Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Therapists Without Empathy
Transcript
- 0:00So, Bob, I got an email about any social personality disorder that got
- 0:04me hot under the collar, and I thought we would read it and respond,
- 0:08what do you say, Bob, Yeah, let's do it. Anonymous
- 0:11militier patron. They say hello, doctor Kirkkonda, and Bob I was diagnosed
- 0:16with antisocial personality disorder some years ago. Wow, I was diagnosed with antisocial
- 0:22personality disorder some years ago, And upon learning of my diagnosis, I decided
- 0:27to seek out information to better understand it and how it relates to me.
- 0:31Fast forward a few years and well, just chiming in here, what would
- 0:35you imagine the circumstances were around this individual having an official diagnosis. I would
- 0:42imagine unless they sought therapy on their own, they were involved in the legal
- 0:46system. Could be could also be actual therapy, could be. Yeah,
- 0:51in fact, I would imagine that to be the case. But I don't
- 0:55know, But yeah, I would say probably the majority of documented diagnosing of
- 1:02an individual of antisocial it would be in the legal system. But I also
- 1:08imagine that you could be in couple therapy or even you know, regular individual
- 1:14therapy. Because people with andy social have a lot of different profiles. There's
- 1:19the stereotypical profile, which is a legit profile in which someone with any social
- 1:26is in and out of prison. They're violent, they are impulsive, they
- 1:30exploit others, they're hurtful to other people. Their life is a bit of
- 1:36a train wreck, they have drug and alcohol problems. You know, that's
- 1:40a profile. But you have other profiles where someone feels like there's something different
- 1:46about them growing up and they don't want to harm other people, but they
- 1:51don't feel bad if they do. And they know that if they act on
- 1:53their impulse of not caring about other people's feelings and using them as stepping stones,
- 2:00that it'll come back around to hurt them. So they will have to
- 2:07pay attention, more energy in their brain to make sure that they avoid consequences
- 2:14themselves by hurting other people. That's a Coldburg stage. I mean, it's
- 2:19basically a morality based on cost benefit. What do you mean, Well,
- 2:23what's the cost of the behavior, what's the benefit of the behavior? And
- 2:28so I choose what I choose based on those factors, and all people go
- 2:32through a state of where do we stand on Coburg these days? Do we
- 2:38think that Coburg holds water? I don't know. It's been a while since
- 2:40I've looked into it, but it's a worthy model of considering. Yeah,
- 2:44so, you know, children go through a stage of morality where that's how
- 2:49they think and what's beyond that stage? By it's been so long, let's
- 2:53see what the old Internet says. You got the pre conventional stage. You
- 2:59have stage one, in which you are obedient and worried about punishment. Stage
- 3:05two is individualism and exchange, which is the stage you were talking about right.
- 3:09At this stage, individuals recognize that there is not just one right view,
- 3:14but that different individuals have different viewpoints. Morality is based on reciprocity and
- 3:19fairness. Stage three is interpersonal relationships. At this stage, individuals seek approval
- 3:23from others and conform to societal norms. At to say approval, Morality is
- 3:30based on maintaining good relationships and following rules to please others. Stage four is
- 3:35maintaining social order. At this stage, individuals conformed to societal laws and norms
- 3:39to maintain social order and avoid guilt. Morality is based on following the rules
- 3:45and fulfilling duties to society. That's kind of interesting because that stage is front
- 3:52and center on Twitter these days. If you think about it, right,
- 3:55Well, you wouldn't know because you don't pay attention to those things. But
- 4:00for people who are on Twitter or on Reddit or whatever, there's this high
- 4:05level of individual scrutiny on oneself about avoiding guilt and maintaining social order and conforming
- 4:15to societal laws as they change over time for the better often. But it's
- 4:21interesting that that's not the highest level, right part of the well. Stage
- 4:26five is societal contract and individual rights. At this stage, individuals recognized that
- 4:30laws and rules are societal contracts that can be changed for the greater good.
- 4:36Morality is based on upholding individual rights and democratic principles. I see. So
- 4:41at this stage you are thinking more meta about the societal order and the societal
- 4:46rules and laws. You're not just following them without thinking about them. You're
- 4:53thinking what's the bigger purpose and value and meaning. That's interesting. Stage six
- 5:00is at this stage individuals develop their more principles based on universal ethical principles.
- 5:08Morality is based on abstract reasoning and commitment to social justice and equality. So
- 5:15that's interesting. That is interesting. I'm sure there's a lot more detail there
- 5:18that I'm not picking up on, but anyway, so you were saying that
- 5:27for some folks with antisocial that lack empathy the way that other people will feel,
- 5:33they might have a version of behavioral management for themselves that involves one of
- 5:44these stages, like you know, they are trying to avoid problems happening to
- 5:50them. I don't really hear that in any of these stages, by the
- 5:55way, maybe some of the early stages. But yeah, so you have
- 6:00someone who ends up in therapy because of depression or anxiety or relationship problems,
- 6:06because you know, that's a misnormal that is often discussed even in clinical circles
- 6:11that people with andy social don't want relationships or don't have emotions. They absolutely
- 6:16do have emotions. They can have subdued emotions or limited emotions, but they
- 6:21still have emotions. They also have attachment needs just like every other human.
