh,
- 1:53:51Dance glob no question. So if people want to get hold of you,
- 1:53:56they want to read your staff all of that sort of good stuff,
- 1:53:59how can they go by doing that if they go to my Twitter, which
- 1:54:03I mean, if you're not on Twitter, I don't recommend it. It's
- 1:54:06it's a soul crushing experience. It's absolutely vile. Oh it's awful. However,
- 1:54:12if the one advantage is that if you go to my Twitter, which
- 1:54:15is at john k it's just six letters Jail and Kay under the profile,
- 1:54:23there's like a link and if you click that link, it takes you to
- 1:54:27this the sort of meta page which has a contact me thing, and it
- 1:54:32also has links to my Collette collect podcast and to my board gaming blog,
- 1:54:36which is a substack which is called let's get bored. But see how clever
- 1:54:43board is spelled b o ar d, so it's very clever. Yeah,
- 1:54:45it's like a blow that's kind of stuff. And you're not even you can
- 1:54:49do doubls and you're not even English. Uh you know what I like?
- 1:54:55I said, I grew up in pseudo Victorian Anglo Montreal, so I got
- 1:55:02a little smatter. We watched Masterpiece Theater, we watched Upstairs Downstairs, huge
- 1:55:09PBS fanatic. This is I mean, this is before the days of Downton
- 1:55:13Abbey when it was all fashionable and such. Alistair Cook was a constant presence
- 1:55:16in our house. Wow. Oh yeah, that's one for the kids.
- 1:55:19Lots of culture, lots of culture anyways. So yeah, so go to
- 1:55:26Twitter, go to at junk, then follow the link. Then immediately close
- 1:55:30the tab that has Twitter on it so your soul doesn't get contaminated. And
- 1:55:35that page that it takes you to, uh will take you to all my
- 1:55:41various scribblings and podcastings. And there's a contact me page if they want to
- 1:55:45troll me. Excellent. Well, Jonathan Kay, thank you very much.
- 1:55:49Thanks for having me on. You can support the show in many ways.
- 1:55:53You can tell your friends. You can talk about it on social media.
- 1:55:55You can talk about it in your own blog, podcast, or video.
- 1:55:58You can support it directly by going to Patreon dot com, forward slash five
- 1:56:00gf D for a rolling donation, or for a one off donation hitting the
- 1:56:03PayPal link at bottom of the website five Games for Doomsday dot com. It's
- 1:56:06these donations that keep the show going. Also, if you want to say
- 1:56:10something nice about the show, if you want to say something horrible about the
- 1:56:13show, you can contact me on Twitter at five Games for Doomsday or send
- 1:56:15me an email at five Games for Doomsday dot com. Also, you can
- 1:56:19join the discord by going to five g fd dot com. And if I've
- 1:56:23managed to stumble away from the cat pictures and the pictures that think they're cats,
- 1:56:27I'll see you in two weeks for another five Games for Doomsday