- 6:27They might be convoluted and difficult for them to navigate, and they might have
- 6:31a lot of associations with relationships that make it hard for them to pursue or
- 6:38trust relationships because when they were teenagers, they might have run into a lot
- 6:43of consequences to themselves, people breaking up with them, people not wanting to
- 6:47be with them, people bullying, them people being very upset at them,
- 6:54and you might, as a developing young person, decide, well, I'm
- 6:58different, and so I I guess I don't like relationships and I'm just going
- 7:01to say that to myself to cope, you know, that kind of stuff.
- 7:05So I can imagine someone like that running into some emotional problems, having
- 7:10some questions about the personality, and ending up in therapy. In fact,
- 7:13I know that I've had clients like that occasionally. Okay, going on,
- 7:18fast forward a few years and I am now a doctoral candidate in a clinical
- 7:23psychology program. Wow. I can see how it may be difficult to understand
- 7:26why someone like me would desire to work in the field, especially given my
- 7:30deficits and empathy and remorse. But I am not just my diagnosis. What
- 7:35do you think about this so far? Bob? This is really interesting.
- 7:38I want to learn more. Yeah, well, what's your initial reaction?
- 7:42I want to ask questions like what led you into the field, and what
- 7:46is it like to sit in therapy with somebody you know, like we what
- 7:51would a session feel like, and how would I you know, I'd like
- 7:56to watch one. That'd be really cool, actually, and I'd like to
- 8:00learn about how since empathy is so essential to good therapy, how they navigate
- 8:09so fascinating. I could imagine them being really good at it. Well.
- 8:16One of my deficits as a therapist is I worry too much about what people
- 8:22think of me, and so that can at times hamstring me and lead to
- 8:28well so, but if I'm not worried about what people think, and I'm
- 8:33just imagining what they need or what would be best, then i might be
- 8:37just very matter of fact and straightforward about what's happening in them and just reflect
- 8:41that back to them without really much compunction or worry at all. That's cool,
- 8:46That's a great point. I had thought of that, but I've heard
- 8:50that before, and that absolutely is a benefit. In fact, I've often
- 8:56said that to be a good therapist you have to be slightly anti social,
- 9:01because you have to be willing to break from social convention to ask the tough
- 9:09questions and to confront social givens that are problematic. And the less anti social
- 9:18you are, the harder it is for people to do that. You know,
- 9:22a little bit of antisocial actually can help people, you know. The
- 9:28classic example that I give is that if you come to a stop sign or
- 9:33a stop light in the middle of a flat plane in the middle of like
- 9:39Kansas or something, and it's broad daylight and there isn't a car in sight.
- 9:46Do you just sit there at the light for however long? Or is
- 9:50it okay if you feel like it to blow through the red light? And
- 9:56what would your answer be to that? Well, this happened to me for
- 10:00months when I would drive down to the beach house. There was some construction
- 10:05going on two lane road and so one of the lanes was blocked off and
- 10:09they had a temporary stop plate there for traffic, and I always just waited
- 10:15for it to turn green, even though there wasn't a single reason, a
- 10:18single safety reason. Yep, yeah, I will blow through those things if
- 10:24I am one hundred percent sure that there's no risk of harm, because it's
- 10:30illogical and annoying to me, but you know, you want to get where
- 10:37you're going. But I'm more antisocial at that way. I'm more willing to
- 10:43put myself before societal norms. Starting a podcast was a big part of that,
- 10:50actually, because especially back then, my goodness, for years, I
- 10:56would hear you know, you know, for years after I started the podcast,
- 11:00I would hear many people in my field talk about how it was unethical
- 11:05as a therapist to be on social media at all. Oh, that's just
- 11:09a little rigid, well, especially now what we would say. But when
- 11:13Facebook first came around, I mean, I don't know if you remember this,
- 11:16but for the first number of years, it was a hotly debated topic
- 11:22of can a therapist have a Facebook page? The only reason I have one
- 11:26is because you made it. Yeah, and I think you have the same
- 11:31profile picture, and yeah. People were saying that up until I heard therapists
- 11:41saying that just like six years ago in a class for online ethics for therapists,
- 11:50and a student said that, and the facilitator, the teacher didn't push
- 11:56back on it, I think because he just didn't want to cause a problem.
- 12:01But it was out there anyway, so it was a very risky thing
- 12:05for me. But I said, this is like a stop light in the
- 12:09middle of nowhere that does nothing. I understand, you know, if we
- 12:13go by the Colberg thing, I understand the bigger picture of the meaning of
- 12:20these ethical codes that they're set up to reduce harmed to clients and to the
- 12:24public and to students and supervisors as well. And so if I feel very
- 12:31confident in my ability to move forward with this and to keep an eye on
- 12:35that. Then I know that I'm doing the right thing, even though in
- 12:39fact, I wish I had given a survey back then. But I'm guessing
- 12:45that if I had asked one hundred therapists if it was unethical for me to
- 12:50have the podcast, I'm guessing ninety five percent would say at the very least
- 12:54it was somewhat unethical just on its face, regardless of what I was talking
- 12:58about. Now, things have rapidly changed since then, but you'll still find
- 13:03therapists today that will you know, they'll have these blanket statements like any therapist
- 13:07on TikTok is unethical, or any influencer therapist is unethical. I'll see that
- 13:13on different forums. To me, I'm like, it fucking depends. You
- 13:20know, you can have a therapist who is doing a lot of good for
- 13:26society and even their clients by being on TikTok, and you can have a
- 13:31therapist that is harming the profession and their own clients anyway. So having a
- 13:39little bit anti social might actually help. But so you're saying that if you
- 13:43have full blown any social it might actually be a benefit because you'd be able
- 13:48to not have to worry about the backlash from a client even though you know
- 13:54this is going to help them ultimately. I mean, your heart rate might
- 13:58not change much a session, Like if you were doing couple therapy and it
- 14:01got heated, your heart rate might not change much. And so you have
- 14:05access to your good thinker and perhaps can as a result of that, intervene
- 14:13more effectively than somebody whose heart rate is But it is a question about that
- 14:18you brought up of. If you don't have empathy, how are you a
- 14:22therapist? How do you get in someone's shoes if it's I mean, it's
- 14:26probably not impossible, but maybe it requires a kind of effort that maybe becomes
- 14:31easier for somebody else. I think another question is, if you lack empathy,
- 14:35or you have very limited empathy, why do you want to be a
- 14:39therapist? What don't you want to learn? I want to learn, like
- 14:43what drove them in? What brought them into the field. Yeah, well
- 14:45they don't really get into it, but maybe they can write in. But
- 14:48I think it's a worthy question, and it is clear from this case that
- 14:52you don't need that, and I think that's an understanding that should be scrutinized
- 14:58a bit right that to be a therapist, you must at least have the
- 15:03normal level, if not an inordinate level of empathy and care and compassion for
- 15:07other people. Also, might this individual anonymous Midlalitier patron have compassion regardless of
- 15:16not having empathy. You know, there's a lot of debate and a lot
- 15:18of research and really philosophy around these words of compassion and altruism and empathy,
- 15:26sympathy. It's complicated. We tend to lump a lot of things, especially
- 15:33today into the world, into the word empathy, because originally empathy just meant
- 15:37that you are feeling someone else's feelings, whether or not you cared to or
- 15:41not. You're on the bus and someone's having a freak out and you feel
- 15:46that freak out. You're starting to feel anxious, and that's empathy. And
- 15:50now empathy is used for that, but it's also used for care and sympathy
- 15:56and compassion and wanting to help somebody else, you know, caring about someone
- 16:03else's feelings. And I feel like we should be saying those other phrases more
- 16:08often than just the word empathy. Anyway, before we move on, let's
- 16:12take a break. What do you say, Bob, yep, take a
- 16:15break. Okay, we're back from the break. So going on with email.
- 16:23Being in my program has really shown me just how many misconceptions there are
- 16:27in the field regarding people who are similar to myself with antisocial I am so
- 16:33frequently subjected to people talking about how treating antisocial personality disorder is not only a
- 16:38pointless endeavor, but also the notion that treating a psychopath is just an exercise
- 16:44in creating a better psychopath. Bob, have you heard of this? No?
- 16:48I never heard of that last bit. Oh, I have, absolutely,
- 16:52really, yeah, it's probably the dominant thing that I've heard. I
- 16:56agree with an on miss military patron. It's upsetting that it's still happening.
- 17:00But people will say that you cannot treat a psychopath or someone with any social
- 17:07there's no benefit, and that it will in the end actually harm because what
- 17:14you're doing is you're teaching the psychopath how to game yet another system, because
- 17:22they're always on the take, they're always manipulating, they're never actually giving you
- 17:30meaningful work in therapy. They're either avoiding or they're playing you, and at
- 17:37baseline is just going to be worthless. But it might even result in you
- 17:41being played such that you actually advocate for the client or for the client in
- 17:47a way that would release them from prison or something, and or the client
- 17:52learns, Okay, I've learned how to manipulate that therapist. I've learned a
- 17:56new skill of manipulation, so now I can continue to diminipulate others. I've
- 18:02heard this my entire career. You've never heard that before. I've heard that
- 18:03last bit. But what was the thing that they wrote. They said that
- 18:11they've heard that treating any social is not only pointless, but that treating a
- 18:18psychopath is just an exercise in creating a better psychopath. Yeah, that I've
- 18:21never heard, but I get it. But I just haven't ever been exposed
- 18:26to that idea. And Bob, have you heard anyone ever say that it
- 18:32can be a fruitful endeavor to treat someone with any social No, I never
- 18:37have. Yeah, and that's kind of think about it. It's sad that
- 18:40that's the case. Yeah, yeah, because that isn't what the research shows.
- 18:42Right by the way, and I'll get more into it at the end
- 18:48of the SEMAO. But going on, I'm not going to act like I
- 18:52do not understand why there is this apprehension in the field around treating any social
- 18:56but I cannot help but look down on my peers my professors for discussing this
- 19:00population as if we were subhuman, especially when there has been so much research
- 19:07in recent years that clarifies many misconceptions about psychopathy and offers potential treatment options.
- 19:15I have found that you are one of the few people who discussed as any
- 19:18social and psychopathic people in an empathic manner. I would love for you to
- 19:22make a deep dive on psychopathy and any social someday, as I'm sure that
- 19:26you will, But in the interim, I would appreciate it if you and
- 19:29Bob could speak to the lack of understanding about any social in the field.
- 19:33Any other thoughts, Bob before I go into my notes here. I feel
- 19:37sad and I really appreciate this email. Yeah yeah, Patron, this is
- 19:42not good. It annoys me too, not only for this particular situation,
- 19:48but also for clients with any social Also, the way that the society and
- 19:56people in our field will talk about people with psychops EPAthe in people with any
- 20:00social on the Internet. It's this very blanket statement that I think is basically
- 20:07just another word for evil that they will use. Narcissistic has replaced that more
- 20:14recently, But there's this very firm notion in our culture that you have good
- 20:21people and you have evil people, and these evil people are subhuman, they're
- 20:26animals. They are fundamentally different, they are functionally different in their brains.
- 20:33And I've bumped up against this many times. You might have heard me bump
- 20:37up against it when I'm talking with Embardo, particularly in the past to be
- 20:41years, to kind of break him of this idea. And it might be
- 20:45true, and there is some evidence that when we measure them through functional MRIs
- 20:52there can be differences on average in their neurology. Yeah, in turn,
- 20:57well, but even that word is a little funny because only what we're saying
- 21:02is that the fMRI is picking up on oxygen being delivered to this brain in
- 21:08a slightly different way than the oxygen being delivered to this other brain. And
- 21:14these studies they often have an end of like twelve, and for someone to
- 21:19claim that they've found a significant difference between the antisocial group and the non anti
- 21:25social group, they could have like, you know, six of each and
- 21:29three on the anti social side had had this difference, and only one in
- 21:34the non antisocial had this difference. So you have many people in the anti
- 21:38social group who didn't show that difference in oxygen in the brain, and you
- 21:44even had some people in the non anti social group who showed the same pattern
- 21:48in the brain. So what are we really saying, right, that's not
- 21:51statistically significant, right, So what are we talking about when we talk about
- 21:56these quote unquote different brains? Right? And it's just way more complicate that
- 22:00In the future, might we find there's an answer to the question as to
- 22:04what is different about the brain and development, maybe even pre birth that leads
- 22:11to developing antisocial Yeah, but we are not there yet. That could be
- 22:15really interesting. Yeah. Well, I'm sure in the future they'll have all
- 22:18sorts of answers to those questions, but we're far from that. But anyway,
- 22:22Yeah, it's just another word for evil. Well do you think that
- 22:26maybe one of the things is for anti social folks that they process information outside
- 22:32of some of the motion centers of the brain or less, So, like
- 22:37maybe they I'm just thinking about this because I'm learning a little bit about neuroscience
- 22:42and I'm just wondering if maybe I don't know the answer to that question,
- 22:48but there are models that I've found to be useful at times to adopt.
- 22:56One of which is that people with any social do not have as robust of
- 23:03a fear center as other people do, and so when they are young,
- 23:10they will see these kids act in very dangerous ways to themselves, like they'll
- 23:15jump off things that are scary to other kids. And also, the model
- 23:22goes is that for kids with the normal level of fear response, when you
- 23:27have an authority like a parent who is upset at you and says, hey,
- 23:32don't do that, don't throw that rock at your brother, or don't
- 23:36steal that candy from the store, that the child will have a fear response
- 23:41and that will encode this association with doing quote unquote bad things, with danger,
- 23:49and that's how we develop morality. That's interesting, right, because we
- 23:52don't normally think of morality as being a fear based process, right. We
- 23:57think of it as an empathetic process. But it's possible that it's largely a
- 24:03fear based process, which isn't a bad thing. I mean, when you
- 24:06word it that way, it sounds abusive to children, but it might actually
- 24:10be the natural way and it kind of makes sense because the way that our
- 24:15emotions evolved seemingly it's hard, it's impossible for us to know, but you
- 24:21know, like a similar parallel emotion would be the fear of separation from our
- 24:27tribe, from our caregivers. We're two years old and we're on the African
- 24:32savannah two hundred thousand years ago, and our parents walk away to do something
- 24:37and were left there alone. Children will have a massive fear response as if
- 24:42they are about to be eaten by a tiger or they're falling off a cliff.
- 24:47It's the same emotional response that was around in our pre social species.
- 24:53And it wasn't that that fear would not happen if the parents moved away in
- 24:59these speed sees that didn't depend on social proximity for survival, and so as
- 25:04our species evolved into the sort of species that required children stay close to their
- 25:10parents, it just co opted that fear of falling off a cliff or of
- 25:17a tiger eating your head, those kinds of fears were just co opted to
- 25:22motivate that child to scream or follow their parents. In the same way.
- 25:29In terms of morality, which is a social thing as well, that our
- 25:33species could have co opted that fear of falling off a cliff to motivate the
- 25:38child to learn how to live in harmony with a community. And without that
- 25:47sort of fear, then it will throw a wrench in that development, that
- 25:52normal developmental process that happens for kids in a natural way when they're growing up.
- 25:57And so by the time there or fifty five, they just don't have
- 26:02that association of fear and cringing. You know. That's that cringing feeling,
- 26:08right that we feel of watching a social bad that's happening, you know,
- 26:12like curb your enthusiasm is kind of thing you're watching Homer Simpson, like say
- 26:18something that's off color, and then we feel that fear because we're identifying with
- 26:25the character and we're worried that there's going to be some kind of social ostraization
- 26:30and rejection. And why do we feel that fear, Well, we might
- 26:34not have been born with it. It might have been taught to us by
- 26:38people actually reacting to us in a way that caused us fear when we were
- 26:42very young, you know what I mean. Yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 26:45so yeah, Patroon, I'm sorry that you're going through that, and I
- 26:51totally understand your disappointment. I mean, even if you didn't have antisocial it
- 26:56would be disappointing, but particularly since you don't have any social and what I'm
- 27:00guessing is that you don't raise your hand and say, by the way,
- 27:02I have any social, I don't appreciate the way you're talking about me,
- 27:06and I don't I frankly, I don't even think you're safe to do that.
- 27:08Yeah, yeah, yeah, which is a I mean, when I
- 27:11say that out loud, it's like, my god, that you could have
- 27:17someone with any social who's in the program, and everyone, including the professors,
- 27:23are talking about people with any socials being subhuman and not following the science
- 27:29and just saying that it's useless to treat these people and that they're basically always
- 27:33monsters and they're always going to be a monster. To think that this person
- 27:38can't raise their hand and say that's not the science and that's not my experience
- 27:42and I have any social is a strong horrific indictment on our field. Yeah,
- 27:51so, yeah, I get it. I usually run into this when
- 27:56it comes to narcissistic or borderline or something, but yeah, with Andrews as
- 28:00well, makes sense that it would Now, I want to be clear that
- 28:03this is one of the factors for this problem in our field, is that
- 28:08there have been many documented cases of psychopaths and people with any social who were
- 28:15not salvageable and did play their therapists and did manipulate their therapists into believing something
- 28:26like a classic example as you have a chronic psychopath who is incarcerated and being
- 28:33evaluated for a parole or for shortening a sentence or something, and a bleeding
- 28:41heart therapist comes in psychologists to evaluate and gets seduced, not in the sexual
- 28:47way but in the social way, and the psychologist becomes not only believing that
- 28:52this client or this prisoner can has been reformed, but becomes an ardent advocate
- 29:00for this person and starts really making it their mission in life to free this
- 29:07man. And then they managed to convince everyone around them, and then the
- 29:11man is freed, and then he kills somebody like the next day. There
- 29:15are many cases like this, and so what happened was that you had those
- 29:23cases and then instead of saying, well, we should have consultation, we
- 29:29should have more education, we should have counter transference management, we should have
- 29:33other kinds of questions Also, is it a viable question that a psychologist would
- 29:38be able to predict someone's behavior in the future. I mean, we do
- 29:41our best, but we can't know we're we're not magical creatures. Nobody is.
- 29:47So instead of that, it's like, well, let's just all agree
- 29:52that psychopaths are unsalvageable and they're always playing you. That's what happened. Also,
- 30:00so personal personality disorders in general are difficult to understand and for clinicians.
- 30:06Research shows that also it's just plain easier to write people off. I see
- 30:12this all the time, people with any social with borderline with narcissistic. It's
- 30:18just easier to say, look, I'm just going to categorize them as the
- 30:23baddies, and I don't want to have to get into it with them.
- 30:27I don't want to have to worry about getting exposed to them. I don't
- 30:30want to have to learn new concepts or deal with my own inner narcissistic person.
- 30:41It's just easier just to say, you know, they're all worthless or
- 30:45they're unsalvageable. So in moving on in life, this happens all the time,
- 30:48even when someone isn't labeled as having a personal disorder. I've had many
- 30:52supervises who will run into a client early in their career who has a personality
- 30:57sorder that challenges there be greatly, but the therapist hasn't recognized the person as
- 31:03a personal disorder. And the supervisor will come to me and say that they
- 31:08are getting advice from other people that they should fire their client because they're not
- 31:12meaningfully participating in therapy. And I will hear their assessment of the client and
- 31:19conclude that the client likely has a personality sort of some sort, and that
- 31:25people come to therapy because they have problems. So if you want to be
- 31:27a real therapist, you're not going to reject them because they have a problem.
- 31:33And this is a well documented problem for over one hundred years in our
- 31:37fields. It's not a mystery, it's not an obscure thing. And so
- 31:41if you sign up to be a therapist, now's your time to shine.
- 31:45And you know, ninety nine percent of the supervises are totally on board at
- 31:48that, because they want to be a roughy, they want to be a
- 31:52real therapist. Also, it's just frankly scary, which is totally rational,
- 31:57to work with someone who lacks empathy because there are questions. If they don't
- 32:04care about my feelings, then are they going to hurt me? Is that
- 32:08going to happen? Are they going to hurt someone that I care about?
- 32:12It's a legit question. It's not hard to overcome that and work with it.
- 32:17But I think that fear can cause people to run and justify their running.
- 32:25Also, there's just too much misinformation fictional villains, and now with online
- 32:31chatter, there's so much information out there that says that once a psychopath,
- 32:38always a psychopath, and if someone's any social then they're a true monster's there's
- 32:44no point. You know, in today's world, I would guess that ninety
- 32:47nine percent of the potential influences on a therapist come from the Internet. And
- 32:57yeah, because you know, young people and people in general there on the
- 33:00internet like five hours a day and for the rest of their life and pre
- 33:05graduate school they're on the internet. So what's the chance that the few hours
- 33:08that you spend in graduate school and the very few hours that are even spent
- 33:14on any social I mean, how many hours in our master's degree would you
- 33:20estimate was spent on any social Oh twenty minutes maybe? Yeah? If that?
- 33:24If that, because we had probably we've talked about this before. We
- 33:29had ten weeks of psychopathology. And it's covering the entire DSM, which is
- 33:37like a thousand pages. It's a big book. One out of what seventy
- 33:40chapters, sixty chapters is the personal disorder chapter, and one out of the
- 33:45nine personal disorders is any social So do the math on that. Not a
- 33:50lot of time spent on it now, So when the DSM, I mean
- 33:54as a resource, it is indeed very limited. So when you match that
- 34:00up with all the content on the internet about any social sure anyway, and
- 34:05all the sort of pop culture tropes. Yeah, right, right, the
- 34:09first bob before moving forward, Let's take a break. What do you say,
- 34:14Yeah, let's take a break. All right, we're back from the
- 34:21break. Let's go on here. And the last factor is that leaders in
- 34:25our field don't have an incentive to stick their neck out for people with any
- 34:31social It's similar to how for seventeen year olds to vote, to get the
- 34:38right to vote, because you know, there's been a movement to lower the
- 34:42age because society does affect younger people. I don't know how I feel about
- 34:47it. I'm not taking a stance on it. One way or the other.
- 34:51In order for seventeen year olds to get the right to vote, you
- 34:54have to have adults that will vote for seventeen year olds because seventen year olds
- 34:59won't have the right to vot. And once some eighteen year olds become eighteen
- 35:01year olds, then there's not a huge motivation to advocate for people a year
- 35:07younger than you. So you're always going to be in a state of powerlessness
- 35:13because no one cares enough or wants to put their reputation on the line for
- 35:22you because there's not a huge benefit and there could be huge consequences. Right,
- 35:29So for people with any social I have the freedom to do it because
- 35:34I'm self employed. But if I worked at a university or if I was
- 35:37part of an agency or something, there could be a backlash and I could
- 35:42get fired, or I could have a boss it could tell me to shut
- 35:45up, or I would have to deal with having to insult all my colleagues
- 35:51and say that they're all idiots. Social astraism, Yeah, and for what
- 35:55that people with any social get treated better, Like, what what do I
- 36:00get out of that? Right? Plus, there are people with any social
- 36:04that don't deserve to be treated better, you know, because it's a it's
- 36:08a thing. There are people with any social who do who do deserve to
- 36:13be treated better, absolutely, but there's not a lot of benefit and there's
- 36:16there's a lot of risk. And so similar to how you don't have a
- 36:21lot of clinicians sticking their neck out for non offending pedophiles, right, what's
- 36:27the benefit, what's the upside, and there's a ton of downside. So
- 36:30it's just easier to just not even if you think the way that we do.
- 36:36There's no hashtag movement, there's no marching in the street, there's no
- 36:40ribbon that you wear that says, hey, we need to treat non offending
- 36:44pedophiles or we need to treat non harmful antisocial people. You know, there's
- 36:50there's not there's not a benefit now that sticks up as the one that gets
- 36:54the hammer. Unless you are at one of the stages of Kolberg's theory of
- 37:01morality development, you're going to be at six, in which you are operating
- 37:07from a universal set of ethical principles and you're operating on you know that morality
- 37:14is based on abstract reasoning and a commitment to justice. That's when you will
- 37:21speak up and say something, boy, man, you move everybody to stage
- 37:24six, they will do two things. They will go slower because they're going
- 37:29to be burning a lot of oxygen and glucose in their brains, and they
- 37:32will make better decisions. What do you mean, Well, most of the
- 37:37time we're on autopilot. Ninety percent of the day, we're just doing shit
- 37:42that's wrote because it's in procedural memory. And in order to actually make decisions
- 37:47based on ethical principles, you have to use that different parts of the brain
- 37:52and they burn a lot of oxygen and glucose and your biology, our biology
- 37:59is based on economy, man, save energy wherever possible. So we are
- 38:04very good procedural procedural memory get through the day ors. We're great at that.
- 38:10But to actually think outside the box, if that's a kind of a
- 38:15traite way to put it, but to actually think about the things that which
- 38:20is one of the things I love about being a therapist is I have to
- 38:23I'm forced to use a different part of my brain and expand it, and
- 38:30that is terrifying at times and mostly awesome. But you could say that a
- 38:37lot of training is getting good clinical behavior into procedural memory, which actually is
- 38:44somewhat true. So if I fuck up with the client like I did the
- 38:46other day and they call me on it, I'm very quick to say I'm
- 38:51sorry because I've done it enough times that I know exactly how this goes,
- 38:53and I don't have to think about it. It doesn't cost me anything,
- 38:58and it actually they were right. I did fuck up, and they were
- 39:04kind enough to offer a correction, and I took it. I took him
- 39:07up on it and also apologized for you know what, in retrospect is a
- 39:13bit of inanity on my part, but when I first had to do that,
- 39:19that was humiliating. Yeah, and uh, there was a pretty steep
- 39:24curve to learn. I'm grateful, but it's painful. It's like all learning,
- 39:30Yeah, right, painful path of least resistance in our brain. And
- 39:37this is possibly the next deep dive I'm going to do so more on this
- 39:40later, but for now, just to explain more because I've basically been saying
- 39:47everyone's an idiot without saying how they're an idiot, and so let me let
- 39:53me tell you what the science is. Dismissing the dismissers is what you're doing.
- 39:58Yeah, it's easy to do that, it's harder to justify it.
- 40:01So let me justify it, which is that absolutely you can have psychopaths and
- 40:07people with any social that are potentially irredeemable. They've gone too far. They
- 40:13just make their own choices such that there's no reforming them and they probably need
- 40:20to be locked up for the rest of their life. I've been close to
- 40:22some of these folks. It's heartbreaking, but when you witness the terrible amount
- 40:29of pain and abuse and harm that they cause around them, I certainly didn't
- 40:34feel bad about them being locked up for the rest of their life. Having
- 40:37said that, there's a lot of factors that go into behavior, with personality
- 40:43and specifically anti social personality being just one of those factors. And in terms
- 40:47of the construct, we have to tease out exactly what we mean when we
- 40:52see antisocial because there are other constructs that are not included in the DSM for
- 41:00weird reasons, but used to be, such as sadism. So sadism is
- 41:06a known personality trait that has a ton of research around it that is separate
- 41:12but overlapping, often being comorbid with someone with antisocial It's associated, but it's
- 41:17not always the case. So you can have someone who is sadistic, meaning
- 41:22that they wake up in the morning and they seek to gain pleasure by harming
- 41:27others or witnessing harm of others. And for some of these folks, they
- 41:30will also be antisocial in that they don't care about other people's feelings. They
- 41:37just don't have that feeling that the rest of us get when we harm other
- 41:42people. And thus they will wake up in the morning have a motivation of
- 41:47harm others, and they will act on it because they don't care. But
- 41:52you can have someone who's anti social, who doesn't have sadism, who doesn't
- 41:55wake up in the morning and say, I can't wait to hurt other people.
- 42:00But if they happen to hurt someone else, they don't register that pain
- 42:05or that empathy the same way that other people would. But that doesn't mean
- 42:08that they still move forward with it, because they might have an intellectual understanding
- 42:14or a slight bit of empathy that they have to highlight and oomph up a
- 42:20little bit to motivate their behavior. It's sort of like with someone with ADHD.
- 42:27They might naturally if they just behave without meds or without any kind of
- 42:32measures in place, they might go through the day and leave their keys at
- 42:38work, or forget to pick up their laptop from the bus station, or
- 42:45they might in the middle of a conversation just say squirrel and walk off.
- 42:52But if they put their mind to it, and they have enough energy and
- 42:58they have these coping skills, they can double check that they might have a
- 43:04little reminder as they're walking out the door that says laptop, keys, whatever,
- 43:07and they do that and that accommodates their issue such that they don't have
- 43:14consequences. Well, people with any social can do the same thing. They
- 43:16can highlight like, Okay, if I just act normally, I'm going to
- 43:22risk harming other people. I don't want to do that, So how can
- 43:27I account for this? And I've worked for I've worked with clients in this
- 43:30situation, and what they will do is they will learn through experience that they
- 43:38have to ask themselves a question consciously. Am I about to hurt someone's feelings?
- 43:45Is there a risk here? Now? For non antisocial people, typically
- 43:51this is a subconscious feeling that we get with empathy and with experience, we
- 43:54don't have to ask ourselves those questions we sometimes do in daily interactions. We
- 44:00don't have to as much but for them, they do, especially if because
- 44:06they often do want intimate attachment relationships with people because they get the same fulfillment
- 44:12that other people do. They might have a flattened affect about it, but
- 44:15they have affect and they have emotions, and so they will have to pay
- 44:21attention to how their behavior might impact their partner more so than other people do.
- 44:29I mean everyone needs to do this, but people with any social just
- 44:31have to pay particular attention and they have to maybe learn. They have to
- 44:35be overtly and I've worked with people like this too. They might have to
- 44:37ask their partner. So, by the way, I have this thing called
- 44:39any social I don't want to hurt you. I actually love you in my
- 44:44way and I want to have a relationship with you that doesn't harm you.
- 44:49But I can't really rely on my own guidance system. So can you work
- 44:53with me on this? Like if I hurt your feelings, can you not
- 44:57assume that I'm a dick and for me in a way that gives me the
- 45:00opportunity to learn because I don't want to do that. Again, it gets
- 45:05weird because even in that process, the personal with any social can get kind
- 45:09of self righteous. You can kind of even hear it in this email.
- 45:14You know, he's talking about how in the same breath of him saying,
- 45:17which is true, that he's being treated as human. In fact, I
- 45:22think I even deleted a sentence from his email where it was more aggressive.
- 45:27The way the way that he was thinking about the people in his school is
- 45:31more narcissistic, you know, which is which comes along with the territory,
- 45:36and it gets weird. It's not. It's not all fun and games,
- 45:39and there are a lot of personality issues you have to navigate it. I'm
- 45:45making it seem easy, but it isn't easy. So you have any social
- 45:51meeting lack of empathy generally, that's what we are referring to when we're talking
- 45:54about any social or psychopathy. We have sadism, we have narcissism, which
- 45:59is an other construct narcisstic personality disorder, but also just general narcisstic personality.
- 46:06And then we have machiavellianism. This is the dark tetread. So all of
- 46:10those things are separate things. If you have all four of those things,
- 46:14my goodness, that's that's someone to avoid. And you spoke, yeah,
- 46:20unless they're really working on it. But If you wake up in the morning
- 46:23and want to harm others and you don't care about the other people's feelings,
- 46:27and you're very, very, very self centered, and you plan in advance
- 46:32the harming of others to get your rocks off, so to speak, then
- 46:37this is a very dangerous individual. But if you just have any social and
- 46:42you're aware of things and you're working on it, and you're a clinician for
- 46:45crying out loud, then the risk is a lot lower. We understand this,
- 46:50and it doesn't mean that you are narcissistic if you're any social well,
- 46:53and it doesn't mean that you have sadism if you're any social They're correlated off
- 46:59they often do together, but they don't always in the same way that you
- 47:02can have someone with sadism that isn't any of the other three. So for
- 47:07these individuals, they know that they love to see other people be harmed,
- 47:13but they care about other people's feelings, so they if they don't engage in
- 47:19self justification, they will figure out a balance in which they will be able
- 47:25to satisfy this need enough. It's sort of like with vampires in a lot
- 47:31of these movies where they'll eat animals, they'll suck the blood of animals instead
- 47:37of other humans. Not satisfying, but I can get by. It's a
- 47:42sublimation, but it's necessary because they have empathy. Well for someone with sadism,
- 47:49they want deep down to suck the blood of another human. But they'll
- 47:54sublimate not with animals, but with like maybe cartoon speaking or metaphorically here or
- 48:01fiction. Yeah, they'll or they'll watch videos of people being harmed that they
- 48:08aren't, you know, like there are a lot of videos now coming out
- 48:15of war people you know, soldiers are walking around with with GoPros and in
- 48:22camp you know, body cameras and publishing them on the internet. And there's
- 48:28a lot of footage in Ukraine and in Gaza right now, but all over
- 48:32the world really and if you want to, you can find these uh these
- 48:39clips online on YouTube and Reddit in other places. And you're not participating in
- 48:46the harm of other people. Hopefully. It's something that's happening whether you watch
- 48:52the video or not. Frankly, and you watch the video and you get
- 48:58this pleasure, but you're not to blame. It's not your fault. It
- 49:02cost time, right, Yeah, now, I'm sure you know some people
- 49:07are thinking well, if you're watching the video, that encourages the person to
- 49:09make the video, which encourages the action, you know, And yeah,
- 49:12okay, we can ask those questions. But you know, I know,
- 49:15I hope you get what I'm saying. At releast if you were to watch
- 49:17a fictional depiction, you know, like a Star Wars movie, you know,
- 49:21which someone gets thrown down a well or something, and you get that
- 49:25kind of charge then, or you really love the villains in a movie then,
- 49:31or you like Hannibal Lecter that's a fictional you know that kind off.
- 49:36So you know, this is well interested, but it's complicated and in our
- 49:43society we don't talk about this kind of thing. And if you're a clinician
- 49:47that doesn't seek this information out, then you're just going to believe what society
- 49:52believes, and you're gonna lump all those things into one thing. You're going
- 49:53to have this very stereotypical vision of someone with any social and then in class
- 50:00as a professor, you're going to say that they're irredeemable and you actually are
- 50:04just causing more harm by reaching out to these people. Yeah, pretty bothersome,
- 50:08yes, And by the way, that attitude fucking perpetuates the problem because
- 50:14if you have any social and no one tries to help you, then guess
- 50:16what more problems? Isn't it funny there's a failure and empathy towards any social
- 50:23people. It's sort of ironic. Wow. Yeah, hurt people, hurt
- 50:29people, hurt people. Well, that does it for that episode of psychology
- 50:31and Seattle. Everyone out there, please take care of yourself because you deserve it.